Latest / Carbon Weekly News / Why Isometric Is Going Beyond Carbon Removal | CWN EP9
Transcript
- speaker-0: If a project developer is successful and builds more value, we're gonna issue more credit. The success of ICMENT requires in the success of the projects. You need CDR everywhere in all of the different industrial categories that power the world today. And so the concepts are the same. And so we're up over 20 protocols now. And so when you've got 20 reps under your belt, you kind of know what the recipe looks like. So you definitely need access to a 400-person science network. Like I have an isometric to get all of your bespoke questions answered. You get three things. You get char, you get some sludgy oily stuff, and then you get the gas that goes out the top. We put direct air capture facilities on the roof of every building. But like what do we have that we don't have before us, we don't have nature for our kids. speaker-1: I know you're basically on the refereeing side. Like what is one thing that at Shopify you did and now from the refereeing perspective you feel like why did you do this? speaker-2: Well, I'm really excited for this next guest here for us. We've we've got the wonderful Stacy Koch with us from Isometric here to talk with us about the world of registries and and what role they play in in carbon markets today and beyond carbon markets. I think we'll get a little bit into that as well because isometric is kind of breaking out now in looking beyond what, you know, what we've traditionally thought the role of a registry would be in carbon markets. So Stacy, thanks for joining us. speaker-0: Thanks for having me. Really excited to be here. speaker-2: Now you had to come across the pond like like me. So how did that feel to fly over the ocean to come to New York Climate Week this time? speaker-0: I mean, yeah, it it's a bit of a trip, but it's always worth it. And special for me. My birthday always falls on New York Climate Week. So this I consider this my birthday party. So it's a great week to be here. Wow. speaker-2: That's crash. speaker-0: But it's a bit early. There's a lot of drinks sessions later, so we need to like resource. speaker-2: I'm five coffees into Monday and I'm just like okay, ready. no, but working to calm down. Well, yeah, thanks, thanks for joining us. And you know, Momback has obviously had a a great relationship with the isometric team here since we since we made the transition to to work with you guys. And it's been really fun to see your journey and your growth alongside of ours. you guys recently just announced a fundraising round or now expanding a little bit, maybe beyond. Carbon, or you'd tell us a little bit about what's the what's the vision over at Isometric and and may introduce the the org for those who aren't familiar with it. speaker-0: Sure. So Isometric is an environmental certification company, started out as a carbon removal registry. We've since, as you said, closed our second second close on our series A, which is really exciting. We've got some cash in the bank and some really strategic and interesting supporters on the cap table now. So with that, we're expanding beyond where we started with the CDR, but it's really not so much about expanding and doing things differently. It's about providing certification for the industrial economy. And like that sounds flashy as this sounds very series A, right? But what it's about is when you think about how carbon removal is going to scale, and this is where we're going, is that and I've been talking about it for years, you need CDR everywhere. And by that I mean you need CDR happening everywhere it's possible in all of the different industrial categories that power the world today. And so if you're going to do that in a meaningful way, you have to have full visibility across all the data. And that's where isometric comes in. Because if you're doing a carbon removal project on say an energy from waste facility and you're doing gas capture on the stack, well, you need to have the biomass dealt with and you have to make sure it's sustainable on the inside, then you have to deal with all of the energy use and the feedstocks. And you know, now if you're going bigger and bigger, you're thinking about, well, am I producing green energy? Is that a wreck? Is it CDR? What are we doing? And so By going beyond carbon removal, we're able to offer certification for wider range of project types, but they're all interconnected because if we're thinking about the net zero world and full decarbonization, you're gonna need to account for all the carbon flows, all the feedstocks and all the inputs and outputs across the entire economy. And so this is a step in that direction. speaker-2: Often people describe the death of a startup as not focusing. Like it seems like you guys speaker-1: But doing series A, need to pitch something new, right? You need money for a new thing. speaker-2: Yeah. I'm just curious, how do you think about the prioritization? And you guys have announced a ton of new protocols. Now you're announcing new products and cement and thinking about low carbon X. And just curious, yeah, what's the process like to to prioritize where you get where you go? speaker-0: Yeah. And I mean that's what I think about every day because my job at Isometric, I lead the science team, the team that writes all of the protocols and methodologies for all of the CDR we do for the nature-based solutions, and now for all the environmental attribute certificates that we're building out. And how do you do that? Well, the recipe is the same. Even if it's carbon removal, it doesn't matter if it's a DAC plant, if it's a reforestation project, enhanced rock weathering, doesn't matter if it's low carbon cement. It's still a project-based life cycle analysis, right? And so the concepts are the same. And so we're up over 20 protocols now. And so when you've got 20 reps under your belt, you kind of know what the recipe looks like. So things, while they're not the same and you need deep expertise in order to do it well, it is a process that we've, I'd say, found the efficiencies in and we can do it well and we can do it quickly. you talked a little bit about losing focus and how do we decide what to work on. We're driven by our existing project base as well as what buyers are looking for. And so if we take, I don't know, maybe a biochar project and they're producing, you know, when you take your biomass in, you pyrolize that, you combust it, you get three things. You get char, you get some sludgy, oily stuff, and then you get the gas that goes out the top. You can do stuff with all three, right? And so as those projects are looking to monetize and get credit value. from those three different products, then we're able to expand into a new area. And we want to do that when they have a buyer and we're paid by buyers. So we're driven by market signals, which is how we've flow gone from durable CDR into nature-based solutions, into soil, into EACs and low carbon materials and fuels. It's because that's the progression that the market is driving us toward. speaker-1: I find it really interesting because especially that thinking around, need to basically measure the whole net zero world. Whereas I mean, really running a carbon marketplace is like, think a lot of us and the competitors, they're looking more into these as different asset classes because they just need more ins into the companies, right? Because there's a lot of companies that either not participating yet in the CDR market. they say like, but in five years, we definitely will start. But if you have something that's for insetting or if you have stuff or if you have other EACs, especially also like SBTI flag, regenerative agriculture and so on, then we can talk now. I think whereas we always look from a where's the opportunity to drive decarbonization in companies forward, but also where we can remake money, so to say. That's how I always look at these. Can we drive it in companies and where is there maybe understanding of investing? especially regenerative agriculture see that a lot, but they say like, if we can make this an insetting and it can be reduction, then we can achieve some of the targets that we already have set, but CDR, we only have a target in 240. Maybe now we're in SPTI, maybe in 235, then now we have to start. but I actually don't have time to spend on that. So I find it really interesting from your perspective, obviously a different one, but also you're thinking about, yeah, if there's no demand then. speaker-0: then why would you do it? Is yeah, he I mean, you need to have demand. But I think you're making as I was listening to you described the role that you play and how you're thinking about how to shape things. I think we saw the world start, you know, back in twenty, I don't know, twenty eighteen, twenty nineteen, where it was like, we need to do carbon removal, we're gonna do standalone projects and everyone was really excited, a lot of money flowed in and then it was like, this is really hard. And then it was like, well, maybe we should do these things within existing systems that already exist, right? And we're seeing ones that bolt on to like wastewater treatment facilities be the ones that are actually delivering credits today where they're manipulating and making adjustments to existing infrastructure where you're not having to build that massive director capture facility that has a crazy cost of capital associated with it and upfront investment. What can we do today by modifying the system that we have? Like what can we do with landfill gas? What can we do with our organic waste? And asking those questions about existing practices means that you can find value. If you can obviously demonstrate additionality, which I think you can, because if it was gonna make you money and you were gonna do it, you'd already be doing it as a for-profit company. So we're actually not really talking about those kinds of changes. We're talking about providing some capital from credit financing. From priv private financing, perhaps from the voluntary carbon market, so that you can actually do industrial decarbonization, right? Because you wouldn't do it otherwise. Yeah. speaker-2: Back to the the prioritization point. maybe I sound like a a board member, maybe maybe not a board. Maybe your board members are telling you, keep keep expanding. We want the world. Yeah, speaker-0: Concerned partner. speaker-2: exactly. A concerned partner. that's exactly what I am. Yeah. How do I know you're not going to forget about me? That's probably my my chief concern here. But how how do you guys work together with the suppliers in this market to think about you talked about where is the demand, how are buyers thinking about this? I I just see an interesting possible interplay of like, okay, I'm a reforestation project developer. Right now I credit and make money based on selling a carbon removal credit in the woody biomass in my project. Obviously, I'm doing a lot of other things as well though. And so to what extent are you getting like a supplier push versus a buyer pull versus saying, Hey, forests ought to exist? Why don't we go out and figure out every possible way to help monetize? rewilding and reforesting nature or you know, what what's the definitely what's the process there? speaker-0: So we do get a lot of supplier push. And we have to think about it in terms of what is what is this gonna mean. And it's not so much a near-term consideration from my perspective. It's like where's the market going and how can isometric help project developers build value? Because at the end of the day, if a project developer is successful and builds more value, we're gonna issue more credits and our buyers are gonna be happy and we're gonna do well too. So like the success of isometric lies in the success of the projects. So we have a vested interest to figure out ways for you to maximize the monetization of your projects, right? And if we think about the nature-based solutions, one of the things we do from the protocol side of things is we write our protocols in modular bits where it's like we're gonna write a reforestation protocol. That is like the high-level framework that that kind of project fits in. But there's a multitude of carbon pools and a bunch of different interventions you can take in addition to just planting some trees. You can do enhanced rock weathering on the site. You can credit the soil carbon that's accumulating because of the replanting. You can do all kinds of things. And so what we do is we start with the basic framework, but then we start adding these other modules so that project developers have the optionality to fit a project to the geography and the local circumstances, but also be able to monetize their intervention because The more you're able to facilitate that for a project, the more likely they're going to be successful. And you're going to get across that gap of like your initial offtakes, your initial big deals. Well, now you have to like go out and deliver on that. But you're also probably, I'm assuming, planning your next things at the same time. So we have to be able to facilitate that because your economics need to get better to come down the cost curve. And then the buyers who've wanted to invest today are going to get those lower cost credits down the road. So I think. As we learn, as our protocols evolve, I think we're able to offer a more comprehensive product. And like when I think about Momback, it's more like a landscape approach. And it's just like we just talked about industrial side of things where I'm like, just decarbonize and do removal in all your processes. Well, we should be maximizing the carbon removal and the restoration that's possible per hectare of project area rather than doing one thing here and one thing over there. Like it's simpler, but we should be able to stack all of that together for a very comprehensive project that then you benefit, right? You're mobilizing and demobilizing for one spot rather than doing enhanced weathering here and planting here and forest protection there. Well, what if you did it all one place and like use the same people, the same resources? It's better for everyone, right? speaker-2: Is there a so the future is stacking is what I hear you saying. Like the the stacked stacked opportunities for projects. Is there like to what extent do you see biodiversity playing a role in nature based projects? Are you guys it feels like a lot of people have tried and for the most part failed? I mean, there are a number of startups that have now just gone completely up, under, trying to build a biodiversity framework. Where where does that rank in the future opportunity? speaker-0: It's definitely on the roadmap and it's a hot topic of conversation. But like the thing that you're pointing out is the complexity of that. And when I think about isometric, you know, we founded ourselves on we're gonna have a very highly reputable measurement based approach. And so if we think about biodiversity, plants are one thing. You can see them, you can count them. They don't run around. They're not flying about. You don't have to like see them, they're there. Whereas like if we're talking about biodiversity in other senses, it's really difficult. Like you can have proxies, but it's like really difficult to measure that thing, actually. And by that thing, I mean like the salamander or whatever we're looking to protect the habitat of. And so the measurement frameworks around that get quite difficult when from like an MRV perspective, that's expensive. That's like people on the ground. I'm not aware of LiDAR being able to help us yet with something like this. So I think we're a long way off from having something that is like comparable to counting carbon molecules. But at the same time, I think it's critical because reforestation's important for sure, but like we're doing that for the climate benefits. But I think more importantly, we're doing that to rewild and t to protect the landscape and the biodiversity that like our lives actually depend on, right? If we don't do that, like we can put direct air capture now and getting philosophical, but like We could just, you know, pump all the money into it, put direct air capture facilities on the roof of every building. But like, what do we have then? We don't have a forest, we don't have nature for our kids, right? And that's a foundational value. speaker-2: Yeah. No, it I mean, it's interesting because when we go and talk to the neighbors around our projects, they see the value from the projects in kind of a completely different lens from what we see them as, right? I mean, they're obviously not thinking about carbon removal, but they do say, we're seeing water flow out of your forest and into our project. And we're wondering, well, why is that? But also it's amazing. This is like my my crops are staying. wetter than they were previously because it seems like your forest is kind of acting like a sponge for us. And, you know, there are all these ways to as you're saying, like that that's the benefit that we're ultimately delivering. This thing called a carbon credit just happened to be one way to try to get that happening. So I think we have to figure out ways to kind of get more holistic and count count animals as well, probably. Probably to count animals. speaker-0: I think so. I mean, not to dwell on it too much, but you know, we're stuck with carbon credits and that's like the financing mechanism that we have. For better or for worse, that's the world we're we're living in. And so we have to find a reasonable way to get the finance from the carbon markets into projects like that. And, you know, it puts us and myself in that a really interesting spot as a registry because we want to issue credits that are beyond reproach. They have all of the data. Like you go to our website, you can see on the registry, Mombacks issued however many credits. And you can like click in and see the calculations and the backup to demonstrate yes and that in fact that's true. Here's all of the data if you want to go scrutinize it. But at the end of the day, we're doing that to justify the flow of finance to the project where like the benefits, yes, climate's important for sure, but you can't really just rely on the measurement. You have to go beyond that. and it's it's tough because you can get into this like pursuit of perfection when it comes to measurement. and we have to be deciding what's what we're comfortable with in terms of risk, right? speaker-1: I actually have been really impressed by the speed of isometric. mean, you worried or not, but we also work together through more indirect, right? With like deep sky, Lufthansa, there was some, some things and there's some other projects. So I've been really impressed and it feels kind of like, isometric is unstoppable, but let's look at, let's say in 10 years isometric has failed and you have to write a post-mortem. Like what is the one thing that could make. Isometric fail. Like what is the hardest thing you have to do. speaker-0: So I'm an optimist, so I don't often let myself think about these things. speaker-1: I'm as well, speaker-2: Germany. speaker-1: challenging question. speaker-0: No, no. And I I think it it's totally fair. And like what are we gonna fail at? And I mean, I kinda talked about this before and our success only relies on the success of the projects. Right. And so what we need is to move from this voluntary carbon market to a regulated market where we can stop having government just fund in fund innovation and philanthropy almost. No strings attached. We'll just do that. But like we actually have to get whole market to a point where things are mandatory and things are standardized. And if we can't have that happen, then there's no role for isometric, right? And so I think at the end of the day, it's going to be whether or not these projects fail or succeed. That's going to be the dictator of isometric's future. Cause like you say, we're fast. I think our priorities are in the right order. and and we're really excited because we're building on the technology wave that's happening right now. Like AI is an unbelievable thing when it comes to being a registry. speaker-1: I was about to ask, like, I just have a feeling, but I'm not a scientist. I'm an engineer, but not a scientist. I just feel on the science perspective that not everything, but a lot can be done by AI, right? So I just have a feeling that 90 % of the stuff that before we had scientists and so on, together with scientists setting up AI models, we could just automate and then the rest, maybe for the last 10%, we need scientists. But it's obviously changes the complete market, the complete setup of the market and also probably your competitors then maybe move in a different path. speaker-0: The AI question's quite interesting because we started, you know, at the beginning of this year, it was like everyone was talking, AI is gonna change everything. Nobody's in eighteen months, nobody who does like clerical work or like any kind of data entry is gonna even have a job. Well, I think we've now all played around with it enough that we understand the limitations and what the current models are capable of, right? And so we did a lot of that internally with our team. It was like, I'm sure we can get it to write us a protocol. No, we cannot. It'll invent your sources. Like it's it's completely not at that point yet. However, it is a tool that then increases the efficiency of the team immensely. so you're able to do research. You obviously have to question it and like tell it it's hallucinating. But what it can do is supercharge the science team that's writing our protocols. But what's more exciting, I'm I find with the registry scenario, with the environmental certification that we do. we don't have to have an individual human checking everything, but we can now check every data point very reliably with properly engineered prompts. which means that we're gaining confidence in the credits that we're issuing even at a faster pace as we even as we expand, because you can use a the agents to check is it complete, is it the right format? Is there a round air? Are the measure like is the units right? Like just basic stuff. And like that basic stuff takes a V V B so long and won't necessarily even catch it. And then you have a credit issuing error potentially because you know you can't just you can't check thousands of cells in a spreadsheet, but AI certainly can. And that's what it's really good at. And so by putting it on those things, you can then have the humans doing, like you say, the 10%, but When I talk to my science team about it, because we were talking about we're gonna get ANRA protocols, they're like, my god, what's my job? I'm like, No, no, no. Don't you worry. There's a role for you because AI cannot do the net new. It can't look at the set it can look at the set of facts and make some suggestions, but like at the end of the day, there's human judgment that's required. And I think about it in terms of like legal, like you can have case precedent, but there's always a new decision that's layered on top of history that has to be made by somebody who's probably not AI. So I think the same is can be said for science. speaker-1: I found it quite interesting, Dario from Anthropik, said, no, everyone has soon Albert Einstein and his fingertips. And then I was like, Hmm, maybe the reasoning power. But if you would give the model something to work with and they don't know what to do with it, then there will still not be Albert Einstein smart and say like, I know how to put this into a model. And then I checked the project, what is good and what is bad. How should they know? So I definitely don't think that's true. think everyone has reasoning power of Albert Einstein, but in the end, they still need to have the understanding of the market and so on and so forth. speaker-0: Hundred percent. And like today with AI, like AI only knows everything that we already know. It doesn't know what we don't know. speaker-1: And also the models they're not learning. Also speaker-2: See, we'll see. speaker-1: the models, the thing, the models are not learning. That's I find quite interesting. You can maybe give a model like context and say like, Hey, look, these are the requirements, but we as humans, learn from every interaction and we change our model internally. like, for instance, let's say fable from entropic. Fable always stays fable. With all the context it's getting, it always stays fable. Whereas humans, we constantly change our table for every learning, which don't just write down our learning somewhere and say like, okay, but always look at this. We actually changing our model and AI at this point. Yeah. speaker-2: Yeah, for now. You mentioned V V Bs. These are the validation and verification bodies for our for our friends on the pod who may not know. Yeah. what you know, the when you mentioned like the when our our pessimistic German friend asked you the question about what could fail, you know, I hear a lot of people talking about V V Bs and there's a lack of capacity in V V Bs, there aren't enough of them, they're slowing down projects. this is one of the choke points. How do you guys think about the role of the V V B, the AI ability to help them and and where they sit in that choke point. speaker-0: Yeah, I mean that's a really important thing to discuss. And it's something that we talk about a lot at Isometric, because especially in some pathways where there's like limp like new novel approaches, not a lot of like global expertise on these things, you have a limited pool of qualified third party verifiers to draw from. And so one of the things that's a big focus for us, because it could be a pain point, is that we need to develop those VDBs. We need to have new entrants coming in. We need to upskill them and facilitate that as best we can because our business relies on that. but what we are seeing is that we're able to automate quite a bit and we also build tools for the V V D so that they can focus on the part that matters, not just whether or not the package is complete, right? What's in the package that they're receiving to verify. So they are being like rather than something that would take months, now takes hours, which is better than what we had before. But like I think it's really important to be like completely transparent. The we cannot have an agent just doing the verification and the role of the third party verifier because, you know, whether the data is complete is one thing, whether or not it's correct and has been treated cor like appropriately because every project has very interesting and unique circumstances. And so unless you've seen that exact unless AI has seen that exact project one time before, It's not gonna be able to make the right decisions, so we always will need that V V B. speaker-1: Yeah. Well, speaker-2: I think on that note. speaker-1: that note, have last question. I know we have to wrap up, but there was just thinking like, what would be an amazing insight? I was like, you were on the corporate side before, right? It's a Shopify. Now you're basically on the refereeing side. like what is one thing that at Shopify you did and now from the refereeing perspective, you're like, why did we do this back then? speaker-0: Verifying my own credits that I was receiving because there was nobody who was doing it and there were no registries. I mean, and that's why I joined Asymmetric was like I should not be going, yeah, that's a good rule book. And okay, that's the data. You know, that was probably not the best thing to do. But at the time, you know, yeah, there's nothing else that needed to be built. but I think that opened my eyes, right? If we're gonna have a functioning market, we need a registry and a certification body that. can do that and and I realized that you know we can't have a Stacy sitting in all of these buyers' seats verifying my own credits. That's just not scalable. so that was probably one of the sillier things. but at the time what are you gonna do? speaker-2: Necessary. speaker-0: Necessary. Necessary eagle. Glad that's not the way it is anymore because you definitely need especially most unique and novel pathways, you definitely need access to a four hundred person science network like I have at Isometric to get all of your bespoke questions answered. So speaker-2: Well, we're very excited to see where you guys go from here, how you scale and how you continue looking out for your early friends who are you're who you're supporting and continue to be very focused on making sure they're successful. But thanks for coming on and and spending the time with us. speaker-0: Yeah, thanks for having me and looking forward to working together for a long time. speaker-1: Yeah, fantastic. Thanks a lot. If you've loved this episode, please, please, please hit the subscribe button. The more followers we have, the more guests we can get and the more coverage we will be able to provide. So thank you so much for your support.