Latest / The So What? / Neither a One-Day, Nor a One-Person Job
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website, jplantman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio. Hello and a very warm welcome to another discussion based on JP's latest
- 0:42newsletter. This one is dated the 20th of September 2023. The heading is neither a one-day nor
- 0:51a one-person job. It's your annual update on what's happening with measures to counter
- 0:58corruption in South Africa, but you start in the US with research done on corruption
- 1:05in that country between, what is it, 1865 and 1941. That was a period infamous for its
- 1:14corruption. What did the researchers find? Yes, indeed. It was a sort of dark period
- 1:19in American history and a period in which there was a lot of particularly corporate
- 1:24corruption. The two researchers found four things. The first one is it is possible for
- 1:33a system to transition from one which is absolutely corrupt to one where corrupt behavior is seen
- 1:40as aberrational. So we can get out of this. You can get out of it. That is the bottom
- 1:45line. I think we as South Africans can take some comfort from that. The fact that we now
- 1:51find ourselves in a system which is systemically corrupt doesn't mean we will stay there forever.
- 1:57That was the first finding. The second finding I think is equally important for South Africa
- 2:03and that is that the change in the US was not a linear one. It was incremental. It was
- 2:11uneven and it was slow. Incremental, uneven and slow. So there was no big bang. There
- 2:18was no upward graph that just went from the left bottom to the top right. And again, I
- 2:24think that is applicable to us here in South Africa. We tend to think, you know, if the
- 2:28NPA loses one case, then that is the end of all action against corruption. And that is
- 2:34simply not correct. The third one is, if you want to have a systemic curbing of corruption,
- 2:42then you must be willing to put resources behind it. The idea that the smallest state
- 2:48gives you less corruption is simply nonsense in the view of the researchers. It is the
- 2:53opposite. What you in fact need is for more money, more resources, more power in the hands
- 2:58of the law enforcement agencies to curb crime and corruption. I don't think we have a particular
- 3:04problem with that in South Africa, except perhaps for budget cuts. You know, we must
- 3:08be careful not to go too far with that. And then the fourth and the last finding was that
- 3:14it is not just about having high profile prosecutions, arrests and prosecutions. It is also about
- 3:23systemic change in the rest of the civil service. It's about ongoing institutional reform that
- 3:30gives you more effective institutions. And I think this last one is particularly important
- 3:35for South Africa. And I focus this note on that point. It struck me so much that I thought,
- 3:41well, it is worth mentioning it and then worth writing about that, which is what we do here.
- 3:47What are the institutions that you see that are coming through, which we didn't know before?
- 3:54Two in particular stand out. Both of them were initiated in February 2019 by the president.
- 4:01The first one is the SIU Tribunal, Special Investigative Unit Tribunal. Now, you may
- 4:07remember the SIU started its life during Mr. Mandela's term as president. Legislation was
- 4:14passed towards the end of the 1990s. And it's basically a unit government agency that specializes
- 4:21in reclaiming money that was lost through corruption or maladministration. And they
- 4:27use civil proceedings. It's not a prosecutorial agency. It is a civil litigation agency that
- 4:34reclaims money lost through corruption or maladministration. Is it part of the NPA?
- 4:40It's not part of the NPA. It's part of the Department of Justice, but it stands next
- 4:44to the NPA. Now, as I say, this dates from the days of Mr. Mandela. The problem that
- 4:49developed over time was because it's civil litigation, the unit always had to go to the
- 4:53high court. Nothing wrong with that, except that the queues in the high court are very,
- 4:58very long. And in 2019, the president announced that he's creating a tribunal which will
- 5:04hear SIU cases. Now, what is a tribunal? It is simply judges of the high court who sit
- 5:10as a tribunal specializing only on SIU cases. So no other cases served before them, and
- 5:17they only deal with SIU cases. So the role is not so overpopulated? The role is not overpopulated.
- 5:24The only people that can bring cases to that role, or put cases on the role rather, is
- 5:29the SIU, the Special Investigative Unit. Now, it is noticeable that since this change was
- 5:34made in 2019 by way of government gazette and presidential proclamation, the activities
- 5:41of the SIU have picked up quite considerably. So we quote the numbers in the book, in the
- 5:49note rather, in 2022, the SIU recovered funds and assets to the value of nearly 6 billion
- 5:54Rand, and they set aside contracts to the value of 5.5 billion Rand. So if they go through
- 6:01Transat, for example, or through ISCOM or any other place in the public sector, and
- 6:05they find that there are contracts which were inappropriately awarded, they can apply to
- 6:11the tribunal to have it set aside, and in fact this has happened. So it has got nothing
- 6:17to do with orange overalls. People are not being prosecuted, but it has to do with getting
- 6:22back the money, the ill-gotten gains of the corrupt, and it certainly is having a great
- 6:29impact. So that's the first institution, was the tribunal that was created to assist the
- 6:34SIU. The second reform, civil service reform or institutional reform that took place was
- 6:41that also in 2019 the president created an investigative directorate. Now this is a unit
- 6:48inside the NPA, and they specialize just on state capture and corruption cases. Hermione
- 6:55Conier was the first director, you may remember. Unfortunately, she resigned after about two
- 7:00and a half years and left, and Andrea Johnson is now the head of that unit. Now what is
- 7:08important about the ID or the investigative directorate is that it is a prosecutor-led
- 7:13agency. So when they investigate a criminal case, unlike the SIU which do civil litigation,
- 7:21the investigative directorate does prosecution. So it's a criminal process. They aim to put
- 7:26people in jail. They aim to put people in jail or orange overalls. And the way that
- 7:31they do it is to have a prosecutor-led investigative teams. The experience is that the prosecutor-led
- 7:40institution is just more effective and efficient than one where the prosecutors are not involved
- 7:45from the beginning. We had that in the scorpions. Can the ID, are they stepping into those shoes
- 7:53or not quite? Yes, they are. Conceptually they are. But remember, their mandate is more
- 7:58limited. They are only mandated to look at state capture and corruption, whilst the old
- 8:03scorpions could investigate any case. But yes, it is in principle exactly the same thing.
- 8:08So in that sense, the scorpions are coming back. Now what is very important is that legislation
- 8:15is now before parliament. It was introduced in September to make the ID a permanent unit.
- 8:22When the president created it in 2019, he did so by way of a presidential proclamation.
- 8:28Now that implies you can also abolish the unit with a presidential proclamation. And
- 8:33you will recall that the scorpions indeed were abolished, not by proclamation, but by
- 8:38an act of parliament. Now to give more permanence to the ID legislation is now before parliament.
- 8:45To make them permanent, to give them the prosecutorial powers and investigative capabilities. And
- 8:52to appoint permanent staff. At the moment they must rely on staff seconded from the
- 8:56Department of Justice or the Saratoga Police Service or the Intelligence Service or from
- 9:02the Revenue Service to come and do work in the investigative directorate. This should
- 9:07also increase their independence. It will certainly increase their independence and
- 9:11it will give them more oomph. And they are now busy recruiting people on the basis of
- 9:17this permanence. Now I was just pointing out that in parliament there was a lot of criticism
- 9:24of the legislation. Not because anybody is against it or at least not the people who
- 9:29criticized, but they wanted more. They wanted the ID to be made a chapter 9 institution.
- 9:34My approach to this is that one must not make the perfect enemy of the good. And to delay
- 9:39the whole process and go through a constitutional amendment and in the meantime you leave the
- 9:45ID at the mercy of a presidential proclamation is as far as I'm concerned not good politics.
- 9:52Because to introduce them into chapter 9 of the constitution. Will require a constitutional
- 9:58amendment process which is much more onerous than just an act before parliament. In any
- 10:03case I think the mood has shifted a lot since the time that the scorpions were abolished.
- 10:07Remember that abolition was tested in the Constitutional Court. The court found it
- 10:11was okay. Well it found that it was legal. It found it was legal. Quite correct. It found
- 10:18it was legal and fitted in with the constitution. One doesn't know whether the Constitutional
- 10:22Court today would again make such a ruling. Now right now at the moment the ID is working
- 10:30on 97 state capture investigations. They have enrolled 35 cases in court involving over
- 10:39200 people or 200 accused. Amongst the accused you find senior politicians, civil servants,
- 10:46former CEOs and also companies, corporate institutions, corporate heavyweights like
- 10:51Tongard Hewlett's, ABB, McKinsey and others. And the ID has also secured restraining orders
- 10:57valued at over 7 billion rand. So while the cases are going on the money gets frozen so
- 11:02that it cannot be spent. I must point out that one of the biggest victories of the NPA
- 11:08is that in December last year they extracted a punitive fine from the international engineering
- 11:14company ABB for fraud committed at ESCOM. This was in addition to 1.6 billion rand which
- 11:22ABB paid back in 2020 already for fraud committed at ESCOM. So clearly you know it's an indication
- 11:29of how corruption is not just a one-way street. You need two parties to participate in corruption.
- 11:37And once again it is not uniquely South African. And it's absolutely not uniquely South African.
- 11:40Because this is a well-known international, good repute.
- 11:45It's Swedish companies. Yeah, absolutely. Then the third institution that has developed
- 11:52is the Anti-Corruption Task Team or ACTT for short and it's exactly what the title suggests.
- 11:58It is the bringing together of several branches of the state. The intelligence services, the
- 12:04police services, prosecutorial services and so on to oversee joint action against suspects
- 12:12in particular cases. And to date as a result of the existence of the ACTT 554 people were
- 12:20arrested and 142 of them have been convicted up to the end of 2022. It's a unique thing
- 12:27in the sense that these arrests and prosecutions were the function of coordination.
- 12:33So this is not, I think South Africans are a bit cynical about more task teams, more
- 12:40coordinating bodies etc etc. So you think this one actually works?
- 12:45Yeah, look it's really simple. I mean crime is evolving all the time and crime is getting
- 12:50better financed, it's getting better organized, crime is becoming more professional. So you
- 12:54can't have that development on one side and the other side you don't take steps to make
- 12:58the anti-crime agencies not also more professional and better coordinated and better integrated.
- 13:05You know the one must balance the other. So no I'm not cynical about it at all, I think
- 13:10it helps to balance the forces between the people who commit crime and the crime fighters.
- 13:18And SARS is also participating in this fight? Absolutely, SARS has scored a number of important
- 13:24victories. They're using lifestyle audits and they're now busy with an unexplained wealth
- 13:29initiative which is most welcome. There was a bit of a rampage a few months ago when people
- 13:36who want to take their money out of the country had to declare where the money came from and
- 13:40some people misinterpreted this perhaps willfully as an extra form of exchange control. It's
- 13:46got of course nothing to do with that. It's got to do with where does the money come from
- 13:50that you want to take out and that you pay your due taxes on it. It's as simple as that.
- 13:55So SARS is also upping the game which I think is very good. And once again that is not unique
- 14:01to South Africa. Friends of ours who wanted to get money out of the UK had to go back
- 14:06in their own history for about 15 or 20 years and declare where it came from. Absolutely,
- 14:12they had to explain to the British bank the origin of the funds that they had in the UK
- 14:18before they could repatriate it. I suspect the grey listing also has something to do
- 14:23with this but I don't have concrete information on that. The private sector is getting involved
- 14:30in many areas of our public life. Can they play a role in this? Yes, there are three
- 14:35areas in which the private sector on an organised basis is helping government. The first one
- 14:41is energy, the second one is logistics, ports and railway lines or railway operations rather
- 14:48and the third one is crime and corruption. And it's the crime and corruption that is
- 14:51important here. Now a couple of things, the private sector created a thing called the
- 14:58Resource Mobilisation Fund and there is some 100 million rand I think in there and from
- 15:05that fund they give help with energy, with logistics but also to the NPA on crime and
- 15:11corruption. So the partnership is not between the NPA and individual companies. I think
- 15:16that's very important. It is with this collective institution. So there is no one on one partnership,
- 15:23no individual companies and secondly... So no one can buy the NPA? No one can buy the
- 15:28NPA and secondly the assistance that the NPA can get is only in kind, it's not money. So
- 15:34for example qualified legal people can be seconded to the NPA to help with prosecutions
- 15:41and I think that's what will happen and we also know that the private sector is helping
- 15:46to resuscitate the forensics laboratory of the police which should have a big impact.
- 15:53So yes the private sector is showing up and having a partnership with government which
- 15:57should give some dividends. All of these are new institutions, new approaches, what's happening
- 16:04with what you call the old workhorses of the NPA in the meantime? Yeah I think it's important
- 16:09not to forget what is there and there are basically three of them that we can refer
- 16:15to. The first one is the asset forfeiture unit which investigates cases of organized
- 16:20crime and can seize assets, money, assets, the proceeds of crime after they obtain the
- 16:27court order. So they have to investigate a case, build it up and convince the judge to
- 16:32give them that order. Over the past five years the asset forfeiture unit has obtained 1630
- 16:39freezing orders to the value of 12 billion rand. It's quite a big amount of money, it's
- 16:45quite a big amount of money and again it indicates that it's not just about audience overalls.
- 16:50The asset forfeiture unit has got nothing to do with prosecutions but they have to do with
- 16:56going after your government gains and getting it back. The money gets paid into CARA, the
- 17:02criminal asset recovery account and I will talk about that a little bit more just now.
- 17:06But the second unit apart from the asset forfeiture unit is the specialized commercial crimes
- 17:11unit in the NPA and they pursue amongst other things corruption involving the state and
- 17:16state owned companies. What is interesting here is that they have got 87% conviction
- 17:21rate of all government officials that they have charged. I mean that is a very good number.
- 17:28The other interesting thing about specialized commercial crimes is that they obtained 52%
- 17:36more convictions of people from the private sector than from people in the public sector.
- 17:41So clearly it's not just people in the, it's not just public servants who put their fingers
- 17:45in a cookie jar. And on the other hand it's not just public servants who are prosecuted.
- 17:51No absolutely. The private sector does also come into it. Yeah more people in the private
- 17:55sector are prosecuted and found guilty. And then of course the biggest unit in the NPA
- 18:01is the prosecuting services and they deal with 850,000 cases per year. Now you know
- 18:06how much is 850,000 cases per year? Well it works out if you work on 250 working days
- 18:13it comes to about 5,550 cases per day or 700 per hour. Now the country is big and you have
- 18:21got many towns and regional cities and so on. But still think about that for one central
- 18:27service to handle 700 cases per hour. It is quite a big operation. It's quite a big operation.
- 18:36And therefore once again the point that we can learn from the Americans, you have to
- 18:40keep on putting resources into that. You have to keep on building those institutions to
- 18:45make them more efficient, help them to cope with bigger and bigger volumes. There's just
- 18:50no ways around that. The prosecuting service actually has a very good track record that
- 18:56I don't think people know about. Yes in the High Court their conviction rate is 90%, in
- 19:02the regional courts it's 82% and in district courts it's 95%. These are impressive numbers.
- 19:11Some people will probably argue they only take cases which they know they can win, but
- 19:15what does they do? They take cases which they know they will lose. Don't people watch law
- 19:19and order? Indeed. I think the bottom line of these numbers is once you are charged by
- 19:25the prosecuting service, it's better to admit and get it over and done with than to run
- 19:33the gauntlet with these kinds of conviction numbers. And then CARA, you said you talk
- 19:38more about that? Yes, CARA is the Criminal Asset Recovery Fund. Now monies that are expropriated
- 19:44by the Asset Forfeiture Unit and by the SIU go into CARA, into this Criminal Asset Recovery
- 19:51Account and then the money is reallocated to fight priority crimes and it is there for
- 19:57the benefit of the victims of crime. Now many billions of rands have already gone into it.
- 20:04Currently it's about 3.5 billion rand, 3.4 billion rand and that is earmarked for building
- 20:11forensic capacity and to fight illegal mining operations. So the money comes back and you
- 20:17can use it again. But a bit of a, we've now said that they are actually doing better than
- 20:23one thinks, but then your next heading is they cannot do it alone. Yes and I think this
- 20:29is a very important point. That is why the heading of the piece as a whole is it is not
- 20:34just a one person job. There are two institutions which are completely independent of the NPA
- 20:40but which really impacts on the NPA's performance. The one is the South African Police Service
- 20:46because they do, remember they do the investigations, they have to take the statements, they have
- 20:50to collect the evidence and the other one is the court system. Now the South African
- 20:55Police Service is, there is a ton of empirical evidence available from for example the Institute
- 21:02for Security Studies on how the South African Police Services has become a dysfunctional
- 21:08organization as their budget has increased and parliament has given them the money. As
- 21:13their budget has increased by more than 80%, their performance has actually gone down.
- 21:20So there is clearly a need for huge people and institutional reform in the police. I
- 21:25think it is a matter of common knowledge that the Crime Intelligence Service is not giving
- 21:30us the kind of information that one would like. So there is work to be done in the police.
- 21:36The president has taken the trouble to start both people and institutional reform in the
- 21:41police. It seems to be the next area of work has to be the police service. Likewise there
- 21:46is the court system. Now the court system is completely independent of the civil service.
- 21:51They have their own budget, their own personnel, their own head office even and they fall under
- 21:56the control of the Chief Justice. But you know the Chief Justice becomes the Chief Justice
- 22:01because he is a good legal person, not because he is necessarily a good manager. And there
- 22:06are numerous cases where our court system is just not functioning properly and more
- 22:13work needs to be done to reform that as well. So these two institutions, the police service
- 22:17on the one hand and the court system on the other hand, are as I say standing next to
- 22:23the NPA, independent of the NPA, but it influences what is going on in the NPA.
- 22:30A bit of a side issue, but I think something that people really worry about. Consequences
- 22:37after the July 2021 KZN riots. It's now two and a quarter years later.
- 22:43Yeah I thought it would be interesting to just follow up on that. And that's what I
- 22:48do here. And I just do a very superficial reference to both the January 6 attack on
- 22:55Capitol Hill in the United States in 2021. We had the President Atoll riots in July
- 23:022021. And then of course in January 2023 there was the similar attack on the Capitol on parliamentary
- 23:10building of Brazil after Bolsonaro lost the election and Lula de Silva won. So you've
- 23:16got actually three of these cases that you can look at. And what I found interesting
- 23:20was that the first prosecutions in South Africa for KZN riots took place 14 months after the
- 23:26riots. In the United States it took exactly 14 months before the first people were convicted
- 23:31in court. You know now the Americans have got a formidable police and crime fighting
- 23:36machine. If it took them 14 months to get a prosecution, then maybe one can look at
- 23:41the KZN thing in a slightly different light. What have we actually done in KZN? Well we've
- 23:47seen 63 people charged up to date, until the date of the note, and 28 preservation orders
- 23:54that have been obtained by the asset forfeiture unit. For example one of them was a guy that
- 23:59was found guilty of commit of looting and creating damage. But he also lost his bucket,
- 24:05which was used to transport some stolen goods. So you know that's the role of the asset forfeiture
- 24:11unit. It's interesting to compare what we are doing and what the United States have done
- 24:18to Brazil. In Brazil the judiciary created what they called fast track courts to deal
- 24:24precisely with the January 23 riots. And they had their first case I think nine months after
- 24:31the riots took place. The riots took place in January and the first conviction was in
- 24:36September. So maybe it's something that we can learn from then in the spirit of institutional
- 24:41reform is to establish fast track courts for criminal for serious crimes like illegal mining,
- 24:47attacks on infrastructure, that sort of thing. That you get it through the court system much
- 24:52quicker and you can lock people up and claim their assets. So with all this data, so what?
- 24:58The first thing that strikes me is that we are not unique, number one. And number two,
- 25:04that as you said in the beginning, that the pattern internationally is that progress is
- 25:10incremental, uneven, slow. Yeah absolutely. I think those two points stand. I mean as
- 25:15we're sitting here talking, it is quite clear that some army generals, military elite in
- 25:21China is being prosecuted, locked up, whatever. We don't quite know. Even in Ukraine? In Ukraine
- 25:29there was a problem. So you know corruption is not a uniquely South African feature. And
- 25:35like those societies, we're fighting to move a system to a better place. And I think the
- 25:40other thing that you've already alluded to is the fact that the progress is incremental,
- 25:46uneven and slow. Forget about the quick fixes and quick solutions. There's no such a thing.
- 25:52You know some member of the commentary art said that the NPA or the investigative director
- 25:59should be involved in some 900 corruption cases. Well that simply doesn't have any
- 26:05contact with reality. You know the British have got an office similar to the investigative
- 26:11directorate known as the SFO, the Serious Fraud Office. It's older than the ID, much older.
- 26:17It's older than the NPA in fact. And it's quite a well-resourced resource company or institution
- 26:22rather. They've got 500 people working there. They limit themselves to about 100 cases at any
- 26:28given time. So the idea is specialized, focused, prioritized. Then you get the best results.
- 26:35And I think that's what one must bear in mind when we talk about let's just have prosecutions.
- 26:41But another so what that you lift up is that it's not just the institutions, it's also
- 26:48the people, the population that we must start seeing things in a different way.
- 26:54Absolutely. It's all about values. And what we learned from UN development is that value shift.
- 27:00Values are not permanent. And societies where they are permanent run into trouble.
- 27:05Now if you think about shifting values in South Africa, there was a time when the most wonderful
- 27:10people put themselves into contortions and twists to defend the inappropriate spending of the
- 27:17Kandla. Now it is a condition of the ANC that to run for office you can't have any serious charges
- 27:24against you. You know that is we've come a long way in a few years. And that process will carry
- 27:31on. That's how you move a system from one state to another. And the work that we're doing around
- 27:37institutions, around fighting corruption, around claiming money, reclaiming money and so on, it's
- 27:43all part of that process. And then there's as you say ongoing civil service reform but it has to go
- 27:50wider than the NPA. Yeah I think we've discussed that at length and don't have to but it's clearly
- 27:55a priority. It's clearly a priority the president must attend to. What about accountability in the
- 28:01private sector? I think that is an equally important point. We cannot shift the system away from
- 28:08tolerance of corruption while you have extensible corruption going on in the private sector.
- 28:15We hear about health professionals who fleece the system. We know about the advocates and lawyers
- 28:21who simply charge outrageous fees to the taxpayer. That kind of nonsense must also be taken up.
- 28:29It's about adherence to the rule of law and that can't be done by the NPA or even the government.
- 28:34It's the regulatory bodies in the private sector that must do that. The regulatory bodies for the
- 28:39legal profession, for the medical profession, for the auditing profession and so on and so forth.
- 28:44And it's corporates. It's corporates that mistake action against people who participate or
- 28:49assist in these processes. SAS is a very good pointer on that. They have prevented two or three
- 28:57deals that went ahead with the concurrence of big commercial banks. And when SAS brought tax claims
- 29:06and so on the deals fell apart. Now that for me is an indication of where the role should be played
- 29:12by the private sector. And then you end on quite a bleak note that there are new battle fronts in
- 29:21South African crime. Yeah look I think it's quite clear if you watch the news that organized crime
- 29:26gangs, illegal mining and extortion are crimes that are on the rise and that are causing havoc
- 29:35in certain communities. And obviously the crime fighting authorities must respond to that.
- 29:40So I think it's a fairly safe bet to say that once the ID legislation is passed by parliament
- 29:46and provided parliament provides money in the budget that we will get more IDs, more investigative
- 29:52directorates that will specialize on illegal mining, extortion, kidnapping and organized crime
- 29:58gangs. And that's the way that it should be. That's the way it should be and at least we are pursuing
- 30:03that. So it's not just a one-way street. I think that's the overall conclusion that I take away
- 30:09from doing this research and writing this note. There's a lot of pushback going on and all of us
- 30:16must climb in behind the pushback and help it. If you say it's not a one-way street what do you mean?
- 30:21Well what I mean is that you know it's not everything is done to favor the criminals.
- 30:25It's not that the criminals are running wild and getting away with things. The Guptas got away with
- 30:31her enormous amount of stealing and I'm sure a lot of that is still going on on the smaller scale.
- 30:37But the fact is the Guptas are no longer here. The fact is they're on the run. The fact is a lot of
- 30:43proceeds of corrupt activities have been confiscated either by the SIU or the asset
- 30:49forfeiture unit or frozen by the ID. So the money is being recovered and it's recycled into
- 30:58further crime fighting. So the battle is on and it's by no means lost. Thank you very much. Thank you.
- 31:08Thank you for listening to the So What Podcast. If you enjoy this content please don't forget
- 31:14to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 31:20Also tell your friends. Remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.