Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Company Is Hiring
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, here's a question that landed in the inbox this week, and I think it's one a lot of people are sitting with right now. The listener writes in and says, 'My company is on a hiring spree. We've got three open roles on my team alone, and I just found out one of the new hires is making more than I am. I've been here two years, my performance reviews are solid, and I want to ask for a raise. But it feels weird to ask when they're already spending so much on new people. What do I do?' Luna: That is such a specific and relatable pain point. And I love that you brought this up because I think the instinct is to feel like you're competing with the hiring budget, when actually the hiring spree might be your best argument. Lucas: Exactly. And let's be clear, this is not about being greedy or opportunistic. This is about market alignment. If the company is hiring, they're paying market rates for new talent. And if you've been there a couple years, your salary is probably lagging behind that market rate. So the question becomes, how do you frame that conversation in a way that feels collaborative, not confrontational? Lucas: Right, so let's talk timing. The worst thing you can do is ambush your manager in the hallway or bring it up during a team meeting. You want a dedicated one-on-one, and you want to give them a heads-up that you'd like to discuss your compensation. Something like, 'Hey, can we set aside fifteen minutes this week to talk about my role and the market?' That way, they're not caught off guard, and they have time to think about it. Luna: And I'd add, don't do it on a Monday morning or a Friday afternoon. Those are the worst times. People are either ramping up or already checked out. Mid-week, mid-morning is usually a sweet spot. Lucas: Good point. And the second part is the evidence. You can't just say, 'I deserve more money.' You have to show how your contributions have grown, and ideally, how they've saved the company money or generated revenue. So before you even have that conversation, write down three or four specific accomplishments from the past year. Maybe you streamlined a process that saved ten hours a week, or you led a project that brought in a new client. Quantify it if you can. Luna: And that's the part that a lot of people forget. It's not about your tenure, it's about your impact. The hiring spree actually gives you a nice hook, because you can say, 'I see we're investing in new talent, and I want to make sure my compensation reflects the value I bring on top of that.' Lucas: That's a great framing. And here's the third piece: the actual ask. You want to be specific. Don't say 'I'd like a raise.' Say something like, 'Based on my contributions and the market data, I'm looking for a ten percent increase.' Or whatever number you think is fair. And if you're not sure what's fair, that's where the hiring data comes in. You can use those new hire salaries as a benchmark. Luna: But that can get tricky, right? Because internal equity is a real thing. If new hires are making more, you might feel undervalued, but you also don't want to come across as if you've been snooping around in the payroll files. Lucas: Exactly. You don't say, 'I know Bob makes twenty percent more than me.' That's a one-way ticket to a bad conversation. Instead, you could say, 'I understand that new hires are being brought in at market rates, and I want to make sure my compensation is aligned with that market.' It's a subtle difference, but it's not about comparing yourself to a specific person. It's about the principle. Luna: And that's a smart way to handle it. So you've done your prep, you've scheduled the meeting, and you've got your talking points. What does the actual conversation look like? Lucas: So you open with the context. Maybe you say, 'I really appreciate the opportunities I've had here, and I'm excited about the direction the team is going.' Then you pivot to your contributions. 'I've led the X project, I've improved Y by Z percent, and I've taken on these additional responsibilities.' And then you make the ask. 'Given that, and given the market rates for my role, I'd like to discuss a salary adjustment.' Luna: And you mentioned market rates. Where can people find that data? I know Glassdoor and Payscale are options, but are they reliable? Lucas: They're a good starting point, but they're not gospel. Glassdoor and Payscale can give you a range, but they're often self-reported and can lag behind the market. A better approach is to talk to recruiters, network with people in similar roles, and look at job postings for similar positions in your area. If your company is hiring, you might even see the salary range in their own job postings, depending on the state. Some states require it. Luna: That's a good point. And I actually had a friend who used that approach. She saw a posting for a role like hers with a salary range that was higher than her current pay. She took that to her manager and said, 'I noticed we're hiring for a similar position at this range. I'd like to be paid fairly for the work I'm doing.' And it worked. Lucas: It's a powerful conversation because you're not being confrontational. You're just pointing out an inconsistency. And if the company is serious about retention, they'll want to fix it. But you have to be prepared for the possibility that they say no, or that they say 'not right now.' Luna: And that's the part I think we should dig into. What do you do if the answer is 'we don't have the budget' or 'we'll revisit this at the end of the year'? Because that's a common response. Lucas: Right, so first, don't take it personally. It might genuinely not be in the budget this quarter. But that's not the end of the conversation. You want to get a commitment. Ask, 'What specifically needs to happen for us to revisit this? What milestones or metrics should I hit?' And then set a date. 'Can we check back in three months?' If they're not willing to give you a timeline, then you have to think about whether that's a company you want to stay with. Luna: And there's also the possibility that they say yes, but with a smaller increase than you asked for. How do you handle that? Lucas: That's actually a good outcome. You should take it. But you can also say, 'I appreciate this adjustment. I'd like to be considered for another review in six months to make sure I'm tracking toward market.' That keeps the door open and shows you're reasonable. Luna: And I think it's worth noting that if you get a no, and you've done everything right, that's data. It tells you something about how the company values you. And sometimes that's a signal to start looking elsewhere. Lucas: Absolutely. And remember, this is a conversation, not a demand. You're having a professional discussion about your compensation, and that's a normal part of a career. If you're nervous, that's okay. But the more prepared you are, the more confident you'll feel. Luna: And I love that you said that, because I think a lot of people feel like they're being pushy. But you're just asking for what you're worth. If the company is hiring, they clearly have money for talent. You're not asking them to do something unreasonable. Lucas: Exactly. And here's one more tip: practice. Say your talking points out loud, even if it's to your dog or your bathroom mirror. The more you say it, the more natural it sounds. And you'll be less likely to ramble when you're in the actual meeting. Luna: That's a good one. And I think it's also worth considering the emotional side. You might feel resentful if you're making less than a new hire. But you don't want to bring that into the room. You want to be calm and professional. Lucas: Right, the resentment can poison the conversation. So take a few deep breaths, remind yourself that this is business, and focus on the facts. And if you need a moment to collect your thoughts during the meeting, it's okay to say, 'Let me think about that and get back to you.' Luna: So to recap, we've got timing, evidence, framing, and a backup plan. That's a solid strategy. And I think the key takeaway is that a hiring spree isn't a reason to avoid the conversation. It's a reason to have it. Lucas: Couldn't have said it better. And if you're listening and you've been in this situation, we'd love to hear how it went. You can send us a voice note or an email through the show's page. And speaking of that, if today's episode gave you a concrete tool for your career, that's what we're here for. If you want to help us keep making these episodes ad-free, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small gesture, but it makes a big difference for us. Luna: Yeah, and it really does help us keep the lights on, so to speak. We don't have advertisers, so listener support is what keeps this going. And we appreciate every single one of you who's ever contributed. Lucas: Alright, let's get back to the nuts and bolts. Another question that came in is about what to do if you're in a role that's been redesigned. Your responsibilities have expanded, but your title hasn't changed. That's a different kind of conversation, but it's related. Because you're not just asking for a raise, you're asking for recognition. Luna: And that's a good segue, because a lot of people don't realize that a title change can come with a bigger increase than a simple raise. If you've taken on more senior duties, you might be able to negotiate a higher title, which comes with a higher salary band. Lucas: That's a great point. So in that case, you'd want to document how your job has evolved. Maybe you're now managing a small team, or you're leading initiatives that weren't in your original job description. That's evidence for a title change. Luna: And that's a longer-term play. But for today, if you're facing the hiring spree scenario, the message is clear: don't be shy. You have leverage, and you should use it. Lucas: And one last thing: if you're a manager listening, this is a good reminder to be proactive. If you're hiring new people, take a look at your current team's salaries. Are they in line with market? If not, address it before they have to ask. That's how you retain good people. Luna: That's a really good point. And I think that's a sign of a good manager. They don't wait for their team to come to them with these painful conversations. Lucas: Alright, let's wrap up. If you're in this situation, we've given you the tools. Go in with confidence, bring your evidence, and be specific. And if you get a no, get a timeline and a plan. You've got this. Luna: And remember, you're not being greedy. You're making sure your compensation reflects the value you bring. That's just smart business. Lucas: On that note, we'll see you next time. This has been Office Hours with Fexingo. Thanks for spending your time with us.