Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E013: Bitcoin is the Real Fintech with Abubakar Nur Khalil
Transcript
- 0:02It all. Comes down to computers
- 0:04communicating. The information superhighway can
- 0:08be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless artificial gold.
- 0:16Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the world of OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational. Technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Welcome back to Final Settlement podcast brought to you by Honor
- 0:55and Media. Today is Monday, September 23rd,
- 1:00and we're very excited about today's guest, Abubakar.
- 1:04Nir Khalil is joining us. Abubakar is a Bitcoin Core
- 1:10contributor and CEO of the Bitcoin venture capital fund
- 1:14Recursive Capital. He is also a board member and
- 1:17CEO of B Trust, a nonprofit focused on training African
- 1:21Bitcoin developers and growing the African Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 1:25He's also an advisor to Early Riders, the Bitcoin denominated
- 1:29investment firm that Michael and I launched earlier this year.
- 1:32Welcome to the show Abu, how you doing?
- 1:36Thanks again for having me guys. It's been good.
- 1:37It's been a good day so far. Awesome.
- 1:40Super excited to to have you join and talk through everything
- 1:43you're working on and kind of share a little bit of the
- 1:46conversations we have behind the scenes as it relates to business
- 1:49building. Specifically on a on a Bitcoin
- 1:50standard and how we see the the the future looks when there's a
- 1:56cost of capital and you have to think more critically about
- 2:00growth and what value looks like to produce in the real world.
- 2:05Definitely, definitely looking forward to.
- 2:07That yeah, so few, you know, various topics we want to get
- 2:11into, but maybe a good place to start it would be, you know, a
- 2:15bit on your, your Bitcoin journey, how you sort of started
- 2:20contributing to Bitcoin in a really meaningful way at a very
- 2:23young age, to be honest. And, and would love to hear a
- 2:26little bit more about that story.
- 2:27And you know how you how you got initially interested in Bitcoin
- 2:31and and sort of grew to the place that you're at now?
- 2:35Yeah, certainly. I mean, ironically it started
- 2:38with my older brother who's now got into the government.
- 2:42So whenever I tell the story that a it's a good government
- 2:44official essentially, not orange Phil me is kind of a ludicrous
- 2:48yeah, I started with this obscure video.
- 2:50I can bring 13. I was 14 at the time.
- 2:52Honestly didn't give too much too much care to it at other
- 2:56priorities as to imagine. And then Fast forward to 2017
- 3:00came back again asking the same questions around Bitcoin.
- 3:02I was like, you know, the hell is this all about?
- 3:05I just fell in through the rabbit hole like really hard
- 3:07that year. That was roughly around the same
- 3:10time I finished high school, so the year after that essentially.
- 3:13So for me, I was pretty much aimless in life.
- 3:15So I figured with all the exit time I had on my hands, I might
- 3:18as well just learn about Bitcoin.
- 3:20And then I realized early on that a lot of that material was
- 3:23work technical. So I was like, why don't I just
- 3:26teach myself how to code? So I started reading up about
- 3:28like computers, programming and all of that.
- 3:30Then the following year in 2018 was when I started programming.
- 3:34And then that was at the point where I realized that actually
- 3:36Bitcoin did the piece of software.
- 3:37So prior to that essentially was mostly just abstract stuff about
- 3:41like mining the potential and all of that.
- 3:44And then Fast forward 2019 was when I grew the, I guess the
- 3:47confidence essentially to contribute to Bitcoin Core.
- 3:49So my first pull request, coincidentally after I saw pull
- 3:53request emerged from another contributor from Nigeria, I get
- 3:56probably the first Bitcoin call contributor probably from
- 3:59Africa, which is Tim Kimbo. And that was very inspiring for
- 4:02me. So I was like, OK, it's
- 4:03possible. So from then on until now, since
- 4:06she just been constantly to Bitcoin core mostly in the last
- 4:10couple of years due to other priorities with like recursive
- 4:13just mostly been PR reviews, but essentially that's kind of had a
- 4:16story. Well, so honestly, it was over
- 4:19time that I realized Bitcoin had a lot more value than just piece
- 4:23of text. I'm boarded myself into Bitcoin
- 4:25in those days, like finally had the bank account at the time.
- 4:28So interestingly, I've had a different view of kind of
- 4:32banking or how money should work perspective, starting big fan
- 4:35and then eventually having a bank account is kind of
- 4:39contrasting the two. So that's kind of where a lot of
- 4:42my insect comes into play slash kind of the experience I've had
- 4:45with just money in general. So it's definitely been
- 4:47refreshing and I'm glad that was the case and not the opposite.
- 4:51Yeah, it's fascinating. I'm curious, what was that?
- 4:53What was that first poll request when you got enough enough
- 4:55confidence to to contribute? Honestly it was a very trivial
- 5:01change. Now in hindsight I essentially
- 5:03changed the name of the the window to node window from like
- 5:06I think debug window or something on that GUI.
- 5:09At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 5:12asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 5:16right There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 5:19exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 5:22arrangement. Onramp solves for these
- 5:25concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 5:27solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 5:31ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 5:34possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 5:37your family is protected as well.
- 5:40On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 5:43whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 5:46to your existing self custody setup.
- 5:49For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 5:52Very cool, very cool. Yeah, it's, it's just, it's such
- 5:56an interesting story and, and one I appreciate.
- 5:59And really a lot of the, you know, a lot of what we try to
- 6:02talk about on this podcast in particular is, is, you know,
- 6:05Bitcoin is a piece of software. It's protocol.
- 6:07It's not just another investable asset.
- 6:10It's not just digital gold. But I think, you know, sitting
- 6:14here in the West, sitting in, in, you know, America in
- 6:16particular, I think, you know, especially recently, you know,
- 6:21with sort of the introduction of ETFs and you know, now last
- 6:26week, the approval of options on those ETFs.
- 6:28Like the sort of zeitgeist and focus in the West is very much
- 6:31focused on sort of finding the increased financialization of,
- 6:35of this thing called Bitcoin and, and really looking at it
- 6:38purely as this investable asset that's part of a portfolio.
- 6:41And, and, and you know, a lot of the work that you do and where
- 6:44you, you know, originally came at it from is, is a very
- 6:47different sort of a different sort of angle.
- 6:49It's, you know, this is a piece of technology, this is software.
- 6:53And in many ways, you know, even on the mining side, like there's
- 6:57incredible things happening at the protocol layer that, you
- 7:00know, most sort of institutional allocators in the West are still
- 7:03just scratching the surface of, right.
- 7:05Like they're, they're very much, you know, if they're, if they're
- 7:08beginning to go down the rabbit hole, it's, it's a cursory look
- 7:12and, and it's very much just an investable asset.
- 7:14So very much appreciate sort of, you know, where, where you're
- 7:18coming at from it because coming at, because it's, it's, it's
- 7:22definitely a refreshing angle as we sit here sort of in, in 2024
- 7:26and, and everyone's focused on ETFs here.
- 7:28Yeah. Definitely, definitely.
- 7:30We definitely have to zoom out and kind of contextualize a lot
- 7:33of things and it just helps with an insight foresight and seeing
- 7:38where the last kit could be in like, you know, 5-10 years,
- 7:41right? One thing before, you know,
- 7:44moving on, on your story, Abu is curious like on that flow of
- 7:49funds, you know, coming in without a bank account, anything
- 7:52you could share like how back in the day somebody got exposure to
- 7:56Bitcoin, but then also you reference that helped in your
- 8:01understanding or thinking about like banking and how that
- 8:04applied. And I think I'm curious if this
- 8:07is kind of this notion in the West that fintechs have this
- 8:11interest in Africa in general, because you can kind of rebuild
- 8:15from the ground up from the first principle layer of tech
- 8:17versus all the like muddiness that exists in the bureaucracy
- 8:22of like the banking system specifically in the US.
- 8:25Curious if that's true and then if that is like how Bitcoin fits
- 8:29into that moving forward with thin tax?
- 8:34I mean, yeah, it's it's definitely an interesting 1.
- 8:36So early days was pretty convoluted in terms of how I was
- 8:39managing my finances. Honestly, if it were to be
- 8:43recorded, I would have probably been seen as like a criminal or
- 8:46something. A lot of tabs, multiple devices,
- 8:49kind of moving close. But what helped was most of the
- 8:52most of the money coming in on my end from that time was from
- 8:54freelancing. And the good thing was most of
- 8:56the people that were paying me or paying me essentially to
- 8:58Bitcoin. And if they weren't, they're
- 9:00essentially paying to, you know, the folks that were doing on and
- 9:03off ramping at the time. So these are people that are
- 9:05doing OTC trade. So I had a couple of friends at
- 9:08the time, I'd send their back account details and then they
- 9:11essentially sell it off the narrative for BTC and they sent.
- 9:14So essentially that was kind of the most of the $10 what was
- 9:18happening, Sometimes even just physical, physical meet ups and
- 9:21then sending it to Bitcoin. Interesting.
- 9:24But other than that, I see when it comes to the Fintech side,
- 9:27the ubiquity of Fintech's not honestly on the continent and to
- 9:31to the point they're making about like having an opportunity
- 9:34to re architect essentially some of the issues of the release
- 9:37that we see on the financial architecture side here in Africa
- 9:39definitely is true. I think the ubiquity that
- 9:42Fintech has found is something that big credit is also going to
- 9:45find in the next maybe 5-10 years for the exact same reason,
- 9:49which is that we have highly inefficient systems of money
- 9:53flows or even just generally our access to international
- 9:57International Monetary network. It's definitely Hanford.
- 10:00It's, it's one of those things where as a Nigerian you kind of
- 10:02expect to be banned off a lot of rails where there's PayPal or
- 10:05things like that just for being high risk.
- 10:07And then locally it's even more computer and it comes to sending
- 10:10money either from your country to another African country.
- 10:14The only thing I can say that works is our banking system here
- 10:18in Nigeria is pretty is pretty good.
- 10:19We have instant payments through banks.
- 10:21So between banks you can actually settle really quickly.
- 10:24But other than that, I'd say pretty much everything else
- 10:27within Africa isn't really at the stage where it's that much
- 10:30or so. Can't see a lot of these
- 10:31fintechs leverage on creating their own small silos of either
- 10:35liquidity pools, more efficient ways to actually send and
- 10:39receive capital from within countries all the way up to
- 10:42outside of countries. I think the one thing that
- 10:44they've been missing for a long time now has been Bitcoin in the
- 10:47sense that you're essentially plugging in from day one into
- 10:49not only just a global monetary network, but one that can
- 10:52facilitate trade and commerce at a local level or even just a
- 10:55regional level. So that's why I feel like there
- 10:57will be that ubiquity when it comes to Bitcoin, not only just
- 11:00for solving that problem, but just in terms of being
- 11:02competitive to, which is why a lot of startups essentially
- 11:06became fintechs here in Africa as well.
- 11:08Yeah, it's it's, it's funny to hear 'cause I've thought about
- 11:11this since working and building and Bitcoin that like you kind
- 11:14of come to this realization like Bitcoin's the real thin tech.
- 11:16When you think about like moving capital border over borders and
- 11:20not needing any intermediary or even custody and thinking about
- 11:23like what does custody look like in collaborative or multi
- 11:26institution? All these notions of like
- 11:27leveraging the protocol multi SIG, they don't require trust to
- 11:31sit with a single entity, which historically existed with the
- 11:34custody of of the underlying to lending against it, right.
- 11:37And how do you like segregate and split?
- 11:39These are all things that you can actually do in the
- 11:41traditional Fiat system. That's like the real financial
- 11:44technology and innovation versus kind of like the lipstick on a
- 11:47pig version that exists in the that kind of like over the like
- 11:51glossing over the traditional banking system.
- 11:54I could definitely say that again.
- 11:55I could definitely say that again, I think they're you'll be
- 11:57hard pressed to see them not realize that in the next couple
- 12:00of years, especially due to all the innovation and and the the
- 12:03tech being built right now. So just take a matter of time
- 12:06before they turn around. So how, how, how would you sort
- 12:10of characterize the state of Bitcoin adoption in Africa?
- 12:14You're, you know, boots on the ground there now, how has that
- 12:17progressed over the past even 12 months or so?
- 12:20I know you gave a, a, a talk recently at Honey Badger that
- 12:24was, that was fantastic. And just talking about like, you
- 12:27know, really what's what's most important here, which is like
- 12:30people actually building on the protocol and using it in, in new
- 12:33and interesting ways and adopting Bitcoin as money in a
- 12:36lot of these areas. So I'm curious, just, you know,
- 12:38how you would characterize at a high level what's transpired
- 12:41over the past 12 months or so? And then also you know where,
- 12:44where I guess your energy and efforts are focused currently in
- 12:48in the region. Yeah, for sure.
- 12:51I'll start with the last 12 months have been kind of just a
- 12:56natural evolution from the last, I'd say five years in terms of
- 12:59people unlearning what it means to build on Bitcoin.
- 13:03And because I think a lot of that, like Michael's talking
- 13:05about regards to the the interplay between Fintech slash
- 13:08Bitcoin here on the content has been highly correlated.
- 13:10I mean, the entire Bitcoin space kind of evolved out of the
- 13:13Fintech space from a lot of entrepreneurs on the ground
- 13:15essentially looking at it as this is a way for us to actually
- 13:19shortcut a lot of the issues that we've been having trying to
- 13:21solve for a while all the way up to realize, OK, this is an
- 13:24actual monetary network that can have its own different niches
- 13:28slash ecosystem that we can kind of build on, whether it comes to
- 13:30mining or things like that. So we've gradually gone from
- 13:33being kind of a pocket of the Fintech space to becoming
- 13:36essentially more and more its own ecosystem that I think will
- 13:39kind of subsume the fintech ecosystem as well.
- 13:42A few others to be honest. And now we're at the point where
- 13:45entrepreneurs understand what it means to build for Africa, at
- 13:47least at a small scale in terms of building on Bitcoin for
- 13:50Africa. And we're starting to see a lot,
- 13:52a lot of these entrepreneurs kind of double down on the ideas
- 13:54that kind of more highlighted on the continent versus outside of
- 13:58the continent. So a lot of that is the reason
- 14:00why you see some of these interesting products, whether it
- 14:02comes to SIM cards that should be used, being used as Bitcoin
- 14:06hardware wallets, for example, with KGS project or even just
- 14:09things around the Lightning Network when it comes to sending
- 14:12sats and receiving in back account and all these kind of
- 14:14things. So I think we're at the point
- 14:17where we've kind of flipped what the paradigm is to what it
- 14:20should be in terms of the builders perspective, in terms
- 14:23of capital allocation slash. Other things I think is just
- 14:26going to naturally follow as more things kind of take better
- 14:29shape in terms of where my energies are focused.
- 14:31Like it's split between two things.
- 14:33So on the entrepreneur side, obviously it's to back up a lot
- 14:36of these early state companies continue on the work that I've
- 14:39been doing for quite a while now in terms of making entrepreneurs
- 14:42understand what it means to build for Africa on top of
- 14:44Bitcoin. Kind of making them understand
- 14:46that they are going to have to shoulder the not necessarily the
- 14:49responsibility, but what it means to architect a Bitcoin
- 14:53company from scratch given all the issues that we have.
- 14:55And then separately on the other side, when it comes to the the
- 14:59developers themselves, some of these projects in education, a
- 15:02lot of that effort is to be trust for essentially 1, giving
- 15:05grants to developers themselves. So they have long term support
- 15:08as well as some of the short term support to kind of figure
- 15:10out a niche and some of these open source products to support
- 15:13them as well, especially Bitcoin Core and focusing specifically
- 15:16on kind of the resilience of Bitcoin and see how they can
- 15:18contribute to that at a global stage.
- 15:20And then when it comes to some of these other projects or even
- 15:22just conferences generally. And to again, narrow down the
- 15:26focus to make sure that people understand what the value
- 15:28proposition is with Bitcoin, the role of Africa in terms of
- 15:31defining the future of Bitcoin and things around that
- 15:34generally. So I see the majority of my time
- 15:36has been spent between these two things, kind of see how we could
- 15:40kind of synthesize both to create a more lasting ecosystem
- 15:43essentially. Yeah, that's, that's super
- 15:46fascinating. Maybe going to the like there's
- 15:50two parts segmenting them. The the first part on the
- 15:53entrepreneurial and and recursive curious like how you
- 15:57know you initially like went down that path and then
- 16:00ultimately you reference kind of rebuilding reground.
- 16:04I think there's a lot happening across Bitcoin in that the 1st
- 16:0715 years we've seen a lot of I don't want to say capital
- 16:11destroyed, even though it's been capital destroyed, but like ways
- 16:13to do things probably that more not right than right.
- 16:18Effectively, if you think about the digital asset crypto
- 16:20ecosystem, right, they only grafted on a lot of the
- 16:23traditional financial system. When you think about custody
- 16:26sitting with a single entity or flow of funds just or even how
- 16:31the company built, right that companies came in and you
- 16:34foundation or fundamentally cannot build in the same way for
- 16:37for lots of reasons, like growth at all costs.
- 16:40One of them was just like the and I don't know if it's the
- 16:43first one, but it's definitely a main one is the reflexivity of
- 16:46the market and the boom bust are are so cute versus the
- 16:51traditional like kind of general 4 to 10 year cycles that you see
- 16:54in, you know, regular kind of business cycles that to like
- 16:58outgrow, right to take that capital and then like, you know,
- 17:01really like go growth at all costs and then literally have to
- 17:04cut, you know, or just have that burn.
- 17:06It just doesn't work in the Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 17:08You've seen a lot of companies have to like learn that the hard
- 17:10way, but I think that's like you, you mentioned the in Africa
- 17:16like building from the ground up.
- 17:18I think that there's this component that that had to
- 17:20happen, one from learnings, but then two, there's a mindset
- 17:23shift when enough people grok Bitcoin that they wouldn't do
- 17:27that inherently wouldn't even make sense to them.
- 17:29They wouldn't if they even could raise that amount of money.
- 17:31They tell, I'm just going to hold Bitcoin and think about it.
- 17:33And it's kind of partially what we're doing at early riders in
- 17:35the sense of, well, you can raise the money, but maybe the
- 17:38opportunity cost isn't the dollar and you're not sitting
- 17:40those dollars in bank accounts, you're sitting them, they're
- 17:42sitting in the BTC and that just has a more discerning prudent
- 17:46allocation of capital. So just curious like how you
- 17:50seen that transpire since starting and recursive And then
- 17:52it feels like that's kind of like migrated over from the
- 17:55African lens of well, maybe when I build it doesn't have to bolt
- 17:59on the Fintech, but I can start from the ground up.
- 18:01And I don't think that could have happened right off the bat.
- 18:03It like we needed all of this kind of like destruction and
- 18:06kind of like learnings over the course of all this, kind of like
- 18:09ups and downs and Bitcoin to come out the other side and
- 18:11realize, oh wait, there's a better way to do all of this.
- 18:15I totally agree. I think it's one of the benefits
- 18:18of this space to be honest, to the entrepreneurs or just
- 18:21builders is that the timeline, a shortened amount of timeline
- 18:25relative to other ecosystem that we have.
- 18:27I think that has helped with sourcing for a signal over time.
- 18:31You can imagine if this reflected the same timelines
- 18:34that we have in regular, whether it's fintech or just generally
- 18:37company building would have probably been another 5-10 years
- 18:40from the period we are right now.
- 18:42So it's good to have those. Well, it's not a good thing to
- 18:45kind of burn capital, but it wasn't necessary sacrifice in
- 18:48the grand scheme of things from my perspective.
- 18:50And what has been interesting is also the evolution of how
- 18:53people, especially capital allocators speaking to or just
- 18:56more generally globally have shifted kind of their
- 18:59understanding and acceptance of one, the permanence of Bitcoin
- 19:02as an actual technology to the kind of the value proposition
- 19:07that Bitcoin already has and has over other ecosystem like the
- 19:11quote UN quote crypto space. A lot of the early conversations
- 19:15I used to have with a lot of folks on the LP side slash
- 19:17investor side has been why just put all your eggs in one basket,
- 19:21which is Bitcoin as opposed to crypto and all these other
- 19:23things. And it's been interesting to see
- 19:25over time as more scams have happened from that the general
- 19:29crypto space. And then the more value is
- 19:31actually created on the Bitcoin space from actual products that
- 19:34solve problems on the ground, the more they've kind of
- 19:36understood the arguments that I've been making, which is that
- 19:39there is no source of signal outside of Bitcoin, the wider
- 19:42space. So right now their understanding
- 19:44is seeing it from this point of view.
- 19:46So they could they not understand that crypto
- 19:49essentially is a large bucket of promises versus Bitcoin, which
- 19:54is a large bucket of use cases and actual case studies.
- 19:57You can see that people have had their lives changed, so it's a
- 20:00lot easier now to kind of convince them of the benefits of
- 20:04having Bitcoin or build. So essentially seeing the
- 20:07dichotomy between like a bucket of promises versus a bucket of
- 20:10case studies and actual and actual use case on the ground
- 20:14that have materially changed people's lives.
- 20:15It's a lot easier for them to crop.
- 20:17I think the next phase for us is going to be the understanding of
- 20:20again, Bitcoin being. This permanent layer that people
- 20:24can be building on and what that means from a venture point of
- 20:27view in terms of again, weighing off the costs, whether it's
- 20:30holding off Bitcoin as opposed to investing in these companies
- 20:33and seeing what the opportunity cost is for that or the cost for
- 20:35capital like you. And it's definitely going to
- 20:39take a lot shorter over time that the general paradigm shifts
- 20:42that they needed to see first to kind of understand where we're
- 20:45at right now. So it's definitely positive and
- 20:47I'm enjoying seeing the the conversation shift from, oh,
- 20:50this guy is a bit crazy playing everything off.
- 20:52What are the other opportunities that we're missing in the
- 20:55general Bitcoin space? So it's definitely been
- 20:57refreshing. Yeah, I know that's that's
- 21:00really fascinating. I think I always, I always think
- 21:02back to and and I might get, you know, details of this slightly
- 21:08incorrect. But I think, you know, when the
- 21:11notion of like Ethereum was first brought up, it was kind of
- 21:15like, yeah, go test these other things, like go build these
- 21:18other things. If any of them work, we'll like
- 21:20bring them the Bitcoin, IE like the more permanent robust
- 21:25blockchain or protocol. And I think we lost that some
- 21:28somewhere along the way where then it was just, you know, a a
- 21:31myriad of different protocols being created for all these
- 21:34promises, like you said. But it always comes back to what
- 21:39you, what I also heard you say was like, you want to build on
- 21:41that permanent robust foundation, right?
- 21:44And I think that is something that people are increasingly,
- 21:48you know, just as education continues around like the actual
- 21:50fundamentals of these things, I think we are sort of making some
- 21:54progress in that realm that people are beginning to see sort
- 21:58of the broader crypto space for what what it really is.
- 22:00And, and it's a lot of promises built on unsound foundations,
- 22:05whereas, you know, there's a lot of really great building going
- 22:08on, on Bitcoin on a, on a sound foundation.
- 22:10So that's, that's sort of like the crux of the difference.
- 22:13I think one thing I'd be curious about in those two sort of sides
- 22:19that you're focused on currently in, in terms of allocation.
- 22:21And then also sort of the more purely on the development side
- 22:25and giving grants to folks. I'd be curious, is there an
- 22:27interplay between those two things in the sense that you
- 22:30know what you're looking for in terms of giving grants to
- 22:33developers or, or they're sort of, I guess ways that those are
- 22:39connected to things that you want to invest in?
- 22:41Like do you need to find the builders to build the things
- 22:44that like the businesses that you want to exist in the world?
- 22:46Is there any interplay between those two sides of of what
- 22:48you're focused on? Oh yeah, a ton.
- 22:51And which is why it kind of makes juggling the two a lot
- 22:55easier than it seems from the outside.
- 22:57So in terms of the inner play, I see naturally it's contributed
- 23:00greatly to kind of the sources of the pipeline for the fun side
- 23:04in terms of recursive. So previously essentially either
- 23:06reaching out to entrepreneurs and seeing what's kind of in the
- 23:09other line and as well as combining that with getting
- 23:12inbound from entrepreneurs that are aware of us actually located
- 23:15in capital. Over time that has shifted into
- 23:18kind of understanding and seeing that we're very, very early.
- 23:21So we kind of have to induce some of the innovation to a
- 23:24certain degree on the the builder side.
- 23:26So a lot of that has been also bringing on three other
- 23:29essentially sources, which is one from the general developer
- 23:32community that essentially managed to create from, I don't
- 23:36want to say thin air, but let's say conjure from the existing
- 23:38talent that is pretty much around that would have gone to
- 23:41crypto that now thank God is Bitcoin.
- 23:43So a lot of that has been folks just testing ideas and then
- 23:46reaching out and seeing if there is a business case that can be
- 23:48followed up on the venture side. The other side is also just
- 23:51seeding ideas into the ecosystem.
- 23:53So coming up with ideas internally at Recursive that
- 23:55want to fund that we think is useful and then kind of looking
- 23:58for entrepreneurs to build on that and then take it off and
- 24:01then we fund that essentially. The other thing is essentially
- 24:05looking at it from the perspective of the existing
- 24:07companies on the ground that are now shifting their focus to
- 24:10double down on Bitcoin building. Because previously a lot of
- 24:12these companies that were quote UN quote Bitcoin companies to
- 24:15the extent that they were at the time all the way up to now and
- 24:17kind of also shifted their focus to expanding some of the things
- 24:20that they've been building on our workmen.
- 24:22Some of that gets spun off into actual companies slash the folks
- 24:26that are building on that get to fart themselves off of the
- 24:28company itself and that forming companies.
- 24:31So that's another essential piece of the puzzle.
- 24:34But I say in general, the interplay is Tebby connected
- 24:37like one of the reasons why I was really, really passionate,
- 24:40especially in in terms of understanding what is necessary
- 24:44for this piece to kind of be at the point where right now in
- 24:47terms of the venture site has been the lack of developers.
- 24:49So it kind of follows essentially a cycle where you
- 24:53need to critical mass of developers to one be in the
- 24:56space building to understanding what can be built based on the
- 24:59tools that are being built more generally in the global space
- 25:02ecosystem and then having companies come out of come as a
- 25:06result of that. So essentially all these cycles
- 25:08are funding these developers, educating them.
- 25:11I'm understanding that, OK, they can build on Bitcoin from these
- 25:14use cases and some realizing that there are business cases
- 25:17that can be built on top of that.
- 25:19And then coming all the way up to the venture side.
- 25:20So essentially is a cyclical, cyclical cycle for kind of
- 25:24development, kind of bridging myself in between the two.
- 25:27So essentially that's the interplay and it's likely going
- 25:29to continue the same way. I don't think there's going to
- 25:31be like a shift where it will be venture creating the first
- 25:34source staff stuff because there's the issue of the tragedy
- 25:37of commerce really at the open source side.
- 25:38So it's always going to follow from the open source side.
- 25:41Yeah, and that makes complete sense to me.
- 25:43I think it's actually the future.
- 25:45Everything we both kind of stumbled into to this recursive
- 25:49feedback. This is hence the name.
- 25:53Yeah. I mean, honestly, I think this
- 25:54is how things were always done and we forgot about them, right?
- 25:57Like if you had a large conglomerate and you built and
- 26:00then you naturally spotted gaps in the market and you had
- 26:04capital, you would go out to the market and you would be able to
- 26:08understand what needed to be built.
- 26:09You weren't theorizing and, and just sitting in an ivory tower
- 26:12being able to think through it. It's a similar example what
- 26:15you're describing as you were coding, you were in the market,
- 26:17You're looking at opportunities, you're seeing things you're
- 26:20building, you're seeing other people build.
- 26:21You're you're ideating and, and influencing some of your vision
- 26:24and thoughts where they're picking it back up.
- 26:29They build things that it enhances or feedbacks into where
- 26:34you're looking at opportunities from recursive and it just kind
- 26:37of is a flywheel versus if you only have one sitting there,
- 26:40you're naturally kind of either stagnant, right?
- 26:42You just look for it. I think about it as like on the
- 26:45VC side, if all you do is is invest your avid hammer and
- 26:48everything needs to look like a nail.
- 26:50And that's just I think as humans, there's not if you do
- 26:55that, our brains are idle, right?
- 26:57Like this notion of like, you want to be building, you want to
- 26:59get and see now you start to like look at you look for
- 27:01opportunities where they may not exist versus if you're
- 27:03constantly building, you have other things you're focused on.
- 27:06It gives you an edge to spot angles in the market that are
- 27:09missing to refine thesis is over time that can now support the
- 27:13investment case. And I think this is just natural
- 27:16way of moving forward. And this is, it's funny because
- 27:19this isn't actually anything new.
- 27:20Like when you look back at the sequoias and the benchmarks of
- 27:23the world, like these individuals were operators back
- 27:27at, I forget the exact firms, but they were like the micro,
- 27:30the semiconductor space in like the late 50s and 60s.
- 27:33They spotted all the gaps where like Atari was a good example of
- 27:37this, like where Atari started to pick up steam because they
- 27:39were buying a lot of these semiconductors and realizing
- 27:41like the growth from there. And they were able to influence,
- 27:45you know, go to market and all the things that naturally come
- 27:47from building a company from the ground up versus not.
- 27:51So yeah, it's it's a very cool like dynamic that you found
- 27:53yourself. In one, one part of what you
- 27:58said that I'm curious about is you, you mentioned sort of you
- 28:03were grateful to have gotten some developers to to stay away
- 28:07from the broader crypto space and and you know, focus on
- 28:09Bitcoin. How would you sort of
- 28:12characterize the general movement of human capital in the
- 28:16development space for the past, call it 12 to 18 months?
- 28:19Because I think there's been this notion of sort of a
- 28:24Cambrian explosion, if you will, of like newer, you know, new
- 28:28people coming to Bitcoin and, and wanting to build on the
- 28:30protocol. But you look at something like,
- 28:34you know, ordinals or runes or these types of things where I
- 28:37think it's, it's almost like going back to what I was saying
- 28:41before, it's like, well, we could look at what Ethereum did,
- 28:44but like we should be a little bit more discerning about like
- 28:47whether we want to bring that to Bitcoin.
- 28:49And I think there's been sort of this influx of people who are
- 28:52just saying like, no, let's just bring all the stuff that we
- 28:55tried on the other protocols to Bitcoin, whether it's NF, TS or
- 28:59different forms of roll ups. So I'm curious like, I guess
- 29:02first part of the question is like how, how would you sort of
- 29:05characterize that sort of flow of human capital, if you will,
- 29:09development mind share? And then second part of that
- 29:14being, you know, what in your mind what is the most valuable
- 29:18sort of two or three areas that a Bitcoin focused developer
- 29:22could be thinking about currently?
- 29:25Yeah, great questions. I mean, before I forget, I'll
- 29:28just like to feed off of the, the last statement you made
- 29:31really with regards to the general issues that we're
- 29:34seeing. Well, I mean, it is an issue to
- 29:36a certain contingent of the Bitcoin space, which is there
- 29:40seems to be this my, my opinion is humbly this confusion that we
- 29:45need to essentially succeed based off of the terms that have
- 29:48been set by the crypto space, right?
- 29:50Whereas I think that is completely unjustified and it's
- 29:52kind of a false premise to start from because again, what is what
- 29:55are the successes of the crypto space to point to my opinion?
- 29:58They're they're lacking or honestly non existent, which is
- 30:00the reason why job security has been a huge issue for a lot of
- 30:03these developers. Like the yes, they do get high
- 30:05paying jobs in those space, but then those jobs last like a
- 30:09week, month plus. The ironic part is like the
- 30:12company just keep busting most of the time.
- 30:14The conversations that I have with a lot of the folks that are
- 30:17working as developers in the crypto spaces constantly keep
- 30:20for the next job versus the Bitcoin space where a lot of the
- 30:23conversations are around sitting, sitting down to look at
- 30:26how they could double down on the work that they're doing that
- 30:28will have effects in the next 5-10 years.
- 30:29So you can definitely see that there is a difference in terms
- 30:32of the mindset when it comes to Bitcoin versus crypto, where the
- 30:36Bitcoin side is mostly around developers that have understood
- 30:39that actually this is a useful tool that now provides for a lot
- 30:43of use cases that were previously either impractical or
- 30:46maybe just purely theoretical that could actually be built on
- 30:49top of. So there's that.
- 30:51I would say resurfacing of interest just as a developer to
- 30:54kind of work on things that materially can make a difference
- 30:57given all the case studies that already are existing in the
- 31:00Bitcoin space. And when it comes to the
- 31:01opportunities that they can explore when it comes to the
- 31:04niches, there are a variety of things from, you know, mesh
- 31:07networking all the way up to him.
- 31:09It's been a huge run all the way up to even some more niche runs
- 31:12around communication protocols with the interplay between no
- 31:15star as well as Bitcoin or even those that are more interested
- 31:17in the artificial intelligence side, which to your point, in
- 31:19the last 12 to 18 months, you've seen quite a lot of them to the
- 31:23realization that maybe Bitcoin is a currency for artificial
- 31:26intelligence in Canada, next wave of the Internet.
- 31:28So we're definitely seeing a lot of those trends.
- 31:30But I think again, just to narrow down to the issues we
- 31:32have right now in regards to people building ruins or some of
- 31:36these other, I do think it's just a natural function of kind
- 31:40of, again, this miscommunication or misunderstanding that we have
- 31:43to succeed on the terms of crypto versus on the merits of
- 31:46Bitcoin as it is. So I think we'll likely continue
- 31:49to see that, but it'll probably die off.
- 31:51Again, like a lot of the cycles we've seen with Bitcoin, a lot
- 31:54of these ideas and protocols are to Bitcoin.
- 31:57You've seen them in the early days.
- 31:58They just keep psyching us. More things happen in the crypto
- 32:01space and then they get brought into Bitcoin.
- 32:02So I wouldn't pay too much attention to that.
- 32:04The long term builders are easily going to outpace
- 32:07importance wise to some of the other guys.
- 32:09They're doing maybe frivolous, but with things that you might
- 32:12consider. Yeah, on the on, on that note,
- 32:18Abu, how do you think about like how do you segment 'cause
- 32:21there's two brains you have to to use in the sense of thinking
- 32:25of innovation and and being a developer and you know, helping
- 32:28fund developers. But historically in Bitcoin, I
- 32:31think objectively innovation is not the easiest to monetize,
- 32:35right. It's it's generally pretty
- 32:36early, takes a while to find commercial use cases and then
- 32:40even the commercial use cases, the businesses generally aren't
- 32:42the most, you know, investable or or monetize.
- 32:46I think about like multi Sig's a great example where, you know,
- 32:49Belshi had the first implementation until maybe 10
- 32:52years ago, 11 years ago, they built a business, but it was an
- 32:55exchange. They had to naturally get, you
- 32:57know, kind of do a little bit more in in crypto to to justify
- 33:00or to make money. But then really the consumer
- 33:02version of multi city came around in like, you know, 1617
- 33:06and you have like collaborative custody, but it's been kind of
- 33:08like hard to monetize that, but at least got commercially viable
- 33:12and lots of people now use it. And we know of like there's the
- 33:14nunchucks that were all in Casas and all these different
- 33:17companies that do that. But that took a while, right.
- 33:20And just curious how you think about, you know, innovation
- 33:25versus and, and how to manage that versus like opportunity
- 33:29sets that meet the market where there's an actual need?
- 33:34Yeah, I mean, it's, it's, it's an interesting one.
- 33:37It's definitely still a learning process, to be honest, because
- 33:39I'm constantly being surprised by just the evolution of the
- 33:42ecosystem. Like there are times where
- 33:44you're like, oh, wow, this is happening a lot quicker than I
- 33:46would have anticipated versus all this is going to take way
- 33:49longer than I had I thought really previously.
- 33:51But I think what's interesting is in terms of kind of the
- 33:54dynamics of bridging doing venture this early stage, given
- 33:59the entire ecosystem is essentially early stage.
- 34:01And when it comes to just general Bitcoin companies, you
- 34:04still don't have like Bitcoin Unicorn companies yet.
- 34:06So really at that stage where even exit strategies have been
- 34:10something that are it's kind of like a general issue in the
- 34:12space where there isn't exactly a path to exit for venture.
- 34:16But then again, it is an opportunity for us to maybe
- 34:18rethink venture, which is was interesting about ideas like
- 34:20early writers to where you don't necessarily give in to some of
- 34:23the some of the incentives that we previously have in terms of
- 34:27general venture. So that's another opportunity in
- 34:29terms of bridging the two. Like the way I see the role of
- 34:32big VCs, especially in this stage is kind of walking the
- 34:36path with the entrepreneurs side by side.
- 34:38So capital allocation is not just enough at the early stage
- 34:41because you can throw capital as much as you want at the problem.
- 34:44It's not going to find a use case on the ground.
- 34:46It's not going to find a business case.
- 34:47It's not going to really help the entrepreneurs because a lot
- 34:49of the work that they're going to be facing such the issues
- 34:52have to deal with partners that can weather their storm together
- 34:55with them, as well as providing a path for them to actually
- 34:57succeed. It's a lot of work really with
- 34:58recursivism, just giving out checks is essentially giving out
- 35:01checks and helping the entrepreneurs on a day-to-day or
- 35:03even to to the frequency that see the problems that they're
- 35:06facing required. So a lot of it has been, I think
- 35:11with more stability into some of the tools and services that are
- 35:14already built on the first side. Your point about multi state,
- 35:18easier it is to find kind of business cases because now the
- 35:20issue isn't relegated strictly to the theoretical side of how
- 35:25can this work on a technical side.
- 35:26It's more a case of, OK, now that this works to the extent
- 35:29that it does, what are the opportunities that we could
- 35:31actually meet on the ground that people have been facing that
- 35:33this now actually is able to do so.
- 35:36So I think again, it goes back into the cycle of feeding from
- 35:39having all these successes, stability when it comes to the
- 35:43open source tech, all the way up to realizing that, OK, this
- 35:46can't be implemented in the real world.
- 35:47And then see what the most effective business cases are.
- 35:50Because again, we're really early stage.
- 35:51A lot of these Bitcoin companies pretty much don't have any
- 35:53viable business cases. And the ones that do are kind of
- 35:56like a handful. And even those ones typically do
- 35:59have to keep working with them to get them to a stage where
- 36:01they're sustainable. Because it's not just enough to
- 36:03have a business case. It's you need it to be
- 36:05sustainable for it to be a business.
- 36:07Otherwise, it's just a project that can make money for the
- 36:10short term. So bridging the two and
- 36:11realizing where to bucket the two and kind of how you support
- 36:14each has been the the primary thing that I think we'll we'll
- 36:18have to continue to work on to, to see where we can get it out
- 36:21of stage where maybe we have templates for others to follow
- 36:23or will be coming into the VC space for it.
- 36:26But that's actually kind of how I see the dynamic.
- 36:29Have you seen more play out in Africa versus the US?
- 36:32Like the example that I think of, and this is probably not
- 36:34completely fair, but I think it's directionally that most
- 36:36people don't talk about as lightning.
- 36:38So lightning was looked at as a, you know, it is, I think a big
- 36:41innovation, you know, scaling Bitcoin by layers, but at the
- 36:43same notion like people just don't spend Bitcoin in the US.
- 36:47And I, I like to like it's like the one that's easy to pick on
- 36:50without naming any others is, is David Marcus's firm.
- 36:55What a light spark. A light spark.
- 36:57Yeah. Because like, I think it was
- 36:59like a waterfall where like you get the big VC to invest and
- 37:03then it's a waterfall of everyone else is buying their
- 37:05product from an enterprise perspective.
- 37:07So then the, you know, pre seed, seed or even Series A uses the
- 37:12top and then you kind of just flow and that's like the capital
- 37:14stack. But nobody's actually spending
- 37:16the money either. The like you're not getting
- 37:18meaningful flow through lightning rails to justify a
- 37:21business model or nobody's using it from an enterprise
- 37:24perspective. Like Coca Cola's not going to X
- 37:26lightning company, right? So it's like this waterfall
- 37:29stack that I think is similar to multi stick in the sense like
- 37:32that was the next layer and probably a few years out where
- 37:35then you see some real crazy use cases that can justifies justify
- 37:39real ventures style returns. But does that I I feel confident
- 37:44that's a version of the West that nobody talks about, but I
- 37:46don't feel confident in Africa. That's a version curious like if
- 37:49more people are utilizing Bitcoin from payments or does
- 37:52that kind of poured over the same use case?
- 37:54That's not really, Yeah. No, no, no.
- 37:58It's, it's definitely the case. I think what's interesting is
- 38:02with Lightning, it's the general issue of I think just share
- 38:04volumes of usage, like a lot of the payments are typically,
- 38:08especially at least here in in Africa tend to be really micro.
- 38:12You're not going to have a lot of these business cases that
- 38:15rely on either transaction fees or some of these other say
- 38:18vanilla business cases really taking off steam because again,
- 38:23having a, a percentage of what is the equivalent maybe $100
- 38:27isn't necessarily going to make you a big business.
- 38:30What's interesting to see is, and this hasn't a whole
- 38:32different conversation without getting into that rabbit hole,
- 38:35but what I've been interested to see is kind of how USDT adoption
- 38:40has progressed in the space, especially in Africa,
- 38:44specifically with regards to tapping into the existing demand
- 38:46of people wanting to have access to USD.
- 38:49And I think in that way it, it probably highlights an example
- 38:52that we could highlight for like more maybe some of these other
- 38:55specific niches in Bitcoin where you don't necessarily have to
- 38:59create demand from scratch in that specific instance.
- 39:03And then have business cases built on top of that.
- 39:05I think you can just tap into existing demand that people
- 39:08already have and then allow for your technology to kind of
- 39:10facilitate that, which is what USDT has essentially done in,
- 39:13which is why the volume is just crazy, especially in the last
- 39:15couple of years where people are starting to realize that OK,
- 39:18government doesn't allow them to hold U.S. dollars, whether it's
- 39:20physical or bank. No, it's sorry, even the bank
- 39:22accounts really don't necessarily support it global
- 39:25level where you can center see USD the same way you would want
- 39:27to, but USDT allows for you to do this globally.
- 39:30So I think the same thing is going to be true for light in
- 39:32the sense that we'll likely need to look for places that have a
- 39:37lot better market fit. That is already solving a larger
- 39:40issue that already has the volumes to support business
- 39:42cases, whereas business is more broadly and then tapping into
- 39:45that as opposed to like recreating it based off of maybe
- 39:48theoretical ecosystem they can build on top of this technology.
- 39:51So we'll see how, you know, artificial intelligence, Noster,
- 39:54all of the buzzwords really can kind of fit into that and to be
- 39:57finding it. Yeah, I'm glad, I'm glad you
- 40:00brought that up because I was going to, it was perfect
- 40:03transition. I was going to ask you your view
- 40:05on sort of stable coins generally in the sense that
- 40:08going back to what you said before around, you know, the the
- 40:12broader crypto space doesn't really have a whole lot to show
- 40:15for it at the end of the day in terms of like successful use
- 40:17cases. I think if we were all being
- 40:19generous, we would say. Well, maybe stablecoins would be
- 40:22the one thing that like they've gotten some traction with in the
- 40:25market. And when you talk to crypto
- 40:26people, they'll point to that too.
- 40:28Now in just saying that, you know, there's a ton of of, of
- 40:32payment volume, payment volume in stablecoins sort of globally.
- 40:35I'm curious, I guess first part being do you do you see that as
- 40:42one of the, you know, one of those opportunities that make
- 40:45sense to bring to Bitcoin in some way?
- 40:48And then if yes, you know, in your view, what are what are
- 40:54what are sort of the best ways that people are going about
- 40:56doing that now, whether it's, you know, something like Taproot
- 40:59assets or you know, things on the E cash side.
- 41:02Curious what your view is on sort of the different ways that
- 41:05people are going about bringing, you know, U.S. dollar based
- 41:11value to Bitcoin. I mean, honestly, it might just
- 41:15be one of those situations where it might not be all too
- 41:19beneficial in the sense that you might have to sacrifice
- 41:22stability and maybe at the certain layers for for you to
- 41:26support either stable coins or maybe just this general paradigm
- 41:29of having stable currencies in the Bitcoin realm.
- 41:33It might just be a case where unless you leave that to the
- 41:35folks that are already doing all these other protocols where
- 41:37there's Tron or things like that, just focus on things that
- 41:40work with Bitcoin to maintain, again, it's resilience, making
- 41:43sure that we're not introducing things on because of sacrificing
- 41:46it as a result of saying, you know, OK, convincing ourselves
- 41:49that there is this an extent amount of use case that people
- 41:53could tap into and that would capture all of that in Bitcoin.
- 41:56I don't necessarily think that that might be the the most the
- 41:59most sound way for us to build something that we want to still
- 42:02be around for decades. I mean, we're taking examples
- 42:05from chains and other protocols that aren't necessarily stable
- 42:08or even going to be around for the conversation that we'll be
- 42:11having with our grandkids or even great grandkids.
- 42:13I don't think that might be a necessary path to take.
- 42:15But in terms of I think the one thing that maybe crypto could
- 42:18show for it, definitely it is stable client.
- 42:20Then I mean, the one thing really is the stable client
- 42:24ecosystem just reflects the the current state of geopolitics one
- 42:28as well as the current state of economics more broadly.
- 42:31There's not a case where it's something that is a big problem
- 42:35or maybe it's a technological problem.
- 42:37It just reflects the stage of human civilization that we're at
- 42:40right now, whether it comes to the dollars hegemony or maybe
- 42:43just some of the issues that we have with regards to the lack of
- 42:46national sovereignty, which is head.
- 42:48It's a conversation that people have been having maybe having
- 42:51currencies that are stable for national for maybe countries on
- 42:55the big vertical. So I think honestly a lot of it
- 42:57is just a completion of we have a lot more things that need to
- 43:00be fixed outside of pickup for it reflecting the these pieces
- 43:03that we could find on top of pickup versus seeing that this
- 43:07works because of the way the things the way things work right
- 43:10now. And then we want to put that
- 43:11into pickup and then kind of replicate that same success.
- 43:13So I think we just have to separate our concerns and then
- 43:16focus on things that are more long term than just kind of
- 43:19replicate the success of stable things.
- 43:22That makes a lot of sense and it goes back to what you initially
- 43:24said or were discussing about something.
- 43:27We just think about it makes it makes foundational sense, but it
- 43:30hasn't been approached in that you want the use case to come
- 43:34from the existing world. Like the you, you graph Bitcoin
- 43:37onto it. It's this notion of you're not
- 43:38recreating the entire wheel, you're kind of repurposing it.
- 43:41And then maybe over time it can look a little different.
- 43:44But it's this notion of if there's demand for a use case
- 43:46and Bitcoin can port over, that's where you can find some
- 43:50kind of monetization, some kind of commercialization that does
- 43:53it. But that generally comes from a
- 43:54market of professionals that have been around for a very long
- 43:57time because they know the existing system.
- 43:59Like to change it, you have to know it very deeply.
- 44:01And then the into that ties into like banking fintechs and it's
- 44:05then it goes to the second order of there's probably a lot of
- 44:08incentives on why people are pushing stables on Bitcoin.
- 44:12But at the end of the day, like to your point, there's tech debt
- 44:15that comes with it, but there's also like commercial debt.
- 44:18There's like this commercial in the sense of somebody has to
- 44:21understand that. Even though people think that
- 44:23you can obfuscate it, like the first movers or the 1st adopters
- 44:25have to start to understand, well, wait, what's happening
- 44:28here? And at the end of the day, like
- 44:30stables have multiple layers of counterparty risk.
- 44:32So putting it on Bitcoin doesn't really help the underlying
- 44:35stability of the, the underlying.
- 44:37So it doesn't matter what the currency is, if it's a Tron or
- 44:39the, the blockchain, it's just a database that somebody else is
- 44:41controlling. We all know that.
- 44:43So just use whatever is there, that's your, you know,
- 44:45understand what stables are used for and then Bitcoin to sit next
- 44:49to it. Just provide a better experience
- 44:51over time for the individual to understand what they're doing
- 44:53within an application versus like trying to merge and
- 44:56conflate into feels like some of those misaligned incentives with
- 44:59VC and like somebody raises $100 million to put things on
- 45:02Lightning. Now you have to start creating
- 45:03these weird Frankenstein solutions that don't rally
- 45:06really make. Sense exactly, exactly.
- 45:10And honestly, that's the main I think insight that we probably
- 45:13have to base a lot of the next couple of decades of building on
- 45:17pop up because we do go to the path of just distracting
- 45:19ourselves, the things that we think are priorities then.
- 45:22And then what is the whole water for the enterprise just working
- 45:25on Bitcoin in general? Yeah.
- 45:27And no, nobody talks about this and I'm not sure why.
- 45:30Maybe it's the incentives, but like the reality is we're so
- 45:33early to Bitcoin. The two main use cases are how
- 45:35to buy it and how to hold it and like you can, you can make
- 45:39successful business as but or venture firms just focusing on
- 45:42those two, because the part that everybody forgets is bitcoins
- 45:46money. And if bitcoins money, it
- 45:48requires financial services. But the kicker is financial
- 45:51services are localized. Everybody forgot about that with
- 45:53the aggregation of big banks. So every city, every like
- 45:57country or every state like can have its own Bitcoin version.
- 46:00There's enough to go and like actually educate and get those
- 46:03people in because nobody's, you know, again, it's .00 whatever
- 46:061% of all humans are into Bitcoin.
- 46:09And I think we get, I think what happened was we graphed it on
- 46:12traditional tech and venture where we got really excited by
- 46:15like just always improving and optimizing for, you know, these
- 46:18big things that are going to come.
- 46:19And there's no doubt like they'll come, but it's like,
- 46:22well, they come and we're alive or in the next 10 years to
- 46:24return to capital or for people to see it.
- 46:26And generally it's probably not the, the, the case.
- 46:30They're good friends. And I don't know if this is
- 46:32exactly fair, but like the person that the, the group that
- 46:35comes to mind is Mutiny community, like had a lot of
- 46:37tech and a lot of things, but like, it's just like, was there
- 46:41enough value, time, motivation to like build something that
- 46:45people are using in 2024? Is it a 2028 project?
- 46:49And I think that's like the, the stuff we have to like work
- 46:51through as like as a, as groups building in the space of like,
- 46:55what do we find the time? And to your point, like capital
- 46:59will be destroyed and I guess it's needed, but I was thinking
- 47:01about like I don't want it to be my investors capital that's
- 47:03being destroyed if we're going to like do it the delicate
- 47:08balance there. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 47:12keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 47:14sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 47:17Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 47:19safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 47:22device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 47:26and our multi institution custody solution.
- 47:29Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 47:32multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 47:36a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 47:41unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 47:44over your coins. With on Ramps multi institution
- 47:47custody you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 47:50stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 47:53tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 47:56going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 48:00exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 48:04in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 48:07you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 48:10custody set up. On ramps, multi institution
- 48:13custody, eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 48:16personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 48:20access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 48:23secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 48:26backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 48:29cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 48:33asset. Secure it right.
- 48:35Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 48:38Yeah, it's a, it's a good point just on like the timing of all
- 48:41this and and you know, just your time horizon on an investment or
- 48:46just like the practicality of a, of A use case.
- 48:49That's why maybe I would be, I'd be interested to hear you talk a
- 48:52little bit about what you've done or invested in on, on sort
- 48:56of the mining side of things, because that's like a very near
- 48:59term, I would say, you know, thing to be focused on at least,
- 49:03you know, again, you know, we've seen a ton of mining
- 49:07infrastructure built out in Texas over the past few years.
- 49:09But then would be curious to hear sort of what you've seen in
- 49:13Africa and in, in the mining side of things because yeah, I
- 49:16think that's a, that's a real time practical use case for, for
- 49:22sort of the Bitcoin protocol, if you will.
- 49:24So we'd love to hear sort of the the status update on that.
- 49:31Well, definitely, I think the the main thing for me thinking
- 49:34about the mining space is thinking about it again from
- 49:37this long term sales, ensuring that we have all the necessary
- 49:41foundations right now to get to the stage where again, we're
- 49:43ready to accept and a lot of these bleeding as things that
- 49:47will happen that maybe we're not necessarily seeing right now.
- 49:49So a lot of them has been kind of a mix of seeing what the
- 49:52energy market is now in terms of both from a sovereignty
- 49:56perspective. Increase in honesty has been one
- 49:58of the main things I've been thinking about in terms of
- 50:01Africa is actually leveraging the clean mining to explore some
- 50:04of the energy sovereignty that has been missing from other
- 50:07ecosystems like just mining for natural resources, which
- 50:10honestly has so much technical death and fantastic all of that.
- 50:14When it comes to looking at some of the consequences of exploring
- 50:16that through that Ave. I think there is that aspect.
- 50:19The other aspect obviously is on the business case side.
- 50:21So it is kind of balancing off, are you trying to start off
- 50:26multiple mining operations and then funding companies that
- 50:29engage in that or maybe is it a specific company that has some
- 50:32use case in some part of Africa that you're trying to explore?
- 50:35It's like a pilot test case for maybe looking at how you can
- 50:38fund that more broadly. And honestly where we do sit
- 50:40right now, it's there are a couple of things that are in
- 50:43there right now, which certainly just close, but high level the
- 50:46way we're looking at this is from all three apples.
- 50:49So looking at what makes the most sense given the state of
- 50:51affairs right now from just a Bitcoin halving cycles all the
- 50:55way up to kind of the unit economics doesn't make sense.
- 50:59It does not make sense. What are the reasons which we
- 51:00can improve some of the issues that we've had with generally
- 51:03repairing machines here on the ground, they come here or even
- 51:05just for some teaching machines getting into Africa.
- 51:07A lot of that honestly is just looking at how some of these
- 51:10early stage companies there in the next maybe 12 to maybe 18
- 51:15months. And then looking at how in
- 51:17between that we could finalize some of the investments we're
- 51:20looking at from that perspective of having these guys in a
- 51:23certain locations haven't got us highlights to kind of feed off
- 51:27of maybe some other operations that might do with maybe
- 51:30government level mining operations or just exploration
- 51:33for energy management. And seeing how we could also
- 51:36explore some of these other bleeding edge aspects when it
- 51:38comes to maybe starting off some of these data centers that kind
- 51:42of missing on the continent and then maybe selling off compute
- 51:44and if using mining system at that cost.
- 51:46So there is just managing the reading the meeting edge,
- 51:50although up to some of the more realistic business cases.
- 51:52So essentially that's kind of where we are, right?
- 51:55Gotcha that that's, that's super helpful.
- 51:57It makes a lot of sense. One thing you mentioned in there
- 51:59was sort of the regulatory landscape and I, I'd be curious,
- 52:05you know something I think I've heard you say in the past is
- 52:08like you would like to see greater consistency from the
- 52:11various regulators across Africa.
- 52:13Are we getting any closer in that respect or is it still very
- 52:16sort of disparate in terms of how regulators are approaching
- 52:20Bitcoin or or mining specifically even?
- 52:24I mean honestly with I still have hope, I don't want to sound
- 52:28too weak. I think the main issue is it's
- 52:31just balancing out two things you're trying to balance out on
- 52:34the government's head at least. Putting my empathetic hat on, I
- 52:38think what they're struggling with is balancing off protecting
- 52:42people, specifically the general populace slash investors, and
- 52:45then also balancing off protecting the national currency
- 52:48as well as obviously defending our economy.
- 52:50Because for contacts like Africa has been no Nigeria specifically
- 52:53has been called, you know, the, the giant of Africa quite a
- 52:56while, but we've slipped down to 4th right now in terms of the
- 52:59size of our GDP, the size of our economy by GDP, like we're way
- 53:02behind I think Egypt, Algeria as well as South African.
- 53:06So for the government, I think managing inflation, managing the
- 53:10the decline of the currency to insane levels where it's on par
- 53:14with Sats is just of high priority.
- 53:16But at the same time, they also do have an obligation to the
- 53:18general populace to kind of spread some of these economic
- 53:22development, which requires you to also kind of prioritize
- 53:26providing an enabling environment for innovation to
- 53:28take place. And now they have realized like
- 53:30there is that permanence to the general ecosystem or
- 53:32specifically with Bitcoin. But the problem I think with
- 53:35balancing these two is the length that they're viewing
- 53:38from, which is crypto and Bitcoin is the same thing.
- 53:41It's the same ecosystem. So the problem they're going to
- 53:43have to face at least confront right now for it to get really
- 53:46good for our end is to segregate these two ecosystems and then
- 53:50regulate them according. Because the problem is Bitcoin
- 53:53is not like anything that's outside of the space and it's
- 53:56its own ecosystem versus crypto, which is pretty much all the
- 53:59same thing. And it's all just security is
- 54:01pretty much so things are high regulated.
- 54:03I think that's up to, you know, our security Exchange
- 54:05Commission. In terms of the other ecosystem,
- 54:07like with Bitcoin, I think it's going to require a lot more, a
- 54:10lot more of an open framework to kind of understand everything
- 54:12that's happening in this space. And then other than that, I
- 54:15think the other thing that they need to do is kind of
- 54:18synchronize on who gets to set what regulation that kind of
- 54:21cascades into other regulatory agencies.
- 54:24I mean, for now the defacto situation we have is the Central
- 54:27Bank of Nigeria, since she's setting regulation and then
- 54:29everyone else adopting regulation that adapts to that
- 54:32new framework. I think what they probably need
- 54:34to do is look at each department and then again, first of all,
- 54:37segregate back from crypto. And then accordingly, if we're
- 54:40talking about the regulation, what are the respects of the
- 54:42Bitcoin ecosystem that should be catered to?
- 54:44Maybe securities is to that extent or maybe commodities or
- 54:48you want to come to just defending the currency.
- 54:50What does it mean for you to regulate a Bitcoin exchange or
- 54:53Bitcoin only exchange? Right now, the unfortunate
- 54:55situation we have is the exchange side.
- 54:57We have two native exchanges that have now been where it is
- 55:00illegal. We aren't necessarily operating
- 55:02as having a license there within an incubation program.
- 55:06So the problem with that is we don't have any Bitcoin native
- 55:08companies and those incubation programs.
- 55:10So what it effectively means for us is if in the next couple of
- 55:14months slash years to the extent of the duration of this program,
- 55:17if you don't have like the obligation that again is ill fit
- 55:22for the entire ecosystem. So like more issues coming out
- 55:25of that as opposed to what they're trying to fix for.
- 55:27So honestly, a lot of it is being and trying to be as
- 55:30consistent with the messaging as possible, trying to understand
- 55:33where they're coming from, trying to engage with them
- 55:35constructively, which is that's not the the easiest thing to do
- 55:39to begin with. And then more broadly, honestly
- 55:41just seeing these cases that work on the regulatory side from
- 55:44other parts of the world and then building a kind of general
- 55:46framework that works for us here on the ground as opposed to just
- 55:48copying it, which is what a lot of these agencies have been
- 55:51doing on the 1st side of them. That's such a a great question,
- 55:54Ryan. In response, Abu, in the sense
- 55:57of like we talk about order of operations again.
- 56:01And you just hit the nail on the head that, like would you said,
- 56:04is, is happens everywhere at the most micro example from a human,
- 56:08an individual wondering like crypto and Bitcoin.
- 56:10And then is it, you know, if it's, if it's conflated, then
- 56:13it's a risk allocation versus if it's a store value, then you can
- 56:17really come from first principles of like an allocation
- 56:19that's material because it's just a better way to store 1's
- 56:22wealth. And we find this all the time
- 56:25happening with institutions, Raas, like there's this
- 56:29conflation. And so now you have to start
- 56:31back from the, the beginning. So we focus heavily on
- 56:33education. But then we've seen this in the
- 56:35UAE specifically, right, where ADGM and Vara, like they're just
- 56:40the, the regulators there are they merge both together.
- 56:43And I think we've kind of seen at least somewhat OK, like in
- 56:46the West so far with, you know, the CFTC and commodity being
- 56:49deemed a commodity versus crypto.
- 56:52But I think like what you, what you outline is, if you can drill
- 56:58a little bit more, because I know you talked about it with
- 57:00Matt on like, I think everybody sees the headlines in Nigeria
- 57:03that, oh, they're like banning Bitcoin, right?
- 57:06And it's like that's not what's happening that they're deeming
- 57:09certain exchanges to, to have a regulatory approval to like
- 57:14participate. And I know you've been work, I
- 57:16think you've been working with them.
- 57:17If you can just share a little bit more about that, like what's
- 57:19actually happening that they're not banning Bitcoin, but they're
- 57:22trying to build. But again, the regulatory body.
- 57:24So they actually have bureaucracy that I think you're
- 57:26hitting on is not the most efficient as well learning.
- 57:30I mean, it's a lot of things that have to be considered like
- 57:33obviously on contingent from the Bitcoin contingent that
- 57:36constantly is making noise on X or other platforms about Bitcoin
- 57:41being binded in XYZ jurisdiction in Africa.
- 57:44Honestly, a lot of it has to do with, in my opinion, three
- 57:46things. 1 is a lack of understanding of how regulation
- 57:49just evolves naturally when it comes to engaging that side of
- 57:53things that happen. And just the general timelines.
- 57:55I think there's another thing that they're kind of not
- 57:57understanding. Like it's easy because we're in
- 57:59this large bubble in the big price space where things went so
- 58:02fast. So the expectations is for
- 58:04everything else that reacts or interacts with this ecosystem to
- 58:07also match that type of energy or that timeline, which is
- 58:10honestly not the case. It's not something that's gonna
- 58:13be practical for us in terms of regulation too.
- 58:15The third thing I think is a lot of the criticism on the
- 58:19government sides from Bitcoin or just general folks in the space,
- 58:23honestly has a lot to do with an implicit framework that they're
- 58:25operating with or they'd like to see operating for a use actually
- 58:30for regulating Bitcoin. Which honestly, what's the time.
- 58:32If you do sit down with some of these critics, you do find out
- 58:35that their frameworks are regulating Bitcoin or what they
- 58:38think Bitcoin should be regulated as is just as
- 58:42confusing or even more complicated than what the
- 58:45regulators are operating with. So I think a lot of it really is
- 58:49you have to figure out what is the most holistic way that we
- 58:52purchase both in terms of what are the needs on the Bitcoin
- 58:56side for people that actually are using Bitcoin, which is the
- 58:58Bitcoiner. So they are kind of primed for
- 59:01engaging with in terms of what it means to regulate Bitcoin
- 59:04effectively. And then on the regulator side,
- 59:05again, it's honestly just letting them sort out that
- 59:09distinction between Bitcoin too and then regulating accordingly.
- 59:12I think again, a lot of it is just to keep it clear, like the
- 59:16bigger regulatory landscape in Africa is it just matches the
- 59:19regulatory regimes across each of these regions.
- 59:22Like if the priority for the specific region has to do with
- 59:25maybe fending off any sort of competition to the national
- 59:29currency, a lot of that would have to do with their central
- 59:31bank regulating that. We've seen that with Nigeria,
- 59:33Kenya and some of those other regions.
- 59:35But if it has to do with maybe commodities or maybe they're
- 59:38facing issues and kind of increase maybe the amount of
- 59:41inbound coming from tags, they, they tend to move forward
- 59:44regulate to that as maybe an asset class essentially on its
- 59:47own. So I think what people have to
- 59:48realize is when you're looking at some of these headlines
- 59:51coming out of Africa, the first thing that you need to do is
- 59:53figure out what the regulatory regime is in that specific
- 59:56region and then understanding how that affects exactly what
- 59:59the the new news is that's coming out of that.
- 1:00:01So for Nigeria, again like you mentioned that the very example
- 1:00:03is with the exchanges, a lot of people read it as.
- 1:00:07Crypto is now legal to do for exchanges, whereas really the
- 1:00:10case is that regulatory agencies banned all operations that are
- 1:00:13engaging crypto and provided for this one Ave. for you to start
- 1:00:17getting working with them to get regulation in shape to regulate
- 1:00:21that equals and stuff. So technically, there is no
- 1:00:24license for you to operate as a crypto exchange or a Bitcoin
- 1:00:27exchange. And what you have right now is
- 1:00:28being a part of this program. And again, it's going to be
- 1:00:32probably the same case for a lot of other African countries.
- 1:00:34Or to be honest, I think what they're doing is looking on to
- 1:00:37Nigeria and some of these other parts that are maybe more mature
- 1:00:40in terms of their regulation to see what makes the most sense
- 1:00:42for them to adopt. But again, if you see me
- 1:00:44standing out of Africa, the first thing to do is get
- 1:00:47contacts around and feed the regulation and then figure out,
- 1:00:50OK, this new regulation itself where the primary source of
- 1:00:53information is it the central bank?
- 1:00:55Go read the press release that they have on the circular and
- 1:00:58then get back to the story As opposed to oh shit they
- 1:01:01corresponded. The cool for is we'll figure
- 1:01:04this out because like El Salvador I think was first and
- 1:01:06everybody that's ever been close to that knows that it was a
- 1:01:09complete shit show and how they had to figure it out.
- 1:01:11And then the UAE came around in Singapore and it's gotten a
- 1:01:14little bit better, but everybody that's there still knows.
- 1:01:17And then obviously what you just described and it just takes time
- 1:01:20for this to like the framework because I think to your point,
- 1:01:23like your brother being involved, like there's good
- 1:01:26people in these agencies. They just have no idea what
- 1:01:28they're doing. And if they do know, then
- 1:01:30there's all the bureaucracy to figure it out.
- 1:01:32And so it kind of like seems like a pretty practical approach
- 1:01:36is like, maybe if this is all a Ponzi, let's or like there's
- 1:01:38some scams here, let's stop it and then let's let people gate
- 1:01:42through as we go. Maybe that's, I don't know if
- 1:01:44that's the right approach, but I can see how you could come to
- 1:01:46the other side of like why that would make sense in a country.
- 1:01:51No, exactly, exactly. Honestly.
- 1:01:53And that's the most practical way forward.
- 1:01:54And this is going to take some patients on both sides, the
- 1:01:58regulator side having the kind of the humility to kind of
- 1:02:01understand that this is frontier tech.
- 1:02:04There are a lot of things that need to be figured out.
- 1:02:05And then our end is looking at it that some of us, let's see
- 1:02:09majority of a lot of folks that are engaging at this level is
- 1:02:12likely their first time slash. Maybe they don't have too much
- 1:02:15experience working on regulators to begin as.
- 1:02:17So there's a lot of learning about what the mechanisms are in
- 1:02:20play and how regulation just evolves and how to most
- 1:02:22effectively and efficiently engage with them really
- 1:02:25constructively. So a lot of both sides together.
- 1:02:31That's super interesting. Well, I know we're, we're coming
- 1:02:33up on an hour here. Michael, is there anything else
- 1:02:35you wanted to touch on before we wrap?
- 1:02:38Definitely, I mean it ties into what we just talked about is I
- 1:02:41know the answer to this. So I'm not going to fully go and
- 1:02:44and like I want to ask like I was he bullish on Africa, but I
- 1:02:48think I feel like he he is bullish on Africa.
- 1:02:51No, maybe not Obviously, I mean we're we're bullish on Africa as
- 1:02:56well. But I want to go into like you
- 1:02:59have intimate knowledge of why you are, you know, boots on the
- 1:03:03ground. And so like curious on the
- 1:03:05different aspects. 2 that I want to just like tease out are the
- 1:03:09engineering development, right? Like since I was back in the the
- 1:03:13Googles and we works for the day.
- 1:03:14I've always seen this interest in engineers in Africa and like
- 1:03:16in Della was a big one from like outsourcing to get talent there
- 1:03:22you were you're engineering at 13 years old.
- 1:03:24So like what? What is it that's happening
- 1:03:26there that has this ability for engineers to to proliferate and
- 1:03:30grow technology in general? Bitcoin is just technology.
- 1:03:34So that's one to tease out. And then the other one is just
- 1:03:37the, the notion of Islamic finance that roughly 50%, I
- 1:03:40believe Muslims are in Africa. And you know, Bitcoin is the
- 1:03:44perfect form of money for everyone, including Muslims.
- 1:03:48And they haven't had it. They've been looking for a non
- 1:03:50debt based, you know, capital structure, not only a money,
- 1:03:53just capital structure in general.
- 1:03:55How do they like do anything? So I mean, I'm sure there's more
- 1:03:58and I'd love for you to share more, but those are the two that
- 1:04:00I'll like tease out if you wanted to start with.
- 1:04:04No, for sure. I think on the dev side, again
- 1:04:07it goes back to job security. I think a lot more people are
- 1:04:10understanding that there is far better job security in the big
- 1:04:12plane space. And a lot of that on C has to do
- 1:04:15with, again, a lot of the great work we've been doing that would
- 1:04:17be just ramping up grants all the way up to the program we've
- 1:04:20been running to just get developers turned down at a rate
- 1:04:22where we can sustain folks. And we do have folks that are of
- 1:04:25sound signal. The other thing I would see is
- 1:04:28there's also this growing understanding within the
- 1:04:30developer ecosystem and for folks that are working in the
- 1:04:34group just based that Bitcoin is the only opportunity that they
- 1:04:38have to actually build things that are meaningful that
- 1:04:41actually will contribute to like a it's not to appreciate what a
- 1:04:44greater society or or better living standards.
- 1:04:47I run across the forest. So a lot of it is seeing one
- 1:04:50there's struck security to they can actually make the lives of
- 1:04:54themselves family members as well as the general continent a
- 1:04:57lot better because a lot of people that are you know younger
- 1:04:59here on the Internet, which is roughly over 60% of the
- 1:05:02population. There is this general kind of
- 1:05:06guilt slash burden that you do have to carry, which is how do
- 1:05:10you effectively contribute to making Africa a better place and
- 1:05:13how do you do that materially without necessarily just like
- 1:05:17Pentel outline have been has been done with by previous
- 1:05:20generations. So I think they're starting to
- 1:05:22realize that Bitcoin is that out in certain fact that useful on
- 1:05:26the continent in terms of shaping the narrative of Africa,
- 1:05:29that the future of Africa and writing really the the very
- 1:05:32consequential chapters in our entire guest history when it
- 1:05:36comes to being a continent. Getting to that stage where
- 1:05:38we're finally, you know, leveraging off of a lot of the
- 1:05:41problems that people see in the continent, but then doing so in
- 1:05:44a way that is able to kind of benefit folks on the ground.
- 1:05:47But I think that's one aspect when it comes to just kind of
- 1:05:50kind of how folks are seeing on the dev side in terms of Islamic
- 1:05:53finance. Like it's an interesting angle
- 1:05:55because we've seen and get to your point, there's a large
- 1:05:58contingent of folks that are missing here on the continent
- 1:06:00over obviously 50 specifically, my country is cycle of 5050.
- 1:06:03So we haven't had a census in a while.
- 1:06:04So those numbers are pretty much just based off of projections in
- 1:06:08terms of how people see it on the Islamic side, I can tell you
- 1:06:11the conversations have definitely drastically shifted
- 1:06:14ironically because I've crypto, not necessarily just Bitcoin.
- 1:06:17And the problem is twofold. Like there's one angle, which is
- 1:06:20the Sonic finance does have kind of inherits the my opinion.
- 1:06:26The I wouldn't necessarily see in coherence, but also the
- 1:06:29hypocrisy of general finance, which is Islamic finance or the
- 1:06:33notion of sound money or the notion of what it means to have
- 1:06:36halal money. Quote, UN quote is completely
- 1:06:39antithetical to the way money works right now where a lot of
- 1:06:41the currency that we have are debt based, which is completely
- 1:06:45around. So there is that issue of
- 1:06:48Islamic finance's birth out of that ecosystem.
- 1:06:51So a lot of the concept that people are used to when it comes
- 1:06:53to what is halal when it's around from the finance side is
- 1:06:56based off of these false assumptions that money to begin
- 1:06:59with is a lot that we use currently, which is, you know,
- 1:07:01Fiat itself, which isn't the case.
- 1:07:03So I think now they're having to kind of come to bear that
- 1:07:07Bitcoin is the only a lot of money that you can have other
- 1:07:10than maybe come on previous currencies like gold or silver,
- 1:07:12which tradition has been within the history of Islam when it
- 1:07:16comes to finance. So again, right now what they're
- 1:07:19realizing is a lot of these moms are shakes.
- 1:07:22Such people issuing fatwas are starting to least understand
- 1:07:25that Bitcoin is in crypto, which has been the main issue that
- 1:07:28they've had because they were seeing Bitcoin turning from an
- 1:07:30angle of gambling or speculation, which is generally
- 1:07:33where crypto is. So a lot of them are
- 1:07:35understanding that this, there's no concept of debt when it comes
- 1:07:39to Bitcoin versus all these other cryptos are just generally
- 1:07:42money. So now it's getting to the stage
- 1:07:45where they have to undo all the technical hypocrisy that they've
- 1:07:48been going through, which is OK, that Fiat is halal because no
- 1:07:52one wants to accept that they're they've been essentially
- 1:07:54engaging in around this whole time, but they're intentionally
- 1:07:57uneventionally. But interestingly, it is
- 1:08:00something that should be expected If you do read into a
- 1:08:02decent a decent of the prophet saw that said them when it comes
- 1:08:06to predicting the state of the future where you won't be able
- 1:08:10to run away from interest to such a river.
- 1:08:12This was what that report is. So people should have expected
- 1:08:15this in the case. Let me, I think right now,
- 1:08:18suffice to say, I think we're going to get to the stage where
- 1:08:22we'll have a lot more fat wealth than our probate one, especially
- 1:08:25coming most likely from the Gulf regions and then having other
- 1:08:28parts of the world can adopt that same stat.
- 1:08:30So you're slowly, but gradually, I think we're seeing a lot more
- 1:08:33than starting to come around. I could definitely tell you, but
- 1:08:35you're locally make sure we're starting to see some of the
- 1:08:37amounts come out open steal. I hold Bitcoin and it's actually
- 1:08:40not around. It's a loud.
- 1:08:42And then gradually you'll have to undo all the Islamic finance
- 1:08:44issues with RIBA and just general dealing with Fiat and it
- 1:08:48could be low. And so we'll see.
- 1:08:50It's going to take a while, but I'm definitely bullish.
- 1:08:52It's definitely positive. It's changing.
- 1:08:54And that's that's like absolutely incredibly exciting
- 1:08:57when you think about both sides of which you outlined going
- 1:08:59backwards of like 2.1 billion Muslims that effectively have
- 1:09:03had to like take trade-offs and how they like manage in the
- 1:09:07economy because of that system and either being apprehensive to
- 1:09:11participate or just not even participate in that all when you
- 1:09:15can unlock that Harris Afron, who's an advisor to honor at
- 1:09:18Mina and believe you guys are in touch with, has been, I think a
- 1:09:22big proponent on the notion of of Bitcoin Islamic finance.
- 1:09:26And I think that's just going to be amazing 10 years from now to
- 1:09:28see like that as well. And then the other side of it is
- 1:09:31the the notion of when you have property rights and money being
- 1:09:35able to be stored in Bitcoin for a continent, what does that mean
- 1:09:38from the productivity, right, Especially an energy rich
- 1:09:42continent such as Africa, when it comes to, you know, commodity
- 1:09:46based money that you can go tap into that can aggregate and then
- 1:09:49you can actually go so super bullish on that.
- 1:09:52And you know, I think bullish on recursive that if anybody wants
- 1:09:55to reach out, they should, you should get a hold of you if
- 1:09:57they're looking at some exposure to the African continent when it
- 1:10:00comes to Bitcoin. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:10:02I just wanted to wanted to, you know, come up where, where can
- 1:10:05people find you for, you know, if they're interested in
- 1:10:08learning more about recursive or what you're doing with B trust,
- 1:10:11let the people know. Yeah, for sure.
- 1:10:14I'm pretty active on X, I'm an Auster, so my handles are both
- 1:10:17the same one both which is IA 1999.
- 1:10:20And what the question is RCRSV capital on both Auster as well
- 1:10:24as X and then B Trust is similar as B Trust team, which is just
- 1:10:27on X right now. We don't have an Auster for now.
- 1:10:29But yeah, this is generally the channel you can buy me on and
- 1:10:32maybe Forbes if you're interested in reading long term
- 1:10:35based on, well, just for discussing you might cover a lot
- 1:10:38of the developments here. Beautiful.
- 1:10:41Love it. Well, thank you very much for
- 1:10:43for joining us today. It's an an awesome conversation
- 1:10:46and I have to have you back on in the future for another
- 1:10:48update. For sure looking forward to it.
- 1:10:51Thanks again for helping guys. Thanks, Oliver.
- 1:10:53All right, take care guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:10:57week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:10:59valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:11:01rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:11:04All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:11:06notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:11:09reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:11:11entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:11:14investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:11:17your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:11:20Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:11:24one of our private Client Advisors.