Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Yasa Axial Flux Motors: Extreme Power Density
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive. So today we're taking you right
- 0:13to the cutting edge of engineering, something that's
- 0:15totally changing the game for electric vehicles.
- 0:18If you follow the car world, you know EVs are already incredibly
- 0:22quick. Oh yeah, but with stringly fast.
- 0:24But the real challenge for engineers now it's not just
- 0:26about speed, it's about getting more power, more range, and
- 0:31doing it all while making the whole system smaller and
- 0:34lighter. It's that constant battle for
- 0:35density and efficiency. Exactly.
- 0:38And our sources today, they're all focused on this huge shift
- 0:42happening under the skin of the car.
- 0:44We're talking about the move away from the old school radio
- 0:47flux motor. The one we've been using for
- 0:48decades. Towards this new kind of
- 0:50revolutionary axial flux design, especially the stuff pioneered
- 0:54by Auk company called Yasasa. So our mission today is to
- 0:58figure out you're not just what this new pancake motor looks
- 1:01like, but why changing one simple thing?
- 1:03The direction of the magnetic. Flow allows it to deliver these
- 1:06just staggering numbers. We're talking up to three times
- 1:09the power density. It's reshaping everything from
- 1:11supercars to electric airplanes. And you know, if you just take
- 1:15one thing away from this deep dive, let it be this In an
- 1:18electric motor, the biggest single difference maker isn't
- 1:21some fancy new material. It's the physical layout.
- 1:25It's the geometry. That one choice dictates
- 1:29everything about the motors, performance and its size.
- 1:32That makes a lot of sense. So we're talking about shape
- 1:34first, physics second. So to help everyone picture
- 1:38this, walk us through the basic difference.
- 1:40What do they look like? Sure.
- 1:41OK, so picture the motor in most EVs on the road today.
- 1:45That's a radial flex motor. It's basically a cylinder.
- 1:47Think of like a can of soup on its side.
- 1:50OK, got it. In that design, the rotor, the
- 1:52part that spins, is inside the stationary part, the stator, and
- 1:56the key thing is the magnetic flow runs perpendicular or you
- 1:59know, outwards from the center. Right, so if I'm looking down
- 2:01the length of the Cam, the force is pushing outwards to create
- 2:04the spin. It's a design that's really good
- 2:06for high speed. Exactly.
- 2:07Now the axial flux motor, it just throws that whole idea out.
- 2:11It's flat. People call it a pancake motor
- 2:13for a reason. It's wide and very, very
- 2:16shallow. And the parts aren't nested
- 2:18anymore. No, they're side by side, like 2
- 2:20dinner plates facing each other and they spin parallel to the
- 2:23axis. So just by putting them side by
- 2:25side, you're getting a huge reduction in depth.
- 2:28The sources say these axial motors can be what, as little as
- 2:3120% of the depth of a comparable radial motor.
- 2:34That's right, and that alone solves a massive headache for
- 2:37car designers. If you're designing A supercar
- 2:39or, say, trying to put a motor right inside the wheel, that
- 2:43depth is your enemy. This flat design just opens up
- 2:46entirely new ways to build a car.
- 2:49OK, so packaging check, that's a huge win.
- 2:52But just being small doesn't mean it's powerful.
- 2:55Let's talk torque. How does that flat shape
- 2:57translate into neck snapping acceleration?
- 3:00This is where the physics really starts to pay off.
- 3:03Torque is what you feel and the formula is super simple.
- 3:06Torque equals force times the radius.
- 3:09The classic lever arm idea. The longer the lever, the more
- 3:12force you get. Exactly that.
- 3:13So you want the biggest radius you can possibly get.
- 3:15And in a traditional motor, you're limited.
- 3:17Precisely in that radial can design, the rotor's radius is
- 3:22stuck. It has to fit inside the stator,
- 3:25so there's a hard limit on its diameter.
- 3:27But with the axial design. Because they're face to face,
- 3:30you can make the rotor diameter much, much larger.
- 3:32The forces are acting on a wider disc further from the center.
- 3:35You're getting a ton more torque almost for free just by changing
- 3:39the layout. That sounds almost too simple.
- 3:41I mean, making a large thin spinning disc sounds like it
- 3:44would be much harder to keep stable than a compact cylinder.
- 3:47Are there challenges there? Oh for sure.
- 3:49It definitely brings up challenges with managing heat
- 3:52and making it's structurally rigid.
- 3:54We can get into the cooling part in a bit, but the trade off is
- 3:57just immense. The sources on Yayos's tech
- 4:00claim up to four times the torque density of the best
- 4:03traditional EV motors out there. Four times that is a massive
- 4:07head start before you've done anything else.
- 4:09And that huge torque combined with being so much lighter gets
- 4:13you to the Holy Grail of electrification, which is power
- 4:16density. The power to weight ratio.
- 4:18And this is where the numbers just start to sound like science
- 4:21fiction. Yeah, they really do.
- 4:22So get this for a specific example.
- 4:24Yasa built a prototype axial flux motor.
- 4:28It weighs just 12.7 kilograms. OK.
- 4:30So that's like a heavy bag of groceries.
- 4:33I could carry that. You could easily carry it, and
- 4:35that little motor produced 750 kilowatts of peak power.
- 4:40Wait a second, 750 kilowatts is that's over 1000 horsepower.
- 4:44It is. So a motor I can tuck under my
- 4:46arm delivers more power than a Bugatti Veyron engine block.
- 4:50That's the leap we're talking about.
- 4:52The power to weight ratio works out to 59 kilowatts per
- 4:55kilogram. That's an unofficial world
- 4:57record. If you wanted that kind of power
- 4:59density a decade ago, you'd be looking at something the size of
- 5:02a beer keg that you definitely need a crane to lift.
- 5:04And the sources generally say these axle motors are about 50%
- 5:07lighter than a radial equivalent, while delivering 2
- 5:10to three times the power density.
- 5:13The numbers just speak for themselves.
- 5:14But the basic idea of an axial motor has been around for a
- 5:17while. It wasn't mainstream.
- 5:18What was the specific bit of engineering magic that Yasa
- 5:21brought to the table? That's a great question because
- 5:24you're right, the concept isn't new.
- 5:26The founder, Doctor Tim Wolmer, had this breakthrough moment
- 5:29when he was working on his PhD. He realized a huge structural
- 5:33part in all motors, even early axial ones, wasn't just dead
- 5:38weight, it was actively hurting efficiency.
- 5:41What part was that? It's called the stator yoke.
- 5:44It's essentially this heavy iron ring that acts like the backbone
- 5:48for the stator. Right.
- 5:49It provides the structure and contains the magnetic field,
- 5:51yes. And his big idea was, what if we
- 5:55just got rid of it? Just removed it.
- 5:56He developed what's called a yokeless segmented design.
- 6:00By taking out that iron yoke, they cut the amount of iron in
- 6:03the stator by a massive amount. We're talking 60 to 80% less
- 6:07iron. Wow, and why is getting rid of
- 6:10iron such a big deal for efficiency in the real world?
- 6:13Well, we always hear about copper losses from resistance,
- 6:16right? Yeah, when you're pushing the
- 6:17motor hard. Exactly.
- 6:18But think about a normal drive. You're not at full throttle all
- 6:21the time. You spend most of your time just
- 6:23cruising, light acceleration, maintaining speed.
- 6:26The daily commute. Right.
- 6:28And under those light load conditions, it's actually iron
- 6:30losses that become the biggest energy thief.
- 6:33It's the energy wasted just magnetizing and demagnetizing
- 6:36the iron core over and over. So by cutting out most of the
- 6:40iron, they slashed the biggest source of energy waste for
- 6:43normal driving. That's the key.
- 6:44They made it incredibly efficient for the kind of
- 6:47driving you actually do, which is what gives you more range.
- 6:50That's brilliant. They're optimizing for the daily
- 6:52drive, not just the drag strip. It's a huge deal.
- 6:55Now, of course, when you do push it to those 1000 horsepower
- 6:58peaks, you create a ton of heat in a very small space.
- 7:02So you have to solve that thermal problem.
- 7:04And how do they keep it from melting?
- 7:06Direct oil cooling. So instead of the usual water
- 7:09glycol mix, YASA uses a special oil that's way better at making
- 7:13direct contact with the hot components and pulling the heat
- 7:15away. This is what allows for
- 7:17sustained power. You know, a typical 200 kilowatt
- 7:20radial motor might only be able to run continuously at, say, 90
- 7:24kilowatts before it overheats. A YASA motor with a 200 kilowatt
- 7:28peak can run continuously at 150 kilowatts.
- 7:32That's a massive difference in repeatable performance and I.
- 7:35Remember the sources mentioning a neat little safety bonus with
- 7:38the oil too? Yeah, oil is an insulator,
- 7:40doesn't conduct electricity. So if there's a leak, there's
- 7:43much less risk of a short or an electric shock.
- 7:46It's a very elegant solution. OK, before we get to the big
- 7:49picture, we have to touch on the one historic drawback.
- 7:52Maximum speed. Radial motors can spin crazy
- 7:56fast, like 20,000 RPM. That's true, that has been the
- 7:59traditional trade off. Axial motors, because of that
- 8:02wide flat rotor, have historically been limited to
- 8:05lower speeds, maybe around 9000 RPM.
- 8:07Is that still the case? It's changing fast.
- 8:10Yasas are already testing motors that can hit 14,000 to 16,000
- 8:14RPM, so they're closing that gap very, very quickly.
- 8:16It's an engineering hurdle they're clearing, not a
- 8:18fundamental wall. Good to know, but like you said,
- 8:21top speed isn't what matters for range, it's that overall
- 8:24efficiency. Exactly.
- 8:26And that's where the design shines because they've minimized
- 8:29those iron losses. These motors hit an average
- 8:31efficiency of 96 to 97% / a standard drive cycle.
- 8:36And most competitors are what, low 90s?
- 8:38Yeah, struggling to get past 90 or 92% consistently, that
- 8:42difference, the extra 5% or so translates directly into a 5 to
- 8:4610% longer range for the vehicle.
- 8:49And this is where that concept you mentioned earlier kicks in,
- 8:51right? The mass compounding effect.
- 8:53This is the real magic for a vehicle designer.
- 8:56It's a domino effect of weight savings.
- 8:58Walk us. Through it.
- 8:58OK, so your motor is maybe 50 kilos lighter right off the bat.
- 9:03Then, because your car is now 5 or 10% more efficient, you don't
- 9:07need as big a battery to hit your target range.
- 9:10So I can use a smaller battery pack, maybe save another 50
- 9:13kilos there. Now you're at 100 kilograms save
- 9:15just from the powertrain. But because the whole car is 100
- 9:18kilos lighter, you suddenly don't need brakes that are as
- 9:21big, or a chassis that's as heavy and reinforced.
- 9:24Your suspension can be lighter, the cooling system can be
- 9:26smaller. And that initial 100K saving can
- 9:30snowball into a total vehicle weight reduction of 200 kilos.
- 9:33It's almost a 1 to 1 compounding effect.
- 9:35The car isn't just faster, it becomes fundamentally more
- 9:38sustainable because it needs less material and less energy
- 9:41just to move itself around. So where are we seeing his tech
- 9:44being used right now? Well, it started where you'd
- 9:46expect, at the very high end. Ferrari, Lamborghini, they've
- 9:51been using it to get that performance edge.
- 9:53The technology is proven. But the big news is
- 9:57Mercedes-Benz buying Yassa. That's the real shift.
- 10:00It means this tech is moving from $1,000,000 hyper cars into
- 10:03the mainstream premium market. That efficiency and power is
- 10:06coming to cars that more people can actually buy and.
- 10:09The future applications get even Wilder.
- 10:12That 12 kilo 1000 horsepower motor you mentioned?
- 10:14Imagine putting four of those on a car, one in each wheel.
- 10:18An in wheel motor system A. 4000 horsepower EV where you have
- 10:21absolute millisecond, 5 millisecond control over the
- 10:24torque at each individual wheel. The things you could do with
- 10:27traction control and handling it would completely rewrite the
- 10:30rules. And it's not just cars, right?
- 10:31This is going airborne. Correct.
- 10:33YASSA is working with Rolls Royce on the ACCL project, which
- 10:36is all about electric flight. Aerospace needs the absolute
- 10:40highest power density you can get, something like 20 or 25
- 10:44kilowatts per kilogram. These axial flex designs are
- 10:47what's making large scale electric aviation start to look
- 10:50possible. So this deep dive really shows
- 10:53that just by flipping the direction of the magnetic field,
- 10:56axial flux motors are delivering this incredible power density,
- 11:00massive torque and the kind of efficiency that leads to more
- 11:03range and lighter cars really feels like the new standard for
- 11:06high performance EVs. And the most fascinating part to
- 11:09me is how they did it. The breakthrough came from
- 11:12making it simpler, from removing things.
- 11:14They took out 80% of the iron in the stator by doing that.
- 11:18They also use less copper, fewer magnets.
- 11:20So maximum efficiency and using minimal material actually went
- 11:24hand in hand. Which leaves you with a really
- 11:26interesting question. If the best way to improve this
- 11:29core component was to remove a huge chunk of it, what other
- 11:33complicated, heavy parts of a car are we just waiting to
- 11:36simplify or remove entirely? That is a fantastic thought to
- 11:40leave everyone with that's a path forward is through elegant
- 11:43simplicity, not just more complexity.
- 11:47Thank you for walking us through all of this.
- 11:48It's been absolutely fascinating.
- 11:50And if you enjoy this deep dive into EV engineering, we really
- 11:53hope you'll follow the deep dive channel for more analysis just
- 11:55like this. And of course, a huge thank you
- 11:57to you. Our listeners for turning in.
- 11:59We'll catch you on the next one.