Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Who Wins The Car Wars? China or the USA with Michael Dunne
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Friday, September 4th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Kyle Mountsert. That's Michael Dunne. We're hanging out talking all about Chinese, Europe, and a brand-new book.
- 0:12So let's get into it. Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I... There we go. Welcome to the morning show, sir. How are you today? Thank you so much for having me.
- 0:22Been looking forward to this conversation. I, I, whenever we get to talk to you, I always come with... I, I get everything that I need about, like, the world's vehicles for the next three months of content. Like- Yeah...
- 0:35I feel like I just... I drop in, I get everything I need, and then we get to run with it, and we always mention it back for the longest time.
- 0:42Uh, I, I wanna get started with you actually just yesterday got the news that you're allowed to start talking.
- 0:49You, this might be the first time that you've talked publicly about it, so I, we're gonna, I'm just gonna, I'm gonna own that. Uh, tell us about what is happening in January.
- 0:58Coming up right around the corner, January 12th, the world, you know how it spins around, the Earth spins on an axis, and it's been doing so for millions of years?
- 1:07It's going to stop for moments when my new book comes out. Yes. [laughs] That's amazing. It's called Car Wars: How China Seizes the Auto Industry and How America Can Win It Back. Ooh.
- 1:19Um, yeah, it's got a really bright red cover with big Car Wars, so there's no mistake about what's the story. It's US versus China for supremacy in the future of cars.
- 1:33Well, and I think that's what's interesting there, and I'm excited to read it because what I've known over the last three, four years since I've been following your content and then having some interviews with you is it's been a lot of a- analysis, right?
- 1:46What is going on? What's happening? What can be we watching out for? But sounds like what you're turning to is not just analysis, but proactivity.
- 1:53How can the US, US manufacturers, um, think about gaining back traction, uh- Right... in, in the world's race for auto, honestly. So, uh, it's a big deal.
- 2:03Well, for too long it feels like America, and Detroit in particular, has been playing defense. Mm. So how do we, how do we move to the offen- like Patton said, "Nobody ever won a, a war playing defense." Nobody.
- 2:16So how do we get back on the offensive? And technology, of course, is gonna be crucial to that. Correct. So that's, that's the story. It's like how China,
- 2:24you know, sort of set up a honey trap and, and lured us into situations that normal-thinking people wouldn't go into, but we did, and they're on top. Yeah. They're in a huge lead.
- 2:37Let's face facts and then see what we can do to sort of not only catch up, but once again lead. Amazing. Well, I'm excited for the book. Uh, we'll, we'll be watching out for it, sharing a, a- about when it comes.
- 2:50Thank you. Let's get in, let's get back to the present though, because I'm scrolling LinkedIn yesterday morning, and I, I honestly had forgotten that, that today we were, we are having you on the show.
- 3:00I, I thought it was, like, another week, but it was just perfect timing 'cause I'm reading through, I see, uh, you're on a news network, and you post about that, and at the very end of your post you make this statement that I feel like needs to be on a big poster.
- 3:15Maybe our team will put it somewhere. But you said Stellantis is the canary. Obviously canary in the coal mine as a reference to the smoking gun for what's about to come potentially.
- 3:27What made you say that particular sentence as what you're seeing specifically in Europe right now? In Europe, and then even before that in China.
- 3:35So as a little bit of background, Stellantis had a joint venture to make Jeeps in China. That joint venture went belly up about two years ago. Mm. Bankrupt. Wow.
- 3:44Forcing Stellantis with, to withdraw from manufacturing the Jeep in China, and then pivoting quietly to a special relationship with a Chinese outfit called Leapmotor.
- 3:56Now, for, they're a recent addition to the Chinese auto industry, but they'll produce a million cars this year. Wow.
- 4:03And the special relationship is such as Leapmotor produces vehicles that will be exported globally in a joint venture with Stellantis, and many of those products will be Opels or Dodges or Fiats, and we may not know the difference.
- 4:20So in a way, just a few weeks ago I asked Stellantis senior executives there, "What's going on?" And they said, "We have come to the conclusion that we cannot compete against the Chinese.
- 4:31Our best bet is to basically join the Chinese." Wow. Okay. [laughs] So- Okay... it sounds like a form of capitulation to me. Who knows?
- 4:41But in Mexico, in Southeast Asia, we're already seeing Stellantis products that are manufactured by their Chinese partner. Wow. Where is the value that Stellantis brings going forward?
- 4:53It looks like they've almost given in. If that's true for Stellantis, what are the implications for everybody else? Yeah.
- 5:00Well, I mean, o- over the past two years, we've, we've seen Ford and GM ask those questions in multiple different ways. Mm. There's been rumors of, of conversations.
- 5:10You have the, the Volvo Geely conversation that, uh, is still kind of, it's writing in the background, and nobody's really saying much about it except for it sometimes rises and falls, the conversation.
- 5:22But, uh, you've kinda said, like, "Hey, we've really got a two-year horizon on this potentially."
- 5:28Is that because of what you've seen in, in Europe and, and the trends in, in, in what it takes to get into a country for these Chinese brands? Absolutely.
- 5:37You know, many of the people I talk to here in the United States in particular will say, "Well, yeah, we had the Japanese in the '80s, '70s, '80s, and then the Koreans came.
- 5:45Well, this is just the next evolution, next step in that evolution. Here come the Chinese, and they'll come in and they'll offer some good products, and the customer will be better off." No. No, no, no. Mm.
- 5:55Just forget that comparison. If you remember nothing else I say, China is of a scale and magnitude and ambition that's like- Like, eons beyond what the Japanese and Koreans were after.
- 6:09China plays a winner-take-all game, and if we look at what's happening in Europe right now, the industry's being dismantled. VW's talking about 100,000 potential layoffs, closing plants for the first time- Wow...
- 6:22since World War II. It's not just the Europeans. Honda declared a loss last, last year for the first time since the 1950s. So the Chinese are taking it to traditional automakers.
- 6:35In Europe, more than a million Chinese cars will go to Europe this year. Uh, but across mid- Middle East, Africa, everyone every- everywhere I travel, we're just seeing this, like, flood of Chinese cars coming in.
- 6:48And most recently, you know, Mexico's got hundreds of thousands of Chinese cars- Sure... running on its roads. Canada's opened up.
- 6:56So we're, we're surrounded here in the United States, and we're sort of blissfully ignorant [laughs] to the potential consequences to our industry right here.
- 7:06Now, in, uh, that eastern part of the world, obviously you have Australia, which is quite separated. It's a different story because they didn't have a manufacturing front. Mm-hmm.
- 7:14They've, they basically have been four years into allowing the Chinese to take over.
- 7:18But then closer to the Chinese front, you have, uh, you have the Japanese automakers, and the story that we've been following over the last couple months is the fact that there have been multiple attempts at joint ventures for parts manufacturing.
- 7:30One of the things that the Chinese have been known for in, in creating this, like, parts layer that everybody rolls into, um, i- i- do you see, uh, the Japanese contingent making an effort, uh, i- in the right direction to correct some of this, gain back market share, potentially leverage their shared resources to do that?
- 7:49We saw a, like, eight manufacturer, uh, uh, a potential joint venture fall through, uh, and then I think it was Honda and Nissan are coming, uh, or, uh, uh, I, I could be mistaken there- Yeah. I think that's right...
- 8:00um, coming together to- Yeah... to have a joint venture for parts manufacturing. Is, is that a trend that we, that may recover something for them, or is it a little too much, a little too late for that smaller country?
- 8:10Right. They've been complacent for so long. You know, success breeds complacency, and for decades they've been really doing well, and suddenly they're confronted with new realities and the Chinese are eating their lunch.
- 8:21So they're getting together, Honda and Nissan are getting together, and the Chinese government's encouraging all automakers to work more closely together. So that's one solution.
- 8:32At the end of the day, they still have to confront this reality that cars manufactured in China today are about 25% to 30% less costly than any other country in the world. So what do you do about that? Yeah.
- 8:43One interesting and unexpected development: Lexus, which historically is only produced in Japan, recently announced they will manufacture in Shanghai in a 100%-owned subsidiary for both the China market and for global export.
- 8:58So I thought this was a monumental decision because they're essentially, the Japanese are essentially saying, "We can't beat the Chinese on cost. Let's try to leverage manufacturing in China- Mm... to stay competitive."
- 9:12And if anyone knows the history between China and Japan, it's n- it's not an easy one. No. [laughs] So for Lexus to make that decision, that was a bold, uh, s- concession.
- 9:22"Hey, to com- compete we have to probably go into China and try to control things ourselves." Yeah, and o- obviously many countries have done that with tactile goods.
- 9:32Uh, uh, uh, all of our clothing and toys and, and- Yes... electronic, consumer electronics kinda come from Chinese manufacturing.
- 9:38Uh, not even joint ventures, just companies going in saying, "We're gonna ma- manufacture there," because of labor costs, manufacturing costs, building costs, uh, that, that create the, the, the price gap necessarily, uh, necessary to win a market.
- 9:52Mm-hmm. Uh, that's an interesting play. Uh, really cool. Let's go just a little bit lighter as we end the show. You're about to head with a bunch of our friends. We had Steve Greenfield, uh, on yesterday on the show.
- 10:03Uh, o- one of our, one of our own, M- Michael Cirillo, will be over in Istanbul communicating with, uh, a lot of Russian and Kazakhstan dealers, uh, thanks to our good friend Alex.
- 10:15Um, talk to us about what you're gonna be communicating there, what that event looks like, why you, uh, why you attend there, and, and, and what people can maybe look forward to hearing from you on the way back.
- 10:26Dealers worldwide are just so curious about the potential upsides of operating with Chinese makers, and for good reason. I mean, your BYDs, your Geelys, your Leap Motors and others are...
- 10:39XPengs are developing awesome products at low prices. The thing to pay attention to, though, is this. There's a saying in China that when Chinese enter an industry, profits are the first to hit the exits. Hmm. So
- 10:55what we've seen inside China is that they've demolished or crushed enterprise value. No one's making money inside China. [laughs] Wow. Not the dealers, not the suppliers, not the manufacturers.
- 11:07And the Chinese are willing to make no profit for a long time, even lose money. "Yeah, let's go. Let's keep going." Now, if they take that global, dealers may in the short term go, "Tremendous. I've got new product.
- 11:20This is awesome." But they wanna think through where is this leading longer term? If my value, if my enterprise value today is a billion dollars, will it be half a billion five years [laughs] from now? That's the risk.
- 11:32And so I want... I'm sharing with dealers, "Hey, when you engage with the Chinese, understand what kind of tango you're getting into. Terrific products, but what happens to margins?"
- 11:41Yeah, because a lot of those dealers are already involved with the Chinese, especially in Kazakhstan and now Russia. Uh, and so, uh, they, they've already, uh, kind of let them in, and so what's the- Mm...
- 11:52what are the questions that they need to be asking? Uh, great that you're bringing that. Michael, as always, fantastic, uh, to be with you.
- 11:59I can't wait to watch your journey releasing this book over the next, uh, four months. I'm excited about it. I will definitely be reading it.
- 12:06Uh, how can people stay connected with you and watch all of your content that you're bringing out as you're dripping it out on a weekly basis? Yes. Th- thank you so much again for having me on.
- 12:16Uh, dunninsights.com is our website. You can also find me on X, uh, Dunn Insights, and on LinkedIn. Uh, soon, coming soon, Instagram page. That's will be devoted to the new book, Car Wars. Amazing.
- 12:30So thank you again for the conversation. I look forward to seeing you in person soon. Yes. [upbeat music] Hey, that's all we've got time for today.
- 12:38It may seem out of touch a bit, but if you are an auto manufacturer or dealer in the US, you should be paying attention to what's going on globally, because there's a downstream impact that will be coming soon if you're not ready.
- 12:49[upbeat music]