Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / The Construction Law Shortcast: EP1 The prevention principle and time at large
Transcript
- 0:12Noe Minamikata: Welcome to the Construction Law Shortcast series where HSL Kramer's London Construction and Infrastructure Disputes team will be deconstructing fundamental principles of English construction law, all in just five minutes or thereabouts.
- 0:26Noe Minamikata: I'm Noe Minamikata, Knowledge Council from the London Construction and Infrastructure Disputes Team.
- 0:33Xavier Milne: And I'm Xavier Milne, Senior Associate, also from the London Construction and Infrastructure Disputes Team.
- 0:41Noe Minamikata: In our very first episode, we'll be focusing on two essential principles that underpin modern construction law, the prevention principle and time at large.
- 0:52Noe Minamikata: So, Xavier, can you start us off by explaining what the prevention principle is and why it's so important in the context of construction contracts?
- 1:03Xavier Milne: Well, it's often overcomplicated, but put very simply, the prevention principle is a rule that a party cannot insist on the performance of an obligation which it has prevented the other party from performing.
- 1:18Xavier Milne: It's not a construction-specific principle, but it is one that the parties to construction contracts need to be particularly alive to.
- 1:27Noe Minamikata: And why exactly is that?
- 1:30Xavier Milne: Well, for example, if the employer somehow interferes with the contractor's contractual rights and causes delay that stops it from finishing on time, the general rule is that the employer won't be able to hold the contractor to the original contractual completion date.
- 1:52Noe Minamikata: Okay, and in those circumstances, how do the parties determine when completion needs to occur, if not by the original completion date?
- 2:02Xavier Milne: Normally, the contract will have a mechanism allowing the employer to reset the completion date where there's been an act of prevention, where it doesn't, or where there is an event that isn't captured by the mechanism, then time is said to be set at large.
- 2:20Xavier Milne: This means that the contractor's original obligation to complete by a specified date is replaced by a lesser obligation to complete the works within a reasonable time.
- 2:33Noe Minamikata: And how would you determine what constitutes a reasonable time?
- 2:39Xavier Milne: You could probably dedicate an entire shortcast on that topic.
- 2:44Xavier Milne: But essentially, it'll be a question of fact and assessed by means of a broad consideration of what would, in all circumstances, have been a reasonable time for performance based on the contract in question.
- 2:59Noe Minamikata: And are there any other consequences to time becoming at large?
- 3:05Xavier Milne: Another important consequence is that the employer can lose its right to delay liquidated damages.
- 3:12Xavier Milne: This is because delay liquidated damages are linked to a fixed completion date.
- 3:19Xavier Milne: So if the contractor is no longer held to a fixed completion date and only needs to complete within a reasonable time, the delay liquidated damages mechanism becomes inoperable and therefore falls away.
- 3:34Xavier Milne: Where this happens, an employer can still claim general damages, but it would need to overcome additional legal hurdles.
- 3:43Xavier Milne: For example, proving actual loss, which it wouldn't have to do if liquidated damages were available.
- 3:52Noe Minamikata: So how do parties address the risk of unintentionally triggering the prevention principle?
- 3:58Xavier Milne: It's important to remember that the prevention principle operates as an implied term.
- 4:04Xavier Milne: It's not an overriding legal rule.
- 4:07Xavier Milne: So if the parties have expressly provided for the consequences of employer acts of prevention and neutral events in their contract, the party's agreement will usually prevail.
- 4:19Xavier Milne: As I mentioned earlier, the way the parties usually address the risk of the prevention principle being implied is by drafting broad extension of time provisions into their construction contracts.
- 4:34Noe Minamikata: We'll talk about extension of time provisions in more detail in the next episode, but perhaps you can give us a flavor of how they operate.
- 4:43Xavier Milne: Sure.
- 4:43Xavier Milne: Extension of time provisions allow a new completion date to be fixed where the contractor has been delayed by the employer or where there has been a neutral event that the parties have agreed will entitle the contractor to an extension of time.
- 4:59Xavier Milne: There is often also a reserve power that allows the employer to extend time for completion at its sole discretion.
- 5:07Xavier Milne: This preserves the contractor's obligation to complete by a new date rather than within a reasonable time, and importantly, the employer's right to liquidated damages for delay.
- 5:22Noe Minamikata: Okay, and to wrap up our whistle stop tour of the prevention principle and time at large, can you sum up the key takeaways?
- 5:31Xavier Milne: Of course.
- 5:32Xavier Milne: So the prevention principle stops a party from insisting on the performance of a contractual obligation where it's prevented the other party from performing.
- 5:42Xavier Milne: Where the prevention principle applies, time is set at large.
- 5:48Xavier Milne: This means the original completion date is replaced by a lesser obligation to complete within a reasonable time.
- 5:56Xavier Milne: This can lead to delayed liquidated damages becoming inoperable.
- 6:01Xavier Milne: Remember, though, that the prevention principle operates as an implied term.
- 6:07Xavier Milne: Because the prevention principle can't override any express contractual terms, the completion date and any liquidated damages will usually be preserved where the contract includes properly drafted extension of time provisions.
- 6:25Noe Minamikata: Thanks, Evia, and that brings us to the end of this episode of the Construction Law Shortcast series.