Latest / The NanceCast / OOPE (Object Oriented Podcast Episode)
Transcript
- 0:13all right and we're going um fuck it continue we'll do an
- 0:17introduction later
- 0:18SPEAKER_00: hypostition hypostition yeah so I was saying I was wondering if um
- 0:27the way I've been using these terms comports with the way you
- 0:30guys are or not
- 0:32because the way I was thinking about it is like there's a way
- 0:36of seeing like we are
- 0:37our being is hypostatic so like there's a way of of seeing the
- 0:43self in which the
- 0:44self dissolves and like the Buddhists will point this out that
- 0:48like there's a way
- 0:49in which you don't exist and I'm like I totally agree for like
- 0:53spirit reasons of
- 0:54SPEAKER_00: like
- 0:55a spiritual exercise in expanding one's consciousness it's
- 0:59important to like pay
- 1:01attention to the element of the truth of reality wherein we
- 1:06don't exist but there's
- 1:09also this sense in which like that could become really
- 1:11nihilistic because yeah
- 1:15there's a sense in which you don't exist but there's a sense in
- 1:17which you do exist
- 1:19and so like we posit ourselves as existing is what I was
- 1:23meaning by the term
- 1:25hypostatic so I don't know if that jives with the way you guys
- 1:31are or it is totally
- 1:33different from the way you guys are using that term hypostition
- 1:38is a play on like a
- 1:42play on hyperstition which is a play on superstition which has
- 1:46to do with like
- 1:48uh beliefs and stuff whereas hypostasis and hypostatic like
- 1:54that's that's more like
- 1:56an actual uh state stasis ecstasis metastatic uh so like I
- 2:04think that right there
- 2:05yeah it is a difference like I think hypostasis the way you use
- 2:10it I think it it's
- 2:11SPEAKER_03: appropriate and I think um
- 2:14SPEAKER_03: We are some kind of hypostatic thing.
- 2:19SPEAKER_03: I think we're also super positional.
- 2:25SPEAKER_03: We're not this one thing.
- 2:30SPEAKER_03: We're not this other thing.
- 2:31SPEAKER_03: We're both and neither at the same time.
- 2:34SPEAKER_03: It's the interplay between the two that is constitutive.
- 2:38SPEAKER_03: I think hypostatic
- 2:43it's different because like hypostitian is explicitly a play on
- 2:52hypostitian not but
- 2:55the term hypostatic it has a long history like it goes back
- 2:59like in theology like
- 3:00hundreds and hundreds of years and so there's like and there's
- 3:04a way that other
- 3:05SPEAKER_00: philosophers have picked up the term and so I didn't know if like
- 3:10SPEAKER_00: I'm using it in my own way.
- 3:12SPEAKER_00: It's been used in many different other ways.
- 3:14SPEAKER_00: And then there's the way you guys are using it.
- 3:16Which maybe you could just elaborate on what you and Mikey were
- 3:20talking about right
- 3:21SPEAKER_00: before we started recording on how you guys are using it.
- 3:26So hypostitian,
- 3:28again,
- 3:29I think it's totally disconnected from hypostatic,
- 3:34hypostasis.
- 3:34SPEAKER_02: Hold on, maybe should we start with hype?
- 3:37SPEAKER_02: Let's do your three.
- 3:39Hyperstition Thank you CCRU 1990s Rave Music Methamphetamine
- 3:50Computers Lemurs
- 3:54Hyperstition It was a play on Superstition Well fuck it let's
- 4:00go to Superstition
- 4:00SPEAKER_03: Superstition is like Throw the salt over your shoulder Or knock on wood
- 4:07SPEAKER_03: um or you know these these things that I think really do satisfy
- 4:14SPEAKER_03: Something in us libidinally,
- 4:17SPEAKER_03: like there's a surplus,
- 4:20SPEAKER_03: there's a nagging feeling that we have,
- 4:23SPEAKER_03: and maybe it's,
- 4:24SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 4:24SPEAKER_03: trained into us with religion,
- 4:26SPEAKER_03: or maybe it's trained into us because religion is never satisfying,
- 4:31SPEAKER_03: and so we start seeking other cosmic justifications or whatever,
- 4:34SPEAKER_03: but superstitions are these harmless beliefs.
- 4:37SPEAKER_03: You see a black cat
- 4:39SPEAKER_03: and you think you're going to have bad luck.
- 4:41SPEAKER_03: You break a mirror.
- 4:42SPEAKER_03: You think you're going to have bad luck.
- 4:43SPEAKER_03: You see a penny on the floor.
- 4:45SPEAKER_03: If it's heads up, you think you're going to have good luck.
- 4:47SPEAKER_03: And so on and so on.
- 4:49I think it's a holdover from pre-modern times when the world
- 4:53really was magical.
- 4:55SPEAKER_03: That went away.
- 4:56SPEAKER_03: And so we all have these little superstitions.
- 4:58CCRU was using the term hyperstition as a play on superstition
- 5:06to talk about beliefs,
- 5:10um that are unjustified and unjustifiable and also fictions
- 5:15that make themselves
- 5:16real so there's all these examples uh in science fiction Star
- 5:20Trek William Gibson
- 5:23SPEAKER_03: um where you have people writing about something in fiction um and then a
- 5:29SPEAKER_02: neuromancer might be a great example of that
- 5:33Neuromancer Neil Stevenson the term metaverse is in Neil
- 5:39Stevenson's novel Snow
- 5:40Crash that came out in the early 90s and then like 30 years
- 5:43later Facebook and all
- 5:45that they're like join the metaverse or Star Trek the
- 5:51communicators or the Jetsons
- 5:53with the self-driving cars and the self-operating robot vacuums
- 5:57and all this stuff
- 5:58SPEAKER_03: there's all these examples in science fiction
- 6:03SPEAKER_03: Where it seems to be people who are
- 6:05writing fiction can see something in the future uh what really
- 6:09happens a lot of the
- 6:11time is people in science and tech and engineering are inspired
- 6:16by science fiction
- 6:17and so they say that looks cool I want that so like the Star
- 6:19Trek communicators
- 6:21were a direct inspiration for the Nokia flip phone because the
- 6:24people who designed
- 6:25the Nokia flip phone were fans of Star Trek the original series
- 6:29um a lot of the
- 6:31SPEAKER_02: shit we see with the internet you called this micro cultural like uh
- 6:35SPEAKER_02: We can call them microcultural interventions.
- 6:39um but hyperstition broadly applied it's a fiction that makes
- 6:44itself true so if you
- 6:47want to be a hyperstitional activist or if you want to engage
- 6:50in hyperstitional
- 6:51praxis in the real world and another person I love to point to
- 6:56is Elizabeth Holmes
- 6:57to talk about hyperstition because she's a recent example she's
- 7:01somewhat culturally
- 7:02relevant and resonates with people although there are a lot of
- 7:04people who don't
- 7:05SPEAKER_03: know who the fuck she is but she was the Theranos lady
- 7:09Who basically tried to be Steve Jobs She wore the black
- 7:15turtleneck and she had
- 7:17weird verbal tics and affectations and stuff But she fleeced
- 7:22people for like 10
- 7:23billion dollars by claiming that she had a magical blood
- 7:27testing machine that could
- 7:29SPEAKER_03: take one drop of blood and screen for all these types of diseases
- 7:35SPEAKER_03: And it just worked.
- 7:37What was really going on behind the scenes was she was taking
- 7:40people's blood.
- 7:41SPEAKER_03: She was having it tested at all these other labs.
- 7:44SPEAKER_03: And then she was presenting them with the results.
- 7:46So she was kind of doing like a pay no attention to the man
- 7:48behind the curtain.
- 7:52SPEAKER_03: Yeah, the reason she was doing it, it's not because she was a grifter.
- 7:55SPEAKER_03: It's not because she was an evil tech lady.
- 7:57SPEAKER_03: She genuinely believed that this technology was possible.
- 8:02And she genuinely believed that if she could follow a certain
- 8:05prescribed set of
- 8:06actions she could actualize this piece of technology so for her
- 8:11this virtual piece
- 8:13SPEAKER_03: of technology
- 8:15Was the justification for the lies she told and the billions of
- 8:19dollars that she stole?
- 8:20Oh,
- 8:20so was it basically like the going around getting blood tests
- 8:26on all these different labs?
- 8:27Was that basically her stopgap measure while she's developing
- 8:31the technology?
- 8:32SPEAKER_00: Like I have to cover my ass and that's fucking crazy.
- 8:35SPEAKER_00: But that's the logic that we're in.
- 8:38SPEAKER_00: That's the fucking logic of the economy.
- 8:41SPEAKER_00: It's like you have to be in the future.
- 8:43SPEAKER_03: Look at Uber.
- 8:45SPEAKER_03: Look at all the AI platforms right now.
- 8:47SPEAKER_03: They're leaking money.
- 8:48SPEAKER_03: They're not making profits.
- 8:50SPEAKER_03: Uber was not profitable for over a decade.
- 8:54SPEAKER_03: But because the people behind it believed that it was the new paradigm,
- 8:59they kept sinking money into it and they kept convincing other
- 9:02people to sink money
- 9:03SPEAKER_03: into it until it became an act.
- 9:06SPEAKER_03: It became an economic act.
- 9:08SPEAKER_03: It reconciled.
- 9:09Recast the world so that no longer the traditional taxi service
- 9:13and the traditional
- 9:14SPEAKER_03: car hire service,
- 9:16SPEAKER_03: that's no longer viable.
- 9:17Like the only place that has a strong taxi economy is London
- 9:22probably because they
- 9:23SPEAKER_03: have the black cabs and that's like an institution.
- 9:26SPEAKER_03: But they lost billions of dollars.
- 9:30But they were successful It's the same kind of thing It's the
- 9:34way the market works
- 9:35It's speculation It's betting on futures Why is NVIDIA stock
- 9:41Why did NVIDIA stock
- 9:42go up a thousand percent I think like two and a half years ago
- 9:46Because it was all
- 9:47SPEAKER_03: speculation Nothing changed materially Nothing real happened
- 9:51SPEAKER_03: But it was people speculating on futures that caused,
- 9:55SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 9:56if you had $100 worth of Nvidia stock three years ago and you
- 10:00held on to it,
- 10:01SPEAKER_03: overnight,
- 10:02SPEAKER_03: essentially,
- 10:03SPEAKER_03: that $100 became $1,000.
- 10:05SPEAKER_03: Like, that's the way the stock market works.
- 10:08SPEAKER_03: That's the way capitalism works.
- 10:09SPEAKER_03: That is hyperstition.
- 10:10SPEAKER_03: Like, exchange value, well, financial value is hyperstition itself.
- 10:18SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 10:19SPEAKER_03: And it's fictional.
- 10:20SPEAKER_00: The economy is, like,
- 10:22Yeah yeah the economy is so fast the churn is so quick that
- 10:25like you have to write
- 10:27into existence yes like the science fiction into existence like
- 10:32you are both the
- 10:33science fiction author and the capitalist yeah at the same time
- 10:38it's like that's
- 10:38how fast if you're not doing that then you're you're not a
- 10:41capitalist yeah yeah um
- 10:44SPEAKER_00: and that's the hyperstition right yeah
- 10:47SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 10:47SPEAKER_03: hyperstition,
- 10:48SPEAKER_03: it's the fiction that makes itself real,
- 10:50SPEAKER_03: and we see it at the level of the economy.
- 10:53SPEAKER_03: We all know money's fake.
- 10:54SPEAKER_03: We all know this thing, exchange value's fake.
- 10:56SPEAKER_03: However, it's the most real thing in the world.
- 10:58SPEAKER_03: It's what keeps us from achieving our dreams.
- 11:03SPEAKER_03: It's what keeps you from taking vacations.
- 11:08SPEAKER_03: It's the most real thing in the world,
- 11:10SPEAKER_03: but it's also fake,
- 11:11SPEAKER_03: and we all know it's fake,
- 11:12SPEAKER_03: and we have no choice but to play along with it.
- 11:15SPEAKER_00: And we see it...
- 11:18Oh so don't you think like what I was trying to say with like
- 11:22hypostasis is I think
- 11:23like we are a fiction which makes ourselves real like I think
- 11:27that's how like that
- 11:29is our identity is like we are a fiction and we're like sort of
- 11:32performing that
- 11:32SPEAKER_00: fiction projecting ourselves into like I've been here
- 11:37I've been here like so many years I'm so many years old that
- 11:41means I've been I have
- 11:42been here that long so I'm projecting myself into the past and
- 11:45into the future you
- 11:46know it's like an act it's like actively I'm doing that yeah
- 11:50and I mean I think so
- 11:53SPEAKER_03: again like I think that's a different register
- 11:56I don't know I think that's maybe more more along the lines of
- 12:00maybe like an
- 12:01anthropology or something whereas I think hyperstition fits
- 12:07into a category of
- 12:08SPEAKER_03: philosophy that would be I don't know
- 12:16It's cybernetics for laying in CCRU whereas a lot of what I
- 12:22think what you're
- 12:22talking about Sean I mean we could talk about it as existential
- 12:28or we could talk
- 12:28about it as psychological look like there's an example of a
- 12:33when we talk about
- 12:33SPEAKER_02: hyperstition we're kind of talking about self-fulfilling prophecies but
- 12:38SPEAKER_02: qualifications need to be made there right so imagine
- 12:44You're a student and you are completely convinced that you suck
- 12:49at math and that
- 12:51SPEAKER_02: you just intrinsically are destined to be shitty at math.
- 12:56There's really nothing you can do and no amount of studying
- 13:00will correct this.
- 13:01SPEAKER_02: Okay.
- 13:03SPEAKER_02: That's the idea.
- 13:04SPEAKER_02: That's the belief you're starting with.
- 13:08SPEAKER_02: And because that's the idea,
- 13:12You say fuck it there's no point in studying for the big test
- 13:16because I'm gonna
- 13:18fail anyway and because you don't study you fail the test and
- 13:23then you make the
- 13:24SPEAKER_02: fiction of you being shitty at math into a further reality Right
- 13:28SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah.
- 13:29SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 13:30SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 13:30SPEAKER_02: that's kind of an example,
- 13:31but that's not the type of example land in CCRU we're really
- 13:36interested in.
- 13:36SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 13:37SPEAKER_02: look,
- 13:37the great hyperstitional object for them is capital itself
- 13:42because it is a,
- 13:44SPEAKER_02: quote,
- 13:44SPEAKER_02: fictional quantity to talk like the Luz and Guattari,
- 13:47SPEAKER_02: right?
- 13:48SPEAKER_02: It's a fiction, MCM Prime, all this, right?
- 13:51SPEAKER_02: It's a symbolic fiction in the Zizekian sense, right?
- 13:57but what this virtual mechanism of capital does in the long run
- 14:02according to Landon
- 14:03CCRU is actualize itself in the form of artificial super
- 14:09intelligence so like
- 14:12that's the hyperstitional object par excellence for them which
- 14:18of course is the
- 14:21the great non-human or anti-human object from their perspective
- 14:28so yeah yeah so
- 14:31yeah the term what I was saying hypostition I'm saying like I'm
- 14:36applying that to
- 14:37like the individual and their identity and how they see
- 14:40themselves and project
- 14:41themselves into the world so that's how I was using that word
- 14:44like hyperstition
- 14:45SPEAKER_00: yeah that's a that's a different
- 14:48a different register yeah but hypos Nance like okay so
- 14:52everybody we're talking
- 14:54about these three terms hyperstition obviously is a CCR use and
- 14:58lands but Nance has
- 15:02taken two other terms and developed them in his own thinking
- 15:06and like this is I
- 15:08SPEAKER_02: mean I cannot not think in these terms now too because
- 15:13so hypostition though nance tell me if you agree it's still i
- 15:17mean for us we're not
- 15:19i mean i guess for us we wouldn't mind it you know being
- 15:22applied to the individual
- 15:23but what it is is a hyperstition that undermines itself and
- 15:31this is where like the
- 15:32structure of disavow comes into play which is to say it's a
- 15:35fiction seeking to make
- 15:37SPEAKER_02: itself real and
- 15:39SPEAKER_02: while simultaneously undermining its own realization.
- 15:44SPEAKER_02: So the example that we were talking about before you hopped on here,
- 15:49SPEAKER_02: Sean,
- 15:50SPEAKER_02: was the showrunners of Game of Thrones,
- 15:54SPEAKER_02: right?
- 15:55Okay,
- 15:56they had this incredible show,
- 15:59like one of the most loved and revered shows in TV history.
- 16:04SPEAKER_02: And then they strike a deal with Disney.
- 16:06They're going to be able to make a Star Wars trilogy of their
- 16:10own once Game of
- 16:12SPEAKER_02: Thrones is wrapped up.
- 16:15SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 16:15they get so excited about the idea of making a Star Wars
- 16:20trilogy that they rush the
- 16:27SPEAKER_02: conclusion,
- 16:27SPEAKER_02: the last two series of Game of Thrones.
- 16:31SPEAKER_02: Now,
- 16:32SPEAKER_02: because they botched it so badly,
- 16:34SPEAKER_02: they end up losing the Star Wars trilogy and they didn't get to make it.
- 16:41And so there's a hypostitonal aspect going on here where you're
- 16:47trying to make the
- 16:49SPEAKER_02: fiction of your Star Wars trilogy into a reality,
- 16:52but you go about it in such a way as to undermine the very
- 16:57realization that
- 16:59of the idea that you're trying to realize and so it has nance
- 17:04points out like
- 17:07hypostiction is similar to perversion or disavow because it's
- 17:12like I know very well
- 17:14that what I'm doing is probably gonna fuck things up for me but
- 17:18nevertheless I'm
- 17:20going to keep doing this that's that's kind of what is going on
- 17:24with hypostition
- 17:26a fiction trying to make itself real but doing so in a way that
- 17:30ensures it never
- 17:30becomes real is it the self undermining like the negativity to
- 17:35hyperstition is
- 17:36SPEAKER_00: hypostition
- 17:37SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 17:38SPEAKER_03: and I think the other day,
- 17:39SPEAKER_03: Mikey,
- 17:41SPEAKER_03: you said hypostition is the death drive of hyperstition,
- 17:44SPEAKER_03: and I like putting it that way.
- 17:46SPEAKER_03: I also,
- 17:47just like the quick and dirty way to explain it to people that
- 17:50I found works for me
- 17:51SPEAKER_03: is hyperstition is a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy.
- 17:55SPEAKER_03: Hypostition is a sort of self-defeating prophecy.
- 18:00SPEAKER_03: Right, yeah, so...
- 18:02So you took the hypo because like the prefix means like beneath
- 18:07or under.
- 18:08SPEAKER_03: Yeah, hyper is above, hypo is below.
- 18:10SPEAKER_00: Yeah, so you took it as like an undermining sort of thing.
- 18:14SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 18:16SPEAKER_00: So like I was using it in a completely different way.
- 18:18SPEAKER_00: Well, you're saying hypostasis.
- 18:20SPEAKER_03: I'm saying hypostation.
- 18:22SPEAKER_03: So yeah, they're different terms.
- 18:25SPEAKER_00: Oh, they're just different words.
- 18:26SPEAKER_00: They just sound releases.
- 18:28yeah hypostasis hypostasis is already a word and it's been a
- 18:33word um right and uh
- 18:36hypostation as far as I can tell was not a word until I started
- 18:39using it now I'm
- 18:40sure other people have because it's it's not like the most
- 18:43brilliant creative leap
- 18:44in the world um but it's I think I saw somebody I think
- 18:49somebody else has done
- 18:50something with hypostation I haven't seen anybody do anything
- 18:53with retro station
- 18:55That's the thing and so just to put a cap on this part of the
- 18:57conversation the
- 18:59SPEAKER_03: hyper hypo and retro stitions it's it's this triad
- 19:05SPEAKER_03: And it's, yeah, I think retro station is the most interesting to me.
- 19:11SPEAKER_03: And it's the most pertinent, I think, politically.
- 19:14SPEAKER_03: And where you have hyper station is the fiction that makes itself real.
- 19:19Hypo station is the fiction that remains fiction by way of
- 19:24trying to make itself
- 19:25SPEAKER_03: real,
- 19:26SPEAKER_03: but disavowing the effort to stay fake.
- 19:29Retro-stition is leaving the real entirely and retreating fully
- 19:35into fiction
- 19:36SPEAKER_03: retreating fully into the land of make-believe and I think that's that's
- 19:40politically what's going on and it's linked to neurosis
- 19:46perversion and paranoia
- 19:48that's what I was waiting for you to say hyperstition for Nance
- 19:52and I'll just
- 19:53SPEAKER_02: co-sign this for us hyperstition is neurotic hypostition is perverted
- 19:59Retro-stition is psychotic Well and here's the thing For me
- 20:05it's paranoid it's
- 20:06paranoid it's paranoiac but I don't know if it's explicitly
- 20:10psychotic or if it's
- 20:13SPEAKER_03: some other category that doesn't currently exist.
- 20:15SPEAKER_02: I'll just say, but paranoia is a species of psychosis for Lacan.
- 20:20SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 20:21and the reason I went with calling it paranoid instead of
- 20:25calling it full-on
- 20:25psychotic is because the thing that I want to identify with is
- 20:31in paranoia,
- 20:33SPEAKER_03: you believe in an embodied big other,
- 20:35SPEAKER_03: an actually existing unbarred big other.
- 20:39SPEAKER_03: And that kind of forecloses...
- 20:42SPEAKER_03: Three Billion Nances
- 20:56SPEAKER_03: Explicitly,
- 20:58but it's that we reject this whole chain of signification that
- 21:03results in the big
- 21:05SPEAKER_03: other who doesn't exist.
- 21:07SPEAKER_03: So I think it's an overcomplicated way of talking about psychosis,
- 21:12but for me there's a reason I identify it as like psychotic but
- 21:18not psychotic.
- 21:20we could pin it down even further right because here's the
- 21:22thing if hypostitian is
- 21:26perverted but to be more accurate it's fetishistic in the
- 21:31system fetishistic
- 21:32disavow it's not sadist or masochist and so just as there's
- 21:36different subcategories
- 21:38of perversion we would say in this case hypostitian is
- 21:43fetishist right yeah
- 21:46it's psychotic in the sense of paranoid the paranoid side and
- 21:49then the question put
- 21:52SPEAKER_02: you on the spot see what you think okay we see this neurotic dimension of
- 21:57hyperstition is it obsessional or is it hysterical that's and
- 22:01you know what dude I
- 22:02SPEAKER_03: think I think it can maybe vacillate I think it's probably
- 22:11SPEAKER_03: I mean, it takes an obsessional person to do hyperstitional praxis.
- 22:14SPEAKER_03: I think that's it, right?
- 22:17But I also think you have to be hysteric in order to come up
- 22:21with an idea that doesn't exist.
- 22:26for Lacan every neurotic is baseline hysteric and then it gets
- 22:31modified and you can
- 22:32kick into this obsessional category I think I want to say it's
- 22:37obsessional with the
- 22:38SPEAKER_02: caveat that there's also a baseline hysteria but
- 22:43so any yeah just to just to put a capstone on that conversation
- 22:47yeah I'm not ready
- 22:49to capstone it I want to say because there's another layer of
- 22:52complexity here
- 22:53because what Nance also does okay so he does this whole like
- 22:58this is like this
- 22:59SPEAKER_02: incredible contribution to fault line theory so he takes CCRU
- 23:04SPEAKER_02: and starts with hyperstition.
- 23:05SPEAKER_02: Then he expands it out to hypostition, retrostition, right?
- 23:10SPEAKER_02: But he does this by thinking hyperstition in relation to Lacanian,
- 23:14SPEAKER_02: Zizekian concepts,
- 23:16SPEAKER_02: but also Heideggerian concepts,
- 23:20SPEAKER_02: right?
- 23:20SPEAKER_02: So just as we think there's a certain clinical structure
- 23:26to each three of these but Nance also shows and I agree they
- 23:32have a primacy in
- 23:33relation to ecstasis so there's ways we stand out from
- 23:37ourselves for Heidegger
- 23:39temporally one is the ecstasis of the future ecstasis of the
- 23:45present ecstasis of
- 23:47SPEAKER_02: the past and so
- 23:50Future Oriented That's why Retrostition has the name it does
- 23:55because it's oriented
- 23:56to this kind of confabulated past because it doesn't really
- 24:00make sense with hyper
- 24:01and hypo and then retro it's like that's a departure I don't
- 24:05know I could have done
- 24:06something else there but I think tying ecstasis to the clinical
- 24:11structures for me
- 24:13I'm more proud of that than I am with with the words
- 24:16hyperstition hypostition and
- 24:18retro because for for me when I say retro station what I really
- 24:23mean is this direct
- 24:24connection between this clinical structure and this ecstatic
- 24:29capture but hold on
- 24:31SPEAKER_02: there's there's so much nuance here right okay so
- 24:38Hyperstition is remains reality oriented right uh hypostition
- 24:46is disavowed reality
- 24:50it's yes and no yeah whereas retro station is a full
- 24:55abandonment of reality well
- 24:57SPEAKER_02: foreclosure yeah and here's why okay
- 25:02SPEAKER_02: The hyperstitionist neurotic has no problem.
- 25:05SPEAKER_02: There is a sense where it's future oriented,
- 25:08but that future orientedness is always connected to the past
- 25:11and the present.
- 25:14There's an emphasis on the future,
- 25:15but it's not disconnected from the other two.
- 25:18SPEAKER_02: This is like just Heidegger ecstatic temporality.
- 25:22SPEAKER_02: The pervert, there's a type of disavowal
- 25:27SPEAKER_02: of reality because it's locked into a present.
- 25:33SPEAKER_03: The immortal now.
- 25:34SPEAKER_03: It's locked into the immortal now.
- 25:36It's the immortal now of the thing you're trying to realize
- 25:38remaining unrealizable.
- 25:41SPEAKER_02: It's like the forever present of fiction.
- 25:45SPEAKER_02: Even though
- 25:47you have an abandoned reality you want to make this thing
- 25:51reality but you're doing
- 25:52SPEAKER_02: so in such a way that keeps it locked frozen in this perpetual present of
- 25:57fictionality and it's the fetishistic disavowal is the lever
- 26:01upon which you can do
- 26:02SPEAKER_03: that right
- 26:05But Retro-stition is psychotic and paranoid in the sense that
- 26:11reality itself is
- 26:12what's foreclosed because the past here is a radical
- 26:17disconnection from the other
- 26:19two ecstasies and it's in a sense collapsing all into a
- 26:24fictitious past which is
- 26:27SPEAKER_02: completely the foreclosure of reality.
- 26:30yeah um and it actually that gets at something I wanted to talk
- 26:35about but I don't
- 26:36want to bring it up yet I want to bring it up later because I
- 26:39want Sean to jump in
- 26:39here um wait so I was thinking about oh did you want to were
- 26:44you no no go ahead
- 26:47jump in okay there was like uh wait so where does the I'm gonna
- 26:53I'm gonna bring it
- 26:54SPEAKER_00: up again uh so there's no place in all of this for ordinary psychosis
- 27:00I reject ordinary psychosis it's not satisfying to me I don't
- 27:05like it but if I'm
- 27:07listening to you talk about like retro station and psychosis
- 27:11and this sort of thing
- 27:12I think the idea of ordinary psychosis is a failure to confront
- 27:16what I call retro
- 27:17SPEAKER_00: station huh cause like at first blush they sound similar yeah
- 27:27absolutely yeah and and they're also but nance is just making
- 27:31the stronger claim
- 27:32that it's it's psychotic yeah right it's not ordinary yeah i
- 27:37definitely have had
- 27:37the suspicion that like what people are calling ordinary
- 27:41psychosis is just like
- 27:44psychosis is being triggered in more and more people like it's
- 27:49just psychosis
- 27:50SPEAKER_00: that's what it is like it's just like more and more people are
- 27:53More and more people who were predisposed perhaps to psychosis
- 27:56are just being
- 27:57SPEAKER_00: triggered by the world we live in.
- 27:59SPEAKER_00: It's not a separate thing.
- 28:01I do think with retro station it's maybe a modality or it's a
- 28:05comportment or it's
- 28:06SPEAKER_03: something you can fall into and fall out of.
- 28:08SPEAKER_03: I do think that.
- 28:12SPEAKER_03: Again, this is why I don't want to identify it with psychosis.
- 28:16SPEAKER_03: I'm comfortable identifying it with paranoia.
- 28:19SPEAKER_03: But taking that, I guess like Mikey said, I am making a hard claim.
- 28:23SPEAKER_03: I am making a hard claim, but I myself am backing away from it.
- 28:27SPEAKER_03: But it's also true.
- 28:29SPEAKER_03: I do think it's a modality that we can fall,
- 28:33SPEAKER_03: all of us can fall into and can fall back out of,
- 28:36back into normal subject or quote unquote normal subjectivity
- 28:40or the neurotic
- 28:42SPEAKER_03: subjectivity that we share in general.
- 28:47Now I think for some people they can do the same thing with
- 28:52psychosis like it's
- 28:53it's not like you are one thing and you are that thing for 80
- 28:55years until you die
- 28:58but I don't know I think people people fetishize these
- 29:01structures and people think
- 29:02SPEAKER_03: like talking to
- 29:04Clinicians and Analysts and Stuff like they'll tell you like no
- 29:07it's it's not like
- 29:08oh you go through and you figure out this is your secret person
- 29:12like you can work
- 29:14with someone over time and they can everybody can have
- 29:17different aspects and
- 29:18different features and different characteristics like these
- 29:20structures are
- 29:22SPEAKER_03: conceptual tools with which to work they're not like identities
- 29:28SPEAKER_03: handed down from on high.
- 29:30SPEAKER_03: It's not like you go into the big other's office and say,
- 29:33SPEAKER_03: hey,
- 29:33SPEAKER_03: big other,
- 29:34let me lay down on your couch and then I'll talk to you for an
- 29:37hour and then you
- 29:38can give me this prescription diagnosis slip and I am
- 29:42heretofore for the rest of my
- 29:43SPEAKER_03: life,
- 29:43SPEAKER_03: this obsessional,
- 29:45SPEAKER_03: like,
- 29:45SPEAKER_03: no,
- 29:46SPEAKER_03: there's always freedom of movement.
- 29:48SPEAKER_03: But no, it is.
- 29:50SPEAKER_00: If you want to,
- 29:51SPEAKER_00: if a normal neurotic wants to experience some psychosis,
- 29:54SPEAKER_00: just like deprive yourself of sleep for 72 hours.
- 29:58um you know like do something like that and find a limit
- 30:02experience and you'll
- 30:03you'll have a little psychotic break uh it's just some people
- 30:06are closer to the
- 30:07break than than others yeah is the only difference you know and
- 30:11I think the world
- 30:11we live in like I really mean like I I kind of I think I do
- 30:16reject ordinary
- 30:17psychosis like as a separate like uh like a third thing in
- 30:22between psychosis and
- 30:24SPEAKER_00: neurosis and then there's ordinary psychosis like
- 30:26I think like the grain of truth the thing I do like about it is
- 30:30it's like it is
- 30:31SPEAKER_00: saying that like we're all we all can be psychotic we all like have that
- 30:35possibility we all can have that break but it's also like yeah
- 30:39I just don't think
- 30:39it's its own like separate category yeah but here's the thing
- 30:44is that really true
- 30:45SPEAKER_02: though because at the same time
- 30:48Lacan said your clinical structure is,
- 30:51once it's locked in,
- 30:52you can never unlock it.
- 30:54SPEAKER_02: Like, it's your default setting forever.
- 30:56SPEAKER_02: So,
- 30:58SPEAKER_02: if a neurotic,
- 30:59SPEAKER_02: for instance,
- 31:00SPEAKER_02: has a psychotic break,
- 31:02SPEAKER_02: that doesn't mean they have a psychotic structure.
- 31:05SPEAKER_03: Means they're a neurotic who's undergone a psychotic break.
- 31:08SPEAKER_02: Yeah, and it's not the same thing.
- 31:10SPEAKER_02: And so...
- 31:11SPEAKER_02: You know,
- 31:11SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 31:12SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 31:13SPEAKER_02: it's been a long time,
- 31:14but I think Bruce Fink is pretty clear on that distinction in
- 31:18his book on clinical
- 31:21SPEAKER_02: Lacanian theory.
- 31:21SPEAKER_02: So there's that.
- 31:24SPEAKER_02: I mean, look, one day...
- 31:25SPEAKER_00: I don't have a, yeah, I don't have a real strong opinion.
- 31:28SPEAKER_00: Just like, that's my suspicion, you know?
- 31:31I mean look if it's just if all we mean by ordinary psychosis
- 31:35is that people don't
- 31:36have a strong sense of interpolated duty anymore I just don't
- 31:41think that counts as
- 31:43I don't think it helps to call that psychotic but one day I
- 31:48mean we should just
- 31:49read Millier's damn essay Ordinary Psychosis Revisited Mike
- 31:56let's go to the fucking
- 31:57SPEAKER_02: text itself and see what we think of the words in it
- 32:01SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 32:02SPEAKER_03: you know,
- 32:02SPEAKER_03: this foreclosure too,
- 32:05SPEAKER_03: like there's these other ideas around foreclosure and I don't know,
- 32:11SPEAKER_03: like I'm not interested in the clinic.
- 32:12SPEAKER_03: Like I really am interested in
- 32:16Fault Line Theory I really am interested in the stuff we're
- 32:21into which would what
- 32:23the fuck I don't know social theory critical theory philosophy
- 32:26I don't even know
- 32:26they think this is this is where clinical Lacanians kind of
- 32:30venture out into the
- 32:31social field though is on this thing with ordinary psychosis
- 32:35and that's why I don't
- 32:36SPEAKER_03: fucking listen to them sorry dude
- 32:41SPEAKER_00: You don't think that you guys have something to learn from them.
- 32:44SPEAKER_00: They have something to learn from you.
- 32:45SPEAKER_00: Oh, 1,000%.
- 32:46SPEAKER_00: You interviewed a clinician.
- 32:47SPEAKER_03: Oh, a million percent.
- 32:49SPEAKER_03: And I respect the shit out of anybody who can actually do that job.
- 32:51SPEAKER_03: Because, I mean, I've worked in a clinic.
- 32:53SPEAKER_03: I know it can be difficult.
- 32:56SPEAKER_03: And I respect the shit out of it.
- 32:58SPEAKER_03: But...
- 32:59I'm not analyzing someone and I'm not making proclamations
- 33:03about analysis I'm
- 33:04making I'm not even making proclamations I'm saying hey man
- 33:08this is my idea maybe I
- 33:10think this you know maybe this is a better way to think about
- 33:14the world we live in
- 33:14today and technology and the interface between the human and
- 33:18technology and the
- 33:20future like that's what I'm saying I'm not saying like this is
- 33:24you know the truth
- 33:24SPEAKER_03: and I'm not saying this is the hard Lacanian
- 33:28Truth like no this is these are my ideas um which is again I
- 33:34think yeah I think
- 33:36which which is another reason why I'm hesitant to say like it
- 33:40is psychosis but I
- 33:42will say I don't like ordinary psychosis um I will go that far
- 33:48and maybe in the
- 33:49future I will go further but but can I also say a lot of when
- 33:54we say we don't like
- 33:55SPEAKER_02: it it's because
- 33:57SPEAKER_02: I don't like how theorists use it, I guess.
- 34:03If we were to actually talk about it with a clinical Lacanian,
- 34:09it might be a different story.
- 34:11SPEAKER_03: The way theorists use it.
- 34:15In the context of a clinic,
- 34:17at that point,
- 34:17I'm just going to shut up and take notes.
- 34:20SPEAKER_03: Me too.
- 34:21SPEAKER_03: That's the thing.
- 34:22SPEAKER_03: I'm not saying anything about that.
- 34:27so look I'll give you the example Sean like at this point is
- 34:31something like however
- 34:34the concept of the superego is actually put to work in clinical
- 34:38analysis that's
- 34:40where I shut up and take notes from a clinician but if they
- 34:44can't understand that
- 34:46SPEAKER_02: I've done a lot of work figuring out how this and Nance too but
- 34:52Like we both I mean the work we've done on superego and tying
- 34:56it to AI there's
- 34:57certain clinicians who would go this is just and I want to go
- 35:02okay I will extend
- 35:03you the courtesy of knowing that you're doing something with
- 35:05this within the
- 35:07confines of the clinic that I'm not I'm not ready to speak on
- 35:10and I should shut the
- 35:11SPEAKER_02: fuck up
- 35:12Do me the same service though as a theorist and realize that
- 35:17there's shit going on
- 35:18out here in society that psychoanalytic concepts with
- 35:24phenomenological experience
- 35:27SPEAKER_02: can we can put that to work in a way to understand our society and
- 35:35the way that we're developing this I don't it doesn't have to
- 35:38be like constantly
- 35:41informed by the clinic because the superego is not something
- 35:45that only exists
- 35:47within the confines of the four walls of analysis it is
- 35:51something that we are all
- 35:52dealing with at our jobs with technology with the economy and
- 35:59so yeah it is it's
- 36:01the super egos as much as of a part of our everyday world to me
- 36:07as money is or you
- 36:09SPEAKER_02: know commuting to work or what it's just it's that so yeah yeah and like
- 36:17psychoanalysis is wild like it or or it's dead you know like I
- 36:23think like if you if
- 36:24SPEAKER_00: you don't let something sort of if you if you want to silo shit off
- 36:31into these like little like hyper protective professionalized
- 36:35niches that like that
- 36:37are completely impermeable and nothing can get out or get in or
- 36:41you start like
- 36:42suing people or acting like you can sue people because you're
- 36:44like stealing their
- 36:46their like guild expertise like that's just how disciplines die
- 36:50so if people do
- 36:51want to act like that we're like the we can't let the the
- 36:56clinical wisdom out or we
- 36:58SPEAKER_00: can't let that scary philosophy get in well that's not how Freud
- 37:01behave that's not how Lacan behave at all you know which is
- 37:05like you know yeah no
- 37:08I'll just say look I mean if we want to go to something else
- 37:10I'll just I think it's
- 37:11helpful to do this so here's what Nance essentially does though
- 37:15there's three
- 37:17threefold connections hyperstition neurosis maybe obsession
- 37:24primarily future
- 37:28SPEAKER_01: hypostition
- 37:30Perversion Probably Fetishist Present Retro-sedition Psychosis
- 37:38Paranoia Past That's
- 37:43the That's how you Conceptually Twist together CCRU Lacan And
- 37:54Heidegger And
- 37:55SPEAKER_03: Heidegger And for anyone listening That's fucking cool
- 37:59SPEAKER_03: For the text from which this conversation is kind of originating from.
- 38:04SPEAKER_03: Please tell them the text.
- 38:06SPEAKER_03: The text is long exposure,
- 38:08SPEAKER_03: psychography,
- 38:09SPEAKER_03: hyperstition,
- 38:10SPEAKER_03: hypostition,
- 38:11SPEAKER_03: and the retro-stitional return.
- 38:13SPEAKER_03: You can find it on my substack.
- 38:15SPEAKER_03: And that's where I talk about these terms.
- 38:19SPEAKER_03: And we, yeah, we started, we're going to do an intro now.
- 38:30SPEAKER_01: Outro Music
- 38:57SPEAKER_01: Two Billion Nances
- 39:49SPEAKER_03: What's up everybody?
- 39:50SPEAKER_03: How you doing?
- 39:50SPEAKER_03: Welcome back to another fantastic episode of the Nance cast.
- 39:54SPEAKER_03: Today we're joined...
- 39:58We're just hanging out this is a this is a hangout episode we
- 40:02before we started
- 40:03recording we were talking and we were like fuck it let's record
- 40:07this now and so I
- 40:10think the first like two minutes of the video I didn't get but
- 40:13I got the audio
- 40:15So anyone watching there'll be I don't know a graphic up or
- 40:18whatever but you'll
- 40:19hear us talking and then that's that was our conversation and
- 40:23now we're getting
- 40:23into it but this is uh yeah this is a loosey-goosey hanging out
- 40:28episode just kind
- 40:28SPEAKER_03: of talking about all kinds of stuff um
- 40:32I think the three of us all have a lot going on right now we're
- 40:36not reading Batai
- 40:37today it'll probably be a couple weeks before we get back at
- 40:41that but in the
- 40:43meantime we wanted to fucking come together and have a
- 40:48conversation so yeah what's
- 40:53SPEAKER_03: up what are you guys doing how you guys doing
- 40:59It's funny,
- 41:01the thing that we just talked about will come after,
- 41:04but that was a...
- 41:06SPEAKER_02: I'm still kind of locked into that.
- 41:08SPEAKER_03: This intro's going at 40 minutes in.
- 41:12SPEAKER_02: Oh!
- 41:12SPEAKER_02: Okay, so it's not editing.
- 41:14SPEAKER_02: Okay, never mind.
- 41:16SPEAKER_02: I'm too lazy to cut this and go back.
- 41:18SPEAKER_02: I'm like, it's a time anomalous intro.
- 41:22SPEAKER_03: It's a retroactive introduction.
- 41:24SPEAKER_02: So, okay, hold on.
- 41:25SPEAKER_02: Just one last thing.
- 41:26SPEAKER_02: So...
- 41:29SPEAKER_02: The title of your essay is long and detailed.
- 41:36SPEAKER_02: What is the title again?
- 41:39Long Exposure Psychography and then the little photo that I put
- 41:46was a long exposure
- 41:47SPEAKER_03: picture of myself that I took.
- 41:48SPEAKER_03: I thought I was being clever with psychography.
- 41:51SPEAKER_03: Long Exposure Psychography
- 41:54SPEAKER_03: on hyperstition, hypostition, and the retrositional return.
- 42:01Okay,
- 42:01but I have my own nickname for the piece,
- 42:05and it's just simply the three threes.
- 42:08SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I like that.
- 42:10SPEAKER_03: I've talked about it in a few episodes,
- 42:14SPEAKER_03: and I just call it the retrosetition essay,
- 42:16SPEAKER_03: and I'm aware of the fact that people may not know what that means.
- 42:22SPEAKER_03: That's bad marketing on my end, but yeah.
- 42:27SPEAKER_03: When did I throw that up?
- 42:28A couple months ago at this point and it stemmed from
- 42:32conversations we were having
- 42:34after Stranger Things well and hypostition goes back to at this
- 42:41point almost two
- 42:41years ago we were talking about unconscious belief and
- 42:46political activism and so on
- 42:48and so on but retro station came out of the conformity gate
- 42:53conversations we were
- 42:54SPEAKER_03: having at the time
- 42:59There are a couple things I want to talk about But I also don't
- 43:04want to get carried
- 43:06SPEAKER_03: away I don't know,
- 43:08SPEAKER_03: do you guys have anything you want to bring up?
- 43:11SPEAKER_03: Anything you want to talk about?
- 43:12SPEAKER_03: Anything that's been on your minds recently?
- 43:14There's a lot going on in the world I've been listening to Sir
- 43:23Roger Penrose interviews
- 43:26um while I've been driving around for work and um it's uh he
- 43:32had a there's a moment
- 43:34where it's like it got super battalion he's talking about like
- 43:37the talking about
- 43:38like the energy from the sun and how that's stored up and used
- 43:43by the planet so
- 43:44SPEAKER_00: they just it was like uh Penrose Bataille
- 43:49That's dope Yeah he got like into a lot more detail But it was
- 43:53like that was cool I
- 43:55was thinking about that recently Did Penrose Do something With
- 44:02tiling Yeah The
- 44:05SPEAKER_00: Penrose Yeah he has his own the Penrose pattern Or whatever it's called
- 44:10So I've been reading a lot about a bunch of old Greek guys that
- 44:16I can't pronounce a
- 44:17SPEAKER_03: lot of their names.
- 44:20SPEAKER_03: It's not Asclesius.
- 44:22SPEAKER_03: But yeah, a bunch of classic mathematicians and thinkers and stuff.
- 44:26SPEAKER_03: But Archimedes...
- 44:30SPEAKER_03: wrote on basically combinatorics or tiling.
- 44:34SPEAKER_03: Like if you have a square made up of... Is it 14 tiles?
- 44:40SPEAKER_03: It's the Stomachion.
- 44:43SPEAKER_03: Uh...
- 44:44But it's a combinatorics problem but it's basically to show
- 44:47like if you take a
- 44:47square and you cut it up into 14 oddly shaped shapes there's
- 44:52this insane number of
- 44:55different combinations that you can combine these shapes to
- 44:59create the same outer
- 45:02SPEAKER_03: outer
- 45:03SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I guess the same area square.
- 45:06SPEAKER_03: And that's interesting.
- 45:07SPEAKER_03: And that, yeah, Penrose also kind of talks about tiling.
- 45:09SPEAKER_03: That's basically old timey tiling.
- 45:12SPEAKER_03: Ye old tiling.
- 45:13But it's also different because does like combinatorics,
- 45:19Penrose isn't doing combinatorics.
- 45:21SPEAKER_03: He's doing something else.
- 45:23SPEAKER_00: I don't even know what combinatorics means.
- 45:26SPEAKER_00: So I couldn't tell you.
- 45:28SPEAKER_03: It's like ordinal maths.
- 45:31SPEAKER_03: So it's like OG math.
- 45:35SPEAKER_03: Like before we discovered... Well, it's actually not before we.
- 45:39SPEAKER_03: I'm talking we.
- 45:41SPEAKER_03: But like Pythagoras and Zeno,
- 45:45SPEAKER_03: they kind of have their whole thing with Infinity way,
- 45:49SPEAKER_03: way,
- 45:50SPEAKER_03: way back in the day.
- 45:51SPEAKER_03: But Combinatorix is from before then.
- 45:54and I think the type of stuff that they do now is a lot
- 45:57different because it like
- 45:59you can do exponential and you can do like diagonalization and
- 46:03you so I think yeah
- 46:04I think the kind of maths that Penrose does are are maybe
- 46:08similar to combinatorics
- 46:09in some way but also probably very different just because
- 46:12Penrose he's a he just he
- 46:14calls himself a I mean he is he's a mathematical physicist you
- 46:20know so he's um
- 46:23SPEAKER_00: I don't know.
- 46:24SPEAKER_00: I don't understand fucking half of it, but I'm trying.
- 46:27SPEAKER_00: I'm ordering like all of his books.
- 46:29SPEAKER_00: I'm going to go up and go to Libgen or Project Gutenberg.
- 46:34SPEAKER_03: Don't buy it.
- 46:35SPEAKER_03: Go to Libgen.
- 46:36SPEAKER_00: I mean, yeah.
- 46:37SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 46:38SPEAKER_00: I like the book.
- 46:39SPEAKER_00: I'm one of those.
- 46:40SPEAKER_00: I like the fucking book.
- 46:43SPEAKER_03: I like physical books too.
- 46:44SPEAKER_03: I just got a new book that I haven't started reading yet.
- 46:47SPEAKER_02: There's like one book in particular I want more
- 46:51SPEAKER_02: Which one?
- 46:53And it's James Ellis' Accelerationism Capitalism as Critique
- 47:00and it's one of the
- 47:01SPEAKER_02: only dedicated books to Landian Accelerationism and I love James,
- 47:08SPEAKER_02: right?
- 47:08SPEAKER_02: Anytime James is talking about land, I'm there, right?
- 47:13and it had a very like small print you know and then it's gone
- 47:18and you can get the
- 47:19PDF but I'm like if somebody out there is listening and has a
- 47:23copy and is willing
- 47:24to part with it yeah let me know that's like get in the
- 47:29comments James doesn't even
- 47:30have one yeah I was gonna bug James can I have yours he's like
- 47:37yeah I don't have
- 47:42Nance what book do you got there this new one same guys that
- 47:48put out Exo Capitalism
- 47:52SPEAKER_03: what is this Retrograde Prometheus well not the authors the publisher
- 47:56SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it's not Mark and Roberto.
- 47:59SPEAKER_03: It's Becoming Press, right?
- 48:00SPEAKER_03: Becoming Press.
- 48:02SPEAKER_03: This Retrograde Prometheus by Christian Nirvana D'Amato.
- 48:08SPEAKER_03: I want that book too.
- 48:09SPEAKER_03: I think this guy, I think he has at least one other book on Becoming.
- 48:14SPEAKER_03: From what I can tell, this guy's too delusian.
- 48:18SPEAKER_03: And
- 48:19SPEAKER_03: and we will have some disagreements with this guy,
- 48:21SPEAKER_03: but there's also,
- 48:23SPEAKER_03: I think,
- 48:23SPEAKER_03: probably a lot of,
- 48:24SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 48:25SPEAKER_03: similarity or whatever,
- 48:26SPEAKER_03: but I just got this.
- 48:26SPEAKER_03: I haven't read it yet.
- 48:27SPEAKER_03: It's short.
- 48:28SPEAKER_03: I'll have it done soon, so.
- 48:32SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I want to read that one, too.
- 48:34SPEAKER_02: But Coming Press just puts out the coolest fucking-looking books, dude.
- 48:38SPEAKER_03: Their shit does look nice.
- 48:39SPEAKER_03: Their shit definitely looks nice.
- 48:43SPEAKER_02: Okay, I got something to, like, a topic we can...
- 48:46You know see how far we get with this but so you guys both know
- 48:52that I basically
- 48:52have no time to sit down and read but when there's something I
- 48:58really really want
- 48:58to read I find a way to do it and I got a chance to finally
- 49:05read Vincent Lay's
- 49:06SPEAKER_02: essay in Machine Decision Is Not Final and the essay is
- 49:15SPEAKER_02: Okay,
- 49:16so the idea is like Reza Negarastani in Intelligence and Spirit
- 49:21putting forth a
- 49:22SPEAKER_02: theory of AI or a theory of intelligence.
- 49:25Well,
- 49:25Nick Bostrom in Superintelligence puts forth a theory of
- 49:29intelligence.
- 49:31And there's a lot of ways that Bostrom and Negarastani are at
- 49:38odds with each other,
- 49:39right?
- 49:40SPEAKER_01: But what Vincent does is
- 49:43SPEAKER_01: is show that they're ultimately,
- 49:48SPEAKER_02: despite their differences,
- 49:52SPEAKER_02: really on the side of the orthogonality thesis,
- 49:55SPEAKER_02: more or less,
- 49:55SPEAKER_02: right?
- 49:57SPEAKER_02: And what Vince does in true Landian fashion,
- 50:00SPEAKER_02: and for whatever reason,
- 50:03SPEAKER_02: I don't know,
- 50:04SPEAKER_02: I mean,
- 50:05SPEAKER_02: there's reasons why you wouldn't mention Nick directly,
- 50:07SPEAKER_02: I guess,
- 50:08SPEAKER_02: but Vincent doesn't mention Nick.
- 50:13Even though he's making a straight up Landian argument But
- 50:18instead of putting it in
- 50:20Landian terms Vincent puts it in Nietzschean terms Now Nick
- 50:26wants to talk about the
- 50:27will to think And would say if we're talking about a truly
- 50:33intelligent entity
- 50:34Especially one whose intelligence is on our level or more It
- 50:40has to be structured
- 50:41SPEAKER_02: by a default drive
- 50:44a default tendency and for Nick it's the will to think which is
- 50:47the will to more
- 50:48intelligence well given the Nietzschean influence on Nick if
- 50:55you want you can go
- 50:56SPEAKER_02: well that's will to power right so what Vincent does is say will to power
- 51:06SPEAKER_02: undermines the orthogonality thesis which is Sean again this idea that
- 51:12There is a separation or division between an entity's
- 51:17capability and the goals that
- 51:22SPEAKER_02: it's trying to achieve.
- 51:24And so something with incredible physical intelligent
- 51:29capability could have really
- 51:31SPEAKER_02: stupid goals,
- 51:32SPEAKER_02: right?
- 51:33SPEAKER_02: And
- 51:35Bostrom worries about this because he's like oh if we build a
- 51:39super intelligence
- 51:40for him that means super potential to act in the world right
- 51:47it's functionalism
- 51:49that means this thing could have massive godlike power but be
- 51:57like the village
- 51:57SPEAKER_02: idiot which is to say right
- 52:00SPEAKER_02: Oh, I have a goal, which is to maximize paperclip production.
- 52:06SPEAKER_02: And because it has this expansive capability,
- 52:10it deduces that the most functional way to do this is to use
- 52:16all of the atoms in
- 52:17SPEAKER_02: the Earth to make paperclips.
- 52:20and Land hates this shit so much he's like that is not
- 52:25intelligence that is a
- 52:27fucking idiot and it will never have that level of capability
- 52:32if it can't truly
- 52:35SPEAKER_02: have some fundamental value orienting the expansion of its capability,
- 52:42SPEAKER_02: which is I want to become more refined in my intelligence,
- 52:46and that means you have a fundamental value that's orienting
- 52:50everything you're
- 52:51SPEAKER_02: doing,
- 52:51and it's not this sharp distinction between capability and
- 52:56value or fact and value.
- 52:59SPEAKER_02: It's the is-ought distinction.
- 53:01SPEAKER_00: Sorry, go ahead.
- 53:04I was just gonna say like for Nick Land then like he's
- 53:06objecting to this like
- 53:08completely functional intelligence I guess if you know I mean I
- 53:14think Land is very
- 53:15functionalist he would just go about he would just say that
- 53:20functional the
- 53:21SPEAKER_02: functionalist type of intelligence
- 53:25SPEAKER_02: can function to comport itself and understand value.
- 53:29He would claim that value itself emerges from the predicates in
- 53:36the system.
- 53:39SPEAKER_03: You can't have value apart from effectiveness.
- 53:45SPEAKER_03: You can't have values and goals separated.
- 53:48SPEAKER_03: They are essentially the same thing.
- 53:51SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I don't know if that's
- 53:55if I agree with that I don't know but like it's weird because
- 54:01like it's funny how
- 54:02you define intelligence because like it seems like what Nick
- 54:06Land is objecting to
- 54:07there would be it means that intelligence has to in order for
- 54:11something to be
- 54:12intelligence it has to have a mind but I don't know if that's
- 54:19true and I don't know
- 54:20SPEAKER_00: if he would want to say that in other contexts you see what I'm saying
- 54:24I don't know if I'm getting him right but LLMs are intelligent
- 54:28they don't have
- 54:28minds though yeah exactly I think Nick is that's what I'm
- 54:33saying and so I'm
- 54:34confused as to why he would have I don't think that they have
- 54:37value either they
- 54:38SPEAKER_00: don't have a mind
- 54:40I think Nick's point is I don't think he would say they have to
- 54:43have a mind I think
- 54:44Nick would reject the fiction of the mind I think for Nick the
- 54:50entire universe is a
- 54:51SPEAKER_03: mind and just depending at what scale you're kind of concerned with
- 54:55SPEAKER_03: Things may appear to look like minds,
- 54:58but planets are also metasystems and they kind of operate in
- 55:02productive ways and
- 55:03SPEAKER_03: they create newness and they create difference.
- 55:05SPEAKER_03: And if you are the size of a planet observing another planet,
- 55:09SPEAKER_03: you might think,
- 55:11SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 55:11SPEAKER_03: look,
- 55:11SPEAKER_03: that is that is a self-contained metasystem.
- 55:14SPEAKER_03: And because we are the size and shape of people.
- 55:17We observe and recognize minds as minds and if we were the size
- 55:23and shape of you
- 55:25know quarks and bosons and mesons and shit like that we would
- 55:28also similarly see
- 55:30this intelligence in the fabric of the universe itself I think
- 55:33that's properly an
- 55:34SPEAKER_03: exposition and I don't necessarily disagree with him however
- 55:40SPEAKER_03: I think on this, we separate goals and values.
- 55:45I think Nick's point is just production itself is good in this
- 55:51sense that we're valuing.
- 55:55SPEAKER_03: If something is effective,
- 55:56SPEAKER_03: if something can accomplish a thing,
- 56:00SPEAKER_03: then that is good from its perspective.
- 56:05SPEAKER_03: He rejects the separations.
- 56:09Yeah and that I couldn't go there at all like I just think
- 56:12that's wrong you know
- 56:14like I think like you can have a goal and also like I would
- 56:19never be so loosey
- 56:20goosey with mind like I think that's why we're weird and we're
- 56:23different from other
- 56:25objects in the universe because we have this like radically
- 56:27different thing and
- 56:30it's subjectivity it's mind and it's quite the bifurcation you
- 56:35know with nature and
- 56:36SPEAKER_00: like um
- 56:41and then value and goal like no those are different like a goal
- 56:45you don't have to
- 56:46like if you're working at your job you take up all of these
- 56:51goals you don't have to
- 56:51think they're good at all like the people building like data
- 56:55centers right now do
- 56:57SPEAKER_00: on construction crews building data centers
- 57:00SPEAKER_00: They're not there because they 90% of the time,
- 57:03SPEAKER_00: at least 90,
- 57:04SPEAKER_00: probably 99% of the time,
- 57:06they're not there because they think this would be a great
- 57:08thing for the community
- 57:09SPEAKER_00: to have is a data center.
- 57:11I would just say it's complicated though but it's also good
- 57:16because it's giving
- 57:17them a paycheck which they can say hey I don't think it's good
- 57:21I have to work but
- 57:22given I have to work it's good that I have a paycheck like this
- 57:26is where shit with
- 57:27us gets very multifaceted where there's values that we don't
- 57:33value but we have to
- 57:34SPEAKER_02: value them even though we don't want to have to value them
- 57:38Yeah and I don't blame them by the way because like that's the
- 57:41world we live in you
- 57:42know but it's also like on some level you'd be able like I've
- 57:47spoke like my when I
- 57:48was working construction my foreman was like we were just
- 57:52sitting there like having
- 57:53a break a smoke break one time and my foreman who's been in
- 57:56this industry for like
- 57:58SPEAKER_00: 30 years was like musing about how we are like ants
- 58:02and we are just mindlessly building and we have no idea why the
- 58:06fuck we're doing it
- 58:06we just keep doing it like automatically like he's been doing
- 58:12this for decades and
- 58:13this is his reflection on all of the work he's done is like
- 58:17what's the fucking
- 58:18point it's just to get a paycheck so I can buy toys like that's
- 58:21it I love that shit
- 58:22SPEAKER_03: I love it when like
- 58:24you know normies for lack of a better term kind of stumble upon
- 58:29that because it
- 58:29does seem like at every job I've ever had for the most part
- 58:32everybody seems to come
- 58:35across that like what are we doing dude like we're just doing
- 58:39the same thing over
- 58:40and over again this is all pointless like in a sense it's like
- 58:45well that's what you
- 58:46SPEAKER_03: know that's why people might
- 58:49SPEAKER_03: Right.
- 59:15SPEAKER_02: to have anything.
- 59:17SPEAKER_02: Otherwise, it's head to the bridge.
- 59:19SPEAKER_02: Either live under it or jump off of it.
- 59:22And I would say that capitals for sake of which is mindless and
- 59:27valueless.
- 59:28It's a goal,
- 59:29and the goal is accumulation,
- 59:31but it doesn't have mind or value.
- 59:33SPEAKER_02: Okay, but hold on.
- 59:34SPEAKER_02: Here's where I was at.
- 59:35SPEAKER_02: This is where I want to go with this thing with Vincent Lake.
- 59:37SPEAKER_02: So his response to...
- 59:46to the Orthogonality Thesis is um Nietzsche and Wilder Powell
- 59:55which is Landian will
- 59:57to think ultimately okay because this position is something
- 1:00:03like Land kind of
- 1:00:04worked this out across various blog posts that are now
- 1:00:09contained in Zeno Systems
- 1:00:11SPEAKER_02: right or Zeno Systems blog um
- 1:00:16SPEAKER_02: So here's how we undermine the Izzot distinction.
- 1:00:20SPEAKER_02: This is kind of like a Heideggerian move, right?
- 1:00:23SPEAKER_02: Heidegger's like, you don't solve the subject-object schema.
- 1:00:29SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 1:00:30SPEAKER_02: there's subjects or observers over here,
- 1:00:33SPEAKER_02: and then there's objects to be known over there.
- 1:00:36SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 1:00:36there's all kinds of philosophical problems in trying to figure
- 1:00:39out how they
- 1:00:40SPEAKER_02: correspond with one another,
- 1:00:43SPEAKER_02: right?
- 1:00:45SPEAKER_02: Heidegger's like, no, you just are starting with a modification.
- 1:00:49SPEAKER_02: You're not getting the primary phenomenon,
- 1:00:51SPEAKER_02: which is being in the world,
- 1:00:53SPEAKER_02: which is not subjects over against objects.
- 1:00:58SPEAKER_02: It is
- 1:01:00Dasein skillfully engaged with ready to hand equipment and this
- 1:01:06sharp division is
- 1:01:08SPEAKER_02: not functional there.
- 1:01:10It's only when a piece of equipment breaks down that this other
- 1:01:13way of viewing things comes out
- 1:01:18SPEAKER_02: You can say,
- 1:01:18SPEAKER_02: oh,
- 1:01:19SPEAKER_02: this modification becomes tricky,
- 1:01:21SPEAKER_02: but that's not the ontological default setting.
- 1:01:33this whole thing with the is-ought distinction with Hume it's
- 1:01:36like an ontological
- 1:01:37default setting that there's facts over here and there's values
- 1:01:42over here there's
- 1:01:44is's and there's ought's and you can't figure out how they
- 1:01:48correspond just like
- 1:01:50SPEAKER_02: with traditional
- 1:01:53SPEAKER_02: Philosophy of Modernity, how do we link up subjects and objects?
- 1:02:00SPEAKER_02: How do we link up is, is, and aughts?
- 1:02:03SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 1:02:04SPEAKER_02: for Vincent,
- 1:02:06SPEAKER_02: and I think for Nick,
- 1:02:08you get out of it by saying the thing that's the most
- 1:02:12fundamental constituent of
- 1:02:15SPEAKER_02: reality,
- 1:02:16SPEAKER_02: will,
- 1:02:17SPEAKER_02: whether it's will to think or will to power,
- 1:02:20SPEAKER_02: In its very is-ing is an ought-ing, is a valuing.
- 1:02:25SPEAKER_02: Will the power is the most fundamental metaphysical reality.
- 1:02:31SPEAKER_02: And what is that reality?
- 1:02:32SPEAKER_02: It's a willing, it's a caring, it's an ought-ing.
- 1:02:36SPEAKER_02: It wants something in particular.
- 1:02:38SPEAKER_02: So
- 1:02:39Sorry like if that's the case then the is ought distinction is
- 1:02:44some abstract
- 1:02:45modification and it's not the fundamental reality it's not the
- 1:02:49fundamental problem
- 1:02:51SPEAKER_02: and yeah
- 1:02:53That would mean that if will the power is at work in all things
- 1:02:57the more something
- 1:02:58has intelligence the more it's guided by will the power which
- 1:03:03means it has a
- 1:03:04fundamental ontological default valuing caring willing
- 1:03:09mattering to it and it
- 1:03:11doesn't it's not a problem because it doesn't have like you
- 1:03:13don't have anything
- 1:03:15SPEAKER_02: without this being the fundamental reality now
- 1:03:20See I brought all that up because Vincent's essay is amazing
- 1:03:24we're going to do an
- 1:03:25exegesis of it when we have time but Todd McGowan years ago
- 1:03:32wrote an essay that
- 1:03:35argues death drive is more fundamental than will the power now
- 1:03:41Vincent would say
- 1:03:42you're not going to get out of this will the power is the
- 1:03:45fundamental drive the
- 1:03:47SPEAKER_02: fundamental force in nature
- 1:03:51SPEAKER_02: But,
- 1:03:52SPEAKER_02: and this is where it goes,
- 1:03:52SPEAKER_02: it's like with Todd,
- 1:03:54SPEAKER_02: it's like,
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_02: hey,
- 1:03:55SPEAKER_02: do we want to say death drive is in nature?
- 1:03:57SPEAKER_02: That doesn't sound right.
- 1:03:58SPEAKER_02: I don't think that's the argument.
- 1:03:59SPEAKER_02: But at least with us,
- 1:04:01SPEAKER_02: you could say,
- 1:04:02SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:04:03we're the beings in which will the power ultimately becomes
- 1:04:07secondary to another
- 1:04:09SPEAKER_02: drive,
- 1:04:09SPEAKER_02: which is death drive.
- 1:04:12SPEAKER_01: But I would just say that
- 1:04:17If we happen to be the most intelligent species on this planet
- 1:04:22and what defines us
- 1:04:23is that we have severed on some level with will to power and
- 1:04:28are far more oriented
- 1:04:29towards death drive then you have to wonder well is there some
- 1:04:32sort of connection
- 1:04:33between intelligence and death drive I'm just saying like this
- 1:04:38is what I'm thinking
- 1:04:38about when I'm reading Vince's essay and here's the other thing
- 1:04:45the other thing I
- 1:04:45SPEAKER_02: would just say is
- 1:04:48I think Vince argues in such a way as to say look I've I've
- 1:04:52established will the
- 1:04:53power is the fundamental reality fundamental metaphysical
- 1:04:59reality and I think a lot
- 1:05:00SPEAKER_02: of people would go yeah I'm still not convinced of that so
- 1:05:05SPEAKER_02: Look,
- 1:05:06SPEAKER_02: the argument completely hinges on the validity of will to power being the
- 1:05:11SPEAKER_02: fundamental metaphysical reality.
- 1:05:13SPEAKER_02: And I think that's still questionable.
- 1:05:17But Vince does this clever thing where it's like if you try to
- 1:05:24disprove will to
- 1:05:25SPEAKER_03: power,
- 1:05:25SPEAKER_03: you're proving it?
- 1:05:28By kind of enacting your own will to power to disprove that the
- 1:05:32will to power...
- 1:05:34right yeah I mean I I think for me the I don't know the the
- 1:05:40pivotal moment is the
- 1:05:41breakdown right like we're we're talking okay Hume fuck you we
- 1:05:46have Heidegger um uh
- 1:05:51but like the break the breakdown is is when the is and the
- 1:05:54ought kind of become
- 1:05:56divested of each other or whatever we are the breakdown in
- 1:05:59nature that's in the
- 1:06:00SPEAKER_02: face of the other with Levinas yeah I did it
- 1:06:06We are the breakdown in nature and so because we have broken
- 1:06:10down or split away
- 1:06:11because we've been cut or Lacan right we are the cut because we
- 1:06:15are separated we're
- 1:06:16bifurcated we are a departure and I think Nick sure will the
- 1:06:23power but I also think
- 1:06:24it's Schopenhauer's will it's just the will or the rotary drive
- 1:06:28like there's just
- 1:06:29SPEAKER_03: something that
- 1:06:31or Deleuzian Metaphysics like there's just some quality there's
- 1:06:33some feature of
- 1:06:36production in the universe and it just kind of is what it is
- 1:06:40and it's positivistic
- 1:06:43in a way but I also think with Hegel I also think negativity
- 1:06:48plays a role at the
- 1:06:50ontological level as well but anyway when we become the human
- 1:06:55subject we are cut
- 1:06:58SPEAKER_03: away from that
- 1:07:00And so we can leave will or will to power or will to think or
- 1:07:05will to will like we
- 1:07:06leave that all behind for death drive itself and it is
- 1:07:11precisely in that breakdown
- 1:07:14SPEAKER_03: where death drive emerges and I think
- 1:07:21so I the other day I read um the Dartmouth proposal for a
- 1:07:25summer research program
- 1:07:27on artificial intelligence there was a two month research
- 1:07:30program at Dartmouth in
- 1:07:32SPEAKER_03: um
- 1:07:34Connecticut or New Hampshire somewhere on the fucking East
- 1:07:37Coast fancy pants
- 1:07:39fucking college but in the 1950s it's where the term artificial
- 1:07:45intelligence was
- 1:07:45created they had a conference bunch of famous scientists and
- 1:07:48mathematicians and all
- 1:07:49this stuff it's where the term artificial intelligence was
- 1:07:52created and they wrote
- 1:07:55up a proposal before it all and it's like the founding document
- 1:07:58of the modern AI
- 1:08:00SPEAKER_03: industry
- 1:08:01I read that the other day on the channel and that was fun and
- 1:08:05yesterday I was I
- 1:08:07SPEAKER_03: almost read Turing's paper on computable numbers with
- 1:08:17SPEAKER_03: with a focus on the decision problem or something like that.
- 1:08:19But Alan Turing's famous paper where he creates the Turing
- 1:08:23machine,
- 1:08:24the universal machine.
- 1:08:25SPEAKER_03: And I still want to read it, although that's a really weird paper.
- 1:08:29SPEAKER_03: There's a lot of math.
- 1:08:30SPEAKER_03: There's a lot of weird shit in it.
- 1:08:31SPEAKER_03: I don't think I'm going to read it.
- 1:08:33SPEAKER_03: I think I'm just going to discuss it.
- 1:08:37SPEAKER_03: But in Turing's paper...
- 1:08:41SPEAKER_03: He proves,
- 1:08:43SPEAKER_03: so there's this famous problem,
- 1:08:46SPEAKER_03: Hilbert,
- 1:08:47SPEAKER_03: the guy from Hilbert's Hotel,
- 1:08:51SPEAKER_03: demands these,
- 1:08:54SPEAKER_03: he's like,
- 1:08:54SPEAKER_03: well,
- 1:08:55SPEAKER_03: we need to figure out math.
- 1:08:56SPEAKER_03: We need to figure out if math is complete,
- 1:08:58SPEAKER_03: and we need to figure out if math is decidable or not,
- 1:09:02or if math is this kind of infinite thing that can go on and on
- 1:09:05and on and on and
- 1:09:06SPEAKER_03: on.
- 1:09:07SPEAKER_03: David Hilbert.
- 1:09:08And Kurt Goodell The Incompleteness Theorem guy He comes along
- 1:09:13And he answers And
- 1:09:15he's like Yeah math is incomplete And everybody's like Okay
- 1:09:18okay okay But like This
- 1:09:20question of decidability Is still open It's still up in the air
- 1:09:23And Turing comes
- 1:09:24along And in the paper Where he creates The universal machine
- 1:09:27That what's now
- 1:09:28called The Turing machine That paper Demonstrates That Some
- 1:09:36things are Undecidable
- 1:09:38Like there are some things that just cannot be mathematically
- 1:09:44proven and the way he
- 1:09:45does this and it's kind of like the Principia Mathematica where
- 1:09:49it's like 800 pages
- 1:09:51SPEAKER_03: is all a preface to them proving that one plus one equals two.
- 1:09:57Like they have to write 800 pages in order to prove to you that
- 1:10:01one plus one equals two.
- 1:10:03SPEAKER_03: Um...
- 1:10:05Turing kinda does that although this is like a 10 page essay
- 1:10:08it's not an 800 page
- 1:10:09book but he he constructs this ultimate reasoning machine and
- 1:10:16then he feeds it back
- 1:10:18into itself and he demonstrates that basically all you have to
- 1:10:23do is take the take
- 1:10:24the output from this complete reasoning machine and feed it
- 1:10:28back into itself and
- 1:10:29SPEAKER_03: you arrive at circularity all over again so he does uh
- 1:10:35what Georg Cantor came up with this idea of diagonalization
- 1:10:39it's basically you take
- 1:10:41a result of something and then you modify it in some way Turing
- 1:10:44does that to his
- 1:10:45universal machine and he says guess what guys math this
- 1:10:51ultimate accounting this
- 1:10:53SPEAKER_03: ultimate scientization of nature I have basically proven
- 1:10:59that we there are limits to our knowledge that's what Turing
- 1:11:02does in this 1936
- 1:11:04SPEAKER_03: paper and everybody else kind of took it and and
- 1:11:10SPEAKER_03: Didn't get that part of the memo.
- 1:11:13SPEAKER_03: They took it and they were like,
- 1:11:14SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 1:11:14we can make this machine and it can do this and it can write
- 1:11:18down symbols and it
- 1:11:19can understand this and it can do this and all these complex
- 1:11:21tasks and stuff like
- 1:11:22SPEAKER_03: that.
- 1:11:23The key thrust of Turing's 1936 paper is he basically
- 1:11:28demonstrates undecidability.
- 1:11:30SPEAKER_03: He basically demonstrates that even in math,
- 1:11:33SPEAKER_03: There are limits to math.
- 1:11:35There are things that we just cannot understand,
- 1:11:38cannot know,
- 1:11:39cannot cope with.
- 1:11:42SPEAKER_03: And then from there, artificial intelligence.
- 1:11:46We have the Dartmouth proposal in the 50s and we have the whole
- 1:11:48field of artificial
- 1:11:49SPEAKER_03: intelligence.
- 1:11:50But like everybody missed the fact that Turing was dealing with
- 1:11:54the decision
- 1:11:55problem and his answer to the decision problem was some things
- 1:11:58can't be decided.
- 1:12:00So this whole field of artificial intelligence is kind of
- 1:12:03predicated on believing
- 1:12:05that everything can be decided and everything is rational and
- 1:12:09everything is
- 1:12:09SPEAKER_03: positivistic.
- 1:12:12SPEAKER_03: So it was really weird when I was reading through Turing's paper,
- 1:12:15SPEAKER_03: I was like,
- 1:12:15SPEAKER_03: oh shit,
- 1:12:16SPEAKER_03: this is Lacan.
- 1:12:17SPEAKER_03: This is Hegel.
- 1:12:19SPEAKER_03: Turing is coming up against negativity and that's basically it.
- 1:12:24SPEAKER_03: And he's like, we can go no further.
- 1:12:28But the entire field of artificial intelligence doesn't reckon
- 1:12:32with that negativity.
- 1:12:33SPEAKER_03: The thing is, this is back in the 1930s, 1940s, 1950s.
- 1:12:37All these other people who are talking about theories of
- 1:12:39intelligence seem to just
- 1:12:43SPEAKER_03: take for granted that everything is decidable.
- 1:12:49Because the most robust theories of intelligence are
- 1:12:52proficiency at playing games
- 1:12:54or the ability to act in a goal-oriented way upon an
- 1:12:58environment or the ability to
- 1:13:00SPEAKER_03: set complex goals over time.
- 1:13:02SPEAKER_03: Like it all comes down to function and it all comes down to rationality.
- 1:13:06SPEAKER_02: And to achieve them with greater efficiency.
- 1:13:08SPEAKER_03: Yeah, and to optimize over time.
- 1:13:12SPEAKER_03: But there's no room for negativity in all these theories of intelligence.
- 1:13:16SPEAKER_03: So a lot of these people...
- 1:13:19and a lot of the neorationalists and this is why I don't like
- 1:13:23intelligence and
- 1:13:24spirit because it's too functionalist and this is why I don't
- 1:13:26like Nick Bostrom's
- 1:13:27ideas on intelligence and I don't like Kurtzweil's ideas on
- 1:13:30intelligence and why I
- 1:13:31disagree with Nick Land on intelligence because for this
- 1:13:36subject and it just it
- 1:13:37SPEAKER_03: blows me away that Alan Turing this guy who celebrated in the artificial
- 1:13:41intelligence world in this 1936 paper he demonstrates
- 1:13:45undecidability like he
- 1:13:46SPEAKER_03: demonstrates
- 1:13:48SPEAKER_03: Basically ontological negativity as far as I'm concerned.
- 1:13:53SPEAKER_03: But nobody seems to reckon with that.
- 1:13:55SPEAKER_03: And so still today,
- 1:13:57SPEAKER_03: like when we're talking about intelligence,
- 1:14:00SPEAKER_03: are we talking about human subjectivity?
- 1:14:02SPEAKER_03: Because if we're talking about human subjectivity, we need to be clear.
- 1:14:06We've already demonstrated that math and reason,
- 1:14:09like we know that it has its limits.
- 1:14:12SPEAKER_03: But for some reason when we transpose that onto machines and artificial
- 1:14:16SPEAKER_03: intelligence we act like that negativity doesn't exist.
- 1:14:20Like we act like oh we can create a machine that can do
- 1:14:22anything a human can do.
- 1:14:24SPEAKER_03: Maybe
- 1:14:25But also maybe there are some things that humans do that we
- 1:14:28can't even properly theorize.
- 1:14:31SPEAKER_03: Something like death drive.
- 1:14:32SPEAKER_03: That's why, I mean, it's so hard to understand.
- 1:14:34It's so hard to come to terms with,
- 1:14:36theoretically,
- 1:14:37because it's counterintuitive.
- 1:14:39SPEAKER_03: It's dysfunctional.
- 1:14:40SPEAKER_03: It's like it's anti-functionalistic in this weird way.
- 1:14:45SPEAKER_03: So to your point, Mikey, about this is-ought distinction, um...
- 1:14:52Yeah sure and we are the breakdown and we are the radical cut
- 1:14:56and this is where
- 1:14:57death drive enters into the scene and becomes primary for us we
- 1:15:01are the subject who
- 1:15:02is not identical and we can go off and create trouble for
- 1:15:06ourselves but it's also
- 1:15:07SPEAKER_03: an emancipation because we aren't married to function and efficiency and
- 1:15:14SPEAKER_03: optimization and all this shit that's my take on all of it
- 1:15:21so um Mikey when you were talking about Heidegger in like tool
- 1:15:27analysis like that's
- 1:15:28the same place where um where Graham Harmon takes off in in oo
- 1:15:36is uh this flat
- 1:15:37SPEAKER_00: ontology um and uh yeah object oriented ontology or oo um but
- 1:15:48the there's something I like about a flat ontology and I do
- 1:15:52think it gets you out
- 1:15:53of the like kind of stupid subject object problems that are
- 1:15:56like kind of pseudo
- 1:15:59problematic but they also point to something real like Nancy
- 1:16:02you were saying
- 1:16:02SPEAKER_00: because I think that like there is a breakdown
- 1:16:07and that's what that's that is the rupture that you get it's
- 1:16:10even there already in
- 1:16:12Heidegger like with the tool breakdown you know that there is
- 1:16:15this breakdown you
- 1:16:16can already get it from Heidegger where Graham Harmon goes off
- 1:16:20and says that like
- 1:16:21no all objects are flat everything exists in the same way and
- 1:16:25it's like I sort of
- 1:16:29SPEAKER_00: agree but I think it's like flat but it's also
- 1:16:33It has like ripples or something you know it's not there's
- 1:16:36planes it's not like
- 1:16:37dualistic like where there's planes but I think it's flat and
- 1:16:41there's like
- 1:16:41topography there's a topology to it yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah
- 1:16:46and so there's a
- 1:16:47breakdown there's a rub there's a hitch well and it's our care
- 1:16:50and concern and I
- 1:16:51think subject it's our care and concern that that kind of
- 1:16:55augments that flatness
- 1:16:56SPEAKER_03: and turns it into a topology
- 1:17:00and the mathematics is important for all this shit too I don't
- 1:17:04know quite how it
- 1:17:05fits in but there's also Godel's incompleteness theorem which
- 1:17:09is really along the
- 1:17:10similar lines which is like more or less it's like this
- 1:17:15statement is unprovable
- 1:17:16within the statement is unprovable within this system like
- 1:17:21there's a point at which
- 1:17:22SPEAKER_00: you like you
- 1:17:25SPEAKER_00: There's things that are like seem obviously true but you can't prove them
- 1:17:29mathematically I don't know quite how those things tie in
- 1:17:32because I don't know
- 1:17:33enough fucking math but you know but there is kind of an
- 1:17:37incomplete a rub I think
- 1:17:41Heidegger would have hated Harmon Maybe I mean seriously like
- 1:17:48look like I'm sorry
- 1:17:49SPEAKER_02: like the number one thing Heidegger was trying to deconstruct was
- 1:17:56Substance Ontology being the ontological default setting and
- 1:18:01what Harmon does is
- 1:18:02the most like radical form of Aristotelian substance ontology
- 1:18:08yes and like
- 1:18:10Heidegger would cringe because this started with his tool
- 1:18:14analysis which is
- 1:18:16SPEAKER_02: fundamentally an attempt to undermine substance ontology
- 1:18:21well what do you mean by substance because like a thing that
- 1:18:24exists independently
- 1:18:26from all other things and is what it is by itself without any
- 1:18:29relation to other
- 1:18:30things ah yeah and it's like Harmon rejects matter as a concept
- 1:18:37like he says that
- 1:18:38yeah but he also says the Civil War is a substance in the
- 1:18:42Aristotelian sense he
- 1:18:44SPEAKER_00: says it's an object but is that the same that's what he means
- 1:18:48yeah yeah he means a thing that is what it is independent from
- 1:18:52any relations to any
- 1:18:54other thing how the fuck am I I can't make sense of that right
- 1:18:58and this is not me
- 1:18:59like I'm not like attacking Harmon I'm just saying like this is
- 1:19:02a philosophers
- 1:19:03whose thought I can't make any sense of where I like and it's
- 1:19:09even more perplexing
- 1:19:10to me that somehow this like he was inspired off of Heidegger
- 1:19:16it's just bizarre
- 1:19:18It is strange but I think it's always been like what question
- 1:19:22are you what like
- 1:19:23what problem are you trying to solve and like I guess it's a
- 1:19:26good counter to people
- 1:19:28who take analytic philosophy to an extreme and it's a good
- 1:19:32counter to people who
- 1:19:33take like a flux doctrine like a Heraclidian or Deleuzian thing
- 1:19:37to an extreme but
- 1:19:38like on its own I don't think it makes sense outside of like I
- 1:19:43don't think I don't
- 1:19:45SPEAKER_00: I'm skeptical that it
- 1:19:46I don't know that it makes any sense outside of critiquing
- 1:19:49other things like on its own.
- 1:19:51SPEAKER_00: I don't know if it stands, you know?
- 1:19:53SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 1:19:53SPEAKER_02: Well, I mean this whole thing of like
- 1:19:58SPEAKER_02: I understand this anti-correlationist impulse.
- 1:20:01SPEAKER_02: I want to know the thing in itself.
- 1:20:03SPEAKER_02: Kant has become a dogma.
- 1:20:06SPEAKER_02: Oh,
- 1:20:06we can only know things through the filter of our own cognitive
- 1:20:10apparatus or
- 1:20:11SPEAKER_02: through the frame of our libidinal economies.
- 1:20:13SPEAKER_02: However you want to say it.
- 1:20:14SPEAKER_02: There's always some human stain on our relation with the object.
- 1:20:20SPEAKER_02: Dude, but it's weird.
- 1:20:23SPEAKER_02: I'm just going to say, for Harmon, for Harmon,
- 1:20:28like he is that's part of that whole speculative realist
- 1:20:32movement is trying to do
- 1:20:35justice to the integrity of the object in itself I mean look I
- 1:20:39think Mayesu like I
- 1:20:41SPEAKER_02: like the way Mayesu goes about it more um
- 1:20:45I mean look I probably if you you know if I went back and kind
- 1:20:49of read I think I
- 1:20:51like all three of the other speculative realists more than
- 1:20:55Harmon just because
- 1:20:56Harmon's work just doesn't make any sense to me and I don't
- 1:21:00know how look I mean it
- 1:21:03sounds like Good Will Hunting talking to you know Robin
- 1:21:07Williams or I forgot what
- 1:21:09SPEAKER_02: the character's name is Robin Williams played in Good Will Hunting
- 1:21:12but no it's like read whatever like blows blows your mind or
- 1:21:16whatever like I I read
- 1:21:18philosophers for because you know I want to focus on the ones
- 1:21:22that teach me
- 1:21:22something and I can use in my own thinking I still I have no
- 1:21:26idea how to use Harmon
- 1:21:27basically for anything and yeah oh yeah like yeah you know yeah
- 1:21:34even Mayesu right
- 1:21:36SPEAKER_02: uh Ian Hamilton Grant like it's just
- 1:21:40Harmon's this weird thing where I'm like I mean it's kinda like
- 1:21:45I kinda have a
- 1:21:45similar relationship to Leibniz like this where I'm like dude
- 1:21:49I'm not denying that
- 1:21:50you don't have philosophical talent he loves Leibniz I'm just
- 1:21:55saying I don't know
- 1:21:55what to do with you like you don't yeah yeah and he he's a big
- 1:22:01fan of Leibniz
- 1:22:02actually but he he weirdly both accepts the Kantian thing in
- 1:22:06itself and like
- 1:22:08SPEAKER_00: Husserl at the same time
- 1:22:11which is like different it's different you know it's just not
- 1:22:17my kind of philosophy
- 1:22:18and like yeah yeah he does have really good critiques of like
- 1:22:23analytic philosophy
- 1:22:24SPEAKER_00: and like it's
- 1:22:26I like how he talks about that where he's like no language like
- 1:22:29is intrinsically
- 1:22:30metaphorical you know saying that an object is vacuum sealed
- 1:22:35and really saying like
- 1:22:38A equals A it is what it is in and of itself without any
- 1:22:41relation to I don't know
- 1:22:43how a tree is what it is in itself without its relationship to
- 1:22:46soil water air I
- 1:22:50SPEAKER_02: don't know how you can vacuum seal it out of all like I'm sorry like
- 1:22:57yeah yeah no I know what you mean it makes no sense to me yeah
- 1:23:01no I know what you
- 1:23:02mean it's weird um I just think like all I'm saying is he has
- 1:23:05some critiques that
- 1:23:06are interesting of other things but it is yeah that's all I'm
- 1:23:10saying I'm just
- 1:23:11saying substance ontology works pragmatically like that chunk
- 1:23:15of matter over there
- 1:23:17SPEAKER_02: that we call a tree cut it down move it over here right like I understand
- 1:23:23SPEAKER_02: No, he thinks that things exist
- 1:23:53SPEAKER_00: He's really big on form,
- 1:23:54but I'm pretty sure he has to say that form inheres in objects
- 1:23:58themselves.
- 1:23:59SPEAKER_00: And I don't think that's true.
- 1:24:01SPEAKER_00: I don't think that's the case at all.
- 1:24:02SPEAKER_00: That's not me.
- 1:24:05SPEAKER_00: But anyway,
- 1:24:06SPEAKER_00: actually the point,
- 1:24:07the only reason I brought that up is just because the flat
- 1:24:11ontology thing I think
- 1:24:12SPEAKER_00: is interesting because it's weird to arbitrarily privilege objects.
- 1:24:20I think you have to accept it as arbitrary to privilege certain
- 1:24:24forms of existence
- 1:24:25over an other and just be okay with the arbitrariness and so
- 1:24:30that's why like the
- 1:24:31flatness of the ontology of like everything that exists just
- 1:24:34exists and there's
- 1:24:38sort of like that is sort of like that's what it made me think
- 1:24:42of when you were
- 1:24:43talking about Heidegger which is where Graham Harmon gets off
- 1:24:45from before the
- 1:24:47SPEAKER_00: breakdown of the tool happens
- 1:24:49SPEAKER_00: Yeah, we are the breakdown, I think.
- 1:24:53SPEAKER_02: But no, if you're doing hardcore flat ontology, though, we're not a cut.
- 1:25:00SPEAKER_00: Yeah, no, exactly.
- 1:25:02SPEAKER_00: And he can't say that.
- 1:25:03He has to say that we exist just like everything else in the
- 1:25:06same way that
- 1:25:06SPEAKER_00: everything else exists.
- 1:25:07And so do leprechauns and,
- 1:25:10you know,
- 1:25:10objects of thought in the Civil War and et cetera.
- 1:25:16I think there's modes of being and yeah I mean I understand
- 1:25:19this desire have I ever
- 1:25:23SPEAKER_02: told you like the first philosophical thought I ever remember having was
- 1:25:27Heideggerian I just when I was a kid I somehow and it's like
- 1:25:32I'm not saying I was
- 1:25:33SPEAKER_02: like overly philosophical as a kid I wasn't
- 1:25:36but I remember sitting in my backyard looking around at all the
- 1:25:40different stuff and
- 1:25:42I go all this I'm thinking to myself I'm like all this exists I
- 1:25:45wonder what it all
- 1:25:46has in common right because it's hard to figure out what it has
- 1:25:51in common but no I
- 1:25:55get it like numbers seem to have an odd ontological status
- 1:25:59right concept have a
- 1:26:01SPEAKER_02: similar but also different um
- 1:26:05SPEAKER_02: It is still this big open question that Heidegger never answered.
- 1:26:08SPEAKER_02: I'm just saying,
- 1:26:08SPEAKER_02: I think trying to treat everything as a vacuum-sealed substance,
- 1:26:11SPEAKER_02: I'm just telling you,
- 1:26:12SPEAKER_02: it makes no fucking sense to me.
- 1:26:30SPEAKER_03: I do know that there is a more and more popular,
- 1:26:38SPEAKER_03: I think by the day,
- 1:26:40SPEAKER_03: type of computer,
- 1:26:43SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 1:26:44SPEAKER_03: programming,
- 1:26:45SPEAKER_03: I guess,
- 1:26:46SPEAKER_03: building apps,
- 1:26:47SPEAKER_03: building stuff,
- 1:26:49SPEAKER_03: building shit on the computer called object-oriented programming.
- 1:26:54SPEAKER_03: And that has always tickled me since I learned about it.
- 1:26:58I was like,
- 1:26:59oh,
- 1:26:59it's like object-oriented ontology,
- 1:27:00but it's object-oriented.
- 1:27:01SPEAKER_03: It's ooh.
- 1:27:02SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:27:03SPEAKER_03: But it also does...
- 1:27:05SPEAKER_03: I mean,
- 1:27:05SPEAKER_03: there's more to it than just the name because I think an ooh world...
- 1:27:10SPEAKER_03: Sure,
- 1:27:11SPEAKER_03: you can have an ooh world that is flat,
- 1:27:14SPEAKER_03: that is entirely flat,
- 1:27:15SPEAKER_03: that is entirely like...
- 1:27:17SPEAKER_03: Things are as they appear.
- 1:27:19SPEAKER_03: And I think...
- 1:27:22That's the computer world like I think for for my computer like
- 1:27:26subtract me the subject
- 1:27:29from the equation and just have this standalone substantial
- 1:27:32computer doing computer
- 1:27:33things there is no difference there is no variation it all just
- 1:27:39kind of is what it
- 1:27:40is I think OOO is yeah I do think you're right Mikey I think it
- 1:27:49is doing this kind
- 1:27:50SPEAKER_03: of substance ontology thing and I also think it's trying to I don't know
- 1:27:59SPEAKER_03: Evaporate the negativity and the negation.
- 1:28:03And I think an OOOologist would be more than happy to live
- 1:28:07inside a computer
- 1:28:08SPEAKER_03: simulation and be nothing more than an NPC in a video game.
- 1:28:14SPEAKER_03: I think for the sake of Skyrim,
- 1:28:17SPEAKER_03: when I'm playing Skyrim,
- 1:28:19SPEAKER_03: if I could transpose myself into the video game,
- 1:28:22SPEAKER_03: OOO would apply to the video game world.
- 1:28:27but we're not in the video game people we're playing the
- 1:28:31fucking video game um but
- 1:28:37I don't know I'm just saying what the other three of the
- 1:28:41speculative realists had
- 1:28:43to say made sense to me and Harmon didn't make sense yeah um
- 1:28:52yeah we don't have to
- 1:28:53SPEAKER_00: talk about Harmon but um
- 1:28:54Let me ask you guys this do you think that there needs to be
- 1:28:57more finessing done on
- 1:28:58these distinctions between pleasure principle will the power
- 1:29:02death drive needs to
- 1:29:06be no probably not but it's weird all I'll say is like will the
- 1:29:13power seems to
- 1:29:16complicate things when it comes because there's this nice kind
- 1:29:21of conceptual
- 1:29:22SPEAKER_02: consistency
- 1:29:24in Lacanian,
- 1:29:24Zizekian Theory with Pleasure Principle and Death Drive,
- 1:29:28right?
- 1:29:29SPEAKER_02: So Pleasure Principle seeks homeostasis,
- 1:29:34SPEAKER_02: which is lack of excitation,
- 1:29:37SPEAKER_02: lack of intensity in the body,
- 1:29:39SPEAKER_02: in the central nervous system,
- 1:29:41SPEAKER_02: being calm,
- 1:29:42SPEAKER_02: cool,
- 1:29:42SPEAKER_02: collected.
- 1:29:44SPEAKER_02: You're basically trying to reproduce a status quo.
- 1:29:48SPEAKER_02: You know, you're cool with how things are.
- 1:29:51SPEAKER_02: You're not trying to change things more than anything.
- 1:29:54SPEAKER_02: You're kind of trying to maintain what you've got.
- 1:29:58SPEAKER_02: Okay,
- 1:29:59SPEAKER_02: death drive is conceived of as a type of force that seeks out intensity,
- 1:30:08SPEAKER_02: seeks out a rupture of the status quo.
- 1:30:12SPEAKER_02: But in that sense, it makes it self-destructive.
- 1:30:17You're undermining your own pleasure,
- 1:30:19which is conceived of as your own well-being,
- 1:30:24right?
- 1:30:25So death drive is connected to a kind of expansive intensity,
- 1:30:30but one that's self-destructive.
- 1:30:34and what defines it is that the sensation that we get from this
- 1:30:39called jouissance
- 1:30:41is a pleasure and pain yeah we're destroying ourselves we're
- 1:30:45undermining ourselves
- 1:30:47SPEAKER_02: but we are enjoying it uh
- 1:30:53SPEAKER_02: But Pleasure Principle is kind of conceived of as,
- 1:30:56SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:30:56SPEAKER_02: calm,
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: cool,
- 1:30:57SPEAKER_02: collected,
- 1:30:58SPEAKER_02: self-mastery,
- 1:30:59SPEAKER_02: I've got shit under control,
- 1:31:01SPEAKER_02: I'm trying to maintain the status quo,
- 1:31:03SPEAKER_02: reproduce myself as I am.
- 1:31:06SPEAKER_02: Well,
- 1:31:06SPEAKER_02: the power seems to be,
- 1:31:07SPEAKER_02: like,
- 1:31:07SPEAKER_02: it wants expansion,
- 1:31:10SPEAKER_02: but it wants some sort of intensive expansion of self-mastery and power,
- 1:31:18SPEAKER_02: too.
- 1:31:19SPEAKER_02: So, because it's not about having power over others.
- 1:31:24SPEAKER_02: I mean, I think that's an unfair criticism.
- 1:31:28Oh,
- 1:31:29will the power just means you want to control everybody or have
- 1:31:32power over everybody?
- 1:31:33SPEAKER_02: No, you want to have power to expand your own capability.
- 1:31:39I think pleasure principle and will to power can both be
- 1:31:45solipsistic things whereas
- 1:31:48I think death drive I mean sure death drive could also be a
- 1:31:51solipsistic thing but I
- 1:31:52think what death drive does what it opens up is is the
- 1:31:56potential for negation and
- 1:32:00the potential for negation opens up the possibility of the
- 1:32:03other coming in and so
- 1:32:04SPEAKER_03: that's how you get like it's not solipsistic whereas pleasure principle
- 1:32:09or Will to Power both like if Pleasure Principle you just sit
- 1:32:13around eating ice
- 1:32:13cream and having orgasms all day I think that also could be
- 1:32:19Will to Power like I
- 1:32:20want to have all the ice cream and I want to have all the
- 1:32:22orgasms whereas I think
- 1:32:25SPEAKER_03: Death Drive is different I just think they're different like I think
- 1:32:32Do you think that Will to Power on its own as a concept has
- 1:32:36trouble making sense of
- 1:32:38us because it doesn't have a self undermining self destructive
- 1:32:42aspect at play here?
- 1:32:44Yeah I don't like Will to Power for that reason because for me
- 1:32:47Will to Power
- 1:32:49like it's okay Schopenhauer's will okay same like same thing
- 1:32:52it's just embodied are
- 1:32:54they the same will nance to you or is is the difference between
- 1:32:57Schopenhauer and
- 1:32:58Nietzsche ultimately that they have different existential
- 1:33:02dispositions towards this
- 1:33:03Will Schopenhauer thinks it should be denied blah blah blah
- 1:33:08Nietzsche's like no
- 1:33:09affirmant or is it a different will altogether where I think
- 1:33:13it's the same thing
- 1:33:13I've heard it talk about Schopenhauer's will is like a will to
- 1:33:16life which is almost
- 1:33:18more like pleasure principle and Nietzsche's will to power is
- 1:33:22like a will to thrive
- 1:33:25Sure but I mean that's because Nietzsche was a romantic and he
- 1:33:29believed in great
- 1:33:31greatness and Schopenhauer was a pessimist and he didn't I
- 1:33:36think it's the same
- 1:33:36thing Maybe it's also the same like Will would just involve
- 1:33:41like a drive towards
- 1:33:43reproduction the status quo of yourself whereas Will the Power
- 1:33:46is a drive for
- 1:33:47self-expansion and self-overcoming See I don't think Yeah the
- 1:33:51self-overcoming part
- 1:33:53SPEAKER_00: I don't think that's in Will the Power
- 1:33:58I think that's part of it I think so because I think the super
- 1:34:08the overman the
- 1:34:09superman that's like the overcoming of man right so it's like I
- 1:34:13think that that
- 1:34:15overman has to undermine man in order to overcome man I think
- 1:34:21you could tie death
- 1:34:22drive and will to power in a way no because death drive is
- 1:34:25something we have no
- 1:34:27Death Drive is not this hypothetical and rocks don't have it I
- 1:34:32guess rocks have
- 1:34:33will to power yeah because it's just Schopenhauer's will but
- 1:34:36like for Nietzsche for
- 1:34:38the overman and for all this becoming blah blah blah whatever
- 1:34:42it's all hypothetical
- 1:34:43it's a Keynesian subject it's deferred whereas Death Drive is
- 1:34:48right now it's
- 1:34:49SPEAKER_03: constitutive of me like there is no self overcoming in Nietzsche
- 1:34:59like the overman is not a real imminent thing the overman is
- 1:35:03this hypothetical like
- 1:35:05oh well what if I don't like it's for me I don't know it's very
- 1:35:09different for me I
- 1:35:11mean look does this let me ask you guys a more basic
- 1:35:14philosophical question do you
- 1:35:16do either of you truly like look again if we're playing in land
- 1:35:21world we're gonna
- 1:35:21play the game if we're playing in Nietzsche world or
- 1:35:23Schopenhauer world we're gonna
- 1:35:24SPEAKER_02: play the game you really think
- 1:35:27The universe Is best made sense of Made sense of Through some
- 1:35:33sort of principle
- 1:35:34That we conceive of as a will I don't know if I actually Like
- 1:35:38me myself I don't
- 1:35:40know if I buy this That I get that look The only part of me
- 1:35:46that's Open to it is Is
- 1:35:49it true that this universe Produces things It makes it
- 1:35:53actualizes Into things
- 1:35:56SPEAKER_02: That's true.
- 1:36:01SPEAKER_02: But does that physicalistic process of production,
- 1:36:08SPEAKER_02: is there an underlying metaphysical will behind it?
- 1:36:12SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
- 1:36:13SPEAKER_02: I guess my thing is,
- 1:36:15do we need a metaphysical explanation for what physics seems to
- 1:36:18be able to explain?
- 1:36:20SPEAKER_00: My question for you is, does Nick Land think that there's a will?
- 1:36:25and yes yeah right he does doesn't he and because he's the
- 1:36:32start I mean he begins
- 1:36:33SPEAKER_02: as a libidinal materialist which in one way or another it's some sort of
- 1:36:38fundamental numinal will is the driving force and whether you
- 1:36:44call it energy or you
- 1:36:45call it libido or you call it matter or you call it
- 1:36:49intelligence or will to think
- 1:36:52SPEAKER_02: that's the
- 1:36:54I mean I think I think it's entirely appropriate to talk about
- 1:37:02the universe having
- 1:37:03a will I think when people were doing thought experiments and
- 1:37:13making observations
- 1:37:14and thinking and figuring this stuff out we didn't have proton
- 1:37:21detectors and the
- 1:37:23SPEAKER_03: Two Billion Nances
- 1:37:54this will towards self expansion it is productive and I think
- 1:37:58it's sure call it
- 1:37:59will that's fine because I don't that's why I don't like will
- 1:38:02to power because like
- 1:38:04yeah sure will means this disembodied cosmic force of
- 1:38:08Schopenhauer I don't like
- 1:38:11will to power because for me will is not the thing that makes
- 1:38:14humans humans like
- 1:38:18SPEAKER_00: even going back to like Epicurus and the Greeks though like um
- 1:38:23There were people who did not describe it as a will then
- 1:38:26because like Plato would
- 1:38:28SPEAKER_00: have said that he believed in like a flux or a flow or something,
- 1:38:32but it was like the creator of the universe just set it off and
- 1:38:37walked away.
- 1:38:38SPEAKER_00: Just set it into motion and fucked off.
- 1:38:42SPEAKER_03: But that still comes down to like the...
- 1:38:45SPEAKER_03: At that point,
- 1:38:46SPEAKER_03: the formal cause or whatever,
- 1:38:48SPEAKER_03: final cause,
- 1:38:49SPEAKER_03: whatever,
- 1:38:51SPEAKER_03: there is still a cause,
- 1:38:52SPEAKER_03: there is still an accounting for,
- 1:38:53there is still something that would be considered a will or an
- 1:38:59agency or even a
- 1:39:01SPEAKER_03: prime mover.
- 1:39:02SPEAKER_03: It always has the same connotations that will does.
- 1:39:05SPEAKER_03: I think it's entirely fine and entirely appropriate.
- 1:39:08Because I don't think it's appropriate to talk about humans in
- 1:39:11terms of will and intelligence.
- 1:39:13SPEAKER_03: I think we have to talk about humans or subjects as subjects,
- 1:39:18not just as intelligent creatures or not just as living things
- 1:39:22with wills to power
- 1:39:24SPEAKER_03: and wills to will and this and that.
- 1:39:27SPEAKER_03: Subjectivity is not that.
- 1:39:29SPEAKER_03: Human intelligence is not that.
- 1:39:31SPEAKER_03: So go ahead and say it's a will, a universal cosmic will, a
- 1:39:36Will and Representation For sure Go ahead and call it whatever
- 1:39:40Because I think
- 1:39:41they're all attempts To account for flow and flux Rotary drives
- 1:39:47All these things
- 1:39:48But there seems Doesn't there seem to be There seems to be
- 1:39:52something vested in like
- 1:39:54Trying to categorize that as a will As distinct from just like
- 1:39:57a movement Like that
- 1:39:58does seem like someone's trying to get Because it involves
- 1:40:01mattering Caring on some
- 1:40:03SPEAKER_02: level
- 1:40:04SPEAKER_00: Yeah, and I just think the flux is indifferent.
- 1:40:08SPEAKER_00: It doesn't care.
- 1:40:10SPEAKER_00: It was put in motion and it's just moving.
- 1:40:14SPEAKER_00: It doesn't give a fuck.
- 1:40:16SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 1:40:18SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 1:40:19SPEAKER_03: I'm not trying to achieve anything.
- 1:40:21SPEAKER_03: But to me, it doesn't matter.
- 1:40:22SPEAKER_03: And I think today it doesn't matter because capitalism killed God.
- 1:40:29SPEAKER_03: And that's not to say that...
- 1:40:33SPEAKER_03: because I think philosophers and thinkers and I don't know.
- 1:40:44SPEAKER_03: Sean, were we talking about Anselm or Erasmus or somebody?
- 1:40:51SPEAKER_03: And I was like, yeah, I think that guy was an atheist.
- 1:40:55Oh yeah I think we were talking about Erasmus yeah and I was
- 1:40:58like I think that guy
- 1:40:58was an atheist he's a Christian fucking mystic but like I think
- 1:41:04like atheists have
- 1:41:05probably existed all along but I don't think it was until
- 1:41:08capitalism and or
- 1:41:09modernity kind of came in that God was really properly dead and
- 1:41:15so even even people
- 1:41:18SPEAKER_03: who wanted to
- 1:41:21SPEAKER_03: Be careful and not attribute a will or an agency or God or whatever.
- 1:41:29SPEAKER_03: Like God was still very much alive in the everyday world,
- 1:41:32SPEAKER_03: in the everyday life world of people and everyone's umwelt.
- 1:41:35SPEAKER_03: God was real.
- 1:41:37SPEAKER_03: God acted or the gods or the ancestors.
- 1:41:42or nature but not in this kind of denatured scientific way that
- 1:41:46we talk about
- 1:41:47nature but like this pre-modern way where nature was alive
- 1:41:50nature was magical so
- 1:41:52SPEAKER_03: there was like the cosmos itself was imbued with a surplus
- 1:41:57SPEAKER_03: That it's fair to call God.
- 1:41:59SPEAKER_03: And then modernity hits and God dies.
- 1:42:01SPEAKER_03: And that happens because with modernity,
- 1:42:05SPEAKER_03: with capitalization,
- 1:42:06SPEAKER_03: with everything being marketized,
- 1:42:07SPEAKER_03: everything becomes accessible,
- 1:42:08SPEAKER_03: everything becomes rational,
- 1:42:11SPEAKER_03: and everything becomes a function of exchange value.
- 1:42:16SPEAKER_03: Previously,
- 1:42:17things were functions of God's divinity or the good graces of
- 1:42:20nature or Gaia or the
- 1:42:21SPEAKER_03: Mother Spirit or whatever it was.
- 1:42:24SPEAKER_03: And so it wasn't fungible in the same way that exchange value is.
- 1:42:28SPEAKER_03: Now exchange value always bottoms out in the prime commodity, money.
- 1:42:32SPEAKER_03: Exchange value always bottoms out in exchange.
- 1:42:35So there's always a rational justification for everything in
- 1:42:39modernity and under capitalism.
- 1:42:42Because everything is reduced To exchange value In some way or
- 1:42:47another And I think
- 1:42:49SPEAKER_03: Marcel Mauss and Baudrillard and all these other guys are really good at
- 1:42:54investigating ideas of value Bataille as well but ultimately
- 1:42:58it's exchange value
- 1:42:59and exchange value is functional and it's rational and it's
- 1:43:03justifiable because
- 1:43:05it's beholden to the market so it has to be able to back itself
- 1:43:08up logically
- 1:43:09because all these things operate hyperstitionally so if people
- 1:43:14have no faith in it
- 1:43:16SPEAKER_03: Then it's just gonna fail.
- 1:43:18SPEAKER_03: So like everything has to be rational.
- 1:43:22SPEAKER_03: And so now I think problems of is it will or is it a disembodied flux?
- 1:43:28SPEAKER_03: I think those questions matter today.
- 1:43:31But I think 700 years ago those questions didn't matter because
- 1:43:35it all meant God or
- 1:43:40SPEAKER_03: the divine or the mystical or whatever.
- 1:43:42SPEAKER_03: Like there was just no...
- 1:43:45SPEAKER_03: There was nothing that didn't have God in it before modernity, I think.
- 1:43:52But in,
- 1:43:53I don't know if like,
- 1:43:56I mean,
- 1:43:56I don't even,
- 1:43:57I don't disagree with that.
- 1:44:02SPEAKER_00: But I guess like, it also seems like to me, nothing's changed.
- 1:44:07Like we're still dealing with the same problems because we're
- 1:44:10still the same
- 1:44:11SPEAKER_00: fundamental problems.
- 1:44:13the same things even though the economic situation has vastly
- 1:44:17changed and we're
- 1:44:17confronting different economic problems but yeah I guess I
- 1:44:22don't think I disagree
- 1:44:23with anything you just said I second it all I agree with you in
- 1:44:29the sense that like
- 1:44:30nothing has changed on the surface for sure but it's I mean
- 1:44:33it's also true I think
- 1:44:35SPEAKER_03: like I don't know
- 1:44:38I think was it Caligula who was like famously crazy and
- 1:44:43perverted and did a bunch
- 1:44:44SPEAKER_03: of fucked up shit.
- 1:44:46I don't know man like sure there were people like Caligula but
- 1:44:50like by and large I
- 1:44:52think kings and rulers and tribal chieftains and all this stuff
- 1:44:56like I think they
- 1:44:58they were genuinely beholden to a logic of God morality some
- 1:45:06type of morality I
- 1:45:07SPEAKER_03: mean we've been reading Bataille talking about human sacrifice yeah
- 1:45:10Isn't the reason Vlad the Impaler stands out is because most of
- 1:45:14them weren't like him?
- 1:45:15SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
- 1:45:15SPEAKER_03: like at the end of the day where it all bottoms out,
- 1:45:20where the rubber really hits the road for social organization
- 1:45:24and politics and
- 1:45:24SPEAKER_03: economics and all that was in the divine rather than exchange.
- 1:45:29SPEAKER_03: That has changed.
- 1:45:30SPEAKER_03: That's the one thing that's changed.
- 1:45:32So while we're still dealing with a lot of the same structures
- 1:45:35and a lot of the
- 1:45:36very same form of all the shit that's come before us and it
- 1:45:40keeps rehashing itself,
- 1:45:42SPEAKER_03: that's what the churn does.
- 1:45:44SPEAKER_03: I think that's a real difference.
- 1:45:47The fact that it bottoms out in exchange today versus it
- 1:45:50bottomed out in divinity previously.
- 1:45:53SPEAKER_03: And what's it going to bottom out in tomorrow?
- 1:45:57Right because even though that's that's that's a great question
- 1:46:00uh but even though
- 1:46:01um even though like Athens was like a market society for
- 1:46:05instance and like that was
- 1:46:07what Plato was like critiquing in the Republic is like we've
- 1:46:10given ourselves over
- 1:46:11to the market too much and it's making us into nihilists yeah
- 1:46:15and we're gonna
- 1:46:16SPEAKER_00: destroy ourselves and that's kind of what happened um
- 1:46:20SPEAKER_00: Like,
- 1:46:21SPEAKER_00: even though that's true,
- 1:46:22SPEAKER_00: there was still,
- 1:46:23SPEAKER_00: even there,
- 1:46:24SPEAKER_00: there's still this stopgap of like,
- 1:46:26SPEAKER_00: yeah,
- 1:46:26SPEAKER_00: but the citizens can just say,
- 1:46:28SPEAKER_00: no,
- 1:46:28SPEAKER_00: we're closing the port.
- 1:46:29SPEAKER_00: Like, that political option is always on the table.
- 1:46:33And the oracle could convince the citizens,
- 1:46:36look,
- 1:46:37God told me we need to close the port.
- 1:46:39SPEAKER_00: Like, that could totally happen in that world.
- 1:46:41Whereas,
- 1:46:42like,
- 1:46:42in our world,
- 1:46:43we have no mechanism for turning the fucker off.
- 1:46:46SPEAKER_00: It's not possible.
- 1:46:48SPEAKER_00: The fucking handle broke off.
- 1:46:50SPEAKER_00: You know, the shit is running.
- 1:46:53SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 1:46:53SPEAKER_00: And that's different.
- 1:46:54SPEAKER_00: That is different.
- 1:46:55SPEAKER_02: There's a weird inversion here, right?
- 1:46:57SPEAKER_02: Which is also that capital itself becomes deified.
- 1:47:02SPEAKER_03: Yep.
- 1:47:03SPEAKER_02: Right.
- 1:47:03SPEAKER_02: Like,
- 1:47:04SPEAKER_02: so look,
- 1:47:05SPEAKER_02: I go back,
- 1:47:06SPEAKER_02: you know,
- 1:47:06SPEAKER_02: the famous that Christ flipping over the tables,
- 1:47:09SPEAKER_02: the money lending tables at the temple.
- 1:47:13what were they doing they were doing the proto version of
- 1:47:17Capital which was usury
- 1:47:19right the one time that he raged out it was on the proto
- 1:47:26version of MCM Prime which
- 1:47:29was using money to make more money right and that very process
- 1:47:38is precisely what
- 1:47:40SPEAKER_01: usurped
- 1:47:43SPEAKER_02: Christ is God and Christ's Father is God and took the position of God.
- 1:47:49SPEAKER_02: What?
- 1:47:49SPEAKER_02: And so... 100%.
- 1:47:52SPEAKER_02: I think...
- 1:47:52SPEAKER_02: So no,
- 1:47:52I just think it's a fundamental moment where you see this
- 1:47:55antagonism between the
- 1:47:57old symbolic orders rooted in God's qualitative value systems
- 1:48:03opposed to our God of
- 1:48:08SPEAKER_02: economic exchange,
- 1:48:09SPEAKER_02: capital accumulation,
- 1:48:12SPEAKER_02: Which is all quantity based evaluations.
- 1:48:15SPEAKER_02: Quality versus quantity.
- 1:48:18SPEAKER_00: And it is like a fucking death bolt.
- 1:48:23SPEAKER_00: I just think about the fact that no one is even talking.
- 1:48:28SPEAKER_00: It's not even on the table to discuss.
- 1:48:31SPEAKER_00: These nuclear weapons that now more countries have than ever before...
- 1:48:38and we're we just don't think about them we're just like that's
- 1:48:41not a thing to
- 1:48:41discuss that's just like part of the world that's it and I'm
- 1:48:45like that's fucking
- 1:48:46nuts that's so much more dangerous than the Cold War like the
- 1:48:50Cold War was like
- 1:48:51everyone's paranoid about nuclear weapons and we're thinking
- 1:48:54about it all the time
- 1:48:55and it's scary as fuck that is a safer fucking world where
- 1:48:59everyone's afraid of the
- 1:49:00bomb than the world now where we just accept it as like this is
- 1:49:03here and we don't
- 1:49:04SPEAKER_00: even fucking talk about it so much more dangerous today
- 1:49:09so much worse we just started building more of them we just
- 1:49:15started increasing our
- 1:49:16fucking nuclear stockpiles yeah dude okay can I just pivot to
- 1:49:22one just completely
- 1:49:23random question because it's been on my mind the last couple
- 1:49:26days and Nance I've
- 1:49:27meant to ask it to you but uh look there's this thought
- 1:49:31experiment Roco's Basilisks
- 1:49:37And so the idea is that in the future as artificial
- 1:49:42intelligence develops it's
- 1:49:44going to become more and more aware of all of our online
- 1:49:50activity and it will have
- 1:49:54combed through all of the everything ever posted on the
- 1:49:57internet so it's going to
- 1:49:58become aware of the people who were against artificial
- 1:50:01intelligence and the people
- 1:50:03SPEAKER_02: who were for it and
- 1:50:06It's going to understand in its mind it it will view itself as
- 1:50:11a good so anybody
- 1:50:13SPEAKER_02: who was out to stop it will be retroactively treated as bad
- 1:50:20The one part of this thought experiment I don't understand is
- 1:50:23that it says then the
- 1:50:25AI will create simulated versions of the people who were trying
- 1:50:31to stop it and it
- 1:50:32will punish those simulations indefinitely for trying here's
- 1:50:37the thing why should I
- 1:50:39give a fuck of like a simulated version of me in what sense
- 1:50:43like how does this make
- 1:50:45SPEAKER_02: any fucking sense
- 1:50:47It's because the people who like Rocco's Basilisk don't make a
- 1:50:52distinction because
- 1:50:53SPEAKER_03: they're functionalists.
- 1:50:55So they think that a subject can be reproduced just by Ray
- 1:51:03Kurzweil legitimately
- 1:51:05SPEAKER_03: thinks he can resurrect his dead father.
- 1:51:07SPEAKER_03: Ray Kurzweil's life works.
- 1:51:09SPEAKER_02: Does he still have his brain?
- 1:51:11No I don't think he can do it without his brain yeah like he
- 1:51:16thinks he can
- 1:51:16genuinely resurrect him and recreate him and turn him into the
- 1:51:21same type of
- 1:51:22creatures that we are in some sense because it would be like in
- 1:51:25a silicon substrate
- 1:51:27but like these these people are functionalists these people
- 1:51:30reject undecidability
- 1:51:33these people reject the surplus like they reject our type of
- 1:51:39subject they just
- 1:51:40SPEAKER_03: think
- 1:51:43SPEAKER_02: On the basis of what?
- 1:51:44SPEAKER_02: Does he think photos and video footage of his dad is enough?
- 1:51:48SPEAKER_02: Does he think he can resurrect Beethoven?
- 1:51:50I'm pretty sure he said that but yeah writing like if you can
- 1:51:57these people in
- 1:51:59general that's like they're all functionalists a table as long
- 1:52:04as something is
- 1:52:05acting as a table it's a table and that's all it is and that's
- 1:52:07all it needs to be a
- 1:52:09person as long as a person is acting like a person then they
- 1:52:12are a person that
- 1:52:14SPEAKER_02: Tupac hologram that performed like 10 years ago at Coachella that's Tupac
- 1:52:23SPEAKER_00: That was actually Tupac in that moment.
- 1:52:26SPEAKER_02: From a functionalist perspective, yeah.
- 1:52:29SPEAKER_02: I'm never buying functionalist ontology if this is what it is.
- 1:52:32SPEAKER_03: It is.
- 1:52:33SPEAKER_03: And so they think that if they can create a computer system that
- 1:52:41SPEAKER_03: That can do all the things that your brain does,
- 1:52:46then you will have interiority and you will have subjective
- 1:52:49experience and you
- 1:52:50SPEAKER_03: should care because in that world,
- 1:52:53SPEAKER_03: you will exist once again and it won't be you as you are today,
- 1:52:57but it will be you as you will be in the future and it will
- 1:53:01have interiority and it
- 1:53:02SPEAKER_03: will suffer.
- 1:53:03SPEAKER_03: So...
- 1:53:06this is what happens when a culture just becomes like entirely
- 1:53:09relativistic in
- 1:53:10regards to truth which is like by definition it's so stupid
- 1:53:14because like by
- 1:53:15definition of truth it's not relative but it's like this is
- 1:53:19what happens when we
- 1:53:20just decide like you end up not being able to distinguish at
- 1:53:24all between simulation
- 1:53:25and reality like there's just no difference and that's
- 1:53:28functionalism right yeah
- 1:53:32SPEAKER_02: well I don't know I think that
- 1:53:36I think we will pull off time travel before we literally
- 1:53:40resurrect Beethoven.
- 1:53:42I think we'll probably,
- 1:53:43we'll never,
- 1:53:44I believe that every subject is a singular subject.
- 1:53:47SPEAKER_03: I think we'll never resurrect Beethoven.
- 1:53:49I think you could,
- 1:53:52if you pulled off time travel,
- 1:53:53you could,
- 1:53:54in a way,
- 1:53:54resurrect Beethoven.
- 1:53:56SPEAKER_00: Sure.
- 1:53:56SPEAKER_00: Go back and get it.
- 1:53:57SPEAKER_02: That's not resurrecting, that's just borrowing.
- 1:53:59SPEAKER_03: That's bringing and borrowing.
- 1:54:05SPEAKER_03: I so
- 1:54:07one of the things I wanted to talk about kind of relates to
- 1:54:09this like truth there's
- 1:54:10no way to distinguish truth from simulation today I was
- 1:54:15thinking about like
- 1:54:16conspiracy theorists and like radical leftists I used to listen
- 1:54:22I used to love
- 1:54:23listening to Art Bell and George Norrie on the fucking on the
- 1:54:27radio AM fucking
- 1:54:28coast to coast radio all the people talking about like aliens
- 1:54:31and fucking all this
- 1:54:33SPEAKER_03: shit reptilians and
- 1:54:35Shit like that and recently there have been there's been a lot
- 1:54:40of shit going on in
- 1:54:41the world but recently fucking Donald Trump released 156 UFO
- 1:54:50files I think it was
- 1:54:51150 something they promised thousands of files about aliens and
- 1:54:55UFOs did you see
- 1:54:56that he posted a photo of himself with an alien yeah that video
- 1:55:00he sent me that
- 1:55:00SPEAKER_03: video
- 1:55:01SPEAKER_03: Oh, that's right.
- 1:55:02SPEAKER_03: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:55:04SPEAKER_03: He put on his Trump Twitter truth.
- 1:55:08SPEAKER_03: He put a photo, an AI photo of him and an alien.
- 1:55:12SPEAKER_03: Like, what the fuck is going on?
- 1:55:13SPEAKER_03: So there's been a lot of spooky hocus pocus bullshit.
- 1:55:22And one of the many narratives that's going on right now is
- 1:55:26that scientists are disappearing.
- 1:55:30SPEAKER_03: And that
- 1:55:31Yeah I have a friend who sent me like one of those like
- 1:55:34conspiracy theory little
- 1:55:35TikTok videos and was like what do you think of this and I'm
- 1:55:38like there's like a
- 1:55:40SPEAKER_03: dozen or so
- 1:55:43End Quotes Scientists Who Have Disappeared Recently I Looked
- 1:55:47Into It Cause That
- 1:55:49That Piqued My Interest I Was Like Oh You Mean Like Nuclear
- 1:55:52Scientists And All
- 1:55:54These Like Actual Scientists Are Getting Merked Like They're
- 1:55:57Getting CIA They're
- 1:55:58Getting Fucking Epstein Black Bag Yeah That Interested Me So I
- 1:56:01Looked Into It Turns
- 1:56:02Out It's Not True There Were A Few There Was One Guy Who Was
- 1:56:06Having Marital Issues
- 1:56:08SPEAKER_03: He Like
- 1:56:09SPEAKER_03: Fucking hiked off into the woods and disappeared.
- 1:56:11There was that shooting in Maryland or Rhode Island or
- 1:56:16something a few months ago
- 1:56:18where somebody suffering from mental issues went and shot up a
- 1:56:23university.
- 1:56:25And there have been maybe a couple more high profile people who
- 1:56:30have died.
- 1:56:31Recently and then there's been like a dozen conspiracy
- 1:56:34theorists who have died and
- 1:56:35for whatever reason people are lumping all these conspiracy
- 1:56:38theorists in with all
- 1:56:39these like nuclear physicists and stuff to make it more
- 1:56:42sensational to say like 14
- 1:56:43SPEAKER_03: scientists have died.
- 1:56:46um but it's it's all it's all bullshit it's all explainable
- 1:56:50it's all normal
- 1:56:50everyday average bullshit uh but it got me thinking about like
- 1:56:54I've known people
- 1:56:55and I I had someone close to me fucking she killed herself and
- 1:57:00she was a normal
- 1:57:00person and then over the course of a couple years she got she
- 1:57:04fell further and
- 1:57:05SPEAKER_03: further into like conspiracy shit on the internet
- 1:57:10and it was tragic just to watch her like deteriorate she was
- 1:57:15into the Mandela
- 1:57:16SPEAKER_03: effect and then she started following this guy who he like could predict
- 1:57:22earthquakes and because he could predict earthquakes global
- 1:57:26warming was really a
- 1:57:28cover up to to do Jeffrey Epstein style stuff to a bunch of
- 1:57:32kids and aliens and
- 1:57:35SPEAKER_03: more and more wacko shit she was an older woman and she lived
- 1:57:40Alone and she didn't have any friends and stuff and it really
- 1:57:42sucked but you know
- 1:57:43she fucking killed herself and I don't know it just sucks and I
- 1:57:48started thinking
- 1:57:49about the other day when we were talking to Chris Chris said he
- 1:57:56said I believe that
- 1:57:58political parties are more intelligent than the individual
- 1:58:02members of that party I
- 1:58:05SPEAKER_03: was like yeah sure whatever you know the wisdom of the crowd
- 1:58:08But it got me thinking along these lines and I was thinking
- 1:58:11about conspiracy
- 1:58:12theorists and radical activists and collective intelligence and
- 1:58:19I don't necessarily
- 1:58:20know if it's true that in every case the collectivity is more
- 1:58:24intelligent than the
- 1:58:25individual Now I do believe Marxists are so much dumber than
- 1:58:29Marx and they've
- 1:58:30always been That's a great point dude I wonder what Chris would
- 1:58:36say to that
- 1:58:38that's a great point can we bookmark that question I could say
- 1:58:42it in a way that
- 1:58:43would flatter Chris also is that the last Marxist is far more
- 1:58:48intelligent far more
- 1:58:50intelligent than his own than the rest of the Marxists out
- 1:58:54there but it got me
- 1:58:59thinking like and Mikey the other day we were talking about
- 1:59:03healthcare and like in
- 1:59:04SPEAKER_03: order for
- 1:59:06SPEAKER_03: Two Billion
- 1:59:29Why I think it's detrimental for people to fall out of society
- 1:59:35and when they lose
- 1:59:37SPEAKER_03: their friends and they say,
- 1:59:39SPEAKER_03: oh,
- 1:59:39SPEAKER_03: I don't watch the mainstream news anymore.
- 1:59:41SPEAKER_03: I only listen to Captain Buttfuck Alien Sauce on the fucking internet.
- 1:59:46SPEAKER_03: All this stuff.
- 1:59:47Where it becomes dangerous and when people actually start to do
- 1:59:49dumb shit,
- 1:59:51it's not because...
- 1:59:52The individual is stupid but it's because when you fall out of
- 1:59:56the mainstream like
- 1:59:57you you become objectified like people say diversity is our
- 2:00:01strength and diversity
- 2:00:03is our greatest strength and all that yeah sure maybe but also
- 2:00:06maybe not I don't
- 2:00:06fucking know but it's true that diversity is constitutive of
- 2:00:10like who and what we
- 2:00:10SPEAKER_03: are like we belong to the collectivity
- 2:00:15SPEAKER_03: We are languished creatures.
- 2:00:17SPEAKER_03: I am not me in isolation.
- 2:00:19SPEAKER_03: I am not me on my own.
- 2:00:22SPEAKER_03: I am necessarily constituted of my situation,
- 2:00:27SPEAKER_03: my material conditions,
- 2:00:28SPEAKER_03: where I live,
- 2:00:29SPEAKER_03: where I'm from,
- 2:00:30SPEAKER_03: the language I speak,
- 2:00:31SPEAKER_03: and so on and so on.
- 2:00:35SPEAKER_03: So it's not to say that like
- 2:00:38The collective is more intelligent than the individual and
- 2:00:41that's a hard and fast
- 2:00:42point and we should always stick to that but it is to say that
- 2:00:46like without the
- 2:00:47collective the individual atrophies and the individual starts
- 2:00:50to objectify
- 2:00:51SPEAKER_03: themselves and either as the conspiracy theorist who kills themselves
- 2:00:57It's a feedback it goes both ways because without the
- 2:01:00individual the collective
- 2:01:01will become really fucking stupid like without the individual
- 2:01:04making themselves an
- 2:01:04individual distinct from the collective individual as such
- 2:01:09without them doing that
- 2:01:10there has to be this if there's not a virtuous circle there's
- 2:01:14going to be a
- 2:01:16SPEAKER_00: A negative, a trophic circle, right?
- 2:01:19Like this collective is composed of individuals who need to
- 2:01:23establish themselves as
- 2:01:24individuals separate from the collective in order for the
- 2:01:27collective to help.
- 2:01:28SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 2:01:28SPEAKER_00: It's por que no los dos.
- 2:01:31SPEAKER_02: Right, it's Nietzsche quote time.
- 2:01:33SPEAKER_02: Famous quote,
- 2:01:36SPEAKER_02: In individuals,
- 2:01:37SPEAKER_02: madness is rare,
- 2:01:38SPEAKER_02: but in groups,
- 2:01:39SPEAKER_02: parties,
- 2:01:39SPEAKER_02: nations,
- 2:01:40SPEAKER_02: and epochs,
- 2:01:40SPEAKER_02: it is the rule.
- 2:01:43So as opposed to the wisdom of crowds,
- 2:01:44we're talking about the madness of crowds.
- 2:01:47SPEAKER_02: Which we have to do.
- 2:01:49SPEAKER_02: But look,
- 2:01:50I get the thing when we were talking to Chris and it's like
- 2:01:54Hegelian Geist or
- 2:01:55SPEAKER_02: collective intelligibility.
- 2:01:57SPEAKER_02: Obviously, me, you, us, I mean, Einstein, Darwin, Hegel.
- 2:02:08SPEAKER_02: No individual has intelligibility without collective intelligibility.
- 2:02:14So there's that,
- 2:02:16but there's certainly the problem of herd mentality,
- 2:02:22of mob logic.
- 2:02:25And if that overtakes,
- 2:02:27I mean,
- 2:02:27it's almost like the fever of a collective,
- 2:02:30right?
- 2:02:32You know,
- 2:02:32a fever dream or something befalls a collectivity of a social
- 2:02:36group.
- 2:02:38The one that doesn't fall victim to that seems to be more
- 2:02:41intelligent than the
- 2:02:42SPEAKER_02: group at that point.
- 2:02:43SPEAKER_02: And I mean, what's that famous photo?
- 2:02:46Isn't there like a crowd of Nazis zig-heiling and there's one
- 2:02:50guy who's standing
- 2:02:51SPEAKER_02: there with his arms crossed?
- 2:02:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:02:53Like in a sense,
- 2:02:54can't you say that guy's much smarter than the collective
- 2:02:57surrounding him?
- 2:02:58SPEAKER_02: Well, I think...
- 2:02:59SPEAKER_03: On that, this feature of mad crowds versus wise crowds.
- 2:03:06SPEAKER_03: I do think, you know, the wisdom of crowds bears out largely.
- 2:03:10SPEAKER_03: But I think the madness of crowds also bears out.
- 2:03:14SPEAKER_03: You know, I think we've all seen it.
- 2:03:15SPEAKER_03: Like mob mentality, you get, or what's the thing?
- 2:03:20SPEAKER_03: A person is smart.
- 2:03:21People are dumb,
- 2:03:23stupid,
- 2:03:23selfish animals,
- 2:03:24whatever the men in black quote.
- 2:03:26SPEAKER_00: Men in black quote.
- 2:03:30SPEAKER_03: This is also true.
- 2:03:31SPEAKER_03: I think the feature of the wise crowd is diversity, ironically enough.
- 2:03:36SPEAKER_03: So I think when you when you draw away from the mainstream,
- 2:03:40SPEAKER_03: you are necessarily drawing into an identity or positivity.
- 2:03:47so like conspiracy theorists or radical activists of the left
- 2:03:51or of the right or
- 2:03:52radical centrists now you dumb fucking assholes I fucking can't
- 2:03:55stand people who
- 2:03:56talk about radical centralism fuck you guys fight me you're
- 2:04:00dumb but uh I just
- 2:04:04SPEAKER_03: there's people on the internet anyway um but don't
- 2:04:10Don't you think I think like I think like intent matters
- 2:04:13because like when you go
- 2:04:14away from the crowd and your intention is just to go away from
- 2:04:18the crowd like
- 2:04:19that's it that's the end of your intention is I have to remove
- 2:04:22myself from the
- 2:04:23collective yeah that's when like bad shit happens but if you if
- 2:04:26your intention is
- 2:04:27to step away from the crowd in order to come back to the crowd
- 2:04:30at a later time when
- 2:04:31SPEAKER_00: you're smarter
- 2:04:32yeah no I think that's it like I think when you when you step
- 2:04:36away from the crowd
- 2:04:37or when you step away from the mainstream or even fall out of
- 2:04:40the mainstream
- 2:04:41because you can't afford it or whatever like if you are seeking
- 2:04:46affirmation if you
- 2:04:47are seeking an identity or if you're seeking like a positivity
- 2:04:50a collective with
- 2:04:51whom to identify that's when dangerous shit starts to happen
- 2:04:54that the people who
- 2:04:55SPEAKER_03: fucking shoot themselves from conspiracy theories on the internet it's
- 2:04:58It's not because they're doing it in isolation it's because
- 2:05:01they become objectified
- 2:05:02and everyone else they talk to is a fucking conspiracy theorist
- 2:05:05who believes in the
- 2:05:06reptile alien fucking global warming kid fucker all this stuff
- 2:05:11and all the radical
- 2:05:12leftists they're all radical leftists and all the Nazis they're
- 2:05:16all Nazis so
- 2:05:18Like the the strength of the mainstream is the diversity and
- 2:05:22not just because it's
- 2:05:23diverse but because it's it's negation it's contradiction it's
- 2:05:27self-overcoming it's
- 2:05:29coming up against your own limits and being forced to encounter
- 2:05:31the other and all
- 2:05:32SPEAKER_03: that it's anti-toxic positivity yeah
- 2:05:35SPEAKER_03: But when you fall out of that and you fall into an identity,
- 2:05:39SPEAKER_03: whatever identity that is,
- 2:05:41SPEAKER_03: I think that's when you become stupid.
- 2:05:43SPEAKER_03: And smaller crowds can fall out,
- 2:05:44SPEAKER_03: like the Nazis were a crowd,
- 2:05:46SPEAKER_03: absolutely,
- 2:05:47SPEAKER_03: but they were a positivistic crowd.
- 2:05:49You belonged to the Nazi party,
- 2:05:51whereas none of us belong in the mainstream.
- 2:05:55SPEAKER_02: There's also a sense in which, like, when we say collectivity,
- 2:06:00Do we mean the totality of actually existing humans that make
- 2:06:06up the collectivity?
- 2:06:07SPEAKER_02: Or are we talking about the symbolic order of that collectivity?
- 2:06:11SPEAKER_02: There's a distinction there to be made.
- 2:06:13Like the English language as a symbolic order has more insight
- 2:06:18and knowledge into
- 2:06:20SPEAKER_02: the English language than I myself have.
- 2:06:22SPEAKER_03: Yeah, dude.
- 2:06:24SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
- 2:06:25So there's that distinction between the virtual symbolic order
- 2:06:30of a collectivity
- 2:06:31SPEAKER_02: and the actual members of it.
- 2:06:34SPEAKER_02: And I'm not sure who Chris had in mind.
- 2:06:37SPEAKER_02: Is he talking about the actual members of a Marxist collective have more
- 2:06:43intelligence than every individual or is it the symbolic matrix
- 2:06:49that has it?
- 2:06:50SPEAKER_00: The symbolic matrix of Marxism.
- 2:06:53SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:06:54SPEAKER_03: I think Chris meant it in that way.
- 2:06:58SPEAKER_03: I'm not trying to say Chris is wrong.
- 2:07:00SPEAKER_03: I
- 2:07:03I think the one guy with his arms crossed is more intelligent
- 2:07:06than the Nazi collective.
- 2:07:25but yeah I think Chris meant it in the way we're also talking
- 2:07:28about different forms
- 2:07:29of intelligence in this case well that's and then intelligence
- 2:07:33is such a fucking
- 2:07:34word man but there's there's there's also there's even a weird
- 2:07:38sense in which like
- 2:07:39SPEAKER_00: the there's a weird sense in which the that the Nazi collective
- 2:07:47could understand something which the guy folding his arms
- 2:07:50doesn't understand
- 2:07:52because he could be protesting because he's like this is stupid
- 2:07:56whereas the Nazi
- 2:07:57collective is like yeah we know like that's the quiet part the
- 2:08:03Nazi collective
- 2:08:04understands that like that the point is to be stupid this is an
- 2:08:08anti-intellectual
- 2:08:09SPEAKER_00: movement
- 2:08:10We're not trying to be smart We're trying to That's the quiet
- 2:08:14part And there's the
- 2:08:15other dimension of it Which is the guy with his arms folded Can
- 2:08:19be viewed as stupid
- 2:08:20Because he's about to get murked Viewed from certain criteria
- 2:08:24Like are you trying
- 2:08:24SPEAKER_02: to get yourself murked?
- 2:08:26SPEAKER_02: Yeah So
- 2:08:28but that's where you come into human intelligence does human
- 2:08:32intelligence value
- 2:08:34self-destruction or hold self-destruction up as a marker of
- 2:08:38intelligence which
- 2:08:39would completely go against functionalism yeah I think if human
- 2:08:47intelligence views
- 2:08:51SPEAKER_02: the willingness to self-destruct
- 2:08:54SPEAKER_02: as a marker of intelligence that goes against functionalist criteria.
- 2:09:02SPEAKER_00: How do you comport this with the dark forest?
- 2:09:05SPEAKER_00: I like that.
- 2:09:05SPEAKER_00: I mean, but like, what about the dark forest theory?
- 2:09:08Whereas like the point is to not self-destruct by shutting up
- 2:09:11and that's the marker
- 2:09:12SPEAKER_00: of intelligence.
- 2:09:13SPEAKER_02: And this is where we're just different than Bagna,
- 2:09:15SPEAKER_02: which is,
- 2:09:16SPEAKER_02: I think,
- 2:09:17SPEAKER_02: I think at this point,
- 2:09:18like there's jouissance or death drive in the risk of
- 2:09:22encountering the other.
- 2:09:24SPEAKER_03: Yeah, I like Bogna a lot.
- 2:09:25SPEAKER_02: And that is a form of human intelligence.
- 2:09:28SPEAKER_03: I like Bogna a lot,
- 2:09:29SPEAKER_03: and I hope we can talk to her again about all kinds of stuff,
- 2:09:33SPEAKER_03: but I think she's a functionalist when it comes to intelligence.
- 2:09:38And I would compare the Homo sapiens and Neanderthals there,
- 2:09:44because on...
- 2:09:47Neanderthals lived in extremely inbred small communities and
- 2:09:53one of the reasons why
- 2:09:54they're not walking around as a large population is because
- 2:09:58they were insular and
- 2:10:00inbred and so they did the safe thing they kept together but by
- 2:10:04doing that they
- 2:10:05encountered all of these genetic fuck ups where the dumbass
- 2:10:08risk taking homo
- 2:10:09SPEAKER_00: sapiens were fucking everything including Neanderthals
- 2:10:14SPEAKER_01: Fuck yeah, dude.
- 2:10:15SPEAKER_00: And going everywhere, you know?
- 2:10:19SPEAKER_00: But who's still, who prospers?
- 2:10:22It's the kind of dumbass,
- 2:10:24throw caution to the wind,
- 2:10:26intelligence of the homo sapiens.
- 2:10:29SPEAKER_03: That's a good point, dude.
- 2:10:30SPEAKER_03: That's a good fucking point.
- 2:10:34Travel to travel to Europe and get some of that Neanderthal
- 2:10:38trim and then go down
- 2:10:40to go down to Indonesia get some of that homo florensis strange
- 2:10:45that hobbit strange
- 2:10:51SPEAKER_03: yeah dude and we all end up with hantavirus
- 2:10:58Oh Jesus dude Hantavirus That's another fucking crazy crazy
- 2:11:02thing in the news cycle
- 2:11:06There's also there's one more thing I wanted to bring up I
- 2:11:11don't know it could go
- 2:11:12on for too long I don't want it to go on for too long There are
- 2:11:16people who are
- 2:11:17SPEAKER_03: using LLMs and they have found that sperm whales have
- 2:11:28A phonetic alphabet And they have a phonetic language And it's
- 2:11:33very similar to
- 2:11:34Chinese In structure Like syntax Yeah it's really interesting
- 2:11:40And they're listening
- 2:11:41SPEAKER_03: to dolphins
- 2:11:42and other cetaceans and I think that's super interesting
- 2:11:46there's also other people
- 2:11:47who are trying to do it with like deers and shit and it's like
- 2:11:50no don't be fucking
- 2:11:51stupid dude what about dogs I know you want to talk to Winston
- 2:11:54oh my god I would
- 2:11:54love to talk to my dogs dude I don't think dogs have language
- 2:11:58but I do think whales
- 2:12:00SPEAKER_03: have language but the way they're going about it
- 2:12:03SPEAKER_03: They're using LLMs to investigate whale language.
- 2:12:10SPEAKER_03: And I think,
- 2:12:11SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
- 2:12:11SPEAKER_03: it's interesting to think about because the way we use LLMs,
- 2:12:14SPEAKER_03: we presuppose meaning,
- 2:12:16SPEAKER_03: but from the perspective of the LLM,
- 2:12:21SPEAKER_03: it's all syntax.
- 2:12:22SPEAKER_03: There's no semantics.
- 2:12:23SPEAKER_03: And LLMs...
- 2:12:26Because Back Propagation And Transformer Models And Neural Nets
- 2:12:32And Gradient
- 2:12:33Descent They Are Able To Arrive At What Appears To Be Legible
- 2:12:38Coherent Semantic
- 2:12:39Meaning But It's There's No Semantics In LLMs It's Pure Syntax
- 2:12:45We Presuppose The
- 2:12:46Meaning We Presuppose The Semantics I Think It's Interesting Is
- 2:12:48This Just A Way Of
- 2:12:49SPEAKER_03: Saying Pure Chinese Room Yeah Like LLMs Are Pure Chinese Rooms But
- 2:12:56At the surface level,
- 2:12:57they appear to use language in the same way that we use
- 2:13:01language.
- 2:13:02SPEAKER_03: Simulate it.
- 2:13:02SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
- 2:13:03SPEAKER_03: But when they're applying that to whales,
- 2:13:06they're actually able to do this and it spits back results and
- 2:13:11it can actually
- 2:13:12SPEAKER_03: predict what the whales are going to say.
- 2:13:15SPEAKER_03: They can give it context.
- 2:13:17SPEAKER_03: And they can say, what is Timmy the Whale going to say?
- 2:13:20Basically,
- 2:13:21if they listen to a generic conversation with us,
- 2:13:24how's your day going?
- 2:13:25SPEAKER_02: Oh, it's fine.
- 2:13:25SPEAKER_02: Exactly.
- 2:13:26SPEAKER_02: They can kind of predict, oh, somebody's going to reference the weather.
- 2:13:30SPEAKER_03: Yeah, dude.
- 2:13:31SPEAKER_03: Minus three, two.
- 2:13:34SPEAKER_03: How's the weather?
- 2:13:35SPEAKER_03: Yeah, but they're doing it with whales now.
- 2:13:38SPEAKER_03: And I think that's pretty amazing because that suggests.
- 2:13:42SPEAKER_03: It's not proof.
- 2:13:44because there's no like there's no semantic there like it's all
- 2:13:47just like pure
- 2:13:48formal there's no content but it does suggest that whales have
- 2:13:54complex language at
- 2:13:57least sperm whales and they're applying it to other dolphins
- 2:13:59and other whales they
- 2:14:00straight up do I know they do that's so dope yeah that's dope
- 2:14:05yeah I mean it's can
- 2:14:06SPEAKER_01: I just say you know what's something depressing
- 2:14:11This isn't like a long thing I'll just say I kind of think dogs
- 2:14:15have something
- 2:14:15Because here's the thing I have seen dogs I'm sorry They
- 2:14:21comprehend Human sentences
- 2:14:26And I don't know how to make sense of it But I'm like They
- 2:14:29understand more than
- 2:14:30SPEAKER_02: just Like
- 2:14:32SPEAKER_02: They, you know, connect this one word to that one object.
- 2:14:36SPEAKER_03: They do seem to have a strange intuition.
- 2:14:38Because I can,
- 2:14:40Winston,
- 2:14:40I can say,
- 2:14:42Winston,
- 2:14:42go to bed,
- 2:14:43and he'll go get in his bed.
- 2:14:46SPEAKER_03: And that's fucking weird.
- 2:14:49SPEAKER_03: Or, yeah, dogs do seem to have a strange intuition of human language.
- 2:14:53SPEAKER_03: But I also think, like, modern humans...
- 2:14:57are so wrapped up with modern dogs like we're like a symbiotic
- 2:15:02relationship at this
- 2:15:03point I don't think we would be us without dogs and dogs
- 2:15:06wouldn't be dogs without
- 2:15:07us so yeah I think dogs are one foot in one foot out when it
- 2:15:12comes to language but
- 2:15:13like properly whales you know yeah they're not hanging out with
- 2:15:19us on a daily basis
- 2:15:20yeah and they're out there fucking speaking Chinese to each
- 2:15:23other and it's pretty
- 2:15:25SPEAKER_03: fucking cool
- 2:15:26SPEAKER_02: Have they done this with chimps at all?
- 2:15:30SPEAKER_03: Not as far as I can tell.
- 2:15:32SPEAKER_03: All the stuff I looked into.
- 2:15:36SPEAKER_03: Oh, there was that Robin Williams movie, wasn't there?
- 2:15:40SPEAKER_00: I think we're pretty good on understanding how much like primates,
- 2:15:45how much that they can understand and use language because we
- 2:15:50teach them sign
- 2:15:50SPEAKER_00: language.
- 2:15:52SPEAKER_00: And so you can get to a point where they like,
- 2:15:55we know exactly like how much language that they can they can
- 2:15:58handle and it's an
- 2:15:59impressive amount it's just like it's not as much as obviously
- 2:16:03like a human anybody
- 2:16:04wants a robust introduction to primates using sign language
- 2:16:10just check out Congo
- 2:16:12yeah I'm joking watch Project X and not the movie about the
- 2:16:19party the one with
- 2:16:20SPEAKER_02: Matthew Broderick and Helen Hunt okay yeah
- 2:16:23SPEAKER_03: It's like wait the house party movie?
- 2:16:25SPEAKER_03: You don't have to watch Congo What's the Robin Williams chimp movie?
- 2:16:30SPEAKER_03: Or gorilla Is it a gorilla or it's a gorilla?
- 2:16:34Did you guys Did you guys hear the sad whale news That in 2025
- 2:16:39we noticed That they
- 2:16:40stopped singing Like the blue whales We noticed that they like
- 2:16:44went quiet Because
- 2:16:45they're fucking starving to that And then this year This year
- 2:16:5050 like a record
- 2:16:51SPEAKER_00: number of grey whales Washed up dead on shore
- 2:16:54in Washington because they're fucking starving because of the
- 2:16:58algae blooms because
- 2:16:59of climate change that doesn't matter Sean GDP GDP exactly dude
- 2:17:04that's the like I
- 2:17:05like this is the most like tree hugger fucking thing in the
- 2:17:08world to say but I'm
- 2:17:09like that is reason enough to like stop everything is that the
- 2:17:13whales stop singing
- 2:17:14like stop everything dude they're sad this is fucked they're
- 2:17:20like most like and if
- 2:17:21SPEAKER_00: anybody can represent planet earth
- 2:17:24I think any species I'm letting them represent the planet and
- 2:17:31they've stopped
- 2:17:31singing so I'm gonna say Earth itself the SETI project needs to
- 2:17:35beam like whale
- 2:17:36thought into space like we need in the capsules to send to
- 2:17:40other planets we just
- 2:17:41SPEAKER_00: need like whale whale language like
- 2:17:45I'm not saying that whales are communist but I'm definitely
- 2:17:49saying they're
- 2:17:49anti-capitalist I think wouldn't it be cool if in the next
- 2:17:54couple years with this
- 2:17:55and it's called Wham Whale Acoustics Model so instead of LLM
- 2:18:00large language model
- 2:18:01they call it Wham Whale Acoustics Model wouldn't it be cool if
- 2:18:05like because this we
- 2:18:06SPEAKER_03: find out that they're like super intelligent communists
- 2:18:10SPEAKER_03: I'm telling you, dude.
- 2:18:11SPEAKER_03: Here's what I need.
- 2:18:12SPEAKER_03: Posadism?
- 2:18:13SPEAKER_03: Posadism has been true all along.
- 2:18:15SPEAKER_02: Fuck all you guys.
- 2:18:17SPEAKER_00: Whale posadism.
- 2:18:19SPEAKER_02: Here's my dream.
- 2:18:20SPEAKER_02: Yes, I want the whales in on it.
- 2:18:22SPEAKER_02: I want the dolphins in on it.
- 2:18:25SPEAKER_02: I want chimpanzees in on it.
- 2:18:27SPEAKER_02: I want dogs in on it.
- 2:18:29SPEAKER_02: But here's my dream.
- 2:18:31Is that artificial intelligence comes to realize that the
- 2:18:35animal with the most
- 2:18:37SPEAKER_02: intelligent,
- 2:18:37SPEAKER_02: complicated language is
- 2:18:40are lemurs and those lemurs actually are communistic and the AI
- 2:18:47agrees with the
- 2:18:48lemurs and it itself is communistic and then we get to be the
- 2:18:53ones to break the
- 2:18:54news to Nick how about them apples Nick how about them apples
- 2:19:01we love you Nick I
- 2:19:04SPEAKER_03: mean I think that's as good a place to end this one as any um
- 2:19:12Dear Reader Thanks for your time and attention Thanks for
- 2:19:16hanging out with us We
- 2:19:18will catch you when we catch you Lots of great things Check out
- 2:19:23Patreon.com slash
- 2:19:24TheDangerousMaybe Check out YouTube and Substack
- 2:19:27TheDangerousMaybe Check outSubstack
- 2:19:30Hail the shining future And do something with your life Do
- 2:19:35something edifying for
- 2:19:36SPEAKER_03: yourself Turn off the computer Turn off your phone
- 2:19:40Go eat ice cream or draw a picture or read a poem or do
- 2:19:43something for no other
- 2:19:46SPEAKER_03: reason than because you want to.
- 2:19:48SPEAKER_03: And sleep tight.
- 2:19:51SPEAKER_03: Don't let the bed bugs bite.
- 2:19:53SPEAKER_03: We'll catch you when we catch you.
- 2:19:55SPEAKER_02: Can I just say last thing?
- 2:19:57SPEAKER_02: You and I, we have a special interview planned for tomorrow.
- 2:20:01SPEAKER_02: And
- 2:20:02We're very excited for you guys to see who the guest is so stay
- 2:20:08tuned it'll be on
- 2:20:09the dangerous maybe but Nance and I we're really looking
- 2:20:12forward to this it's
- 2:20:13special to us Yeah Peace out the internet Over and out We'll
- 2:20:20catch you on the next
- 2:20:20SPEAKER_00: one Bella says bye internet Bye Bella Bye Bella
- 2:20:32SPEAKER_03: Outro Music Outro Music Outro Music
- 2:20:57SPEAKER_01: I said it before, and I'll say it again.
- 2:20:59SPEAKER_01: Life is pretty bad.
- 2:20:59SPEAKER_01: If you don't stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it.
- 2:21:03SPEAKER_01: It's that you don't have to laugh at these two-colored models.
- 2:21:05SPEAKER_01: That's it.
- 2:21:06In other words,
- 2:21:07it's not enough to just think they're going to be a bit
- 2:21:10different.
- 2:21:10SPEAKER_01: I'm really excited that person has a great laugh.