Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Earnings] Circle’s $12 Trillion Internet Money Machine
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the deep dive. Today is Thursday, February
- 0:0326th, 2026, and if you've been watching the markets lately, you
- 0:08know the the plumbing of the Internet just sprung a massive
- 0:11leak of information. We are cracking open the hood on
- 0:14circle Internet group it. Really feels like we've been
- 0:16waiting for this specific day for what, three years now?
- 0:19Yeah, easily. Yesterday's circle ticket symbol
- 0:22CRCL dropped their Q4 and full year 2025 earnings report.
- 0:28And look, I know financial plumbing usually sounds about as
- 0:30exciting as well, actual plumbing, right?
- 0:32But when the pipes are moving trillions of dollars and the
- 0:36company behind it is basically trying to become the Federal
- 0:38Reserve of the Internet, you really have to pay attention.
- 0:41Absolutely you do. This is a milestone moment.
- 0:43Honestly it is circles first complete fiscal year as a public
- 0:46company. Which is huge.
- 0:48It is because for a decade they were this black box in the
- 0:51crypto ecosystem. You know, we saw the tokens, but
- 0:53we didn't see the books. Now the books are open, the 10K
- 0:56is out, and the results are pretty complex.
- 0:58They're telling a story that is much bigger than just crypto.
- 1:01And that's exactly the debate we're settling today for you, Is
- 1:05Circle just a a supplier of poker chips for the crypto
- 1:08casino, or have they actually pulled off the impossible here
- 1:12and built a legitimate, profitable Internet financial
- 1:16system? Because the number suggests
- 1:18something major is happening. Oh yeah, I was looking at the
- 1:20top line numbers this morning and one stat literally made me
- 1:23spit out my coffee. I think I know exactly which one
- 1:25you're talking. About on chain transaction
- 1:27volume for the full year 2025, it hit $11.9 trillion.
- 1:32Yeah, that is trillion with a capital T.
- 1:35Yeah, a 247% increase year over year.
- 1:38It's absurd. It's a staggering figure.
- 1:40To put that in perspective for you, that is approaching Visa
- 1:43and MasterCard territory in terms of raw volume and the.
- 1:46Kicker here is they did this while interest rates were
- 1:48hitting three-year lows, right? So the old argument that stable
- 1:52coins only grow when rates are high, that just seems to be dead
- 1:54in the water now. But we really have to ask, how
- 1:57does a single company bridge the gap between traditional banking,
- 2:01which still runs on what COBOL mainframes from the 70s, and
- 2:05this highly programmable instant blockchain world?
- 2:09And more importantly for you, if you're eyeing that stock chart
- 2:12right now, can they actually make money doing it?
- 2:15That is the multibillion dollar question and before we start
- 2:19dissecting those billions and trillions, we really need to set
- 2:22the stage regarding our approach today.
- 2:24Yeah, let's get the ground rules out of the way.
- 2:26So we are looking at the raw data from the February 26th
- 2:29earnings report, but we are also applying some necessary
- 2:32skepticism. Right.
- 2:33Standard rules apply for the deep dive.
- 2:35Yeah, we're navigating some pretty complex waters here.
- 2:38All the analysis we're doing is based on publicly available
- 2:41sources and obviously may be subject to revisions or
- 2:44differing interpretations. Always.
- 2:46All contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 2:48purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 2:52Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 2:55decisions. Exactly markets move extremely
- 2:58fast and narratives change overnight.
- 3:00If you want to go beyond just what we talked about here to
- 3:02access more Advanced Research as applications and our latest
- 3:05published and personal intelligent multi agent deep
- 3:07value intelligence. Welcome to subscribe on Deep
- 3:10Values dot AI. And Speaking of tools, for those
- 3:13of you who obsess over market cycles like we do, if you want
- 3:16to track total market temperature, welcome to search
- 3:19and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 3:22It's an essential sanity check, especially when you see numbers
- 3:25like 11.9 trillion and you want to know if the broader market is
- 3:29just totally overheating. Yeah, you need that context.
- 3:32Also, if you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 3:34investing philosophy, please subscribe to our sister channel
- 3:37at Deep Values and don't forget to like this video.
- 3:40Much appreciated. OK, housekeeping is done.
- 3:42Let's get into the machine. Let's.
- 3:44Do it so let's. Start with the headline numbers
- 3:45for Q4 and 2025 because looking at this report, the growth
- 3:51trajectory looks like a a hockey stick.
- 3:54It certainly has that optical shape on the charts.
- 3:57If we look at Q4 specifically, total revenue and reserve income
- 4:01hit $770 million. That is up 77% year over year.
- 4:0677% growth is incredibly impressive, but I kind of want
- 4:10to push back on that immediately before it.
- 4:12Isn't that number heavily skewed by the sheer volume of assets
- 4:15they're holding now in the end of the year with 75.3 billion
- 4:19USDC in circulation? Correct, which is up 72%.
- 4:23So revenue is basically just tracking circulation growth
- 4:26almost exactly 1 to 1. That's a very fair observation.
- 4:30The revenue efficiency hasn't necessarily improved, but the
- 4:32raw scale has. And you really have to remember
- 4:35the context here. You know, 2022 and 2023 were the
- 4:39crypto winter. Right.
- 4:40It was brutal. Exactly.
- 4:41So seeing circulation bounce back to 75 billion suggests that
- 4:45the demand for digital dollars is incredibly sticky.
- 4:47Wasn't just a speculative fad. OK, but here is where I get
- 4:50completely stuck. I'm looking at the bottom line
- 4:52of the income statement and I see a net loss full year, net
- 4:56loss of $70 million. Now if I'm an old school value
- 4:59investor, I see a company that moved $12 trillion through its
- 5:03pipes and somehow still lost $70 million and I walk away.
- 5:08Why shouldn't I? Because you'd be entirely
- 5:10missing the forest for the trees.
- 5:12That $70 million net loss is almost entirely technical.
- 5:16It is essentially an IPO hangover.
- 5:18Are we talking about the stock based compensation here?
- 5:20Exactly. The SBC, when Circle went public
- 5:23in June 2025, they triggered this massive vesting event for
- 5:28their employees. We're talking about RSU's
- 5:30restricted stock units that had basically been accumulating for
- 5:3310 years, right under Jap accounting rules.
- 5:36The absolute moment those vest, the company has to record it as
- 5:40an expense on the PNL. But it's a non cash charge.
- 5:43It's not like Jeremy Allaire wired 400 million out of the
- 5:46corporate bank account. Correct.
- 5:48They recorded a one time charge of $424,000,000 for SBC.
- 5:52It is dilutive to shareholders, sure, because there are more
- 5:55shares floating on the market, but it doesn't impact the core
- 5:58cash operations of the business at all.
- 6:00If you strip that accounting noise out, the picture
- 6:03completely flips. 20 to the Adjusted EBITDA then?
- 6:06Yes. Adjusted EBITDA for the year was
- 6:08a positive $582,000,000 and if you isolate just Q4, the
- 6:14Adjusted EBITDA margin was 54%. 54% that is.
- 6:19I mean that's just obscene. That is better than most high
- 6:23flying sauce companies. That's approaching visa levels
- 6:26of efficiency. It perfectly demonstrates what
- 6:28we call inherent operating leverage.
- 6:30This is the absolute beauty of the software plus finance
- 6:33business model once Circle builds the pipes.
- 6:36The API connections, The minting engines.
- 6:38Right, the whole compliance stack.
- 6:39Once that is built, it cost them virtually 0 marginal dollars to
- 6:43onboard the next gillion dollars of USDC.
- 6:45Right, because whether I personally hold $10 in my
- 6:48hardware wallet or black Croc holds $10 billion circles, AWS
- 6:52server costs are basically identical.
- 6:54Precisely. They don't need to build new
- 6:55physical bank branches. They don't need to hire
- 6:57thousands of tellers to handle the new volume.
- 7:00So as circulation grows, that 54% margin should theoretically
- 7:03just keep expanding. It could go much higher.
- 7:05OK, so the machine prints cash conceptually, but let's look at
- 7:09how it does that. I want to dismantle this
- 7:12economic operating system they keep talking about in the
- 7:14report, because to me it looks an awful lot like a plain old
- 7:18bank, just without the marble columns.
- 7:20It is actually simpler than a bank.
- 7:23Much simpler. It is what economists call a
- 7:26narrow bank. Define that for us.
- 7:28Sure. So a traditional bank takes your
- 7:30deposit and immediately lends it out to your neighbor to buy a
- 7:34house, or to a business to build a factory.
- 7:37That is inherently risky. If the neighbor defaults, the
- 7:40bank effectively loses your money.
- 7:43Fractional reserve banking. Exactly.
- 7:44Circle doesn't do that. They run 100% reserve model.
- 7:47You give Circle $100, they give you 100 USDC tokens.
- 7:51And then they take my actual $100 and do what with it?
- 7:53They put it straight into the Circle Reserve Fund.
- 7:56This is a very critical distinction.
- 7:57It's managed by BlackRock and it is an SEC Register 2A7
- 8:02government money market fund. Which means it buys what
- 8:05exactly? It buys exclusively short
- 8:07duration U.S. Treasuries and overnight
- 8:10repurchase agreements. The absolute safest, most highly
- 8:13liquid assets on the entire planet.
- 8:15So they are effectively just a massive pass through entity for
- 8:19U.S. government debt. In a way, yes, But here is the
- 8:22senior edge aspect, the profit model. the US Treasury pays
- 8:25interest on those bonds. Currently, let's say that's
- 8:28around 3.8%. Circle keeps that interest.
- 8:31They do not pay it out to you. And that's the rub, right?
- 8:34I hold the USDC. I take the platform risk of
- 8:37holding a digital token but they keep the yield.
- 8:39That is the trade off for the utility.
- 8:41You get a digital dollar that moves at the exact speed of the
- 8:44Internet 24 hours a day, seven days a week and they get the
- 8:47yield. And in 2025, that yield
- 8:49accounted for 96% of their total revenue. 96% That is a
- 8:54terrifying number if you are an investor looking at
- 8:56diversification. That means they are essentially
- 8:58A1 trick pony. If interest rates go to 0, their
- 9:01revenue goes to up. Well, not 0, but it collapses
- 9:03completely. It is an extreme concentration
- 9:06risk. You have to understand they are
- 9:07effectively making a long rate bet.
- 9:09The whole valuation is betting that the era of 0 interest rate
- 9:13policies, the RRP is over and won't come back.
- 9:17But the Fed is totally unpredictable, which I guess
- 9:19leads us perfectly into this decoupling narrative that Circle
- 9:22is pushing so hard in this earnings report.
- 9:25They clearly know they have this rate dependency and they're
- 9:28trying to tell us that the story is fundamentally changing.
- 9:31It is easily the most important strategic signal in the entire
- 9:34document. The core argument they are
- 9:36making is we are no longer just a crypto trading tool.
- 9:38Right. And the data point they lean on
- 9:41is that transaction volume explosion we talked about up
- 9:44247%, even though crypto volatility was relatively flat
- 9:47this year and interest rates were down.
- 9:49So if people aren't using USDC just to buy Bitcoin, and they
- 9:53aren't using it to yield farm on D5 protocols, what are they
- 9:57actually doing with $12 trillion?
- 9:59They are using it as middleware for the real global economy.
- 10:03We are finally seeing a massive shift toward corporate treasury
- 10:06management and cross-border settlement.
- 10:08Can you give me a concrete example of that?
- 10:10Like who is actually doing this day-to-day?
- 10:12Think about a complex multinational supply chain.
- 10:16You have a manufacturer in Taiwan, a parts supplier in
- 10:19Brazil and a final distributor in Germany.
- 10:22Moving Fiat currency between those 3 entities takes days and
- 10:26costs anywhere from 1 to 3% in FX fees and wire transfer fees.
- 10:30Plus you have to deal with correspondent banks and banking
- 10:32hours. Exactly.
- 10:34The friction is immense. With USDC, that settlement
- 10:38happens in seconds on a Saturday at 2:00 AM for a fraction of a
- 10:41single cent. We are seeing large corporate
- 10:44treasuries starting to use USDC strictly for that velocity.
- 10:47It's not about crypto anymore. It's entirely about working
- 10:50capital efficiency. So that perfectly explains the
- 10:52volume metric, but volume doesn't necessarily equal
- 10:55revenue if Circle isn't charging a per transaction fee on those
- 10:58transfers and we know they make money on the reserves on the
- 11:01transfers. Correct.
- 11:02But this brings us to the other revenue line item in the report.
- 11:06It's very small right now, just $37,000,000 in Q4, but it grew
- 11:1015.3 times year over year. 18.3 X growth is exactly the kind of
- 11:15number that gets venture capital investors absolutely salivating.
- 11:19What is actually inside that bucket?
- 11:20This is their strategic pivot to Sauce software as a service.
- 11:24It includes Circle Mint which is their enterprise API for large
- 11:27scale wallet management. It includes the Circle Payments
- 11:30Network or CPN, which actually does charge fees for that real
- 11:34world payment processing we just discussed.
- 11:37And it includes USYC, which is their tokenized treasury fund
- 11:40where they charge management fees.
- 11:42OK, so the long term goal here is basically saying even if
- 11:45interest rates go back to zero, we will still make money by
- 11:48charging companies like Nike and Siemens subscription fees just
- 11:51to use our software. Stack exactly.
- 11:53They desperately want to shift their valuation multiple from a
- 11:56bank, which typically trades very low, to a software company,
- 11:59which trades very high. Currently, that sauce revenue is
- 12:02only about 4% of the total pie. Tiny, very tiny.
- 12:05But if that 15.3 X growth trend continues, it becomes the
- 12:09dominant financial story in maybe three years.
- 12:11Let's talk about why Circle is the one winning this race
- 12:14though, because there is a massive elephant in the room and
- 12:18it's name is Tether. Tether is huge.
- 12:20They have way more market share globally.
- 12:22Why is Circle the one going public and getting the BlackRock
- 12:25deals? Because Circle has built a very
- 12:28specific type of Moat, I generally call it the regulatory
- 12:32network hybrid. Which is just a fancy way of
- 12:34saying they play by the rules. It's much more aggressive than
- 12:37that. They didn't just play by the
- 12:38rules, they actively helped write them.
- 12:40While Tether and a lot of other offshore staple coins operated
- 12:43in the regulatory Gray areas, Circle spent years and millions
- 12:47of dollars pursuing the highest level licenses available.
- 12:50They are Mica compliant in Europe right now.
- 12:53That's the markets in crypto assets regulation.
- 12:56It is the gold standard for crypto compliance globally and
- 12:59they are actively chasing AUS National Trust bank charter.
- 13:03So they are essentially selling trust as a product.
- 13:06Precisely. If you are a highly regulated US
- 13:08institution, say a state pension fund or a Fortune 500 publicly
- 13:12traded company, you literally cannot use Tether.
- 13:15Your internal compliance department will outright block
- 13:18it. You have to use the onshore
- 13:20audited SEC registered option and that is Circle.
- 13:24And the weekly reserve reports they published, that's just part
- 13:26of the product packaging, right? Yes, weekly disclosures, monthly
- 13:30attestations and annual BIG4 audits.
- 13:33And the BlackRock Partnership acts as the ultimate seal of
- 13:36quality. The reserves are held in what's
- 13:38called a bankruptcy remote structure.
- 13:40Explain that bankruptcy remote part.
- 13:42That sounds like intense legal jargon, but I feel like it
- 13:45really matters if Circle goes bust.
- 13:47It matters immensely. It means that if Circle the
- 13:50operating company goes bankrupt tomorrow, the corporate
- 13:53creditors cannot touch the user reserve funds.
- 13:55That money strictly belongs to the USDC token holders.
- 13:59It is entirely segregated. That specific level of legal
- 14:02protection is what actually allows institutional capital to
- 14:05enter the space safely. But safety on its own is kind of
- 14:08boring. Ubiquity is where the real money
- 14:10is made. And the report mentions they are
- 14:12now native on 30 different block chains.
- 14:15And this is the network part of that mode.
- 14:17In the early days of crypto, if you wanted to move digital
- 14:19dollars from, say, Ethereum over to Solana, you had to use a
- 14:22bridge. And bridges are incredibly
- 14:25famous for getting hacked. North Korean hackers absolutely
- 14:28love bridges. Exactly.
- 14:30Bridges are the weakest link in the entire ecosystem.
- 14:34By issuing USDC natively on 30 different chains, Arbitrum Base,
- 14:39Solana, you name it. Circle completely eliminates the
- 14:42need for the bridge. They become the teleporter.
- 14:45It's like being the only currency that is legally
- 14:47accepted in every single country so you never have to visit a
- 14:50sketchy currency exchange kiosk at the airport.
- 14:53That is a great analogy actually.
- 14:54It massively reduces risk for software developers.
- 14:57If I'm building a new financial app, I just plug in the USDCAPI
- 15:02and I know it works everywhere instantly.
- 15:04That creates a network effect that is phenomenally hard for a
- 15:07new competitor to replicate. And now they're moving even
- 15:10further up the stack. I saw a brief mention in a
- 15:12report of the ARC blockchain. This seems like a major
- 15:15deviation. Why does a digital bank need to
- 15:18build its own layer 1 blockchain?
- 15:20Pure vertical integration. Right now, when you send USDC on
- 15:23the Etherium network, you pay gas fees to Etherium validators.
- 15:26Circle doesn't see a single dime of that fee.
- 15:28So they are tired of paying rent to other networks.
- 15:30Exactly. By launching ARC, their own
- 15:34proprietary layer one blockchain, they can control the
- 15:36full economic stack. They can choose to subsidize gas
- 15:40fees for users to make transfers completely free, driving
- 15:43adoption, or they can capture those transaction fees as a
- 15:46massive new revenue stream. It fundamentally moves them from
- 15:50being just an app on the Internet to being the Internet
- 15:52service provider itself. OK, we've painted a pretty rosy
- 15:55picture so far. Rocket ship growth, regulatory
- 15:59moats, owning the stack. But I'm looking at the headwinds
- 16:02and risks section of this report and I see some serious landmines
- 16:06that could blow this whole thing up.
- 16:07We need to play devil's advocate here.
- 16:08We do. There are very significant
- 16:10risks. This is absolutely not a risk
- 16:12free trade. Let's start with the Coinbase
- 16:14situation. The earnings report calls it a
- 16:16quote strategic partnership. I look at the numbers and I call
- 16:19it a dependency. It is effectively a joint
- 16:22venture. Circle and Coinbase launched
- 16:24USDC together years ago, but the current economics are aggressive
- 16:28to say the least. The report highlights that
- 16:30roughly 56% of the reserve income is shared directly with
- 16:34Coinbase. Wait, pause on that 56%.
- 16:38So for every dollar a profit circle makes on those U.S.
- 16:41Treasury reserves, they just hand 50-6 cents straight to
- 16:44Coinbase. The exact split fluctuates based
- 16:47on exactly how much USDC is held natively on the Coinbase
- 16:50platform versus external self custody wallets.
- 16:53But yes, the blended rate results in a massive revenue
- 16:56share going out the door. That sounds like Circle is being
- 17:00held hostage. Coinbase clearly owns the
- 17:02distribution. They own the retail users so
- 17:04they extract all the rent. What stops Coinbase from just
- 17:07waking up tomorrow and saying you know what, we want 70% now
- 17:11or worse, we're launching Coinbase USD tomorrow.
- 17:13Goodbye Circle. That is the ultimate key person
- 17:16risk, but applied at a corporate scale.
- 17:18If that relationship sours, or if Coinbase simply decides to
- 17:21vertically integrate and launch their own competing token,
- 17:24Circle loses its absolute biggest distribution channel
- 17:27overnight. They are legally bound by
- 17:29contracts for now, but contracts eventually expire.
- 17:32It really makes me wonder if Circle is just the back end
- 17:34plumbing utility for coin bases front end retail empire.
- 17:38It is a highly valid concern and it heavily forces Circle to
- 17:42diversify its distribution channels, which is exactly why
- 17:46that other revenue saws bucket and the independent developer
- 17:50ecosystem we talked about are so critical.
- 17:52They desperately need to prove they can survive and thrive
- 17:55without Coinbase. Then there is the macro risk
- 17:58interest rate sensitivity. We touched on this earlier, but
- 18:01let's really look at the math. In 2024, Circle earned an
- 18:04average yield of 4.49% on their cash reserves.
- 18:08In 2025, that dropped to 3.81%. That's a 68 basis point drop in
- 18:14just one year. And if the Fed decides to
- 18:16aggressively cut rates down to say 2.5% or 2% to stimulate a
- 18:20slowing economy circles top line revenue, basically it's cut in
- 18:23half unless they can magically double their circulation at the
- 18:25exact same time they're stuck on a treadmill.
- 18:28They have to run faster and grow circulation just to stay in the
- 18:30exact same place and maintain revenue if rates fall.
- 18:33And then there's what I consider the existential threat the Fed
- 18:36coin, central bank, digital currencies, or CBDCS.
- 18:39If the US Federal Reserve finally issues a true digital
- 18:42dollar that is backed by the full faith and credit of the US
- 18:46government, and it settles instantly on a Fed Ledger, why
- 18:50does USDC even need to exist? That is the ultimate steel man
- 18:54argument against private stable coins.
- 18:57Why use a corporate proxy when you can just use the real
- 19:00sovereign thing? Exactly.
- 19:01It's like insisting on using a casino chip at the grocery store
- 19:04when you could just use physical cash.
- 19:06Circle score counter argument to that is innovation.
- 19:09Governments are historically terrible at building consumer
- 19:11software. A Fed coin would likely be very
- 19:14clunky, it would lack good developer API's, and it would
- 19:16have incredibly concerning privacy controls.
- 19:19Circle fundamentally believes the private sector will always
- 19:22build a much better wrapper for the dollar.
- 19:24I buy that to an extent. The Fed isn't exactly going to
- 19:27have 2047 live customer support or a sleek highly rated iOS app,
- 19:32but still the regulatory risk of the government just stepping in
- 19:35and saying we are now the only ones legally allowed to issue
- 19:38digital money. That risk is definitely non 0.
- 19:41It is non zero though. Given the current political
- 19:44climate here in 2026, the legislative appetite for a
- 19:47surveillance heavy government issued coin is extremely low.
- 19:52The private market seems relatively safe from that
- 19:54specific threat for now. There's one more immediate risk
- 19:58though, direct competition from yield bearing stable coins.
- 20:02We are seeing these aggressive new startups pop up basically
- 20:06saying hey, hold our coin instead and we will actually
- 20:09give you that 4% interest. That is classic margin
- 20:12compression. Right now, Circle keeps 100% of
- 20:15the interest generated. That is a glorious, highly
- 20:18profitable business model. But in a fully competitive free
- 20:21market, margins always trend towards 0.
- 20:23Overtime. If large institutional users
- 20:26start demanding their fair share of the yield circles, core
- 20:29profitability completely collapses.
- 20:32They might be forced to start paying out a huge chunk of that
- 20:34yield just to defend their current market.
- 20:36Share, which entirely destroys the free money engine they are
- 20:38currently running. All right, let's get to the part
- 20:40I know everyone listening is waiting for the valuation.
- 20:43The stock is currently trading around $73 a share based on the
- 20:46roughly 235,000,000 shares outstanding.
- 20:50It was up near $300 right after the IPO hype.
- 20:53Is it a screaming value by right now or is it just a falling
- 20:56knife? Well, we ran a full DCF, A
- 20:59discounted cash flow analysis to try and find the true intrinsic
- 21:02value, and the mathematical results are pretty sobering.
- 21:07Walk us through the steady state scenario first.
- 21:09OK. So if we assume Circle just
- 21:11completely stops growing, they just maintain their current
- 21:13circulation levels and maintain that free cash flow of roughly
- 21:17$326 million, The stock is intrinsically worth about $13.87
- 21:23per share. $13 and it's currently trading at 73.
- 21:26That is a massive, massive downside risk.
- 21:29Right. The public market is clearly not
- 21:31pricing this as a slow growth, steady state utility company.
- 21:34OK. So let's look at the management
- 21:36guidance scenario. They are publicly promising 40%
- 21:39growth year over year for the next 5 years, which honestly
- 21:41feels aggressive. It is extremely aggressive for a
- 21:44company of this scale, but even if we plug that exact optimistic
- 21:48projection into the model, 40% compounding growth for five
- 21:51straight years, our DCF model spits out a fair value of
- 21:54roughly $61.79 per share. Wait, hold on.
- 21:58Even if they hit their absolute moon shot growth targets
- 22:02perfectly, the math says the company's only worth $62.00 and
- 22:07the market is actively paying $73 today.
- 22:10That is the inescapable conclusion.
- 22:13The market is currently pricing imperfection plus alpha is
- 22:17pricing and growth well beyond what even the management team is
- 22:20officially promising. Or perhaps there's a deep belief
- 22:23that interest rates will unexpectedly spike back up to
- 22:256%. So it completely fails the
- 22:27margin of safety tax. Particularly, traditional value
- 22:30investors usually want to buy a dollar for $0.50.
- 22:32Here you are buying a dollar for $1.20 and just aggressively
- 22:36hoping it magically turns into to a gold bar.
- 22:38Let's run it through the Buffett checklist.
- 22:39We do this for every deep dive. Does it pass the basic smell
- 22:42test for a quality investment? Let's start with the PE ratio.
- 22:46Fail. It's technically negative right
- 22:48now on a strict gap basis because of that net loss and
- 22:51it's sky high on any forward-looking basis.
- 22:53Price to book value. Fail Again 6.38 X Buffett
- 22:58generally likes to see financial institutions trading under 1.5 X
- 23:02book value. This thing is priced like an AI
- 23:06tech Unicorn, not a highly regulated narrow bank.
- 23:09How about the balance sheet safety I'll.
- 23:11Give that one a pass. They have a very strong cash
- 23:13position and very little actual corporate debt.
- 23:16They certainly aren't going bankrupt anytime soon.
- 23:18And the economic mode? I'd give that a pass too.
- 23:22The network effects of being on 30 block chains and having those
- 23:24high level regulatory licenses are very real, very expensive
- 23:29barriers to entry. So what's the final verdict on
- 23:31the stock? It's a genuinely great business,
- 23:34but a remarkably bad stock. At least a $73.
- 23:38It feels entirely like a momentum play right now, not a
- 23:40value play. I would completely agree with
- 23:42that assessment. It is firmly a watch list stock.
- 23:44If we see a macro sell off and it drops down to that 40 to $50
- 23:48intrinsic value range, it becomes incredibly interesting.
- 23:51At 73, you're just betting on miracles.
- 23:53Let's talk about the specific people responsible for
- 23:55delivering those miracles, the management and governance.
- 23:57Jeremy Allaire, He has been the CEO for 12.5 years now.
- 24:01Which is basically a full century in crypto time.
- 24:04He is a true industry survivor. He successfully navigated the
- 24:07ICO boom, the subsequent crash, the entire FTX collapse, the
- 24:11regional banking crisis of 2023. He kept Circle alive and growing
- 24:16through all of it and his shareholder alignment is very
- 24:19strong. He personally owns roughly 7% of
- 24:22the company and. I saw in the proxy statement
- 24:24that 92% of his compensation is entirely performance based.
- 24:27Correct. He doesn't get rich sitting on a
- 24:29fat base salary. He only gets rich if the stock
- 24:32price goes up over the long term.
- 24:34That is exactly what you want to see as a minority shareholder.
- 24:38Who else on the executive team stands out to you?
- 24:40Heath Tarbert, the chief Legal officer.
- 24:42He is the former chairman of the CFTC.
- 24:44That is the classic DC revolving door in action.
- 24:47But honestly, for shareholders, it's a massive asset.
- 24:50It is a strategic weapon, yeah. Having a former top tier US
- 24:53regulator directly navigating the current regulatory landscape
- 24:56is just invaluable. It's a very clear signal to the
- 24:59market that their core strategy is compliance first.
- 25:02And the broader shareholder base has fundamentally shifted
- 25:05recently too. It's no longer just early stage
- 25:08venture capitalists looking for a quick exit liquidity event.
- 25:10No, not at all. If you look at the recent
- 25:13filings we are seeing Vanguard, BlackRock, Marshall, Waste, the
- 25:16traditional smart money is slowly building positions.
- 25:19They are likely betting on that 10 year Internet financial
- 25:23system thesis, just completely ignoring the short term
- 25:26valuation noise. Oh and it's worth noting there
- 25:28are zero share buybacks happening.
- 25:30Every single dollar of free cash flow is going straight into R&D
- 25:34and aggressive global expansion, specifically into emerging
- 25:37markets like Brazil and Nigeria. Which makes sense for where they
- 25:40are in the growth cycle. Yeah.
- 25:42So let's wrap this up. We've torn apart the headline
- 25:44numbers. We've looked at the saws pivot,
- 25:46the massive risks in the highly demanding valuation.
- 25:49What is the final distilled verdict on this deep dive?
- 25:52Circle is clearly at a major historical inflection point.
- 25:55They've successfully transitioned from being just a
- 25:58crypto casino chip to a truly legitimate Internet utility.
- 26:02That decoupling narrative is entirely real.
- 26:04People are actually using USDC for daily global commerce and
- 26:08the unit economics are just beautiful with that 54% Adjusted
- 26:12EBITDA margin. But the current valuation
- 26:14mathematically demands absolute perfection and the structural
- 26:18risks, the Coinbase dependency, dropping interest rates, the
- 26:20looming thread of CBDC's, they are very real.
- 26:24You have to truly believe that Circle will become the single
- 26:27global standard for all money movement to justify paying $73 a
- 26:31share today. I want to leave you, the
- 26:33listener, with one final, somewhat provocative thought.
- 26:36Something that wasn't in the big flashy headline numbers, but was
- 26:38buried deep in the R&D section of the.
- 26:40Report I know exactly what you're thinking about Lights in
- 26:42a fans work, yes. Lisa and the chief technology
- 26:45and AI officer at Circle. She is quietly building out what
- 26:48they call eugentic payments and this connects directly back to
- 26:52the multi agent intelligence research we do over at Deep
- 26:55Values. This is the sci-fi scenario that
- 26:58is rapidly becoming everyday reality.
- 27:00We are actively moving toward a world driven by AI agents,
- 27:04personal digital assistants, automated supply chain bots,
- 27:08algorithmic traders. Right, so imagine this scenario.
- 27:12You have an AI agent actively managing your household
- 27:14logistics. It notices you are out of milk.
- 27:18It independently orders the milk from a local supplier, but it
- 27:21also has to instantly pay for the milk.
- 27:23And an AI agent doesn't have a physical leather wallet.
- 27:26It doesn't have a traditional Visa credit card.
- 27:29It certainly doesn't want to fill out a web cap, chaw, or
- 27:31type in a physical billing address form.
- 27:33It fundamentally wants a digital bearer asset.
- 27:35It wants fully programmable money.
- 27:37Exactly. We are looking at a very near
- 27:39future economy of machine to machine or M2M commerce, an AI
- 27:43server in New York, autonomously negotiating a micro price for
- 27:47compute space with an AI server in Singapore and perfectly
- 27:50settling the transaction in USDC in 400 milliseconds.
- 27:54With absolutely zero humans involved, right?
- 27:57No traditional banks involved, just pure code and instantaneous
- 28:00value transfer. If Circle successfully becomes
- 28:03the native default currency for that rapidly approaching agentic
- 28:07economy, then the $11.9 trillion volume we saw this past year is
- 28:12just a rounding error. That is the ultimate upside
- 28:16case. That is what they mean by the
- 28:17Internet financial system. That is the real aha moment for
- 28:21me. If you believe in the future
- 28:23scale of AI, you almost mathematically have to believe
- 28:26in the necessity of digital currency.
- 28:29The two technologies inevitably converge right here.
- 28:32It is a truly fascinating convergence to watch unfold.
- 28:35Well, on that somewhat mind bending note, we're going to
- 28:38sign off for today. We've given you the hard data,
- 28:40the structural risks and the long term dream.
- 28:43Now it's entirely up to you to decide what to do with it.
- 28:45Indeed it is. A final reminder, if you want to
- 28:47understand that agentic future better, go check out Deep Values
- 28:50dot AI for the Advanced Research.
- 28:52And remember to download the Buffett Indicator app on iOS to
- 28:55keep your feet firmly on the ground regarding these high
- 28:57flying market valuations. So please, if you enjoyed this
- 29:00deep dive, hit the like button, rate the show.
- 29:02It really helps us keep the lights on and the servers
- 29:03running. Until next time.
- 29:05Stay curious, we'll see you in the next deep dive.