Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Motivated seller, the European connection and a glass of green whisky
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:07the UK energy market, BP's potential North Sea exit on
- 0:15Europe and finally, the Highlands.
- 0:18Get some hydrogen. That's a lot to talk about if
- 0:21you're just me. Aberdeen features leave Ryan
- 0:22Duff, but thankfully, we've got a crack team of experts that
- 0:26talked me through the headlines this week.
- 0:27First up, news editor Erica Askland, how are you keeping
- 0:31this week? Hi Ryan, I'm trying to absorb as
- 0:34much sunlight as possible to top up those vitamin D levels.
- 0:39Trying to stave off rickets. Well, mean you're down in
- 0:41London, so that makes it a little bit easier than your
- 0:43usual usual base of operations up here in Aberdeen, which has
- 0:47been kind of miserable this week after a good week last week.
- 0:50Unfortunately, this isn't a weather podcast, but that would
- 0:53have been very British of us. Ed Reed, you've also been
- 0:56enjoying the sun in in London. How's things going with you?
- 0:59Yeah, good, good. And, and obviously we had an E
- 1:02forward expedition to Hull this week which was fantastic,
- 1:08although I mean a little bit of feedback.
- 1:10It was raining. How dare though, you know I
- 1:13mean. I, I blame the organizers.
- 1:16Really. That's my, that's what I blame.
- 1:19And you know, Michael Bert, renewables reporter, you're
- 1:22based in Edinborough. We might as well complete this
- 1:24weather chat. How is the weather in the
- 1:26Scottish capital? It's gloomy, it's grey.
- 1:29I've got rickets, I've got scurvy.
- 1:32It's it's a it's a tough time. Not quite in the North.
- 1:35I can't, I can't call myself the the far north compared to you,
- 1:37but in the relative north. Oh, there we are.
- 1:40So the the weather seems like it's a tale of two halves, as
- 1:44potentially is is BP. We've got some turmoil, but
- 1:48maybe a way of turning the order book around, trying to look a
- 1:50little bit more positive by divesting from the North Sea,
- 1:54something that all the other super majors have already done.
- 1:57Erica, you were looking into this this week, right?
- 2:00You know, the rumors of Ithaca maybe buying, maybe not.
- 2:03What's going on? Sure.
- 2:05Well, the question is, would BP be able to flog the, you know,
- 2:12West of Shetland, Clairfield, including the much expected but
- 2:19not quite achieved Clair Bridge expansion West of Shetland?
- 2:24And maybe it was just a little bit pricey.
- 2:30You know, rumors were that they were looking for a little tidy 2
- 2:34billion. And that would of course, then,
- 2:37you know, if this deal had succeeded and sold it to Ithaca,
- 2:42which of course, let's not forget is a joint venture
- 2:46between Italy's Annie and Israel's Delic, then, you know,
- 2:52then that would have been the the last.
- 2:55Well, you know, almost, you know, with the exception of a
- 2:58few remnants of the Super majors who have historically been
- 3:05operating in the North Sea, but they've not quite been able to
- 3:09get out yet just because looks like maybe it was a bit too rich
- 3:13for Ethica's blood. And now they have to find a
- 3:17buyer. And now we just have to figure
- 3:18out who that buyer is going to be because you know what, it
- 3:21matters who invest in the North Sea.
- 3:23We kind of still have standards about the right people, you
- 3:27know, buying the right assets. We're not quite sure if that
- 3:30happens anymore, but we can still hope.
- 3:32As certain other North Sea operators have found out, to the
- 3:36chagrin of of deals being delayed, I suppose, in recent
- 3:39months. Well, I'm not talking about
- 3:41Viero in this one, but you know, Oh.
- 3:43OK, well we should name them out right?
- 3:46This is the company, of course, that it was stymied in its
- 3:50increase of acquisition positions in the North Sea over
- 3:54regulatory concern. So, you know, but we don't
- 3:58really know much more than that. I would say, look, I think I
- 4:00think there's like where there's a will as a way, right when,
- 4:02when BP is sufficiently motivated to sell its assets,
- 4:07then obviously they can find like, I mean, look, there are
- 4:09all different ways in which you can structure the deal.
- 4:11Obviously they could, they could, they could rethink the
- 4:13price, they could rethink, you know, how, you know, the sort of
- 4:16deferred consideration, you know, all these sorts of things
- 4:18about actually how much they want to help, you know, whoever
- 4:23it is going to come in and buy it.
- 4:25And, and, and I think, look, there is clearly appetite in the
- 4:28market to support these companies, right?
- 4:30So Ithaca, I think raised 155,000,000 last last week.
- 4:36I think you know so, so and you know, and and then you know,
- 4:40this week I saw a Ventra raise something like $40 million.
- 4:44So there there is. There is money in the market and
- 4:47there is an. Opportunity 2 billion in the
- 4:49market. Yeah, Yeah, that's the question.
- 4:51Has been successful too. I mean, last year they seem
- 4:53quite proud of being able to hit the euro bond market to raise a
- 4:59little extra cash, although, you know, like is, is this just too
- 5:04big a bite for Ithaca unless they're hoping to become a
- 5:10European super major, whatever that is these days?
- 5:13Well, you know, it's quite interesting because you know, I
- 5:16just thought, you know, when you said 2 billion, I just quickly
- 5:18compared that figure to the right down the Ecuador took when
- 5:22it, you know, essentially gave up its stake in UK fields by
- 5:26giving it to a Jura and it valued its its assets, which
- 5:31includes, you know, the operating stake in Rosebank, the
- 5:36UK's largest untapped oil field. It's 7.87 million, which seems
- 5:41like a, quite a step change between the two, doesn't it?
- 5:45So I don't, I don't know, it's, it's an interesting, interesting
- 5:49divide there. But I suppose is it a sign of
- 5:53the times? You know, I was thinking about
- 5:54this recently. It was when, when the story hit
- 5:56our website, I was thinking, the last time I spoke to Doris
- 6:00Reiter in a proper interview was what, August 2024 Those are.
- 6:05The days. And what were they?
- 6:08Because, you know, I spoke, I remember speaking to her at the
- 6:10time and saying, what's happening with clear phase
- 6:13three? Are we going to get that?
- 6:14And it's like, well, we'll see, you know, there's still some,
- 6:16right, you know, still some challenges in the, the fiscal
- 6:19regime and certainty of projects and so on and so forth.
- 6:22The things we've heard for the past few years.
- 6:25And you know, maybe I'm talking sharp a little bit here, a
- 6:28little peek behind the curtain. But I was speaking to some folks
- 6:31at BP recently and sort of, you know, made a little jab of, Oh,
- 6:34well, maybe we'll get, arrange another interview with Doris,
- 6:37you know, see how things are going.
- 6:39And the, the sincere answer I was given is what would you talk
- 6:44about that wasn't covered last time?
- 6:46And that's a, that's a fairpoint.
- 6:48There's not really much happening other than they don't
- 6:50have wind assets anymore, which wasn't Doris's.
- 6:54That was you either. No, that's a that's a good point
- 6:59because nothing's really been happening kind of North Sea
- 7:01wise. Of course, there's been a lot
- 7:03happening down at Saint James, you know, in the headquarters.
- 7:08Well. I wonder if like they're just
- 7:09maybe feeling a little bit distracted having, you know,
- 7:12literally been to the chairman. You know, in a way that kind of
- 7:18makes you think, good heavens, what was that man up to 'cause
- 7:22you know, you don't kind of take that sort of thing lightly just
- 7:25because, you know, markets don't like that kind of thing.
- 7:29But I think I know there's that sense that maybe they were
- 7:33justified, but hard to say. And so now the search for a new
- 7:39chairman goes. Do you think I should go for it?
- 7:41I think absolutely I'm going to throw your name into the into.
- 7:44The hey, thank you. Thank you.
- 7:45Yeah. Yeah.
- 7:46It's that kind of support that gets you there, right.
- 7:47So hard to hear first. But I, I feel like that's that,
- 7:52that I mean, I think as, as Ryan says, right, this is the
- 7:54problem. They're stuck in a holding pad,
- 7:55aren't they? Where they're not, it feels like
- 7:57they're not going to take FID because of this, of the fiscal
- 8:00challenges, because they've got so many other fish to fry around
- 8:03the world, right? Azerbaijan basin, you know,
- 8:07anger. Brazil, of course.
- 8:09Not too right? All these opportunities.
- 8:11Where where there, there are, there's a sort of a more
- 8:14welcoming sort of an environment and look, so it comes back to
- 8:19the question of like, actually, God, how, how, how much do they
- 8:22want to get rid of the North Sea?
- 8:23And it feels like if they're asking too much money, like, you
- 8:27know, maybe maybe 2 billion is too rich a, a, a sum for, you
- 8:31know, any sort of, you know, one of the sort of, you know, sort
- 8:33of smaller sort of independence that we've, that we've got left
- 8:35in, in the North Sea. So at that point, we're going to
- 8:39be stuck. So.
- 8:40So something's going to change. Yeah, I think one of the holdups
- 8:43with, you know, Claridge 3/2 was also the uncertainty around
- 8:50Shell, which was their joint venture partner in it.
- 8:54You know, they had a stake in it anyway.
- 8:56And then of course, now that it's kind of shifted over to a
- 8:59Jura, what does a Jura want to do?
- 9:01Because everyone has to come to that agreement.
- 9:03So presumably a Jura is now in a position to have made a call,
- 9:08but now it's kind of BPS court looking to figure out whether
- 9:14it's worth putting in. And the interesting thing is, is
- 9:18that, you know, Gordon Burrell, who's the head of exploration,
- 9:22you know, he's always been quite proud, I think of, you know,
- 9:26kind of what BP has built in terms of her portfolio.
- 9:29And then North Sea, you know, he, he, he has said, you know
- 9:33previously that, you know, they're good barrels.
- 9:37So I think they're going to try to want to stick to their guns
- 9:40on value on this one. Unless the trouble is, is that
- 9:43you you say it's up for sale and then all of a sudden no one
- 9:46buys. Then you have to start knocking
- 9:48down the price. Well, I'm sure this is a story
- 9:50that we'll be continuing to talk about for the weeks and months
- 9:53to come. I mean, who knows?
- 9:54Is there an opportunity for another joint venture?
- 9:57High tech vision, spending a lot, Maybe Neo Next could
- 10:00acquire another super major, Who knows.
- 10:02But stick around because after this break OUK are looking to
- 10:06the continent. Hello, I'm Ed Reed, the editor
- 10:10of E Forward. E Forward is a membership
- 10:12community that brings together the entire UK energy supply
- 10:16chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 10:19Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 10:22industry and policy makers to unlock the UK's opportunities
- 10:25and advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 10:29increased investment, improved policy making and better
- 10:32collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 10:35influence and access. Join me forward today.
- 10:43So we're very familiar with Offshore Energies UK sharing its
- 10:47two cents on the domestic energy market.
- 10:50But you've been speaking to Enrique Corneille about this,
- 10:55his take on the continent, on mainland Europe, CCS hydrogen.
- 10:59What's going on? Yeah, I was at the Offshore
- 11:03Energy UKCCS and Hydrogen summit the other day.
- 11:08I sat down with him and we had a nice sort of discussion about
- 11:13both technologies, I think as well the where Europe comes into
- 11:17the Scottish energy plan. But to start things off, I kind
- 11:19of just wanted to see that, you know, we're halfway through the
- 11:22year we've hit this summer. What is the state of Scottish
- 11:25hydrogen and CCS right now? Yeah.
- 11:27No, it's obviously been really good for us to see such a good
- 11:33turn out in our event here in Edinburgh.
- 11:35And we've had in the room the key projects from across the UK,
- 11:41but also from Europe. And I think we will be talking
- 11:45more about the importance of Europe to the UK CCS sector and
- 11:50hydrogen. But more generally, I think
- 11:53these are critical moments for the sector in the UK today.
- 11:58The discussions have focused on the progress that we have made
- 12:04so far in getting the first two projects across the line, the
- 12:08first two CCS clusters which are already under construction.
- 12:12There is an acknowledgement from both industry and government
- 12:16that a lot of work has gone in delivering those policy
- 12:21frameworks to de risk those projects and enable them to
- 12:25reach final investment decision. And we are seeing tangible
- 12:29results from those projects that are already delivering for the
- 12:33UK. And I think that's really
- 12:34important when we talk about what comes next for the UK.
- 12:38We're seeing the two cluster projects making a big effort to
- 12:43make sure that they hit the minimum 50% of local UK content,
- 12:49that they are already sourcing billions of pounds of pork to
- 12:54the UK supply chain. And you know, the frameworks for
- 12:59those projects that are already in place mean that we have gone
- 13:03to a position where the CCS sector is now real.
- 13:07It's delivering. But going forward there is a
- 13:10recognition that the model needs to evolve and to change because
- 13:15the government is taking too much of that risk, which is
- 13:20important for early projects to come through.
- 13:24The other important point that we have discussed today in the
- 13:28sessions, but also in one to one meetings is we have those great
- 13:32strengths in the UK because of the experience we have in the
- 13:36North Sea and the oil and gas. Peace continues to be critical
- 13:41to deliver seas US and this is something that we are very
- 13:45strongly championing at Offshore Energies UK.
- 13:49Given where we are in the political discussions now in the
- 13:54UK and what we're seeing a lot of, I guess, discussions taking
- 14:04things to one end of the spectrum or the other in terms
- 14:06of how quickly we should decarbonize or if we should
- 14:09continue to produce our own oil and gas.
- 14:11Absolutely critical that we continue to do both.
- 14:16And what we have set out today is that a strong investable oil
- 14:21and gas sector is absolutely critical to deliver CCUS, right?
- 14:25And I do think that there needs to be a stronger recognition
- 14:29about this within government, within policies.
- 14:34And you know, the fact that we have had such a difficult
- 14:38investment environment for the North Sea and for oil and gas is
- 14:43only going to make more difficult delivery of CCS and
- 14:45hydrogen. So in the sessions today, we
- 14:48have seen again all those key developers investing in those
- 14:52early projects in the UK on CCS and hydrogen are largely oil and
- 14:57gas companies. They have that commitment to
- 15:01deliver for these issues and hydrogen objectives for the
- 15:07country to enable, you know, decarbonization.
- 15:10But at the same time, I think it's more it's really important
- 15:12to make that clear link between what happens in oil and gas and
- 15:15how critical that is for those new sectors.
- 15:19The other big part of the discussion has been the Track
- 15:23one projects are progressing well and that's really
- 15:25important. However, next year, particularly
- 15:29the spending review in 2027, is going to be really critical for
- 15:34the Track 2 projects. And that includes obviously
- 15:36Acorn in Scotland and Viking in the Humber area.
- 15:41And that is those two projects are absolutely critical for the
- 15:45UK to meet its decarbonization objectives.
- 15:49And they do need that certainty from the UK government that they
- 15:54will be able to get the support they need to reach final
- 15:57investment decision. So there's been a clear call
- 16:03from industry to make sure that these projects go ahead.
- 16:08But at the same time, government have been here today discussing
- 16:11how the business model and the support mechanism for these
- 16:15projects, not only the track twos, but also the future
- 16:19pipeline of CCS projects needs to evolve.
- 16:23And the business model needs to adapt.
- 16:25Because I think there is a very clear recognition that we need
- 16:29to move away quicker from this model that we have, which is
- 16:33really fully dependent on on subsidy.
- 16:37So a lot of discussions about how quickly or how the business
- 16:42case for CCUS is evolving. Obviously, carbon prices are
- 16:47still not yet at the point, which on their own, you know,
- 16:51makes CCS investable as such. So there's still a gap that
- 16:57needs to be filled, but that early investment on those early
- 17:01projects unlocks a very substantial opportunity in the
- 17:06future. And if we do not invest in these
- 17:09early projects now, then we're going to miss out on the
- 17:14opportunity to develop a resilient strong CCS sector in
- 17:17the future, particularly when you're thinking about
- 17:19connectivity with Europe. Well, that does bring me on to I
- 17:23think what's been one of the big themes of the event has been
- 17:27Scotland and EU KS relationship with Europe, especially on CCS
- 17:32hydrogen. But there is a connection I
- 17:35think between for CCS capacity that's the UK has, you know this
- 17:41fantastic resource in the North seats store carbon, European
- 17:45supply slash demand. If you think of it either way,
- 17:48if they've got carbon that needs stored and also hydrogen, that's
- 17:53so, you know, especially country like Germany will not be able to
- 17:55produce the hydrogen that they want, but they're going to have
- 17:57the demand. I mean, does this almost feel
- 18:00like a step change in, in the discussion around this?
- 18:03I mean, I know that Europe has definitely been on the on the
- 18:06agenda. For example, I think when I
- 18:09spoken to a lot of the the merchant CCS project developers,
- 18:13they've always had Europe in their sight as a source of
- 18:17carbon. But does I?
- 18:19I don't feel like it's been quite as central to the
- 18:22discussion as it has been today. Yeah.
- 18:24No, I I completely agree. And there are many reasons for
- 18:27that. But the first one is there is
- 18:31now more than before, a very clear recognition from projects
- 18:36in Europe, particularly the emitters from across the
- 18:40industrial base in Europe that they need access to UK storage.
- 18:45That access gives them optionality, that access can
- 18:49help them reduce their costs as well of storage, which is really
- 18:53key. And the fact that we have seen
- 18:57the key projects from across Europe in this conference, I
- 19:02think is a really positive signal because they have really
- 19:06set out how urgent for them it is to have access to the UK.
- 19:12And you know, we had the projects from the Netherlands
- 19:15for example here with us, the we've had Ghassini and DBN
- 19:20talking about the Portos and the Aramis projects, setting out how
- 19:25important for those projects it is to have the ability to branch
- 19:31out their infrastructure to the UKA recognition that the
- 19:36geography, the quality of our stores, the capacity that we
- 19:39have is an ideal match for them to grow their own projects in
- 19:44Europe. And we've had also Northern
- 19:48Lights here presenting on how they now have become operational
- 19:53and from a region perspective, how they have enabled a real
- 19:59market for cross-border transportation of CO2.
- 20:02Where we see that the demand for that is there, Northern Lights
- 20:06are proving that it works. And we are seeing many of those
- 20:11projects in the UK, both the track projects, but also the
- 20:14merchant ones having discussions today with their European
- 20:18counterparts, calling both governments, governments across
- 20:22both sides to really urgently set out a timeline to make sure
- 20:28that we overcome some of those policy barriers, particularly
- 20:33around not only London Protocol, but alignment of emissions
- 20:37trading schemes. That will then send a positive
- 20:40signal to those investors in Europe that the UK is open for
- 20:44business. And the fact that we have the
- 20:46Europeans coming here to talk not only to the UK projects, but
- 20:50also to set this out to UK and Scottish governments and set out
- 20:55how urgent it is for them as they talk to their boards, to
- 20:59have the certainty that the UK will be accessible to them.
- 21:03I think has has really, you know, grown the importance of
- 21:08these discussions in a way that we hadn't seen before.
- 21:11And we're also launching a couple of reports today that
- 21:14clearly set out the scale of that opportunity.
- 21:17The report we published alongside DNV clearly sets out
- 21:21how investment on these networks both in the UK and in Europe is
- 21:28going to be key to grow that infrastructure and develop that
- 21:33interconnectivity to connect carbon coming from Europe into
- 21:39UK stores. But also hydrogen production,
- 21:41low carbon hydrogen production from the UK going into into
- 21:46Europe. And this is not going to happen
- 21:47overnight. So there is, if you like, in a
- 21:53way misalignment between the project timelines because these
- 21:57projects are going to take time to deliver benefits on both
- 22:02sides. But it's really important to
- 22:04start investing in developing these early interconnected
- 22:08networks across the North Sea now.
- 22:11And the misalignment is with, you know, some of the political
- 22:15time scales that are seeking to deliver shorter term benefits,
- 22:21right. And that's something that is a
- 22:24misalignment. But we are seeing that those
- 22:27early projects are starting to send really positive signals to
- 22:30the supply chain and to European customers that if we invest now,
- 22:35if we set up those early networks today, then the benefit
- 22:40of having that in interconnectivity in the future
- 22:42is going to be really crucial to protect our industries in Europe
- 22:48and in the UK, particularly thinking of emitters of CO2 that
- 22:53will only have CCUS and or hydrogen as a route to
- 22:57decarbonize. So in a few years time, if we
- 23:01don't invest in these networks now, we're likely to see a lot
- 23:05of that industrial base disappear being eroded with all
- 23:09of the thousands of jobs that support those industries going
- 23:14away disappearing. But if we're able to invest in
- 23:17these industries now and in these early networks now, then
- 23:22we are able to future proof our cement sector, our iron and
- 23:26steel sector, our ceramic sector that as we continue to
- 23:31decarbonize, they will be protected in a way in in the
- 23:36future. And that's something that I
- 23:39think speaks about how important it is to invest in these
- 23:43projects now and how that payout in the future is is already
- 23:48inside for this credible. Be the first to hear breaking
- 23:52energy news through the Energy Voice app, available to download
- 23:56for free. You get features like saving the
- 23:59articles you want to return to access to the Energy Voice
- 24:03supplement. You can read exclusive E Forward
- 24:06content and even listen to the Energy Voice Out Loud podcast.
- 24:11If you work in the UK energy sector, stay in the loop by
- 24:14saving the energy Voice app to your home screen.
- 24:17Download the app through the Apple App Store or Google Play
- 24:21for breaking energy news on the go by searching Energy Voice
- 24:25app. So hydrogen in the UK is an
- 24:29interest. An interesting point in time
- 24:31right now, isn't it? We're waiting for the strategy.
- 24:34We're waiting for hard to results where you know, there's
- 24:36an awful lot of waiting. However, the Highlands got an
- 24:40update this week and it's a project that maybe it's close to
- 24:43your heart because it's tied to whiskey.
- 24:44Erica, who knows what's what's going on?
- 24:47What's not to love about hydrogen fueled whiskey?
- 24:51I mean, we've kind of come up that hill before, but it looks
- 24:55like this particular project called the Cromartie Project,
- 25:02because I presume it's based in the Cromartie Firth is it looks
- 25:06like it's got some serious oomph behind it.
- 25:11It had been of course, developed by Sterega, that of course being
- 25:17the, you know, developer who is also looking to sell out of
- 25:23their carbon capture and storage stake in Acorn over in the
- 25:28northeast of Scotland. But recently they had collected
- 25:32a portfolio of hydrogen production schemes that had some
- 25:39success in the hydrogen allocation round one.
- 25:43The chromatic contract of course, is aimed at producing
- 25:49green hydrogen in order to support remote facilities,
- 25:54particularly whiskey distilleries.
- 25:57But it had been sold Surrega sold at the Protium.
- 26:00Green Solutions and Protium have since teamed up with ITM Power
- 26:06and they are going to collaborate on a range of
- 26:10things. Cromartie being the first one.
- 26:13And it looks like, I mean of course, then perhaps listeners
- 26:18will have remembered ITM Power. They are the hydrogen
- 26:23electrolyzer manufacturer based in Sheffield, which was able to
- 26:29have, was pleased to have been backed, I think of course by
- 26:3386.5 million from the UK government.
- 26:37It was a mix of Disney's funding directly but also national
- 26:43wealth fund support. It was a great move, I think to
- 26:47anchor ITM in the UK because otherwise I think ITM was doing
- 26:52very good in Germany, you know, with businesses and I think they
- 26:55also have facilities over there. But now they're in the UK and
- 26:59now they're going to be producing green hydrogen in the
- 27:03Highlands hopefully soon. So it's a win win I think for
- 27:09the anyone who has been involved in the development of the
- 27:12project. So, you know, should we raise a
- 27:15drum to that? Last, I mean, I'm, I'm always
- 27:17happy to do that, maybe not this early in the morning, Erica, but
- 27:20I mean I will follow my fearless leader if needs be.
- 27:25But you know, here, here's a question for you because
- 27:27obviously we, we've seen some, some renewables projects stall
- 27:32in Scotland this year and we've obviously seen as I mentioned at
- 27:35the top of the segment, hydrogen industry slightly beleaguered, I
- 27:40think would be a polite way of putting it.
- 27:42That's a. Very nice way of putting.
- 27:43It. Yeah, very.
- 27:43Very restrained of you. Yeah, up Ship Creek's another
- 27:47way I could put it. Yeah.
- 27:49But but you know, when it comes to when it comes to that, you
- 27:53know, when it comes to the the sector and this sort of moving
- 27:56forward with this hydrogen project, is it, is it gonna just
- 28:00get into the same roadblocks as everyone else or do you think
- 28:03this this has legs? Do you think there's
- 28:05opportunities here? Well, I mean, you know, the
- 28:08point about this sort of thing is you're hoping that, you know,
- 28:12you'll have an off taker. I mean, you know, energy isn't
- 28:16dissimilar from, you know, any other product you need a buyer.
- 28:22So, you know, it could very well be that the distilleries that
- 28:27they have in mind are off takers.
- 28:29And of course, you know, when you're looking at remote areas
- 28:32like the Highlands, you are kind of looking at a lot of
- 28:36facilities that are off grid, you know, that are looking, you
- 28:41know, for other solutions, cheaper solutions and of course,
- 28:46decarbonized solutions. Because I guess, you know,
- 28:50there's a market out there for decarbonized whiskey, maybe
- 28:53green whiskey. Yeah, green whiskey for sure.
- 28:56Right. It doesn't sound very good.
- 28:57It's like green eggs and ham. But on the other hand, you know,
- 29:01I guess, you know, there's a a market out there for everything.
- 29:05So, yeah, I mean, it, it does sound positive.
- 29:07I mean, it is it does cut it. They didn't say Mou, but, you
- 29:11know, that looks like they're taking this collaboration
- 29:13seriously. So for teams London-based and of
- 29:17course, you know, as part of the deal, they could also be buying
- 29:22ITM electrolyzers for other projects.
- 29:25So it all sounds good. And I mean, we've been kind of
- 29:29looking for, you know, some real momentum in like Har One
- 29:33projects are still in kind of maybe not quite, you know, where
- 29:36they should be. And there's been a few of them
- 29:38shelved. So I guess, you know, we have to
- 29:41take those positive news, you know, despite the fact we're
- 29:44still waiting for the strategy. And, you know, there's still a
- 29:49lot of people who are probably, you know, raised eyebrows about
- 29:54the whole hydrogen push, all be it, you know, kind of national
- 29:57gases, still thinking that they're going to be injecting
- 30:00that into the network gas network at some point for home
- 30:05heating. And then, of course, they're
- 30:07busy building big hydrogen pipelines connecting, you know,
- 30:13areas in the northwest and the northeast of England awaiting,
- 30:20of course, government imprimatur, although I'm not
- 30:24quite sure what that would look like.
- 30:27You know, I mean, I'd have to defer to maybe other hydrogen
- 30:31experts. Actually.
- 30:32You were in Hull recently talking about hydrogen, weren't
- 30:35you, Ed? You know, was there some sort of
- 30:39outcome on that? Is everyone feeling, you know,
- 30:41happy hydrogen hoppers like over in Hull?
- 30:45Exactly, exactly. I mean so, so, so this way.
- 30:47I mean, like Hull is, you know, actually, you know, very, very
- 30:50keen on, on sort of, you know, developing hydrogen and those
- 30:52sorts of options. And there was a lot of
- 30:54discussion around and our own hydrogen and it feels like
- 30:57there's sort of two things going on on there.
- 30:58So, so the hydrogen strategy, I remember speeding people last
- 31:02year, people were saying like, oh, it's going to be out by, you
- 31:04know, the autumn and then it's going to be out by Christmas and
- 31:07then and then it was going to be out by mid 2026.
- 31:11I think the latest we've heard is it's going to be out in 2026,
- 31:16so. You can.
- 31:18Well, I'm. Crossing my fingers here.
- 31:20I'm crossing my fingers. Your own.
- 31:21Conclusions about what that means in terms of calendrical
- 31:25time, I suppose. So 31st of December, you know,
- 31:28kind of like 5:00 PM Yeah, yeah. But I suppose.
- 31:32I suppose so I think there's but there's a kind of like a bigger
- 31:36question around sort of government uncertainty.
- 31:38Isn't that right? I feel like actually we get into
- 31:39a point where clearly reform the conservatives are raising
- 31:43questions around essentially around subsidies for you know,
- 31:47sort of decolonization around transition technologies.
- 31:50So I think that's the kind of the kind of the top down kind of
- 31:53question that's kind of hanging over the industry and actually
- 31:59companies are looking at that and some of them are saying, my
- 32:02God, let's not touch this with a barge pole, let's go somewhere
- 32:05else where frankly the environment's more welcoming.
- 32:09But some are looking at this and saying what are the
- 32:11opportunities. And I think that there is a
- 32:13sense of actually trying to find sort of incremental sort of
- 32:17small scale steps trying to find demand and linking sort of
- 32:21supply and demand is is actually the kind of, you know, the way
- 32:24in which some of these projects are moving forward.
- 32:26So I feel like in that way, it kind of speaks to that kind of
- 32:29that kind of whiskey sort of side of things.
- 32:30We like, look, there is an off taker.
- 32:32We just need to sort of provide the technology and we can sort
- 32:35of, you know, provide some sort of a hedge to, you know, sort of
- 32:38say volatile energy prices against the future.
- 32:41So it feels like this is an industry that's kind of moving
- 32:45forwards in some ways contrary to the kind of, you know,
- 32:50despite or in the headwinds of, you know, kind of government
- 32:54lack of certainty. But see this, this connection
- 32:56with with hydrogen and whiskey isn't a new thing.
- 33:00We've heard, we've heard sort of firms speak about this before.
- 33:03And from my understanding, this wasn't the preferred route for
- 33:08government in HAR 2. I think they they were going for
- 33:11we want to electrify whiskey. Yeah, whiskey distilleries
- 33:13rather than use hydrogen was my understanding of how this this
- 33:17went. So if this project looks like
- 33:19it's got legs, is the does that then create some some headaches
- 33:24for the government? Is there going to be yet more
- 33:25rewriting behind the scenes of a strategy going, Oh well, we'll,
- 33:29we'll delay it till early 27 now as we as we think about
- 33:33hydrogen. That strategy written on, you
- 33:35know, Ed Miliband's fag packet, you know, kind of like that
- 33:38seems to get renewed every day, you know, to try to fit, you
- 33:44know, kind of whatever narratives goes.
- 33:46Yeah. I mean, honestly, I'm, I'm kind
- 33:49of like hydrogen neutral. I don't know, does that, you
- 33:52know, kind of make me chemically unbalanced?
- 33:53But I mean, I do think that, you know it, you know, Ed's hit it
- 33:59on the nose and that's clearly the worry, you know, that people
- 34:03were having when they were at the E forward event in Hall, you
- 34:07know, is about scale. You know, I've, you keep on
- 34:10hearing about, you know, people in order for this hydrogen to
- 34:15really fly, you know, there just needs to be, you know, that big
- 34:19market for it because otherwise it's very expensive and very
- 34:23volatile and difficult to manage fuel.
- 34:27So sure, maybe electrification, you know, kind of would be
- 34:31better, you know, why not put a floating solar panel in a lock
- 34:36and, you know, connect that to your distillery or a bit windy
- 34:41up the Highlands sometimes, you know, maybe wind or offshore
- 34:46wind. Or they've got a new cable
- 34:48factory being built by Sumitomo. Maybe they just get a big old
- 34:53HVDZ cable to kind of whatever it is, they're going to be
- 34:56connecting it to maybe Shetland because they've got a lot of
- 34:59wind farms up there. So, yeah, I mean, there's lots
- 35:03of different kind of opportunities, but it just is a
- 35:08worry that, you know, for this to develop, it needs time and
- 35:13scale and lots and lots and lots of cash.
- 35:17And so, you know, where's this all coming from?
- 35:19I mean, I think, I think the the question around HA is I think
- 35:22obviously a very live 1 and obviously it's it's largely
- 35:25intended to incentivize people to produce hydrogen and then
- 35:28just assume that there will be an off taker.
- 35:31Build it and they'll come. That's and it.
- 35:33Feels like. Solid business strategy there,
- 35:35isn't it? Yeah.
- 35:37And I and I, you know, and there was, I mean, there was
- 35:38discussion this week at our event where actually it was
- 35:41like, oh, actually, maybe we should be thinking about
- 35:43incentivizing demand and say, and then and then sort of
- 35:46essentially saying, you know, like, oh, you know, help these
- 35:49people to, to, to, to off take the hydrogen, Don't worry quite
- 35:53so much about what low carb the, what green hydrogen means.
- 35:56Maybe think about more just like low carbon hydrogen and then
- 36:00just kind of allow the kind of the market to develop from that
- 36:02side. And obviously, you know, we're,
- 36:04we're into the process now. So I feel like it's going to be
- 36:06kind of hard to, to, to, to weaken.
- 36:08But it, you know, clearly that there is a need to kind of try
- 36:11and, you know, if, if, if there is hydrogen potential, we maybe
- 36:14do need to, to, to rethink about quite how we're doing it.
- 36:18A strategy would be nice, but it feels like the government is
- 36:22clearly shying away from making decisions and as a result
- 36:26companies have just got to sort of try and make up their own
- 36:29minds. Well, do you know what I think
- 36:31that does it for, for this segment?
- 36:33I'm sure we could keep speaking about this more.
- 36:35I'd be interested to hear your, your take, Eric, on how much
- 36:39renewables the Highlands actually does have with all
- 36:41these wind farms being cancelled.
- 36:43But that's, that's neither here nor there.
- 36:45That'll be a conversation for another day, right?
- 36:48Next time, Right now, we're thinking about strategy.
- 36:51By the time this next episode, the next episode comes out, the
- 36:55World Cup will have started. Let's hope Scotland didn't.
- 36:57I guess England as well have a strategy to to get out of the
- 37:01group stages and that will do it for this week's episode.
- 37:05Thank you very much, Michael, Erica and Ed for joining me and
- 37:08thank you for listening. We'll be back same time, same
- 37:11place next week.