Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Wake Up Call (7.22.24): Loren Asmus, Canterbury Consulting
Transcript
- 0:00Thank you for joining us today. We're excited to bring you a
- 0:02brand new show from the On Ramp Media.
- 0:04Umbrella wake up call. Is a weekly show that will be
- 0:07streamed live on LinkedIn every Monday morning.
- 0:10To catch the premiere of each episode, follow On Ramps
- 0:13LinkedIn page and add Wake Up Call events to your calendar.
- 0:16After the live premiere on LinkedIn, we will distribute
- 0:19each episode across On Ramp Media's podcast channels.
- 0:21And YouTube page wake up. Call aims to educate financial
- 0:25professionals on the merits of the Bitcoin investment thesis,
- 0:28how this asset represents both a threat to legacy financial
- 0:31service businesses and an opportunity to differentiate
- 0:34oneselves and retain and attract new clients.
- 0:37Hosted by Mark Connors, Onramp's Head of Global Macro Strategy,
- 0:40and Rich Kerr, Onramp's President of Managed Wealth,
- 0:43this show seeks to provide financial professionals the wake
- 0:46up call they need, prompt them to have an open mind with
- 0:49respect to Bitcoin, rethink their prior assumptions, become
- 0:52more educated on the topic, and learn from others who are
- 0:55already farther down this path. Mark and Rich bring a combined
- 0:5860 plus years of experience across traditional markets and
- 1:01financial services and will share their unique perspectives
- 1:04and how their peers and colleagues can approach the
- 1:06realm of Bitcoin. Wake Up Call will feature guests
- 1:09from various backgrounds and industries will also share their
- 1:12own journeys to Bitcoin and how others can get up to speed.
- 1:15Now time for the show. Well, good morning everybody,
- 1:19and welcome to On Ramps wake up call.
- 1:22I'm Rich Kerr, President of On Ramp Managed Wealth and I'm
- 1:26alongside Mark Connors. Mark say good morning.
- 1:30Good morning, everybody and Rich, thanks for kicking off in
- 1:34usual wonderful form. Trying to look through what
- 1:37happened maybe over the weekend. You going to give us a little
- 1:39context? Yeah, you know, last week we
- 1:43started off with a bang. I no pun intended with an
- 1:47assassination attempt this week. We've got Joe Biden stepping
- 1:52down and I'm, I'm fascinated. Mark, I'd love your comments.
- 1:57Well, I think it's such a packed unprecedented in the last 30
- 2:04years, at least you got to go back to Johnson's Great Society
- 2:08really to see another president not continuing your term,
- 2:11another person coming in, a candidate being assassination
- 2:15attempt, at least this time. And what we forgot about was
- 2:19crowd strike, you know, planes not taking off the airspace of
- 2:22the US becoming desolate because of a global glitch.
- 2:26So it's so much going on, we are not able to digest it all.
- 2:31And I think that's one thing that we want to do here on wake
- 2:34up call. It's just talk about the
- 2:35opportunity in the markets for asset managers because it's you
- 2:41can be distracted by what's fast but fleeting and then what
- 2:45really is the nugget to take away.
- 2:47So hopefully, Rich, when with Lauren's help today, we can get
- 2:51that done. Rich, I think you may be on
- 2:59mute. Rich, did you have the leaf
- 3:03blower going in the background? Did you have the?
- 3:05Leaf blower, hey. Sorry, that's what I have.
- 3:07Yeah, I've got all sorts of chaos outside the window here,
- 3:11so forgive me, but yeah. So it we do have the distinct
- 3:16privilege today of sitting down and having a conversation with
- 3:19Lauren Asmus. And Lauren is a chartered
- 3:21financial analyst and chartered alternative investment analyst
- 3:26who is the Vice President of Investment Research at
- 3:29Canterbury Consulting. Canterbury's a $38 billion firm,
- 3:33and they focus on high net worth, ultra high net worth,
- 3:36family offices, endowments and foundations throughout North
- 3:41America. And correct me if I'm wrong,
- 3:42Lauren, I think you guys serve clients through Canada, United
- 3:46States, Mexico, maybe maybe another country that I'm
- 3:50forgetting about, but a sizable firm and one that that has done
- 3:57a little bit of work on Bitcoin along the way.
- 4:00And, and so we're delighted to have you here today as a guest
- 4:03to, to talk a little bit about how investment advisors,
- 4:07investment professionals might think about Bitcoin and how you
- 4:12as a firm at Canterbury kind of came to your conclusions.
- 4:15And so welcome, Lauren, we're we're thrilled to have you.
- 4:20No, thank you, Rachel. Thank you, Mark.
- 4:21Pleasure being here. Yeah.
- 4:23Well, maybe let's start off with A2 part question.
- 4:27So how does a large firm, I I guess like Canterbury, arrive at
- 4:32a decision to evaluate an asset like Bitcoin?
- 4:35And then what notable attributes or or rationale stood out in
- 4:41developing a Bitcoin thesis for your firm?
- 4:45No, I mean it. It's a good question, question,
- 4:47Rich. You know, I think even just
- 4:48taking a step back, you know, when we're, when we're looking
- 4:52at a new asset class or a new type of investment strategy or,
- 4:55or whatever it is, you know, we, we come in with the mindset of,
- 5:00of having an open mind and having a curiosity to it.
- 5:03And I think you need to have that specially sitting in the in
- 5:06a manager research seat, due diligence seat, you need to be
- 5:10able to take in a lot of new information, information maybe
- 5:14you haven't heard before. And then you don't really trying
- 5:18to cast a wide net across a lot of different groups out there, a
- 5:21lot of different thought experts, you know, like
- 5:23yourselves within the Bitcoin space and, and, you know,
- 5:27questioning and, and prod and, and try to get down to the truth
- 5:31of things. You know, we, we, we have a
- 5:32slogan on the research side, question everything, you know,
- 5:36and then we, we apply that across all of the asset classes
- 5:40that we cover and that we evaluate on behalf of our
- 5:42clients. And so when it comes to, to
- 5:45Bitcoin and, and digital assets, you know, for us it, you know,
- 5:50it really started doing more work and, and, and, you know,
- 5:53creating an internal working group, you know, 3-4 years ago.
- 5:56And even before that on the research side, you know, I
- 5:59predominantly covered credit and fixed income for Canterbury, you
- 6:03know, which includes core bonds down to high yield, down to, you
- 6:07know, private credit and, and hedge fund oriented strategies.
- 6:10And you know, even prior to, to us formulating an internal
- 6:14group, it was having discussions internally on the research side
- 6:17of, you know, what is this Bitcoin thing?
- 6:19What, what, what is digital assets?
- 6:20How could this fit or not fit in a client's portfolio?
- 6:24And so it really started with that curiosity first and then
- 6:28developed as time went on and as the asset class grew into
- 6:32creating an internal working group.
- 6:33So we can bring in thought experts like on Ramp and others
- 6:35out there to, to really dig into the asset class and how it may
- 6:40or may not fit for clients. So I know that's a lot there,
- 6:44very high level, but happy to kind of get a little more
- 6:47granular or wherever you, you, you both would like to take it.
- 6:51Yeah, I, I mean, maybe I'll, I'll kind of drilled down.
- 6:56So when you think about the merits of Bitcoin, I mean, you
- 6:58obviously you guys have developed a, an opinion.
- 7:02You you got curious around it. You developed a thesis, you
- 7:05started thinking about how it fits into the overall portfolio.
- 7:09Ultimately, you're doing due diligence on various ways to
- 7:12access Bitcoin. You know, maybe maybe highlight
- 7:16some of the things that stood out in your process, you know,
- 7:21as it relates to Bitcoin in particular, any, any unique
- 7:24attributes or characteristics that that created an aha moment
- 7:29for Canterbury where you went? Oh, wow, OK, that's, that's
- 7:34really relevant. Or maybe there's maybe there's
- 7:36three, maybe there's five, I don't know.
- 7:38But I'd love to hear your thoughts there specifically.
- 7:41Yeah, and, and I'll just just copy out that, you know,
- 7:44opinions across our firm vary and we have really good
- 7:47discussions and so you know, my opinion could be different from
- 7:50somebody else's and, and, and our client too, right.
- 7:52So we have, you know, at the end of the day, we need to be a a
- 7:55solutions provider for our clients.
- 7:57And so it's really about us providing good solutions for
- 8:01clients. I want to access something like
- 8:03Bitcoin. And so yes, we have opinions, we
- 8:06develop thesises, but at the end of the day, we want to be open
- 8:10to a lot of different ideas and, and, and opinions.
- 8:12And so, you know, we're not trying to canvas our clients to
- 8:15go a certain direction all the time.
- 8:17It it's more of, OK, how would you like to pursue or how would
- 8:21you like to look at this? And then how would you like to
- 8:23pursue it? And it's our job to go it out
- 8:24there and find the best groups and, and best partners to, to do
- 8:27that for, for our clients. And so from a thesis standpoint,
- 8:32even just taking a step back and, and thinking about digital
- 8:36assets, you know, we had discussions a few years ago
- 8:39about if we were to do this, how, how would we bucket it,
- 8:42right? Where would you place it?
- 8:43Because it is a completely new, different, distinct, nascent
- 8:48still asset class, especially when you compare it to equities
- 8:51and, and fixed income and, and, and even alternate other
- 8:53alternative asset classes. And so for us, it was about, OK,
- 8:59one, you know, find a place where we can bucket this, but
- 9:02then two, you know, how are you going to, to access it?
- 9:05And so we, we really canvassed across groups that focus on
- 9:08Bitcoin, groups that focus on other digital assets.
- 9:12And then really, you know, trying to find your point
- 9:14earlier options that fit clients specifically for what they're
- 9:17trying to do. And I think my opinion related
- 9:20to to Bitcoin is it's a scarce asset and it's scarce because it
- 9:26can have a 21 million supply that is enforced by a
- 9:31decentralized group of participants that run the
- 9:35Bitcoin blockchain. And so the the same, and I just
- 9:40said, I think both of all of us on this call would agree, but
- 9:43that's something that we would then discuss internally with
- 9:45other groups and, and, and, and, and with other individuals at
- 9:48Canterbury. And so it's it's one having a
- 9:51thesis, doing some of the work, but then getting together as a
- 9:54group and then discussing some of these merits and and
- 9:56considerations. Yeah, that's awesome.
- 10:03I think for me, and I mentioned this in last week's, you know,
- 10:07when you recognize the scarcity component of Bitcoin and you
- 10:13start to really evaluate the monetary policy of Bitcoin, all
- 10:16of a sudden everything starts to really click.
- 10:19And, and so that that rings true with me.
- 10:23I, I'm curious about return characteristics and, and, and
- 10:28volatility. And maybe, you know, there's a
- 10:30lot of people that believe that volatility is, is a feature and
- 10:34not a bug, you know, But that being said, I'd love to kind of
- 10:38hear your, your impression of the return characteristics and
- 10:42the merits from that standpoint. Yeah.
- 10:45I mean, the work that we've done and you know, there's a lot of
- 10:48other studies out there that show this, even even if you have
- 10:52a very small position in Bitcoin, you know, 1-2 percent
- 10:55it, it moved, it has historically moved the needle on
- 10:58your risk adjusted returns to, to the upside.
- 11:02And I think with volatility that, that is something that we
- 11:05get in terms of consideration. But as in the day, it comes down
- 11:09to portfolio sizing and, and, and how to think about managing
- 11:13that volatility within the context of the fully diversified
- 11:16portfolio. And so it, it, it's interesting,
- 11:20right, because you have this asset that has historically been
- 11:25one of the better performing assets, you know, over the last
- 11:2710 to 14 years, but the volatility has also been very,
- 11:32very high. But then at the end of the day,
- 11:37you look at the shark ratio or the risk adjusted type of return
- 11:40that you're getting and, and it's still very, very
- 11:44attractive. So it all comes down to how you
- 11:48size and how you position it. And then also just really at the
- 11:51end of the day, setting expectations and making sure
- 11:54that we're covering all of the risk factors with our clients on
- 11:58Bitcoin, right? There's, there are numerous risk
- 12:01factors and, and volatility is one of them.
- 12:02And I think it's it's a matter of making sure that that is very
- 12:05explicit when we're having conversations with clients and
- 12:08also explicit when we're discussing this internally.
- 12:15Rich, can I jump in for a second here on on a couple of points.
- 12:20Lauren, you kick this off talking about being curious and
- 12:24it's great because we all say things like we want to work in a
- 12:29place that's forward thinking yet preserves capital and trying
- 12:33to balance those two aspects about, you know, the leading
- 12:37bleeding edge so you don't miss the next opportunity versus, you
- 12:41know, preservation of capital, which is one of the larger not
- 12:44for your firm, maybe not, I mean, not in particular to your
- 12:46firm, but most asset managers there was to to change it to
- 12:53make an analog to another period, another active manager
- 12:58versus the firm like yours. In the 90s, I worked with a firm
- 13:04called Dawson Sandberg as a salesman.
- 13:05And so they were very big into tech and one of their key
- 13:12features was that they had this very large fund called the Scout
- 13:16Fund. And they had this very unique PM
- 13:22who was just could look at a lot of factors at once.
- 13:25I think there were hundreds of names in the portfolio, but he
- 13:29would size the opportunities, look for trends.
- 13:31And it was basically his fishing pond and it was a fishing pond
- 13:35for the principals of the firm and he would bring things in and
- 13:39manage them. It was the one of the better
- 13:40performing funds of the entire firm, but they couldn't scale it
- 13:43because the opportunities were so small.
- 13:45So when we look at that analogue to one of the more successful
- 13:49tech firms from the 90s looking at new opportunities in an
- 13:52evolving asset class or an evolving industry, tech related,
- 13:56Internet related. When you say curious, what are
- 13:59some of the processes that you, Lauren in particular or the firm
- 14:05engage in to make sure that that curiosity is being fed?
- 14:11That's a good question, Mark. It's, it's really a cultural
- 14:14thing. And that's, you know, one of the
- 14:16reasons why I've, I've really enjoyed being at Canterbury.
- 14:20And, you know, I've been with the firm for now over 11 years.
- 14:23And it's the fact that we have as a firm this natural curiosity
- 14:27to learn and to get better at what we do and, and provide the
- 14:30best type of service we can for our clients.
- 14:32And I think it's having the mentality of a, of a yes.
- 14:35And so yes, let's let's look into Bitcoin and then what
- 14:39should we do to make sure that we're doing it the right way
- 14:42and, and, and analyzing it in, in, in the most pure form versus
- 14:49no, this is too volatile. No, this is an innocent funny
- 14:56money, you know, magic Internet money facade.
- 15:02So I think it starts from this, from the very, very beginning of
- 15:04saying this is interesting. Let's look at it.
- 15:07It may not lead to anything, right?
- 15:09It may not lead to clients allocating, it may not, it may
- 15:14not produce any sort of defined outcome.
- 15:17But I think it's our job as a consultant to have a curiosity,
- 15:23be open to new ideas, because that's to your point, Mark, you
- 15:27need to be early on some of these things to, to, to really,
- 15:30you know, potentially enjoy the fruits of, of that investment.
- 15:34And if you have this, this no mentality at the start, you,
- 15:41you're just never going to never going to get there.
- 15:44And so, you know, bringing that all back, we're, we're in the,
- 15:48in the, in the job, in the market of finding best solutions
- 15:51for our clients to produce the best types of risk adjusted
- 15:55returns and, and meet their outcomes of what they're trying
- 15:57to do as an organization, you know, where, where they're
- 16:00effectively their investment arm.
- 16:02And it's up to us to make sure that we're doing that in the
- 16:04most appropriate way. And that you need to have a very
- 16:06open mind to, to, to really do this, this, this job, this role.
- 16:12Lauren, one of the more authentic answers and for the
- 16:15people listening, we we've only spent a few minutes prepping for
- 16:19this call. Everything's live.
- 16:21How many people, Rich Kerr, have you heard in our field say yes?
- 16:25And which is a very nuanced way of approaching something.
- 16:29It means that I have to have the temerity to be wrong, the
- 16:32temerity to not have everything line up to my existing protocol
- 16:36or my existing process in my firm and not have all the
- 16:38answers. But over time, that type of
- 16:41approach is that is part and parcel to an open mind, someone
- 16:46that does bring it this love that that the fact that you you
- 16:50answer the question by stating it comes with a mindset and then
- 16:54it goes to our process as a firm.
- 16:57Great. Thanks, Lauren, for that.
- 16:59Absolutely. I think it relates to on a
- 17:01personal level, right of, you know, I would, you know, say all
- 17:06three of us on a personal level probably took an attraction to
- 17:10Bitcoin because we had this yes and mentality of OK, there's
- 17:15something here. Let me look into it.
- 17:17Let me do my own research and, and figure out what what's here.
- 17:21And maybe it's nothing, but the fact that we're on this call.
- 17:24I, I think we, we maybe at least personally my opinion, we think
- 17:27that there's potentially something here.
- 17:30Yeah, it's a it, it certainly rings true with me, right.
- 17:34I think we were all, all three of us, you know, came from a
- 17:37traditional finance background in, in slightly different roles
- 17:41and spaces. And you know, it, it's, it's
- 17:45that intellectual curiosity that really helps tremendously,
- 17:51right. It, it's the way that we connect
- 17:52with clients. It's also the way that we
- 17:55evaluate, you know, our processes to support and and do
- 18:00well by our clients. And so no doubt about it,
- 18:05Lauren, I just, I loved hearing your response there.
- 18:08So, you know, maybe maybe this is a good point in time for a
- 18:14little disclaimer, because we obviously are talking about
- 18:17Bitcoin and, and I think it's important to always highlight
- 18:21that it that whether you're an investment professional and or
- 18:25not an investment professional and, and tuning into this live,
- 18:30live feed, it's important that you do your own research.
- 18:33And, and nothing that we're Speaking of here is construed as
- 18:37an investment recommendation for you.
- 18:42Everybody needs to have those conversations with their own
- 18:45financial advisor and, and evaluate whether or not it's
- 18:48right for you as an individual and, or as a firm.
- 18:51And, and so we're here just kind of building our strength and
- 18:54understanding around Bitcoin, how it integrates into financial
- 18:58services firms much like Canterbury, but also how it
- 19:03ultimately falls into the portfolio.
- 19:06So thank you for let me just take a little aside.
- 19:10So Mark what, what other things are you curious about as, as we
- 19:14sit here and, and have a conversation with Lauren about,
- 19:17you know, his process and, and maybe the broader Canterbury
- 19:21approach? So thanks for that, Rich.
- 19:24As, as Rich said, we all come from different backgrounds and
- 19:26mine was more on the hedge fund and institutional side as a
- 19:34hedge fund manager for a short period of time.
- 19:36But Moore as a chief risk officer at several hedge funds
- 19:40and then as a strategist speaking to funds from the
- 19:43platform of a bank that no longer exists, which speaks to
- 19:46the, you know, growing fragility of the banking system.
- 19:51So I bring that up as a launching point because Lauren,
- 19:56when you're speaking to people, it's hard to change process and
- 20:00say, hey, if you're, you know, if you only understand English.
- 20:03I'm going to send you a message in, you know, Greek or Spanish
- 20:07and maybe you can't take it on. So I've heard you talk about
- 20:11sharp and Sortino ratios when you approach Bitcoin with
- 20:15clients or even at an investment Policy Committee internally.
- 20:20What literally what's on the paper, just assuming it's going
- 20:23to start with a report and then you'll discuss to it.
- 20:26Is it numbers? Is it a fundamental view?
- 20:30What what what is the best way to, I'll call, create that
- 20:34attachment or that engagement with someone for the first time?
- 20:39Yeah, I know it's, it's really a, a wide range of, of things.
- 20:43And maybe, you know, from an, you know, from an internal
- 20:46perspective, you, you always hear, right, the institutions
- 20:49are looking into the SAS of class, right?
- 20:52They're doing their due diligence.
- 20:54They're, they're, they're putting in the work.
- 20:56You know, what does that entail, right?
- 20:58What, what, what actually goes on and really it, it, it's a
- 21:02really irritative process where, you know, it's, it's, it's a
- 21:05process that can take months to even over a year.
- 21:08You know, like I said, we, we started our internal working
- 21:10group four years ago. And so, you know, we have
- 21:13monthly or, or, or, or every other month committee meetings
- 21:16where we all get into a room or, or a zoom and, you know, we'll,
- 21:19we'll prep certain materials that you to talk about, given
- 21:24manager that's in the space or, or just, you know, the ask class
- 21:28in general. And then it's, it's a mix of
- 21:30things, right? It's looking at historical
- 21:32performance risk. It's bringing in thought experts
- 21:37and having them talk to our committees and any of their
- 21:40viewpoints and, and making sure we get a diverse group of, of
- 21:43people coming in and, and, and hearing different types of views
- 21:47as well. I think that's really important.
- 21:49And then it, it's just having those, those frank discussions
- 21:52at the committee level of, you know, what are the merits?
- 21:56What are the considerations? Is there anything we're missing?
- 22:02And then, you know, going back and forth with, with other
- 22:04thought experts out there and, and, and kind of getting more
- 22:06and more granular as you go. And so it, it does take a while.
- 22:11You know, there's, at the end of the day, it's a committee
- 22:14process, right? So you need to get buying from a
- 22:17lot of different types of, of stakeholders and people within
- 22:19the organization and, and people are at different levels of their
- 22:21education with Bitcoin or with what really with any other asset
- 22:25class. And so it's just a, it's just a
- 22:28time thing where it's like you're trying to get a internal
- 22:31consensus within your organization.
- 22:33And it's very different from on the personal level, right?
- 22:35Like you, I, you're rich, Mark, we can do our own research on
- 22:39Bitcoin and, and figure out what we want to do for our own
- 22:41personal stakes. And, and, but from a
- 22:46institutional side, when you're trying to get consensus and, and
- 22:49also from a fiduciary mindset of this is potentially going into
- 22:52client portfolios, it just needs to be more thought out and, and,
- 22:56and more more formalized. At Onramp, we believe that
- 23:00Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 23:04The hard part is securing it right.
- 23:07There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 23:09exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 23:12arrangement. Onramp solves for these
- 23:14concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 23:17solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 23:21ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 23:23possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 23:27your family is protected as well.
- 23:29On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 23:32whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 23:35to your existing self custody set up.
- 23:38For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 23:42Yeah, it's, it's such a great point.
- 23:44You know, it's, it's interesting you were talking about the, you
- 23:47know, the due diligence process and it may take months or it
- 23:50might take upwards of a year. Oddly enough, I had a
- 23:53conversation with a very large firm earlier or about a week ago
- 24:01today. And that being said, they have
- 24:05been developing a thesis since 2021 where and it's very deep,
- 24:11right? Like they're, they're going
- 24:13along the process and, and they're exploring the right
- 24:16things and they're, and they're bringing the right materials
- 24:19forward to educate the investment committee, but they
- 24:24still haven't arrived at that decision.
- 24:26And part of that right is you've got different generations that
- 24:30live inside of a large firm, right?
- 24:32You may have a principal that is, you know, has had and built
- 24:38tremendous success, you know, you know, doing things
- 24:42traditionally and, and within their ethos and, and their
- 24:45investment philosophy. And this is something so new,
- 24:48right? It, it's a new asset class.
- 24:52It is something, although it now has 15 years of track record,
- 24:56but it is a new asset class that requires a, you know, a
- 25:00different way of thinking. And so it's fascinating to me to
- 25:04watch how you have, you know, research analysts or portfolio
- 25:10managers or whatever inside of a firm that have really strong
- 25:15conviction around Bitcoin. And then yet you still have to
- 25:20be able to make certain that everybody arrives at that same
- 25:24place in order to have the conviction and and put the
- 25:27firm's name forward in front of clients with the idea.
- 25:31Yeah. Well, at least even just fully
- 25:33understanding the, the, the, the risks and, and the
- 25:36opportunities, right. You don't need to be an expert
- 25:39in it to, to, to, to get that. But you, you do need to make
- 25:42sure that you fully understand what those risks and
- 25:45opportunities are very, very explicitly across and everyone
- 25:48across the organization understands that as well.
- 25:51And then I would just say, right, we're covering all asset
- 25:54classes, equity, fixed income alternatives.
- 25:57And so just from a time allocation perspective,
- 26:00everyone's very, very busy, right.
- 26:01Our consultants are working directly with their clients on
- 26:03different parts of their portfolio, us on research are,
- 26:06are, are evaluating different types of, of asset class and
- 26:09strategies consistently. And so just from a time
- 26:12perspective, I'm sure other groups out there have to have a
- 26:15similar, similar story where it's just you got to split up
- 26:19your time and there's only so many hours a day to cover the
- 26:22whole investment universe. So these things just take time.
- 26:27Yeah, no doubt, No doubt. It's interesting, though.
- 26:30It it certainly feels like things are picking up steam.
- 26:35You know, I think there's been tremendous curiosity about, you
- 26:39know, what is Bitcoin? How do I integrate it?
- 26:42Do my clients need it? You know, how do we address the
- 26:46the most common question when a client is curious about, you
- 26:51know, inflation or the debasement of their currency or
- 26:54whatever geopolitical matters that are causing them a degree
- 26:59of uncomfort or confusion, one or the other.
- 27:04And so Bitcoin seems to be a possibility that kind of steps
- 27:08in and gives people confidence that they're at least insulated
- 27:12in some way, shape or form. So we're seeing a lot more
- 27:16curiosity on the on ramp side from all sorts of institutions,
- 27:21whether that be investment consultants, advisors, family
- 27:25offices, certainly and, and, and even pensions.
- 27:29And so it's it's fascinating to watch that groundswell of
- 27:34curiosity kind of build and, and, and I'm excited to to see
- 27:39how that plays out. No, I think that's, that's
- 27:44right. We, we've seen something similar
- 27:45internally at Canterbury. You know, like I mentioned, you
- 27:48know, we, you know, initially started looking back, you know,
- 27:5120/17/2018 during that cycle. And then, you know, we, we've
- 27:55effectively gone, most people within our industry have now
- 27:59seen, you know, at least two cycles of Bitcoin.
- 28:01You know, the, the ups and downs and the volatility and all that.
- 28:04I think the fact that it's, it's still here and, and, and you
- 28:08know, it's, it's continued to, to gain mindshare and, and
- 28:12market share. To your point, Rich, I, I agree.
- 28:15I, I think there there's just continuing curiosity to, to, to
- 28:19really dig in now and, and, and do more detailed work and, and
- 28:22look at this more closely. So Lauren, you Lauren Rich Rich
- 28:27asked you about you know, about the clients and and digging in
- 28:32to the bit to to Bitcoin for its own merits.
- 28:35Are you seeing anyone get curious about what's going on in
- 28:38the treasury market? You know, it's last, what, four
- 28:42years? It's down 3% annualized I think
- 28:45over the last three or four years about changes in, you
- 28:50know, is private debt the right place to go if there's no
- 28:52transparency or little transparency on on the
- 28:56underlying or history late stage cycle, you know, credit risk?
- 28:59Yeah. Are people.
- 29:01Because there's two things that like I ran to Bitcoin because I
- 29:04was running away from the other stuff that I was seeing.
- 29:06That's why I picked the book up because I saw, I saw the pathway
- 29:10narrowing and yeah, I didn't run to it.
- 29:13I ran from the other side. And are you seeing people still
- 29:17kind of clipping coupons, not worried and then getting slowly
- 29:21curious or are they concerned about purchasing power for their
- 29:25client portfolios going forward? That's a.
- 29:28That's a leading question, in case you couldn't tell there.
- 29:32No, I mean, I, I would say opinions vary across our client
- 29:34base and even with, with the groups that we partner with had
- 29:38a strategy level. And it's interesting, right,
- 29:43Because I think if you were to ask a fixed income manager,
- 29:47right, they're going to have very different views on fiscal
- 29:49deficits and, and they'll look forward basis for fixed income
- 29:53returns and where all that goes, right, versus talking about
- 29:58talking with the Bitcoin manager, right?
- 30:00They're going to have a very different view on where
- 30:01inflation is and, and the the value of the dollar going
- 30:05forward. And so it's really as a
- 30:07consultant, it's taking in all of those views, few points and
- 30:11making sure that those are conveyed to our clients.
- 30:13And, and, you know, trying to come up with, with the best, you
- 30:17know, diversified portfolio that, you know, at the end of
- 30:22the day, can, can fit in, in a, in a lot of different types of,
- 30:25of macro scenarios. And, and to be clear, we're not,
- 30:28we're not in the business of trying to forecast where the
- 30:32macro goes very, very difficult to do.
- 30:36You know, we're in the business of, of building diversified
- 30:40portfolios across a lot of different asset classes.
- 30:43And, and I'm working with the best partners and, and, and
- 30:47thought experts out there. And, and to my point O earlier,
- 30:50being open to different ideas. So no, I mean, you know, that's,
- 30:55that's how we view it. You know, really just just
- 31:00making sure that we're, we're open to all different types of
- 31:02viewpoints from the macro perspective.
- 31:05Yeah, and. You mentioned you know that your
- 31:09investment consultants are out there having these conversations
- 31:12with clients and, and you serve a, a, a wide set of clients.
- 31:17You know the high net worth, ultra high net worth, individual
- 31:20family office, endowment foundation, right?
- 31:24All different sets. Do you see one area or client
- 31:29segment that seems to be more curious about the asset and the
- 31:37inclusion of the asset in their portfolios over another?
- 31:41And and you know, I don't know whether or not you have that
- 31:43data or information in your role, but I'd be curious.
- 31:49Yeah. I mean, just anecdotally, we,
- 31:51we, it seems to be more from the family side where we've had a
- 31:54lot of more of the inbound interest in, in Bitcoin and
- 31:57digital assets in general, you know, but that's not to say that
- 32:02we haven't had some inbound interest from, from the E&F side
- 32:05too. You know, that that has, I would
- 32:07say has picked a bullet more as of late in terms of inbound
- 32:10interest or, or just questions from, from the, from those types
- 32:13of clients. And so, yeah, and I don't know
- 32:18if that has to do just with how clients are structured or, or
- 32:21kind of what their internal processes are in themselves.
- 32:25But but that's really been where we've seen at least, you know,
- 32:28inbound interest today it is more family oriented.
- 32:33But no, I think to your point, right, we, we saw news of a big
- 32:36pensions allocating a small percentage to Bitcoin and there
- 32:40seems to be some sort of news newsreel every month now of, of
- 32:43some other large organization and really kicking the tires on
- 32:46the asset and, and doing the, the, the deep dive.
- 32:49So and that I you know, my opinion that that's what we
- 32:53expected as you see the asset continue to grow and and be be
- 32:57more formalized. ETFSI think I've had a large
- 33:00part of that too. There's been improving January,
- 33:03February earlier this year that has really institutionalized the
- 33:06asset class. And then you have big groups out
- 33:08there that are actively promoting it and and and have
- 33:12their own products around it. And so that that all gives more
- 33:15and more credibility to to Bitcoin.
- 33:19That's very helpful and it and it makes sense, right?
- 33:22I mean, if you think about the origins of Bitcoin, it always it
- 33:25felt like everything was coming grass roots up versus, you know,
- 33:30being driven by banks in Wall Street, you know, from its
- 33:35beginnings. And so stands to reason that
- 33:38that curiosity is certainly there.
- 33:39But I, I do agree, you know, the, the curiosity of, of
- 33:45institutions, especially at once.
- 33:46We saw Swed make their announcement in May with their
- 33:50allocation. And while I'll be at a small
- 33:52allocation, you know, a very sizable allocation in dollar
- 33:59terms. And so that being said, it's,
- 34:01it's, it's got a lot of people paying attention and, and
- 34:06saying, OK, well, how the, how, you know, asking the questions
- 34:08that you're sharing with the audience today on, you know, how
- 34:12to, how do I do this? How do I do it smartly?
- 34:14How do I do it within my fiduciary responsibility and and
- 34:19ensure that I'm vetting all sources of ways to access
- 34:23Bitcoin in a portfolio or other assets in the crypto space I
- 34:26suppose. Everybody, everybody should have
- 34:28a Co host like Rich Kerr because you just brought a full circle
- 34:32back to my point about Dawson Sandberg with a scout fund.
- 34:38Now SWIB is a successful 9th largest pension fund.
- 34:41They have a setup that interfaces with Wall Street.
- 34:44And what what they did was a scout fund.
- 34:47They put 110th of 1% in. They said, let's see how you
- 34:50swim with the rest of the fishies in our portfolio.
- 34:52And that's exactly what they did.
- 34:54You know, to Lauren's point about being curious, they did
- 34:58the work. They're not wed to it.
- 35:00They're they're dating it. And that's exactly, you know,
- 35:04from the allocation standpoint, they've done enough to say,
- 35:07let's go. And it'll be, that'll definitely
- 35:11be. And we are watching the Edgar
- 35:14filings on that position up and down to see how it passes muster
- 35:20within SWIM. What you know, Bitcoin is one of
- 35:26the, at least from my experience, one of the few ask
- 35:29classes where it really came from this grassroots bottom up
- 35:32versus top down Wall Street. You know, when, when when we did
- 35:36our initial work, it was more from the curiosity point of this
- 35:39is interesting. This is different.
- 35:41It wasn't because some firm came in and said, hey, you should
- 35:44really look at this. We have a product that you know,
- 35:47we think may fit with your client.
- 35:48It was, it was more of grass roots.
- 35:51This is interesting. Let's do the work.
- 35:52And now you're starting to see groups like yourselves, you
- 35:55know, come in and provide really good institutional quality
- 35:58solutions for clients. Or typically it's the other way
- 36:02around, right? You get the product 1st and then
- 36:04you kind of see how it fits. This was this asset class is
- 36:07interesting from the bottom of grass roots.
- 36:09Now the products are starting to to come.
- 36:13Yeah, yeah, no doubt about it. And I think that that's the
- 36:16right way to be honest with you, because it gets people into the
- 36:19space of, of asking questions of the asset and really learning,
- 36:26you know, what, what it is, how it operates, how it fits into
- 36:32the overall schema and, and more importantly, you know, the, the
- 36:36global situation that we're in. And so I, I think it's a, it's,
- 36:40it's a, it's a fascinating, fascinating time to be alive
- 36:45and, and to get intellectually curious about everything that's
- 36:48coming down the Pike. And Bitcoin just seems to have
- 36:51hit at the very right time for the world, in my opinion.
- 36:57But that being said, I know we're, we're closing in on, on
- 37:02our time. Lauren, any, any closing
- 37:04thoughts or perspectives that you think our audience might
- 37:07benefit from that that you'd like to share?
- 37:11No, I mean, thank you both for having me.
- 37:13It's great to, to be on, you know, I would just say that, you
- 37:16know, if you're evaluating Bitcoin or really any new
- 37:21emerging ass class, you know, just just keep an open mind and,
- 37:25and, and ask questions. And I think that's really how
- 37:29you get down to, to making a decision for yourself or for
- 37:31your clients. Is, is asking a lot of
- 37:34questions, ask, you know, asking the opinions of a lot of
- 37:36different types of, of, of people out there and then coming
- 37:40to your own conclusion. And, but the only way you do
- 37:45that is if you have an open mind, you have this, this
- 37:47curiosity to, to want to take in that information.
- 37:51So you know, to your point, rich bitcoins been around for 15
- 37:55years, but it is still somewhat new for the traditional finance
- 38:01world and, and, and investment advisory industry.
- 38:04And so, yeah, I would, I would just say just keep an open mind
- 38:06as you're doing your own work on the on the asset.
- 38:10Yeah, and there and there's so many great partners out there
- 38:13that are are eager to help you formulate an opinion and and get
- 38:18the right resources to be able to formulate your own opinion.
- 38:21And that's really the critical piece of the equation.
- 38:24You know, Lauren kind of gave us some insights into Canterbury's
- 38:28culture, which is that intellectual curiosity.
- 38:31Just get curious about something and ask the questions and, and,
- 38:35and allow for competing ideas to be in the room.
- 38:39And, you know, I think that that's a winning, you know,
- 38:43culture in my opinion. And, and so think about your own
- 38:46culture as an RIA or investment consultant or whatever you might
- 38:52be, you know how it fits in. And, and I think you'll, if
- 38:57nothing else, be able to answer questions that clients bring to
- 39:01you in a really competent way. So do the work, right?
- 39:05Get curious. And and maybe one last thought,
- 39:11Mark, anything that we should be paying attention to this week?
- 39:17I know we've got Bitcoin Nashville, which in 2024, which
- 39:22is Lauren's backyard. So he's going to be, he's going
- 39:26to be hosting a lot of people. I'm sure he's like, no way.
- 39:31Nobody's getting in my house. It'll.
- 39:33Be it'll be, it'll be fun. But if anybody's out here in
- 39:35Nashville during the conference, happy to happy to meet and, you
- 39:38know, grab a coffee or, or just, or just meet up.
- 39:40But yeah, it will be pretty entertaining.
- 39:45Wild, but I think very impactful week in Nashville.
- 39:49Yeah. No doubt.
- 39:51And we've got rumors of Elon Musk landing in Nashville.
- 39:57Who knows whether or not he becomes a speaker, but Donald
- 40:00Trump is certainly going to be speaking and all sorts of
- 40:04speculation on what he might be talking about.
- 40:07I've seen things as crazy as the crazy, you know, maybe for the
- 40:13broader public, not so much for me, but I would.
- 40:16Talking about a potential backing of our or a Treasury
- 40:20reserve asset, Mark, any thoughts there on what we might
- 40:24see on that front? Yeah, you know, we always like
- 40:27to insert a movie quote here, Rich and Lawrence.
- 40:30So I would I would go back to Rocky Three.
- 40:34And the Clubberlang's prediction for the fight was pain.
- 40:40And I would say that that my prediction for the presidential
- 40:44election is not paying but printing.
- 40:48Whoever comes in is going to be spending regardless of party or
- 40:53person. And if anyone has access to some
- 40:58the 10 year, go look at what happened the day after Trump was
- 41:00elected to the 10 year on November 9th, the day after the
- 41:04election, it the the rate spiked like a 99.9 percentile move
- 41:10higher through 2%. And I don't know if it came back
- 41:14down again. So twin deficit Trump in 2016
- 41:18probably won't be any different than what the Democrats have
- 41:21been doing. And we have data on that to
- 41:24share. This is not political.
- 41:25This is an investment in macro call trying to frame what's
- 41:28going on in the broader world and then bring on guests like
- 41:32Lauren to say, how is that information being on boarded.
- 41:35So I'll leave it with that, Rich, to say, look through the
- 41:38noise of what they're saying and go to the policy and then look
- 41:42at the numbers, look at M2, look at that and then look at the
- 41:46market. Standing, thank you for those
- 41:50closing words, Mark. We appreciate it.
- 41:53Lauren, we are so grateful that you took the time to join us
- 41:58today and share some of your thoughts.
- 42:01We may have you back again and press press the conversation at
- 42:05some point down the road. But in the meantime, thank you
- 42:09for hosting the what, 25 to 50,000 people that are going to
- 42:14be coming into Nashville. We're, we're, we're thrilled
- 42:17that you're there in the epicenter and welcoming
- 42:19everybody at the airport with, you know, cowboy hats and, and
- 42:24other fun things, right? Yeah.
- 42:29And, and we'll and we'll be there too.
- 42:31Lauren, front and center. We'll see you.
- 42:33Yeah, no, looking forward to Enrich.
- 42:35Mark, thank you for having me on.
- 42:36This was a fantastic discussion. Really enjoyed it and look
- 42:41forward to continuing our conversations as well.
- 42:44Great. Thanks, Lauren.
- 42:45Thanks, Rich. Cheers.
- 42:46Thank you. Thanks for listening to this
- 42:50week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 42:53valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 42:55rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 42:57All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 42:59notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 43:02reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 43:05entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 43:08investment or legal. Advice, regardless of where you.
- 43:10Are on your Bitcoin journey? We'd love to hear from you.
- 43:13Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 43:17one of our private Client Advisors.