Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Use Take Rate Cuts to Jumpstart Growth
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this idea in marketplace economics that feels almost backwards at first: sometimes you make more money by charging less. Luna: You mean cutting your commission — your take rate — to drive more transactions? Lucas: Exactly. It sounds like you're leaving money on the table, but a growing number of platforms have tested it and found that the volume response more than compensates. The key is understanding how elastic your marketplace is to the take rate itself. Luna: And that's what we're digging into today — when and why a marketplace should lower its take rate to jumpstart growth. Lucas: Right. And I want to anchor this with a specific example from eBay. In early 2023, eBay cut its final value fee on luxury handbags from something like 13.25 percent down to 6.5 percent for listings above $2,000. That's a pretty dramatic cut — roughly half. Luna: Wow. Why handbags specifically? That seems like a narrow category to experiment on. Lucas: It was strategic. Luxury handbags — think Chanel, Hermès, Louis Vuitton — are a high-consideration, high-price category where sellers had been migrating to competitors like The RealReal and Vestiaire Collective. eBay was losing supply in that premium tier. So they lowered the take rate to entice sellers back, betting that the volume of listings and final sale prices would grow enough to offset the lower per-transaction revenue. Luna: And did it work? Lucas: Based on what eBay shared in subsequent earnings calls, the category saw a significant uptick in listings — double-digit growth quarter over quarter — and the average selling price actually increased because more high-end items were listed. eBay's take rate on that segment dropped, but total dollar revenue from the category grew because there were many more transactions. Luna: So it's a volume play. Lower price per transaction, more transactions, higher total revenue. That's basic elasticity — but in a marketplace context, it's complicated by network effects. Lucas: That's exactly the twist. When you cut the take rate on one side, you're not just affecting that side's behavior. More supply attracts more demand, and that demand in turn makes the platform more valuable for all sellers. So the initial revenue sacrifice can compound into a much larger marketplace over time. Luna: Upwork did something similar in 2024, right? They reduced their fee on large, long-term projects. Lucas: Yeah, Upwork cut its take rate from 5 percent to 3 percent on contracts over $10,000. That's a forty percent reduction. Their logic was that high-value clients were often taking relationships off-platform after the first project to avoid the fee. By lowering the take rate, they hoped to keep those relationships inside the ecosystem, capture more lifetime value, and increase the total volume of high-value work. Luna: And that's a different kind of elasticity. It's not just about price sensitivity — it's about retaining trust and reducing the incentive to disintermediate. Lucas: Exactly. Disintermediation is the silent killer for marketplaces. If your take rate is too high, the best participants will find ways to bypass you. So cutting the take rate can be a defensive move as much as a growth move. Luna: Let's talk about the math. How do platforms figure out the right take rate to cut without leaving too much money on the table? Lucas: It comes down to estimating the elasticity of transaction volume with respect to take rate. If you lower your commission by one percentage point, how many more transactions do you expect? That's hard to know in advance, which is why many platforms run experiments — they test a lower take rate in a specific category or geography and measure the response. Luna: So it's not a blanket strategy. It only works if the marketplace has untapped liquidity — if there are buyers and sellers who are ready to transact but are being held back by the fee. Lucas: That's the key insight. A take rate cut isn't a growth hack for every marketplace. If your platform is already at full capacity — every potential transaction is happening — then cutting the fee just destroys revenue. But most marketplaces, especially in early or growth stages, have latent demand and supply that are price-sensitive. Luna: And there's a timing element too. Cutting the take rate too early, before you have strong network effects, might just mean you're subsidizing transactions that would have happened anyway. Lucas: Right. That's why you often see take rate cuts in mature categories where the platform is losing share, like eBay with handbags, or in segments where off-platform leakage is high, like Upwork with large projects. It's a targeted tool, not a universal lever. Luna: What about the opposite — raising the take rate? Some marketplaces do that as they gain dominance. Lucas: Sure, and that's the classic playbook: build liquidity first, then monetize. But there's a risk. If you raise your take rate too much, you invite competition. That's what happened with eBay in the 2000s — their fee increases opened the door for Etsy and others in niche categories. Luna: So the optimal take rate is dynamic. It changes as the marketplace matures and competitive landscape shifts. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings us to the concept of take rate elasticity. If a marketplace has a high elasticity — meaning a small fee change causes a large volume change — then cutting the rate can boost total revenue. But if elasticity is low, you're better off keeping the rate high. Luna: And how do you know which one you have? Lucas: You run experiments. A/B test a lower take rate on a subset of users. Measure the change in transaction volume, average order value, and retention. Also look at whether the new transactions are incremental or just cannibalizing existing ones. That's the hard part. Luna: Also, consider the messaging. If you announce a permanent fee cut, sellers might delay listings waiting for further cuts. So some platforms make it temporary or conditional. Lucas: Good point. eBay's handbag fee cut was initially framed as a promotional period, which created urgency. Later they made it permanent after seeing the results. That's a smart way to test without committing long-term. Luna: Another example: Airbnb's fee structure shift in 2020. They moved from a mostly host-paid model to a split-fee model, effectively lowering the take rate on hosts in many cases. That was partly to encourage more supply during the pandemic downturn. Lucas: Yeah, and that's a different angle — using take rate changes to manage through a crisis. When demand collapsed, they needed to keep hosts on the platform, so they reduced the cost of listing. That's a defensive cut. Luna: Let's zoom out. For a founder building a marketplace today, what's the big lesson from these stories? Lucas: I'd say: don't treat your take rate as sacred. It's a lever, not an identity. Test it, measure the elasticity, and be willing to cut it when the math supports it. But also be aware that once you lower it, raising it again is very hard — sellers and buyers will resist. Luna: So it's a one-way ratchet in practice. You can lower, but raising is politically difficult. Lucas: Exactly. That's why the decision to cut should be intentional and backed by data. You don't want to be in a position where you need to raise it later because you cut too aggressively. Luna: Honestly, if today's episode was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That kind of support is what keeps this show free and independent. Lucas: Yeah, and it really does make a difference. We don't run ads, so listener contributions are what let us keep drilling into these topics. The site is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, all one word. Luna: Okay, back to take rates. One more thing I want to touch on is the competitive dynamic. If you cut your take rate, competitors might follow. Lucas: That's the risk of a race to the bottom. If every marketplace in a category starts slashing fees, eventually no one makes money. The key is to differentiate on something other than price — better matching, higher quality, faster service — so that your take rate isn't the only reason people choose you. Luna: Right. A take rate cut is a tactic, not a strategy. The best marketplaces use it sparingly and in specific segments. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the thread we'll pick up next time — how marketplaces can build moats that let them maintain higher take rates without losing users. Luna: Sounds good. For now, I think the headline is: take rate cuts can unlock growth, but only when you understand your marketplace's elasticity. Lucas: And test, test, test. Thanks for listening. Luna: See you next time.