Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Fringey Minis - Memeing passed 1.5
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, Chelsea, this week I have what could be not necessarily a bad news article, probably
- 0:06a bad news article, but more of a fun bad news article.
- 0:09I'm saying that because I've only read the headline so far, but it seems like a fun
- 0:13bad news kind of article.
- 0:14I always love just vague feelings before we actually read anything about the article.
- 0:19I really need this to be a category of fun bad news just because it'll make my categorizing
- 0:24more than just bad news.
- 0:26You really do need something other than just plain bad news.
- 0:29Bad news you didn't know about.
- 0:31Anyhow, there's a ton in that category.
- 0:34What I have here is it comes from The Guardian.
- 0:36It was published very recently, Friday, August 9th, by Helena Horton.
- 0:41Article title, excess memes and reply all emails are bad for climate researchers warn.
- 0:46Glad to know that about the people who are always replying all day everybody at my work
- 0:50and personally, hate it when people do that.
- 0:52Yeah, I think you can reply all to that.
- 0:54Don't you know you're ruining the planet or something along the lines now.
- 0:57Let's see if that's true or not.
- 0:58I'm gonna send this vertical.
- 1:00When I Can Has Cheeseburger became one of the first internet memes to blow our mind,
- 1:04it's unlikely that anyone worried about how much energy it would use up.
- 1:07But research has now found that the vast majority of data stored in the cloud is quote dark
- 1:12data unquote, meaning it is used once then never visited again.
- 1:17That means that all the memes and jokes and films that we love to share with friends and
- 1:21family from all your base are belong to us through Ryan Gosling saying, hey girl to
- 1:26the Tim Waltz with a piglet are out there somewhere sitting in a data center using up
- 1:31energy.
- 1:32And by 2030 the national grid anticipates that data centers will account for just under
- 1:356% of the UK's total electricity consumption.
- 1:39So tackling junk data is an important part of tackling the climate crisis.
- 1:42Ian Hodgk, a professor of strategy at Lowborough University, never heard of that.
- 1:48Louborough?
- 1:49Lowborough, I don't know.
- 1:50A British university has been studying the climate impact of dark data and how it can
- 1:55be reduced.
- 1:56Here's a quote from him.
- 1:57I really started a couple of years ago, it was about trying to understand the negative
- 2:01environmental impact that digital data might have.
- 2:03And at the top of it might be quite an easy question to answer, but it turns out actually
- 2:07it's a whole lot more complex.
- 2:09But absolutely data does have a negative environmental impact.
- 2:13He discovered that 68% of data used by companies is never used again and estimates that the
- 2:19personal data tells the same story.
- 2:21Hodgkinson again, if we think about individuals and society more broadly, what we found is
- 2:25that many still assume that data is carbon neutral.
- 2:28But every piece of data, whether it be an image, whether it be an Instagram post, whatever
- 2:33it is, there's a carbon footprint attached to it.
- 2:35So when we're storing things in the cloud, we think about the white fluffy cloud, but
- 2:39the reality is that these are data centers which are incredibly hot, incredibly noisy,
- 2:43and they consume a large amount of energy.
- 2:45End of quote.
- 2:46One funny meme isn't going to destroy the planet, of course, but the millions stored
- 2:50unused in people's camera rolls have an impact, he explained.
- 2:54Quote, the one picture isn't going to make a drastic impact.
- 2:57But of course, if you maybe go into your own phone and you look at all the legacy pictures
- 3:02that you have, cumulatively, that creates quite an impression in terms of energy consumption.
- 3:07End quote.
- 3:08Cloud operators and tech companies have a financial incentive to stop people from deleting junk
- 3:12data as the more data that is stored, the more people pay to use the systems.
- 3:16Again Hodgkinson quote, we're paying for that storage.
- 3:19Now effectively you're paying for something which you're not ever going to use again
- 3:23because you're not even aware it exists.
- 3:25And when we think about the significant costs it has for financial terms, but also the environment
- 3:29to the bigger picture, we're falling short of the required trajectory to meet that zero
- 3:34by 2050.
- 3:36There may be other big contributors to greenhouse gas emissions which maybe haven't been picked
- 3:41up.
- 3:42And we could certainly argue that data is one of those and it will grow and get bigger.
- 3:46Particularly think about that huge explosion, but also we know through forecast that in
- 3:50the next year or two, if we take all the renewable energy in the world, that wouldn't be enough
- 3:54to accommodate the amount of energy data requires.
- 3:56So that's quite a scary thought.
- 3:58End quote.
- 3:59One thing people can do to stop the data juggernaut, he said, is to send fewer pointless emails.
- 4:04Quote.
- 4:05One figure that often does the rounds is that for every standard email that equates to about
- 4:10four grams of carbon.
- 4:11If we then think about the amount of what we mainly call legacy data that we hold, so
- 4:16if we think about all the digital photos that we have for instance, there will be a
- 4:20cumulative impact.
- 4:22And of course we have the dreaded reply all button, which Hawkins can also add quote,
- 4:26if we think that our email or the data we produce is carbon neutral, we will never ask
- 4:31the question of ourselves in terms of if I do X, what's the consequence.
- 4:35And so when we think about the likes of different analytics, we think about things like chat
- 4:40GVT for instance.
- 4:42Again, for many individuals, they believe that to be carbon neutral, but it isn't.
- 4:45So asking yourselves those questions, which we've never really asked before within the
- 4:49organizations and individuals can make such a big difference for behavioral change.
- 4:54That's the end of the story.
- 4:55My first question, I don't get the reply all because I just generally delete those.
- 4:59Yeah, I get that.
- 5:00I get why they go out sometimes because it can be important information.
- 5:04A lot of them are just bureaucracy for the sake of bureaucracy in my mind and don't
- 5:09actually put out that much information.
- 5:12Most reply all said I've ever seen shouldn't be a reply all.
- 5:15Although I've always heard in response to a meeting, couldn't this be an email?
- 5:19I wonder what the difference in energy output would be for a zoom call versus a reply all
- 5:25email.
- 5:26I think we're thinking of it differently.
- 5:28Usually the reply all.
- 5:29Oh, no, I, I, I understand what you're saying.
- 5:32It's completely pointless things where it's an email that went out and somebody said like,
- 5:35what does this mean or something?
- 5:37They accidentally hit reply all.
- 5:39Yes.
- 5:40Instead of a reply.
- 5:41Yeah.
- 5:42My second, it's more of an observation than a question.
- 5:44I was at first thinking that they were going in just like the internet itself, just like
- 5:50in the creation of means and the floating out there and like the internet ether was having
- 5:56some sort of carbon footprint, but it's the storage of all the photos that I back up,
- 6:01but never look at again.
- 6:03Well, Chelsea, this is the weird thing we need to conceptualize.
- 6:07There is no internet per se.
- 6:10What you're accessing is data storage more or less.
- 6:13You're going into somebody's storage data.
- 6:16Like when we're talking about somebody's paying for those websites to be up, they're
- 6:19being stored on the server somewhere.
- 6:21So you're going into that server just through an ethernet cable more or less.
- 6:24So is my MySpace profile still out there having a carbon footprint?
- 6:28I highly doubt it at this point, but I can't confirm that for sure.
- 6:32Okay.
- 6:33Back to the reply all.
- 6:34How was our reply all having a bad carbon footprint?
- 6:37Where is it being stored somewhere?
- 6:39Yeah.
- 6:40Everything gets stored.
- 6:41If you go back and look at it, then it's being stored somewhere.
- 6:44And if it's not being stored by you, it might be being backed up by your company or whatever
- 6:49server you're paying for somewhere within.
- 6:51Part of this is the profit incentive that you're using up data or storage space to do
- 6:57so so they can charge you more as you're going to use more spaces that keeps accumulating.
- 7:01Right.
- 7:02Okay.
- 7:03So even because I just immediately believed it.
- 7:05See, I thought they're talking about you shouldn't reply all with like a super funny
- 7:08meme that you saw and then it makes it worse because then everybody else stores it because
- 7:13they think it's so funny.
- 7:14It's not even that.
- 7:15You don't know how many people don't delete in that reply all.
- 7:19Even then, even if they do delete, you don't know what that server's policy is on retaining
- 7:24deleted information.
- 7:25So I need to add something to my signature that says, please delete this email and think
- 7:30about your carbon footprint.
- 7:32Please put a magnet to your servers after reading this email.
- 7:35I think is actually what it should say.
- 7:37Okay.
- 7:38Girls Monday, firstly.
- 7:41I think that's all I have to add.
- 7:43I've never paid for it, but I know a ton of people who pay for like the Apple cloud for
- 7:47the extra space or the Google or Microsoft.
- 7:50It's paid for something similar.
- 7:51Yes.
- 7:52Yeah.
- 7:53They have an incentive for you to keep all that crap that you're never going to see
- 7:55again.
- 7:56Oh, I can tell you, but 100% sure.
- 7:58I'm not the same person that I am when I started using it and there's stuff that I'll
- 8:02never look at again in which they're in case I need it.
- 8:05But because it's a profit structure, they have an incentive never to fix that for you.
- 8:10I'm not going to do it.
- 8:11I don't want to look at that stuff.
- 8:13I find it hilarious because this reminds me of that whole idea of this is AI and this
- 8:18is cryptocurrency too.
- 8:20These are industries that don't seem to produce anything but pollution and will be the perfect
- 8:25bad guy in like a Captain Planet episode or the raccoons per se.
- 8:29Maybe that's what that like industry did in the raccoons because I can't remember for
- 8:33sure.
- 8:34I don't know guys, what were they up to?
- 8:35It was so ahead of its time.
- 8:37And it's perfect because out of all things that we don't know that are creating pollution,
- 8:43that are like things actually creating pollution, you would never think that it's something
- 8:47digital, like memes that we're paying for.
- 8:49No, and that's because we have such a weird like the cloud makes you think that it's not
- 8:53somewhere physically, but it is.
- 8:55Everything is somewhere physically.
- 8:56I would have never thought it was anywhere physical.
- 8:58I just want to bring up because I tried to touch on it earlier.
- 9:01There's kind of like a meme out there of if you're having a meeting, couldn't this have
- 9:04been an email?
- 9:05But I'm wondering of the carbon footprint of a meeting that's on Zoom versus an email.
- 9:11And if that's a difference, of course, if you're going to save and record that meeting,
- 9:14yes, probably worse still.
- 9:16Maybe just an in-person meeting or phone call.
- 9:18Maybe the meme will reverse back to couldn't this have been an in-person meeting?
- 9:22Save the planet.
- 9:23And yeah, maybe this makes you rethink life in some way.
- 9:26It probably won't.
- 9:27We're not people of change.
- 9:29We are people of speaking of weird things.
- 9:32We are.
- 9:33We are people of podcast.
- 9:35If you're going to do it, you got 48 hours because I don't expect you to remember this
- 9:39after you're blown away on Friday when you listen to that episode.
- 9:43Exactly that.
- 9:44Anyhow, bye.
- 9:45Thanks for watching this morning's animation, talk to my community and I look forward to