Latest / Building Brand Gravity: Attracting People Into Your Orbit / How AI Shook the Foundations of Ethics and Industry in 2023
Transcript
- 0:06You are listening to Building Brand Gravity Attracting People into your Orbit, a GNS
- 0:12Business Communications podcast. This is a show for communications pros across industries looking to
- 0:19gain an inside of you into industry influence. You're about to hear a conversation
- 0:24with leading industry professionals talking about the importance of building business impact through sound brand
- 0:31strategy. Let's get into the show. Hey, everybody, welcome to Building
- 0:37Brand Gravity. My name is Ann Green. I'm a principal and managing director
- 0:42here at g and US Business Communications and soon to be CEO here at the
- 0:46agency, and I am very excited to be curating a conversation with the wonderful
- 0:52Kyle Turner, who is our Digital Growth Director. Kyle. Welcome, Hello,
- 0:56Hello, glad to be here. Hello, Hello, So we're here
- 1:00to talk about the year in Generative AI. It has been a year,
- 1:04and I would say it feels like one hundred years since the Moniker Chat GPT
- 1:10first exploded into our consciousness, just last November twenty twenty. Now, kudos
- 1:15to those who already knew all about it long before. I know you're out
- 1:19there, but for most of society it was last November, and it's kind
- 1:23of amazing to live through a moment when a new tech utterly captures all aspects
- 1:30of our imagination and really simultaneously shifts conversations everywhere in business world, tech world,
- 1:37academia and also like your mom is asking you about it, So you
- 1:41know, Kyle, I'm sure you're having lots of conversations with family members too.
- 1:45And as we close out twenty twenty three, and the reason we wanted
- 1:48to talk today is the big question for me is, as long time integrated
- 1:53marketing communications practitioner and a counselor and an organizational leader, where are we now?
- 1:59And then where is this going? And how fast? So I would
- 2:02venture to guess that there's about sixteen million podcasts of this kind looking at JENAI
- 2:07at the end of the year. And Kyle and I do not have the
- 2:10energy nor the time to recap every advance that's happened in generative AI into twenty
- 2:15twenty three. But I think our goal today is to take one another's temperature
- 2:22on where AI is now. The big advances run down how our industry,
- 2:28integrated marketing communications and all of its forms has started to learn and adapt and
- 2:32incorporate and talk a little bit about what we see what's coming for the year
- 2:38ahead, including I think, Kyle, you said what is BS and what
- 2:40is not BS? So does that sound good to you, Kyle? I'm
- 2:44excited to get into that for sure. Yeah, exactly. So just to
- 2:49start it off, Kyle, first question for you, what's one of the
- 2:53big technological advances in JENAI from twenty twenty three that really made you stopping your
- 2:58tracks or get interest? Yeah. I've been seeing a lot in this space,
- 3:02as as I'm sure you have to me. What stopped me in my
- 3:07tracks? I saw earlier this year. I was talking with one of our
- 3:12colleagues here an AI model was used to spot pancreatic cancer and high risk individuals
- 3:19up to three years before diagnosis. Now, this follows a similar story I
- 3:24saw maybe about four years ago of an AI model using being used to spot
- 3:30brain cancer using blood samples. So what does that say to me? It's
- 3:36we're at the precipice of I think some really interesting and life changing and in
- 3:40some ways probably life affirming ways that I think AI can start to change the
- 3:46way that we do medicine. This kind of predictive stuff, which we'll probably
- 3:50get into later a few times, is where I find the most excitement.
- 3:53I think as a cancer survivor especially, you could make the argument that despite
- 3:59the research and the dollars that have been poured into the cancer spaces early now
- 4:03maybe last like four or five years, starting to see some real sea change
- 4:06in the way that cancers treated diagnosed, and I think AI represents just yet
- 4:14another way that we can get to diagnoses faster and hopefully give more people a
- 4:19chance to live a life that they want. Yeah, it's interesting you said
- 4:24that because having had former clients working in the cancer space like Memorials and Cuttering,
- 4:30there was so much talk about IBM Watson in the early days and maybe
- 4:33overhype of what its capabilities would be in the cancer space, and when it
- 4:39didn't immediately deliver on the dream that you know, we saw out there,
- 4:45there was almost like this huge skepticism to say, oh, look it's overhyped,
- 4:48it doesn't work. Meanwhile, I think the truer thing was those are
- 4:53some of the early tests and learnings, very early of AI in that space.
- 4:58Obviously IBM has one X now they're very advanced in this area, but
- 5:02it is interesting to see now, and you and I have been around long
- 5:08enough I certainly have to see a lot of tech cycles. There's stuff that
- 5:12in the early blushes is not going to fully make it and people kind of
- 5:15say eh, but then it's cooking along the whole way. So I think
- 5:19that's an exciting one. I mean, I think for me, the thing
- 5:23that blew me away this year is not maybe any one advance. It's just
- 5:28the speed of it all and how listening to even deep experts who've been in
- 5:33the development realm of AI for many years talk about how much exponentially faster this
- 5:40is coming now than they had seen before. And also just it is,
- 5:46as I said earlier, really wild to be both a human being and a
- 5:50professional around and awake and alert and mindful when the lightning bolt hits and everybody
- 5:58says, I don't know what to make this, but it feels so different
- 6:01and powerful. So I think I think that's a really, really, really
- 6:04big one, you know, in terms of so we've talked about sort of
- 6:10the big picture, like what's that thing that really stopped us in our tracks,
- 6:13But there's a lot of milestones and breakthroughs happening that have started to certainly
- 6:17affect our industry. You know. I'll start on that one. For me,
- 6:23it's watching Ai be baked in everywhere, you know, very very quickly.
- 6:27We went from the large language models, you know, and open Ai
- 6:30made a very deliberate decision to release that to the public. And it's actually
- 6:33really interesting to see the coverage behind the scenes after that whole insanity. That's
- 6:39kind of getting more into how the soup was made there and why open ai
- 6:42decided to release chat GPT when it did. But we knew very early on
- 6:46that it needed to be baked into enterprise products that we're already using. And
- 6:50the speed with which that's happening has been really really striking me. What has
- 6:56struck you on some of the front in terms of actual milestones and things being
- 6:59really use this year? You know, when you said the speed is striking
- 7:04you, I wanted to ask why you were surprised about that, and I
- 7:12only asked because of this. I remember reading long ago, and I used
- 7:15to work in media planning and buying. I saw a chart I'm sure you've
- 7:17seen it too, that shows the speed at which different technological advancement hit one
- 7:23million users. I think by the time you get to Facebook, that happened
- 7:27in like a week, you know, starting with like radio, which took
- 7:30you know, five ten years. You know Moore's law, isn't it is
- 7:33Moore's law that dictates like change accelerates with change. I think I've been I've
- 7:40been on this this boat and for so long I've been waiting for to see
- 7:46the practical uses of generative AI, and I guess that's what's exciting me the
- 7:51most. You know, you can say striking too. I am starting to
- 7:56be a lot more interested or a lot less interested. I started there with
- 8:00the projections of what jenai could be, and way more interested with the practical
- 8:05day to day uses of it. Now I've told you this. The more
- 8:09that I use platforms like Dolly or gpt for or claud or whatever it is,
- 8:16the more creative ways I think of using it. And I think that
- 8:22also speaks to the ways that GENAI is changing right now. To your point
- 8:24about the speed, I think since Sam, especially since somebody like Sam Altman
- 8:30has been kind of empowered by the staff at open AI, I only think
- 8:35that we're I mean, just going to continue to accelerate at this point,
- 8:39and we're going to have to get smarter, much faster about the ways in
- 8:43which we protect our ethics when using this stuff, because it's I think the
- 8:50practical uses are going to expand just as exponentially as the technology itself is.
- 8:56Yeah, you're so right, and I think you're right to ask me that
- 8:58question. And I show be surprised at how fast things develop the curve,
- 9:03Like if I think about one of the last seismic shifts, which was really
- 9:07the right to web, the meaning WordPress, typepad, I don't need to
- 9:13code, the web is open to me Web one. Yeah, and then
- 9:16social media. That arc of adoption of process change, of societal change happened
- 9:26at a certain speed. This one's coming even faster. I think something you
- 9:31just said, Kyle, and I had a session internally yesterday here at GNS
- 9:35with many many of our colleagues, just to talk about the state of jen
- 9:39Ai, what we're seeing, what it's baked into now, what our roadmap
- 9:43is, et cetera. But we had a lot of fun with prompts in
- 9:48the chat, prompts for the human beings, not for the AI. And
- 9:50we are asking folks to share some of the uses they do at work or
- 9:54at home. And you're right, Kyle, like the diversity and createsivity and
- 10:01in some cases, the total randomness, but you're like, seriously, you
- 10:05thought to do that? That's so random, but it's so smart that I
- 10:09was kind of stunned, And it was funny in the chat to see other
- 10:11of our colleagues being like, whoa, I never thought of all these things,
- 10:15so that to me, I think something came to my mind. It's
- 10:18like you light a sparkler, you know, at fourth of July, and
- 10:22all these sparks start to fly off of it. That's what it felt like
- 10:24watching the chat, like all this creativity and energy that just seems to feed
- 10:31on itself. And maybe that sounds a little bit like the experience you're having.
- 10:35Oh oh for sure, I think like kind of crystallized for me.
- 10:39I started using it a while ago, maybe a couple of weeks ago,
- 10:43to help me draft And this is why to even admit this, but I
- 10:48asked it to help me draft a conversation with my five year old because our
- 10:54zones are changing here, so his school that he's in now is not going
- 10:58to be a he will be able to attend without some alternate, some extenuating
- 11:05circumstances next year. So I asked chat GPT GPT four specifically like, give
- 11:11me the draft of a conversation that explains to a five year old why he
- 11:15has to change schools in a year from a school he doesn't like or he
- 11:18that he likes a lot. And I thought that the way that this thing
- 11:22framed up a conversation like this was fascinating to me, Like not something I
- 11:26would have thought of doing six months ago. However, and this is why
- 11:33I'm being specific about citing GPT for GPT four is a more advanced version of
- 11:39the open aas GPT, so it is a little smarter, a lot smarter
- 11:43honestly about picking up on cues and understanding prompts than three point five was.
- 11:50It was fascinating. I thought that the way that it framed this up,
- 11:54obviously from the perspective of the parent, it framed it up as a situation,
- 12:00a playground. These these are ways in which I had not thought of
- 12:03using it, but helping you navigate real human interactions, not replacing them,
- 12:09but kind of giving you a way to frame your mind around potentially difficult conversations.
- 12:16I think sounds it sounds maybe this topic in some ways, but to
- 12:20me it is almost therapeutic. It gives you a way to kind of get
- 12:28your thoughts out, help you organize them, and then perhaps come up with
- 12:31a more productive way of having a conversation that perhaps may have been harder to
- 12:37have previously. Kind of primes you for that. That's such a fascinating example.
- 12:41And see that's just another thing of like wow, you know, just
- 12:45see experiments, see what it does. It reminds me, you know,
- 12:48in the discussion with our colleagues yesterday, a big theme came out, which
- 12:52is helping you think about things in a fresh way or maybe coming at it
- 12:56from a different corner. And if you look at Deep Mind and their experiments
- 13:00with Alpha Go, you know, which built on what IBM did with chess
- 13:03earlier, you had this question of could a machine ever beat you know,
- 13:09the elite Go players around the world, and everybody knows the story now it
- 13:13did because it tried to move. That just was so atypical that a player
- 13:16that was decades and generations of human knowledge, that wasn't the way a master
- 13:22would play the game. And it's that reminds me that It's like it's taking
- 13:26a conversation that you, as a parent, we usually approach in like a
- 13:31set variety of ways and bringing it into a totally different context, to bring
- 13:37it into our industry, the marcom industry. I feel like in talking to
- 13:41many agencies and many colleagues and many client side folks over the course of the
- 13:46year, because it's such a top I mean, all of us are talking
- 13:48about it all the time. How are you using it? What are you
- 13:50doing? The real theme right now this year is experimentation to implementation, And
- 13:56I use implementation loosely because as it's not as fully realized in many ways as
- 14:03it will be. I mean that's obvious right now, but people are trying
- 14:07to put the rubber on the road in terms of how are we going to
- 14:09use this. So if you look back at twenty twenty three, Kyle,
- 14:13what are some of the early implementations you've been seeing in our industry or contexts
- 14:16that have been interesting to you? Well, you know, I think we're
- 14:20still at the nascent stages of what's possible in PR, PR and comms.
- 14:26For JENAI, I see the most readily applicable ways to use JENNI would be
- 14:35in data and analytics. I think the more that you are leveraging data to
- 14:41make decisions, the more help you will likely need to interpret that data,
- 14:46especially now as we are getting access to more and more information. One of
- 14:52the ways that we are or that certainly that I am trying to leverage JENNI
- 14:56is to help with it media analysis, is to help with sentiment analysis.
- 15:03I think most of these tools are a lot smarter than tools like net base
- 15:09were, and that when they were using early versions of AI to kind of
- 15:11help or machine learning to kind of help understand how sentiment is coming through in
- 15:18people's commentary on social media. We're in a much smarter place now, and
- 15:22though we may be still at the early stages of what's possible in data generally
- 15:26in PR and comms, I do think that JENNAI gives us an opportunity to
- 15:31catch up to other industries like you know, marketings and media buying and playing
- 15:37around with data for decades basically, and so now we're I think, you
- 15:41know, I can see a situation where maybe we throw in a few examples,
- 15:46a few articles that highlight a client's crisis from you know, let's say
- 15:50a five year period, and then use an AI model to help kind of
- 15:56predict what crises may come up based on a PR an article. An advancement
- 16:02as a newsworthy item that our clients talk to us about, so that we
- 16:07can start to understand a little bit better how the past maybe influences our future
- 16:12actions. And I think you can use that same exact philosophy for content creation
- 16:18as well, like kind of just understanding what you should be able to reasonably
- 16:22predict about a person's reaction to a piece of content just based on how they've
- 16:29reacted to other pieces of content before. I mean, I think obviously we're
- 16:32still very early on in that, but to the points that we were making
- 16:37earlier. The more that we start to use this stuff, the more creative
- 16:41we we think of using it. And I think this is just one of
- 16:44those ways. The data side of this, I think is what really really
- 16:48excites me, and I think that's where a lot of smart organizations are starting
- 16:51to leverage it now. Yeah, and it's interesting. I think back over
- 16:53the course of my career, and it's always been exciting to watch the convergence
- 16:57of major trends and themes. So I early in my career I got to
- 17:02watch the early advent of mobile phone working and wireless, and then the early
- 17:07advent of the transformation of the financial services industry into online, and then some
- 17:12of the really interesting technologies that were in the physical world, like contactless,
- 17:18you know, like tapping to get into the subway. One of the earliest
- 17:21examples that that was in Singapore and the Singapore metro system. And then suddenly
- 17:25you had this all come together into the mobile phone. You needed iPhone,
- 17:30you needed the financial services industry to come to a certain point, You needed
- 17:33certain other technologies like RFI D and others. But when you converge together,
- 17:38suddenly you have mobile wallet and tap to pay and Apple Pay and et cetera,
- 17:42et cetera. Right now, what you just said, we are at
- 17:45a convergence point of all the discussion that's been had about big data. Remember
- 17:51when that was the term big data? And then data takes me back exactly
- 17:56big lakes and you know, pools of data that everybody was talking about as
- 18:03if that was the answer. No, that is actually the problem. I
- 18:07have this data, What do I do to derive value? Then we heard
- 18:11about machine learning? How will that help us? And then we hear about
- 18:15predictive analysis. Well, predictive that sounds exciting. How does that work?
- 18:18Now we're seeing the convergence of all of this and Clearly, there are many
- 18:22professionals and industries that have deeper into this, as you said, that have
- 18:27already been unlocking this. But I think now it's the proliferation of it across
- 18:33enterprises and even into the consumer realm that's so exciting. And yeah, I
- 18:38agree with you, that's going to unlock value in ways for our clients and
- 18:42for ourselves that we've only thought about in the past and hoped for. As
- 18:48a leader of a company with one hundred, one hundred and fifty two hundred
- 18:55plus people, how do you realistically think about implementation of some of these using
- 19:00some of these use cases as examples. I mean, cause you sit in
- 19:03a place where you're kind of getting a thirty thousand foot view of the goings
- 19:07on in the operations of g ands, But you've also got to think of
- 19:12like practical on the ground implementation too. So where do you find the threads
- 19:18that allow you to anchor some of this more conceptual thought into like real tangible
- 19:21action. As an organizational leader but also a practitioner, you know, I'm
- 19:25still an active counselor and media and presentation trainer and practitioner. I feel it's
- 19:33incumbent upon us to think at multiple levels at one time. We need to
- 19:38think one hundred thousand foot as in, what does this mean to society?
- 19:42How will this change how we live? What does this mean to be human?
- 19:47What does it mean about authorship? How do we understand the ethical dimensions
- 19:52about humans will interact with this unbelievably powerful technology, and can an agency like
- 19:59our survive into the future. That sounds this topic, but I mean that
- 20:03very seriously. What will our business look like? What will our services look
- 20:07like? How do we bring the best of ourselves augmented by technology to be
- 20:11the best partners and counselors. So that's one hundred thousand foot level, But
- 20:15then you're right, I have to zoom down onto the ground to say how
- 20:18do we actually operationalize this and some of the things you and I are invived
- 20:22involved in, Kyle, with our Genai team here, it's going to be
- 20:26very much about the big picture. But then also what are the use cases?
- 20:33How do we separate them into pillars? What are the pilot tests,
- 20:37how are people are really using it? What are the ethical guidelines we need
- 20:41to put around this? Based on my work with the PR Council, and
- 20:45how do we both experiment and support business model. So you know, I
- 20:49don't know if you have any reactions to that, but I think it requires
- 20:52all of us to be very elastic and flexible in our thinking, go big
- 20:56and then zoom in, I do. I mean, you know, we're
- 21:00about to get into a conversation about the industry adapting to some of these,
- 21:04uh these changes, and you know, I don't want to spend too much
- 21:08time naval gazing. However, I do think that, you know, kind
- 21:14of pursuant to the title of this podcast, I think the brand gravity around
- 21:21our agency and probably about around a lot of legacy agencies will probably need to
- 21:26shift, and probably, you know, it's worth it to think of the
- 21:30ways in which we maybe need to adjust how we brand ourselves. I think
- 21:33everything you're talking about makes total sense. And you know, having dedicated people
- 21:38here that you've picked to be at the forefront of this experimentation and having and
- 21:44give them like actual tangible tasks, it's paramount here. But I even think
- 21:48the way that we talk about this agency, as we start to blend some
- 21:52of this technology into our day to day, I think that's really going to
- 21:56be what's necessary for most organizations, really ourselves included, you know, as
- 22:02we start to change and adapt to some of these some of these new techs
- 22:06and new ways of doing things. Yeah, and part of it will be
- 22:08I'm not doing the same thing that I did thirty years ago when I came
- 22:15into integrated marketing communications at a very large agency person Marstellar. And of course,
- 22:21yes, my role is different. I'm not entry level now. But
- 22:23nobody and this is the funny example, but there's a billion of these.
- 22:27Nobody is cutting out press clips and measuring columnches and pasting them onto a piece
- 22:33of paper. That sounds absurd now, But the reason I say that is
- 22:38jobs changed, agency capabilities change, client needs change, client organizations changed.
- 22:45Sometimes that changes fast and really painful and disruptive. Other times it's such a
- 22:51slow arc that suddenly you wake up and say, my god, how much
- 22:55our lives have changed. I think if we can pivot into what we speck
- 23:00to come in the next year or so and what you know, very practically
- 23:03but also bigger picture, I think that what I'm going to be watching,
- 23:07both as a practitioner, as a colleague and as a client counselor and as
- 23:11a leader, is where is the change going to be fast and where is
- 23:15it will be a more steady organic arc where hey, it's just getting baked
- 23:19in. Oh we're unfolding abilities. Oh we can work faster versus Wow,
- 23:25we really need to shift what people are doing, like we need to make
- 23:27that decision tomorrow or today. We need this tool, this platform, and
- 23:32I think you're right call it. It takes a lot of intentional thought about
- 23:36and also what is it that client organizations will need. One of the most
- 23:40fascinating things I've watched over the years is which capabilities live where and who feels
- 23:47they need them. Who is it that brought web development in house, agency
- 23:51or client side? And then when was it farmed out again to partners who
- 23:53are specialized. How many people are on internally on a social media team,
- 23:59how many are doing content internally at a client? Where are they using an
- 24:02agency for that? Where do we begin an end? There's a million answers
- 24:06to that question, but I think part of it for us is also understanding
- 24:10where the human begins and ends, where the machine begins and ends. Conversation
- 24:14that came up in the town hall we were doing yesterday. Listen, I
- 24:18think most people when taught, when you talk to them about this. I
- 24:22think we'll probably have a somewhat fearful reaction at worst and cautious one at best.
- 24:30I think there's probably merit to a blend of those two sentiments. Honestly,
- 24:37however, I'll say this, the fact that we and other agencies like
- 24:40US are starting to explore and sign on pilots and partnerships, I think that
- 24:44shows some of that thinking as being shed. You know, caution is justified
- 24:47to an extent. I think no one really knows what the next five ten
- 24:51years are going to look like when it comes to jobs, especially in the
- 24:55comms industry. You know, I've seen a couple of studies. I will
- 24:59not try to cite them here, just google them, but I've seen a
- 25:02couple of studies. Yeah, I could see a couple couple of studies that
- 25:06talk about the industries most that are probably going to be most affected by generator
- 25:10of AIS, preponderance PR, comms marketing, writing like all that stuff.
- 25:15I mean, it's it's near the top of the list, and all of
- 25:17them not surprising. I think all that just means, though, is that
- 25:22the ways in which we think about how to use this stuff in these advancements.
- 25:26I think you have to. You have to, to your point,
- 25:30move both with caution and with intention, but you also have to be curious
- 25:36enough. I love the for the phrase curiosity. I think curiosity is one
- 25:40of the more redeeming characteristics and anyone can have. You got to be curious
- 25:42enough to actually try some of this stuff for yourself, to my point earlier,
- 25:47identify the ways in which you're using it that could spark more esoteric ways
- 25:52of using generative AI, and then use that as a guide to maybe on
- 25:57a larger scale, what you can implement and what actually maybe you need to
- 26:02take more time to do. Yeah, part of what I'd love to sparkle
- 26:06myself and others is the joy of this exploration and experimentation while being really clear
- 26:12eyed about cautions and concerns and also possible very difficult futures if we as a
- 26:18society and as human beings don't stay attentive to that. I think we are
- 26:25at our best in this field. Counselors, thought partners, innovators. We
- 26:33are called on because we're not in the day to day, every day with
- 26:37each of our client organizations their talent, and they're situated in the business that
- 26:41they're in we stand at a crossroads of many industries, and that's supposed to
- 26:48be our goal and our role, and we can never lose sight of that.
- 26:52And it's not a defensive posture at all. It's actually a really celebratory
- 26:56one because it does celebrate curiosity and intellectual rigor and being open and cross pollination
- 27:02and multiple industries and what are we learning. But we have to remember that
- 27:06our value is to bring that spark back to those who are contracting with us,
- 27:11you know, spending their you know, valuable capital to bring us in
- 27:15as partners. So if I look ahead to the future, you know,
- 27:19let's both think for a minute about what are we most excited about over the
- 27:22next like one, two, three years. I'm pretty excited about AI everywhere.
- 27:27I'm very excited about it being baked in in all kinds. I mean,
- 27:32there's such an explosion of development and creativity on the technology front, especially
- 27:37as these platforms open source or allow folks to you know, create off of
- 27:44them, and also as the larger entities allow enterprises to sort of create their
- 27:49own large language models and you know, predictive models, et cetera. So
- 27:56that's exciting. So that mass integration and I'm also really excited in the next
- 28:02year about really leaning into the places that we can make ourselves more efficient and
- 28:08creative where things were a little bit rote before. It's always hard. You
- 28:12get the most amazing talented young people who come in and you're like, hey,
- 28:15there's this stuff that you have to do that is a little bit rote.
- 28:19But if we can make that more strategic and fun and interesting and faster
- 28:26and smarter, that they can then add value to places where that human instinct
- 28:33is there. I think that's amazing. I mean, what are some of
- 28:34the things that you're excited about. I mean, you heard me talk about
- 28:37this at the beginning of the podcast, and it's been this way for a
- 28:41while. But I really think that the biggest and most interesting advancements are probably
- 28:48going to be in medicine. I want I hope that's the case, Kyle,
- 28:53I really do. I mean, that's an amazing opportunity, man.
- 28:59I think the diagnosiostic abilities of AI are probably its strongest suit. Its ability
- 29:03to digest, find connections, build on identify trends that are probably often missed
- 29:12by humans. I think that creates so much potential for being able to find
- 29:18diseases, being able to diagnose people early, and to my point, earlier
- 29:22give them a better chance of living. I think the less kind of I
- 29:30guess life changing examples that I can cite. I love the ability to create
- 29:37images. I think the Creative Spaces is obviously handering a little bit because of
- 29:42this, and for good reason. You know, a lot of what the
- 29:45writers and directors and the actors have been fighting over is about ownership of IP
- 29:52and how things like Generat Vegi models are being fed. However, I see
- 29:59it as a potential for expanded imagination. I recently used Dolly to give me
- 30:06an idea for a tattoo, and I'm not expecting to walk into a tattoo
- 30:11parlor with this exact thing. In fact, Dolly has a weird thing where
- 30:17if you if you gave it my son's name, but it kept misspelling it
- 30:21weirdly. Ad letters, remove letters, it was combined letters, just keep
- 30:26It's keeping us on our toes. It's making sure that we don't understand what
- 30:30the hell is going on. Yes, exactly, but I had I had
- 30:34that idea of you know, my son's name emerging from the water for years
- 30:41and really couldn't properly articulate how it should look. But this gives me at
- 30:48least a starting point that I can talk to an artist about to actually make
- 30:52it something real, something tangible, something a motive for me. And I
- 30:56think that's where a lot of I think smart creators are using it just as
- 31:00an inspiration engine, like, oh, let me just spit this idea out
- 31:03and see what it comes back with, and then maybe I can take that
- 31:07and tweak it and change it. Just because I now have a physical representation
- 31:14of something I was just thinking. I think that's really powerful. Our creative
- 31:17team, and even folks beyond our formal creative team who are exercising their own
- 31:22creativity. We have people at Gens to do so many different things, but
- 31:26our creative team is really leaning into this and understanding its edges and boundaries and
- 31:30pushing those edges and blank page brainstorming. And also, you know the enterprise
- 31:37piece, the baked in piece. When platforms like Adobe bake some of this
- 31:42capability right into the tools we're already using, that just is a game changer,
- 31:47right, So you know, simple things like hey, there's a photograph
- 31:51with two people and I need only one of them, and I'm going to
- 31:55have AI erase them and fix the background and seconds what you used to take
- 32:00some careful work over maybe an hour or so to really get it right.
- 32:05That is the kind of removal of friction and speed that then allows each individual
- 32:10here, each professional, to bring even more of themselves to what we do,
- 32:16you know, and that to me is really really exciting. I think
- 32:20that brings me to the places as a counselor where we need to exercise thoughtfulness,
- 32:27caution, advice. I'm still I used to work with ASCAP years ago,
- 32:32the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, and I was very
- 32:36involved with digital copyright issues in the early days of Creative Commons and post Napster,
- 32:42and you know, this world now is supercharged some of the issues like
- 32:46the rights of creators, the proliferation and digital of IP ownership payment. I
- 32:53think we as agency people need to keep intellectual property law, protection of creators,
- 33:01protection of people's images, and also authentic representations of things. Deep fakes
- 33:08misinformation is definitely a concern to me. I think you'd be completely Pollyanna and
- 33:14blind not to be concerned about, as you said, what are the choices
- 33:17that individual people or groups are going to make on how to use technology that
- 33:22is this powerful, So as we come into an electioneer, as we try
- 33:27to advise our clients and ourselves and what proper use is. I want to
- 33:30make sure that we're looking at this through an ethical lens and that we never
- 33:34lose in our excitement, that we also never lose the other side of the
- 33:37coin, which is what's a responsible and intentional use of this technology. I
- 33:43mean, what are your thoughts on that? Yeah, you know, when
- 33:45I think about policy, it is always really really nuanced thought for me,
- 33:54only because everyone whenever you write a new policies for a policy for something that
- 34:00nobody understands one hundred percent and that is constantly changing. I think we're probably
- 34:06still dealing with some of this with social media, honestly. I mean,
- 34:08it requires a certain level of understanding. And I think when I think about
- 34:15you know, I know we'll get into the future a little bit. But
- 34:16when I think about the future, I think about the ways in which people
- 34:20are going to try to regulate AI and whether or not the regulations are going
- 34:24to do more harm than good as far as our ability to understand how best
- 34:30to use it with intention like and I don't know that. Like I'm making
- 34:37some wild assumptions here obviously, but I do think that there's enough evidence in
- 34:43the ways that policy has been written for social media that we you know,
- 34:47you run the risk of not including like nuanced thought into how we leverage AI
- 34:53if you kind of are not just quick to advance it but also quick to
- 35:00overregulated. You know. I don't want to sound like a deregulation like mayven
- 35:05here, but I'm just I'm just bullish on advancement. And I think that
- 35:10the more you have people or a more diverse array of people who are willing
- 35:15to experiment with it, much like I said about more creative ways to use
- 35:20it, I think you come up with more creative and more nuanced ways to
- 35:24manage how to ethically use it. You know, I don't think any policy
- 35:29can stay stagnant. I think even ours at GNS, which is a good
- 35:32one, I think we'll probably need to change next year as this technology becomes
- 35:38more ubiquitous and it changes itself, and we're going to have to find different
- 35:44ways to think about what experimentation looks like and get more comfortable with how things
- 35:50that we maybe have felt comfortable doing as humans can either be come either obsolete
- 35:58or heavily augmented. Are our humanity can be augmented using some of the creativity
- 36:05that this might unlock for people? I think you're very right. The way
- 36:09I would phrase it is that regulation in the space is likely to lag.
- 36:15That's why it's incumbent upon us as counselors to our clients and experts in our
- 36:20field to create both the environment for experimentation, pushing opening up, transforming how
- 36:28we work, but also understanding what we think are the proper guide rails and
- 36:32what we feel is an ethical lens on the application of generative AI. I
- 36:37think that's going to be very very important. What's your advice for marcom's and
- 36:43PR professionals to stay ahead and just we cover the whole integrated marketing communications landscape.
- 36:50So what are you most hoping that even our own colleagues do in the
- 36:53future. I mean, honestly, I think experimentation is key. I think
- 36:59getting getting access to and using the most advanced versions they advanced models. You
- 37:07know, I think a lot of people still use GPT three and a half
- 37:10three point five and that is kind of their baseline baseline of knowledge for what
- 37:15AI kind of is and when you actually look at GPT four even even claude
- 37:23to an extent, and some of the other platforms that exist that are coming
- 37:29into coming online. Now it's way more advanced, you know, it's way
- 37:34smarter, it's it's way easier to kind of get at some useful responses.
- 37:39You know, I've even started using GPT four as like the facto replacement for
- 37:45Google right now. You know, if you if you write your prompts the
- 37:49right way, you can get a detailed answer on anything, way more detailed
- 37:54than what you would get from Google, because Google is just a collection,
- 37:58like a list of websites, as opposed to an articulation and explanation of why
- 38:02something is with citations, which is what you would get from CHATBT. So
- 38:08I would just encourage people in the marcoms industry to experiment with it, not
- 38:14just in prompt writing, not just in research, but in the ways that
- 38:17you can more readily show off tone and voice. You can ask AI to
- 38:27help you identify with the thesis of a pressure release of a blog post of
- 38:32a white paper is to make sure that your ideas are actually coalescing into something
- 38:38useful. And I think that just some of the things that I was talking
- 38:43about earlier with crisis prediction, I think I just thought of this, Like
- 38:49one way that you could I can conceivably think of using AI right now is
- 38:53to take an article about a crisis and maybe start playing with your prompts to
- 39:00see if there was a way this crisis could have been predicted, Like what
- 39:02ways could a crisis like this be prevented? And then maybe start building content
- 39:08off of those ideas. I mean, but that only comes with experimentation,
- 39:14right, Like, I think you have to just start playing with it.
- 39:16Yeah, I think you're right. Yeah, And I would my advice to
- 39:21colleagues in our industry and really beyond experimentation, but then also really lean into
- 39:28what we are talented at in this industry, which is critical and discerning,
- 39:32thinking what is the source? Can we go back and verify something in a
- 39:38world where AI is still suffering from hallucinations and it will get better over time?
- 39:45How do we ask ourselves? How do I know this is right?
- 39:49You know? What do I think about this? And also really lean into
- 39:52the collaboration you talked about augmented humanity. I love hearing people talk about what
- 39:57that could be in the future. And I think it goes in a lot
- 40:00of different directions, including in the physical world. But how do you take
- 40:05your skill as a writer who can iterate on different drafts, who you don't
- 40:09make as human as a human being? The first thing you write isn't the
- 40:14final draft. Usually you're going to iterate and you're going to learn something and
- 40:17what you intend to write may not be what the final product ends up being.
- 40:22So how do you use AI and the machine for lack of a better
- 40:27word, to help you iterate and use and lean into and open up more
- 40:30space for what makes us truly human? So to finish off today, because
- 40:36this conversation, as we said, could go on forever at this point on
- 40:40these topics, there's a lot of prognosticating out there, Kyle. There's a
- 40:45lot of people who have a lot of things to say, and I guess
- 40:46we're two of them as well. So I think we should call what is
- 40:52the pronostication that's BS and what is not BS. I think that's a good
- 40:55way to end. So I'll start with one thing that I think is a
- 41:01little bit of BS, which is what I'm calling the utopic dystopic binary,
- 41:07meaning it's either all awesome, or it's all the matrix and it's all I
- 41:15robot and they're going to destroy humanity. Right. So my feeling about people
- 41:21who have prognosticated about our industry over the years, as in the press release,
- 41:24is dead. All agencies are going down. There's never going to be
- 41:28any you know, stockbrokers again. You know, I've heard too many of
- 41:31these over the years. What I usually find is that the binary is the
- 41:36zeros I'm thinking is BS. The truth is usually in the middle, and
- 41:39usually what will happen is we will bring the best and worst of ourselves to
- 41:44it. That's right. I mean, you're spot on. I don't think
- 41:47you can go to extreme in either direction because that leaves you way open to
- 41:52missing a lot of really interesting, nuanced things. So I agree with you
- 41:55total BS. What's a BS for me is and I think you've heard a
- 42:01lot of people say this, the fear of human obsolescence by AI. Now,
- 42:08do I think that there is some very obvious negative outcomes that are possible
- 42:15with generator of AI gone unchecked? Of course, I'd be foolish not to.
- 42:20However, my thinking is, and this has been repeated ad nauseum by
- 42:24a A lot of people who are a lot smarter than I am. The
- 42:28most likely scenario is that people who don't use AI are going to be replaced.
- 42:32Just like with any new technology, the people who learn it, who
- 42:39adapt to it, who integrate it into their day to day experience often accelerate
- 42:45either professionally, socially, whatever have you, at a much faster rate than
- 42:50those who don't. Not to say that that it's impossible, but I certainly
- 42:52don't believe that human obsolescence is on the horizon. What I do think is
- 42:58that the world that we know, the world that we're comfortable with now that's
- 43:01probably gone forever, but it will just give rise to a new comfort,
- 43:07a new normal which we should all be familiar with. Thatfter COVID. Honestly,
- 43:12I think that's really yeah, it's true. We're having to go through
- 43:15a lot of change and embracing it and being open to it. So final
- 43:20advice, learn, self, educate, experiment, and we're going to keep
- 43:22going on that I know here and hopefully I just love learning. So for
- 43:28me, it's an exciting time to be leading an organization but also still doing
- 43:34the tasks that we love to do. So Kyle, thank you. And
- 43:37we really appreciate those who tuned in. This is Building Brand Gravity and we
- 43:40will see you back for our next set of episodes in twenty twenty four.
- 43:45Hi, have a great year. Guys. We are GNS Business Communications.
- 43:50We are a team of media strategists, storytellers, and engagement experts who meet
- 43:54you at the intersection of business and communications. To learn more, visit gscommunications
- 44:01dot com. You're listening to Building Brand Gravity Attracting people into your orbit,
- 44:08a GNS Business Communications podcast. Keep connected with us by subscribing to the show
- 44:14in your favorite podcast player. If you like what you've heard, please rate
- 44:17the show that helps us to keep delivering the latest in industry influence. Thanks
- 44:23for listening. Until next time.