Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Navigating Kaiser Permanente’s Arbitration Process
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to navigating Kaiser Permanente's arbitration
- 0:06process. My name is Romay Diemrian, Chair of
- 0:09the BHBA Barrister's Section. I am delighted
- 0:12to introduce our speaker today, the Honorable
- 0:14Mark Pierce. Judge Pierce is a mediator and arbitrator
- 0:17with Signature Resolution, where he brings a
- 0:20refined approach to conflict resolution grounded
- 0:22in civility, fairness, and deep listening. Judge
- 0:26Pierce began his legal career in 1975, inspired
- 0:29by a lifelong interest in history, political
- 0:31science, and a family culture of service. After
- 0:35completing mediation training at Harvard in 1994,
- 0:38he focused on resolving disputes across a broad
- 0:41range of areas, including business, employment,
- 0:44medical malpractice, and personal injury. In
- 0:472005, he was appointed to the Santa Clara County
- 0:50Superior Court by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger,
- 0:53where he served for 15 years. Throughout his
- 0:56career, he remained active in his community and
- 0:58professional organizations, building a reputation
- 1:01defined by empathy, patience, and an unwavering
- 1:04dedication to justice. Now, let's get started
- 1:07with the program. Thank you. I'm happy to be
- 1:15able to present this program today to give you
- 1:18some additional information that you may not
- 1:21be aware of with regard to the Kaiser Permanente
- 1:23arbitration process. In California, it's a unique
- 1:28situation where Kaiser members are required to
- 1:33participate in an arbitration program if they
- 1:37have a claim against Kaiser. This has been a
- 1:43long -standing program with Kaiser. going back
- 1:47many years. And it's a program that is somewhat
- 1:52unique in the medical field and is one that is
- 1:59very distinctive in the way that it is set up.
- 2:03There are over nine million members of Kaiser
- 2:06in the state of California. And when I speak
- 2:11of Kaiser, I'm really referring to Kaiser hospitals
- 2:15and as a separate organization, the Permanente
- 2:17Medical Group, which is theoretically the physicians
- 2:22that are employed by Kaiser. When I refer to
- 2:28Kaiser today, I'll be referring to both Kaiser
- 2:30as the hospital and as the Permanente Medical
- 2:34Group. As I said, the Kaiser program is unique
- 2:40in that when a person becomes a member of Kaiser,
- 2:45they sign an agreement that states that basically
- 2:49any claims against Kaiser must be arbitrated.
- 2:53And as a result of that, if one is attempting
- 3:00to make a claim against Kaiser, it will be required
- 3:04to be in arbitration. Rules are such that the
- 3:12courts have uniformly enforced this arbitration
- 3:16agreement. And it is a requirement then of any
- 3:22Kaiser case that it go to arbitration. The program
- 3:30itself can be, that is the arbitration process
- 3:33can be started in several different ways. Sometimes
- 3:37people will attempt to file a civil lawsuit,
- 3:41for example, in Superior Court against Kaiser.
- 3:44Kaiser routinely will file a motion to compel
- 3:47arbitration, and the courts have routinely enforced
- 3:51the arbitration agreement. Now, there is one
- 3:56exception, and that exception is under the EFAA,
- 4:00which is the end of forced arbitration for sexual
- 4:06assaults. It's a recent law that was passed in
- 4:092022. What it is, is basically it states basically
- 4:15that a victim of sexual assault or battery cannot
- 4:19be mandated to participate in an arbitration
- 4:23process. This is a unique situation for Kaiser
- 4:28in that it is perhaps the only exception that
- 4:33there is to the arbitration process. What it
- 4:38does is it creates an interesting situation from
- 4:42a legal standpoint in that you potentially can
- 4:45have a claim that a person is making for a sexual
- 4:49battery, for example, against a Kaiser employee
- 4:53and Kaiser itself. What can happen is that you
- 5:00can have a separate civil action for the sexual
- 5:04assault and a separate arbitration proceeding
- 5:09for the claim itself against Kaiser. This presents
- 5:17some interesting legal questions as to the potential
- 5:20for having different results if you have two
- 5:24separate cases going on involving the same situation,
- 5:28the same issues. In any event, I haven't actually
- 5:31seen that occur yet, but it certainly is a potential
- 5:35and one that has to be dealt with. Obviously,
- 5:44the medical malpractice cases against Kaiser
- 5:48are the most common claims that are made. One
- 5:54needs to be aware of the fact that any claim
- 5:56against Kaiser, except as I just talked about
- 5:59with the sexual assault, needs to go through
- 6:02the arbitration process. And what that means
- 6:05is, is that a slip and fall in the parking lot
- 6:10when you're going into for treatment, something
- 6:13of that nature, that is a claim. that you were
- 6:16required to arbitrate through the Kaiser arbitration
- 6:19process. So it's not just med mal cases. It is
- 6:23all cases against Kaiser. The rules for Kaiser
- 6:32arbitrations have changed over the years. Initially,
- 6:38for those who have some history, if you will,
- 6:42with regard to Kaiser, will realize that as much
- 6:47as 30 years ago, the Kaiser process was such
- 6:52that if you had a claim against Kaiser, you would
- 6:58file the claim and then you would choose your
- 7:02own arbitrator and Kaiser would choose their
- 7:07own arbitrator and the two arbitrators would
- 7:10then choose a neutral third arbitrator. This
- 7:15was a process for many years. Unfortunately,
- 7:20as one could imagine, it wasn't a very efficient
- 7:24or very good process. You could imagine, and
- 7:28I had this actually happen way back when and
- 7:31many years ago, that you choose a competent attorney.
- 7:37For example, if you're the defense attorney,
- 7:39um to be your arbitrator and similarly the the
- 7:43plaintiff's attorney chooses a good competent
- 7:45attorney familiar with malpractice cases and
- 7:49then of course they choose uh the the third arbitrator
- 7:53now one can only imagine what it was like back
- 7:57way back when uh when you were trying to schedule
- 8:00something with these these uh arbitrators because
- 8:04They're uniformly busy. They're not full -time
- 8:07arbitrators. They were generally attorneys practicing
- 8:11law with busy practices. They would have to make
- 8:16time for these arbitrations. Now, they were paid
- 8:19by the party that requested them. But still,
- 8:23the fact of the matter was that it was extremely
- 8:25difficult to get something scheduled. For example,
- 8:29to schedule an arbitration, You had to schedule
- 8:32it with the attorneys, obviously representing
- 8:36the parties, but also the three arbitrators.
- 8:40It was very time -consuming, very difficult,
- 8:43and led to many delays and so on in the process
- 8:47that were really unacceptable. As they say, the
- 8:54old adage that justice delayed is justice denied
- 8:57was really that sort of an issue. So as a result,
- 9:02there was a case that was then went through the
- 9:05courts and became law that I refer to as the
- 9:09Angola case. And in that case, the court considered
- 9:14the Kaiser arbitration process and found that
- 9:18there were unnecessary and needless delays, that
- 9:23the program was not correctly supervised. There
- 9:27were no independent parties that were running
- 9:30the program, and as a result of it, it just wasn't
- 9:34a good program, and the court ruled that Kaiser
- 9:37effectively had to change it and do something
- 9:39different. As a result of that, and I gave you
- 9:44the citation, I think, on Angola, it's really
- 9:47the fact that it was done and it was completed
- 9:51is the important part of it. It really has been,
- 9:56you know, over the years. made to be unnecessary
- 10:01because of the new rules that Kaiser had established.
- 10:08I'm also looking here to see. I will also encourage
- 10:14you to ask questions during this program if you
- 10:16have something that comes up that you want me
- 10:19to respond to. Okay, I see there's a question
- 10:27in case Chloe Brockman. I'll have to answer that
- 10:32later. As a result of INGALA, basically the Office
- 10:49of the Independent Administrator was established
- 10:52by Kaiser. And this is a very crucial and important
- 10:57organization that was set up to deal with Kaiser
- 11:00cases. Actually, the Office of the Independent
- 11:04Administrator is paid for by Kaiser, but they're
- 11:10not an employee of Kaiser. They're a separate
- 11:13organization in Los Angeles. They actually are
- 11:20attorneys that are simply responsible for maintaining
- 11:27and organizing the arbitration process. As I
- 11:33said, the office was established after Ingala
- 11:37and it set forth a lot of very comprehensive
- 11:44rules. It set forth the requirements for the
- 11:50maintaining new panel of arbitrators, and so
- 11:55on. It was very critical and very crucial at
- 11:59the time. You'll find information about that
- 12:04at their website, which is oia .kaiserarb .com.
- 12:13It's a very comprehensive website, includes lots
- 12:16of important information about dealing with Kaiser
- 12:20cases, choosing arbitrators and all the rules
- 12:24that go along with that. So the office of the
- 12:35independent administrator, as I said, is responsible
- 12:39for literally everything involved in Kaiser arbitrations.
- 12:44They have, as I said, network of rules, regulations,
- 12:53and so on to make the process effective. They
- 12:57do a very good job, in my opinion, in doing so.
- 13:00They encourage rapid resolution of cases and
- 13:06claims, and it's helpful, I think, in trying
- 13:11to give everyone their rights under the law and
- 13:18still maintain effective legal processing. There's
- 13:35a question here that I have with regard to his
- 13:39jurisdiction laws to hear a motion for reconsideration.
- 13:43once a neutral arbitrator makes his ruling. I'll
- 13:47get to that later, but the bottom line is, yes,
- 13:50you can't. There is no authority for reconsideration
- 13:56of an arbitrator's ruling unless, of course,
- 13:59there's some sort of issue. The Office of the
- 14:07Independent Administrator is designated to handle
- 14:11all claims in California, both Northern California
- 14:15and Southern California. They operate out of
- 14:20Los Angeles, but they are effectively operating
- 14:25throughout the state. They have set forth extensive
- 14:30rules for the Kaiser arbitrations as far as how
- 14:36to start an arbitration, and so on, and requirements
- 14:42for the choosing arbitrators. The initial thing
- 14:49that, of course, is important in a Kaiser type
- 14:52arbitration is, how do you initiate the claim?
- 14:56As I said, if you try to file a lawsuit in civil
- 15:00court, the Kaiser attorneys will move to compel
- 15:04you into arbitration. The other way, of course,
- 15:11the most simple and the straightforward way of
- 15:15starting a Kaiser arbitration is by simply filing
- 15:18a claim against Kaiser. You can do that with
- 15:23the office of the independent administrator.
- 15:28There is a filing fee of $150. That filing fee
- 15:32can be waived under certain circumstances for
- 15:36indigent type situations. But basically, that
- 15:41fee is required and that is the thing that starts
- 15:44the process. Now, there's no formal claim form
- 15:51that you must use in order to initiate an arbitration.
- 15:56Actually, the OIA does have a claim form that
- 15:59you may use to initiate an arbitration, but it's
- 16:03not mandatory. The fee is mandatory, but not
- 16:06the form. Once the claim is filed, then that
- 16:16starts the whole process. Now, I think that it's
- 16:19important in filing the claim that the party
- 16:24spell out what the nature of the general claim
- 16:27is. In other words, so that Kaiser has a little
- 16:32bit of an idea what's going on because I found
- 16:35in handling a number of arbitrations that initially
- 16:40Kaiser has no idea what the claim is about. They
- 16:44don't know anything and just because a claim
- 16:46was filed, it doesn't always spell out what the
- 16:49nature of it is. In this situation, it is helpful
- 16:54and important that the claim be spelled out.
- 17:00Once the claim is actually initiated, the process
- 17:08then begins of choosing an arbitrator. Now, there
- 17:11are several different ways in which you can choose
- 17:16an arbitrator. First of all, you can stipulate
- 17:21to an arbitrator. Sometimes you can even stipulate
- 17:24to an arbitrator who is not on the Kaiser panel.
- 17:29That's pretty rare, I think, because the advantage
- 17:32of the Kaiser panel is that the people are experienced
- 17:36in medical malpractice cases and are aware of
- 17:39the various issues in med mal cases and are much
- 17:42better prepared to handle that. Another way that
- 17:49you can choose an arbitrator is by going to the
- 17:53OIA website and they have a list and photos and
- 17:58so on of all of the arbitrators that are qualified
- 18:01through OIA. They've all been vetted for their
- 18:07experience and their knowledge of medical malpractice
- 18:10cases. important thing with regard to choosing
- 18:19an arbitrator is that you are cautious and careful
- 18:23about that. And if you can stipulate between
- 18:26both sides to a person, I think that you're much
- 18:31better off and it is very helpful. However, as
- 18:36often as the case, parties are unable to agree
- 18:40as to who the arbitrator should be. And as a
- 18:44result, they will request that OIA appoint an
- 18:49arbitrator. Now, the panel of arbitrators, as
- 18:54I indicated on the OIA website, consists of about
- 18:5950 % retired judges and 50 % non -judges, if
- 19:05you will. And there's no requirement that you
- 19:08choose a retired judge or not. The other thing
- 19:12is that one needs to be aware of who the arbitrator
- 19:19is because, as indicated previously, the arbitrator's
- 19:24award is going to be final and you are going
- 19:28to be stuck without any basis for appeal of an
- 19:33arbitrator's award. Being cautious and careful
- 19:37in choosing an arbitrator is a really good idea.
- 19:41What happens when you're not able to agree on
- 19:44a particular arbitrator is that you advise the
- 19:53OIA that you want a list, if you will. Basically,
- 19:59that is a situation where you will get a list
- 20:08of arbitrators. about 10 or 12 or so, out of
- 20:14which you are able to strike a certain number
- 20:17of them. And then you rank the remaining arbitrators
- 20:22on the list that you get. And each side does
- 20:24that. And then it's submitted back to the OIA.
- 20:27And then as a result of the ranking system, the
- 20:32arbitrator initially will be appointed. The arbitrator
- 20:36then is appointed and is advised of his or her
- 20:42appointment. And she has an opportunity to accept
- 20:46the appointment or not. Generally speaking, the
- 20:50appointments are accepted. And this process hopefully
- 20:55only takes 30 to 45 days. Again, the idea with
- 21:01the arbitration program with Kaiser is to get
- 21:06this the The remedy and the resolution of the
- 21:10case is moving along without unnecessary delays.
- 21:22Now, with regard to filing the claim, it's interesting.
- 21:28You will find that there are statistics on the
- 21:31website that can be helpful. You will find on
- 21:35the website that the number of claims against
- 21:38Kaiser has gone down substantially over the past
- 21:4120 years. I don't know exactly why that case
- 21:45is, but I do know that it is important that the
- 21:52claims are handled judiciously and effectively.
- 21:56And I think that the new system, the OIA system,
- 21:59is doing a very good job doing that. Now, the
- 22:06interesting thing as applies in a lot of our
- 22:11arbitrations that are compelled is that in a
- 22:16typical arbitration, Kaiser will be responsible
- 22:20for paying all the expenses of the arbitrator
- 22:24and any other expenses in the arbitration, such
- 22:27as a court reporter, that sort of thing. different
- 22:34situations that arise. For example, if the claim
- 22:38is less than $200 ,000, the situation is that
- 22:47one arbitrator is to be selected and chosen to
- 22:50be the arbitrator for the case. In a case that
- 22:54has a value and it needs to be stated in your
- 22:58claim, if the claim is more than $200 ,000, You're
- 23:02required to waive the right to have more than
- 23:06one arbitrator. And in the case of the Kaiser
- 23:11situation, if you have a case that's valued where
- 23:16the claim is more than $200 ,000, and you want
- 23:22to have one arbitrator, again, paid for by Kaiser,
- 23:26the expense is all paid, both parties need to
- 23:29waive their right to have multiple arbitrators.
- 23:34You are allowed, like the old system was, to
- 23:40choose your own arbitrator. Each side can choose
- 23:44their own arbitrator, and then that arbitrator
- 23:46chooses the neutral arbitrator. So you would
- 23:48have a three arbitration panel. This is like
- 23:52the old system, and it has some significant,
- 23:56in my opinion, disadvantages. For example, Each
- 24:01party is required to pay their own arbitrator
- 24:04and half the expenses of the neutral arbitrator.
- 24:08It can be a very costly situation. It's fairly
- 24:14unusual to have that situation arise, although
- 24:18I have heard it does occur where the parties
- 24:22are insisting upon the three arbitrator panel.
- 24:28If you want that, it's available. It's costly,
- 24:32and it's something that one should think very
- 24:35seriously about. Now, there are other things
- 24:43that you need to consider when scheduling or
- 24:48choosing an arbitration through Kaiser, and that
- 24:52is that you can designate the case as a complex
- 24:56case. And that's just a request through the OIA
- 25:01to designate it as complex. And the reason that
- 25:06you might do that is that would give you more
- 25:10time to resolve the discovery issues or to handle
- 25:13the issues that may come up in the case, such
- 25:18as discovery issues and that sort of thing. I
- 25:23see that I have some more questions here. See
- 25:26if there's some of them that I can answer. There's
- 25:38a question here about the question of a civil
- 25:44rights or anti -discrimination claim. How do
- 25:47you handle that? Well, that again is one that
- 25:52can and should be handled through the arbitration
- 26:00process. Again, unless there's an exception such
- 26:04as the sexual assault issue, I think that it
- 26:09has to go through the Kaiser process. Okay, I
- 26:19have another question with regard to a wrongful
- 26:22death claim in an arbitration. The question is
- 26:38with regard to arbitration of a wrongful death
- 26:41claim. The negligence claim, it has to be handled
- 26:48separately. I think that it would be unusual
- 26:57for them not to do so. Okay, I have another question
- 27:04here with regard to discovery tools such as depositions,
- 27:07interrogatories. Are they available in arbitration?
- 27:09I'm going to be getting to that. So hang on.
- 27:19All right. As I said, the arbitration expenses
- 27:26are an expense that is typically pay for by Kaiser.
- 27:33And those include the cost of the arbitrator,
- 27:35which can be fairly expensive. The arbitrators
- 27:40are, as I said, private attorneys and retired
- 27:44judges. And their fees are significant. And one
- 27:51has to be aware of that. Now, when the Kaiser
- 27:57process was set up. I mean, it was intended that
- 28:00I think initially that of course they would be
- 28:04in person. But times have changed and the process
- 28:10for handling arbitrations has changed greatly.
- 28:16You find now that the arbitration process can
- 28:22be done entirely by a zoom type proceeding. In
- 28:27other words, I'm aware that there was a birth
- 28:33injury case, a three -week birth injury case
- 28:36that was heard during the issue when COVID was
- 28:44an issue. And that case was held entirely by
- 28:50Zoom, which is shocking to me and amazing to
- 28:54me because Of course, it's a very serious case.
- 28:57And the idea that there would be no live bodies
- 29:00present is pretty shocking to me. But I'm an
- 29:03old coot. I do believe that the new system that
- 29:10is evolving is good. It's very good, and it's
- 29:14good for a number of reasons. Basically, what
- 29:18I see evolving now for purposes of the arbitration
- 29:23process itself is that the arbitrations are becoming
- 29:27what I would call hybrid, meaning that their
- 29:31parties will oftentimes the parties themselves
- 29:35will appear personally before the arbitrator
- 29:39and the arbitrators usually the arbitrators office.
- 29:43But some of the witnesses will appear by Zoom
- 29:48or other video type conferencing. I think that
- 29:54this is really a pretty good process because
- 29:57over the years, if one who has handled med mal
- 30:01cases knows how difficult it is to arrange for
- 30:05physicians to testify. They have busy practices
- 30:09and they have lots of things going on and the
- 30:14idea that that some of the physician witnesses
- 30:16in particular can testify, and other expert witnesses
- 30:20as far as that goes, can testify by Zoom, makes
- 30:24things very efficient and very good, I think.
- 30:29I still prefer to see a live body in an arbitration
- 30:35proceeding, but that's not to say that they don't
- 30:38get. that someone who is appearing by Zoom doesn't
- 30:42get full faith and credit for everything that
- 30:44they say and just as much as just believable
- 30:47as anybody else. However, the process is evolving
- 30:53and I'm finding that it's different in different
- 30:59times of the year and different parties. Some
- 31:02people I find some attorneys now are not even
- 31:07operating in state. They're living out of state.
- 31:10They can handle the arbitration proceeding totally
- 31:15by Zoom while living in another state. That's
- 31:19pretty incredible for me as an old PI lawyer
- 31:24way back when to think that everything would
- 31:27be done by Zoom. That's perhaps an exception.
- 31:33and then perhaps for a smaller case. But in any
- 31:36event, that is the way that these cases are being
- 31:40handled. And they are being done both in person,
- 31:44totally by Zoom and a hybrid, which I think is
- 31:48the most common way that things are going right
- 31:49now. Now, one of the questions that was raised
- 31:56here was what are the discovery processes and
- 31:59what rights does people have for discovery and
- 32:01that sort of thing? Well, the discovery and the
- 32:07civil procedure aspects of an arbitration are
- 32:12virtually identical to that of the civil process
- 32:16in the courts. That's what I have found. It works
- 32:23best. For example, the arbitrator has the right
- 32:28to subpoena records. to issue subpoenas. The
- 32:33arbitrator also has a right to issue subpoenas
- 32:35for witnesses and to compel records to be produced
- 32:42by outside sources. Now, when it comes to parties,
- 32:47I think that most arbitrators follow the rules
- 32:51of discovery that are set forth under the CODESIL
- 32:54procedure and the timeframe that is set forth.
- 32:59for that type of discovery. I find that, for
- 33:04example, that Kaiser is very cooperative in providing
- 33:07medical records and that sort of thing. And I
- 33:10think that the process of obtaining records is
- 33:16generally pretty smooth and pretty good. Also
- 33:19with regard to... taking expert witnesses and
- 33:24and and percipient witnesses depositions that's
- 33:26that process seems to work pretty well too. I
- 33:29do have in my practice and my as an arbitrator
- 33:33I do have issues that will occasionally come
- 33:36up and what I tell the parties is that if they
- 33:41have any disputes about discovery don't file
- 33:44a long motion don't don't file lots of things
- 33:49until we talk about it first. I find that so
- 33:52many issues in these types of cases can be resolved
- 33:57by simply talking about it and ironing out issues
- 34:00that someone may be confused about their rights
- 34:05and their requirements that they have to do.
- 34:16You can expect that in arbitration that discovery
- 34:20is going to be similar, although somewhat more
- 34:23informal than you would see it in a civil court.
- 34:27I find that the attorneys seem to work well for
- 34:31the most part in arbitrations. I think that there's
- 34:36not a courtroom or a court. courthouse that's
- 34:40sort of in between them and whatever is happening
- 34:43with the case and that people seem to work better
- 34:49and more smoothly and efficiently in the arbitration
- 34:52proceedings. Occasionally, there will be specific
- 34:56issues about compelling an answer to a specific
- 35:00interrogatory. or something of that nature. And
- 35:03I find that by talking about it and working through
- 35:05it, most often it's able to be resolved. And
- 35:09rarely does there have to be an order about something
- 35:12like that. It just is a much smoother, easier
- 35:16going process than you might find in a regular
- 35:21court. I'm looking to see if I have any other
- 35:36questions. Now, we talked a little bit about
- 35:45the actual hearing process as to where we would
- 35:53have that type of a hearing. Basically, again,
- 35:57it's much more efficient, frankly, than in a
- 36:01courthouse because we're able to schedule things
- 36:04much more easily, and we're able to be more flexible
- 36:11in scheduling witnesses and that sort of thing.
- 36:15Now, the typical arbitration process is that,
- 36:19as I said, it's usually held in the arbitrator's
- 36:25office, whether it's by Zoom, even by Zoom or
- 36:28by in -person or hybrid. In an arbitration, med
- 36:34mal arbitration, such as the Kaiser process,
- 36:39the rules of evidence apply. I follow all the
- 36:43rules of California evidence, perhaps a little
- 36:48bit more simplified as far as some of the rules
- 36:56of objections with regard to foundation and things
- 37:01of that nature, it depends on the arbitrator
- 37:03as to how strictly they want to follow the rules
- 37:06of evidence. But of course, the basic rules of
- 37:09evidence have to be followed at all time with
- 37:10regard to hearsay and things of that nature.
- 37:13But basically, the process itself is fairly straightforward
- 37:18with regard to the testimony of witnesses, with
- 37:25regard to admitting records, uh, medical records,
- 37:30whether they're Kaiser records or others, um,
- 37:33or other employment records, for example, usually
- 37:36we are able to, to, um, not have to have custodian
- 37:39records appear, that sort of thing. Excuse me,
- 37:43it makes it, it makes it a more simple process
- 37:46to, to get, get things done and, and move along
- 37:49more quickly. So I think that you can find that,
- 37:53that an average, um, um, med mal arbitration
- 37:56might take four or five days, whereas a case
- 37:59like that could take several weeks in a civil
- 38:03trial setting. Generally speaking, the witnesses
- 38:09can be arranged for in advance. And sometimes
- 38:16nowadays we're using the videotaped depositions.
- 38:19They can be played when there's a little lull
- 38:24in the evidence, if you will. And so it works
- 38:27fairly well that that we were able to make the
- 38:32process work fairly smoothly. One of the issues
- 38:38that has come up in some of my arbitrations is
- 38:44whether or not one wants to have a court reporter
- 38:47present because these days it's tough. it's tough
- 38:53to find good court reporters that are able to
- 38:55appear. One of the problems is that the attorneys
- 38:59oftentimes want daily transcripts if they have
- 39:02a court reporter. Of course, that puts additional
- 39:05pressure on the court reporter. Sometimes you
- 39:06have to have two court reporters. I'm lukewarm
- 39:12as to whether or not one needs a court reporter
- 39:15for these med mal hearings or not. It's, again,
- 39:22up to the parties and maybe up to the decision
- 39:29of the attorneys as to whether or not it's really
- 39:34necessary or not. It's definitely an additional
- 39:36expense. And it's additionally difficult, like
- 39:40I said, to get a court reporter who's going to
- 39:41be able to do that and do the dailies also. So
- 39:45I think that one would have to consider the importance
- 39:51of having a court reporter or not. Now, the hearing
- 39:55usually, as I said, is done in the arbitrator's
- 40:01office, and usually the facilities there are
- 40:05really good for Zoom and that sort of thing,
- 40:07so that everything usually goes pretty smoothly.
- 40:10The award then, once the hearing is concluded,
- 40:15is required to be done in 30 days. Or if it's
- 40:20a complex case, it can be a little bit longer.
- 40:23But again, is to move these things along to get
- 40:28the decision done as soon as possible. OK. I
- 40:41have a question. I think that the rules, there's
- 40:52a question as to whether or not CCP 425 .13 with
- 40:56regard to punitive damages, whether that applies
- 41:00or not. Again, I treat that exactly as it would
- 41:05in a civil court. And so, the requirements for
- 41:10proving punitive damages would be the same. Then
- 41:13I have another question here. asking whether
- 41:17or not the arbitration award is appealed. And
- 41:20as I indicated earlier, it is not appealable.
- 41:23That is a final decision. The only grounds for
- 41:28appeal would be not on the merits of the case,
- 41:32but on the issue of was there a mistake by the
- 41:39arbitrator in the process, or was there a mistake
- 41:45or fraud by the arbitrator, something of that
- 41:48nature, but it's really not appealable on its
- 41:51merits per se. I have another question here.
- 41:57Who pays for the court report? Well, my belief
- 42:01is that because Kaiser is responsible for the
- 42:05expenses of the arbitration, they would be responsible
- 42:08for the court report. Let's see. I'm reading
- 42:20by these questions. Suppose a wrongful death
- 42:24claim in arbitration. I think I already answered
- 42:32that question. Okay. I think that the. in any
- 42:42wrongful death case, it's treated as the same
- 42:45as it would be in a civil court. Okay. One thing
- 42:55that I think we should... discuss a little bit
- 42:59is, and it doesn't necessarily apply to the attorney
- 43:01so much, but you should be aware perhaps for
- 43:04your own clients that they have a claim that
- 43:06they want to pursue that you don't want to pursue.
- 43:10That happens sometimes and maybe even a smaller
- 43:13claim. But the issue of self -represented litigants
- 43:18is an issue for Kaiser and for the arbitrators
- 43:22who have to deal with that situation. process
- 43:28through OIA is set up to allow people to represent
- 43:31themselves. And in fact, as many as 20 or 25
- 43:34% of the cases are people who have filed claims
- 43:38on their own behalf and are attempting to represent
- 43:43themselves. The problem of course here is that
- 43:46in a med mal case, the proof required is going
- 43:52to be such that Most likely the self -represented
- 43:56litigant is going to have to have expert medical
- 44:00testimony to testify as to the standard of care
- 44:03that's required in that particular case. If there
- 44:06was a violation of that standard of care, what
- 44:09that violation was. Now that, of course, anyone
- 44:14who's ever handled medical malpractice cases
- 44:16knows that obtaining medical testimony is a difficult
- 44:21challenge. It's not easy to do. And particularly
- 44:26for someone who is representing themselves, it's
- 44:29very challenging for them to try to represent
- 44:32themselves and have medical testimony. What Kaiser
- 44:39generally does in these situations is they will
- 44:42file a motion for summary judgment or summary
- 44:45adjudication. if you will, and present evidence
- 44:50that there was no violation of the standard of
- 44:52care. And generally speaking, self -represented
- 44:55litigants are going to be out of luck because
- 44:57they're just not going to be able to present
- 44:59medical evidence. Now, as soon as I said that,
- 45:03I had a case recently where the Kaiser attorneys
- 45:08submitted a motion for summary adjudication.
- 45:12And the self -represented litigant And of course,
- 45:16they thought there would be no opposition. The
- 45:20self -represented litigant did find a physician
- 45:22to testify and submitted a declaration that there
- 45:26was a breach of the standard of care. That's
- 45:29pretty unusual, but it does happen, and it can
- 45:31happen, and it's necessary to be aware that that's
- 45:36a problem. But self -represented litigants their
- 45:40cases generally go away because it's so difficult
- 45:43for them to pursue that case. But it is something
- 45:47that is encouraged by OIA to let people at least
- 45:50potentially have the opportunity to have their
- 45:53claim be heard. Now, before we wrap up, I did
- 46:02want to talk a little bit about the resolution
- 46:07of these cases out of arbitration. As I said,
- 46:13there's over 500, 600 claims filed each year.
- 46:19Many of them are dropped. A few of them go to
- 46:25actually go to hearing, but many of them are
- 46:27resolved out of the arbitration process. I think
- 46:31that attorneys who are want to participate in
- 46:36the Kaiser process should be aware that, number
- 46:40one, it's going to be very expensive for them.
- 46:43Any attorney who is handling a med mal case or
- 46:47who has ever handled a med mal case knows that
- 46:50physicians are extremely expensive, whether they're
- 46:53testifying as an expert or even as a recipient
- 46:56witness, sometimes you have to pay them too.
- 47:01the cost of these cases is extremely high. My
- 47:05experience is that, and of course, it's expensive
- 47:08for Kaiser too. My experience has been that Kaiser,
- 47:14when there is a case where they have some exposure,
- 47:18they're not a hard liner per se, they will resolve
- 47:21a case where they have some exposure. On the
- 47:25other hand, if they don't feel they have any
- 47:27exposure, they're not inclined to offer nominal
- 47:30or cost of defense settlement offers. They will
- 47:39pursue a case to judgment if they feel that there
- 47:44is no liability and they will not offer a nuisance
- 47:49settlement, in my experience. I think that an
- 47:53early discussion between the attorneys about
- 47:58the case is really helpful. In other words, if
- 48:02you have a medical negligence case, number one,
- 48:08as a plaintiff's lawyer, you should have gotten
- 48:10an expert witness ahead of time who's going to
- 48:12say that there was something that was done wrong
- 48:14and who is competent and capable of testifying
- 48:17and who's willing to testify for you. Having
- 48:20that information I think, and this is not always
- 48:26agreed to by everybody, but my feeling is that
- 48:29an early discussion between the attorneys, where
- 48:33the plaintiff attorney feels that they have a
- 48:35valid claim and they have evidence to support
- 48:40that claim, I think an early discussion in the
- 48:43form of a mediation of some sort is very helpful.
- 48:47And I think that there are several ways that
- 48:49you could go about that. One would be simply
- 48:52just a typical mediation where the party sort
- 48:56of lay out their cards early on before the, for
- 49:02example, the attorneys. And of course, everyone
- 49:05has to spend money on experts. And so Kaiser
- 49:08spends money too. So I think it's in their advantage
- 49:10early on to have a discussion about if there's
- 49:14a... legitimate claim to talk about what resolution
- 49:17might be hammered out. So that's more the standard
- 49:25or traditional mediation. But again, I advocate
- 49:30doing it early. Now, one of the things that people
- 49:35will claim is that they don't have the medical
- 49:37records to review and yada, yada, yada, that
- 49:40sort of thing. But I think that you can find
- 49:43it in most cases, the parties can get enough
- 49:46together to have a pretty good idea of where
- 49:49they stand and what they could do. Now, in a
- 49:52catastrophic case, no, this is probably not going
- 49:54to work. But I'm talking about the more average
- 49:57case. where there's been a mistake, perhaps an
- 49:59oversight, that something might be worked out
- 50:03early on. Now, another thing that takes it even
- 50:07a step further is by using a mediator as a sort
- 50:13of a, if you want to call it a referee, okay?
- 50:16And that meaning that, and this is kind of my
- 50:19own thoughts on this issue, which I think is
- 50:22potentially something that should be worked on.
- 50:24is that you can hire your mediator slash referee
- 50:30to set some groundwork for perhaps an early resolution
- 50:35of the case or early discovery in the case to
- 50:39indicate the strength or weaknesses of the case.
- 50:43In my own personal experience, I had a case many
- 50:46years ago where the defense attorney who I knew
- 50:51and I was representing the plaintiff, the defense
- 50:55attorney whom I knew and respected said, tell
- 50:59me what you got. Well, a lot of people are really
- 51:01hesitant to do that because they're afraid that
- 51:04they're just going to be turned around on them.
- 51:05But in this particular case, I felt like I could
- 51:09trust this attorney to give me a straight shot.
- 51:12In fact, what I did was I actually presented
- 51:16my expert witness. for a conversation with his
- 51:21defense attorney as to what the grounds were,
- 51:24why he felt that it was medical negligence and
- 51:27so on. Interesting different approach to handling
- 51:31that kind of a case, but you know what, it worked.
- 51:34And in that case, my client was very challenging.
- 51:37He had mental health issues and so on. And we
- 51:39were able to resolve that case early on because
- 51:43I had my expert lined up and he was going to
- 51:45be, you know, a pretty effective strong witness.
- 51:50Try to think of alternatives to trying to get
- 51:56cases resolved early. As I said, assuming that
- 52:01a person representing someone in a med mal case
- 52:04has medical expert testimony and is prepared
- 52:08to go forward, I think that they should consider
- 52:12ways of giving the defense attorneys an opportunity
- 52:18to know the exposure that they have in the case.
- 52:23Of course, there's always a question, well, if
- 52:25you tell them what you got, then they go out
- 52:27and try to find somebody who's going to rebut
- 52:28that. Yes, that's an issue and that always will
- 52:31be an issue and that's a risk that you take.
- 52:35I throw that out as only a possibility, as a
- 52:39potential that somebody might want to try in
- 52:43order to resolve what can be a very expensive
- 52:47proposition, and that is taking on these medical
- 52:52fees and expert witnesses and so on. I think
- 52:56I have another question here. There's a question.
- 53:10It says, what is the process to have Kaiser pay
- 53:13the full fees for the arbitration? Again, if
- 53:21there's one arbitrator, the Kaiser pays the fees
- 53:25for cases less than $200 ,000. And if you stipulate
- 53:29for a claim more than $200 ,000, they pay all
- 53:31of the fees. Another question is, what if the
- 53:35arbitration hearing is held beyond 24 months?
- 53:39depending upon, you know, you're going to have
- 53:41to get permission from the OIA to do that. But
- 53:51if you get permission to do that, it can go longer,
- 53:54again, if it's designated as a complex case.
- 54:00Okay, so if Kaiser erroneously cancels my policy
- 54:04while I am pursuing my claim and waste my right
- 54:06to go to arbitration, do I have a viable claim
- 54:09in civil court? No, I don't think so. I don't
- 54:11think you do. I think you have to pursue the
- 54:15claim in arbitration whether or not you continue
- 54:18to be a Kaiser member or not. I think that I
- 54:35have answered all of the questions that were
- 54:38poised and I have basically covered all the issues
- 54:45that were put before me today. The Kaiser arbitration
- 54:55program is one that is unique. It's different
- 54:58in the California legal system. But I do think
- 55:04it's a valid and good process. And that through
- 55:08the OIA, that all parties are able to get a good
- 55:13resolution, including the ultimate end result
- 55:23of the case. So that being said, I'm going to
- 55:30go ahead and conclude the the program today and
- 55:35I thank you all for being present. This concludes
- 55:38today's presentation. Thank you so much Judge
- 55:40Pierce for sharing your knowledge and for giving
- 55:44your time to our members today and thank you
- 55:46so much to our audience. Have a great afternoon
- 55:48everybody.