Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Is Compensation Regulation About to Drop & Classic Rewind Rating Credit Risk on Commercial Member Business Loans
Transcript
- 0:00, Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is mark Treichel with a, another episode of, with flying colors.
- 0:04I'm going to have a brief discussion here on a potential compensation
- 0:08regulation that may be coming out and emphasis on the word.
- 0:11May.
- 0:12A real short update on governance and pointing you towards some guidance out
- 0:17there that you might want to check.
- 0:18And then most of this episode is going to be a classic rewind
- 0:22episode from VIN Vieten of my team.
- 0:25For those who have listened.
- 0:27To this podcast for awhile.
- 0:29You remember that van wrote the commercial loan rule.
- 0:32And this is a podcast we did on rating credit risk on
- 0:35commercial member business loans.
- 0:37And we're seeing this being hit kind of hard in some instances, from our
- 0:41conversations with credit unions.
- 0:43But first before we get to that.
- 0:45I heard a rumor and I don't like to pay attention to rumors, but as Stefan
- 0:51Diggs, formerly of the Minnesota Vikings and formerly of the Buffalo
- 0:55bills, and now down with the Houston Texans, I believe once said there's.
- 0:59There's some level of truth to all rumors.
- 1:03Anyway.
- 1:03The rumor came from Twitter, also known as X or formerly known as Twitter.
- 1:09From a.
- 1:10Kind of capital account and they said a little mini scoop this evening.
- 1:14Was this from a couple of days ago, May 3rd.
- 1:17A little mini scoop this evening.
- 1:19OCC F H F a N N C way to announce proposal curbing wall street pay as soon as Monday.
- 1:26So the first question.
- 1:28You might have, is wall street pay that doesn't make sense.
- 1:31Well, here's why it might make sense.
- 1:33Back in 2020.
- 1:34NCUA and the other banking regulators proposed a compensation rule.
- 1:40That was required by Dodd-Frank and this rule was never finalized.
- 1:46And I'm guessing that there's rumor is that the Biden administration is pushing
- 1:52the banking regulators to get this out.
- 1:54It's long overdue from the.
- 1:57Concept of the Dodd-Frank act requiring it.
- 2:00It's not, I'm not saying it's long overdue saying it's needed.
- 2:03I'm saying that the act required it.
- 2:05So I believe they're dotting their I's crossing their T's and
- 2:07that's what this is referring to.
- 2:09So I believe there is some truth to it.
- 2:11Will it be Monday?
- 2:12I don't know.
- 2:12Will it be this week?
- 2:14I don't know, but it's something you should be watching for.
- 2:17The other item I wanted to mention is NCUA is hitting hard on governance.
- 2:22Again, based on conversations.
- 2:24I am having a, with many credit unions.
- 2:28And it seems like anytime anything is going wrong.
- 2:31In a credit union is a business plan.
- 2:34Is doubling down on governance and there, I wanted to point out that, but also
- 2:39wanted to point out that there is some.
- 2:41Proposed guidance from the FDA.
- 2:44Out there that our sister podcast we'll be doing.
- 2:47An episode on this proposed guidance from FDA, and I've discussed this, read this.
- 2:53This guidance is excellent guidance.
- 2:55Hopefully Hopefully, you'll give a listen to the other podcast and we
- 3:00will have a podcast highlighting it here in the coming weeks or months.
- 3:05Some really good Summaries of what you should have relative and what financial
- 3:10institutions need relative to governance.
- 3:11Now I will say in some instances, I think.
- 3:15Is using governance as the catchall.
- 3:18For interviews that they're seeing in credit unions, and
- 3:20sometimes they're raising it and it makes sense sometimes there.
- 3:24Raising it, it makes sense.
- 3:25And sometimes I think they just want to find from all of them.
- 3:28And puffing to blame and the governance card is the one day plate.
- 3:32In any event, good corporate governance, as better than I is very important.
- 3:36This FBIC guidance.
- 3:37Is good.
- 3:38And we'll have more on that in the future.
- 3:40All right, that's it for the intro here and now.
- 3:43Here comes our musical intro followed by then beaten on
- 3:48rating credit risk on commercial business member, business loans.
- 4:00Do you wanna maximize your success with NCUA?
- 4:03Join Mark Trico as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 4:07your exam with flying colors.
- 4:09The With Flying Colors Podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 4:12Exam Solutions by Mark Trico.
- 4:14If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions team and
- 4:18receive support to optimize your results with NCUA, so you save time and money,
- 4:23visit us@marktrico.com to find out more.
- 4:32Hey, this is Mark and we've got another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 4:36I'm thrilled to have Vin Vieten here with me this morning.
- 4:40Hey Vin, how are you today?
- 4:41I'm great, Mark.
- 4:42How are you doing?
- 4:43I'm doing good.
- 4:44Well, you've been on a couple other episodes with Flying Colors and Vin
- 4:47is a commercial lending guru, formerly of NCOA and other places, but Vin,
- 4:52could you kind of introduce yourself for those listeners who may not
- 4:55have listened to our previous chats?
- 4:58Sure.
- 4:59I was a commercial lender in New England for a good 30 years where I worked
- 5:04for, thanks to the nineties, there was a lot of changes in bank ownership.
- 5:08So I worked for a number of banks.
- 5:10And exposed to a number of good credit systems, including large regional banks.
- 5:15So that was very helpful in developing a knowledge for commercial lending.
- 5:19Then I had the opportunity to start two commercial loan
- 5:22departments and two community banks.
- 5:24So that was a lot of fun.
- 5:26I've got to work with a lot of small and medium sized businesses and learn
- 5:30the importance of Providing a good, valuable commercial lending service to
- 5:35those businesses and because of their importance in their local communities
- 5:40between the economic activity they create and also the employment they provide.
- 5:45And then I had an opportunity to go to work for 1 of my customers,
- 5:48a large ready mix concrete company.
- 5:50Those are the guys who deliver concrete to the job sites.
- 5:53He was located in 3 states, he had about 300 employees.
- 5:57So I got to get a feel for what it's like to be a borrower because
- 6:02I managed his banking relationships and leasing relationships.
- 6:05And that was again, what that taught me again is how important
- 6:09small business lending is as this, as I said, this business had 300
- 6:13people and he used to say, I have to feed 300 families every week.
- 6:17So it really does reinforce how important.
- 6:20And rewarding actually to provide commercial financing
- 6:24at the right way to a business.
- 6:27And then after that, I had an opportunity to go to work as a regulator.
- 6:31So I've now been a lender, a borrower, and now a regulator
- 6:34working for the NCOA, where I spent the last 11 years of my career.
- 6:38I retired in February of 2021.
- 6:42While there, I was able to take that experience as a lender.
- 6:46In good and bad times a borrower, but working for that ready concrete
- 6:50company and get involved with providing commercial lending the expertise
- 6:55to the agency and to credit unions.
- 6:57A couple of things I was involved with that I really enjoyed at N.
- 7:01C.
- 7:01U.
- 7:02A.
- 7:02was working on the taxi situation and helping to write guidance.
- 7:06And then ultimately, I think the most important contribution was the principal
- 7:11author on the rewrite of the part 723, the commercial ending regulation.
- 7:16So it was a lot of fun.
- 7:17I felt very fortunate to end my career having an influence actually nationwide
- 7:22helping credit unions who I have a strong affection for because of your purpose
- 7:28of serving members and making sure they get the best financial services.
- 7:33Very good.
- 7:33Yeah.
- 7:34And as you said, you were the principal author of NCUA's current
- 7:36commercial lending rule, which was more of a principal based rule.
- 7:40We've talked about different parts of that rule up until this point in time,
- 7:44global cash flow being one of them.
- 7:46But today's topic is going to be rating credit risk, right?
- 7:50Is that what we're talking about today, Ben?
- 7:52That's what we're talking about today, Mark.
- 7:53Rating credit risk.
- 7:54Rating credit risk.
- 7:55So going back to the regulation that you were the principal author of, why
- 8:00didn't make it a regulatory requirement to have a credit risk as part of
- 8:04policies and procedures at credit unions?
- 8:06It was interesting, Mark, because when we were writing the rule, we had had a
- 8:11conversation with our regional lending specialists to say, what do you think
- 8:15the percentage of credit unions are using a credit risk rating system?
- 8:19And they said, probably a little over 50%.
- 8:22Which reinforced that it's important that we discuss and make it a requirement
- 8:26to have a credit risk rating system.
- 8:28Rating credit risk is a standard practice accepted practice.
- 8:31In managing commercial loan risk, all the other regulators focus on
- 8:36it and that's not the reason to do it because other regulators do it.
- 8:39But since it is the accepted practice, and those of us who were
- 8:44involved with commercial lending in the past knew how important it was.
- 8:48In monitoring risk.
- 8:49Another reason why it made sense.
- 8:52Is what we had noticed is sometimes boards were not as informed as
- 8:57they should be at the level of risk in the commercial portfolio.
- 9:01So, that just reinforced why it was important that credit risk
- 9:06rating system be put in places as part of the new rewrite of 723.
- 9:12We required the board to be reasonably informed and a reasonably timely way
- 9:18of the level of risk in the commercial loan portfolio at the credit union.
- 9:22I don't think there's any better way and it is again, I'm going
- 9:26to keep saying accepted practice.
- 9:28It is the accepted practice in the commercial ending world.
- 9:31That you inform those responsible for the risk in the department of the level of
- 9:37risk through a credit risk rating system.
- 9:39So, it only made sense that we felt overall credit unions with over 50%.
- 9:46And that was an anecdotal survey.
- 9:48So, the science is there.
- 9:49Let's do it, but since over 50 percent had been using them, it probably was
- 9:54the right thing to do to make sure there was a common practice in the industry.
- 9:57So it made sense to make sure that all credit unions focused on that
- 10:04and that it would help the board fulfill its obligation to know the
- 10:09level of risk in the portfolio.
- 10:11So let's speak to what's in a good credit risk rating system.
- 10:17So we established the concept that you should rate it, right?
- 10:20You do an ABCDEFG, you do high, medium, low.
- 10:24Could you walk through how, what the reg requires and like what the options
- 10:28might be, because the regs are a little less prescriptive in some areas, but
- 10:32can you speak to what prescriptiveness there is relative to how to do this?
- 10:36As it relates to the regulation, I will, but I want to make 1 more point mark.
- 10:40If you don't mind to be effective, the risk rating system should be accurate at
- 10:46all times reason again, being reasonable.
- 10:48If something happens with a borrow and you don't hear about it for a few
- 10:51weeks, and there's no way you could have known that's fine, but each
- 10:55credit should be rated at inception.
- 10:59And then ongoing risk management through site visits, regular submission of
- 11:04financial information, annual review of the credit and 3rd party reviews.
- 11:09There should be additional confirmation of.
- 11:13The risk, and if the risk rating changes.
- 11:16As a result, then that should be reported to the board and I'll talk about this a
- 11:20little bit later in the discussion, but well applied accurate credit risk rating
- 11:25system really ensures that all your risk monitoring systems are in place.
- 11:30Because, as I just said.
- 11:32Initial underwriting has to be thorough and comprehensive.
- 11:35In order to be accurate, when you 1st sign a risk rating, and
- 11:38then again, that regular risk monitoring has to be in place.
- 11:42To ensure that the current rating is accurate.
- 11:45The ongoing risk monitoring.
- 11:46You reminded me of my early days at NCUA when I was an examiner,
- 11:50then a problem case officer.
- 11:52NCUA used to send people that they wanted to learn about how to review commercial
- 11:56loans to the School of Banking of the South at Louisiana State University.
- 12:01First time I had crawfish, we had a crawfish boil on Sunday, they
- 12:04flew in, you had the crawfish boil.
- 12:06Monday morning, you met a gentleman named Willie Stocks, S T A A T S, and
- 12:11he was a professor of commercial lending at the School of Banking of the South.
- 12:15I remember Willie up in the front of the class talking about when he
- 12:18was a commercial lender and he had to foreclose on a chicken farm.
- 12:22There were chicken running all over the place and they had to figure out how to
- 12:24keep the chickens healthy, how to feed the chickens, and he was contrasting that day.
- 12:29The difference between making a car loan, that you measure the risk on
- 12:33the front end, other than making sure that they have insurance.
- 12:36It's not a high maintenance type loan after you grant that loan.
- 12:39And he was contrasting that for the students the first day.
- 12:42That this is not one and done.
- 12:44It's not you approve it and you move on.
- 12:46And so as you're explaining that you're going to want to do the credit
- 12:49risk rating, you're going to want to understand it based on the financials.
- 12:52And maybe it's low risk at one point in time and stays that way,
- 12:55but it might transition to another.
- 12:57So I'll tell you a quick story.
- 12:58I can remember back in the nineties when the world was upside down and we
- 13:02were very actively monitoring risk on all accounts, I called one borrower.
- 13:07Let's say a Wednesday 1 week and had a conversation with him.
- 13:11Everything seemed fine.
- 13:12And then on Monday, when I was driving to work that time, I was the bank
- 13:15that was owned by a foreign concern.
- 13:17So nobody was comfortable that they had a job on my way to work on Monday.
- 13:22I noticed that store that he was a landlord of was empty.
- 13:26And, of course, I panicked.
- 13:28I just talked to him.
- 13:29I should have known this was happening.
- 13:31Well, anyway, I went screaming back to the office and that was before the days
- 13:35of texts and emails and everything else.
- 13:37And I left them a message and he called back a few days
- 13:40later and he said, don't worry.
- 13:42I told you I would pay you.
- 13:43Don't worry about it.
- 13:45But my tenant moved out.
- 13:46So.
- 13:47I felt better, but at the same time, I quickly went in and downgraded it that
- 13:53credit and put it on the watch list.
- 13:55So had I ignored that, then I wasn't responsibly monitoring the risk associated
- 14:00with that credit and we got paid in full and that's where character comes in.
- 14:05He knew he owed the money.
- 14:05He was going to pay it whether he had income or not.
- 14:07So from the property.
- 14:09So that's the sort of thing you need to recognize.
- 14:12And a good lender is out there visiting with their borrowers and a good lender.
- 14:16You just develop a sense over time.
- 14:18You can walk into a business and just feel something's not right.
- 14:22Especially I've always tell this story.
- 14:24If you go into a business at 11 o'clock and the individual says,
- 14:28Oh, everybody went for an early lunch because nothing's happening.
- 14:32Make sure you go back a week later at two in the afternoon to see
- 14:34if they're taking a late lunch.
- 14:36And if they're taking a late lunch, then it's time to have a conversation.
- 14:39That might impact where you have lunch and also your credit rating.
- 14:42I'll tell you what, that was the best source of new business
- 14:45on the way back from lunch.
- 14:46You're passing a customer or in this case, a member that was a banker at the time.
- 14:51Stop in and say, hi.
- 14:52You're going to find out a little bit about the business and also that's
- 14:56when somebody says, you know, I've been thinking about calling you.
- 14:58Well, great.
- 14:59Yeah, very good.
- 15:01So, back to the regulation and what it requires, what it doesn't request.
- 15:04Let's talk a little bit about what a credit risk rating system is, how
- 15:07you might set it up, what the reg requires, what options they might have.
- 15:11I just dumped about 6 questions on you, but feel free to tackle any
- 15:14of them in any particular order about credit risk rating system.
- 15:17This podcast isn't to give you everything you need to know about what a risk
- 15:20rating systems, but just conceptually talk about what you should be thinking
- 15:24about and where you can go for some help.
- 15:27But again, like we said, we wanted the credit unions to know their risk
- 15:31at all times and actually so that.
- 15:33When the examiner came in, and ultimately what we wanted was not examiners doing
- 15:39a credit review, which was happening, the examiners were reviewing credit as
- 15:43if as a credit review person, and that slowed down the examiners, they only got
- 15:48through a few credits, and they had then form opinion about the whole portfolio.
- 15:53And the quality of the portfolio based on that.
- 15:55So if they've pulled 2 or 3 credits that they felt was, were not well underwritten.
- 16:00Well, then the examiner applied that opinion to the rest of
- 16:05the portfolio, because that's the only information they had.
- 16:08So, ultimately, what this transition to requiring credit risk grading.
- 16:13Is to put the burden and aggressive way, but put the
- 16:17burden of knowing the credit risk.
- 16:19On the credit union and the board of the credit union, and as I said earlier, if
- 16:23you have a good credit rating system.
- 16:25Then you probably have all the other policies and procedures are
- 16:28probably in good shape and will support the credit risk rating.
- 16:31So that instead of reviewing credits.
- 16:35The examiner will come in and evaluate the accuracy of the credit risk rating system.
- 16:41So they're going to say, okay, this credit's rated, let's say a 3 and then
- 16:45they're going to read your policy.
- 16:46What makes up a 3.
- 16:47And then review your underwriting and risk monitoring to see if they agree or not.
- 16:53And there was an old rule of thumb that generally what the
- 16:56other regulators do is evaluate.
- 16:59Credit risk grades and, you know, you want to be less than 5 percent of those
- 17:04that are reviewed changing and that can be changed in either direction
- 17:07in an up direction of you've upgraded the credit or downgraded to credit.
- 17:12So clarify that you don't want a change of more than 5%.
- 17:16Yeah, they are.
- 17:17What?
- 17:17So how they looked at?
- 17:20Well, let me do it with a easy number because I can't do math
- 17:22on small numbers of 100 credits.
- 17:24You wouldn't want 5 of those credit ratings changed by the examiner,
- 17:28meaning changed by the examiner.
- 17:30Got the examiner saying, I disagree either because your rating system is odd.
- 17:37Or it says that you would downgrade in these scenarios and you did not.
- 17:41Right.
- 17:42And even up in often you hear, and I'm going off on a tangent a little bit,
- 17:46often you hear is, well, we're really conservative, so we don't upgrade.
- 17:49What we're talking about is we want accurate grades.
- 17:53They should be accurate and being conservative.
- 17:56It can indicate also that you're shortcutting it.
- 17:59It's easier just to keep it at a lower grade than do the work to upgrade it.
- 18:02You really need to make sure they're accurate because ultimately
- 18:05what you should be doing also is analytics on the migration and
- 18:09trends of your credit risk grades.
- 18:12In your portfolio, obviously, if they're all moving to a lower level, and we'll
- 18:15talk about that in a minute, then you want to address whatever is causing
- 18:19that in policies or even personnel.
- 18:22And if it's upgrading, well, the borrower should get the benefit of that.
- 18:26And also, so should you in your portfolio.
- 18:29I know you asked earlier about what should be in a credit risk rating system.
- 18:33I do suggest that everybody read the examiner's guide on credit
- 18:36risk ratings because that will give you a real good idea of what
- 18:40the expectations of the agency are regarding credit risk rating system.
- 18:45And often what you do see is a matrix.
- 18:48I'm from the old school.
- 18:49That I like to see definitions that make sense for each credit grade.
- 18:54So let's say you have an 8th grade system.
- 18:561 should be defined to have these characteristics of 234 and just go down.
- 19:01But what's really important is that.
- 19:05There's qualitative and quantitative evaluation and a matrix is
- 19:10very good for quantitative.
- 19:12That would be leveraged debt service coverage, that sort of thing.
- 19:15But the qualitative is how good is that management?
- 19:18Is there some competition coming in?
- 19:21That could impact this credit is that they just lose their top salesman who
- 19:25had been producing all the business.
- 19:26So I personally believe that the quantitative is the easy part.
- 19:31It's that qualitative.
- 19:32And that's where your skills as a lender come in.
- 19:34And so there should be.
- 19:36In defining these risk rates, some comment on the qualitative
- 19:41issues that should be considered.
- 19:44And so then if you use strictly a matrix to arrive at a rating,
- 19:49there's ways of using the qualitative process, certain risk management,
- 19:53your rate management, your rate market position, that sort of thing.
- 19:56But a lender should also have the flexibility to say, I know this rates as
- 20:02a 3, but I'm going to make it a 4 because of whatever the following reasons are.
- 20:05So it's sort of like a picture, paint the picture, then take a stand back
- 20:09and take a look at it and adjust it the way you think it should be.
- 20:12Just be able to support the reasons you may be downgrading it or upgrading
- 20:17it based on what a definition may be.
- 20:19So a top grade would be what?
- 20:21A top grade.
- 20:22Number one, usually it's cash secured.
- 20:23What would it be called?
- 20:24A risk rating one.
- 20:26Okay.
- 20:26That was spreading.
- 20:26What?
- 20:26And the general numbers are used, but you can use letters.
- 20:29You can some kind of ordinal system that progresses through the level of risk.
- 20:33And typically do you see one through what would be the worst?
- 20:38I think what you find for credit unions, seven to eight ratings.
- 20:43With 1 through 4 being past ratings, meaning good quality credits, but you
- 20:49want granularity even in your past grades so that if there's progression
- 20:55of downgrades, meaning all of a sudden a 2 is a 3 and you've got 3s moving to
- 20:584, you can pick up those trends earlier.
- 21:01So it's important to have granularity in the past grades.
- 21:05I used to think maybe you only really need 1, but I've changed my opinion on that.
- 21:11That progression is very important and with analytics available these days.
- 21:15It's even more important because you can really drill down on that
- 21:18and then that's the past grades and then there's the adversely rated.
- 21:22And generally what we suggest, because NCUA talks about what the
- 21:28system should have, it doesn't specifically say this is what you
- 21:32should do, or this, use this system.
- 21:35However, the adversely classified, those credits that are not strong, the
- 21:40best way, in my opinion, To manage that is follow the regulatory risk grades
- 21:46of substandard, doubtful and loss.
- 21:48I was wondering that relates back to when I looked at loans a long
- 21:51time ago, and the 1st commercial lending rule that went in place.
- 21:54Gosh, 87, 88.
- 21:56Right piggyback off what the bankers had created.
- 21:59Substantial losses.
- 22:01It's a proven system.
- 22:03There's plenty of support for it, which we'll talk about in a minute unless
- 22:06you can come up with a better one.
- 22:07And I don't think I've ever seen a better 1 because most
- 22:10credit unions use that standard.
- 22:12And although the, it's not stated clearly in the guidance that
- 22:16that's an acceptable way to do it.
- 22:18It does indicate that's a good way to go.
- 22:20So we've got 1 through 4 and we just did 6 through 8.
- 22:25And then is that 5?
- 22:26What is that?
- 22:27And although watch list is not technically risk grade, it
- 22:33generally falls in that 4 to 5 area.
- 22:35And what a watch list is, obviously, there's a, you've got a credit,
- 22:39something's happening with that credit or customer borrower.
- 22:43And where the rating could change or move most likely in an adverse direction
- 22:49and you just want to keep an eye on it.
- 22:51Generally, that's called the transition rating and always used to use.
- 22:55Something's going to happen within the next 6 months, but
- 22:57that's not carved in stone.
- 22:59So you've got your risk rating there.
- 23:00And when it slips into that category, is the credit union
- 23:04reevaluating it more frequently?
- 23:06You kind of like when your camel go goes from a two to a three, you're
- 23:08going to see NCOA every six months.
- 23:10When a camel code goes from a three to a four, you're going
- 23:12to see them every four months.
- 23:13Yeah.
- 23:14A borrower slips to a five.
- 23:15What does that mean relative to the level of effort that it's going to take
- 23:18for the credit union to watch that?
- 23:20Sure, and we're using 5 as an example in this discussion, right?
- 23:23Example only, not required.
- 23:25And the answer to that, Mark, is yes.
- 23:28You're going to be looking at it more often because
- 23:30you've identified some issue.
- 23:32Either they've lost a big customer, there's new competition in town.
- 23:36There's a list of things, but you want to see how the business responds.
- 23:41To whatever this issue may be, I was going to say threat, but that's a
- 23:44strong word, but something that may have an impact on their business.
- 23:49And yes, you'll probably visit them more often.
- 23:51And along with that, when there's a watch list, you should have a plan associated
- 23:55with how you are going to monitor it.
- 23:56So there should be a plan.
- 23:58How often are you going to collect financial information?
- 24:00How often are you going to visit the borrower?
- 24:02And what may cause it to be downgraded to a lower risk rate.
- 24:07Got it.
- 24:08So we talked about adverse credits relative to credit risk.
- 24:12What would you like to speak to next, Ben?
- 24:14I just wanted to go over a few real important things that the
- 24:18agency identifies as important to be involved with, but be part of
- 24:23the credit risk grading system.
- 24:25It should be dynamic.
- 24:26We've mentioned this already, but if there's a change in that credit in a
- 24:30reasonable amount of time, The, the lender needs to recognize that and what
- 24:38that reasonable amount of time is not an exact time, but considering the complexity
- 24:44of the credit, the risks of the credit that should determine how quickly you
- 24:47should be identifying those issues.
- 24:49So that's really, really important that.
- 24:53The response is, well, we haven't seen him in three months, so how would we know?
- 24:56That's really not a good answer.
- 24:58You should know your credits well enough to know who you have to
- 25:01see more often than three months, and then every three months.
- 25:04The other reason, and when we're writing the rule, it really hit us, being in the
- 25:09member service business, how important it is to know the level of risk.
- 25:14Because we're in business for that individual sitting across from the
- 25:18desk, meaning the borrower, the member borrower, commercial borrower.
- 25:22And if you have an accurate risk grade, it means that you're
- 25:25actively monitoring the account.
- 25:27And if you see a issue developing early that could impact the business,
- 25:33you're really providing a great service to that borrower to let them
- 25:36know we have some concerns here.
- 25:38And develop a relationship where you can say that telling somebody
- 25:42something negative about their business is really important.
- 25:45And I've said this before, but I'll say it again.
- 25:47I think the best service that a commercial lender provides.
- 25:52To their bar or at least once a year, they get a full financial
- 25:57review of their business for free.
- 26:00Well, they're paying an interest rate, but no direct charge of their business.
- 26:04And so develop that rapport with your bar or that they respect your opinion.
- 26:09And in a respectful way, discuss those things that could impact their business
- 26:13and are important to their business.
- 26:15So with the credit risk rating system, maintaining that and
- 26:17keeping it up to date and accurate.
- 26:20Again, you're visiting that borrower, you know, what's going on and you can
- 26:23share your financial expertise with them.
- 26:26If you see some trends that are of concern, the earlier you
- 26:30get them, the easier the fix.
- 26:32Sure.
- 26:32So trends in credit ratings.
- 26:35One of the things that NCOA.
- 26:38And credit unions always are wondering how NCUA is going to approach it.
- 26:41It relates to the allowance for loan loss and lease loss, the ALLL, and how that
- 26:46relates to the commercial loans and how that rates to the credit risk rating.
- 26:50Is there anything you can share with the listener relative to how these
- 26:54credit risk ratings can play into the ultimately to the financials
- 26:58and there's any best practices that you might suggest in that regard?
- 27:01This is not my strongest area, the accounting behind these things, but
- 27:05I know when I use a common sense of what's doubtful, what's substandard.
- 27:09So when you're setting those reserves and I'm not a CECL expert and how
- 27:12it'll apply there, obviously, if you're going to look at the buckets and see
- 27:16where the risks are and hopefully.
- 27:18Be very assigned proper amount of reserves for each of those buckets.
- 27:23And at the same time, as you get further into it, maybe you're
- 27:26going to be looking more for specific reserves to those credits.
- 27:30Doubtful and lost, you've identified all of those and obviously it's in
- 27:34order to set the proper reserve.
- 27:36You need to know the risk.
- 27:37How can you know the risk of the overall portfolio and individual credits,
- 27:40unless you have some way to rate it?
- 27:42Sure.
- 27:43Well, so going back to the contrast between seven column and the systems
- 27:47that were in place when you started in commercial ending and where it
- 27:51was at when you were last doing it and then helping it, and there's
- 27:56MIS systems out there, there's QCIS out there that can cull data, every
- 28:01element so that you can analyze those.
- 28:03Quantitative side of things, the ability to analyze that quantitative
- 28:07has gotten better, but still, as you said earlier, it comes down
- 28:10to the qualitative side of that.
- 28:12You need to understand what those numbers mean, but over your career,
- 28:16were there aha moments relative to wow, now that we can actually track this
- 28:20quantitative number, it makes things.
- 28:23Easier or better?
- 28:25That's a good question, Mark.
- 28:26And I probably won't answer it exactly as you asked it.
- 28:28Go for it.
- 28:29Yeah.
- 28:29Answer it in any way that makes sense to you.
- 28:31And because what we do notice, this is where commercial ending is different.
- 28:36When you get into analytics of a consumer portfolio, you got loan to value, you got
- 28:40credit scores and praise values, which you can adjust in the overall portfolio to
- 28:47find out what bucket they fit in for risk.
- 28:49But with commercial lending, and this is what I always liked about
- 28:52commercial lending, you actually know, not that's guessing at the
- 28:56risk, but estimate the risk based on that use and portfolio analytics.
- 29:01I support wholly.
- 29:02It's a great process.
- 29:03And the only way you're going to be able to manage the risk in a
- 29:06consumer portfolio, but here's the beauty of commercial lending.
- 29:10You actually know the risk of each credit.
- 29:12And then that's why I used to get in trouble.
- 29:14I used to say on speaking events, I think commercial lending is the safest
- 29:18lending you can do because you know the level of risk with the borrower.
- 29:22You have proper covenants.
- 29:23You can take actions to help the borrower.
- 29:25I know to look at covenants as a way to take an aggressive action against the
- 29:28borrower, but it gives you some leverage to sit down with the borrower and help
- 29:32them make the changes in their business.
- 29:34So with that said, now you can take the debt service coverage ratio
- 29:38leverage and everything else and put that into the MIS systems.
- 29:43Unless.
- 29:44There's a consistent way to look at each one of those.
- 29:48The quality of that input is only good as the quality of the lender.
- 29:52So it's not always accurate to say, all right, anything with
- 29:56that service coverage of under 1.
- 29:5815 or over 1.
- 29:5925, it all depends on how they looked at it.
- 30:00How did you get there?
- 30:01Yeah, but with credit risk grading, it's supported by the analysis.
- 30:06So that reviewer that goes in there is going to double check it and
- 30:09say, so if you're really looking at just migration of credit risk.
- 30:13Hopefully all that underneath the underwriting, the monitoring and all
- 30:17that stuff supports that risk rating.
- 30:21So the risk rating itself tells you a lot.
- 30:23Got it.
- 30:24So I wrote down covenants too.
- 30:25That might be something then we can talk offline on this, but that might be.
- 30:28An actual podcast that talk about what are your favorite covenants that you've seen?
- 30:32What's the goal of certain covenants?
- 30:34Yeah, I think that'd be a good one.
- 30:36It's just time to do a deep dive, maybe a shorter podcast on that particular
- 30:40topic, but put that in your notes to remind me that we'll be down the road.
- 30:43I will.
- 30:43Yeah, that's a good idea.
- 30:46Yeah.
- 30:46And then so credit union wants to improve their credit risk rating.
- 30:49They listen to this or it's somebody who's getting thinking about getting
- 30:53new into commercial What resources would you recommend that they take a look at?
- 30:58Well, there's four.
- 31:00Look at the preamble to the rules and what it says about it.
- 31:04What the part that's MBL commercial ending rule part 723.
- 31:09Look at what the rule specifically says about it.
- 31:12That's one.
- 31:14Two would be the examiner's guide on rating credit risk or credit risk rating.
- 31:19And then there's two other really, really good resources.
- 31:22One is the interagency guidance on credit risk review.
- 31:27We, when I say we, I mean, the agency NCOA was part of the group, the interagency
- 31:33group that wrote that guidance.
- 31:34And it does a really good job of discussing.
- 31:39How to use credit risk rating system, how credit review should use
- 31:44credit risk rating system, how that should be reported to the board.
- 31:48So what appropriate components should be and independence of
- 31:52assigning those risk ratings.
- 31:54So that's an excellent piece of guidance.
- 31:56And there's a preamble that goes with that too.
- 31:58It's always worth it.
- 31:59I mean, the stuff can maybe put you to sleep.
- 32:01If you read through it, at least you'll say, yeah, I know where to look for that.
- 32:04And when you have a question down the road or know where to look.
- 32:07When you're writing your policy and your process.
- 32:11And then the Bible for rating credit risk.
- 32:15Is the OCC handbook on rating credit risk.
- 32:19Your question earlier, Mark, about what I've seen change in it.
- 32:23But I found interesting when I looked up the OCC's.
- 32:26Handbook on rating credit risk was written in 2001.
- 32:29Wow.
- 32:30So, as I say, it's an accepted practice.
- 32:33Only, but it's a goodie.
- 32:34Yeah, they haven't been able to improve on that.
- 32:36That says a lot.
- 32:37That would be a great resources for.
- 32:38Right.
- 32:38And what that will tell you is, I mean, I just read off some of the table
- 32:43contents, but these sections are really important functions of a credit rating
- 32:46system, expectations, the development of the risk rating system, the risk
- 32:51rating process, examining risk ratings.
- 32:54Rating credit risk, and then the credit risk evaluation process, which
- 32:58includes financial statement analysis, other repayment sources, quantity.
- 33:02So it's just an excellent guide.
- 33:04And beyond just rating credit risk, but commercial loan risk management process.
- 33:09Very good.
- 33:10Any last thoughts here before we wrap it up?
- 33:12And I get one more Willie Stotts reference from my LSU days of
- 33:15school banking of the South.
- 33:17Again, managing risk.
- 33:19And I just want to say, cause I get on my soapbox.
- 33:21If you manage risk correctly.
- 33:24Not only does the credit union benefit by obviously having a stronger portfolio
- 33:30and less adverse effects from having a poor portfolio, which means losses
- 33:35again, the 1 of benefits the most, if you really care about what you're
- 33:39doing is the borrower because you again, I'm going to talk about lender
- 33:44is a financial expert and you're the financial expert on financing a business.
- 33:50A fully informed lender can then structure the best credit package for that borrower.
- 33:56And if you look at it that way, you're going to be sure to get all
- 33:58the information you need to make sure that you're recommending the
- 34:02right solution for that borrower.
- 34:04Very good.
- 34:04Well, and so then on that covenants future podcast, I'm going to
- 34:09connect that to my reference to the school of banking of the south.
- 34:11When I was down there learning from some experiences that they had had
- 34:15the teachers and Willie Stott's in particular, it had relative to
- 34:19commercial loans that had gone bad.
- 34:21He told a joke about the fact that you need to control the
- 34:24draws on a commercial loan.
- 34:26That you need to make sure that you do inspections.
- 34:28And if you're giving them 10 percent to do X, Y, and Z, that you make
- 34:31sure that you have covenants in place and that you do different reviews.
- 34:34And his joke was a commercial loan gone bad.
- 34:38Would allow people to take that first draw and purchase a boat.
- 34:43And so they would take it and it would all be profit.
- 34:45The commercial construction people would get their profits.
- 34:47And he said down in Louisiana at the time, the most common name for boats of
- 34:52people in the construction business was.
- 34:54First draw that they took and they bought their boat.
- 34:57That's not how you want to do commercial.
- 35:00And sometimes you can learn from more stories from that.
- 35:02And I referred back to this class where I learned.
- 35:05A lot of things early on in my career again, and, you
- 35:08know, so much more than that.
- 35:09You went into a much deeper level, but.
- 35:11Let's slot that.
- 35:11We'll talk about a covenants on a future podcast, Vin.
- 35:14I want to thank you for your time today for those listeners out there.
- 35:18I want to thank you for your time and hopefully we'll see you
- 35:21again or you'll hear us again.
- 35:23This is Mark Treichel signing off for With Flying Colors.
- 35:32Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 35:36your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 35:40of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 35:45If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 35:48out our services at marktreichel.
- 35:50com.