Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Keeping Arbitration Costs Down
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to today's program, Keeping Arbitration
- 0:06Costs Down. I'm Alla Poli Castro, Director of
- 0:09Education and Professional Development for the
- 0:11Beverly Hills Bar Association. And I'm delighted
- 0:14to introduce our speakers today, Erin Gotthelf
- 0:17and Stephanie Kubaca. Aaron is the Vice President
- 0:20of the American Arbitration Association's Commercial
- 0:23Division for the Pacific region. He serves as
- 0:26the National Chair of AAA's Entertainment Dispute
- 0:28Resolution Advisory Council and the Western U
- 0:31.S. Chair of AAA's Healthcare Dispute Resolution
- 0:34Advisory Council. Prior to joining AAA, Aaron
- 0:38was the Northern California Regional Director
- 0:40for Judicate West. Stephanie is the Vice President
- 0:44of the Employment Division of the American Arbitration
- 0:46Association International Center for Dispute
- 0:48Resolution. Prior to joining AAA, Stephanie practiced
- 0:52family and immigration law in the Chicagoland
- 0:55area. Stephanie received her JD from the Benjamin
- 0:58N. Cardozo School of Law in New York. We are
- 1:01excited to hear what they have to share with
- 1:03us today, and so I'm going to turn it over to
- 1:05them. All right. Thank you so much, Ala. Appreciate
- 1:08it. Everybody, thank you for joining Stephanie
- 1:11and myself this afternoon with our program, Keeping
- 1:14Arbitration Costs Down. This program kind of
- 1:18came to light as a variation of a program that
- 1:21I've done in the past, basically arbitration
- 1:24efficiency. The promise of arbitration, if you
- 1:28will, has always to been a faster, more cost
- 1:31-effective way of resolving disputes than traditional
- 1:33litigation. But we've seen that kind of get a
- 1:36little bit out of control or not be necessarily
- 1:41true in recent years. All right, so the goal
- 1:46of arbitration was always to be a faster, more
- 1:48cost -effective way of resolving disputes and
- 1:49traditional litigation. And what we see now is
- 1:53arbitration is starting to really mirror litigation.
- 1:56So extensive discovery, protracted motion practice,
- 1:59Highly contentious advocacy, longer case life
- 2:01cycles, higher costs. These are all things that
- 2:05scare attorneys. They scare clients. They're
- 2:08the reasons why people say they don't want to
- 2:11use arbitration because they think it's either
- 2:15cost the same as traditional litigation or potentially
- 2:17could cost more. Well, this presentation today
- 2:22is going to be provider neutral, as I say, meaning
- 2:25that Various ADR providers have some variation
- 2:30of the individual programs we're going to discuss
- 2:32today. These are just good things to keep in
- 2:34mind when trying to control the cost of your
- 2:37arbitration. A cost -effective arbitration starts
- 2:44with how you incorporate an ADR provision into
- 2:47a business contract. The ADR provision in your
- 2:51contract essentially is the roadmap for your
- 2:54arbitration. And in a lot of ways, it's going
- 2:56to determine costs and whatnot. So the types
- 3:01of ADR provisions that lead to high costs, I
- 3:02always like to say are first, poorly drafted
- 3:04arbitration provisions. So an arbitration provision
- 3:07that doesn't cite a specific set of rules, maybe
- 3:12applies the wrong rules to a particular dispute
- 3:15type, doesn't clearly lay out who pays for the
- 3:19arbitration, requires a panel of three arbitrators
- 3:23instead of a single arbitrator when a single
- 3:25arbitrator would have been a lot less expensive.
- 3:28Just so everybody knows, The typical three arbitrator
- 3:32panel is four to five times more expensive than
- 3:35a single arbitrator panel, regardless of individual
- 3:38rates and all that kind of stuff. And there's
- 3:40some variation there. Why is that? Because typically
- 3:43the chair has to build considerably more than
- 3:45the wings, just doing the work, supervising the
- 3:48wings. So you have to really think about whether
- 3:49you want three arbitrators on an arbitration.
- 3:52Does it make sense to require mediation first?
- 3:55A great way to save money on arbitration is never
- 3:57having to get to arbitration in the first place,
- 3:59right? So you see some arbitration provisions
- 4:01that have what we call a mediation speed bump
- 4:05or a mediation step. This would require the parties
- 4:07to do some sort of early mediation. early neutral
- 4:11evaluation, some type of dispute resolution process
- 4:16prior to the arbitration even being filed. And
- 4:19you'll find that a good chunk of disputes can
- 4:22be resolved relatively quickly in the early stages
- 4:26of disputes just by talking to their side. Which
- 4:30industry rules should I incorporate? Now, whether
- 4:33it's AAA jams, signature, ADR services, whichever
- 4:38provider you're working with. They all have some
- 4:40variation of commercial rules or construction
- 4:44rules or employment rules. And specifically,
- 4:49you want to obviously select the rules that most
- 4:52closely match the anticipated dispute type because
- 4:54that's going to set out a lot of different protocols
- 4:57and how the case will be handled. Everything
- 4:59from how many arbitrators might be handling your
- 5:01case to how many days of hearing time you get.
- 5:06to discovery provisions, all that kind of stuff.
- 5:08A lot of these are specific, rule specific. Fixed
- 5:13fee mediation arbitration versus a standard fee
- 5:15schedule. This is something we're gonna talk
- 5:17about a little bit later. Again, most providers
- 5:19offer some form of fixed fee mediation or arbitration.
- 5:25An example would be, I saw another provider was
- 5:28running an ad in the local legal publication
- 5:30a couple of weeks ago. And it said that they
- 5:34would, mediate any personal injury or medical
- 5:39malpractice dispute with a claim value under
- 5:42$100 ,000, a four -hour mediation for a simple
- 5:47flat fee of $800 per side. And they had a specialized
- 5:51panel that had agreed to accept that compensation,
- 5:55right? So you know up front, what things are
- 5:57gonna cost. How does that relate to arbitration?
- 6:02Typically for claim values under a certain threshold,
- 6:07you're going to see providers limit the number
- 6:11of hearing days, limit how many depositions can
- 6:15be taken or any depositions at all. establish
- 6:19an efficient timeline. The award has to go out
- 6:23within 60 days or 90 days or 120 days of appointment.
- 6:29Things like that are great ways to keep down
- 6:31costs. You don't have to guess what the arbitration
- 6:34is going to cost because it's not based on some
- 6:37hourly rate selected by the individual neutral,
- 6:40it's based on a set flat rate by the provider.
- 6:43Cost shifting provisions, who pays for the mediation
- 6:46or the arbitration. Again, in most contracts,
- 6:49the general rule is at least for commercial arbitration,
- 6:54that the fees are to be split between the parties.
- 6:58And if the provision allows for it, you can write
- 7:01the prevailing party is entitled to recoup their
- 7:05attorney's fees. or their arbitration costs or
- 7:08their attorney's fees and their arbitration costs.
- 7:10You want to be really specific about that in
- 7:12the arbitration provision about what it is they're
- 7:14entitled to get. Should discovery be limited?
- 7:17This is a fantastic way to cut down on costs
- 7:20in arbitration. Sometimes you'll see an arbitration
- 7:23provision drafted where it'll say, if the claim
- 7:27is under $100 ,000, each side is limited to no
- 7:31more than one deposition, right? Because We know,
- 7:35especially these days, one side could weaponize
- 7:40potentially the cost of discovery to force the
- 7:42other side into a bad settlement, and that's
- 7:44not good. Should the hearing be heard by via
- 7:48documents only? At AAA and at other providers,
- 7:51sometimes when some disputes are just literally
- 7:54over a couple of thousand dollars, it makes sense
- 7:57to submit the disputes on paper. Claimant submits
- 8:00their complaint in supporting evidence. Respond,
- 8:04it would issue an answer and they're supporting
- 8:06evidence and the arbitrator just without the
- 8:08need for any temporal argument issues of ruling,
- 8:10right? That's going to be very efficient. How
- 8:14will the mediation settlement or arbitration
- 8:16award be enforced? It's always going to save
- 8:19you money if you actually have a directive in
- 8:23the arbitration provision explaining that, which
- 8:27leads into the next part, how will appeals be
- 8:28handled? One of the most expensive parts of arbitration
- 8:31is enforcing awards or attempting to vacate awards.
- 8:35So many providers actually have optional appellate
- 8:37rules, where if one side's not happy with the
- 8:41award and wants to vacate it, or one side's happy
- 8:44with the award and wants to enforce it, there's
- 8:47a way that the provider can help you with that
- 8:49without you having to go to court and spend that
- 8:51kind of money. Also, whenever you go to court,
- 8:53whatever you've discussed in private and arbitration
- 8:57becomes very public very quickly on a public
- 9:00court document. Then, of course, addressing the
- 9:03issues of what happens when one side doesn't
- 9:06pay, which is a pretty typical tactic to a slower
- 9:11stop in arbitration. I just did an example here
- 9:16of a fixed rate mediation. Again, it's something
- 9:19that most providers offer some variation of.
- 9:23I initially drafted this slide as the AAA program
- 9:26with our thresholds and all that kind of stuff,
- 9:28but we have to be neutral here in this presentation.
- 9:31So typically, you know, where it saves you money
- 9:33is there's usually not a filing fee, especially
- 9:35if it's already tied to an existing arbitration.
- 9:38One thing that AAA that we really support is,
- 9:41you know, resolving disputes, having parties
- 9:45resolve disputes on their own. So if a mediation
- 9:48is going to avoid a full -blown arbitration.
- 9:52You might as well save the money up front, and
- 9:53we all support that here at AAA. Fixed rate compensation
- 9:57for the mediator. In arbitration and mediation
- 9:59in general, your biggest wild card is going to
- 10:01be the hourly rate of the neutral. In California,
- 10:05I see mediators and arbitrators out there doing
- 10:08things for $200, $300 an hour. I see mediators
- 10:12and arbitrators doing cases for $2 ,000 to $3
- 10:15,000 an hour. Right. There's a huge range as
- 10:18far as what people charge for stuff. Um, and
- 10:20it's usually based on the types of cases they
- 10:23handle and how popular they are. Um, but that
- 10:25can get really out of control. And if the rate
- 10:27is, it's a fixed rate compensation, you kind
- 10:30of know exactly upfront kind of what things are
- 10:31going to cost holding things virtually, right.
- 10:34Is always going to cost a lot less money than,
- 10:36um, making everybody show up to a hearing room
- 10:40center, charging them a room, mental fee, charging
- 10:43them a food fee. If they offer catering, that
- 10:45kind of stuff. If you've been to a provider and
- 10:49been charged an administrative fee or a room
- 10:51rental fee, that's what typically is covering
- 10:53all the external costs, including the food and
- 10:55staffing, the place and all that. The mediator
- 10:58could decide to limit or forego pre -mediation
- 11:00statements. I'm not a big fan of this one, but
- 11:03if it's a small enough. dispute in a simple enough
- 11:07dispute, at least the mediator thinks so. It's
- 11:10not always necessary to have the mediation statements,
- 11:13but mediation statements in general are usually
- 11:14a good idea. The mediator might actually decide
- 11:18to forego a pre -mediation conference call if
- 11:22they feel they understand enough about the case
- 11:24based on the mediation statements if they ask
- 11:26for those. And then procedures are written with
- 11:29accessibility as a key feature. One thing in
- 11:31AAA and other providers is we don't always have
- 11:36both sides necessarily represented by counsel
- 11:40and actions. Oftentimes, you'll have a pro se
- 11:44claimant. The claimant is usually the pro se
- 11:47side on a lot of these things, especially in
- 11:48consumer cases. You want to make the process
- 11:51as easy as possible, whether someone is an attorney
- 11:53or not, whether they understand the law or not.
- 11:56ADR is supposed to be accessible to everybody.
- 11:59All right, this was an example of fixed rate
- 12:01arbitration. So again, these are going to be
- 12:04for claims or counterclaims under a specific
- 12:06dollar threshold. So don't expect to file your
- 12:09$100 million arbitration claim and have an arbitrator
- 12:14that's going to do it for $300 an hour unlimited
- 12:17to a single day hearing. That's not how it works.
- 12:19Fixed rate compensation, again, for the arbitrator.
- 12:22Fixed rate compensation for the arbitrator could
- 12:24fall in two forms. The provider might cap their
- 12:27hourly rate. They might save for fixed rate arbitrations.
- 12:30All of our arbitrators receive $300 an hour compensation.
- 12:34Or they might cap the entire cost of the arbitration
- 12:37in general. So it would be something billed hourly.
- 12:39It would be, let's say, a commercial expedited
- 12:43case where the total compensation for the arbitrator
- 12:46was $2 ,000 for the case or something like that.
- 12:49So whether they spend an hour working on it or
- 12:51they spend 20 hours working on it, $2 ,000 is
- 12:54their compensation and the parties know that
- 12:56upfront. I'm a big fan of limiting strikes. on
- 13:02an initial rank and strike list when you're trying
- 13:04to save on costs. The more rank and strike lists
- 13:09that have to be sent out, the longer this process
- 13:11gets drawn out, really the more expensive it
- 13:13turns to be, especially for your clients if you're
- 13:15constantly reviewing rank and strike lists and
- 13:18then charging them for the time that you're doing
- 13:20that. Limiting discovery and motion practice.
- 13:23Again, for arbitrations under a certain threshold,
- 13:26we talked about, for example, limiting both sides
- 13:29to one deposition. or no deposition or doing
- 13:35everything via interrogatories and limiting the
- 13:38number of interrogatories, whatever you might
- 13:40want to do, a ban on site visits, things like
- 13:44that, all things that add the cost of an arbitration.
- 13:49And as well as limiting motion practice, outside
- 13:54of maybe just filing a general dispositive motion
- 13:56at the beginning of the case, something like
- 13:58that. The filing of lots of exotic discovery
- 14:02motions is one of the most expensive parts of
- 14:04the arbitration process and really starts to
- 14:07raise the cost. Again, for very low claims or
- 14:10counterclaims, you could hear it via document
- 14:12submissions. So it would basically be what we
- 14:14call a paper arbitration. You just hear it on
- 14:15the paper. Requiring the evidentiary hearing
- 14:19within a certain number of days of the preliminary
- 14:20hearing. So these things don't just kind of lay
- 14:24out there in the wind, right? The teams get to
- 14:26them quickly. And then having an award issued
- 14:29within a set number of days of the evidentiary
- 14:32hearing. Sometimes you might have an evidentiary
- 14:34hearing and the parties are wondering where the
- 14:36award is with a fixed rate arbitration. Usually
- 14:40in the procedures, this is all explained out
- 14:43what the time limits are for resolving some.
- 14:49Okay, drafting arbitration classes is your general
- 14:51options. So the arbitration rules to apply in
- 14:53the arbitrator selection process. The arbitrator
- 14:58selection process is something that I don't see
- 15:01as often in arbitration provisions, but it's
- 15:03going to save parties a lot of time and money.
- 15:06If this is spelled out. So whether it's a single
- 15:10arbitrator to be selected via rank and strike
- 15:12list, you can just literally write that into
- 15:14the arbitration provision. So the parties aren't
- 15:17wasting time over figuring out a point method.
- 15:20Or if it's going to be a three arbitrator panel,
- 15:22you write in there that Each side has 30 days
- 15:26after the initiation of the arbitration to appoint
- 15:28their party appointed arbitrator and the two
- 15:30party appointed arbitrators have 15 days to select
- 15:33a neutral chair or something like that. Again,
- 15:37single arbitrator cases are the most cost efficient.
- 15:42Rarely do I think you'd actually need a three
- 15:44arbitrator panel unless it's an extremely complicated
- 15:46issue and it's a very large claim out. Arbitrator
- 15:50qualifications, if you're specific in the arbitrary
- 15:52provision about the specific type of arbitrator
- 15:54you're looking for, that's going to make this
- 15:57a faster, less costly process. And you're going
- 16:01to get an arbitrator that has the right subject
- 16:04matter experience for your dispute type. Why
- 16:06is that important? Well, I don't like to think
- 16:10of arbitrators as necessarily being jacks of
- 16:12all trades, right? If you select an arbitrator
- 16:15for your case that does not have the right specific
- 16:19background for that type of a dispute type, they're
- 16:22going to bill you for the time it takes them
- 16:25to learn about the dispute type and to research
- 16:27the case and look at things that maybe an arbitrator
- 16:31that was a little more experienced within that
- 16:33practice area wouldn't have to bill that time
- 16:35for it because they already know it. Again, we
- 16:38talked about single panel or panel three arbitrators.
- 16:41Three arbitrators is always going to be typically
- 16:42four to five times more expensive. Keep that
- 16:45in mind. We've done studies, at least at AAA,
- 16:48as far as a single arbitrator versus a three
- 16:53arbitrator. Does one side tend to win more with
- 16:58one versus three? Are the award amounts? greater
- 17:03or less, one versus three, all these kinds of
- 17:05things. And really there's no statistical difference
- 17:07as far as the number of times a claimant might
- 17:09win versus a respondent might get a judgment
- 17:12or a victory and the size of the award. So really
- 17:17you have to really think about why you want three
- 17:18arbitrators. Governing law, and I always write
- 17:22not only substantive law, but the FA or the various
- 17:25state act that you're going to use. This is especially
- 17:28important when you're obviously dealing with
- 17:30parties in two different states. If it's an international
- 17:33arbitration, you're dealing with parties in two
- 17:34different countries. Again, if this isn't spelled
- 17:37out and you have parties that are in different
- 17:39jurisdictions, then this is another thing that
- 17:41the arbitrator is going to have to ask the parties
- 17:44for briefing on, possibly oral argument, I don't
- 17:46know, and make a decision on. And they're billing
- 17:49you for all that time while they're doing that.
- 17:51Again, it's a waste of money. Spell it out in
- 17:53the provision. Locality arbitration, location
- 17:57of the evidentiary hearing. Listen. one city,
- 18:02one state, one city, one country, do not put
- 18:04in multiple cities and multiple states, multiple
- 18:06cities and multiple countries. I've seen some
- 18:08of these provisions that just give all these
- 18:10different options and I guarantee you that's
- 18:13just going to create conflict that has to be
- 18:15resolved either by the provider or by the arbitrator.
- 18:19Again, costing the parties more money for that.
- 18:23Confidentiality issues of where we made public
- 18:25and all that. The general presumption is arbitration
- 18:27is supposed to be a confidential process, but
- 18:29there's always going to be situations where the
- 18:31law says it's not confidential. For example,
- 18:33I had, I don't know, a big case a couple of months
- 18:37ago where a large publicly traded company was
- 18:42issued a $100 million award and they had to disclose
- 18:47to their shareholders where the $100 million
- 18:49came from. losing side was very upset about this.
- 18:53They didn't want any of the award to be made
- 18:56public in any way or disclosed to anyone. But
- 18:58that's what the law said, right? And so that
- 19:00could have been clarified in the arbitration
- 19:02provision. The discovery process that we talked
- 19:04about, whether you're going to limit depositions,
- 19:08force everybody to use interrogatories, whether
- 19:12testimony is going to be done via live witnesses
- 19:16or sworn statements, whatever it might be, you
- 19:18can add this all kind of into the provision,
- 19:19right? Remedies, including emergency relief.
- 19:23For those of you that don't know what an emergency
- 19:25relief is, occasionally there might be an emergency
- 19:27arbitration that takes place if there's some
- 19:29issue that has to be resolved right away that's
- 19:31not handled by necessarily the merits arbitrator,
- 19:35but a secondarily appointed process arbitrator.
- 19:39Again, I don't see it commonly drafted in arbitration
- 19:41provisions, but it would kind of clarify what
- 19:43happens in those types of times of the essence
- 19:45situations. In the assessment attorney's fees
- 19:48cost of the arbitration, some becomes prevailing
- 19:50party provision. It is very important to be highly
- 19:55specific if you are going to have a prevailing
- 19:58party provision about what the prevailing party
- 20:01gets. What I typically see is the winning side
- 20:06will submit a attorney fee application. And I
- 20:12don't want to say sneak it into the attorney
- 20:14fee application, but in addition to the attorney's
- 20:17fees that they're seeking, they start adding
- 20:20in the cost of the arbitration, the deposits
- 20:23they paid to the arbitrator, the filing fee and
- 20:26the administrative fees of the arbitration, room
- 20:28rental fees, hotel rooms, plane tickets, meals,
- 20:32all this kind of stuff, the greater cost of the
- 20:35arbitration. Well, you need to really take a
- 20:37look at what the provision says. Are you entitled
- 20:40really to get everything back or is it just the
- 20:43attorney's fees? So if you're the drafter of
- 20:46a contract and you intend for them literally
- 20:48to get every dime they spent back on the arbitration,
- 20:51really spell that out and be clear about it.
- 20:56And then the type of arbitration award you'd
- 20:58expect, standard reason, simple whatnot. A simple
- 21:02award that simply can be a couple of sentences
- 21:05explaining who won and what they got is going
- 21:08to be the least expensive to draft. And if you
- 21:10have a relatively small case, let's say you're
- 21:13issuing an award under $25 ,000 or something
- 21:16like that, that might make the most sense. But
- 21:20on the other hand, if it's a multimillion dollar
- 21:23award, tens of millions of dollars, hundreds
- 21:25of million dollars, billions of dollars, then
- 21:28you're going to probably want a reasoned award
- 21:29that really explains how the arbitrator, the
- 21:33panel got to reach the conclusions that they
- 21:34reached. Because if you have to go to court and
- 21:37file an enforcement action, I think it's going
- 21:39to be really hard to enforce a $100 million award
- 21:43in court, where the judges reviewing the award
- 21:46and the arbitrator didn't actually explain how
- 21:50they got to their numbers. All right. Poorly
- 21:54drafted arbitration clauses result in a failure
- 21:55to meet the party's expectations. Well, what
- 21:57are the party's expectations about arbitration?
- 21:59Why are we using arbitration in the first place?
- 22:01Because it's a faster, more cost -efficient way
- 22:03to resolve disputes in traditional court. Right
- 22:07now, even on the biggest cases, it's still a
- 22:09lot faster to resolve a dispute. I think I saw
- 22:12in California, the average federal district court
- 22:15in California, it's about three years, last I
- 22:18checked, from the date a demand for jury trial
- 22:21is filed till you actually get the jury trial.
- 22:26Most arbitrations, I think, can be done within
- 22:27a year, so it's about a third of that time. But
- 22:30the expectation is going to be faster and more
- 22:32cost effective. Costs that quickly spiral out
- 22:35of control with the advantage going aside that
- 22:37is one way to spend on the process. Arbitration
- 22:39was never designed where if you have more money
- 22:42to spend on the arbitration, you have a better
- 22:45chance at winning the arbitration. It's designed
- 22:47to be a fair and neutral process regardless of
- 22:51your ability to pay for things. And we see this
- 22:53all the time. Usually respondents or well -funded
- 22:57respondents will start asking for all sorts of
- 23:01exotic discovery, They'll demand a three -week
- 23:05evidentiary hearing when maybe one week is probably
- 23:08enough time. There's really protracted motion
- 23:12practice on just about everything. Every motion
- 23:15they file, they're going to demand an oral argument.
- 23:17They're not willing to just let the arbitrator
- 23:20decide on the papers. Listen, you can write into
- 23:25the arbitration provision as much or as little
- 23:28as you want about controlling the process, the
- 23:31discovery process, the timeline. whatnot. It's
- 23:34something that you might want to think about
- 23:35if you're trying to keep your arbitration costs
- 23:37down. And then ultimately, the side that has
- 23:40more money that's spent on the process, their
- 23:42goal is to basically force the other side into
- 23:44a less than desirable settlement agreement. So
- 23:47yes, the case does settle prior to the evidentiary
- 23:49hearing, and you might save some money that way
- 23:51by not having the evidentiary hearing, but usually
- 23:55the side that was forced into the bad settlement
- 23:58agreement is not too happy with that result.
- 24:00Unnecessary court intervention. If an arbitration
- 24:03provision is not drafted clearly and the parties
- 24:06disagree with the interpreters, sorry, the providers
- 24:09interpretation of it or the arbitrators interpretation
- 24:13of it, unfortunately, sometimes we see these
- 24:16things going to court. We see one party filing
- 24:18a TRO. to stop the arbitration in its tracks,
- 24:22to have a judge look at the arbitration provision
- 24:25and answer some of the finer points of what the
- 24:27process of the arbitration should be. The second
- 24:30you go to court, court's expensive, and court's
- 24:33an extremely public process. Probably somebody
- 24:37put an arbitration provision here because they
- 24:38didn't want all their dirty laundry hang down
- 24:40in the air. As soon as it gets to court, that's
- 24:42where it ends up. Then of course, the arbitral
- 24:44process itself being blamed for the unfortunate
- 24:46result, not the poor arbitration clause. So many
- 24:49people I talked to that say that they hate arbitration,
- 24:52they've always had a bad experience with it or
- 24:54whatnot. I can look back to like their arbitration
- 24:57provision, I can be like, boy, that was a really
- 24:59bad one. This is a 200 page contract and somewhere
- 25:02on page 197, section two clause 3a, there was
- 25:07a one sentence arbitration provision that doesn't
- 25:10make any sense. Somebody spent all this money
- 25:13drafting a 200 page contract, and they spent
- 25:16one sentence on the arbitration provision, it's
- 25:18not even good. Terrible. All right. If you take
- 25:22nothing else from our presentation today, and
- 25:25some of you may have heard say this before, because
- 25:27these five items never change, listen up on these
- 25:31five items. In these five items, I compiled based
- 25:35on the number of disputes I've seen from the
- 25:39case management side. What are the five things
- 25:41most commonly argued about if they're not clear
- 25:43on the arbitration provision? or they're missing
- 25:45entirely. Okay, so the rules to be used. Every
- 25:48provider has some variation in the commercial
- 25:50rules or the construction rules or the employment
- 25:53rules, et cetera, right? It's very important
- 25:55to have the right rules for your dispute type
- 25:57because if the wrong rules are being used, you're
- 26:01gonna get the wrong type of arbitrator. It's
- 26:03gonna follow the wrong process. And oftentimes
- 26:05the rules determine who has to pay for the arbitration.
- 26:08So for example, And the consumer rules or the
- 26:11employment rules, it's the respondent company
- 26:13that's paying for everything, right? And if that's
- 26:15not what you intended for, you want to make sure
- 26:18the right rules are in there. Unfortunately,
- 26:20what I see in a lot of contracts is according
- 26:23to the American Arbitration Association rules
- 26:25or according to the GM's rules, right? There
- 26:29is no such thing as the American Arbitration
- 26:31Association rules. rules. There's no such thing
- 26:33as the jams rules. There's the American conversation
- 26:36commercial rules, right? There's the jams employment
- 26:40rules, right? So you have to really be specific,
- 26:42don't just say the name of the provider and assume
- 26:44that the person, the case manager and the arbitration
- 26:49provider are going to know exactly what you're
- 26:52talking about. Alright, the location of the evidence
- 26:55you're hearing. It's going to be one city, one
- 26:57state, one city, one country, right? Do not give
- 27:00people options. Do not leave this section blank.
- 27:04Everybody is going to want home turf advantage.
- 27:07So they're going to argue the location of the
- 27:09hearing should be closest to what suits their
- 27:12needs best. All right. Well, the arbitration
- 27:15we heard by a single arbitrator, three arbitrators,
- 27:18some providers, if you're silent on this. are
- 27:21going to make this determination for you based
- 27:23on the size of the claim. And we talked about
- 27:26this in the past, that a three arbitrator panel
- 27:28is way more expensive than a single arbitrator
- 27:30panel. And at least at AAA, the threshold is
- 27:33only a couple million dollars, the difference
- 27:34between one and three. So you really should be
- 27:39specific about this. And I wrote, do not just
- 27:43rely on the word arbitrator and the singular
- 27:45to convey what you're trying to talk about, because
- 27:48courts have interpreted Arbitrator, that could
- 27:51mean a single arbitrator or a three arbitrator
- 27:53panel. So you're going to want to use the word
- 27:54single or the word three. All right. Choice of
- 27:57law provision. Obviously very important if dealing
- 27:59with two different states. You want to have the
- 28:01procedural law and the substantive law explained.
- 28:07And then does the arbitrator have the authority
- 28:09to award attorneys fees and arbitration costs
- 28:11to the prevailing party? What constitutes those
- 28:15costs? So that's going to be very important to
- 28:19lay out. Okay. All right. And then this is just
- 28:25a sample general arbitration clause that I drafted
- 28:28here. Again, you could use this for any provider.
- 28:32I even wrote in fill in the provider name, but
- 28:35this is going to hit all five of those elements
- 28:43I discussed for a properly drafted arbitration.
- 28:51Okay, and I will turn over this part of the presentation
- 28:54to my colleague Stephanie, take it away. Thank
- 28:57you, Aaron. So this is going to be pretty, this
- 29:02slide is going to be very similar to just what
- 29:04Aaron just discussed. This is how we can keep
- 29:06things down in the pre -dispute stage. So one
- 29:11is to require a cooling off period in your ADR
- 29:14provision. So have some time built in. uh you
- 29:18know 30 days before a party can file an arbitration
- 29:22um you know some meet and confer time built into
- 29:25your arbitration provision in the contract uh
- 29:29and then again consider a mediation step so With
- 29:34this, though, I do want to emphasize that having
- 29:37some discovery, some document exchange prior
- 29:41to that mediation step is something that may
- 29:43be important to include. You want a full picture
- 29:46when you go into a mediation or at least a fuller
- 29:48picture, and you don't want to waste your time
- 29:51or your client's time and money in having to
- 29:55do a mediation, having that be a prerequisite
- 29:58to filing an arbitration. if nobody has any reason
- 30:02to really proceed with some discovery exchange
- 30:05and document exchange. And then, like Erin said
- 30:10before, making sure you're picking the appropriate
- 30:12rules for your contract type. So I won't go into
- 30:16the rest of these too much. We did kind of talk
- 30:19about these a lot in the earlier slides. So the
- 30:22next slide, Erin. And so now you're in arbitration.
- 30:30something's been filed and you are now in front
- 30:34of a provider and the parties are ready to move
- 30:37forward. Here you want to, and I cannot emphasize
- 30:42this enough, one of the biggest benefits of arbitration
- 30:45is that many times you have control or you have
- 30:50the ability to help select your arbitrator. your
- 30:56decision maker is, it's usually that decision
- 30:58is in the hands of the parties and their attorneys.
- 31:02So this, selecting the right arbitrator for your
- 31:06case may be the most important decision you make,
- 31:09at least in the beginning stages of your arbitration.
- 31:13Depending on the case, you want to make sure
- 31:15that if you are looking, if this is a claim that
- 31:18requires subject matter expertise, then select
- 31:22an arbitrator with that. review their resume,
- 31:25talk to your case manager about that. You know
- 31:30- Can I just add something to that real quick,
- 31:32Stephanie? Sure. One thing that I unfortunately
- 31:34see a lot in the arbitrator selection process
- 31:38is I will be going over the qualifications that
- 31:42the parties are specifically looking for in an
- 31:44arbitrator to handle their case, and I'll inevitably
- 31:47get one side that says They absolutely have to
- 31:52be a retired state or federal judge. If I see
- 31:55a single attorney arbitrator on this list, I'm
- 31:57going to absolutely strike them outright. Okay.
- 32:03Subject matter expertise matters way more than
- 32:06somebody spending time on the bench, especially
- 32:09when you're dealing with really technical type
- 32:11things. Stephanie and I both work with our national
- 32:16technology practice here at AAA. I would take
- 32:20an attorney arbitrator that understood something
- 32:22about a complex technology matter like a semiconductor,
- 32:27you know, IP dispute or something like that any
- 32:30day over some, you know, judge who's been off
- 32:33the bench for 10 years that knows nothing about
- 32:35what I'm talking about. So do not discount someone
- 32:38simply because they're not a retired state or
- 32:40federal judge. The other the other items that
- 32:45you'll want to focus on are maybe meeting with
- 32:49opposing counsel to discuss how to work out any
- 32:53procedural issues that you have before. Is there
- 32:56going to be a jurisdictional issue? Is somebody
- 32:59objecting to arbitration altogether? Is somebody
- 33:02objecting to the jurisdiction of this provider?
- 33:06Make sure that you have tried as best you can
- 33:10to work with opposing counsel to see if there
- 33:12are any of those issues. If you think a motion
- 33:15to compel is going to be necessary, it may be
- 33:19best to do that in advance at the same time.
- 33:27I know we don't always know. You may not always
- 33:29know before you get into arbitration that someone's
- 33:31objecting. But if it can be discussed beforehand,
- 33:35then try to. I want to say 90 % of the cases
- 33:41that I've worked on, opposing counsel work really
- 33:43well together. Of course, there are some cases
- 33:46where you see the back and forth, but most of
- 33:49them, opposing counsel, even if they're not in
- 33:51agreement, they can work together through some
- 33:53of those issues to help save their clients some
- 33:55time and money. And then this is just a list
- 33:59of different things that you're going to want
- 34:01to consider. A joint stipulation of facts for
- 34:05your arbitrator protective order. If you know
- 34:08that if this is a tech case or an IP case or
- 34:11something where there's some trade secret issue
- 34:13and you want to have all of those, you know that
- 34:16that's going to come up, draft it beforehand
- 34:18so that all you have to do is have the arbitrator
- 34:20ready for it to sign. Do the red lines back and
- 34:24forth before you get it to the arbitrator. so
- 34:27that you're not also paying the arbitrator for
- 34:29their back and forth while you're doing it. And
- 34:33then again, depositions, interrogatories, if
- 34:36necessary, try and talk to opposing counsel before
- 34:39you get on the phone with the arbitrator about
- 34:42what each side is looking for. That will also
- 34:45help keep the costs down for the arbitrator to
- 34:48potentially have to referee any discovery issues
- 34:51at the very beginning. Again, I cannot stress
- 34:57enough in trying to address, if you can, any
- 34:59jurisdictional issues before you even get to
- 35:03the arbitrator appointment stage. Next slide.
- 35:06Then one jurisdictional issue specifically with
- 35:10an arbitration that really might make more sense
- 35:13for a court dealing before an arbitration is
- 35:14being filed is occasionally I'm reached out to
- 35:17by a claimant that's in the process of filing
- 35:20an arbitration against what we call a third party
- 35:23respondent. uh somebody who's not named uh in
- 35:26the contract right and uh the legality of this
- 35:31um you know while not governed by statute is
- 35:34you typically govern kind of by case law uh different
- 35:37jurisdictions looking at different ways some
- 35:39really try to do everything in their power to
- 35:42see how this third party respondent could be
- 35:44somehow tied to the contract or the ones just
- 35:46outright dismiss them as they're not a party
- 35:48proper part of the arbitration um that's the
- 35:50exact kind of thing even before you file an arbitration,
- 35:54you're going to want to go to court and get a
- 35:57motion to compel signed off on by a judge against
- 36:00a third party respondent. So they can't immediately
- 36:02come back once they're served saying, my client's
- 36:04not a party to this contract, because then the
- 36:07arbitrator is going to have to spend some time
- 36:10deciding whether or not they're a party to the
- 36:11contract because the arbitrator has an authority.
- 36:13And then if The third party respondent doesn't
- 36:16agree with the arbitrator's decision. It's going
- 36:17to end up in court anyways. So you could have
- 36:19just saved the entire step having the arbitrator
- 36:21involved as well as the cost. So thanks, Stephanie.
- 36:24I'll advance the slides. Thank you. OK. So as
- 36:29I was saying earlier, selecting the correct arbitrator
- 36:32for your case is the most important. the most
- 36:36important decision you're gonna make early in
- 36:37the arbitration, at least from the provider standpoint.
- 36:41I have managed hundreds of cases and I have seen
- 36:45how important this step is. So, like I said,
- 36:50if it's something that you believe really is
- 36:52going to require subject matter expertise, Talk
- 36:56to your whichever provider. We all have great
- 37:00case managers who can really help assist. They
- 37:04know this process well. They know their panel
- 37:06well. Reach out to them. Use them as a resource
- 37:09to help you find the best arbitrator for your
- 37:12case. If a subject matter expertise is not as
- 37:20important, then, you know, they can help you
- 37:21find an arbitrator that is going to fit your
- 37:25client's budget. And they might find an arbitrator
- 37:28that's going to fit a timeline if timelines are
- 37:30an issue in your contract clause. What you don't
- 37:35want to do is select an arbitrator who doesn't
- 37:38have the subject matter expertise that you need.
- 37:41and then you and your clients are going to spend
- 37:44a lot of money and time trying to get that arbitrator
- 37:47up to speed, especially if it's a very technical
- 37:50type of claim. And one, especially for larger
- 37:57cases or cases where there's very technical claims
- 37:59or issues, one thing that I don't see very much
- 38:04and I think it is underutilized is having counsel
- 38:08interview potential arbitrators. So that can
- 38:14be very helpful. It can be very helpful in also
- 38:17keeping the arbitrator selection process moving
- 38:20along quickly and efficiently. Sometimes we'll
- 38:23have parties who they know what they want, but
- 38:28they're not seeing it in the list or they don't
- 38:30know anyone who might make a good arbitrator
- 38:32for this case. And there could be a really good
- 38:37arbitrator, just not the experiences enlisted
- 38:39in that arbitrator's resume. So what I've had
- 38:44happen is they will send me a list of questions
- 38:47together, that they've worked on together, that
- 38:49they're both in agreement, we can ask the arbitrator.
- 38:53We'll all get on the phone, we'll all get on
- 38:55a Zoom call or a Teams call, and they'll be able
- 38:58to ask the arbitrator those questions, or potential
- 39:01arbitrator those questions. and both parties
- 39:04are present, so they're both going to get the
- 39:07answers. And then at that point, once we're done
- 39:10with the call, the parties and their representatives
- 39:13can meet and confer and see, you know, is that,
- 39:17were those the answers that they wanted or do
- 39:19we need to keep looking? It really does help.
- 39:24No, they're not allowed to ask to talk about
- 39:26the merits of the case or anything like that,
- 39:28but it is something that if your provider offers
- 39:32it, You should use it if you need to and if they
- 39:36don't you should ask Yeah, I was really surprised
- 39:39to see that Stephanie's been here what nine years
- 39:42and I've been here close to seven and I asked
- 39:46Stephanie how many times in your career at AAA
- 39:48had you Seen anybody actually do an interview
- 39:51and she said once and I said the same thing with
- 39:54me I've only seen happen once too. I don't know
- 39:57why more parties don't take advantage of it,
- 39:59but it's a fantastic way to really get to know
- 40:02an arbitrator beyond just kind of what you read
- 40:04on a piece of paper. A couple of things I want
- 40:06to add here. So I always like to think, you know,
- 40:10beyond the state bring strictly if you have a
- 40:11good working relationship with opposing counsel,
- 40:13why not select the arbitrator together? Just,
- 40:17I'm a generally a pretty trusting person. But
- 40:20in this process, you really have to know who
- 40:22you're dealing with on the other side. Of course,
- 40:24I've seen situations where you send the party's
- 40:2710 names. They try to discuss the names with
- 40:31each other. One side says they like these names.
- 40:34The other side says they like these names. Inevitably,
- 40:38they come back to you and say, let's go ahead.
- 40:40We just want to do it as a traditional rank and
- 40:41strike list. And one side strikes the five that
- 40:45they knew the other side wanted, and then vice
- 40:47versa. We see that happen here. So if you truly
- 40:51are getting along with the other side and you
- 40:53actually trust them, then you should have a elaborate
- 40:57discussion with them. Be honest about the process.
- 41:01If you're sent a bunch of names and let's say
- 41:03I have the 10 names, you like three of them and
- 41:06you tell the other side you like them. If you
- 41:08have used them as an arbitrator in the past,
- 41:10especially recently, you really need to disclose
- 41:12that because the last thing we want is the arbitrator
- 41:17is certainly going to make those disclosures
- 41:19when they fill out their disclosure paperwork
- 41:20and that can really end up costing a lot of extra
- 41:24money and taking a lot of extra time. All right,
- 41:31next slide here. So again, these are just other
- 41:36things that you can do to help promote efficiency
- 41:41in your arbitration. And it's things that can
- 41:45be done prior to the preliminary hearing that
- 41:46takes place with the arbitrator. talk about when
- 41:53you can schedule, when you can both schedule
- 41:55or if there's more than two parties, when everybody
- 41:58can have some mutually, what are some mutually
- 42:01convenient dates? How long do you expect the
- 42:04hearing? I have a case now where the parties
- 42:08had booked five days. It's now eight. And so
- 42:13they had discussed it. They had done everything
- 42:15by the book. So it does come up. As you go along
- 42:19in the case, as you do more discovery, you realize,
- 42:23oh, we have four or five more witnesses than
- 42:25we anticipated at the beginning of this case.
- 42:29But if you can talk about it beforehand, it's
- 42:32easier to add on dates after you've already had
- 42:36some set time than try to do that a lot later.
- 42:40And then if you can, witness availability is
- 42:43always really good. Party representative availability
- 42:46is something that multiple times I've been on
- 42:49preliminary hearings and, you know, counsel will
- 42:52say, well, I can do this date, but I have to
- 42:55check with my client. And then we have, so then
- 42:58it further delays being able to even set your
- 43:00hearing date, which kind of delays being able
- 43:02to set discovery cutoff dates and things like
- 43:04that. So just think about all of those things
- 43:07if you can in advance with opposing counsel.
- 43:11Again, the protective orders and then make sure
- 43:15that you address any choice of law issues. So
- 43:19what does your contract say? Which rule is going
- 43:23to govern? Is it going to be the FAA? Is this
- 43:25going to be under state law? Will the CCP rules
- 43:28apply? All things that I have seen where parties
- 43:32have had to, sometimes the contract isn't clear.
- 43:37There's some ambiguity. So if you know, you may
- 43:41not agree, you know, you're an opposing counsel,
- 43:42one opposing, one party might say, well, no,
- 43:44New York law is listed in this clause in the
- 43:47contract and California law is listed right next
- 43:50to the ADR clause. So California law applies.
- 43:54If you know it's going to be an issue, raise
- 43:57it with the arbitrator at the preliminary hearing
- 44:00or beforehand in case the arbitrator wants briefing.
- 44:05or try and see if you can come to an agreement
- 44:07with the policy council on it. Another thing
- 44:10to keep in mind too with all of this and everything
- 44:13that Stephanie is saying is, for those of you
- 44:15that are watching this presentation today that
- 44:17are not advocates but actually arbitrators yourselves,
- 44:20you should have a letter customized to yourself
- 44:24as far as what you want to discuss during the
- 44:27preliminary hearing, basically homework in advance
- 44:30for the parties to complete. before the preliminary
- 44:33hearing, so none of this is like a surprise to
- 44:36them. You should send a letter out in advance
- 44:38saying, hey, please meeting confer on all these
- 44:41issues so we can have a quick and efficient preliminary
- 44:43hearing. I would say that, unfortunately, for
- 44:46the large complex cases that I've case managed,
- 44:50maybe 30 % of them have actually had to have
- 44:52a second preliminary hearing because none of
- 44:56these issues were able to be worked out on the
- 44:57first preliminary hearing. Some, it's because
- 44:59the parties didn't know what they were going
- 45:01to be working out. which I find it hard to believe,
- 45:04but at least that's what the parties would say.
- 45:07But again, a second preliminary hearing is another
- 45:12hour or two of billed time by the arbitrator
- 45:15that could have not been spent, and this is about
- 45:18keeping arbitration costs down. Sorry, Stephanie,
- 45:20continue. Go on to the next slide, please. These
- 45:31are also, you know, I'm going to focus more on
- 45:35the like, you know, have the parties talked about
- 45:40the scope of the arbitration. So we talked about
- 45:42that earlier. Have you discussed what the scope
- 45:45of this arbitration is? Sometimes there's multiple
- 45:48claims and I've had cases where they have both
- 45:52state court claims and then arbitration claims.
- 45:55So making sure that the arbitrator in advance
- 45:59knows what claims they're going to be hearing
- 46:01and what claims are being taken care of in state
- 46:03court. And then if there is a state court action,
- 46:06making sure that everyone is aware of any outcome
- 46:09or any orders that take place in the state court
- 46:12action, especially in case they inform anything
- 46:14that has to take place during the arbitration.
- 46:17So just keeping those lines of communication
- 46:19open with your case manager, with your arbitrator.
- 46:24If it can be narrowed, if the scope of this arbitration
- 46:27can be narrowed, especially to help keep things
- 46:29moving along, try and do that. If there's a counterclaim
- 46:35that will be filed, most times by the time we
- 46:38get to the preliminary hearing, it's been about
- 46:41a month or two since a demand has been filed.
- 46:44And generally the parties will know. The other
- 46:47side will know whether or not they're going to
- 46:48be filing a counterclaim. Very rarely will I
- 46:52see arbitrators give long periods of time for
- 46:56a party to make a determination as to whether
- 46:59or not they're going to file a counterclaim.
- 47:00It's usually, if they don't know by the preliminary
- 47:03hearing, I want to say it's maybe 14 to 30 days
- 47:06that the other side is going to have to file
- 47:09that counterclaim. Because it really does also
- 47:12inform the length of the hearing. how long discovery
- 47:16is going to take, how many depositions each side
- 47:18is going to take, because if there's a claim
- 47:21and a counterclaim, then there might be more
- 47:25discovery that needs to take place. And then
- 47:30a lot of providers allow for dispositive motions.
- 47:35And sometimes parties will say, well, we don't
- 47:39know if we're going to file a dispositive motion.
- 47:41And then they won't allow time for it in the
- 47:45preliminary hearing schedule, scheduling order.
- 47:47And a lot of arbitrators will put that in anyways,
- 47:51but have that discussion with the opposing council.
- 47:54Do they anticipate doing that? Normally, you
- 47:57know, everybody kind of knows if somebody is
- 47:59gonna be filing a dispositive motion, but it's
- 48:04better to talk about when you can file it, when
- 48:08you expect to be able to respond, when you expect
- 48:11to be able to have a hearing on it if necessary.
- 48:14and work that out in advance, then waiting until
- 48:17six months into the case and the hearing is just
- 48:21a few months out. And now you're like, well,
- 48:23I want to file a dispositive motion. And if you
- 48:26lose, everything is going to have to be pushed
- 48:27out even further. Talk about making sure that
- 48:33your mediation, if you're going to be scheduling
- 48:35one, that it's well in advance of the arbitrator's
- 48:38cancellation policy. a lot of providers have
- 48:44provisions in their rules that you know mediation
- 48:47has to take place or at least has to be attempted
- 48:49and the arbitrators will will give a mediation
- 48:54cutoff date as well. Working with your arbitrator
- 48:57reviewing when their cancellation policy starts
- 48:59is going to really help if you do get that mediation
- 49:02scheduled and assume that it's going to take
- 49:05maybe two weeks after the mediation date to actually
- 49:08get everything finished and get your settlement
- 49:10agreements signed and finalized because what
- 49:14you don't want to do is schedule the mediation
- 49:17right before the arbitrators cancellation policy
- 49:22kicks in and then you settled the case but you're
- 49:26still paying for the arbitrators time for the
- 49:29hearing, whatever their cancellation policy is.
- 49:31So you'll want to keep that in mind when you're
- 49:35putting together, which is our last point, drafting
- 49:37a proposed joint scheduling order. So again,
- 49:41this assumes that council can work together.
- 49:44This assumes, I've had a lot of council who even
- 49:48said, we don't belong in arbitration. Just say,
- 49:51we're drafting this, but we are not waiving our
- 49:53right to. to jurisdiction or to fight jurisdiction.
- 49:59We don't agree that we should be here. That is
- 50:02something that you're gonna want to, if you can,
- 50:05do it together and send it to your arbitrator
- 50:07in advance. They can look at the dates. Will
- 50:10these hearing dates even work for the arbitrator?
- 50:12And you can kind of get some of that taken care
- 50:14of instead of doing it at the end or having to
- 50:18wait, like Aaron said, to have another preliminary
- 50:22hearing. I've seen some parties prepare so well
- 50:25before the preliminary hearing that the preliminary
- 50:27hearing, which on average lasts an hour, I've
- 50:30seen some last five minutes because the parties
- 50:33were so prepared. And then the arbitrators billing
- 50:36you five minutes of their time, not an hour,
- 50:38right? So keeping arbitration costs down. Again,
- 50:41the biggest waste of money is if you have to
- 50:43do the preliminary hearing twice because absolutely
- 50:46nothing was decided first time around. Okay,
- 50:49Stephanie, take it away during the preliminary
- 50:51hearing. All right. So this is gonna be what
- 50:55happens when you're on the phone with the arbitrator
- 50:57and you're setting out the schedule for the rest
- 51:00of the case with the opposing counsel. Sometimes
- 51:03representatives join, sometimes they don't. So
- 51:05again, that's a personal preference of each attorney.
- 51:09Do you want your - It's not required. It's not
- 51:11required. I don't believe any of the providers
- 51:15require that, but I - None of the providers require
- 51:17the client to be on the call, correct? Page limits.
- 51:23Page limits on both actual briefing and exhibits
- 51:27are something that you are going to want to think
- 51:29long and hard about because when we are putting
- 51:33together estimates for the arbitrators' compensation
- 51:38for the whole case, one of the biggest issues
- 51:41that comes up towards the end when we're doing
- 51:44pre -hearing briefs and post -hearing briefs
- 51:46is the arbitrators will get a 200 -page pre -hearing
- 51:52brief, it's 25 pages for the brief itself, which,
- 51:57you know, they'll set those limits, but then,
- 51:59you know, 175 pages of exhibits or more that
- 52:04the parties are going to have to pay the arbitrator
- 52:06to review, but the arbitrator didn't realize
- 52:09that he or she was going to get 200 pages of
- 52:13briefs per side. So that's something that you're
- 52:17going to want to think about. Discuss that. setting
- 52:21page limits on both the briefs and the exhibits
- 52:26themselves. I had one case where it was a very
- 52:29small, it was an expedited case, but the one
- 52:34party sent 800 pages of exhibits. And an expedited
- 52:41case, it was a flat rate case. So the arbitrator
- 52:45was only We had only billed $2 ,500 for a day
- 52:49of hearing and what they thought were going to
- 52:51be small briefs. No, it was 800 pages. So try
- 52:56to avoid that. We didn't end up having to bill
- 52:59the arbitrator's hourly rate because we weren't
- 53:04able to say, here arbitrator, yes, you also have
- 53:07to read 1 ,600 pages because I think there were
- 53:10two sets of briefs. It was a mess. try to talk
- 53:15about that beforehand, because it will really
- 53:18help keep your arbitrator costs down. And probably
- 53:21the attorneys who are having to put together
- 53:23all those exhibits and all that brief. Then we're
- 53:29starting to run a little short on time. So you'll
- 53:31post most of these on the slide. So just make
- 53:36sure whoever keeps your calendar, either they're
- 53:38on the call with you or they are. part of the
- 53:41services for whichever private provider you're
- 53:43on. We have seen where council won't show up
- 53:49because it wasn't put on their calendar because
- 53:55they forgot to share it with their support staff.
- 53:59Make sure you're sharing everything with support
- 54:00staff or have them be on the call with you. Really
- 54:05tailoring discovery. discovery motions, discovery
- 54:09issues, I think, for at least on the administration
- 54:14side, are one of the things that really increase
- 54:17costs and increase length of arbitration. Tailoring
- 54:22it, it's also, you know, you hear parties complain
- 54:26about how it's, you might as well have just gone
- 54:29to court, and it's like, well, if you're gonna
- 54:31do court -style, you know, CCP -style discovery,
- 54:36then yes, this is going to take almost as long
- 54:41as court would. And it will be expensive. It
- 54:44might be even more expensive because you're also
- 54:46paying your arbitrator. So that's on the attorneys
- 54:49to really try and tailor and narrow that discovery
- 54:52as much as possible. And then go ahead and go
- 54:59to the next one because I think those are all
- 55:01things that we've discussed. Okay, so let's say
- 55:08you have to have a three arbitrator panel for
- 55:12whatever reason. Consider a streamlined panel.
- 55:17So consider having your chair arbitrator hear
- 55:23the day -to -day items, hear dispositive motions,
- 55:26hear discovery issues, so that you basically
- 55:29have a single arbitrator. The panel will be on
- 55:33during the preliminary hearing. So everybody
- 55:35has all the dates. Everybody's aware of all the
- 55:38issues. The chair arbitrator handles everything
- 55:42between the preliminary hearing and the final
- 55:44hearing. And then the full panel will hear the
- 55:49evidentiary hearing. So you're basically just
- 55:52paying for the full panel to hear the case and
- 55:55then decide it. But all the day -to -day items,
- 55:59all of the discovery, like I said, or its positive
- 56:01emotions will be handled by your chair. So you
- 56:04essentially have a single arbitrator during the
- 56:06bulk of the case. That's been really successful
- 56:10for a lot of cases where the parties feel like
- 56:13they want a full panel to hear it, or they couldn't
- 56:16agree to not have a full panel, and the contract
- 56:20either calls for it or whichever rules where
- 56:24the case was under called for it. It's been really
- 56:29successful in helping to keep costs down and
- 56:33to keep the case moving along. You're not trying
- 56:35to schedule a dispositive motion hearing. First,
- 56:40all of the panel needs to have the same availability.
- 56:44It's just a little bit easier. Let me just add
- 56:47this really quick too. One concern that we have
- 56:49is folks will say, well, I don't mind if one
- 56:52person's handling all the discovery motions.
- 56:54That's fine. But if a dispositive motion comes
- 56:57up, absolutely, I want the full panel hearing
- 57:00that. So you can customize it any way you like.
- 57:03If you'd like to have one person to do all the
- 57:07discovery motions and the dispositive motion,
- 57:09sure. If you want one person just to do the discovery
- 57:11motions and then get the whole panel going on
- 57:14a dispositive motion that could dispose of the
- 57:16case, that's fine too. And the other option is,
- 57:19of course, just appointing one person literally
- 57:23up until the evidence you're hearing to do everything.
- 57:27And this is a great option because it puts maybe
- 57:31a little bit more pressure on the parties to
- 57:32maybe settle a dispute, because you have this
- 57:35deadline looming over them where they're going
- 57:37to have to appoint the two wings as you get closer
- 57:40and closer to the evidentiary hearing dates.
- 57:42So that's really highly effective. OK. OK. And
- 57:48then so this is just once you're past the preliminary
- 57:53hearing stage, setting the stage for your case.
- 57:57basically legal writing, be succinct, be concise,
- 58:02don't over promise. And then if there was a ruling
- 58:07on a summary disposition motion, learn from it.
- 58:12Try and get your attorneys for the most part
- 58:16so you'll know how to do all of these things
- 58:18and then focus on the key factual issues. Really
- 58:22just plain, paint things as plainly as possible
- 58:27for your arbitrator. Give them what they need.
- 58:29Don't hide the ball. The e -sites are critical
- 58:36with e -links and then hard copies as well, especially
- 58:39if that's what the panel requests. And then,
- 58:42eliminate motions are going to save a lot of
- 58:44time because you can do them during the period
- 58:45of the actual evidentiary hearing as opposed
- 58:48to having to stop the evidentiary hearing in
- 58:50its tracks and get that going. OK, sorry, we're
- 58:53rushing to these last ones. We're going to go
- 58:54a little bit past 130, folks. Stay with us. Was
- 58:58I doing this one, Stephanie? Yes. Yes. OK. Presenting
- 59:02witnesses and evidence. So obviously, a joint
- 59:04stipulation when disputed facts. Not everything
- 59:07is being argued about in an arbitration, right?
- 59:09So show the panel or the arbitrator what you
- 59:12agree to. Fact witnesses live testimony or by
- 59:14sworn statements. Sworn statements are going
- 59:16to be a lot faster and a lot less expensive.
- 59:19than having live testimony. Live testimony involves
- 59:22having somebody physically go somewhere, being
- 59:25on a Zoom, whatever it might be, it's expensive.
- 59:29Expert witnesses consider hot tubbing. A lot
- 59:31of people are like, well, what do you mean by
- 59:32hot tubbing? In the old days of arbitration,
- 59:35you used to have your expert witnesses all show
- 59:38up on different days at different times, kind
- 59:41of be questioned one by one. Why not have them
- 59:43all together and just fire questions off at them
- 59:47all as a group? That's the way you can literally
- 59:50cross -examine statements. Literally that one
- 59:54just said by referencing the expert next to them.
- 59:58It's really the most efficient way to do this.
- 1:00:01Using a witness's deposition for submitting impeachment.
- 1:00:06If you have it in writing that they've already
- 1:00:08impeached themselves, why do you need them? They're
- 1:00:11live testifying to impeach themselves during
- 1:00:13live sworn testimony. It seems like it saves
- 1:00:15time and money. And then arbitrary questioning
- 1:00:18of witnesses. This is very controversial. I'm
- 1:00:20sure we have some advocates on the call today
- 1:00:22that would say the last thing I'd want is the
- 1:00:26arbitrator directly asking my witness for clarification
- 1:00:30or questioning my witnesses. But I gotta tell
- 1:00:33you, when... If the arbitrator is confused about
- 1:00:37something that your witness just said, rather
- 1:00:39than getting it more confusing by going through
- 1:00:42you for the clarification, sometimes it's great
- 1:00:45to get it straight from the horse's mouth and
- 1:00:46I'd really consider allowing the arbitrator to
- 1:00:50directly question your witnesses if that's what
- 1:00:51they want to do. All right, managing exhibits.
- 1:00:55Whether live or remote, you want to make sure
- 1:00:57all exhibits are legible and manageable for the
- 1:00:59arbitrator both during and after the hearing.
- 1:01:03Again, common sense. Joiner separate exhibits.
- 1:01:07Obviously, joint exhibits are gonna be better.
- 1:01:10It's even better if you can have joint exhibits
- 1:01:12in the same trial binder, right? That's even
- 1:01:15more efficient. And then of course, considering
- 1:01:17the wholesale admission of exhibits, if we have
- 1:01:20to do individual admissions of exhibits, it just
- 1:01:24adds a lot of wasted time to the process. So
- 1:01:28it's not necessarily being efficient cost -wise.
- 1:01:32All right. Closing arguments and issues of attorney's
- 1:01:34costs and attorney's fees. So obviously present
- 1:01:36a solid argument. Your closing argument should
- 1:01:39just be just highlighting the strengths of your
- 1:01:41case. Nothing more than that. Drafting effective
- 1:01:44post -tearing briefs. You want to make sure your
- 1:01:46post -tearing briefs are focusing on the strong
- 1:01:48points of your argument. And this is not the
- 1:01:50opportunity. to bring up stuff that you really
- 1:01:53forgot to bring up during the course of the evidentiary
- 1:01:56hearing, because then, you know, even though
- 1:01:58the other side will get a chance to reply to
- 1:02:00your statement, it's really not the same as cross
- 1:02:02-examining a witness or whatnot. All right. Drafting
- 1:02:06clear and concise attorney fee applications.
- 1:02:08Again, a well -drafted arbitration revision will
- 1:02:12actually explain what an attorney fee application
- 1:02:15is. Is it attorney's fees? Is it arbitration
- 1:02:18costs? Is it attorney's fees and arbitration
- 1:02:20costs? you don't want you if and if you're not
- 1:02:23sure what what constitutes an attorney fee application
- 1:02:28at the conclusion of the evidence you're hearing
- 1:02:30when the arbitrator is giving post hearing briefing
- 1:02:34instructions and all that kind of stuff raise
- 1:02:36your hand and ask them to get clarification on
- 1:02:38that in front of the other side so they know
- 1:02:40all right so we have interim award versus final
- 1:02:43word can a step be saved All of us have been
- 1:02:45on arbitrations where an interim award is issued,
- 1:02:47basically letting you know who the winning side
- 1:02:49is and what they get. And then it's just a matter
- 1:02:51of figuring out the attorney's fees, where you
- 1:02:54submit your applications and then a final award
- 1:02:57is issued with those numbers in them. I don't
- 1:03:00think it needs to be a two -step process. I think
- 1:03:02your request for attorney's fees and costs can
- 1:03:05be added into the post -turing briefing and there
- 1:03:07doesn't need to be oral argument or additional
- 1:03:10stuff added to that, and they can just go straight
- 1:03:12to a final award. If you have an issue with this,
- 1:03:14you can take it up with the arbitrator, but I
- 1:03:16think that's a great way to save money. Should
- 1:03:18the parties draft a model final word together
- 1:03:20after the interim award is issued? So what is
- 1:03:22a model final award? Sometimes the smallest detail
- 1:03:29can be really important to one party. I had a
- 1:03:31case where The arbitrator said that the claimant
- 1:03:35was entitled to XYZ amount of money and the check
- 1:03:41should be made. payable directly to the party,
- 1:03:45right? Or something like that. When the agreement
- 1:03:47between the claimant and their council was the
- 1:03:50funds, the check would be made payable to council
- 1:03:52to their trust fund because it was a contingency
- 1:03:55case, right? And council will be able to take
- 1:03:58their cut out of that and then pay their client
- 1:04:02what was left. I know that's a very minor issue.
- 1:04:04It wasn't something that was. debated or argued
- 1:04:08over between the attorney and their client, but
- 1:04:11just to be difficult, the losing side said, no,
- 1:04:14this is what the award says. You don't have the
- 1:04:17authority to change it after you've issued a
- 1:04:18final award. And they wanted to do post -briefing
- 1:04:23on the topic and have an oral argument if you
- 1:04:25can change the pay to person in an award and
- 1:04:27all that. Think of how much time and money this
- 1:04:30wasted. a lot, right? So just if you had drafted
- 1:04:34the model final award together, little things
- 1:04:36like that wouldn't be tripping you up. All right,
- 1:04:39should the arbitrators retain jurisdiction post
- 1:04:41award? This is extremely controversial. I am
- 1:04:43not a big fan of retaining post award jurisdiction
- 1:04:48for enforcement actions, right? That's what the
- 1:04:51whole court system is for. I've seen cases where
- 1:04:56Something has gone to a ward or maybe it's been
- 1:04:58a settlement. They've settled but they've asked
- 1:05:00the arbitrator arbitrators to keep the case open
- 1:05:03pending Satisfaction of all the settlement terms
- 1:05:08and they want them to retain the jurisdiction
- 1:05:09to help help that process along Some of these
- 1:05:12cases stay open for three four or five years
- 1:05:15post settlement or post award That's that's just
- 1:05:20dumb and it doesn't save any money Issue the
- 1:05:23final ward No post award jurisdiction retained
- 1:05:28by the panel. Go to court if you want somebody
- 1:05:31to enforce your word. Do the appellate rules
- 1:05:33make sense? Just about every provider has some
- 1:05:35form of appellate rules. If you are unsatisfied
- 1:05:39with the result of an arbitration, let's say
- 1:05:41you're on the losing end of it and you want to
- 1:05:43attempt to vacate an award, does it really make
- 1:05:49sense to go to court to try to do that? And I
- 1:05:54study kind of vacated awards, right? 97 % of
- 1:06:00the time, 98 % of the time your vacature motion
- 1:06:03is gonna be denied by a judge just because the
- 1:06:06courts are really good about backing arbitration.
- 1:06:09It might make more sense to have written into
- 1:06:11your arbitration provision that. If you're disputing
- 1:06:16something, it goes to an appellate arbitrator
- 1:06:18within that institution, basically to look at
- 1:06:21everything that happened during the arbitration
- 1:06:23and what the, if you will, trial level arbitrator
- 1:06:26decided and how they came to that decision, and
- 1:06:28to see if it should be reversed or something
- 1:06:30should be changed. That's going to save you a
- 1:06:32lot of money instead of using the court service,
- 1:06:34and you might even have a better chance, who
- 1:06:36knows, at winning your break at your motion.
- 1:06:38And then last but least, if the court is your
- 1:06:42only option for a vacature action, you have to
- 1:06:44decide if you're really wasting your client's
- 1:06:46money. So again, I'm speaking for myself here
- 1:06:50from experience, just what I've observed in the
- 1:06:52marketplace. Most vacature actions fail. Vacature
- 1:06:57actions fail for misapplication of law, they
- 1:07:02typically fail. They fail because one party is
- 1:07:05arguing that the arbitrator arbitrators didn't
- 1:07:09follow their providers rules to the letter of
- 1:07:11the law or exactly the letter of the rule or
- 1:07:13whatnot. One arbitrator arbitrators refused to
- 1:07:19let me in discovery let me in let in some evidence
- 1:07:22that my entire case somehow hinged on this one
- 1:07:26little bit of evidence that they wouldn't let
- 1:07:27me admit into the case. All of these arguments
- 1:07:32typically fail. They're all terrible. I mean,
- 1:07:34I know it's all terrible, but they're all they're
- 1:07:36all terrible options to get your award vacated.
- 1:07:39The one thing that you might have a shot at is
- 1:07:41if you can prove bias and you can prove bias
- 1:07:45via a failure to disclose issue. So you went
- 1:07:48through this arbitration, you lost and you hired
- 1:07:50a private investigator to look into the arbitrator
- 1:07:53and their personal life. And it turns out that
- 1:07:57the arbitrator failed to disclose that opposing
- 1:07:59counsel was his sister. Right. something major
- 1:08:03like that, yeah, the court's gonna vacate that
- 1:08:06award and overturn it. You know, things like
- 1:08:10that. But other than gross examples of a failure
- 1:08:17to disclose issue that... that the case probably
- 1:08:19would have hinged upon, or you can demonstrate
- 1:08:22with 100 % certainty, had the arbitrator disclosed
- 1:08:25X, Y, Z information during the disclosure period,
- 1:08:28there's no way you would have agreed to select
- 1:08:30him. You would have struck him during the confirmation
- 1:08:33period. That's when a judge will work up the
- 1:08:36rears and maybe think about your vacature action.
- 1:08:41Okay. Again, I'll just - Go ahead, Stephanie.
- 1:08:47Yeah, I'll just go over this very briefly. So
- 1:08:49this is just, these are things to consider in
- 1:08:52the event that we have another pandemic. Right
- 1:08:55now, I think I don't believe there's any mask
- 1:08:59requirements outside of maybe hospitals or doctor's
- 1:09:02offices in certain counties in California that
- 1:09:05are seeing an uptick in flu and COVID. But I
- 1:09:09can say that one thing that has persisted is
- 1:09:12the use of hybrid hearings or completely remote
- 1:09:14hearings. So just something to think about, especially
- 1:09:18as witnesses tend to be, they can be far from
- 1:09:22where you are, where you're having the case heard.
- 1:09:25Hybrid hearings have proven to be very successful.
- 1:09:29A lot of arbitrators and parties are very pleased
- 1:09:31with the ability to either appear in person and
- 1:09:34virtually have witnesses or conduct the entire
- 1:09:38hearing virtually. So this is a list of items
- 1:09:43to think about, who's going to pay for it, what
- 1:09:45to do if there is a technical failure. Should
- 1:09:48we have a third party host the hearing? hearing
- 1:09:57transcribed, the core reporting service will
- 1:10:00do it. Just something to think about so that
- 1:10:02it's not you or the arbitrator who is going to
- 1:10:05be having to let witnesses in or if there's some
- 1:10:09internet issue. So that's it. This is just very
- 1:10:15things to think about in the event that you do
- 1:10:17have a virtual hearing or hybrid. All right,
- 1:10:23we've included our contact information here if
- 1:10:25you have any questions. Again, I'm a regional
- 1:10:28VP for California's commercial division for AAA.
- 1:10:33Stephanie is a VP with the employment division
- 1:10:34for the, I would describe you as the Western
- 1:10:37United States now, right? So not just California.
- 1:10:41But if there are no questions and I will ask
- 1:10:45Rin, I believe I don't see any questions in the
- 1:10:47webinar, is that correct? Yeah, no questions.
- 1:10:50Okay. Then we can wrap it up and thank you to
- 1:10:54everybody who attended today and spending some
- 1:10:56time with us this afternoon. Bye. Thank you.