Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Stock Market Indicators On Fire: Are you still playing fire? 🔥 [Preview]
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Our mission today is, well, it's
- 0:04about cutting through that relentless noise in the
- 0:06financial news, trying to find the real signals for you.
- 0:08Because let's face it, the market right now, it's a lot.
- 0:11It feels like a flood of data, often pointing in totally
- 0:14different directions, makes it tough to know what actually
- 0:17matters. So today, we're diving deep into
- 0:20the US financial markets as they stand in mid 2025.
- 0:23And what we're seeing is a complex, a mix of signals, often
- 0:27contradictory, but really important to understand.
- 0:29We're going to unpack 3 key indicators, the Buffett
- 0:33indicator, the Shiller PE, you might know it as the Kappa E
- 0:35ratio and the VIX index. And you'll notice this, this
- 0:39tension playing out, these big long time warnings about
- 0:41overvaluation bumping up against the surprising calm among
- 0:44investors. In the short term, we'll get
- 0:46into what each one means, their track records, you know how
- 0:48reliable they've been historically and importantly,
- 0:51how today's economy, which is different in many ways, might be
- 0:54challenging how we interpret them.
- 0:55Our goal for you simple to give you a more holistic view, help
- 0:59you see the forces at play, move past the headlines, and
- 1:02hopefully feel genuinely informed.
- 1:05OK, let's kick things off. Let's start with a really big 1A
- 1:07metric Warren Buffett himself once called probably the best
- 1:11single measure of market valuations.
- 1:12The Buffett Indicator sounds impressive.
- 1:15At its core, though, it's pretty simple, right?
- 1:17What's fundamentally telling us and how do we calculate it?
- 1:20Yeah, it's conceptually straightforward.
- 1:22Essentially, it's asking, is the stock market's total price tag
- 1:26getting way ahead of the country's actual economic
- 1:28output? Think of it like a potential
- 1:30warning sign that things are getting overheated.
- 1:33The calculation is simple too. You take the total market value
- 1:36of all U.S. stocks and divided by the country's annualized
- 1:39gross domestic product, or GDP. It's almost like a price to
- 1:42sales ratio. But you know, for the entire
- 1:44country, market cap is the price, GDP is the sales.
- 1:47OK, And based on that calculation, where are we right
- 1:50now? Because I get the sense it's a
- 1:52telling a story. It is.
- 1:54As of June 30, 2025, the US stock market value is roughly
- 1:58$65.47 trillion. Annualized GDP was about $30.15
- 2:03trillion. Do the math and you get, well, a
- 2:05Buffett indicator of 217%. Wow, 217.
- 2:09Yeah, and even a slightly more recent check, August 26th, had
- 2:12it around 213%. Still incredibly high.
- 2:15And put that 217% in context for us historically, what's
- 2:18considered normal or fair? What's considered overvalued?
- 2:21Historically, a range of maybe 75% to 90% is seen as fair
- 2:25value. Anything above 120% you're
- 2:27already talking overvalued. So 217%.
- 2:31That's roughly 2.2 standard deviations above its long term
- 2:34trend line. OK.
- 2:35And what label does that kind of reading get?
- 2:37Starkly put, it suggests A strongly overvalued market.
- 2:41And what makes this indicator compelling, or maybe concerning,
- 2:44is its history. It has a track record of
- 2:47flashing red before major market downturns.
- 2:49Like when? Well, think back to the.com
- 2:51bubble in 2000. It surged up to the 100 and
- 2:5441160% range right before that crash.
- 2:57It also peaked before the Great Financial Crisis in 2000, 2008,
- 3:00again showing this disconnect between the market and the
- 3:02underlying economy. And even more recently, in late
- 3:052021, it hit 202%. That was just a few months
- 3:08before the bear market we saw in 2022.
- 3:10And now we're even higher than that 2021 peak at 2:17.
- 3:14Exactly higher. And there was a 2022 academic
- 3:16study that looked at this across 14 developed markets.
- 3:19It found the indicator explain something like 83% of the
- 3:22variation in future 10 year returns.
- 3:24So it's definitely metric that commands attention.
- 3:26OK, that's a powerful history, but let's play devil's advocate
- 3:29for a second. The economy today isn't the
- 3:32economy of 2000, let alone 1987. With globalization, the rise of
- 3:36tech, does the Buffett indicator still carry the same weight?
- 3:40Are there criticisms we need to consider?
- 3:42Oh. Absolutely.
- 3:43And those criticisms are really important.
- 3:45You can't just look at the number in isolation.
- 3:48Critics raise some very valid points about its relevance
- 3:50today. A big one is the globalization
- 3:53gap. Globalization gap?
- 3:54What does that mean? It means GDP, the denominator,
- 3:57is purely domestic economic output, right?
- 4:00But the numerator, the market cap, includes companies that
- 4:03earn a huge chunk of their revenue internationally.
- 4:05For the S&P 500, it's around 40%.
- 4:09So you're comparing global company values to domestic
- 4:11output. It's a bit apples and oranges,
- 4:13and that could artificially inflate the ratio.
- 4:15Right, I see the sales figure doesn't fully match the price
- 4:18figures scope. What else?
- 4:20Well, there are also arguments about structural and
- 4:23digitalization shifts. The indicator might not fully
- 4:27capture the value of intangible assets, things like intellectual
- 4:32property, brand recognition, software, which are way more
- 4:35important today. And if the nature of the economy
- 4:38has fundamentally changed, maybe the old relationship between
- 4:41market cap and GDP doesn't hold quite the same way.
- 4:45It might understate the true size or potential of the economy
- 4:49in the denominator. OK.
- 4:50That makes sense. And maybe most tellingly, even
- 4:53Warren Buffett himself has kind of walked back his initial
- 4:56strong endorsement. He said he's hesitant now to
- 4:59rely too heavily on any single metric, saying they aren't
- 5:01always comprehensive or consistent over time.
- 5:04So the take away is it's a flashing red light, historically
- 5:07significant, but maybe with some modern static or interference.
- 5:10That's a good way to put it. It screams overvalued, but there
- 5:13are asterisks. Important.
- 5:15Works. So the Buffett indicator points
- 5:17to long term overvaluation. But with those caveats, is there
- 5:20another long term measure that maybe sidesteps some of those
- 5:23issues, like the globalization gap or accounting changes?
- 5:26That brings us nicely to the Schiller PE or the KP ratio.
- 5:30Cape stands for Cyclically Adjusted Priced Earnings.
- 5:33It was popularized by Nobel laureate Robert Shiller, and
- 5:36it's specifically designed to smooth out the short term bumps
- 5:39you get with a standard PE ratio.
- 5:41How does it do that smoothing? Instead of using just the last
- 5:44year's earnings or expected future earnings, it uses a 10
- 5:48year average of past earnings adjusted for inflation.
- 5:51So you take the current market price divided by that 10 year
- 5:54average inflation adjusted earnings.
- 5:56The idea is that a decade is long enough to smooth out the
- 5:59ups and downs of the business cycle, giving a more stable long
- 6:02term perspective on valuation. It tries to cut through that
- 6:05short term market noise. Makes sense. 10 years averages
- 6:08out booms and busts. So what's the KPE ratio telling
- 6:11us right now for the S&P 500 given the Buffett indicator?
- 6:14I'm bracing myself. Yeah, well, you're right to
- 6:16brace. The latest S&P 500 CP ratio is
- 6:19hovering around 37.78. Some sources might show it as
- 6:2237.87, but it's right in that ballpark.
- 6:25OK, 37.78 and the historical average is?
- 6:28The long term historical average going way back is about 60,
- 6:3015.88 so. More than double the historical
- 6:34average. Significantly more than double
- 6:36this current level, around 37.8, is actually near the third
- 6:40highest point it's ever been. What were the other times?
- 6:43The only times it's been higher were right before the 1929 crash
- 6:47and during the peakofthe.com bubble in 2000.
- 6:50Those are periods historically linked with what Schiller
- 6:52himself famously called irrational exuberance.
- 6:55OK. That's quite the historical
- 6:57company to be keeping. So if we zoom out, what does AKP
- 7:01ratio this high generally mean for investors looking ahead?
- 7:05Is it a short term warning or more about the long haul?
- 7:08It's definitely more about the long haul.
- 7:09The KP ratio isn't really about predicting when a crash might
- 7:12happen. Its strength lies in predicting
- 7:15long term returns, say over the next 10 or even 20 years.
- 7:18Schiller's research, which goes back to 1881, shows this really
- 7:21consistent inverse relationship. Inverse, meaning high Kate now
- 7:25equals lower, returns later. Exactly.
- 7:27A higher than average Kate has consistently been followed by
- 7:30lower than average long term annual returns.
- 7:33And the opposite is true too. Low Cape often precedes higher
- 7:37returns. We saw it play out after 1929.
- 7:40Very high Kate followed by weak returns.
- 7:42Same thing after the peak in 1997.
- 7:44Two thousand. That led into a decade where the
- 7:47S&P 500 actually had negative returns overall.
- 7:50And again in 2021, AP hit its second highest point ever,
- 7:5438.58, and that was followed by the 2022 bear market.
- 7:58Is there a general rule of thumb with the numbers like above X is
- 8:01bad, below Y is good? Generally speaking, yeah.
- 8:04Historically a Cape below 20 has often led to better than average
- 8:07returns going forward. A Cape above 30?
- 8:09That's usually pointed towards lower than average returns over
- 8:12the next decade or two. So like the Buffett indicator,
- 8:14it's another long term warning flag about future returns being
- 8:17potentially subpar, but again, can't be perfect, right?
- 8:20What are the counter arguments for the criticisms leveled
- 8:22against the CP ratio? No, it's definitely not perfect,
- 8:26and it has its share of criticisms.
- 8:29One common 1 is that it's inherently backward looking.
- 8:32It uses 10 years of past earnings data to value a market
- 8:36that's supposed to be pricing in the future.
- 8:38Right. The market looks forward.
- 8:39The indicator looks back. Precisely.
- 8:42And then there are arguments, particularly from economists
- 8:45like Jeremy Siegel, that accounting rules have changed.
- 8:48He argues that changes in GAP or generally accepted accounting
- 8:52principles, especially since the 90s, tend to under report
- 8:55earnings compared to how they used to be calculated.
- 8:58So if earnings are understated in the denominator.
- 9:00The ratio looks artificially high compared to history.
- 9:03That's the argument. Interesting.
- 9:05Are there other reasons people say, well, maybe a high Cape is
- 9:08OK this time? Yes, definitely.
- 9:11Some argue that today's environment justifies higher
- 9:13valuations. Persistently low interest rates,
- 9:16for one, make future earnings more valuable in today's
- 9:18dollars. And then there's the dominance
- 9:20of highly profitable tech companies in the S&P 500.
- 9:24These companies are arguably more efficient, have wider
- 9:28moats, and generate higher returns on capital than the
- 9:30average company of the past. Maybe they deserve a higher
- 9:33multiple. OK.
- 9:34So structural changes in the economy and market composition.
- 9:37Exactly. And the other big criticism is
- 9:39practical. It's just not actionable for
- 9:43timing the market, even if it's right about lower returns over
- 9:45the next 10 years. If you'd sold everything in say,
- 9:481996 because the CPE looked high.
- 9:51You would have missed a massive bull run for several more years.
- 9:54You got it. You'd have missed huge gains, so
- 9:57it's a great tool for setting long term expectations, maybe
- 9:59adjusting your portfolio risk, but it's a terrible signal for
- 10:02trying to jump in and out. OK.
- 10:04So we have two major long term indicators, Buffett and K Pia,
- 10:08both basically shouting about overvaluation and potentially
- 10:11muted future returns, albeit with some important modern
- 10:14caveats. Let's pivot now let's look at
- 10:17something completely different, an indicator that measures the
- 10:19mood of the market in real time, the VIX index, the so-called
- 10:23fear gauge. What exactly is the VIX telling
- 10:26us? How does it work?
- 10:28So the VIX, officially the CBOE Volatility Index, is trying to
- 10:32capture the market's expectation of volatility over the next 30
- 10:34days. It does this by looking at the
- 10:36prices of a whole bunch of S&P 500 index options, both puts and
- 10:40calls, across different strike prices.
- 10:42It gets called the fear gauge because, well, when investors
- 10:45get nervous about big price swings, they tend to buy options
- 10:49for protection, either pushed ahead against losses or calls to
- 10:52play potential upside volatility.
- 10:54And that demand pushes up option prices.
- 10:56Exactly. Higher demand for options means
- 10:58higher implied volatility and that pushes the VIX calculation
- 11:01higher. So a rising VIX generally means
- 11:04rising fear or uncertainty. It's like a real time pulse
- 11:06check on market anxiety. OK, Pulse check time then as of
- 11:10late August 2025, where was the VIX?
- 11:14As of August 28th, the VIX was sitting at 14.4. 314.43 and give
- 11:19us the context. What do different VIX levels
- 11:20usually mean? Generally, A VIX reading below
- 11:2320 suggests A relatively calm, stable, low stress market
- 11:27environment. Complacency.
- 11:29Even once you get above 30, that typically signals heightened
- 11:32fear, uncertainty, significant market stress.
- 11:35So 14.43 is remarkably calm. Remarkably calm, Yes.
- 11:40It suggests investors right now are expecting very smooth
- 11:43sailing ahead for the next month.
- 11:44Very little fear priced in. Which is fascinating, right,
- 11:47given the alarm bells from the Buffett indicator in KP?
- 11:49It's a huge disconnect, and this low reading raises that key
- 11:52question. How does the VIX actually play
- 11:54out historically? What's its main use?
- 11:56Its primary utility is often as a contrarian indicator.
- 11:58Contrarian, meaning you do the opposite of what it suggests.
- 12:01Kind of extreme spikes in the VIX, like when it goes way above
- 12:044050, even higher. That signals peak panic,
- 12:07absolute maximum fear in the market.
- 12:10But paradoxically, those moments of peak fear have often
- 12:13coincided historically with market bottoms.
- 12:15They've often been the point of maximum pessimism and therefore
- 12:19potentially great buying opportunities for investors with
- 12:21a longer time frame. By when there's blood in the
- 12:23streets, even if it's your own, that kind of thinking.
- 12:26Essentially, yes. Think about recent history.
- 12:28March 16, 2020, the depths of the COVID crash.
- 12:31VIX hit 82.69 market bottom shortly after November 2008,
- 12:36height of the global financial crisis, VIX hit 80.86 again near
- 12:41a major bottom. Go way back to Black Monday
- 12:431987. The VIX pedecessor hit 150.
- 12:46Even more recently, that terrorist crisis scare in April
- 12:492025, VIX jumped to over 52. Market stabilized afterwards.
- 12:53So high VIX equals panic, but often peak panic equals
- 12:56opportunity. Got it.
- 12:57But what about the flip side? A low VIX like now.
- 13:00Well, that implies complacency, but it's important to remember
- 13:02the VIX just measures the expected magnitude of price
- 13:04swings, not the direction. Ah, right.
- 13:07It doesn't say stocks will go up or down, just that investors
- 13:10don't expect them to move violently either way.
- 13:12Exactly. It measures the expected size of
- 13:14the earthquake, not whether the ground will shift up or.
- 13:16OK, but like the others, the VIX isn't a magic ball either,
- 13:20right? Are there limitations or
- 13:23criticisms here too? Does it always accurately
- 13:25predict the next 30 days? No, not perfectly.
- 13:29One key characteristic is its mean reverting nature.
- 13:33It tends to eventually drift back towards its long term
- 13:36average, which is somewhere around 19 or 20.
- 13:38It doesn't stay super low or super high forever.
- 13:42Also, studies have shown it often overstates the actual
- 13:45volatility that ends up happening in the following 30
- 13:47days. It reflects fear, which can
- 13:49sometimes be more extreme than reality.
- 13:51So it's more a measure of current psychology than a
- 13:54precise forecast. That's the best way to think
- 13:56about it. It's real value is giving us
- 13:58that dynamic real time snapshot of market mood, of risk
- 14:02perception, rather than a perfect prediction of future
- 14:04price swings. It's a thermometer for
- 14:06sentiment. OK, let's pull these threads
- 14:09together. We've looked at the Buffett
- 14:10indicator, the CAP ratio, and the VIX, and what really jumps
- 14:15out is this stark, almost jarring contrast.
- 14:19We have two major long term indicators practically screaming
- 14:22danger, overvalued, expect lower returns.
- 14:26And then we have the short term VIX indicator suggesting
- 14:29everything's fine, total calm, No Fear.
- 14:32How do we reconcile this? What does this contradiction
- 14:35tell us? It's a fascinating and frankly
- 14:38quite unusual situation, this combination of extremely high
- 14:41long term valuation metrics alongside extremely low short
- 14:45term fear. It really brings to mind the
- 14:47work of Hyman Minsky. Minsky, The financial
- 14:49instability hypothesis. Exactly.
- 14:51His core idea was that periods of prolonged stability and low
- 14:53volatility, like we're seeing with the low Vics, can actually
- 14:56breed complacency and excessive risk taking.
- 14:58That stability itself can sow the seeds of future instability.
- 15:01So in this context, the very low VIX might not be a sign of
- 15:04genuine safety. It could actually be a red flag,
- 15:06a sign of a complacent market that's ignoring the underlying
- 15:09valuation risks highlighted by the other indicators.
- 15:12So low VIX plus high valuations could equal dangerous
- 15:16complacency. That's certainly one
- 15:18interpretation. It might be fueling a sense of
- 15:21this time is different or irrational exuberance that could
- 15:24make the market vulnerable if something disrupts the calm.
- 15:27So just to quickly recap the dashboard, Buffett indicator
- 15:30near 217% warning long term overvaluation.
- 15:34Schiller PE near 38 Warning poor future long term returns.
- 15:39VIX near 14 Signal market complacency.
- 15:43Wow. OK, so putting all that
- 15:44together, what is this mix of signals mean for the bigger
- 15:48economic picture? We've heard so much talk about a
- 15:50potential soft landing after the Fed hiked rates aggressively.
- 15:54Where does this fit in? Well, it adds another layer of
- 15:56profound uncertainty to that whole debate.
- 15:58You know, one classic recession indicator is the inverted yield
- 16:01curve when short term Treasury yields are higher than long term
- 16:04ones. That's historically preceded
- 16:05every US recession since World War 2.
- 16:07Right. And the curve was inverted for a
- 16:09long time. Where is it now?
- 16:10As of mid 2025 it is actually uninverted.
- 16:14But historically the recession doesn't always start during the
- 16:16inversion. Sometimes it comes a few months
- 16:19after the curve on inverts following that prolonged period
- 16:22inversion. So that historical signal is
- 16:25still kind of ambiguous, maybe even leaning towards caution.
- 16:28OK, so the yield curve is tricky.
- 16:30What about other economic data? Is it painting a clear picture?
- 16:34Not really. It's pretty conflicting right
- 16:36now. On the one hand, supporting the
- 16:38soft landing idea, Q2 corporate earnings for 2025 we're
- 16:41surprisingly strong. About 82% of S&P 500 companies
- 16:46beat expectations. Tech in particular, boosted by
- 16:49AI investment, looked robust. And crucially, the Fed has
- 16:52pivoted and is now in a rate cutting cycle, which usually
- 16:55helps the economy. OK, points for the soft landing.
- 16:57What about the other side? Well, the labor market is
- 16:59showing signs of softening. The July 2025 job report came in
- 17:02lower than expected and job numbers for the previous couple
- 17:05of months were revised down significantly by a combined
- 17:08258,000 jobs. That suggests the economy might
- 17:12be losing momentum. So strong earnings, but a
- 17:15potentially weakening job market.
- 17:17Add in the conflicting market indicators, it really is a
- 17:19picture of uncertainty. Deep uncertainty.
- 17:22And it circles back to that fundamental question, is the
- 17:25modern economy with globalized tech giants and maybe different
- 17:28inflation dynamics truly different this time?
- 17:31Do these high valuations make sense now or is history right?
- 17:35Is a reversion to the mean meaning lower valuations and
- 17:39potentially a correction or tougher economic times
- 17:41inevitable? That's the multi trillion dollar
- 17:44question these signals force us to ask.
- 17:46And nobody have a crystal ball. Absolutely not.
- 17:49And that's why trying to perfectly time the market based
- 17:51on any single one of these indicators, or even all of them,
- 17:55is so risky. History is littered with people
- 17:57who tried and got it wrong. The smarter approach really is
- 18:00to use these indicators together as more of a holistic compass to
- 18:04gauge the overall level of risk in the market, to understand the
- 18:07long term probabilities and maybe adjust your strategy
- 18:09accordingly. So what's the compass pointing
- 18:12to now? Right now, the collective
- 18:14signals strongly suggest that caution is warranted.
- 18:17Not necessarily that a crash is imminent tomorrow, but that the
- 18:21odds for generating high returns over the next decade are
- 18:24historically quite low based on current starting valuations.
- 18:29Right, with KB predicting low long term returns and the
- 18:33Buffett indicator screaming overvalued, it underscores the
- 18:36need for that discipline. Diversified long term approach.
- 18:41This doesn't seem like a market environment for chasing quick
- 18:43gains. Precisely.
- 18:45It feels like the market might be priced for perfection.
- 18:48And if those perfect conditions don't materialize, if earnings
- 18:51stumble, if inflation resurges, if anything unexpected happens,
- 18:54the lack of a fear buffer shown by the low VIX could mean
- 18:58volatility returns quickly, leading to corrections.
- 19:01And for listeners who do want to keep a closer eye on one of
- 19:04these key metrics, you mentioned the Buffett indicator, there's
- 19:06actually an app for that, right? That's right.
- 19:08If you're interested, you can search for and download the
- 19:10Buffett Indicator iOS app from the Apple App Store.
- 19:13It helps track that total market temperature we discussed.
- 19:15Good to know, and of course the usual disclaimer applies here.
- 19:18Absolutely. Everything we've discussed today
- 19:20is based on publicly available data and analysis.
- 19:23It can be subject to revision, different interpretations, and
- 19:25most importantly, this is all for educational purposes.
- 19:28It is not investment advice. You absolutely need to do your
- 19:32own research and due diligence before making any investment
- 19:35decisions. Well said, and if this
- 19:37discussion has peaked your interest in diving deeper into
- 19:40value investing principles, please do subscribe to our
- 19:42channel, Deep Value Investing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 19:45We've also put together a list of recommended value investing
- 19:48books, which you can find in the episode description.
- 19:51So let's leave you with this thought to chew on.
- 19:53We have these historical indicators suggesting we're in,
- 19:56well, uncharted territory valuation wise.
- 19:59Does that mean the old rules genuinely don't apply anymore
- 20:02because the economy has fundamentally changed?
- 20:04Or are we perhaps more vulnerable than ever to the
- 20:08oldest rule of all? That market sentiment, currently
- 20:11so optimistic and calm, can flip on a dime, shifting from that
- 20:14complacency to something much, much more cautious.
- 20:17What stands out most you in this complex, contradictory market
- 20:20landscape? Something to think about.
- 20:22Thanks for joining us on the Deep Dive.