Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Fair Lending Basics
Transcript
- 0:00Training should be not only for those in the lending department, but managers,
- 0:06anybody who deals with any aspect of lending, but also credit union management
- 0:11and board members, because they have responsibility for policies and procedures
- 0:16and what happens in the credit union.
- 0:19Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:24I hope you enjoy.
- 0:28Do you wanna maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:31Join Mark Trico as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:35your exam with flying colors.
- 0:37The With Flying Colors Podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:40Exam Solutions by Mark Trico.
- 0:42If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions team and
- 0:46receive support to optimize your results with NCUA, so you save time and money,
- 0:51visit us@marktrico.com to find out more.
- 1:00Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal.
- 1:02Thank you for joining me for this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:07I'm excited today that I am joined by Joe Goldberg, a member of my team and the
- 1:12team here at Credit Union Exam Solutions.
- 1:15Joe, welcome.
- 1:16Hi, Mark.
- 1:17Thanks for having me.
- 1:18You bet.
- 1:18My pleasure.
- 1:19So, Joe, for people who aren't familiar with what you did at NCUA and perhaps
- 1:25before NCUA as it relates to credit unions, why don't you share that with us?
- 1:29The real short version is I graduated from law school in 1980, practiced
- 1:34law in a lot of different ways, doing different things for a long time.
- 1:38Among those, I was in the Pennsylvania Attorney General's Office, Bureau of
- 1:43Consumer Protection for almost 7 years.
- 1:45Where I kind of took a deep dive into consumer protection matters.
- 1:50I came out, among other things, I taught consumer law as an adjunct professor,
- 1:55and eventually in early 2014, I joined NCUA in the, what was then the Office of
- 2:02Consumer Protection in the Division of Consumer Compliance Policy and Outreach.
- 2:07After a couple of years, I became the director of the division and stayed
- 2:11there doing consumer compliance work, including fair lending work.
- 2:15Until I retired in December of 2021.
- 2:18Very good.
- 2:18You're joining a big cast of care who've left NCA recently.
- 2:22A lot of people hit that point in time where it's time to do something else.
- 2:26And I'm glad that you're out here now assisting credit unions more directly.
- 2:30So today we're going to talk a little bit about fair lending and a fair
- 2:35lending one on one, if you will.
- 2:36So.
- 2:37So, NCOA has a lot of examiners that do exams, and then there's a structure
- 2:42about fair lending exams and things like that, and that was housed in your
- 2:47office, but before we kind of get into that, let's just start with, when someone
- 2:51says fair lending, what does that mean?
- 2:53There's no formal definition of fair lending, but in essence, it's
- 2:57a system that requires Decisions on applications for credit to be based
- 3:02solely on credit related factors, not on factors that are unrelated to
- 3:06creditworthiness and are discriminatory.
- 3:09So fair lending is usually looked at by what is prohibited
- 3:13rather than what is required.
- 3:14There's an example on HUD's website, HUD's Department of
- 3:18Housing and Urban Development, which oversees the Fair Housing Act.
- 3:22Here's what it says on its website for consumers.
- 3:25What is fair lending?
- 3:26Fair lending prohibits lenders from considering your race, color, national
- 3:31origin, religion, sex, familial status, or disability when applying
- 3:37for residential mortgage loans.
- 3:40Fair lending guarantees the same lending opportunities to everyone.
- 3:45We'll see also that in addition to that, that fair lending is designed
- 3:49to enhance the availability of credit.
- 3:51As I mentioned, I had been an adjunct law professor and when I would teach
- 3:55different laws and regulations, I'd always like to see why were the laws created?
- 4:00What's the purpose of the laws?
- 4:01And fair lending is one of those subjects where that's generally
- 4:05contained right in the laws themselves.
- 4:07There's language in them that says why Congress passed the law.
- 4:11For example, the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, which is probably
- 4:15the main fair lending law, says this right in the statute itself.
- 4:20The Congress finds that there is a need to ensure that the various
- 4:24financial institutions and other firms engaged in the extensions of credit.
- 4:29exercise their responsibility to make credit available with fairness,
- 4:34impartiality, and without discrimination on the basis of sex or marital status.
- 4:40Now, as an aside, the original ECOA only covered those two prohibited
- 4:44bases, sex or marital status.
- 4:46But then Congress went on to say a little bit more.
- 4:49It says economic stabilization would be enhanced and competition among
- 4:53various financial institutions and other firms engaged in the extension
- 4:58of credit would be strengthened by an absence of discrimination on the basis
- 5:04of sex or marital status, as well as by informed use of credit, which Congress
- 5:10has heretofore sought to promote.
- 5:12In the Fair Housing Act, there is language that says this.
- 5:15It is the policy of the United States to provide within constitutional
- 5:20limitations for fair housing throughout the United States.
- 5:25And then in HMDA, the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act, this
- 5:28is a statement of findings.
- 5:31The Congress finds that some depository institutions have sometimes contributed
- 5:36to the decline of certain geographic areas by their failure pursuant to
- 5:41their chartering responsibilities.
- 5:43To provide adequate home financing to qualified applicants on
- 5:47reasonable terms and conditions.
- 5:50That's kind of a direct reference to redlining, which I'll talk
- 5:54about a little bit later.
- 5:55And then it talks about the purpose of the chapter, which is to provide
- 5:59data and other information to those who are interested in making
- 6:03sure that housing financing is extended on a remuneratory basis.
- 6:08Just one quote I like, it's from President Lyndon Johnson, when he proposed the Fair
- 6:12Housing Act, it was part of the Civil Rights Act of 1968, which was I think
- 6:17the second one, the first one was in 64.
- 6:20But he said this, I am proposing fair housing legislation again this
- 6:24year, because it is decent and right.
- 6:27Injustice must be opposed, however difficult or unpopular the issue.
- 6:32So that's sort of the long answer to your question.
- 6:34What is there?
- 6:35There's a lot of meat there.
- 6:36Let's unpack it a little bit in a second.
- 6:38I'm going to ask you why this is important.
- 6:40But before I get to that, that quote is great.
- 6:43I love quotes and the finding of Congress, when you highlighted that on redlining.
- 6:49As you're reading through and discussing all of these things,
- 6:52I'm thinking, okay, that is why N.
- 6:54C.
- 6:55U.
- 6:55A.
- 6:55has the office that you worked for.
- 6:57That is why N.
- 6:58C.
- 6:58U.
- 6:58A.
- 6:59goes out and does.
- 7:00A certain number of fair lending examinations.
- 7:03I want to say somewhere between 25 and 30.
- 7:05We can get into a little bit of that and how those things work.
- 7:08But before we dive into what this means for credit unions specifically, and
- 7:12how it works with NCA, explain a little bit why these laws are so important.
- 7:18There's two reasons.
- 7:19One is what I just described, which is that the right thing to do is to
- 7:23prevent injustice, but it's also because for those of you listeners who are
- 7:28responsible for consumer compliance.
- 7:31Involved in lending consumer lending, especially, you need to know what
- 7:35the law is, because it can affect the viability of the credit union.
- 7:39So, the laws and these regulations that I'm going to discuss that are fair
- 7:44lending related, they tie into some very important credit related concepts.
- 7:49We're not talking just about mortgage lending here, because the fair
- 7:52lending laws also apply to other types of credits, such as auto lending,
- 7:56credit cards, and personal loans.
- 7:59They're pretty wide ranging.
- 8:01So some of the policy issues that consider when you talk about fair lending are,
- 8:06number one, the availability of credit, which ties into financial inclusion.
- 8:11Not just a credit union issue.
- 8:13That's kind of a social issue, as we've learned, especially in the last few years,
- 8:16that it affects equality in credit terms.
- 8:20It tries to ensure that, as I mentioned earlier, as a law state,
- 8:24that credit is extended solely based on credit related factors and no other
- 8:30aspects that aren't credit related.
- 8:33And then I talked about redlining and you had mentioned it, Mark.
- 8:36Just so you know, this sounds like it's ancient history, but unfortunately,
- 8:41there still are issues with redlining, and it's really important for
- 8:44credit unions to know about this.
- 8:46And I'll talk about that in a second.
- 8:47But redlining, just a little refresher, is a method of excluding properties
- 8:52in a specific geographic area from eligibility for mortgage loans.
- 8:57It can also be affected by who the borrower is.
- 9:01There are racial implications in borrowers were African American, they would be at a
- 9:06disadvantage and it was used to actually perpetuate segregation and deny African
- 9:13Americans the ability to improve their financial standing and achieve wealth.
- 9:18Through home ownership, the way that non African Americans could, and
- 9:23unfortunately, this was actually a government policy, federal housing
- 9:26administration no longer exists in the way it was originally,
- 9:31but had an underwriting manual.
- 9:33There was a quote from that underwriting manual that says that incompatible
- 9:38racial groups should not be permitted to live within the same communities.
- 9:43And this is an official US policy.
- 9:45The Federal Housing Administration used color coded maps, and in those maps, the
- 9:52red zones were considered to be hazardous, and generally, communities which were
- 9:57predominantly African American were in those red zones or were those red zones.
- 10:02There are instances where the manual required walls to be
- 10:05built between neighborhoods.
- 10:08And obviously this is no longer official government policy, but
- 10:12there are remnants of this that affect predominantly people of color
- 10:17and the values of their properties.
- 10:20Generally, credit unions have a different analysis of their lending when determining
- 10:26whether they're involved in redlining.
- 10:29And there are some people say that credit unions cannot redline because of the
- 10:32field of membership issue that forms a basis of their customer base, the members.
- 10:39But let me just throw this out at you because it's a real life example.
- 10:43A credit union that is chartered to allow as members, people who live or work
- 10:50within a specific specified metropolitan area and the surrounding counties.
- 10:57And this particular credit union does not have any branches
- 11:01in the metropolitan area.
- 11:03It's a major metropolitan area.
- 11:05And the majority, I should say the largest number of majority minority
- 11:10neighborhoods are in that metropolitan area, as opposed to surrounding areas.
- 11:14So the question can be asked if the credit union does not have a physical
- 11:19presence where the minority applicants are, or most of them, can it redline?
- 11:25I'm not going to answer the question, because there's a lot of factors that
- 11:28go into it, but I'm just throwing it out there because it's not a simple yes or no.
- 11:34Pause there for one second.
- 11:35So when someone expands into a community that in part would explain by why NCUA
- 11:40requires them to establish a presence or define when they're going to establish
- 11:45a present as part of their business plan, because obviously, if you're
- 11:49expanding to include an area, you should provide service to that area.
- 11:53And you can get into the whole concept of most or a lot of
- 11:57banking happens on phones.
- 11:58Well, there are a Areas and there are people who need to have branches
- 12:03in order to conduct business.
- 12:04I guess even I said another way, a lack of action to have a branch somewhere
- 12:09could be perceived as a violation.
- 12:11Is that an overstatement or is that actually something
- 12:14that you would agree with?
- 12:15I would agree with that.
- 12:16Yeah, I think you touched on something.
- 12:18Obviously the world is changing and the way that people interact with
- 12:21financial institutions is changing, but I think the credit union system
- 12:25has grown up on being community based.
- 12:29You know, that without being physically present, that can have an effect
- 12:33on how your lending is dispersed.
- 12:36Yeah.
- 12:36Who you can serve.
- 12:37It was sad to hear what policies were in government as recently as the 1950s.
- 12:43And I think if I heard you right, you said they had actually defined red zones.
- 12:47And I'm, am I right to assume that it was those red zones that may
- 12:52have led to the phrase redlining?
- 12:54Yes, absolutely.
- 12:55Okay.
- 12:56Got it.
- 12:56There's other issues too, which have come to light recently.
- 13:00There's a presidential initiative around appraisal bias and ways
- 13:05to counteract appraisal bias.
- 13:07Unfortunately, and this is tied into the redlining because whole
- 13:11neighborhoods may be subject to Appraisals that lower property
- 13:16values and they're self perpetuating actually has a regulation regarding
- 13:22appraisal accuracy and it imposes obligations on credit unions to make
- 13:26sure that appraisers that they use are providing appraisals that are based on.
- 13:31non discriminatory matters or factors.
- 13:34But anyways, the reason I mention all this is, again, it sounds like ancient history
- 13:39to some extent, but it really is not.
- 13:41It's something that it's important to guard against.
- 13:44Another reason why all this is important is because non compliance
- 13:48creates risks to credit unions.
- 13:50You can set aside all those policy issues, but all these laws and regulations
- 13:55I'm going to talk about generally have some type of enforcement provision
- 14:01for regulators, including the NCUA, but also they provide for private
- 14:06actions, including class actions.
- 14:08So, there's all several different types of risk are implicated with or for
- 14:14non compliance with fair lending laws.
- 14:16very much.
- 14:16So, I'm a credit union.
- 14:18I'm doing every type of loan that you can imagine.
- 14:21I'm a community charter credit union.
- 14:23I've never had any issues with the normal exams, but NCUA has the authority to come
- 14:30in and do a specific fair lending exam.
- 14:32And that was the group that you were in charge of at NCUA.
- 14:36And there are some authorities that NCUA has.
- 14:39There's some authorities, I believe you said that DOJ has, and then
- 14:43Housing and Urban Development or HUD.
- 14:45Am I interpreting all that right?
- 14:46And then along those lines, if you were running a credit union, and
- 14:51you were wanting to be ahead of the curve on NCOA coming in and poking
- 14:56around and taking a look at this whole arena, what would you do if you were
- 15:01out there running a credit union?
- 15:02Well, if we can wait for a few minutes, I got it.
- 15:05I want to talk about, I want to talk about that after I talked about the laws
- 15:09because it'll detail nicely into it.
- 15:11But yeah, there are things that the credit union should focus on
- 15:14and can do to help protect itself.
- 15:16So, let's talk about the laws and regulations that are involved with this.
- 15:20As I mentioned before, the main one is the Equal Credit Opportunity Act.
- 15:24It's a federal law.
- 15:26ECOA is the acronym for those who are familiar with acronyms.
- 15:30And the Equal Credit Opportunity Act prohibits discrimination in
- 15:34any aspect of a credit transaction.
- 15:37And it applies to a wide variety of extensions of credit, including extensions
- 15:44of credit to small businesses, And also the corporations, partnerships
- 15:48and trusts under certain circumstances.
- 15:50So there are two major requirements in ECOA.
- 15:54The first is that it expressly prohibits discrimination in any
- 15:58aspect of a credit transaction based on a list of prohibited bases.
- 16:04And these are race or color.
- 16:08And this terminology is from ECOA.
- 16:10Race or color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status, age, and that's
- 16:17provided the applicant has the capacity to enter into contracts generally 18.
- 16:23The applicant's receipt of income be derived on from any
- 16:27public assistance program and the applicant's exercise in good faith.
- 16:33Of any right under the Consumer Credit Protection Act, that's to
- 16:37prevent retaliation for an applicant who has asserted certain rights.
- 16:42That's the first major requirement of a COA.
- 16:45This podcast is too short to go into all the excruciating details.
- 16:49But I do want to at least mention that that's the basis for it.
- 16:53The 2nd, major requirement is that a creditor.
- 16:57Must provide applicants with the reason for any adverse action and
- 17:02what adverse action means is a denial of credit that was applied for, or
- 17:07a denial of credit under the terms.
- 17:10Applied for so if an applicant applies for a mortgage that's advertised
- 17:14at a certain rate, some type of term and the creditor counters and
- 17:19says, you don't qualify for that.
- 17:21But here is a less favorable set of terms that you qualify for.
- 17:25Not necessarily discrimination, but this must be disclosed to the applicant, the
- 17:31adverse action notices, the colloquial term for the disclosure of information.
- 17:36I just want to mention that the Dodd Frank Act created a new section in ECOA.
- 17:43And that requires the collection of data from applications
- 17:48for small business credit.
- 17:50And in fact, CFPB has issued a proposed rule about what data would be collected
- 17:55and how it would be collected.
- 17:57But nothing's going to happen until that becomes a final regulation.
- 18:00But I did just want to mention that.
- 18:01And as you raised Mark, ECOA does provide for enforcement by regulators and it
- 18:09provides the right to bring private lawsuits, including class actions.
- 18:13Generally, the N.
- 18:15C.
- 18:15U.
- 18:15A.
- 18:16is the enforcement agency for federal credit unions.
- 18:20And the states or the Federal Trade Commission were named as the enforcement
- 18:26agency for state charter credit unions.
- 18:29Most of you probably know that the CFPB is responsible for enforcement of the
- 18:33larger financial institutions, those with over 10 billion dollars in assets.
- 18:37I don't want to get into that, but generally speaking for federal
- 18:41credit unions, the NCUA is the primary enforcement agency.
- 18:44And one other thing that you mentioned, the Department of Justice.
- 18:48It has certain enforcement authority, but the equal credit opportunity act requires.
- 18:55The regulators, including the excuse me to refer to any financial institution.
- 19:02It regulates.
- 19:03Where it uncovers a pattern or practice of discrimination, that's a requirement.
- 19:09It's not discretionary.
- 19:10Right.
- 19:11So then when that happens during a fair lending exam at NCOA where
- 19:15you've determined that that's happened, NCOA must refer to DOJ.
- 19:20Correct.
- 19:21One other thing before we go on.
- 19:22So ECOA establishes, as you stated, expressly prohibits discrimination
- 19:27based on race or color, religion, national origin, and the other
- 19:30items that you went through.
- 19:32When I think back to my examiner days, a phrase someone once said is,
- 19:36you can discriminate based on income.
- 19:39And that's where you get the debt ratios.
- 19:41And that's where you get the ability to repay and things like that.
- 19:44The list of the things that ECOA protects people from being
- 19:49discriminated against, it makes sense.
- 19:51When you look at them, you want to treat people fairly in all of these areas.
- 19:54Do you have any comments relative to the statement?
- 19:56You can discriminate based on income.
- 19:58First of all, you have to determine whether or not it's discrimination, quote,
- 20:02I mean, this gets into a legal analysis.
- 20:04If it's not listed, then is it really discrimination?
- 20:07I agree with you.
- 20:08You obviously can use credit related factors and making that credit
- 20:13determination and income is one.
- 20:16It's used all the time.
- 20:17What I should mention is there are essentially two different
- 20:19types of discrimination.
- 20:21Disparate treatment, which is where you would provide all people with a certain
- 20:27prohibited, within a certain prohibited basis, you treat them differently.
- 20:32And age is one that is probably most common.
- 20:35You're not supposed to discriminate based on age.
- 20:38When I was at NCUA, my people found a number of credit unions
- 20:41who had different age thresholds.
- 20:45For certain types of credit or terms or how they were evaluated
- 20:48and that is disparate treatment.
- 20:52Let's pause there.
- 20:53So let's use me as an example.
- 20:55I'm not quite this age, but let's say I was 65 and I'm still working
- 21:01and I want to get a 30 year mortgage.
- 21:03You might have policies that were written theoretically that.
- 21:09Might have given better opportunities to someone a little younger with the
- 21:13theory that a 30 year loan for a 65 year old like me isn't necessarily a
- 21:18risk, but they're also presupposing that I'm not going to work till 75, 85.
- 21:24Am I in the right arena of what you're thinking there?
- 21:27It gets a little dicey when you start talking about that.
- 21:30There are some exceptions, if you will, when you're dealing with the adequacy
- 21:34of collateral and those types of things.
- 21:37But generally speaking, that would be discrimination depending
- 21:40on how things are worded.
- 21:42I should also mention that ECOA does permit creditor to treat older people
- 21:47differently if there is a benefit to them in the way they're treated.
- 21:51But that's a different issue.
- 21:52So a credit union could have no ill will, could have no intent, but just by having
- 21:57worded things in a certain way, could be creating a situation where there's
- 22:01discrimination, even though all their intent is good, they just chose to write
- 22:06the policy in a way that if you step back and looked at it, could be discrimination.
- 22:11You're exactly right.
- 22:12Intent is not an element of violating ECOA.
- 22:15To complete the thought, the second type of discrimination is what's called
- 22:19disparate impact, where on its face the rule treats everybody the same,
- 22:25but the result is that some group in one of these prohibited bases ends
- 22:30up on the short end of the lending.
- 22:33They get overwhelming majority, get credit under different terms.
- 22:36And then the question is whether there was any kind of business
- 22:39justification for what was happening.
- 22:42It's to eliminate discrimination that is not overt, but occurs because
- 22:50the terms or the conditions for the extension of the credit are done
- 22:54in such a way that they improperly affect the people in that group.
- 22:59Let me give you an analogy from the concepts of disparate treatment and
- 23:03disparate impact, stepping aside from fair lending, and I'll give you an
- 23:06analogy where I'm going to try and build in what you referred to as the
- 23:10business purpose from some things that I learned in my previous life at NCUA.
- 23:15So, the research I did relative to disparate treatment and disparate impact.
- 23:20Gave an example of being a fireman and if a fire department could establish
- 23:27that fireman, but or fire woman using the fireman as covering everybody
- 23:32needed to have the ability to carry.
- 23:3630 pounds of equipment, 60 pounds, pick a number, a reasonable number that they
- 23:42had to carry that up X number of flights of stairs, because odds are that's what
- 23:47that person is going to have to do at some juncture that would establish the business
- 23:52purpose for having that requirement.
- 23:54And on average, a male fireman.
- 23:57Theoretically is going to have a better and easier ability to carry that weight,
- 24:02perhaps, but that if it is set up in a sound fashion, that is a business purpose
- 24:08where you might have disparate impact where people succeeding that test to
- 24:12get into the door to be a fire person.
- 24:14That could create disparate impact, but it would not necessarily mean
- 24:18that it was disparate treatment.
- 24:20Is that a corollary to what we're talking about here in Fair Lending?
- 24:24Yeah, I think it's analogous.
- 24:25There's some deeper analysis that would probably have to be done in a Fair
- 24:29Lending context, but yeah, but that's essentially a good way to explain it.
- 24:32The threshold and the burden of proof might be higher in Fair Lending.
- 24:36Probably, yeah.
- 24:37Very good.
- 24:37Back to where you were.
- 24:38Okay.
- 24:39I should have mentioned that ECOA was implemented by Regulation B.
- 24:43That's a boy.
- 24:44So you're looking for the regulation that contains more details.
- 24:48It's Regulation B.
- 24:50Now, the second law is the Fair Housing Act.
- 24:53As I mentioned a little bit before, and in conjunction with Lyndon Johnson, and
- 24:57that prohibits discrimination in all aspects of residential real estate related
- 25:02transactions, and that includes loans for buying, building, repairing, or improving
- 25:08a dwelling, purchasing real estate loans.
- 25:12Selling, brokering, or appraising residential real estate,
- 25:15unselling, or renting a dwelling.
- 25:17And the Fair Housing Act also has a list of prohibited bases,
- 25:23but it's different than E.
- 25:24Coli, it's shorter.
- 25:25It's only race or color, national origin, religion, sex, menial status.
- 25:33And handicap, but you should keep in mind that ECOA also applies
- 25:39to mortgage related transactions.
- 25:42So, even though a transaction might not fall under the Fair Housing
- 25:48Act, it could still fall under ECOA.
- 25:50So, just something to keep in mind, and the regulations for the Fair Housing Act
- 25:56are promulgated by HUD, and it's enforced by HUD and the Department of Justice,
- 26:02and it also allows for private actions.
- 26:05And then the third major law that relates to fair lending is, as I mentioned before,
- 26:12HMDA, the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act.
- 26:14That requires financial institutions and that includes credit unions to compile and
- 26:20disclose data about home purchase loans, home improvement loans, and refinancings.
- 26:26They originate or purchase or for which they receive applications.
- 26:30So it doesn't have to be account summated transactions relating to applications.
- 26:34And the purpose of HMDA is to provide the public with data that can be
- 26:39used to help determine whether credit unions are serving the
- 26:42housing needs of their communities.
- 26:44We're all creditors, not just credit unions, but also it's to assist
- 26:49public officials in distributing public sector investments.
- 26:53So, as to attract private investment to areas where it is needed.
- 26:57And also to assist in identifying possible discriminatory lending patterns.
- 27:04And enforcing compliance with anti discrimination statutes.
- 27:08It covers, depends on certain thresholds being met in terms of lending activity.
- 27:13Again, there's way too much detail on HMDA to cover it here.
- 27:17Probably be a good subject for another session.
- 27:19And finally, HMDA is implemented by Regulation C, as in CAT.
- 27:24Originally, it was a Federal Reserve Board regulation.
- 27:27It's now a CFPB regulation.
- 27:30And just let me just mention a couple of other laws and
- 27:32regulations that are important.
- 27:34I did mention the NCOA non discrimination regulation earlier, but actually I
- 27:39mentioned the appraisal regulation.
- 27:41The non discrimination regulation prohibits discrimination in real estate
- 27:45lending and in real estate appraisals and advertising by federal credit unions.
- 27:50I also want to mention.
- 27:52Two other laws, which are sort of lumped together with fair lending laws, even
- 27:57though technically they are not one is the service members civil relief act or
- 28:02and the other is the military lending act.
- 28:05The service members civil relief act applies to certain
- 28:09transactions generally entered into before the onset of active duty.
- 28:15The Military Lending Act applies to certain transactions that are
- 28:20entered into by active duty service members or their dependents.
- 28:25And although I did say a second ago that they are technically not fair
- 28:29lending laws or regulations, that's sort of not true in some states.
- 28:34Because there are some states that actually have anti discrimination laws.
- 28:40That include a prohibition against discrimination on
- 28:44someone based on military status.
- 28:47So, you could have lending to service members be a fair
- 28:52lending matter in certain states.
- 28:54And I'm going to talk about that in a minute when I talk about what the credit
- 28:57unions need to do to protect themselves.
- 29:00Let's kind of jump into that.
- 29:01That's where I was going straight for that about 15 minutes back.
- 29:05And now we're about to get to that.
- 29:06So if you were out running a credit union, what would your focus be?
- 29:11And how would you do your best efforts to protect members and
- 29:15to protect the credit union?
- 29:17Sure.
- 29:17All right.
- 29:18Well, the very first thing is whoever's going to be in charge of consumer
- 29:21compliance or fair lending would know the law and to be an expert in
- 29:27the law, but they need to read it.
- 29:29And the regulations so that they understand that if something
- 29:32happens, a light bulb will go off.
- 29:34Ah, I think I remember there's something in the Fair Lending Act or in HMDA.
- 29:39I better go look at it to see.
- 29:41So, knowing the law is very important.
- 29:43And that ties in to the second thing, which is That the credit union should have
- 29:48a robust compliance management system.
- 29:52The consumer compliance management system is important because that affects
- 29:57those transactions dealing with members.
- 30:00There is no requirement that the CMS has separate policies
- 30:06and procedures for fair lending.
- 30:08When I was at NCUA, we recommended that credit unions do.
- 30:13Because Of the significance of fair lending, what it means to credit
- 30:18unions members, you're better served and the members will be better served.
- 30:23It's a separate fair lending policy so that those in the credit union
- 30:28who deal with fair lending are very clear about their obligations.
- 30:34Part of a robust CMS is adequate training.
- 30:37Training should be not only for those in the lending department, but managers,
- 30:44anybody who deals with any aspect of lending, but also credit union management
- 30:49and board members, because they have responsibility for policies and procedures
- 30:54and what happens in the credit union.
- 30:56There has to be adequate oversight within the credit union.
- 31:01Over the lending practices, so that if there is issues with fair lending,
- 31:06management will be able to see them.
- 31:08And finally, the last thing is oversight over third parties
- 31:12that the credit union deals with.
- 31:14Indirect lenders who the credit union has relationships with, especially
- 31:19car dealers, because auto financing is troublesome, can be troublesome
- 31:23on several different levels.
- 31:25But also vendors, the people who are creating the systems that the credit
- 31:29union is using for lending purposes, you need to have an understanding
- 31:34of generally how they work.
- 31:35You don't have to know how the programming works or the code.
- 31:38Yeah, you do have to have some understanding about that.
- 31:41A lot of great ideas as you walk through those, I can highlight that you and I
- 31:44might need to do some separate podcasts on several or all of those specific
- 31:48categories from knowing the law to CMS, to training, that's something
- 31:52I'm looking forward to maybe doing a deeper dive on sometime in the future.
- 31:55That would be helpful.
- 31:56I think you're right.
- 31:57All right.
- 31:58I've got just two other points when I do want to talk about NCUA's fair lending
- 32:03program that you mentioned before earlier, Mark, the Office of Consumer Financial
- 32:08Protection and actually the division that I was head of the Division of Consumer
- 32:12Compliance Policy and Outreach runs the fair lending program in the NCUA.
- 32:17There are dedicated examiners to conduct the full fair lending exams.
- 32:23There had been 30 a year, the board approved the hiring of a
- 32:27couple of additional fair lending.
- 32:31Personnel for this year, so that number is probably going to increase
- 32:35and in addition to those full blown fair lending examinations.
- 32:39There are also what are known as supervision contacts prior to those
- 32:44were considered to be off site as opposed to the onsite examinations.
- 32:48But they are a little bit more targeted, they're not as lengthy, and they are often
- 32:56based on analyses of the HMDA data that we talked about a little bit earlier.
- 33:01In addition to those dedicated fair lending exams and supervision contacts,
- 33:07pretty much every year, field examiners who are doing the general exams of
- 33:12credit unions are also looking at several consumer compliance areas.
- 33:18And generally each year there are some fair lending aspects to those targeted
- 33:23review areas for 2022 in the NCUA supervisory priorities letter, it says
- 33:29that examiners will identify fair lending policies and practices that indicate
- 33:34discrimination risk or loan portfolio and underwriting discrimination risk.
- 33:39In addition, examiners will assess whether a credit union has policies and procedures
- 33:44to evaluate the consistency, fairness, and accuracy of the appraisals it obtains.
- 33:50So that's sort of general description of the targeted fair lending
- 33:53reviews at all exams this year.
- 33:55That's a great summary.
- 33:56Let me kind of paraphrase.
- 33:58Correct me if I misstate anything.
- 34:00So the, the standard exam that credit unions are used to seeing.
- 34:05Generally speaking, the priority letter that you referred to are the topics that
- 34:10those examiners may have some discussions with the credit union during the contact.
- 34:14And then within the office that you worked at, there's the fair lending exams.
- 34:19And the supervision contacts, and it sounded like the supervision
- 34:23contacts, if I heard right, could come from looking at data.
- 34:27So at there's some analysis of the data that may trigger a supervision
- 34:33contact, which is more of a, maybe a rightful approach of a contact.
- 34:37And then there's the full fair lending exams, and am I right or wrong to
- 34:41assume that those fair lending exams, that might be where it's a random
- 34:45sample where NCUA comes up with who won the lottery and who's going to
- 34:49get a fair lending exam, that would be more of a random sample that wouldn't
- 34:52necessarily been driven by any data.
- 34:55It depends.
- 34:56Each year, the agency would look at anything that field examiners
- 35:01may have found when they were in during the previous year.
- 35:04Occasionally, we'll get information from whistleblowers.
- 35:08There is information that was obtained from other either
- 35:12states or other federal agencies.
- 35:14It wasn't totally random.
- 35:16In addition to, excuse me, and there could have been information
- 35:20that was obtained during the supervision contact in a prior year.
- 35:23So some of those fair lending examinations are based on information
- 35:29obtained that indicated there could be a fair lending problem.
- 35:34In addition, there was a desire to look at some of the larger credit unions
- 35:40and possibly some of the smaller ones.
- 35:43So it was not quite random for those who weren't there because
- 35:48there was some information obtained, but to some extent, yes.
- 35:52Okay, got it.
- 35:53So, Joe, if someone was wondering what the best resources out there on the
- 35:58World Wide Web for wanting to study this area, enhance their operations in this
- 36:05area, where would you refer them to?
- 36:07The first thing I would look at if you're federally insured credit union
- 36:11would probably be the NCOA Fair Lending Guide, which is on the NCOA's website.
- 36:16And there is also what's called the NCOA Federal Consumer
- 36:21Financial Protection Guide.
- 36:23That guide contains pretty much all of the interagency
- 36:27approved Examination procedures.
- 36:31So those 2 resources will help.
- 36:33I can tell you that the NCUA Fair Lending Guide was undergoing updating
- 36:38and some revisions at the time that I retired at the end of last year.
- 36:42So, at some point, there will be a new version of that, but
- 36:46those 2 things are very helpful.
- 36:48The FFIEC, Federal Financial Institution Examination Council, which is a group
- 36:50of the federal regulators, and the FFIEC, Federal Financial Institution
- 36:53Examination Council, which is a group of the federal regulators.
- 36:56is responsible for collecting hum the data.
- 37:00There are a number of hum the resources on the FFIEC.
- 37:05gov website.
- 37:07And then the CFPB, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has
- 37:13a lot of both fair lending and hum the resources on its website.
- 37:18And finally, for those of you who receive the The NCUA regulatory
- 37:23alerts and letters to credit unions.
- 37:25I would recommend looking at those.
- 37:27They're all archived on the NCUA website, but every year there are several
- 37:32regulatory alerts here to HMDA and occasionally there will be one or two
- 37:37dealing with federal lending as well.
- 37:39Those would be the primary resources I recommend credit unions use.
- 37:42There's a lot of good nighttime reading there, I'm sure.
- 37:45So two things, if there's some easy to find web links that you
- 37:48want to send me, I can put them in the show notes for this episode.
- 37:51So that someone who's listening on their laptop might be
- 37:54able to go there and find it.
- 37:56And then lastly, before we wrap with this episode, is there any final words
- 38:00that you want to share with the audience?
- 38:02I think that, from my experience, credit unions as a whole do a
- 38:07really good job with fair lending.
- 38:09The attitude of most credit unions is that they are there to help their members.
- 38:13I would say that the majority of the problems, the overwhelming majority
- 38:17of the problems that with fair lending that were uncovered while I was there,
- 38:21not out of intent as you mentioned, but it was out of ignorance of the
- 38:26requirements of the several laws.
- 38:28And probably over reliance on vendors of lack of training
- 38:32and those types of things.
- 38:33That's why I mentioned the compliance management system requirement.
- 38:37Credit unions try to get it right, but they don't always do that.
- 38:41The more they can educate themselves, the better off they will be and the
- 38:45better off their members will be.
- 38:47That's a great summary, Joe.
- 38:49All right, well, Joe, I want to thank you for being available
- 38:51here for me and for credit unions.
- 38:53And that's a wrap, folks.
- 38:55That's it for today.
- 38:56I'm Mark Treichel and I hope you join me next time for With Flying Colors.
- 39:08Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 39:12Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 39:16experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 39:20If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 39:24out our services at marktreichel.
- 39:26com.