Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Wake Up Call (10.28.24): Jennifer Murphy, CEO & Founder of Runa Digital Assets
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to another episode of Wake Up Call.
- 0:03Before we get started, please like, share and subscribe to
- 0:06unramped media channels to receive the best Bitcoin
- 0:08education and content in the industry.
- 0:10And also be sure to check out our latest research report
- 0:13called Bitcoin The Emergent Asset Class has Arrived, a
- 0:17three-part series aimed at introducing important Bitcoin
- 0:20centric concepts to the institutional allocator world.
- 0:23Part 1 available now and LinkedIn, the show notes
- 0:25explores Bitcoin volatility and why it is a uniquely desirable
- 0:29characteristic of the asset that can boost returns and dampen
- 0:32overall volatility in traditional portfolios.
- 0:35Wake Up Call aims to educate financial professionals on the
- 0:38merits of the Bitcoin investment thesis.
- 0:40How this asset class represents both a threat to legacy
- 0:43financial services businesses and an opportunity to
- 0:46differentiate oneselves to retain and attract new clients.
- 0:49Hosted by Mark Connors on Ramps, Head of Global Macro Strategy
- 0:52and Rich Kerr on Ramps President of Managed Wealth, this weekly
- 0:56show seeks to provide financial professionals the wake up call
- 0:59they need, prompt them to have an open mind with respect to
- 1:01Bitcoin, rethink their prior assumptions, become more
- 1:04educated on the topic, and learn from others who are already
- 1:07farther down this path. Wake Up Call is live streamed on
- 1:10LinkedIn every Monday morning and the recordings can be found
- 1:13across on RAMP media channels. Now time for the show.
- 1:17Well, good morning everybody. Happy Monday.
- 1:20Thank you for joining us on wake up call.
- 1:23This should be a real special show.
- 1:24Today we are delighted to have Jennifer Murphy, who many know
- 1:30is a 30 year Trad 5 vet in the asset management space and
- 1:36Jennifer, your experiences at Legg Mason and Western Asset
- 1:42Management and now leading Runa Digital Assets.
- 1:46It's just awesome. We're delighted to have you
- 1:50today. And before maybe we kick off,
- 1:54we'll kick it over to my Co host, Mark Connors.
- 1:57Let's talk a little bit about what's going on in the world.
- 2:01It's got your attention. All right.
- 2:04Well, thanks for that, Rich and Jennifer.
- 2:08They were really excited about ripping it up with you today on
- 2:12probably the we talked about being bilingual about the person
- 2:16who brings that history of traditional finance and then why
- 2:19and how you ended up focused on digital.
- 2:23And some of the news points suggest that we're going to be
- 2:27in the right side of history here because some of the players
- 2:31are getting loud in Tratify Microsoft, which we will talk
- 2:36about later because that's one of the pieces in some of your
- 2:38foundational research about the the arc of revolutions in
- 2:43technology. They have driven value.
- 2:45Microsoft stated that our files that they plan on voting on
- 2:52whether or not to add Bitcoin to their balance sheet.
- 2:56You know, people say it wasn't on their bingo card.
- 2:58Certainly it's not a slam dunk. The board is against it.
- 3:02Shocker, right? They want to add value.
- 3:03They don't want it to come from a decentralized commodity that
- 3:06they had nothing to do with. So you know, we understand
- 3:09incentive structures drive a lot of value or a lot of attention
- 3:14and innovation and the shareholders apparently want it.
- 3:17So we'll see. The reason that's relevant is
- 3:20because one other company that added as we all know is
- 3:23MicroStrategy and MicroStrategy was lagging Microsoft for
- 3:27decades until he added Bitcoin. And now Microstrategy's 20 year
- 3:32compounded return is 21% and and Microsoft's is only 17.
- 3:38Now 17's a good number, but just shows you the power of this of
- 3:42adding Bitcoin to the balance sheet.
- 3:44So front and center that ranks up high.
- 3:47And the other one which will pull on from the investment side
- 3:50was has to be Paul Tudor Jones when he said all roads lead to
- 3:55inflation on long, you know, Bitcoin on long commodities.
- 3:59I don't own bonds. And if nothing, he can, he can
- 4:06really pick out those regime shifts.
- 4:08I mean, 87 he was there when, you know, Fort Black Monday kind
- 4:12of made some money on that trade and then the rest is history.
- 4:16So my ears perk up when when he says all roads lead to
- 4:21inflation. And then just the divergent in
- 4:24markets is pretty legion right now.
- 4:27You have a lot of commodities dropping.
- 4:29You have oil down, you have, you know, Europe going to single
- 4:33digit slash fractional growth, less than 1% GDP expected yet
- 4:39inflation's almost 3% there. So tough spot there.
- 4:42You have equities hitting all time highs.
- 4:44You have bonds in the basement down month to date.
- 4:48Some of them are down over the past one year and five years and
- 4:5210 years as far as longer dated bonds.
- 4:55So kind of a a mess all around. But the one thing that's there
- 4:59is low growth and inflation means that central banks may
- 5:03have lost the plot or the ability to manage the economy
- 5:08effectively like they used to. So the the last thing I'll say
- 5:12before I hand it back to you all and and also poke at some of the
- 5:16things I spoke about in case you want to add anything, is in
- 5:22credit. You're seeing high yield and
- 5:25investment grade have almost no distinction.
- 5:28Historically, it's the lowest spread between high yield and
- 5:32investment grade that we've seen in the last five years and
- 5:35almost the last 30 years. It's the tightest spread since
- 5:412007, which if memory serves, was right before a little bubble
- 5:46pop. So no one is thinking there's a
- 5:50problem in credit yet. On the Treasury side, volatility
- 5:54for Treasuries is in the top quartile over the past 10 years.
- 6:00It's like a VIX at 40. It's just it doesn't make sense
- 6:05in the brain. Except the government has
- 6:08assumed so much risk and the buyers of Treasuries have walked
- 6:12away. So it's not unusual to expect
- 6:15that there's going to be kind of pushback.
- 6:17The reserve tank is blowing out. No one's going to be buying
- 6:20treasuries or more people are walking away.
- 6:23They're buying gold all time high.
- 6:26So, so that's the market we have right now.
- 6:28We have low growth. We have regional distinctions,
- 6:31we have market asset class distinctions and we have Bitcoin
- 6:36just racking up good news and returns along the way.
- 6:40So I know it sounds a little too bullish to believe, but I'm
- 6:43data-driven as you are, Jennifer, and we're going to go
- 6:46through some of the work you've done.
- 6:48Look forward to it. And why don't you Rich, kick off
- 6:52or give me Jennifer? How does that want to proceed?
- 6:54Yeah, maybe a maybe a you just kind of jogged my memory.
- 7:00I believe it's 95 years ago today that the mark, the stock
- 7:08market dropped 12% on a Monday and then came back the following
- 7:14Tuesday, Black Tuesday, which dropped an additional 15%.
- 7:18If I, if I remember the, the math and, and let us into the
- 7:23Great Depression. And so I don't want to be doubt,
- 7:26you know, bearish or anything of that nature.
- 7:28I don't want to forecast. That's not what I do, but it is
- 7:31an interesting period of time. And and Mark, you were just
- 7:34going over some very interesting, you know, insights
- 7:39into, you know, bonds and, and how they played out in 1987 or
- 7:44in 2000 and seven, 2008. And so interesting period of
- 7:50time. And, you know, we'll see where
- 7:53everything kind of goes from here.
- 7:55But you know, I, I had mentioned, you know, kind of
- 7:58just briefly, you know, how excited we were about having
- 8:02Jennifer join the show today. I mean, CEO of Legg Mason
- 8:07Capital Markets. And you know, that would what a
- 8:10tremendous distinction that is. But you know, what I didn't cut,
- 8:15you know, provide color on is, you know, she also has quite an
- 8:20academic background, a CFA, an MBA from Wharton.
- 8:25She is just, you know, a wealth of knowledge, but also a leader
- 8:31in the space that helps kind of shape where the industry is
- 8:34going. And five years ago, I believe
- 8:36you kind of made the big journey into the digital asset space.
- 8:41So might be a good time just to share a little bit about your
- 8:44career arc because it really is quite exceptional.
- 8:47And you've come across some amazing, amazing people in your
- 8:52own right in your journey. And so I'd love to kind of hear
- 8:55and share with the audience a little bit about who you are and
- 8:58what you're up to these days. Jennifer.
- 9:01Great, Rich. Mark, thanks for having me.
- 9:04In 1997, I was working with Bill Miller, who was also my first
- 9:09boss. I had a couple of other jobs in
- 9:12between coming back to work with Bill.
- 9:14But in 1997, I was working with Bill Miller, who I, I know you
- 9:17both know is a very, you know, one of the world's best equity
- 9:21managers at that time. He was, I think six or seven
- 9:25years into a streak of beating the market, which he would do
- 9:27for 15 years straight, which no one's ever come close to.
- 9:31I think the the closest streak before that was eight years.
- 9:35But interestingly, he was a value manager.
- 9:37That's how most people would describe him in the in the time,
- 9:41as you both know, in the late 90s was the Internet.
- 9:44Would have what eventually would be called the Internet bubble,
- 9:46You know, and I think one of the most interesting things about
- 9:50Bill is he as a value manager kind of rejected this Warren
- 9:54Buffett idea of I don't understand technology.
- 9:56So I'm just not going to invest in that.
- 9:59And he really waded in. He met with Jeff Bezos when
- 10:02Amazon was going public in 97. He sat down with him and really
- 10:06wanted to understand what Jeff had in mind.
- 10:09And that was back when you could still do that, you know, as a as
- 10:13a portfolio manager. And what Jeff described to him
- 10:17was not what he heard from other people.
- 10:19You know, he described a global e-commerce platform and sort of
- 10:25a focus on capital allocation. If you look at the a lot of
- 10:28people like to refer back to the Jeff Bezos 1997 IPO letter.
- 10:33And if you read his letter, it's sort of a Tour de force and how
- 10:35to think about capital allocation.
- 10:37I think people recognize that now, but at the time you have to
- 10:42get to Page 3 before he even says the word book.
- 10:44You know, whereas back then when during the IPO, most people
- 10:48would describe Amazon then as bookseller and they would sort
- 10:52of analysts would view their potential as well.
- 10:56How much of the book market can they take from Barnes and Noble
- 10:58or, you know, other booksellers? So that that what what Bill
- 11:02really focused on is the description.
- 11:04Is that the right description of Amazon as a bookseller?
- 11:08And his conclusion was no, Amazon's a global, global
- 11:12Internet, you know, sales platform and maybe more than
- 11:16that. And here's their CEO is
- 11:18incredibly focused on capital allocation.
- 11:20And so I think those two insights from Bill of the
- 11:23description matters. And he's, he's a philosophy PhD
- 11:28student, so he he would put up slides in front of our clients
- 11:31quoting Wittgenstein and other philosophers about how important
- 11:36description is. And you know, it's very and it
- 11:38worked. You know, Bill could make that
- 11:39work. So, so, but I really took from
- 11:42that, that how you describe something matters a lot.
- 11:45And so sort of Fast forward to Mark and Rich things I know
- 11:49you're well aware of, but when Jamie Dimon calls Bitcoin a pet
- 11:54rock, you know, is that is that is that a good description of
- 11:58Bitcoin? You know, absolutely not like
- 12:01so, so you have sort of that you and you have people like Larry
- 12:05Fink and Jenny Johnson at Franklin Templeton and Abigail
- 12:08Johnson at Fidelity. You know, their description of
- 12:11Bitcoin is a global financial asset.
- 12:13You know, their their vision is it's total addressable market is
- 12:17the global financial market. Those two differences in
- 12:21descriptions matter a whole lot, right?
- 12:23That's a dramatically different outcome.
- 12:26So I think one of my great gifts of my career is and what really
- 12:31set me on this arc was really Bill's, you know, insistence on
- 12:35always sort of going to the root of the matter, going to the
- 12:39data, as you said, Mark, but also to important concepts from
- 12:43history and really applying them without being relegated to well,
- 12:47value investors can't buy technology.
- 12:52Wow. Yeah.
- 12:52This is something, Jennifer, that Rich always brings up or
- 12:55often brings up is the anchoring.
- 12:58You know, we're smart people. The advisors are disruptors.
- 13:02But in that condiment Diversky book about making it fast and
- 13:05slow. And what reminded me is when you
- 13:08said Bill Miller was a student of philosophy.
- 13:11I mean, we love data, but variations on a theme don't get
- 13:15you to the next one. And you have to step back
- 13:18sometimes and bring on people like you who've done work and
- 13:22say, wait a minute, you know, that's this has run its course
- 13:26or we have to rethink and reimagine.
- 13:28And the description that you bring to it that you mentioned
- 13:32Bill did that, that got you thinking differently.
- 13:35That's what we're trying to do here.
- 13:36I mean it that we didn't really know we're trying to do that
- 13:39until we said, wait a minute, It's exactly what we're trying
- 13:41to do. No doubt.
- 13:44Yeah. I mean, he, he brought a similar
- 13:46sort of insight I think to Google then its IPO.
- 13:51It was. You know, you probably remember
- 13:54this, but Google was. Went public in 2004.
- 13:57This is after the Internet bubble burst.
- 13:59You know the. Exuberance was gone.
- 14:02There was a lot of skepticism. And you remember Sergey Brin and
- 14:06they they didn't want to do evil, so they wouldn't use an
- 14:09investment banker. It was a Dutch auction to try to
- 14:13level the playing field. For the little guy.
- 14:16So it had all these like weird aspects to it from the point of
- 14:19view of a trad 5 firm. So you know, the initial price
- 14:23talk was $1.35 a share It, it ended up coming at $85 a share,
- 14:28which was a $23 billion valuation.
- 14:31And because of all these obstacles, as it turned out,
- 14:35only two institutions bought Google on the IPO.
- 14:38That was my boss, Bill and Fidelity, the Fidelity portfolio
- 14:42manager and the rest was, you know, retail investors.
- 14:47So that seems incredible now given that, you know, Google is
- 14:49now 20 years later, A2 trillion, 2 plus trillion dollar company
- 14:54and one of the great most valuable companies in the world.
- 14:57But at the time it was described as a search company that had a
- 15:00lot of competition. It wasn't clear how they were
- 15:02going to monetize it, that, you know, there, you know, their
- 15:08user base. And I think that whole idea of
- 15:11network effects, Bill, Bill was already talking about those
- 15:16things, about the power of networks and how networks have
- 15:19such important attributes. And there was a lot of work
- 15:23being done by people like Duncan Watts who wrote the book 6° That
- 15:28whole idea of 6° of separation, you know, that comes from that.
- 15:34So the, I think that whole idea of the, of the power of networks
- 15:37is very non intuitive. So, and in essence, the idea is
- 15:42that the value of networks are grow faster than the than the
- 15:45network grows itself. Its value comes from the the
- 15:49growth and participants on the network.
- 15:51So I think Bill was sort of focused on that early and and
- 15:56persisted with it, whereas I think most people are still 20
- 16:00years later today. I think if you ask most people
- 16:03to describe network effects other than you 2 and maybe some
- 16:06of our our peers, you know, they would have trouble describing
- 16:10it. Still not a familiar concept.
- 16:12So actually, this is fascinating.
- 16:15So how? I mean, those are really
- 16:17powerful early lessons in your career, right?
- 16:20And and I'm certain that those have stuck, you know, with you,
- 16:23but maybe share with our audience, you know, how that's,
- 16:26you know, kind of stepped you into into the digital asset
- 16:31space. And then maybe what you're
- 16:32seeing with Bitcoin in particular, because I I think
- 16:35largely admit must most of our audiences is pretty focused in
- 16:40that space. But I would love to hear some of
- 16:41your thoughts and how that how that those lessons in your
- 16:45career have stayed with you as as we're watching this massive
- 16:50transformation happened right in front of us.
- 16:55Well, I spent a lot of time, you know, working with Bill directly
- 17:00and then then when he retired or went off to do his own thing, I
- 17:04was, I sort of continued on. So I worked for a long time in
- 17:08equity asset management and then in fixed income asset management
- 17:12in many roles, some some financial, some leadership
- 17:16roles. So I have many different seats
- 17:19and but all the while sort of following this sort of Bill
- 17:22approach of heavy reading, you know, heavy thinking, listening
- 17:27to podcasts, you know, people like you talking about things
- 17:30broadly. So when I was at Western asset
- 17:34in, I was this chief operating officer there, one of our, I was
- 17:39reading about blockchain and thinking, I don't, this sounds
- 17:41important, but I, I don't know. And I asked our technology team
- 17:45about it and they were very skeptical, which I find is
- 17:48common when someone is really knowledgeable about something,
- 17:53you can really see the flaws, right?
- 17:55So the technology team was very cognizant of a lot of this stuff
- 17:59has been around for years. These are just databases.
- 18:02They're ledger's. It's not revolutionary, you
- 18:05know, so they had a lot of skepticism and correctly, they
- 18:09believed it would take a long time.
- 18:10That was true. But what was interesting to me
- 18:13was our operational team brought it to me.
- 18:16So Penny Morgan who at the time was in a operation leadership,
- 18:20the role in operations with me, she came to me and said we
- 18:24should be doing more with this. We could collapse our
- 18:28infrastructure with this technology.
- 18:30So we started working with the support of our CEO Jim Hershman,
- 18:33we started working on applications that were
- 18:37developed. They were sort of written for us
- 18:40by IBM and using their proprietary blockchain software.
- 18:46And we actually developed and implemented those applications
- 18:51and demonstrated that they could work.
- 18:52So proof of concept and Western we with JP Morgan, even though
- 18:57Jamie Dimon says bad things, he doesn't they they do a lot of
- 19:01positive things. We bought the first bond that
- 19:06was issued on a blockchain infrastructure from the National
- 19:08Bank of Canada through JP Morgan.
- 19:11Western was the buyer of that. And it was so interesting to me
- 19:14because we had been talking, you know, the business and
- 19:16operations team to the investment team about why we
- 19:19thought this was important. And they were like, you know,
- 19:22OK, maybe. But when what was interesting
- 19:29was when they actually, they did the trade, you know, on the, on
- 19:32the blockchain Pat for so this was a new issuance.
- 19:35They did the trade and it everything settled and updated.
- 19:38Everything happened instantaneously.
- 19:40And that was the first time they walked out of that room.
- 19:42And they said to us this, this would change the whole way we
- 19:46manage our accounts. I was like, yes, exactly.
- 19:50That's great. And and this is, this is 2018 if
- 19:55I'm not mistaken, right? That's so you're talking.
- 19:58Was that a good thing? Did they did they take that as a
- 20:00good thing or a scary thing? Definitely a good thing.
- 20:03They definitely saw it potential of it and but it was interesting
- 20:07that we we could tell them about it and and that wasn't very
- 20:10effective and when as soon as they did it, they used it, then
- 20:14they they were telling us, you know, what would happen if this
- 20:17infrastructure, you know, came to pass.
- 20:19So it was that was a powerful lesson for me that really people
- 20:22do really need to experience these things to really, you
- 20:26know, incorporate them. Most people need that.
- 20:29So, so that was when so to sort of bring this to a close, Rich,
- 20:33sorry I'm taking too long, but the, I started thinking, you
- 20:38know, in several years ago, this is going to transform.
- 20:44It's certainly financial services infrastructure.
- 20:46Bitcoin looks like it may be among the most important assets
- 20:50going forward for investors. And what am I doing?
- 20:52I'm I have a front row seat to all this and it's happening
- 20:57right now around me and I have a great my partner, Max Williams
- 21:00is equally committed to these ideas.
- 21:04And we thought we gotta we gotta try.
- 21:07We have to leave these comfortable roles and
- 21:09traditional finance. He was at NASDAQ and we need to
- 21:13dive in here. So that's what we did.
- 21:19You're on mute there, Rich. We're, we're, we're a bunch of
- 21:2530 year trapfi refugees sitting here on the Internet talking
- 21:31about something that has got us really, really energized about
- 21:36the future. And, and thankfully, you know,
- 21:40in many respects, like I, I, I constantly am grateful that I
- 21:44was able to fight past my own. I don't know what it was.
- 21:51Maybe, you know, my indoctrination into traditional
- 21:56finance. It was such a struggle for me to
- 21:58break that and actually get intellectually curious and, and,
- 22:05and see what, what, you know, kind of live behind Bitcoin in
- 22:09particular for me. And, and, you know, I was one of
- 22:12the naysayers and, and spouting FUD and, and then all of a
- 22:16sudden here I am, you know, completely on the other side of
- 22:20the fence. Because I think once you really
- 22:22start, you know, speaking with people like yourself, Jennifer
- 22:26and, and Mark, and you start doing a little bit of research
- 22:30and you're looking at the world and you're like, Oh my goodness.
- 22:33This is a really, really tricky landscape for an individual
- 22:38investor, let alone a registered investment advisor to be able to
- 22:43think about how do I really do well by my clients.
- 22:49Because this is going to be a transformation in the financial
- 22:53services industry, let alone other industries, by the way.
- 22:58But it will be a significant transformation that requires,
- 23:02you know, some, some rethinking of things that I thought I
- 23:06already knew. And so, you know, here we are
- 23:10today. It's a, it's a pretty
- 23:12interesting world and I am just unbelievably grateful to have
- 23:17found Bitcoin. I'm very optimistic about where
- 23:20the future is going to go. And maybe we'll, I'll, I'll
- 23:25table it. I, I want to talk to you a
- 23:27little bit towards the end about how you see the future.
- 23:31And you've seen a lot of significant changes in your
- 23:34career and and LED a lot of those changes.
- 23:37And so I think it's going to be an exciting show to kind of let
- 23:41it unfold. So sorry for the aside, but I
- 23:44just had to say that. So rich.
- 23:47Oh, sorry, go. Ahead, I was going to lead us
- 23:50into Rich wants to land the plane saying, where are we
- 23:54going, right? It's just like, let's open the
- 23:56presents up now and see. What we got like the kid at
- 23:58Christmas, I'm so excited. I love that, but go ahead, I'm
- 24:03going to I'm going to bring us basically a Jennifer.
- 24:06I look at you like an iceberg, which is one of the highest
- 24:08compliments I can pay to someone.
- 24:10You show this much and then just hang out because you got a lot
- 24:13below the surface that you've done that.
- 24:16We're going to try to, you know, share with people.
- 24:19But before I do that, you were going to say something.
- 24:22I was just going to say, Mark, you mentioned history and I
- 24:24think one of the benefits of the, that we have that everyone
- 24:28can have by reading is history. But I, I have access to some
- 24:33amazing people to teach me. Like, I don't know if you know
- 24:36Chuck Royce, but he's one of The Pioneers of small cap investing,
- 24:41famous long term small cap investor.
- 24:43And he started his firm in the 70s.
- 24:46And when he started, he was, he had to take the train, take
- 24:49Amtrak from New York to DC and go to the Securities and
- 24:52Exchange Commission to copy the pink sheets so that he could
- 24:56price his portfolios. Like that's how little
- 24:59information was available and small cap stocks were
- 25:02considered. See if this sounds familiar, low
- 25:05quality, too speculative, not necessary.
- 25:08Why do you need to invest in small caps when you have these
- 25:11high quality companies available?
- 25:13So institutions had no interest in them.
- 25:16There were no indexes available to you know to benchmark
- 25:20yourself against. There were no allocation buckets
- 25:23from consultants, etcetera, etcetera.
- 25:25So when I was thinking of launching Rena Digital Assets, I
- 25:28went to talk to Chuck about that and it's, it's so hard to
- 25:33experience the, the, the emergence of a new asset class
- 25:36because it only happens every, I don't know, 30 or 40 years or
- 25:4050, I don't know, but many, you know, more than.
- 25:43You know, maybe a. Generation, so, so I think it,
- 25:47but if you look back through history, it has it does happen
- 25:51periodically and the emergence of a new asset class is
- 25:54generally very important to investors, you know, to to
- 25:57future returns and I think that's what we have in digital
- 26:00assets. Well, you gave me a layup there
- 26:03to go where I wanted, which is some of the work that that
- 26:07you've done, which, you know, it's proof of proof of work.
- 26:14We can talk a lot. And as we said, some people like
- 26:16to just sort of assert and say stuff.
- 26:18And then Shazam, there's nothing behind the curtain when you go
- 26:22open it up. And then, you know, joke's on
- 26:24you, but you've written it, you've published.
- 26:28And what I think what I love about, you know, searching for
- 26:31different people is I never heard of Carlotta Perez before.
- 26:34So I'm going to raise my hand and say didn't, didn't know
- 26:37about her. And what we're hopefully.
- 26:40Yeah. Sharon, here is something that I
- 26:42think you wrote about and I don't know if you want to sort
- 26:45of share with how you found it and how it's relevant to what I
- 26:48think you just spoke about with information.
- 26:51Well, Carlotta Perez, she wrote this book.
- 26:53This book, which is very small, but it's called Technological
- 26:58Revolutions and Financial Capital.
- 27:00It's very small but dense, but it is a book about concepts, as
- 27:05you mentioned before, Mark, and it is, you know, the subtitle is
- 27:09the dynamics of Bubbles and Golden ages.
- 27:12But in it she, it's more, it's a it's a data, it's rooted in
- 27:17data, but it's more she attempts to describe how technology
- 27:21creates revolutionary ages that impact not only investors, but
- 27:27society, you know, all of the way all of us live and the
- 27:30governments that we have and regulations, etcetera.
- 27:33So in this book, she goes back to the industrial revolution and
- 27:38goes from there. And she observes, she tries to
- 27:42sort of lay out a number of different technological ages,
- 27:45each of which is, you know, roughly 50 years in length that
- 27:48not not perfect, but roughly. And she points out that there
- 27:52are some in each of these ages. There's several big technologies
- 27:57often interacting with each other.
- 27:59So not just one, but usually several that end up first
- 28:03disrupting, causing enormous disruption of speculation and
- 28:08corruption. Corruption is.
- 28:10You know a. Common feature of technological
- 28:12ages and but ultimately leading then to regulation and a golden
- 28:17age of enormous value creation. So she lays out these and I
- 28:21think they'll the final one, the information age will be
- 28:23familiar. You know, I think to everyone
- 28:25watching this, but if you notice, 1971 is about 50 years
- 28:30ago. And so I think Carlotta Perez is
- 28:34thinks and we we agreed that we're likely entering a new
- 28:37technological age and so. We think that's important for a
- 28:41number of reasons, but for investors, I think Mark, you
- 28:45know, we, you and I talked a little bit about this, but the.
- 28:49Why? Why do investors care about
- 28:50this? The if you look at all the
- 28:53companies that were public from in the last, in the 90 years
- 28:57from 1926 to 2016, there were 25,000 plus companies that were
- 29:04public. And of those 25,000 companies
- 29:08that were public, they created a total of $35 trillion of value.
- 29:11I mean, these are just big numbers, but five of those
- 29:14companies created 10% of that total, 35 trillion in value, and
- 29:2090 of them produced more than half of it.
- 29:23So you think about that, 25,000 companies and 90 of them were
- 29:26responsible for more than half of the value creation and all
- 29:29the other ones returned less than T-bills, which is a
- 29:32remarkable stat, right? And this is, you know, these are
- 29:38called sort of fat tails of distribution.
- 29:40I know, I know you're both familiar with them, but what
- 29:43that means is in in distributions that have fat
- 29:46tails, a very few, few things produce the majority of the
- 29:50returns. And that's certainly what
- 29:51happened in, in equities. So you see here, these are the
- 29:55five that produced 10% and they were the top, you know,
- 29:58producing value producing companies of this whole time
- 30:02period. And you'll notice each of them
- 30:05started at the beginning of of one of Carlotta Perez's
- 30:09technological ages and some captured too.
- 30:13IBM was, you know, able to to ride the wave of two of these
- 30:17ages. But it it sort of speaks to the
- 30:20importance of being in early and getting the benefits of that
- 30:24compounding for the entire period of the technological age.
- 30:28So I think you know, if you if if we went went around, decided
- 30:32to my family and asked them, you know, what do you think?
- 30:34This is one of. The most valuable company in the
- 30:36world at the time, now it's NVIDIA, I think, but it was
- 30:38Microsoft. And I think that surprised a lot
- 30:41of people because Microsoft seems to them sort of like.
- 30:45Old tech, maybe you know, but one of the great advantages of
- 30:50Microsoft is it it, it began as Apple did you know it right at
- 30:55the beginning of the of the information age.
- 30:58So I know, I know you know where I'm going with this.
- 31:01But we believe we're in a new technological age.
- 31:04It's likely. AI is certainly a huge disruptor
- 31:09that is part of one of those dominant technologies.
- 31:12We think blockchain is too, and we think Bitcoin.
- 31:14Is Bitcoin is the OG, it is the IT is the asset that is at in at
- 31:20the beginning, it in fact created the asset class and so
- 31:24that's one of the reasons we're so.
- 31:25Bullish on Bitcoin? It it is the, we think one of
- 31:30those dominant assets that will be one of the biggest value
- 31:34creators over this very long, you know, period of this new
- 31:38technological age. At Onramp, we believe that
- 31:41Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 31:45The hard part is securing it right There are shortcomings
- 31:48with keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 31:51up your own self custody arrangement.
- 31:54Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 31:56Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 32:00minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 32:03remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 32:06inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 32:09well. Onramp provides Peace of Mind
- 32:12for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 32:15for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 32:18setup. For more information, check us
- 32:20out at onrampbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 32:23And and what we we're showing here about the fat tail, pardon
- 32:28my times, my watermark over some of the labeling here.
- 32:34Traditionally when people think of distributions, they think of
- 32:37kind of like normal distributions, like gold has a
- 32:39relatively normal distribution, little bit Poly skewed, some
- 32:43good, good numbers, some bad numbers.
- 32:46Around 3% mean you're, you're looking at the last five or
- 32:50seven years of returns distributed in the histogram.
- 32:57But equities believe or not in the aggregate, you know, when
- 33:01you lump in those 25,000 companies or the 500 in this
- 33:06Bloomberg large cap, which is like the S&P, we know that 7
- 33:11have done very well. But when you put everybody in
- 33:13there it, it kind of pulls the index a little bit to the left
- 33:16more than it does to the right. There's more numbers down the
- 33:20downside and bonds in particular, which we've talked
- 33:23about just there's no way to turn that frown upside down when
- 33:27you're buying bonds these days because there just aren't as
- 33:30many buyers. So back to data.
- 33:33I mean, Carlotta wrote it, you popularized it and Bitcoin is
- 33:39demonstrating what a fat tail looks like.
- 33:42And as you said, it seems like the being in that beginning of
- 33:50the and revolution is a key component.
- 33:54And you know, we started out the conversation what's going on
- 33:57that maybe is why Microsoft is getting in because they're not
- 34:01happy that MicroStrategy added four years before they did and
- 34:07now leapfrog them on wealth creation, on being a more
- 34:11optimally created or vehicle for wealth preservation and
- 34:18creation. Like, and what we love about
- 34:21these calls with rich, it's like we never know where we're going
- 34:23to go. But we just the key is like
- 34:25Bitcoin, like getting the right ingredient and getting you on
- 34:27here. It's just spurring all sorts of
- 34:29ideas for us. Right.
- 34:33Yeah, I agree. I think the, I think Bitcoin, I
- 34:37think MicroStrategy, one of the great benefits of MicroStrategy,
- 34:40even if it's controversial, is I think it's it the numbers are
- 34:45now so compelling that you really even the skeptics have to
- 34:48decide I need to learn about this.
- 34:52That's, that's I think the great benefit of, of what Michael
- 34:56Saylor is doing. So I think, you know, Microsoft,
- 34:59they, they may fight it now, but I think eventually, you know,
- 35:04other people, I'm sure you saw, I know, you know this, but you
- 35:07know, might have metaplanet in Japan is, is pursuing now a
- 35:11micro strategy strategy and appears to also be doing so
- 35:14successfully. So I think that's going to get
- 35:17harder and harder to ignore. And I think eventually I think
- 35:21Microsoft, I hope will start to link back to that.
- 35:24Bitcoin really is part of a new technological age, which what
- 35:28there's no more natural place for Microsoft to go then to, you
- 35:32know, to look to dominate a second age as as IBM did in the
- 35:37past. Yeah, and it's interesting.
- 35:40Right before the call, I, you know, I'm a junkie, right?
- 35:45Like I'm, I'm constantly scouring for interesting videos
- 35:48and, and news items and things on that nature.
- 35:51And right before we, you know, joined together in the green
- 35:54room, I saw a Michael Saylor video where he was basically
- 36:00outlining why Apple ought to solidify their balance sheet.
- 36:06And, and it's a pretty compelling, you know, 62nd clip.
- 36:11And I was just like, man, that guy really, really has done his
- 36:15work. There is no doubt about it.
- 36:18And, and we're already seeing all of these small and, and, and
- 36:21mid sized companies starting to think about solidifying their
- 36:25balance sheets, you know, with, with Bitcoin, which I think is
- 36:30really exciting because that does so much for small
- 36:34businesses not to be, you know, thinking about how to preserve
- 36:37their store, you know, their wealth and retained earnings and
- 36:40things on that nature. But they can actually focus on
- 36:43their business and their clients, while, you know, their
- 36:47assets are, are keeping up with, with the debasement of currency
- 36:51or money, money supply. So that being said, it's a, it's
- 36:55a fascinating period of time to, you know, watch what's happening
- 37:00not just in the corporate space with balance sheets, but also
- 37:04nation states, right? I mean, I saw you had the bricks
- 37:08are are potentially threatening to, you know, purchase Bitcoin
- 37:13in significant ways. That could be a game changer in
- 37:18terms of reserve assets, you know, for currencies and things
- 37:23on that nature. So there's so many fascinating
- 37:26things that are happening in Bitcoin.
- 37:28One of them is ETFs and I know that you've been paying
- 37:32attention to that space and you know maybe share with with our
- 37:37audience because I know that it's something that they're
- 37:39paying a lot of attention to, not just looking at 13 F
- 37:43filings, but just in conversation that I'm having
- 37:45with a lot of the different registered investment advisory
- 37:49firms. And you know, they're all paying
- 37:51attention to the ETFs and they're contemplating ways to
- 37:54enter the asset class on behalf of clients.
- 37:58So I'd, I'd love to hear your thoughts there on that
- 38:00disruption. Back in 2023 in the summer when
- 38:06the the the great SEC lost its battle with Grayscale about the
- 38:15filing of a Bitcoin ETF, when the, when the judicial system,
- 38:19you know, the courts told the SEC that they're continuing to
- 38:23deny an ETF for Bitcoin spot Bitcoin was arbitrary and
- 38:27capricious. We and I think many others, you
- 38:31know, sort of sat up, you know, I liken it to like, you know,
- 38:34like Prairie dogs and. Like.
- 38:38What this is we at the time we wrote, I think this is the most
- 38:44important thing to happen in digital assets since Bitcoin
- 38:47like it was. We thought it was so important
- 38:49because the two reasons we thought was important, one was
- 38:52just the reputational risk of buying Bitcoin at that time,
- 38:56given the SEC especially being so hostile towards it is so
- 39:00high. Where with the with that change
- 39:03with Bitcoin ETFs, we believed and this has happened that
- 39:07companies like Franklin Templeton and Invesco and
- 39:10Fidelity and BlackRock are all, you know, especially Larry
- 39:14Fink's been very, you know, vocal as has Jenny Johnson,
- 39:18Franklin Templeton out there really making the case for the
- 39:21asset class. So I think the reputational
- 39:23risk, they are really bringing down that that significant
- 39:27reputational risk. You know, we thought that that
- 39:29would happen and we also thought the rest of the world now
- 39:33finally could through their brokerage accounts, invest in
- 39:36Bitcoin. And so we'd really move from the
- 39:39early adopters who I think are own Bitcoin right now.
- 39:42You know, the sort of innovators and early adopters on that sort
- 39:45of classic technology adoption curve.
- 39:47And you know, the the big numbers start to come in when
- 39:50you get into the early majority and the late majority.
- 39:54And I don't think we're even, I think we're just sort of getting
- 39:56to the early majority now. But we thought this is going to
- 40:00push us across the chasm to the early maturity.
- 40:03And that's where most technologies die because they
- 40:05never cross that chasm. Anyway.
- 40:07Fast forward a year. The Bitcoin ETF's, I think we
- 40:10got the, the reputational benefit.
- 40:13These are the most successful ETF launches of all time.
- 40:17Mark, you probably know these numbers better than I do or
- 40:19maybe rich you do the, but I think of, you know, ETF's for
- 40:23the year there, you know, the top five ETF launches for the
- 40:26year, like four of the five or Bitcoin ETF's, you know, or
- 40:29something like that. And they're the, you know,
- 40:31they're rivaling in size the largest ETF's in the markets
- 40:34already. They haven't been out for a
- 40:36year. So I think we really did get
- 40:38that reputational benefit of those really big credible firms
- 40:42out there, you know, talking about and educating people about
- 40:46Bitcoin as you are. But I think we didn't get the
- 40:49second. BlackRock did a study of people
- 40:52who bought their Bitcoin ETF and in the study said only 20% of
- 40:56buyers were 13 F filers, those institutions that have to file
- 41:0013 FS about their, you know, investment activities.
- 41:03So 80% were not, they were, you know, more individuals or
- 41:08smaller, you know, wealth offices.
- 41:11So the, well, only 8080% were were not institutions.
- 41:16And then of that 80 percent, 80% of them were, this was the first
- 41:21time they bought any ishare product according to BlackRock.
- 41:25So these were like completely new buyers, which I maybe that's
- 41:28good from black box point of view, but from my point of view,
- 41:31it's like, wait, I think these are people like me and you and
- 41:36March and Rich and Jennifer are the ones who bought the Bitcoin
- 41:39ETF, son. I did.
- 41:41I bought them for my, you know, children for my retirement plan,
- 41:43you know, things like that. So, so I think we did not yet
- 41:47get that, you know, early majority through the ETFs based
- 41:52on the data that that BlackRock has given us.
- 41:54I don't know, is that what? What do you think based on?
- 41:56Yeah, Yeah. I think it's evolving quickly,
- 42:00which is good. The number of firms that I'm
- 42:03talking to are all in some level of due diligence, which is,
- 42:09which is a healthy thing, right? Like they're giving, they're
- 42:11giving the asset a little space and they're trying to recognize,
- 42:15OK, what how do we bring this forward to our client base?
- 42:20You know, how do we do it thoughtfully?
- 42:22What are the risks that we need to consider?
- 42:24Custody and digital assets is very different than than, you
- 42:29know, what we have come to experience as custody in
- 42:32traditional asset classes. So how do you mitigate those
- 42:36risks and what are the best types of products and solutions
- 42:40to enter into the space? But you also have other elements
- 42:45too, right? It's not just a regulatory
- 42:47framework that they're looking for more, you know, teeth that
- 42:51gives them that air cover. They're looking for partners,
- 42:55too. And they're trying to figure out
- 42:56who's going to help us, you know, one, be expert in the
- 43:02space because we are financial advisors and we are getting paid
- 43:06by our clients to have a point of view.
- 43:09And so they're, they're, they're really trying to build the
- 43:12competency. They're trying to, you know,
- 43:16work with their compliance partners.
- 43:18In fact, I think in the next month, Mark, you and I have a
- 43:22compliance firm that will be joining us to talk a little bit
- 43:26about how they're guiding and advising the advisor in
- 43:31approaching the assets. So I think that there's a lot of
- 43:33moving parts, right? It's making certain that they
- 43:36that they've done their level of due diligence, that they've
- 43:39skilled up their organization to be able to talk intelligently
- 43:43and ask answer questions of end clients and they're looking for
- 43:47some level of air cover. A true partner that you know, is
- 43:51providing them with, with sound investment council and asset
- 43:57management firms will produce a lot of things for a lot of
- 44:00people, but it doesn't necessarily customize to the RIA
- 44:05level. And that's one of the challenges
- 44:08I think that they're facing. So just some thoughts there that
- 44:11I have. I'm, I'm curious, I mean, do you
- 44:13have observations there, Mark or Jennifer?
- 44:23Following on what Jennifer said just prior about the ETS and
- 44:27about 20% were filers. That's definitely green space.
- 44:31And, you know, talking about you and, or Bill Miller and Fidelity
- 44:36being the only two institutions on this odd Dutch auction for
- 44:39something called Google, which yes, there was a broad field.
- 44:43You know, it reminds me of we just did a report on bitcoins
- 44:46unique quality of fat tailedness that you mentioned about its
- 44:51ability to reduce risk and AD return.
- 44:54And the opening quote is from Gibson about the future is here.
- 44:59It's just not evenly distributed in that the the ideas are there,
- 45:03but you know, we got too much going on and there's a, you
- 45:06know, we're a mile wide, an inch deep, but really can't take
- 45:09everything in. So I, I think when we looked at
- 45:16what was the university that just the first endowment to add
- 45:20Bitcoin. Thank you, Emery.
- 45:23And $11 billion. Fifteen million only .1%, but
- 45:29that may be the little bit of that might be potent enough, you
- 45:33know, because SWIB did that too. State of Wisconsin added just
- 45:36point 1%, which was 150 million for them because they're bigger.
- 45:40So, so it is 20%, but it was 0 a year ago until Judge Rao's
- 45:45decision, which you I just love the fact you call it like
- 45:48Prairie dogs. That's the maybe the best image
- 45:51I've ever heard to a reaction of a legislative for efedropping
- 45:55because you're like, she said how many, how many times did did
- 45:58she say arbitrary and capricious in her 21 pages?
- 46:02That image because my head popped up too.
- 46:06And like, is anyone else seeing this?
- 46:10It was, it was like a bugle blaring that no one else was
- 46:13hearing. So before I get to what Richard
- 46:18was saying, yeah, I, I, I, I do think the arc of adoption is
- 46:21there. It's proven.
- 46:22It's, you know, it's, it's not a Tulip bubble, which is three
- 46:25years. This is 15 years hasn't been
- 46:27broken, proven. It's just transforming.
- 46:30So on the part about compliance, Jennifer, maybe if you know you
- 46:35spent a few minutes talking about, we talked a lot about
- 46:38what you did and now what are you doing and how did you start
- 46:41a digital asset firm going from all that support at your prior
- 46:47firms to now doing this? What were the hurdles and what
- 46:50can you share with other advisors?
- 46:53Well, there there are hurdles still and that's natural.
- 46:58You know, you think about one of the things I like thinking about
- 47:02was like the auto industry, like the, you know, the first
- 47:05automobiles were were invented by bike manufacturers, like in
- 47:09the late 1880s, eighteen 90s. And you think about it then they
- 47:14had they had to manufacture every single component
- 47:16themselves, like every like the tires, the the the carburetor,
- 47:22the any component they had to manufacture themselves.
- 47:25There were no suppliers. There were no roads that were,
- 47:28you know, automobile roads. There are no gas stations you
- 47:31had to buy gas at like at. At the drugstore it was sold in
- 47:34like a quart, you know, container.
- 47:37There were all the like, there were so many, so many things
- 47:39that prevented adoption of automobiles.
- 47:42And yet, you know, and what really accelerated it was
- 47:45assembly line technology. When Henry Ford combined the the
- 47:49automobile with assembly line technology, that's when
- 47:52everything took. Off.
- 47:53So I think what I'm expecting is we have all this stumbling
- 47:58around that we experienced too in trying to start up our own
- 48:01firm. We, we have all the same
- 48:04concepts as traditional finance firms.
- 48:06We have a custodian and a prime brokerage relationship and
- 48:10trading relationships and an administrator.
- 48:12But all the mechanics, the technology, everything is
- 48:16different. It's all different rails, we
- 48:18call them, I think. So the when, when you come from
- 48:23a traditional finance background as I do, the concepts are very
- 48:26familiar, but the mechanics are not.
- 48:28So my partner Max is, he's our chief operating officer and he
- 48:32he plows through all this stuff. So, but getting that up and
- 48:36running, getting a bank account, you know, banks are not anxious
- 48:40to serve, you know, digital asset firms.
- 48:43That was a challenge. In fact, the first time we sent
- 48:47money to Coinbase, our bank reported us to the FBI for money
- 48:51laundering. So.
- 48:52Nice, can't catch a break. Fortunately, you know what's
- 48:59funny was the local the FBI agent in the Baltimore field
- 49:01office told me. Don't, don't worry, I'll explain
- 49:04it to them like he knew. He understood what we were
- 49:07doing. So there were lots of obstacles.
- 49:11Many of those things are being smoothed out now.
- 49:14They're getting better and better all the time.
- 49:17So but it was a big challenge before.
- 49:20So I think that's a there's some opportunity there where we can
- 49:24on behalf of investors, you know, you know, take care of a
- 49:27lot of those things so they don't have to.
- 49:29On the other hand, I think it prevents a lot of innovation
- 49:32that could be happening, you know, if if a lot of these
- 49:37frictions, you know, didn't occur.
- 49:39So, so I think there's still still a lot of friction out
- 49:42there. And I know you both know this,
- 49:43but we all lament the sort of the user experience on digital
- 49:48asset rails and crypto is still pretty confusing.
- 49:52And you know, for for many people, more than they want to,
- 49:56more than they want to get into themselves.
- 50:00Yeah, Yeah, it wouldn't. It's interesting.
- 50:03I, I, you know, not only do I speak with a lot of registered
- 50:06investment advisors, I'm speaking to a lot of custodians
- 50:11and, you know, in traditional finance and they're all trying
- 50:16to pull together a cohesive way to think about the space, right?
- 50:22And more importantly, what is their role, you know, that they
- 50:26have. And, you know, so like, often
- 50:29times when I'm speaking with the Rias, they're like, hey, look,
- 50:32yeah, I know, you know, all of the custodians.
- 50:34What? What, where are they at in this
- 50:36space? Like, until they enable, I feel
- 50:39like I'm hamstrung and I have to work in completely unfamiliar
- 50:44grounds. And so very similar to what you
- 50:46are describing there, Jennifer, if you know and opening up, you
- 50:50know, various relationships with, you know, frankly what are
- 50:55new or fairly, you know, startup type of entities.
- 50:59Now, they may be very bright people and very capable
- 51:02technologies and platforms, but they're, but from a, from an
- 51:07experienced eye, you're taking a bit of a chance.
- 51:10And so they get a little bit nervous.
- 51:12And I think that that's a, a, a, your experience is, is what, you
- 51:18know, a lot of my clients are experiencing today, which is,
- 51:21you know, doing the right level of due diligence, not just on
- 51:24the asset and, and the space, but who am I working with?
- 51:30Who am I working with? And are they credible people?
- 51:33And, and you know, and so that's half the battle.
- 51:36But you know, I think, you know, traditional custodians are
- 51:40really trying to figure out who they are, what their what their
- 51:44point of view is, what their value proposition is and how to
- 51:47integrate those rails that you were referencing.
- 51:51Yeah, that's where we really need this legislative action or
- 51:54some help from regulators. You know, bank regulators are
- 51:57really making it impossible for banks to be have meaningful, you
- 52:02know, offerings and digital assets, custody and other
- 52:05things. But you're right, I many of the
- 52:07people we talked to, they want that custodian to be a household
- 52:10name. You know, they want that to be
- 52:12custodian they know will be there through thick and thin and
- 52:16will help them if there's a problem.
- 52:18And there's very, there's not a lot of choices.
- 52:20There are a few, but not a lot of choices there right now.
- 52:23Yeah. So go ahead, Rich.
- 52:27I was just going to ask, I mean, Jennifer, you've had significant
- 52:32leadership roles, right? You know, CEO at Lake Mason, CEO
- 52:37at Western, I mean, huge firms, very accomplished firms.
- 52:42And, and you know, part of your job is being able to kind of
- 52:46cast forward a vision of where things are going.
- 52:49And, and you know, you're in the, in the heart of it in
- 52:52digital assets with Runa. And, and I'm, I'm fascinated to,
- 52:58to hear from you. What do you, how do you see the
- 53:01next three, 5-10 years playing out not just in traditional
- 53:06finance, but but also in the digital asset space with this
- 53:10emerging asset class? Well, two things.
- 53:15One, I think that one of the things you hear from asset
- 53:18management firms is that how little organic growth there is
- 53:21available to for asset managers or at least especially in the
- 53:25United States, but there's a real struggle.
- 53:27This is why you see them branching out to private credit
- 53:30and private equity and other things trying to find growth
- 53:33areas. So I think one thing that will
- 53:37happen is I think as digital assets become more understood by
- 53:43regulators, by legislators, and we get more clarity there that
- 53:47we will come to this. Carlotta Perez describes it as a
- 53:50golden age of really getting a value, you know, out of these
- 53:55rather than having corruption and disruption.
- 53:58We're going to have, you know, a legislative framework and a
- 54:01regulatory framework and really the big, you know, firms can,
- 54:06can also and will also participate because it is a new
- 54:09a growth area that's available and those are so they're so hard
- 54:13to find. So I think the firms that are
- 54:15early, especially like Franklin Templeton and Fidelity, we're
- 54:20very early to this. I think they'll have a big
- 54:22advantage because they have so many people working on this
- 54:25that, you know, you mentioned an iceberg.
- 54:27That's how they are. There's so many people
- 54:29internally that have been working on it for years.
- 54:31So I'm expecting them to, you know, provide to some of some
- 54:35asset managers really will get it and and catch that growth
- 54:39wave. So I am expecting that to
- 54:42happen, but I'm also expecting in digital assets, you know?
- 54:46There are, there are already. You know, I don't even know how
- 54:50many digital assets there are because of meme coins and think
- 54:52there's like hundreds of thousands of digital assets
- 54:55already. So they're, they're just, you
- 54:59know, people call it a Cambrian explosion.
- 55:03It definitely is that. And that's common in a new
- 55:05technology to have a lot of experimentation.
- 55:08So you have all these different, you know, there used to be back,
- 55:11back to the car analogy and there used to be hundreds of car
- 55:13companies in the United States until you sort of coalesce on,
- 55:18on sort of who the winners are, who's got it right, who's, who's
- 55:20put the right combination of technologies together.
- 55:23So I think that we'll see that in digital assets, most will
- 55:26fail. We we invest with the idea that
- 55:28almost everything will fail. Only a few will survive.
- 55:32I think Bitcoin is clearly, you know, a survivor.
- 55:35I think Ethereum is 2. Maybe you'd put Solana or
- 55:39Uniswap in that category. But beyond that, it's like it's
- 55:43all a big question mark. I think it's TDD, which is
- 55:47typical. But I do think one thing, one
- 55:50interesting thing that I think is coming around now is AI
- 55:54dominates everyone's thoughts, especially investors.
- 55:58You know, AI is why that Magnificent 7 is really
- 56:01outperforming everything else. And I think the, the, the
- 56:07promise of AI is so big. That's why I think investors are
- 56:10having trouble even gauging how big it is.
- 56:12But what AI needs it the support that it needs, kind of like the
- 56:16auto business and the assembly line.
- 56:20You know, maybe the assembly line isn't that sexy, but it was
- 56:23critical to the to the development of the auto
- 56:26industry. It was also, by the way, how IBM
- 56:29started was applying that technology to typewriters.
- 56:33So that was, I think that's what will happen with, with block
- 56:36chains. And AII think AI has some
- 56:39problems about how to how to, how do you establish what's
- 56:42real, you know, provenance, where did something come from?
- 56:46You know, how to stamp something in a way that can't be faked,
- 56:49How to, how to have AI agents that can make contracts and do
- 56:54transactions. All those problems that people
- 56:57are already seeing in how to make AI do the fantastic things
- 57:01that we want it to do, I think blockchain and and Bitcoin are
- 57:06essential technologies for that. So they may not be as visible or
- 57:09as sexy as AI, but they're essential.
- 57:12So I think that that sort of connection, people are going to
- 57:16start making that much more overtly.
- 57:18I love that layering you did of the collapse in the time of the
- 57:23100 year old assembly line to the integrity of Bitcoin maybe
- 57:28being aggressions, law manifesting AI where they choose
- 57:32the most integral currency to play on as they as they scheme
- 57:38together to create money. Like who's?
- 57:42And like Anderson's project, you know this stuff is moving fast
- 57:47here. It is.
- 57:48It is. That's why I love it every day.
- 57:51Every day we wake up, there's some big thing that's happened,
- 57:54right? But not of a sentence so.
- 57:58Rich and I were talking before I know we're, we're, we're running
- 58:00up close or and as Rich said, we were going to break all barriers
- 58:04because we had Jan here on time. Rich, we were talking about old
- 58:08tools and new toys and does when you started your, your firm
- 58:17Runa, were you able to port over existing metrics and tools to
- 58:25assess the behavior or portfolio of a pool of assets that would
- 58:30help use a familiar lens that people could then say, oh, I, I
- 58:36know what this looks like, you know, change it.
- 58:38And so all of a sudden they can see the behavior of what you're
- 58:41doing. Yeah.
- 58:43So the thing you mentioned, I have a CFA, so I have to sort of
- 58:46closer all the classic training and evaluation work and, and
- 58:51securities analysis and all that stuff is very relevant, but it
- 58:55isn't immediately applicable. So there are a few things like,
- 59:00pardon me, like Ethereum that have significant revenues, you
- 59:04know, billions of dollars in revenues.
- 59:06They have profits, they conduct things that look like dividends
- 59:11or stock buybacks. And so you can cast some of the
- 59:15more mature assets in a light like that, but most of them are
- 59:19not, they're much more like venture capital or like
- 59:23something completely new than they are like familiar equity
- 59:26analysis. So we we take the ideas that are
- 59:30familiar from sort of classic investment ideas, but we we have
- 59:35to come up with new tools. So one of the things we found
- 59:37was, for example, we think a big, an important difference
- 59:41between digital assets and other assets is that their networks.
- 59:45And so if you, there's a law called Metcalf's law that, you
- 59:51know, it's not, it's not a real law, it's just an idea.
- 59:53But the idea is that, and there's a lot of data to support
- 59:57this, that network value grows faster than the, then the
- 1:00:00network itself grows. So, and one of the implications
- 1:00:04of that idea is early networks tend to, all things equal,
- 1:00:09dominate because they have more time to make connections, which
- 1:00:12makes their value grow. So we think that's a really
- 1:00:15interesting idea. And we took, you know, Facebook,
- 1:00:19we looked at the value of Facebook and you know, you can
- 1:00:23look at Facebook's revenues and earnings and all cash flows and
- 1:00:27all sorts of metrics, classic metrics.
- 1:00:29But if you just regress Facebook's price against its
- 1:00:33growth in the network, you know, number of participants on
- 1:00:35Facebook, that explains 94% of Facebook's price action, you
- 1:00:40know, so it's pretty much like it's a network.
- 1:00:43That's it. That's the, that's the answer.
- 1:00:46And the same thing is true of Bitcoin.
- 1:00:47So if you regress Bitcoin price action against Bitcoin wallets
- 1:00:52for example. Or you know.
- 1:00:55Bitcoin participation in the network that explains 91% of
- 1:00:58Bitcoin price action. So for us, concepts like
- 1:01:02Metcalf's law are not they're certainly familiar like the the
- 1:01:08top company, you know those magnificent 7 companies, almost
- 1:01:11all of them are are network effects companies.
- 1:01:13But that idea is still not very talked about, but it should be.
- 1:01:18And I think that that sort of thinking is what the kind of
- 1:01:23thing that we're bringing to digital assets because I do
- 1:01:26think we need some new new metrics and new ideas because
- 1:01:29these are different. They are not, they're not equity
- 1:01:32securities and you know, on different technology software.
- 1:01:38I got to say First off, Jennifer, that that was a great
- 1:01:41description. Oh, jeez, Mark, I was just going
- 1:01:44to give you a kudo. Hold on, that was a great
- 1:01:46descriptor. But you know, Mark is getting
- 1:01:50quite good at, at flashing slides and and his timing and
- 1:01:55sequencing is just really good, Mark.
- 1:01:58So a little kudos to you. But yeah, this is a really
- 1:02:01interesting slide here. So maybe you were just kind of
- 1:02:03describing it. I didn't mean to to talk over
- 1:02:07you if I did. So you've, you've got Facebook
- 1:02:10here. We're at 94.46, is that right?
- 1:02:15Yeah, that's the R-squared on regressing Facebook's price with
- 1:02:20its participants in the network. So it explains 94% of its price
- 1:02:25change. So, and you can see on the
- 1:02:28right, same thing with Bitcoin, it's, you know, very high
- 1:02:31R-squared for for Bitcoin as well.
- 1:02:35And that's really a, you know, a the implication of Metcalf's
- 1:02:40law. You know, if Metcalf's law is is
- 1:02:42a valid concept, you should find this sort of result and you do.
- 1:02:47Yeah, and linking it back to, you know, a concept, applying it
- 1:02:50to tratify with something that obviously broke the barrier what
- 1:02:56Facebook did when the biggest networks on the planet.
- 1:03:01And one reason why we, you know, have you hear what we try to be
- 1:03:04besides The Muppets and the balcony, you know, casting
- 1:03:07aspersions upon people, not adopting digital assets.
- 1:03:09It's really to be that bilingual animal to be able to speak to
- 1:03:13both. And you did it perfectly in this
- 1:03:15slide. I can't believe it took me this
- 1:03:16long to bring it up. Rich Chinese.
- 1:03:19Yeah, this is, this is such a powerful slide.
- 1:03:22And Mark, kudos to you too, because you're doing some really
- 1:03:25interesting research as well, which just, you know, I think,
- 1:03:29you know, we spoke about last week when we had Fidelity
- 1:03:32Digital assets, Chris Kiper, head of research there, join us.
- 1:03:37And, and, you know, the, the work that you're doing on
- 1:03:41volatility, it's, you know, it's really, really helpful, I think
- 1:03:45to the larger investment community who's, who's saying,
- 1:03:48OK, what, how do I lean into this a little bit with things
- 1:03:52that are familiar? And so, you know, Metcalf's law
- 1:03:55and the, the work that you did with good ball, bad ball and,
- 1:03:59and, you know, really compelling stuff.
- 1:04:02And it's, and I'm, I'm grateful to both of you for, you know,
- 1:04:05helping, you know, people figure out different ways everybody
- 1:04:09comes to Bitcoin differently. I've come to find and, and you
- 1:04:13guys are helping bring some familiar ways for, for
- 1:04:16investment advisors forward. So thank you.
- 1:04:21Well, that being said, we're at the top of the hour, right?
- 1:04:23And I, you know, we had a chance to meet with you, Jennifer, over
- 1:04:27the weekend and I knew the second that we started talking,
- 1:04:32my goodness, we're going to be in for an hour and we normally
- 1:04:35go for 3035 minutes. Try to keep it short and sweet,
- 1:04:40but you know, your insights and your sets of career experiences
- 1:04:44and the journey that you've had into digital asset space is
- 1:04:47rare. And, and it, and it's very, very
- 1:04:50valuable to our audience who's, you know, grappling with how do
- 1:04:55we bring, you know, digital assets or Bitcoin forward to our
- 1:04:58clients and thoughtful and prudent ways.
- 1:05:00And, and so we're just overjoyed to have you and, and grateful
- 1:05:04for your time and, and the work that you're producing in the
- 1:05:08community to help others, you know, see the opportunity with a
- 1:05:13clear lens. And so thank you so much for for
- 1:05:17joining us today. Any closing thoughts on how
- 1:05:21people can find you, Jennifer? We do.
- 1:05:24You can find a lot of our work at our website
- 1:05:27runadigitalassets.com. And Mark and Rich, thanks for
- 1:05:31having me and I'm really enjoying what you're doing.
- 1:05:33So keep keep it going. I'm I'm following along with
- 1:05:37great interest. I think especially Bitcoin is
- 1:05:39especially important to to really developing the whole
- 1:05:42space. Awesome.
- 1:05:44Well, thank you. Jennifer Pleasure was ours.
- 1:05:48Thank you. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:05:50week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:05:53valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:05:55rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:05:57All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:05:59notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:06:02reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:06:05entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:06:08investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:06:11your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:06:13Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:06:17of our private client advisors.