Latest / Braver New Worlds / Courage, Propaganda, and Standing Up for Justice with Karim Bouris
Transcript
- Nathan Young: Hello, and welcome back to Braver New Worlds, a podcast about the stories we need to tell for the future we want to see. My name is Nathan Young. I am your host. And today's conversation gets into some pretty big questions about storytelling, propaganda, courage, and what we really believe is possible. My guest is Karim Bouris. He is the principal of strategy and advocacy at Mixte Communications, the agency itself always been one I've been very impressed by by the way that they have really adhered to a certain set of values for the kind of clients that they're gonna work with. the conversation pretty quickly gets into something that's been coming up a lot more and more in my own work, which is courage and leaning into our own values. I think for those of us living in relatively comfortable lives in America, but we see things happening all over the world that challenge our belief in humanity. We've got things going on in our own country, whether we see them on our front doorstep or not. And I think a lot of us we struggle with like how easy it is to get comfortable with doing nothing and even being complicit based on where we work and what we buy and the choices that we make. Because all of those do factor into this sort of system that we're in that creates these conditions that can be very harmful for a lot of other people And so what does it mean to fundamentally stake your own values to how you make a living and who you do and don't allow yourself to work with especially in an entrepreneurial capacity? And Karim introduces a pretty interesting way of thinking about it. instead of thinking about courage as something that very brave individuals simply possess and do out of some magnanimity of their own, he argues that courage is also something that communities and organizations can create the conditions for. And as we'll also be discussed, Karim is of Palestinian and Lebanese descent. so our conversation definitely got into Israel, Palestine, and the ongoing genocide that Israel has been perpetrating in Gaza. And I see that somewhat deliberately as a big part of the conversation was about the language we use to talk about situations and things going on in our world. the conversation got very challenging in some places. I tried to show up with my own sort of emotional honesty and the struggles I have around the situation as it is. I feel like I've I've definitely been somebody that's been a little bit more willing to be outspoken about it than others and, post on social media or whatever we do to to make our thoughts known. But even with that, it has been a challenging thing for me to talk about Whether it's finding the language or finding the fortitude in myself to to state what I truly believe. And I feel quite affirmed that, Benjamin Netanyahu is a war criminal and the Israeli state led by Netanyahu is committing a genocide right now against the the Gazans. And I'll even take it a step further. the United States is complicit in this genocide, and by extension, you and me and all of us that are probably listening to this podcast. I feel a sadness for humanity about it and I feel a sadness for all parties involved. I still like, worry a little bit about who I'm gonna upset by saying that or what kind of ramifications there will be. And then couple that with, how I can just sort of sit back and say nothing most of the time And approach it from a place of detachment or resignation or just emotional exhaustion. I think it gets to a feeling that a lot of us have when and where and how to speak up what is what is the value of it and what are we able to to offer each time that we do. And I tried my best to express these kind of conflicts and reservations and different feelings I have the language we use, and just, My own sort of emotional resonance and stakes in the situation. And I do that almost to the point of putting my foot in my mouth sometimes. it was a difficult conversation for Karim I really appreciate that he was here to have that conversation with me and be willing to let all of you listen to it here too. So hopefully, maybe some of this resonates with people that are still struggling with how they feel about the situation or they are struggling to find a language to talk about it or just believing themselves around it. And to get back to that idea of courage. What courage do we need to bring and inhabit and share with the people around us so we can actually like talk honestly about things going on in our world like, you know, genocides that we might all actually all be complicit in. So if you're a person sorting out how you feel about the world, sorting out how much you should or shouldn't be talking about a certain topic. Finding courage to be outspoken or just living into your values. I think you're gonna get a lot out of this conversation. So with that, let's get into my conversation with Karim Bouris. Karim Bouris, welcome to the podcast. Karim Bouris (he/him): Thanks for having me, Nathan. Nathan Young: So, as I like to start off all these, just introduce yourself real quick to the folks at home. Where to start? Karim Bouris (he/him): Nathan, is this whi which which introduction do we want here? Do we want my professional introduction? Do we want when I screw around with people and I just try to get with it? What's the what's the Nathan Young: Let's do seventy percent professional, thirty percent screw around. Karim Bouris (he/him): Okay. Okay, cool, cool, cool, cool. it was actually a loaded question because my introduction professionally also involves some screwing around. So if you go to our Nathan Young: Okay, perfect. Karim Bouris (he/him): company website, it's how I say so. I'm Karim Bouris. I am one of the two principals at Mixte Communications. We are a communications shop that only works on health, justice, and freedom for all people. So our North Star from an ethical standpoint is really guided towards just making the world a better place. the way that I like to introduce who I am is that I am 100% Palestinian, 100% Lebanese, and 100% American. And the math does math. And I think that's when people Nathan Young: Ha ha ha. Karim Bouris (he/him): usually get really confused. And then the only other thing that I like to tell people about me is that I'll because I am from that makeup, I tell stories to make a point. And I am going to learn as you ask me any question to start with the end, make the point and then tell the story. But if I go down the rabbit hole, Nathan, your job is to reel me back in, really. Nathan Young: To reel you back in? Okay, I can do that. I mean sometimes I like the rabbit hole, so that's the problem. So we'll we're Karim Bouris (he/him): man, we are in trouble then. Nathan Young: sort of pro rabbit hole here a little bit. Yeah. Yeah. Okay, cool. Well that I do want to start Karim Bouris (he/him): man, I am gonna take us down some good ones. Nathan Young: talk about your professional role and Mixte and what goes on there because I do think it's interesting. A lot of times I think There's this notion of like doing values based business, but I know compromises are made sometimes too, right? And so do you have to make compromises for the sake of income and capitalism and all that good stuff? And but it seems like I don't know if that's just sort of what I'm getting from out here, but it seems like you guys are very uncompromising in the type Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: of organizations you'll work with. And I guess I'd be curious to just hear about like a little bit about the organization and how you think about the the values of the organization. Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. I mean we do have values that we live by and we call it our mixty code and but at the end of the day we do only work with clients who are clear about where they stand when it comes to The vision of the world and it has to align. We're really lucky that that's not just something aspirational, but we have to compromise on some. It's more of a kind of a baseline agreement that we have. And it begins with the first conversation where we just have this chemistry check that we'll do. And we are not uncompromising because we know that in this moment, especially with this administration, the skill that we have to offer is also that it is the modulation and the able to adapt who you are and what you do so that you don't become a target from this administration. It's an arbitrary way of applying regulations and laws. so while we do have a niche and it would be significantly easier to not have to worry about the ethics and the values of our clients, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): there is maybe a cost to doing that, but the benefit that we get In terms of who gets to work with us, clients, but also our team, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): that's the joy. We get to work with people who are believers. And we everybody works with clients that they would basically be on the streets or at their events or supporting at City Hall, even Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): if they weren't doing it with Mixte. yeah, so I just love that overlap of the personal and the professional Venn diagrams, that there's this Nathan Young: Mm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): really large overlap between who we are as people at Mixte and the work Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): we get to do. So yeah, I was part of the starting of Business for Good in San Diego. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): And the team over there and the folks over there just that's the ethos. that was the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): vision too of how do we get that bar raised for all businesses? And the members of Business for Good really understand that that's their goal too. So while it does feel like maybe there is a cost, it's also good to know that there's a community around us that is Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): aiming and building for the same world. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Well, it's interesting too because this has been a consistent theme on this podcast too. I've had people from Business for Good and B Corp, B Local groups, but also like a lot of nonprofits, a lot of people involved in communication. And yeah, we're all doing the best we can, right? And trying to make a better world in the things that we're doing. And to different extents, you some of us are able to really kinda draw the line and some of us have to be a little bit fuzzy about it. So it's always interesting to know that like 'cause I'll just speak for myself. Like I've been lucky enough to mostly work in value aligned ways in my life, but there's definitely been times that I haven't and it it's frustrating. And it's just a drag and it just feels like you're wasting your life and when I worked in values a line things. I mean it was fun and I liked the people I worked with. I liked who my clients were. I liked the different members of the public I had to interact with in the course of doing that work. So it really does just make a huge difference. And, I hate to I guess the only bub bummer about it is like, yeah, you end up sort of in your bubble that way, but I don't know, it's not a bad bubble, I guess, if you gotta be in one Karim Bouris (he/him): No, I know. one of the things that we talked about was you and I ahead of today who is just courage. I think maybe writ large, like kind of the big umbrella around what I've been thinking about is this notion of courage and what it means. Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): And I think it just applies on so many levels of the Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): choices we get to do every day, whether it's business or Palestine or the the people we surround ourselves with. Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Okay, I will come back to Palestine, but I want to stick on this one a little bit more because I'm very curious about it. Cause yeah, Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah, sure. Yeah. Nathan Young: you're a communications firm, in case we haven't said that all already, like Mixte communications. And so yeah, I am a little bit curious too about your approach to communications. And I know storytelling's a big part of it, but I'm curious about that courage piece too, because that's coming up more and more in my work too. And I usually work more consulting with like individuals and Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: smaller organizations and working within like the teams and organizations for their own communication. And this idea of courage has been coming up a lot. And that wasn't the word I've been using. I've been talking about like bold leadership and to like really like, yo, stake a claim and have a vision and have a purpose and have the vision that you want to put forward and don't be afraid to be a little bit bold and controversial. And I courage I think is probably the word there too. I'm wondering if you ever encounter organizations to where that's a little bit tougher for them or maybe they're not quite ready to step up to the plate on that one. Karim Bouris (he/him): You know, Yes. and I think it's the question around courage is one that's just been super recent for me. and I'm gonna answer you because in a little bit of a roundabout way because I took Nathan Young: Mm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): a class recently and I'm gonna give her a shout out because it's Michelle Myong Kim through her organization, the Courage Studio. it was four week course called the AI Strategy Lab for Social Justice Advocates. Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): So she's a DEI and justice advocate Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): and trainer, TEDx speaker. She is one of the most incredible people I've gotten a chance to work with. And I'm in a so opinionated about everything I do. my expectations for things like conferences and trainings is So high that more often than not I'm disappointed because but also my level said with myself that I'm really there to learn one or two things and I just can't Okay, so I've got this really cynical view on what I'm gonna learn out of anything. And it was game-changing because there was not a single thing about that course over four weeks that was not helpful. And it wasn't about AI because one of the things that Michelle spoke about and at the end, because it was all about the ethical lines that AI forces us to cross. And there's no purity of it. And she defines courage, and that's why it's so front and center in my mind right now. And I think it applies to what you're asking, which is how do folks make that calculus and live with it? And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): she said that courage is this decision to live and act beyond the edge of comfort, despite that perceived risk and for what truly matters to you. And the part that really changed how I think about it is that it really got me to think that s courage isn't something I do solo, right? It's not me as a one-man show, I'm brave and that's it. It's a collective, right? People freeze Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): and organizations freeze. And I say people because the decision makers are people within organizations. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): And When they're expected to carry out risk alone with no safety net. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): it's really I love it because my answer is that if unless we address the conditions or that create that fear, it's not somebody's individual responsibility. So I love to step back and say what's happening around to make a nonprofit leader or company Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): leader be afraid of being able to be true to what they Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): want. so that was really helpful for me because I had a very pure mindset around well, these are your values. I mean, you saw me invert me at business for good. Well, you know, there's a right way and a wrong way, and now I'm way more modulated with that because I and it's not about tiptoeing, but it's not about more risk. It's about shared risk and shared infrastructure now. And so Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): when that's why I love even from a distance now, even more what business for good represents. It's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): that shared infrastructure so that businesses can be bridged. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Right? And that's what I love about it. So I don't know if I answered your question here. Nathan Young: Yeah. No, I think you did. And it's interesting, so where I go with that is because I have that speaker series Big Idea Night here in San Diego too. And part of what I'm trying to do there too is have conversations about these sort of big ideas that might seem a little bit radical or antithetical to like what we've all been socialize to believe and try to think of our world differently. And a lot of it is like having people there that have these feelings already, but maybe they don't have an outlet for it anywhere else. But so that if you get a room full of people that are like, yeah, okay, we all think this is a good idea. Like we all don't need to be working forty hours a week and we all sort of agree they'd like be destroying our planet and being agreeing with this current administration we got. We're all here together believing this. Like we can see each other, we can talk to each other. And that community creates courage too. And we had one speaker a couple of weeks ago talk about how like, yeah, a lot of times our political systems and our the way our society is organized, the hierarchy and the patriarchal hierarchy that our societies are organized under, they're gonna be more doctrinaire whenever Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: they get the chance. And to the point of like cruelty even, and from it's almost like that Hannah Arendt book, what was it called? the way that like cruelty is sort of Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: the banality of cruelty or the banality of evil where like you just sort of follow orders and because at some point like you're gonna have to like stop like no I'm not gonna follow that order and that can be really scary unless you have that community there to back you up. And so whether you're sort of asserting your point of view or you're just not gonna let somebody else assert a point of view on you that you don't agree with that Courage also yeah, comes from the backup, comes from the community that you've got. I think that's yeah, a very valuable point. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Okay. Nathan, can I just like before we can continue, Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): you just like raise the bar for who I think is listening and watching this? Because you just went with a deep cut with Hannah Rent. you just like really went on a postmodern deep cut. I'm not sure that I can roll with you like that. I see what you did. I'm gonna try, but that was that was good. That was good. Nathan Young: I I think I think it'll keep up. I thought that was a pretty famous book, wasn't it? I don't know. Karim Bouris (he/him): Sure, but then let's poll your audience on how many have actually read Hannah Arendt and postmodern philosophy. Nathan Young: I think Karim Bouris (he/him): Okay, I'm I'm ner I'm not nervous. I'm not nervous. I can do this. I can do this. We're not gonna have postmodern philosophy questions. Nathan Young: Okay. I think a lot of people have. I think well at least to be aware of it and the overarching thesis of it. You know? That's something that gets talked about a lot in our society right now too, right? Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Yeah. You know what's funny because when I hear you talk about that, I hear the underpinning of an individualistic society. the notion that this capitalistic community society we live in pushes that it's about the booster ups and individual effort that creates the hero in you. That it's an individual journey. We talk about it even in storytelling and in narrative, right? What is the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): hero's journey and it's individual? When if you come from a collectivist culture, that's not the way that courage and bravery looks. It is a very different approach to solving problems. You have generations Nathan Young: Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): together, families together, communities together. So this very Western and individualistic mindset Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): dictates how we think about courage so that when we see it coming from different communities, maybe we downplay Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): the strength that they're and the resilience that they're displaying in a moment like that, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): because we just can't see it. Nathan Young: I'm curious what that like kind of collective courage looks like, the courage you're talking about. But I would sort of argue that individuality narrative that we have here is like sort of propaganda. Like we're Karim Bouris (he/him): yeah. Nathan Young: told to be individuals, but there's a price for not conforming too, right? I think that sort of that individualism is a sort of a sales pitch that we're given that Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: when we step outside when we actually like do like choose to be individuals, you know, there's there's a price to pay as opposed to the Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: the reality of it. but also it's sort of like but we're individuals when it comes to our basic needs. you're on your own there. Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Totally. And if I mean it's really the perfect message here that the problem is you. It's not the system around you that is disinvesting Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): in you, that is underinvesting in some communities, that is prioritizing the benefits to the wealthy versus the community as a whole. I mean, it is absolutely a really beautiful PR frame to to sell the notion of success as something that is individual versus structural Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): conditions that have been designed and created to work exactly the way that they are to benefit the few. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, totally. And the few that, you know, work together as a team, as a community of Karim Bouris (he/him): yeah. Yeah and for someone like me who does not consider himself white, also they look the same. Not just working with people like them, but people who look like them more often than not. That's the Nathan Young: Yeah, Karim Bouris (he/him): other precondition of that club that they belong to. Nathan Young: Yeah. So you mentioned that yeah, in more collectivist cultures there's a different way of thinking. Can you give us any like insight into that? Karim Bouris (he/him): That's a big one, Nathan. Nathan Young: I know. Karim Bouris (he/him): That's a big one. I think the way that I think about it is where the locus of control is. Maybe that's the simplest. The answer to our problems here in America is to look within. Right. So how much do we talk about self-care when things get tense and frightening, I think, versus how much do we say and expect that there's a community that we can rely on around us? Maybe that's The easiest example that I think about, which is this the solution to what ails us is around us, not only within us. Nathan Young: Yeah. it's funny though, 'cause you don't realize how individualistic America is until you go somewhere else. And like my sort of secret shame is how little international travel I've done. But I did go to just Paris, not even like some insanely collective culture, but it was interesting to me just watching how the whole city went out to lunch at the same time. Like twelve o'clock, doors open, everybody's out at lunch. And then there would be school kids and they all the whole class, twenty probably a smaller class size, like twenty students. They would all just sit in one pretty close knit circle in the park and eat their lunch together. And then there might be another class over there, but like people from offices and stuff, like everybody would be eating lunch together. And yeah, you go out in America, where food courts and stuff, most people are sitting alone, maybe one other person, sometimes maybe a small group. Even in school cafeterias, it's usually two Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: or three people are sitting in small groups there, two, three kids, maybe four. And it was just fascinating to see that Yeah, basically everybody sitting eating the lunch in groups of like five or more. There was nobody just by themselves. Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nathan, you know I grew up in Paris, right? Nathan Young: I don't think I knew that, but it makes sense. your last name is pronounced a little like French the way it's pronounced, right, right? Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah, but it's very much a Palestinian last name. I think this is more about the social contract of collectivism that is when your history predates capitalism as a group by and the industrial revolution by centuries, maybe there's a little bit more of a runway to be able to maintain that sense of a broader community. America's founding is really on this kind of like Puritan work ethic of the individual Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): bootstraps, I am only as good as my own physical labor can produce and so I'm not surprised. To me it's like i if you ask my wife Jamie what's the number one way to trigger me is ask me to eat while multitasking while at my Nathan Young: Ha ha. Karim Bouris (he/him): desk So to your point, I'm like no We take lunch together, right? We what and the worst of the worst when I first moved to America was watching people eat while driving. I don't understand to this day how people can hold a sandwich in one hand and drive with the other and be okay. Now, admittedly, I can pull that off now when I'm on a road trip. I have assimilated enough that I can eat while driving, and I hate every moment of it still, but I will do it. But that's the line. That's my line. Nathan Young: Yeah, fair enough, fair enough. Karim Bouris (he/him): Other works republic. Nathan Young: Yeah. What that's interesting. well now I'm kinda curious too. we'll get back to the other topic of but as a communications professional too, I'm always thinking about these narratives that we've adopted of that sort of like rugged individualism and how is it possible and how to shift that narrative in American culture? Is that something that could be done? Karim Bouris (he/him): We are gonna have to move into the notion of public relations and propaganda sooner than later, because that is to me at the core of the brand of America that we love to push out there. And there's a difference between the brand of America and the reality of America. If you just looked at numbers of who is America, but then what our image is to the world and the policy positions we take. And that is the answer to I think what your question is here. this story of who America is, this Paul Bunyan, greater than life, this Paul Revere hero who just rides a horse and all night to say right it that is baked into our mythology of America. and where are our women? Where's our native? Who are Our first communities over here way before us, and this is still their land. where are they in that story? They're nowhere. We have done what a Western colonial state does when it just takes over, which is it recreates and erases and creates a new narrative. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): the narrative that we have is very much one of Western European colonial settler mindset that says, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): We are worthy of this land. So it is Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): our story that begins this land. The timeline of this land begins with us, with the scepter, the Mayflower, not the communities that we're here for centuries and centuries since Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): time immemorial, not us. Nathan Young: Yeah. No, totally. so the podcast that is gonna come out right before this one is with this woman, her name's Hilary Giovale and she talks about how to be a good ancestor, how to be a good relative. But basically kind of talking about us as white people or else me as white people, us, you know. and that detachment we have from these sort of cultures and stuff. But one of things we started talking about too was like how little like I know the Mayflower came here. I sort of vaguely know that they didn't agree with the religion of England and that's why they came here. I don't know what the stories were of anybody that came here. And I think of my own family and I know they came here in the late eighteen hundreds from Germany and Scandinavia. They went to North Dakota, Minnesota. that was a wave of immigration. And I have no idea. I'd like go look up what was happening in those places prior I mean I still need to, but I do know that there was like a some revolutionary fervor going on in Germany around that time and stuff. And so I do know that there was some upheaval there. I don't know what was going on in Scandinavia during that time, maybe some carryover there too. But I wonder if part of the answer is we need to trace our roots back to our family like where our families came from and understand what was going on there and like who they were because I think a lot of us sort of have this notion that maybe they were just these individualists that couldn't handle the collectivist cultures of where we came from and decided to strike out to America for their fortune. But yeah, they might have been moved here under duress. Karim Bouris (he/him): one of the first chapters in the authoritarian playbook is how you selectively retell history. so I'm not surprised that as an American, your starting point for who you are, your identity and your story is one that has a lot of holes, you know, that Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): precedes it. I do you remember the Calvin and Hobbes comic strip? There's my favorite one that I think kind of gets to this notion of how we are conditioned to not have the energy or the care for it. And it's this quick strip where Hobbes walks into the room and Calvin is lying on the floor and he's reading the newspaper like any good six-year-old does reading the current affairs page. He's like, What should you do? And he Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, of course. Karim Bouris (he/him): says it says here that religion is the opiate of the masses. and then he looks at Hobbes and he says, What do you think that means? You know, Hobbes, his imaginary tiger, Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): stuffed tiger who becomes real when no adults are out. And they're both like pondering it. And then the next strip is of the good old boottube, the TV with a bubble, thought bubble above it that says that answers the question says It means Karl Marx ain't seen nothing yet. Nathan Young: Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): And I think that that answers our question, right? Which is that if that the conditioning of the massive is coming from this brainwashing, and I'm keep coming back to propaganda and to who controls the message, where the means of production and the means of information that is who gets to write the stories we tell. And so this Nathan Young: Mm-mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): brand of America of who we are, where we come from, what is our shared history, it doesn't take into account this melting pot and the difficulties of the melting pot to get together. Right. We all kind of start in this perfect way, but there was a lot of ethnic and cultural layers to it in that not all communities that were emigrating to America at the same time as your family were equal. Right? And so everybody Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): was, if you think about that time, one of the things I do know is everybody was kind of jockeying to be seen and considered and counted as white. Because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Then you maybe had a better access to those who weren't. So at that time where the Scandinavians and the Germans were considered the okay ones to come, the Italians, the Irish were considered the riffraff, the dirty ones, the ones that were not the ones you wanted. So to me, there's a direct through line between that period of our emigration and who we were in America and what is happening now 200 and you know, let's say 150 years later with this administration, the through Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): line is there. And so it's kind of Sad to think about how little our thought process has evolved and our acceptance of difference and others has Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): changed since then. And that's really frustrating. Nathan Young: Yeah. I mean, yeah, what is your take on I guess I'm kind of curious to hear your take on where we are as a country in that regard in general, like just with that sort of level of acceptance. Because I think on one hand, we see what's on the news and stuff, we hear the worst of the worst. And I don't want to diminish what that means for people that are like on the direct receiving end of like that danger, that discrimination. But on the other hand too, it's sort of like I don't wanna like overemphasize this too, but I don't know if you s watch some of the World Cup coverage and then these posts from people in Europe that were coming here, people all over the world that were coming here and like just found America to be like this very great, welcoming, warm nation, so different from what they saw of us on the news and how this small town in Kansas embraced the Algerian soccer team, right? so I don't know. I don't want to like for a second deny that we're like a sort of deeply racist country on many levels. But I wonder how much that is in institutions and even sort of like man, I feel like I'm like stepping into a little bit here, but like exaggerated or not. I realize I'm saying this is a guy that like has no fear of this at all. So what are your thoughts? Karim Bouris (he/him): right, as I wanna just ask you then what you're tiptoing around and why. Well as you're finding yours because you Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): know I can tell you all day long why I have firm convictions, but I think figuring out with you would probably Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): be more helpful to other listeners who may be struggling with it. Because if Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): I'm just saying, well, I'm confident about my worldview and why then I'm speaking to my echo chamber who already are convinced, right? So I'm Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): curious for you why even being able to say out loud that our nation's legacy is one of institutional racism that has not made much progress since Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): why you tiptoe around words like that. Nathan Young: for what it's worth, I don't feel like I was tiptoeing around that so much, but just sort of like trying to also like I felt like the optimism maybe was where I was like tiptoeing too of like I don't want to assume the experience of people that are in much more marginalized position than me, right? 'cause Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: even if the net is that like America's not as bad, It doesn't take the majority to really like repress a minority. Like it takes another minority to repress a minority. And to like elevate, another a majority and give a sort of special status to white people just to spell it out in a way that we sort of take for granted and are a little bit loath to give up sort of unwittingly And like yeah, that it allows for a certain level of repression against other groups of people. And I guess I didn't want to represent the optimism in a way that was unfair and not acknowledging of like, no, shit's fucked. Karim Bouris (he/him): And maybe, maybe what you heard me react to is the World Cup is a flash in the pan moment Nathan Young: Yes, that too. Karim Bouris (he/him): of what America can be. And it is not representative of the reality of America day in, day Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): out. And there's a false equivalency between the welcoming nature of folks in Kansas to the Algerian fans who are traveling with their team to catch a game at Arrowhead Stadium. Is that where they were playing? Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): again. Nathan Young: Mm. I don't even know. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): then than thinking about the policies that those same Kansans Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): are willing to vote for and pass against LGBTQ, trans rights, access to Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): abortion or immigration policies or anything that maintains a certain power structure. And that's my immediate mindset that we I worry that in this brand of America, we still look at the good deeds of the few as the hope that we can still hang on to. And so it's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): it's so funny. so this is a timely one. I because just last night I went to the movie theater first time in a long time. And I went to see Hades Town with some friends. So Hades Nathan Young: I've never heard this one. Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): Town was this Broadway play that it was fantastic apparently I had not heard about it. And it's basically this Broadway production of the Greek tragedy of Orpheus and Eurydice. Nathan Young: Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): and going into the Hades. so but it's a movie made of the final show that they they played on the in the West End in London. So Nathan Young: Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): it's a movie, but you're watching the musical of This Greek tragedy. And at the the end of it, the point here is that, we all know, those of us who studied and who read this Greek tragedy years and years ago in middle school or high school, we know that it ends bad. It's a Greek tragedy. There is no Greek chat tragedy that ends well, ever. Right? That's the point of the tragedy. Some people love Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): it because they know that it's gonna end bad. The people you follow die or don't get together. That's the point of the tragedy. And yet, in the closing of that musical version of the play I didn't know who he was until somebody pointed, and my friend pointed it. His name is Andre de Shields, and he is the guy who was in the whiz. He's this iconic musical theater persona. And he's plays the character of Hermes in the play. And he closes Nathan Young: Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): it by saying that it's this old sad tale that never once ended differently. But he says masterfully in as a part of his character that He says something like, They're gonna sing again. That on the chance at this time, the beauty of the character of Orpheus is that he has the optimism that things could go differently if he keeps trying. Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): And it's not the optimism that things are gonna go well and have a beautiful, successful ending, but choosing to keep showing up To a story that you already know the ending of is basically what we're talking about here, right? It is Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): this guy just almost made it out of the depths of hell Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): with his love that he went down to get, and he just made one fatal mistake and lost her forever, and yet he's gonna keep trying. So that's the beauty of it. I feel like you're kind of touching on a similar storyline here, which is Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): you wanna believe that This version of America that those Kanzans represented, that can Nathan Young: Ha ha. Karim Bouris (he/him): be that can be our America, right? That if Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): we can. So what's behind the curtain? What is behind who is the whiz activating these levers? Who's controlling our story and what we see in Oz here? Nathan Young: I know who, who some Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): I love I love it. If you want me to go there, because that's what you and I talked about, right? Which is that Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): I mean that is I think the my own field of work and what fundament what Mixte communications we started with public relations and that field of public relations that started in World War One when the US government started its What is it? the committee on public information. And at the time, the founder of Arfield, a young man named Edward Bernays, who was Sigmund Freud's nephew, and who was Nathan Young: well, okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): obsessed with his uncle's work on psychoanalysis and how the brain works, he became the father of public relations. His first book was literally titled Propaganda. And what he Nathan Young: He probably said that as like a neutral phrase, right? It wasn't like yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): You know, a hundred and ten years ago, it wasn't a bad word, propaganda. It was literally the way we do public information. And the way he defined it was the engineering of consent. So, this is not something that I'm making up right now, but when it comes to the way we think about things, that's the what's behind the scenes is who is controlling what we read, what the information is. that is old. The only reason propaganda and Edward Bernays really worked on this during World War One was because public opinion from Americans at the idea of joining this war overseas across the pond in World War One, where you had to take ships for weeks to make it to Europe. We were like, wait, we're gonna send thousands of our young men to go fight over there. Nobody wanted it, so his job was to shape opinion, was how to engineer a consent. Uncle Sam I want you. That came from Edward Bernays's campaign. So that's an example of the I love telling about the levers and how we move it. So it's relevant to me today in terms of the conversation about how we get there, right? And where the what the media landscape is, right? Nathan Young: You may have noticed that one of the recurring themes of this podcast is that the world as it is isn't the only world that's possible. And the people I talk with on here are often exploring different ways of leading, working, building community and creating change in the world here too. you also may have noticed that we have a few problems in our world. Things, you know, aren't aren't the way that a lot of us would like them. And many of the guests I've had on here have had on specifically for the ideas they have to share about what could make our world a better place. and this all gets back to the kind of work that I do too. This connection of leadership and social change. Very much part of the work I do. I work with leaders to help them own and share their own bold vision for a better world. Sometimes this means helping someone find the message in the heart of a talk they're giving or an overall message they're sharing about, who they are and the kind of work they're doing. Sometimes it means helping an organization tell a clearer and more compelling story about the work they're doing and the change they're trying to make. And sometimes this even means helping my clients understand what it means to be courageous applying that courage to the message they wanna share. Right now I do this primarily through coaching and consulting with leaders specifically, but also with some organizations. I'm also developing a set of tools and training models an idea I call narrative leadership, which is a framework for understanding how the stories we tell shape what we believe is possible and our ability to make these stories real. And I'll be sharing much more about this work here soon. So if any of this sounds interesting, it sounds like something that you could use help with for your either for yourself or for your organization, I'd love to hear from you. I'd love to see if we could work together. you can start by visiting my website which is storyculture consulting dot com or finding me on social media and all the channels. It's Nathan Cody Young on all of There are ways you can message me either through social media, through the website. And of course keep listening here. I plan to roll out some pieces of this here very soon. So as more and more of that comes together, you're all gonna be the first to hear about it. So thanks so much for listening to my little commercial here, And now let's get back to the episode. Karim Bouris (he/him): There's been a collapse in America of the newsroom in general. I mean, you came from the newsroom, right? Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Right. I was always on the advertising side, but I came from like news media. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Right. So you were inside news media. So you probably saw the collapse of the newspapers, right? I mean, in the last twenty years, almost eighty percent of job loss has happened in the newsroom. That is by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, that is the steepest drop in any industry that the Bureau of Labor Statistics tracks in the last twenty years. And forty percent of that drop comes from local TV news stations. So cool. So who is sharing the story? Who's writing the stories? Who's going out in the communities and interviewing people and talking? And if you then know that forty percent of all local TV news stations are now controlled by just three conglomerates: Gray Television, Nextstar, and Sinclair. And that they operate in about 80% of US media markets, like you can see how it doesn't take much. It takes three sources to get information to eighty percent of them of people who watch local TV. So how does opinion get shaped when there's only one version coming to most of us? So it's shrinking this notion of variety of thought and opinion because the information sources are getting less and less and less. Nathan Young: Yeah. Well, I don't know. what do you think about though? I understand that argument, I get it. And I think on one hand, there's a lot of truth to it, but on the other hand, what was great about those the local newspapers and local T V stations, newsrooms in the past was that there was a sort of editorial like the good and the bad was there's a sort of editorial control there to where it sort of kept things in line, but it also did editorialized, usually along a more like corporatist point of view. Whereas now, I don't know what the reality of it is in the grand schema thing is that we have a lot of creators out there reporting on the news and I have my Instagram feed is full of people doing local news of what's going on in San Diego whether they are people that are chasing down ice fans and recording it as they go or people that are actually reporting on news stories here in San Diego just as an independent person just decided to do this on Instagram, you know? or tick TikTok and Substack, all these platforms. what's your sense of like to what degree those are filling in the gap and how effective that is? And what's your optimism about that, if any? Karim Bouris (he/him): not much. you know, so if we start with the merger between CBS Skydance and Paramount's merger and then Nathan Young: Mm, mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): the owners of that new company now buying CBS. I'm gonna start with legacy media, these brands Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): that are known for like the journalistic integrity that we think of, right? The New York Times, the Washington Post, CBS, things like that. So who bought? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Who was behind the Sky Dance Paramount merger that eventually bought CBS? It's David Ellison, who's the son of Oracle's Larry Ellison. Those are the people who are very proud Zionists. The fourth richest man on the world is behind that merger, and he is putting people who have the same ideology about what our role is in the Middle East and who we should support behind that. So you think about this guy. What is his next purchase? TikTok. Nathan Young: Yeah, okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Right. So we were worried about the Chinese controlling our thoughts. And now it's David Ellison who put Barry Weiss of the former what was it, the free press, free press, who's now in charge of CBS evening news, like you know, Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): what is it, sixteen minutes? I mean this like the lunacy of the what we see happening in the standard Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): bearing of journalistic integrity Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): is really funny to me. But Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): so when you're asking me, do I have hope? Sure. But for fleeting moments, because the moment they see, they know that if something is working, they have to do something against it. I mean that you know you're doing something right when they start doing laws or organizing themselves to take it away from you. That's kind of a good line. So TikTok was doing Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): something good because it was giving creators it was beating the algorithm somehow, and they didn't like that. So now we get a Fourth richest man in the world to say, no, I can do something about that to control the narrative. So Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): how much does it take to keep building to break through Elon Musk and X, Ellison and the Ellison's and Twitter? How many new platforms can we create that can compete with that when they're trying to control the algorithm? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): And the algorithm is not easy to compete with. So the opposition is organizing their money. Really, really, really well. I mean, I'm back to the propaganda that manages to keep us frozen on the Israel-Gaza situation, like genocide Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): that is happening now. That influencers are being paid $7,000 per post Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): to put pro-Israel content out there. Who's Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): competing with that? Community-based organizations that are trying to organize to bring human aid? and maybe do something to improve human conditions on the ground, they're not trying to raise it, they're not competing at that level. So I'm worried when we talk about the ecosystem of social media, because for every shining light, and so far so good, because it you are right. I'm saying all this, Nathan, and you are still right in that the only silver lining in the last almost three years of the genocide in Gaza. And what is happening in the West Bank on Palestine, what's been extending to where I was born in Lebanon is that the intention to control the technology is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): there. But social media has been the only silver lining that has managed to break through the control of the media market that we are in. But they're also doing things specifically right now with AI to regain that control and Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): it's an arms race of sorts that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): those of us on the front lines for advocacy, for human rights and civil rights, we just don't have the backing and the corporate and financial backing that those that want to control the the narrative do. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. And I take your point very explicitly too, like there's those three companies that own all the T V stations while there's like three people that own all the social media. So they could turn on and off the faucet as they off the faucet as they want. no, you're right. And that's an interesting what you're saying. So you're pivoting to what we said we're gonna talk about was a lot of like Israel Palestine and Yeah, it's like the media that's come out of there like it is interesting how there has been an awakening of just how bad the situation has been for the Palestinians for a long time and it's something I've always been aware of and it's kinda come and gone as I mean I'm I'm just gonna like put disclaimer now. I'm gonna talk about this probably l like rather flippantly for some so Karim Bouris (he/him): Okay, it's okay. Nathan Young: but like it's sort of come and gone as like a cause celebre amongst, more quote unquote left leaning ideologies. And relative to whatever else is going on in the world. And it is wild just seeing it all laid bare now, just how brutal Israel has been willing to be Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: with the Palestinians, like, yeah, especially with the world watching too. But then again, maybe the world isn't really watching. Maybe maybe, I'm watching, you're watching, the other parts of the world aren't seeing this at all. And, that's Maybe people aren't watching. So yeah, I Karim Bouris (he/him): You know, one I've been doing public presentations in my little neck of the woods to like local amnesty international groups or a church that wants to understand more. and one of the things that I talk about bec and why I speak a fair amount about PR and propaganda and is there's a word in Hebrew that's Hasbara and it's a word that basically just translates to explanation, but Hasbara is the state of Israel's sanctioned public diplomacy technique. And it's really it's just propaganda by another name. the budget that they keep pumping into it just grows, and especially their efforts in the US media market. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): So an example of how that information comes up to me is how are we stuck in this moment? public opinion in America is what you're describing. Right? And if you look at it on the left, so on the Democrat side, there is overwhelming over seventy five percent, seventy-seven percent of Democrats don't align with what Israel is doing to Palestinians in Gaza and in the West Bank, and now again in Lebanon and Iran and this kind of like expansion of wars left and right, and do not want our government to support it. So almost eight in ten. And if you look at the right, on the Republican side now, in the last poll by the Pew Research Center that I saw, and that was in March, so it was about a year ago, but the largest swing in two years on a three-year window that they've seen on any topic among Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Republicans is the position on Israel. We had went from in 63% of Republicans being supportive of Israel. and those are Republicans under 50, under the age Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): of 50, to now less than 50% have a positive view. No other topic has swung Republicans under the age of 50 as much Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): than the what Israel is doing. Granted, we're not gonna fool ourselves that there's not an undercurrent of now I have an open way to talk about my anti-Semitism. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm mm yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Maybe. But still, we have an alignment where the policy decision we're asking our government to make is don't keep supporting this. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): yet, whether it's on the Dems side or on the Republican side, they keep voting repeatedly to support that. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): we here we find ourselves three years later of what has been unquestionably by any way that we consider the old the rule of law in the world, the International Court of Justice. The over 500 genocide scholars who say this is a genocide, we sim we still sell weapons and we call it aid, by the way. We call it aid. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): We don't say this is weapon sales. It is aid to Israel. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): So how is it that we have our public opinion asking us to do one thing and our elected officials doing the exact opposite repeatedly? And Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): that is what keeps me up at night and frustrates us who are in this space. And Why is it that we keep supporting that and asking for for change and they don't do that? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): it's really frustrating. Nathan Young: Yeah. No, that is I take all your points there. Especially it's interesting how Israel has been sort of carved out as this sort of exceptional partner in the world. And I think it's been so ingrained in the culture that so many of us have grown up in that like it's one, it's always a little bit like fraught to go into this because yeah, it does like You can be accused of like anti Semitism just for being like, I think Israel went too far, or we shouldn't be sending so many weapons to Israel. but it is interesting how like, relative to other countries in the world, like they almost get sort of treated like the fourth most important state, like, New York, California, Texas, Israel. and there's no other countries in the world that we have that kind of level of partnership with. not even like England who is probably the number two, right? Or Canada or Mexico, so that's always like yeah, when you stop to think about it, that's kind of fascinating, just like right there and right there. And I'll stick your point about there has been this sort of sustained just Israel has always been sort of framed as the good guys in this and there's this sort of nobility of giving Jews a homeland and again, I'm not gonna argue with that, Yeah, I've always been like, Okay, sure. but now we're seeing this is that came at the expense of other people and as somebody that doesn't necessarily have an emotional stake in it, I'm just watching all this being like, These are groups killing each other. Israel's got so much more power in this dynamic than the Palestinians. And so that's just the repression and the firepower and cruelty that comes to bear is a whole other level. even assuming is that like the Palestinians are wanting to fight back on the same level. And again, sorry, I'm talking so flippantly about this thing that I'm sure you have a much more emotional stake in. But to take your point too, where they're like they're I forget the one that you used, but I was just sort of tripped out how Palestinian or Gaza fighters were called terrorists, whereas like Karim Bouris (he/him): Uh-huh. Nathan Young: Israeli soldiers are called like soldiers and they're dropping Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: bombs from afar and somehow that's more noble than like, actually like coming across the fence and fighting there and again and how that's much more noble or just to do it that way, or much more civilized to do it that way. And how, the Israeli prisoners in Gaza were hostages, how Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: the Gazan prisoners in Israel in Israel were prisoners Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: yeah, and just the use of language of you're even like the way things like Palestinians were sort of passively dying because Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: bombs just happen to be falling on them for some reason, as opposed to like this Palestinian killed this person, killed this Israeli person. And just that sort of subtle choice of language, but it's pervasive and it's everywhere and it's every single time. And it is just a very, very subtle propaganda. And To go back to bringing this full circle, that courage point, I think part of the tension is this has been so ingrained in so many newsrooms for decades that bringing up the courage to be like, nah, let's actually like say what Israel's doing here, or put just the actions of Israel in the same language that we use for the actions of Hamas or Hezbollah or what you know, what we term terrorist groups and use that same language for them and see how that comes across. But that's just not happening in our news media at all. Karim Bouris (he/him): it's not. I'm biting my tongue because again there is a symmetry. With one of the beautiful things is just listening to you when you said something like, they're killing each other. there is no symmetry. There is no comparison in numbers in any way. If you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): look at the number of Palestinian lives lost compared to Israeli lives lost. Nathan Young: Totally. Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): and the words matter to us because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): what is absent from that framing is the conditions are on it. Israel is occupying, is considered an occupying force. And the Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Palestinians, according to international law, have the right to resistance. Right? They are in their land. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): and so there's that. And so this word of resistance, we love in America to talk about and then we'll talk about Luke Skywalker and the the the rebellion, right? And that's good. That resistance Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): is good. But when we look at what we're doing around in Palestine, we kind of are afraid of using the word resistance. But let's look at what Palestinians have done for decades. And I'm talking since the thirties, since Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): the British mandates, when we have not had a land with our own government since the Ottoman Empire, the British came and then handed us off to after the 1916, when the Ottoman Empire ended, the French and the Brits, who were loving to take over the world and create some boundaries around stuff, said, Cool, this is mine, this is yours. This the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Sykes-Picot Act. But since the thirties, Palestinians have tried every form of resistance. Diplomatic resistance. We've gone through peace processes. We've accepted that partition plan. We've engaged with the UN and other international bodies. We appeal to Every legal framework that is available to us. That resistance has been met with what? Ignorance, delays, and then basically bought time for Israel to do what they're doing now, which is to illegally occupy and build illegal settlements on Palestinian land. So we Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): tried diplomatic resistance. That's not going anywhere. We've tried non-violent resistance, hunger strikes in Israeli prisons, work strikes, civil disobedience. Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): What's that met with? Force, imprisonment, deliberate Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): disruption, destruction of any kind of civil institution for Palestinians. We've tried intellectual and artistic resistance as Palestinians. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): do you know that Israeli government, the occupying force on the West Bank banned the Palestinian flag? So what do we Palestinians Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): do? We say, cool, we'll paid watermelons because it's the same colors that right? It's the red, the black, The green and the white. So then the watermelon becomes our form of resistance because we can't put our own flag up there. So this notion that resistance, the word being used to describe it, and just just shortcut and and overlook any of that is terrorism. And we use Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): what? We use a group that is trying the only means available to them. Occupy people Have the right to resist occupation. That is not Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): a French position. That is the foundational international law and international order that the United States claims to uphold. Again, we say it, but we keep supporting those that break that notion. So, you know, it's the word resistance for me matters when we talk about Palestine. And it really is crazy making How those of the left in America, even those that are pro-Palestine, that want to see this change, still tiptoe around those words about using words like everything I just said in today, Zionism, occupation, resistance. Like there's this, unless you are in the movement, most kind of like, you know, Dems are like, maybe we're Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): gonna try and find a safer word than those things you say. Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah, totally. I mean and I'll speak for myself here too. It's just sort of like again, as a person that doesn't necessarily have an emotional stake in it, but just sort of wants to see people as people, but you know, it is like For example, this will come out quite a few weeks after the moment, but like even just a couple like just the other day, like Zohran Mamdani called Benjamin Netanyahu a war criminal. And a pretty like, you know, left of center podcast I listened to were like, No, I don't like that like anti-Semitism in that. And it's like, that's not anti Semitic. he's a war criminal. and so one is just getting a label and it says it's sort of like here's just the truth of it. I'm gonna say it very bluntly. It makes it uncomfortable with like Jewish friends. And then you're sort of put in this position of like, well, which are my put Jewish friends uncomfortable or Palestinian friends uncomfortable? and as a person in my position, it becomes a sort of like I don't know what to do. And in the meantime, I'm just gonna like not say a whole heck of a lot. Or Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: you know, or just feel like I have to like watch my words a little bit more and On one hand, I feel like I have to a certain degree been pretty outspoken because this is you know, right from the get-go, it's like, no, this is like this isn't good and this is a genocide. and I almost say that with the care of like the Israeli people in mind because they've just been signed up for another like fifty years of war, you know? Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: from the actions of like Israel in the last two years. I don't know what the notion of people in Israel are, but I'm sure that they would rather I don't know, I feel there are seem to be some very bloodthirsty people in Israel, but I think there's a lot of people that would like want to have peace and like yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): I'm sad to say that and I could pull up if I had known I would have pulled it up, but public opinion in Israel is Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): very much in favor of what is happening right now. So this Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm. Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): notion that our ally is the only democracy in the Middle East is is false. Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): the majority of Israelis and again I'm not talking about Jewish people in America, I'm talking about Israeli people in Israel. Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Are okay living their life and over 80% condone what is happening and the actions of their government in Gaza. Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): So we keep acting as if the good guy in this story is our ally when our ally Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): is the only nuclear power bully in the region. Nathan Young: Totally. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): And so, you know, I heard a comedian Bassem Youssef. Egyptian comedians say it this way early when this started. He's like, when you see your friend have a drinking problem and Nathan Young: Mm. Yes. Karim Bouris (he/him): and routinely get behind the wheel drunk, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): you probably have an intervention when they get into fights or drive drunk. If your friend has a problem, you intervene. In this case, Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): his joke was your friend Israel has a war problem, has a violence problem, has a occupation problem, has an end an apartheid problem. Maybe Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): we should intervene to help say this is not the civil institutions that we are investing in to call you an ally of American democracy. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm mm. Yeah, totally. Karim Bouris (he/him): so for any friends who are Jewish in America, my only question is do you separate anti Semitism is real and it has Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): been alive and well in America and in the U Western world for centuries. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): What is happening right now is not about anti Semitism, it's about the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Political ideology of Zionism that is at the core of the foundation of Israel, the state. Big difference between Zionism and Judaism. And it's Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): the conflation of the two that make it so that you're afraid of saying one because the other word comes in, it's like, well, then if you're anti-the government of Israel's and what they're doing, then you hate Jews. I'm like, that has nothing to do with these. Nathan Young: Mm, mm-hmm. No, it's not the no. Karim Bouris (he/him): And maybe the other part that gets to me, and that's because I am Arab. But the let's bring the other side into this too, right? Because we're afraid about anti Semitism and what's been going on with anti Arab and anti Muslim hate in America. Nathan Young: Yeah, exactly. We just don't have a a sna a snazzy word for it. Karim Bouris (he/him): We don't and we don't have because do you know the FBI did not start the federal tracking of anti Muslim and anti Arab hate crime since twenty fifteen. So twenty years there was a big twenty year window when that was not even recorded and captured as a number. So The Council on American Islamic Relations CARE Nathan Young: Yeah, Karim Bouris (he/him): documented that since the first half of twenty twenty four, so in the last two years, there's been a seventy percent rise in anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian incident. So if you think about that six year old kid in Illinois who was stabbed, like that's what happens when we don't count people, when we we just prioritize the well-being of one group and not mention the other. And that's why I'm Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): saying it is this knee-jerk reaction that if I don't give equal airtime to the plight Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): and the pain of Jewish people, I'm prioritizing Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): my people who are literally erased and ignored physically, intellectually, and in stories. So Nathan Young: Mm, mm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): the comparison here is that we can't it's not raw numbers. There are significantly more Jewish people in America. So if we just looked at the numbers, of course there's significantly more hate crimes against Jewish people. We're a much Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): smaller population. But if you look at the trends and the percentages, why aren't Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): we talking about it? Because it is happening way more on my side of my people's equation than it is on the Jewish side right now. But Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): I'm asked to do this kind of two sidesism that, well, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): I see your pain and can we look at my people's pain and the Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): shit we've got to be enduring right now? Because we can't even count. So We're barely counting. So it's my advocate hat on here, strong, that if you're wanna make that argument that there's anti Semitism, it's like, sure, let's deal with anti Semitism. You wanna deal Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): with anti Semitism, watch what the Trump administration is doing, right? Because that is Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): not good for any religion at this point that is not white Christian, in America. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah. Well and it's it's okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): Boy, I went I went I went off on this one. I have I have some thoughts here. It's the same climate, right? I can this is what I wanna say. Both sides are living in a climate of fear. Whether you are a Jewish person or you are a Muslim person or an Arab person, there is an undercurrent of fear that we have to live with right now for the last few years and we can't let go of. So that's why I am so intent on not just naming one without mentioning the other. Because right now, you may not like it if you're Jewish to say, well, why are they getting the attention? But I also don't want it to just be about anti Semitism without us talking about Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): anti-Arab hate right now. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Definitely. That what do you say that all really stood out to me like last year when there was the protest or like two years ago when there's a protest on college campuses and the way that it even just the way it was phrased too, like they're like these anti Israel pro Palestinian protesters Karim Bouris (he/him): Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: and they're chanting from the river to the sea or whatever, like I don't know, I've you know heard Israeli people chant from the river to the sea too and nobody's criticizing them. But also it's like, a lot of them are like, I'm not necessarily anti-Israel and I'm not necessarily pro Palestine in a way. I'm just like, these are people that all these people deserve to live. And I'm anti Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: genocide. That's my point. I don't have a solution for the bigger problem, but you can't be committing a genocide in there. I don't know. I feel I'm sorry. I worry that I'm like just sticking my foot in the mouth and I know this is probably like a sensitive topic for you, but like I it's Karim Bouris (he/him): No, I don't know. It's it's it's it's not. It's there are a couple of things that the chess master Gary Kasparov said. and he said that the goal of propaganda is to exhaust your critical thinking so that it could annihilate truth. So if that's true, right, then Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): there's a he also said he said you don't get to choose which part of the machine to fight. It's the same machine. Nathan Young: Mm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Right? So to me those are Just soundbites and that I keep in my mind that if you are anti-war, if you consider yourself a peacenick, if you consider yourself a human rights activist, then you don't get to pick one set of crimes and say that's bad, and then try to put conditions and maybe just temper why another one is. The moment you see that over 20,000 children have been killed. Nathan Young: Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): In whatever whatever sanitized word you want to call what's going on, like conflict, doesn't want to hate the most. That is no two sides on this one. There is Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): one side dropping 2,000-pound bombs on tents and killing not just children, but using them as target practice. And that is documented, fact by Doctors Without Borders, Amnesty International, Oxfam. So even if you don't believe or trust Government institutions. You also don't want to trust NGOs that have been doing this for 60 years, the International Rescue Committee. I mean, how many times do you need to ignore facts? It's because it's uncomfortable. So back to courage, right? Back to courage. It's that allowance of discomfort that I'm asking for people to have in this moment. It is not Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): easy. So yeah, thanks for being at least honest and courage about saying that out loud, because there is I want you to not be afraid of saying that, right? There's the until Your line is clear that the level of violence and destruction and pain being brought by one side, Israel on the other, just crosses your ethical line. So your Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): value set as a progressive is consistent when you get to say that, period, without equivocation, without caveats. And I thank you for that. So I'm just gonna keep encouraging you, don't censor your words because everything you've said right now is good. And the moment you start worrying about how it's gonna be heard Is where you start filtering more. So don't worry, your value set Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): is good. You're progressive. Hold your line. It is good, Nathan. Nathan Young: Okay. Well thank you. but I will say I think the challenge more is that line the Kasparov line you just gave, like my courage is running up against that exhaustion and me just trying to make sure that I'm speaking the truth and I've got the facts and I know what I'm talking about because yeah I do realize I am being propagandized on all sorts of levels too. I don't assume that just 'cause I see like some things do you see through your little phone screen and it seems unrefutable. But I want to be sort of judicious and not just assume every single thing. And so as I do be like, okay, well is that really as bad as it looks? 'Cause it looks really, really bad. Yeah. And not just jump there, but Yeah, and that's sort of where the exhaustion comes in and that courage meeting the exhaustion. So yeah. Thank you though. I appreciate thank you. I appreciate that. Karim Bouris (he/him): No, sometimes there's a moment where you can just say I see these kinds of images a lot. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): And at some point, there's only so much fake AI powered content that can be this consistent. Well Nathan Young: Yes. Yes. Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): So the other part that's back to the who controls the story, it is not an innocent fact that over two hundred Palestinian journalists have been deliberately killed. Because Nathan Young: Yep, totally. Karim Bouris (he/him): CNN, ABC, they don't have ground crews on the ground. Israel has prevented, because they control and lock the borders, any Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): foreign media from being on the ground to dip report in. So the only way that again our legacy media reports back is through they have to get their stories approved through the censorship office, which is under the umbrella of the International the Israeli Defense Forces, the Army. That is propaganda again. So Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): Your social media is the only way that these independent journalists who work for outlets like Al Kudz, Al Jazeera, there are other outlets in the world aside from America Media that have the same journalistic standards, that have the same kind of way of reporting objectively. And when they are the only ones on the ground and they are being killed at the rate they have been more in the five plus years that There's been a war in Ukraine. We have had less than I think about 20 journalists killed and killed in five years. In Gaza? In Ukraine. Thank you. Thank you. Right? Twenty, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. In Ukraine. Yeah, yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): I think it's twenty in five plus years versus over two hundred in Nathan Young: Yeah, Karim Bouris (he/him): two years in Palestine. it's not a coincidence. It is intentional To remove those who are giving you the images and break through the algorithm to make it to you. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well I feel we had a positive note. I want to say one more thing and then but we could talk all day of this. We'd probably wrap this up here 'cause I think all this stuff is valuable though too to realize and I just hope that people listening to this are conscientious of the news that they're getting and where it's coming from and just to know that like I don't know. I hear so much talk about like, the news should be impartial or something. It's like there's no such thing, you know. there's it at least be like upfront where their partiality lies is what we hope for from the news. and even that isn't done very well all the time, but you know. Karim Bouris (he/him): I would say if there's any call to action for anybody who's made it this far in our conversation is follow, Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): follow one new Palestinian news person. Assal Rad, there are others on the ground. They're not hard to find. If you literally Google, you will see there because they have a lot of followers and they're reporting every day. So the only thing I remind folks when I talk about this is that the people in power They are counting on two things. They're counting on our fatigue and our silence. Right? And fatigue, they can wait out, but silence, they can legislate. And I just ask people, don't give them either. Keep trying, it doesn't matter, but every day, keep reading, don't ignore it, and keep trying. You can take an action. Something else that Michelle from the Courage Studio said in the course I took. It was again on that this courage. And Michelle Told a story when she was a young activist who at some point had to pay her bills and she took a job, a corporate gig. And she was feeling so guilty about it that she talked to her mentor at the time as a Filipino queer activist, Kalaya'an Mendoza. And he told her to reassure her about just not giving up, not being a sellout. He said the front line isn't just on the streets. The front line is where wherever you are doing the work. And that matters to me because the silence and the freeze is what they're counting on. And I'm just asking folks to not keep scrolling through if it's uncomfortable and to just remember that it doesn't matter what you do, but if you do something, it's better than nothing. Nathan Young: Yeah. Okay. we're calling it right there. We're wrapping up right here. Yeah. Karim Bouris (he/him): Thanks, Nathan. Nathan Young: So okay. people that wanna get in touch with you, know more about you, follow along, where where can they find you? Karim Bouris (he/him): I would just say go to Mixte Communications. Gomixte.com. There should be a pop-up. You can sign up for a newsletter. I'm easily findable on the website. and yeah, and if they want to take one action, because I will not close with that one action, there is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Karim Bouris (he/him): just call. there's a bill called Block the Bombs Act. I think if you go to block the bombs.org. And that is, I am asking that we say no more of our tax dollars To transfer arms to Israel so that they can bomb my people in Palestine and in Lebanon. That's it. So there's one action, block the bombs.org and just say no. I won't don't want Nathan Young: Okay. Karim Bouris (he/him): that to be what Nathan Young: Okay. that might get decided one way or the other by the time this gets out, but we'll see. all Karim Bouris (he/him): Yeah. Nathan Young: right. Well, Karim Bouris, thank you so much for being on the pod. I really appreciate it. Karim Bouris (he/him): Thanks for having me, Nathan. It's always a pleasure to talk with you. Yeah, take it easy. Nathan Young: Yeah, you two man. All right, take care. All right. Thank you so much for Karim Bouris. for joining us here on the podcast. one idea I keep coming back to is Karim's definition of courage, simply as being willing to take a risk, but as acting beyond the edge of our comfort for something that genuinely matters to us. And maybe even more importantly is his argument that courage doesn't have to be something that we do alone. Sometimes the most courageous thing we can build in the community is the infrastructure that allows others to be able to step up and take that risk too. So if this conversation made you think differently, just gave you something to think about, I encourage you to share it with someone else who you think might find it useful. And if you want to follow Karim's work, you can find him through Mixte Communications at go mixte.com. That's G-O-M-I-X-T-E dot com, where they also have a newsletter you can subscribe to. put information about all this stuff in the show notes as well. And with that, thank you for listening to Braver New Worlds. Really appreciate it. And we'll see you with the next one.