Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Direct Listings to Go Public
Transcript
- Lucas: So SpaceX's valuation hit two-point-six trillion dollars this week — briefly passing Amazon's market cap. That's an insane number for a company that hasn't even gone public yet. Luna: It's wild. And it raises the question — when they do go public, will they do a traditional IPO? Or something else? Lucas: Right, that's exactly what I want to dig into today. Because more and more tech companies are skipping the traditional IPO playbook and opting for a direct listing instead. And it's not just the high-profile names — we're seeing it across the board. Luna: What's the fundamental difference? I mean, we all know the rough idea, but let's get specific. Lucas: Sure. In a traditional IPO, the company hires investment banks to underwrite the offering. The banks set an initial price, buy all the shares from the company, and then sell them to institutional investors and the public. The company gets the proceeds, but the banks take a cut — typically around three to seven percent. Luna: And in a direct listing, there's no underwriter. The company just lists its existing shares on an exchange, and the market finds its own price. Lucas: Exactly. No lockup period required either, which is a huge deal. In a traditional IPO, insiders are usually locked up for 180 days. With a direct listing, employees and early investors can sell immediately. That changes the whole incentive structure. Luna: But doesn't that also create more volatility? I mean, if everyone can sell day one, the stock could get hammered. Lucas: It can, but it also means the price discovery is more genuine. The first trade in a direct listing reflects real supply and demand, not the bankers' guess. Look at Roblox — they went public via direct listing in March 2021. The reference price was forty-five dollars, but it opened around sixty-four and closed at sixty-nine. Luna: So investors who got in at the open made money that day. But the company didn't raise any capital, right? That's the trade-off. Lucas: Correct. A direct listing doesn't raise new money for the company. It's just a liquidity event for existing shareholders. So it works best for companies that don't need the cash — they're already profitable or well-funded. Roblox was cash-rich from venture capital and revenue. Luna: And Roblox's stock today? It's at forty-nine thirty-four, up nearly nineteen percent in the last five days. So the direct listing didn't hurt it long-term. Lucas: No, and in fact, some argue the direct listing allows for a healthier aftermarket because the price isn't artificially suppressed by the IPO discount. In a traditional IPO, banks intentionally underprice to ensure a first-day pop — that leaves money on the table for the company. Luna: So the company leaves money on the table, but the banks make their fees and their clients get the pop. There's a conflict there. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the New York Stock Exchange actually changed its rules in 2020 to allow companies to raise capital in a direct listing — a primary direct listing. So now you can do both: raise money and let the market set the price. Luna: Has anyone done that yet? Lucas: Yes — in 2021, Coinbase did a direct listing, but it wasn't a primary one. Spotify was the first big name in 2018. Slack followed in 2019. None of them raised capital. But Palantir? They did a direct listing in 2020 and also didn't raise capital. So it's been primarily secondary. Luna: I think the primary direct listing is still rare. But it's an option. Lucas: It is. And the SEC has been supportive. So going forward, I think we'll see more companies choose this route, especially high-profile ones like SpaceX. If they go direct, it could set a precedent for the next generation of tech unicorns. Luna: What about the role of investment banks? Are they completely cut out? I mean, even in a direct listing, don't companies still hire advisors? Lucas: They do. Banks can act as financial advisors, but they don't underwrite the deal. So their fees are lower — more like a consulting fee. But they still play a role in advising on the structure, the valuation range, and the listing process. Luna: So it's not a total disintermediation, but it reduces the banks' power. And for investors, what should they watch out for? If a company does a direct listing, the volatility on day one is probably higher. Lucas: Much higher. There's no stabilisation from underwriters. So if you're an individual investor, you might want to wait a few days to let the price settle. But if you believe in the long-term story, it's still a good opportunity. Luna: And the data on aftermarket performance? Are direct listing stocks more volatile in the first year? Lucas: Some studies suggest they are, but they also tend to have less of a first-day pop — which is actually a good thing for valuation. The pop is just a wealth transfer from the company to early buyers. Without it, the price is more efficient. Luna: I think for founders and employees, the ability to sell immediately is huge. It gives them liquidity without waiting six months. Lucas: Absolutely. And it removes the pressure to time the sale around the lockup expiration. We've talked about lockup expirations before — how they can depress the stock when insiders dump shares. With a direct listing, that selling is spread out from day one. Luna: So it's smoother. But it also means insiders might sell earlier, which could be a signal to the market. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why disclosure is so important. In a direct listing, insiders have to file their sales publicly, so you can see who's selling and how much. It's more transparent. Luna: You know, the more we talk about this, the more it seems like direct listings align better with the ethos of tech companies — less middlemen, more market-driven pricing. Lucas: It does. And honestly, conversations like this are exactly why listener support matters. We keep this show ad-free because people find it useful for what they're building or running. If you get value out of these deep dives, you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the conversation going without any commercial breaks. Lucas: So back to direct listings — the big question is: will we see a wave of them in 2027? With SpaceX possibly leading the charge, and other big private companies like Stripe and Instacart still waiting, the pressure is on. Luna: I think the trend is clear. More companies will at least consider it. And the market will adapt. Lucas: Agreed. And for investors, it means paying closer attention to the structure of the offering, not just the hype. Next time we'll look at how these listings affect index inclusion and ETF demand. Luna: Looking forward to it.