Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Spielworxx Bulletin-Episode 2-The Great Crowdfunding Debate.
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the most informed boardgame news show on the Internet, with the beating
- 0:04heart of the German ballgame industry, Uli Blenheman and Sam Bloki found slammed outside
- 0:09of a pub in a pool of his own offerings, Ben Meadows, this
- 0:13is the Spielworks work. So here we are the second ever episode of the
- 0:20Spielworks Bulletin, and I'm here with the technical Master, the man who can't
- 0:25help but make sure the computers work all the time. It's Uly Blenheim and
- 0:30Uli. Welcome to the second spiel Works Bulletin. So I'm exciting talking to
- 0:35you again, Ben, and for the listeners, it just took us forty
- 0:40seven minutes, only forty seven minutes to get Mike working. Mike working,
- 0:44and all my fault. But as Ben said, I'm the tech master.
- 0:49I suppose during you know what, with you being a boomer and everything,
- 0:52during your days, it was just Abacus's so it was very difficult. This
- 0:57is a very difficult time for you. It is. It is effects pigeons,
- 1:00of course, and to get messages across town and all this stuff.
- 1:07What I could do, what I could do for the next one is just
- 1:10get chat GPT to pretend to be you just just say to chat GPT do
- 1:14German accent and then just just have chat GPT do it. I think that's
- 1:19an excellent idea and probably the answers would make more sense anyway. It's not
- 1:26only the accent, it's better responses. So I think it's a true win
- 1:30win situation. All right. So this is the opening section as it usually
- 1:36is, and you know, you're all business zui most of the time,
- 1:38of course, so un rarely, you know, we get to think of
- 1:42you as a gamer. So in this opening section we talk about something you've
- 1:46played, So tell us about something you've played that you're particularly excited about this
- 1:51month. Yeah, so I played Land and Freedom several times over the last
- 1:57couple of months. And this is a cut driven game by Alex Knight,
- 2:02produced by Blue Panther Games for three players. It's one to three, but
- 2:07you should be three players. And I've heard that it is picked up by
- 2:13Four Circle Games, so it will come out in a professionally produced edition next
- 2:20year. And so it's also it's also quite a light one then because a
- 2:23fort Circle of publishing it. It's not a super heavy wargame, right right,
- 2:28It's a light cart driven games. The rules are pretty simple. Playing
- 2:31time for a card driven wargame is probably around one hundred, five hundred twenty
- 2:39one hundred and fifty minutes. But what is really excellent. There are probably
- 2:46more than a dozen wargames on the Spanish Civil War out there, but this
- 2:52one is different. It's not that one plays a fascists and the other plays
- 2:57the Republicans, but the fascists looked by the system, and the three players
- 3:02are anarchists, Communists are moderates. So this is interesting because Weimar does something
- 3:09similar. When you do this, when you take one of the factions and
- 3:15have it run by the computer, are you essentially making a statement about the
- 3:23relative values? Are you saying, well, the communist and the anarchists and
- 3:25the moderator of the good is so we're allowing you to play them because we
- 3:30know you're all sensitive. We know you're all sensitive flowers, and the fascist
- 3:35obviously the bad is so you don't get to play them because that would make
- 3:37you feel bad? Is that is that the case? Maybe we'd have to
- 3:44at first. I think this is an excellent question, and I think that
- 3:49we should ask Alex Knight why he had chosen that pass. Unfortunately he's not
- 3:55here only Yeah, So my guess is and it's just gases that most of
- 4:02or the main reason is that he wants to be first different from other Spanish
- 4:09civil war games, and then have a very tense situation at the gaming table
- 4:17because the game is semi cooperative, which means either the fascists are winning the
- 4:25civil war, then the game is over and we have all lost, or
- 4:29one of the three factions is winning. So it could mean I'm not really
- 4:33want to do a lot militarily. I'm an anarchist and I want to pursue
- 4:39my strategy of collectivation. And in all our games, so I think we
- 4:45played the game three or four times, we always lost because of course I'm
- 4:49a bad person. I'm also only playing with bad persons, and nobody wants
- 4:56to see the others are winning. So I guess in the context of land
- 5:00and freedom that these are the main reasons. But I think I'll ask Alex
- 5:08what was the reason for it. In Vima, I think mattias A did
- 5:15it for a different reason. Most of the time of the Weimar Republic,
- 5:19the Nazi Party was a minor force, a minor a splinter party, so
- 5:26that is why it isn't represented by a play affection. So I'm I'm looking
- 5:35at the internet here, so there isn't the squeamishness. So people are squeamish
- 5:46about fascism and the Nazis, I mean justifiably, but there doesn't seem to
- 5:53be that squeamishness about far left parties right right people have less squeamishnists about the
- 6:00USSR. And looking here, the death toll of the USSR is between twenty
- 6:05eight million and one hundred and twenty six million, right, which is more
- 6:11than the Nazis killed. I mean, they were in power a lot longer,
- 6:14and it's I was listening to a podcast the other day where Stalin basically
- 6:18starved Ukraine because they disagreed with him, that the peasant farmers disagreed with the
- 6:24communists, so he killed millions, six to eight million people in the Ukraine
- 6:29through deliberate starvation. Yet we don't have the squeamishnists playing the Communist as we
- 6:35do as the Nazist. Why do you think that is? Is it because
- 6:41the left is considered more virtuous than the right in modern discourse? It may
- 6:46be it, Actually, it may be a first, getting back to the
- 6:51Holodor here in the Ukrainian everybody should read from Kimersy Snyder Blood Lens, because
- 7:00this is a fantastic books and it outlines everything which happened to the Ukraine in
- 7:06the thirties. I think the main reason here, and I'm talking from my
- 7:13German position, is that the USSR still was the main factor in World War
- 7:23two in getting rid of the Nazis, and I think this is very important
- 7:29for German history, and yeah, in Germany and Russia, which we now
- 7:35see in the Ukrainia in the war. In the Ukrainia, we see that
- 7:41it has always had a special place in German history and a special fascination.
- 7:47And we see this before the US, before Russia took the Crimea into twenty
- 7:55fourteen, and even nowadays. Just the other day read from the German Trading
- 8:03UNI and the Ostfa bant doutschen via Shaft. So the companies that are doing
- 8:09trade with Eastern countries and especially with Russia, they now want to get rid
- 8:18of most of the sanctions again. And it is very strange, but I
- 8:26think it's fascinating. I interviewed someone the other day and they firstly said they
- 8:31were a Marxist, and then they explained why they were a Marxist, and
- 8:35they had absolutely no I'm not saying they had absolutely no sort of shame or
- 8:41embarrassment about declaring themselves as a Marxist. Right, and yet we have seen
- 8:48Marxism recavoc amongst the world in the late twentieth century, right Marxist leaders standing
- 8:56on piles of skulls. Right. Absolutely, And yet it is clear that
- 9:03no one if I interviewed someone on my podcast, they wouldn't say, yeah,
- 9:07I'm a Nazi. I consider the national Socialist ideals. I mean clearly
- 9:11they wouldn't. Right, you wouldn't. You wouldn't do that in a public
- 9:13forum. And do you have any idea why something that is why two extreme
- 9:22extreme political views that there is such a difference in how they're perceived. Yeah,
- 9:28first personally, and by the ways, as a disclaimer, this is
- 9:33not to defend Nazis. By the way, I'm not defending Nazis. I'm
- 9:35just saying I find it strange that Marxism reeked as much havoc as national Socialism
- 9:41did, and yet there is less there is less embarrassment about it. Yeah,
- 9:46and I think nobody thought this about Nazism. So first, I think
- 9:52that Nazism is still very special because they killed industrially people. And yes,
- 10:01you could say, well, in total in the desk toll during the so
- 10:05many years of communist regime that took more people that desktall was higher. I
- 10:13think first there is still some romanticism, if this is even a word in
- 10:18English about communism and socialism, because people try still to this day detach what
- 10:30happened in the US s are from true socialism because the ideals is that everybody
- 10:35is equal, so that has to be fantastic. Whereas if you are living
- 10:43longer than a couple of years on this planet, you know that people are
- 10:46greedy and that it is very very difficult to set up that everybody is is
- 10:52equal. So that famous biologist who said great ideology, wrong species exactly,
- 10:58So I'd say that is one of the reasons. And the other reason is
- 11:07that people are sometimes really weird. When I was studying in the eighties in
- 11:15Bochum in the rural area, I studied history and politics and at that time
- 11:20the climate and it was still Cold war. We had the US s R.
- 11:24But the climate was so different from today, and I talked in politics,
- 11:28and I had history courses, of course, and I know what happened
- 11:33in the Soviet Union, what happened during communist regime reign. And they were
- 11:39telling me, no, that this is all bullshit. Intelligent people, really
- 11:43intelligent young people, It's all bullshit. And then I said, well,
- 11:48what about Totsky. Trotsky was a total liar. It was okay that he
- 11:54was removed. And we are not talking about the thirties in the Soviet Union.
- 12:00We are talking about the eighties in Western Germany at politics at university.
- 12:07Do you think it's a matter of people, privileged people not realizing the luxury
- 12:15that liberal democracy gives them so they're able to take a holiday in Marxism when
- 12:18they're young and naive. I think you are completely right, But maybe we
- 12:26are scratching when they are young and naive because we are seeing this everywhere and
- 12:33all the time with some people. I'm glad gladly, I think that gladly
- 12:39most people are not like this. But definitely liberal democracy as we see everywhere.
- 12:48Let's look at towards the Netherlands now has huge problems, has huge problems,
- 12:56and maybe and now we are getting back to Matias Karma's Weimer. Maybe
- 13:05the democratic factions parties are not strong enough anymore. For why this is,
- 13:15I'm not even sure, but maybe we are too weak. We are also
- 13:18lazy. Are we going out a couple of times a months for demonstrations against
- 13:26something radical? No, we aren't. It's more radical people who try to
- 13:31demonstrate for people. And of course I'm really privileged here in Germany as as
- 13:37a white person and for me and my family, it's not really necessary to
- 13:48do this on a daily basis, but probably it is a huge mistake.
- 13:54So anyway, we've gone off a bit of a sidebar. But how why
- 13:58is like freedom goodwin? Yeah? I think first it is the tension between
- 14:09the three players. They have the common goal to beat the fascists in the
- 14:13game, which is otherwise the game is lost, but they have all different
- 14:20aims. And in the end, if we if the three players, if
- 14:24they can beat fascism, still one player is winning. And yeah, with
- 14:30my group of people at the table, it's very difficult to achieve this because
- 14:35I'm saying, no, you're not winning. Yeah, the fascists attacking,
- 14:41are attacking in the noise at the Norse Front, but maybe you are doing
- 14:46all the stuff to defend and I'm doing something else here, and that makes
- 14:52for a great game. And the cards, of course have lots of flavor
- 14:56text. I did not know a lot about the Spanish Civil War, and
- 15:01even the game the flavor text on the cards, and I'm not a huge
- 15:05fan of flavor text on the card, but here it made me want to
- 15:09read something more detailed about the conflict. So excellent work here. So I
- 15:16just want to speak briefly about my current obsession, please. And this is
- 15:20a game from the publishing house of your close friends Mattaeus Nudge and Peter Eggert.
- 15:31And this is I think probably my favorite designer. And this is Palo
- 15:35Morris's Match of the Century, which is dealing with the Spasky and Fisher chess
- 15:39match in nineteen seventy two. And it's just a brilliant two player game.
- 15:46So you're not playing chess, you are playing the overall match of chess,
- 15:50and it's just typical Palo Mori. It is so simple and yet so deep.
- 15:58And what is so amazing about it is it gives you the feeling of
- 16:03playing an intense chess game without having to be really good at chess. Because
- 16:07obviously that would be a nightmare, and it is. It is brilliantly engaging.
- 16:11It is super it's so tight and its design, the decisions, all
- 16:18of the decisions are fantastic and it plays in thirteen minutes. It's an absolute
- 16:23work of genius. Palomo is so good, I think. Yeah, I
- 16:27agree, Paulo is wonderful. I just said. I just saw him very
- 16:30briefly at Essence, so in between meetings, and I know him from many
- 16:36years ago, and I think he's one of the best designers out there,
- 16:38and he can do a lot of different things. So I haven't played the
- 16:44game yet, but it is high on my two playlist. I think it
- 16:48did. I love it, so I've read in the net it's a little
- 16:53bit like Watergate. Is this true? Well, I can't tell you because
- 16:56I've never played Watergate, so I don't know, but I think I think
- 17:00Deep Print are sort of pushing it as a sort of a cousin, a
- 17:04cousin to Watergate, right, yeah, And it's just it is just a
- 17:07brilliantly tense two play a game, that is, and it has this brilliant
- 17:12mechanic that you have your chess pieces have values, but each chess piece also
- 17:18has a special power, but the special power only activates if you lose the
- 17:22exchange against your opponent, and so and so you have that idea, should
- 17:26I deliberately play to lose this exchange, which might contribute to me losing the
- 17:32game, but it then gives me something absolutely brilliant that I can use to
- 17:37fuck over my partner or I can use to I can use to benefit myself.
- 17:41It's it's, it's it's it's super clever and it's super tense. Very
- 17:45good. Yeah, I need to play it and maybe we get a chance
- 17:49at ad Learia ben in next year. Yeah. I think they have it
- 17:52in their library. Yeah, it's absolutely fantastic. All right. Then with
- 17:56that discussion of Marxism, let's move on in act cross self promotion. Uli
- 18:03Blenemen got so the German board game industry will tell you what's happening in words,
- 18:11all right, annwly, this is the bit where you get to come
- 18:14on my podcast feed and mercilessly advertise your own company. So tell us about
- 18:19what beer Works have got. Yeah, so so right now, this week
- 18:26the five new root modules arrived in the warehouse. So this of course is
- 18:30just for German language speakers. It's the German editions of five new modules and
- 18:37they will now deliver to pre order customers and I think that Root fans will
- 18:44be really happy about these so they arrived. Then still going strong is Matias
- 18:51Karmas Weimar for me, and which is interesting because as we all know,
- 18:55it's a pure four player game place in six hours. But I think the
- 18:59word of mouse is excellent here and going back to just German language customers because
- 19:04I still get males almost on a daily basis with questions. And yes,
- 19:11speed Works will do the German edition of Morley House by Whorli when I have
- 19:17no clue. It will take some time, but we will do the German
- 19:21edition. And yeah, in December, Speedworks will have some special offers at
- 19:30the website, so if you're interested in something special, check out the website,
- 19:37the news and my webshop during December and there will be various offers at
- 19:44various times. And finally, the main thing which we are working on is
- 19:49epos Against game by Stefan Risthaus and Stefan did a really outstanding job. Hanning
- 19:56is working as developer hard on on this one. Harald is doing the graphics
- 20:02I'm helping. And this game has a base game, it has eight different
- 20:11chapters. You don't have to all play them, you can play them.
- 20:14You can play each one five times. It's not legacy, it's a campaign
- 20:18type game. And finally, it has two campaign games where you play some
- 20:25or all of these scenarios in succession, and you can even take a couple
- 20:30of your cards or other pieces from one chapter to the next. So I
- 20:36think this will be one of the most important games for Schweelwork's next year.
- 20:41Excellent. So with that merciless advertising out of the way, let's move on
- 20:48to our main topic. Do you like informed opinions on board game topics that
- 20:52are important to you? Then don't listen to Ben. It's our topic of
- 20:56the all right, OLEI. So we discussed AI last time, and now
- 21:03we're discussing the greatest evil in games, considering I've just seen how much they're
- 21:08charging for the new food chain Magnet game. We're talking about crowdfunding, and
- 21:17you're interesting in this because spel Works were a absolute sort of conventional publisher.
- 21:25You just went straight to retail, well straight to Spielworks retail essentially, and
- 21:30you didn't use crowdfunding. To get the capital for your games, and then
- 21:33a few years you pivoted and you went into crowdfunding. So I want to
- 21:37talk to you about that, and I want to talk but I want to
- 21:40talk about crowdfunding in general. What do you think it offers to the industry.
- 21:44What do you think it's you know, the positives, the negatives,
- 21:45all of that good stuff. So first thing, what was your first experience
- 21:51of crowdfunding as a consumer? And are you a kind of person who backs
- 21:55kickstarters and things? Yes, I bet kickstartus and and game found and backer
- 22:00kid from time to time, so not that many games, but I do
- 22:03it. My first experience actually was before kickstarter with kind of crowdfunding. I
- 22:10was always in for pre orders. I'm a wargamer and GMT has this interesting
- 22:15had this interesting model already I think in the nineties is established where they have
- 22:22this P five hundred system, so if they have at least five hundred direct
- 22:26orders pre orders, they will print the game, not immediately, but at
- 22:30a certain time, so it's secure. So I knew this, and so
- 22:33I was used to send money in advance basically because it was done by credit
- 22:40card and you were charged and yeah, all this. My first kickstart was
- 22:44in twenty thirteen. I looked it up in my Kickstarter I list because I'd
- 22:48completely forgotten about this game and I do not own it. It's that classic
- 22:53Septicon Oranium Wars. Yeah, I mean twenty thirteen. I can't that.
- 23:00Not a day goes by when I don't think about Septicon Uranium Wars. So,
- 23:06and that was my first kickstartup back at the day. Yeah, and
- 23:11so you've seen the progression of kickstarter, are you, Because I remember when
- 23:18I first got into gaming, there was this phrase a kickstarter game, and
- 23:22what that meant is that it was kind of a game that was a bit
- 23:27low quality, not as good as you know, a gain that had gone
- 23:33straight to retail, and that changed very quickly. Are you surprised now how
- 23:40crowdfunding dominates this industry or was it just an inevitability? Does it really dominate
- 23:47this industry? I'm not sure? Okay, well it dominates a certain wing.
- 23:51I think the sort of real sort of hobby games. Yes, it
- 23:55dominates. Yeah, I think you're you're right here, And because I I
- 24:00still think that games going straight to distribution for families, kids or others are
- 24:06still very important but I'm a bit I'm definitely a bit surprised here and that
- 24:15it went that well for crowdfunding companies. And in the early days, it
- 24:22was small companies, independent publishers who really need to raise capital to print the
- 24:27game. And then we quickly saw that large companies entering the field like Queen
- 24:36Games, Semon and many others, and nowadays basically everybody is doing it.
- 24:41And well, I think Semon were the ones that really sort of pioneered that
- 24:48change, right They were a company who whose entire sort of business model was
- 24:53based around crowdfunding, right, and because of Semon, the idea that stick
- 25:00stick a load of minis in a game and you'll get a million dollars on
- 25:04kickstart. So that's that's what Simon started, right side. Yeah, exactly,
- 25:11all these minisier games changed crowdfunding in the view of people, and yeah,
- 25:19hopefully it won't it will change again, because I think it's a really
- 25:25bad trend for the industry. So why Yeah, I think it's a more
- 25:32is better or what we see nowadays is the more you put in, and
- 25:38especially in plastics, the better it is. You mentioned food chain Magnet,
- 25:45and if you see the plastic houses and the numbers in there. It is
- 25:49a certain attraction for people, but does it make a better game? God,
- 25:55they look shy though I'm sorry, I agree, I agree it's nothing
- 26:00for me. Yeah, I love Charoon, I love Splotter excellent games,
- 26:06and yeah, although I love Charoon, graphics, quality could be something better.
- 26:11I think Food Chain Magnet is incredibly charming, to be honest, I
- 26:15think the art on Food Chain Magnet original edition is much better than the Lucky
- 26:19Dark one exactly. So with some I think they could change a little bit,
- 26:25But the Splotter has its charm, and I think I think host this
- 26:32carriage looks great honestly. Yeah, and if you now look at that edition
- 26:37and at double the price of it, it's strange. Or before that,
- 26:41Castles of Virgin d So I'm going to talk about this right because one of
- 26:45my favorite publishers is a Leah and they publish fantastic games and their production is
- 26:53for shit. But but when you're buying a game as good as Castlesburgundy for
- 27:02thirty euros, who cares if the cards are a bit thin and the ball's
- 27:06a bit ugly right at Someone in my game group last night had the big
- 27:11dildo infested new version of it with all the Baker like tiles, and honestly,
- 27:19it did nothing. The thing is it was completely without charm. I
- 27:26agree, one hundred percent. And I think even gameplay, it's not functional
- 27:32playing with his pieces because you can't see everything as well on the table.
- 27:37And I think that trend is bad trend. But apparently all the Beckers thought
- 27:45we need this addition. So good for stefan Feld and royalties, and good
- 27:52for the company, and good for a game fund at the site. And
- 27:59you know, screw you if you don't make enough money to be able to
- 28:03monthly pay for a two hundred quid game, right right. I mean it
- 28:07was a middle class hobby to begin with, why not make it more middle
- 28:10class? Anyway? So poor person rantings aside, So we talk about this,
- 28:17But a couple of years ago you pivoted to crowdfunding. Why yeah,
- 28:22and so several reasons. So one thing is I only did one thousand copies.
- 28:27I started even with five hundred. Then I moved to one thousand copies,
- 28:32and I wanted to know what is the true demand for a game?
- 28:36So is it really a thousand copies or is it a little bit higher because
- 28:41when I sold out quickly, I had got so many males I want to
- 28:45have the game, but this is and I couldn't deliver anymore. But of
- 28:49course this is a loud, vocal minority. So maybe I could have done
- 28:56another or sold another one hundred or two hundred copies, but I can't print
- 29:00another one hundred or two hundreds, and I don't want to have lots of
- 29:04stock. So this allows me to really print depending on the true demand of
- 29:11the game. Second thing is we have to be realistic. How many people
- 29:15are looking at the speedworks website. They is it one me or is it
- 29:22ten people? So I don't know, and this is marketing. Of course,
- 29:29lots of people are looking at crowdfunding websites all day or at least once
- 29:36a day, and there are so many other sites who are grouping the new
- 29:40releases. So that's definitely another reason. And it allows me to stay independent,
- 29:48to not use distribution, because even with the fee that the crowdfunding sites
- 29:56are charging charging and this is fine because they are provided this service, I'm
- 30:00not. I do not have to do distribution. And so how hau shpiel
- 30:11Works changed since you made the crowdfunding model not really, I'd say we are
- 30:18independent. We do not try to have our components done the way that we
- 30:26are getting the last euro out of a campaign or the last dollar out of
- 30:33a campaign, and we are not making lots of additional things for just for
- 30:41a crowdfunding a campaign, all these add ons that really you think this is
- 30:48ridiculous. We are not doing this, and in the campaigns, I'm telling
- 30:52this is a complete game and we won't have any stretch goals here if there
- 30:56is maybe in the future, if I see something that could be a great
- 31:00strategical yes, of course I will do this, but not with plastics or
- 31:06and only if it's really a good thing to add. And has this changed
- 31:11your production? Do you produce because previously you produced in Europe? Are you
- 31:17still producing in Europe or do you now produce in China? I produce.
- 31:22I still continue to produce in Europe with your numbers done in Europe, but
- 31:27realistically these days, but this has nothing to do with crowdfunding per se.
- 31:36If you do not produce in China, you will have a very hard time
- 31:41because your prices are so high. It's if you see the difference in pricing,
- 31:47even with shipping and even with shipping smaller quantities so you can cannot fill
- 31:52a complete container. The price difference is is you and I cannot explain a
- 32:02customer why the price is that high, and he doesn't care if I'm saying,
- 32:10well, the game has been produced in Europe standard. Customer does not
- 32:15care for that, and should he. I don't think, well, this
- 32:19is a fascinating thing, right, because the world is populated by dickheads who
- 32:22go on Twitter and they moan about they moan about everything all the time,
- 32:25air being the latest thing, right, and yet no one talks about the
- 32:31fact that this is an entire industry whose production is based on working with a
- 32:36totalitarian company who is trying to ethnically cleanse the wigas, who completely are completely
- 32:46what's the word I'm looking for, gives no freedom to the people within their
- 32:52country. And the reason that games are cheap in China is because people don't
- 32:55get bloody paid. Essentially, I mean, is this whole Is the discourse
- 33:05around this industry basically hugely hypocritical because even in the tiny and I understand there
- 33:13are people who will say the board game industry is infittestimal, but regardless,
- 33:15even in the infantestible manner. We are choosing to prop up an autocratic system.
- 33:25Aren't all the people who moan about other stuff on Twitter just hugely hypocritical
- 33:30if they're playing any games that come out to China. I think we are
- 33:35not only these people, we are all and we are always like this and
- 33:43everywhere, not just in gaming, it's everywhere. My closest probably if I
- 33:47check this, they are all coming from China, most of the stuff,
- 33:52probably even the mic I'm now talking in after trying to connect it for forty
- 33:55seven minutes from from China. No quantum and it is a really strange world.
- 34:07But on the other hand, people getting some money each month, hopefully
- 34:15they're getting this and they are spending it according to their priorities, and this
- 34:22for most people is not a priority, and it's very difficult then for smaller
- 34:29companies. We had the same discussion about the Splotter again, and we have
- 34:34this which Speedworks releases all the time. If I'm or if Splotter is thirty
- 34:40percent more costly than others are in the same field, then it's very difficult
- 34:46to sell. It is difficult, but also very difficult to change, and
- 34:55probably it is only going to change. If something is happening that we do
- 35:00not want to see happening, and that could be a take off Taiwan by
- 35:07China, then everything probably will change. And so do you think crowdfunding is
- 35:17responsible for games getting more expensive? Or am I just being very blinkered and
- 35:22looking at the ultra hobby aspect of the game and disregarding you know, kids
- 35:29games and games that are in more mainstream channels. I don't know, but
- 35:36I think that these I still remember when a Fantasy Flight independently so not owned
- 35:45by ASMO day when they had this could be two thousand and three, maybe
- 35:50it was two thousand and five when they started with their huge kitchen sink game
- 35:57boxes charging eighty for them, and people said, this is not going to
- 36:02sell. It's not going to sell. You opened the box. It was
- 36:06at that time it was mainly toys for boys, hundreds of small minisers,
- 36:13and people said, O wonderful, and they bought it. And companies noticed
- 36:17that a lot of people in our society have a lot of money, and
- 36:22I mean really a lot of money, and if this is your hobby number
- 36:28one, you are going to spend it on that part. And so I'm
- 36:32not sure if crowdfunding is responsible. I think it increased the speed that this
- 36:38is happening. And I think also we see it even a game that was
- 36:45game of the Year in Germany sh Bilde siars Flugel Shlarks so Wingspan. I
- 36:52think it costs. The retail price was forty five to fifty, which for
- 36:58a game of the year is very very high price. Of course, having
- 37:01produced it several hundred thousand times reduced the price, especially before Christmas, but
- 37:07I think pricing. But we notice this every every year if we go Ben
- 37:13and you if we go to the bakery and just have four smallish things,
- 37:19and we are surprised how much we are spending these days. So crowdfunding offers
- 37:27you marketing. It offers you capital upfront for the thing that you're making.
- 37:31You're able to conduct market research. Right, Why does anyone go start to
- 37:37retail anymore? It is difficult because and especially now after s andwhere I had
- 37:47so many talks with distribute distributors and also with a few retailers, tells you
- 37:55that nobody is looking waiting for your game. A lot of the distributors are
- 38:02mainly fulfillers nowadays. If a retail stores orders two games or one game they
- 38:08will fulfill, but not doing anything actively. And of course it's very difficult
- 38:15for distributors to actively distribute your product because they can only do this for the
- 38:22ones that are selling and during the pandemic. Now after the pandemic, the
- 38:28warehouses are full of stock and people have to and companies have to get rid
- 38:31of this stock first, and it is very difficult unless you have a proven
- 38:40classic or a proven best seller. But first try to prove if it's a
- 38:45best seller, and very difficult. So I think that retail distribution is still
- 38:52most important, and we'll see it with now we are in November. We
- 38:55see it with a Game of the Year, with others which are not now
- 39:00everywhere. But for all the others, it's most difficult to be seen in
- 39:07stores. It's hard. So distribution has its place, but I also think
- 39:14it does not really work. I'm in Germany, I'm a distribution with asmode,
- 39:21great people over there, but of course as a company, I have
- 39:24my problems with asmoday because they are dominating the distribution circuit worldwide and that cannot
- 39:36be a good thing. Why yeah, because right now they are they are
- 39:45still taking most of the games that they are interested in. But you see
- 39:51they are very reluctant because there are so many games out there, and of
- 39:54course they will push and this isn't a natural thing there own brands. They
- 40:00have so many studios in there, so that they are concentrating on these ones
- 40:06first. And with their large muscles, they're big muscles. They can make
- 40:13retailer's offers that nobody else can do. So if you buy this package of
- 40:17games included US three classics from us Modi plus three other titles, you can
- 40:27pay within ninety days. And so with which games are you filling your star
- 40:34shelves with this offer or from somebody else. Others who are in distribution cannot
- 40:39make the same offer to a retail store. It's impossible, and so the
- 40:45field is not level, it's not plain. But we own capitalism, so
- 40:50why should it be so Fundamentally, cristfunding allows independence in a world where Asthma
- 40:55day By produce games and own all the distribution channels, the only option is
- 41:02crowdfunding it It is a very good option at least, so you could still
- 41:07go from your website do direct pre orders, but first you have to be
- 41:13a known force, otherwise nobody is looking at your website, and as long
- 41:17as there is are independent crowdfunding sites, there will be independent games because you
- 41:24can't kill creativity. It's the same thing with the Hollywood black blockbuster movies.
- 41:31You still have independent art house movies, but of course they are not seen
- 41:37everywhere. And that's the same thing with smaller crowdfunding campaigns because a lot of
- 41:43the crowdfunding campaigns are now by large companies. Excellent, Well, I think
- 41:49we solved that. Let's move on to now the big toe of the German
- 41:53board gaming industry. Julie Blademain will regale you with all right, So I
- 42:04want to talk about something in this Tales of the Industry section. I want
- 42:07to talk about something sort of general because I am not a game publisher and
- 42:14all I see, really I only see game publishers at conventions, and being
- 42:20at a convention as a game publisher seems like an absolute bloody nightmare to me.
- 42:24You know, you're chained to your booth and it just seems to be
- 42:28like incredibly four days of just horrendously hard work. So I want to talk
- 42:32about benefits of being a game publisher, especially those kinds of things that people
- 42:38may not think about. Why so, why is it You've been in this
- 42:44industry for years now, why are you still in it? And what sort
- 42:49of good things do you get from it? Yeah, excellent question. So
- 42:55one thing, of course is that it allows me some independence, so I
- 43:00can work here as I want to be, at least that's what I'm thinking.
- 43:07Of Course, I have my regular things to do, so I cannot
- 43:13say I'm doing this tomorrow. It has to be done today. But it
- 43:17allows you some independence and some freedom. Better term is freedom. But I
- 43:24see, going back to games, I see some games well before they are
- 43:30released, and I'm not looking at Speerworks games. I'm playing and testing games
- 43:36by a lot of other companies, and this is interesting to me because I
- 43:42see some early trends. And on the other hand, this is really a
- 43:49benefit to see them that early, because I could play them when they are
- 43:53developed completely or in full afterwards and probably have a better experience, and so
- 44:00probably it's a good thing. But the main benefit is that I'm having that
- 44:06I'm working in a very creative field, so I'm talking to so many creative
- 44:12people, so designers, other publishers, developers, podcast artists, podcaster,
- 44:20podcasters. Apart from five G four D. But no. But actually this
- 44:29is a wonderful thing and they give not only valuable input for the product,
- 44:35but we can talk about other things in life. And this is a real
- 44:40benefit I'm seeing. And do you think you can work in this industry and
- 44:47not love it? Probably not? Probably not. I mean, especially like
- 44:55you a small independent publisher, right you know if you it, you're not
- 45:00making enough money to greet your teeth and bear it, I assume so,
- 45:05so definitely not. So you have to really love it because you have not
- 45:12only this once a year Essen and some other shows which Essen, although how
- 45:19nice that event was this year, I think that's the new Mats Valakh did
- 45:24a great show, really great show this year. But still for me it's
- 45:30my worst week of the year because there is so much to do before at
- 45:35the fair and even afterwards. So you really need to love this. And
- 45:42if you're thinking you are working for forty hours a week and then it's freedom
- 45:46and it's all you're working way longer, way longer. Otherwise as an independent
- 45:54publisher you won't make it, so you have to invest a lot of time.
- 45:59But again, looking at it, what I'm gaining from it, I
- 46:04think it's more that then I'm losing or having a bad time. And so
- 46:09just one last question then, so if someone was thinking about being a publisher,
- 46:15what's the one piece of valuable advice you'd give them Set aside money or
- 46:22set as much money aside that you can live for twelve months without any earnings.
- 46:32And I'm not saying ah yah, I will earn at least that amount.
- 46:37No, say I'm not earning anything from gaming for twelve months. And
- 46:43if you are confident and saying, well, I have that amount of money
- 46:47and I want to try it, do so it's really rewarding. If you
- 46:52are unsure, don't do it. Excellent, Well, OULEI, let's move
- 46:59on to the outro. Then I actually actually there's no bumper for the outro,
- 47:05so we'll just move straight onto it. So all the details. Where
- 47:08can we find spiel works? Yeah you can still it's still in capital letters.
- 47:16Find me at x which was Twitter at ulibla U l I b l
- 47:22E. You can find me at Blue Sky at the same handle. It's
- 47:28a blue sky. Just a load of self righteous dickheads jerking themselves off.
- 47:32At this moment, I'm so unsure about this. Everybody is saying well,
- 47:37it's such a wonderful environment. Oh and it's so much nurs and everyone so
- 47:42much neice. I mean, I don't want to spend time with these bloody
- 47:46people wagging their bloody fingers at me. Blue Sky sounds like an absolute nightmare.
- 47:52Yeah, well I haven't seen this fingers yet. But if you look
- 47:59at the investors in Blue Sky, Dorsey and Robert Kennedy Junior, well well
- 48:07there'll be There'll be no bloody vaccines over a blue Sky, were there?
- 48:10Yeah, exactly. So it is really strange. But you can find me
- 48:15there at this moment at least, and of course you can drop me an
- 48:19email at ULI you l I at Spielworks dot d and yeah, and if
- 48:25people want to, if people want to, go to the spiel Works website
- 48:28and buy some stuff, that is www. Speedworks dot d. And you
- 48:35will find the news, the products and everything else over there. And if
- 48:40you like this, you can listen to the other podcast in the five g
- 48:45FO D network. We've got the main show. The last one was just
- 48:50Jamie from the Secreca bal which was a great show. We've got some We've
- 48:54got Fred Saval coming up in December and Matthew Jude coming up in numbers of
- 49:00interesting stuff. You can also support five GFD at patreon dot com forward slash
- 49:05five gf D, every little kanks and so you have one minute. What
- 49:10have you got in stock? In stock? Also look at the product list
- 49:16at my website. We have view none, we have Viima, we have
- 49:22lots of Route, we have still o's and some extras. We have Magnet
- 49:27German Edition, the First City and some other stuff that I probably have forgotten
- 49:31at this moment. So please take a look. And when Ben is saying
- 49:37you can take a look at five g for D, that's wrong. You
- 49:40have to. You have to take a look, download and support the show.
- 49:45Excellent. Well, Uli Blenneman, thank you very much. I thank
- 49:51you Ben. Was my pleasure and thank you all for listening to This month
- 49:54should be a works bulletin. So thank you for listening and come back next
- 50:00month for another Yeah,