Latest / Quantum Potential / The Price of Deregulation with Ganesh Sitaraman
Transcript
- 0:00The airline industry as it is currently operating, is an industry that is fragile.
- 0:06Like, there will be boom and bust again.
- 0:09And when it happens again and the airlines come running to Congress hat in hand saying, "Please give us a bunch of taxpayer money." That's the moment when I think members of Congress should be ready to say,"Sure, we'll give you the money, but this time we're actually gonna have some real conditions on it, and we're gonna require that we change this— and so we're not in a place where we're constantly just giving you money in the bad times and letting you keep all the profits in the good times while not providing service to big chunks of the country that need it." Today I'm excited to welcome our guest, Professor Ganesh Sitaraman, an expert in constitutional law, regulatory law and political economy.
- 0:45Professor Sitaraman teaches and writes about the Constitution, about democracy, about foreign policy and economic inequality.
- 0:53He's been profiled in 'The New York Times' and 'Politico' for his work at the interstices of politics and ideas.
- 0:59Professor Sitaraman is holder of the New York Alumni Chancellor's Chair in Law and directs the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator for political economy and regulation.
- 1:08The Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator works on key projects designed to accelerate leaders' implementation of solutions at the forefront of education, research and public debate.
- 1:31Welcome to 'Quantum Potential,' a podcast dedicated to curiosity and discovery.
- 1:36My name is Cybele Raver, and I serve as the provost of Vanderbilt University.
- 1:40As a leader in higher education and as a social scientist, I believe that we can transform higher education for the 21st century.
- 1:47At my core, I am wildly curious about other people's work, whether it's in science, the social sciences, the humanities or the arts.
- 1:55This podcast gives us the opportunity to break open new ideas through discovery and creative expression.
- 2:09Under Sitaraman's leadership, the accelerator tackles tough issues such as trade wars, economic sanctions and governance issues.
- 2:17His most recent book is 'Why Flying Is Miserable and How To Fix It.' And I'm super excited to introduce you, Ganesh, thank you so much for being here.
- 2:25Today we're talking about how our lives are affected by laws and about regulations that shape different industries in the United States.
- 2:33I'm really grateful for the way that your work breaks that open for us to help us understand how constitutional and regulatory laws affect these different areas of our lives, whether it's airlines or telecommunications or AI.
- 2:46Um, your work is so great, not just in breaking that question open, but giving us a road map as we navigate these rapid technological transformations in communications, in banking and in transformation.
- 2:58So before we get started, you know, I'd love to do what I sometimes do with guests, which is just ask you to read from your work.
- 3:04So I'm gonna ask you to read page 29 from your great new book.
- 3:07Well, well, thanks so much.
- 3:08And before, before I, before I read from this, I'll, I'll give a little context to...
- 3:12Great.
- 3:12...this section of the book.
- 3:14And you know what the book, 'Why Flying Is Miserable' is, is really about is how we got to this place where there are so many things that are so frustrating about flying.
- 3:24And at the personal level, those are things like, you know, oversold flights or there's no space in the overhead for your luggage, or having to connect through, you know, Dallas or Atlanta to get somewhere.
- 3:38All of these little frustrations that, that we feel over and over when we fly.
- 3:42Um, but at the big level, also the crisis of the airline industry, which, you know, despite coming to Congress in the midst of COVID and asking for billions of dollars of taxpayer money, which they got, then still had tens of thousands of cancellations the following year, still had huge staffing problems, still had all these issues in addition to dropping service from cities all around the country, rural areas, small cities, uh, even big cities losing, losing service, um, as they consolidate into these larger and larger fortress hubs.
- 4:14And, and all of this is part of the same story, and it doesn't seem like that.
- 4:18These seem like really disconnected problems and irritations, but the real story is that they all come down to one thing, which was airline deregulation.
- 4:27Fascinating.
- 4:28And in 1978, we, we deregulated the airlines.
- 4:31We had a system that worked before that, a kind of regulated capitalism.
- 4:35And then we shifted and we took a very, very different turn that I argue in the book is really the source of all of these problems that we face when we're flying.
- 4:42And so this portion of the book, uh, is really describing the regulatory model and tradition that the mid 20th century system, the system started in the 1930s with really its origins in the 1920s— and that continued through the seventies before deregulation— you know, how did that system work and where did it come from?
- 5:04And so that's this section... Great.
- 5:05...uh, of the book.
- 5:06And, and it really starts with this quote that I, that I think is really interesting, um, by a guy named ... Edgar Gorrell, who is the president of the Air Transport Association, uh, which was basically the trade association for the airlines in the 1930s.
- 5:21So when Gorrell invoked the traditional American way, he didn't mean that airlines should be governed by free markets or laissez-faire principles.
- 5:30Rather, Gorrell thought airlines should be regulated under what were then called common carrier or public utility principles, and which some scholars now call the law of networks, platforms, and utilities.
- 5:42These principles were critical to what we can think of as the American tradition of regulated capitalism.
- 5:47The American tradition of regulated capitalism had its roots in three
- 5:50different areas of law and policy: communications, the postal system, money, the banking system, and the English law of innkeepers and common carriers, which went all the way back to the 13th century.
- 6:03different areas of law and policy: There was no single moment of its founding, no single theorist responsible for its creation and and no manifesto outlining its tenets.
- 6:10different areas of law and policy: It was truly a tradition, a set of practices and principles that evolved and was refined over generations.
- 6:17different areas of law and policy: The central insight was that some sectors of the economy were different than others.
- 6:21different areas of law and policy: Some businesses were critically important to commerce, social life and national success and security because they had infrastructural features.
- 6:30different areas of law and policy: Under the common law of the Middle Ages and into the 19th century, for example, these businesses and professions included markets, mills, inns, ferries, blacksmiths, wharfs and carriage companies, among many others.
- 6:41different areas of law and policy: With industrialization and new technological developments, scholars and judges and policymakers alike recognized that grain, elevators, slaughterhouses, the telegraph, the telephone, railroads, pipelines, local utilities like electricity, water and sewer service also fit into this category.
- 7:00different areas of law and policy: So what I think is really interesting about the American tradition of regulated capitalism, um, or NPU law—networks, platforms and utilities—uh, is that it carved off a set of businesses that people understood were unlikely to be competitive, that were likely to be monopolies or oligopolies, that had kind of a gatekeeper or infrastructural function in that they were essential services.
- 7:23different areas of law and policy: They were usually services, means to some other end rather than an end in themselves.
- 7:26different areas of law and policy: They often had network effects.
- 7:28different areas of law and policy: Um, they often had high capital costs, but not always.
- 7:32different areas of law and policy: And there were a lot of economies of scale at issue usually.
- 7:35different areas of law and policy: And that these factors, and some others too, in some cases, meant that they were critically important to the public.
- 7:43different areas of law and policy: Totally.
- 7:43different areas of law and policy: To commerce, to communication, to all of these kinds of things and that they had to be governed differently than, say, a company that makes sofas or, uh, coffee mugs.
- 7:52different areas of law and policy: And that those had the habit of being under some regulatory and federal or state and or both federal and state, uh, legal constraint that then helped them and the federal government to mobilize in the time of great national need.
- 8:10different areas of law and policy: Like those, you make really cool historically anchored, um, points about why an airline or a telecommunication system operates quite differently than, uh, if I'm running a set of Dairy Queens, uh, in various cities offering folks a, a dessert treat...
- 8:30different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 8:30different areas of law and policy: ...right?
- 8:31different areas of law and policy: That's, that's exactly right.
- 8:31different areas of law and policy: And, and the geographic point, I think, is really critical.
- 8:34different areas of law and policy: Because in a lot of these industries, whether you're thinking about the telegraph or the telephone or railroads or airlines, one of the key features is that the United States is a shockingly large country.
- 8:47different areas of law and policy: We often don't think about that in our kind of daily lives, but it is a gigantic country.
- 8:52different areas of law and policy: And what that means is that if you want to have commerce or economic growth or communication in all parts of the country, you actually have to have the kind of infrastructure that connects those places to the rest of the country.
- 9:04different areas of law and policy: And you know, this principle really goes back to the post office, and the founding, and one of the things that the founders recognized was that you needed to stitch together the nation.
- 9:14different areas of law and policy: And back then it was a lot smaller— I mean 13 colonies, all on the Eastern Seaboard—not that large compared to where we are today.
- 9:20different areas of law and policy: But they recognized in their context that if you didn't have some communications means for everyone to be in touch, to understand news of what's happening elsewhere, to be able to communicate, you weren't gonna have a commercial society or a democracy.
- 9:33different areas of law and policy: And you know, the modern version of that over time has been to build these other infrastructural resources that are more industrial or or mechanical um, or technological.
- 9:44different areas of law and policy: And, and airlines are a great example of that, you know, who would ever want to start a business in a city that doesn't have air service?
- 9:51different areas of law and policy: You know, why would you, if you were a, a kid who had an amazing idea, why would you start a Fortune 500 company in a city where no one could fly there?
- 9:58different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 9:58different areas of law and policy: I was at Cornell, where in Ithaca, you know, I was hired under a time when there were, there was one airline that served Ithaca, and then that airline stopped serving the, that city and suddenly the only way to get out of Ithaca to any other city was by bus unless you had a car and you were gonna drive, right?
- 10:16different areas of law and policy: And, and that's a real chill on people visiting, on tourism.
- 10:20different areas of law and policy: I mean, you know, I, I imagine even as an academic there, you know, do you really wanna give a talk at Cornell if it's gonna take you, you know, a day and a half to get there and a day to come back?
- 10:29different areas of law and policy: It's a real hassle to do that.
- 10:30different areas of law and policy: There was a definite sense of panic.
- 10:31different areas of law and policy: Like, we have to find some solution, right?
- 10:35different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 10:35different areas of law and policy: And, and this is a critical point, is this regulatory system was designed to make sure that we could have dispersal of economic activity across the country.
- 10:46different areas of law and policy: And so in the airline context, what that meant was that the Civil Aeronautics Board, which was the regulator that governed the space from the thirties to the seventies, um, had a mandate to allocate routes to different airlines.
- 10:57different areas of law and policy: And so would say, okay, you can fly New York to L.A. That's a high volume.
- 11:01different areas of law and policy: You know, a lot of people want to do that, and you're gonna make money off of that route, but you're also gonna have to fly Seattle to some random place in Alaska where there's really not gonna be much volume.
- 11:11different areas of law and policy: You're gonna lose money, and you internally cross subsidize.
- 11:15different areas of law and policy: Yes.
- 11:15different areas of law and policy: And, and, and as I mentioned, this is, this is the post office, this is the postage stamp.
- 11:19different areas of law and policy: It is more expensive to send the letter down the street in New York than it is to send it from New York to Alaska, but the price of the stamp is the same.
- 11:27different areas of law and policy: And, and that's because we want to encourage and support people who live in farther away places in smaller cities to make sure that you can have communication.
- 11:35different areas of law and policy: And in airlines it worked kind of the same way, a kind of regulated rates, allocation of routes so that big airlines had to serve both smaller markets and larger markets, and you were not allowed to just start an airline and start serving.
- 11:49different areas of law and policy: You had to be approved by the regulators to do that, because if you didn't have that kind of system, what's called entry restriction, what would happen is a new airline would just wanna serve, say New York and D.C. or New York and Boston, because a lot of traffic on those routes.
- 12:03different areas of law and policy: Why serve Alaska?
- 12:04different areas of law and policy: It's very expensive.
- 12:05different areas of law and policy: Don't serve it.
- 12:06different areas of law and policy: And what ended up happening is after deregulation, you actually moved to a world where you take away that entry restriction, you take away route allocation and you say, airlines just fly wherever you want, whenever you want, charge whatever you want, do whatever you want, basically. I think of this period as a little bit like the Hunger Games where there's just this kind of cutthroat competition between the airlines and so at the beginning there's all these benefits like that you had with the, with student rates early on, on all these new airlines.
- 12:36different areas of law and policy: But pretty soon the big airlines come back and, like, they don't want these small airlines competing with them and undercutting them on price.
- 12:44different areas of law and policy: And so they start doing things to try to push those guys out.
- 12:47different areas of law and policy: And what do you end up with after dozens of bankruptcies and mergers in the eighties is the exact same oligopoly of a small number of airlines that are dominant in the country, but just now unregulated.
- 13:00different areas of law and policy: And that's a real problem, and that's the world that we live in now where we have a smaller and smaller number of airlines that are are dominant.
- 13:07different areas of law and policy: You know, today the biggest four airlines have a larger market share than they did under regulation.
- 13:12different areas of law and policy: So if the idea is that deregulation is somehow gonna increase competition, we're actually worse off on competition now than we were in the 1970s when the airline industry was pervasively regulated, right?
- 13:24different areas of law and policy: Uh, prices, routes, uh, all of that was regulated—we're worse off now, from a competitive perspective, which is so fascinating.
- 13:32different areas of law and policy: I love that you use that phrase, or you quote someone talking about bare-knuckled competition.
- 13:36different areas of law and policy: Maybe not brass-knuckled, but bare-knuckled, right?
- 13:39different areas of law and policy: That there's something about the American spirit of competitiveness and a sense of beating the competition that we love, that we wanna support, and that the Chicago School of Economics, you know, endorsed heartily from a theoretical perspective, right?
- 13:54different areas of law and policy: And that many businesses and political leaders were really pushing for that, both from the neoliberal side and from the conservative side, right?
- 14:03different areas of law and policy: Do you wanna talk a little bit about that moment where, um, you know, how did policy change happen?
- 14:09different areas of law and policy: Because I think we're facing a time where suddenly regulation is kind of a big question.
- 14:15different areas of law and policy: Do we regulate foods and drugs?
- 14:18different areas of law and policy: Do we regulate air travel?
- 14:20different areas of law and policy: Do we regulate TikTok?
- 14:22different areas of law and policy: Help us think about how that moment in time happened.
- 14:26different areas of law and policy: What I think is really interesting about the seventies in that moment for, for deregulation, is that it actually has, uh, two features that are pretty weird when you think about it today.
- 14:39different areas of law and policy: The first is that industry was against deregulation.
- 14:43different areas of law and policy: The industry understood that in a world where you deregulated, it would become kind of a boom and bust cycle that would ultimately be bad for Americans and bad for the industry.
- 14:55different areas of law and policy: That's what we have seen over time.
- 14:57different areas of law and policy: When you take out the rules that made it stable and reliable, what you're gonna get is unreliable and unstable.
- 15:03different areas of law and policy: And it's gonna be unstable for all the parties involved—workers, the companies and passengers— not just one group of them.
- 15:11different areas of law and policy: And, and I think that was something that they were quite prescient on in that period.
- 15:16different areas of law and policy: Um, but there was this general belief that if we just unshackle the market and let it go, everything will just be better.
- 15:23different areas of law and policy: And, you know, there've been real trade-offs and, and we haven't really seen that pan out.
- 15:27different areas of law and policy: So the airlines are deregulated, suddenly all these new entrants come in.
- 15:32different areas of law and policy: And then how does it end up that we don't get the free market solution that we dreamt for?
- 15:39different areas of law and policy: How is it that we end up having, you know, these massive fisticuffs between all of these carriers, and yet there aren't, you know, heroic good airlines that emerge, that provide the right-priced tickets the way a rational actor and other rational actors would yield in a perfect economically framed model?
- 16:03different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 16:03different areas of law and policy: It's, it's, it's that the perfectly framed economic model for this industry doesn't exist, right?
- 16:08different areas of law and policy: As, as I started with, some businesses are different than others.
- 16:11different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 16:12different areas of law and policy: And, you know, restaurants are, you know, a good example of a competitive industry.
- 16:17different areas of law and policy: If you have a long enough street, you can have 200 restaurants that compete with each other.
- 16:22different areas of law and policy: That just doesn't make sense for airlines if what you're trying to do is compete and do any sort of reasonable service that is related to cost.
- 16:31different areas of law and policy: First of all, there's some places that are really expensive to serve.
- 16:34different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 16:34different areas of law and policy: Because you're just not gonna get enough volume there.
- 16:36different areas of law and policy: Do you really wanna fly to remote parts of Alaska?
- 16:40different areas of law and policy: To Dubuque, Iowa?
- 16:42different areas of law and policy: I think we should fly to those places because it's really important that people have air service to them.
- 16:47different areas of law and policy: But it's more costly because you're not always gonna have a full flight.
- 16:51different areas of law and policy: You're certainly not always gonna have a full flight, say three, four, five times a day.
- 16:55different areas of law and policy: And if we're thinking there's 200 airlines, or let's not get greedy, maybe there's like eight airlines— can you really sustain eight flights a day each by one airline to one of those places?
- 17:06different areas of law and policy: And the answer is no.
- 17:07different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 17:07different areas of law and policy: You can't.
- 17:09different areas of law and policy: And so it's high cost, which means you're gonna give up service to some of those places, and that's what we've seen happen.
- 17:14different areas of law and policy: The second thing is it's really beneficial to concentrate your operations in one place.
- 17:20different areas of law and policy: So under the regulated system, they actually didn't allow what we have now, which are these fortress hubs—your Dallas, your Detroit, your Atlanta— where one airline is just overly and incredibly dominant, you know, Delta in Atlanta, American in Dallas.
- 17:36different areas of law and policy: Instead, they made sure that at these big cities, cities with any real scale, that no airline really had more than 25% to 30%.
- 17:45different areas of law and policy: That was kind of being the big player in town.
- 17:47different areas of law and policy: So there was always more competition.
- 17:49different areas of law and policy: What's happened instead is what, uh, since deregulation, is airlines have shifted to concentrate all their operations in one place, which means we're all connecting through these different cities.
- 17:58different areas of law and policy: But that also means that they take away the number of flights and the concentration that they have in some other places.
- 18:04different areas of law and policy: So if you're a city that loses its airline hub, this is also devastating,'cause you used to have hundreds of flights—international, domestic going to lots of different places—and now you have a bunch of flights just going to a few hubs.
- 18:18different areas of law and policy: Everyone has to connect.
- 18:19different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 18:19different areas of law and policy: Again, do you really want to have your, like, national convention in one of those cities where everyone's gonna have to connect to get there?
- 18:26different areas of law and policy: Do you really want to have your company there?
- 18:27different areas of law and policy: What if it's a global company?
- 18:28different areas of law and policy: Do you really want to be there where you can't fly to any other part of the world?
- 18:32different areas of law and policy: And companies move because of that.
- 18:33different areas of law and policy: Conventions go away because of that, and that hurts economic growth and so on.
- 18:39different areas of law and policy: And this is all predictable because the economic model of what it costs to run an airline, how it works to run an airline, you're gonna fly it.
- 18:46different areas of law and policy: You know, there isn't a, the seats are just going, whether they're empty or full, right?
- 18:50different areas of law and policy: This is a different kind of thing than selling coffee mugs or running a restaurant.
- 18:55different areas of law and policy: And so competition doesn't work in the same way in this industry, and, and what that basically means is you're never gonna have the kind of competitive system where you can do things based on marginal cost pricing.
- 19:05different areas of law and policy: But it's just, I think it's helpful for us to just widen the aperture enough to understand all the decisions we've already made, right?
- 19:12different areas of law and policy: We've already made a decision to be in a fairly to highly competitive space with, you know, some to none to very high amounts of regulation, but probably not in the very high amounts, right?
- 19:25different areas of law and policy: Given everything that you just described.
- 19:28different areas of law and policy: Mm-hmm.
- 19:28different areas of law and policy: So I think then the question is how do you mobilize that level of knowledge and that level of expertise and that kind of storytelling so that it's actually impactful in the hands of decision-makers, right?
- 19:42different areas of law and policy: We have clearly this fascinating interaction between elected government leaders, commissioners of various commissions that I didn't even know existed that manage and oversee this particular industry, corporate leads and then the public, right?
- 20:00different areas of law and policy: So it's a lot of different constituencies, a lot of different actors, and, and you've got to enter into that and somehow convince everybody that there is a solution and that it could be better.
- 20:12different areas of law and policy: How do you do that?
- 20:14different areas of law and policy: Yeah, I think there's a lot of things.
- 20:15different areas of law and policy: I mean, you know, you do podcasts, for example, um, as, as one easy one.
- 20:19different areas of law and policy: But, but, but I think there's a real mix.
- 20:20different areas of law and policy: So, so for the airplane work as, as one good example, you know, I, I've done some quite technical work.
- 20:26different areas of law and policy: We have a case book, a textbook in networks, platforms and utilities, and it has the airline story, but in, you know, pretty technical language for training lawyers. And then 'Why Flying Is Miserable and, and How To Fix It.' As, as you could tell from the title is really geared toward a broad audience.
- 20:46different areas of law and policy: And it's a short book.
- 20:47different areas of law and policy: It's a really quick read.
- 20:49different areas of law and policy: In fact, if you're delayed ever, you know, you could probably finish the book.
- 20:52different areas of law and policy: It's a, it's not that it's not that long, um, or you could finish it on a single flight.
- 20:55different areas of law and policy: And there's some great pot boiler moments where people are, you know, threatening to beat each other up.
- 21:00different areas of law and policy: And, there's you know, the halls of Congress.
- 21:02different areas of law and policy: There's, it's got everything.
- 21:02different areas of law and policy: There's bad language, there's violence, there's, you know, drama...
- 21:06different areas of law and policy: Who knew?
- 21:06different areas of law and policy: ...there's bankruptcies, there's all kinds of things in the airline industry.
- 21:08different areas of law and policy: It's a, it's, um, it's, it's, it's a rollicking tale in, in some ways.
- 21:13different areas of law and policy: Um, and, and so that's really geared for a popular audience.
- 21:16different areas of law and policy: And then, um, through the policy accelerator, we've recently put out a couple of white papers that are really more geared for a policy-specific audience who are interested in what are the concrete ideas that we could use that are kinda drawn from this research, the history, the comparative history, the understanding of how all these systems work and how to think about them.
- 21:40different areas of law and policy: Um, and how would we apply some of those today in ways that are plausible and viable.
- 21:44different areas of law and policy: And so, you know, we've put out one paper on how to fix flying, which has, you know, dozens of ideas ranging from ways to think about geographic access to gates and slots at, uh, for landing...
- 21:58different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 21:58different areas of law and policy: ...to issues about seat sizes.
- 22:00different areas of law and policy: Um, and then we did a very specific, uh, white paper on the passenger experience, really focusing on seat sizes, experience of people in wheelchairs, uh, people who have small kids, either infants who you know, really should be in a car seat or bringing a stroller and how we can improve that, that experience for people.
- 22:18different areas of law and policy: And, and those ideas go into a lot more depth on things like, well, literally how would you rewrite the law and what would that look like?
- 22:26different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 22:26different areas of law and policy: Um, to show that it's doable to do these things and to connect the dots between what, in some cases can seem like history or just big ideas or theory, um, but really get it down to the ground level of literally how do you...
- 22:42different areas of law and policy: Highly technical.
- 22:42different areas of law and policy: ...how do you do it in a technical way?
- 22:43different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 22:44different areas of law and policy: And that's what a policy audience needs.
- 22:45different areas of law and policy: And so, you know, I try to, in my work, do things for all of those audiences, for academics, for the general public and for policy folks um, because I think that's helpful for getting different people engaged at different levels in the process of understanding what problems are and how we could solve them.
- 23:01different areas of law and policy: I'm so fascinated by the range of types of solutions, right, that it could be from both the customer or the, you know passenger experience.
- 23:11different areas of law and policy: But also from the how to run an airport more effectively, right?
- 23:15different areas of law and policy: How to, if you're gonna expand the airport in Nashville, let's say, how do you wanna think about that to maximize rather than to constrain the exact kinds of solutions that you're talking about.
- 23:26different areas of law and policy: And I think one of those immediate next questions then is "do you ever see, or do you hope for corporations to actually take up some of those changes themselves and, but essentially to self-regulate or to, you know, industry regulate in ways that would not require or need as much kind of federal oversight?" Or is that just a bananas idea that makes no sense.
- 23:47different areas of law and policy: You know, I, I would welcome it if industry wanted to do it, but I am, I think hardheaded and a realist enough to know that, I think it's mostly naive that they will.
- 23:56different areas of law and policy: And so politically, there's actually a lot of people who should want to take on something that actually would help their constituents by expanding access to air service in a bunch of different places.
- 24:09different areas of law and policy: And in fact in the eighties, you know, one of the things we quote in the book are members of Congress, um, senators, you know, for from Tennessee, from West Virginia who regretted their vote for airline deregulation...
- 24:20different areas of law and policy: Yeah. They felt lied to.
- 24:20different areas of law and policy: ...and wish they could have reregulated the airlines because they lost a lot of service in their states.
- 24:24different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 24:25different areas of law and policy: And so the flip...
- 24:25different areas of law and policy: Huge economic downsides, right?
- 24:27different areas of law and policy: Huge economic downsides.
- 24:28different areas of law and policy: Huge cascading effects that are very costly.
- 24:30different areas of law and policy: And, and there should be the flip of that now. People from those states where they've lost a lot should now want to reregulate and they don't, or they're not.
- 24:38different areas of law and policy: And I think there's a couple things going on there.
- 24:40different areas of law and policy: One is this kind of just ideological problem, which is a bunch of people think actually airline deregulation has been good and there's nothing else we can do.
- 24:48different areas of law and policy: And part of what I try to show in the book is that's just wrong.
- 24:50different areas of law and policy: We used to do it differently.
- 24:52different areas of law and policy: We could do it differently.
- 24:52different areas of law and policy: Lots of other places do it differently.
- 24:54different areas of law and policy: There's nothing stopping us except for our own desire to do it or not do it.
- 24:58different areas of law and policy: The other thing that is stopping us, which is an influence, but I don't think should be dispositive, is that airlines are a concentrated lobbying group and industry, and passengers are diffuse and we're in every state and every congressional district around the country.
- 25:16different areas of law and policy: Yeah, It's a lot for the public to get organized.
- 25:18different areas of law and policy: The public is hard to get public organized.
- 25:20different areas of law and policy: And you know, most of us don't have, you know, hundreds of lobbyists that we deploy to Congress whenever we want something, but the airlines do.
- 25:29different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 25:29different areas of law and policy: And so I think the other challenge is if you're in that kind of asymmetric environment where the industries that have a lot of power are influential and they don't wanna be regulated different from the seventies, it's really hard to get something done.
- 25:40different areas of law and policy: But I think there's space for policy entrepreneurs Who want to move because there is a possibility that actually voters would be more interested in this.
- 25:48different areas of law and policy: Wait a minute.
- 25:48different areas of law and policy: I love that phrase— policy entrepreneurs.
- 25:51different areas of law and policy: Mm-hmm.
- 25:52different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 25:53different areas of law and policy: Tell me a little bit more about what you mean when you say that.
- 25:55different areas of law and policy: Well, I, I think it's just people who are willing to take on new policy ideas and bring them into the public conversation and, and lead with them.
- 26:03different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 26:03different areas of law and policy: And I think there's space here for someone who wants to kind of take up this mantle and lead on this question...
- 26:10different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 26:10different areas of law and policy: ...and to bring it into the debate in a serious way.
- 26:13different areas of law and policy: And we just haven't seen anyone do that, but it's kind of ripe for the taking.
- 26:17different areas of law and policy: My sense is that what's likely to happen and where I think the ideas in the book and in our white papers are most likely to get traction is ... they'll slowly get some traction, hopefully over, over some years.
- 26:27different areas of law and policy: But you know what I, what I show in the book, and I, I feel pretty confident about is that the airline industry as it is currently operating, is an industry that is fragile.
- 26:40different areas of law and policy: Like, there will be boom and bust again.
- 26:43different areas of law and policy: And we've seen it over and over again.
- 26:45different areas of law and policy: It happened with the Gulf War.
- 26:46different areas of law and policy: It happened with 9/11.
- 26:48different areas of law and policy: It happened with the COVID crisis.
- 26:50different areas of law and policy: Um, it will happen again.
- 26:52different areas of law and policy: And when it happens again and the airlines come running to Congress hat in hand saying, "Please give us a bunch of taxpayer money." That's the moment when I think members of Congress should be ready to say,"Sure, we'll give you the money, but this time we're actually gonna have some real conditions on it, and we're gonna require that we change this.
- 27:09different areas of law and policy: And so we're not in a place where we're constantly just giving you money in the bad times and letting you keep all the profits in the good times while not providing service to big chunks of the country that need it." So in many ways, you're providing a road map, whether people use it now or whether they use it sometime in the future.
- 27:25different areas of law and policy: I think it's super, super interesting to imagine what it would take to utilize that map and how hard it would be to make change.
- 27:34different areas of law and policy: I'd love to come back to that, really thinking about tech platforms like Facebook and like TikTok, but let's go ahead and take a break.
- 27:59different areas of law and policy: We are back with Professor Ganesh Sitaraman talking about all the ways in which some sectors of our American economy and the ways in which we live in the world really look, feel and, uh, act differently in terms of both our safety, our experience as having equal, you know, opportunity to do things like fly or make phone calls, but also in terms of our national security.
- 28:26different areas of law and policy: Ganesh, it was super helpful to think about our national interests in terms of safety and economic growth when we were talking about airlines.
- 28:33different areas of law and policy: I'd really like us to shift, to talk about another great point that you've raised in your work, in your 'Stanford Review' article, you give a great example of our need to control wireless communications— things like literally radio waves, uh, being picked up and sent— at the turn of the 20th century through the Radio Act of 1912.
- 28:54different areas of law and policy: You use that as the sort of introductory or prequel chapter to really understanding or helping us to understand the big intense concern around China, uh, and its ownership of TikTok.
- 29:09different areas of law and policy: So can you just give it, lay, lay the foundations for us, set the stage for us by talking a little bit about, um, in one example, you talk about undersea cables.
- 29:18different areas of law and policy: In another, you talk about the wireless telecommunications and ways of, of sending messages.
- 29:23different areas of law and policy: How do we think about that in terms of our national security?
- 29:26different areas of law and policy: Well, well, let me go back and connect this up to the airline conversation...
- 29:29different areas of law and policy: Great.
- 29:29different areas of law and policy: ...to get us to get us into it, which is the system of regulating networks, platforms and utilities— the American tradition of regulated capitalism—was one that applied to a number of different sectors.
- 29:43different areas of law and policy: And like I said, these were businesses that were not like all the others and the classic categories of businesses were transportation, energy, telecommunications, banking.
- 29:55different areas of law and policy: And these sectors are fundamentally different than other ones.
- 29:58different areas of law and policy: And there were lots of others, of course, uh, but, but those were the really big categories.
- 30:03different areas of law and policy: And so things like railroads, telephones, uh, oil and gas pipelines, electricity um, we governed as public utilities with the kind of public utility principles that go back into, as I mentioned, the postal system or the banking system or...
- 30:18different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 30:18different areas of law and policy: ...common carrier laws under English...
- 30:19different areas of law and policy: You don't want different states,...English common law.
- 30:21different areas of law and policy: Different banks issuing different currencies.
- 30:23different areas of law and policy: We need one currency.
- 30:24different areas of law and policy: It's gotta be the same one.
- 30:25different areas of law and policy: It's backed by the government.
- 30:26different areas of law and policy: There, there has to be a kind of uniformness to that.
- 30:29different areas of law and policy: So, so in all of these areas, we had this distinctive system of regulation.
- 30:34different areas of law and policy: And one of the things that's really interesting is that in many of these areas, we have throughout our history restricted foreign ownership, influence and control over that infrastructural service.
- 30:49different areas of law and policy: And the history, which I describe in this paper called the "Regulation of Foreign Platforms," and 'Stanford Law Review' goes back really to Alexander Hamilton and the First National Bank, um, but continues throughout our history in different sectors and in the communications context is, is one that was really understood in the 20th century and especially at the turn of the 20th century to be really important for national security reasons.
- 31:16different areas of law and policy: That if you had a foreign government that was an adversary that was able to control the core communications technology, like the radio, uh, that they would be able to do problematic and nefarious things—not just communicate with themselves or listen to what's going on in the U.S. Right...
- 31:38different areas of law and policy: ...intercepting our communications.
- 31:39different areas of law and policy: Intercepting our communications.
- 31:41different areas of law and policy: But they would also potentially be able to propagandize in the U.S.
- 31:43different areas of law and policy: Plant false communications.
- 31:45different areas of law and policy: Plant false communications, plant false stories, all kinds of things that if you're in a real war, would be a real problem.
- 31:51different areas of law and policy: And so in World War I, we actually have examples of this that come up, and the federal government, through the Navy, take over the radios in the United States.
- 32:02different areas of law and policy: And we nationalize the radio system, it's run by the government, uh, for a period of time because there's this military exigency and this deep, deep concern about German communications and control over communications in the United States.
- 32:15different areas of law and policy: And this, that's just one example, but we have a lot of these.
- 32:20different areas of law and policy: And so, as I mentioned, Alexander Hamilton, you know, was worried that at the founding of the country, if foreigners had all the capital, because the United States is comparatively capital-poor at the time, and controlled the bank, they would control the American economy.
- 32:38different areas of law and policy: And where were those foreigners likely to be from? England, who, while we think of as close friends today, you know, 1787, we just fought a war to get out from underneath the, the English.
- 32:48different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 32:48different areas of law and policy: Um, these are not our friends.
- 32:50different areas of law and policy: We are gonna fight another war with them in a couple decades.
- 32:53different areas of law and policy: They burned down the White House, right?
- 32:54different areas of law and policy: Like this is, this is our rival at the time, and you don't want your rival controlling your economy...
- 32:59different areas of law and policy: Yes.
- 32:59different areas of law and policy: ...and your currency and your money supply and, and everything about your economic fates, particularly in a conflict, but even outside of a conflict, you don't want that.
- 33:06different areas of law and policy: And so they put restrictions on who the bank directors could be.
- 33:10different areas of law and policy: Um, and this is a, a thing that's been pretty consistent in, in U.S. banking law.
- 33:14different areas of law and policy: Specifically, that they had to be U.S. citizens.
- 33:15different areas of law and policy: They had to be U.S. citizens.
- 33:16different areas of law and policy: And, and so part of the thing that we have had in a number of these sectors is restrictions on foreign ownership, restrictions on foreign control, restrictions on foreign investment.
- 33:27different areas of law and policy: And there's different ways that they've been designed over time— sometimes percentages, sometimes directors have to be American citizens or officers, uh, leading officers have to be American citizens.
- 33:38different areas of law and policy: And they're not always perfect, but, but they've worked in a number of different ways.
- 33:40different areas of law and policy: And what I do in the paper is show that this history is really quite extensive and pervasive.
- 33:47different areas of law and policy: And it is in stark contrast to the public debate over TikTok in which, where you often hear from people are things like, "It is unprecedented to have restrictions on foreign companies," like a restriction or a ban on TikTok.
- 34:05different areas of law and policy: And the answer is no, it's not.
- 34:06different areas of law and policy: We actually have done it all the way back.
- 34:08different areas of law and policy: And some people you've heard of, like Alexander Hamilton, you know, did these things.
- 34:12different areas of law and policy: Um, it's quite common, and we do it for particular purposes and there's better and worse ways to do it.
- 34:17different areas of law and policy: And there are lots of ways to do it, which I described in the paper, but the fact of it happening is not new um, and therefore not particularly interesting.
- 34:25different areas of law and policy: It's the question of when should we apply it and how that's the, that's the important question.
- 34:30different areas of law and policy: And, and I think what's happened is, is really two things, and it's part of what my work, the airline book and this paper and more broadly some of the work we're doing at the policy accelerator um, and that me and a colleague, Morgan Ricks here have been doing, uh, in our academic research is reviving the study of networks, platforms and utilities.
- 34:51different areas of law and policy: And that there's a coherent set of regulatory tools that apply to those businesses that are a kind of model or toolkit.
- 34:59different areas of law and policy: And so if you're thinking about, for example, What are the tools in your toolbox?
- 35:04different areas of law and policy: And you read Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein's book, 'Nudge,' you'll say, "Okay, nudge.
- 35:09different areas of law and policy: I can nudge things. Great.
- 35:10different areas of law and policy: I can have default rules in favor of one thing or another." And that's a tool, And you can apply it to a hundred things— you know, hammer that hits a lot of nails.
- 35:17different areas of law and policy: The networks, platforms, utilities law, and, and that tradition is also, is a different hammer.
- 35:23different areas of law and policy: It's not nudges, it's a different hammer.
- 35:25different areas of law and policy: And it's got its own set of...
- 35:26different areas of law and policy: Yeah, its own tool.
- 35:27different areas of law and policy: ...components and you can use it for, for a whole bunch of things.
- 35:29different areas of law and policy: And it's just that for the last half century or so, we kind of stopped using that tool.
- 35:36different areas of law and policy: That's so interesting that the kind of frame, the intellectual framework dropped out.
- 35:41different areas of law and policy: And, and it turns out that in all the sectors where we used to use that tool and then we got rid of it and stopped using it, they're all sectors that are in various stages of crisis or disaster.
- 35:56different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 35:56different areas of law and policy: So it immediately makes me think when you talk about banking, you know, we hadn't put it on the list of things to talk about, but immediately crypto comes to mind, right?
- 36:04different areas of law and policy: That suddenly you have all these different forms of electronic currency, and no one's really sure whether they're legit or whether they're robust or how long they're gonna last or, you know, that sort of space.
- 36:16different areas of law and policy: And do law students know how to think about that?
- 36:20different areas of law and policy: Or is NPU...
- 36:21different areas of law and policy: I think...kind of a way to assist them in...
- 36:24different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 36:24different areas of law and policy: ...thinking about that.
- 36:25different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 36:25different areas of law and policy: NPU's a way to, to learn about that.
- 36:27different areas of law and policy: And when you think about it in the banking context, it's, it's really the same story.
- 36:30different areas of law and policy: You know, we actually had boom and bust cycles in the American economy that were driven by financial panics and depressions every couple of decades from the founding of the country up until the Great Depression in 1933.
- 36:44different areas of law and policy: You know, there's the panics and you can go the panic of 1819 and the panic of 1873 and there's a whole bunch of other 1837.
- 36:50different areas of law and policy: There's a whole bunch of panics around the way.
- 36:52different areas of law and policy: And then you get to the Great Depression in 1930, uh, in 1929, and then you have regulation. And it's a regulated system in the New Deal period that then means there are not runs on banks, there's not panics, there's not financial crises, there's not the boom and bust cycle that destroys the economy and sends a bunch of people into unemployment or, or other kind of, um, economic crisis, uh, until deregulation.
- 37:19different areas of law and policy: And then you deregulate the whole industry, and within a decade you have the greatest financial panic and crisis since the Great Depression, and that's the 2008 crisis.
- 37:27different areas of law and policy: And I. You know, so once you start thinking about these regulatory systems, it, it enables you to see how we've actually done things and what worked and what didn't.
- 37:37different areas of law and policy: That we've really forgotten as a kind of mental model.
- 37:40different areas of law and policy: And, and I think what's striking, and it's true about crypto, it's true about the TikTok conversation, is the industry that emerged in the period of forgetting was tech.
- 37:50different areas of law and policy: And, and tech feels so not of the same, you know, if we're thinking of species, right?
- 37:57different areas of law and policy: It feels so not the same species as banking or telecommunications, but here, but it is very clearly that it is, right?
- 38:04different areas of law and policy: It's, it's, but it's the same genus or the same family.
- 38:07different areas of law and policy: It's, it's in the same, you know, analogous kind of categories.
- 38:11different areas of law and policy: When you break it down into the specific business lines that we're talking about.
- 38:16different areas of law and policy: And the question of TikTok fits in comfortably to that.
- 38:19different areas of law and policy: We've never seen anything like it before.
- 38:21different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 38:21different areas of law and policy: It's brand...
- 38:22different areas of law and policy: It's totally new.
- 38:22different areas of law and policy: ...brand new.
- 38:23different areas of law and policy: Yes.
- 38:23different areas of law and policy: And nothing can even be thought about...
- 38:25different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 38:25different areas of law and policy: ...with respect to tech.
- 38:27different areas of law and policy: And this is just wrong.
- 38:28different areas of law and policy: In fact, almost everything is actually pretty similar to something else we have. Specific technologies are different and so on, but it turns out business practices are kind of the same.
- 38:38different areas of law and policy: Well, and I think for those of us who feel completely like blown over by the suddenness and intensity of that particular technology or that particular platform, the only things that then pop into heads are things like, well, then we're gonna ban TikTok, right?
- 38:52different areas of law and policy: Rather than, well, actually we have, as you said, this huge array of different tools, this huge array of different ways of thinking about both the risks that, um, we might face, the magnitude and intensity of those risks, but also the solutions.
- 39:08different areas of law and policy: So for the purpose of just backing up a little bit, just tell us a little bit about why TikTok was originally viewed as a, as a threat.
- 39:15different areas of law and policy: What, what is the actual threat in terms of national security that one might argue TikTok poses?
- 39:20different areas of law and policy: Well, there are a few different ones that people, that people have raised.
- 39:23different areas of law and policy: Um, one, uh, and I'll, and I'll take them I think from a little narrower to a little broader.
- 39:28different areas of law and policy: I think some of the narrower ones are that, you know, you can collect a lot of data from individuals.
- 39:35different areas of law and policy: You can, you know, effectively surveil people in some ways or others in terms of their, uh, behaviors on the platform.
- 39:43different areas of law and policy: And that there's concerns that, that could be used against individuals, say in government or who have national security, uh, relevant positions, maybe, uh, uh, to try to put pressure on them or just collect information about them, build psychological profiles or something like that.
- 39:58different areas of law and policy: So that's kind of one set of concerns.
- 40:00different areas of law and policy: I think the bigger set of concerns that, at least in the early stages didn't get as much discussion, but I think has gotten more in recent years, is that the application itself curates through its algorithm the kinds of things that people see.
- 40:14different areas of law and policy: And if you are downplaying certain kinds of content and playing up other, amplifying other kinds of content, uh, this is potentially problematic, particularly if you're in a conflict with an adversary. And if we're in a place where, uh, as as many believe, um, that we're in a, in a, uh, competitive relationship, if not adver, adversarial relationship with China, and that there's a possibility of a future war at some point, if that were to come to pass, do you really want your adversary to have a kind of direct line to everybody in the country.
- 40:51different areas of law and policy: Your population.
- 40:51different areas of law and policy: In the population, and to be able to shape how they get their news and what kind of things they're seeing and so on.
- 40:57different areas of law and policy: And even in the absence of that, do you really want your competitor to be shaping that kind of information ecosystem even now, where you could still have an influence on the trajectory of, of the country domestically?
- 41:09different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 41:09different areas of law and policy: A flash on, you know, an image of what if Germany were able to funnel radio messages into American households during the second World War that the U.S.
- 41:20different areas of law and policy: couldn't actually easily surveil or stop, right?
- 41:23different areas of law and policy: There are great examples that that's a, that's a great one.
- 41:25different areas of law and policy: What, what kind of misinformation, what kind of operations would Germany have run. Or what if you let the Soviet Union own NBC, ABC you know, during the Cold War, we would never have allowed that.
- 41:39different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 41:39different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 41:40different areas of law and policy: You know, the, the evening news instead of Walter Cronkite is gonna be some like Soviet person telling you about how the Soviet Union is great.
- 41:46different areas of law and policy: We would not have allowed that...
- 41:49different areas of law and policy: Yes.
- 41:49different areas of law and policy: ...in the Cold War.
- 41:50different areas of law and policy: And so that's, that's the kind of analogy that you might think of for thinking about TikTok, and it doesn't really get into the debate as much.
- 41:59different areas of law and policy: Uh, when, but when you think about it at that level, like do you really want the Germans, like having access to, you know, radio in the United States in World War II, I think most people would say like, that's a bad, I like, why would we do that?
- 42:12different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 42:12different areas of law and policy: That's not a good idea.
- 42:13different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 42:13different areas of law and policy: And, and that's, that's basically the debate.
- 42:16different areas of law and policy: So in a hyper globalized technological universe where tons of content is coming from tons of different people in tons of different countries, through those different formats.
- 42:29different areas of law and policy: If I open Instagram and I see something from a Canadian woman posting, right?
- 42:35different areas of law and policy: And you just imagine how free flowing that information flow is.
- 42:39different areas of law and policy: You know, banning obviously sounds very intense and restrictive.
- 42:43different areas of law and policy: What are the other tools that we could use to be able to dis disentangle foreign influence, foreign control, foreign investment, right?
- 42:54different areas of law and policy: There's, you do a great job of kind of pulling apart, using banking as an example, all the different ways in which we engage with foreign partners, uh, or adversaries at different levels.
- 43:05different areas of law and policy: Just help us understand a little bit of those.
- 43:07different areas of law and policy: Yeah, so I'll, I'll just highlight a few of the elements in the, in the kind of range of things.
- 43:11different areas of law and policy: Um, so obviously there's the outright ban.
- 43:13different areas of law and policy: You're not allowed to have a foreign owner or operator of, uh, uh, of a certain kind of industry within the United States.
- 43:21different areas of law and policy: Um, but there are also things short of that.
- 43:22different areas of law and policy: So you could have a foreign investor, for example, but the control of the company can't be foreign.
- 43:28different areas of law and policy: So maybe you cap investment at say 15%, knowing that investors have some influence over management, but they wouldn't have so much influence.
- 43:35different areas of law and policy: Or they're an investor, but they're also not allowed to vote.
- 43:37different areas of law and policy: So they have no governance, uh, power over the, over the, over the company.
- 43:43different areas of law and policy: Um, you could have restrictions on the citizenship, which is a proxy for loyalty of the, um, directors of the company or for the management of the company.
- 43:54different areas of law and policy: Uh, you could have certain aspects of the company's operations that have to be domestic.
- 43:59different areas of law and policy: Held domestically, sourced domestically.
- 44:01different areas of law and policy: Hence the U.S. subsidiary. ...built domestically.
- 44:03different areas of law and policy: And the U.S. subsidiary would be a version of that, where every aspect of its governance is just in the U.S. and you still have a parent company that's foreign.
- 44:11different areas of law and policy: And in that sense, you know, some amount of the profits go to the parent company, but it's not governed in a functional way by the, by the foreign parents.
- 44:18different areas of law and policy: So there are different ways that you can design these kind of systems and we can think carefully about what makes sense in any given context.
- 44:27different areas of law and policy: And I think that's where a lot of the debate or more sophisticated debate needs to go on the TikTok question.
- 44:33different areas of law and policy: Super helpful because I think, you know, when we say regulation, a set of concerns or, you know, opportunities come up in our heads.
- 44:41different areas of law and policy: And then when we say regulation of a foreign actor in the face of national security, maybe that that whole question starts to rotate.
- 44:49different areas of law and policy: Mm-hmm.
- 44:49different areas of law and policy: Right?
- 44:50different areas of law and policy: And then does it rotate again, when we talk about AI and when we think about, you know, ChatGPT or other platforms in which we put our data and our questions to be circulated widely and with audiences and to users for whom we have perhaps no trust or little trust. We've been doing it almost, you know, I would say relatively unthinkingly, right?
- 45:14different areas of law and policy: The, the technology has so rapidly outpaced our ability to imagine the risks, much less protect against them.
- 45:23different areas of law and policy: Can.
- 45:23different areas of law and policy: How does that work in terms of your work in AI?
- 45:25different areas of law and policy: I think the thing to focus on when we think about AI is to start, or, or the thing to help us focus when we, when we talk about AI, is to think about what I, what I, and a number of others call the, the AI tech stack, which is basically like the supply chain for AI.
- 45:42different areas of law and policy: When you go from down this chain, from the application all the way down to the machines that make the semiconductors, it turns out there's less and less competition all the way down.
- 45:55different areas of law and policy: There is only one company in the world, a Dutch company called ASML, that makes photolithography equipment.
- 46:00different areas of law and policy: Which is the stuff that you need to make semiconductors.
- 46:03different areas of law and policy: There is one dominant company on manufacturing semiconductors, that's TSMC, Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company.
- 46:10different areas of law and policy: There is one dominant company on designing them.
- 46:13different areas of law and policy: That's Nvidia.
- 46:15different areas of law and policy: There are three dominant companies in cloud. AWS, which is Amazon Web Services, GCP, Google Cloud Platform, and Microsoft Azure.
- 46:23different areas of law and policy: Just three.
- 46:23different areas of law and policy: There's a few more when it comes to models, and there's reasonable competition at the application layer, drawing on some of these other things.
- 46:32different areas of law and policy: So I think when you think about this from an NPU perspective, one thing to think about is a core piece of understanding NPU is we're looking at the sectors where there's likely to be not very much competition, where there's high capital costs, where there's network effects, where there's lock-in effects, where there's things that are going to lead us not to have, you know, competition in industries like making coffee mugs or sofas or restaurants.
- 46:56different areas of law and policy: Uh, you're locked into AWS because it's So there isn't gonna be competition there.
- 47:02different areas of law and policy: Um, vertical integration across the different layers.
- 47:05different areas of law and policy: We might be really worried if we same company owns the cloud, the model, the application, and the chips and everything else, because you're gonna ask your AI—a good example, I think could be, you know, you put into Microsoft Bing, what should I do this weekend?
- 47:19different areas of law and policy: And, and the, uh, the AI or or whatever will tell you, well, you should play, uh, Xbox.
- 47:25different areas of law and policy: Well, why, why should you do that?
- 47:27different areas of law and policy: Because Microsoft owns Xbox and they own Bing.
- 47:30different areas of law and policy: And the AI that they're operating is theirs too.
- 47:32different areas of law and policy: And it did it on its own cloud.
- 47:34different areas of law and policy: Like it's going to push you.
- 47:35different areas of law and policy: They're not gonna say, you know, play some other play Nintendo.
- 47:38different areas of law and policy: That's not what they're gonna tell you.
- 47:39different areas of law and policy: Right?
- 47:40different areas of law and policy: So maybe we should be worried about these things, and especially if you're a business person.
- 47:44different areas of law and policy: And you're thinking about starting a business in some of these sectors.
- 47:48different areas of law and policy: You know, if you start an application, and it's a pretty good application.
- 47:52different areas of law and policy: Why is, aren't one of the model companies gonna just copy you, steal your thing and offer it and you'll just go out of business?
- 48:01different areas of law and policy: And this happens in other sectors.
- 48:02different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 48:02different areas of law and policy: This is what's going on in the tech sector in a bunch of places.
- 48:04different areas of law and policy: And so, you know, you should be worried about this kind of thing.
- 48:08different areas of law and policy: And if we want to have a vibrant, dynamic, innovative, competitive ecosystem, you have to have these foundational infrastructures that are available to everyone.
- 48:17different areas of law and policy: So that that bare-knuckled competitiveness that we love so much...
- 48:21different areas of law and policy: Can exist.
- 48:22different areas of law and policy: ...can thrive.
- 48:22different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 48:23different areas of law and policy: Can thrive.
- 48:23different areas of law and policy: That we actually at every level and in every way aren't constrained because we didn't think about it.
- 48:30different areas of law and policy: That's right.
- 48:31different areas of law and policy: It's so fascinating to hear the extent to which those substrata are playing such a integral and yet unexplained undiscussed role.
- 48:42different areas of law and policy: I mean, perhaps somebody is discussing them, but I think we are all still just trying to catch up with how to utilize and how to capitalize on those technologies, not on how we need to manage or regulate them or whether to manage or regulate them, right?
- 48:58different areas of law and policy: Mm-hmm.
- 48:58different areas of law and policy: These are the boom times, and the boom times come before bust times is, you know, the way of history.
- 49:03different areas of law and policy: But you know, I think one of the challenges is if you don't think about that, you, you are gonna fall into the trap.
- 49:11different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 49:11different areas of law and policy: I mean, it's the old, the old saying, you know, those who don't study history are doomed to repeat it.
- 49:15different areas of law and policy: Great point.
- 49:16different areas of law and policy: Uh, and certainly a great point for us to take a break.
- 49:19different areas of law and policy: I can't wait to talk a little bit about how you found your way into this space, Ganesh.
- 49:24different areas of law and policy: It's really amazing to think about you as a legal scholar and you as a, you know, person in the middle of political economy and law, trying to sort it, uh, at a time when it's so rapidly evolving.
- 49:39different areas of law and policy: So we'll come right back.
- 49:57different areas of law and policy: Welcome back, Ganesh.
- 49:58different areas of law and policy: Thank you so much for talking about all of these incredibly, uh, rapidly evolving processes and institutions and technologies and industries.
- 50:08different areas of law and policy: I don't even know where to start, much less finish.
- 50:11different areas of law and policy: Of course it makes me immediately wonder, you know, how did you know you wanted to do this?
- 50:17different areas of law and policy: Would you, were you sitting around at the age of seven cracking open antitrust law and saying, you know, um, this game of Monopoly has serious implications for my life?
- 50:28different areas of law and policy: Uh, you know, what led you in this really exciting direction?
- 50:32different areas of law and policy: And how, how did you train to be this?
- 50:35different areas of law and policy: I, I wish it was, I wish I had a good story, like, uh, like playing Monopoly or something as a kid.
- 50:39different areas of law and policy: That would be, that would be excellent.
- 50:40different areas of law and policy: But no, I, I do have a story that goes, that goes, it's sort of a story that goes, that goes way back, um.
- 50:46different areas of law and policy: But I think sometime around high school I, I observed and realized that many of the people I admired in history had this interesting shared characteristic of being people who were both deeply intellectually engaged, but also practically engaged in the world of politics and public affairs.
- 51:09different areas of law and policy: And as someone interested in history, interested in constitutional law and founding, especially, you know, you look at your Madisons and Jeffersons and Hamiltons and Adamses and so on— and they are both writing works that we even independently of their presidential or political status would read as very thoughtful, canonical works of political theory and that make real contributions on an intellectual level.
- 51:40different areas of law and policy: And yet at the same time, you know, they're also running for office and stabbing each other in the back and ghostwriting articles in the, in the newspaper about how somebody else...
- 51:48different areas of law and policy: They're as human as the rest of us.
- 51:49different areas of law and policy: ...somebody doing something else.
- 51:50different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 51:50different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 51:50different areas of law and policy: And they're deeply engaged in the political world while also being engaged in the intellectual world.
- 51:54different areas of law and policy: And, and I think I had this theory that doing both would be beneficial to each.
- 52:02different areas of law and policy: And that you might be a little, bring something different to the world of politics than everyone else if you have this intellectual background, and you'll bring something different to the intellectual world if you also have this practical background.
- 52:15different areas of law and policy: And so tell us a little bit about, and so how did you end up managing those two worlds?
- 52:19different areas of law and policy: Yeah, it's, it's, it's mostly luck, but I think, um, you know, for me, doing both has been, I think, quite generative and, and in interesting ways.
- 52:28different areas of law and policy: I, um, you know, study all of these things, uh, but also, uh, worked a fair bit in, in the political world.
- 52:35different areas of law and policy: My, and, and like I said, it's basically just luck.
- 52:38different areas of law and policy: You know, my contracts professor on the first day of law school uh, was Elizabeth Warren.
- 52:42different areas of law and policy: Um, I helped her with her, uh, during the financial crisis and then with her race for the Senate and then in the Senate and then her presidential campaign.
- 52:50different areas of law and policy: And through that and through other things have been, you know, quite involved in different aspects of, of law policy, government, uh, politics in different ways.
- 52:59different areas of law and policy: And through each of those have been able to see the kind of practical things— so what people in government need when they're thinking about ideas— and so can, as an academic, not just do the things that make for, you know, getting into a top journal.
- 53:14different areas of law and policy: But also the version of that same paper, but that is actually able to reach a broader audience, the audience that can use it and do something with it, um, or the general public.
- 53:24different areas of law and policy: Uh, and so thinking about different ways to communicate the same set of ideas based on research, um, is I think one of the real, the real payoffs that I, that I've had from that.
- 53:32different areas of law and policy: And just to interject there for a second, when you've done that work, have you found that you are able to pivot to be able to speak to different ideologically more conservative or more progressive or left-leaning political leaders in ways that meet everyone's agendas?
- 53:50different areas of law and policy: Or do you find that there's a certain taste or preference for the framing of how to think about banking, or how to think about transportation, or how to think about telecommunications that really works for one, uh, side of the aisle and not for the other?
- 54:06different areas of law and policy: It's really both.
- 54:07different areas of law and policy: And it depends on the issue, and it depends on the particular framing of the issue.
- 54:11different areas of law and policy: For example, on the, the TikTok questions, I'm pretty confident that most of the people who like my paper on TikTok in the political universe are conservative.
- 54:21different areas of law and policy: I've seen it kind of pushed around in those spaces much more than in the, uh, on the, on the progressive or liberal side.
- 54:29different areas of law and policy: Um, and I think that's a combination of the topic, people's interest and what their agenda is and just happens that on this topic, the things that I do align with some set of people's agenda... Particularly concerns with national security, particularly actors, actors, foreign actors and so on.
- 54:44different areas of law and policy: So there's just an overlap there.
- 54:46different areas of law and policy: In other areas I think my work probably appeals to the other side more.
- 54:49different areas of law and policy: And so it really depends on the topic, the subject, the kind of framing.
- 54:53different areas of law and policy: What's really interesting right now for a lot of this work is there's been a real scrambling and shift in the last decade in how people think about economic policy generally.
- 55:04different areas of law and policy: You know, really for the last half century, before the last decade, there was a pretty good consensus in Washington, um, that people have called, uh, including myself, have called the neoliberal consensus.
- 55:14different areas of law and policy: That was effectively, we should deregulate everything, privatize everything, globalize everything, and we shouldn't spend any money—fiscal austerity.
- 55:23different areas of law and policy: And that consensus is broken down on both right and left.
- 55:26different areas of law and policy: Uh, you know, you think about the, the globalization story. Well, nobody today is really making the argument for more trade deals and full force globalization...
- 55:37different areas of law and policy: Yeah.
- 55:37different areas of law and policy: ...like they did in the nineties and two thousands.
- 55:40different areas of law and policy: We are just not there.
- 55:41different areas of law and policy: In fact, it's the opposite conversation.
- 55:43different areas of law and policy: We're talking about tariffs and export controls and trade restrictions of all kinds.
- 55:49different areas of law and policy: Um, that's the conversation.
- 55:50different areas of law and policy: Nobody was really talking about antitrust law and regulating or grappling with enormously concentration, enormous concentrations of, of economic power in the nineties and two thousands, and even in the 2010s.
- 56:05different areas of law and policy: I mean, you couldn't really go around Washington and have a conversation about antitrust, uh, in say 2013 or 14 without it being a very technical conversation— antitrust economists and some lawyers having a kind of very narrow conversation.
- 56:18different areas of law and policy: That's very different now antitrust on the front page of, of newspapers.
- 56:21different areas of law and policy: It's a thing that people talk about in the world, not just some scholars and...
- 56:26different areas of law and policy: Right.
- 56:27different areas of law and policy: ...and the bureaucrats.
- 56:28different areas of law and policy: So we've had a big shift.
- 56:30different areas of law and policy: Industrial policy— if you were to go around Washington as, as I occasionally did, uh, in the kind of late Obama era, mid Obama era, and talk about industrial policy, I think the general mood was, like, "Don't invite that guy back." Um, it was not allowed to talk about that stuff, to talk about that.
- 56:46different areas of law and policy: It was the Lord Voldemort of policy, like it must not be named because it was so horrific to do industrial policy.
- 56:54different areas of law and policy: The only thing we can do is globalize.
- 56:56different areas of law and policy: Right?
- 56:56different areas of law and policy: That's, that was the world.
- 56:58different areas of law and policy: Well now you have everybody interested in industrial policy.
- 57:01different areas of law and policy: You've got the Biden administration, or the National Security Advisor and the head of the NEC are giving speeches on industrial policy.
- 57:07different areas of law and policy: You've got Marco Rubio, who's been writing reports as a senator on industrial policy now the Secretary of State on, on the Republican side.
- 57:13different areas of law and policy: So, you know, there's been a really big shift, and I think that scramble and that shift has meant that there are people on both sides who are interested in some of these topics and people on both sides who really dislike some of these. Both.
- 57:25different areas of law and policy: So.
- 57:26different areas of law and policy: Yes.
- 57:26different areas of law and policy: So it's, so in terms of reaching out, I, I think it's, it's a weird thing where I've found traction in some of my work on both sides, which, uh, which, which is good, but, uh, perhaps surprising to some.
- 57:36different areas of law and policy: I feel, uh, very hopeful to think about the marketplace of ideas, the marketplace as a place where, you know, university faculty members have an opportunity to get those ideas out and to shop them, not only to leaders, but to the public, right?
- 57:53different areas of law and policy: And the ways in which you do that, I think you've discussed really clearly as a, you know, exciting and also kind of a clear responsibility is kind of way in which you navigate both the intellectual and the political dimensions of your work.
- 58:07different areas of law and policy: I think a lot about you training the next generation of attorneys and, um, scholars at a law school, you know, at Vanderbilt's Law School, which I think is known to be very ideologically heterogeneous, uh, with, you know, viewpoint diversity.
- 58:22different areas of law and policy: What's it like to teach students?
- 58:23different areas of law and policy: Do they, are they caught up?
- 58:25different areas of law and policy: Are they hungry for this information?
- 58:27different areas of law and policy: Do they want to talk about industrial policy?
- 58:30different areas of law and policy: Are they ahead of you?
- 58:31different areas of law and policy: You know, in saying, well, how does that work for rural markets?
- 58:34different areas of law and policy: How does that work for, um, labor?
- 58:37different areas of law and policy: How does that work for shareholders?
- 58:39different areas of law and policy: Is there a sense of this strong appetite among the next generation?
- 58:43different areas of law and policy: Yeah, I think people are really interested in these questions.
- 58:45different areas of law and policy: When we talk the professor, uh, Morgan Ricks and I taught the networks, platforms, utilities course together.
- 58:51different areas of law and policy: And when we did it for the first time, students were just so interested.
- 58:56different areas of law and policy: Because you rarely get to learn about the kind of basic industries and of our society and both learn about their industrial history and their legal and policy history together.
- 59:13different areas of law and policy: And that's how we teach the course.
- 59:14different areas of law and policy: And so if you've interacted with the post office, as almost everybody has at some point in some way, you learn in our class about the whole history of the post office and how it started and how it grew and what its components are and how it works and how they did postal rate setting and how we have geographic access and how universal service started and rural free delivery and all of these interesting innovations...
- 59:36different areas of law and policy: Fascinating.
- 59:37different areas of law and policy: ...of the post office that you experience as a person but have no idea how they work.
- 59:42different areas of law and policy: So you really learn about society.
- 59:43different areas of law and policy: And when we do tech platforms in the course, for example, you know, I remember teaching digital advertising and one of the really interesting things about that is all of us have seen ads digitally, uh, if you've engaged at all in the digital world, which most people have.
- 1:00:02different areas of law and policy: And so if you've seen Google ads, if you've seen ads in Facebook, if you've seen ads anywhere on these places, where do these ads come from?
- 1:00:11different areas of law and policy: How does that ad get served to you?
- 1:00:14different areas of law and policy: Well, that's what we teach in the class.
- 1:00:15different areas of law and policy: We show them how that industry works and how the ads are built, which are the companies doing, which parts of this, what does that exchange look like?
- 1:00:23different areas of law and policy: Who's getting paid?
- 1:00:24different areas of law and policy: How's that?
- 1:00:24different areas of law and policy: How's that actually work?
- 1:00:26different areas of law and policy: And then we think about where the problems are.
- 1:00:27different areas of law and policy: Are there antitrust problems?
- 1:00:29different areas of law and policy: Are there abuses of power?
- 1:00:30different areas of law and policy: What are the downsides?
- 1:00:31different areas of law and policy: What are the pros?
- 1:00:31different areas of law and policy: What are the cons?
- 1:00:32different areas of law and policy: How do these systems work?
- 1:00:33different areas of law and policy: And again, it's one of these fascinating things for the students because you actually get to see how this thing you interact with every single day works.
- 1:00:40different areas of law and policy: And airlines are another great example.
- 1:00:42different areas of law and policy: I mean, almost nobody knows in detail the history of how airline regulation actually worked.
- 1:00:47different areas of law and policy: What actually happened after deregulation.
- 1:00:49different areas of law and policy: A number of people who are still around have lived through it, but our students have not.
- 1:00:53different areas of law and policy: Yes.
- 1:00:54different areas of law and policy: They weren't around in the early eighties.
- 1:00:55different areas of law and policy: No, but it just makes me, the images, They didn't experience it.
- 1:00:57different areas of law and policy: So.
- 1:00:57different areas of law and policy: Yeah, it's like that, you know, that old thing that some of us did as little kids, like using invisible ink and then using the, the weird little pen to make the invisible ink be visible or using heat, right?
- 1:01:09different areas of law and policy: That that's what you're doing in some way.
- 1:01:11different areas of law and policy: You're making visible all of those invisible layers that I think many of us feel suspicious of, or at least hesitant.
- 1:01:19different areas of law and policy: Like why is it that suddenly my phone keeps telling me about the shoe company from, for which I just thought about ordering shoes— didn't actually order them, but somehow I'm being pummeled by ads, right?
- 1:01:32different areas of law and policy: Well, clearly I must have done something behavioral that signaled and that signal penetrated the system and now I'm, I'm being sold shoes.
- 1:01:41different areas of law and policy: On, you know, high.
- 1:01:43different areas of law and policy: Mm-hmm.
- 1:01:44different areas of law and policy: High, high tech, high energy, right?
- 1:01:47different areas of law and policy: So that you are able to do that.
- 1:01:49different areas of law and policy: But to people who are actually going to lead and to make decisions and to argue for directions that we should all go is, is super exciting.
- 1:01:58different areas of law and policy: And I think one that I hope makes us feel empowered and emboldened rather than caught up or swept along...
- 1:02:07different areas of law and policy: Mm-hmm.
- 1:02:08different areas of law and policy: ...by technology in ways that feel often so fast paced and so complex that we don't really understand how to navigate them.
- 1:02:16different areas of law and policy: In that way, you know, just thinking about sort of final words, where would you like us to go, Ganesh?
- 1:02:22different areas of law and policy: Where would you like this work to go?
- 1:02:24different areas of law and policy: How do you want us to think about this in future?
- 1:02:26different areas of law and policy: Well, I think the thing that, that, that I'm hoping and that we're hoping is that by giving people more access to understand the tools of NPU law, its history, how it's operated, how it worked, and the great things that it actually did.
- 1:02:42different areas of law and policy: And there are certainly some trade-offs and downsides, too, but to understand the positives, uh, in that, which I think are quite undervalued, um, that if we can do that, it will actually provide some really helpful answers to solving some of our thorniest problems.
- 1:02:57different areas of law and policy: And so, like I said, if, if you think about the areas that we removed this toolkit from— railroads, maritime, shipping, these are not areas that airlines—these are not areas that one would say were massive successes during COVID.
- 1:03:16different areas of law and policy: There were real problems in that period.
- 1:03:18different areas of law and policy: Uh, banking, we had the financial crash.
- 1:03:21different areas of law and policy: We had just had some bank failures just recently, a few years ago.
- 1:03:25different areas of law and policy: You know, these are all problems that we see in the world.
- 1:03:27different areas of law and policy: So I think that this lens into thinking about regulation can actually help us with actually some of the hardest, most fundamental, most important, most critical issues for addressing how we have a thriving, stable economy and society.
- 1:03:43different areas of law and policy: And, and my hope is that the more people that hear about them, the more people who we can teach, the more people who understand how they play out in these different sectors, the better chance we'll have at actually governing them in a way that actually achieves some of the, the positive social goals that that we know from history they can achieve without some of the downsides.
- 1:04:03different areas of law and policy: Thank you so much for being with us.
- 1:04:05different areas of law and policy: Thank you to our listeners for tuning in.
- 1:04:07different areas of law and policy: We'll be back next time with another guest who's pushing the boundaries of discovery.
- 1:04:11different areas of law and policy: Until then, I'm Cybele Raver and this is 'Quantum Potential.' The 'Quantum Potential' podcast comes from Vanderbilt University.
- 1:04:29different areas of law and policy: Your host is C. Cybele Raver.
- 1:04:32different areas of law and policy: Thank you to our guest, Ganesh Sitaraman.
- 1:04:35different areas of law and policy: Production by Matriarch Digital Media.
- 1:04:38different areas of law and policy: For more information about'Quantum Potential,' go to Vanderbilt.edu/quantumpotential.
- 1:04:47different areas of law and policy: Stay curious.