Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mediation 360: Preparation from the Defense, Plaintiff, and Mediator Perspectives
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to mediation 360 mediation preparation
- 0:07from the defense plaintiff and mediator perspective.
- 0:11My name is Mike Douglas and I'm a partner at
- 0:14Parker Shaffey in Los Angeles. My practice is
- 0:17focused on representing plaintiffs in legal and
- 0:20accounting malpractice cases. I'm chair of the
- 0:24Beverly Hills Bar Association's ethics and legal
- 0:27malpractice law section and I'll be moderating
- 0:29today's program. Joining us today and leading
- 0:33the program are Peter Thompson, Joshua Furman,
- 0:38and David Simani. Peter Thompson is a mediator
- 0:41with Judicate West. He brings over 30 years of
- 0:45experience litigating and resolving attorney
- 0:47liability cases for both plaintiffs and defense
- 0:50with extensive trial experience in legal malpractice
- 0:54matters across federal and state courts nationwide.
- 0:58He has advised law firms on ethics and has testified
- 1:01as a legal expert in over 100 cases, addressing
- 1:05standards of practice, conflicts of interest,
- 1:08and attorney ethics. Peter is currently dedicated
- 1:11to resolving attorney -related claims, including
- 1:14negligence and breach of fiduciary duty through
- 1:16mediation. And he's also experienced in law partnership
- 1:21dissolutions and attorney -client fee disputes.
- 1:26He has taught extensively in the area of attorney
- 1:29responsibility and has served on the San Diego
- 1:33County Bar Association fee arbitration committee.
- 1:37David Simani is a partner in the Los Angeles
- 1:41office of Louis Brisboye where he chairs the
- 1:44legal malpractice defense practice. He focuses
- 1:47on defending attorneys against claims of legal
- 1:50malpractice, malicious prosecution, and breach
- 1:53of fiduciary duty. across a broad range of practice
- 1:56areas including transactional litigation and
- 2:00regulatory matters. David is a co -author of
- 2:04the California Legal Malpractice and Malicious
- 2:07Prosecution Liability Handbook, a publication
- 2:10I might add I have on my bookcase and it's an
- 2:13excellent product. Last and not least, Joshua
- 2:17Foreman is a sole practitioner in Encino focusing
- 2:21on client -side representation in attorney -client
- 2:24disputes. Joshua is a certified specialist in
- 2:27legal malpractice law, certified by the California
- 2:31Board of Legal Specialization, and he currently
- 2:34serves as the vice chair of the LA County Bar
- 2:37Association Professional Responsibility and Ethics
- 2:40Committee. When he's not practicing law, Josh
- 2:44enjoys officiating flat -track roller derby,
- 2:47particularly when his kid is playing. And he's
- 2:49also a contest winning fine scale model maker.
- 2:54So with that said, we're going to start our presentation.
- 2:58We will hold all questions until the end. I like
- 3:01to think of this presentation as giving plaintiffs
- 3:05an opportunity to see things from the defense
- 3:08side in the course of mediation and the reverse
- 3:13for defense interests and then Peter's going
- 3:17to give us some insights into something that
- 3:19we all are probably very curious about, and that's
- 3:21what's going on behind the scenes with the mediator
- 3:24as we're trying to get cases resolved. So I'm
- 3:27looking forward to a really informative panel.
- 3:29With that being said, I think we're going to
- 3:31start off with Josh. You want to start, Josh?
- 3:35Thanks a lot, Michael. I'm Joshua Furman, a sole
- 3:38practitioner. in Encino and I do a lot of plaintiff
- 3:42side legal malpractice. I'm going to talk about
- 3:45some of the things that I think about when approaching
- 3:48mediation and settlement and some of the best
- 3:50practices that we've learned along the way. Not
- 3:55in any small fashion. Mediating with Peter is
- 4:00an excellent mediator and of course having David
- 4:04on the other side of some of those cases as well.
- 4:08Hopefully If you've done any level of mediation,
- 4:11most likely this is not gonna be entirely new
- 4:13knowledge, but hopefully this will be a little
- 4:15organized, a way of thinking about steps that
- 4:17we can take to get a successful mediation, even
- 4:22if it doesn't settle, and maybe pick up something
- 4:27new along the way. So of course, if we go to
- 4:30the next slide, the guiding star, of all plaintiff
- 4:36work really is client communication. And this
- 4:38starts at the very beginning of the case. But
- 4:41during the mediation process, when you're getting
- 4:43ready to mediate and when you're deciding that
- 4:46it's time to mediate, it's very important. Even
- 4:49when you're selecting the mediator, you have
- 4:52to talk to your client, understand their level
- 4:54of sophistication, and understand the extent
- 4:57to which they need to be involved in that process.
- 5:00Some clients have never been involved in litigation
- 5:03before and some clients know half the mediators
- 5:06on a particular panel. You just have to make
- 5:09sure that you understand what your client's experience
- 5:12has been and what kind of inputs they may expect
- 5:16to bring to that situation. The best way to do
- 5:18that is simply talking with them and explaining
- 5:20where you are in the process and what steps you're
- 5:23taking along the way. Throughout this entire
- 5:26process, the duty of the attorney, of course,
- 5:29advise the client. We're not necessarily making
- 5:32decisions for them. Sometimes we're the only
- 5:35ones that have that expertise. We need to be
- 5:37making those decisions. But the idea is that
- 5:39we're telling the client about those decisions,
- 5:42why we're making those decisions. And if they
- 5:44want to make a different decision, trying to
- 5:46understand why and advising them about that decision.
- 5:51So through that initial process of getting ready
- 5:55to mediate, I'm going to talk to the client about
- 5:57the process for selecting a mediator. That's
- 5:59someone that we pick usually. The cost of mediation,
- 6:04this can be very important on the client side.
- 6:08All the costs, of course, are very important,
- 6:11but mediation costs can be one of the bigger
- 6:13costs you have before you start getting into
- 6:15experts and a lot of depositions and that sort
- 6:18of thing, depending on where you are in the process.
- 6:21So it's important that the client understands
- 6:22that you do have to pay for this, that it could
- 6:24be a significant investment. And you may want
- 6:27to consider whether or not, given a particular
- 6:29client or case, Simply advancing those costs
- 6:33is the best course of action, or depending on
- 6:35what kind of arrangement you have with your client,
- 6:37you may just have them pay for it. But a lot
- 6:42of you that might be on straight contingency
- 6:43are just going to have to be paying for that.
- 6:45Of course, it comes out of the client's end ultimately
- 6:47when you get a recovery. So client consent on
- 6:50cost is still important. You talk about dates.
- 6:55Client has to understand that they need to be
- 6:57there. understand your client's availability,
- 6:59make sure that the client knows that this could
- 7:03be an all day affair. They may not think that
- 7:05off the top of the process, you need to let them
- 7:08know. And all these conversations should be tailored
- 7:13around the idea of preparing the client for the
- 7:16process. Mediation mindset is a bit different
- 7:22than litigation. when you're going to court and
- 7:24you're fighting all the time, now we're going
- 7:26to change our gear a little bit and start thinking
- 7:28about the idea of compromise, the idea of potentially
- 7:33having to walk away from a situation with a less
- 7:35than satisfactory feeling. So we need to talk
- 7:39to the client, meet them where they are in terms
- 7:43of that mindset, and try and get them in a position
- 7:46where they're willing to be open to the process.
- 7:50and not going to be put off by that initial low
- 7:53ball that the defense lawyer is probably going
- 7:55to give you and the dance that you go through
- 7:59throughout the course of the mediation. And last,
- 8:03in 2019, of course, we have the new statute that
- 8:06came into effect at evidence code 1129. And that's
- 8:12a form that you're supposed to have your client
- 8:14sign as soon as it becomes apparent that you're
- 8:17going to go to mediation. It's got a disclosure
- 8:20and it explains things to the client about the
- 8:22mediation process and the confidentiality and
- 8:25the privilege that attaches to that process.
- 8:29You may not remember that you have to get that
- 8:31signed. And I haven't seen anything as far as
- 8:35cases having to do with what happens if you don't
- 8:38get it signed and issues that come up there.
- 8:40But that is a requirement as of 2019 to have
- 8:46that form. provided in the evidence code 1129
- 8:51signed. Next slide. So as you are getting ready
- 9:01for the mediation, and even before you get ready
- 9:03for the mediation, there's a way of looking at
- 9:06the entire litigation process that at least has
- 9:08one track towards potential settlement. And that
- 9:11begins at the time of pleading. Of course, when
- 9:14you're pleading, you have to worry about getting
- 9:16past demurrers, you have to worry about making
- 9:18sure you've got accurate information. You've
- 9:21prepared for the first few steps of pleading
- 9:24challenges or whatever may happen at the beginning.
- 9:27But pleading is also part of the settlement process.
- 9:30The insurance carrier is going to set a reserve
- 9:32for your case at some point. Usually it's somewhat
- 9:35early on, they'll do an initial. And it's in
- 9:38your interest to have that be as much as possible
- 9:40in order to ultimately effectuate a settlement.
- 9:43So the amount of damages that you're pleading,
- 9:45the credibility of that pleading, that all starts
- 9:48at the very beginning when your case is being
- 9:52evaluated by the defense side. Of course, discovery
- 9:56then plays an even more important role. We're
- 9:59going to get some cases, we're going to get hundreds
- 10:02of interrogatories, all these document production
- 10:04requests from the defense side. And yes, perhaps
- 10:08they're papering. Yes, perhaps we could call
- 10:10that churning even. throwing no shade on the
- 10:15defense bar, but sometimes we see some voluminous
- 10:19questionable items. But the more we can provide
- 10:23in those responses, think about that as educating
- 10:27the insurance carrier. The carrier needs to know
- 10:30why they should be writing you the check. You
- 10:32can explain that to the client, look, we need
- 10:35to tell them and be as forthright and clear as
- 10:37possible on the facts that are good for us. on
- 10:42the documentation that we have of the issues,
- 10:46on the damages that we have. Let's put that out
- 10:48there. Let's not try and be too cagey about it.
- 10:51Of course, you need to plan about that, perhaps
- 10:54leaving avenues open if you need to in the future,
- 10:58particularly if there's developing issues, but
- 11:01educating the insurance carrier on what they're
- 11:04going to have to do in order to settle this case
- 11:06as early and often as possible. is an approach
- 11:09to think about as you're going through the pretrial
- 11:11process. Then again, once you are starting to
- 11:16prepare for the mediation itself, is this tenderization
- 11:19process, talking to the client about the issues
- 11:23that come up in a mediation, talking about what
- 11:28a compromise actually looks like, giving something
- 11:32away to get to yes, and then the risks, risks
- 11:36of not settling. the costs that are involved.
- 11:40Sometimes a war story about we did everything
- 11:43right and still the jury went sideways or the
- 11:46judge made the screwball ruling or whatever it
- 11:48is. There's always a story or two like that.
- 11:52Just so they understand, anything can happen
- 11:54at trial. You could have the best case, you could
- 11:57have the best lawyer, and you still have some
- 12:01risk at least going into trial. And of course,
- 12:05if you don't settle, and you still have a lot
- 12:07of pre -trial to go or even just trial to go,
- 12:10there's money that's going to come out. And it's
- 12:12ultimately the client's money, whether it's court
- 12:14reporter fees, which can be very, very high now
- 12:17for trial, whether it's other discovery costs,
- 12:21depositions, subpoenas. In our line of work,
- 12:25dealing a lot with legal malpractice, we've got
- 12:27the expert costs, which can be very substantial.
- 12:31So that's something else that cost risks should
- 12:33be explained. as part of this tenderization process,
- 12:37and then talk to the client about how you came
- 12:40up with the damages number. Obviously, most of
- 12:42that stuff is going to come from the client,
- 12:44but you're filtering it through. You're understanding
- 12:46what is legally cognizable, what is not legally
- 12:50cognizable, what arguments can you make credibly,
- 12:53and you're going to take those numbers and put
- 12:55them into your damage calculation and then sit
- 12:57down and tell the client, look, here's what's
- 12:59recoverable in your case. This stuff over here
- 13:02might not be recoverable. We've got much better
- 13:05chance of this. We have a worse chance of this.
- 13:07Put together your best numbers that you can as
- 13:10you're getting ready for mediation, but it'd
- 13:11be sanguine with the client about what's actually
- 13:13reasonable. And then when you're thinking about
- 13:16how to talk to the client about those numbers,
- 13:19I try and back into it by building the biggest
- 13:22damage number I can and then say, okay, this
- 13:26number over here is a little less likely. Let's
- 13:28take a discount on that. the chances that we
- 13:32get to a ultimate best day in court are 60%.
- 13:39And we just sort of find those ways of discounting
- 13:43to figure out what might be a reasonable settlement
- 13:46value. In the abstract, I'll even look at something
- 13:49in the range of 40 to 60 % of a best day in court
- 13:52as a reasonable settlement value to try and target
- 13:55discussions. And in tenderizing the client to
- 13:59what that number looks like, early can lead to
- 14:02a settlement. If it's warranted, you know, don't
- 14:06sell your client short. But when you're trying
- 14:08to figure out how you're going to get a compromise
- 14:10out of it and settlement seems to be the right
- 14:12way to go, these are strategies to consider.
- 14:16Again, this is all part of the communication
- 14:18process. As you get ready for the next step,
- 14:22make sure that you have enough information from
- 14:23the client to be able to prepare a good mediation
- 14:27brief. And lastly, as you're going through this
- 14:31process, think about if you have issues with
- 14:35multiple clients. This is something as we're
- 14:36preparing for this presentation that came up
- 14:39in our conversation, particularly, you know,
- 14:41Peter was expressing some concerns about this.
- 14:43We walk into a mediation and suddenly it's chaos
- 14:47in one room because there's all these different
- 14:49ideas and different needs and different wants.
- 14:52Obviously, if you've got a conflict situation,
- 14:55hopefully you've already dealt with that. That's
- 14:56something you can't really walk into a mediation
- 14:58with. And maybe a conflict situation arises in
- 15:00the mediation and you've got your duties that
- 15:02you have to adhere to in that situation. But
- 15:06usually you'll be in a situation where you don't
- 15:09have an actual conflict. You simply need to have
- 15:11an understanding of what's going to happen with
- 15:13the money should you get a recovery and what's
- 15:16going to happen with client authority to settle
- 15:18and how that's going to work. And ideally, The
- 15:20clients, if you have multiple clients, will have
- 15:22agreed amongst themselves prior to going into
- 15:24that process, how that's going to work, of course,
- 15:28with your guidance if needed. We'll go to the
- 15:31next slide. The mediation brief. Don't underestimate
- 15:37this, what it means, how important it is. This
- 15:40is how you educate the mediator. Your goal is
- 15:43to get that mediator in that defense room advocating
- 15:46for your client and explaining why they need
- 15:47to write the big check. So it can be very important
- 15:53from the fact standpoint for understanding the
- 15:57actual issues. That's usually where the rubber
- 15:59meets the road. Maybe a few critical exhibits
- 16:02are very important, but you're trying to be succinct.
- 16:04You're trying to be precise. I prefer a clinical
- 16:07approach. I think explaining things from a sort
- 16:11of a neutral perspective can be engaging with
- 16:13the mediator. and helps them understand why they
- 16:16should be advocating for you instead of, you
- 16:20know, sort of overblown rhetoric that you sometimes
- 16:22see. And as you're going through this process,
- 16:28exchanging briefs with the other side is usually
- 16:31considered more productive for ultimately being
- 16:33able to get to a resolution. But even if you
- 16:37can't, exchanging briefs with the other side
- 16:41is very helpful. for just understanding where
- 16:44you need to go with that case. Think about it
- 16:46as additional discovery. If you have a really
- 16:49good point and you're not sure how that defense
- 16:51is going to argue against it, what facts or evidence
- 16:55they're going to bring on what may be your smoking
- 16:58gun, make sure you emphasize that because over
- 17:02the mediation process, you can hopefully pull
- 17:04that out. And at least if you don't settle, have
- 17:07some more information to help you with the case
- 17:09as you move forward. If there are difficult issues,
- 17:15client credibility issues on either side, availability
- 17:20issues, consider whether you need to address
- 17:23that separately, what things need to be said
- 17:25only to the mediator, because you need to fuel
- 17:29that mediator with the things that they can use
- 17:32as leverage in that case for you. And all these
- 17:35things can be important. Even being aware and
- 17:38letting the mediator know you're aware of weaknesses
- 17:40can be important. It just helps with the advocacy
- 17:45process, not only as you're advocating for your
- 17:48client in the mediation, but as the mediator
- 17:51is trying to advocate for a settlement. And make
- 17:56sure you are being careful with your damages.
- 18:00Make sure your damages number is credible. Go
- 18:02back to your discovery responses. Make sure that
- 18:04is harmonized. Make sure that it makes sense
- 18:07with your legal theories. and put it out in plain
- 18:11numbers by category as succinctly as you can,
- 18:15and then make a demand. And at this point is
- 18:18when you're gonna put, at least in most situations,
- 18:21that big number that you're able to come up with
- 18:23your best day number on a piece of paper. And
- 18:26then you can start your process from there. But
- 18:28obviously you wanna try and get your best number
- 18:30forward and hopefully communicate that to the
- 18:33other side by exchanging briefs ahead of time
- 18:36so that... there's time for the insurance on
- 18:39the other side to be able to tenderize themselves
- 18:44to settling with you. Tell the mediator about
- 18:48any history of talks. Of course, it's important
- 18:50to understand those dynamics and what you know
- 18:52about the insurance on the other side. It could
- 18:55be that the other side hasn't disclosed something
- 18:57to the mediator that's important about insurance.
- 18:59It could be that you have a misunderstanding
- 19:00about the insurance and you can get that corrected
- 19:04throughout at the mediation process, which is
- 19:07also obviously helpful, not just for settlement,
- 19:09but understanding the dynamics in the other side.
- 19:13And last slide. So at the mediation should be
- 19:20unspoken, but be on time and look the part. One
- 19:23of the things that's going to help you get to
- 19:25a settlement, if that's appropriate in your case,
- 19:27is the client believing that you're there to
- 19:28advocate and that you've done that job and that
- 19:32they've seen somebody fighting for them. in that
- 19:35room. This isn't to say you need to be barking
- 19:37at the mediator, you're matching their tone,
- 19:40you're being professional, but at least look
- 19:42like, you know, the lawyer that your client wants
- 19:44to see. At least present yourself that way and
- 19:48make sure the client feels the support. Be ready
- 19:51to talk about other things in the case that weren't
- 19:53in your brief. Have additional exhibits at your
- 19:56fingertips if you need to share them. It's very
- 19:57easy, you know, when a lot of these mediations
- 19:59are online. on Zoom, you can just pull it off
- 20:03your computer if you've got it ready or bring
- 20:04your laptop with you to the session. During the
- 20:09initial merits discussion, the mediator is going
- 20:11to be talking to you about why the claims are
- 20:13bad, and they're going to be talking to the other
- 20:15side about why your claims pose tremendous risk.
- 20:18Make sure the client understands that so that
- 20:21they aren't put off by the negativity they're
- 20:24getting from that mediator. Understand that's
- 20:26part of the process. And when you get to the
- 20:28monetary portion, things that are second nature
- 20:31for people who've mediated quite a bit or been
- 20:34involved in cases. Make sure the client understands.
- 20:37What is midpoint negotiation? What's a bracket?
- 20:41Why are these different numbers going back and
- 20:44forth and we're seemingly playing a game? That's
- 20:48gonna be very frustrating for a less sophisticated
- 20:50plaintiff who doesn't do this all day. And you
- 20:54need to explain that along the way. What goals
- 20:56you are trying to achieve by putting different
- 20:58numbers forward. and take cues from the mediator
- 21:03in that process. Of course, use your own judgment.
- 21:07You might not have as good a mediator as Peter
- 21:09there, but assuming that you do, assuming that
- 21:13you've chosen this mediator from reason, think
- 21:15about what the mediator's saying because what
- 21:17you really wanna do is read between the lines
- 21:20to understand what's going on in that defense
- 21:22room. You're trying to get every last dollar
- 21:24that they can put on the table in that session.
- 21:27And the best way you can do that is understanding
- 21:28their psychology, understanding the different
- 21:30dynamics that are at play, and what hard limits
- 21:33they have over there. And that's really just
- 21:35what you're trying to probe throughout the day.
- 21:39And as part of that, consider your audience.
- 21:41Maybe a point or a certain discussion isn't the
- 21:45best thing for your client to hear. Maybe you
- 21:48need to have a separate call with the mediator.
- 21:50Maybe just put it between counsel. Again, use
- 21:52your judgment along the way and your understanding
- 21:54of your client's sophistication and how they
- 21:56might respond to something. An issue that I see
- 22:00on occasion is giving advice outside of expertise
- 22:05that the lawyer has, particularly in the area
- 22:07of tax. If you've got a complex tax issue, perhaps
- 22:12your damages come out of some sort of securities,
- 22:15some sort of other business entity or investment
- 22:18vehicle. Maybe you need to have tax counsel on
- 22:22hand to discuss what a settlement might look
- 22:24like or what the consequences of a settlement
- 22:26might be or things that have to be in a settlement
- 22:28to accomplish those goals. Having tax counsel
- 22:32available to you in those kinds of situations
- 22:36is super important or super helpful at least
- 22:41and certainly avoids the problem of you kind
- 22:44of going outside your expertise. And last is
- 22:49to advise the client when the right offer is
- 22:50made. It's the client's decision to settle. Rule
- 22:561 .2 of professional conduct says a lawyer shall
- 22:59abide by a client's decision whether to settle
- 23:01a matter. But you're the professional and it's
- 23:04your job to tell the client, this is the offer
- 23:07that you should consider accepting. Now you abide
- 23:10by their decision, of course, and if you think
- 23:12they're wrong, you're going to explain to them
- 23:14why they're wrong. Ultimately, if you're making
- 23:17an unequivocal recommendation at the right time
- 23:20when your judgment says this is the right settlement,
- 23:22or this is as far as they should go, then you've
- 23:26performed your duty and hopefully have a successful
- 23:31mediation that came out of that. It's Josh. Thanks,
- 23:41Mike, for that introduction. So when Josh and
- 23:43I are adversaries, we don't often agree on much,
- 23:46but I think you'll probably find that on the
- 23:48topic of how to plan and have an effective mediation
- 23:51in a lot of areas, our thought processes are
- 23:54aligned. And not only on the notion that Peter
- 23:57is an excellent mediator, who you'll be hearing
- 23:59from soon. So from the defense perspective, I
- 24:03think as Josh started with this is where I would
- 24:06start to, it sort of begins with communication.
- 24:09Let me go to the next slide. communication with
- 24:14a client from an outset as defense counsel, you
- 24:17want to start discussing what the client's objectives
- 24:20are about the case. And to do that meaningfully
- 24:24and fruitfully, an attorney will want to, from
- 24:27an early stage, develop an assessment of the
- 24:31case, the merits, the potential exposure, but
- 24:34also from the defense perspective, the cost of
- 24:37litigation. Defense counsel, you can be dealing
- 24:40with a client that has any level of sophistication
- 24:43ranging from an insurance carrier whose business
- 24:46is to evaluate risk and then to litigate and
- 24:50oversee litigation of cases to an entity that
- 24:54also may have a lot of experience with litigation,
- 24:57or you may be representing an individual who
- 25:00doesn't have any sort of familiarity with the
- 25:02process. And so from the outset, I think a lawyer
- 25:06on the defense side will want to discuss with
- 25:08them the lawyer's perception of the case. strengths,
- 25:11weaknesses, and particularly importance is cost.
- 25:15The attorney's fees, budgeting can be very helpful
- 25:18at an early stage so a client will understand
- 25:21even if the client thinks that this is a case
- 25:23that they did nothing wrong, that it's going
- 25:27to be costly to defend potentially. And that's
- 25:29something that always should be communicated
- 25:32to the client so the client understands what
- 25:35an aggressive defense might entail, what it might
- 25:37look like to their bottom line. you know, oftentimes
- 25:41at the beginning of a case and maybe through
- 25:44the end, clients may be on the defense side,
- 25:47clients may be, you know, vociferously pushing
- 25:49for defense, you know, adamant that they want
- 25:51to try a case. And that's fine, obviously, as
- 25:55Josh said, clients decision to settle is ultimately
- 25:57what's going to govern. But the client should
- 26:00know what the flip side of an aggressive defense
- 26:04posture might mean, because it can be very uncomfortable
- 26:07when at the end of the day, you've reached a
- 26:10point in the clients looking at a bill that they
- 26:11didn't anticipate was coming. Ultimately, these
- 26:16sort of things will evolve, too, over the course
- 26:18of the case. So it's important, too, to continue
- 26:20that dialogue. A client might start out adamant
- 26:23about wanting to defend the case, but as the
- 26:26case unfolds, things change, right, as bills
- 26:30mount or just as more information is obtained
- 26:33or even if litigation fatigue starts to set in,
- 26:36the client's position might change. So communication
- 26:38with the client early about their case, the lawyer's
- 26:41assessment, and the potential cost is really
- 26:45important to sort of set the groundwork for when
- 26:48you want to try to seek mediation as a potential
- 26:51way to resolve a case. In terms of the defense
- 26:55side too, I always like to look at cases at the
- 26:58beginning and try to discern whether I think
- 27:02this is a case for early resolution. Is it a
- 27:05case? You know, cases that are candidates for
- 27:08early resolution, there can be varying reasons
- 27:11for that. On the one hand, you may have a situation
- 27:13where it may be a case that... looks meritless,
- 27:18but is it a type of case that you think the other
- 27:21side might be willing to settle for something
- 27:23that's within the realm of cost of defense? And
- 27:27in those cases, an early mediation might be helpful
- 27:30so you can use the money that would otherwise
- 27:32go towards resolving or defending the case towards
- 27:34a settlement. That'll also depend on the client's
- 27:37perspectives, whether they want to look at things
- 27:39economically or otherwise. Also, obviously, certain
- 27:43times you'll be looking at cases and you'll wonder
- 27:45whether additional discovery or investigation
- 27:48is going to be helpful to the defense point of
- 27:52view? Or do you think you're going to uncover
- 27:54information that will aid the case in resolving?
- 27:58Or it might be harmful. There are some cases
- 28:01that you see from the outset that plaintiff may
- 28:04not know all of what's lurking behind the curtain
- 28:07and maybe an early resolution to pursue settlement
- 28:11might be in the client's interest for that reason.
- 28:14These are all things that are important to kind
- 28:17of identify and discuss with the client at early
- 28:21stages to the extent that it's possible. So the
- 28:24client understands those things and can take
- 28:26it into consideration when considering whether
- 28:29to mediate a case. So when you are also looking
- 28:33at setting a mediation, I think the next thing
- 28:37to consider too is what mediator are you going
- 28:39to go with? In my practice area, defending lawyers,
- 28:44there's a lot of different underlying subject
- 28:48areas that might be implicated. I like to think
- 28:51about, do cases involve specialized practice
- 28:56areas where a mediator has a background? Maybe
- 29:00it's an underlying securities case, underlying
- 29:03bankruptcy case. Do you want a mediator who's
- 29:06going to be able to bring a depth of knowledge
- 29:08to that subject area? certain times and certain
- 29:13clients may be more receptive to different types
- 29:17of neutrals. Albinators have their own styles
- 29:20for one thing, and backgrounds in some cases
- 29:24may be helpful to have a retired judge. be a
- 29:27mediator if you feel like the client needs to
- 29:29hear from somebody who's had that role and can
- 29:32bring that depth of knowledge and experience
- 29:34as a mediator. Other cases, having a private
- 29:38practitioner, someone who was a trial attorney
- 29:41or understands the realities of private practice,
- 29:46that might be a helpful perspective to have and
- 29:49a helpful person facilitating settlement discussions.
- 29:54Party dynamics as well will come into my mind,
- 29:57at least in my process when I'm thinking about
- 29:59mediators. If I think there's a party who's being
- 30:03driven by emotion, whether it's on the plaintiff's
- 30:05side or the defense side, I'll think about whether
- 30:08that can be something that a skilled mediator
- 30:13may be able to address and whether that should
- 30:15be part of the thought process in selecting a
- 30:19mediator. Another consideration, too, in terms
- 30:23of deciding when to mediate that I'll often think
- 30:26about, and this dovetails with whether a case
- 30:29is a candidate for early resolution, will be
- 30:31the procedural posture of a case. Oftentimes,
- 30:37if there's a potential dispositive motion, mediating
- 30:41while... that motion is on file but hasn't been
- 30:44heard can be a successful tool for the defense.
- 30:48It creates some additional leverage points for
- 30:50a mediator to focus on, or sometimes perhaps
- 30:54the trial date. Is this one where a trial date
- 30:58needs to be looming to have an effective mediation?
- 31:03This is also something where the cost calculus
- 31:05comes into play too, because mediating under
- 31:09either of those circumstances entails incurring
- 31:12upfront costs for the defense that you could
- 31:14avoid if you settle the case. So again, dialogue
- 31:18with the client, understanding the client's objectives
- 31:20and desires, and making sure the client is sort
- 31:23of apprised of the various alternatives that
- 31:25exist, all important when sort of making the
- 31:28first and early initial steps towards mediation.
- 31:36So then when you're more ready to move forward
- 31:38towards actually mediating, it's important to
- 31:43proactively prepare. And preparation in this
- 31:47context takes on a number of meanings. The lawyer
- 31:51obviously needs to be prepared. The lawyer needs
- 31:53to understand the case and be able to advocate
- 31:56effectively and persuasively for the client.
- 31:59But really having a successful mediation will
- 32:02require that the clients be prepared as well.
- 32:04And there's multiple levels to that as well.
- 32:09As Josh alluded to from the plaintiff's side,
- 32:12you'll want your clients and key decision -makers
- 32:14ready to be able to meaningfully participate
- 32:17in mediation. So if it is a case where there's
- 32:21an insurance carrier involved, you'll want both
- 32:24the client and the carrier's representative to
- 32:27be adequately apprised of the risks of the case,
- 32:32the strengths, the weaknesses, the exposure,
- 32:35the attorney's assessment, the reasonable settlement
- 32:38value range that an attorney believes applies
- 32:43to this particular case. And also, you want them
- 32:46to be prepared for the settlement process itself.
- 32:51So Josh mentioned the disclosures under evidence
- 32:54code 1129. That applies to obviously to any lawyer
- 32:57to the defense side. You'll want the client to
- 32:59understand what mediation confidentiality is,
- 33:03what to expect from the mediation. And then from
- 33:06the defense perspective too, you'll want to try
- 33:08to identify potential hurdles that might present
- 33:12themselves when you're in the mediation process
- 33:14and deal with them in advance if possible. And
- 33:17this can range from all manner of things. In
- 33:20a case where an insurance carrier is involved,
- 33:23sometimes there might be insurance coverage issues.
- 33:26There may be a reservation of rights from the
- 33:28carrier. The client may have retained a coverage
- 33:33counsel of their own. Oftentimes, if there's
- 33:36a serious coverage issue that's going to bear
- 33:38upon resolution, it's likely helpful to have
- 33:41coverage counsel for the client and the carrier.
- 33:43involved in the process potentially at the mediation
- 33:46themselves, but certainly aware and discussing
- 33:48the coverage issues in advance of the mediation
- 33:51so that a game plan can be developed and an understanding
- 33:55reached and you're not, you know, stuck at the
- 33:58mediation with these things coming to light and
- 34:00disputes arising. That's sort of a nightmare
- 34:03scenario that you want to avoid from the defense
- 34:05perspective. There can be Other hurdles too,
- 34:10in my practice area, most insurance policies,
- 34:14almost everyone I've dealt with, for a lawyer
- 34:17will have what's called a consent clause. So
- 34:19the client has to give consent before the carrier
- 34:21can offer money to settle a case. That's something
- 34:25that definitely needs to be discussed in advance
- 34:27and presumably has been before a decision immediate
- 34:30has been reached. But if there are consent issues,
- 34:34that needs to be discussed. The client certainly
- 34:36needs to understand that consent is necessary
- 34:40and be ready to discuss and address that. Sometimes
- 34:46there may be things like cross claims where the
- 34:49defense counsel may not be handling the cross
- 34:51claim. Obviously that will need to be taken into
- 34:54account in the preparation process so that the
- 35:00client knows that and is ready to negotiate or
- 35:03deal with the cross -claim at the mediation.
- 35:07These are all things too that will work its way
- 35:11into the mediation brief too. As Josh said, crafting
- 35:16a brief, it's a really important part of the
- 35:18process. You want the mediator to know it's your
- 35:22opportunity to educate the mediator and you want
- 35:24to do it as concisely but clearly as possible
- 35:28in the brief you're preparing. This is an opportunity
- 35:31to expand on the defense's themes of the case
- 35:34and theory of the case, address the defense's
- 35:37strengths, but also to the extent that it's possible
- 35:41in the brief. And I agree with Josh, too. I would
- 35:44certainly recommend and usually advise exchanging
- 35:47briefs because I want the other side to see my
- 35:50position and I want to see the other side's position.
- 35:54Addressing both the strengths and to the extent
- 35:56that you can do it in a document that you feel
- 35:59comfortable exchanging, the weaknesses because
- 36:01you can anticipate that your worthy adversary
- 36:04on the other side is going to be raising those
- 36:07weaknesses. And this is your opportunity to confront
- 36:10them and let the other side know how you intend
- 36:13to confront them. There's obviously in every
- 36:16case is different. And there's certainly going
- 36:18to be cases where there's information that you
- 36:21don't want the other side to see. That could
- 36:24be information that is harmful to the client.
- 36:27that you don't want the other side to know about
- 36:29and you don't think they know about. Or frankly,
- 36:32it could be information that you think is really
- 36:33harmful to the other side or information that
- 36:36you think that if you publicly, not publicly,
- 36:40privately disclose it to the other side in the
- 36:42mediation conflict, in context, may be detrimental
- 36:48to settlement. Maybe it'll be something that'll
- 36:50inflame the other side, you know, that oftentimes
- 36:52in those cases I'll do sort of a confidential
- 36:55supplement. that's for mediators eyes only, so
- 37:00that that can be taken care of, you know, separately.
- 37:03But to me, the mediation process, you know, in
- 37:06addition to trying to resolve a case and obtain
- 37:09a settlement, it's also an educational process,
- 37:11both for the lawyer and for the client. And so
- 37:14obtaining as much information as possible, I
- 37:17think is critical. And that starts with being
- 37:22open and using the process and mediation confidentiality
- 37:26to its full extent. All of these issues too,
- 37:30problems with coverage, problems with client
- 37:33consent, the sort of thorny issues I think are
- 37:36helpful things to... discuss in advance with
- 37:39the mediator if it's possible. I'm a big fan
- 37:41of pre -mediation calls. I think we'll talk more
- 37:43about that later. But all of this, I think, is
- 37:46helpful to get out and address before you actually
- 37:49get there on the day so you can set yourself
- 37:51up for hopefully as productive a mediation as
- 37:55possible. And let's go to the day itself. So
- 38:01obviously at the mediation, your role is to be
- 38:03the client's advocate and you want to be there
- 38:05and you want to advocate effectively. You also
- 38:09need to be advising the client appropriately.
- 38:12As Josh said, they need to understand the mediator's
- 38:15function. They need to be prepared and ready
- 38:19for the mediator to come in and lean hard on
- 38:23you and try to educate you about gaps in the
- 38:27defense or weaknesses that you may be aware of
- 38:30or maybe that you don't appreciate. And being
- 38:33able to understand and appreciate and educate
- 38:36the client about risk is a key part of the process
- 38:39always for a defense lawyer. Mediation can really
- 38:41be a valuable tool in issue spotting or getting
- 38:46a new perspective on aspects of the case that
- 38:49you may not have appreciated to that point. during
- 38:53the mediation process to, you know, avoiding
- 38:57ambiguities, particularly in terms of settlement.
- 38:59You know, when you're preparing for settlement,
- 39:02it's important to, again, sort of understand
- 39:04the client's desires in terms of what the settlement
- 39:08is going to look like, both from a monetary and
- 39:10non -monetary perspective. So if there are key
- 39:14non -monetary terms, you know, confidentiality,
- 39:17non -disparagement, whatever that may be, that
- 39:21should be communicated explicitly during the
- 39:25mediation process, hopefully before, but when
- 39:28you're making settlement proposals and offers,
- 39:31it's important that the mediator knows what the
- 39:34client's expecting so that you're not stuck in
- 39:37a situation where you think you've come to an
- 39:39agreement, you may have an agreement on a number,
- 39:41but the non -monetary terms then come to light
- 39:44and there's an issue and you're sort of back
- 39:47to square one, or at least back to not the final
- 39:49square. I personally, you know, where possible,
- 39:53where you have a case that allows it, like to
- 39:56bring a proposed long -form settlement agreement
- 39:58to the mediation. So my hope would be that we
- 40:01could, you know, use the mediator potentially
- 40:03to hash out any disputes and come away with a
- 40:06signed settlement agreement when all is said
- 40:08and done there and then. So you don't have to
- 40:11worry about these things flaring up and becoming
- 40:14problems down the line or after you think you've
- 40:17had a deal. Always my diverted. Think you have
- 40:20a deal and then and then realize there's a problem.
- 40:29And I'll turn it over to Peter then. Thanks David,
- 40:33I will try not to repeat what David and Josh
- 40:37have have said. I may want to emphasize a few
- 40:41areas and go a little deeper, but I do. I do
- 40:47want Josh and David to jump in, feel free to
- 40:49interrupt and add your perspective as I go through
- 40:53this. Initially, the pre -mediation conference,
- 40:59I think, is important because of the ability
- 41:05to let the mediator know about your case and
- 41:09about your clients. When you choose a mediator,
- 41:13you should choose somebody carefully. And I say
- 41:17that because sometimes people say, well, I let
- 41:22the other side choose a mediator and whoever
- 41:24it is is okay with me. If they think that person's
- 41:27good, I'll be fine. I don't believe that's the
- 41:30right way to go about it. I think you need to
- 41:33carefully analyze the qualifications of the mediator
- 41:37and whether they are the right person for your
- 41:41case. You have to know your mediator. There are
- 41:45many mediators who, for example, have a limitation
- 41:49on the number of pages for a brief. Well, if
- 41:52you've got a very complex legal malpractice case
- 41:56arising out of a securities problem, and it's
- 42:00going to take 40 or 50 pages of brief to fully
- 42:03explain it, you don't want a mediator who's only
- 42:06going to accept 10 pages. You want somebody who
- 42:09is going to read all of the brief and maybe another
- 42:13200, 300 pages of exhibits. On the other hand,
- 42:17if you have something that's a very straightforward
- 42:20case and you want it to be brief, maybe the person
- 42:24who accepts 10 pages is exactly what you want.
- 42:27Keep it simple. Another thing about briefs quickly
- 42:33is you have to submit them well in advance. Too
- 42:40often I get briefs a day before. two days before,
- 42:44and it's 30 pages, 40 pages, and I'm thinking,
- 42:49how am I going to get through this and then remember
- 42:53any of it and then be able to talk knowledgeably
- 42:59about the issues to both sides? You put the mediator
- 43:04in a really difficult spot. The earlier you submit
- 43:09the brief, the better chance you have that the
- 43:12mediator is going to be able to analyze what
- 43:16you're saying. And in conjunction with a pre
- 43:21-mediation conference, the mediator often will
- 43:24say, okay, I need this, I need that. Send me
- 43:28the case that supports this proposition. I don't
- 43:32understand your damage analysis. You may want
- 43:35to rethink how you set forth your damages. It
- 43:38could be a number of different things. But if
- 43:40you're having that pre -mediation conference
- 43:45that takes place two days before the mediation,
- 43:49you will learn what the mediator is confused
- 43:53about. And if you can clear that up for them
- 43:55before the mediation itself, you will be in a
- 43:58far better position at the mediation because
- 44:02the mediator will be able to be your advocate
- 44:05in the other room as opposed to your critic.
- 44:10Now, I'm one of those mediators that's a little
- 44:12unusual. I tell both sides the same thing. I
- 44:17think it's super important that both sides understand
- 44:21my analysis of the case. And I'll start out the
- 44:25mediation by giving each side my analysis of
- 44:28the case based upon the conversations I may have
- 44:31had with the attorneys and the briefing and the
- 44:35documents themselves. I read every single page.
- 44:41Because I do legal malpractice mediations, the
- 44:44devil is in the details, so I have to become
- 44:47extremely familiar with the details. It is not
- 44:50uncommon for me to read entire depositions, entire
- 44:56lengthy agreements, multiple drafts of agreements
- 44:59to see how they progressed. All of those things
- 45:02are important because of the details. So, the
- 45:07quicker you get your mediation brief into me,
- 45:09in advance of the mediation, the better off you're
- 45:12going to be, and I think that's the case for
- 45:1599 % of the mediators. In terms of content of
- 45:20the brief, again, if you know your mediator,
- 45:24you can tailor the content. I can't tell you
- 45:28how many times I will get briefs that go on for
- 45:32four or five pages about what the law is, and
- 45:35the standard of proof, and the elements of proof.
- 45:38for legal malpractice case. Hey, you picked me
- 45:42because I've been doing this 40 years. Why do
- 45:46you need to tell me what the standards are? Get
- 45:51to the point. Make the brief shorter and emphasize
- 45:55the issues that are important in the case as
- 45:59opposed to educating me. Now, there may be a
- 46:04recent case that you want to point out. There
- 46:06may be a case in the past that is right on point
- 46:10and you want to point out the similarities. Fine.
- 46:14Understood. It never hurts to remind me. But
- 46:19to have the general elements of a legal malpractice
- 46:22case repeated over and over doesn't do you any
- 46:26good. I'm just going to skip over it anyway.
- 46:36It's really important to understand, and I think
- 46:39both Josh and David address this, if there's
- 46:43a key issue in the case that is potentially a
- 46:48problem for you, you need to address it. Now,
- 46:53whether you address it in the brief that you
- 46:55exchange with the other side or in a separate
- 46:58supplemental confidentiality, you know, confidential
- 47:03brief only to me, No problem. But you have to
- 47:08address it. If you think the mediator is going
- 47:12to miss it and somehow not address it, well,
- 47:19think again, because the other side is going
- 47:22to address it and the mediator, nine times out
- 47:26of ten, is going to understand that there's a
- 47:29problem and start asking questions. That doesn't
- 47:33look good in front of you or your client. So,
- 47:37any problem areas, address them head on, even
- 47:41if it's confidential. Now, there may be issues
- 47:44that the other side would never know. Your client
- 47:50wants to retire. He wants this out of his life.
- 47:54He doesn't care what it settles for. He's never
- 47:57getting insurance again. Things like that, where
- 48:00the mediator needs to know, okay, the client
- 48:03is pushing for a settlement. So, tell the mediator,
- 48:09okay, we need to get this case resolved, get
- 48:11this out of my client's life. Now, it may be
- 48:14that you tell me that the insurance company is
- 48:18not cooperating with that theory, that they want
- 48:22to save every penny possible. Okay, but tell
- 48:26me beforehand. It's not something I want to find
- 48:29out during the mediation. Again, the pre -mediation
- 48:32conference is a great place to do that. If you
- 48:36have a piece of evidence that, as I think both
- 48:39Josh and David alluded to, either helps you or
- 48:44hurts you, and you don't want to disclose it
- 48:46to the other side, but you do want to have it
- 48:51affect the way the mediation goes, tell me. I'm
- 48:56really good at compartmentalizing information,
- 48:59and I never, ever, ever would betray the trust
- 49:06of the lawyer who tells me you can't tell the
- 49:08other side this. They may not know about it.
- 49:12Now, if the other side brings it up, I'll go
- 49:15straight back to the lawyer and say, ah, they
- 49:17already know. So don't worry about it at this
- 49:21point. Figure out a way to address it. Insurance
- 49:27information, again, addressed by Josh and David,
- 49:31very important to know. In the legal malpractice
- 49:34area, there's always issues of insurance, coverage,
- 49:39covered issues versus non -covered issues versus
- 49:42limits versus deductible, self -insured retentions,
- 49:48reservation of rights letters. There's so many
- 49:51issues of insurance. If those issues are important
- 49:55to your case, bring them to my attention early.
- 50:01because it will affect how the mediation goes.
- 50:07It is not uncommon for me to do pre -filing mediations
- 50:13and the plaintiff's side will say, we don't know
- 50:18anything about their insurance information. We've
- 50:22asked, but they haven't told us. I will always
- 50:27go to the defense and say, They want to know
- 50:30about the insurance information. How much? What's
- 50:34the deductible? Is it a burning limits policy?
- 50:39Those types of things. Basic, basic, basic things.
- 50:43Is there a reservation of rights letter? Often
- 50:48the defense will say, we're not going to disclose
- 50:51that. My first question is always, can I tell
- 50:56the other side that any insurance issues, limits,
- 51:03problems won't affect the settlement of this
- 51:06case. If they say, yes, you can tell them that.
- 51:12I'll say, fine, you understand that, you know,
- 51:15you need to be honest about it, but fine, I have
- 51:18no problem, and you can tell the other side that.
- 51:20If they say, well, I don't know, you know, it
- 51:24could, my response is always, Why don't you tell
- 51:28the other side? If you really think that you
- 51:33want to settle this case, the other side's not
- 51:35going to negotiate in the dark. And if I can't
- 51:39tell them that it's not an issue, they're going
- 51:42to become very suspicious as to why you're acting
- 51:44the way you're acting. Let's get it on the table.
- 51:47Figure it out. Next slide, please. Again, just
- 51:59to remind everybody, most mediators, if you ask
- 52:03in advance, say two weeks, three weeks, contact
- 52:07the mediator directly. If I send you a deposition
- 52:11and ask you to read it, will you read it? If
- 52:14I send you a 25 page brief, will you read it?
- 52:19Get to know your mediator. The next thing I would
- 52:24say is, Understand and be prepared to identify
- 52:29your non -negotiables. Now Josh and David both
- 52:33alluded to this. The non -monetary terms of a
- 52:40mediation settlement, a mediated settlement,
- 52:42are so important. You know, is this going to
- 52:45be a mutual general release? Is it going to be
- 52:50a mutual specific release? Is it going to be
- 52:54a 1542 waiver? You know, what are the things
- 52:58that you want? Confidentiality, non -disparagement,
- 53:03enforceability under 664 .6. All of these issues
- 53:08need to be addressed early in the mediation so
- 53:12that everybody understands before you get down
- 53:16to the last minute where you say, okay, we've
- 53:19got a deal. Now let's talk about the non -monetary
- 53:22terms. Well, all of a sudden, you don't have
- 53:24a deal. If you get those non -negotiable, non
- 53:30-monetary terms out of the way early, you'll
- 53:34be surprised how much easier it is to come to
- 53:36reach a settlement. Next slide, please. I wanted
- 53:46to talk about success in a mediation. I think
- 53:53David addressed it and Josh did as well. You
- 54:01can measure success and remediation by whether
- 54:04you settle or not. That is one measure, of course.
- 54:08But in my opinion, you should also measure the
- 54:12success of a mediation by how much you've learned
- 54:15about the other side's case and how much you've
- 54:18learned about your own case. A good mediator
- 54:22is going to challenge you on the issues in your
- 54:27own case. He's going to analyze your case for
- 54:31you. He or she is going to analyze your case
- 54:35for you. And they're going to say, these damages
- 54:39don't make sense to me. And here's why. Or, I
- 54:46understand your causation argument, but Is that
- 54:50really causation? Is that really something that
- 54:53caused this damage, or is it a third party, or
- 54:58a different issue, or the economy, or COVID,
- 55:00or is it something else? You're going to learn
- 55:06a great deal about the other side's case and
- 55:08remediation, but I think even more importantly,
- 55:11you're going to learn about your own case and
- 55:14how to present it, what the problems are, and
- 55:19how you overcome them. And a good mediator is
- 55:23going to, again, challenge you to explain logically
- 55:30your case. Mike. All right. Thank you, guys.
- 55:38Great presentation. We've only got about five
- 55:41minutes left. If anybody wants to toss out a
- 55:45question. please do so. We'll take a couple of
- 55:48minutes here. I have a question for the panel
- 55:50and to start with you David. You know one of
- 55:53my favorite boxers Mike Tyson said everybody
- 55:56has a plan going into the ring until they get
- 55:58hit in the mouth and so I want to talk about
- 56:01what happens when your evaluation, your carefully
- 56:05crafted evaluation that you David have gotten
- 56:08authority from your your claim adjuster in the
- 56:11insured cases. You Josh have properly conditioned
- 56:15your client and you've got their expectations
- 56:18reined in. All of that work has been done and
- 56:21then you show up at the mediation and your evaluation
- 56:24doesn't track with the mediator. Peter's evaluation
- 56:30of the case and I've had that experience with
- 56:33Peter. How do you handle that pivot now that
- 56:38maybe the case as you've seen it isn't quite
- 56:42tracking with this third party neutral that you've
- 56:45hired to give you a new fresh perspective. David,
- 56:50you wanna start? Sure. And I take it you want
- 56:54a better answer than just sit there and cry,
- 56:56because that might be my... Well, if that's your
- 56:58approach. Yeah, no, it certainly, one of the
- 57:04things that... It's oftentimes useful in a way
- 57:09like to learn. Okay, this is a perspective of
- 57:11someone I really respect You know or somebody,
- 57:14you know a mediator who really knows their stuff
- 57:15that I haven't seen So the part of the dialogue
- 57:19I will have in that situation once the beaters
- 57:21out of the room with the client is well This
- 57:23is one of the reasons that we we hired this media
- 57:26that we put our trust in this mediator he's bringing
- 57:28this new perspective and Let's talk about it.
- 57:32Let's consider it from a practical perspective
- 57:36it can often mean that this mediation is probably
- 57:39not going to result in a settlement. Because
- 57:41if to that point you've evaluated and assessed
- 57:45a case a certain way and the mediator says you
- 57:47got it all wrong, likely what that's going to
- 57:52mean is that what I want to do is use today to
- 57:55continue the dialogue, to continue gathering
- 57:57information and exploring the analysis so I can
- 58:01then take all that in, probably, unless the carrier
- 58:05has brought way more money than I thought they
- 58:07were going to, you know, the clients willing
- 58:08to just settle it. But probably take all of that
- 58:11and reassess and say, okay, let's look at round
- 58:14two, right? Now that we've educated ourselves
- 58:17and we can digest it and, you know, how does
- 58:20that change to how we were thinking about it?
- 58:22Let's go at it again, you know. That's probably
- 58:25how that's going to play out. Unless, you know,
- 58:28I'm on my best, I ate my Wheaties that morning
- 58:31and I can talk the mediator out of it. Well,
- 58:37Mike, if I could continue your boxing analogy
- 58:40a little bit, you got to roll with the punches.
- 58:45And part of the conditioning of a client when
- 58:48you're going in is to be flexible, to be ready
- 58:53to handle with an open mind what's going on in
- 58:58that mediation. And I had an issue not too long
- 59:02ago, I think it was with Peter. maybe a year
- 59:05or so ago, where I had a legal issue that ended
- 59:10up being very significant for damages that we
- 59:15hadn't really considered. And the defense was
- 59:18all over it. And the first time I came, it was
- 59:20at the mediation. I fought back at first. If
- 59:29you think you've got some... some merit, you
- 59:31know, feel free to push back in a professional
- 59:34way. But then I reached into the briefcase, if
- 59:37you will, and started really pulling out documents
- 59:40that I thought I could use to reinforce a new
- 59:48set of trenches, if you will. So, okay, the line
- 59:52has moved. What do we have at this other space?
- 59:55And we're able to kind of rejigger on the spot
- 59:57and come up with a modified defense theory. But
- 1:00:04I think the direct answer to your question is
- 1:00:07it starts with that preparation process and being
- 1:00:10ready to move and making sure as you're going
- 1:00:14in, if you're really going to settle it, no one
- 1:00:19can be firmly entrenched in one position or another
- 1:00:22and there has to be some willingness to move
- 1:00:24around. We've got a question from Shelly O 'Connor.
- 1:00:30I want to toss out, what is your approach to
- 1:00:34having your client speaking directly and responding
- 1:00:37to the mediator's questions? Why don't we start
- 1:00:40with you, Josh? Yeah. David would like to hear
- 1:00:42from you on that, Peter, and then we'll wrap
- 1:00:45up. That's a strategic thing to think about.
- 1:00:51Sometimes the mediator wants to talk to your
- 1:00:54client directly and establish some rapport. and
- 1:00:57sometimes you know that's going to be a disaster.
- 1:01:01But there's a couple ways to think about it.
- 1:01:03One is to let the mediator see what you're dealing
- 1:01:06with and some of the perhaps emotional barriers
- 1:01:11to settlement that are there and that can help
- 1:01:12give the mediator an understanding of what they
- 1:01:14need to do to get the deal done. But you don't
- 1:01:17want that to damage your credibility and your
- 1:01:20client's credibility at the same time and the
- 1:01:22impression of what they might be like at the
- 1:01:24stand. So you kind of have to approach that strategically.
- 1:01:29I'd go back to the point about knowing your audience.
- 1:01:32Think about what you're projecting, how you're
- 1:01:34projecting it, and if you have to take your client
- 1:01:36aside and say, look, mediator, give us the room,
- 1:01:41take your client aside and say, look, this part
- 1:01:43isn't helping. Let me just do my job and we'll
- 1:01:46have a chance to talk later. That might be your
- 1:01:50best option. But there are challenging clients
- 1:01:52out there and sometimes clients do make it harder
- 1:01:54to to settle. From the defense perspective, I
- 1:02:00agree with Josh really, it is a strategic consideration
- 1:02:03and it'll depend a lot on the client and what
- 1:02:06you, you know, are trying to convey to in the
- 1:02:10case, you know, for me, oftentimes I'm representing
- 1:02:13lawyers who can advocate effectively and you
- 1:02:16know, I think a client is going to make a great
- 1:02:18witness. I'll always discuss this in advance,
- 1:02:23typically with my clients to be ready. At their
- 1:02:27comfort level too, sometimes clients will tell
- 1:02:28me, I don't want to, you're my lawyer, I don't
- 1:02:31want to be talking directly to the mediator and
- 1:02:33I'll let that guide me. But where I think it'll
- 1:02:35be effective or oftentimes to my clients might
- 1:02:41be subject matter experts, if it's a particularly
- 1:02:44complex underlying litigation or legal practice
- 1:02:48area. where they can speak effectively, that
- 1:02:52can be really useful. But there can be times
- 1:02:54when it might be to the client's overall detriment,
- 1:02:59if it is something emotional or if credibility
- 1:03:03issues are going to become apparent. Those are
- 1:03:05things to consider and discuss and guide how
- 1:03:09you want that interaction to go. Mike, if you
- 1:03:14want my side of this, typically if I don't ask
- 1:03:22questions directly of the client, that's quite
- 1:03:24unusual. I want to talk to the client directly.
- 1:03:29It gives me a feel for how they will be as a
- 1:03:32witness, whether they contradict themselves over
- 1:03:39and over or are just simply unable to accurately
- 1:03:44communicate their position, if I have the lawyer
- 1:03:50jump in and answer questions that I've addressed
- 1:03:53to the client, my first thought is, oh boy, that
- 1:03:59client's being hidden. There's a problem. I mean,
- 1:04:03it's just my first thought. And I'll often say,
- 1:04:06David, let me ask him. Let me ask him directly
- 1:04:09and I'll get the Well, Peter, we've looked at
- 1:04:13this issue, and I'll think to myself, uh -oh,
- 1:04:17there's a client problem here. Now, maybe the
- 1:04:19other way. Josh, I may ask a question, and he'll
- 1:04:23say, let me have the client address that. And
- 1:04:29this happens both on the defense and the plaintiff's
- 1:04:31side. And I'll say, OK, great. And then I'll
- 1:04:34start a dialogue with the client. And I can get
- 1:04:37a feel for whether the client's being truthful
- 1:04:41or maybe a little avoidance is going on, I get
- 1:04:46a feel for how they are. I think all three of
- 1:04:51you have experienced maybe unfortunately my sort
- 1:04:55of soft cross -examination of a client. If there's
- 1:04:59an issue that I think is really detrimental,
- 1:05:03I may ask in very cross -examining type of terms,
- 1:05:07questions of the client to see how they're going
- 1:05:10to respond. And typically, you know, at a break
- 1:05:17in the mediation, I may have a separate, you
- 1:05:19know, private conversation with Josh or David
- 1:05:22and say, hey, if you think my cross examination
- 1:05:28of your client was bad, wait till you get to
- 1:05:31court or wait till you get to a deposition. I'm
- 1:05:35a pussycat compared to what the other lawyer's
- 1:05:38going to do to this client, and you've got to
- 1:05:41be prepared for that, and here's why, and here's
- 1:05:44the problem with it. And often it highlights
- 1:05:47issues that affect, you know, whether or not
- 1:05:52the client's going to settle. At least as to
- 1:05:56David's side of the cases, I often want to ask
- 1:06:00questions of the lawyer -defendant in front of
- 1:06:05the carrier. So the carrier begins to understand
- 1:06:09the vulnerability that the lawyer might have,
- 1:06:13which in turns, you know, purposely, I'm trying
- 1:06:17to loosen up the purse strings. And it's not
- 1:06:23just idle question asking. There's a purpose
- 1:06:26to it. So I'm actually probing. I'm trying to
- 1:06:31ask questions of the client's to find out information
- 1:06:36not only about them, but to convey information
- 1:06:40to them and maybe the carrier. Great. All right.
- 1:06:46Well, we are out of time. And so I'm going to
- 1:06:50end our presentation. I want to thank our panelists,
- 1:06:52Peter Thompson, Josh Foreman, David Simani. Thank
- 1:06:56you guys for a great presentation. Those of you
- 1:06:59who attended, please be on the lookout for more
- 1:07:02BHBA programming. The Ethics and Legal Malpractice
- 1:07:06Law section, we've got some CLEs coming up. Those
- 1:07:09of you that are members of the section, please
- 1:07:11feel free to reach out to me. If there are CLE
- 1:07:15topics that you're interested in, we're happy
- 1:07:18to put together a panel that'll meet those needs.
- 1:07:21Thank you all for attending and have a great
- 1:07:24day.