Latest / Politics with Paul / What Do Democrats and Republicans Agree On? More Than You Think | Politics with Paul #85
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10Today, we're gonna talk about what do democrats and republicans actually agree on.
- 0:15That's that's crazy.
- 0:17Right?
- 0:17All the talk in politics is about how much we fight and
- 0:20we don't see eye to eye and we're just at each other's throats.
- 0:23Democrats and Republicans disagree on just about everything.
- 0:27Well,
- 0:28not exactly.
- 0:30We are hardwired toward in group and out group dynamics where we overly feel the need to focus
- 0:39on how much we are different to people while finding our group that thinks just like us.
- 0:45And some people take a couple steps further and perceive differences in opinions as threats.
- 0:51It's part of what leads us to overstate how much we disagree on things.
- 0:56But there are many more similarities than we may realize, certainly more than certain
- 1:02polarized interests want to admit or have you believe.
- 1:06Now, is true that there is a lot that divides us.
- 1:08We can't pretend that that's not the case.
- 1:11But with how much focus there is on that division, we often perceive there to be more
- 1:16differences between us than there actually are.
- 1:20So why is that?
- 1:21And how do we scientifically study where there is agreement and disagreement?
- 1:26And where is there more agreements across parties than you may realize?
- 1:31Well, let's talk about it.
- 1:33So first of all, why do we perceive more difference than there actually is?
- 1:37Well, for one thing, we have a tendency to focus on negatives, and we perceive differences
- 1:43as negative a lot of times.
- 1:44Now, of course, differences are inherently negative.
- 1:47In fact, a lot of times they're good because they help you find different perspectives on
- 1:52things and you can find angles that you didn't think about and possibly head off any potential
- 2:00issues, unintended consequences of policies, things like that.
- 2:04But we often perceive differences in opinion as such.
- 2:07And look, all of us have that issue at some point where we get mad at somebody for thinking
- 2:12something differently than us.
- 2:13But of course, for some people, that's a more chronic attitude.
- 2:17But it is too common where we treat differences of opinions as not just annoying, but as
- 2:23threats to our existence.
- 2:25And we tend to like and gravitate toward people that we are similar to, to groups that we are
- 2:30similar to because we wanna find naturally as social creatures, we want to find people that
- 2:36we are similar to.
- 2:38So when we perceive a lot of difference with other people in groups, we tend to dislike
- 2:43them, and that can further drive this perception of huge difference.
- 2:48And there's also this issue where we have these fallacies where we compare groups to
- 2:54individuals, which doesn't really work, not in an academic context where we have variables
- 3:00that we're comparing groups and then sometimes we accidentally compare individuals instead,
- 3:04but also just from a simple sociological standpoint, groups and individuals are not the
- 3:11same thing.
- 3:12Individuals, even as part of an overall group, can often think very differently.
- 3:17Not every Democrat's the same.
- 3:19Not every Republican's the same.
- 3:20Certainly not every Independent is the same.
- 3:22And a
- 3:23lot of times when we describe
- 3:25a group, we are erroneously describing individual behavior instead.
- 3:29Sometimes that's unintentional, and sometimes for some people that is on purpose to try to
- 3:34paint an entire group as monolithic and terrible, and you shouldn't listen to them.
- 3:39But, of course, groups don't think all the same.
- 3:43Even some of the most ardent super out there groups will have some differences in opinion,
- 3:49and sometimes they'll just turn in on each other.
- 3:52And when an individual in an out group, meaning groups that are not ours that we've designated
- 3:57as opposing us, when an individual in that out group acts differently than we expect, instead
- 4:03of treating that as possibly more common than we think, we just tend to think, oh, well,
- 4:08they're just one of the few good ones.
- 4:09They they're they're they just maybe they don't know what group they really should be a part
- 4:14of.
- 4:14We we we find some sort of reason to not attribute it to as, oh,
- 4:19well, maybe that group is
- 4:20you know, maybe they're
- 4:21actually there's some good people in there.
- 4:23Or even if we don't think that they're terrible people, we still don't necessarily change our
- 4:27opinion of that group just because of one individual.
- 4:31I mean, how many times have you heard somebody say, oh, that's one of the few Republicans I
- 4:34like.
- 4:34Oh, that's one of the few Democrats I like.
- 4:37It happens quite a bit.
- 4:38And there's also this issue of that we've already kinda touched on already, this issue of
- 4:44false polarization.
- 4:46There's a lot of evidence that suggests that a lot of this perception of division and this
- 4:52chasm between us is a self fulfilling prophecy of polarization.
- 4:56We perceive there to be more division than there actually is because it's what gets all
- 5:01the clicks and we just focus on, Oh, you know, how divided?
- 5:04Is this the most divided we've ever been?
- 5:06And so, people react accordingly by perceiving people to be way different than them because
- 5:10they think, Oh, wow, those people are so extreme.
- 5:12I'm going to be more extreme too, not realizing that their side is also contributing to the
- 5:20polarization or just not wanting to admit that they're contributing to polarization.
- 5:24And so
- 5:24that polarization increases.
- 5:26So then it actually becomes sort of a
- 5:28true polarization, but then we still perceive there to be more difference than there actually
- 5:33is because of just how we're misunderstanding each other.
- 5:36And it's driven by our biases about out groups and our reliance on stereotypes and media
- 5:43promoting excessive coverage of these divisive figures and vocal minorities.
- 5:48So it tends to make us think that there's a lot more that we don't have in common and we don't
- 5:55realize just how much we are similar to each other.
- 5:58Now how do we actually study the level of difference and similarity between the
- 6:03Republican and Democratic parties?
- 6:06Well, if you just look at Democrats and Republicans at a very basic level and
- 6:12conglomerate them together, of course, they're gonna look very different.
- 6:16It's like, oh, well, we just look at all the things that Republicans typically stand for,
- 6:21compare them to things that Democrats typically stand for, and, oh, wow.
- 6:24Look at all the differences.
- 6:26Well, yeah, that's why there are different parties in the first place.
- 6:30They generally don't see eye to eye on a lot of things.
- 6:33But when you start breaking things down, that's how
- 6:37you start to find common ground.
- 6:38You start to look at more specific nuances and realize, Oh, wow.
- 6:43Actually, you know what?
- 6:44I see I like what that person says.
- 6:47I actually think that same thing too.
- 6:50And then you start to find some sort of similarity with that other person and think,
- 6:56oh, you
- 6:56know what?
- 6:57Maybe I had this person wrong.
- 6:59So
- 7:00some of the ways that you can look at these similarities and differences through a study,
- 7:06through a more scientific lens.
- 7:09There's really a bunch of different ways, but some of the ones that I really want to hone in
- 7:13for the purposes of this episode are four different contexts.
- 7:19We can look at it through the context of party and government versus organization versus
- 7:24electorate.
- 7:25More on what that is in a second.
- 7:27Can look at it from the level of government, how much division and similarity is there
- 7:31between federal level of Republicans and Democrats, then look at the state level
- 7:37Republicans and Democrats and by each state, not necessarily all the states as a whole, and
- 7:42then also look at it from the local level.
- 7:45You can also study similarities and differences on, of course, particular political issues and
- 7:52policies.
- 7:53And then lastly, on specific values, which can sometimes be mistaken for policies.
- 7:59And in all these contexts,
- 8:01if you even try you don't even need to try that hard.
- 8:04But if you try just a little bit, you can actually find a possibly surprising level of
- 8:09similarity between the Republican and Democratic parties.
- 8:13So first context, mentioned it just a moment ago, party and government versus organization
- 8:19versus electorate.
- 8:20This is a concept that is often used in political science where we look at the
- 8:25Republican and Democratic parties through the lens of in governments, the party
- 8:32organizations, and then the voters.
- 8:34So government party in government is party members who have been elected to office.
- 8:40Fairly straightforward.
- 8:41It's presidents, congress people, governors, state legislators, city councilors, a whole
- 8:47bunch of different people that get elected to office at the federal, state, and local levels.
- 8:52And these are the ones that are responsible for enacting policies of the party.
- 8:56They're the ones who get elected for that very reason.
- 8:59And then you also have party and organization, which is the formal structure of the party.
- 9:05So these are like campaigning entities like the National Republican Congressional Committee,
- 9:10NRCC, or the D triple c, which is the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.
- 9:16Local chapters of the parties, so you can find your county and find a Democratic chapter
- 9:21chapter or a Republican chapter.
- 9:23Sometimes you can find a college Republicans or a college Democrats.
- 9:27Maybe other interest groups that are not don't specifically have Democrat or Republican in
- 9:33their names, but they are heavily aligned with one party or the other and typically stumped
- 9:38for that party.
- 9:39And so these ones, the the party and organization, they are responsible for
- 9:43coordinating party behavior, supporting candidates through fundraising and media
- 9:47strategy, and organizing voters to support candidates.
- 9:51And then the most obvious one is the electric, which is the voters in the citizenry.
- 9:55And those can sometimes look like the party and organization because citizens are participating
- 10:00in these party activities like these local Democratic and Republican chapter meetups.
- 10:07But these are the ones that are directly responsible for choosing who gets elected for
- 10:11the party.
- 10:12So these are the ones who are actually going to the ballot box, which, of course, can also be
- 10:15the people who are in party in government or party in organization.
- 10:19But in this context, they are the party in the electorate because they're the ones who are
- 10:23actually voting on these people in this instance.
- 10:26And so when you look at government versus organization versus electorate, you can find a
- 10:31whole bunch of republican and democratic similarities, and that varies somewhat based on
- 10:37whether you which of those levels you're talking about and on what context you're
- 10:42talking about.
- 10:42But you can find similarities between the two parties on all of those levels in certain
- 10:47contexts, which we'll talk about shortly.
- 10:50But another context that you could study similarities between the parties in is the
- 10:56level of government.
- 10:57So federal versus state versus local.
- 11:00Might sound obvious, but just in case it's not, federal is president and congress are
- 11:05technically the only positions that are officially partisan.
- 11:08They're the only federal positions that we actually vote on, so US house and US
- 11:12senate and president.
- 11:13Now appointed positions will occasionally be partisan, but a lot of
- 11:21times they're not officially nonpartisan.
- 11:23Even though really in reality, a lot of the time they are because they're picked by
- 11:27partisan officials, partisan presidents.
- 11:30They're confirmed by partisan congresspeople.
- 11:32And so they're, in reality, they really are gonna be Republicans or Democrats, but their
- 11:38position is nominally nonpartisan.
- 11:41And then for the state level, have governors and other state executives like state attorney
- 11:46general, a treasurer, an insurance commissioner.
- 11:49There's a whole bunch of different state executives you can find depending on the state.
- 11:53State legislators and state judges like a state supreme court.
- 11:57And some of these positions are also nonpartisan depending the state.
- 12:02In some states, it might be a partisan position.
- 12:05In some states, it might not be.
- 12:06And then some states might not even have that position.
- 12:10And then, again, still a lot of the occupants of these offices may actually be registered
- 12:18with or aligned with a party.
- 12:21And Nebraska, in particular, is the only state legislature that is officially nonpartisan even
- 12:27though they really aren't.
- 12:29Most of them really are Republican Democrat.
- 12:31They just can't campaign as such and list themselves as such on a ballot.
- 12:38And then local, you have mayors, county commissioners, city councilors, local judges.
- 12:43There are a lot of local level offices that are considered nonpartisan.
- 12:47A lot of school boards, for example, are considered nonpartisan.
- 12:51And I would say more often in the case of local level politics, those positions really are more
- 12:59nonpartisan.
- 12:59Even if they are occupied by people that are really Democrats or Republicans, they don't off
- 13:06as often get to act in a Democratic or Republican manner like you would see more often
- 13:12at the state and federal levels.
- 13:14And so depending on whether you're talking about the federal, state, or local levels, the
- 13:19similarities and differences between the two parties can vary and on what context in that
- 13:25level that you're talking about.
- 13:27And then the third context we'll talk about with regards to how similar Republicans and
- 13:34Democrats are is obviously specific political issues and policies, and that's where most of
- 13:40the focus lies on when it talks about how different the parties are.
- 13:43Well, Democrats support tend to support abortion and Republicans don't.
- 13:49Republicans tend to oppose gun control and Democrats tend to support gun control or pick
- 13:56any other issue that you can think of that typically has a partisan angle to it.
- 14:01And now, of course, this makes a lot of sense to some extent because the parties exist
- 14:06largely because of their differences on policies, and so they conglomerate together to
- 14:11try to get their preferred policies enacted with the people that think most like them.
- 14:17But of course, you're still gonna get people that don't think quite like you do.
- 14:22And of course, political issues are often made heavily oversimplified by polarized interest
- 14:29because it behooves them to make things very black and white and tell you, you're either for
- 14:34this or against this.
- 14:35And if you're for this, well, depending on what the issue is.
- 14:39Sometimes if you're for it, you're a terrible person.
- 14:41Or if you're against it, you're a terrible person.
- 14:43And that's why you should actually think the other way because you don't wanna be a terrible
- 14:48person, do you?
- 14:49And, you know, all this
- 14:52these campaigning ads you see for people that play on that kind of thing, they often take
- 14:58complex issues.
- 14:59Sometimes they're they really are straightforward issues, but a lot of times they
- 15:02really aren't that straightforward or there's been a lot of complicated wheeling and dealing
- 15:06on these policies that aren't necessarily talked about right then and there.
- 15:11Also, we
- 15:12naturally want things made simple and straightforward.
- 15:16That's even the people who really love complexity, at some point in time, they want
- 15:21things told straight to them.
- 15:23We only have so much brain capacity and at some point we do sometimes just fall into this,
- 15:29oh, you know what?
- 15:30Just just tell me yes or no on this thing.
- 15:33Just just give it
- 15:34to me straight.
- 15:35Even though, of course, politics is rarely that obvious and straightforward.
- 15:40So policies are often talked about in more general terms when it comes to rhetoric and
- 15:46campaigns.
- 15:46And now, well, you know what?
- 15:48Republican party thinks this because they're stupid.
- 15:50Democratic party thinks this because they're stupid or they're evil or whatever the word of
- 15:57the day is, the insult of the day is.
- 15:59And so a lot
- 16:02of similarities and differences can arise when you're starting to break down these things.
- 16:07When you're talking about them very broadly, yeah, probably not going to be a whole lot of
- 16:14similarity there.
- 16:15Although, there are some issues that are not inherently partisan, which we'll talk about
- 16:20shortly.
- 16:21But when you start breaking down a
- 16:23lot of policies, you actually can find a surprising number of similarities in that
- 16:28regard.
- 16:30And then lastly, the last context talking about similarities and differences is specific
- 16:36values, and these are things like freedom and liberty or equality and fairness, order and
- 16:43stability, safety, individualism, rule of law, democracy, family values, social justice,
- 16:50religious faith, tradition, a whole bunch of things that you can come up with here.
- 16:55And these are not necessarily opinions on policy, though they often do drive policy
- 17:00views.
- 17:01So for example, Democrats tend to place a lot more emphasis on equality.
- 17:07Republicans tend to place a lot more emphasis on freedom.
- 17:09Doesn't mean Democrats don't care about freedom.
- 17:11Doesn't mean Republicans don't care about equality, but there is a difference in how much
- 17:17emphasis they put on certain values or interpreting them in certain ways.
- 17:21So that's where a lot of these similarities and differences can arise.
- 17:27They might have a similar emphasis on a specific value, but the
- 17:32way they interpret them is different.
- 17:34But the fact that you share those values can be a way to build off of and develop some sort of
- 17:41relationship with the other side.
- 17:44So let's get more into these
- 17:48specific situations here to talk about how some more specific examples of how similar these
- 17:57parties can be in these regards.
- 17:59So let's talk about similarities and differences when it comes to elected fish
- 18:05officials in government.
- 18:06So we talked about earlier, this is the party in government because they're the ones who are
- 18:10actually elected.
- 18:11They are the ones actually making the policies.
- 18:13Sometimes we call these people the, quote, unquote, elites.
- 18:16And this is where when we talk about differences between the parties, this is where
- 18:20it tends to be most focused on because we talk about gridlock in congress and state
- 18:25legislatures about how these parties can't get along or in a certain state legislatures where
- 18:31one party can run rough shot over the other because they just have so many more members in
- 18:37that state legislature talk about, oh my goodness.
- 18:40These there's so much hostility between the parties.
- 18:43And, yes, there is.
- 18:44And, of course, a lot of this focus on the differences and similarities between the
- 18:49parties is gonna be focused on here because they're the ones who are ultimately deciding
- 18:54our policies and what's on the agenda.
- 18:57And they are much more polarized compared
- 19:01to the general population.
- 19:02We tend to conglomerate elites and the population and say, look how divided they both
- 19:09are, and there and there is, again, a lot of division here, but people in governments are a
- 19:14lot more polarized than regular voters are.
- 19:18But even so, you'd still be surprised at how much agreement on legislation there can be in
- 19:23congress and state legislatures.
- 19:26Now hard stats aren't robust a lot of
- 19:29the time and most aren't readily available or easy to come by, But one example I can point to
- 19:35is that the 2024 Washington state legislature, which is mostly it's been mostly democratic
- 19:43legislature for for quite some time.
- 19:45But even that saw a lot more agreement across party lines, much more than you would expect.
- 19:53And for some stats there, back in the 2024 session for for that for Washington state
- 20:03legislature in 2024, 95.8% of bills that passed both chambers received at least one republican
- 20:11vote.
- 20:11Now, guess, one vote from the opposite party is it's not much, but to have 95.8% of votes do
- 20:20that, and in a in a state which is not like it's not one of the most democratic state
- 20:25legislatures you'll find, but it is pretty
- 20:28heavy on the Democratic side.
- 20:32But then
- 20:32what about more Republicans signing on to Democratic bills?
- 20:36Well, 91.3% of bills that passed both chambers of the state legislature had at least six
- 20:43Republicans support it, which was about 10% of GOP legislators at that point.
- 20:49And then 89.2% of bills had 10 or
- 20:53more Republicans support those bills, and
- 20:56then 80.8% of bills had a majority of Republican legislators support it, which in
- 21:03this case was 31 plus.
- 21:04That's a pretty high number,
- 21:08much higher than you would probably expect.
- 21:10And then in other states, you might expect a similar thing, but for only one democrat to
- 21:14sign on
- 21:15to a republican bill.
- 21:17But the
- 21:17thing is most bills in congress and state legislatures get passed by large proportions of
- 21:23both parties regardless of whether the legislature is largely one-sided.
- 21:29Because well, for one, a lot of bills aren't really partisan in nature.
- 21:35Sometimes they're just simply renaming a road or, you know, bolstering some mental health
- 21:42service, and that's a pretty bipartisan issue.
- 21:47All sorts of things that you can find where it's like, oh, okay.
- 21:51There's not really a whole lot of dissension here.
- 21:53There might be, like, a few stragglers, but it's not really necessarily a partisan thing.
- 21:58It's it's just it is a pretty sizable proportion of both Democrats and Republicans
- 22:03supporting these things.
- 22:04And and you also will have lots of bills that will even have a sponsor or a cosponsor.
- 22:10That is to say that's someone who takes it upon themselves to stump for support in the bill or
- 22:15for the bill.
- 22:16So they go to their legislative buddies, you know, trying to do a little bit of wheeling and
- 22:22dealing, say, hey.
- 22:23I'll support that bill if you support this one.
- 22:25And sometimes it'll be a republican doing it for a an originally democratic bill or a
- 22:30democrat doing it for an originally Republican bill.
- 22:32Now in fairness, some bills are considered bipartisan even when they only have a handful
- 22:38or maybe even one member of the minority party support it, but
- 22:42it is still noteworthy to find
- 22:45somebody who is bucking the trend of their party and supporting a certain bill.
- 22:51We should still
- 22:52recognize that, but at the same time,
- 22:56we realize that it's hard to call that bipartisan if it's only one member of the
- 23:01opposite party.
- 23:02But nonetheless, a lot more bills get both parties to agree
- 23:06on them than you would expect.
- 23:09Now how about some similarities and differences on particular political issues and policies?
- 23:14So, again, if you look at simple yes or no opinions for the broadest policies, then, yeah,
- 23:21the two parties are often going to differ.
- 23:23Republicans oppose abortion and gun control.
- 23:26Democrats generally support both of those things.
- 23:29But as said in the previous section, a lot
- 23:32of policies aren't really inherently partisan.
- 23:36And so you'll sometimes see some unusual alliances.
- 23:40And now if we talk about the party organization, these campaigning groups who try
- 23:45to stump for these candidates and trying to get voters to turn out, you'll see some unusual
- 23:52alliances there making strange bedfellows, especially on ballot measures because ballot
- 23:59measures can be about a whole bunch of different things.
- 24:02And a lot of times, they're not partisan in nature.
- 24:05Down here in Florida, for example, I could tell you measures relating to the environment here
- 24:10have had both Republican and Democratic support due to the importance of tourism in the state.
- 24:15But then there's also been Republican and Democratic groups that might have opposed it
- 24:19because they thought, oh, this is actually not really an environmental bill.
- 24:22It's it's it's in disguise.
- 24:24What this would actually do is, you know, something that harms
- 24:28the environment.
- 24:29But in any case, it got Democratic and Republican groups on the same side.
- 24:35I wanna say also, if I remember correctly, there's a lot of talk about banning cell phones
- 24:41in schools and what certain technology should
- 24:43be allowed in schools.
- 24:44And I believe it's teachers' unions and moms for liberty that have been on the same page on
- 24:51a lot of that stuff.
- 24:52And those two groups are not typically in alignment.
- 24:56Teachers unions tend to be Democrat.
- 24:59Mobs for Liberty tends to be Republican, but yet they're both aligning on certain policies
- 25:04relating to schools.
- 25:05And then there's also, according to the election reformers network, initiatives in 2024
- 25:12that would have made it more difficult to propose ballot measures in Arizona, Colorado,
- 25:17and North Dakota were defeated by sizable numbers of both Democrats and Republicans,
- 25:21including a lot of counties that had voted for Donald Trump, which some people might have
- 25:25expected to actually support these ballot measures that would have made it harder to
- 25:31propose ballot initiatives, but it actually did the opposite.
- 25:36And it had sizable enough support where you can't actually directly look at what these
- 25:42voters, whether it's a Democrat or Republican voted on these things unless they tell you in a
- 25:47poll.
- 25:48You can't actually go into these databases and say, oh, well, which which thing do they vote
- 25:52on?
- 25:52No.
- 25:53It doesn't actually tell you that.
- 25:54They can ask voters or they can get a little bit of an intuition based on data that's on
- 26:01their voter file or if they are a campaigning arm that has looked them up and says, oh, well,
- 26:06they have all this stuff in their lawn that suggests they're a democrat or something on
- 26:11their truck that suggested they're republican.
- 26:13They might be able to insinuate what they voted on.
- 26:16But nonetheless, these measures to try to make ballot measures more difficult to propose, you
- 26:23could tell by the vote shares defeating these bills that a sizable number of both Democrats
- 26:30and Republicans came together to defeat these bills.
- 26:34But then even if you look at these partisan and ideological policies, you start to see some
- 26:39agreement when you are breaking them down into more specific instances.
- 26:44And this is where you get into what's called ambivalence, basically conflicting opinions
- 26:49about an issue.
- 26:51When you start looking at specific provisions, you might say, I agree with this provision, but
- 26:57not this provision.
- 26:58Abortion, for example, sees a lot more variance in Democratic support and Republican opposition
- 27:04depending on the context you're talking about.
- 27:06Like, if you're talking about the life of the mother being at stake, tends to see a
- 27:09lot more support from both parties.
- 27:11Or if
- 27:12the baby has a possibility of significant health challenges, there can be some
- 27:18fluctuation in how much democrats support it and how much republicans oppose it.
- 27:23Really just depends on the context.
- 27:25Now if you just say, oh, do you support abortion or do you not?
- 27:28It's gonna be a different story than if you say, what about this specific context?
- 27:32And another great example of that is gun control.
- 27:35And I'll use back in 2018 for Florida state government despite it being much more
- 27:42Republican.
- 27:43Back in 2018, we had the sad, the the Parkland School massacre that Marjorie Stoneman Douglas
- 27:50High School, and the state government responded despite being mostly Republican.
- 27:55It responded with raising the age to buy guns from 18 to 21 years old.
- 28:01And they also declined to institute open carry and campus carry for some time, although those
- 28:07policies have changed within the past year.
- 28:10But nonetheless, you found a lot of democratic and republican agreement on these two issues
- 28:15that tend to be very clearly designated this side as Democrat, this side
- 28:20as Republican.
- 28:22Despite what you would expect, they
- 28:24found some common ground.
- 28:26And sometimes it depended on the actual context and what what extenuating circumstances
- 28:31happened, but nonetheless, you still found common ground there.
- 28:36And then one last bit of data I'll point to was a 2022 report by YouGov on 100 policies that
- 28:44majorities of both Democrats and Republican voters had supported under various policy
- 28:50topics.
- 28:51So a couple of education policies where you saw majorities of Democrats and Republicans voters
- 28:56support was increasing spending on security services and mental health programs on public
- 29:02schools and providing free lunch to low income students in public schools, elections and
- 29:07government banning lobbyists from participating in redistricting and limiting how much money
- 29:13groups that are unaffiliated with a candidate are able to spend on campaign ads.
- 29:18When it came to policing and crime, both parties largely agreed on outfitting all police
- 29:24officers, excuse me, with body cameras and requiring law enforcement agencies to report
- 29:29data on the use of force.
- 29:32And then with technology, ensuring universal access to high speed Internet.
- 29:36And many of these are still being discussed and worked on in the twenty twenty six legislative
- 29:41sessions, and they were being discussed in the last year's legislative sessions.
- 29:45But you see how voters, party and electorate, found a lot of agreement on some of these
- 29:51policies, and certain polarized interests might be trying to tell you, oh, well, Republicans
- 29:56won't actually support that.
- 29:57Democrats won't actually support that.
- 29:59But, no, you find that a lot
- 30:00of them actually do.
- 30:02You just have to look
- 30:05a little bit harder and you just have to not take polarized interests at their word.
- 30:10So similarities and differences with the level of government.
- 30:13So federal versus state versus local.
- 30:16Already demonstrated that there are a lot of bills that federal and state legislatures find
- 30:20bipartisan support on, though, of course, there is a lot of pronounced division at those levels
- 30:25too.
- 30:26But local level government tends to see far less division than federal and state
- 30:31government, and that's for several reasons, for several major reasons at least.
- 30:36For one thing, they are much closer to their constituents, so they are the most localized
- 30:41and ingrained in their communities relative to state and federal governments.
- 30:45It's a lot easier to be abrasive and incite people when you're not meeting them day to day,
- 30:51or when you are actually meeting them, you just get to talk to people that think just like you.
- 30:56The policies that local government focuses focuses on is also the most day to day
- 31:02essential nonpartisan issues that the community is most directly impacted by.
- 31:07And these town halls for local government are also a lot easier to attend and directly engage
- 31:13with local officials in and build relationships because they are so close to the community by
- 31:19default.
- 31:20Meanwhile, federal and state officials have a lot more relationships to maintain.
- 31:24They can also big dog you and say, oh, well, you're not worth my time.
- 31:27I'm gonna talk to these bigger donors or these bigger interest groups that have more
- 31:31influence.
- 31:32And they also interact more with interest special interests that are not connected with a
- 31:38particular community.
- 31:39Whereas if you're talking to your county commissioner,
- 31:42they are focused on your county.
- 31:44Most of
- 31:44the time, sometimes there will be some outside influence, but it doesn't happen nearly as
- 31:48often as it does or like it does with the state and federal governments or your city council or
- 31:54your mayor, they're gonna be focused on your city.
- 31:56And so local level government will actually find a lot of common ground on a bunch of
- 32:01different areas because, a, they are a
- 32:04lot more nonpartisan, and b, it's they're just so much closer to people, and so they actually
- 32:11can hear more easily what people want directly.
- 32:16So
- 32:17some of these places of agreement that you often see, maybe not necessarily how to go
- 32:22about making these policies happen, but at least the basic idea of these policies they
- 32:28agree on.
- 32:29So, you know, when you talk about infrastructure and utilities like repairing
- 32:32roads, upgrading water systems, managing waste, Those aren't partisan issues.
- 32:38Public safety and services like funding police, fire, and EMS services and parks.
- 32:45Now the I know funding police can get a little bit more of a partisan issue.
- 32:52But still compared to what a lot of other issues can be, it's not as partisan as a lot of
- 32:58things, at least not at the local level as much, even though you do sometimes see it.
- 33:04But you still have fire and emergency medical services.
- 33:08Those aren't partisan.
- 33:09Parks aren't partisan.
- 33:12There's also regional cooperation, so they're collaborating with nearby communities on
- 33:17housing and transportation, disaster planning that crosses these community boundary lines.
- 33:24And so even when there is disagreement, it's much less common for it to be based on
- 33:29partisanship.
- 33:30And that's not just because a lot of local offices are considered nonpartisan.
- 33:33It's just the nature of their work tends to be much less partisan.
- 33:37Not that there isn't any partisanship because there is.
- 33:40We've seen it a lot with school boards, for example, but you still see a lot less of it.
- 33:46And it's the last point I will get on to about similarities and differences when it comes to
- 33:52these specific values.
- 33:53Because ultimately, what is behind policy values is, or excuse me, what's behind policy
- 33:59views is our values and how we perceive those values.
- 34:04So a republican and a democrat can both highly value public safety, but a republican could see
- 34:11open carry as necessary to promote public safety while a democrat sees open carry as
- 34:16antithetical to public safety.
- 34:19Those values are the same.
- 34:21How to achieve those values tangibly
- 34:25isn't the same, but
- 34:27there is still a point to start with.
- 34:29There is some data point where you could say, okay,
- 34:32we both want the same thing.
- 34:34We just need to figure out a way to hash this out.
- 34:39Now values can also look like policies themselves, but really they are the essence of
- 34:45these policies.
- 34:46What is ultimately driving these policies?
- 34:50And so there are a lot of values that you can point to from the basic to the more specific.
- 34:55So your basic value might be freedom, but then if you get more specific, you're talking about
- 35:00the freedom of speech or of press or of assembly to petition of religion.
- 35:07And so I want to highlight two studies here in this regard to show just how much we actually
- 35:14share in common when it comes to these values, a lot of these things that Americans in general
- 35:19share.
- 35:20And so first, I'm gonna share an Associated Press National Opinion Research Center poll
- 35:27from 2024.
- 35:29So, look at these values and how much there is agreement on these fundamental rights.
- 35:36For the right of everyone to equal protection under the law, the right to vote, freedom of
- 35:41speech, at least 90% of respondents said that those were either very important or extremely
- 35:48important.
- 35:49Freedom of the press, right of the people to assemble peaceably, excuse me, the freedom of
- 35:55religion, the right to privacy, those had at least 77% or more respondents say that those
- 36:02were very important or extremely important.
- 36:05Even the right to keep and bear arms, which definitely has more of a republican symbolism
- 36:11to it, but even then that still has 54% of people say that that is very important or
- 36:17extremely important.
- 36:18And even though those people who didn't say very or extremely important, there's still a
- 36:21lot
- 36:21of them that said somewhat important.
- 36:24So, you're seeing
- 36:27levels of agreement that you would not expect if you were just going to say, oh, well, look
- 36:32how divided we are.
- 36:34We can't agree on anything.
- 36:36Well, no.
- 36:37There's certainly things we can't agree on.
- 36:39And with just how many people are agreeing on it, clearly, it's a sizable number of Democrats
- 36:44and Republicans and independents too.
- 36:46Obviously, this is talking more about Democrats or Republicans because those are the ones that
- 36:50tend to be considered as diametrically opposing each other.
- 36:55But nonetheless, you see just how much they have in common when it
- 37:01comes to those values.
- 37:03And then so the next piece I wanna show you is actually a civic profile study that my guest
- 37:11from a
- 37:12few weeks ago, Daniel Yudkin promoted and also worked on and really fascinating stuff.
- 37:19This study looked at what people considered to be their civic responsibilities.
- 37:25And the study looked at each of these specific points here to say, What do you think is a
- 37:33basic civic responsibility?
- 37:35And so one of the biggest points of agreement, if not the biggest point of agreement, is that
- 37:4193 of the respondents in the survey from the study agreed that now more than ever, it is
- 37:46important to honor our civic responsibilities.
- 37:50Now, of course, there is some difference on what those civic responsibilities were, but
- 37:55even so, you can look here and see at least 33 of Republicans and at least 38% of Democrats
- 38:05agreed that at one of these points, at least one
- 38:08of these points, one of
- 38:10these values was part of our civic responsibilities.
- 38:13Even things that you expect to be more symbolically tied to one party or the other,
- 38:19like honoring the flag.
- 38:21That is a very symbolically Republican thing.
- 38:2589% of Republicans supported that.
- 38:28But look here, 69% of Democrats also said that was a civic responsibility.
- 38:34Or how about we go and look at supporting equality?
- 38:38More symbolically democratic, 83% of democrats supported it as a civic responsibility.
- 38:45But look here, 64% of republicans also said that was a civic responsibility.
- 38:50And that's only looking at people saying that is it a civic responsibility.
- 38:54That's not necessarily looking at people who say it's not a civic responsibility, but if
- 38:58they still think it's important because some people
- 39:00might interpret the question that way.
- 39:03So really,
- 39:04that's a pretty substantial amount of agreement even if you look at some here where it looks
- 39:09like, oh, Republicans are so far out here.
- 39:12Democrats are so far out here.
- 39:14But you still see a sizable proportion of both parties agree on at least one of these things
- 39:19here being part of your civic responsibilities.
- 39:25And I think we should take some comfort in that.
- 39:28When you show people how much they have in common, they become a lot more amenable to
- 39:33finding common ground, just simply listening to moderating their attitudes.
- 39:38And that's really how you actually start to get things done.
- 39:40That doesn't mean that you can't stand your ground on certain views.
- 39:44That doesn't mean that you can't be very adamant on certain principles or that you
- 39:49should just be flailing in the wind as soon as somebody says an even moderately compelling
- 39:56argument.
- 39:57You should still have some sort of basic values,
- 40:01but to the point where you're just so hardened and you just don't bother to listen to anybody
- 40:07because you think you've that you've got
- 40:09it figured out or just just that there is no room for common ground.
- 40:14Sometimes you hear people say compromise, and compromise is often considered a dirty word
- 40:19because they think, oh, I'm
- 40:20compromising myself or I'm going back on my word about things.
- 40:25I think it's much more effective to talk about it as a common ground perspective.
- 40:29You're not giving up on any beliefs, but you are at least trying to see things from other
- 40:37people's perspectives because you realize, oh, wait, you know what?
- 40:40Maybe I don't have the other side quote unquote figured out.
- 40:44Maybe there is something that we can actually agree on here, and you'd be surprised just what
- 40:51you can find to agree on there.
- 40:53But that's gonna do it for today's episode of the Politics with Paul Podcast.
- 40:57As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 40:59Please like, comment, share, and subscribe, and rate and review on YouTube and Spotify and
- 41:05Apple Podcasts.
- 41:06And if this expands to other podcast platforms, please rate and review those as well.
- 41:12My links in the show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, medium.com profile, my five day educational
- 41:17email course about how to more effectively mitigate polarization in
- 41:21this country, very relevant to this topic in particular.
- 41:25My email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com, and believe that's it.
- 41:32Oh, my website, Paul Raider dot org.
- 41:34So that's gonna wrap things up here for today.
- 41:37So thank you so much again, and we'll see you next time.