Latest / Inside Media Relations / Episode 4 - The First Answer: Why AI Is Changing the Value of Earned Media
Transcript
- 0:01Jack Murray: Welcome to Inside Media Relations, the podcast for
- 0:03PR people serious about getting their stories covered. In this
- 0:07episode, the first answer: Why AI is changing the value of
- 0:11earned media. We're looking at how AI is reshaping visibility,
- 0:15discovery, and influence, and why earned media is more
- 0:18important than ever. I'm joined by Johnny Bentwood, Global
- 0:21President of Data Analytics at Golin. We will explore how
- 0:25brands are adapting to a world where audiences are increasingly
- 0:29getting answers from AI systems instead of search engines. We'll
- 0:33discuss AI visibility, generative engine optimization,
- 0:37and what communications need to do to remain visible in the AI
- 0:40age. Let's get inside media relations. Johnny, welcome to
- 0:45the show. Good to see you.
- 0:46Jonny Bentwood: Good to see you, and thanks for having me on.
- 0:47Jack Murray: Yeah, so Johnny, we've known each other for a few
- 0:50years through the International Conference Network, and let's
- 0:56start this. Let's start this chat in a cave in Bulgaria,
- 1:00where we were a couple of years ago, we went, we were brought by
- 1:03a mutual friend on a road trip in Bulgaria,
- 1:07Jonny Bentwood: and who thought the world of data and
- 1:09measurement was boring,
- 1:10Jack Murray: exactly. Yeah, I didn't quite.. it was roasting
- 1:14that day, was a little bit trepidatious at the start as we
- 1:16went down the ravine. I thought, where are we going? Well, we got
- 1:20to talk on that day about some of the work that you do at
- 1:23Golin, and your career path has been really interesting, and I'm
- 1:27really interested to tease - I'm interested at the start, just to
- 1:30tease out what you do, like, and I know some of it is about
- 1:35communication measurement, it's about data leadership and data
- 1:39science leadership, strategic consulting, looking at future
- 1:42trends. If you know that feature in the Sunday Times, A Day in
- 1:46the Life, where people describe kind of a normal day, if one
- 1:50exists in your world, what does it look like?
- 1:53Jonny Bentwood: You know, not even my mum really understands
- 1:55what I do. She still thinks we're working advertising, but
- 1:58I'm very clearly in the data business. I was in the data side
- 2:02before it's a thing, but if I tried to think about how I
- 2:06describe my job, think of it in terms of I want companies to be
- 2:11data driven in their communications, so all that time
- 2:15people are working in marketing and think, hey, this sounds like
- 2:18a really cool idea. Well, it may be a cool idea, but I want to
- 2:22make sure that cool idea is baked in solid data. Is it the
- 2:26right message for the right audience? Are we going to hit
- 2:28them in the right way, in the right place, where they hang
- 2:31out? Being data driven makes us better, makes us smarter, and
- 2:36it's not just about how did we do, it's making sure we do well
- 2:39in the first place.
- 2:40Jack Murray: If we start at the start, and when I was a
- 2:42corporate PR practitioner, before I got into the software
- 2:45world, one of the one of the greatest mysteries to me, when
- 2:48I'd meet a prospective client, and it never got any easier,
- 2:52where they'd say, oh, can you do some public relations, can you
- 2:55communicate for me, and we'd sit down, and I'd say, what do you
- 2:58want to achieve, and would try and explain to the client that
- 3:01if we design it to be measured, we'll be able to measure the
- 3:04progress, and that notion of at the start of a campaign knowing
- 3:08what you want to measure, knowing what, like in sporting
- 3:11analogy, we know what the cup looks like, we know what the
- 3:14trophy looks like. Is it correct in saying that in a lot of these
- 3:17cases, like understanding what you're trying to measure is a
- 3:20good place to start.
- 3:21Jonny Bentwood: It is, but you'll find that people don't
- 3:23know where to even start thinking about that. So, you
- 3:25need to, I always say, write for the reader, put it in terms of
- 3:29the person you're speaking to understand, so everyone
- 3:31understands the purchase funnel, the customer journey. Now, let's
- 3:34go back to that question, but what are we trying to achieve?
- 3:37Now, the first step is awareness, so if people aren't
- 3:40aware of you, then okay, that's what we're going to be
- 3:43measuring, and the kind of metrics you look at, that may be
- 3:46share of reach across your tier one audiences. Now, if they're
- 3:49aware of you, the next stage in that funnel is consideration:
- 3:53should I buy this product or that product, Coke or Pepsi,
- 3:57Burger King or McDonald's, and then it's a differentiation
- 3:59play. If that's the objective, then the KPIs are around
- 4:03consideration. It's around engaging people who really
- 4:06believe in that point. If they understand who you are and how
- 4:09you differentiate, then the next stage is affinity. Do they like
- 4:12you? And that's the case of the KPIs there would be around
- 4:15sentiment and love and trust of that brand. The next stage is
- 4:20that action or purchase, are they going to buy from you, and
- 4:23the KPIs around that, and finally, are they recommending
- 4:26you the advocacy? So to ask you a question, What are you trying
- 4:29to achieve? Well, let's see where you are in the customer
- 4:31journey, and that defines the KPIs you should go for,
- 4:35Jack Murray: and in a like a fabled agency like Golin, that's
- 4:38been, you know, one of the most famous PR agencies that was ever
- 4:41created, and it's probably what is it 80 years old now, from
- 4:46from when it started. Like when clients come in, have you've -
- 4:50I'm assuming you've created analysis frameworks, you've
- 4:53created things that can plug and play, and then you tweak them as
- 4:56people come in, based on what their needs are. What does that
- 4:58look like when a new piece. Business comes in,
- 5:01Jonny Bentwood: you know, the skeleton remains the same. It
- 5:04adapts to the current need. I think about how we measure now
- 5:07and how we measure 20 years ago. A lot of the core principles
- 5:10remain the same. The problem is the world has changed.
- 5:13Jack Murray: Yeah,
- 5:14Jonny Bentwood: and so we've had to bring in new approaches with
- 5:16it. Gen AI being a great example, because we're now
- 5:19marketing and looking at more channels than we ever have done,
- 5:23so the concept remains the same, but I always like to think if
- 5:27people are just using measurement to evaluate the
- 5:29past, being descriptive, yeah, that I give ourselves a mark of
- 5:32four out of 10. What we need to do is move from descriptive to
- 5:35prescriptive, so just to measuring the outcomes, what we
- 5:38do is descriptive, measuring what we should be doing is
- 5:43prescriptive, and if it can be even better by going from
- 5:46prescriptive to predictive, which is anticipating the
- 5:48future, so we can get there first.
- 5:50Jack Murray: And do you still think, like, you know, one of
- 5:53the greatest pitfalls of public relations is the soft nature of
- 5:55it? And sometimes I think that the industry sells itself short
- 5:59because, you know, if it's not going to execute properly, or if
- 6:03it's not measuring properly from the start, of course, it'll be
- 6:05soft, but if you, if you, you know, obviously there are
- 6:07unintended consequences to being proactive, but if you go with a
- 6:12full measurement framework, and you're intent on taking the
- 6:15ruler out at the start, and you design something that can be
- 6:18measured, obviously you're going to be able to give harder data
- 6:21and hard success metrics to people.
- 6:23Jonny Bentwood: Yeah, we should be made accountable for what we
- 6:25do. If we don't set clear goals, then people just going to do the
- 6:29wrong stuff. And we also need to be honest. I'd say we need to
- 6:32embrace the ugly baby, say, you know what, what we're trying to
- 6:35achieve, it didn't work.
- 6:36Jack Murray: Yeah,
- 6:37Jonny Bentwood: if we do some bullshit metric, then we're
- 6:39going to make sure we repeat that same mistake in the future,
- 6:42Jack Murray: so you mentioned Gen AI, and you know you've,
- 6:46you've got a lot of domain expertise in this new area of
- 6:51generative engine optimization, and I want to talk about that,
- 6:55and you have a manifesto, and when I heard it first, I'm, I'm
- 6:59a sucker for a manifesto, I love, I love a good clarion call
- 7:03to action. Could you read the manifesto first? Because when I
- 7:06heard it, it really plugged me into the new reality of AI, what
- 7:11it means for communicate communicators, and this for
- 7:15public relations communications, the huge opportunities there to
- 7:18to reframe ourselves and to be completely aligned with this new
- 7:21wave.
- 7:22Jonny Bentwood: Yeah, pretty delighted to. The world has
- 7:26changed. Every audience you've ever communicated with now has a
- 7:33machine in front of them. Power has shifted from publishers to
- 7:38platforms, from editors to algorithms, now the
- 7:43organizations that understand this shift will lead, the ones
- 7:48that measure but don't act will disappear. We are no longer
- 7:53competing for headlines, we are competing for inclusion. We are
- 7:59now marketing to machines.
- 8:02Jack Murray: I love it, and it's just that notion of like when
- 8:05you, when, when I heard you read it the last, like, the first
- 8:07time, I thought, God, that, that, that so simplifies
- 8:09everything. Talk to me about inclusion, and talk to me, you
- 8:16know, you also have, you know, you've very, very clearly 4f for
- 8:22visibility, and this notion of if I'm a, if I'm a practitioner
- 8:25now, and I'm a communicator. Talk to me about the importance
- 8:29of being visible in Claude and perplexity in Chat GPT, and what
- 8:36that means to drive the objectives and the things that
- 8:41are underpinning the communications, and I suppose
- 8:43then it's a big question, and then you know the methods by
- 8:46which I can make that easier for myself.
- 8:48Jonny Bentwood: Well, let's just say why it's important first. I
- 8:50mean, people have been talking about Gen AI for years now, and
- 8:54it sort of came about when I realized that people picking up
- 8:57their phones and they were scrolling past all those results
- 9:00that came in, and say, oh yeah, that sponsored they bought those
- 9:03keywords, and they scroll past them. That's called zero click.
- 9:07It doesn't go anywhere. But now people pick up the phone, they
- 9:10ask that same question to Gen AI, and go, bloody hell, that's
- 9:14perfect. I'm just going to accept that first answer, and I
- 9:19find that shocking. What that actually means is people have
- 9:22gone from critical thinking, where they sort of scroll past
- 9:26those results, to anchor bias, where that first answer that
- 9:29comes in, they go, 'yep, I love it. Now, I prefer to live in the
- 9:33reality of where we are rather than where we'd like to be. I'd
- 9:36love people to apply more critical thinking, but they
- 9:38don't, and so, knowing they're going to accept that answer that
- 9:42Gen AI comes back with, it's so critical that we influence the
- 9:47results of that first answer. And what I've done is I've put
- 9:51together a framework, I call it the 4f's that has to be
- 9:54practical, so that anybody who listens to this can think I know
- 9:59what I can do tomorrow to make a head start into be influencing
- 10:03that results that come in,
- 10:05Jack Murray: and before you go into the four Fs, it's important
- 10:07to say, like, earned media is hugely significant in this new
- 10:11world. Tell us a little bit just about the data behind that.
- 10:14Jonny Bentwood: So, we have looked across millions of
- 10:17different citations, hundreds of different brands, and there's a
- 10:20few stats that always come out. The most shocking one is that
- 10:25around 70 to 95% of all AI citations are driven by earned
- 10:32media. That's incredible.
- 10:34Jack Murray: It is incredible.
- 10:35Jonny Bentwood: It's not coming from advertising, it's not
- 10:38coming from paid discovery, it's coming from earned media. Around
- 10:448% typically comes from social media, and you know what, that's
- 10:47not it's not Instagram, it's not TikTok, it's not Snapchat, it's
- 10:53Reddit, it's YouTube, it's LinkedIn, and the final, just a
- 10:57few small percentage points is on owned media, your own
- 11:00websites, so that huge chunks coming from earned media,
- 11:05Jack Murray: as you said, that's the pitch we're playing on now.
- 11:07Jonny Bentwood: Well, PR has traditionally been the people in
- 11:09the background, it's like this is incredible, the most
- 11:13impactful impact in modern times on Gen AI. The biggest influence
- 11:18is PR, because who understands PR more than who understands
- 11:24earned media more than PR? That's what we do day in, day
- 11:27out, and we know how to make a difference.
- 11:29Jack Murray: And isn't this a huge shot in the arm to the
- 11:30profession? And you know, there was there was a whole thing
- 11:33about us losing ground to search engine optimization, and that
- 11:37being the, that being the place where the marketeers were, and
- 11:40this huge blurred area, and it seems from the way this
- 11:43discussion is framed now that there's huge power in the core
- 11:47skills of public relations in the current context.
- 11:52Jonny Bentwood: I really feel sorry for the people who are SEO
- 11:55based, because their time is up. I used to last year when I
- 12:00talked about it, was 65% of searches with zero click. That
- 12:0465% of SEO goes nowhere. The CEO of Condi Nast said last week
- 12:10that they're expecting it to be 100% of searches go nowhere. SEO
- 12:15is dead. I'm really sorry, but there's a new game in town, and
- 12:20that game is GEO Generative Engine Optimization.
- 12:24Jack Murray: So, tell us about the four, the 4f in helping
- 12:27people to, I suppose, to frame their outreach and how they can
- 12:32get better.
- 12:33Jonny Bentwood: The first F is, can you be found? It's as simple
- 12:37as that. So, think about the things that may mean you can't
- 12:41be found, so if you've got a paywall on your website, you
- 12:44can't be found. Axios, I had a six grand subscription to Axios.
- 12:50They gave me a refund because they took away their paywall
- 12:53because they want to be found. If your site is built on
- 12:57JavaScript, like lots of websites are, because it's
- 13:00beautiful, it's great for humans, it's rubbish for
- 13:03machines. Gen AI cannot read JavaScript, so what about the
- 13:09URL? Can you, what can you do to optimize that URL to make it
- 13:14more visible for Gen AI? So all these things make a difference.
- 13:17So the first,
- 13:18Jack Murray: here's a
- 13:18good example earlier on where you even included the current
- 13:22year in a URL. If
- 13:23Jonny Bentwood: If you just put dash 2026 at the end of your
- 13:26URL, it increases your chance of being cited by Gen AI, along
- 13:30with a few other tips by 11.4% So, number one, can you be
- 13:34found? Get rid of paywalls, get rid of JavaScript on your main
- 13:39content pages, improve your meta description, optimize your URLs.
- 13:43Those things make a huge difference. The next step is the
- 13:47feel of what you're saying. You know, all my working life people
- 13:51have talked about message pull through as a key thing we want
- 13:53to do is the customer using the language of my brand, and that
- 13:57was great. Not anymore. What we've got to do now is adopt the
- 14:02language of our customer. It makes sense. I have no idea why
- 14:06we don't do more of it, but if someone asks a question, what is
- 14:09the best widget in Dublin? If my answer is the best widget in
- 14:13Dublin is this, it's almost a carbon copy of the question.
- 14:17That's why Gen AI, I would pick it. So, if we can copy that same
- 14:21language,
- 14:22Jack Murray: and it's interesting on feel like I know
- 14:23what our customer success people, with the consent of the
- 14:27of the users of Media HQ, we record a lot of calls, and the
- 14:32best marketing material is to use that is to describe your
- 14:35product the way the users are talking about it.
- 14:37Jonny Bentwood: Yeah,
- 14:37Jack Murray: talk about their problems in their terms. Who
- 14:39knew? Like
- 14:40Jonny Bentwood: Eureka,
- 14:41Jack Murray: yeah, and you gave a good example earlier of of of
- 14:45FAQs being framed in different ways.
- 14:48Jonny Bentwood: Yeah, so I mean, I'd like this comes down to the
- 14:50format, the third F. Now, in the format, what we need to do is
- 14:54remember how Gen AI works. It's got a quarter of a second as
- 14:59soon as it's. Add your question, your prompt to scour the world
- 15:03and come back with an answer. Now, if you write your content,
- 15:07if you want to get the first answer, you need to answer first
- 15:09content. So, if you write it in a way that is most likely to get
- 15:12picked up, so if people ask your question, is that question
- 15:16written as an FAQ? If people say, should I buy this or that,
- 15:19if you list it as I've got a listicle explaining why we're
- 15:22good and why we're bad compared to our different competitors.
- 15:25Gen AI would just love to copy and paste that, so that format
- 15:29is going to be fantastic. So, think how-to guides, FAQs,
- 15:32expert quotes, user-generated content, take all those things
- 15:36with listicles and blogs, things that it can copy, h, h
- 15:40formatting, TLDRs, Gen AI loves that the fourth F is freshness.
- 15:48Gen AI has a recency bias, that amazing piece of content, that
- 15:53white paper I wrote that I published in October last year.
- 15:57Great, but something that gets published last week is even
- 16:01better, Gen AI likes that freshness, that recency bias,
- 16:05and this is one of the hardest things for practitioners to
- 16:08think about, because we work in tentpole moments, we think about
- 16:11summer holidays, back to school, Valentine's Day, Christmas, and
- 16:16we think about those tent pole occasions, and we'll do
- 16:19something for that moment in time, that tent pole, but what
- 16:22do you do in between those moments? That's why we need to
- 16:25have a rolling thunder, that always on approach that is
- 16:28churning content out for the machine,
- 16:31Jack Murray: and it's that it's that PR scale of a hook and
- 16:33something that's interesting, and something that you know,
- 16:36like I have an equation that says a raw idea plus an angle
- 16:41equals a story, so once you hook it in with an angle or a hook,
- 16:45it becomes interesting.
- 16:46Jonny Bentwood: Well, the thing is, I'm going to disagree with
- 16:48you here. Yeah, actually, I don't care what you just said.
- 16:51Yeah, because I'm not this rolling thunder is not for you.
- 16:54Jack Murray: Yeah,
- 16:54Jonny Bentwood: I'm chucking out content only for the machine to
- 16:57read,
- 16:57Jack Murray: okay?
- 16:58Jonny Bentwood: Just as much as I'm putting a press release on
- 16:59the wire, not for journalists. No, I'll call the journalists
- 17:03up. I know them. I'm putting it on the wire. Going to 5000
- 17:06websites, it's for the machine. We need
- 17:09Jack Murray: to, so think machine can read it. It's a
- 17:11gateway to everyone else seeing it.
- 17:12Jonny Bentwood: Yeah, totally.
- 17:13Jack Murray: Go through that gate first.
- 17:15Jonny Bentwood: We need to not only market to humans, we've got
- 17:17to market to machines, and all these different activities we
- 17:21can do to make a difference is fantastic. So, yeah, do your
- 17:25tempo moments for humans, churn stuff out for machines. Now,
- 17:30those are my four Fs.
- 17:31Jack Murray: You have a fifth F.
- 17:33Jonny Bentwood: I do have a fifth,
- 17:34Jack Murray: and it's the one with the F star, star, star.
- 17:38Jonny Bentwood: Can I say the F star star,
- 17:41Jack Murray: off you go.
- 17:42Jonny Bentwood: Okay, the most important F of the law is
- 17:45because people feel overwhelmed by all this, what they've got to
- 17:48do. It's just fucking get on with it, because people just
- 17:51aren't doing anything.
- 17:53Jack Murray: Yes,
- 17:53Jonny Bentwood: people
- 17:54Jack Murray: inertia
- 17:55is still, it's still a big thing.
- 17:56Jonny Bentwood: It is a big thing, and people say, "Oh, that
- 17:58so far had no one is doing anything. I have been analyzing
- 18:01brands across the world from Fortune 50 companies. No one is
- 18:04doing a good job, and I think people are waiting for the
- 18:07perfect plan. Forget it, just do one little thing. Maybe tomorrow
- 18:12that YouTube video you've got, you're going to put the
- 18:14transcript in. That's amazing. Well, I couldn't make a huge
- 18:17difference when
- 18:18Jack Murray: you, when we talked about this earlier, and you said
- 18:20that I was on the chat to the office, and I said, every
- 18:23episode of this podcast, can you please upload all of the
- 18:26transcripts, so that they're going to be much more easily
- 18:29found. Exactly. Yes.
- 18:31Jonny Bentwood: Also, stick it on your website as well. I mean,
- 18:33do everything you can to be found by Gen AI, but just start.
- 18:39Just do a few little things, marginal gains make a big
- 18:42difference,
- 18:42Jack Murray: and do you find, like, one of the things I find,
- 18:44and, like, look like you, I've been evangelizing using
- 18:48technology for 20 years now, but, like, it can take some
- 18:53people get it really quickly. One of the good things about the
- 18:56dawn of AI is that if you've been hiding under a rock, very
- 19:00few places to hide now that it's, it's, you know, it's not
- 19:03coming, it's here, and it's been here for a while. So, like
- 19:07giving people a framework, or you know, a way in which they
- 19:11can, and people have to change their work processes, I suppose,
- 19:13to, and that can be hard.
- 19:16Jonny Bentwood: It is going to be hard, because we need to,
- 19:18we've got to, we've got a different way of working now,
- 19:20and those old school PR practitioners who say this is
- 19:22how we do it. You go wake up because there's a whole new way
- 19:27of working. I don't care how wonderful creative your idea is
- 19:31if you're getting killed by someone else because you're not
- 19:33turning up in the first dancer. To be clear, though, I'm not
- 19:36saying stop doing those wonderful PR activations. I'm
- 19:40saying you need to do something as well.
- 19:43Jack Murray: Yeah, you have times that you have to have a
- 19:45game plan for this other thing.
- 19:46Jonny Bentwood: Yeah,
- 19:46Jack Murray: yeah, this
- 19:46Jonny Bentwood: is an additive, not of a placement approach.
- 19:51Jack Murray: You also have a theory on if we're 12 months
- 19:53from a commercial point of view of the impact of where AI is
- 19:57going to be and how it's going to be driving commerce to. A
- 20:00little bit about that, about where the hockey puck is going
- 20:03on that,
- 20:04Jonny Bentwood: so this is my vision bit here. Um, you can
- 20:07come in here and tell me I got it completely wrong, but I'm
- 20:11thinking about where we're going, and it's sort of..
- 20:13remember a few things that I've said. I've talked a little bit
- 20:16about the rolling thunder, I've talked a little bit about the
- 20:19importance of being that first answer, so I'm going to extend
- 20:22that thinking. The first that I've got for you is that we need
- 20:28to recognize that, and especially in the consumer space
- 20:33in the UK, Ireland, US, a third of all prompts that people ask
- 20:39in the consumer space are generating a shopping
- 20:43experience. What that means is that when you go there, it
- 20:47actually says at the bottom, hey, here are some products that
- 20:50actually do what you're looking for. That's new. Now, out of
- 20:55those, a third of the people who are looking at that from that
- 20:58category in the Gen Z space actually go and buy that's still
- 21:03a small percentage, a third of a third, it's a tiny amount of a
- 21:06specific demographic, but that's going to grow. This is a genetic
- 21:11commerce. This is why I think it's important, and I think it's
- 21:15going to be groundbreaking in the PR industry. PR has
- 21:18historically had a tough time because we are too far away from
- 21:24the euro from the money spent and that's why a lot of the paid
- 21:28advertisers go we did this it click there they bought that and
- 21:32they got that clear link between action and outcome and we try in
- 21:37the PR space to sort of talk about different outcome metrics
- 21:40but nothing as good as dollars spent. So, now let's go back to
- 21:45the agentic commerce. A third of all prompts are generating a
- 21:49shopping experience. A third of those people are buying in
- 21:52agentic commerce. Well, what influences that scenario? Said
- 21:58earlier, 70 to 95% is earned media. Well, who influences
- 22:03that? That's us. Yes. So, where's the future? We are lower
- 22:07funnel visibility, lower funnel agentic commerce. We are going
- 22:12to be focusing there because PR suddenly has the greatest
- 22:17influence on dollars spent, and that can be directly attributed
- 22:21to the work that we are doing, and we're not saying stop the
- 22:25other stuff. Advertising marketing to humans still has
- 22:27its play, but for marketing to machines, this is PR's moment.
- 22:34Jack Murray: So I said to someone earlier today that I
- 22:38love hanging out with you, and I love listening to you, because,
- 22:41like, it's almost like a full semester module, when I look,
- 22:44when I listen to one of your keynotes, that that transaction
- 22:47of of knowing how to how to give value, and we started with the
- 22:52manifesto, we spoke about the four Fs. I want to bring you to
- 22:57another piece of work, and we're not overloading the viewer and
- 23:00the listener here, because I love practical action plans.
- 23:04Your takeaway on 10 ways that PR people can now influence. Let's
- 23:09go. Let's do a quick run through on, you know, you were saying
- 23:13people need to change their workflows, they need to get on
- 23:15it, they need to start now. Let's, let's run through that
- 23:19list of 10 ways to influence now. Do you want to kick it off?
- 23:22Jonny Bentwood: Yeah. Number one, engage with your new tier
- 23:26one AI media list. Like it's obvious we already understand
- 23:30the concept of a tier one media list. Now you need to have your
- 23:33tier one gen AI media list, different group of media, but
- 23:38you engage with them in different way. But there's so
- 23:41many tools out there that will help you define which media
- 23:44should be speaking to that gets highly cited in Gen AI, so you
- 23:47engage with them, it's a no-brainer.
- 23:49Jack Murray: You curate your list and you create your content
- 23:52in the formats that you said you may not be speaking to
- 23:54journalists, you may just be sending stuff over, and that's
- 23:57fine, but it's a whole different media list. Number two, optimize
- 24:01data-rich press releases and blog posts with structured
- 24:03markup distributed on wire.
- 24:06Jonny Bentwood: I'm going to send out press releases on the
- 24:08wire all the time. We did this for Mountain Dew in 20 minutes.
- 24:14Chat GPT was recommending us for that query. I am not talking
- 24:19about press releases for journalists. I don't put them on
- 24:21the wire for journalists, because journalists don't read
- 24:24those necessarily. I'm doing it for the machine. It goes to 5000
- 24:28websites. It's genius.
- 24:30Jack Murray: And when you optimize it, is the structure
- 24:33and the form of it really different or just slightly
- 24:35different?
- 24:36Jonny Bentwood: It's really different. The contents all
- 24:38there, but I put things in a slightly different order, think
- 24:41of it like TLDRs, bullet points, things that Gen AI can copy and
- 24:45paste without having to rethink what you're doing.
- 24:48Jack Murray: Number three, answer first content, build FAQ
- 24:52pages, how to guides, answer common AI queries.
- 24:56Jonny Bentwood: If you want to get the first answer right,
- 24:58answer first. First content, and your FAQs shouldn't be about
- 25:03you. It should be the questions that your customers are asking,
- 25:06even if it's not just about your brand. How-tos, if you're in the
- 25:10food place, recipes, anything listicles, just do the answer
- 25:15first content
- 25:16Jack Murray: number four: position executives as quotable
- 25:19experts and create versus competitor content. This is
- 25:22interesting.
- 25:23Jonny Bentwood: Two parts, there. So, the first bit around
- 25:26quotable experts, Gen AI loves stating facts. It loves even
- 25:31more saying an expert stated something as facts. So, you've
- 25:36got experts in your company, use them. You've got advocates, use
- 25:40them. But if you think the second part of this was versus
- 25:44content, so let's say I am in the I'm looking for some
- 25:49technology. If I go to SAP website, it's like buy me, buy
- 25:52me, buy me, have a demo of me. If I go to g2 which is a
- 25:58reference point, it's highly sites talks about different
- 26:00technology, it says, well, you could pick SAP, and this is why
- 26:03it's good and bad, or you could pick this company, which is why
- 26:05it's good and bad, or this company, why it's good and bad.
- 26:08Gen AI is going to go to that firm g2 to say, here's a bunch
- 26:12of content compelling good and bad for different companies. It
- 26:14makes it easier for Gen AI to give the answer.
- 26:18Jack Murray: Number five, produce or sponsor YouTube short
- 26:21form videos with transcripts,
- 26:23Jonny Bentwood: so simple thing everyone can do tomorrow. Every
- 26:26YouTube video you've got, stick the transcript in there. If you
- 26:29say, 'Oh, I've got, I've got subtitles, forget that, that's
- 26:33JavaScript, Gen AI, I can't read it. Now, a load of people in PR
- 26:36form do influence work with influencers that are going to
- 26:40put stuff on Instagram or TikTok. It's like, great,
- 26:44continue to do that. Add a clause, put it in YouTube as
- 26:48well. Make sure you've got the transcript, even happy from,
- 26:52say, sponsored by my brand. It's great, you're included with a
- 26:55transcript,
- 26:56Jack Murray: and the technology is powerful enough to consume
- 26:59it, and to and to find what's useful.
- 27:00Jonny Bentwood: Even though Gen AI, I can't read a video, it can
- 27:02read the transcript, and for Google approach, when people go
- 27:06there, it loves going to YouTube as the highest sites and
- 27:09individual bit within the Google Gen AI platforms.
- 27:11Jack Murray: This was a real, this was like a real moment for
- 27:14me when I heard this about Reddit number six, engage Reddit
- 27:18and Quora communities with listicle style answers, the
- 27:20power of that,
- 27:22Jonny Bentwood: so we've got to be careful with Reddit here.
- 27:24Let's make no mistake, Reddit is ridiculously important. It's
- 27:28ridiculously important, even if you weren't doing Gen AI, but
- 27:31there's an approach to do it. Let's talk about how we do it.
- 27:34Well, first of all, get your brand as a verified brand on
- 27:38your own page. You can say whatever the hell you like, you
- 27:40can't get banned for it, so verify your own brand and
- 27:43publish stuff on your own page. If there's a sub domain about
- 27:47your brand, if it isn't one, sorry, create one, you can own
- 27:51that and moderate it. But if there's a community already
- 27:53being there, fish where the fish are, go to that community, but
- 27:57critically contribute, don't talk about yourself, contribute
- 28:02and add value. Do it regularly, and it's going to make a huge
- 28:06difference.
- 28:07Jack Murray: And you have to be careful once you promote, you're
- 28:08out.
- 28:09Jonny Bentwood: If you promote, you're out. If you jump in, then
- 28:11don't come back for six months, you're out. The community on
- 28:14Reddit are harsh, but they like having value, so contribute and
- 28:19add value.
- 28:20Jack Murray: Number seven, and this is when we spoke to when we
- 28:24spoke earlier. I said to you, God, it's amazing how we go back
- 28:27to the fundamentals. Number seven: use your own website,
- 28:30meta description, URL, reduce JavaScript, agent analytics.
- 28:35Jonny Bentwood: So look at the beginning, I said just a few
- 28:37percentage points are influence AI citations and owned media. I
- 28:43predict over the next few years that's going to become from a
- 28:46few percentage points to double digits, maybe even to 20th
- 28:49percentile. But there's things we can do: make your meta
- 28:53description rich, look at your URL slugs, keep them tight,
- 28:56lowercase no more than six words, add 2026 at the end of
- 29:00it. If you've got key content and it's full of JavaScript, get
- 29:04rid of that JavaScript, and just as much as you've got Google
- 29:07Analytics to understand human traffic, make sure you've got
- 29:10the equivalent. Understand when Gen AI is indexing your page,
- 29:14whether your page is training the Gen AI or whether you're
- 29:17being cited. Key metrics that make a huge difference.
- 29:21Jack Murray: Number eight: Amplify your presence on review
- 29:23sites and Wikipedia.
- 29:24Jonny Bentwood: God, I hate Wikipedia. I totally hate that.
- 29:28It's just impossible to make a change. I have to accept the
- 29:31fact
- 29:32Jack Murray: you talked earlier about trying to change an
- 29:33address for a client, and it was impossible.
- 29:35Jonny Bentwood: It took a year, because Wikipedia won't just
- 29:37take my word for it. They have to find an earned citation to
- 29:41validate it, so if I do it in the right way, you can change
- 29:44it, but accept the fact that Wikipedia is a massive
- 29:47influence, and you need to play the long game in getting it
- 29:51done. The same thing I added review sites on there, because
- 29:55that's user behavior. We talked before about expert quotes, so
- 29:58stuff like TripAdvisor G2 To booking.com all these things
- 30:02make a big difference.
- 30:03Jack Murray: One question on Wikipedia. So, if you're getting
- 30:05high-quality earned media, the way to activate the earned
- 30:09media, so that the Wikipedia editors use it, I'm assuming
- 30:13there's a, there's a strategy around that, as opposed to it
- 30:16being there and it being activated.
- 30:18Jonny Bentwood: Yeah, for Wikipedia, it's a point, you say
- 30:20you've got this structural comment here, I want you to
- 30:22replace it with this factual comment to validate this point
- 30:25is accurate. Please refer to this Guardian article that
- 30:28validates it. That's the approach to do it. It's for long
- 30:31game, it's important, but don't expect to manipulate Wikipedia.
- 30:36Don't expect to do it fast.
- 30:37Jack Murray: We're on the, we're on the home straight now. Number
- 30:40nine, monitor citations and fix negative responses, and publish
- 30:44frequently for recency.
- 30:46Jonny Bentwood: Yeah, GenAI, I can get it wrong. You ask a
- 30:50question, the result comes up, and it's actually taking
- 30:52someone's erroneous content from a website that from four years
- 30:56ago. Well, you got to know about that. If it's important to you,
- 30:59identify the content that's incorrect, so we can fix it, and
- 31:04the recency bias. I'm going to say again and again and again.
- 31:08Jack Murray: Last but not least, then where we started off,
- 31:11start, but don't wait for perfect,
- 31:13Jonny Bentwood: the most important thing of the lot. Do
- 31:15not wait for that perfect plan. Don't be so intimidated by all
- 31:19the things you can do, you don't start, just get on with it, just
- 31:23do one little thing tomorrow, because your competitors aren't
- 31:27doing it. I was doing some stuff in the esthetic space for one of
- 31:31my clients. The number one cited source was not any of the top 10
- 31:37multi million dollar companies that influences what esthetics
- 31:40you should get. You know what it was. It was a mum and dad blog
- 31:45that is written from a New Jersey esthetic walking clinic,
- 31:49and they were so sick of people saying, 'Do I buy this treatment
- 31:52or that treatment? So they wrote blogs like, 'These are the top
- 31:54five treatments. This is what's good or bad about each of them.
- 31:57That was a one-sided source. So in this multi million dollar
- 32:00industry. If a mum and dad blog post is the most important
- 32:04source, it shows how no one's even started yet. Don't be
- 32:07intimidated, thinking everyone's quite far ahead. No one's doing
- 32:10jack.
- 32:11Jack Murray: Yeah, now if you ever get tired of the data
- 32:14analytics and the geo, you should definitely get a job in
- 32:17motivation, PR motivation speaking. Like, there's there's
- 32:21such value in what you're sharing here from an educational
- 32:25point of view, like the structured education within
- 32:28public relations communications tends to lag way far behind
- 32:33what's what's happening for practitioners, like when I hear
- 32:36all this stuff, I get so excited, so motivated, so
- 32:40delighted that I'm doing what I'm doing. Do you think it'll
- 32:44take long for people to catch up with what's happening?
- 32:48Jonny Bentwood: You know, what scares me. It scares me that PR
- 32:52have been so subservient historically to other marketing
- 32:55disciplines in this, in a similar way to SEO. Other
- 32:59marketing disciplines are going to say, yeah, we're going to own
- 33:02this,
- 33:03Jack Murray: yeah, and there's a land grab for all,
- 33:05there's a
- 33:05Jonny Bentwood: land grab going on at the moment, and I want PR
- 33:08to take it seriously,
- 33:09Jack Murray: and when you like, you work with multidisciplinary
- 33:11teams, and you have marketing, you've SEO, and you've social,
- 33:15you've brand managers, like, how, like, how does that all
- 33:19hang together, like, I, the tension is different with
- 33:21different teams,
- 33:23Jonny Bentwood: and I've seen the land grab, and I've also
- 33:25noticed something else. The light, anyone can read the same
- 33:29PowerPoint slide until one question is asked, and so tell
- 33:32me more about that, and that's when the earned media, the PR
- 33:36teams take over and shine, because they know this stuff.
- 33:39Jack Murray: Yeah,
- 33:40Jonny Bentwood: and that, because
- 33:41Jack Murray: you live
- 33:41and die,
- 33:42Jonny Bentwood: we live and die every day. I
- 33:43Jack Murray: like sometimes when I'm evaluating staff from
- 33:46different teams, I always say, like, I always go back to this,
- 33:49this age-old thing. I said, give me journalism, give me public
- 33:52relations, you're only as good as the last good story you
- 33:54wrote, you're only as good as the last good bit of coverage
- 33:56you got. It's very simple, if you're not getting, like, if,
- 34:00when I was working as a PR practitioner, if I wasn't
- 34:03getting good-earned media, what was I doing?
- 34:05Jonny Bentwood: Well, the fact is, companies around the world,
- 34:08every one of them is talking about AI transformation at the
- 34:12moment, they're thinking, how can we bring AI into our company
- 34:15to be smart, to be more efficient? I don't care about
- 34:20that, I'm talking to those same companies that good that you're
- 34:23doing that AI transformation. I want to talk about sales. We can
- 34:27help make a difference to your bottom line, because this is how
- 34:31people, your customers, are that sync, your stakeholders, your
- 34:35B2B colleagues. This is making a difference,
- 34:38Jack Murray: and you're going to design data frameworks to
- 34:40capture all that information, I'm sure
- 34:42Jonny Bentwood: the data framework is as simple as
- 34:44anything, but there's key metrics that count. What is your
- 34:46share of visibility across the most important topics that we're
- 34:50talking about? What position are we in ranking within that? How
- 34:54are we perceived versus our competitors in terms of
- 34:57sentiment in the lower funnel aspect of. What percentage of
- 35:00prompts are generating shopping experiences, and this is our
- 35:04visibility position change? What merchants are recommending our
- 35:08products, and out of all the merchants, how much are they the
- 35:12most important merchant in all recommendations? There are new
- 35:15metrics we can be thinking about that no one's even considered
- 35:18before, but I also want us to get away from some of the vanity
- 35:23stuff that's going around, so stuff like the number of
- 35:26citations is a vanity metric, it means nothing. We've got to make
- 35:30sure that at the outset we are using the correct data points.
- 35:35Amec, the PRSA have all gone up together and say this is where
- 35:39how you measure Gen AI because we've got to do it right from
- 35:43the beginning,
- 35:44Jack Murray: and when you're, I suppose it's when the prompt
- 35:47goes in that you know you're in the rankings, that like that's
- 35:50that's the most important thing.
- 35:53Jonny Bentwood: The most important thing is you in the
- 35:54first answer,
- 35:55Jack Murray: you're in the first.
- 35:55Jonny Bentwood: I'm trying to get brands to pay attention, and
- 35:58a lot of them are trying to do the same job, the way they've
- 36:01done it for years, and it's just trying to get them to think
- 36:04differently. We're not saying what you're doing is wrong, but
- 36:07we got to do something extra.
- 36:08Jack Murray: How are you measuring that now, like with
- 36:10the platforms, like about where people appear in rankings, and
- 36:13that?
- 36:14Jonny Bentwood: So, I use there's plenty of tools out
- 36:16there that my personal preference is a tool called
- 36:18Profound. It's a great way to understand the questions that
- 36:22people are asking, as well as the visibility of core topics,
- 36:26but I want to just talk a little bit about memory, because this
- 36:29is where a lot of people are getting wrong, they're treating
- 36:31everything equally. So, let's say I wanted to buy something
- 36:36earlier today, I had a great slice of pizza, where was it
- 36:38from?
- 36:39Jack Murray: Bambino,
- 36:40Jonny Bentwood: Bambino, it's like an American pizza in
- 36:42Dublin. It was great, and if I asked Chat GPT about where I can
- 36:47get a bambino, it sort of learned that, okay, maybe I'm
- 36:50after a discount thing, I'm after fast food, so maybe in a
- 36:53couple of weeks' time I want to go out for dinner and ask a
- 36:56recommendation. It may be suggest other kind of more
- 37:00economical fast food Instagram exciting kind of restaurants,
- 37:05because it remembered what I asked for last time. We need to
- 37:09take memory into account. We've got to be careful, so think
- 37:12about where the audience is, and let's think about what kind of
- 37:15phones do they have.
- 37:16Jack Murray: Yeah,
- 37:17Jonny Bentwood: so if you're in the States, you've typically got
- 37:19an iPhone, they're going to iPhones use Chat GPT because
- 37:24it's been built into it. Therefore, I would think about
- 37:27that as the main platform in the Nordics. It's more Google,
- 37:30Jack Murray: okay? Because
- 37:31Jonny Bentwood: they've got Android phones, so think about
- 37:32the phone they've got. If in business it tends to be more
- 37:35Copilot, so think about the audience and build that into how
- 37:39you're doing your measurements.
- 37:41Jack Murray: We finish every episode with the rapid fire
- 37:43round, so let's get into it. We have five quick fire questions
- 37:47to really get a sense of you as a communicator. Question number
- 37:51one, What is one media moment that has changed how you work?
- 37:55Jonny Bentwood: This would have been around 20 years ago when I
- 37:57was working at Edelman, and people were saying, yeah, we've
- 38:00got to measure these influencers, and everyone only
- 38:03did it by how many followers they had. I thought, but why are
- 38:05we doing it that way? Surely we'll be talking about relevance
- 38:09and engagement, and I thought, let's not do it the way it's
- 38:12always been done, let's do it differently, and that pivoted my
- 38:16career immediately.
- 38:18Jack Murray: Okay, and so that was around, like, a social media
- 38:21index,
- 38:21Jonny Bentwood: it was. It's called a social media index, and
- 38:23it became a little meme in its own right.
- 38:25Jack Murray: Brilliant. Question number two: Give me one example
- 38:28of something that failed that you learned from,
- 38:32Jonny Bentwood: that having the best data isn't - doesn't mean
- 38:34anyone listens
- 38:35Jack Murray: to it. Okay,
- 38:36Jonny Bentwood: it makes no difference how smart you are,
- 38:38makes no difference how insightful you are, if you don't
- 38:41write for the reader, it's just as important to be a good
- 38:44storyteller as it is about having a great insight. The real
- 38:47art is taking stuff away, so all you've got left is a clear
- 38:51defined story,
- 38:52Jack Murray: so you're using the data to tell the story.
- 38:54Jonny Bentwood: Use the data, but you don't need to kill
- 38:56people with hundreds of graphs and charts. I'd be really happy
- 39:00with one picture and six words.
- 39:02Jack Murray: Number three, what one universal belief about
- 39:05public relations do you think is wrong or overstated?
- 39:08Jonny Bentwood: You know, people think PR is about spin. The best
- 39:11PR actually does the opposite, it removes the spin, it's about
- 39:14making the truth interesting, clear, and impossible to ignore,
- 39:18Jack Murray: and it's a lot more like it's easy to categorize it
- 39:21as spin into a box, all the detail we've discussed since the
- 39:24top of the program. Number four, what is one piece of advice that
- 39:27you wish you'd had earlier in your career?
- 39:30Jonny Bentwood: I would say be interested, not interesting. If
- 39:33you're interested in things you seek learning continuously,
- 39:36learn continuously, think why, how, what could be different, is
- 39:40this the best way? If you're interesting, it's just telling
- 39:42more stuff. Be instant in things.
- 39:44Jack Murray: Curiosity is a superpower. I said to my head of
- 39:47HR, like, if you know, we could all retire with a huge bank
- 39:51account. If we could actually invent a universal curiosity
- 39:55test that got good employees in the door, and we've experimented
- 39:58with it in many different ways. Is most recent one was we got
- 40:02people in for a design job and we gave them two hours of
- 40:05discovery, but didn't tell them what they were trying to
- 40:07discover, so they literally had to ask a whole load of
- 40:09questions.
- 40:11Jonny Bentwood: That's great.
- 40:11Jack Murray: And at the end of the discovery period, if they
- 40:13hadn't done the discovery, they would fail whatever test was
- 40:16coming, and that was the most effective one we did. Actually,
- 40:18Jonny Bentwood: I love that.
- 40:19Jack Murray: Yeah. Last question, then what book do you
- 40:24think everyone in your job should read?
- 40:26Jonny Bentwood: It's not a book about data or PR, it's The One
- 40:29Minute Manager, it's a short book by Ken Blanchard and
- 40:31Spencer Johnson, and it basically summed up as you can
- 40:34get a lot done in one minute, and that conciseness, that smart
- 40:38brevity is really important, one minute praise, one minute
- 40:41thinking, one minute goals. Just think about what you can do. It
- 40:44doesn't need to take a huge ream of information. Be focused.
- 40:49Jack Murray: You've, uh, you have a very complex job, and you
- 40:51have a lot of reports, and a lot of people that you work with.
- 40:54I'm assuming taking that sort of focus helps you manage, manage
- 40:57in those sort of situations.
- 40:59Jonny Bentwood: It really does. Like, I mean, the thing that I
- 41:01really focus on with the people around me is the values of them.
- 41:04It's not the skill, and that sort of is a bit of a weird
- 41:07concept. I mean, I've hired people who are infinitely
- 41:10smarter than me and have failed in the company because they
- 41:13don't have the same values, you know. The culture at Golin, we
- 41:16like to say we're the, we're the kind people who kick ass, nice
- 41:23people who kick ass, and it took me a while to get that.
- 41:26Jack Murray: Yeah,
- 41:26Jonny Bentwood: yes, we should kick ass. We should be the best
- 41:28at what we do, and our bar is high
- 41:32Jack Murray: and like, if you're hungry and you're curious, I
- 41:34often said, like, to people, sometimes I said, stepped up,
- 41:36don't get confused here, like, we're all here to do good work.
- 41:39Sometimes things will get in the way, but that's okay.
- 41:41Jonny Bentwood: But if you're not kind, oh man, what a toxic
- 41:44environment.
- 41:45Jack Murray: No, exactly.
- 41:45Jonny Bentwood: We want people to be there for each other.
- 41:47Yeah, so that value system is important to me as well.
- 41:50Jack Murray: And actually, just back to the curiosity thing, I
- 41:52always find it really easy to manage curious people, because
- 41:55they'll come and they'll say, "Hey, Johnny, you asked me to do
- 41:57such and such yesterday, I've this, this, and this done. Now,
- 42:00the four questions about the other thing, and by the time the
- 42:02conversation is over, you fully know where that person is. You
- 42:05know exactly their position on the map, and you know where
- 42:08they're going.
- 42:08Jonny Bentwood: Want people to think, I really do. I want
- 42:10people to question, to challenge. What I don't want is
- 42:13someone I call it like that seagull, they just swoop in shit
- 42:17on it and fly off. I mean, I want people to be considered. I
- 42:20want people to think about it, and say, what about this? I love
- 42:24that, that interest, that curiosity.
- 42:28Jack Murray: Johnny, that is a great sentiment on which to end
- 42:30this chat. Heartfelt thanks, very interesting, engaging,
- 42:34loads of detail, and really rich content that people will be able
- 42:37to plug in. Thanks for joining me today.
- 42:39Jonny Bentwood: Thank you for having me. It's been great.
- 42:40Jack Murray: Thanks for listening to Inside Media
- 42:42Relations. If you liked the show, please like and subscribe,
- 42:45and tune in next time.