Latest / Portfolio Talks / Lawyers Opinion On Buying Your Dental Practice (Alliance Lawyers LLP)
Transcript
- Vishal Gill, CFP: Welcome to a special episode of Portfolio Talks. Last episode, we talked about buying a dental clinic. So, those of you who are dentists, you tuned into last week's episode to learn about the do's and don'ts about buying a dental clinic and the specifics around it. In this episode, it was a follow-up based on popular demand, and we want to get a lawyer on the episode to chat with you about even more specifics about buying a dental practice, some common issues that they see, things that make you walk away, things that want to make you want to proceed. And really some traps and some things to look for, what to ask your realtors, due diligence, all that fun stuff that's going to allow you to, you know, ask a lot of questions, to fine-tune is this clinic right for me or not, and then go into the next step. So this episode will equip you with those types of resources, that type information. And without further ado, let's jump into it. Special episode of Portfolio Talks. All right, everyone, welcome to another episode of Portfolio Talks. As mentioned, this is a special episode for you dentists who are looking to purchase a clinic. I want to get as much information as possible before spending the money and going into the commitment of next steps. What we want to do is equip you with as much info to go into the conversations with some leverage, to realize which deals make zero sense for you and which ones are worth further pursuing. And luckily for you, you get to hear it from your favorite financial podcasts who are actually three guys wearing glasses for the first time ever. I usually don't wear these, but I have had some bad allergies and dry eyes. So I'm gonna try to put these blue block blue blocking lenses. I don't know why that was a tongue twister. but we have us three have a couple things in in common. So number one, we got the glasses on, and number one, or sorry, number two, we actually have disgusting sock tans from golf season, I'm sure, all by now. Cause me and Tyson were talking about it. We actually know about your feet, funny enough, Umrit, before we jumped on, we're like, this guy has a deadly sock tan from golf season and ours is less or so. Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah, you gotta you gotta pay to see those. Vishal Gill, CFP: That's Tyson Nagasaka: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: a different retainer that you gotta pay for the lawyer fees, right? So Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: but I remember like three years ago when I first had my first full golf season, I made the rookie mistake of wearing like mid socks in the summer. That was that was my thing then. So I had like those mid level socks and halfway through I realized how disgusting that sock 10 was and the rest of the year was just trying to get rid of it. So I had to go through some embarrassing moments to get rid of those. So one of the first takeaways for everyone in the audience is wear ankle socks when you go golfing or just wear pants. You don't have to worry about that as well. Amrit Dhaliwal: Pants. Vishal Gill, CFP: Pants are the way to go. I can do Vantham. awesome. So, what we want to do is actually get someone that's smarter than us in front of you all, which is a lawyer here. So Amrit is a lawyer who's been working on a lot of files for our firm, really helping a lot of doctors expand into the next stage of their careers, which is buying into a practice. For the most part, we we don't really see too many cold starts. Like that's that's someone that has very large appetite of of risk and wanting to build out their way, which isn't wrong. It's just not what we see too often. More times than not, we see someone that worked in a clinic as a locum or an associate and they're looking to buy into or buy out the existing dentist and take over that practice. So that's kind of what we want to talk about today is more specifics around the buying mechanics of it. We have a couple of questions that we got from the audience. And this was by popular request to have I'm right, you're you're a popular man. there's a lot of people banging on the podcast walls. However, you would do that to try and get you on here. But as a quick plug, our Doctors in Canada Facebook group, that's where you can get these questions in. put them into our mailbag. And the feedback that we get there is gonna be, you know, really how we curate these episodes down the road. So if you want to get some questions in for ourselves or next guests or next topics, make sure you join the Doctors in Canada Facebook group, and that's gonna be linked in the show notes. So QA style here, we got some questions. We're just gonna fire them off. I'm ready if you're ready to go. Lock and loaded. First first question did you get that bake from Italy or is that like a local bake? What what is that? Looks nice. Amrit Dhaliwal: This is this is it is an Italian brand. I did source it in in California. Vishal Gill, CFP: There you go. You just anywhere but home. You got from like one country to the next country and then eventually brought it home. Love it. Amrit Dhaliwal: It's duties and tax shelter. Vishal Gill, CFP: Love that. all right. So, first question: there's a a dentist. So when they want to buy a practice, it seems like such a weird transaction. For the most part, they're like, I don't even know what the steps are. I just know that I want to buy this practice and eventually I'll ha have the practice, I'll own it. But what's everything in between? So if you're gonna walk our guests through like a full acquisition timeline chronologically from when They first reach out to you saying, Hey, I have intent to buy this dental practice until closing and getting the dental practice. What does that timeline look like? Amrit Dhaliwal: It's there's no real hard and fast rule on what the timeline looks like. we can, you know, close deals in a matter of a few weeks. and you know, sometimes they take seven to eight months. Depends on just, you know, the hiccups that we get throughout the way. If everything runs smooth, I would say you would want to give yourself a solid four to five months. And that probably seems like a long time, but you know, when you're in it, it actually goes by pretty quick. So when we we don't see a lot of people, you know, go through brokers, at least at not at at my office. Most of the the deals that we get are from, like you had mentioned, Vishhal, locums, associates that already work there and you know get a beat on, you know, maybe the owner wanting to retire or the head dentist wanting to retire and you know, looking for some sort of succession plan. So we get involved fairly early, but it's also important that, you know, you as a dentist get your team involved very, very early. that includes, you know, yourself and Tyson. It includes the your accountant, and then obviously your lawyer as well and any other sort of financing bankers, mortgage people that you know assist you around the road. But you know, you will generally come into an idea of you know what you want to pay. You maybe you get some financials before you can kind of want run through it with your team and find out, you know, kind of this is roughly what your your purchase price is looking like. And usually that's a calculation of some sort of line item on a financial statement. We get involved usually around the letter of intent. So that's essentially saying that, hey, I'm very interested in this product and I want to do now further investigation, further research, and you know see if it makes sense. So this will include your exclusivity. You can't sell this to anyone else while during this window because I'm looking at it now. and then for the vendor side, confidentialities are huge because they're gonna give you all this information, kind of giving them the secret sauce, you know, the Big Mac sauce. And you're gonna promise that you're not gonna tell anyone what the underlying secrets or underlying processes of this product is. those are the main two things. and then you'll you'll discuss in there whether what kind of structure you want as well, whether it's gonna be an asset purchase or a share purchase, and then the conditions that you're gonna have. So Once you received all the documents, if I'm not satisfied with something, we can wash our hands of this walk away. Usually comes with some sort of deposit structure as well. that's kind of the good faith payment that you'll put into my trust account, which will allow the other side to feel a little bit comfortable that if I give this to them and then for whatever reason it doesn't go through, maybe I might get some of that money that's parked in Umrett's trust account. so that you know, just no like I said. no real rule on how long the letter of intent process takes. I would recommend that you know you spend some time dealing with the letter of intent because it'll save some time down the road when it comes down to doing the purchase agreement. things that you don't discuss or negotiating the letter of intent become a little bit harder to negotiate when it comes down to actually finalizing the actual deal. So try to make that as robust as possible. We have a lot of experience in that. And save yourself some time and money down the road. I'm not gonna say that it's gonna cost you any less in the aggregate, but might save some time when it comes down to crunch time. Then you're gonna pay a deposit into my trust. You know, that's fairly quick depending on if you have the funds ready to go. and then the real hard work starts. And that's not just my hard work, it's Vishall and Tyson's hard work. It's your accountant's hard work and your hard work with the bank to try to get the money if you need a loan for it. this process can take several months. depending on how old this company is and what kind of structure you have. there's probably a lot of doors that you gotta open to you know peel back to see what's back there. and you wanna be certain in your letter of intent that you have all these conditions in there because if you find something that you don't like and it's not in letter of intent, you might not be able to rely on it to get you out of that deal to get your deposit back. So you know things you're looking at is financials. You know you've come up with a purchase price maybe at this point already. You want to see if that's a realistic price. you want to look at if there's any liens on any of the assets. If you're doing an asset purchase agreement or a share purchase, you want to ensure that you know you're not j taking on some asset that you know is got 15 different lenders on it and actually has no value. Another thing that we see is the the lease likely you're going to be running your dental practice out of a commercial building. Very likely that the dentist that's sending selling it to you may not own that unit. Maybe they do, but they want to retain that as their own investment. You wanna get a a lease renewal assignment or something that allows you to use that premises to continue on that business. That's gonna be something your bank requires too if you need a loan. They need to have some sort of security that. looking at the financials, this company or this business has made a certain amount of money over a certain amount of time. Maybe we attribute that to the location that it's in. pretty important. I I can almost guarantee you that's going to be a requirement from the bank. The other thing is the landlord's consent. the landlord will if it's properly drafted lease will there will definitely be something in there that requires the landlord to sign off on the change of control of the company or a change of control in the the operating business there, whether it's an asset or a share purchase. very good to get that going immediately. not to take that to the the the last minute because it seems like it's pretty easy. Like, I gonna get the landlord to sign off on it. Sometimes it doesn't go that quickly. I've s recently found that out. employment records you want to find out, you know, who are the employees. This is you know big topic of liability for severance vacation pay, any sort of outstanding wages. There could be claims that the company might have against it for, you know, unpaid wages that, you know, survive two years past the actual closing date because, you know, that's how long our limitations is in BC. and then there's you know regulatory issues with your college. so you want to take the brunt of your time and really do a full some due diligence to determine whether this is something that you're willing to move forward with. And then at a certain point, kind of like a real like a residential real estate, you'll say, you know what, let's remove all the conditions. I'm satisfied or I'd waive them. And now let's hammer home the purchase agreement. Purchase agreement's gonna have its own conditions in it as well, but at that kind of point the deposit becomes non refundable sometimes, depending on who drafts it. and depending on if I'm drafting it, depends on who my client is. Obviously, I'm gonna give you enough, you know, windows or doors to sneak out of this if you need to. but you know, at the end of the day, you're you're dealing with two parties and it's a negotiation at the end of the day. and then, you know, I would say maybe if you're, you know, you're could take about a month, month and a half, two months to prepare the purchase agreement. also depending on how intricate it is, how many, you know, moving parts there are. if there's a long standing history of the company, if you're doing a share sale, you know, there's probably a lot of indemnities that you have to put in. and that's essentially just saying that if there's something that comes up with the company, it's pre-closing, I'm not responsible for it, you're responsible for it. yeah, so give yourself some ample time to get that done. You know, lawyers are busy, you know, maybe you send a draft back and forth once a week and three, four drafts later, and now it's you know, you're a month up. You're already a month into drafting what's generally a simple document. just has a lot of boilerplate language, but you know, it's the part that we actually have to fill in is, you know, fairly important. and then just the general closing mechanisms of removing directors if we're doing share purchase, we're removing any PPSA s registrations, those are the liens that are on assets. if there's any lines of credits for the company that need to be closed or if we have to transfer those. maybe you need to get reapproved by the bank for the ch after the change of control. Give yourself three, four weeks for that too. Hopefully it doesn't take that long, but I mean sometimes it does. Getting the bank's conditions in place too, that's something that a lot of people forget about is, you know, yeah, I have I have approval from my bank and they're gonna give me all this money. And then you know, it's a week before it's like, okay, now we have all these conditions that you got to sign. You know, you gotta, you know, give your arm and leg to the bank in case you don't pay them. They have all their own documents is too. so yeah, that all that takes about four to five months. Vishal Gill, CFP: Crazy. Amazing rundown. Thank you for that and and the clarity on it. And there's two quick follow-ups I have there. Number one, just for the audience out there, vendor vendor is the seller, is another way to think of that. So when I'm risk referencing the vendor, like a vendor take back or what the vendor wants, that's the selling dentist in this example. So who's selling the practice to you? That's the vendor and the vendor's team. And the second thing that's it's funny that and I I'm glad you ended it with saying all that happens, you know, within the same. you know, three, four months around there. It reminds you of the episode of the office when they're going through like the the safety when they're talking about okay get up and take a 10 minute walk a day then make sure you stretch for 10 minutes and Michael's like, well that's like you know 30, 40 minutes of the day. But you do it at the same time. So a lot of these things that seem really complicated and time consuming, they're happening you happening unilaterally at the same time. and that's the benefit of your team while your lawyer is working on something, your accountants and your financial planners are working on something else. so it's it's the whole team working on all this stuff at the same time, but all of it is very Very important. amazing. great, great timeline and way to break down such a opaque example of like, okay, I'm just buying something and what does it actually look like into actual, actual steps. So amazing. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, that was awesome. so when you're when you're walking through some of these deals and when you've seen these come across your desk, you start doing due diligence. What's one of the most surprising numbers that came across a file that in due diligence is like shocking or scary, or maybe the client didn't know that this was hidden under the hood? Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah, I mean as discussed in the your due diligence part, we talk about employees. Employees are very expensive. they depending on how like if we're doing a share sale or even an asset purchase, the employees jet will stick around with the the company as you know, continuity, like just employees go with the company. Even for asset purchases, you can't just fire an employee and hire them back. You know, the BC court say that That's not a loophole anymore, or maybe it was. I don't know. but even if you hire them back, like they've are deemed to have continued working for that same operation. They've been an employee the whole time. So, during the due diligence pay stage, I think the cost of an employee's severance is something that, you know, doesn't necessarily make it into the financials because it's not an expense, it's not an ingoing or an outgoing sort of figure that's on the financial statement. So it's not something you think about. So that happens when you find out that you know Susan's been working at the the the dental clinic as a you know receptionist for 35 years. And you know a lot of people don't understand that there's two types of severance payments in in British Columbia. One is the statutory requirements under the Employment Standards Act. that is a minimal type of payment if you want to look at it in the grand scheme of things. It's eight weeks A maximum of one week per year at a maximum of eight weeks. So you're looking at a regul relatively small number. What people don't necessarily consider is the common law severance. And that's essentially saying that, hey, I've been working here for 30 years and you only paid me seven thousand dollars to terminate me. BC courts have said that you are general rule of thumb is like one month per year. And now you're looking at 30 months of pay for someone that maybe their salary is 60, 65,000. That's a lot of money. very Tyson Nagasaka: That is. Amrit Dhaliwal: surprising that people don't understand. but in terms of numbers, you know, because you're in the due diligence stage, there's there's a lot of outs. You find something, it's like, all right, you know, I can walk away from this. this the Everything's kind of surprising as all was saying, like if it's someone's coming into this first time, you know, they're having experience, you know, a lot of the stuff that they're gonna see that is it's pretty surprising. But one thing that I have noticed and what I now tell my clients when they're doing these types of deals is you know, just because you know you're doing a one million dollar purchase and you maybe the bank's gonna finance you a hundred percent, but maybe they're only gonna finance you ninety percent. That means you gotta still put up a hundred of your own thousand dollars to take the keys on closing day. What about the next 365 days? There's working capital, there's you know, accounting fees, there's incorporation fees or whatever there is. The actual amount of money that you need to survive the year is you know a lot more. probably an extra 50, 60, 70,000. So when you're looking at, hey, I need $10,000 as a down payment towards this, you should probably need you should probably have closer to 20, 25 percent. if you don't want to stress too much. So I think that's the number that people are surprised by the most. And it's they tell me this after. And it's now advice that I give my clients during the process is hey, consider what it's gonna cost you to run the dental practice as soon as you take the keys and how long it's gonna take for you to how much it's gonna cost for you to run it for 365 days. You know, after 365 days or one year, you can You'll have money obviously coming in and you can use those funds to offset the cost or whatever. But that's a surprising number because your actual cost isn't Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. Amrit Dhaliwal: what your what what the bank's gonna lend you on based on the purchase price. So they're not gonna look at what your future cost is gonna be. It's gonna be you we're you're buying this for a million dollars and we're gonna give you nine hundred thousand of it. That's it. Tyson Nagasaka: Great answer. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah. And I think that's Amrit Dhaliwal: Thank you. Vishal Gill, CFP: it's a good ego. We're we're we're pumping your tires at the same time. but I think a good thing to note there as well is sometimes, you know, dentists will say, Well, Scotia, for example, let's just pick one. Scotiabank also give me an operating line of credit. So they give me the purchase price, I don't know, plus a hundred thousand dollars of an operating line of credit. That's great. But keeping in mind that they're still charging interest on that line of credit. So to Umbrella's point about having some extra cash on hand to Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: run the business, actually knowing what your slush fund should be to keep the business operating. You don't want to use just a line of credit for that because you now that same hundred thousand dollars would cost you, I don't know, $120,000, for example, and just lost capital. But instead, that that sometimes can only make sense if you're doing a vendor take back or an example where I don't know the dentist, you're doing a buyout. So the selling dentist is gonna stick around for a little bit of time and then they're gonna drop off. So then you're gonna replace that high Expense dentist with an associate who's going to be saving you money. And then that difference is going to be allowing you to start paying down that line of credit. In those examples, you know, if you can work with your team, your financial planners, your accountants, see if that makes sense and then use the line of credit in the interim. Then when that person drops off all that freed up cash flow, you just chip away at that debt. then it can make sense. But you know, Tomber's point, just be aware of the actual costs of running the business are very different than just buying the business. Buying the business is going to allow you to take that future income potential, but you got to Be a business owner at the same time, not just a dentist. So knowing those numbers are are very important. so you talked about things that were surprising that almost made us walk away, which would be like severance requirements for the employee and then the actual cost of running the business. what about some good numbers that made you want to continue? Or not not necessarily numbers per se, but some good situations. So when these numbers come up that scare people and they're like, well, I don't know, I'm kind of on the fence now about this deal. What have you seen that allow the deal to move forward or give comfort to the buying dentist to move forward because that can seem like a scary number for anyone of like, hey, now you're on the hook for this much money. What still made sense for them to move forward so the audience can actually see the light at the end of the tunnel. Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah, I mean, the big one is that employee employment severance. That's something that, you know, like I mentioned, you don't really necessarily consider even at the LOI stage. I tell my clients now, like this is something that we need to consider now. But, you know, maybe the first time I did a transaction that we didn't consider that, that was something that obviously came up during due diligence. Now, at the end of the day, if both parties want to get this deal done, mainly the buyer, if he wants to get or she wants to get the deal done, we'll find a way. there's there's so many ways to bake in protections into the agreements. You can share the liability, you can rego reduce the the purchase price to take on that liability. you can put in indemnities for pre-closing activities specifically to the employment one. You can you can negotiate directly with the employee that would have that outstanding severance liability to you know I don't wanna say wave or, you know, ask them to not be entitled to whatever common law severance might they might have. you can't do anything about the Employment Standards Act, like you're guaranteed the eight weeks, max eight weeks. you there's no there's no nothing you can put in any employment agreement that can reduce that. but you can New new employment agreement, you can offer some fresh consideration, maybe like a retention bonus of some sort. And as that consideration, they can n you can negotiate a reduction of the whatever common law severance entitlement there would be. recently I've did one where, you know, I've negotiated with the the vendor dentist and the buying dentist to share. The liability on some sort of schedule that, you know, if for whatever reason there needs to be a termination of a longstanding employee within the first year, they'll share it in a certain percentage. As for year you go down, the the liability that's going to be shared by the outgoing dentist is reduced to a certain point where it's okay, this person's been working for me for five years, they're gonna be entitled to a bunch of money anyways. I'm comfortable with that. So bake. clauses into the agreement to protect yourself, negotiate with the employee, negotiate with the outgoing dentist to, you know, share the liability. Or at the end of the day, maybe you just chalk it up to, you know, cost of doing business. I'm buying a company or buying a dental practice that has six long standing employees. Yeah, that's just the cost of my business now. If they've been there for 30 years, they probably know what they're doing. And If you're gonna relieve them of their duties, you should probably have a pretty good reason to do so and definitely document it because in the event they do file a claim in Supreme Court saying you didn't give them enough notice and they want hundreds of thousands of dollars from you, you can pull out your little log sheet that says, Well, no, they did this, they this, they this, did this, and I've talked to them about it. They didn't get any better, so I terminated them with cause. that's other way to get around it actually. Tyson Nagasaka: Hmm. That's crazy. Vishal Gill, CFP: Exactly. Tyson Nagasaka: Do you when you're walking a brand new dentist through this process? I mean, they're essentially going from being a an associate or even like an employee mentality to being a business owner mentality. Do you have to have conversations Amrit Dhaliwal: Mm-hmm. Tyson Nagasaka: that are educational on like this is this is the role that you're actually stepping into now? It's not just a money printing machine. Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah, I mean I I wouldn't say that's my place to give that type of advice. I'm not a a business counselor or a business professional or putting myself out to be some sort of business professional. But I mean the most that I can give them is just my experience and I know what my clients tell me. I have pretty good relationships with all of them still. So I know I talk to them and I, you know, continue to do their legal work for them when they need it. you know, and just in general conversations, they'll tell me these kind of things. But there's there's no real the the one thing I'll say to my clients is you know when you when you buy a business you're probably a business owner first before you're a professional whether it's a medical doctor or a a dentist or optometrist or whatever it is. you should take some time with the outgoing practitioner and you know be a sponge learn as much as you can Learn as much as you can from Susan, who's been there for thirty-five years. She'll she'll probably be the the most amount of the best resource for you in terms of what the day to day looks like at the business. So be a sponge. Don't don't put your nose up to anyone, you know, just yeah, be a sponge. That's that's my advice. Tyson Nagasaka: That's awesome. When you have these initial conversations with somebody that's they come to you and they're like, Emirate, I'm gonna buy this practice. Now I need to engage my my team. What are some of the questions that you advise them to be asking to kind of like open the doorways in their mind to like these are some of the things you should be looking for, questions you should be asking? What are some of the top ones that you kind of like advise new people to to be on the on the lookout for? Amrit Dhaliwal: I think the structure of the deal is very important and it can there's really two ways you can structure a deal, whether you're buying the assets of the business or you're buying the the shares of a company that own the assets, own the good goodwill and all the own the clients, if you want to call it owning a patient. but that is that that's a a big question. And that's not necessarily a question for a lawyer to s determine what makes sense. I think If you're buying, it's better to buy an assets. Just based on my conversations with accountants and tax professionals and professionals like yourselves. I think for buying professionals, you want to buy assets because you don't take on the liability of a long-standing company. You're buying a a fixed item, a tangible item that you can depreciate and amortize a certain way. and your accountant obviously will help you with that. and Sellers want to do share sales generally based on what I've been told. especially because when you're selling the shares, money comes to you personally. I think you can maybe Sean and Tyson, you can allude on this a little bit more, but you can maximize your lifetime capital gains exemption to save as much tax as possible. So when you're doing discussing whether it should be structured a certain way, you're looking at mostly tax efficiencies. and from a legal standpoint. you want assets because as I mentioned, you don't want to take on the history of a long-standing corporation. We don't know what we're gonna find when we peel back the wallpaper, peel back the drywall. You know, there could be tax debts, there could be c la lawsuits that are in the pipeline or maybe that are already out there. We haven't dealt with it or haven't dealt with it properly, maybe properly. Maybe you have a release, but it's insufficient release. and because maybe you didn't have your lawyer draft it, you just had Chat GPT draft something for ya. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. Amrit Dhaliwal: so that's a big one. How to structure the deal, tax efficiencies, protect yourself legally as much as possible. asset versus shares, you can reduce the price based on shares potentially because you're taking on significantly more liability, plus the vendor is getting a benefit from a tax efficiency standpoint. second thing you maybe also this is a question for the vendor and the vendor's rep is you know how much of the the the figures that are on the financial statements that you know what we've used to determine the purchase price, how much of that is the product of the vendor's own output, their own production? in the the dentist space, you know, there's multiple people that work their hygienists and the dentists. How much of the income earned or the EBITDA is based off of the vendor's own production. And if it's minimal, it's probably that's you're you're looking at more of a business running a business. If it's fairly high percentage, now you're looking at potentially just taking on a job and having a large loan associated with that job. I think I've beaten the the employment angle to death on this, but that's another thing, you know. What's the employees look like? How many staff members? How long have they been there? Is there employment agreements? we want to get that information from the vendors as well. you're you want to discuss with the landlord. You want to get that question out of the way. Are you gonna allow me to operate this business here? Maybe they just don't like you and they're like, I'm not gonna give you a renewal on this lease. you want to get that out of the way as well. and then any regulatory issues, any CRA stuff, that kind of stuff. So these are all questions for your team. Your lawyer can answer the legal stuff. Your accountant can answer the tax stuff. Your financial planners can assist you in the the the strategy and the financing portion of it as well too. How to take your money most effectively. those are the main things I think I would want to know. Tyson Nagasaka: Great list. Vishal Gill, CFP: Love it. Yeah, great list. And I love that one about the best list, best list ever. Amrit Dhaliwal: Best list. Vishal Gill, CFP: And I I love that point about where's the revenue being derived from. that's something we talked about last week on the episode as well that we we see often. and it's one of the first questions. You can have a clinic that's just absolutely crushing it, but you run the risk of like a key employee that's leaving, which is the original dentist. So if they are let's just say a multi generational clinic and gen two is the one that you're eventually buying from and they don't have a gen three, so selling it to you. a lot of that could be like legacy clients that like that person, they work with that person, they trust that person. So additional services, specialty treatments, all that revenue is really just derived from that trust that that person has in the community. And we see this a lot in like rural communities. And not to say they're not valuable as far as clinics go, but to Amherst point I think that's really well put is you're really just being a hardworking employee With the debt associated to being a hardworking employee. Whereas you could just go be an associate dentist or general dentist somewhere else or local wherever you want to get the flexibility of traveling. just one of the things you that's one of the first questions I always ask when our clients first approach us of like, hey, are you looking at buying this dental clinic? That's one of the first things we pointed towards as well. Okay, just find out where the revenue is coming from. That'll almost kill the deal right away. If it's like, hey, it's pretty much all for this person, that's not really worth it. so that's that's one of the first things that we look at, unless It is derived from that person and you are seasoned or experienced enough to optimize that. Whereas, okay, this revenue is derived from this dentist. I'm not too worried about that because I know how to send it down to the hygienist or power the hygienist. And then I can also add some specialty treatments as well. Then it can make sense, but at least you Amrit Dhaliwal: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: have ammo to underbid for lack of a better term, the asking price on that. And then you can work with your lawyer to structure it how you want structure it. One of my last question or our last question actually, you kind of answered some of it already, which was, you know, what are some specific things in the deals that you'd like to see and what's your preferences mostly? Is it asset sales? Is it is it share sales? you answered that one already and it seems like asset is really the way to go. and it's more advanta advantage, more favorable from the buyer's perspective. anything else you want share as far as like what's on your wish list? The best list. but your your wish list for on the buying side, is it? favorable terms, is it like bioles for dentists, like a anything that you like to see? Amrit Dhaliwal: I I like having transitional agreements where the outgoing vendor sticks around for a bit. 'cause like Vajal, you were saying, like in in a situation where this this outgoing vendor has a really good relationship with the patients, they can smooth that transition over a little bit. so I I like seeing associateship agreements or independent contractor agreements baked into the deal as like a condition, like okay, you're gonna stay on for a year, two years, and I'm gonna pay you a certain percentage and maybe you gotta pay a little bit extra, but you know, like I'd mentioned before, be a sponge, having that person in there day to day, especially if you weren't already an associate or locum at that practice, you're gonna learn a lot in that first year. so I like baking those into the the agreements. I like vendor takebacks, because you know, you don't have to deal with the banks too often. And they can the vendor takebacks can assist with that, you know, maybe lack of liquid funds that you might have at closing or, you know, in that first 365 days post closing. yeah, I mean I I don't have necessarily have a preference for drafting or negotiating share purchases and asset purchases, but asset purchases a little bit cleaner. You know, you have a probably a pretty expensive machine at a dental practice or optometry clinic or whatever it is. And at the end of the day it's just it's got a an serial number associated with it. You go to your account and say, hey, what do you think this is worth after X amount of years in service? You put a number on it and you attribute this purchase price to each of those assets and you amortize it a certain way. It's a little bit cleaner on my end. the due diligence is a little bit cleaner and a little bit more streamlined as well. but I have no problem drafting forty, fifty page share purchase agreements. That's what I do. Vishal Gill, CFP: Is the best at it. On that point, you talked about vendor take backs. And we mentioned it a couple of times. If you just can explain in in in basic terms what what is a vendor take back. Amrit Dhaliwal: so essentially it's just the vendor is loaning you the sum of the purchase price. So if you're buying something for a hundred million dollars and the vendor's gonna loan you back or loan you the eight hundred thousand dollars or whatever it is to buy the buy the practice, you're just instead of paying money to the bank, you're paying money to the vendor. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah. So s seller Vishal Gill, CFP: Mm-hmm. Tyson Nagasaka: financing what what other areas would call it, right? Yeah. Amrit Dhaliwal: Tell our finance. Yep. Tyson Nagasaka: That's like d in your agreements do you do like what b what would be termed like earnouts? So if the if thirty percent of the client base leaves, are you do you have a clause baked in to protect the buyer from like, hey, all these clients walked when you left or they were poached or or whatnot? Amrit Dhaliwal: We have our s our non s non solicitation, non competes, after, you know, if the associate if she stay on as an independent contractor, those kick in after termination or mutual termination of that. earnouts and all that stuff, you know, we have we have our we have our standard clauses for all those as well too that we put in. But at the end of the day it's a negotiation. So depending on what side I'm on, most of the time it's on the buyer's side and we're trying to protect our buyer as much as possible. So we have very aggressive, you know, language for her notes and all that kind of stuff. but then it's just stripping it back to everyone's equally unhappy. Vishal Gill, CFP: And you know, it's it's really funny that you mentioned that because in our closing thought, what I was wanting to leave the audience with is the reality of lawyers. And this is one thing that I see a lot when we work on files and refer files out and kind of monitor it. because our our job is a strategy, then we need specialists like yourselves to to help with all that stuff. One thing that I find funny is people think lawyers are like how they are on TV shows or or dr TV dramas where okay, well, my lawyer is a good negotiator. That means he's going like a like a pit bull and they're gonna be yelling at each other and and being unreasonable and and this and that. For the most part, what we've seen, and I'm curious to know your opinion on it as well, Ember, but the best lawyers as far as negotiating are you know ones that want to collaborate with each other. It's the smoothest way, it's the best way, it protects both clients. And at the end of the day, in this example, both clients want the clinic to be successful. It's in everyone's best interest to Get a good deal. The definition of a good deal in my eyes are something that makes sense for you and me at the same time. Is it optimal? Do I get everything that I want? No. Do you get everything they want? No. But where are we willing to compromise and sacrifice on to make the deal happen? And that is what a good lawyer does is give you as much paperwork in the beginning to protect you from ever needing to go to litigation. And secondly, have a collaborative approach. So when they're negotiating, it's actually in good spirit and good terms. And it's just it's just kind of happening. Yeah, this doesn't make sense. We're thinking about this. What are your thoughts on this? And and just it moves smoothly as opposed to being contentious and you know, prefer conflict because that stalls everything. So that's just my opinion Amrit Dhaliwal: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: based off what I've seen. But just curious in closing, what are your thoughts on that? Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah, I mean there's a time and place to be aggressive, you know. there's certain things that are non negotiables, certain things that are deal breakers, there's certain things that are negotiation points that you can concede on. There's certain things that are, you know, if it goes this way, that's fine, it's not a big deal. the the thing that I like most about drafting is because, you know, we're At this firm, we're born litigators. That's what we do. We are in court all the time. And so we see where contracts fail. we see where litigation stems from, you know, poorly drafted contracts or maybe ambiguous contracts. So we use that experience and when we prepare our our documents. I necessarily not an overly contentious person. I think I can easily deliver s you know, my proposed revisions to counsel on the other side. And you know, if they're not good with it, I can advise my client, be like, hey, they're not good with it. I don't think you should continue with this deal and we just walk away. I think most of the the lawyers that I've dealt with in the especially in the BC bar were all pretty cordial. Not too many lawyers that I've encountered on the transactional side where they are overly contentious contentious and want to fight over unreasonable things. so my experiences have been generally pretty good that, you know, that could be different for other people, but I like to think when, you know, I'm on one side, the lawyers have a pretty good good time dealing with me. yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: And in this segment of the episode, I'm just gonna name the names of the bad lawyers. I'm just joking. It's it's actually this person, this person, this person. Amrit Dhaliwal: Yeah. Vishal Gill, CFP: no just joking on that one. But in closing, Tyson, anything that we forgot to ask for for while we have the lawyer here, while the tab is running and the retainers being drained as we speak, you know, what what do we wanna add on? Tyson Nagasaka: No, I think that was good. there's definitely other areas where I think maybe we can spin it off into another episode. But I think this was a really, really good base case understanding of rather than the the rest of the financial team or the accounting team saying you need a good lawyer. this is a g an example of like what the lawyer or the legal side will bring to the table and what they're essentially paying to protect themselves from. And you did a great job. Amrit Dhaliwal: Thank you. Thank you for having me, fellas. Vishal Gill, CFP: Of course. And in closing, Amra, there's gonna be a lot of people that probably have follow up questions or perhaps are looking to do a purchase. So if they want to get in touch with you, where can they find you? Where how can they reach out? Amrit Dhaliwal: yeah, I'm at a a law firm in Langley, Alliance Lawyers, LLP. office number, you can you know call and get get a book an appointment with me free 15, 20 minutes. We can just have a chat, discuss what you know what your plan is and what your goal is, and then if we need to dive in a little bit deeper, we can sit down and have a chat. we can do it over Zoom, we can do it over a cup of coffee or whatever it is. but number at the office is seven seven eight two seven seven two five five nine. If you want to send me an email directly, make sure Vishal will post it somewhere, but it's just Amrith A R I T at Alliance Lawyers with an S dot ca. Vishal Gill, CFP: Yeah, we'll put everything in the the show notes and link it there. And the good thing about having coffer coffee with Amarh is he doesn't just meet you. Someone actually hand brews you a coffee and brings it to you. So it's not coffee what you Amrit Dhaliwal: Like like a chemist. Tyson Nagasaka: Mm-hmm. Vishal Gill, CFP: breaking bad, but like coffee, it's wild. amazing. Well, Amrit, thank you so much for spending the time walking us through buying a dental clinic. It is one of those things that can make or break your career. it can really catapult you into a unlimited earning potential and and it is really fun. owning a business. I'm sure there's many memes that you see online where it's like big red eyes where it's like, this is fine, everything's fine. But if you get a good lawyer, everything is fine. Then it can be a great career with unlimited earning potential and can put you and your family onto a a different path. But it can also be a huge liability if you don't do your due diligence and buy the Ron Clinic. That ends up being an anchor as opposed to a sale. So hopefully this episode gave you some direction to equip you to have leverage in the conversations when they eventually arise. And you're working at a clinic and someone brings up partnership or buying them out or things like that. These are some questions you can ask to do some due diligence. Anything besides that, you can reach out to Amrit and and start that journey from there. So until next time, see you on the next episode of Portfolio Talks.