Latest / When Killers Get Caught with Brittany Ransom / “No One Saw Anything” | The Skidmore Shooting of Ken Rex McElroy

Transcript

“No One Saw Anything” | The Skidmore Shooting of Ken Rex McElroy · When Killers Get Caught with Brittany Ransom

0:00
It's just before 11 AM on a quiet Friday morning in
0:02
Skidmore, MO, July 10th, 1981. Population 440.
0:10
Main Street is small, familiar, the kind of place where everyone
0:15
knows everyone and everything. A man walks out of a local bar
0:20
and climbs into a pickup truck. He's tall, around 6 feet, with a
0:24
solid build. Dark hair, bright blue eyes, by
0:28
some accounts even attractive. In the passenger seat sits his
0:33
wife, Trina McLeod. Smaller, quiet, long, dark hair.
0:38
Still, at first, there's nothing really unusual about this scene.
0:43
Until people start showing up. Not one or two dozens.
0:47
Some standing in the street, some lingering near the bar,
0:51
others watching from a distance. No one says anything, but you
0:56
can feel it, the tension, the weight of it, the kind of
1:00
silence that isn't empty, it's just waiting.
1:04
The man behind the wheel looks at the crowd.
1:06
They're angry. He is too, because as far as
1:09
he's concerned, they should know better than to cross him.
1:14
Then gunshots. Not one or two.
1:17
Several, all coming from different directions, tearing
1:21
into the truck. The crowd scatters.
1:23
Some duck, some run, some freeze.
1:26
Inside the cab, Trina drops down into her seat.
1:30
The man behind the wheel slumps forward, and just as quickly as
1:33
it started, it's over. Silence again, until Trina
1:38
starts screaming. Her husband is dead.
1:41
Shot in broad daylight on Main Street in front of over 50
1:46
witnesses. The police arrived to a street
1:49
full of people. And when they start asking
1:52
questions, no one saw anything. I'm Brittany Ransom and This is
1:59
When Killers Get Caught, a podcast where I examine the
2:01
people, the psychology, and the moments that lead to the most
2:04
extreme acts of violence and what happens when silence
2:08
finally takes over. Now, I've said this over the
2:11
years and I'll say it again, I really don't like unsolved
2:15
cases. I hate the endless theories, all
2:18
the speculation, the way that we go in circles and still end up
2:21
with nothing. So if you've been listening
2:24
since 2021, you've probably wondering why I'd even be here
2:27
right now. And if this story sounds
2:29
familiar, it should. I covered it years ago, It's one
2:32
of my favorites. And as we are leading up to
2:35
episode 100 next week, I wanted to revisit this case with a
2:39
different lens. Error.
2:41
A better understanding of what this case actually represents
2:45
because it is different. This isn't a mystery where we
2:48
don't know what happened. It's a case where dozens of
2:52
people were standing right there when Ken Rex McElroy was
2:55
murdered. They saw it, they knew who did
2:58
it, and still no one has ever been arrested.
3:01
So this episode isn't about guessing.
3:04
It's really about systemic failure, fear and what happens
3:08
when a group of people are just pushed too far.
3:16
Now, to understand how something like this could happen, we have
3:19
to talk about where it all started.
3:21
Skidmore, Missouri. It isn't just a small town, it's
3:25
isolated. At the time, the population
3:28
hovered around 440 people. Today, it's closer to half of
3:32
that. This is a rural farming
3:34
community where generations of families have lived within a few
3:38
miles of each other, The kind of town where everyone knows your
3:41
name, your parents name, and all of your business.
3:45
There's really no anonymity, and there's not much in the way of
3:49
protection either. Law enforcement has always been
3:52
limited, thinly spread across a massive county, slow to respond,
3:57
and in some cases, hesitant to get involved.
3:59
Not because they don't care, but because in a town so small,
4:03
stepping in can mean putting a target on your back.
4:07
And that's the part that people don't always get.
4:10
In a place like Skidmore, the fear doesn't stay contained.
4:14
It spreads, and it spreads quickly.
4:17
Reputation matters. Power matters.
4:19
And when the system that's supposed to protect you feels
4:21
unreliable, people start looking for other ways to feel safe in
4:25
their homes. And that's where the story
4:28
really starts. It all cycles around Ken Rex
4:33
McElroy, a man not born into power.
4:36
He was born into abject poverty on June 1st, 1934 in Overland
4:41
Park, KS, 15th of 16 children. His parents were migrant
4:47
sharecroppers moving between Kansas and the Ozarks before
4:50
eventually settling in Skidmore, Missouri.
4:53
Home was cramped into a 2 bedroom house packed with
4:57
people, noise, and not a lot else.
5:00
By most accounts, McElroy stood out physically.
5:02
He had dark hair, bright blue eyes, and that's pretty much
5:05
where all the positives end when discussing this man's childhood.
5:09
He dropped out of school in the eighth grade, just 15 years old.
5:13
Around that time, he also suffered a serious head injury
5:16
after he fell out of a hay wagon bad enough that doctors
5:20
implanted a steel plate in his skull.
5:22
Something that gets mentioned a lot in discussions about him,
5:25
but it doesn't fully explain what happened next.
5:28
Because by 15, the pattern had already started.
5:34
If we're fair, he'd already become known by the police by
5:38
the age of 13. And not in a passing way, in a
5:42
we pick this kid up often kind of way.
5:46
It started with him just bullying other kids,
5:48
specifically kids from families who were doing better
5:50
financially than his. He would take lunch money,
5:54
intimidate people, steal things from their book bags or their
5:57
lockers, But it didn't stay small.
6:00
As he got older, the crimes escalated.
6:02
Shoplifting turned into breaking and entering, stealing from kids
6:05
turned into stealing from businesses.
6:07
And next to that, his behavior towards women started raising
6:10
red flags. He was drinking heavily, chasing
6:14
women constantly, and harassing anyone he found attractive,
6:19
whether they were interested or not.
6:23
Now, most kids eventually hit a space where consequences forced
6:29
them to stop. This kind of behavior McElroy
6:34
never did. By the time he died, he had
6:37
racked up over two dozen felony charges assault, arson, cattle
6:41
rustling, burglary, theft of grain, theft of livestock,
6:45
repeated allegations of child molestation and statutory rape.
6:49
But somehow, nothing ever stuck. His own attorney once said that
6:54
Ken averaged 3 criminal cases per year every year, and he
7:01
never spent more than a short stint in county jail.
7:05
It wasn't that people didn't report him.
7:08
Nothing ever stuck. And that wasn't luck.
7:11
It was Ken's strategy. See Ken McElroy build his life
7:16
around intimidation. Witnesses would always back out
7:19
of trial surrounding him. The victims would recant their
7:22
testimony. People who considered speaking
7:24
up suddenly had someone sitting outside of their house or
7:28
calling in the middle of the night.
7:29
Or making it very clear that if you testify against Rex, there
7:35
will be consequences. He didn't just commit crimes, he
7:39
also controlled the aftermath and at one point even pulled a
7:42
gun on a town Marshall. And when the other officers
7:46
refused to step in, afraid of retaliation, the Marshall quit.
7:51
That's the kind of presence that Ken Rex McElroy hadn't Skidmore.
7:56
And then there was his lawyer, Richard McFadden, a very skilled
8:00
defense attorney who knew how to work the system.
8:03
Delays, venue changes, technicalities.
8:06
Whatever it took, he was willing to do it.
8:10
And McElroy always had the cash to pay him, because while
8:13
farmers in the area were struggling, McElroy would show
8:16
up to bars with pockets full of money, sometimes sitting right
8:20
next to the man who he'd just stolen from, and no one could
8:24
ever say a word. And then there's the part of the
8:28
history that's a little harder to hear but impossible to
8:31
ignore. McElroy had a pattern when it
8:34
came to women. He started young, when they were
8:37
vulnerable, still girls, usually from poor families.
8:41
He gained their trust. Offer them rides, give them
8:44
small gifts, and then isolate them.
8:47
At 18 years old, he married a 17 year old named Auletta.
8:51
But she wasn't the only one. Over the next decade, he
8:54
fathered multiple children with different women, many of them
8:57
underage. He never had it.
9:01
At one point he was married to a 15 year old while also abusing a
9:04
13 year old that he beat into compliance and then moved her
9:08
into his home. And this wasn't rumor.
9:12
Everyone in town knew these girls.
9:14
Families knew, law enforcement knew, but nothing stopped him.
9:20
By the early 70s, McElroy wasn't just a criminal, he was a
9:23
constant presence. A man who would steal from you,
9:27
threaten you, hurt you, and walk free every single time.
9:32
For this case, the point of Rex's abuse centers around 1
9:39
girl. Trina McLeod was 14 when she
9:43
became entangled in Ken Mcelroy's world.
9:47
By that point, he already had his pattern.
9:50
He wasn't just dating the young girls.
9:51
He would groom them, move them into his orbit, away from their
9:54
family, away from all stability, away from anyone who would
9:57
intervene. And when Trina became pregnant
10:00
as a teenager, that pattern locked into place completely.
10:04
She dropped out of school and moved in with Rex and another
10:07
young woman in his household. Neither of them were there by
10:10
choice. At one point they actually both
10:13
tried to escape and ran to family for help, but McElroy
10:17
found them and at gunpoint he forced both girls back into his
10:20
car. The followed wasn't just
10:24
violence, it was escalation with no limits.
10:29
He beat one of the women severely.
10:31
He forced Trina into sexual acts.
10:34
Then he took her back to her own family home, killed her dog in
10:38
front of her and her family, and burned her parents house down as
10:44
they watched. That wasn't just punishment,
10:47
though. This was a message, a reminder
10:50
of what would happen if you tried to leave.
10:55
But Trina was stronger, probably stronger than most people
10:57
realized. She tried again just two days
11:00
later. This time, she used a medical
11:03
appointment as a cover to escape at the doctor's office.
11:06
She was visibly distressed, and the staff immediately recognized
11:10
that something was wrong and contacted authorities.
11:12
Social services intervened. Her baby was placed in foster
11:15
care. Trina got hospitalized for her
11:18
own safety and mental health issues.
11:20
And for a moment, it looked like the system was going to actually
11:23
do something. And then in June of 1973, Gelroy
11:28
was indicted on charges of arson, assault and rape.
11:32
He was arrested, arraigned and then released on $2500 bond.
11:38
Within days, he walked back into his attorney's office with
11:41
$15,000 in cash. His defense was already
11:45
structured. Delay the case, break things
11:48
apart, wear the system down. And it worked.
11:52
Meanwhile, Trita was in foster care, supposedly protected, but
11:57
Ken found her anyway. He began showing up outside of
12:00
the home where she was staying, sitting in his car for hours,
12:03
watching, waiting, just close enough to be legal, but distant
12:09
enough that he was still untouchable.
12:11
When the police were called, they would tell him to leave,
12:14
and he would, briefly. Then he would start making phone
12:18
calls, Threats, constant surveillance, psychological
12:21
pressure that followed Trina into every part of her life.
12:24
She was terrified of ringing phones, of strangers, of
12:27
silence. And at one point, McElroy called
12:31
the foster family directly and said, I know where your daughter
12:34
goes to school and she can be taken care of.
12:39
That's when the case expanded. Prosecutors actually added
12:42
additional felony charges after interviewing Trina and learning
12:46
the extent of the abuse that she had endured for years.
12:50
That should have been the turning point, but it became
12:52
another delay. Mcelroy's attorney split the
12:56
charges into separate trials. Dates were set, postponed, reset
12:59
again. The process stretched on for
13:02
years, bleeding momentum out of a case until it didn't have any
13:07
urgency anymore. Eventually, Trina got moved
13:10
again, this time to live with her grandmother, And that's when
13:14
everything fell apart. In rapid succession, Mcelroy's
13:18
wife filed for divorce. And then, almost immediately, he
13:21
reappeared, asking for Trina's hand in marriage.
13:24
Her mother signed the paperwork, exhausted after the years of
13:27
being worn down. A judge married them the next
13:30
day. And just like that, Mcelroy's
13:34
defense lawyer made the final move.
13:36
He informed the prosecutor that Trina, now his legal wife, could
13:39
no longer be compelled to testify.
13:42
And just like that, the central witness to the case was gone.
13:47
It could have been challenged. This could have been something
13:50
that was fought. But it wasn't.
13:52
Everyone was just so tired and they really understood the same
13:59
truth. Even when the system had
14:02
McElroy, it still let him go. For a brief stretch.
14:09
Things and Skidmore go quiet, but the silence is short lived.
14:13
On July 27th, 1976, Ken McElroy crossed the line he had never
14:17
crossed before, at least not publicly.
14:22
Romaine Henry was working on his farm.
14:24
When McElroy arrived, uninvited, he fired a shotgun into the air,
14:28
claiming Henry had been on his property earlier in a white
14:31
Pontiac. Henry was confused.
14:34
He didn't know what Ken was talking about, and he told him
14:37
plainly. I don't even have a white
14:40
Pontiac. That's when McElroy shot him
14:44
once in the stomach, and then again as Henry tried to get into
14:47
his truck. The second blast hit him in the
14:50
face. Henry survived only because the
14:53
shotgun jammed after the second shot.
14:56
His wife drove him to a nearby hospital, and McElroy was
14:59
arrested the next day on a charges of assault with intent
15:03
to kill. But from the beginning, he
15:05
denied even being there. And then the system did exactly
15:09
what it did before. Delays, venue changes,
15:12
procedural resets. McElroy walked right back into
15:16
his attorney's office, and McFadden was already working it,
15:20
just like all the other trials. But something changed.
15:25
This time, Mcalroy didn't just rely on the courtroom.
15:28
He returned to Henry's farm over and over again, over 100
15:33
separate visits between the shooting and the trial.
15:35
Sitting, watching, waiting. Henry reported him over and over
15:40
again, but nothing happened. And that's the moment the town
15:43
really understood something. Reporting McElroy doesn't
15:48
protect you, it exposes you. When the trial finally started,
15:53
the prosecution was inexperienced and completely
15:56
outmatched. The state presented witnesses
15:59
who placed McElroy at the scene, but the defense countered with
16:03
conflicting testimony, including men who claimed he was elsewhere
16:06
entirely, out hunting with them miles away.
16:11
The jury ultimately returned a full acquittal.
16:14
No assault, no attempted murder, no consequences.
16:18
And Miguel Roy didn't just walk free.
16:20
He made sure people knew it. He bragged openly that he might
16:25
as well as killed Henry and gotten away with it.
16:29
A few months later, Henry was back on his tractor when he got
16:33
shot again, this time with a rifle.
16:35
There were no witnesses, no arrest, no trial.
16:39
He survived again, but he didn't return to the same life
16:42
afterward. And in Skidmore, a message had
16:45
been delivered that everyone understood without anyone having
16:49
to say it. The first time you report Ken
16:51
McElroy, nothing happens. The second time, it'll be worse
16:56
for you. By 1980, Skidmore wasn't just
17:00
tense. The town was waiting.
17:03
Everyone knew something bad was going to happen eventually.
17:06
The only question was when and who it would happen to.
17:10
And it started, almost absurdly, with a 10 cent piece of candy.
17:15
On April 25th, children from the Ken McElroy family walked into a
17:19
local grocery store. There was confusion at the
17:22
register. Multiple kids, lots of different
17:24
payments. A small mistake.
17:26
One child left without paying for one piece of candy.
17:29
The clerk called after her, and that's when things escalated.
17:33
One of the older children came back furious, threw the candy
17:37
down, stormed out. Another sibling followed,
17:40
yelling that no one was going to accuse them of stealing.
17:44
The store owners were Lois and Bo Bowen Camp, new residents to
17:48
the town, trying to run a quiet business in a town that didn't
17:51
feel all that quiet anymore. Bo was almost 70.
17:55
Louis was in her late 40s. They tried to calm the situation
18:00
down. They didn't stand a chance and
18:03
within minutes the tension boiled over.
18:05
Beau told the family they were no longer welcome in the store
18:08
and that really should have been the end of it.
18:09
But it wasn't. About 20 minutes later, Ken Rex
18:12
McElroy arrived in his truck carrying a knife and right
18:15
behind him was Trina McCloud shouting threats at Lois.
18:19
Beau tried again to de escalate. He explained it was just a
18:23
misunderstanding. No one was being accused of
18:25
theft in any serious way. For a moment it almost worked.
18:30
And then Ken demanded free cigarettes, and that's when he
18:35
was told by Bobo and camp that his family were no longer
18:39
welcome in the store. Ken left, but he stayed outside
18:44
for hours, just watching. Later that night, he followed
18:49
the Bowen camp's home and circled their property over and
18:52
over again. They called the sheriff, who
18:55
told them to ignore it. That's just Ken being Ken.
19:00
At one point, McElroy even offered Lois $100 if he would
19:05
physically fight Trina and whatever happened would settle
19:10
what was between them. Lois refused.
19:13
The next day, Ken returned again, this time with Trina,
19:17
waited outside their home when police were called.
19:20
They left before they arrived, helped by a police scanner he
19:23
had in his truck. And again, officers said there
19:27
was nothing they could do as long as Ken stayed off of their
19:30
property. But it escalated.
19:33
About one month later, McElroy and Trina parked outside the
19:36
Bowen Camp property. Lois watch from inside as
19:39
McElroy walk the perimeter with a shotgun.
19:41
He fired it into the air, left, came back, fired again.
19:45
She reported it, but no report was even filed.
19:49
No follow up was made by police. No interventions came and on
19:54
June 8th, 1980, Bo, Bo and Camp was working late at his store
19:58
when Ken McElroy arrived again. This time, though, it wasn't a
20:01
threat, he shot him. A young boy found Bo collapsed
20:05
inside of the store and called for help, and when police
20:08
arrived they asked him who did this and Bo answered
20:12
immediately. Ken McElroy.
20:15
McElroy was arrested hours later.
20:17
He denied everything as usual, called his lawyer, posted bond.
20:21
He was released. That night, he and Trina were
20:23
seen at a local bar celebrating. Beau survived, but just barely.
20:28
And when he returned home, the intimidation didn't stop.
20:31
It escalated. Anyone who visited Beau was
20:35
threatened. A minister came to offer support
20:38
and received warning calls. Not only were the Bowen camps
20:43
being threatened, but they were being isolated from friends,
20:46
family, and any kind of comfort. Lois began writing to state
20:51
officials, begging for help. Are we to live in fear for the
20:55
rest of our lives? She asked them.
20:58
And yet, despite a shooting, a named attacker, and a town all
21:01
watching this unfold, Ken McElroy was still free.
21:07
He started telling people in bars that Beau had actually come
21:10
at him first with the knife that he used while cutting boxes,
21:14
that he'd been forced to act in self-defense.
21:18
But the story didn't really hold up, not to the people who knew
21:21
the timeline, But Ken wasn't really trying to convince
21:25
everyone. He was reinforcing something
21:28
subtly. The rules don't apply to me.
21:34
Then came the moment that made law enforcement uneasy.
21:38
McElroy walked up to the part time town Marshall, David
21:41
Dunbar, and asked him, Are you planning to testify against me?
21:46
And Dunbar said I might have to, and McElroy responded.
21:53
I'll kill anyone who tries to put me in jail.
21:56
Then he pulled a shotgun from out of his truck and pointed it
22:00
at the Marshall. That should have been the moment
22:03
where everything changed, but instead Dunbar simply calmed him
22:08
down. De escalated and called it in.
22:11
The response from the authorities was routine and
22:14
almost comical. Don't provoke McElroy, just keep
22:18
an eye on him. By Monday morning, Dunbar turned
22:22
in his badge. He had a family, and he
22:25
understood the direction that this was going.
22:28
If the system wasn't going to back him up, he was not going to
22:30
be the only one left standing in front of McElroy alone.
22:34
Later, he would learn that McElroy had also harassed the
22:38
state officer who arrested him, including drive by intimidation
22:41
attempts aimed at the officer's wife while the officer was on
22:45
duty. There was no boundary this guy
22:48
wasn't willing to cross. Meanwhile, his attorney,
22:51
McFadden, continue doing what he always did, moving the case,
22:55
delaying things, breaking things apart until it barely resembled
22:58
urgency anymore. The trial got moved 75 miles
23:02
away to Bethany, MO, and in June of 1981, it finally began.
23:07
The prosecutor was young, only a couple years out of law school,
23:11
but presented a very straightforward case.
23:13
Witnesses placed McElroy at the scene of the shooting.
23:15
The evidence was clear enough, even if the system wasn't.
23:18
The defense countered with the familiar tactics witnesses
23:21
brought in from Mcelroy's circle, claiming he was
23:24
elsewhere. Men who waited nearly nine
23:26
months to come forward with their version of events.
23:31
They couldn't explain the delay, but it didn't matter.
23:35
The jury deliberated quickly and for the first time and Mcelroy's
23:39
life, he was convicted. Assault second degree, two to
23:44
four years recommended. Ken Rex McElroy had just been
23:48
convicted of assault in connection with the shooting of
23:51
Beau Bowenkamp. For the first time in his 47
23:54
years, someone had found him guilty of something.
23:59
But in Skidmore, it didn't feel like justice.
24:02
It felt like this was just a delay because nothing even
24:06
changed about Mcelroy's behavior after the conviction.
24:10
If anything, it made him worse. He posted bail immediately, and
24:14
within days he was back in Skidmore.
24:17
Four days after his conviction, he walked into a local bar
24:20
carrying an M1 rifle with a sharpened bayonet.
24:24
He told people in the bar he was looking to sell it, but he
24:27
couldn't resist talking trash. Sitting there openly, He
24:33
described how he planned to kill Bo Bo and camp in detail in
24:37
front of witnesses, with Trina sitting beside him.
24:40
One man in the bar, retired farmer Pete Ward, walked out
24:44
immediately. He gathered other people.
24:46
They documented what they all heard, signed statements, went
24:50
to the authorities. They revoked his bail.
24:54
It should have been urgent, a convicted man openly threatening
24:59
to kill the person he had tried to kill before sitting armed in
25:03
public. The judge set the hearing to
25:07
discuss the bail revocation for five days later.
25:12
Even that wasn't the breaking point.
25:14
Not yet, because the town was preparing, People were
25:18
organizing. They were going to travel to
25:20
court, watching, waiting, hoping the system would finally do
25:25
something. Then came another delay.
25:29
The trial was pushed 10 more days.
25:32
McFadden had a scheduling conflict.
25:35
And in that gap, everything shifted.
25:39
People decided to gather in the Legion hall to coordinate
25:42
travel, to talk, to figure out what came next.
25:46
What they didn't know yet was the next chapter wasn't going to
25:48
be decided in a courtroom. It would happen on Main Street,
25:52
and the question really wasn't if something would happen, this
25:56
was just a win kind of thing. By the morning of the final
26:02
confrontation, about 60 people gathered at the local legion
26:05
hall. It started the way these things
26:07
often do in small towns. Quiet frustration spills into
26:10
conversation. People comparing stories,
26:12
shaking their heads, asking the same question they've been
26:14
asking for years. How is this still happening?
26:19
But this time, things felt different.
26:21
There was talk of finally bringing in outside help.
26:24
Someone suggested reaching out to the sheriff from nearby
26:27
Maryville. Someone believed that he might
26:31
actually listen. The idea wasn't revenge or
26:35
violence. They were actually talking about
26:37
protection, structure, anything that felt like a control on a
26:40
situation where they didn't have any.
26:43
According to Sheriff Danny Estes, the conversation that
26:46
morning even turned toward forming A informal town watch.
26:51
People asked if they were legally allowed to patrol each
26:53
other's homes and farms. This wasn't to confront anyone,
26:56
but they just wanted to feel safe again because by then,
27:01
safety and Skidmore was theoretical.
27:04
And while the group sat trying to figure out what they were
27:06
allowed to do, they were about to discover that the question
27:11
had already stopped being about what was allowable at all.
27:15
About an hour later, the idea of a town watch stopped mattering
27:20
entirely. What happened next has never
27:24
been confirmed in full. It's been reconstructed through
27:27
witness statements, law enforcement reports, and the
27:29
silence that followed. But somehow, Ken heard the town
27:33
was talking about him again that morning.
27:36
And true to pattern, he came into Skidmore anyway.
27:39
Just before 11 AM, he pulled his brand new Chevy Silverado onto
27:43
Main Street, parked in Plainview.
27:46
No hiding, not cautious in the slightest.
27:50
It was like he always wanted to be seen.
27:54
He wanted the reminder that it didn't matter if he had been
27:57
convicted. He was still moving freely
27:59
through a town that had spent years trying to stop him.
28:03
He and his wife, Trina McLeod, walked into the same bar they
28:05
always went to. He ordered a beer, Camel,
28:08
cigarettes, Rolaids. Ordinary motions.
28:11
Familiar habits. Almost casual.
28:14
As the Legion Hall meeting broke up, people filtered out onto
28:17
Main Street and saw his truck was there.
28:21
Word spread fast through the crowd.
28:23
By the time that Sheriff Estes left for his office in Nottaway
28:26
County, 15 miles away, the crowd had shifted.
28:31
They weren't scattering. They were converging.
28:34
Roughly 30 people stayed outside the bar.
28:37
Another 30 went inside. No one announced anything.
28:41
This wasn't coordinated. It just happened.
28:45
A presence, a pressure. People all standing still,
28:49
watching the door, watching the windows, watching the man inside
28:53
who defined their fear for years.
28:56
And Ken noticed it. Witnesses later said the
29:00
atmosphere changed. The conversation stopped.
29:03
The room got tighter after a while.
29:06
Ken got up, paid, and bought a six pack to go.
29:09
He walked outside, but the crowd didn't move. 45 people stood on
29:15
or near the street now, close enough to see, close enough that
29:19
everyone knew what was happening, even if nobody said
29:21
it. Trina got into the passenger
29:23
seat first. McElroy got behind the wheel.
29:26
He paused for a moment, long enough that several witnesses
29:30
described it the same way. Not rushed and not panicked.
29:35
It was deliberate, like he was aware of being observed and he
29:38
wanted to acknowledge it. Without speaking, he reached for
29:42
a cigarette. Someone said he even started to
29:45
light it, but he never finished. The shots rang out first from
29:49
the left, then several more from different directions.
29:52
The sound didn't come as one moment, it came as pieces
29:54
breaking apart in real time. People dropped, people ran,
29:59
others froze. Katrina's screams cut through
30:03
everything as she was pulled from the passenger side, covered
30:06
in her husband's blood, then chaos distance, then nothing.
30:12
By the time Sheriff Estes heard the call over the radio, he was
30:15
already miles away. He turned his car around
30:18
immediately and drove back towards Skidmore, and when he
30:20
arrived, Ken was sitting dead in the driver's seat of his
30:23
Silverado, bullet holes marking the truck like evidence of
30:27
something that had already finished happening.
30:32
After the shooting, Skidmore didn't erupt.
30:36
It went quiet. There were dozens of witnesses,
30:41
people in the street, people outside the bar, people close
30:43
enough to see everything unfold in real time.
30:46
And yet, as law enforcement began asking questions, the
30:49
story started to dissolve. No one saw anything.
30:54
Or at least, they wouldn't say they did.
30:56
The first round of interviews made it clear almost immediately
30:59
there was going to be no cooperation.
31:02
There was no hesitation, no confusion, just silence.
31:05
The state stepped in. Then federal agencies.
31:08
A task force of 23 officers from six different law enforcement
31:12
agencies was assembled to sort through what happened in a town
31:16
full of eyewitnesses. They brought in the men who have
31:19
been standing closest to the car.
31:21
They interviewed the witnesses one by one.
31:23
They set up a tip line, but nothing came in.
31:26
No statements, no leads and no names.
31:29
Missouri Sheriff Gary Howard later summarized it quite
31:33
simply. We had 35 leads and 35 leads,
31:37
said nothing and heard nothing. And the investigation stalled,
31:42
not because there were no witnesses, but because none of
31:45
them were willing to become one. On July 20th, Ken Rex McElroy
31:50
was buried in Saint Joseph, a deliberate decision to keep him
31:54
out of skin. More soil.
31:56
That same day, all evidence was handed to a county prosecutor.
32:00
Witness statements, autopsy findings, sheriff's testimony
32:03
from the Legion Hall meeting, everything that should have been
32:06
able to build a case. And the grand jury heard it.
32:09
The next day, Trina McLeod testified, So did the law
32:13
enforcement. So did townspeople who had been
32:15
standing feet away from the truck.
32:17
But there was no indictment. The conclusion was blunt.
32:20
McElroy had been killed by bullets fired by a person or
32:23
persons unknown. No arrests, no charges, no
32:27
names. Sort of a delicious irony.
32:32
Three weeks later, a state grand jury tried again. 15 meetings,
32:36
five weeks of testimony. They heard from witnesses, from
32:39
officers, from survivors of Mcelroy's violence.
32:42
They even revisited conflicting accounts involving a man named
32:47
Del Clement, whose name had surfaced in Trina's statement.
32:52
Some forensic evidence suggested proximity, but most witnesses
32:56
contradicted Del Clement being anywhere near.
33:01
The jury ultimately refused to indict.
33:04
Then it went to a federal level. The Department of Justice opened
33:07
an FBI investigation. Agents interviewed the same
33:11
witnesses in winter, then again in spring.
33:14
The answers never changed. I didn't see anything.
33:19
A federal grand jury followed. Same testimony, same outcome.
33:23
No one was ever charged, and by the fall of 1982, the prosecutor
33:27
closed it formally. There's not enough evidence with
33:30
which to establish guilty on a reasonable doubt.
33:33
And that was the end of the criminal case, not with
33:36
resolution, but exhaustion. In 1984, Mcelroy's widow fought
33:43
A wrongful death lawsuit against Nottaway County, the sheriff,
33:47
the mayor and every other person they thought they could connect
33:50
to the day it settled for 17,600 across all defendants.
33:55
No admission of guilt, just the quiet logic of cost versus time.
34:00
Years later, in 2001, Dell Clement would dismiss renewed
34:04
attention with blunt finality. Everything I ever said about it
34:09
has been said before. Inside Nottoway County, most
34:13
people eventually settled into the same pattern.
34:16
Avoidance. Not really denial, not
34:19
confession, just attempting distance away from the
34:22
situation. Even today, there is no agreed
34:25
upon version of who fired what shot, only theories, only
34:29
fragments. Some residents rejected the idea
34:32
of vigilante justice entirely, insisting no one at the Legion
34:36
hall had ever discussed anything violent, only protection.
34:39
Sheriff Estes himself maintained that virgin for many decades.
34:44
The outside observers rarely describe it that way, though.
34:47
They call this unresolved, a silence that survived every
34:51
investigation. Life after Skidmore split in
34:55
predictable ways. Trina McLeod remarried and left
34:58
Missouri. Mcelroy's children scattered
35:00
across the country. Most of the people involved
35:02
Asian to retirement, carrying versions of the story they were
35:05
willing to repeat, or some refusing to repeat it at all.
35:09
Bobo and Camp died a decade later.
35:11
Lois eventually served on the town council.
35:14
Romaine Henry lived until 2012. When asked about McElroy years
35:19
later, Lois Bowencamp didn't hesitate.
35:22
Her answers stayed consistent. The town is well rid of him.
35:26
Justice is served. But even Lois's words added
35:33
something more complicated beneath it.
35:37
Things should have never reached the point where someone had to
35:42
deal with Ken Rex McElroy on their own, and Skidmore never
35:49
really returned to what it was. The population shrank, attention
35:53
faded. The story remained.
35:55
To outsiders, it was a true crime case, a mystery, a moral
35:58
debate. To the people who stayed, it was
36:01
something else entirely, a memory that everyone agreed not
36:05
to fully look into. A town that couldn't stop one
36:08
man and then couldn't explain how he died.
36:12
So where does this leave us? Because this isn't really a case
36:15
you can neatly close. There's no final confession, no
36:17
verified shooter, no clean answer that ties everything
36:20
together with a bow. What happened in Skidmore forces
36:24
you into uncomfortable questions.
36:26
Was this justice? Was it what happens when justice
36:30
fails for too long? Was it inevitable that a man
36:33
like Ken Rex McElroy would eventually meet a moment like
36:36
this, when fear, frustration, and exhaustion all occupy the
36:40
same small stretch of Rd. And more importantly, what does
36:44
it say about a place when the system designed to protect it
36:46
becomes something that you can't trust?
36:49
Because the law didn't just fail to stop Miguel Roy in the eyes
36:54
of the people who live there, it failed to stop anything.
36:57
And when that happens, communities don't stop having
37:00
standards, they just start enforcing them from somewhere
37:04
else, silently, collectively, without ever agreeing to say it
37:10
out loud. And that's what sticks with you,
37:13
right? It's not just the violence, but
37:15
the coordination of silence that followed.
37:18
Dozens of witnesses, multiple investigations, state, federal,
37:23
and still no one could or would explain what happened.
37:28
There wasn't a lack of truth, just a refusal to carry it
37:30
forward. And maybe that's the most
37:32
unsettling part. Because if you follow this story
37:35
for long enough, you realize something strange.
37:38
The truth didn't really disappear.
37:40
It split every time someone was asked to speak.
37:43
It fractured again. More versions, more distance,
37:46
less clarity. Almost like the truth itself
37:48
stopped being one thing and became something that only
37:51
existed in places no one was willing to hold it.
37:54
The truth always leaves a trail, but in Skidmore, it didn't lead
37:57
to answers. It led to more trails and less
38:00
truth. So maybe the real question isn't
38:03
who pulled the trigger. Maybe it's what had to break in
38:06
order for a town full of people to decide that silence was safer
38:11
than certainty. I'm Brittany Ransom and this has
38:15
been When Killers Get caught And next week's episode is episode
38:20
100.