Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Apology Research (2016 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00So Betto or Berto or Umbeto, please give me an apology, apologize for
- 0:07something, think about something either makeup or or real or something, and apologized
- 0:14for something that you did to me, and then we're going to evaluate it
- 0:17based on the psychological literature. Go ahead. Well wait, before we do
- 0:22that, let's introduce the podcast. This is a Psychology in Seattle podcast.
- 0:26I'm your host, doctor Kirk Honda. I am chair of the Couple and
- 0:30Family Therapy program at Antioch University, Seattle, and I'm also a licensed marriage
- 0:35a family therapist. My name is Umber, and I am a professional apologist.
- 0:40Yeah. I can't roll the R like that. Okay, So go
- 0:43ahead apologize, Oh, Kirk, I guess I should probably say that I
- 0:52I'm sorry if I if, I'm sorry if what I did or said caused
- 0:57you to feel like bad the other day. Okay, so you know whatever?
- 1:03Okay, that's it. You want more? No? Okay? So
- 1:07good? All right? That awesome? Isn't that the best apology? No?
- 1:14Do it? Okay? Okay? Real one? But what can we
- 1:15analyze the other one? Two? Because I'm a little campy, but yeah,
- 1:19so this is a real one. Um, all right, Kirk,
- 1:23I want to honestly apologize for a time in which I was being I want
- 1:30to call it selfish as more uninformed and stupid about certain aspects of our relationship.
- 1:37And um, and my actions were not nice and you know, I
- 1:42want to apologize. Okay, good, Well that felt sincere psyche all right.
- 1:49Well. The following analysis comes from an article written by Watkins and colleagues
- 1:55published in twenty fifteen called the Ruptured Supervisory Alliance and Its Repair. It's in
- 2:00the Clinical Supervisor Journal, and they refer to a way of Analyzing Apologies by
- 2:08Kirchoff and colleagues published in oh nine, and they based it on a review
- 2:15of thirty nine studies. Blah bah blah. But they identified ten different elements
- 2:20in the literature identified as as components to an apology as a way of trying
- 2:28to you know, psychologists love to, like, you know, make things
- 2:30concrete, So they're trying to identify ten different elements of an apology. What
- 2:36do you think those elements are? Okay, and then we'll analyze your um,
- 2:39Okay, acknowledgement of the thing that you're apologized of your role, I
- 2:46guess acknowledgement of your role and what you're apologizing about Okay. Well, that's
- 2:51that's two different things. That's that's uh oh I see, Okay, that's
- 2:53naming the effect, acknowledging the offense. Yeah, and then the thing is
- 2:57also your role, acknowledging your role or your responsibility. Um, acknowledging the
- 3:05other person's uh how they how it might have affected them good, addressing the
- 3:10emotions of and or damage to the offending party. Um the uh maybe the
- 3:19effects acknowledging the effects of what they did, the consequence of their actions.
- 3:23It's kind of the same thing. But yeah, uh, maybe offering a
- 3:30repair like a kind of a but I'm you know, like I'm gonna repair
- 3:35it somehow. And here's how that's exactly offering reparations, which I just resed
- 3:40I didn't do in my apology. Okay. Um. Then uh, providing
- 3:46context for your actions maybe so attempting to explain the offense but not trying to
- 3:53explain it away. Yeah okay, um acknowledging oh I know. And then
- 4:03just asking for forgiveness. Yeah. So that's uh one and ten, which
- 4:10is just saying I'm sorry, and then ten is actually requesting that the person
- 4:15accept your appausey. So you got you got seven out of ten identified.
- 4:19The only other three are conveying emotions like shame or remorse or something, and
- 4:27seven is sort of like three, which is admitting fault, which is,
- 4:31you know, similar to taking responsibilities. So I don't really see how those
- 4:34are. I guess maybe one of them could be you know, I know
- 4:39that it was it was my words that caused this, but but the other
- 4:43one could be um and and I did that and I'm sorry that. I
- 4:47like, it's almost like my words caused it, but I'm the I'm at
- 4:51fault, right, I don't know subtle that. Yeah, it's maybe it's
- 4:54just like really putting a fine point on this is my fault. And the
- 4:57last one is promising, forbearing instance, what they call it meaning I want
- 5:00to refrain from doing this again. Oh right, yeah, I'm not going
- 5:03to do it again. Yeah. So just to review statement of apology for
- 5:08one's transgression, for example, just saying I'm sorry, just just those words,
- 5:13I'm sorry, naming the offense for example, what I did was dot
- 5:17dot dot number three, taking responsibility for the offense. For example, I
- 5:24am responsible for what happened number four, attempting to explain the offense but not
- 5:29trying to explain it away, which is an interesting thing. A lot of
- 5:31people say, like, well, you don't want to like give excuses,
- 5:33but I find that in a good apology, if you can pull it off
- 5:38well providing that can be helpful. But you got to be careful with that,
- 5:42because if it sounds like you're making excuses, a lot of people won't
- 5:46consider it a real apology. You know. Number five conveying emotions saying you
- 5:51know, I feel really bad, I feel bad, you know, I
- 5:56feel just terrible. I'm mortified that I did that. Comment on the previous
- 6:00one is that the context giving might be more in the sense that like,
- 6:04look, I want you to know this wasn't me being vicious towards you right
- 6:09on purpose or right like for instance, you know, you might say,
- 6:14you know, I was in a bad mood that day because this other thing
- 6:16happened, I'm not nothing to do with you, orfore doesn't it doesn't doesn't
- 6:19excuse what I did, but I just want you to know, like there
- 6:23were all these circumstances that led up to that event or when you said blank
- 6:27before that, I've I misinterpreted it, and so that's why I said what
- 6:30I said, especially like if you said something mean or hurtful, right,
- 6:34like you're the worst driver I've ever seen. Okay, Larry, you might
- 6:38see like, listen, you're not a bad like I was just in a
- 6:41car accident last week, and I'm a highper sensitive about whatever I was triggered.
- 6:45And you know. Number six addressing the emotions or damage to the offended
- 6:49party. So really just saying I'm sure I hurt your feelings or I you
- 6:55know, I'm sure that you were upset at me, and that makes sense
- 7:00admitting fault, which I'm guessing is just putting a really fine point on just
- 7:03to remind you it's my fault. Number eight promising forbearance, for example,
- 7:09I will try to not ever do this again. It's I'm going to really
- 7:12try to dedicate myself. Number nine Offering reparation, you know, something tangible
- 7:17to the offended party, you know, like I will, I don't know,
- 7:23a sexual favor. And number ten requesting apology acceptance, saying and do
- 7:29you accept my apology? So like you go, you sexually harass someone,
- 7:33and as you're apologizing, but I can fuck you if you'd like, So
- 7:41let's evaluate your your apology. So number one, you said you're sorry.
- 7:46I'm pretty sure. Number two naming the offense. You didn't name the well,
- 7:49you've named it in general because you're trying to keep a general podcast.
- 7:53But but you did basically, and I even think I know what you're talking
- 7:57about. It's what I walk d on you that one time when you offered
- 8:03to fuck me and I was like, no, uh. Number three,
- 8:07you took responsibility for the offense. You didn't say it was anyone else's.
- 8:11It wasn't. Number four attempting to explain the offense but not trying to explain
- 8:18it away. It didn't really get it. Yeah, because again it's a
- 8:20podcast, you're not trying to but you know whatever, I didn't even know
- 8:24about that one. Number five conveying emotions. I think you conveyed your own
- 8:30emotion bit. I mean, I'm sure I could see it in your eyes.
- 8:33So that's another thing, like you don't have to say. This isn't
- 8:35like a thing you have to do in words all the time. But like
- 8:39you, I could, I could see the genuineness in your eyes. Honestly,
- 8:46addressing the emotions of the you know, offended party. Did you address
- 8:50my emotions? I don't think you didn't admitting faults. Pretty sure you did
- 8:56that. Um, you didn't promise for Barren to you know, you didn't
- 9:01promise, you know, that you would refrain from doing it. I don't
- 9:03want to pin myself into a corner here. Yeah, you didn't offer reparation
- 9:07and you didn't request apology acceptance. Okay, so like five at him.
- 9:13You know, I don't know, I felt it. It was it was
- 9:15real. So but how is the first apology? Yeah? Right, the
- 9:20first apology had nothing in it actually, right because it wasn't. Yeah,
- 9:24okay, So according to the research that I looked at here, and it's
- 9:31just so funny when you read psychological research, it's like anyone in their mother
- 9:35knows this is true, but somehow, like psychology proves this or demonstrates it.
- 9:41So Number one is when the offense is more severe, you have to
- 9:46involve more of the ten of these elements. So if it's just a minor
- 9:50offense, you could, like you step on someone's foot, you could just
- 9:54say I'm sorry. Can you imagine if you operated like this all the time.
- 9:58Yeah, so I put a cup on your table, like, don't
- 10:01don't put on the wood. Oh my god, it was when I put
- 10:07it on your table, do you accept my apology? You know? Yeah,
- 10:13So the more severe, more of the ten need to be demonstrated,
- 10:18less severe not as many. Uh, Different offense contexts seem to require more
- 10:24or fewer apology components, you know, like if it's at work, for
- 10:28instance, maybe you don't need to do all ten, but if it's in
- 10:31a marriage, maybe you need to do more of them or so, I
- 10:33don't know. In resolving conflicts, not all apology components are created equal,
- 10:39with some being more important than others. So you know, like if you
- 10:43did eight of them but didn't do taking responsibility or admitting fault, like you
- 10:48could imagine that that might bother some people. Like so in my in my
- 10:52silly example, at first obviously I was doing it. It was a caricature.
- 10:56But unfortunately a lot of people apologize like that. They will literally say
- 11:01something like, listen, I'm sorry if you took offense at what I said,
- 11:07right, that's not our apology. That's that's saying I'm sorry. I'm
- 11:09sorry you're too stupid to process what I say right. And honestly, I
- 11:16find that people in because because as a I'm a professional, apology facilitator in
- 11:24my job, and I can tell you that the vast majority of people I
- 11:30come across personally and professionally are terrible at apologizing, even though in their heart
- 11:35they want to. Yeah, I know that most people really actually want to
- 11:41apologize, but because it's a vulnerable expression, you know, someone can use
- 11:48this against you. It's like, we'll remember that time when you did that
- 11:50thing. Well, you know, when you apologize, you're admitting fault.
- 11:54Someone could come back at you, but no one does. When you actually
- 11:58sincerely apologize, people don't use that against you. They only use it against
- 12:03you when you don't apologize. I mean, not all the time, but
- 12:05but anyway, So I have personally actually developed over the years as a as
- 12:11a marital and family therapist. I don't want to toot my own horn,
- 12:16but I'm a very good apology giver, not only because I fuck up all
- 12:20the time, but I also I just learned a long time ago that if
- 12:26you can dig down deep and actually just sincerely apologize without a single butt I
- 12:30mean, because part of it comes from observing so many bad apologies, you
- 12:33know, in therapy, and just being like you know, they'll they'll have
- 12:39those kinds of apologies and I'll just watch it. I'll just be like,
- 12:41you know, we got to get to the good apology and then we can
- 12:46move on, you know. And so in my own personal life, I've
- 12:48I just for decades now, I've just found myself to be very good at
- 12:52apologizing, whereas other people aren't. You know, most other people just have
- 12:58a harder time with it. I'm so sorry I was saying those things.
- 13:01They were terrible, but you were being a dick, yeah, because I
- 13:07know that in interpersonal issues, in in you know, loving relationships, if
- 13:16you can apologize, well you can, you can you can erase all bads.
- 13:22And that's how I've always felt myself as like, you know, people
- 13:26make mistakes. You you lose perspective, you get triggered. You you know
- 13:31you're in a bad mood. You know, something goes wrong. Everyone makes
- 13:35mistakes, everyone loses perspective, everyone loses their temper. But you know,
- 13:41if you can apologize for it sincerely, then I will wipe that clean.
- 13:46You and I got into a fight not too long ago, right, and
- 13:52it was you know, ridiculous, uh, both of us. It was
- 13:56nasty. It was a nasty fucking fight. You and I it was,
- 14:00you know, it was not pleasant. Some you know, some seriously horrible
- 14:05things were said, and you know, after you let it was, it
- 14:11was actually, you know, coincidentally, after we podcasted, we like,
- 14:15yes, hit stop on the podcasting, and then we just continued the conversation
- 14:20into my kitchen. And then and then before I even knew what was happening,
- 14:24we were in an argument. Now, she's never discussed politics, religion,
- 14:28or sex with anyone ever, I guess. And then as soon as
- 14:35you left my place, you know, I'm pacing around and you know,
- 14:39and I'm talking talking shit behind your back to people in my life, and
- 14:43I'm just like, he said this, and he said that. And then
- 14:48eventually I'm just like, I'm just like, well, what am I going
- 14:50to do with this? You know? And then I just thought, well,
- 14:56you know, I've you and I have been in a lot of fights
- 14:58in our our ten years or enough anyway to the point where I can trust
- 15:05that you deep down don't want to actually harm me or hurt my feelings.
- 15:11And so I just figured, you know, something must have gone weird,
- 15:16something must have been triggered, you know, on both both of our sides,
- 15:20And so I decided I texted you and I said something like, you
- 15:30know, I don't know what I said, but I said something like I'm
- 15:31sorry, or you know, I got sorry for what I said. I
- 15:37must have been triggered. Now the full thing I wanted to say was fuck
- 15:41you, and you know, yeah, I'm sorry for what I said,
- 15:46but you better fucking apologize for you know, like, but that's not what
- 15:50I said. What I said. I just apologized because I was ninety five
- 15:56percent sure that that would begin the reparation process. And you apologize right away
- 16:00too, which you did, and then we immediately just started joking around with
- 16:04each others and just being like, you know, well you're still a dick,
- 16:10you know, or something like that, and then you know, and
- 16:11then all was fine. Do you remember that? Oh yes, So it
- 16:15was a that was a very frustrating evening when I left, because yeah,
- 16:21I mean, we were just podcasting and then you know, um, before
- 16:26before we knew it, we were in a runaway situation and there were no
- 16:30moderators there. There was no one to like help, like, you know,
- 16:33uh, And I don't mean moderators as something you're right, you're wrong,
- 16:36it was I mean, I actually mean facilitator or mediator or someone to
- 16:42be like shut up the two of you. Yeah, exactly. So um
- 16:48it was yeah, and and and you know, I'm a sensitive person with
- 16:52my friendships and relationships, so it hit me hard that night. As I
- 16:56left, I was like, man, it's it's not a good way to
- 16:59leave someone's house that you care about, you know. But you know,
- 17:03I was in the same kind of boat. I was like, you know,
- 17:06I think we just need to look cool off because like, just if
- 17:10I say anything right now, it's gonna be bad. And so I was
- 17:12very glad when I got your text. I'm like, oh, great,
- 17:15yeah, whatever, forget about it. Yeah, I mean, whenever that
- 17:18happens and I managed to break the ice, it always goes well. Yeah,
- 17:25you know, it's just like, just apologize for your part, take
- 17:27responsibility, you know, be remorseful and show that you care. And that's
- 17:36often all that's needed, you know. And you know, and when you
- 17:41were apologizing earlier, were you really apologizing for something? Yeah, the real
- 17:45one? Yeah, were you apologizing for this? Oh? It was something
- 17:48else you did. Okay, Well you'll tell me later what you're really apologizing
- 17:53for. Okay. The last part of the research that we can mention here
- 17:59is there are four most important apologic opponents, so maybe you can guess them,
- 18:04Burtos. So let me let me go through the ten again and it
- 18:07try to and when I say one of them, that's the most important component
- 18:12you chime in. So the first one is statement of apology for once transgression.
- 18:18This is a very simple thing of just saying the words I'm sorry or
- 18:22I apologize. Do you think that's one of the most important ones. Yes,
- 18:26let's see, it is not, because it's basically implied in some of
- 18:30the other ones. But I'm a number two naming the offense. Do you
- 18:36feel like that's one of the important ones out of the town. Well,
- 18:40I guess so because we're having a little bit of uncertainty about thought about.
- 18:45But no, actually, because I think in most situations, you know it's
- 18:49implied you. Uh. Number three taking responsibility for the offense. Yes,
- 18:55this one, I'm gonna go yes, uh it is not. Oh my
- 18:59god, suck it um another one attempt. I mean when you hear the
- 19:04later ones, you might you might go, oh, sorry, I suck
- 19:07at apologizing um. Attempting to explain the offense, but not trying to explain
- 19:14it away, so the context okay, good? Uh. Number five conveying
- 19:18emotions. Yes, yes, that's right, So that's a that's one of
- 19:22the four. Convey your emotion involved, that makes it real. Number two.
- 19:27Number six addressing the emotions of the damaged party. Yes is that No?
- 19:33That's uh. Number seven admitting fault yes, yes, very good.
- 19:38So conveying emotions at mining fault. Number eight promising forbearance no, uh yeah,
- 19:48right, Actually you were right about a previous one. I am not
- 19:52I wasn't reading this right. Um. Actually I appollo lgize, I apologize
- 20:00severely. The way this was written is confusing. You were right already so
- 20:07that you've already said the four. So number one is so in order is
- 20:12a statement of apology for once transaggression. Number two is attempting to explain the
- 20:19offense. Actually you said no to that, yeah, and then admitting fault
- 20:23and uh and then finally making uh and then conveying your emotions. So that's
- 20:30interesting. Okay, the emotions I get at fault, I get, and
- 20:33I'm glad I got the what's it called? Um the first one king?
- 20:38Yeah, but they offering the explanation expl surprising you know that is surprising because
- 20:45that's usually the part that really bothers people, Right, But I find that
- 20:52when I when someone apologized to me, that's that's a big component I want
- 20:56to hear. Now, as long as they're not making excuses, but is
- 21:00to me when people do bad things to me, I figure there's got to
- 21:03be a logical reason, and I kind of want to know that because if
- 21:07there's if they're literally, you know, someone you know, calls me a
- 21:12name and they're just like, I am just you know, they just out
- 21:17of the blue walk into the room and like shout serious horrible shit at me,
- 21:22and they just go, you know what, I'm really sorry I did
- 21:23that, and I know I did it and it's my fault. Yeah,
- 21:30and it's my fault. But I'm You're just like, but why, yeah,
- 21:33why did you do that? You know, what was the context?
- 21:37Then don't worry about it. Yeah, the less you know, the better.
- 21:44All Right, Well, that does it for this episode of Psychology in
- 21:47Seattle. Thanks for joining us out there. Please take care of yourself because
- 21:51you deserve it. Do they do? They really deserve it. I'm sorry,
- 21:53I'm sorry that came out wrong. Yeah, my f