Latest / The KAJ Masterclass LIVE / How Brands Can Navigate Cancel Culture Successfully
Transcript
- 0:25None. Welcome to this very special
- 0:28edition of the Kaj Master Class Live the show which ensures that
- 0:32you profit from your time spent here with experts, either
- 0:35through the industry insights, information or simply learning
- 0:39from them. And today we have Cat Cannon.
- 0:42She is a founder and CEO of Radical Customer Experience, a
- 0:46groundbreaking consulting firm that encourages brands to
- 0:49establish genuine customer connections with their customers
- 0:53by embracing strengths based, drama, informed and inclusive
- 0:57marketing services. Welcome to the show, Cat.
- 1:01Thank you so much. I'm thrilled to be here.
- 1:03You are welcome to the show. You are welcome to India in this
- 1:06online form. And I'm sure a lot of people in
- 1:09India will benefit from this, but not just in India.
- 1:13A lot of people globally will benefit from what we are going
- 1:16talking about. We're talking about how
- 1:18companies can avoid cancelled culture.
- 1:21But first to understand, when I was introducing you there were
- 1:24so many words, you know, trauma, informed, inclusive marketing
- 1:29services, trends based, so many things and cancel culture.
- 1:33So first to understand how does this trauma come into this
- 1:38business jargon? And also you know to understand
- 1:41what exactly do you mean by cancel culture with regards to
- 1:46companies and how they can avoid it.
- 1:49Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 1:51So I mean, I think the word trauma is very scary in terms of
- 1:55business and business. It gets executives.
- 1:59But the truth is, especially after the pandemic is that all
- 2:03of us, 100% of the global population has experienced at
- 2:07least one major trauma in our lives.
- 2:10And that affects how we perceive messages, whether that's in the
- 2:14workplace or in the marketplace. So it is an overall technique
- 2:20that I teach my clients. I would say that strengths based
- 2:24marketing as a subset of that. But you know as marketers we
- 2:29were all taught fear based techniques.
- 2:31We have to create urgency like now, now, now, now, now.
- 2:35You have until midnight to to hit get the sale or limited
- 2:40quantity and repeatedly pushing those negative messages.
- 2:46Can be really dangerous for consumers, psychologically
- 2:49speaking. And so, you know, I teach
- 2:53companies to take that same data and just flip the message and
- 2:57instead of saying, hey, limited quantity, you better get it now.
- 3:02Instead, you can send out a message.
- 3:03It's like, hey, we, these are our customer favorites this
- 3:07month, right? That just reframes the message
- 3:11in a positive light. In terms of inclusivity, it's
- 3:16just really making sure that you know, your your materials are
- 3:22inclusive for everybody, regardless of culture or
- 3:26ethnicity, religion, you know, I honestly, all three are really a
- 3:33part of the same thing. But yeah, I think they're really
- 3:39critical for business right now. Yeah, right.
- 3:43Right. And where does the cancel
- 3:46culture coming? From well, I mean, I think
- 3:50cancel culture is something we all see every single day or
- 3:54someone or something or some company being cancelled.
- 3:59You know, whether it's a celebrity, which of course
- 4:02celebrities are brands on their own, you know, where there's a
- 4:08uproar? Right.
- 4:10About a message or a video or a campaign or something that seems
- 4:16particularly insensitive. I know in the US we've had a
- 4:21couple of very recent examples. You know, whether it was the
- 4:25musician Lizzo or Target, which is our, you know, the store or.
- 4:34The beer brand Bud Light, they've all sort of stepped into
- 4:38it as we would say here in the last 6 or so months and you know
- 4:45and then they lose business. Target as an example, you know
- 4:49is such a behemoth, but they lost 90% of their stock share
- 4:54six months ago and it hasn't come back.
- 4:57So I think that's how I mean cancel culture in this sense
- 5:02and. You know, it can be really
- 5:03disastrous for businesses, you know, and our research tells us
- 5:09that companies and executives, to be honest, are terrified of
- 5:13saying or doing anything and misstepping because, you know,
- 5:17the Internet can be very unforgiving.
- 5:22And so I just try to. Teach brands to get ahead of it
- 5:28by using the trauma informed strength based techniques I
- 5:32mentioned and really understand how their consumers are thinking
- 5:39about them and perceiving them beyond just pure sales numbers.
- 5:46Absolutely, absolutely. Now let's look at it from both
- 5:50sides. One is the customer side, one is
- 5:55the company side. Who is the one who is
- 5:59cancelling? The other usually?
- 6:03Customers, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 6:06So can customers be taken for granted by the companies when
- 6:10you when you when you do not give good services or or you are
- 6:18bringing a message? Like for example, normally in
- 6:21old days whenever you had a product you used to do a pilot
- 6:25study in a small market, go for that messaging or product
- 6:29services and then went for the bigger market.
- 6:33But you act very smart. Suddenly you come out with a
- 6:37celebrity who has also lost credibility.
- 6:40You think they have credibility because they have got following
- 6:45and then you push on a message and you want to thrust on
- 6:48people. Why do you want to people just
- 6:52be your servant and just, you know, accept that message.
- 6:55People do not want to be questioned.
- 6:57What is so divine about companies if customers are
- 7:00questioning it? Because there might be other
- 7:03vested interests in between, but that is your job to tackle it.
- 7:07Where does the cancelled culture come in?
- 7:09Because you see who? Who is responsible for this
- 7:13cancelled culture? I am not talking about the tall
- 7:15puppy syndrome here. I am talking about plain
- 7:18relationship between a customer company who is responsible for
- 7:22this mistrust and the distance you don't talk to the customer.
- 7:27You create what's in between and then that is where the problem
- 7:32is. Your leaders, most of these
- 7:34business leaders, they are found on LinkedIn talking about
- 7:37thought leadership and the customer is trying to reach even
- 7:40the, you know, even one level up.
- 7:43Then the customer care executive who simply does not care.
- 7:46Tell us about this because we got to be very clear about who
- 7:50is cancelling whom, because I in my opinion, my personal
- 7:53experience with some of the big companies is that companies are
- 7:57cancelling the customer till they find that customers are
- 8:00actually, you know, hitting that.
- 8:03Yeah. No, absolutely.
- 8:05I think there's been maybe a learned arrogance.
- 8:10I haven't phrased it that way before.
- 8:12So let's stick with me on behalf of companies because they.
- 8:18I have never been challenged in the way that they are now with
- 8:23the way culture is, you know, current culture can be very,
- 8:28very unforgiving. You know, for some things that
- 8:32are just, you know, pure accidents and oversight, it it
- 8:37happens to all of us. I know I was a brand side
- 8:40marketer for the majority of my career.
- 8:43You know, sometimes like. There was seriously APR fail or
- 8:48misstep, but they think you know and then they will be cancelled
- 8:54by their customers, right? But I think companies need to
- 9:00get ahead of it and anticipate and protect themselves and I
- 9:05think by understanding really where their customers are and
- 9:09even consumers out of hole, they can.
- 9:13Really help mitigate those kinds of risks.
- 9:17Absolutely correct. Absolutely.
- 9:19You have a very difficult job to do and you get a very difficult
- 9:23because why I explain, I'll tell you how the way I have seen it,
- 9:27I understand it. I may be wrong, but this is what
- 9:30I understand of it. Two big things.
- 9:32What is the relationship with customer?
- 9:35Everyone knows even in the US I've been talking to some very,
- 9:39very, you know, informed people about this.
- 9:42We all know how difficult it is to even get a simple thing
- 9:45sorted through the customer care, several of them.
- 9:48There is no very rarely there is customer service.
- 9:51So that thing now let us look at the company employee
- 9:54relationship. We are still dealing with the
- 9:57great resignation. Again who is responsible for
- 10:00that in customers you say who when you come into the picture
- 10:04it means companies create artificial urgency.
- 10:07It is like you know, archiving who, who is responsible for that
- 10:11this marketing you. So you see both the places.
- 10:15You have lost that credibility even in employees.
- 10:18Your employees are not ready to work for you.
- 10:20You are not. You have not been seeing the
- 10:22writing on the wall except that you know suddenly, suddenly when
- 10:26your ship was sinking. Then you are shouting consult
- 10:28culture. So help us understand how what
- 10:31is it that companies come to you for?
- 10:33How do you salvage the situation for them?
- 10:37It is not a PR exercise. It has to be an exercise in
- 10:40genuinity, authenticity. If they do it, customers also
- 10:45understand that. So I want to understand.
- 10:47See, I have no growls against any company.
- 10:50I have a simple customer. I want the I pay money.
- 10:54I just want my services accordingly as per what I pay
- 10:58for. That's it.
- 10:59Nothing more to help us understand what they want from
- 11:02you. How do you show them the way
- 11:04from here? Yeah, absolutely.
- 11:07I think that. You know, like I said, it's
- 11:09really easy to messed up. You know, I often use the phrase
- 11:14internal customers as it comes to employees.
- 11:19I think companies, you know, they're like the big giant,
- 11:23right? And they've been in this
- 11:24position of authority, whether it's over their employees or
- 11:29over their customers, and that just doesn't fly anymore.
- 11:33You certainly see it with a great resignation.
- 11:37You know, going on with employees, it's just like not
- 11:40worth, like any kind of poor environment for them to keep
- 11:44working there. And then, you know, in terms of
- 11:48consumers, like, there are so, so many choices, right?
- 11:53And so if a brand messed ups and again, like I'm not saying
- 11:56anyone is sitting in a conference room trying to ruin
- 11:59people's day, right? Like that's not.
- 12:02That's not how it happens. But you know, sometimes like
- 12:06mistakes are made or poor choices are made on behalf of a
- 12:09marketing team and even marketers like themselves like
- 12:14are under so much pressure from the rest of the executives, from
- 12:18the board, from stockholders. There's a lot of pressure to
- 12:21increase sales continually and you know it makes it very easy
- 12:28to then be short sighted and really go for the sales.
- 12:32But then there's no sustainability underneath of it.
- 12:35If you have an issue, you know, maybe there was a product issue,
- 12:39right? Like maybe there's a quality
- 12:41issue that happened. Maybe you pushed out a campaign
- 12:46that was misinterpreted. I mean, probably the most
- 12:50egregious example of that was last fall, the Balenciaga
- 12:56campaign. I don't know if anyone watching
- 12:58is familiar. But they put out a fashion
- 13:02campaign featuring kids wearing bondage gear.
- 13:06It was really horrifying, to be honest, and and very, very
- 13:12disturbing. But take it one step further and
- 13:16imagine that you were sitting there as a as a customer seeing
- 13:20that, and perhaps you'd experience some kind of trauma
- 13:23along those lines in your childhood.
- 13:26Boy, wow. Watch out.
- 13:29You know, it's really, really hard to recover from something
- 13:32like that. So, you know, I'm I'm happy to
- 13:36come in to a client after some kind of incident, but I don't
- 13:41spin. I am not APR agency you.
- 13:45They really have to genuinely mean it and repair the trust,
- 13:51which is why I recommend, you know, getting ahead of it.
- 13:57And the way that both my business consultancy and and the
- 14:01software which we can get to is formed around a methodology.
- 14:05It's called my 3RS framework, which is radical empathy,
- 14:09radical vulnerability and radical authentic investment.
- 14:14Obviously, we all know I like the word a radical, but yeah, I
- 14:19mean, I think it is really putting the customer first in a
- 14:24totally different way. Thinking, taking a minute to
- 14:29just think about how a message might be perceived.
- 14:34You know, is it, is it going to hit on some kind of generational
- 14:38trauma? We saw that, you know, last year
- 14:43Walmart put out an ice cream in honor of Juneteenth, which you
- 14:50know. Is a really, really sensitive
- 14:53issue here. And you know, essentially, like,
- 14:57they may have meant it as a positive thing, but it was not
- 15:00perceived that way and it was a really big misstep.
- 15:05And I think really understanding like if you do run into a
- 15:11mistake, we also see so many brands who just go silent when
- 15:15they've made a mistake, right. And sorry, sorry to interrupt
- 15:20you. I want to learn from you.
- 15:21When was the last time Brand came out and said I made a
- 15:26mistake? It's.
- 15:28Rare do you think? Do you think?
- 15:29Tell me, I want to know, especially big brands.
- 15:32So if you think that you are the most intelligent person of the
- 15:36universe just because you got the designation in your hands,
- 15:40where why do you blame the curbs customer for cancel culture?
- 15:44Yeah, no, I mean typically it's a a misstep made on behalf of
- 15:48the company and you know the whether it's intentional or not
- 15:53doesn't matter. You know, even to individual to
- 15:56individual if you've hurt someone with your words, it
- 16:00doesn't matter if you didn't intend it, it, it matters how it
- 16:03was perceived. So that's definitely what I try
- 16:07to teach my clients is like, let's just take a moment and
- 16:10think about. How these words, this copy, this
- 16:14imagery might be perceived by someone else and a think you're
- 16:22never going to get 100% right, but you do have to acknowledge
- 16:28it when you don't. So this we now have this
- 16:32analytics product that I call the cancel culture check up that
- 16:36is based around these 3R factor and.
- 16:40It's an assessment that you can send to your customers or
- 16:45general consumers as well. And it really breaks down
- 16:52empathy and vulnerability and authentic investment into these
- 16:56questions and words like empathy and vulnerability, you're like,
- 17:00wait, business. What?
- 17:02How are these the same, right? But if you think about, just say
- 17:07vulnerability, right? For a company, it means that
- 17:13they will actually acknowledge when they've made a mistake, and
- 17:16they will sincerely apologize for it.
- 17:19That's the only way to rebuild trust.
- 17:22And you know, when you're willing to admit a mistake, you
- 17:25are being vulnerable. You know, just as if you were an
- 17:29individual. You know in terms of authentic
- 17:33investment, right? You're not just donating?
- 17:36You're not doing 'cause marketing where X percentage of
- 17:39your profits go somewhere, set it and forget it.
- 17:43You are genuinely supporting things that are in the actual
- 17:47DNA of your brand and you know that are critical.
- 17:52If we look at, you know, the brand Patagonia for example, you
- 17:56can't separate sustainability from Patagonia.
- 18:00They are sustainability. Sustainability is Patagonia,
- 18:03right? Or, you know, perhaps there's
- 18:07someone that is helping train the next generation of workers
- 18:12in the community around their headquarters that's genuine,
- 18:15authentic investment. It's not just throwing money
- 18:19because someone has asked them for a donation.
- 18:21There's a difference now and I think that customers expect
- 18:25more, consumers expect more. You know are more and more
- 18:30sophisticated particularly as we look at millennials and Gen.
- 18:33Z, they don't give second chances.
- 18:37You know if they've had one negative interaction for a
- 18:39brand, they will leave. Whereas I think some of the
- 18:43older generations, it's almost a learned helplessness where you
- 18:48don't think that there's another alternative and so you stay with
- 18:52that brand even if they are have terrible customer service or you
- 18:57know. What have you, but it's just not
- 19:00the way of the world anymore and you just have to get ahead of
- 19:07it. You know, it doesn't have to be
- 19:09hard, but you should really be aware as a company of how your
- 19:14customers really feel and really see you otherwise.
- 19:19Like, how can you be proactive? Absolutely.
- 19:24Absolutely. So how do you actually get
- 19:27things done on the ground? As you said, it's not APR
- 19:31exercise, it's a genuine exercise.
- 19:34How do you understand whether this company is genuinely
- 19:38seeking your help or wants to actually conduct APR exercise
- 19:44under this excuse? It happens.
- 19:46See, they are they are smart, but but people are also smart.
- 19:50Very smart. Just because they are not in
- 19:52that company does not mean they have lost their brains.
- 19:55Yeah, no, absolutely. I think that eventually, if
- 20:00someone's not really serious about it, if someone is just
- 20:04sort of, you know, trying to make up for a mistake and, you
- 20:09know, sort of cover themselves, it comes out eventually.
- 20:13It doesn't read as sincere, you know, for me.
- 20:19I'm happy to help a customer, you know, a company that's
- 20:22gotten in trouble if they really are sincere about changing
- 20:27things and figuring out what went wrong, you know?
- 20:32So I think some of it is just, you know, how I interact with
- 20:36people, like to think that I'm pretty good at reading folks.
- 20:41But yeah, I think if someone is really, really serious about,
- 20:49you know, let's let's see what the scores are, let's send this
- 20:52assessment out and you know, really do some smart analytics
- 20:59around this. And then we can make
- 21:02predictions. We can like, you know, really
- 21:06figure out and dial in on like maybe someone is actually doing
- 21:09really well on empathy in terms of their messaging.
- 21:14The, the software I use that analyzes language as well, you
- 21:20know, maybe they're doing really well and they are, but customers
- 21:23don't perceive them being great on authentic investment, right.
- 21:28Maybe they don't think they're really participating in in
- 21:31society in that way. So we have an idea of like what
- 21:35we need to adjust and nothing's overnight.
- 21:40Absolutely not. But you know, it gives you
- 21:43something to like operate on and you know and then it's backed up
- 21:49by numbers and you know and psychology and those don't lie,
- 21:54you know and you can see the trends over time and you know
- 21:58perhaps how much more deeply you're connecting with
- 22:02consumers, how much more loyal and and trace that over time.
- 22:10Absolutely. I want to understand the trend
- 22:12that people who take your expertise.
- 22:16How? What is the percentage of those
- 22:19who are actually, you know, utilizing that output given by
- 22:23expertise and output that is given by you I?
- 22:26I will get a trend through that that OK, it is just that you
- 22:30know for green as they use this word green washing, white
- 22:35washing this, this must be image washing.
- 22:38Whatever it is I want to understand.
- 22:40Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Well, I mean, honestly, if I
- 22:44was, you know, washing over something or helping a company
- 22:49wash over something, that would be sort of counter to who I am
- 22:55as a person. And you know, my top priority is
- 23:01not income. I need.
- 23:04I need revenue to live and support my family.
- 23:06But there are just, you know, certain companies that I
- 23:12wouldn't do business with. You know, that's just hard facts
- 23:17I guess. But I think there's an
- 23:19opportunity for everyone, company or individual to change
- 23:24and to improve if they're really willing to open up and analyse
- 23:31how many of my clients are really taking action as to what
- 23:38they see. I honestly, right now I would
- 23:43say most of them are. There's actually even like
- 23:46consulting hours that are baked into most of the subscription
- 23:50levels, so they can't avoid me. So that certainly helps.
- 23:58You know the other customer insight platforms that are out
- 24:02there whether it's a Net Promoter score or similar things
- 24:06don't give any real information about your customers other than
- 24:10maybe how they feel at a given moment in time.
- 24:14That as a marketer that gives you no information at all.
- 24:19You know, whereas this system really dials in and we even have
- 24:26what I'm now calling marketing Rorschach or you know, the ink
- 24:30block block test where it's a separate assessment that brands
- 24:36can send their customers that presents a series of fairly
- 24:40generic images and ask their customers to respond in writing
- 24:45as to what that image evokes for them in terms of the brand.
- 24:48And so that combined with that number score, that quantitative
- 24:52score, we can get pretty deep into those insights and and I
- 24:58can help them figure out how to move forward, right?
- 25:02Absolutely, absolutely. So whatever methodology they
- 25:07adopt, my understanding is that the solution is pretty simple.
- 25:11Talk to the customer, listen to the customer, and the customer
- 25:15will listen to you when your time is tough.
- 25:19Yep, absolutely. Absolutely.
- 25:22Yep, absolutely. Have a conversation.
- 25:26Have a conversation. So be that as it may.
- 25:29It all depends on whether they want or don't want.
- 25:32You know at the end of the day, the customer is still the king.
- 25:35He has not been dethroned at as yet.
- 25:39So those people who would want to learn more from you about you
- 25:43know about the cancel culture check up about anything else.
- 25:47What is the best way for them to learn as well as those companies
- 25:50who would want to engage with you professionally?
- 25:53Yeah, absolutely. So our website
- 25:56isradicalcustomerexperience.com or they can always find me on
- 26:01LinkedIn under Kat Cannon. I would welcome a conversation
- 26:06from anyone no matter where you're based.
- 26:10Maybe it's just to learn more about cancel culture or trauma
- 26:16informed marketing. I'm happy just to have a
- 26:19conversation, but definitely hit us up on the web or ping me on
- 26:24LinkedIn. Absolutely, with this.
- 26:27It's a wrap on this very special edition.
- 26:30Of the KJ Master class live. Thank you so much indeed for
- 26:33joining us. Thank you so much.