Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E081: Confronting the Chaos of Currency Collapse with Ralph Gebran
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I. Say when we sell.
- 0:26Hey, I say when we sell. All right, welcome back to the
- 0:34Last Trade as always joined by my Co host Michael Tanguma and
- 0:37Brian Cabela's. And this week we have Ralph
- 0:39Gibran, Managing Partner at on Ram Mina.
- 0:43Great to have you on, Ralph. How are you doing?
- 0:45Doing great. Thanks for having me guys,
- 0:47always a pleasure. Long overdue to have you on the
- 0:50last trade. We've had so much exciting stuff
- 0:53happening in the Middle East and I think a number of trips for
- 0:56this whole team. So it's fun to be able to talk
- 0:58about what's been going on out there.
- 1:01The the conference that happened in was it when did the
- 1:04conference happen? This month?
- 1:06No last. Month 4 weeks ago.
- 1:07Yeah, four weeks ago. Yeah, time.
- 1:10Time's been in a weird spot with the holidays and then the
- 1:13conference. Yeah, it was early December.
- 1:15Yes, that's correct. Yeah.
- 1:17It's a good conference, Ralph. It's, it's great to have you on.
- 1:20I think you've actually been on some of the other shows that we
- 1:23produce here at On Ramp, but you haven't been on the last trade
- 1:25before. So maybe for those who are not
- 1:28familiar with you, we can just start with your background in
- 1:31traditional finance and what shaped your personal, personal
- 1:36journey into Bitcoin and ultimately LED you to join On
- 1:40Ramp MENA early on. And then from there, we can go
- 1:42into, there's a lot of things to talk about in the region,
- 1:44including the conference last month, but why don't we just
- 1:48start there so people could be more familiar with who you are?
- 1:51Yeah, for sure. So I had spent the vast majority
- 1:55of my career both academically and professionally in
- 1:58traditional finance. So the last 10 years I've been
- 2:02in the institutional asset management space where I work
- 2:05with two top asset managers, CIBC Asset Management and TD
- 2:08Asset Management based in Canada, Montreal.
- 2:12So I I spent, you know, a lot of time in that space.
- 2:16Before that I worked on trading desk.
- 2:18So I've done foreign exchange, treasury management.
- 2:22So at my previous firm while back, we managed the foreign
- 2:26exchange reserves of a bank in Lebanon because that's
- 2:29originally where I'm from. I worked also at a Western, so
- 2:33TD brokerage where I also traded a variety of instruments across,
- 2:39you know, equity, fixed income, commodities, foreign exchange.
- 2:43I also traded derivative assets. But you know, when you're so
- 2:47knee deep in traditional finance and especially institutional
- 2:50finance, you fail to look at the underlying layer, which is the
- 2:55money. What got me into Bitcoin really
- 2:58is kind of tied to where I'm from.
- 3:01So it was really when the banking system in Lebanon
- 3:04slapped me, my parents, my family and everyone in the face
- 3:08by basically placing unofficial capital controls on withdrawals.
- 3:13And so we had to withdraw limits, you know, $100 per
- 3:18month, $50.00 per month, basically what they determined
- 3:21to be fair so the country didn't go bankrupt officially.
- 3:26So these capital controls are actually imposed purely by the
- 3:31banking system and not by the government itself.
- 3:35Now that was a wake up call. And you know, I had been in
- 3:39Canada at the time, so I was a bit more lucky, even though, you
- 3:43know, I did have some savings back home.
- 3:45Because what they did is they incentivize people to actually
- 3:49move money back home because when the US dollar was paying
- 3:53.5% on your deposit account, you could get 10% in Lebanon on your
- 3:59U.S. dollar deposit account. So a lot of Jaspora, what they
- 4:02did, they transferred a lot of their savings back home and
- 4:06placed it in these term accounts where they were making 10%.
- 4:10So you know how everyone's trying to beat inflation and
- 4:14everyone's trying, you know, to make money with the least amount
- 4:16of risk. So that's, that's what happened.
- 4:19And that, that's kind of what got me into Bitcoin and to, to
- 4:23really try to understand it. Because if that was something
- 4:27that happened once, who's to say that's not going to happen
- 4:30again? So right now there's this whole
- 4:33convoluted solution. We're now in Lebanon.
- 4:35You have 5 different accounts. You have your old accounts where
- 4:38technically there are numbers on the screen.
- 4:40You have something called the fresh account.
- 4:42So these accounts are post that day where you can actually
- 4:45withdraw the money. But who's to say these fresh
- 4:47accounts won't be blocked in the future?
- 4:50And then they create new accounts where you can put in
- 4:52and move money out. That's kind of how I got into
- 4:56Bitcoin. It was really pain.
- 4:58So I'd like to say pain is the best educator.
- 5:01And, you know, we learned the hard way that, you know, trust
- 5:05is something that comes at a cost.
- 5:08So there's, there's risk and trust and trusting institutions,
- 5:11large scale institutions now, especially in countries that
- 5:16have, you know, very tense political environment such as
- 5:20Lebanon. And you know, following that,
- 5:22the currency peg, which was, you know, 1500 Lebanese # to a
- 5:26dollar on average skyrocketed to 80,000 and to 100,000 per
- 5:32dollar. So in Lebanon, it's similar to
- 5:35like Venezuela, where you walk around with a little purse that
- 5:39has millions of Lebanese pounds and that that just covers
- 5:43potentially a dinner for two. The country has fully dollarized
- 5:46since then. So right now in Lebanon, the
- 5:50dollar is king and the Lebanese pound is, you know, barely used.
- 5:55It's just used within the banking system, etcetera.
- 5:57But it's really just representative money.
- 6:00What? What year?
- 6:02Just for context, the from a timeline perspective was that
- 6:06And then also just just to piggyback on the second part and
- 6:08that is you being insulated in the West.
- 6:11I think you said you had some losses, but not not too big.
- 6:15How can you share, like how, because I would imagine friends
- 6:18and family suffered a lot more, you know, have your assets
- 6:21there, how that affects and like what somebody has to do when
- 6:24they realize that only a certain percentage of their wealth may
- 6:27be available to them, like, how do they move forward?
- 6:31Yeah. So that was a year or two before
- 6:35the port explosion, which added to the problems of Lebanon, that
- 6:39major explosion that happened. So 2019-2020 were the peak years
- 6:45of the economic collapse of a few years now.
- 6:48And we haven't fully recovered. So we've hit the fully
- 6:52dollarized stage. But the reaction is, yeah, so we
- 6:55were blessed being outside of Lebanon and have lost, you know,
- 6:59a single portion. But, you know, friends and
- 7:01family, you wake up one day and some individuals have worked
- 7:06their entire life in Lebanon. Some individuals have
- 7:09transferred every penny they made outside of Lebanon to
- 7:13Lebanon. And you wake up overnight and
- 7:16you realize that it's just evaporated.
- 7:19So what happens is it changes societal structures entirely
- 7:25because those who were untrusting of the system, and
- 7:29there's quite a few of them who had invested in like gold or in
- 7:34real estate, the initial stages were much better off.
- 7:39But after the collapse, because even real estate, which a lot of
- 7:43people say it's, you know, store your money in real estate.
- 7:46But in Lebanon, you bought a house for $500,000 because
- 7:51there's no mortgages in Lebanon right now because the entire LBP
- 7:54system has failed. Now it's a cash economy.
- 7:57So if you need to buy a property, you literally pay cash
- 8:00and people are going to sell it to you for half the price
- 8:04because they're going to be paying you in cash.
- 8:06So did you really store the value of your life, energy and
- 8:11hard work? Not really, because you know,
- 8:14you ended up having to liquidate at like half the price.
- 8:18You purchase the property, you've lost all the upside.
- 8:21And the problem is you get that money.
- 8:23You need a bank account outside of the country because, you
- 8:25know, smart people are not going to keep the money at home, nor
- 8:29are they going to, you know, keep it in the Lebanese bank,
- 8:31even though, you know, they say you can withdraw it with these
- 8:34new type of accounts. You've learned your lesson once.
- 8:37So really bank accounts in Lebanon are used just for, you
- 8:41know, into like small time frames.
- 8:44Like you keep the money in there for 5-10 days and then you move
- 8:47it out and find some better investment to put it in that.
- 8:50That's really the situation right now.
- 8:52But it's it's a very big swill, big pill to swallow, waking up
- 8:58and realizing that, you know, if you're at the age of retirement,
- 9:00you can't retire anymore. And it opened up a black market.
- 9:05So one of the consequences of that is people started selling
- 9:09the checks, right? Because you can still write a
- 9:12check because then the money's transferred from one account you
- 9:15can't take money out of into another account that you can,
- 9:18you can't take money out of. But on the screens, you've
- 9:21gained money. So what people would do would
- 9:23they would cut a check and they give you cash for that check and
- 9:30they give it at a discount, right?
- 9:31So they'll tell you, OK, I'll buy that $20,000 for $10,000
- 9:35cash. And then you go, you deposit it
- 9:37on a computer screen, you are now more rich.
- 9:40But this is something more that corporations did to settle
- 9:44transaction between each other because that's a way to get some
- 9:48of your money out. But it's at a significant
- 9:51haircut, as you can imagine, similar to selling a property.
- 9:54You're going to sell it at a significant haircut because $100
- 9:57today is much more than $100 it was before the collapse, right?
- 10:02So people value a harder asset. So they're going for the dollar.
- 10:06Even though in the West you view the dollar as a debasing,
- 10:09depreciating asset, in countries like Lebanon, the dollar seems
- 10:13stable. So that's that's one of the
- 10:16consequences of this. So it's really a paradigm shift
- 10:19in thinking and one that the vast majority of the country
- 10:23hasn't really come out of. And then you add to that, you
- 10:28know, tons of people made lots of money in Lebanon playing this
- 10:31check games and, you know, speculating on the black market
- 10:35rates. So it, it creates really mayhem,
- 10:38chaos and things change really fast.
- 10:41You see less and less US or external products and more local
- 10:48products come into market. And that's just a state of
- 10:51affairs right now. Yeah, not to be real this too
- 10:54much, but this I can't help but call out how uncanny this
- 10:58reminds me of like the crypto markets and claims on bankruptcy
- 11:03notes because there's a reason where we talk about people
- 11:07haven't stepped into this space and like what Ralph described
- 11:10happens all over the world and is it is it's not obviously like
- 11:14it is it's existential to the person because you lose
- 11:17everything you may like lose your life.
- 11:18So it's a very serious thing and that you have to deal with it.
- 11:22But in the digital asset crypto world, like you can make an
- 11:26option to come in or not. And so some people come in and
- 11:29get rugged, but others they look at it and like, why would you
- 11:32want to participate in what happened in Lebanon?
- 11:33Like you don't, but in the digital asset world, you have
- 11:37that option. So you just stay away.
- 11:38You don't touch it because A, you may wake up and all of it's
- 11:41gone and then B, now you have to deal with this headache of like
- 11:45moving out claims and all of this like it's, it's very eerily
- 11:48similar like to this free banking style.
- 11:50That's like started to be what happened with digital assets.
- 11:53And some are trustworthy, others aren't.
- 11:55And it kind of ties into maybe later in the conversation, what
- 11:57we talked about what we do here in the reality where we're
- 11:59heading. You shouldn't have to trust a
- 12:00single entity with your assets because they've been shown that
- 12:04maybe they can be trusted for a while.
- 12:05But at a certain point, you know that trust kind of fades away
- 12:08and you want to check and balance on that.
- 12:11At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 12:14asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 12:18right. There are shortcomings with
- 12:20keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 12:23up your own self custody arrangement.
- 12:25Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 12:28Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 12:31minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 12:34remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 12:38inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 12:40well. Onramp provides Peace of Mind
- 12:43for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 12:46for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 12:49set up. For more information, check us
- 12:51out at on rampbitcoin.com. Ralph, how does appreciate you
- 12:56sharing your background? I mean, it's it's really
- 12:58devastating to hear kind of first account stories of friends
- 13:00and family that have lived through that.
- 13:02And it's as Michael mentioned, it's not isolated to Lebanon,
- 13:06right? Like this is happening all over
- 13:08the world. And in fact, in even in 2022,
- 13:11right, we saw financial controls and bank account freezes in the
- 13:17Western world too. And so do you kind of see the
- 13:21challenges that exist outside of the West?
- 13:23Do you think that that is kind of a precursor to what happens
- 13:25in countries like Canada, for example?
- 13:28Or do you think do you think I may be missing the mark there?
- 13:32No, actually, the way I like to see it, what happened?
- 13:35So the vast majority of the world has hyperinflating
- 13:39currencies. Like realistically when you
- 13:41count the numbers, very few countries have stable solid
- 13:45currencies. And usually it's the countries
- 13:47that have those strong currencies that, you know, make
- 13:50it harder for other countries to get out of that environment
- 13:52because they export the inflation.
- 13:54But what happens in countries like Lebanon?
- 13:58Basically they happen at hyper speed.
- 14:00The exact same thing is happening in Western countries,
- 14:03but at a much slower rate is the way I view it.
- 14:06So it's really is gradually then suddenly in the Western world,
- 14:11in the less developed world, it's actually suddenly it just
- 14:16happens overnight just because of variety of influences.
- 14:19The political environment is much less stable.
- 14:23So that just amplifies the collapse overnight versus in the
- 14:27West. You know, there's much more
- 14:29whether they're real or not, but there's much more checks and
- 14:32balances that kind of slow the process.
- 14:36But what happened in Canada? I mean, I was in Canada and for
- 14:42almost 10 years, so right before Trudeau took power and Canada
- 14:49was a different country. Even my dad and my mom, they
- 14:53immigrated to Canada. So I am Canadian and they have a
- 14:58very different vision of what Canada is and they visited us a
- 15:02few years back and they hadn't been to Canada for quite some
- 15:05time and they were really shocked by the state of the
- 15:08country. So there is a deterioration, but
- 15:11you don't see it if you live there unless you're actually
- 15:14looking for it. And, you know, being in Bitcoin,
- 15:16understanding sound money, understanding the consequences
- 15:20of the basement, monetary printing, you start to realize
- 15:24changes at a much faster pace than if you were just ingrained
- 15:27in the system and just a part of it.
- 15:30What happened in Canada? I mean, you know, there was a
- 15:32trucker incident, which was surreal.
- 15:34I mean, they used executive wartime hours to freeze
- 15:40accounts. I mean, the banks, supposedly
- 15:44they are independent entities from the government.
- 15:47They're not public entities, like, they're not owned by the
- 15:50government. But the problem is when the
- 15:53government states something the banks have to, for example, you
- 15:57know, not be on the wrong side of that statement in fear of
- 16:02repercussions. It's the same thing, you know,
- 16:04with the vaccination process. They never said you have to get
- 16:09vaccinated, but they made a few statements and then all the
- 16:13companies basically they understood it as, oh, you can't
- 16:16work here if you don't get vaccinated, maybe because of
- 16:19insurance problems, Essentially the incentives become all whack.
- 16:23But definitely, you know, over the years, Canada inflation has
- 16:27skyrocketed. The cost of living is crazy.
- 16:30There's been a massive deterioration in the healthcare
- 16:33system. It takes nine months to get an
- 16:37appointment with a specialist. Yes, it's universal healthcare
- 16:40and it's free and you're paying on average 5055% in annual tax.
- 16:45But you would expect to get a better service, but you don't.
- 16:49The roads are deteriorating, so you start noticing small things.
- 16:53And really the peak of this was when the trucker convoy was
- 17:00basically had their whole accounts frozen.
- 17:04And some of them are coming out now lots of years later, winning
- 17:10their cases. But that doesn't mean that they
- 17:13didn't suffer. They didn't struggle throughout
- 17:15their years because being unbanked in the West is not the
- 17:18same as being unbanked in Lebanon.
- 17:21Because in Lebanon people are used to, you know, barter trade.
- 17:26They're used to, you know, cash. It's in the West.
- 17:30I, I never held cash in my wallet, for example, ever.
- 17:34And if you're unbanked, you know, some places you walk into,
- 17:36they're like, oh, no cash or like, we don't take cash or
- 17:40stuff like that. So things have started changing.
- 17:43But yeah, I think now is a good time because things are
- 17:49changing. We're witnessing change across
- 17:52the Western globe with, you know, Trump in the United
- 17:57States, Trudeau resigning in Canada and upcoming candidate
- 18:03Pierre Poliev being more on the, you know, sound monetary side.
- 18:08I mean, say what you will, some people will tell you, yeah, but
- 18:10he's not, you know, he's not a St. either, but who is?
- 18:14I mean, Trump isn't saying either, but what he says and
- 18:18what he claims, like just sending to him to talk talking
- 18:21about, you know, fiscal spending, monetary debasement.
- 18:26I mean, it's just common sense. And it's either that or, you
- 18:30know, the handout economy, which Canada overtime really took to
- 18:36heart where, you know, just pay taxes and we'll give you
- 18:39everything you need basically. But the everything you need is
- 18:43it up to the standard that you're expecting?
- 18:45Well, that's you know what? For me it wasn't at least, but I
- 18:49don't know. It's a, it's a fascinating
- 18:51dynamic. When I was in Dubai last, Ralph
- 18:53was telling me about the healthcare system and just the
- 18:55deterioration, deterioration of everything.
- 18:58And it was just like, so it was so fundamentally different than
- 19:02what the media portrays. And then I came home and maybe I
- 19:05was just more aware to it and it was, it was in the news, like a
- 19:09guy that went to the emergency room, got told he was OK, went
- 19:12home and passed away, like had a heart attack.
- 19:14And there's this, it's this very interesting dynamic where you
- 19:18would look at like from an the way that the media portrays just
- 19:22picking on a few as California and New York and Canada as these
- 19:26bastions of like progressiveness and and the like pinnacle of
- 19:31societal, you know, whatever you want to like make up.
- 19:35And then you go boots on the ground.
- 19:37And these are like third world countries.
- 19:38Like we know what's happening in New York City subways.
- 19:41We know what's going on right now in California.
- 19:43Canada sounds like it's even worse than both.
- 19:46It's just a very interesting dynamic on the things the way
- 19:48it's these societies are portrayed as being progressive
- 19:52and it's usually the closest to the money spigot.
- 19:54The academics are the people that are closer to high finance
- 19:57that are living the best while everyone else is effectively
- 20:00just getting like suck drive of all like capital or time.
- 20:03Yeah, And you know, this might surprise you, but you'll get way
- 20:09better healthcare in Lebanon at a fraction of the cost.
- 20:14At a fraction of the cost. You just show up to the doctor,
- 20:17they see what's wrong with you. If you need the surgery, you do
- 20:20it in a week and you're in and you're out.
- 20:22And it cost you a fraction of the cost.
- 20:24Like some people, they don't do their dentistry in Canada, for
- 20:29example. They go to Lebanon because it's
- 20:31way cheaper. Even with insurance.
- 20:32You end up paying less in Lebanon with no insurance and
- 20:36that's crazy from a third world country that has a
- 20:39hyperinflating currency. But yeah, I mean, it's
- 20:43fascinating how the media portrays certain things.
- 20:46And in Canada, you know, this is a problem with socialism if you
- 20:50ask me, because everyone under the same nationality.
- 20:55So if you have a Canadian passport, you are considered
- 20:58equal in a way and certain angles that's, that's, that's a
- 21:03good thing. But let's say you have a salary
- 21:06of 150,000 in Canada. You're going to be in the, you
- 21:09know, clearly in the top 5% of income earners in Canada, you're
- 21:13going to pay around 55, maybe 57 effective annual tax rate.
- 21:18And someone is making 20,000. When you enter the healthcare
- 21:23system, there's no distinction. So a homeless person in Canada,
- 21:27because Canada is really cold, will go sit in a hospital
- 21:31because he's Canadian and will go sit in a hospital the entire
- 21:34day. They don't care about waiting 10
- 21:37hours to see a doctor because for them, they're sitting in
- 21:40warmth and they are, you know, have no income.
- 21:44But because they're Canadian, they are in the same queue as
- 21:47you are. So basically those who are
- 21:52creating value or, you know, having higher salaries are
- 21:56giving the same service level as someone who produces no value in
- 22:02the economy. It's a sad thing, of course, and
- 22:05you want everyone to be treated right, but the system is not
- 22:09equipped to do that. There's not enough doctors
- 22:11because for example, even if you're American or like if you
- 22:14studied medicine in Paris, you can't come and study and be a
- 22:19practitioning Dr. in Canada. You have to go through a
- 22:23education process as well. So they have a lack of dog.
- 22:26And if you're a Canadian doctor, why would you stay in Canada?
- 22:29You have a quota on the number of clients you can get.
- 22:32So most of the good doctors leave to the US, They get paid
- 22:36maybe way more in the US and you can have as many clients as you
- 22:39want. Yeah.
- 22:40And I think to like reframe this to you can't insulate yourself
- 22:45from a bad form of money over a long enough time arisen.
- 22:47So this can happen to anyone and you kind of see where the states
- 22:52the the states that have adopted, whether it's lower
- 22:54income taxes or making it more favorable.
- 22:57I would think post like 2020 because I feel like that's a big
- 23:00line of demarcation. And a lot of this Tennessee,
- 23:03Florida and Texas have really thrived.
- 23:06And I think we're going to increasingly thrive given
- 23:07everything we just talked about where the best human capital is
- 23:11moving there because of those favorable things.
- 23:13I think ideally with this post administration that supports,
- 23:18but Jackson, I, I know there's some geopolitical stuff we want
- 23:20to talk to that ties into that I do.
- 23:21Yeah, I want to appreciate that. And Ralph, I want to drive
- 23:25toward your experiences now in the Emirates.
- 23:27So you lived in Canada for a while, you're Lebanese and
- 23:32you've since moved back to where you've moved to the UAE, which
- 23:36is now closer to home for you and your managing partner at On
- 23:40Ramp MENA. So you've been there now for not
- 23:43a full year, but maybe six months or so, right?
- 23:45And so how do your experiences in the UAE, in Dubai, Abu Dhabi
- 23:50compare to what you've seen in your traditional finance
- 23:53background, mostly in Canada? And then after that, I want to
- 23:58drive toward what you're seeing in terms of Bitcoin adoption and
- 24:01growth and interest among institutional investors, high
- 24:04net worth individuals. But first, I think it'd be
- 24:06interesting just to hear a quick compare and contrast to life in
- 24:10the Emirates. And how does that compare to the
- 24:14experiences that you've lived so far outside of in the Western
- 24:18world? Yeah.
- 24:19So the Emirates is big, right? So I'll speak to Dubai for
- 24:25starters, and we can extrapolate on that.
- 24:28But one thing I'll start off with.
- 24:30So there's no income tax and there are roads and tons of
- 24:35infrastructure. So you don't really need income
- 24:37tax to build infrastructure. There are a variety of ways you
- 24:40can do that. One thing that's fascinating and
- 24:44you know, it's a young city, but they've been at it for 30 years
- 24:47or so, 40 years. And if you came 40 years ago, it
- 24:51would be like images you see of the desert, like there was no
- 24:55infrastructure. And one thing that's huge
- 24:58contrast to Canada is the quality of the infrastructure.
- 25:02The stuff they're building here is, you know, out of a sci-fi
- 25:05movie and there's a level and Michael, when you were in town,
- 25:09you said something which I found really interesting, a level of
- 25:13excellence. Like if they want to do
- 25:14something, they're going to do it big and they're going to do
- 25:16it right now that is is very different.
- 25:21They have a much more entrepreneurial mindset.
- 25:25So you feel like a young person, you know, they're more willing
- 25:29to take risks. They're more willing to try new
- 25:31things. Well, the UAE is taking that
- 25:34mindset when it comes to building a nation, so they are
- 25:38willing to try the untried or to test the untested to grow the
- 25:44economy. They've been labeled in the
- 25:46past, especially in the GCC, as, yeah, they're only in oil.
- 25:50That's their only thing. But if you come here, you'll
- 25:53realize that, you know, you don't really notice oil in any
- 25:58form of way. What you see is, you know, a
- 26:00very thriving economy that's really diversified.
- 26:04All you have to do is look at the, you know, fintech industry.
- 26:08You have to look at the, you know, tourism and service
- 26:12industry, which it's uncomparable.
- 26:17There's one thing they do here which is to rather in comfort
- 26:21you in the sense that if something were to happen, you
- 26:24just go to the hospital and you're taking care of.
- 26:27You don't have to pay a dime. What they do here is more of a
- 26:30enablement so they don't take the money away from you.
- 26:34They will find other ways to take it away from you by making
- 26:38life so easy. I mean, you can get gas
- 26:42delivered to your home while your car is parked outside.
- 26:45Anything you want can be facilitated here.
- 26:48And even one thing that was really different is the
- 26:51government aspects of things. So in the West, at least in my
- 26:54experience, getting something done at the government level is
- 26:57slow and painful. Here, everything is digitized.
- 27:01I mean, government agents are quick to respond.
- 27:05You can get on a call. I almost never wait on a queue
- 27:08line when I call a government agency, which is something that
- 27:11was a shock to me. I just call and someone picks
- 27:13up. So what they're trying to do is
- 27:15incentivize growth and to do that they are enabling people to
- 27:21come here and they enable them when they are here to actually
- 27:25build. And that's extremely noticeable
- 27:28in the digital asset space because that's what we're in and
- 27:32within the digital asset space. I'll segue into the question
- 27:36about Bitcoin adoption. So the UAE has taken a very
- 27:40different stance than Western countries in the sense that they
- 27:43saw an opportunity and they decided they won't take
- 27:46advantage of that while the West was still, you know, battling
- 27:50between all, should we legalize this?
- 27:52There's no regulatory framework. We don't know what to do with it
- 27:55here. They decided to sit down, build
- 27:58a whole framework around it to incentivize people to come here
- 28:02and build something. So that's the approach they
- 28:05took. So unlike other countries, here,
- 28:07you're very quickly capable of knowing what you can and cannot
- 28:11do. So the Gray area has been
- 28:13removed from the equation, which allows entrepreneurs to build
- 28:18effectively. And you would say, oh, but now
- 28:21there are rules and things are set in stone and there can't be
- 28:25changed. But that's another thing that's
- 28:27very different. Rules are not supposed to be
- 28:30broken, but rules are supposed to be enhanced when they are
- 28:34outdated. And so one thing we've noticed,
- 28:37because for example, we're trying to bring multi
- 28:39institution custody into the region to save keep Bitcoin the
- 28:42right way. The regulators are always
- 28:45fascinated because it's new and different.
- 28:48And the first thing they're thinking is how can we grow the
- 28:50ecosystem and how can we do something to improve the
- 28:53ecosystem? And when you come with a solid
- 28:56value proposition and a product that you know they can't deny is
- 29:01a upgrade to the current state of affairs, even if it's not
- 29:05regulated under your current guidelines, they will speak to
- 29:09you. So the answer no doesn't come
- 29:12across often. It's more like, OK, let's talk
- 29:16more about it, walk me through how this works.
- 29:19And then they will work with you to trying to find the fit either
- 29:23within the current framework or if they need to, they have a
- 29:27division called regulatory enablement.
- 29:30Meaning if they notice that there's something they want to
- 29:32bring in, but the rules don't allow it, and they think maybe
- 29:36they put in the wrong rule or an outdated rule, they will work
- 29:40with you to try to adjust that rule or to find a way to fit you
- 29:45in the economy. So that's, I mean, every
- 29:47entrepreneur's dream. If you have a crazy idea or
- 29:49something really outside of the box or different, you want a
- 29:54regulator that's willing to have a conversation with you.
- 29:57And if they see that, you know, no one else is doing this, but
- 30:01we have the opportunity to bring this technology and be the first
- 30:05to bring it into the region, then you know what?
- 30:08That's what they're going to do because they're they always are
- 30:12trying to catch up or, you know, improve upon the current
- 30:16standard, which is, you know, everything in the West is
- 30:19better. But over time, we've seen a lot
- 30:22of the teacher variation in the West, even from a technological
- 30:25point of view, most of the tech in the West maybe is designed
- 30:29but is not built in the West. And so they're trying to bring
- 30:32some of that on shore and actually own the space, whether
- 30:35it's AI, digital assets or fintech striving environment.
- 30:40And I think you can see that across the UAE.
- 30:43Of course, there are areas that are more conservative than
- 30:46others, but they found a loophole to that.
- 30:48So they created these islands called free zones that use
- 30:53basically common common law, so foreign companies can come and
- 30:57set shop in a very familiar way than, you know, stuff that they
- 31:02are used to outside of the GCC and start working the market
- 31:07from those free zones. And the UAE is just one of those
- 31:10countries. Bahrain, it's a tiny country,
- 31:13but the regulators there are, I mean, a few months ago we were
- 31:16inside the central Bank of Bahrain.
- 31:19As someone in Bitcoin, I never thought in my entire life I
- 31:22would set foot in the central bank even less so that I would
- 31:25have a very productive convert conversation around Bitcoin
- 31:29custody and multi institutional custody.
- 31:31And you know, I don't think anyone in the West can say that.
- 31:35I mean, if I wanted to meet with someone at the central bank, it
- 31:39might take two years to get that meeting through between all the
- 31:41background checks, making sure, you know, it's just that's just
- 31:46my viewpoint. I hope that answers your
- 31:47question. Yeah.
- 31:48I appreciate that Ralph 11 thing that you mentioned maybe like 30
- 31:52seconds ago or a minute ago that I think really ties into this
- 31:56conversation. And what we're seeing is there's
- 31:58an attitude of complacency versus competitiveness, right?
- 32:01What you anchored to was in the Middle East, maybe they have a
- 32:06perception that everything is better in the West or we're
- 32:08ahead in terms of innovating. But we have that same attitude,
- 32:11right? In the United States.
- 32:12We think that we're the best at everything.
- 32:14And we've had that attitude for decades now.
- 32:16And that's ultimately led to the deterioration and this pain that
- 32:21we're kind of living through as a society.
- 32:23And now, hopefully, on the other side of this, there will be more
- 32:25of an attitude of competitiveness in the United
- 32:28States, which I think would mirror more closely the
- 32:31competitiveness of the Gulf countries.
- 32:33Right? And so now with the Trump
- 32:36administration coming in, I think this ultimately ties into
- 32:39sovereign game theory. And what are we seeing in terms
- 32:42of geopolitical competition for Bitcoin, for gold, hard assets,
- 32:47outside money versus inside money, right?
- 32:49Because ultimately, what's going to drive these economies forward
- 32:52and what drives Bitcoin forward this next decade is
- 32:55competitiveness between nations and who wants to lead within
- 32:58Bitcoin. So to that extent, I know the
- 33:01team worked on a report recently about sovereign game theory
- 33:05around Bitcoin adoption, particularly anchoring to
- 33:09Trump's administration and what they've said on the campaign
- 33:13trails as it relates to policy and regulatory, let's say, a
- 33:17more positive regulatory stance around Bitcoin.
- 33:20And so maybe what we could do is just talk a little bit through
- 33:23the high level of that report and how does that ultimately tie
- 33:26into what you're seeing in the Emirates, in the Gulf countries?
- 33:30Before jumping into that, I just want to call out one thing
- 33:33because I think this is an important distinction.
- 33:35Dubai gets an interesting rap because you usually have
- 33:38polarizing feel like it's either super pro, everything's amazing,
- 33:42or you'll get the other side, which is, well, it's a
- 33:45dictatorship or kings, or they have oil and they're both like
- 33:49not fully in my like everything's nuanced.
- 33:52And you can look at Canada and say Canada has a bunch of oil,
- 33:54but they don't know how to pull out of the ground because it
- 33:56lacks leadership, right? And so just calling out a lot of
- 33:59these things come down to leadership, but also this notion
- 34:02of we talk about startups like the UAE is effectively like a
- 34:05really well run startup because they have leadership that has
- 34:11autonomy and control. But any good startup, you know
- 34:14that the leadership while you can move fast and they're
- 34:17directing, you need the buy in from your effective
- 34:19constituents, your employees to be bought in or they won't be
- 34:22there very long. And so that's where we're kind
- 34:24of seeing in the West. He's like populist movements and
- 34:26like new leadership is because eventually people get tired of
- 34:30being cold and poor and broke. And so because they have a
- 34:34different government structure and style does not necessarily
- 34:37mean it's good or bad. It's just a different.
- 34:39It's the way I think about in my mind is ultra conservative.
- 34:43So they they they've been a little slower for things.
- 34:45And now Dubai is one of the ones starting to move like this way.
- 34:48We're over here. We got way progressive weeks,
- 34:50like insanely compressive and we kind of see these in the states
- 34:53where certain conservative states have been more from a
- 34:57revenue, from an innovation perspective, people are going
- 35:00there. So it's just a constant battle
- 35:01of like conservative progressiveness.
- 35:04And then the natural, like whatever we call it, employees,
- 35:08constituents, citizens are ultimately always going to be
- 35:13able to move with their feet at a certain point.
- 35:15And now they're capital Bitcoin. And that's where the game theory
- 35:18starts to take off. So just going to set that stage
- 35:21because I think a lot of people generally look at the GCC, it's
- 35:24like they have all the money. That's why they have all this
- 35:26stuff. It's like, well, that's only one
- 35:28part. Venezuela has a bunch of oil and
- 35:30they can't get it out of the ground because they have no
- 35:32leadership and no government to be able to do that.
- 35:34So you have to like need to be able to coordinate economic
- 35:36activity while also having the natural resources.
- 35:40And also the government, yes, some people have, you know,
- 35:45negative things to say, but the government here is extremely
- 35:51efficient. I mean, I, I, I do have to say
- 35:55that they've aligned their incentives.
- 35:58They are very patriot. And all they really care about
- 36:01is to see their people prosper and to have other people come
- 36:05here to build and prosper as well.
- 36:08So what allows them to do that is like you said, they have,
- 36:12it's a lot of control over decision making.
- 36:15There's no bureaucracy, like the level of bureaucracy is really
- 36:19minimal compared to like in the West where 1000 people have to
- 36:23look at a document until, you know, a final decision maker
- 36:26signs off on it. Well, here, if something is
- 36:28crucial and needs to happen, it will happen at a much faster
- 36:31pace. And that's how you have, you
- 36:33know, these crazy infrastructure projects that are being built,
- 36:36these crazy initiatives because, you know, you can just go ahead
- 36:40and build it if you choose to. So in a way, there's our pros
- 36:43and cons. I know Saifuddin has a lot to
- 36:45say about, you know, monarchies. I don't think we should get too
- 36:49much into that. But it I think people, when they
- 36:53come here, a lot of them are surprised about the openness,
- 36:56the progressiveness, and they're shocked by the amount of freedom
- 37:00they have here. I mean, Michael, you've been
- 37:02here. Did you ever, I mean, you forget
- 37:05your wallet in the middle of the road.
- 37:07No one picks it up. I mean, there's so much security
- 37:09and so much comfort. It reminds me of like, would you
- 37:12rather work for like Uber and be an employee number 11 or the SEC
- 37:16employee number like 5000, right?
- 37:19Like, because there's two different people that want to do
- 37:21that, but one wants to be able to have a meritocracy and be
- 37:24able to exceed and the other one wants to be part of like and go
- 37:28to work and go home. And like, I think there's a
- 37:30place in society for both, but over time, 1 ends up just eating
- 37:34itself and the other one ends up innovating and becoming a
- 37:38leader. And that's like effectively
- 37:39where you start to see these disconnects to your point of the
- 37:41bureaucracy built into that. That's why I, I do love the, the
- 37:46analogy of, you know, America being the greatest startup ever,
- 37:49but, you know, sort of losing, losing our way in some sense.
- 37:52And also ties to what Jackson was saying around complacency.
- 37:55And that's, that is the perfect metaphor because you know, if
- 37:59you think about, you know, whether it's the United States
- 38:02or other countries in the West getting complacent, thinking
- 38:04that they're ahead, and also just having this sort of
- 38:07administrative state build up, metastasize over time.
- 38:10And that's what the your the bureaucracy you're talking
- 38:13about, Ralph. And it's like, yeah, you can't,
- 38:15you can't move fast and make decisions and be innovative and
- 38:18forward thinking if you have all that sort of holding you back,
- 38:23that that bureaucracy holding you back.
- 38:24And I think that's why it's been refreshing.
- 38:27I, I don't know about you guys, but I feel like we we have
- 38:29turned a corner in some sense, at least in the US.
- 38:33And now it looks like Canada with Trudeau resigning, which
- 38:37Ralph, I don't know if if you have any thoughts there.
- 38:38Like, what do you think prompted him to to actually resign?
- 38:41I mean, people have been calling for him to resign for for
- 38:44several years now. Do you think it was just Trump
- 38:46winning and, and kind of, you know, jockeying back and forth
- 38:49with him threatening tariffs? And he was just like, I'm, I'm
- 38:51over this. Let me get out.
- 38:53I don't think it was that moment itself.
- 38:57What I think this has been something in the making for
- 39:00quite some time. I mean, if you look at the
- 39:02approval ratings of Justin Trudeau over the past few years,
- 39:07they've been in decline consistently.
- 39:09And a lot of the policies that he's implemented have been
- 39:13extremely unpopular. For example, the carbon tax,
- 39:17like Michael, you said they have tons of oil, but they just can't
- 39:19take it out of the ground. Well, you know, you have tons of
- 39:22oil, it's your natural resource and then you go and you tax
- 39:27every time they they pull it out of the ground, which means
- 39:30everyone has to suffer because those costs are transferred to
- 39:32the consumer, not really the corporations, because the
- 39:36corporations are just going to push the price up and then
- 39:38transfer it on. I think it's a few combinations.
- 39:43So the trucker incident was the kick off the COVID vaccine.
- 39:48Authoritarian policies was secondary and then similar to
- 39:53the US, the cost of living, that was one of the biggest issues he
- 39:59had and the amount of spending. Canada has no gold, for example.
- 40:04And I mean, it doesn't really produce a lot of stuff, if
- 40:08anything of significance. I think they also pushed out the
- 40:13Pharmaceutical industry as well, if I recall.
- 40:15So really they have no. Industry or you know, foundation
- 40:21and their, their energy sector is taking a hit as well because
- 40:23of all the carbon tax. I think.
- 40:25So it's a combination of people seeing what happened in the US
- 40:29as well, which also helped a lot because, you know, Trump is loud
- 40:34and Trump has had a lot of saying he's backed by a lot of
- 40:38very influential people. So when you're in Canada, you
- 40:40look a lot at what's happening in the US because they're your
- 40:44direct neighbor. There's huge trade in between
- 40:46those countries. So what they decide to do or
- 40:49who's coming to run the show is definitely going to affect your
- 40:52living standards here. And Trudeau just seemed somewhat
- 40:56weak in that record and couldn't, you know, stand face
- 40:59to face and negotiate with someone like Trump.
- 41:03Now also, Trudeau has been able to maintain power because of
- 41:08certain alliances with other socialist parties like the NDP
- 41:12and the Conservatives, even though they've had a weird
- 41:16history. I mean, not all Conservative
- 41:18year has been have been great. Pierre Poliev is kind of the
- 41:22equivalent of Donald Trump in a lot of the things he says.
- 41:27You know, he wants to build things internally.
- 41:29He wants to reduce the cost of living.
- 41:32He wants to stop fiscal spending.
- 41:35And basically, he wants to audit the government and figure out
- 41:38where the waste is happening. So I think the world hit a
- 41:42turning point. So when you're in pain, you look
- 41:44for solutions and, you know, you start to think, I have nothing
- 41:48else to lose. I mean, I'd rather change than
- 41:52no change. So it doesn't matter who the
- 41:55other candidate is. You just want a fighting chance
- 41:59with someone new. So I think all those factors,
- 42:02add them together. And you saw, and what's funny is
- 42:07he was overthrown by his own ministers.
- 42:11I mean, basically they all turned their back on him.
- 42:14And I think here there's political incentives to do that
- 42:17because they felt that he wasn't going to be able to maintain his
- 42:21position of power. And so the pieces of the chess
- 42:25board starting already positioning themselves in a way
- 42:27that was advantageous to their 'cause that's what led to the
- 42:32collapse, in my opinion. Like from a Oh yeah, go ahead,
- 42:35Michael, sorry. Was the same time back to
- 42:37Jackson's. I think the game theory aspect,
- 42:42there's like the game theory on the coalition that happened in
- 42:46the US with, you know, technologists and just business
- 42:50individuals realizing what the other administration look like.
- 42:53And you have to make a, you know, a concerted effort to like
- 42:56who you're in a back. And we saw this with the Trump
- 42:59election win. But then time back to what
- 43:02Jackson was referencing, whether it's game theory of Bitcoin or
- 43:06any hard tech, every government, every country is fighting on
- 43:11behalf of their own constituents, natural resources.
- 43:15And so the UAE, among others, have started to invest heavily,
- 43:18whether it's an AI, you know, mining.
- 43:20We know like a lot of these countries have been mining, you
- 43:23know, years before this. But I think that there's this
- 43:26notion and Luke Roman was and was a big inspiration for this
- 43:31piece that our team put together referencing this dates back to
- 43:35post 08 financial crisis. I won't be able to do the
- 43:37justice for the report justice, but I would encourage anybody to
- 43:41go listen to the podcast Luke did with Robert Breedlove or the
- 43:44report. But in its essence, it ties back
- 43:46to post 08/09. There hasn't really been a
- 43:50sustained treasury buyer because at the end of the from an
- 43:53external perspective, because at the end of the day, if you're
- 43:56exporting natural resources and then re.
- 43:59So those are resources that you need for your constituents and
- 44:04your citizens. And if you are recycling those
- 44:07assets into treasuries that are effectively losing capital and
- 44:10you can't go buy the things that you need to import them, well,
- 44:14you're in a really bad spot over a long enough time horizon.
- 44:17And so that's where the heavy gold accumulation and dumping of
- 44:21treasuries has occurred. And then I think it was
- 44:23accelerated post Russia being sanctioned.
- 44:27And so countries starting to realize all of this are making
- 44:30this bet that I need to hold something else other than
- 44:33government debt. And this goes into the inside,
- 44:35outside money. I don't know, Brian.
- 44:37You want to pick up Jackson? Yeah, real quick on that.
- 44:39It's almost the perfect analogy just at the sovereign level to
- 44:42Ralph, what you described at the start of the show about the
- 44:45banking system in Lebanon. The the same thing happens at
- 44:49the sovereign level where historically and, and still to
- 44:52the state, but at a declining rate.
- 44:54Other nations are purchasing U.S.
- 44:56Treasuries and other US assets, but are inclined to decrease
- 45:01those purchases over time because of A, the inflation
- 45:04embedded in fixed income securities issued by the
- 45:07government and then B, because it could be confiscated.
- 45:11There's kind of capital controls tied to, to those investments,
- 45:14right? So it's pretty much the same
- 45:15thing that you described earlier, but now it's happening
- 45:17at a sovereign level. And I think that ultimately
- 45:20kicks off what we've seen since Michael you mentioned post 2008
- 45:23certainly accelerated in the past couple of years here where
- 45:26other nations are looking for a political and investments or
- 45:32sort of values that are free of counterparty risk.
- 45:35Yeah. I would even go as far as to say
- 45:37like I think the past three or four years, like that is the,
- 45:43the, the preference or the recognition by various cohorts
- 45:47that you'd rather own or at least have some allocation to a
- 45:51form of outside money. Like that's been the main driver
- 45:54of Bitcoin adoption and demand for the asset in my mind.
- 45:58And I think to to your point, Michael, it was very much
- 46:01exacerbated by Russia's treasury being seized.
- 46:04So this asset that everyone sort of perceived as risk free or at
- 46:08least you can trust the counterparty that sort of
- 46:12collapsed or deteriorated. And you know, a a piece that I
- 46:17think was formative in my understanding of this was Zoltan
- 46:20Pozar, who was formerly an economist at Credit Suisse.
- 46:24Now he's he's launched his own business.
- 46:27I think it's an advisory business, but he wrote a piece,
- 46:29I think in 21 perhaps around there that was talking about
- 46:35this concept of inside versus outside money and this new
- 46:39monetary order that he was sort of recognizing was, was in the
- 46:42midst of, of developing. And then the other, the other
- 46:46note, which I think is not often talked about or, you know,
- 46:52under, under, you know, represented it when people talk
- 46:55about game theory in general and also sovereign game theory when
- 46:58it comes to Bitcoin specifically, is it's very
- 47:01different than every other sort of instance historically of
- 47:06sovereign game theory in the sense that the individual can
- 47:10participate. So if you think about like other
- 47:13instances in history of, of sovereign game theory playing
- 47:16out, whether it's, you know, resource control or nuclear arms
- 47:20race, or, you know, any of these things where nation states are
- 47:24competing against each other in almost all of those scenarios,
- 47:28like the individual, the person is completely removed from that
- 47:32game. Like they have no say, no
- 47:34influence. And this sort of Bitcoin game
- 47:37theory is this, you know, very egalitarian thing where like,
- 47:40yeah, now we're seeing it play out at the sovereign level, but
- 47:42it's like the individual is very much involved and can play in
- 47:46this game. And that's just extremely
- 47:48unique. And something that isn't, is I
- 47:51don't think anyone, I've heard many people bring it up when
- 47:53when they talk about this game theory and it's it's it's very
- 47:57unique. It's different than any other
- 47:58game theory we've watched play out because you and I, the
- 48:00individual, can participate. Well, and it is the thing
- 48:03because I think it's the interplay that the sovereigns
- 48:06are playing at a level this like ties back to in its essence.
- 48:09And I don't think many people talk about what you just
- 48:11described. And I would again encourage to
- 48:13go listen as pod because it references that you usually
- 48:17think the common notion of Bitcoin becoming or competing
- 48:21with the dollar. People are saying that it's it's
- 48:23competing with the dollar and the government will never allow.
- 48:25But there's like 2 factions or concerns when you think about 1
- 48:28is coming with the doll and the other one's competing with
- 48:30national security. And national security
- 48:33effectively means that you have to produce arms and weaponry to
- 48:36protect your citizens. And in Luke, growing makes the
- 48:39case that in Ukraine, it was shown that we cannot manufacture
- 48:43the things that are needed at the scale of other sovereigns.
- 48:46And so if you're going to come back and reassure all these, you
- 48:50know, things that need to be made here, which we understand
- 48:52from all the things that we know about hollowing out and
- 48:55manufacturing, well then that isn't a natural cause for
- 48:59inflation. Well, your citizens have to be
- 49:01able to have an asset A, if you're going to inflate that
- 49:04they can benefit so it can increase GDP, but B, that they
- 49:07actually hold a form of money that's inflating faster than the
- 49:10assets cost so they can still be able to buy things.
- 49:13And that's the interplay that doesn't get discussed on why
- 49:16this would make sense from it's the game theory plays into it
- 49:20from a national level to create a sovereign stockpile, but also
- 49:24from everyone that's holding, which just happens to be the
- 49:27United States citizens hold the majority or a large percentage
- 49:31of the total Bitcoin supply. Sorry, Ro.
- 49:33Yeah. And I'll just add so the way I
- 49:35view Bitcoin, because I'll tell you just from my personal
- 49:39experience, 20 years ago, it was unheard of that, you know,
- 49:44Russia or China would be so involved in the Middle East and
- 49:49Africa. Nowadays that's just a regular
- 49:52occurrence, and the reason we've seen the shift over the years
- 49:56is, especially since the Russia Ukraine war, with the
- 50:01financialization of the financial rails.
- 50:04Because at the end of the day, sovereign game theory is reliant
- 50:07mostly on financial rails. Yes, weaponry and national
- 50:12security is important, but none of that could exist without
- 50:15being able to move money around. The easiest way to choke your
- 50:19opponent is to cut them off the financial system.
- 50:22It will stop import of needed resources to build any type of
- 50:26equipment you want. It will just isolate you.
- 50:29So these countries, China, Russia, have been trying to
- 50:32position themselves in areas where the US has started to lose
- 50:37geopolitical power or influence. That's why sometimes rumors come
- 50:41out about the bricks, for example, separating from the
- 50:45Petro dollar, etcetera. So the Russians and the Chinese
- 50:48are in the region trying to influence them so that they are
- 50:52a player within the energy rich area.
- 50:55But Bitcoin solves, you know, this political maneuvering
- 50:59because it is much more efficient to be able to just buy
- 51:04or mine Bitcoin and build a strategic reserve than to have
- 51:07to move human capital, resources and investments into those areas
- 51:12to try to build loyalty and influence.
- 51:16So by owning Bitcoin, these nation states really technically
- 51:20are, you know, reducing the capital load on their nations
- 51:24and trying to basically secure what Bitcoin already does, which
- 51:29allows you to move value anywhere and to settle within 10
- 51:34minutes. So I think they're picking up on
- 51:36that and now in the region here, you'll notice most of the
- 51:41countries have been stockpiling tons of gold.
- 51:44So that's another, you know, money that's sitting outside of
- 51:48the system. So out money that the term you
- 51:50use in the report and Bitcoin just makes sense because as an
- 51:56asset is it would be much easier to transact at a global scale.
- 51:59So I view Bitcoin as you know, the end game when it comes to
- 52:04political influence. And the reason why is because it
- 52:07removes the need for excessive deployment of troops to secure
- 52:14the financial rails of your nations.
- 52:16So that's that's just one thing I view because 20 years ago it
- 52:20was unheard of that Russia would be in the Middle East or that
- 52:22China would be involved in the Middle East.
- 52:24It was purely AUS dominated area or European dominate dominated
- 52:28area. Yeah, the other the other
- 52:32component too is and you know, whether it's if you want to talk
- 52:37about, you know, some of the work that Jason Lowry has done
- 52:42on this in terms of, you know, Bitcoin being this new form of
- 52:45power projection. And effectively, if you if you
- 52:49can get to the assumption that this is going to be a heavily
- 52:53trafficked monetary rail into the future, then you want to be
- 52:57able to secure some amount of that.
- 52:59And Bob Burnett I think also does a really good job about
- 53:01talking about this in the sense that like not only is Bitcoin
- 53:05itself scarce, but block space is scarce.
- 53:07So it if there's blocks every 10 minutes, you as a nation state
- 53:12want to be sure and, or even just as a private company or an
- 53:15enterprise, you want to have some amount of confidence that
- 53:21you'll be able to transact on the network.
- 53:24And so that means either, you know, setting up hash rate.
- 53:28And so that's why I think, you know, what Lowry talks a lot
- 53:31about is sort of these hash rate wars that will probably have
- 53:35already started playing out, particularly in the Middle East.
- 53:37I think that's, that's pretty readily apparent.
- 53:41And you could argue what's happening here too.
- 53:43It's just they're, they're public companies, but they're
- 53:46they're within our border. So I think that, you know, if
- 53:49you're being honest about it, like that would count in terms
- 53:52of United States house, right? So I think that's, that's the
- 53:56other component too, is like you need to have access to the rails
- 54:00to the scarce block space in order to truly participate.
- 54:04Like yes, owning a stockpile helps you from more of a
- 54:08financial or economic perspective, but like in terms
- 54:10of actually using the rails, that's where the mining mining
- 54:14game theory comes in too. Yeah.
- 54:17And in the UAE, I mean, no one will confirm that the government
- 54:22at the sovereign level is building hashtray.
- 54:25Why would? But I mean, every single person
- 54:27you speak to that's involved in energy infrastructure or data
- 54:31centers and mining will tell you that the government is mining.
- 54:36I mean, their sovereign wealth fund has an allocation to
- 54:40Phoenix Group, which is one of the biggest miners in the
- 54:42region. Bit Main and Giga are really
- 54:46present within the region as well.
- 54:48So I mean, there's a reason for that.
- 54:50There's someone that's buying up the equipment and setting up
- 54:53these shops, right? I mean, energy isn't necessarily
- 54:57cheap at the, you know, retail level, but somewhere it's cheap
- 55:04for this demand of mining companies setting up shop here.
- 55:08There is someone who is buying these machines and building
- 55:10these mining farms. And, you know, we can't really
- 55:15say who I, I, I don't think we'll, we'll know until some
- 55:19major announcement happens in the US where the actual Bitcoin
- 55:23reserve actually goes live or is officially announced.
- 55:26At that point, I wouldn't be surprised if some country within
- 55:30the GCC, mainly Oman or you know, the UAE comes out and
- 55:36says, yeah, we've already been doing this for 18 months, for
- 55:39example. The best part about all the
- 55:41stuff we talked about and I think how everybody's talked
- 55:43about Bitcoin in the space at all these levels is they always
- 55:47sound theoretical, but they're generally rooted in some micro,
- 55:50like practical example. And like the one that came to
- 55:53mind when Ralph was sharing, thinking about mining is like
- 55:55Texas having a deregulated grid and then 22.
- 55:59I think it's like up to 23 1/2% of all money hash rate lives in
- 56:03Texas. It's like it is an actual
- 56:05example of game theory playing out.
- 56:08And then it happens at the micro example from every individual
- 56:10buys Bitcoin because they're expecting others to buy Bitcoin
- 56:12because there's only 21 million. And so all these things are
- 56:15already been playing out. It's just at what level does the
- 56:18education, the again the, the, the bureaucracy live at the
- 56:24organizational level, which is why we see at the treasury in
- 56:27company level, it's usually smaller companies before it gets
- 56:29up to publicly traded because you have to generate consensus.
- 56:32And this is a hard asset to generate consensus on given the
- 56:35polarizing and nature of all of it.
- 56:38Yeah. And the difficulty it's Bitcoin
- 56:42is funny in a way because it's much easier for the individual
- 56:46or the small corporation to get into it than it is at the higher
- 56:50levels. Because, you know, one of the
- 56:52most complex aspect at those institutional levels or
- 56:57sovereign levels is, you know, securing it because the amounts
- 57:01are extremely big. And, you know, history hasn't
- 57:05been kind to safekeeping Bitcoin at the institutional level.
- 57:10And so I think a lot of them would rather internalize it
- 57:14until they see a better solution come into the market that they
- 57:17can leverage to hold the asset. But definitely in the UAE, we
- 57:22see a lot of, you know, qualified custodian coming out,
- 57:25but what we've been talking to them about, you know, for
- 57:28example, multi institutional custody.
- 57:30And when I first got here, people were kind of reluctant to
- 57:34look into that. But over the last few months, a
- 57:38lot of these players have found interest and are starting to
- 57:40understand it. I mean, just a funny story.
- 57:42I met a guy when I first got here and he was into all types
- 57:46of, you know, digital assets and investing.
- 57:49He's like, yeah, I mean, I have a small stack of Bitcoin.
- 57:52I saw him two months ago and he's like, dude, I sold
- 57:55everything. Now I'm Bitcoin only.
- 57:57So you see a shift in mindset because because altcoins, what
- 58:01he thought was going to perform, did not.
- 58:04And the only thing that's basically dominating the market
- 58:07is Bitcoin. And with the ETFs, with, you
- 58:09know, the Bitcoin strategic reserve, he's like, yeah, I'm
- 58:12wasting my time. I sleep better at night and this
- 58:14is just where I want to be. The this is the polarizing take
- 58:18and we don't have to go deep on at Jackson, but I will call it
- 58:21out because it's the perfect contrast of what Ralph started
- 58:25the beginning of the conversation referencing the
- 58:28gravity of having a bad form of money and what happens if it's
- 58:31not sitting your control and over the course of bitcoins 15
- 58:35years, every cycle, every couple of years there is a new thing
- 58:38that takes your Bitcoin and it always looks good until it's not
- 58:41in retrospect. And so the referencing of all of
- 58:44this notion of financializing it into the asset and creating
- 58:50publicly traded companies and Bitcoin only companies and
- 58:52people like there is that next wave.
- 58:55You can see where you end up with these like elegant or these
- 59:00over complex forms of Bitcoin exposure that effectively will
- 59:04take people's Bitcoin from either ever purchasing it or
- 59:07moving Bitcoin into what they believe is going to have a
- 59:09return multiple. But again, it goes back to the
- 59:12outside money notion of like, if you have your money, you can
- 59:15control it. You can have, you know, trust
- 59:17minimize ways to have a bare asset that you know, you can
- 59:20sleep good at night knowing that somebody can't rug you the next
- 59:23day. It's a literally the opposite of
- 59:25what we're describing what's happening in the financial
- 59:27markets. And not to say that these
- 59:28companies don't need the exposure and they can't do it,
- 59:30but there's something fundamentally different than
- 59:32protecting your purchasing power as a corporation versus turning
- 59:35into a financialization of it because it's part it's it's
- 59:39intertwining the whole system that we know eventually has you.
- 59:43Know problems I think I think that's also what what you're
- 59:45describing is also just part of how adoption plays out because
- 59:49there are various pools of capital that aren't necessarily
- 59:55prepared or don't have the mandate to go to the fully sort
- 59:59of outside version of the Bitcoin right.
- 1:00:01And so that's why MSCR everything sailors doing from
- 1:00:05sort of you know creating these different sort of flavors of
- 1:00:09proxy exposure to the asset. I think it's super important
- 1:00:13just generally for broader awareness, people adopting not
- 1:00:18Bitcoin natively. But getting exposure, learning
- 1:00:22more about it, I think that's all super important.
- 1:00:25And I think where it eventually goes is they realize there's a
- 1:00:28better way to own it outright and you don't need to do various
- 1:00:34leverage games because it's just going to continue to be the best
- 1:00:36performing asset regardless of what kind of leverage you put on
- 1:00:39it. I think what you're getting at
- 1:00:42is like more on the retail side of like people, you know, I, I
- 1:00:47get concerned when people say they're selling their Bitcoin to
- 1:00:50buy MSTR like that. That feels like a bad idea.
- 1:00:53And it's kind of what you're describing like this
- 1:00:56financialization that is ultimately getting people to to
- 1:01:00not own the asset outright. Well, there's.
- 1:01:03Yeah, Yeah. I think there's two aspects to
- 1:01:05that because I think like you can make the case that if
- 1:01:07somebody can't get spot equity exposure or spot exposure via
- 1:01:10like some ETF, you would adopt A company with good fundamentals
- 1:01:16that holds Bitcoin from a fiduciary perspective.
- 1:01:20Then buying a company that has turned into financialize because
- 1:01:24you're effectively take, it's like if us as individuals took
- 1:01:27out a bunch of credit cards, bought Bitcoin, we do looked at
- 1:01:30degenerates with no cash flow. Like if we made a bunch of
- 1:01:32money, it's not a big problem, but the second that we reduce
- 1:01:35our cash flow versus like the the obligations on liabilities,
- 1:01:39we'd be looked at as degenerates.
- 1:01:41Well, if companies are getting spun up just effectively to do
- 1:01:43the strategy and don't have the financial acumen to do that and
- 1:01:46as a fiduciary, that's your angle to get exposure.
- 1:01:48Well then that makes zero sense. But people will tell the story
- 1:01:52that that's their only way to get it to like justify either
- 1:01:54start in the business or investing in it as the multiple.
- 1:01:56Like from a first principle perspective, it just, it's also
- 1:01:59a symptom of like how messed up the system is because those
- 1:02:02people should theoretically be able to figure out how to get
- 1:02:04exposure to the underlying that doesn't layer like 10 levels of
- 1:02:07risk on. It and financialization doesn't
- 1:02:11necessarily have to be a bad thing.
- 1:02:13I think it's how the product is built that that gives it a bad
- 1:02:18Rep. Like if you read the filings of
- 1:02:20the ETFSI mean basically what they're saying is that, you
- 1:02:24know, if the custodian goes bankrupt or whatever, basically
- 1:02:28you're gonna be an unsecured creditor.
- 1:02:30And so the Bitcoin's not even yours, so you might lose
- 1:02:33everything. I think it's, you know, a bit
- 1:02:35more transparency. I mean, having the ability to
- 1:02:37actually take out, because with stocks you can't take out the
- 1:02:41stocks from an ETF, you can't take them and self custody them.
- 1:02:45But with Bitcoin, because it's a better asset, it just makes
- 1:02:47sense that any financial product that you build, because pension
- 1:02:51plans for example, cannot own spot Bitcoin.
- 1:02:54Certain institutional entities just can't from a regulatory
- 1:02:58legal point of view, they can't own the underlying commodity
- 1:03:00directly like physical gold or oil, gallons or barrels of oil,
- 1:03:04etcetera. So they need a financialized
- 1:03:07product, but you want that product to be closer to actual
- 1:03:10ownership than less similar to the ETFs that we have right now.
- 1:03:15So you want something that would allow you to take custody of the
- 1:03:17asset and that's secured in a more decentralized way?
- 1:03:24Agreed. Yeah, I mostly agree with Brian
- 1:03:27here too just in the the instance that 2024 was really
- 1:03:31just the first touch point for mass adoption, at least here in
- 1:03:34the United States as relates to the ETFs and getting exposure
- 1:03:37for and for many people, they still have not gotten exposure.
- 1:03:41And for, for the folks who did get exposure through the ETFI
- 1:03:45think it'll be a learning process just as it has been for
- 1:03:47all of us in terms of understanding the, the monetary
- 1:03:50properties of Bitcoin. And Brian, I think I know we're
- 1:03:55kind of coming up on time, but I do want to give you some airtime
- 1:03:57on the shareholder letter that you published yesterday because
- 1:04:00I, there's a lot of things we could talk about.
- 1:04:02It probably warrants a separate discussion.
- 1:04:04But the thing that I, I thought of immediately was that you call
- 1:04:08out in that letter that in 2024, there's only four top tier hedge
- 1:04:12fund managers that beat the S&P 500, which returned about 24%,
- 1:04:17right. And so we're, we're getting to a
- 1:04:20point now where more investors, whether it's the individual or
- 1:04:22the institution will recognize that they can hold a better form
- 1:04:25of money, a savings technology that will pass passively
- 1:04:31outperform the active money managers and also equity
- 1:04:35indices. So Brian, I want to I have some
- 1:04:37questions, but maybe you can just give an overarching context
- 1:04:40about your public. Yeah, sure.
- 1:04:43So for starters, I, I always love putting this piece
- 1:04:47together, mainly because in my prior life when I, when I worked
- 1:04:52at Brown Brothers Harriman, a lot of what I did was read not
- 1:04:55only shareholder letters, but quarterly letters from a variety
- 1:04:58of, of asset managers and investors across the asset class
- 1:05:03spectrum. So always enjoy, particularly in
- 1:05:06sort of the January, February time period, digging through
- 1:05:10people's letters, hearing their thoughts and, and how they were
- 1:05:13thinking about the year completed and sort of looking
- 1:05:15ahead. So it's, it's been fun to put
- 1:05:17this together the past couple years.
- 1:05:19And really given that, you know, in my mind, a shareholder letter
- 1:05:24is, is very much a traditional finance sort of practice that I
- 1:05:31want, I like to tie in certain themes that would resonate with
- 1:05:35people sitting in that world, sitting in those seats.
- 1:05:39And So what I wanted to talk about with this one was this
- 1:05:42trend of really the past two decades of, you know, there's
- 1:05:46there's been this debate around active versus passive management
- 1:05:49and active management. All that really means is your
- 1:05:51stock picking, you are picking individual securities as opposed
- 1:05:55to just allocating to an index like the S&P 500 or the NASDAQ,
- 1:06:00which would be considered passive investing.
- 1:06:02And so there's been this massive trend of capital flowing from
- 1:06:07active managers to passive managers really for a few
- 1:06:11reasons. One, just the cost associated.
- 1:06:13So, so index funds are much lower cost than an active
- 1:06:17managed strategy. And the other reason is that
- 1:06:22there was just continued underperformance of active
- 1:06:25managers. So, and it's sort of this
- 1:06:27recursive flywheel in the sense that the, you know, index funds
- 1:06:32like the S&P are increasingly driven by a handful of mega cap
- 1:06:36stocks. And what that does over time is,
- 1:06:40you know, capital flows into these index funds.
- 1:06:42It sort of adds to the performance of those top names
- 1:06:47in the fund. Their weight then increases that
- 1:06:50that increases their performance, increases the
- 1:06:51flows. So it's like this recursive loop
- 1:06:53of over time. If you want to just pull up that
- 1:06:56that chart that I had on I think Page 3 Jackson in there that
- 1:07:00just shows just the past two years.
- 1:07:02And like I said, this is a multi decade trend, but just the past
- 1:07:05two years of the weight of the top seven companies.
- 1:07:08So the mag 7 you know what you would think of as as the sort of
- 1:07:12mega cap stocks, the weight of that of those names has
- 1:07:16increased. It's now, you know, over a third
- 1:07:19of the S and Pi Think page for Jackson.
- 1:07:23It's on Michael's screen. And the the contribution to the
- 1:07:30returns of the index is also, you know, outsized from these
- 1:07:35these particular names. And so if you look at, you know,
- 1:07:39the performance of the S&P minus the MAG 7, it's like basically
- 1:07:44flat, very meager returns without those those seven names.
- 1:07:50And so all this is really to say, you know, Jackson, you led
- 1:07:52with at the beginning, like a very select few of what you
- 1:07:57would think of as like top tier hedge funds actually outperform
- 1:08:01the S&P. And part of the reason is that
- 1:08:04it's just driven by, you know, that that benchmark is getting
- 1:08:06harder and harder to beat year over year because it's just
- 1:08:08driven by these few names which, you know, have economies of
- 1:08:12scale have really significant business modes.
- 1:08:15It's not to say that these businesses aren't good
- 1:08:16businesses and won't continue to be, but there's still a ton of
- 1:08:20execution risk, key man risk. Like these are individual
- 1:08:23companies that, you know, I think the, the concept of index
- 1:08:27investing when it was first originated was like, OK, this is
- 1:08:30like diversified, a little less risky than stock picking.
- 1:08:34But really all it is today is like stock picking, but you're
- 1:08:38just picking the seven biggest stocks in the market.
- 1:08:42And So what I, what I go into after that is sort of like,
- 1:08:47well, where's Bitcoin fit into all of this, in this, in this
- 1:08:50active passive debate? Because it's somewhere, it's
- 1:08:53somewhere in the middle. It's it's, you know, in, at its
- 1:08:56core, it's very passive in the sense of, you know, the, the
- 1:09:00predominant strategy is just accumulate the asset, buy and
- 1:09:04hold it, don't trade around it, don't leverage it.
- 1:09:07So that would, that would appear very passive on the surface, But
- 1:09:10on the, on another hand, like it is the most active sort of macro
- 1:09:15bet you could be making in the sense of going back to the
- 1:09:18inside versus outside money conversation.
- 1:09:22It is a digital form of sound money, outside money that is
- 1:09:27completely detached from stocks, bonds, you know, real estate.
- 1:09:33And so it's a, it's very much an active bet.
- 1:09:35So I, I, I sort of coined this phrase actively passive as, as
- 1:09:39an allocation because it doesn't really fit within this, you
- 1:09:43know, traditional finance active passive debate somewhere in the
- 1:09:46middle. And it's actually very unique in
- 1:09:48the sense that you're taking a a very deliberate stance that
- 1:09:55you're concerned about currency debasement and you don't want to
- 1:09:58own all these other assets that are linked to that currency
- 1:10:01debasement. Well, at the same time, it's
- 1:10:04very simple, like you don't have to be a stock picker, you're
- 1:10:06just owning a better form of money.
- 1:10:08So it is this, this elegant sort of solution for everyone from
- 1:10:13the individual up to, you know, institutional allocators going
- 1:10:18back to sort of the, you know, the egalitarian nature of it,
- 1:10:21which we referenced earlier. But yeah, that was that was sort
- 1:10:24of the main point of of this report, this letter.
- 1:10:27And yeah, Jackson, if you had any questions on it.
- 1:10:30Yeah. Brian, I really liked what you
- 1:10:32did with with the letter. Overall, it was very well done.
- 1:10:35I'd encourage anyone to check it out.
- 1:10:37We'll include it in the show notes and the actively passive
- 1:10:40framework is such a good way to describe it and the the way you
- 1:10:44positioned it. You mentioned trying to fit it
- 1:10:47into an active or passive bucket.
- 1:10:50It kind of reminds me of conversations we had early on,
- 1:10:53right, in communicating with institutional investors and
- 1:10:56trying to fit Bitcoin into an existing asset allocation
- 1:11:00framework where we could position Bitcoin as a real
- 1:11:04asset. Or is it more akin to a venture
- 1:11:07type of bet? It's, it's not right.
- 1:11:09It's, it's, it's it's own asset class.
- 1:11:11And I think we're, we're finally getting to the point now where
- 1:11:14we can have these conversations with institutional allocators,
- 1:11:17with registered investment advisors and we can use new
- 1:11:20frameworks, Brian, like what you just developed here with
- 1:11:22Bitcoins, a passively active investment.
- 1:11:24And we can describe why that is. And we're also able to describe
- 1:11:27why Bitcoin is its own unique standalone asset class, which we
- 1:11:31finally kind of have now an industry in within traditional
- 1:11:34finance that is coalescing around that standard as well.
- 1:11:37That Bitcoin is different than crypto.
- 1:11:39Bitcoin is not a, it's not an asset that fits into one of
- 1:11:42these existing buckets. It is a new bucket that
- 1:11:44investors need to think about. And so I don't know if you agree
- 1:11:48with that, Brian, but it's generally just like a take away
- 1:11:50that I had after reading the report as well.
- 1:11:52Yeah. I mean, I think that that was
- 1:11:54certainly part of my intent is like, you know, crafting ways to
- 1:11:57talk about what Bitcoin represents as an out allocation
- 1:12:01in your portfolio and really speak the language of
- 1:12:06traditional finance, but in in a different flavor that that
- 1:12:08speaks to the unique nature of of Bitcoin.
- 1:12:12The other component which you reference, like maybe I'm a
- 1:12:15little less optimistic of like people recognizing the
- 1:12:18distinction between Bitcoin and crypto.
- 1:12:20Like, I don't know, Michael, you, you texted in, in our, in
- 1:12:23one of our threads, like, you know, Fidelity's referencing
- 1:12:28Solana as a legitimate competitor to Ethereum.
- 1:12:31They talk about Ethereum a lot. And we've and you know, we have
- 1:12:35a lot of respect for Fidelity. I think they have a lot of
- 1:12:37really smart people there, but even them are still not fully
- 1:12:42rocking the distinction or at least portraying the distinction
- 1:12:45that we believe in. And I think that's, that's
- 1:12:49largely true across the board is still in the institutional
- 1:12:52space. Like I, I do think there's still
- 1:12:54a lot of conflation that's occurring and you still see this
- 1:12:57even on like CNBC, like Jackson, there was that clip that you
- 1:13:02tweeted out the other day of, of I forget who it was or what
- 1:13:05network it was, but like the woman was, was aghast.
- 1:13:09She was like, well, how can Bitcoin be legitimate or a thing
- 1:13:12if like hawk to a coin just rubbed It's like what would
- 1:13:16like? So I, I don't think we've
- 1:13:18actually come that far in terms of people understanding the
- 1:13:21differences here. I think there's still a ton of
- 1:13:23conflation and that's just going to take time and it's going to
- 1:13:28take more ruggings. Unfortunately, people getting
- 1:13:31wrecked on these other coins. Like Ralph said his, his buddy
- 1:13:35was just like, Oh yeah, it took me a while, but now I'm now I'm
- 1:13:37Bitcoin only because, you know, I, I wasn't lucky enough to
- 1:13:40allocate to fartcoin and get a, a massive return.
- 1:13:44Like I, I invested in the, you know, one of the other thousand
- 1:13:47of, you know, options I had and got wrecked like that.
- 1:13:50That's what if you give it enough time that that's
- 1:13:53ultimately how it plays out. I think the price is actually
- 1:13:56going to take care of that randomly.
- 1:13:58I was talking about everyone conflating and I think is a bias
- 1:14:03projection because they missed Bitcoin.
- 1:14:05So everything else has to be like Bitcoin.
- 1:14:07They're going to lose the money because it must all be hooked to
- 1:14:10a coin. But once it gets to 5500
- 1:14:13strategic reserve, it's like, OK, this is something else than
- 1:14:16this other stuff. It's just a function of price.
- 1:14:18I don't even think it'll have to be education.
- 1:14:19It'll just be more of like this is the obvious thing.
- 1:14:22Jackson has a nice chart of 60% market cap or of the market of
- 1:14:27the crypto market. It is the market and just most
- 1:14:30people when you go share that like credit to Jackson, we have
- 1:14:33a nice slide deck if anybody's curious and seeing of the market
- 1:14:37of Bitcoins dominance being roughly 60% at the time.
- 1:14:41And then the way he analogizes it is to the the magnificent 7
- 1:14:45or 35% of the S&P 500. And when you tell that to
- 1:14:48people, they're just like, wait, what?
- 1:14:49Like they don't they don't that one in the and that 1.2 to 1.4
- 1:14:53trillion of the two trillion and Bitcoin sits with individuals.
- 1:14:56Those two just like mess with people's head in the trap fire
- 1:14:58world because it just paints a completely different picture on
- 1:15:01like how this assets emerged and what is that like the obvious
- 1:15:04winner. Yeah, it's a great, it's a great
- 1:15:06point there, Michael, because it ties into Brian what what the
- 1:15:10work that you did on the passive verse active and Bitcoin being
- 1:15:13actively passive. People want to own the ETFs,
- 1:15:16right? They want to own S&P 500 because
- 1:15:19they want exposure to the broader market, but more
- 1:15:21importantly want they want exposure to the largest
- 1:15:23companies that are driving the outsides of the return.
- 1:15:26So if you take that same lens to the digital asset market, same
- 1:15:30thing applies. But even at a greater scale, you
- 1:15:32have Bitcoin that's currently sitting at maybe 55 to 60%
- 1:15:36dominance in the market. So Bitcoin really is the market.
- 1:15:39And so as long as you have an allocation of Bitcoin over the
- 1:15:42long term, that's really what you want to be paying attention
- 1:15:45to, similar to if you if you're going to own equities, you're
- 1:15:47going to want to have an allocation to the companies that
- 1:15:50are driving most of the market return.
- 1:15:52That's a key point because if you, I think I put the A line in
- 1:15:56the report about this, it was just like if you had just, if
- 1:15:59you had not bought the S&P 500 and you had just bought those
- 1:16:03five to seven names, you would have vastly outperformed the
- 1:16:06S&P. And so that's a very similar
- 1:16:08dynamic where it's like you just need to own Bitcoin.
- 1:16:10You don't need a, a diversified basket of crypto currencies to
- 1:16:15get exposure to the market. You just need to own what is
- 1:16:18actually driving the performance of the market.
- 1:16:20Yeah, and. Yeah.
- 1:16:22And Brian, just the report was amazing.
- 1:16:25So I encourage everyone to read it.
- 1:16:27It made me think of one thing, especially when you talk about
- 1:16:30MicroStrategy being now a part of NASDAQ, right, NASDAQ 100.
- 1:16:35So let's say MicroStrategy joins SMP 500, another Bitcoin,
- 1:16:41another company that holds Bitcoin joint as well, the SMP
- 1:16:44500. Over time, what's going to
- 1:16:46happen, similar to what happened with the Magnificent 7, the top
- 1:16:49performers of the index will be Bitcoin companies that hold
- 1:16:54Bitcoin under treasury reserve. So inevitably what will happen
- 1:16:57is you'll still underperform potentially Bitcoin if they're
- 1:17:01just holding it without leveraging it and using that
- 1:17:03stuff. But at the end of the day,
- 1:17:05passive investing becomes Bitcoin investing over the next
- 1:17:08maybe 1520 years. Like that's just something that
- 1:17:10I thought of when you were talking.
- 1:17:12I just went there because I'm like if more companies hold
- 1:17:15Bitcoin and more companies in these indexes are holding
- 1:17:18Bitcoin and they're performance is also tethered to bitcoins
- 1:17:21performance over time. I mean it might not make sense
- 1:17:25anymore to diversify into an index and you would just hold
- 1:17:29Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 1:17:30No, that's exactly right. I think part of what I was
- 1:17:32trying to get out in that part was just like this sort of
- 1:17:37osmosis of capital flowing from all these other asset buckets
- 1:17:41into Bitcoin, like micro strategy is what that looks
- 1:17:44like. It's in some practical sense, at
- 1:17:46least right now in the current time, like it's that is forms of
- 1:17:51capital flowing through these other instruments to get proxy
- 1:17:54exposure to Bitcoin. And over time to your point,
- 1:17:58like as those equities and other instruments enter indices that
- 1:18:05goes back to the same like recursive flywheel that I
- 1:18:07referenced earlier, where it's like higher performance as to
- 1:18:11the weight more flows like and so that I think you're exactly
- 1:18:14right. That's what we're going to see
- 1:18:15out, you see play out over the next 1020 years.
- 1:18:19Yeah. Well, I'd encourage anyone who
- 1:18:21hasn't seen it to check out the report.
- 1:18:23I called it out already. We got a wrap here in just a
- 1:18:26moment. But we first have to call out
- 1:18:28the single point of failure of the week.
- 1:18:30I think it's going to be, it's going to be a good segment to
- 1:18:33just call attention to risks that people should be thinking
- 1:18:36about less. So at the institutional level, I
- 1:18:38think institutions will naturally be isolated from these
- 1:18:43risks just in terms of how they hold the asset.
- 1:18:45But certainly investors at the retail level, individual Bitcoin
- 1:18:49hodlers should be thinking about various types of risks.
- 1:18:53One of those includes something I saw come across Bitcoin news
- 1:18:59recently. I can't remember 1 exactly, but
- 1:19:02there was this crypto influencer, someone who
- 1:19:04moderated a forum, I think it's some sort of event with in
- 1:19:06Canada actually, and was kidnapped.
- 1:19:10Him and his family were kidnapped and tortured for
- 1:19:14their, I guess Bitcoin and their crypto.
- 1:19:17And so I don't necessarily think that when I think about the risk
- 1:19:20profile and what people need to think about, I still think that
- 1:19:23these types of physical threats are more isolated to people who
- 1:19:26have public images, whether you're, you're known as a, an
- 1:19:31early adopter or you work within an organization.
- 1:19:35Unfortunately, like us, for most people, I don't think they have
- 1:19:38to worry about this just yet. But I do think there's a
- 1:19:40recognition that is Bitcoin appreciates we're, we're in a
- 1:19:43bear market right now. We're at 92,000.
- 1:19:45So, but when Bitcoin, you know, recovers back above 6 figures
- 1:19:49and into 20252026 and beyond, this is going to become a more
- 1:19:54real threat for more people. And so there's not enough talk
- 1:19:58about the industry, but people should be thinking about these
- 1:20:00types of physical threats. And how to protect yourself and
- 1:20:04your family. It's an unfortunate thing with a
- 1:20:06bare instrument, just like if you had a bunch of gold in your
- 1:20:08home and that became public information, eventually someone
- 1:20:11would be motivated to try to take that from you.
- 1:20:13So I don't know if you guys have any thoughts there.
- 1:20:15It's obviously a sad thing to see and it feel like we're just
- 1:20:18seeing more and more headlines, certainly as of the past couple
- 1:20:20months about it. Yeah, I think part part of it
- 1:20:23too is, you know, you reference, it's most likely to occur with
- 1:20:29with known folks in the space or if you're vocal or public about
- 1:20:34your ownership of the asset. That's certainly true today.
- 1:20:37But I think, I think we all agree, like, you know, I don't,
- 1:20:41I, I think we in a future state 10 years from now, like
- 1:20:45everybody's holdings are docks, like whether you're famous or
- 1:20:47not, like someone's going to be able to sleuth, an attacker is
- 1:20:51going to be able to sleuth out how much Bitcoin you have and
- 1:20:53where you live. Like just that's the, that's the
- 1:20:56reality of, of data leaks and what I expect to occur over the
- 1:20:59next decade. So to your point, yeah, maybe
- 1:21:02right now it's it's primarily someone is is very vocal in
- 1:21:06public about it, but that's not going to be the case forever.
- 1:21:09Yeah, Jackson, thanks for reminding.
- 1:21:11We got to figure out when in the segment.
- 1:21:13So we just do it every, every we get the exact same point because
- 1:21:16we almost forgot or I almost forgot.
- 1:21:19But to Jack, to Brian's point, I think it's just a part again, of
- 1:21:23broken or not fully developed market structures in a similar
- 1:21:26way, like where you have FDIC and you have to park all your
- 1:21:29money across all these banks because you can't plan on them
- 1:21:31to be whole in the same way that you have to, you know, in the
- 1:21:35digital asset space, every week we hear about some crazy thing
- 1:21:38happening because, you know, you can take somebody's family or
- 1:21:40wealth by just there's a point of failure there, whether it's
- 1:21:43them or their homes. And you can see again, the micro
- 1:21:47examples how this played out with like single sig and the
- 1:21:49multi sig happened Because then you could, you know,
- 1:21:51theoretically have a it like you can pretend to use multi sig if
- 1:21:56you had single sig. And then you can imagine you
- 1:21:58have multi institution and you could say, look, I use this.
- 1:22:00So you start to build market structures like I can't just
- 1:22:03take all my Bitcoin or you can't take all somebody's Bitcoin.
- 1:22:06Similar how you can't take all of a billionaire's wealth or
- 1:22:09equities sold in over the course of a day.
- 1:22:12But the other thing I was going to reference is doesn't have to
- 1:22:15be people. We saw our latter late middle of
- 1:22:18last year, the natural disasters in the southeast of the US.
- 1:22:22Now we have a lot of things going on in California still in
- 1:22:26real time, you know, praying for folks there.
- 1:22:28So I think this is just a natural thing to look at and
- 1:22:31underwrite your exposure because that's the last thing is
- 1:22:34especially with what Ralph went into with the Lebanon situation,
- 1:22:39it's like just, it's just God forbid, like I can't imagine
- 1:22:42waking up all the things you've worked for and then just the
- 1:22:44next day not having them. It's just a crazy idea to be in.
- 1:22:47And I think where it's been tolerated in the Bitcoin or
- 1:22:49crypto spaces because it's generally looked at as a risk
- 1:22:51asset. So people put one percent 2%,
- 1:22:54but people have done the work or holding material wealth there
- 1:22:56and you want to be able to protect that and protect it for
- 1:22:58your family. So that's also just re
- 1:23:00underwriting why we're going to focus on having a quick piece on
- 1:23:03this every week. Yeah, I love that.
- 1:23:07Well, appreciate it guys. And Ralph, thanks for joining us
- 1:23:09this week. Always a pleasure.
- 1:23:12If anyone were just wanted to get in touch with you to learn
- 1:23:15or to have a conversation about on Rammeno or just if your story
- 1:23:18resonated with them, where's the best place for them to get in
- 1:23:21touch with you? Yeah.
- 1:23:22So through our website on rammeno.com or through LinkedIn,
- 1:23:27we're extremely active. It's at on Rammeno, similar to
- 1:23:32Twitter or X at on ramp Meno. So we're very proactive and very
- 1:23:39responsive. So please feel free to reach
- 1:23:41out. Happy to walk you through
- 1:23:42bitcoins value proposition, how to custody it and you know, talk
- 1:23:47about multi institution custody. And even if you're just curious
- 1:23:50about what we're up to in the region, have to share details on
- 1:23:53that. And one last plug on ramp
- 1:23:55Institutional series kicking off next week with James Lavish and
- 1:23:59Dave Foley. Brian shareholder letter like to
- 1:24:02think of as the kickoff for the institutional work that we'll be
- 1:24:05doing this year. So if you want to attend, we'll
- 1:24:08have you'll be able to find it on our LinkedIn and Twitter
- 1:24:10page. But there'll be some other stuff
- 1:24:12coming out between release tomorrow on Friday and then the
- 1:24:16series that kicks off on Thursday.
- 1:24:19Amazing. Sweet.
- 1:24:20Thanks, Ralph. Appreciate you joining.
- 1:24:22My pleasure. Thanks guys.
- 1:24:23Thanks boys. See you.
- 1:24:25Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:24:27If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:24:29episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:24:32app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:24:34today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:24:37Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Ramp Media is
- 1:24:39for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:24:42nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:24:45Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:24:48to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:24:51to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:24:54advisors.