Latest / The New Paris Podcast / Best of: Fine dining in Paris with sommelier Etheliya Hananova
Transcript
- 0:08You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:10I'm your host, Lindsay Trimuto. Running a restaurant in Paris is
- 0:15fraught in the best of times, but the last several years have
- 0:17presented a few additional challenges.
- 0:21Some have closed as a result, but I'm happy to report that
- 0:24many of the city's best independently run
- 0:26establishments, spanning street food to fine dining, have held
- 0:29on and even grown stronger. I know my own desire to support
- 0:33them has grown as well, certainly a result of having
- 0:36experienced more than six consecutive months of restaurant
- 0:38closures between 2020 and 2021. But so has my desire for more
- 0:43immersive, memorable dining experiences.
- 0:46One of two meals that delivered that for me in the last year was
- 0:49at Comis, a contemporary family owned fine dining restaurant in
- 0:52the 16,000 E small run by Canadians Noam Gedolov, the
- 0:55chef, and today's guest Atelia Hananova, the sommelier.
- 1:00She talks to me about the journey from Montreal to Paris,
- 1:03the type of dining environment and experience she and Noam set
- 1:06out to create, and what it means to be working in wine in Paris
- 1:11on her own terms. Hello there.
- 1:15Welcome to the show. Thank you.
- 1:18I'm so glad to to, I'm so glad for you to be here because, you
- 1:22know, you're often in a restaurant, which makes it
- 1:25difficult to have downtime. But also, I feel like between
- 1:29COVID and being on opposite sides of the city, you and I
- 1:33have been like ships in the night for a very long time until
- 1:37it feels like you're, well, it actually is years but.
- 1:40It has literally been years. Well with the COVID years just
- 1:44blur together so it's it makes it even worse.
- 1:47One year. One very long year.
- 1:50And October 45th, 2020 for such a long time.
- 1:56But Speaking of October, I mean, I finally got to come and see
- 1:59you, but in, you know, we, we were in the same place at the
- 2:04same time and it was in your dining room last October.
- 2:08So, you know, obviously that wasn't a time to talk so much
- 2:13because you were, you know, busy working.
- 2:14So can you start with a little bit of background on, you know,
- 2:18when and why you moved to Paris and some of the restaurants you
- 2:21were working in actually before you started Clanice with your
- 2:24husband? Well, to make a Long story
- 2:26short, I was in Montreal for about 13 years and my husband,
- 2:31who had worked in California for a long time, was very eager to
- 2:35move to France and work in kitchens in France.
- 2:38And we met in Montreal just before he decided to come to
- 2:42France. So we met in Montreal and then
- 2:44two weeks later he asked me to move to Paris with him.
- 2:46And I was like, no, because we just met and and then he kept
- 2:51asking and I was like, OK, he's serious.
- 2:54Over the course of a year, he kept talking about France
- 2:56Transparent. So I said, you know what?
- 2:58Go and go and see what's out there and go and see if there
- 3:00are opportunities and then we'll go from there.
- 3:02And he came here in 2013 to work at a Sauce for a while and the
- 3:07Three Star restaurant, which which isn't is and was on the
- 3:1116th. And it was through that that he
- 3:15made contact with the Sao Jean Recuto, which is a one star
- 3:18restaurant on El San Luis, who at the time was looking for a
- 3:21head Summaria and a head chef because theirs were moving into
- 3:25opening their own business. And so we got hired together and
- 3:29were sponsored and we came in the beginning of 2014 to to do
- 3:33that. So we came for jobs, basically.
- 3:35Which is quite rare I would think, I mean in terms of the
- 3:38way chefs make their way over. Yeah, it was, it was just a once
- 3:43in a lifetime opportunity as a Canadian couple, you know,
- 3:47living and working in North America for our whole career.
- 3:50You know, it's kind of the dream.
- 3:51You get to come to France and work and and live and we really
- 3:55came here. You know, we bought a one way
- 3:56ticket. We didn't know if we were going
- 3:57to be here for two weeks or two months or two years or how it
- 4:00was going to go and just sort of packed our bags and said let's
- 4:04see what happens and. And so how long did you you both
- 4:07stay at the Sergeant recruiter? We were there for about a year
- 4:11and a half and then that there were some projects affiliated
- 4:15with the Sergeant accoutre that started to kind of unravel for
- 4:18financial reasons and our jobs got eliminated.
- 4:23That's Grant ended up getting sold.
- 4:25Yeah, yeah, it was taken over. And so we had to figure out what
- 4:29was our next step. We kind of looked at each other
- 4:32and said, you know, we've been doing this for so many years.
- 4:34We've done it in so many markets.
- 4:36And we kind of see an opening in France, in Paris for something
- 4:41that might not exist yet, which is the idea of a warm,
- 4:45welcoming, sort of cozy ambience, but still a fine
- 4:51dining restaurant, still refined, still elegant, still,
- 4:55you know, concentrating on details and, and, you know, sort
- 4:58of striving for perfection, but without kind of the formality
- 5:03that can exist in fine dining restaurants sometimes.
- 5:07You know, we didn't want to go casual, but we didn't want
- 5:09people to feel like they had to behave a certain way or like be
- 5:13afraid to laugh or dress, you know, really formally.
- 5:16We just wanted it to feel like our living room but with better
- 5:19food than our living room. Certainly better design than
- 5:22most living rooms. It's much nicer than my own
- 5:24living room. But it's also in a part of town
- 5:29that is has, you know, at some points been considered, you
- 5:32know, a dining desert. It's in the 16th Al Andy Small,
- 5:37which, you know, I imagine has been a both a blessing and and a
- 5:41challenge in some ways for you. Yeah.
- 5:44That's right about it. There are a couple of factors.
- 5:48We were adamant about finding a space that was adapted to our
- 5:54ideas, one of which the the main deal breaker and the one non
- 5:58negotiable thing was having an open kitchen that looked over
- 6:01the dining room. We'd always felt very strongly
- 6:04that the kitchen should be able to see what's going on in the
- 6:09dining room. It's important for the cooks to
- 6:11feel a sense of connection to the guests and to see what their
- 6:16work is translating to out in the dining room, and not just to
- 6:19be like hiding in a closed space and kind of working without a
- 6:24sense of what it is that they're doing it for.
- 6:26I think also for efficiency of service, it was a big deal for
- 6:30us to have the possibility for Nam to sort of survey what's
- 6:33going on in the dining room and and be able to sort of
- 6:36anticipate calling tables and that sort of thing.
- 6:39So from a logistical standpoint, it was, it was something that
- 6:41we're very taken with and this space happened to sort of
- 6:46provide us with the layout that we were looking for more or less
- 6:52and we looked at I think 52 spaces before this one, so.
- 6:56And not necessarily in just in the 16th.
- 6:58We looked all over the city, we looked everywhere and we'd
- 7:01actually made offers on spaces in, in the Upper Marais and also
- 7:04in the eighth LNG small. So but they fell through for
- 7:07different reasons. And and then so this was sort of
- 7:11our last stand before we gave up and it kind of worked out.
- 7:14So we're like. OK, this is.
- 7:15It, you know, obviously it was important for us to be in a
- 7:20neighborhood where fine dining made sense, you know, where
- 7:24there was a certain clientele for it.
- 7:25And West Parisian is, is an area that does have a lot of
- 7:30residents who do enjoy fine dining.
- 7:32And it's a big curious that there isn't more of an offering.
- 7:36But I think that that has changed.
- 7:38There are a handful of, you know, very high quality
- 7:41restaurants in the area as well. I think it's just slow going
- 7:45because it's a very established sort of old bourgeois area that
- 7:49takes time like everything in Paris to to sort of evolve.
- 7:53But it is happening, I think actively.
- 7:55And, and do you think, I mean, based on from the time that you
- 7:59opened, obviously a lot has happened.
- 8:01And so, you know, your, your, your key diner is perhaps not
- 8:05the same as it was when you first opened, but is it a lot of
- 8:09locals? Do you get a, you know, sort of
- 8:11West Parisian diners or are you getting people who are coming,
- 8:15who are travelling from across the city to dine just just.
- 8:19It's incredibly mixed. It's incredibly mixed.
- 8:22There are some nights where 90% of the dining room is French
- 8:25speaking. There are nights where it's all
- 8:27people from around the surrounding areas.
- 8:29There are nights where it's people who have heard about the
- 8:31restaurant from other parts of the city or even other parts of
- 8:34France. And we have a ton of traveling
- 8:39visitors also who come to the restaurant who have heard about
- 8:41the restaurant's reputation and and are interested in dining
- 8:44with us. So they plan it in in advance
- 8:46in. Advance.
- 8:47Well, certainly having a Michelin star doesn't hurt.
- 8:49Which, yeah, you know, it's. Part of the, it's part of the, I
- 8:54think you know, visibility of the restaurant to foreign
- 8:58diners. And was that something you both
- 9:00hoped for, Kumice, you know, that, that, that you were you
- 9:03were aiming for a star. I mean, what I I know, I'm never
- 9:07quite sure whether that's the same ambition for foreign chefs
- 9:11and sommelier working in France as it is for, you know, local
- 9:16natives. For us, it was never about
- 9:18chasing anything. It was never about saying we
- 9:20need to get a star at all costs and we'll do whatever it takes.
- 9:23It was about saying, we know that the work we do is at a
- 9:28certain level that, you know, it's a certain level of
- 9:32technicity, of commitment to focus, of, you know, years of
- 9:35experience that lend lends itself to attracting the
- 9:41attention of a guide like the Michelin Guide.
- 9:44Now, what we do is based on what we're really seriously,
- 9:48genuinely passionate about doing.
- 9:50And so we're not doing it because we're looking to attract
- 9:53that attention. It just so happens that the work
- 9:55that we really love to do is sort of commensurate with what
- 9:58the Michelin Guide has tended to recognize.
- 10:00And the reality is that in Paris, as foreigners, it wasn't
- 10:06exactly like an easy pass for us to open a fine dining restaurant
- 10:12and get taken seriously. So to be perfectly honest, the
- 10:16Michelin Guide was what sort of gave us the validation that we
- 10:20needed in the eyes of, you know, the global market here and and
- 10:23also for foreigners in in recognizing the work.
- 10:28I mean, it was by by far one of the most exceptional meals I had
- 10:32in all of 2021, which is saying, I mean, which is wild because I
- 10:38tried to like quickly make up for all the lost time by eating
- 10:40at restaurants as soon as they reopened on May 9th, May 19th,
- 10:45you know, But like, regardless of, you know, of, of
- 10:50environments and, and atmospheres and style, there's
- 10:54just something so pleasurable about being taken care of sort
- 10:58of in this, this environment that, as you described, is kind
- 11:02of like a really polished living room, but cozy.
- 11:06And you wouldn't be surprised if there was a fire going
- 11:08somewhere. Yeah.
- 11:10Well, that that was, you know, thank you for saying that.
- 11:13I really appreciate that And. I'm not just I'm not just
- 11:15Tooting your horn. I.
- 11:17I know you do a fair bit of eating so as my.
- 11:20Digestion can attest. I I trust your, I trust your
- 11:25words. I know, I know that you do the
- 11:27research on the ground. Yeah, it was, it's, it's really,
- 11:31it's, it's we were just saying the other day.
- 11:34No, we had a couple of guests who came up to the kitchen to
- 11:38say hi to Noam and they were talking to him.
- 11:40It was actually fellow restaurateurs and, and we were
- 11:42sort of exchanging a little bit and he kind of looked at her and
- 11:46he was like, you know, we're just so fortunate to be doing
- 11:49what we do because we are genuinely passionate about it.
- 11:52Like it's really hard work. We're really tired all the time
- 11:57and sometimes in difficult times we're like, why have we done
- 12:00this to ourselves? You know, whether it's COVID or
- 12:02strikes or whatever. But ultimately, you know, that
- 12:06is a, that is a blessing and a privilege to be able to do what
- 12:09you are keenly interested and passionate about doing.
- 12:14And and it's important to step back and recognize that
- 12:17regularly as you wade through the exhaustion.
- 12:22Well, and you both have a you know you added onto your project
- 12:27by having a child throughout all of this we.
- 12:29Did. Yeah, because we just weren't
- 12:31busy enough. We're tired.
- 12:33Enough. Really.
- 12:34Yeah. We just.
- 12:35I mean, why? Why have more sleep when we
- 12:37could have less? But but, but yet even even with
- 12:41that, even with the challenges you've had, because
- 12:43unfortunately, fortunately and unfortunately, like before
- 12:46COVID, there were plenty of other challenges.
- 12:48Yeah, the Paris, the, the, the Paris, what do you call it sort
- 12:53of like the Paris experience, the the strikes and the gilet
- 12:56jaunes and you sort of were impacted by all of that.
- 13:00How do you feel running a, a restaurant, you know, sort of
- 13:05now versus through those times? I mean, is it just sort of like
- 13:08now you feel like if you've conquered that, you can conquer
- 13:10anything? I feel resilient.
- 13:14I don't good choice. We feel resilient.
- 13:17We feel actually, interestingly enough, I feel like now, in
- 13:21spite of the ups and downs, now we kind of feel like we sort of
- 13:25found our footing in a way that we hadn't thus far, I think
- 13:30since let's say September of last year, since we were able to
- 13:33reopen the restaurant, you know, in decent conditions, with the
- 13:36exception of this past January with Omicron.
- 13:39We, we kind of found the schedule, the, the vibe, the
- 13:45team, the thing that makes it sort of feel like it flows in a
- 13:49way that's harmonious and, and forward moving.
- 13:53There was, there were periods where we felt like we were
- 13:56swimming upstream a lot, you know, for a variety of reasons.
- 14:02And, you know, for a while we did lunch and then lunch wasn't
- 14:05really relevant in the area anymore after the yellow vest
- 14:07protests. So we had to pivot and we've had
- 14:09to make adjustments along the way as a relatively young
- 14:13business. But I think today we feel more
- 14:16solid, more sort of lucid about what we're doing and how we're
- 14:20doing it. And I think it feels more
- 14:22organic and real and, and as a result enjoyable than it has in
- 14:26the past. I think we've always enjoyed
- 14:29ourselves to a certain extent, but it's come with, you know, a
- 14:31pretty healthy dollop of stress. And I think today we're sort of
- 14:35getting to enjoy more of what we do on a daily basis.
- 14:39It's it's we're also appreciative of the times that
- 14:42are that are calmer when they happen.
- 14:44Sure, sure. And and of course those have
- 14:48been perhaps too frequent in the last couple of years and and not
- 14:53the kind of calm you've anyone would hope for, but you, you
- 14:58definitely have. I mean, I know you guys
- 15:00attempted to do not attempted. I mean, you did it for a time,
- 15:05some delivery options during the first confinement and.
- 15:07You know, that was insane. It was insane.
- 15:10Well, it was insane because like, I'm amazed that anyone in
- 15:13the restaurant business, like could get their mind wrapped
- 15:17around doing something like that.
- 15:20It was just. It was just a matter of
- 15:22survival. So we were like, what do we do?
- 15:25We're going to do take out and we're going to do comfort food.
- 15:28And I found myself bagging individual Baggies of Caesar
- 15:33salad dressing at like 7:00 in the morning, pulling an all
- 15:36nighter because our first meatballs and handmade pasta
- 15:42option was we got like 100 orders because people were just
- 15:46so desperate to eat something that they didn't cook.
- 15:49And we're like, Oh my God, how do we do this?
- 15:50It was just Noam and I and we made like kilos of bechamel and
- 15:53kilos of Bolognese and kilos of pasta.
- 15:57And we were like doing all the dishes.
- 15:58And it was. I never want to do it again.
- 16:04Was really the last in the end because I ordered it.
- 16:07I remember it being wonderful, but not wonderful for you.
- 16:11No, you know, it actually was a very emerging experience and it
- 16:15really taught us a lot. And it was really, it was really
- 16:17fun in a crazy way sometimes. We did it till May, I think of
- 16:222020. And then restaurants started to
- 16:25slowly reopen. And then, you know, orders kind
- 16:27of fell off and we were like, great, let's go back to doing
- 16:29normal people like normal, you know, format of the restaurant.
- 16:32Right. Normal quantities normal.
- 16:34Yeah, not like scramble to make kilos of food put in boxes.
- 16:39And I mean, that is, that is what, you know, the French call
- 16:42a mitier, that is. It's a different and it's a
- 16:44different job. Yeah, absolutely.
- 16:46The Togo that. We know.
- 16:48Yeah, well. And that's why you saw and in
- 16:51fact, I think, you know, you guys jumped right into it.
- 16:53But there were some, you know, big multi Michelin starred
- 16:57restaurants associated with hotels who got into this sort of
- 17:00activity and it took them a long time to get up and running
- 17:04because, you know, they tried to do the packaging in some.
- 17:07Yeah. You know, excessively formal
- 17:09way, but at the end of the day, it's like people would have been
- 17:12happy with whatever. Well, I think, you know, for an
- 17:17upscale hotel, they have the reserves financially and and in
- 17:22terms of the team as well to be able to sort of orchestrate that
- 17:25in that way. You know, we're a small family
- 17:27business. We couldn't we couldn't do that.
- 17:29We couldn't bring in a full team and like make that work.
- 17:33And and we certainly didn't see ourselves doing fine dining food
- 17:36to go because we just, you know, the whole the whole thing that
- 17:41Noam and I are passionate about is alaminut cooking.
- 17:44So to prepackage food that you want, you know, served in an
- 17:51alaminut way, it doesn't make any sense.
- 17:53And that's why we sort of decided to do like really
- 17:55delicious lasagna and really good, you know, Curry and that
- 17:59sort of thing. Well, it was comforting while it
- 18:02lasted. And certainly if I mean in a, in
- 18:05a way, you know, I, I kind of wonder, and maybe this is
- 18:08completely out there, but it, it felt like more people learned
- 18:12about you. Sure.
- 18:14Yeah. You know, I think it was, I
- 18:15think it was a window to the restaurant's existence for some
- 18:18people who otherwise wouldn't have necessarily known about us.
- 18:21And perhaps the the people on the 16th, you know, decided in
- 18:24that moment that as soon as it were possible, they would come,
- 18:28you know, eat what you guys really cook and and the wines
- 18:30you do really serve. Speaking of.
- 18:34Actually, just as a quick anecdote, we just had a guest
- 18:37come last week for her birthday who was one of the guests who
- 18:41discovered the restaurant through the take out, a really
- 18:43nice woman. And I remember distinctly that
- 18:47she had a tomato allergy because I remember like carefully
- 18:51creating a separate dish for her during the comfort food take out
- 18:54stuff that didn't have any tomato in it.
- 18:56So when she came to the restaurant, she was like, she
- 18:58didn't think I would recognize her.
- 18:59I was like, hi, tomato allergy and she was in.
- 19:01She was like, how do you remember that?
- 19:05I'm like, I don't know, but I do.
- 19:08The the mind works in mysterious ways.
- 19:10The things that we, you know, we choose to remember.
- 19:13But I, I, it's already been, you know, like half of our
- 19:16conversation and I haven't even talked about wine, which is, no,
- 19:19I just mean about, about wine, which is, you know, your
- 19:21expertise. I, I hope we get to the point
- 19:25someday where we don't have to specify that the sumuliye or
- 19:28sumuliye is a woman. And, and maybe we don't even
- 19:31need to do it now. But I highlight this mostly
- 19:33because we're in one of the capitals of, of wine.
- 19:36France is a, you know, obviously this is a, a culture entrenched
- 19:41in wine and with a tradition, tradition of mastery and, and
- 19:45certainly with well documented challenges for women in the
- 19:48industry. So I'm wondering, 'cause
- 19:50obviously you started in wine outside of France, but what has
- 19:53that process been like for you in your previous roles and then
- 19:56now as you're running the show for yourself?
- 20:00It's actually been, it's a, it's been a very interesting
- 20:03evolution both culturally and just professionally.
- 20:06Because for one thing, you know, from the professional
- 20:09standpoint, you know, I started off as a, as a very eager and
- 20:13wide eyed young sommelier and then sommelier.
- 20:16And then, you know, I started in New York, I continued in
- 20:19Montreal, studied in Montreal and then worked and had great
- 20:23jobs in Montreal and then met Noam.
- 20:25And that's what made us come here.
- 20:26And I made the shift professionally to being a
- 20:28sommelier in a fine dining restaurant in Paris.
- 20:31And that was a learning curve because I realized that, you
- 20:34know, whereas in Montreal or New York, for example, where tastes
- 20:37are relatively democratic and people will sort of be open to
- 20:40drinking whatever from anywhere, though they have very strong
- 20:44French wine markets here. Foreigners come here to drink
- 20:47French wine, and locals want to drink French wine.
- 20:50There are exceptions, but they're much fewer and far
- 20:53further between than in North America.
- 20:55And so that was definitely a learning curve.
- 20:58And then, you know, over time have evolved into being a
- 21:02restaurateur and not just a someday.
- 21:04And that has also completely changed how I work because now I
- 21:10have to think about the whole picture.
- 21:11I have to think about the business of viability, how
- 21:14purchasing is, you know, in line with our, you know, global needs
- 21:20and, and abilities to, to take care of, you know, our, our
- 21:23entire structure. You know, I have to think about
- 21:26the payroll before I make orders.
- 21:27I can't just be like, oh, I want, you know, this Burgundy on
- 21:30my list. And we're a young restaurant.
- 21:31You know, we're a young family restaurant.
- 21:32We're not a palace hotel or, you know, a very established chef
- 21:37who has 30 years of background of buying in France.
- 21:39And so it's still 4 1/2 years in a huge learning curve.
- 21:44And obviously all of the things that have happened in the last
- 21:47few years have also had an impact on how we go about, you
- 21:50know, doing our work from the wine side of things.
- 21:52And honestly, I think the best is yet to come.
- 21:55I still have like tons of stuff I want to develop and, and, and
- 22:00grow in terms of the wine program and I, I just have to be
- 22:04patient and do it one step at a time.
- 22:06But it's it's been a very interesting and enriching
- 22:09process. And in terms of being the one in
- 22:13charge of the wine list, but also sort of the master of
- 22:16ceremonies in the dining room, because you're the also the one
- 22:19circulating and you're as much a part of that experience as the
- 22:23other servers. How have certain guests received
- 22:28you as or Or do they sort of assume you're also the one in
- 22:31charge of the wines or like? Well, in the beginning, it took
- 22:35a while. In the beginning we had a fair
- 22:37bit of press about the fact that I handled the wine, but it still
- 22:40took a little bit of time for people to sort of catch on to
- 22:43the fact that I had sort of run that I run the wine program.
- 22:46I think today it's established and a lot of people have read
- 22:50about the husband and wife team and the wife is the sommelier.
- 22:53And so it's a little bit less of a discovery for people.
- 22:57They, they understand that coming in.
- 22:59So that's nice. It's rarely but can happen that
- 23:05guests will be like, oh, I'll, I'll wait for the sommelier.
- 23:09And I'm like, I'll look around and I'm like, OK, hi, what can I
- 23:13help you with? And it takes them a minute to
- 23:16sort of, oh, oh, OK. And nobody is nobody is, you
- 23:23know, unpleasant about it or, or nobody, you know, nobody comes
- 23:27to the restaurant and goes like, no, no, no.
- 23:28I want to see the sommelier but it does happen once in a blue
- 23:32moon where they'll like frantically look for the guy in
- 23:34the suit that was just there taking their food order and like
- 23:38grasp for any man. So like come take over.
- 23:41It's rare, but it. Well, it's good.
- 23:43That's a relief. It's a relief to hear.
- 23:46I usually try to smooth it over. I mean, it's kind of like
- 23:50assuming that, you know, I don't know, someone who works in a
- 23:54clothing store is necessarily female or all, you know, these
- 23:57traditional, I don't know, these traditional roles.
- 23:59But I think we need to, you know, as diners, also be better
- 24:04about our own assumptions and not go in, I don't think.
- 24:08Personally, I think people are a little bit like sometimes people
- 24:13are just a little bit disconnected from what you know.
- 24:17I, I don't even think it's intentional necessarily.
- 24:20I think it's just sort of like a, a reflex action.
- 24:22It happens just as often, if not more often, that people when I
- 24:26come to the table will ask me if I'm also the chef so well.
- 24:31That's a that's a positive. I think that it's just like it
- 24:35doesn't occur to them that because I'm not in the kitchen
- 24:39that I, you know, might not be the chef, right?
- 24:45I'm not sure where these ideas come from.
- 24:47And that's OK. You know, the other day I, I
- 24:51went to greet a guest and he was like Mont suave chef.
- 24:53And I was like, it's like, wow, this is a first.
- 24:58I've been doing this for 25 years.
- 25:00No one's ever said that. Well, if if there's going to be
- 25:03a first, it's going to happen in this country, I mean.
- 25:05Every single day there's something I'm like, I see it
- 25:08all, but I haven't. But that's great.
- 25:10I mean, I kind of love that, that they there's an assumption
- 25:13and it clearly it wasn't a a negative assumption.
- 25:15It was I'm prepared to eat no matter what.
- 25:19He was super deferential too. He was like Bo Swell chef and I
- 25:22was like Bo Swell. It's true that there's that.
- 25:25That's another thing that that strikes me as being far more, I
- 25:29don't know if specifically French, but European in the way
- 25:31that people when they go to these fine dining establishments
- 25:34will refer to either the the the cook in charge or the IT it.
- 25:40It's a much different relationship to the dining out
- 25:44experience than I think most North Americans have, at least I
- 25:47think from. What I would call, I mean it's
- 25:50it's it's interesting to me because and then there's another
- 25:54dynamic which is the owner dynamic, which is really funny
- 25:57because I am incredibly operationally active.
- 26:01We both are, we are there for the entirety of service and much
- 26:06of the meson plus. No, I was there for all of every
- 26:08day and I'll be serving tables and like I do everything.
- 26:14I pour water and I fold napkins and I pull out chairs and it
- 26:17cleared plates. Like I started in this business
- 26:19as a waitress and I am still basically a waitress and I love
- 26:25it and I enjoy the work and I find it stimulating and it keeps
- 26:28me fit. And I, I get a kick out of it
- 26:30and, and I also get a kick out of working with my staff who are
- 26:36younger and who have less experience and who learn on the
- 26:40ground instead of me sort of top down telling them what to do but
- 26:43not doing it myself. I think it's much more effective
- 26:45and much more stimulating for them.
- 26:47And it creates a really great team dynamic.
- 26:50And so I'll be running around the dining room all night and
- 26:52serving people and talking to them and exchanging with them.
- 26:54And then at some point, many guests will be like, wait a
- 26:58second, are you the owner? And I'll be like, yeah.
- 27:02And they'll be like, Oh my God, blood.
- 27:04And I'm like, I'm exactly the same person I was 10 seconds
- 27:07ago. I.
- 27:08Think it's probably well, but I think it's the idea that while
- 27:11you're running this whole thing and yes, you're two people, but
- 27:15they mostly are seeing you and it just seems kind of like a
- 27:19miraculous one woman show. Like, wow, she's doing all of
- 27:23this and she's getting everything right and she's
- 27:25remembering and because it, as you said, it requires so much
- 27:28attention to detail. It does, yeah, which I find very
- 27:32enjoyable. So I like to be very active in
- 27:35service. It makes me crazy not to get in
- 27:38hands on and and I I wouldn't have it any other way.
- 27:41I mean, as long as I'm young and healthy, I.
- 27:46Can keep doing. Of course I'm happy to.
- 27:47I'm happy to be there with my hands, you know, fully in, in
- 27:52the work. But it's just funny the the, the
- 27:55relationship dynamics. 99% of the time it's just an expression
- 27:59like a gleeful expression of like, wow, you're the owner.
- 28:02Cool, let's exchange what made you come to Paris.
- 28:04You know, people will get excited about it 1% of the time.
- 28:09People will not necessarily be so nice.
- 28:12You know, there it happens that people are a little bit, you
- 28:15know, I'm not appreciative of of service staff or perceive them
- 28:20as like a lower caste of society.
- 28:22It's incredibly rare. But there's a bit of that sort
- 28:25of like, oh, you're a service person.
- 28:27Well, you know, you're lower than I am, so I'm going to boss
- 28:30you around or kind of torture you a little bit.
- 28:33And it happens very rarely, especially in our restaurant
- 28:35because we sort of have a certain dynamic and a warmth
- 28:38that makes people feel quite at ease.
- 28:40But when it happens, and it happens to me because they don't
- 28:44realize they're the owner, and I'll kind of like, take things
- 28:47in hand and be like, you know what?
- 28:49We're here to have a good time. We're here to make sure that you
- 28:52have a good time. And I promise everything's gonna
- 28:55be OK. And then they clue in and
- 28:56they're like, wait, you're the owner?
- 28:58And then they completely change the way they talk to me.
- 29:01And I'm just like, like, yeah. You've now seen the the the
- 29:08their. True.
- 29:08Selves you know who they who they bestow respect and
- 29:12politeness upon an incredibly. Like there, it's a, it's a
- 29:18minority. I'd say it's happened like three
- 29:21times, you know? Well, that's good, that's good.
- 29:23But it's still disheartening that it happens.
- 29:26Yeah, it's disheartening. I I don't care if it happens to
- 29:29me. I care if it happens to my staff
- 29:31because they're a little bit less in a position to sort of
- 29:35rein things in. But I keep an eye and if I see
- 29:37anybody, and again, it almost never happens, but if I ever see
- 29:40anybody sort of trying to like steamroll anybody, I'll be like,
- 29:44let me get in there. I'm going to take care of
- 29:46business and I'm going to make sure it's all going to be OK for
- 29:48everybody. And then it is.
- 29:50Well, let's hoping anybody who's listening, who has a tendency to
- 29:53do this, will, you know, shape up before they come back to, to
- 29:58dine in Paris. I, I don't want to miss out on
- 30:01asking you specifically about some wine things because your
- 30:03wine selection was so superb and I loved the champagne you chose
- 30:07during our meal because I remember, I'm hoping I'm
- 30:10remembering this correctly, but it was from the western part of
- 30:13Champagne. You know if if that's correct, I
- 30:17don't know from. Your it was from the South of
- 30:20Champagne. No, but it's it's.
- 30:23It's not, it's not France. It wasn't, no.
- 30:25What matters, it's not from the sort of prestigious cities of
- 30:30Montes or Ipaner and the surrounding areas.
- 30:32It was from the Cote de Bao, which is in the South of
- 30:34Champaign, which is quite far removed geographically, both
- 30:38soil wise and distance wise from the sort of more prestigious
- 30:42areas that people know the big houses from.
- 30:45And in the last, I'd say 10 to 15 years, but especially 10
- 30:49years, I think there's been a huge sort of the word in French
- 30:54is en goumen. But like a huge excitement over
- 30:57the champagne houses, usually younger domain or older domain
- 31:02that have been taken on by a, by a new generation and sort of
- 31:04revamped and, and a lot of them working biodynamically,
- 31:08organically or with, you know, very sort of artisanal methods.
- 31:11And what's interesting is, is that for years the big
- 31:15prestigious houses have been buying grapes from those areas
- 31:18all along. But because Champagne is, you
- 31:22know, traditionally a grape buying area, it's not
- 31:25necessarily been a grower producer area.
- 31:28You know, the big houses buy grapes from all over the the
- 31:30region. And so it's, you know, nothing's
- 31:35really changed. It's just that the notoriety has
- 31:37well, they. They they deserved it after all
- 31:40this time, I mean. Yeah, they're they're, you know,
- 31:43their grapes are worth more now and they're and they're growing
- 31:45their grapes and making wine themselves instead of
- 31:47necessarily selling everything off.
- 31:48And it's it's exciting. You know, those small producers
- 31:50are grower producers are now becoming an established reality
- 31:54in Champagne. And that's really important
- 31:58because, you know, I really appreciate big House Champagne
- 32:05in that it, it's just such a special, celebratory, wonderful,
- 32:11you know, meaningful thing for so many people, especially in
- 32:14France. You know, that's something I've
- 32:15learned. French families have like a
- 32:17champagne brand that they will have adhered to for generations
- 32:22in their family. And they'll be like, this is the
- 32:24champagne that my grandfather would open when we would
- 32:26celebrate Christmas, or this is what, you know, we would drink
- 32:28at baptisms or christenings or, you know, bar mitzvahs or
- 32:31whatever. And, and I think that there's,
- 32:37there's something really important about that because it
- 32:39is, it's part of that established importance of wine
- 32:43and French culture that totally surpasses the notion of a drink
- 32:49or a beverage. It's about much more than that.
- 32:52And I think Champagne is very much about that.
- 32:55It's, it's about the experience and the memories and, and the
- 32:58generational meaning of a brand. And so the brands matter, but
- 33:03the grower producers are also really important because, you
- 33:06know, whereas brands tends to invest a very significant amount
- 33:10of their, you know, income in marketing, the grower producers,
- 33:15you know, 100 or 99% of what they're earning is going into
- 33:19the bottle. So I just think quality wise,
- 33:22there's something really, you know, worth worth discovering in
- 33:26that regard. So is that sort of your your
- 33:30main criteria for or among the criteria you you consider when
- 33:35you're choosing even from other regions?
- 33:37You're sort of looking for a mix of, you know, super established
- 33:42that maybe some diners would recognize if they see it on the
- 33:44menu, but also a whole host of more small batch or small
- 33:50producer. I don't usually work with super
- 33:55established wineries because in the in the sense like of, you
- 34:04know, maybe higher volume or industrial practice wineries,
- 34:08including house champagnes for that very reason.
- 34:11Because I just think that they're really, really well
- 34:14represented in a lot of fine dining restaurants and have been
- 34:17for many years. And I think that what excites me
- 34:20is the notion of discovery or tasting something without that
- 34:25sort of veil of a brand recognition element to it.
- 34:31I really enjoy the tasting with your like heart and with your
- 34:35palate and saying like, I'm enjoying the flavour of this for
- 34:38itself. And not because somebody told me
- 34:40that it's cool or I've seen it here.
- 34:41You know, of course there are people, especially French locals
- 34:44who will come and say, like, oh, well, you know, I always drink
- 34:47Tetanje or I always drink Filibonar.
- 34:49I always drink this. And, and, and I have a huge
- 34:52appreciation for a lot of these champagnes.
- 34:54As a sommelier, I'm totally democratic and open to tasting
- 34:58everything and appreciating it, appreciating everything in a
- 35:01case by case basis. I don't have a dogmatic approach
- 35:03to wine at all. I've never believed in doing
- 35:05that. I'm Canadian.
- 35:07It's just not my thing. I really believe in sort of
- 35:12forgetting about categories and just tasting case by case.
- 35:15And I don't care about looking cool or not because I have a
- 35:18certain name on my wine list or not.
- 35:19I, I, I feel like that's one of the liberties of having my own
- 35:24restaurant is that I don't really have to worry about
- 35:27trying to like follow trends or, you know, we just kind of hide
- 35:30in our little, in our little neighborhood in the 16th and we
- 35:33can kind of do our thing and we're not in like a hip area.
- 35:36And I'm totally fine with that and happy with that.
- 35:38And so same thing for the wines. I'm excited about representing,
- 35:43you know, smaller producers. I do my best to do that.
- 35:46I do try to buy from some regions.
- 35:49That tends to be somewhat reassuring for a certain
- 35:52clientele that are looking for a certain drinking experience.
- 35:55We do have an established clientele that enjoys Burgundy,
- 35:58that enjoys their own valley, that enjoys Bordeaux.
- 36:01And what I try to do is I try to pick and choose small family
- 36:05producers who work in a sincere and authentic way within those
- 36:08established regions so that like, I'm kind of killing two
- 36:11birds with one stone. They're happy and I can sleep at
- 36:14night. Well, I hope you're sleeping at
- 36:17night. I mean, given the amount of work
- 36:18you're you're doing, but but also you're choosing in a
- 36:22similar way that people are choosing to come dine with you.
- 36:26Yeah. The you know, the small,
- 36:29considerate, thoughtful family run in many cases or
- 36:33independently run operations and so those go together quite
- 36:39seamlessly. Yeah.
- 36:41I mean, it's, it's, it's also something that I think has
- 36:44gelled for me more than ever. I think, you know, in the
- 36:47beginning, maybe we felt like we had to figure out what our, you
- 36:51know, I was saying earlier that we kind of feel like we've found
- 36:54our footing in certain ways in terms of like the schedule of
- 36:56the team, how we're working. But I think also in terms of our
- 36:59focus and our ethos, I think we've kind of come to a point
- 37:03where we know who we are and, you know, today at least, and
- 37:07who we've been thus far. And we know what interests us
- 37:10and what doesn't. And like, for example, in our
- 37:14cuisine, you know, no, I'm somebody who really likes to do
- 37:18something regularly and well, so of course we work with seasonal
- 37:22products and of course we work with as many local producers as
- 37:25we possibly can. And when I say local, I mean
- 37:28French, not local, like within 5 kilometers.
- 37:31Because you know, obviously there are certain regions that
- 37:34grow certain things that other ones don't.
- 37:36I'm not looking, I'm not looking for sending mountain lemons, you
- 37:38know, but he really loves to perfect a technique over weeks,
- 37:44months and years, you know, like the handmade Talia tale that we
- 37:47make. There's been such a lot of
- 37:51research and tweaking and changing and adjusting and
- 37:54developing and different drying and all these different things
- 37:58that he's, you know, done over the years.
- 38:00And I mean, it's just so interesting to see, like, this
- 38:04concentration of work that like, becomes denser and denser in its
- 38:09sort of quality because there's been so much research behind it
- 38:11over years. So on one hand, there's a
- 38:15certain notion of, like, creativity, obviously, and, you
- 38:19know, inspiration, but also there's something very
- 38:23meaningful to know about working on something for a long time and
- 38:26developing it and deepening it. I think the word is deepening.
- 38:30And so we're not the kind of restaurant that looks to change
- 38:33their menu every single week or, you know, get as many sort of
- 38:39funky ingredients together as we can to be, you know, to make
- 38:44fireworks happen on a superficial level, but not have
- 38:47that depth of work behind it. He's somebody really, you know,
- 38:51likes to methodically work on techniques and develop and, and
- 38:54deepen what he does. And so we'll change the menu,
- 38:57you know, seasonally based on what's available, you know, but
- 39:01we're not going to be like looking to shock and and
- 39:05impress, you know, on a weekly basis and do this and that and
- 39:09change. And, you know, it's just not the
- 39:11way we work. And same with with the wine.
- 39:12I just feel more confident than ever, you know, that what I feel
- 39:17really passionate about, if I can transmit my excitement about
- 39:20it, that that will be the best dining experience in our
- 39:23restaurant. And that may not apply for
- 39:26another sommelier or another context or another restaurant.
- 39:29Maybe it's about the bottom line, or maybe it's about
- 39:31getting the most, you know, fancy brands or the most luxury
- 39:34labels. Or maybe it's about getting the
- 39:37hippest, most natural wines possible.
- 39:39And all of that has its place, and all of that has its benefits
- 39:43and its disadvantages. But I just know.
- 39:45I just know where I'm at. And it's about, you know,
- 39:48getting the maximum amount of pleasure for me and for my
- 39:50guests at the same time. And you've totally succeeded
- 39:54because they still think about the meal that we had.
- 39:56And I think you that tends to be harder to achieve as a as a
- 40:00diner, even where as a restaurant owner, when you are
- 40:03constantly changing and doing what you described as sort of
- 40:05like these superficial fireworks.
- 40:07Because we all know, those of those of you know, those of us
- 40:11who eat at restaurants a lot and have sort of experienced a wide
- 40:15range of styles, knows exactly what that looks like when there
- 40:20are some elements that are done beautifully.
- 40:22And you might remember, but if the food is all about the sort
- 40:25of not posturing but like, you know, trying to impress and flex
- 40:30a certain creative muscle but without that substance.
- 40:34You're going to pedigree or the substance behind.
- 40:36It exactly so. I mean, there are some, there
- 40:39are some chefs who are genuinely like that and they're just like
- 40:42pure creativity and explosive and want to change.
- 40:45But it's more rare than I think people real like.
- 40:49Yeah. Like to admit.
- 40:51I think it really has to come from the heart and it really has
- 40:53to be something that's organic and, and sincere.
- 40:55I, I remember I actually, we won't get into this on a, on a
- 40:58deep level, but I before pivoting into wine for many
- 41:03years, I pursued a career in opera.
- 41:05I wanted to be an opera singer and I worked very hard for 10
- 41:07years to pursue that, which is how I ended up in New York and
- 41:11then switched to wine because kind of hit a wall quickly and
- 41:14effectively. And I remember in in my studies
- 41:19as an opera singer coming across this quote, which I'm going to
- 41:22misquote somehow, but it was David Bowie saying something
- 41:25about how you should never try to anticipate what an audience's
- 41:32preferences or tastes might be. Because if you try to produce
- 41:36according to what you think their expectations are and you
- 41:39fail, then you suffer the worst kind of inward humiliation.
- 41:43Whereas at least if you fail on your own terms and you know that
- 41:47you did what means something to you genuinely, at least you can
- 41:51go to sleep at night knowing that you tried what was really
- 41:54who you are, you know, and I, I really, that has continued to
- 41:58apply, I think in my work and wine and in the restaurant
- 42:02business. I really think that especially
- 42:05living in Paris as a foreigner and especially being in a market
- 42:08where there's so much, you know, there's at any major city, fine
- 42:14fine dining or any dining market tends to have a lot of trends
- 42:19and a lot of things that, you know, gain a lot of hype.
- 42:23And people will come here and they'll be like, oh, I've heard
- 42:26this place, I've heard about this place and I've heard about
- 42:28this place and I have to get in here and this is the hardest
- 42:30reservation to get. And that's all really great.
- 42:36And I think it's also really great to sort of be kind of a
- 42:41little bit outside of that and just focus on the work like on a
- 42:48daily basis. I think I think a lot of those
- 42:50hyped places too don't exactly look for that hype.
- 42:54I mean, there are some, you know, very established reputable
- 42:58restaurants where there are, there's total pedigree and
- 43:01chops. And you know, I think someone
- 43:03lists 15, for example, they didn't, they didn't do their
- 43:06work to garner that attention. They did their work to do their
- 43:08work and they continue to do that.
- 43:09And it just so happens that that comes with that attention.
- 43:12And I have so much respect for, for those restaurants who
- 43:16continue to put their head down and work and create employment
- 43:19and take care of their, you know, employees and create
- 43:24livelihoods for people and, and create an environment that is
- 43:28long lasting and enduring. I, I think that that's like the
- 43:31ultimate dream is to create something that, you know, has
- 43:34positive repercussions on many social levels.
- 43:38And I, I think that's what a restaurant is.
- 43:40I mean, ultimately it comes from, you know, whether you're
- 43:43trying to do your best to support your suppliers and do
- 43:47your best to support your staff and do your best to to support
- 43:50your guests and create an experience that is commensurate
- 43:52with their expectations. Because it's kind of a big deal
- 43:54to dine in a restaurant in Paris.
- 43:56You know it's not it's. Not it is.
- 43:58Absolutely. It's a huge budget and it's, you
- 44:02know, whether you have the means to do it or you've saved up an
- 44:07enormous amount of time to be able to do it.
- 44:10We have a responsibility to people to create an experience
- 44:14that that is meaningful. Well, if only every single
- 44:17restaurateur in this city thought the same way, I think it
- 44:21would have a consistently better experience.
- 44:23But I think that's that would be true for any city.
- 44:26Yeah, you said so many thoughtful and, and, and moving
- 44:32things just now and I would, but I and I and I could have ended
- 44:37anywhere. But I, I'd be remiss not to ask
- 44:40the question that I think our listeners are going to be
- 44:42asking, which is also what is the significance of the word
- 44:45komis? Because I feel like that's
- 44:48that's an important element to this story.
- 44:50Yeah, well, so we got the name. Noam came up with it single
- 44:54handedly. We just, we were like
- 44:55struggling. It's like a baby name like this
- 44:57note, this note. And then one morning he was
- 45:00like, what about Komis? I was like, great, what does it
- 45:02mean? And he said, well, what it means
- 45:05is it comes from the Comis Agricole, which are gatherings
- 45:08of farmers and agricultural workers that get together to
- 45:12talk about their techniques and improving their trade.
- 45:15They've existed since the 1800s. They start in the Loire Valley.
- 45:19The root of the word is comitea and Latin, which means
- 45:21gathering. And and so it's sort of an
- 45:25homage to the farmers that we do work with or the wine growers
- 45:30that we do work with. It's it's an to their to their
- 45:33work because their work makes our work possible.
- 45:36And, and, you know, you mentioned something earlier,
- 45:38which was that people sometimes are disconnected from the actual
- 45:42operations of a restaurant. You know, they're not thinking
- 45:45necessarily that the, they might look at the staff, the, you
- 45:49know, the front of house staff differently than they consider
- 45:51the, the people in the kitchen. And I think that would probably
- 45:54apply to, you know, the relationships behind the scenes
- 45:58that they never necessarily see with the producers and the the
- 46:01growers and the delivery people. And, you know, that whole chain.
- 46:06And so I hope that everybody listening now when they come to
- 46:08Paris, whether it's at Comis or where, wherever they go are are
- 46:13going to be thinking about that connection because it really
- 46:16makes all the difference. I think one really important
- 46:19thing to to underline, and I think maybe it's not something
- 46:22that a lot of people talk about, is that those relationships are
- 46:24not always like romantic and fluid.
- 46:27Like it's really challenging, you know, we're a small business
- 46:32who when things are difficult, it's difficult for us.
- 46:35And it's really like, it has repercussions on the supplier
- 46:38side and it has repercussions on hiring and it has repercussions,
- 46:43financial and societal that are very significant.
- 46:46And sometimes we have to make concessions and sometimes we
- 46:49have to make, you know, adjustments.
- 46:51And sometimes we have to, you know, this notion that like,
- 46:54it's just a perfect happy rainbow where it's like, you
- 46:57know, I only work with small producers and I only work with
- 47:00organic products. And I, you know, I am a virtuous
- 47:05restaurateur. I just don't think that's
- 47:06realistic to be, you know, 100% perfectly virtuous.
- 47:10It is an absolute goal, it is an absolute ideal and if as a small
- 47:16family business we could achieve that utopia, I would be so
- 47:20happy. In reality, it's, you know, a a
- 47:24river with many different curbs and we have so much desire to
- 47:33achieve a level of having the most profound relationships on
- 47:40every level of our restaurant. And that is what drives us.
- 47:43And then reality is that we do our very best within that to
- 47:48make it all work and and be in the balance.
- 47:51I don't want to, I don't want to come off as saying like, you
- 47:53know, it, it happens that restaurateurs will be like I am,
- 47:56you know, an environmental St. And, you know, I don't think you
- 48:00can really be one having a restaurant in Paris because
- 48:04fundamentally there's waste and and sure.
- 48:07No, but the idea is that you try to limit that and you're, you
- 48:10know, you're being respectful of the land.
- 48:12And. And you know, certainly if that
- 48:15and if that became a requirement, you know how many
- 48:17places would have to shut their doors 99, right?
- 48:21So no, I mean having having your vision and your drive to do the
- 48:27best that you can do, I think is more than honorable and everyone
- 48:32really should go have at least one meal, one special moment at
- 48:37COMIS. It was it was beautiful and I
- 48:39cannot wait to get back. Well, thank.
- 48:41You this, I'm, I'm going to put it out there on the Internet
- 48:45that maybe for my birthday someone will take me, you know,
- 48:48just a thought, someone who might or might not be listening.
- 48:51But either way, I'm so glad that you are part of this city
- 48:55because it's, you know, dining is so tightly connected to to
- 49:01Paris and this heritage and and you're really part of that story
- 49:04and important to keeping it alive so.
- 49:06Well, thank you, thank you very much for saying so because it,
- 49:09it's, you know, at the end of the day, that's really what we
- 49:12do it for us to make those connections with people and, and
- 49:15you know, people like you who, who have like a real passion and
- 49:18an interest in it and, and are actively professionally and
- 49:21personally engaged in dining in Paris.
- 49:23And it's meaningful to hear from.
- 49:25You but don't think I won't at some point talk to you about
- 49:27that opera blipping your career. So I'll just come to see you and
- 49:32talk about it at at at Comis. I tell you, thank you so much
- 49:36pleasure. That's the show for today.
- 49:40As always, thank you for listening, subscribing and
- 49:43sharing with friends. You can find all previous
- 49:46episodes of the new Paris podcast wherever you stream your
- 49:48podcasts and on World Radio Paris.
- 49:51If you're enjoying these conversations, please consider
- 49:53picking up a copy of the new Paris.
- 49:55Book. For my recent release, The New
- 49:57Poesian.