Latest / Secrets of the Centuries / The First Crusade - (1096–1099) Holy Land
Transcript
- 0:00I want you to picture something for a second.
- 0:02Just put yourself right in this scene. Oh, this
- 0:05is a good one to visualize. Right? So it's late
- 0:09autumn, November 1095. You are standing in this
- 0:13open, incredibly muddy field in Clermont, which
- 0:16is in southern France. And it is freezing. Exactly.
- 0:20The air is just biting. It's, you know, that
- 0:22damp, bone -chilling cold that just seeps right
- 0:25through your cloak. And you aren't alone out
- 0:27there. Not at all. You are surrounded by hundreds,
- 0:30I mean, maybe even thousands of people. You've
- 0:33got bishops shivering in these thin robes, rough
- 0:36-hewn knights, and local farmers who literally
- 0:38just walked off their fields to be there. And
- 0:40we should point out just the logistics of that
- 0:43are wild. I mean, gathering that many people
- 0:45in a medieval field without any modern infrastructure,
- 0:48it's a total nightmare. Yeah, a complete mess.
- 0:51But all of you are staring at this wooden platform.
- 0:55And standing up there is an aging man. He's speaking
- 0:59to this shivering crowd for, well, less than
- 1:01an hour. Which is pretty short for a speech that
- 1:04changes the world. Right, but think about the
- 1:06physics of this for a second. There are no microphones.
- 1:09No amplifiers. None. He is basically just shouting
- 1:12into the cold wind, his voice is probably cracking,
- 1:15and he's just desperately trying to reach the
- 1:17back rows. And he has no money to hand out either.
- 1:20Exactly. He doesn't command a standing army.
- 1:22He's not a king. He doesn't wear a crown. He
- 1:25is armed with literally nothing but theology,
- 1:28some very terrifying descriptions, and this wildly
- 1:31audacious idea. That's the crazy part. Because
- 1:35the man is Pope Urban II. And the words he screams
- 1:39out into that cold French air, they prompt tens
- 1:42of thousands of people from absolute beggars
- 1:45all the way up to the highest nobility to literally
- 1:47take out their knives. Just right there in the
- 1:49field. Right there. They cut up their clothing
- 1:51and they start sewing pieces of cloth in the
- 1:54shape of crosses under their shoulders. It's
- 1:55just mass of hysteria. It is. And over the next
- 1:59few years, these people will liquidate absolutely
- 2:01everything they own. They begin this march of
- 2:04over 2000 miles on foot or, you know, horseback
- 2:08toward a city most of them have only ever heard
- 2:11about in Sunday sermons. And we really have to
- 2:13emphasize the sheer physical reality of that
- 2:15march for the listener. They are basically walking
- 2:18into a geographical void. They've no idea what's
- 2:21out there. Right. They will endure a staggering
- 2:24thirst, like the kind of thirst that makes men
- 2:27drink animal blood. They deal with fever, starvation,
- 2:30and just these storms of arrows and lands they
- 2:33could never, ever point to on a map. And it all
- 2:36starts here. So our mission for today's Deep
- 2:38Dive is to figure out exactly how this happened.
- 2:41Because we're talking about the First Crusade.
- 2:43Which spans roughly from 1096 to 1099. Yeah.
- 2:47And we want to uncover how this quiet incredibly
- 2:50bureaucratic request from an emperor in the East,
- 2:53who just wanted a few professional mercenaries,
- 2:56somehow spiraled into a continent -wide, world
- 2:59-altering armed migration. It is the ultimate
- 3:03unintended consequence. Okay, let's unpack this
- 3:06because the myth you and I usually get in pop
- 3:08culture is this grand, organized, very shiny
- 3:12holy war. With the pristine white tunics and
- 3:15red crosses. Right, like a movie. But the historical
- 3:17reality is completely unhinged. It is messy.
- 3:21It is full of divided empires, astonishing misunderstandings,
- 3:25and just massive, catastrophic collateral damage.
- 3:28To even begin to understand how that huge crowd
- 3:31gathered in that French field, we actually have
- 3:33to leave France completely. Wait, really? We
- 3:36have to leave where it started? Yeah. We have
- 3:38to travel thousands of miles to the east to see
- 3:41the geopolitical crisis that actually triggered
- 3:43the initial plea for help. Okay. That makes sense.
- 3:46Because if you lived in the 11th century, you
- 3:48have to understand that there was no such thing
- 3:50as a single, united Christian world. I mean,
- 3:53it was a deeply fractured religion. Right. It
- 3:56was basically split right down the middle into
- 3:58two distinct civilizations that, frankly, just
- 4:00did not understand each other. And often couldn't
- 4:02stand each other. Yeah. So in the West, you had
- 4:05the Latin world. This is what we now call France,
- 4:09Germany, Italy, England. And if we're being completely
- 4:12honest, it was a violent, chaotic mess. It really
- 4:15was. You had this absolute patchwork of small
- 4:18kingdoms, dukedoms, and counties. The nobility
- 4:21in the West basically viewed warfare as their
- 4:23primary occupation. It was what they were bred
- 4:25to do. Exactly. They just spent their time fighting
- 4:28each other over patches of dirt or perceived
- 4:30slights to their honor or these old family grudges.
- 4:33And the Pope in Rome claimed spiritual authority,
- 4:35sure, but secular kings often just totally ignored
- 4:39him when it suited them. Which happens a lot.
- 4:41But then you cross the Mediterranean and you
- 4:44look to the east. and you find a completely different
- 4:47creature entirely. Right. The Byzantine Empire.
- 4:49Ruled from this massive, heavily fortified city
- 4:52of Constantinople. And a quick note on terminology
- 4:55here, which is important for the listener. They
- 4:58didn't actually call themselves Byzantines. Oh,
- 5:00right. That's a historical invention, isn't it?
- 5:02Exactly. That's a term historians just made up
- 5:04centuries later to keep things straight. They
- 5:06called themselves Romans. Because politically
- 5:09and legally, they just... were the Roman Empire.
- 5:12Right. They were the unbroken eastern half of
- 5:14the old Roman Empire. They were Greek speaking,
- 5:17but legally Roman. Wait, really unbroken? Because
- 5:20I always think of the Roman Empire falling in
- 5:22the 400s, you know, with the barbarians sacking
- 5:24Rome and all that. A lot of people think that.
- 5:27But only the western half fell. Constantinople
- 5:29just kept right on going for another thousand
- 5:31years. That is wild to think about. And to a
- 5:35rough, illiterate knight living in some drafty
- 5:37stone keep in the French countryside, Constantinople
- 5:39would look like a literal alien civilization.
- 5:42Because of the infrastructure, right? Yeah, it
- 5:44had paved streets, working aqueducts, this massively
- 5:48complex bureaucratic civil service, and half
- 5:50a million people living inside its walls. Half
- 5:53a million. To put that in perspective for you,
- 5:55a large town in Western Europe at the time maybe
- 5:57had 10 ,000 people tops. That is mind -boggling.
- 6:02It's like someone from a tiny rural village today
- 6:04suddenly being dropped into the middle of downtown
- 6:07Tokyo. That's a perfect comparison. But as our
- 6:10sources detail, by the late 11th century, this
- 6:13ancient, proud Roman Empire was actually bleeding
- 6:16out. It was. It was facing this existential crisis
- 6:19from the East. The Seljuk Turks had arrived.
- 6:22And who were they exactly? For the listener who
- 6:24might not know. Well, the Seljuks were on nomadic
- 6:26people who had swept out of the Central Asian
- 6:29steppes, converted to Sunni Islam, and basically
- 6:31built a massive, rapidly expanding empire of
- 6:34their own. And militarily, they were terrifying,
- 6:37right? Arguably the finest light cavalry and
- 6:39horse archers in the entire world. And they were
- 6:41pressing incredibly hard against the Byzantine
- 6:43frontier in Anatolia. Which is modern -day Turkey.
- 6:47Exactly. And let's be clear about what Anatolia
- 6:49meant to Constantinople. It wasn't just some
- 6:51remote, rocky borderland that no one cared about.
- 6:53No, it was everything. It was their breadbasket.
- 6:56It was the heartland where they grew their grain,
- 6:59where the imperial tax collectors gathered most
- 7:00of their wealth. And most importantly, it was
- 7:03the traditional recruiting ground for their armies.
- 7:05Right. So if you lose Anatolia, you basically
- 7:08lose the engine of the entire empire. Which is
- 7:10exactly what happens. The absolute breaking point
- 7:13is the year 1071 at a place called Manzikert.
- 7:16Yeah, the Byzantine Emperor at the time, a guy
- 7:19named Romanos IV, decides he just has to stop
- 7:23the Turkish incursions. So he takes an army out?
- 7:25He marches out into eastern Anatolia with a massive
- 7:28force to crush the Seljuks once and for all,
- 7:31but the campaign is just a master class and disaster.
- 7:33How bad are we talking? Well, due to a combination
- 7:36of terrible battlefield coordination, some really
- 7:39bad luck, and outright blatant treachery from
- 7:41his own political rivals who literally command
- 7:45wings of his army. Wait, his own men betrayed
- 7:47him during the battle? Yes. They just abandoned
- 7:50him on the field. And because of that, the Byzantine
- 7:53forces are just completely shattered. And the
- 7:55outcome for the emperor himself is completely
- 7:58unthinkable. Unprecedented. Emperor Romanus IV
- 8:01isn't just defeated. He is physically captured
- 8:04alive by the Turkish Sultan, Alp Arslan. That
- 8:08is a tectonic shift in the medieval world. I
- 8:11mean, an anointed Roman ruler dragged into the
- 8:13tent of a nomadic chieftain as a prisoner of
- 8:15war. It must have felt like the end of the world
- 8:17to them. It totally shattered the aura of Byzantine
- 8:20invincibility. Now, interestingly, the sources
- 8:23say the Sultan actually treats him with immense
- 8:25courtesy, negotiates a ransom and just releases
- 8:28him. Which is surprisingly chill. But the real
- 8:31danger wasn't the Sultan, right? It was Romanos'
- 8:34own people. Exactly. Because when he gets back
- 8:37home, the political rivals who betrayed him and
- 8:39mansecured, they capture him and blind him. Yep.
- 8:44Which, as our sources dryly point out, was a
- 8:46very common, highly permanent way of settling
- 8:49leadership disputes in Byzantine politics. Because
- 8:52a blind man could not legally be emperor. It
- 8:54was a loophole. Wow. And with the emperor disgraced
- 8:58and the army totally shattered, the defense of
- 9:01Anatolia just evaporates. The Turks don't even
- 9:04have to launch a grand organized conquest. They
- 9:06basically just wander in. It's worse than a conquest.
- 9:09It's a collapse. Total collapse. Byzantine generals,
- 9:12who are currently fighting each other for the
- 9:14empty throne, start literally inviting Turkish
- 9:17warbands into Anatolia to act as their personal
- 9:20mercenaries. Just giving away the land to pay
- 9:22for internal squabbles. Yes, they pay these warlords
- 9:25with land. So within 20 years... Turkish rulers
- 9:28aren't just raiding anymore. They are holding
- 9:31major cities. You even have a Turkish prince
- 9:33who sets up his capital at Nicaea. And just to
- 9:37give you some geographical context, Nicaea is
- 9:39just a short, very pleasant horseback ride away
- 9:41from Constantinople itself. It is dangerously
- 9:44close. The emperor sitting in his palace can
- 9:46practically feel the Turks breathing down his
- 9:48neck. The buffer zone is completely gone. Which
- 9:51brings us to the man who actually has to clean
- 9:52up this colossal mess. Emperor Alexios I Komnenos.
- 9:57He seizes the Byzantine throne in a military
- 9:59coup in 1081. And he inherits a total nightmare.
- 10:02He's got the Turks deeply entrenched in the east.
- 10:05He's got nomadic Pechenegs raiding from the north.
- 10:08And from the west, the Normans. Wait, the same
- 10:11Normans who conquered England? The exact same
- 10:13guys. They are eyeing Byzantine lands in Greece
- 10:16with open hunger. So Alexios is surrounded. But
- 10:20he's an ultimate realist. He looks at his empire
- 10:22and realizes he simply can't raise massive native
- 10:25armies of farmer soldiers anymore. Because all
- 10:27those farms in Anatolia are currently occupied
- 10:30by Turkish warlords. Right. So he turns to classic
- 10:33Byzantine statecraft. He decides to buy an army.
- 10:37Constantinople had been hiring foreign mercenaries
- 10:40for centuries, right? Paying Vikings, the Rus,
- 10:43and Franks, and gold to fight their wars. So
- 10:46Alexios looks westward. He knows that Western
- 10:49Europe produces this endless supply of aggressive,
- 10:53heavily armored, and frankly, dangerously underemployed
- 10:56young men. And we really should talk about why
- 10:58they were underemployed, because this blew my
- 11:01mind when we were going through the sources.
- 11:02Oh, it's all about inheritance laws. Right. Primogenitor.
- 11:05Yes. In much of Western Europe, they practiced
- 11:08primogenitor, meaning the eldest son inherits
- 11:10everything. The castle, the land, the serfs,
- 11:14the entire state. So what happens to the second,
- 11:16third or fourth sons? They basically get a warhorse,
- 11:19an incredibly expensive suit of chainmail armor,
- 11:22a sword and a hearty good luck. They were a deeply
- 11:25destabilizing force in Europe. I mean, you have
- 11:27thousands of highly trained professional killers
- 11:30wandering around with absolutely no land and
- 11:32a terrible temper. A massive problem. The Catholic
- 11:35Church was constantly pulling its hair out trying
- 11:37to stop these rogue knights from attacking peasants,
- 11:39robbing merchants and literally extorting priests.
- 11:42They were a disaster looking for a place to happen.
- 11:46And Alexios looks at this surplus of Western
- 11:48violence and thinks, that is exactly the resource
- 11:51I need. So he makes a move. In March of 1095,
- 11:55he sends a diplomatic embassy to a church council
- 11:57in Piazenza, Italy. And he formally asks Pope
- 12:00Urban II for help. He says, send me soldiers.
- 12:03And here is where we must be incredibly precise
- 12:06about what Emperor Alexios was. actually asking
- 12:09for, because this is the core misunderstanding
- 12:12of the entire era. He didn't want a crusade.
- 12:15No, he wanted a few thousand manageable professional
- 12:18Western mercenaries, men he could pay with Byzantine
- 12:21gold, give specific tactical orders to, used
- 12:24to recapture a few key cities in Anatolia, and
- 12:27then send back home. He wanted a scalpel to do
- 12:29a very specific limited geopolitical surgery.
- 12:32Precisely. It's like a... It's like asking your
- 12:35neighbor if you can borrow their garden hose
- 12:37to put out a small brush fire in your backyard.
- 12:39Good analogy. And instead, your neighbor shows
- 12:41up with a wrecking ball, a flamethrower, and
- 12:43100 ,000 religious zealots chanting about the
- 12:45end of the world. That is exactly what happened.
- 12:47Because Pope Urban totally hijacked this request.
- 12:50And this brings up a huge question for me. Why?
- 12:54Did Urban actually care about the Byzantine Empire's
- 12:56borders, or was this entirely a cynical political
- 13:00power play? Well, to answer that, we have to
- 13:02look at what was happening to Urban II at that
- 13:05exact moment in history. He wasn't interested
- 13:08in acting as a temp agency for Byzantine mercenaries.
- 13:11Urban was locked in this bitter existential struggle
- 13:14known as the investiture controversy. Right.
- 13:17I've seen this term in the sources. Can you break
- 13:19down exactly what that means for the listener?
- 13:21Because investiture sounds like a really boring
- 13:23banking term. It sounds incredibly dry. I know.
- 13:26But it was basically a massive geopolitical wrestling
- 13:29match over who ruled the world. The pope or the
- 13:33Holy Roman Emperor in Germany. Exactly. Investiture
- 13:36was the physical act of giving a newly appointed
- 13:39bishop his ring and staff, the symbols of his
- 13:42office. OK, but why does that matter so much?
- 13:45Because bishops in the Middle Ages weren't just
- 13:47guys who gave sermons on Sunday. They controlled
- 13:49vast swathes of land, massive wealth, and sometimes
- 13:52they even had private armies. So whoever gets
- 13:54to appoint the bishop essentially controls a
- 13:56massive chunk of the economy and military power
- 13:58in that region. You nailed it. The Holy Roman
- 14:01Emperor said, These bishops live on my land,
- 14:04so I get to appoint them. The pope said, no,
- 14:07they are spiritual leaders. Only the church can
- 14:09appoint them. That's a huge conflict of interest.
- 14:11It got so vicious that the German emperor had
- 14:14literally marched an army down to Rome, driven
- 14:17Urban out of the city, and set up his own rival,
- 14:19puppet pope. Wait, so in 1095, Urban is effectively
- 14:23a pope on the run. Yes. He is literally governing
- 14:26the Catholic Church from the road in France.
- 14:28Wow. Okay, so when Alexios' ambassadors show
- 14:32up asking for a few thousand troops, Urban doesn't
- 14:35hear an administrative problem in the East. He
- 14:37hears the political opportunity of a lifetime.
- 14:40Exactly. This is his chance to show the German
- 14:43emperor who the real boss of Europe is. If he
- 14:46can raise a massive army that answers only to
- 14:48the papacy, he unites a fractured Christendom
- 14:50under his authority. Plus, he gets to solve the
- 14:53church's domestic problem by pointing all those
- 14:55violent landless knights at an external enemy.
- 14:58It is a masterstroke of political maneuvering,
- 15:02truly. So, we are back in that freezing field
- 15:05at the Council of Claremont in November 1095.
- 15:08Urban gets up on that wooden platform and he
- 15:11delivers what is arguably the most influential
- 15:13speech of the entire Middle Ages. Now, we don't
- 15:16have an exact transcript. The exact wording is
- 15:18lost to history because the chroniclers who recorded
- 15:21it wrote it down years later, heavily coloring
- 15:23it with the hindsight of what actually happened.
- 15:26They knew how it ended when they wrote it down.
- 15:28But the core mechanics of his argument are very
- 15:30clear across all the accounts. He paints this
- 15:33terrifying picture. He tells these French knights
- 15:35that their fellow Christians in the East are
- 15:37being slaughtered and tortured. He heavily exaggerates
- 15:41the desecration of holy places. And most importantly,
- 15:44he reminds them about Jerusalem. Which was the
- 15:47literal center of the medieval map, the city
- 15:48where Christ lived, died, and was resurrected.
- 15:51And it is currently held by non -believers. But
- 15:55he didn't just ask them to go fight a war. Kings
- 15:57asked knights to fight wars all the time. Urban
- 16:00offered them a spiritual technology that had
- 16:03never really been weaponized like this before.
- 16:05He offered a complete remission of sins. Okay,
- 16:08let's break down the mechanics of that. Why was
- 16:10that such a game changer for these guys? Well,
- 16:13you have to put yourself in the psychological
- 16:14mindset of an 11th century knight. You live in
- 16:17a society that is absolutely terrified of literal
- 16:21physical hellfire. It's very real to them. Very
- 16:23real. You are taught from birth that your soul
- 16:26hangs in the balance. But your entire profession,
- 16:28your entire social class, is built on warfare,
- 16:32killing, and extortion. The church is basically
- 16:34constantly telling you that your daily activities
- 16:36are mortal sins. Exactly. So you are basically
- 16:40guaranteed to go to hell just by doing your job.
- 16:42You are trapped in this constant state of spiritual
- 16:45anxiety. Oh man, that's heavy. So what Urban
- 16:48offers in that field is an irresistible loophole.
- 16:51He says that if you take this arduous physical
- 16:53journey to liberate Jerusalem, the hardship of
- 16:56the journey itself will act as a full penance
- 16:58for every sin you have ever committed. Your greatest
- 17:02sin, warfare, could now be the very instrument
- 17:05of your salvation. It was revolutionary. The
- 17:08psychological impact of that is just explosive.
- 17:11I mean, the sources say the crowd just roared
- 17:13in response. In their rough Latin and regional
- 17:16French dialects, they started screaming, Deus
- 17:18Vult. God wills it. Yes. A prominent cardinal
- 17:22immediately felt his knees in the mud begging
- 17:24to take the vow. People started frantically tearing
- 17:27up their own cloaks and sewing the strips into
- 17:30crosses on their shoulders to mark themselves.
- 17:32And this is a vital piece of trivia to keep in
- 17:34mind for you listening. They did not call themselves
- 17:37crusaders. No, that word didn't even exist yet.
- 17:40It wouldn't be coined for decades. They called
- 17:42themselves pilgrims or they said they were signed
- 17:45with the cross. They viewed this whole thing
- 17:47as an armed pilgrimage. But almost immediately,
- 17:51the sheer scale of the reaction completely shatters
- 17:53Urban's careful bureaucratic planning. Because
- 17:57Urban's timeline was actually very logical. He
- 17:59wanted organized, well -supplied armies, led
- 18:02by aristocratic noblemen, to leave in August
- 18:04of 1096. Right. After the summer harvest was
- 18:08brought in so they'd have food, he even appointed
- 18:10a papal legate. Bishop Atomar of the Pui to act
- 18:13as the spiritual commander in chief. But like
- 18:16we said earlier, you cannot spark a continent
- 18:19wide fire of apocalyptic religious fervor and
- 18:22then tell it to wait patiently for an agricultural
- 18:24schedule. You really can't. The fire caught in
- 18:28the dry tinder of the common people long before
- 18:30the nobility were even remotely ready. And this
- 18:34leads us to an incredibly tragic false start,
- 18:36which historians call the People's Crusade. This
- 18:39phenomenon reveals the terrifying, completely
- 18:42uncontrollable nature of mass religious passion.
- 18:45Urban's message essentially escaped the church's
- 18:48institutional control. Wandering, unsanctioned
- 18:51preachers took the message out of the cathedrals
- 18:53and into the rural villages and town squares.
- 18:56And the most famous of these was a man named
- 18:58Peter the Hermit. I am so fascinated by Peter
- 19:01the Hermit. He honestly sounds like a cult leader.
- 19:04He really does. Our sources describe him as this
- 19:07shabby, unwashed, intense man who rode around
- 19:10on a donkey, ate practically nothing, and possessed
- 19:13this unmatched hypnotic charisma. People were
- 19:16literally plucking hairs from his donkey's tail
- 19:19to keep his holy relics. That is so gross, but
- 19:22it shows the devotion. He was tapping into a
- 19:24deep vein of popular piety and profound economic
- 19:27desperation. He travels through northern France
- 19:30and into Germany, preaching this message of immediate
- 19:33salvation. And tens of thousands of people just
- 19:36drop everything to follow him. We are not talking
- 19:38about soldiers here. No. We are talking about
- 19:41peasant farmers leaving their plows in the field,
- 19:44blacksmiths, bakers, women, children, the elderly.
- 19:48There were a few impoverished knights mixed in.
- 19:51Guys with literal names like Walter the Pennyless.
- 19:53Great name. But structurally, it was a civilian
- 19:56mob. And they had absolutely no idea what they
- 19:59were doing or where they were going. Think about
- 20:01the logistics for a second. How do you feed 100
- 20:04,000 people on the move in the 11th century?
- 20:07You can't. You absolutely cannot. They had no
- 20:09supply train. They had no treasury to buy food.
- 20:12They had no maps. There is this truly tragic
- 20:15detail in one of our sources where it mentions
- 20:17that as this massive sprawling horde marched
- 20:21eastward, whenever they saw a large town in the
- 20:23distance, like in Germany or Hungary, the children
- 20:26would point at the walls and ask their parents,
- 20:28is this Jerusalem? And they were thousands of
- 20:31miles away. It just breaks your heart. But because
- 20:34they had no logistical support, reality set in
- 20:37very quickly. People have to eat. So this holy
- 20:39pilgrimage essentially mutated into a starving
- 20:43mob of locusts. They had to strip crops from
- 20:45the fields, steal livestock, and raid storehouses
- 20:48just to survive. And ironically, they were doing
- 20:51this in Christian lands in Eastern Europe. Local
- 20:54Hungarian and Bulgarian militias had to be called
- 20:57out to fight pitched bloody battles against the
- 21:00Crusaders just to protect their own towns from
- 21:02being sacked. And then the story of this unorganized
- 21:05fervor takes an incredibly dark, horrific turn.
- 21:09Because as bands of this popular movement were
- 21:12forming in the Rhineland area of Germany, some
- 21:14of the leaders, most notoriously a German count
- 21:17named Emiko, applied a twisted highly convenient
- 21:21logic to the Pope's call. It is a textbook example
- 21:24of how mob psychology devolves into atrocity.
- 21:28Count Emiko and his followers looked at the arduous
- 21:312 ,000 mile journey to the Middle East and essentially
- 21:33said, why should we march to the other side of
- 21:36the world to fight the enemies of Christ when
- 21:37the enemies of Christ live right here in our
- 21:39own cities? Meaning the Jewish communities. Yes.
- 21:42There were prosperous, deeply -rooted Jewish
- 21:45populations in major Rhineland cities like Speyer,
- 21:48Worms, Mainz, and Cologne. They were integrated
- 21:51into the local economies and enjoyed the protection
- 21:53of the local Catholic bishops and the Holy Roman
- 21:56Emperor. But what followed was a series of absolute
- 22:00unspeakable massacres. The mobs descended on
- 22:04these cities. Thousands of Jewish men, women,
- 22:07and children were slaughtered in their homes
- 22:08and synagogues, given the impossible choice of
- 22:12immediate conversion to Christianity or death.
- 22:15And it is critical to note that the institutional
- 22:18church never called for this. Pope Urban's appeal
- 22:21was entirely directed eastward against Muslims.
- 22:25Right, this was totally rogue. When the mobs
- 22:27arrived, local Catholic bishops in cities like
- 22:30Mainz actually opened their own fortified palaces
- 22:33to hide the Jewish population, sometimes at great
- 22:35personal physical risk to themselves. But the
- 22:38mobs just breach the palaces and overwhelm the
- 22:41bishop's guards. It's a bitter, terrifying early
- 22:44sign of the horrors unleashed when religious
- 22:46zealotry completely severs itself from any central
- 22:49authority. Eventually, the main body of this
- 22:52people's crusade the faction actually led by
- 22:55Peter the Hermit, staggers all the way to the
- 22:58massive walls of Constantinople in the summer
- 23:00of 1096. I always try to imagine Emperor Alexios
- 23:03standing on his balcony looking out over the
- 23:06plains. Right. He asked the pope for a few thousand
- 23:09highly disciplined, professional armored mercenaries.
- 23:12And instead, he has a starving, diseased, unhinged
- 23:15refugee camp of tens of thousands of civilians
- 23:18camped outside his gates. And they are already
- 23:20starting to loot the suburbs of his capital.
- 23:22He must have just put his head in his hands.
- 23:24Like, what have I done? Alexios does the only
- 23:27sensible thing a ruler can do in that situation.
- 23:29He gives them a massive donation of food and
- 23:32money, and he ferries them across the Bosporus
- 23:34straight into Asia Minor as fast as his boats
- 23:37can carry them. Just get them out of here. Exactly.
- 23:40Once they are on the Asian side, he gives Peter
- 23:42the Hermit a very strict warning. He says, do
- 23:45not march inland. Wait on the coast for the real
- 23:48armies of the Western lords to arrive. Do not
- 23:51provoke the Turks. Which, naturally, they immediately
- 23:53ignore. Completely. As soon as they are out of
- 23:56the emperor's sight, all discipline evaporates.
- 23:59The horde splinters into rival ethnic factions,
- 24:01chiefly the French and the Germans. And they
- 24:03become obsessed without doing each other in raiding
- 24:06the Turkish countryside for loot. They actually
- 24:08march inland and start pillaging villages right
- 24:11up to the walls of Nicaea. Which, remember, is
- 24:13the capital of the young Turkish sultan, Kilij
- 24:15Arslan. And Peter the Hermit just loses complete
- 24:18control over them. He actually gets so frustrated
- 24:20trying to stop the madness that he sails back
- 24:22to Constantinople to beg Alexios for help reining
- 24:25them in. Which means Peter providentially misses
- 24:27the absolute catastrophe that happens next. In
- 24:31October 1096, a rumor spreads through the main
- 24:34crusader camp on the coast. The rumor claims
- 24:36that a German splinter group has successfully
- 24:39captured the city of Nicaea and is currently
- 24:41dividing up a massive pile of Turkish treasure.
- 24:44The reaction is pure unthinking greed. The entire
- 24:48mass of people in the camp, the men, the women,
- 24:50the unarmed pilgrims, they just pour out of their
- 24:53encampment in a totally disorganized frantic
- 24:56column. Racing down the road toward Nicaea because
- 24:59they don't want to miss out on their share of
- 25:00the loot. But it was a trap. Nicaea hadn't fallen.
- 25:04Kilij Arslan was waiting for them. Oh no. The
- 25:07Sultan had brought his professional army of horse
- 25:09archers down out of the hills. They set up an
- 25:11ambush in a narrow wooded valley near a place
- 25:13called Sivet. And when the disorganized strung
- 25:16-out column of crusaders marched into the valley,
- 25:19the Turks just fell upon them. It wasn't a battle.
- 25:22It was an utter annihilation. The horse archers
- 25:25just poured arrows into the dense crowd. The
- 25:28few armed knights in the front were cut down
- 25:30instantly, and then the panic set in. The crowd
- 25:32tried to run, but they were slaughtered by the
- 25:35thousands. Our sources describe the aftermath.
- 25:38The bones of the people's crusade were so numerous
- 25:40that later travelers saw them piled up into grim,
- 25:44massive white walls on the Anatolian shore. The
- 25:46entire movement was wiped out in a single afternoon,
- 25:50having never even come close to seeing Jerusalem.
- 25:52It is a devastating end. But historically, it
- 25:55sets up a fatal miscalculation for the Turks.
- 25:59Kilijarslan rides over this battlefield, looks
- 26:01at the tens of thousands of dead peasants and
- 26:03rough -spun wool and concludes, well, that was
- 26:06incredibly easy. These Westerners, these Franks,
- 26:09are just a disorganized, unarmored rabble. They
- 26:12are zero threat to my empire. Which, to be very
- 26:15to the Sultan, is a perfectly reasonable deduction
- 26:17based on the hard data he had just collected.
- 26:21Entirely logical. But it was completely, disastrously
- 26:24wrong. Because the people he had just slaughtered
- 26:27weren't the army the Pope had summoned. No. The
- 26:31real army, the dukes, the lords, the professional
- 26:34killers encased in iron, were just finishing
- 26:37their preparations back in Europe. Right. While
- 26:39the peasants' bones were bleaching in the Anatolian
- 26:42sun, the true crusade was finally assembling.
- 26:46Let's talk about the leadership of this real
- 26:48army, because it's fascinating that not a single
- 26:51reigning king went on the first crusade. The
- 26:54geopolitical timing was terrible for kings. The
- 26:57King of France, Philip I, couldn't go because
- 27:00he had been excommunicated by the pope for adultery.
- 27:03Ouch. The Holy Roman Emperor in Germany, Henry
- 27:06IV, couldn't go because he was actively at war
- 27:09with the pope. And the King of England, William
- 27:11Rufus, simply wasn't interested in religious
- 27:14adventures. So the leadership vacuum is filled
- 27:16by the high nobility. These are dukes and counts
- 27:20who are basically kings in all but name, men
- 27:22accustomed to absolute authority on their own
- 27:24vast estates, and entirely unaccustomed to taking
- 27:28orders from anyone else. Which basically guarantees
- 27:31command dysfunction from day one. Yeah, you have
- 27:34Raymond of Toulouse, an immensely wealthy, proud,
- 27:37older nobleman from southern France. He brought
- 27:39his wife and a massive treasury, and he fully
- 27:42considered himself the natural secular leader
- 27:45of the entire expedition. You had Godfrey of
- 27:48Bouillon, a tall, famously pious duke from Lorraine,
- 27:51and his fiercely ambitious, highly capable younger
- 27:54brother, Baldwin. You also had Robert of Normandy,
- 27:57who was the eldest son of William the Conqueror.
- 27:59And we have to stop and talk about the financial
- 28:01cost to these men, because it is staggering.
- 28:04It really is. You mentioned earlier they were
- 28:06liquidating their assets. Breakdown would it
- 28:08actually cost to equip a knight for a multi -year
- 28:11journey in 1096? It was an astronomical capital
- 28:14investment. A trained war horse, a destrier,
- 28:17was bred for aggression and weight carrying capacity.
- 28:21One horse cost as much as a small functioning
- 28:23farm. Just for one horse. And a knight needed
- 28:26several horses plus pack animals. Then there's
- 28:29the armor. We aren't talking about solid plate
- 28:31armor. That comes centuries later. We are talking
- 28:33about chainmail howebergs. Now, how was that
- 28:36actually made? Because it sounds incredibly labor
- 28:38intensive. It is mind -numbing labor. A blacksmith
- 28:43has to draw out iron wire, cut it into individual
- 28:46rings, overlap the ends of each ring, punch a
- 28:49microscopic hole through the overlap, and insert
- 28:52a tiny rivet to seal it shut. That sounds like
- 28:55torture. A single shirt of mail covering a man
- 28:57to his knees could contain 30 to 40 ,000 individual
- 29:01rings. Wow. It took months to make. It weighed
- 29:0430 to 40 pounds, and it had to be constantly
- 29:07oiled to prevent rust. So to afford all this,
- 29:10plus wages for his foot soldiers, Robert of Normandy
- 29:13essentially mortgaged the entire Duchy of Normandy
- 29:16to his brother, the King of England, for 10 ,000
- 29:19marks of silver. Which is an insane amount of
- 29:22money. For you listening, 10 ,000 marks of silver
- 29:24in the 11th century is roughly equivalent to
- 29:27tens of millions of dollars today. It is the
- 29:30liquid wealth of an entire nation. They were
- 29:32betting their generational wealth on a terrifying,
- 29:34unprecedented gamble. And perhaps the most dangerous,
- 29:38complex, and militarily capable leader of them
- 29:41all was Beaumont of Toronto. Beaumont. Yeah.
- 29:44Beaumont was a Norman lord from southern Italy.
- 29:46He was a massive man, highly charismatic, and
- 29:49a brilliant tactical commander. But uniquely
- 29:53among the leadership, he and his family had spent
- 29:55the previous decade actively trying to invade
- 29:58the Byzantine Empire. Wait, really? He had personally
- 30:01fought Emperor Alexios in pitched battles. Talk
- 30:04about awkward. Hey, remember when I tried to
- 30:06kill you? Anyway, I'm here to help. Exactly.
- 30:10Bowman saw the crusade completely differently
- 30:12than the pious dukes. He was landless in Italy
- 30:15due to family disputes. For him, this was less
- 30:18of a purely spiritual pilgrimage and far more
- 30:21of a heavily armed job hunt. He sought an opportunity
- 30:23to carve out a rich, independent principality
- 30:26for himself in the East. So you have these four
- 30:29or five distinct mass of armies, each loyal only
- 30:33to their specific lord, marching across Europe
- 30:35via different routes, and they all converge on
- 30:38Constantinople in the spring of 1097. And the
- 30:42culture clash when they arrive is just spectacular.
- 30:45We have this incredible primary source, a history
- 30:47written by the Byzantine princess Anna Komnena,
- 30:51Alexios' daughter. The Alexiad. Right. Her observations
- 30:55of these Westerners are hilarious and highly
- 30:57revealing. Her writings give us the vital Byzantine
- 31:00perspective. To the educated, sophisticated Greeks
- 31:04sitting in their palaces in Constantinople, these
- 31:06Frankish lords were essentially heavily armed
- 31:09barbarians. She writes about them with this mixture
- 31:12of sheer terror and aristocratic disdain. She
- 31:17admits they are incredibly brave in battle, but
- 31:19she finds them crude, incredibly greedy, completely
- 31:23unpredictable, and lacking even a shred of diplomatic
- 31:25nuance. She basically views them as violent children
- 31:29with very sharp toys. Exactly. They embodied
- 31:32a fundamental clash of civilizations. Byzantine
- 31:36statecraft prioritized survival through bribery,
- 31:39containment, stalling tactics, and complex political
- 31:42maneuvering. Well, Western feudal honor, on the
- 31:44other hand, was entirely based on direct, violent
- 31:48confrontation and rigid oaths of personal loyalty.
- 31:51So Alexios is sitting in his palace, getting
- 31:53reports that tens of thousands of heavily armored
- 31:56Westernites are arriving at his gates. And one
- 31:59of the armies is led by Beaumont, his old nemesis.
- 32:03Right. How does he not just panic and lock the
- 32:06gates? Because Alexios is a political genius.
- 32:09He handles it masterfully. He refuses to let
- 32:12the armies combine inside the city walls. He
- 32:15meets the lords one by one. Divide and conquer.
- 32:18Exactly. He showers them with gold and silk,
- 32:21trying to overwhelm them with the wealth of Rome.
- 32:24But he draws a hard line. He refuses to ferry
- 32:27them across the Bosphorus straight into Asia
- 32:30Minor until they give him two very specific things.
- 32:33Which are? First, an oath of vassalage, meaning
- 32:36they acknowledge him as their overlord. And second,
- 32:39a solemn promise to return any conquered land
- 32:42that had previously belonged to the Roman Empire
- 32:45back to Byzantine control. And the Western lords
- 32:48push back, right? Because they didn't march 2
- 32:50,000 miles to become employees of a Greek emperor.
- 32:52They absolutely push back. Godfrey of Boyan initially
- 32:56refuses to swear the oath, which actually leads
- 32:58to armed skirmishes outside the city walls between
- 33:01Crusader knights and Byzantine mercenaries. So
- 33:04they're fighting before they even get to the
- 33:05Turks. Yeah. But Alexios essentially starves
- 33:08them out politically. He controls the local food
- 33:11markets. If a lord refuses the oath, Alexios
- 33:13just cuts off their grain supply. Oh, that's
- 33:15smart. Once they are hungry enough and once they
- 33:18realize they can't cross the sea without his
- 33:20boats, they submit. Wait, what about Beaumont?
- 33:22The guy who used to actively invade Byzantium,
- 33:25how does he react to being told to kneel to his
- 33:28old enemy? This is the most fascinating interaction.
- 33:32Boamond swears the oath almost immediately, with
- 33:34a massive smile on his face. What is his angle
- 33:37here? Why is he suddenly Alexios' best friend?
- 33:41Boamond is playing three -dimensional chess.
- 33:43He knows Alexios doesn't trust him for a second,
- 33:46and he doesn't trust Alexios. But Boamond wants
- 33:49to become the supreme commander of the entire
- 33:51crusade. Oh, I see. He even suggests Alexios
- 33:54that the emperor should appoint him as the Grand
- 33:56Domestic of the East, basically the commander
- 33:58-in -chief of all imperial forces in Asia. He
- 34:01uses charm and blatant flattery to try and win
- 34:04Alexios over, hoping to use Byzantine logistics
- 34:07to build his own empire. Did it work? Alexios
- 34:10accepts the oath warmly, gives Beaumont a room
- 34:12literally overflowing with golden jewels, but
- 34:16firmly denies him the military title. It's a
- 34:18masterclass in mutual, high -stakes political
- 34:21theater. Both men are lying through their teeth,
- 34:24and both men know the other is lying. The only
- 34:26major holdout is the proud old Raymond of Toulouse.
- 34:29He outright refuses a full oath of vassalage,
- 34:32saying he took the cross to serve God, not a
- 34:35mortal emperor. But they worked out a compromise,
- 34:37right? After weeks of tense negotiation, he eventually
- 34:40agrees to a modified oath, simply promising not
- 34:43to harm the emperor's life or interests. With
- 34:47the political haggling finally done, Alexios
- 34:50breathes a sigh of relief and ferries this massive
- 34:53combined army across to Asia Minor. He also sends
- 34:56someone with them, doesn't he? Yes. He attaches
- 34:58a veteran Byzantine general, a man named Tachios,
- 35:01to guide them, offer logistical advice, and physically
- 35:05take possession of the cities they conquer. So
- 35:07on parchment, it looks like a great alliance.
- 35:09But structurally, the foundation is entirely
- 35:12rotten with mutual suspicion. The psychological
- 35:15divide is just too wide. The crusaders feel insulted.
- 35:19They feel they are being treated like hired muscle.
- 35:21And they deeply suspect the perfidious Greeks
- 35:24will use them to do all the dying on the walls,
- 35:27only to sweep in at the last minute and take
- 35:29the rich prizes. And Alexios, conversely, is
- 35:31absolutely certain that the moment these Franks
- 35:34get their hands on a wealthy city, they will
- 35:36immediately break their oaths and keep it for
- 35:37themselves. And the incredible, darkly humorous
- 35:40thing about this is... They are both entirely
- 35:43100 % correct about each other. Which brings
- 35:46us to the Crucible of Anatolia, where this fragile
- 35:48alliance faces its first real military test.
- 35:52It is May 1097, and the massive Crusader army
- 35:55arrives at the walls of Nicaea. This is the city
- 35:58where the People's Crusade was trying to get
- 35:59to when they were massacred. Exactly. But now
- 36:02the real army is here. Nicaea is a formidable
- 36:05target. It's heavily fortified with over 100
- 36:07towers, thick stone walls, and Geographically,
- 36:11its western wall sits right on the edge of the
- 36:13massive Ascanian lake. Which means the Crusaders
- 36:16can surround the landward sides, but they can't
- 36:19fully blockade it. Where is the sultan? Kilij
- 36:21Arslan during all this? Because he's the guy
- 36:23who wiped out the first wave. Remember his fatal
- 36:25miscalculation. He thought the Crusaders were
- 36:28just a peasant rabble. So when the real army
- 36:30arrived, he wasn't even in the city. He was hundreds
- 36:33of miles away in the East fighting a minor border
- 36:35war against a rival Turkish emir. So he just
- 36:38gets this panicked message that an army of ironmen
- 36:40is at his gates. When panicked messengers finally
- 36:43reach him and tell him that tens of thousands
- 36:45of heavily armored knights are outside his capital,
- 36:49he rushes back. He gathers his cavalry and tries
- 36:51to smash through the crusader lines to relieve
- 36:53the city. But this time, he isn't charging into
- 36:56unarmed farmers. He hits the battle hardened,
- 36:59heavily armored veteran knights of Raymond of
- 37:01Toulouse. And the shock to the Turks is profound.
- 37:04The crusaders hold their ground in a brutal,
- 37:07day -long melee. Their chainmail protects them
- 37:09from the lighter Turkish arrows and their disciplined
- 37:12shield walls hold. The sultan takes heavy losses,
- 37:16realizes he cannot break the siege, and is forced
- 37:18to retreat into the hills, effectively abandoning
- 37:21his own garrison to their fate. The siege becomes
- 37:24a grim, grinding affair. We have reports of the
- 37:27Crusaders using catapults to hurl the severed
- 37:30heads of slain Turkish soldiers over the walls
- 37:33into the city to induce psychological terror.
- 37:35That is brutal. But the defenders are holding
- 37:37out for one simple reason. The lake. As long
- 37:41as that massive lake is open, the city is quietly
- 37:43getting resupplied by small boats bringing in
- 37:46food under the cover of darkness. This is where
- 37:48Emperor Alexios steps in and provides a marvel
- 37:50of ancient logistical engineering. The Crusader
- 37:54lords send an urgent message to Alexios in Constantinople
- 37:57saying, we need ships to block the lake. And
- 38:00Alexios agrees. He gathers a flotilla of small
- 38:03Byzantine warships. But there is a massive geographical
- 38:06problem. There is no navigable river connecting
- 38:09the sea to the Iscanian lake. So how do you get
- 38:12a navy into a landlocked lake? You carry it.
- 38:15Wait, really? Alexios has the boats transported
- 38:19to the closest coastal point. Then his engineers
- 38:22lay down miles of wooden rollers, essentially
- 38:24felled tree trunks, across the dry land. They
- 38:28greased the rollers with animal fat. Oh my god.
- 38:30They hitch hundreds of oxen and thousands of
- 38:33conscripted laborers to these boats. And by sheer
- 38:36brute physical force, they haul an entire fleet
- 38:38of warships over land, up and over hills, mile
- 38:42after agonizing mile, until they finally slide
- 38:45them down into the lake. That is just incredible.
- 38:48can't even fathom the manpower required for that.
- 38:50But it works. The Byzantine fleet suddenly appears
- 38:54on the lake. The blockade is total and the city
- 38:57of Nicaea is doomed. The Turkish garrison realizes
- 39:00they are going to starve. The Crusaders can smell
- 39:03the victory. They are sharpening those swords,
- 39:06building scaling ladders, getting ready for the
- 39:08final bloody assault. Now we have to explain
- 39:10the brutal rules of medieval siege warfare. Right.
- 39:13If a city refuses honorable terms of surrender,
- 39:16and forces the attacking army to take it by storm.
- 39:19The attackers are legally and morally allowed
- 39:22to sack the city. That means plundering all the
- 39:24wealth, enslaving the survivors and usually slaughtering
- 39:28the garrison. And the common Crusader soldiers
- 39:30are absolutely desperate for this sack. They
- 39:33have spent all their money getting here. They
- 39:35need the gold hidden inside Nicaea to buy food
- 39:37for the march to Jerusalem. So they go to sleep
- 39:39on the night of June 18th, fully expecting to
- 39:41storm the walls at dawn and get rich. But then
- 39:44they wake up the next morning. form up their
- 39:46ranks. And they look up to see the imperial banners
- 39:50of the Byzantine emperor fluttering peacefully
- 39:53from the highest towers of Nicaea. Wait, what
- 39:56happened? How did he get in? Alexios had completely
- 39:59outplayed them. While the crusaders were sleeping,
- 40:02Byzantine diplomats from the fleet on the lake
- 40:04had secretly rode up to the Watergate and negotiated
- 40:08a bloodless surrender with the Turkish garrison.
- 40:10Wow. Alexios offered the Turks incredibly generous
- 40:14terms, their lives, their property, and safe
- 40:16passage if they surrendered to him rather than
- 40:19letting the Franks storm the walls. because Alexios
- 40:23has zero desire to see a city he intends to rule
- 40:25again completely destroyed and its taxpaying
- 40:28population butchered. Exactly. He is thinking
- 40:30like an emperor, not a warlord. He even takes
- 40:33the sultan's captured wife and children, brings
- 40:36them to Constantinople, treats them with royal
- 40:38honors, and eventually releases them back to
- 40:41the sultan without demanding a ransom. It was
- 40:43a highly civilized, sophisticated diplomatic
- 40:46move designed to foster future peace with the
- 40:48Turks. and it absolutely enraged the Crusaders.
- 40:52I mean, put yourself in the shoes of a French
- 40:54knight. You just spent weeks fighting in the
- 40:56mud, bleeding, losing your friends, doing all
- 40:59the heavy lifting. And the moment the prize is
- 41:01ready to fall, the slippery Greeks sneak in the
- 41:05back door and steal all the glory and the gold.
- 41:07Alexios tries to smooth things over. He opens
- 41:10his treasury and gives the Crusader lords massive
- 41:13gifts of gold and jewels to soothe their bruised
- 41:15egos. But the psychological damage is permanent.
- 41:18The seed of total betrayal is planted. The crusaders
- 41:22now feel that Lexios is a manipulative coward.
- 41:25From this day forward, they view their oaths
- 41:27to him as highly conditional, if not entirely
- 41:30void. Despite the boiling resentment, strategically,
- 41:34the capture of Nicaea is a massive win. The door
- 41:37to the deep Anatolian interior has been kicked
- 41:40open. In late June, the massive army packs up
- 41:43its camp and sets out. Now, to forge for food
- 41:46and water more efficiently, they make a tactical
- 41:49decision to divide this massive host into two
- 41:52separate columns, marching about a day apart.
- 41:54Beaumont takes command of the vanguard, and Godfrey
- 41:58and Raymond follow behind with the rearguard.
- 42:00And this seemingly minor logistical decision
- 42:02almost ends the entire crusade, which leads us
- 42:06to the Battle of Dorleum on July 1st, 1097. Okay,
- 42:09here's where it gets really interesting, because
- 42:11Khalid -jar -slan, the sultan, has not been idle.
- 42:14He has called in every favor, allied with rival
- 42:17Turkish emirs, and gathered a massive, terrifying
- 42:21coalition army of tens of thousands of light
- 42:24horse archers. He has been tracking the Crusaders.
- 42:27And at dawn, near a ruined town called Doraleum,
- 42:31he springs a massive ambush on Bohemond's vanguard.
- 42:34Now you used an analogy earlier in our notes
- 42:37that I think perfectly describes the tactical
- 42:39nightmare Bohemond suddenly found himself in.
- 42:42Right. I was thinking about this when preparing.
- 42:45It is exactly like putting a slow, massively
- 42:48powerful heavyweight boxer in a ring with a swarm
- 42:50of angry hornets. That's it exactly. The Western
- 42:53Knights rely entirely on one specific tactic,
- 42:56the heavy cavalry charge. They line up, lower
- 42:58their lances, and rely on the sheer mass of armored
- 43:01horses to shatter the enemy's infantry lines.
- 43:04But when they try to charge the Turks, there
- 43:07is no line to shatter. The Turkish tactics were
- 43:10revolutionary and completely alien to the Westerners.
- 43:13The Turks fought as lightly armored horse archers.
- 43:16Their primary weapon was the composite recurve
- 43:18bow, made of horn, wood, and sinew, which could
- 43:21punch arrows through mail at close range. And
- 43:23they wouldn't stand still, right? Never. Their
- 43:26tactic was the feigned retreat and the Parthian
- 43:28shot. They would gallop in a terrifying speed,
- 43:31unleash a storm of arrows, and the moment the
- 43:33heavy knights tried to charge them, the Turks
- 43:35would simply wheel their fast ponies around and
- 43:37gallop away, shooting arrows backward over their
- 43:40shoulders as they rode. So the heavily armored
- 43:42French knights are just chasing shadows. They
- 43:45are exhausting their massive, expensive war horses
- 43:48in the burning heat, getting peppered with arrows
- 43:50from all sides by an enemy they can never quite
- 43:52catch. And the Turks accompanied this with psychological
- 43:55warfare. They used shrieking war cries, howling
- 43:59wolves, and the deafening thunder of massive
- 44:01kettle drums strapped camels. The noise alone
- 44:03panicked the European horses. Beaumont realizes
- 44:06within minutes that if his knights keep trying
- 44:08to charge out and fight, they will be picked
- 44:11apart and destroyed piecemeal. So Beaumont, showing
- 44:14why he's the best general they have, issues an
- 44:16agonizing, highly counterintuitive order. He
- 44:19orders his proud, aggressive knights, do not
- 44:22charge. That must have been so hard for them
- 44:25to accept. Oh, completely against their nature.
- 44:27He pulls his entire force back to a marshy area
- 44:29near a shallow river to protect their rear from
- 44:32being surrounded. He puts the unarmed civilians,
- 44:34the women, and the baggage train in the center.
- 44:37He dismounts many of his knights to form a solid
- 44:39wall of wooden shields. And he tells his men
- 44:42to just stand there. Imagine the psychological
- 44:45discipline required for that. You are encased
- 44:48in iron under a blazing Anatolian summer sun.
- 44:52Arrows are raining down on you in the thousands.
- 44:55Men are falling. Horses are screaming as they
- 44:58are hit. But if you break formation, everyone
- 45:02dies. For ours, they just stand there and take
- 45:05the punishment. We have accounts of women from
- 45:08the camp bravely running back and forth to the
- 45:10river carrying buckets of water to the front
- 45:12lines to keep the men from collapsing of heatstroke.
- 45:15The only hope Beaumont has is the handful of
- 45:17fast riders he managed to send back down the
- 45:19road at the start of the battle. to find the
- 45:21second column. If Godfrey and Raymond don't arrive,
- 45:25Beaumont's force will be bled to death. It is
- 45:28a near -run thing. By midday, the Crusader shield
- 45:31wall is buckling. The Turks are pressing closer.
- 45:34But then, cresting the ridge behind the Turkish
- 45:36positions, the banners of the second column appear.
- 45:40Godfrey and Raymond had received the frantic
- 45:41messengers and force -marched their knights at
- 45:44a grueling pace. They don't even pause to form
- 45:47up. They just lower their lances and slam directly
- 45:49into the Turkish flank. And the tactical brilliance
- 45:52of Bishop Ademar comes into play here. The papal
- 45:56legate actually leads a detachment of knights
- 45:58around a hidden mountain path and hits the Turks
- 46:00from the rear. Suddenly the Turkish horse archers
- 46:03are pinned in a valley between three angry crusader
- 46:06forces. The one thing light cavalry cannot survive
- 46:09is being boxed in. Their speed advantage is instantly
- 46:12neutralized. The heavy crusader cavalry finally
- 46:16connects and the Turkish coalition just shatters.
- 46:19They break and flee in absolute panic, abandoning
- 46:22their camp, their tents, and massive amounts
- 46:24of treasure. It is a stunning, miraculous victory.
- 46:29The Crusaders proved that their heavy armor and
- 46:31discipline could withstand the absolute worst
- 46:33the Turks could throw at them. But the victory
- 46:35comes at a terrible cost. And Kilij Arslan learns
- 46:39a dark lesson. The Sultan realizes he can't beat
- 46:42these iron men in a pitched battle. So as he
- 46:45retreats, he changes his strategy to something
- 46:48far more lethal. Scorched earth. And this is
- 46:51where the march across Anatolia turns into a
- 46:53literal hell on earth. Kilijarslan rides ahead
- 46:56of the Crusader army and he destroys his own
- 46:59country. He orders his men to burn every field
- 47:02of grain, poison every well with animal carcasses,
- 47:05and drive all the livestock up into the inaccessible
- 47:08mountains. The Crusaders are marching across
- 47:10the high arid Anatolian plateau in the dead of
- 47:13July and August. There is no shade. There is
- 47:17no water. The attrition is horrific. Men are
- 47:21dropping dead of heat stroke and dehydration
- 47:23right on the road. The pregnant women in the
- 47:26camp go into premature labor from the stress
- 47:28and die. And crucially, the war horses, the absolute
- 47:32pride and joy of the European aristocracy, the
- 47:35engine of their military power, start dying by
- 47:38the thousands from lack of water. The chroniclers
- 47:41record these incredibly surreal, humiliating
- 47:44images. We're talking about the finest, proudest
- 47:48knights of Europe, men who defined their entire
- 47:50social status by fighting on horseback, and now
- 47:53they are trudging through the dust on foot. Or
- 47:56they are riding on the backs of oxen. Because
- 47:59the pack mules died, the knights had to take
- 48:01their priceless 30 -pound chainmail shirts and
- 48:05strap them to the backs of goats, sheep, and
- 48:08even hunting dogs just to carry the weight. It
- 48:11is an apocalyptic procession. Some accounts say
- 48:14they were so crazed with thirst, they were cutting
- 48:16the veins of their own dying horses to drink
- 48:19the blood. But here is the critical psychological
- 48:22outcome of all this. Surviving this shared unimaginable
- 48:27trauma forges the Corps of the Army into a single
- 48:30hardened brotherhood. The weak died. Those who
- 48:34survived the crossing of Anatolia were fanatical
- 48:37veterans. They finally reach the anti -Taurus
- 48:40mountains, which is another nightmare. The mountain
- 48:42paths are so steep and muddy that horses are
- 48:45slipping and falling into ravines, and knights
- 48:48are literally unbuckling their expensive armor
- 48:51and throwing it off the cliffs just so they can
- 48:53climb to safety. But they make it over. They
- 48:55descend into the fertile valleys of northern
- 48:57Syria and encounter friendly Armenian Christian
- 49:00territories. And this is where the narrative
- 49:03pivots sharply because the very moment the army
- 49:06escapes the trauma of the desert and sees wealthy,
- 49:10unconquered lands, the unity forged in suffering
- 49:13immediately shatters. The raw, personal ambitions
- 49:16of the lords take over. Right. And this centers
- 49:20around Baldwin, Godfrey's younger, fiercely ambitious
- 49:23brother. Let's look at Baldwin's mental state.
- 49:27During the march across Anatolia, his wife died
- 49:29of illness. Which is tragic, but geopolitically
- 49:32it means Baldwin no longer has any ties back
- 49:35to Europe. The lands he had claimed to were through
- 49:37her. He is now completely landless. He has a
- 49:40core group of loyal knights and he realizes he
- 49:43doesn't want to march to Jerusalem and be just
- 49:45another soldier. So Baldwin splinters off. He
- 49:48takes his small band of heavily armored knights
- 49:50and leaves the main crusader host. He heads east
- 49:53toward the Euphrates River, marching into Armenian
- 49:55territory toward the incredibly wealthy ancient
- 49:58city of Edessa. Now, Odessa is a fascinating
- 50:02place. It's an ancient Christian city that actually
- 50:04claimed to possess letters written by Jesus himself.
- 50:08It's currently ruled by an Armenian governor
- 50:10named Thoros. But Thoros is in a terrible position.
- 50:13He's a Christian ruler surrounded on all sides
- 50:16by hostile Turkish warlords who extort him constantly.
- 50:19Furthermore, Thoros is deeply unpopular with
- 50:22his own citizens because he belongs to the Greek
- 50:25Orthodox Church, while the population is Armenian
- 50:28Orthodox, a significant theological divide at
- 50:30the time. So when Thoros hears that a towering,
- 50:34undefeated Western warlord named Baldwin is roaming
- 50:36the countryside with an elite bodyguard of knights,
- 50:39Thoros doesn't see a threat. He sees a savior.
- 50:43Thoros invites Baldwin into the city. He hires
- 50:46him as a mercenary captain. But Baldwin is way
- 50:49too ambitious for a paycheck. He basically hints
- 50:52that he's going to leave unless Thoros makes
- 50:54him a permanent partner. So Thoros, desperate
- 50:58to keep him, formally adopts Baldwin as his son
- 51:01and legal heir. And this leads to one of the
- 51:03most bizarre diplomatic ceremonies in recorded
- 51:06history. To make the adoption legally and culturally
- 51:09binding, according to local Armenian custom,
- 51:12they have to perform a public ritual. I am still
- 51:15trying to picture this because it's so weird.
- 51:16The elderly, likely frail, Thoros, and the towering,
- 51:21battle -scarred, Frankish knight, Baldwin, have
- 51:24to strip to the waist in front of the court.
- 51:26Okay, weird start. They bring out a single, massively
- 51:30oversized white shirt. Both men step inside the
- 51:33shirt together, pressing their bare chests tightly
- 51:35against one another, symbolizing that they are
- 51:38now of one flesh and one blood. Okay. And then,
- 51:41just to complete the awkwardness, Thoros' wife,
- 51:45has to get under the shirt and rub her bare chest
- 51:48against Baldwin's back. It's so wildly intimate
- 51:51and strange. But for Baldwin, it is a highly
- 51:53calculated, cynical move, because his gratitude
- 51:56to his new father is incredibly short -lived.
- 52:00Within weeks of this touching family moment,
- 52:03the citizens of Odessa suddenly rise up in a
- 52:05violent revolt against Thoros. A mob surrounds
- 52:08the palace. Thoros tries to escape out a window
- 52:11by a rope, but he is caught by the mob and torn
- 52:13to pieces in the street. And where is Baldwin
- 52:16during this? He is sitting quietly in his quarters,
- 52:19ordering his knights not to intervene. Did Baldwin
- 52:22actively orchestrate the assassination? Our sources
- 52:25say he wasn't the type to leave a written confession,
- 52:27but the timing is highly, highly suspicious.
- 52:31He basically watches his new adoptive father
- 52:33get murdered, walks out onto the balcony, and
- 52:36smoothly accepts the crown from the mob. He becomes
- 52:39the ruler of the county of Edessa. This is the
- 52:42very first crusader state. We need to pause and
- 52:45look at the profound moral and strategic shift
- 52:47this represents for the entire crusade. Remember
- 52:51the solemn oaths sworn to Emperor Alexios back
- 52:54in Constantinople. The crusaders swore on holy
- 52:57relics that they would return captured lands
- 52:59to the Byzantine Empire. Well Baldwin just tossed
- 53:02that oath completely out the window. He carved
- 53:05out a personal independent kingdom for himself
- 53:07hundreds of miles away from Jerusalem and had
- 53:10absolutely no intention of giving it back to
- 53:12Alexios or holding it in trust for the pope.
- 53:15It sets a deeply contagious precedent. It shifts
- 53:18the entire psychological framing of the expedition.
- 53:22The leaders stop looking at this as a temporary
- 53:24spiritual pilgrimage of liberation and start
- 53:27looking at it as a permanent expedition of colonial
- 53:30conquest. Exactly. The mask slips and Boamond.
- 53:34The Norman tactical genius is watching Baldwin
- 53:37get a crown and thinking, if the younger brother
- 53:40can have a Dessa, I can have something much,
- 53:44much bigger. And that bigger prize is the city.
- 53:47The main army has just arrived at the ancient
- 53:50metropolis of Antioch. Antioch was a monster.
- 53:54It was the gateway to Syria, one of the greatest
- 53:56cities of the ancient world. Taking it by direct
- 53:59assault was completely impossible. The walls
- 54:02ran for miles, they were studded with hundreds
- 54:06of massive stone towers, and they literally climbed
- 54:09up the precipitous side of Mount Silpius, culminating
- 54:12in a massive, impregnable citadel at the peak.
- 54:15And the Orontes River protected the other side.
- 54:17It was a masterpiece of military engineering.
- 54:20The Crusaders arrive in October 1097. They realize
- 54:24they can't storm it. They don't have enough men
- 54:27to fully encircle the massive perimeter, which
- 54:29means the Turkic governor of Antioch, a man named
- 54:31Yaghi Siyon, is still able to sneak supplies
- 54:34in through the mountain gates. The crusaders
- 54:37are forced to settle in for a long, agonizing
- 54:40siege. Which leads to the darkest chapter of
- 54:42the crusade. Winter hits northern Syria and it
- 54:45is brutally cold and wet. The crusaders, camped
- 54:49outside in the freezing mud, quickly eat through
- 54:51all the forage in the local countryside. And
- 54:54then, the starvation begins. The famine in the
- 54:57crusader camp over that winter is horrific, almost
- 55:00apocalyptic. The supply lines are nonexistent.
- 55:03The chroniclers report men eating the remaining
- 55:05horses. When the horses are gone, they eat the
- 55:09stray dogs. Then they eat rats and roots dug
- 55:12out of the frozen mud. Eventually, they are cutting
- 55:15up their leather belts, boiling the leather for
- 55:17days and chewing on it just to trick their stomachs
- 55:20into feeling full. Disease, likely typhus or
- 55:24dysentery, runs rampant in the unsanitary camps.
- 55:28Morale absolutely craters. Desertion spikes.
- 55:32Men are sneaking away into the night in droves.
- 55:35Even Peter the hermit, the guy who literally
- 55:38started the whole popular movement, the firebrand
- 55:40preacher, he loses his nerve. He tries to sneak
- 55:44away back to Europe under the cover of darkness.
- 55:47He is caught by Boamond's men and dragged back
- 55:49to the camp in utter disgrace. But the most consequential
- 55:52desertion, the one that changes history, is Stephen
- 55:55of Blas. Stephen was one of the wealthiest men
- 55:58in all of France. He was married to Adela, the
- 56:01daughter of William the Conqueror. He was writing
- 56:03these glowing letters home to his wife, but in
- 56:06reality, he was terrified. In June 1098, after
- 56:10eight months of agony, Stephen decides the situation
- 56:13is completely hopeless. He feigns an illness,
- 56:16gathers his personal retinue, and abandons the
- 56:19siege, fleeing north toward Constantinople. And
- 56:22here is where the dominoes fall. because as Stephen
- 56:25is fleeing north through Anatolia, he runs into
- 56:28Emperor Alexios. Alexios is marching south with
- 56:32a massive fresh Byzantine army to relieve the
- 56:35crusaders at Antioch and take possession of the
- 56:37city, just as he promised he would. Stephen is
- 56:41brought into the emperor's tent, and Stephen
- 56:43is deeply embarrassed that he ran away. So to
- 56:47justify his own cowardice, he lies. He tells
- 56:50Alexios, don't bother marching south. The Crusaders
- 56:53are all dead or about to be. Andiok is completely
- 56:56surrounded by Muslims. It is a lost cause. If
- 56:59you march south, your army will be destroyed,
- 57:01too. Alexios is a cautious, pragmatic ruler.
- 57:05He listens to one of the senior leaders of the
- 57:07Crusades say all is lost. So Alexios turns his
- 57:10massive relief army around and marches back to
- 57:12Constantinople. History literally pivoting on
- 57:17a single act of cowardice. And this moment provides
- 57:20Beaumont with exactly the legal loophole he has
- 57:22been waiting for. When the starving crusaders
- 57:25outside Antioch finally get word that the Byzantine
- 57:28emperor turned around and went home, Beaumont
- 57:31stands up in the Council of Leaders. He argues,
- 57:33brilliantly, that the emperor has abandoned them
- 57:35in their darkest hour to die. Therefore, the
- 57:38oaths they swore at Constantinople are legally
- 57:41void. Beaumont says, if we take Antioch without
- 57:44his help, it belongs to whoever captures it.
- 57:46And Bolman says this because he already has a
- 57:48secret plan to capture it. He has been running
- 57:51and espionage ring. He made secret contact with
- 57:54a man inside the city named Feroz. Feroz was
- 57:56an Armenian Christian who made armor, and he
- 57:59had been placed in command of one of the towers
- 58:01on the walls by the Turkish governor. But Feroz
- 58:04had a bitter grudge against the governor. Some
- 58:06sources say the governor had confiscated his
- 58:08wealth or insulted his family. Through messages
- 58:11snuck in and out of the city, Bolman bribes Feroz.
- 58:14Feroz agrees to lower a rope ladder from his
- 58:16tower in the dead of night and let Beaumont's
- 58:19men over the wall. But Beaumont doesn't tell
- 58:22the other crusader lords how he plans to do it.
- 58:25He just goes to them and says, I have a way into
- 58:27the city. I will only spring my trap if you guarantee
- 58:30right now that I get to keep Antioch as my own
- 58:33personal principality. Raymond of Toulouse is
- 58:36furious. He sees right through the manipulation.
- 58:39He knows Beaumont is holding the army hostage.
- 58:42But the lords have no choice. Because they have
- 58:44just received terrifying, catastrophic news.
- 58:48A massive Muslim relief army led by the powerful
- 58:51warlord, Kerboga of Mosul, is only days away.
- 58:55It's a race against time. If Kerboga's massive
- 58:58army catches the crusaders outside the walls
- 59:00of Antioch, pinned against the river, they will
- 59:03be annihilated. So they agree. On a dark, moonless
- 59:06night in early June 1098, Bo Amman takes a small
- 59:09strike team to the base of Farrouz's tower. A
- 59:12leather rope ladder drops down in the darkness.
- 59:15Beaumont's men climb up, silently slit the throats
- 59:18of the sleeping guards in the adjacent towers,
- 59:21and run down to throw open the main gates. The
- 59:24entire starving crusader army pours into the
- 59:27sleeping city. What follows is a horrific, chaotic
- 59:30bloodbath. The pent -up frustration and trauma
- 59:33of the eight -month siege is unleashed. The crusaders
- 59:36sack the city, killing thousands. The Turkish
- 59:39governor, Yagi Siyin, tries to flee on horseback,
- 59:42but falls, is found by local peasants, and is
- 59:45beheaded. But the victory is incomplete. In the
- 59:48chaos, a large portion of the Turkish garrison
- 59:51retreats up the mountain and locks themselves
- 59:53securely inside the massive, impregnable citadel
- 59:56overlooking the city. The crusaders have the
- 59:59city streets, but they don't control the fortress
- 1:00:01above them. And just days later, Kerboga's massive
- 1:00:05coalition army arrives and fully surrounds the
- 1:00:08walls of Antioch. The irony is suffocating. In
- 1:00:11a cruel twist of fate, the besiegers are now
- 1:00:14the besieged. The crusaders are trapped inside
- 1:00:17a city they had just completely stripped of whatever
- 1:00:20food was left. They're pinned between the hostile
- 1:00:23Turkish garrison in the citadel above them and
- 1:00:25Kürboga's overwhelming forces outside the walls.
- 1:00:28They traded one nightmare trap for an even worse
- 1:00:31one. Starvation returns instantly. But this time
- 1:00:34it's worse because they are trapped inside stone
- 1:00:37walls. Panic sets in. Soldiers are so desperate,
- 1:00:40they are tying ropes to the battlements at night
- 1:00:42and sliding down the walls to desert. The men
- 1:00:45who did this were mockingly called rope dancers.
- 1:00:48The leaders are paralyzed. The end seems entirely
- 1:00:51inevitable. And this brings us to a moment where
- 1:00:54military history collides with sheer unadulterated
- 1:00:57mass psychology. In moments of utter inescapable
- 1:01:01despair, when tactical reality offers absolutely
- 1:01:04no hope of survival, human psychology often turns
- 1:01:07to the supernatural. Enter Peter Bartholomew.
- 1:01:11Peter Bartholomew was a poor, ragged peasant
- 1:01:13pilgrim from southern France. Not a soldier,
- 1:01:16not a priest. He comes forward to the crusader
- 1:01:18leadership with a wild, ecstatic claim. He says
- 1:01:22that St. Andrew appeared to him in a series of
- 1:01:24vivid dreams, and the saint told him a secret.
- 1:01:27That the holy lance, the actual iron spearhead
- 1:01:30that a Roman centurion used to pierce the side
- 1:01:32of Christ on the cross, is buried right under
- 1:01:35the stone floor of the cathedral of St. Peter.
- 1:01:37right there in Antioch. Now, the papal legate,
- 1:01:39Bishop Adomar, is a highly educated, cynical
- 1:01:42man. He is highly skeptical. Why? Because Adomar
- 1:01:45has been to Constantinople. He has personally
- 1:01:48seen a relic claiming to be the actual Holy Lands
- 1:01:51resting comfortably in the emperor's treasury.
- 1:01:54He basically says, it can't be here. I saw it
- 1:01:56in Greece. But Raymond of Toulouse immediately
- 1:01:59embraces Peter Bartholomew's vision. Why? Because
- 1:02:02Raymond hates Boymond. Boyment holds the military
- 1:02:06power at Antioch. Raymond realizes that if he
- 1:02:08controls a relic of supreme holy power, he gains
- 1:02:11absolute spiritual authority over the army. It's
- 1:02:14a political calculation. So Raymond orders the
- 1:02:17cathedral floor torn up. A team of men, including
- 1:02:20Peter, dig a massive trench in the cathedral
- 1:02:23all day long. They dig down to bedrock. They
- 1:02:26find nothing but dirt and rubble. The skeptics
- 1:02:28are standing around sneering. Bishop Atomar is
- 1:02:31probably rolling his eyes. Finally, as evening
- 1:02:34falls, Peter Bartholomew himself strips down
- 1:02:36to a tunic, jumps down into the muddy hole, scrabbles
- 1:02:39around in the dirt, and miraculously pulls out
- 1:02:41a rusted piece of iron. He raises it up and claims
- 1:02:44it is the Holy Lance. Okay, I have to ask. Was
- 1:02:49it a fraud? Let's be real. A peasant who knows
- 1:02:51exactly where to dig suddenly produces a random
- 1:02:54iron head in an empty hole when no one else could
- 1:02:56find it. The logistics of a sleight of hand fraud
- 1:02:59are highly probable. Most modern historians and
- 1:03:02frankly, many educated leaders at the time believed
- 1:03:04Peter smuggled a piece of scrap iron into the
- 1:03:06hole. But here's the crux of the matter. The
- 1:03:10objective material truth of the relic doesn't
- 1:03:13matter in the slightest. The belief in the relic
- 1:03:16is what physically alters the course of history.
- 1:03:18The psychological whiplash in that starving army
- 1:03:21is absolute. They go from total weeping despair
- 1:03:25to electric burning fanatical confidence in a
- 1:03:28matter of hours. They truly believe the creator
- 1:03:30of the universe has just handed them a physical
- 1:03:33token guaranteeing their victory. Fueled by this
- 1:03:36manic energy, the Crusaders decide to do the
- 1:03:38unthinkable. They don't wait to slowly starve
- 1:03:41to death behind the walls. They decide to march
- 1:03:44out of the gates of Antioch and face Karaboa's
- 1:03:47massive army in open battle. They march out fasting.
- 1:03:51Many are barefoot as an act of penance. The priests
- 1:03:55are marching in the front ranks. Raymond's chaplain
- 1:03:57is physically carrying the holy lance mounted
- 1:03:59on a pole like a battle standard. Most of the
- 1:04:03proud knights don't even have horses anymore.
- 1:04:04They are fighting as foot infantry. From a purely
- 1:04:08military standpoint, marching an exhausted, starving
- 1:04:12infantry force out onto an open plain against
- 1:04:15a massive cavalry army is a suicide mission.
- 1:04:18It should have been a massacre. But caribou,
- 1:04:20makes critical tactical errors born of arrogance.
- 1:04:24As the crusader columns start crossing the bridge
- 1:04:26out of the city, Karaboa's generals beg him to
- 1:04:29attack them immediately, division by division,
- 1:04:31while they are bottlenecked. But Karaboa refuses.
- 1:04:35He wants to let them fully deploy onto the plane,
- 1:04:37so he can surround them and crush the entire
- 1:04:40crusade in one single glorious blow. But Karaboa
- 1:04:43has a massive vulnerability of his own, right?
- 1:04:46His army looks huge, but structurally it's a
- 1:04:48house of carts. Exactly. Kyrboga's army is a
- 1:04:52fragile political coalition. The Islamic world
- 1:04:55in this era operated on the Iqta system, essentially
- 1:04:58land grants given to military commanders. The
- 1:05:01various emirs and warlords under Kyrboga's command
- 1:05:03were fiercely independent. They despised Kyrboga.
- 1:05:07They only joined him because they feared his
- 1:05:09growing power. In fact, many of these emirs secretly
- 1:05:12feared that if Kyrboga won a massive victory
- 1:05:15against the Franks, he would become too powerful
- 1:05:17and conquered their lands next. So as the starving
- 1:05:20fanatical crusaders advance across the plain
- 1:05:22in this terrifying eerie silence, moving with
- 1:05:25absolute unbroken discipline, the Muslim coalition
- 1:05:29just shatters. The emirs look at the ferocity
- 1:05:32of the Franks, look at Karaboga, and they just
- 1:05:35start packing up their tents. Entire divisions
- 1:05:38of the Muslim army simply turn their horses around
- 1:05:40and walk away from the battlefield to deny Karaboga
- 1:05:42the glory of a win. The sudden withdrawal of
- 1:05:45allied contingents triggers a cascading panic.
- 1:05:48The Turkish front line collapses. Suddenly, this
- 1:05:51massive, overwhelming host breaks and flees in
- 1:05:55absolute terror. The crusaders, fighting on foot,
- 1:05:58chase them down and win an impossible, total
- 1:06:00victory. Seeing the relief army destroyed, the
- 1:06:03Turkish garrison holding the citadel finally
- 1:06:05surrenders to Bohemund. The trap is broken. It
- 1:06:08is the defining miracle of the First Crusade,
- 1:06:11but the aftermath is incredibly messy. You'd
- 1:06:14think, having been saved by God, they would immediately
- 1:06:16march to Jerusalem. Instead, the lords spend
- 1:06:19months sitting in Antioch, bickering bitterly
- 1:06:22over who actually owns the city. And while the
- 1:06:32lords play politics, a devastating outbreak of
- 1:06:35typhus sweeps through the unsanitary crowded
- 1:06:37camp. It kills thousands of common soldiers,
- 1:06:40but critically, it kills Bishop Adomar. the papal
- 1:06:43legate dies. Why is that so crucial? Itamar was
- 1:06:46the glue holding the crusade together. He was
- 1:06:49the only man who possessed the spiritual authority
- 1:06:51and diplomatic tact to force these massive egos
- 1:06:54to cooperate. Without him, the rivalries boil
- 1:06:57over entirely. Beaumont firmly entrenches himself
- 1:07:00as the Prince of Antioch and refuses to leave.
- 1:07:03Raymond marches south and tries to lay siege
- 1:07:05to random Syrian towns to carve out his own territory
- 1:07:08to rival Beaumont. And the common people, the
- 1:07:11peasants and the foot soldiers? just lose their
- 1:07:13minds. They're furious. They have starved, bled,
- 1:07:16and died to go to Jerusalem, not to help French
- 1:07:19Dukes build real estate portfolios in Syria.
- 1:07:22They essentially go on strike. They threaten
- 1:07:24the lords, basically saying, if you don't march
- 1:07:26to Jerusalem, we will physically tear down the
- 1:07:28walls of these Syrian cities brick by brick so
- 1:07:30you can't live in them. It's a wild, unprecedented
- 1:07:32dynamic. The armed peasantry forcing the high
- 1:07:36nobility to fulfill their holy vow. And during
- 1:07:39this delay, the skepticism over the Holy Lance
- 1:07:41finally boils over. Peter Bartholomew has been
- 1:07:44using his status as the finder of the lance to
- 1:07:47issue all sorts of convenient prophecies that
- 1:07:49usually favored Raymond of Toulouse. The other
- 1:07:52factions get sick of it. They publicly accuse
- 1:07:54Peter of being a fraud. To prove the relic's
- 1:07:57authenticity, Peter Bartholomew demands an ordeal
- 1:08:00by fire. This is a medieval judicial mechanism
- 1:08:03where God is expected to intervene to protect
- 1:08:06the innocent. They build two massive walls of
- 1:08:09stacked olive branches, 14 feet long with a narrow
- 1:08:12path down the middle. They set it ablaze. The
- 1:08:14heat is so intense that onlookers can't even
- 1:08:16stand near it. Peter, wearing only a tunic and
- 1:08:19carrying the iron lance, walks down the burning
- 1:08:21path between the pyres. And what happens? He
- 1:08:23emerges on the other side, but he is horribly,
- 1:08:26deeply burned. He dies in agony 12 days later.
- 1:08:30Now his diehard supporters claimed he actually
- 1:08:32emerged completely unharmed, but that the frantic
- 1:08:35crowd mobbed him in their religious ecstasy and
- 1:08:37accidentally broke his spine. But the skeptics
- 1:08:40and most of the army concluded that God had burned
- 1:08:43a liar. Either way, the magical spell of the
- 1:08:47lance is broken and Raymond's prestige takes
- 1:08:50a massive hit. Finally, in early 1099, forced
- 1:08:54by the rioting cometers, the army turned south.
- 1:08:57but it is a much smaller, deeply hardened force.
- 1:09:01From the tens of thousands who left Europe, only
- 1:09:03about 12 ,000 and 15 ,000 men are left. Boamond
- 1:09:07and Baldwin stay behind in their new kingdoms.
- 1:09:09The rest march toward Jerusalem. As they march
- 1:09:12south along the Levantine coast, they enter a
- 1:09:15completely different political reality. The Sunni
- 1:09:19Seljuk Turks, they had been fighting for years,
- 1:09:22no longer control Jerusalem. Taking advantage
- 1:09:24of the chaos caused by the Crusaders, the Shia
- 1:09:27Fatimid Caliphate, which is based in Egypt, has
- 1:09:30marched up and captured Jerusalem. And the Fatimids
- 1:09:33actually hate the Seljuk Turks just as much as
- 1:09:36the Crusaders do. Exactly. The Fatimid vizier
- 1:09:39in Cairo completely misinterprets the Crusaders.
- 1:09:42He thinks they are just a mercenary army doing
- 1:09:44a job for the Byzantines. He sends envoys offering
- 1:09:47the Crusaders an alliance against the Turks.
- 1:09:50He says, If you come in peace, we will grant
- 1:09:53small, unarmed groups of Christians protected
- 1:09:55access to Jerusalem to pray as pilgrims. But
- 1:09:58the Fatimids completely fail to understand the
- 1:10:01absolute fanatical mindset of the men they're
- 1:10:04dealing with. The Crusaders didn't walk 2 ,000
- 1:10:06miles, mortgage their entire countries, and drink
- 1:10:09the blood of their own horses just to be tourists.
- 1:10:12They came to conquer the city and rule it. The
- 1:10:15diplomatic offers are rejected outright. And
- 1:10:18so in June 1099, this battered fanatical remnant
- 1:10:21of an army finally arrives at the walls of Jerusalem.
- 1:10:25The Fatima governor of Jerusalem has prepared
- 1:10:27a brutal reception. He knows it just has to delay
- 1:10:30them until a relief army from Egypt arrives.
- 1:10:32So he orders his men to poison all the wells
- 1:10:35and cisterns outside the city with animal corpses.
- 1:10:38He also chops down every tree for miles around
- 1:10:40to deny the Crusaders timber. The summer heat
- 1:10:43in Judea is lethal. The Crusaders are immediately
- 1:10:46dying of thirst drinking from stagnant putrid
- 1:10:48pools. And because there is no wood, they cannot
- 1:10:51build the massive siege towers required to breach
- 1:10:53the towering stone walls. They are stuck baking
- 1:10:57in the sun. It looks like the crusade is going
- 1:10:59to end in failure right at the finish line. But
- 1:11:02then, literal salvation arrives by sea. A small
- 1:11:06fleet of Genoese and English merchant and naval
- 1:11:08ships puts into the nearby ruined port of Jaffa.
- 1:11:12These sailors don't just bring food and water.
- 1:11:14When they hear the army needs wood, the Genoese
- 1:11:17commander orders his men to do something. Incredible.
- 1:11:21They dismantle their own ships. Wait, they take
- 1:11:24apart their own boats? Yes. They take the massive
- 1:11:28oak timbers of the hulls, the ropes, the rigging,
- 1:11:31the iron nails. And because there are no draft
- 1:11:33animals left, the sailors and soldiers physically
- 1:11:36carry these massive ship timbers overland for
- 1:11:3830 miles to Jerusalem. Under the direction of
- 1:11:42a brilliant Genoese engineer named Gluliamo Imbriaco,
- 1:11:46they used mortise and tenon joints to construct
- 1:11:48two enormous multi -story wooden siege towers
- 1:11:52mounted on wheels. They literally turned a navy
- 1:11:55into siege weapons. But pushing a wooden tower
- 1:11:58up to a city wall is incredibly dangerous because
- 1:12:01the defenders are using Greek fire. I want to
- 1:12:04explain this because it's terrifying. Greek fire
- 1:12:07wasn't just a flaming arrow. It was a secret
- 1:12:10chemical weapon. likely a mixture of naphtha,
- 1:12:13quicklime, and sulfur. It was essentially medieval
- 1:12:16napalm. It stuck to whatever it hit, and if you
- 1:12:18threw water on it, it actually burned hotter.
- 1:12:21To protect these wooden towers from the Greek
- 1:12:23fire, the Crusaders had to flay animals, oxen
- 1:12:27and camels, and drape the freshly skinned, wet,
- 1:12:30bloody hides all over the front of the towers
- 1:12:32to act as a fire retardant. Before the final
- 1:12:35assault, the psychology of the army shifts again.
- 1:12:38Following a vision reported by a priest who claimed
- 1:12:41the spirit of the late Bishop Adomar spoke to
- 1:12:44him, the entire army undergoes intense spiritual
- 1:12:47purification. They fast for days. And then the
- 1:12:51entire army walks barefoot in a solemn, silent
- 1:12:55procession all the way around the walls of Jerusalem,
- 1:12:58carrying their relics. It mirrors the biblical
- 1:13:01story of Joshua at Jericho. Meanwhile, the Muslim
- 1:13:04defenders on the walls are shouting insults.
- 1:13:06banging drums and erecting crosses on the walls
- 1:13:09and spitting on them to provoke the Franks. But
- 1:13:12for a brief transcendent moment, the bitter,
- 1:13:15quarreling lords Raymond, Godfrey, Robert, set
- 1:13:19aside their political differences and swear to
- 1:13:21fight as one. On July 14th, the attack begins.
- 1:13:25They push these massive creaking wooden towers
- 1:13:27against the walls under a terrifying hail of
- 1:13:30arrows, rocks and Greek fire. The fighting is
- 1:13:33desperate. The next day, July 15th, 1099, around
- 1:13:38midday, Godfrey of Bouillon's tower manages to
- 1:13:41get close enough to the northern wall. They chop
- 1:13:43through the defenders' barricades and drop a
- 1:13:46heavy wooden drawbridge from the tower directly
- 1:13:48onto the stone battlements. Godfrey and his elite
- 1:13:51knights surge across the bridge. They secure
- 1:13:54a foothold on the wall. They fight their way
- 1:13:56down to the gate of St. Stephen and throw it
- 1:13:58open. The main army pours in. The Fatimid defense
- 1:14:01shatters. The city falls. And this is where we
- 1:14:05reach the bloody, horrifying climax, an event
- 1:14:08that casts a permanent, dark shadow over the
- 1:14:11entire history of the Crusades. Once inside,
- 1:14:14the Crusaders unleash an almost unfathomable,
- 1:14:17indiscriminate massacre. For three years, these
- 1:14:21men had suffered unimaginable trauma. They had
- 1:14:24watched their friends die of thirst, disease,
- 1:14:26and arrows. They were fueled by a toxic mix of
- 1:14:30extreme religious fervor, PTSD, and raw greed,
- 1:14:35and they took all of it out on the unarmed population
- 1:14:37of Jerusalem. They slaughtered Muslims and Jews
- 1:14:40alike, systematically clearing the streets and
- 1:14:43houses. The Jewish community retreated into their
- 1:14:46central synagogue, and the Crusaders burned the
- 1:14:49building to the ground with everyone inside.
- 1:14:51Thousands of Muslims sought sanctuary on the
- 1:14:53Temple Mount at the Al Aqsa Mosque. Crusader
- 1:14:56knights broke down the doors. and cut them down
- 1:14:58in such staggering numbers that multiple chroniclers
- 1:15:01describe the blood literally running ankle deep
- 1:15:04across the paving stones. We must be very clear
- 1:15:07here as historians. We are not judging 11th century
- 1:15:10warfare by 21st century moral standards. Sacking
- 1:15:13a city that resisted was standard military practice
- 1:15:16worldwide. But even by medieval standards, the
- 1:15:20sheer scale and religious fanaticism of the Jerusalem
- 1:15:23massacre was noted as exceptionally brutal. The
- 1:15:27duality of the crusader mindset in that moment
- 1:15:29is deeply jarring. Immediately after committing
- 1:15:33this mass slaughter, these men, literally soaked
- 1:15:37in human blood, sheathed their swords, washed
- 1:15:40their hands, and walked barefoot to the Church
- 1:15:43of the Holy Sepulcher, the site of Christ's tomb.
- 1:15:46And they fell to their knees on the floor, weeping
- 1:15:49in pious joy, singing hymns of gratitude. To
- 1:15:54the modern mind, it is... horrific hypocrisy.
- 1:15:58But to the medieval crusader, there was absolutely
- 1:16:01no contradiction. They deeply believed they were
- 1:16:04purifying the holy city. The extreme violence
- 1:16:07was the act of spiritual cleansing. But to the
- 1:16:11Islamic East, this event created a profound traumatic
- 1:16:15wound. It shattered the old assumption that these
- 1:16:17Franks were just temporary mercenaries working
- 1:16:20for the Greeks. It introduced a legacy of religiously
- 1:16:23motivated total war that fundamentally altered
- 1:16:27how the East viewed the West. They'd achieved
- 1:16:30the impossible against all logistical and military
- 1:16:33odds. They took Jerusalem. But conquering a city
- 1:16:37is one thing. Governing it is an entirely different
- 1:16:41nightmare. Right. They have to set up a government.
- 1:16:43They hold a council and Godfrey of Bouillon is
- 1:16:46chosen to rule. But Godfrey is famously pious.
- 1:16:50He refuses to wear a crown of gold in the very
- 1:16:52city where his savior wore a crown of thorns.
- 1:16:55So he rejects the title of king and takes the
- 1:16:58humble title, defender of the holy sepulcher.
- 1:17:01However, Godfrey dies of illness just a year
- 1:17:04later. And guess who gets the call? His younger
- 1:17:07brother, Baldwin, the same Baldwin who ruthlessly
- 1:17:09stole the county of Edessa from his adoptive
- 1:17:12father. Baldwin rushes down to Jerusalem and
- 1:17:15he has absolutely no theological scruples about
- 1:17:17crowns. He happily places a golden crown on his
- 1:17:20own head and becomes the first official king
- 1:17:23of Jerusalem. The Fatimids down in Egypt are
- 1:17:25obviously furious. They launch a massive, well
- 1:17:28-organized counterattack. But the Crusaders march
- 1:17:31out and catch the Egyptian army by surprise in
- 1:17:33the Battle of Ascalon, completely breaking the
- 1:17:35Fatimid forces and permanently securing the conquest.
- 1:17:39And then an incredible thing happens. Having
- 1:17:42fulfilled their vows to God, most of the Crusaders
- 1:17:45just pack up and go home. Robert of Normandy,
- 1:17:48Robert of Flanders, the surviving Counts. They
- 1:17:51gather some palm fronds as proof of their pilgrimage,
- 1:17:54board Italian ships, and sail back to Europe
- 1:17:56to reclaim their lands. Out of the tens of thousands
- 1:17:59who started, only a few hundred knights and a
- 1:18:02few thousand foot soldiers stay behind in the
- 1:18:04East. These few men are left to hold and govern
- 1:18:07the four newly created Crusader states, Edessa,
- 1:18:11Antioch, Jerusalem, and later Tripoli, a tiny
- 1:18:15elite ruling over millions of hostile subjects.
- 1:18:18The macro -historical impact of the First Crusade
- 1:18:20is staggering. First, it is the only crusade
- 1:18:24in history to actually fully achieve its stated
- 1:18:27military goals. It also completely restructured
- 1:18:30the European economy. The Italian merchant cities
- 1:18:32like Venice and Genoa were granted massive tax
- 1:18:36-free trading quarters in the conquered coastal
- 1:18:38cities. This funneled the vast wealth of the
- 1:18:41Silk Road directly into Italy, laying the economic
- 1:18:44foundation that would eventually fund the Renaissance.
- 1:18:47It also permanently destroyed the relationship
- 1:18:49between the Orthodox Byzantine Empire and the
- 1:18:52Catholic West. The portrayal over Antioch created
- 1:18:55a schism of trust that culminated in the horrific
- 1:18:57sack of Constantinople by Western crusaders a
- 1:19:00century later. It gave birth to entirely new
- 1:19:03concepts like the military orders, the Knights
- 1:19:05Templar and the Hospitallers, men who were paradoxically
- 1:19:08both monks and professional killers. And tragically,
- 1:19:12it deeply galvanized the Islamic world. The shock
- 1:19:15of the massacre at Jerusalem sowed the seeds
- 1:19:18for a unified, religiously -charged Muslim counter
- 1:19:21-crusade. It forced the fractured emirs to slowly
- 1:19:24unite, culminating decades later under leaders
- 1:19:27like Saladin, who would eventually crush the
- 1:19:30crusader armies and retake Jerusalem. The reverberations
- 1:19:34of this single expedition echoed for centuries,
- 1:19:37shaping the borders, the theology, and the conflicts
- 1:19:40of the modern world. It is just staggering to
- 1:19:42look back at the scope of this journey. from
- 1:19:45an aging pope standing in a freezing muddy field
- 1:19:47in France trying to solve a bureaucratic dispute
- 1:19:50with Germany through the massacres of the People's
- 1:19:54Crusade, the starvation and cannibalism at Antioch,
- 1:19:57the profound psychological miracle of the Holy
- 1:20:00Lands, and finally the horrific blood -soaked
- 1:20:04climax inside the walls of Jerusalem. I want
- 1:20:06to leave you, our listener, with a final thought
- 1:20:08to mull over. Consider the terrifying reality
- 1:20:11of the butterfly effect in history. Go all the
- 1:20:13way back to the beginning. If the Byzantine Emperor
- 1:20:16Romanos IV had not been betrayed by his own jealous
- 1:20:19generals at the Battle of Manzikert in 1071,
- 1:20:22his army wouldn't have been destroyed. The breadbasket
- 1:20:25of Anatolia wouldn't have fallen to the Turks.
- 1:20:27Emperor Alexios would never have needed to ask
- 1:20:30the Pope for Western mercenaries. Pope Urban
- 1:20:32II wouldn't have had the geopolitical pretext
- 1:20:35to launch his Grand Holy War. And the centuries
- 1:20:38of deep -seated religious, cultural, and military
- 1:20:41conflict between the Christian West and the Islamic
- 1:20:44East might look unimaginably different today.
- 1:20:47It is a profound reminder that the loudest, most
- 1:20:49deafening, world -breaking echoes in human history
- 1:20:52often start with a single, deeply misunderstood
- 1:20:55whisper. That is a perfect place to leave it.
- 1:20:58Thank you for joining us on this deep dive. Keep
- 1:21:00asking questions, keep exploring the mechanics
- 1:21:03of how we got here, and we'll catch you next
- 1:21:05time.