Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Unsolved Murder of Teryl Orcutt | Florida Cold Case Mystery
Transcript
- Zalle: And in a twenty eighteen interview with First Coast News, she said, It hurts like hell. She has been dead twenty eight years. She was only alive twenty six years. It's a crying shame that your murder goes unsolved longer than you've been alive. And I couldn't cur. I completely agree with her. I think that's horrible. Nicholle: That is horrible. Cheryl has also been very clear about what she believes happened that night. She told News for Jax she wouldn't have pulled over for a lawman. I don't know why she pulled over or how she pulled over. All I can think is she was forced over and she got over it like that to keep from getting run over. Zalle: Why wouldn't she w pull over for a lawman? Is of course maybe on the dark road. ⁓ don't know. Nicholle: Yeah, maybe it's cause she was on that dark road. She was probably like she wouldn't pull over for anybody back there because she was scared. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Yeah, because where w because where it was at, yeah, yeah. And so Cheryl believes that the killer was local, which I feel like is truthful. It had to have been yeah. She said the area where Terrell's body was Southley Road, was unknown in nineteen ninety, like we said already. Nicholle: Yeah, to be. Yeah. Zalle: So you have to think about it. on. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. January twenty first, nineteen ninety. A red nineteen eighty nine Ford Thunderbird sits abandoned on the shoulder of County Road two hundred eighteen in Middleburg, Florida. The engine is still running, the headlights are on, her purse is inside, her keys are still in the ignition, but the woman driving that car, twenty six year old Terra Lynn Steel Warcut, is gone. Zalle: had to think who put her there. Someone who was familiar with the area, as Detective Schoonover put it. Schoenover is the name. Nicholle: That's a name. Cheryl also made a powerful promise. Her mother, Rosie Robinson, was consumed by grief after Terrell's death, of course. She hounded detectives for answers and kept Terrell's ashes in a small marble box near her unicorns and photographs. Zalle: For days her family searched for answers. Then exactly one week two young boys on three wheelers made a horrifying discovery in a wooded area less than four miles away. Nicholle: Terrell had been stabbed to death. She was found wearing only underwear, socks, and shoes, and more than thirty six years later nobody has ever been arrested. Zalle: Heartbreaking. I love her name by the way. I love that. Rosie Robinson. Nicholle: love alliteration. Zalle: But Rosie never got her answers, unfortunately. She died of brain cancer on august twenty first, nineteen ninety seven, never knowing who killed her daughter. Nicholle: Tonight we're talking about the life, disappearance, and unsolved murder of Terrell Orcut. That makes my heart hurt. Cheryl told News for Jax that before their mother died, she promised her she would never stop pushing for justice. She said my mother died of cancer before she got her answers, and I promised her while she was going through her treatment that I would push this and I am pushing it. Zalle: It makes mine hurt too. And we're digging into the theories, the possible psychology behind the killer, and why law enforcement believes someone in that community knows far more than they've ever admitted. Yeah, so ⁓ I just wanna let y'all know whoever's standing in Cheryl's way, she is a force to be reckoned with, okay? Because one, she has a sister who is gone and from what it seems like she loved her sister. So she's her sister's voice when she can't no longer has one. And then her mom, she promised on her deathbed to her like, I'm gonna make this happen for you. Yeah, she's not gonna ever give up. Yeah. Nicholle: ⁓ yeah. Zalle: back to Coffee and Crying with Mom. I'm Zay. Nicholle: Yes. And I'm Nicole, Mom. Grab your coffee. Mm. Zalle: And let's get into it. Nicholle: Okay, before we start, this case honestly scared me. Right. Right. And she lost her sister and doesn't know what happened and then her mom had cancer and died. my God. I feel I feel for her so much. Zalle: Same. It's the abandoned car part for me. Cases with cars left running always feel extremely ⁓ because ju it's because it suggests that something happened like super fast. And then her mom. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Yeah, that is Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: That's just heartbreaking. Yeah. I'm gonna boo boo on myself. Okay, hold on. Nope, I'm gonna hold it in and we're gonna get through this episode. Nicholle: Yeah. Exactly. Like she didn't plan to stop. She didn't plan to leave the car. Something interrupted her. Do you need to go boo boo's in? Zalle: And when asked what she would say to her sisters her sisters, Keller, Cheryl responded through tears. The only thing I want to know from that person is why. I want to know what you did. ⁓ I don't want to know what you did, how you did it, or anything. I wanna know why her. Mm. Nicholle: I don't. I don't. And family members describe Tarot as vibrant and full of life. Zalle: Yeah, and that's something that we always try to emphasize in true crime. I mean, victims are not just headlines, they had futures, families, routines, dreams, friends, people who cared about them, lives. And I don't know about everybody else, but for me there's always something terrifying about real world at night, especially before the cell phone. Nicholle: No. Can you imagine? Because you're isolated and if something happened, you couldn't just text someone your location. Mm. Yes. And Terrell loved fashion, makeup, and dancing. Her sister said she would not check the mail without putting her makeup on first. Zalle: Yeah, I remember those days. so she was a girly, girly, girl. Yeah. Yeah, she loved Christmas. I love Christmas. Okay. Her last one in nineteen eighty-nine was the historic snowfall in Northeast Florida. So that's awesome. That for her last Christmas she got to see snow. Cheryl remembers we had so much fun. We tied ropes to trash can lids and took everybody sledding. That was our last Christmas, the whole family was together. That's so sad. Nicholle: Are you that old? Zalle: And I am that old. What do you mean? what do you mean? Nicholle: She's a diva. Okay, go good. I feel like you had a phone about eight? Yeah. Yeah. Zalle: But at least like her last, you know, big holiday. They ha yeah, they have good memories. Nicholle: At least they had fun that last Christmas. Seemed like it was almost magical with the snow and all of that in Florida. Right. And her family has now spent decades without answers, and that is just unfair. All right, so one major theory is that Terrell may have known her killer. That's how you are. Zalle: Yeah, that's how old I am. Right. Don't do me. I'm old. Okay. ⁓ And then in Florida in the late eighties and early nineties, had a lot of like unsolved violent crimes happening around highways and wooded areas. So didn't help. Yeah. In Florida. Mm-hmm. Cheryl Turner has been very clear about this. she told First Coast Nicholle: It didn't and that makes this case even more chilling. Terra Lynn Steele Orcott was twenty years old in nineteen ninety ⁓ and she lived in Clay County, near Jacksonville, where we used to live. Where you were born. there doesn't appear to have been a prolonged struggle at the vehicle scene. Her purse was untouched and her money was still inside. Let me stop right here because this is where I want to say it. So how they found the car, it was the man who saw the car. He was driving to the store. He saw the car sitting there. He's like, That's weird. ⁓ he went to the store. When he came back from the store, the car was still there. So he pulled over and he's, you know, hello, looking for somebody. He didn't see anybody. So he goes in the car. Zalle: Right. Which I do not remember. Yeah, have no recognition at all. But her family members described her as outgoing, ambitious, andstylish Nicholle: She worked as a bank manager. Some sources say vice president. I heard she was about to get a promotion to be vice president. And she was just twenty six years old and was reportedly on track to become the first female president of her bank in the city. That's awesome. takes the keys out of the ignition, he takes the purse, closes the door, and he goes and calls the police. Then it takes an hour for the police to get there. In between that time, there all these people, like I said, had come because they see it's a small town at that time. They see the police, this car over there. So all these people are pulling up on along the side of the road behind her car. Zalle: Hm. Yeah, at a young age, that's awesome. anybody could have done anything. The person who killed her could have came back. Yeah. Nicholle: Yeah, and if there were tire tracks Right. If the tires if they had tire tracks, not to mention the gentleman who I don't feel it didn't seem like he had anything at all to do with it. And you know, in nineteen ninety, how much did people know about forensic? How much could that they could do fingerprints and things like that, but the fact that he went in and touched everything. So we don't we don't know what if what information, what evidence was lost. Zalle: And according to her sister Cheryl Turner, she was not someone who would just disappear voluntarily. Which it doesn't seem like it if she was on track for a promotion. Nicholle: I know, and that's important because in many missing missing persons cases, especially back then, adults were sometimes initially treated as if they may have simply left. But her loved ones immediately knew something was wrong. Zalle: Into the car. Yeah, I turned the keys. Nicholle: Because it took the the cops an hour to get there and then it was two hours before the detective got there to s to he came in and ⁓ know, cut off the crime scene. ⁓ two hours that these people have been out there Zalle: Which is insane. You really can't even do anything. Nicholle: January twenty first, nineteen ninety, Terrell had been visiting her boyfriend in Jacksonville. Zalle: Right. And then at some point around like five AM in the morning, left to drive home ⁓ to Middleburg. First of all, why wouldn't the cops have done that as soon as they got on site? Because once you find a car and there's nobody in there, there's no owner, you can't find anything, that's ⁓ that should automatically become a crime scene. You have no answers. So it's at least a crime scene until we can figure out if it was a damn crime. Yeah, that is insane. Nicholle: I don't know what they were thinking. Mm-hmm. But she never made it. Zalle: No, no. Later though, her red Ford Thunderbird was found abandoned along County Road two eighteen in Middleburg. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. That it didn't make sense. And even even if you think, even if it was the first cop, it took him an hour to get there. And whatever these people were doing before he got there, this caused damage. You know, we don't know what was there. Somebody had to pull off with her to get her out of the car. Somebody's car had to be sitting there for her to pull over. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: the case becomes incredibly eerie. The was running, her headlights were on, her purse was left inside the car, her keys were in the ignition, and her prescription eyeglasses, which she always wore, were found about 50 feet from the vehicle. And let me say something about those glasses being found by the vehicle. Because her sister said that. Zalle: Yeah. Right. So I mean, but also what if more of her stuff was over there? You know what I'm saying? And people are like, ⁓ what's this? And they just took shit, you know, and maybe that could be a reason why somebody didn't speak up because they took shit from the crime scene and now they're not trying to get involved. Or the person who actually committed the crime could have easily came back in the midst of all of this shit and acted like, ⁓ well, what's we want we and clean shit up. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Her and other people from cause it's a pr it was a pretty small town back then had all come there when they saw the cops in the car over there. And so everybody was looking around. We'll talk about the crime scene later but everybody looking around. Nobody found these glasses. ⁓ Everybody so this boyfriend walked up. ⁓ family had not met him yet. he walked up and then, you know, talked to them or whatever. Everybody left. Yeah. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Nicholle: What think about the boyfriend who magically found these glasses that nobody else saw. So at first I was like, Well, he just knew where they were. But now I'm like, if everybody was pulling up, yeah, we don't know if he if he picked them up while he was there or maybe they did get moved and you know, with all these people out there not not knowing what it was because the glasses were broken, I believe. Zalle: All of these people. And then we searched and the cops. Nicholle: And then he came back saying he found the glasses out there by her car. Zalle: Yeah. And then the fact that the the money was still inside her purse, all of that stuff. I'm happy I mean the guy took the purse to keep yeah to keep it safe, whatever. His intentions were good. Yeah, but he didn't he don't have that that bad yeah. Yeah. But that in itself makes me agree with the sister because if it wasn't personal and it was just like a robbery or somebody doing some shit, the the money or ⁓ the car itself. so I everybody is automatically like mm Nicholle: Dispensation. Yeah. We were just out there. We were just out there looking at Yeah. Yeah. He I I know that his in I feel like his intentions were good. It just it didn't help the case. Yeah. Zalle: Yeah, that's weird. That's suspicious. Yeah, yeah. I don't know. And then we don't know you? Mm. Right. I'm sure that immediately raised all of the questions. Okay. Nicholle: Right. Right. Uh-huh. ⁓ her sister in that documentary, one of the documentaries I watched, she don't trust nobody and everybody did it. And I don't blame her after thirty something years. Yeah. They would have at least taken her purse. Yeah. Like you were saying, get in the car and take the car and then do what you want to do with her. Why pull her? It had to be about terror. Zalle: ⁓ yeah. I'm sure first questions had to have been did somebody force her out of the car? ⁓ Did she for somebody that she trusted? Was somebody in the middle of the road? Was she flagged down? Or was there some kind of like roadside emergency set up so that people would stop? You know, so all of that to be left the part Yeah. Yeah. It had to have been something about her. Yeah. And so I mean Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: I feel like all of that can suggest that the victim probably initially felt safe enough to approach someone voluntarily ⁓ or ⁓ that the offender was able to the quickly. And it just ⁓ really, really, really makes me feel like ⁓ A it was somebody impersonating a cop or was a police officer. That is the only things that made because Nicholle: Mm, because people generally do not leave a running vehicle voluntarily in the middle of nowhere. Zalle: No, I've never heard of that ever, ever. And then another critical tidbit was that the route that she was taking where her car was found was not her normal route home. It was an alternate route, which is another thing, suspicious. Nicholle: They had to. Mm-hmm. And so then but I keep coming back to the boyfriend. And I don't know why. It's just it was just those little things. Like her family hadn't met him. ⁓ and then because and the sister was saying it's not that they hadn't tried, like for holidays and stuff, they would invite him, but like he wasn't from that town. So like or that he wasn't from Florida, I don't think. So he would be going back to see his family. So none of the family had met him. Mm, that's right. At four or five o'clock in the morning when it's dark, yes. So according to her sister Cheryl, Terrell typically took I two ninety five to a hundred and third Zalle: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Nicholle: That's right. According to her sister Cheryl, Terrell typically took I two ninety five to one hundred and third street, then south on County Road two seventeen. She usually avoided dark roads. They said she was scared to drive in the dark and she had another option. And then he just comes up with these glasses that nobody else was able to find. Zalle: You kinda answered the question about why she avoided dark roads. No, it didn't. ⁓ okay. You said cause she was scared of dark. Okay. Well, I'm scared of the dark. So that makes sense to me because I hate to drive down dark roads. Plus plus my beautiful mother over here used to force me to watch movies that I was terrified of. And Jeepers Creepers happened to be one of them. And I am 30 years old. Nicholle: No, i you you don't know why she avoided Dark Road Jet. It's just that she avoided them. Yeah, no. There's a reason. ⁓ yes you do. And I mean it is also possible that she stopped to help someone or respond to someone signaling her. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. That I mean that is possible. And that she would not have needed her purse or to turn the truck off to do that. Or the car off. So I agree. I mean and then also if the offender knew her routines or her route home, it could explain the timing and location, except again, that wasn't her normal route. So I mean that also doesn't make sense either. Another theory. Okay, and I am still scared of driving on dark roads, especially if you got like the little sun route. Because baby he not about to come snatch me up out my car over here where ain't no street lights at. Okay. Now that might be my reasoning why I'm scared of dark roads, but what was her reasoning why she avoided the dark roads? 'Cause maybe it's more sensible than Jeep Scrapers. Nicholle: Mm Right. Mm-hmm. Not that Jeepers proper no thank you. Then that you had to watch scary movies with your mom. Yeah. Well, it was because years earlier she had experienced something traumatic. Her sister Cheryl was driving Terrell and their brother to a friend's house when a drugged woman jumped into the van holding a knife. Zalle: Yeah. that this was a predator searching for vulnerable victims along isolated roads. Nicholle: Especially because isolated highways and rural roads have historically been hunting grounds for opportunistic offenders. Zalle: The problem for that though is that opportunistic offenders often leave less connection to the victim, making cases much harder to solve. But for me, it also doesn't like make sense because when when you see the car and where it is, what the hell could somebody else have done to have gotten her to pull over on the side of the road specifically like that? Nicholle: Tarot had been afraid of the dark and of stopping on isolated roads ever since. ⁓ Mm-hmm. Zalle: First of all, okay, let's just rewind. Where the hell were they at that this woman jumped into a van holding a knife? And secondly, was the door just opened? Nicholle: Right. ⁓ Zalle: Like she did not go far. It's not crooked. It's not all off. Like she it's neat. She pulled over neatly. So I don't get that. Nicholle: So the only thing that I'm thinking is if we put those two theories together. So maybe somebody was signaling for help or something. ⁓ could have been a woman, maybe. It could have been two people. And so she pulled over to help and she got out, and then somebody attacked her, you know, like a man attacked her. I'm I'm saying a man because like her clavicle was broken. I mean, not that women don't kill, it's just I mean these are questions. They are questions and not bad questions, but I don't have the answers to those questions. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: These are questions. They're I mean not bad questions. Because I feel like ⁓ yeah, I would have ⁓ some kind of trauma too if a crazy bitch on drugs jumped in the van with a knife and was like I w and I'm sure it had to have been on some like I don't know, I can't I have like ten different scenarios playing in my head on what possibly could have happened. Got her. Yeah. Nicholle: Ha ha ha. We don't know. We we don't know. Zalle: Okay, so we don't know. Yeah, that is insane. I would be traumatized too. But ⁓ so that makes her being on County Road two eighteen even more significant because she has this trauma, right? So something or someone had to have gotten her there or to go that route. Nicholle: It seems this is this is not an easy bone to break. So something traumatic happened. And so I mean it c unfortunately in this situation it could be different things because we just don't have enough evidence one way or the other, which makes it horrible. And in nineteen ninety, forensic technology was nowhere near what it is today. Zalle: We have to be strong. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. But the sexual element, the partial nudity, the possible assault points strongly towards a sexually motivated offender, not just a random opportunist. Which, yes, I do agree with because that it still blows me though, the shoes. I mean, it's not finding women dead in their underwear and bras and stuff like that, like not having clothes, that's not unnormal or like uncommon. But finding them And then there was a witness. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And they're bra in panties and their shoes are on. That's weird. Why is everything missing? But the shoe. Why why the shoes? Nicholle: Weird, right? Yes, there was a woman who lived very close to where the car was found, who reported something chilling to investigators. She told deputies she was awakened by a woman screaming, I didn't do anything, I didn't do anything. But that that is that's weird. So but investigators have consistently believed the body disposal sites suggests local famili familiarity and I have to agree with that. Zalle: ⁓ my goodness. What what what why didn't do anything? Yeah, I do. I mean, I feel like it's important psychologically, right? Because offenders usually choose locations when they feel like comfortable and unlikely to be interrupted or like you were saying earlier, caught. Nicholle: That is tet like I can feel it in my body right now. That is like terrifying. To think that she's out there on that dark road and that's what she's screaming. Somebody was out there with her. I'm sorry, we're early. Zalle: Yeah, you had to have been scared. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: So she had to have thought that she was being accused of something, was over and confronted. She was obviously wasn't doing this of her own free will, screaming I didn't do anything. ⁓ But could they have said to her that that was the response? You know what I'm saying? Like do you think that makes it feel like maybe it was somebody that was ⁓ trying A it could be ⁓ impersonating police officer, fake pulled toe over? Nicholle: Right. And a remote wooded dump site can indicate confidence, familiarity, that word is very hard to say, or a prior experience navigating that area. Because how would you know? Like how would you know to even if you stop someone, how would you know to go four miles or go down the road, turn off this little bitty road in the dark. Right. Zalle: Right. Right. Four miles this way. That's like a d that's like a driveway in the dark. Right. And then walk fifty feet into the tree line and just dump her. Nicholle: ⁓ Right. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Something like that. It's crazy. And then come fine go back to your vehicle. I mean, like all of this, it it does feel like it has to be somebody from that area. Zalle: You know, or was a cop. Or yeah or some another drugie was like, You took all my coke, give me all my coke, you know, yeah. Definitely. Definitely. ⁓ And then Captain Gain ⁓ and Cheryl both noted, South Lee Road was not a well known road. Like we keep saying it in the nineteen nineties. So you had to have known they said it was almost driveway like. ⁓ Nicholle: Something. Yeah. Zalle: I Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: Is Okay, And that detail became seed of a rumor that would haunt this case for decades. Authorities quickly launched an investigation. Right. And in so when I think of a rural road in at night, I don't picture street lights. I just picture if you have light if your headlights and the moon if there's moonlight. So it's very dark. But but this is perhaps the most chilling and specific theory. Zalle: Right, and according to reports, investigators believe foul play was likely involved almost immediately, which makes sense because one of the car was left on with nobody in it. No. The moon. Yeah. So it's very dark. Yeah. Nicholle: Right. Right, and then exactly one week later, on january twenty eighth, nineteen ninety, the worst fears of her family became reality. Her body was discovered in a wooded area off South Lee Drive, less than four miles from where her car had been found, and it was two teenage boys that found her body there. And they ran home and they told their parents and then the dad came back and that's who called the police. Zalle: Okay, so like I said, the way car was pulled or found was pulled close to the edge of the road, literally it's like she just dipped right off of it into the dirt. You you can see it in the earlier part. ⁓ Or you look. We'll put it here so you can see. Mm. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: That's crazy. So that's three people who had to see the body. Mm. Okay, but here's here's the thing though. Her body wasn't hidden. It was just dumped. Like it was just there. You could you they didn't have to like go looking for it. She was just out. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. Mm-hmm. Right. And detectives said she was found about fifty feet into the tree line, not covered, not buried, just left there. Like you said, dumped. Zalle: Right, but she pulled close to the edge of the roadway, her engine was still running, the headlights were on, all of that clearly mimics a traffic stop. Nicholle: It does, and the witness hearing I didn't do anything suggests Terrell believes she was being confronted by authority. Zalle: Yeah, which is insane 'cause that's not normally they people do that if they're in a hurry. People who like actively kill don't just typically just dump bodies, you know. So And then Captain Gaines' statement that blue lights and badges were easily obtainable during that time makes this theory frighteningly more plausible because what really were they running into? Yeah. Nicholle: Right. Or somebody who's not concerned about being found out. Zalle: That could be it too. Yeah. When she was found though she had suffered two stab wounds to the chest. Though some of the early reports said several stab wounds. So we just you know we're gonna go with two cause that was what we were saw mostly. Nicholle: It would be easy. Mm-hmm. It'd be very easy. And Gann also noted no one ever reported seeing flashing lights or hearing a siren the night Orcut was kidnapped, which supports the impersonation theory rather than a real officer. Mm-hmm. Bright. And she also had a broken clavicle on her left side. She was fighting. Zalle: Right and then remember Tara was afraid of dark road dark and I and sorry. Tara was afraid of the dark and avoided isolated roads. But if she saw flashing lights behind her, she might have felt compelled to stop, knowing that it was or assuming it was an officer, even without the siren. Mm. She was fighting. She was fighting. And then most disturbing, she was found wearing only her underwear, socks, and shoes. Her clothes were missing. How did you get her cloth like what was she it d ⁓ depending on what she was wearing? If it was like pants and stuff, her shoes her like did you take her clothes off over the shoes or did you put the shoes back on her? Like what ca that is just disturbing. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That it was a town. And most of us would be, we would feel like, okay, we need to pull over. If we saw a cop behind us. Right. That's crazy. And nothing that I looked at said what articles of clothing exactly were missing. They just said these were this is what she had on. This is all she had on. And because of decomposition, detectives couldn't say with certainty whether she had been sexually assaulted. But the state of her clothing strongly suggests a sexual motivation. Definitely. Zalle: Right. So if a cop got behind me and put lights on, I would pull over. Even if it wasn't for me to pull over, yeah, even if it wasn't for you to get to me. First of all, if you pull me over without any without a whoop whoop, I'm not getting over. Like I'm not you can't you're not walking up to my car. I'm sorry. If I don't hear that, then I know you're not a cop 'cause a cop gonna hit me with the whoop whoop at least. Nicholle: Yeah, that would be my natural reaction. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: Right. Zalle: Yeah, that's crazy. Nicholle: Yeah. And we know now that we sh I mean, of course she didn't have this option if she thought she was being pulled over by a cop on that dark road. But we kind of know now if you feel uncomfortable pulled to a light it, you know, go to the nearest police station or gas station. But she didn't really have that option out there. ⁓ we are not diagnosing anyone. This is behavioral analysis based on known offender patterns. ⁓ Zalle: Yeah, and then I think the location of where her body found became like super focused, right? Because it's in the middle. It's in the w woods, but it's right there on the like tree line. So investigators believe that the killer may have been familiar with the area because that's a oddly specific place to just dump a body. And it's not far. Yeah. Yeah. Right. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: Mm. Nicholle: And it's not far from where she was taken. Only four miles. And ⁓ on Southley Drive in nineteen ninety, it was described as little more than a rural driveway, virtually unknown. Someone had to know it was there. And over the years, the Clay County Sheriff's Office has repeatedly stated the case remains active. Zalle: Right, the attack itself appears highly personal and physical, hence the broken bone. Nicholle: Right. And stabbing is often considered more intimate form of violence compared to something more detached like shooting. Everything about stabbing is more sexual than other ways that you're killed. Zalle: Mm. Yeah, a logo. It's more So officials have also said that advances in forensic technology, including newer DNA testing, could potentially generate new leads, which we love forensic science over here. it definitely is a more personal thing. Like it takes a lot more energy and time and concentration to stab somebody. Right. And then like I said, the broken clavicle suggests force, restraint, or a violent struggle, which it could be any of ⁓ but if it was a violent struggle, ⁓ clearly it didn't happen at the car ⁓ in the car. Nicholle: Mm. ⁓ yeah. And you're right up close. We do, we do. And in so in twenty thirteen, Detective Katie Paget, then the lead investigator on the Cole case, told News Four Jax one thing about the car that stood out to us was that it was parked so close to the roadway. It was running when it was found. Her purse being in the passenger seat was just another thing that's not normal. And I just wanna point out ⁓ a little bit more detail. So ⁓ yeah, we'll cut that out. Mm-hmm. Right. Right. But we also have to consider the sexual element, the partial nudity, the possible sexual assault. Zalle: Behaviorally several possibilities stand out. Nicholle: We'll go on. It's later. This offender may have shown organized traits, isolated location, victim removed from the scene, and minimal immediate evidence at the car. Zalle: Okay, yeah, but that's even more weird because if somebody was taking you or something like that was happening, when they just normally people just push you over and get in the car. You know what I'm saying? So they could dispose of your body in the car. There's nothing left there and then they could come back and get their car. So like Yeah, that is so that is weird. But ⁓ Detective Pat Paget, that's how you said it? Nicholle: Okay. Zalle: I mean, but the body being dumped, not concealed at all, suggest either disorganization, panic, or simply not caring about discovery. And if he's local, here's a because it just makes me think about how many other people went missing or like how many other situations are like this in that area. You know, because if it is somebody impersonating a law enforcement officer, I don't feel like that's a one and done thing. Maybe the it may be the killing part. Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. Right. They could take the evidence away. I said pageant. Zalle: Page Detective Paget also noted that for him the car being parked close to the edge of the road led to some people assuming that a law enforcement officer had pulled her over, like I said, because that's the only thing I could think of for it to be pulled over. And then I didn't do anything. Yeah, and that's the only reason people normally because n everybody doesn't just turn their car off when they get pulled over. Some people just pull over and sit in the car. So she could have just Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That's true, yeah. That it is true. Zalle: W that was the first time. But impersonating an officer, you don't get comfortable like that where you can just pull somebody out of their car without having done that shit. Nicholle: Mm. With what she yelled out. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Right. And even if it was their first time or or their last time, we would even there would be a pattern of people reporting this. I didn't see anything about a pattern like that, you know, where they're saying, Well, there were instances of people, you know, somebody pro personating cops. Right. Zalle: pulled over and then he could've just yanked her or she could have just yanked him out of the guard like Nicholle: We don't know. Right. And and that rumor was fueled by what the witnesses what that witness heard. Patrick confirmed the witness who lived very close to where the car was found reported to them that she was awakened by a woman screaming, I didn't do I didn't do anything, I didn't do anything. So it it definitely makes it sound like I mean, I don't know, it has to be somebody that's after her if it's not a police officer. But it's not didn't seem like there's there w wasn't really any Zalle: Yeah. I mean, but think about it too. Think think about the other cases we covered where it was the police officers who were not giving information or, you know, corrupting cases and trying to keep their names clean. So if it Yeah. Nicholle: That's true. Mm-hmm. Right. But I'm just saying in the in the instance that it's an imper somebody impersonating a a cop, it would seem like Zalle: Right, but I'm saying even if it wasn't even if it is somebody impersonating a cop, real cops aren't gonna want to put that out there that there's somebody impersonating a cop. They're not gonna want you to know that, ⁓ we could easily and it's a pattern, it's happening multiple times. We don't want people to know that we out here letting somebody get away with impersonating us and we're not catching them. That make us look bad. Nicholle: talk about her being on any kind of drugs where maybe a drug dealer would be looking for. I mean she was about to be the VP of a bank. Although I probably know a few VPs in that banks who are on drugs, but probably, you know, I would just that's not the norm. Zalle: Right. Nicholle: I mean, I would just hope that they would want to say somebody is impersonating a cop so when there's a cop out there doing crazy stuff. Zalle: Right. But ⁓ but I don't know. I don't know because I feel like it's too clean. ⁓ you know what I'm saying? Like the car is po just there. It's not like no sign inside the car. It was a struggle or nothing like that that you could really tell so far, you know. Her glasses weren't found that far. So I feel like if it was somebody coming for her, it probably would have been more like more of a rough experience or like a messier crime scene, you know? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: I think the reason why they're not doing that either because they can't confirm or deny whether it is an actual cop or somebody impersonating a cop. So you can't cover that there's nothing to cover up. And then if it is now that it's extra, you're covering up knowing it's a police officer by just saying it's not this or it's not that. If you don't put that information out there, you don't bring it up, then you're necess not necessarily in the wrong Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. That's true. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I would almost think if somebody yeah, some drug dealer or something was after her, maybe she owed somebody money, I don't know, it would seem easier for those people to just kill her where she was and just leave. Zalle: Then it just the car being left. Nicholle: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: You know, so that and it keeps you from looking bad. Even if you do think it's a cop or somebody impersonating a cop. Yeah. The law enforcement is sticking out for me. That just makes the most sense. But Captain Ronnie Gann. Captain Ronnie Gann, who has worked this case extensively, addressed the road cop theory directly. He told News for Jack, Jack. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. But organized offenders often plan ahead and control victims quickly, but they also usually hide bod bodies better than this. Zalle: Yeah, so in this instance we're looking at a mixed profile, which believe it or not, doesn't it nowadays probably happens more often as people switch things up but during this time was not a huge thing. People normally just had a p one profile, this is their thing, you know. Nicholle: Jacks. It's Jacksonville. Zalle: Jax. Yeah. Mm, got you. He told news for Jax, but back in the nineteen nineties, the community perception was that it was law enforcement related based on how the vehicle was found on the side of the road. No one would stop and leave the engine running unless they were stopped by a law enforcement officer, which is what I said. So the fact that the captain felt the same way. Nicholle: Really? Yeah, and I think ⁓ I think that police officers back then wouldn't even know to look for it. If it is somebody with a mixed profile, they wouldn't know if they were thinking serial killer in nineteen ninety, then they they wouldn't have thought that they could do you know, that they switch up. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. Not they're not gonna think mixed profile. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Well, but he also said, In my heart, I don't believe it was a cop. And I don't want to believe it was any of the guys that were working that night. They're good men. They were great cops. I don't think they had murder in them. I can tell you that. And here's my issue with that. I don't know Detective Gann or anything. I just think that it's always hard for people to believe that people that they know can do horrible things. Zalle: Yeah, or it's possible it could be multiple offenders, one organized and one less organized. So the one who killed was the organized one, or you know, took her out of the car and then the one who got rid of the body was the less organized one. Yeah. Cases like this are often psychologically connected to control because I'm it just makes sense. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. That's possible. Zalle: Yeah, that's always the case. All of the time. All the time. Instead, he believes that someone may have impersonated a law enforcement officer, which I also said could be the case too. If it wasn't an actual cop, it could have just been somebody impersonating a cop because that's the only reason I can think for somebody to pull over and leave their car on. To me. So that's right. I didn't do anything. Right. Nicholle: But they do all the time. Mm-hmm. Yeah. The offender may have experienced gratification from overpowering and isolating a victim. Zalle: I mean, especially if the attack was involving surprise or force forced movement from one location to another and then the sexual degratification. No, I didn't say that right. Sexual degradation. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah, it could be. Mm-hmm. And scream, I didn't do anything. Zalle: Right. And he also said that back during that period it was very easy to get your hands on a blue light, which was what they were using, just slap that baby on the hood or, you know, out the window. And then it was also pretty simple to get your hands on a badge. So and then if I'm not mistaken, during this time it was another case completely unrelated, but somewhere in New York where they had found ⁓ these like bag full of it was like Nicholle: So the stabbing itself, it's close, personal, and violent. And this suggests rage or need to dominate. Yeah. Yeah. Blue blue. Zalle: And that's why it brings us back to the sisters saying it's personal. ⁓ it it definitely gives like they were specifically out for tarot. Maybe a crazy ass ex boyfriend or something. Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. That's why I keep going back to this boyfriend. ⁓ geographic profiling. Hold on. Because I say that because who else knew she was going to be on that road? I don't know that she told him necessarily, but that's the way, that's not the way she normally goes. So something like her sister keeps saying must have made her take that way. And that's the last person that she was with. Now I'm not saying it was him. That's just what I'm thinking. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Police officer uniforms, the fire department, like fake like uniforms, but they looked super real and somebody had just dumped them. They were like put them on the side of the road for trash and it got like bust open. They noticed there was a whole bunch of NYC officer Yeah. So like you know what I'm saying? That was around the same time. So it I could see where it was easy. So the impersonation thing definitely seems more plausible. Crying. Nicholle: Yeah. ⁓ wow. Zalle: Right. Nicholle: Police arms. Yeah. Zalle: It just the shoe fits. Yeah. Nicholle: Yeah, and then geographic profiling is also interesting here because the suspect may have lived nearby, worked, hunted, or routinely traveled those roads. Yeah. It could be, yeah. And Gam believes there may be and Gam believes there may have been more than one offender. He stated, I believe that it was more than one person based on it would be very difficult to pull that person over, get them into a vehicle and leave with them by yourself. With them putting up a fight, I believe it was more than one person. Zalle: I mean, yeah, because most offenders operate within areas that they know. You know, like there's a well known area. I'm from here. And even if I'm not from here, I work out here, I'm here all the time, I know the lay of the land. Yeah. Mm hmm. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Something a place you're comfortable with, you know the routines kinda. And as Detective Schoenover said, you have to think. Who knew to put her there? Someone who was familiar with this area, like they keep saying. And cases like Tyrell's matter because unsolved murders leave families trapped in permanent uncertainty. Zalle: Well, the way it sounds like when it talks about the stab wound and the broken clouds, it sounded like she was fighting. So I mean, I can understand that, but if it was one big ass man, then Nicholle: Mm-hmm. I mean, yeah, because if you think about her clavicle was broken, her left clavicle. She stopped on the side of the road. I don't a thunder we used to have a Thunderbird. It's a huge car. Especially the old ones. They're big. And so the window is down. If there's a big guy and she starts screaming and he just yanks her out of that window, then that could have I mean if you if you move that fast and hurt somebody that seriously, they're even though they're fighting. Zalle: And coat cases are not dead cases. We just the police are struggling or don't have enough information to cover them. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. And DNA technology has solved murders decades later. Zalle: Yeah, and sometimes that's all it takes is one person finally deciding to talk. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. And Detective Page said it best, someone back there in nineteen ninety, you commit a murder, you don't keep it quiet. You s you tell somebody, somebody knows. All these years later, the family going through this, it is going to take someone stepping up and making that phone call. Zalle: Yanks are out the car, yeah. Nicholle: It's less impactful because the Zalle: And what if she still had her seatbelt on? And that's that that's that size. So they could have tried to yank her out of the car with the seatbelt on and that broke. You know what I'm saying? So I mean, either way, it it it lines up. It lines up. But in more recent coverage, though, investigators expressed hope that someone who was afraid to speak decades ago might finally come forward, which hopefully somebody is brave, like the Nicholle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Cheryl Turner's fear is that whoever did this has done it before or will do it again. She said he's done it before because you can't go 23 years unless you're a devil without doing it. My that's my biggest fear is that he's killed somebody else. And I mean, yeah, if you're out here killing one person, it is tip statistically. You know, once you kill somebody, you keep doing it, just Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Right, right. Zalle: the one woman who spoke up and said she was woken up out of her sleep. 'Cause I'm sure they had to you're that close to hear her screaming. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. I mean it yeah, it's there are so many possibilities, but thirty six years later, Terrell Tyrell Right, right. Zalle: So Nicholle: And when you don't know what happened to her and she's gone, especially at that time, she's just gone. They they haven't even found her yet. And honestly, that's common in older cases. Relationships change, loyalties change, fear changes, people die off, they go to jail, you know. Zalle: Yeah. Terror. Nicholle: Can't say it. thirty six years later, Terrell Orcut's murder remains unsolved, but her family has never stopped pushing for answers. Zalle: Mm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Exactly. People who stayed silent in nineteen ninety may not stay silent forever. Hopefully somebody comes forward and they say something knowing that, you know, we need this information and it's been thirty years, thirty plus years. Yeah. So And honestly, someone out there may still know exactly what happened on that road in January nineteen ninety. Nicholle: Hopefully. Mm-hmm. Whether it was a secret kept out of fear, loyalty, or guilt. Zalle: But secrets like that rarely stay buried forever. Nicholle: Just about. Mm-hmm. And one of the strongest voices keeping this case alive has been Terrell's sister, Cheryl Turner. She was in all of the information videos, things I read. She's really fighting to find her who killed her sister. So if you en Mm, I don't wanna go there. So if you know anything about this, please get in contact. Make sure you say something. This family has waited almost three decades to figure out who did this to their loved one. Zalle: Yeah, she definitely has spoken publicly about wanting justice for her sister and making sure that her sister, Tarot, is remembered as a person and not just as a code case file, which tends to be a the case a lot of the times with family dealing with situations like this. Nicholle: But if you enjoyed this episode of Coffee and Crime with Mom, make sure you follow us wherever you listen to podcasts. Zalle: And come join the Crime Fam on social media for polls, discussions, episode updates, and behind the scene content. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah, when there's no there's nothing in this case, unless it's a cop, it seems like whoever did this, there was just nothing for the police to go off of. From what I see. It's like there was just not enough. There it seemed like there was gonna be a lot when you talk about finding that car with everything in it. She has to be somewhere near here and then they find her, you would think there would be some type of evidence, but it looks like they either couldn't test things or there was nothing there. So And again, if you have any information about the murder of Terrell Orcutt, please contact the Clay County Sheriff's Office I'll call First Coast Crime Stoppers to remain anonymous. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: It just makes it harder for them to find that person, but it's also horrible for the family. ⁓ And in twenty thirteen interview with News for Jax, Cheryl said through tears, it's almost twenty four years and I still cry over it. Zalle: We'll see you next time. Nicholle: And until then, Zalle: ⁓ huh. Nicholle: safe and curious. Zalle: Stay safe and stay curious.