Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Twenty Years of Urban Driving: Electric vs. Combustion Costs
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive, where we take the stacks of academic
- 0:12studies and market reports that you share with us and we we
- 0:16really try to cut through the noise to deliver the essential
- 0:18insights you need. Today we're tackling the great
- 0:21automotive debate. You know the one electric
- 0:24vehicle, traditional internal combustion engine or a hybrid,
- 0:28which one is actually the better long term choice when you look
- 0:32at the whole picture, right? Our mission today is to use your
- 0:36source material and this is some rigorous multi criteria research
- 0:40to find the scientific winner. We're talking no brand loyalty,
- 0:44no marketing hype. And, you know, we should
- 0:45probably just jump right to the core finding because it really
- 0:48challenges what a lot of people think, OK?
- 0:50Let's hear it. This comprehensive study was
- 0:52done, and when you compare everything, and I mean
- 0:55everything, from running costs to safety to environmental
- 0:58impact, EVs are scientifically ranked as the preferred choice.
- 1:02Preferred over everything, yes. Followed by hybrids and then in
- 1:06last place conventional gasoline vehicles.
- 1:08That is a definitive, almost provocative ranking.
- 1:11Electric, then hybrid, then ICE. OK, but hold on.
- 1:16When you say scientifically ranked, you're talking about
- 1:18this BWM 2 app PSIS methodology, right?
- 1:22For listeners who maybe aren't deep into academic modeling,
- 1:25what is that? Why should we trust its ranking?
- 1:28That's a really important question.
- 1:29BWM with two app PSIS. It's a mouthful.
- 1:34It stands for best worst method combined with a technique for
- 1:38order preference by similarity to ideal solution.
- 1:42But Simply put, it's just a rigorous system.
- 1:44It uses a panel of experts and consumers to weigh different
- 1:47criteria against each other. So things like cost versus range
- 1:51versus comfort. Then it scores the vehicles
- 1:53against those weighted goals. So it's not just an opinion.
- 1:55Not at all. It's a sophisticated way of
- 1:57quantifying what buyers actually prioritize and then seeing which
- 2:00technology best meets those priorities.
- 2:02Understood. So it's a road map based on what
- 2:04we, the people buying the cars, actually care about.
- 2:08And this shift away from the traditional engine is, well,
- 2:10it's critical right now. We know transportation is a
- 2:13massive contributor to climate change.
- 2:16I think it's responsible for something like 9% of global
- 2:19greenhouse gas emissions. And in some places, it's even
- 2:22more of a focus. India, for example, is the third
- 2:25largest emitter globally. So the need for cleaner mobility
- 2:29isn't just a theory, it's it's immediate.
- 2:31OK, so let's unpack this. If EVs are the superior choice,
- 2:35we need to understand how we got there.
- 2:37Let's start with the biggest factor for almost everyone,
- 2:40money. Specifically, the total cost of
- 2:43ownership. TCO is where the entire
- 2:45narrative really shifts. It looks beyond that initial
- 2:48sticker shock. It accounts for the purchase
- 2:50price, maintenance, fueling or electricity, infrastructure
- 2:54costs, depreciation, and, of course, government incentives.
- 2:58The whole life of the vehicle. Whole life, and we do have to
- 3:00acknowledge the first hurdle. EVs still have a higher upfront
- 3:03capital cost, and that's almost entirely because of the
- 3:06expensive battery pack. So the average person is putting
- 3:08more cash down at the start. Does that ever get balanced out
- 3:11and I guess where do we start seeing the savings?
- 3:13It starts melting away the moment you drive off the lot,
- 3:16really. And that's because of a
- 3:18staggering difference in energy conversion efficiency.
- 3:21It's a core physics difference. OK, efficiency.
- 3:24An electric motor converts an astonishing 5962% of the energy
- 3:29it consumes into direct power to the wheels. 62% That sounds
- 3:33incredibly high. What's the gasoline equivalent?
- 3:37It's not even close. A conventional ICE vehicle is a
- 3:40fundamentally inefficient machine.
- 3:42It only converts about 17 to 21% of the energy from gasoline into
- 3:47power. Wait, only 21%?
- 3:49Where does the rest of it go? It's wasted.
- 3:51The other you know 80% is lost primarily as heat, noise and
- 3:54friction through hundreds of moving parts.
- 3:57You are literally just heating the air around you when you
- 3:59drive a gasoline car. I see.
- 4:01And that massive inefficiency gap translates directly to what
- 4:04you pay at the pump, or in this case at the charger.
- 4:08We have some comparison data that really highlights this,
- 4:11don't we? We do.
- 4:11Let's use a clear example from say, a major market like
- 4:14Germany. Driving 100 kilometers cost
- 4:17roughly €3.92 in an average EV. That's assuming, you know, 14
- 4:21kilowatt hours at about $0.28 per kilowaters.
- 4:24Now a comparable gasoline car, it might need 5 liters for that
- 4:29same distance. At 150 per liter, the cost jumps
- 4:33to €7.50. That's that is nearly double the
- 4:37cost for the same distance. And that's just for 100
- 4:39kilometers. When you annualize it, those
- 4:42savings add up fast. Driving 10,000 kilometers a year
- 4:45saves you roughly €375 in energy alone.
- 4:50And that doesn't even factor in things like home charging.
- 4:52Exactly, that's a crucial point that saving doesn't account for
- 4:55charging during off peak hours when rates are lower or if you
- 4:58have a rooftop solar setup which and drive that operational cost
- 5:01down to almost 0 for a lot of commuters.
- 5:04So if less energy is wasted as heat, I'd expect less wear and
- 5:07tear. Which brings us to maintenance.
- 5:10It feels a bit counterintuitive that this complex new technology
- 5:13would lead to lower repair bills.
- 5:15That's where it gets really interesting, because the
- 5:17perceived complexity is mostly in the software and the battery,
- 5:20not the drivetrain itself. How so?
- 5:23Think about it. An electric motor has what, a
- 5:26handful of moving parts? An ICE vehicle has thousands.
- 5:31You completely eliminate routine things like oil changes, spark
- 5:35plug replacements, air filters, transmission flushes, the list
- 5:39goes on. All those little things that add
- 5:41up at every service. Do we have hard numbers and what
- 5:44that actually saves you? We do, and they're substantial.
- 5:46Long term studies found that service, maintenance and repair,
- 5:49or SMR, costs for EVs are about 27% lower than gasoline cars
- 5:55over 10 years. 27%. And if you look just at the
- 5:58modern battery electric vehicles, some reports show that
- 6:01saving can get as high as 40%. That makes the TCO advantage
- 6:05just enormous. But there's a kind of secret
- 6:08weapon, right? A piece of tech.
- 6:09It cuts down wear on a part that every car owner dreads replacing
- 6:13the brakes. You're talking about
- 6:14regenerative braking. It's a brilliant feature.
- 6:17It essentially reverses the electric motor, so when you slow
- 6:19down it captures that kinetic energy and uses it to recharge
- 6:23the battery. So it's slowing the car down for
- 6:25you? Right, without you having to
- 6:27rely as heavily on the traditional friction brakes.
- 6:29Which means it means your brake pads and rotors, components that
- 6:32cost a lot of money to service and replace on an IC vehicle,
- 6:35last significantly longer in an EV.
- 6:38The regenerative system does most of the heavy lifting OK.
- 6:42Let's pivot from the economics to the actual user experience,
- 6:45convenience, safety. Forget the data for a second.
- 6:49How does this tech change the daily reality of driving?
- 6:52The change is immediate. It's tactile.
- 6:55EVs deliver high torque instantly.
- 6:58There's no transmission, no gear.
- 6:59Shifting as the acceleration is just.
- 7:01On it's instantaneous and the drive is exceptionally smooth.
- 7:05And because that heavy battery pack sits low in the chassis,
- 7:08you get the much lower center of gravity.
- 7:10That translates directly to better handling, more stability,
- 7:14and just a better feeling of control.
- 7:16And what about convenience? We touched on skipping the gas
- 7:18station, but what is home charging really mean day-to-day?
- 7:21It completely changes your routine.
- 7:23I mean, imagine never having to stop at a crowded, smelly gas
- 7:26station again, especially during rush hour for your local
- 7:30commute. You just you plug in when you
- 7:32get home. It takes a few seconds.
- 7:33You wake up with a full tank. You wake up with a full tank, it
- 7:36turns refueling into this passive overnight activity.
- 7:40It's hassle free for most drivers.
- 7:42There's still this persistent public fear around EV safety,
- 7:45though, especially about battery fires.
- 7:47Are EVs actually safer? Yes, generally they are
- 7:51structurally. For one, the lack of a big
- 7:54engine block upfront let's manufacturers design much bigger
- 7:57crumple zones to absorb impact. But more importantly, you're not
- 8:01driving around with a tank of flammable liquid.
- 8:03So the fire risk is actually lower.
- 8:05The risk of an accidental fire is lower.
- 8:08While battery fires get a lot of media attention when they
- 8:10happen, they are less common and there's a lot protecting that
- 8:14battery. What's doing that protecting?
- 8:16That's the job of the battery management system, the BMS. It's
- 8:19basically the brain of the battery pack.
- 8:21It's constantly monitoring the voltage, current and temperature
- 8:25of every single cell. And if it detects a problem.
- 8:28It can automatically isolate cells or regulate the
- 8:30temperature to prevent something like thermal runaway.
- 8:33The pack itself is also double insulated and heavily armored
- 8:37and makes it dramatically safer. OK.
- 8:39So if we connect this to long term value, depreciation is
- 8:44often brought up as a big weakness for EVs.
- 8:47People worry the battery will degrade and the car will be
- 8:50worthless. Right.
- 8:51And the TCO models and real world data are proving that
- 8:54worry wrong really. Absolutely.
- 8:56It's one of the biggest myths out there.
- 8:58Battery degradation is real, of course, but it's often more than
- 9:01offset by those low operational costs we just talked about and.
- 9:04What about the actual resale value?
- 9:06The studies actually show that the average resale value for EVs
- 9:10is higher. It's around 50% retained value
- 9:13over five years. For a gasoline vehicle, it's
- 9:15only about 38%. 12 point difference.
- 9:18That's huge. So why does this idea of poor
- 9:21resale value persist? It's often because of a faulty
- 9:24comparison. If a buyer gets a big government
- 9:26incentive or tax credit when they buy the car, it lowers
- 9:29their effective price. So when they sell it five years
- 9:32later, the resale value is compared against that
- 9:35artificially low price, not the original sticker price.
- 9:38It makes the depreciation look worse than it actually is.
- 9:41So what does this all mean for the future?
- 9:43It sounds like the EV is becoming more than just a car.
- 9:46It really is. The EV is evolving into an
- 9:48energy asset. This concept of vehicle to grid,
- 9:51or V2G is revolutionary. EVs aren't just for
- 9:55transportation anymore. They can act as mobile energy
- 9:58providers. Which enables things like
- 10:00vehicle to home or V2H. Give us a tangible example of
- 10:04that. How could I use my car to power
- 10:06my house? Well, imagine a major power
- 10:09outage in your neighborhood. Instead of firing up a loud,
- 10:12smelly generator, your EV, which might hold enough energy to
- 10:16power an average home for a couple of days, can just
- 10:19automatically start running your essential appliances.
- 10:22It makes your home smarter, more resilient.
- 10:24That's something a gasoline vehicle, which only stores
- 10:26chemical energy, can never, ever offer.
- 10:29Let's move to the environment. This is often framed as The
- 10:31Dirty secret of EVs 0. Tailpipe emissions is a clear
- 10:36win, but that's always questioned by where the
- 10:38electricity comes from. And that's where the calculation
- 10:41gets a bit more dynamic. And it's regional.
- 10:43The way a nation, or even a specific city's grid generates
- 10:47its power has a direct impact. If you're charging on a grid
- 10:50that's heavy on coal or natural gas, the benefits are
- 10:53diminished. And there's the peak load issue
- 10:55too. Right.
- 10:55For sure, if mass EV adoption means everyone plugs in at 6:00
- 10:59PM when they get home, you might force older, less efficient
- 11:02fossil fuel plants to fire up just to meet that demand, which
- 11:05generates more CO2. That sounds like a long term
- 11:08challenge. Is there an optimistic, scalable
- 11:11outlook here? Absolutely, because we're moving
- 11:14toward integration and scale first.
- 11:16Power plants are just inherently more efficient and easier to
- 11:19regulate than millions of individual inefficient car
- 11:22engines. OK, that makes sense.
- 11:23And as countries integrate more renewable solar, when the grids
- 11:27emissions profile just drops and drops.
- 11:29Plus the battery circular economy is improving.
- 11:32Using recycled raw materials already cut CO2 emissions from
- 11:36new battery cell production by a measurable 28%.
- 11:39Now for what I think is the recent AHA moment, the thing
- 11:43that should really ease a lot of anxiety for people.
- 11:46Let's talk reliability and longevity.
- 11:47Specifically citing that UKMOT study from Nature Energy.
- 11:52This feels like it counters one of the biggest lingering doubts
- 11:56about EVs. This data is critical.
- 11:58Researchers looked at almost 300 million records from EU KS
- 12:01Ministry of Transportation. Basically vehicle health checks.
- 12:05And what do they find? The finding was conclusive.
- 12:08The argument that EVs don't laugh is officially dead.
- 12:11EVs now have comparable lifespans to ICEVS.
- 12:15What were the actual numbers on lifespan?
- 12:17The average projected lifespan was 18.4 years for a battery
- 12:21electric vehicle, which is, you know, virtually identical to the
- 12:2318.7 years for a comparable gasoline car.
- 12:26And what about mileage? How far are they going?
- 12:28They were found to travel around 124,000 miles in their lifetime,
- 12:32which is actually slightly more than a typical gasoline car of
- 12:35the same generation. But the real kicker is the rate
- 12:37of improvement that shows where this is all heading.
- 12:39Precisely. While older first Gen.
- 12:42EVs did have some reliability issues, the technology is just
- 12:45maturing so rapidly. The study showed that Bevs had
- 12:49the fastest reliability increase year over year.
- 12:52Faster than gasoline cars. Much faster.
- 12:54A 12% decreased chance of failure for every successive
- 12:57year of production. For gasoline models, that
- 13:00improvement was only 6.7%. It shows EV tech is on this
- 13:04steep, aggressive learning curve that is quickly leaving
- 13:06traditional vehicles behind. OK, let's circle back and tie
- 13:09all of this together, the TCO, the safety, the reliability and
- 13:12plug it back into that BWMTIPS ICE analysis.
- 13:16This is what determined what you, the average consumer and
- 13:19expert panel, actually prioritize.
- 13:22And the analysis showed 2 overwhelming factors driving the
- 13:24decision. Number one by a huge margin was
- 13:27cost of ownership. It was weighted at 31.65%.
- 13:30Makes perfect sense. Everyone cares about their
- 13:32wallet, but the number 2 factor is the real shocker.
- 13:34Here it is. Number 2 was policy push and
- 13:37regulations weighted at a massive 27.82%.
- 13:41So government incentives and tax breaks are almost as important
- 13:43to a buyer as the actual cost of owning the car.
- 13:45Almost as important, it shows that favorable policy is a huge
- 13:49driver of consumer confidence and adoption in this market.
- 13:53And it's fascinating to see how low other factors scored.
- 13:56Environmental impact was only 3.87% and safety and comfort
- 14:00just 5.45%. Right.
- 14:03But even with those being lower user priorities, the intrinsic
- 14:07benefits of the EV in those areas still help push it to the
- 14:10top of the overall ranking, Which?
- 14:12Brings us to the final result. Across different price segments,
- 14:15from entry level to premium, the ranking held true, didn't it?
- 14:18It did. EV's consistently took the top
- 14:21preferred ranks. Hybrids consistently ranked
- 14:23better than ICEVS, showing the value of that efficiency, but
- 14:27they couldn't beat the pure electric offering.
- 14:29So the final conclusive fact is what?
- 14:31The conclusive facts synthesizing all these sources
- 14:34is this EVs are a sustainable mode of transport.
- 14:37They offer lower maintenance, better operational costs, and
- 14:40enhanced safety, making them a better choice than conventional
- 14:42and hybrid cars in comparable price brackets.
- 14:45So the total cost of ownership advantage which eats away at
- 14:48that high initial price, combined with rapidly increasing
- 14:51reliability and that strong government push, it makes the
- 14:55long term choice of the EV crystal clear.
- 14:58And now a provocative thought for you to consider as you go.
- 15:01Given that policy and incentives make up nearly 28% of that
- 15:05purchase decision, how might this entire transition shift if
- 15:09those incentives start to dry up right?
- 15:11Will the TCO savings and reliability alone be enough to
- 15:14keep E VS dominant in that crucial consumer ranking?
- 15:17That is the perfect question to Mull over as this market
- 15:20matures. Thank you for joining us for
- 15:23this deep dive into the true cost and value of our electric
- 15:26future. We really hope this has created
- 15:28some genuine interest in just how complex this transition is.
- 15:32If you enjoyed getting the full picture on EV adoption and want
- 15:34more detailed analysis delivered straight to you, Please remember
- 15:37to follow and subscribe to the channel.
- 15:39We'll be back soon with another deep dive just for you.