Latest / Deconstructing Horror / Before Clayface, I Ranked Batman Villains From "Laughable" To Pure Nightmares
Transcript
- Ryan Does: Friends, on this episode, we are gonna be talking about Batman. Clayface is coming out from DC Studios, and I'm really excited to see this body horror take on a I'm not like a super duper popular Batman villain, but an interesting one at that. I am also right now reading through Batman the Long Halloween. So I'm in a I guess I'm in a Batman mood right now. I am a casual Batman fan. At most, I have seen all of the Batman films and I enjoy most of them, but I'm really excited for this new take on a Batman story without Batman with the new Clayface movie. So I thought it would be really fun to rank some Batman villains based on their ability to horrify, to scare people. Some of them are incredibly terrifying, and some of them are. kinda jokes. So I wanted to do a fun bonus Halloween season episode with with the villains from Batman like Clayface, like the Joker, like the Riddler, characters that are definitely gonna show up on this list. So we're gonna try this. I am going to share my ultimate the ultimate Batman tier list that I found. So it's got most of this list has most of the iconic Batman villains on it. So let's get started with telling you what my tears are. so I went from the the the bottom is like laughable. This villain is not scary, not horrifying, does nothing for me personally. The next level up is spooky. There's a little bit of horror vibes there. But nothing that that I can't I can't I can't get through an issue or a movie with them as the lead villain. Unsettling, we're getting more into like, okay, this character is kind of kinda kinda spooky, little creepy, not as laughable. Then we get to spine chilling. This is where, okay, they make me uncomfortable. they're they're they don't just unsettle me, they're like, okay, I I don't really like their vibe. And then terrifying, they're they're straight up scary. They are a horror villain. And then nightmarish. They are like the tippy top level of Batman's Rogue Gallery when it comes to the scare factor. So I'm just gonna do this list in the order that this Tear Maker list template put them, and we're gonna see where everybody lands. Now, of course, this is my personal preference for these villains, and since I am a casual appreciator of Batman. I know there are probably reasons why all these characters should be in different places. Just needless to say, this is my personal, my personal approach to how I view Batman villains. So, first one, Harley Quinn. So I I love Harley Quinn. I think she's had such a you know renaissance in the last few years with Margot Robbie's take on the character. But I think this one, I I find her I find her unsettling because of how unhinged she is. she's not necessarily the top tier. She's not laughable by any means. She is a she is a threat. She's a spooky gal. and she's definitely unsettling. So I'm gonna put her in the unsettling tier of this list. Now, next one. When I think of Batman villains, I would not want to run into in a dark alley, Killer Croc is he's right up into spine tingling. Territory. and man, he actually, you know what? I find him terrifying. He is a straight up monster. And I think he is a fantastic, simple design for a for a monster. So Killer Croc up in the terrifying level of our tier list. And next one is really the one who's getting the spotlight right now. It's Clayface. I find Clayface I'm gonna say spine chill. Because I think he's he can be so many things and he can take on so many different forms. but at the end of the day, he's like a he's like a mud monster that can shape shift. And I personally enjoy the body horror of Clayface, but I don't find him overly terrifying. So he's he's spine-chilling, we'll say that. The Riddler. Okay. I find the Riddler to be spooky because he's maniacal. He is a strategist, a thinker, but I'm not intimidated or scared by the Riddler. More more more spooked out by him. So the next one, Black Mask. Black Mask, I find unsettling, just strictly because of the design of the character. I think he leans into scaring people by the aesthetic that he puts on the way he The way he looks. So yeah, we're gonna put Black Mask right there. The next is Talia Al Ghoul. I she's gonna go right next to the Riddler because she's definitely not laughable. That that's for sure. She is not laughable, but hers is more of a hers is more of a I'm intimidated by her. I think she's a very cape, she's extremely capable. Being from the League of Assassins, but I don't find her scary in the horror sense. And it's really the same thing with Deathstroke, but even a little bit more with Deathstroke, he's unsettling because of kind of some of the tactics he uses, thinking more specifically of the Judas contract, the levels to which he's gonna go to inflict his form of villainy. Deathstroke is yeah, he's an un he's an unsettling dude. Slade is Slade's kind of a weirdo. And I think Red Hood is a I think I think Red Hood belongs right next next to Deathstroke. We're gonna get a lot more horror specific characters in this list. And I think Red Hood is unsettling because of what he's capable of and what Jason Todd went through. so I think it's more unsettling what he'll go to, the lengths he'll go to. To inflict his form of horror on people. So we'll put Red Hood as unsettling. Our first entrant in the nightmarish category: the Batman Who Laughs. This guy is straight out of nightmares. He is Freddy Krueger and The Joker and Pinhead, like all rolled into one. The Batman Who Laughs is, I mean, if you can't get a good look at the image that I putting up here right now, just Google the Batman Who Laughs and you will definitely not not be laughing as maniacally as he is. You will be a bit like, okay, something is clearly wrong with that guy. and yeah he's from the death metal overarching series that was done quite a few years ago and I've read enough of that series to know that he is definitely not a character to be messed with. The next one is now I I I apologize if I'm getting this name wrong. I believe it's Firefly. Firefly is he's he's spooky, he can set things on fire, and I think Batman can take care of him pretty easily. I I wouldn't say he's a horrific, terrifying villain, but a little spooky. You know, the f the fire aesthetic does a little bit of something. Okay, next, we're going right back to a laughing, cackling maniac. I mean the Joker. He's he's the king of Batman villains. He is the clown cr clown prince of crime in Gotham. And I mean even if you don't know who Batman is, maybe if don't know who you know the the movies have in them, if you've never read Batman comics, you know who the Joker is. The Joker is as iconic as Batman himself, and the Joker. Has its early roots in an old horror film, The Man Who Laughed. and I just the design is so good, the design has been redone so many different times, and I I I really enjoy the Joker's brand of chaos and definitely something out of nightmares. This next character, I must admit, I have never read Hush. So I'm gonna just from the aesthetics, just from the design of the character, I'm gonna say that Hush is unsettling. Cause there's some mystery to him. There's definitely an unhinged spirit about the character. And I I wish I knew more about the character. And that's the one of the drawbacks of being a casual Batman reader and Batman fan, is I'm just looking at the aesthetics here. Hush would make me unsettled. If I saw them walking down the street and I'm a citizen in Gotham, I am unsettled by the look of Hush. So I don't want to mess with him. I'm just gonna let him do his thing, but I'm not gonna like, you know, I'm not gonna freak out and scream and have nightmares over over him specifically. The next one though, the Mad Hatter is if there was a sub like a sub breakdown in unsettling, Madhatter would be at the top of unsettling. Because it's another one of those characters where they are unpredictable. And I think a lot of Batman villains do have that unpredictability about them that makes them a certain kind of menace and a horrifying figure. So I am going to put Mad Hatter right next to Harley Quinn because they both make me unsettled in a similar way. Now the next one is Zaz. Zaz, I find spine chilling. Because he is a murderer, a serial killer who marks himself with you know these reminders, these the psychonography of his kills. That is like some crime horror, real-world true crime kind of twistedness. And I just that that is that is spine chilling to me that someone would mark themselves. with their kills. So yeah, Zaz goes right in that tier. The next one is Deadshot. Deadshot is scary because of how good he is at his job, but in terms of a horror villain, I am gonna say that he's he's spooky. There's nothing about his character that gives me the creeps that unsettles me, like Deathstroke and Red Hood, who are similar kind of characters, assassins that use guns and and weapons like that to take out different people. Deadshot just doesn't have a menacing enough design to be unsettling, so he's spooky. We'll we'll call him spooky. Okay. S Hugo Strange, the twisted Arkham psychiatrist. he is he is spine chilling because of the psychological horror that he enacts on his his patients, his victims, heroes of Gotham, and his design is simplistically it it chill it chills me. I I find him to be just a just a creep just a creep, but he he makes me it doesn't make me feel good, we'll put it that way. but Hugo Strange is gonna go in that tier right there. Next is another character that I I will again admit, much like Hush, I don't know a ton about is Prometheus. And because I have a similar relationship to Prometheus that it did to Hush. I'm gonna put him right next to Hush because I know he is an alternative version of Bruce Wayne or the and you know, hey, if you're listening right now and you are a big Batman fan and you know more about Prometheus, I didn't wanna just take the easy way out and Google things and pretend that I I I know Prometheus so well. I'm gonna be honest with you, I don't know much about Prometheus, but I I just get the feeling that if he's going up against Batman. There's gotta be something a little bit unsettling about him, and his design almost looks too bright and colorful for Gotham, so that in and of itself is unsettling. The next character, I'll be honest, I I find the Vrentriloquist laughable. I think this character it's crazy this character still pops up in modern comics. I know that the, you know, the mannequin Ventriloquist dummy, they have you know machine guns, and I'm sure there's a story out there where this character instills a lot of fear in people. Just from the design of it, I I kind of find the gimmick laughable. So yeah, ventriloquist, you are the first official member of the laughable tier of our Batman villains horror list. Next one for Similar reasons to Killer Croc, Man Bat goes up into terrifying. A giant humanoid bat that is super strong, can fly, just looks terrifying. That this villain, honestly, I wish there were more like vampire movies that had characters like Man Bat. And maybe it's the name. Maybe the name doesn't instill enough terror and horror into people, but Man Bat I find terrifying. the idea of this creature coming after you, no thanks. I'll pass. I'm good. But I do find him, I do find him terrifying. Now, next is a character that has been replaced more recently in recent years by a modern update of the design in the character. But anarchy, he's spooky. Like the instilling anarchy into Gotham kind of feels redundant. But yeah, anarchy is he's fine. in this version of him, he looks like a like a an occultist leader. but I'm I'm not overly scared of anarchy, mostly because I mean it's Gotham. You're you're already in one of the most dangerous psychotic chaos cities in all of DC comics. so what more harm could you do? Honestly. The next one, okay. Professor Pig. Like this is this guy's twisted. I do know a little bit more about his backstory because I saw the design of this character and I was like, okay, I have to know more about this. Professor Pig, he's terrifying to me. It it's he he gives me that like leather face, but like a more cerebral leather face. And There's just something about the pig the pig face and how he tortures and takes apart his victims. I'm like, yeah, that's that's pretty close to home. And and you might think like, well, Zaz does that. Zaz kills a bunch of people and he he keeps around trophies and marks but but like Professor Pig has a gimmick about it. Like a 80s slasher would have, or you know, twisted torture porn kind of slasher villain. Professor Pig, I actually find truly terrifying. So yeah, I don't think I'll be running to a Professor Pig story anytime soon. Next is is Catwoman. I think Catwoman's awesome. I don't find her to be a necessarily horrific character. So I'm gonna put her in the spooky category. She's definitely not laughable, but I think Selena Kyle is. one of those kind of like Talia where she's she is intimidating and she's capable in a different kind of way. She doesn't have to necessarily horrify you, but she can best you. she can be intimidating and she can instill fear in different ways. I just don't think it's a horror character. Now I'm sure there's a version of Catwoman out there where she gets cat powers and she becomes like like Simone Simone in cat people like That, like, that would be that movie, Cat People, it the original Cat People, Hulk Boy Howdy. I actually find that movie unsettling and spine-chilling, but Catwoman, she's awesome. Lover. And yeah, I don't I don't think she's necessarily a horrific character. So next we have Talon and the Court of Owls. I find let me I'll draw a distinction here. I have read the original Court of Owls story. And I'm gonna say talent I don't find necess necessarily horrifying, but the Court of Owls I do. That secret society, that masked, you know, people that are running Gotham secretly behind the scenes and they've been doing it for a long time, the secret society vibe. That is unsettling to me. Bordering on spine chilling, and That's one thing with with Batman villains that I really like, the ones that I really gravitate to or that I find interesting, is they find different ways around beating Bruce or beating Batman and Robin and Batwoman and Batgirl, like the whole the whole cast, they find different ways to beat them. And I think the quarter vowels is a really cool way to try and best Batman and his Bat family. Okay. The next one is Too Face. And I think Two Face is spine chilling. Because everything is up to chance. Now, in certain iterations of the character, they take that to where he's forcing chance. Like in the in the Dark Knight movie, which is my favorite Batman movie to this day. I know there's many, many good ones, but the Dark Knight is still my personal favorite. I saw it three times in the theater. Back when I was in high school, and I just like I could not get enough of that movie. It was like a cultural moment we were all living in when The Dark Knight came out. And Aaron Eckhart's Too Face is not as like cartoonish like Tommy Lee Jones is, but he is sadistic and he left an impression that he was always forcing chance. And then it came back to bite him in the end. So I think Two-Face is. Terrifying in the way he thinks. His logic, a lot like Hugo Strange, like they are mentally and fill you know, they are psychologically terrifying. And that is that is spine chilling to me, bordering on terrifying because he he has that facial deformity and he can actually scare, but we're gonna stick him in spine chilling. The next is Bane. So I am gonna put Bane up in terrifying because Bane is like an 80s hulking juggernaut slasher. He uses his his hands and this this mutated power that he's developed to destroy Batman, to destroy Gotham, and his his mask is also part of it. Like there are a lot of elements to Bane that I do find. lend themselves to being like a slasher design. And I find that really cool. But also I am not like if Bain is on the other side of the street and I'm a citizen in Gotham, hell no, not messing with it. Absolutely not. would he stalk me in my nightmares? probably not, but I put him in a similar tier to Killer Croc and Man Bat and and and and Bainer like there there is there are a certain kind of terrifying that I I guess as as a fan of you know designs of characters, I I gravitate to those kind of characters. So I'm noticing a theme here. So Razoghoul Razal Ghoul's spooky. Say he's spooky. a lot of the similar things with Talia, but he does have that, you know, Lazarus pit, you know, thing where he's died and been resurrected and there's kind of a like a almost good looking zombie kind of thing that he has going for him, but he's spooky. I wouldn't say that he's an overly horrific villain. And again, he feels like another character where someone in a comment or a friend of mine is going to be like, but this story with him is is is crazy and it's terrifying. I I'm sure I'm sure just the version of him that I know is not overly horrific. So we'll call him spooky. Now this next one. Is the scarecrow. And I think by the just the nature of the character, the scarecrow is nightmarish because it fe feeds on fear. And I remember when Cel Killian Murphy, Cillian Murphy, I've never known how to say that properly, so if you do let me know. But his portrayal of the character is psychologically twisted, but Some of the designs for the Scarecrow that have popped up in comics where he looks like a cornfield scarecrow, but just with the nightmare fuel turned up to 11. That personally, that no go, no go for Ryan. So Scarecrow, by the nature of his character and you know, just the the designs that have been done with him, he's nightmarish. Now, I don't mean to be too cheeky with this. But I do find Mr. Freeze spine chilling because of literally the chills that he puts into people, but also the different kind of villainy he has, the different kind of horrific things that have happened to him, but also that he he enacts, because there's not another villain like him in Batman's main rogues gallery. I think that makes him unique because a lot of these characters, there's kind of a comp or a comparable character that you could find. Freeze is totally different than a lot of them and his stories almost make him sympathetic. to where you're like, okay, I I don't approve of your your villainous the terrifying things you're doing to people, but I also kind of get it. Ugh. Yeah. Okay. Second to last. And I'm sure a lot of these characters deserve a lot more time. It's just that I I don't want to wax poetic. As a casual fan, I want to give you my my first impression of these. And I will tell you, the penguin I find terrifying. Now, a lot of this may be due to the first Batman movie I remember seeing as a kid was Batman Returns. I didn't see the original Batman until till I was much older, but I Danny DeVito as the penguin did terrify me. I did not like I did not like my first experience watching Batman Returns. and a lot of it was due to Danny DeVito's penguin. But also there have been modern stories where the penguin is this terrifying entity of working in the background and then being a a mob boss, but also this tortured outsider, and he is willing to go to terrifyingly violent and gross lengths to keep his slice of the pie in Gotham. And yeah, a lot of it is really due to that initial memory of Danny DeVito when I was a kid. I I won't lie, that was formative, the first Batman villain that actually scared me. so yeah, here we go. Poison Ivy. The last one on this horror-themed Batman villains tier list. I think Poison Ivy is a great character. She is getting a modern reclaiming right now, and her comic at DC has been going for so long, which is great. Kudos to the character. I think there is a version of her that could be absolutely nightmarish and terrifying, but for the most part, I find her spine chilling of what she's capable of. She is the one villain on this list where. She is capable of so much because she can control nature. And I think that is something that could be used to absolutely nightmarish effect. But with where the character is at, and my introduction to the character is Uma Thurman's Poison Ivy, and not exactly a a a spooky character, a horror character, more of like a femme fatale kind of villain, but I think she is spine chilling because of what she is capable of. And that is that is so much more than I think she does on most of her appearances in comics or in media and film. So there you go, everybody. That is a fun bonus this Halloween season. I wanted to stick in as many appropriate things that were gonna be happening along with the release of Clayface, but also Halloween is here. Ranking Batman villains on their ability to be horror icons and horror villains feels appropriate. So we did end up with just three people in the three characters in the nightmarish category of the Batman Who Laughs, the Joker, and the Scarecrow. The next level down was a lot of things that I just like I am interested in the design and I'm creeped out by the design of Killer Croc, Man Bat, Professor Pig, Bane, and Penguin. And then from there, we did have Clayface. In our third from the top tier. I really do like Clayface as a design. I love that they're going so hard into the body horror for this new movie. I am a fan of body horror. It's one of my favorite horror subgenres, and I can't wait to see Clayface. I don't know when I'm gonna be able to see it, but I'm really excited to see it and I'm interested to see what they do with a villain-led movie in James Gunn's DC universe. So just remember. that if you're you're checking this out, you can leave a comment, tell me what Batman villains I'm missing, and what Batman villains you find especially horrifying, nightmarish, terrifying. And if you wanna subscribe to the show, follow it, leave leave a like, all those things. Do all those things. I hope that you have a great Halloween. And remember, just like if you were a city, you were a citizen of the city of Gotham, the horrors are gonna persist. Look at this villain. How could they not? The horrors are gonna persist, but so can we.