Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E036: Beyond the Fiscal Facade with Gary Brode
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation as we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:12having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class. We are having all annual
- 1:18maintenance fees for clients that secure their wealth before
- 1:21the next Bitcoin epoch. What you're telling me is that
- 1:25music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:28the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:33history of governors 1974198792972000.
- 1:40And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:42It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:44We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:51when we sell. And we're back with Gary Brod
- 1:57Gary, welcome back to the show. Thanks for having me.
- 2:01It's interesting times right now.
- 2:04There's competing narratives in the market right now, one of
- 2:09which we're going to open up the show with Jason Calacanis on the
- 2:13All In podcast last week, making the case that all is rosy, all
- 2:18is well and the economy is as strong as ever.
- 2:21Let's play it, Logan. Tons and tons of interesting
- 2:24topics on the docket. Markets are ripping jobs and
- 2:27inflation looking good as the Dow hits an all time high.
- 2:30Forget about soft landings, boys.
- 2:31Sentiment is now flipping to a market melt up.
- 2:33In 2024 the GDP numbers that just came out smashed at 3.3%
- 2:36year over year. In the fourth quarter
- 2:37expectations were just 2%. Dow and S&P 500 both hit all
- 2:41time highs in the past week. Dow's above 38,000, first time
- 2:44in history. The CPI number reasonable up 30
- 2:46basis points month over month, 3.4% from last year.
- 2:49Getting close to that 2% target And the jobs data beat
- 2:52expectations. 2023 jobs, not so bad at 2.7 million.
- 2:56It's the 5th strongest year for job increases since 2020.
- 2:59Real test will be of course this year we've seen a bunch of
- 3:00layoffs. We'll get to that later.
- 3:01Gas prices plummeted 40% from $5 a gallon in the summer of 2022.
- 3:05Now just $3 a gallon. And consumers are apparently
- 3:08feeling great about the economy. University of Michigan, which is
- 3:10the most respected report on consumer sentiment that
- 3:14increased in the past two months, the most since 1991.
- 3:20Just glad the University of Michigan, the most respected
- 3:23source for this material, has provided us with that context.
- 3:28Yeah. So I'm a Michigan grad and I
- 3:31would actually rather talk about the Michigan football team than
- 3:35the the consumer sentiment index, which I'm not sure is
- 3:38indicative of a whole lot. Congratulations, Congratulations
- 3:43on your first national title in many decades.
- 3:47I was actually in the Rose Bowl in 97 when they won it then.
- 3:51So you know, it's it's been too long, but not as long as people
- 3:55make it out to be. No, that must have been a fun
- 3:57time. It was.
- 3:59It was amazing to be there. Yeah, this isn't a football
- 4:02podcast though. It's a Bitcoin.
- 4:05Financial markets, podcasts. What do you think about Jason's
- 4:09comments there, Gary, because? Yeah.
- 4:13First of all I mean you have to admire his energy, right.
- 4:15I mean that was that was like somewhere between newscaster and
- 4:20guy who reads the disclaimer at the end of a drug commercial.
- 4:25So I, you know I I got to respect his energy.
- 4:30I I disagree with with some of his analysis.
- 4:33I was furiously taking notes while listening to the to the
- 4:37commentary which at the speed he was going was really impressive.
- 4:40But you know first of all the Dow is at all time highs.
- 4:43That is completely irrelevant. That's 30 some companies.
- 4:48I I don't know that the performance of you know 30 some
- 4:51companies is indicative of the economy.
- 4:54You know if we want to talk about the S&P 500 or the NASDAQ,
- 4:57I I think we should but I don't actually care that the Dow is at
- 4:59all time highs. The other thing is, there are
- 5:01some. Quirks in the way the the Dow
- 5:03is. Calculated most notably, it's a
- 5:06price index. And so as the price of stocks go
- 5:10up, they have a higher weighting in the index.
- 5:13And if one of the companies in the Dow ends up doing a stock
- 5:18split, they're weighting in, the index goes down.
- 5:21And so that's kind of a quirky way to calculate things that
- 5:23made sense 100 years ago on GDP. Yeah, that 3.3% number was
- 5:28certainly impressive, especially when everybody was looking for
- 5:312%. But the issue there is that was
- 5:33a manufactured number. I think, you know, we had GDP up
- 5:37by something like $1.5 trillion and that was up by $2 trillion.
- 5:41And so, you know, this is, I was actually just talking about this
- 5:46on the deep knowledge investing video version of the five
- 5:49things. But imagine for a minute that
- 5:52you're a typical, you know, median income person you're
- 5:56making. You know, maybe. $60,000 a year.
- 5:59And you know, in a particular quarter you decide to run up
- 6:02$15,000 of credit card debt annualizing to $60,000.
- 6:08And so you say, hey, this is like I'm earning $120,000 a
- 6:11year, except they're forgetting the fact that all they've done
- 6:14is pulled $15,000 of income or consumption rather forward in
- 6:19time. I don't know that the the
- 6:22government spending trillions and trillions of dollars, which
- 6:26raises GDP regardless of whether it produces any value or not, is
- 6:30really, I mean it's it's kind of a ridiculous way to calculate
- 6:33GDP. The thing is, I think we can
- 6:36expect that will continue for the rest of the year.
- 6:38It's an election year. No one wants to be responsible.
- 6:40No one in Congress rather or the White House wants to be
- 6:43responsible for somebody not getting their Stemis or their
- 6:47entitlements or, you know, whatever it is that that people
- 6:50feel like they want. So more of that will continue,
- 6:53but I don't know that that means the economy is in great shape.
- 6:57Regarding the the stock market, you know what we're seeing right
- 7:00now is 7 stocks price for perfection.
- 7:04You know, over the last year and a quarter, all of the
- 7:07performance of the S&P 500 has, yeah, there, there it is, right,
- 7:12has come from 7 stocks. And we just saw last night,
- 7:15Google and Microsoft announced absolutely fantastic numbers,
- 7:20but they didn't meet these really high expectations.
- 7:24These stocks were priced for perfection and based on
- 7:28expectations that they keep growing.
- 7:31And so, you know, Google was getting hammered.
- 7:33Microsoft was outperforming on a down day.
- 7:36But you know, last I looked, that stock was actually down the
- 7:39jobs number. That's kind of mixed news as
- 7:42well. Certainly having 9 million jobs
- 7:46available would indicate a healthy economy.
- 7:48Except a lot of these jobs aren't real, right?
- 7:50Companies just post them, but they're not really hiring.
- 7:53The job growth we've seen is really people taking second
- 7:56jobs. There's been a decrease in full
- 7:59time employment and those second jobs get get calculated.
- 8:03So if somebody is working a full time job and then you know they
- 8:07lose that job and they take on two-part time jobs, you know,
- 8:12one, it's unlikely they're going to be making the same amount of
- 8:15income. But more importantly, that
- 8:16counts as two jobs. Again, not it.
- 8:18When when you look at the the big picture jobs number, the
- 8:22headline number, it seems like a great economy.
- 8:25When you start to dig down into the details and realize that
- 8:28people are losing full time jobs and taking on multiple part time
- 8:32jobs, that to me doesn't seem like a really healthy economy.
- 8:37That's that's not what you'd see when things are continually
- 8:41getting better. The final thing is, yeah, gas
- 8:44prices are certainly down from where they were a year ago and
- 8:47two years ago. But you know, we're seeing a lot
- 8:50of geopolitical conflict and transportation issues that are
- 8:53causing the price of. Fuel to go up.
- 8:56And you know, I don't know if you guys saw this, but earlier
- 8:59this week the Saudis announced that they were stopping capital
- 9:03expenditures on another million barrels a day of capacity.
- 9:07That's going to be very hard to replace.
- 9:09So there are problems in the oil producing parts of the world and
- 9:13the United States, which for years was actually actually
- 9:16taken over for Saudi Arabia as the world's swing producer.
- 9:19Our energy policy which is not coherent at the moment is, is
- 9:24not encouraging US production and US refining.
- 9:30And so you know all of that I think is going to drive oil
- 9:32prices higher and gas prices are going to follow.
- 9:35None of that's going to be good for the people tracking the CPI.
- 9:39Wow, that was such a a cogent dismissal of the narrative from
- 9:44the All In podcast that just wants to see all time highs and
- 9:47doesn't care that it's about the currency being debased because
- 9:50of the expansion of the national debt, which they don't think is
- 9:52a problem. Yeah, it's it's perfect.
- 9:56Their solution is 100 year bonds.
- 9:58It's a It was a cogent, concise, perfect clip to share with our
- 10:02friends and family that we know believe that everything is all
- 10:05rosy in the economy. And that's where I was really
- 10:07happy to listen to that clip and then know that you're coming on
- 10:10the pod, because it was just a perfect description of Yep.
- 10:14Well, like, so let's juxtapose this.
- 10:16You have Jason's long rant, Gary's rebuttal, and then
- 10:21there's more data on top of that.
- 10:22So Logan, pull up the silent depression tweet that I sent out
- 10:25yesterday on the heels of this all in podcast was which
- 10:30launched last Friday. Open up the tweet that I quoted.
- 10:34We have all these layoff announcements that have happened
- 10:37so far this year. So PayPal has cut 9% of its
- 10:39workforce. GPS cut 12,000 rolls yesterday.
- 10:43This both happened yesterday. Throughout the month Microsoft
- 10:46has cut almost 2000 jobs. Twitch cut 35% of its workforce.
- 10:50Unity Software 25%. Brex 20%, Discord 17%.
- 10:54Wayfarer 13%. Riot Games, 11%, Duolingo, 10%,
- 10:58Rent the Runway 10%. eBay, BlackRock, Citigroup, Google and
- 11:03Amazon, all cutting material roles as well.
- 11:08And so you have this juxtaposition of the Dow at all
- 11:11time highs. These job numbers that are
- 11:14manufactured, as Gary explained, coming out rosy, GDP coming out
- 11:18rosy. And yet we have layoffs across
- 11:23the board. Many different sectors we have
- 11:27today. The New York Banking
- 11:29Corporation, which bought Signature Bank last year opened
- 11:3240% down. They reported a fourth quarter
- 11:35loss of $230 million and they were expected to have net income
- 11:40of the same amount around $230 million.
- 11:43It seems like the commercial real estate exposure that
- 11:46Signature Bank had, that New York, NY Bank absorbed is
- 11:53beginning to take them under. And so with the layoffs on top
- 11:58of that, you have what seems to be the tremors of another
- 12:01banking liquidity crisis coming to the fore there.
- 12:04There's clearly a mismatch between the reported numbers of
- 12:10how the economy is doing and the underlying the underlying
- 12:13economy. What's actually happening?
- 12:16Yeah. And and and as as Gary pointed
- 12:19out that you know it's an election year and it's not just
- 12:21any election year, it's it's a rather existential election year
- 12:26for the establishment. And that's everybody in power
- 12:28really because they're all afraid of orange man coming
- 12:30back. And so there's there's more than
- 12:34normal of a willingness to circle the wagons and defend the
- 12:39party line and that means making number go up in the stock
- 12:42markets. So I think that, you know, in in
- 12:45every election year there's that motivation from the White House,
- 12:48but it it might be stronger and more aligned across Washington
- 12:55and then the seats of power there this time around because
- 12:58of the threat of Donald Trump coming back and they and you
- 13:01know, they're afraid of that. Yeah.
- 13:03And that's actually an interesting topic because of
- 13:05what you just mentioned, Jesse, and then what Gary kind of
- 13:10glossed over because he was trying to give him some
- 13:11credibility. But in the sense of like let's
- 13:13not talk about if it's productive or not productive and
- 13:16where the capital goes or that, you know, the the trillion
- 13:19number he threw out in debt. But there's a whole angle of the
- 13:23numbers being cooked, whether it's the unemployment or two
- 13:25jobs, but there's also the private sector or from the
- 13:30government or the public sector getting that capital.
- 13:32And so I think we threw out a few weeks ago, there was like I
- 13:34think 100% increase in employment or in New York was in
- 13:39the public sector and then Illinois was like 53%.
- 13:44And so there's this notion or this idea that the growth in any
- 13:48of the GDP is actually related to the government spending as it
- 13:51relates to anything that they're spending on whether it's
- 13:53healthcare, you know municipal. And so that's another part that
- 13:57ties into what Jesse just referenced in like government or
- 14:00the actual election and you know, kind of cooking that in a
- 14:04different way. Yeah, that that part is
- 14:09absolutely true. It's not just that there's been
- 14:12GDP growth or that the GDP growth has been completely tied
- 14:15to government spending. It's that government spending
- 14:18and the jobs number, they're creating their own jobs, right?
- 14:21So they're basically manufacturing their own numbers,
- 14:24their own consensus. And one of the things that I
- 14:27consider to be particularly dishonest about this and
- 14:30government numbers are always dishonest.
- 14:32This isn't a Republican thing or a Democrat thing.
- 14:35Everybody always wants their numbers to look good and so the
- 14:38the numbers are adjusted and massaged in so many different
- 14:41ways to make them look better that you know, we would actually
- 14:44consider them to be lies. But but the trend that they have
- 14:50right now is they're actually just manufacturing their own
- 14:54numbers and they're lying about what, Yeah, there you go,
- 14:57healthcare growth government and remember government is half of
- 15:00healthcare spending. So that's that's a huge part of
- 15:04it as well. But basically the thing that I
- 15:09consider to be particularly dishonest is, you know, let's go
- 15:12back a few decades and what would happen is the government
- 15:16was largely funding itself through tax receipts.
- 15:20And that forced conversations at dinner tables across the entire
- 15:24country about the proper size of government and how we wanted to
- 15:27pay for it and how much we wanted to pay for it.
- 15:30And going back through history, even during the time of kings,
- 15:33if they wanted to go to war and they had to tax their people too
- 15:36much before that, they would lose the support of their
- 15:39people. And you know, as a king, you
- 15:41have a certain amount of leeway, but there's a point where you
- 15:43end up facing a revolt. And so we have all of this
- 15:48spending right now, but instead of funding it through taxes,
- 15:52which would cause people to say, is this good use of our money?
- 15:55Do we really want to pay for this?
- 15:57Is this a program that I'm in favor of?
- 15:59They're financing these programs through the Treasury Department,
- 16:03right. So Congress is engaging in
- 16:05trillions of dollars of excess spending.
- 16:07The Treasury Department monetizes it, and we are now
- 16:10paying for our excess spending not through taxes, but through
- 16:15inflation. And the thing that's
- 16:16particularly insidious about that is 1 Congress.
- 16:19They're acting like there are no limits to how much they can
- 16:23spend, right? They're going to overspend this
- 16:25year by $2 trillion. Why not $10 trillion next year
- 16:27and $20 trillion the year after that?
- 16:30Nobody really has to pay for. Why are we paying taxes at all?
- 16:33And and that's a, you know, a huge part of the problem.
- 16:35The other issue is that when people are taxed to pay for
- 16:39government programs that they don't benefit from or don't
- 16:42think have value, or they're not interested in, or they think are
- 16:45wrong, they know where to direct their anger.
- 16:48But the system that we have right now, it's really easy for
- 16:51the government to blame greedy corporations or supply chain
- 16:55issues. Now, does some of that matter?
- 16:57I don't know, maybe. But there's no question that we
- 17:00just had a massive increase in inflation directly tied to a
- 17:04massive increase in government spending.
- 17:07Basically, our government went full Ben Bernanke, who suggested
- 17:11we could and should stimulate the economy by throwing money
- 17:13out of helicopters. That's what we did.
- 17:16The result of that was inflation.
- 17:18And So what they're doing right now, and by they, I mean the
- 17:20government, Congress and the Treasury Department is they're
- 17:24hiding their spending. They're acting like there are no
- 17:26limits and they're hiding it, inflation and not taking
- 17:28responsibility for it. Yeah.
- 17:33And with the election year, nothing's probably going to get
- 17:36done which. Is.
- 17:38It's not going to change. No.
- 17:40And you had the with the last debt ceiling, right, they they
- 17:44pushed it to Q 1/20/25 and they'll be able to do anything
- 17:48about it and you could have a lady duck period as well.
- 17:51Which was a departure from how they've done it in the past.
- 17:54Because usually when they lift the debt ceiling, they set a new
- 17:57ceiling. But this time they they just
- 17:59suspended the ceiling for and to get us through the next election
- 18:02cycle, laying the groundwork for being able to have, you know, an
- 18:07expansion of deficit spending in 2024 to try to make everything
- 18:11look good through the election cycle.
- 18:14Yeah. That's a that's a great point
- 18:16Jesse. And one of the the key things
- 18:18here is to remember you know how they how they lie about this
- 18:22stuff. They it's it's it's kind of a
- 18:28complicated topic but you know they they tell us they're going
- 18:33to first of all you're you're right they they run this through
- 18:38the next election it's because they don't want to have a
- 18:41conversation. But these guys spent the
- 18:45different part of the two parties spent six months
- 18:47pretending that they were having a huge fight about cutting
- 18:51spending and gutting government spending and people were going
- 18:53to be you know homeless and but none of that's true.
- 18:56The the level of spending always goes up.
- 19:00It's just the Republicans wanted a slightly slower increase in
- 19:04growth than the Democrats wanted.
- 19:06But what we really need to do right now is cut spending.
- 19:09And so, you know, they're having, they're having this
- 19:11debate and pretending that they're talking about cutting
- 19:14spending. They're not.
- 19:15They're talking about a slow reduction in the rate of growth
- 19:18of spending. It's not the same thing.
- 19:20And the entire conversation takes place in a playing field
- 19:24that doesn't match the language that they're using.
- 19:28And they're using hyper politicized events like what's
- 19:31going on at the border to as bargaining chips during these
- 19:34spending negotiations. Looks like we're Saber rattling
- 19:40to potentially get into a couple more wars, at least at a time
- 19:43when our our weapons depot is as depleted as it has been in quite
- 19:49some time. Which if we, God forbid do get
- 19:53into more wars would would dictate more spending just to
- 19:57get our arsenal up to to go actually fight those wars.
- 20:00It's a complete mess right now and with that being said, we
- 20:05have big day today. Jerome Powell and the Fed the
- 20:08Federal Open Markets Committee meeting today.
- 20:11Gary, what are your thoughts on what they'll do, especially
- 20:13considering this New York Community Bancorp situation
- 20:18where it seems like a liquidity crisis can be popping up and the
- 20:22suspension of BTFP come March? Yeah.
- 20:27So one of the things we've been tracking for the last five
- 20:31quarters actually has been this inconsistent data.
- 20:35What we've seen is that the consumer is spending that
- 20:37inflation has while it's come down, is still running hot.
- 20:40And again, I'm using the CPI as a proxy for inflation.
- 20:43I actually think real inflation is experienced by most American
- 20:47families is higher than the CPI. You know, unless you guys want
- 20:49to tell me that your food costs are only up, you know, 1.6% in
- 20:54the last year. You know, my view is anybody who
- 20:57believes that hasn't been in a supermarket in a couple of
- 21:00years. But where we're seeing the
- 21:02stress in the economy is in the upstream part of it.
- 21:06The manufacturing numbers have been horrendous.
- 21:08The PCE has been coming down. And so, you know on the
- 21:13manufacturing side, the planning side, it looks like people are
- 21:17preparing for a recession. On the consumer side, people are
- 21:20spending like, you know, it's still the good times.
- 21:22They've got money to party or like they'll never have to pay
- 21:26their their debt again. My thinking is that with all of
- 21:31this inconsistent data that Powell and the Fed are likely to
- 21:36pause here, I think the people who are betting that they lower
- 21:39rates today are likely to be disappointed.
- 21:42I also think the people who are betting on six rate cuts or a
- 21:45total of 150 basis points of cuts this year are likely to be
- 21:49disappointed. Now look, you know, could the
- 21:53Fed come out in an hour and a half and say we're cutting by 25
- 21:55basis points? Sure.
- 21:56You know, right. As of this morning, Wall Street
- 21:58thought it was a 5050 bat. You know, I'm not 100% on it,
- 22:02but I think the most likely thing is that they hold pat for
- 22:05now. And if I'm wrong about the six
- 22:09rate cuts, if they really do cut 6 times, if they cut the Fed
- 22:12funds rate by 150 basis points, and I'm wrong about, my
- 22:16prediction will be less than that.
- 22:17It will be because we have an economy that's extremely weak
- 22:20and that's not going to be as good for the stock market as
- 22:22people think. No, just thinking here because
- 22:32what are your thoughts on the suspension of BTFP?
- 22:34Because it seems like the Fed with all their new facilities,
- 22:38they're attempting to plug a hole somewhere.
- 22:40They plug that hole and water comes out the other end.
- 22:42And it seems like with the BTFP particularly opened up this
- 22:47arbitrage trade that the banks were taking advantage of when
- 22:50they're able to get these these loans at par value and then put
- 22:54that money somewhere else and get a yield on it which was
- 22:57hindering the Fed's balance sheet and they decided to shut
- 23:01that down. And what does that mean?
- 23:03Like it seems like just based off this conversation so far,
- 23:07like the banking crisis is an afterthought.
- 23:09The potential of the banking crisis re emerging is an
- 23:12afterthought for for many people.
- 23:14And if that does re emerge, how, how does that disrupt the the
- 23:17plans of everybody? Yeah.
- 23:20So you're talking about the plans of everybody and
- 23:22unintended consequences and unintended consequences of
- 23:25policy is why I've always been against a centrally planned
- 23:29economy. It's why centrally planned
- 23:31economies rarely work. So, you know, what happened was
- 23:34the the Fed had this, you know, pretty much an emergency
- 23:38situation about a year ago. And what they wanted to do was
- 23:41provide liquidity to the banking system.
- 23:43OK, I get it. But The thing is they were
- 23:47acting in emergency mode and they came up with a plan that
- 23:50had unintended consequences, which was a risk free arbitrage,
- 23:53which is a fancy way of saying they basically were funding the
- 23:58banks with free money. They were charging the banks a
- 24:03lower interest rate than they were paying the banks.
- 24:05And So what the banks were doing is they were borrowing money at
- 24:08a low rate and then depositing money with the Fed and receiving
- 24:11a higher rate. And they had a risk free rate of
- 24:13return at the expense of the Federal Reserve.
- 24:15That was not the intention. And so, you know, I don't think
- 24:19it's crazy that they're unwinding it.
- 24:20But I think when you look at government policy or you know
- 24:25the Fed as a quasi government agency, the number of times how
- 24:29frequently we end up with negative unintended consequences
- 24:33from policy that's made, it happens really consistently and
- 24:37it's why we need more of a free market and less central bank or
- 24:41central planning direction in the economy.
- 24:46I do love how it's like the the voracious appetite of banks to
- 24:52make a profit come through in this particular anecdote of like
- 24:57basically the the the the banks are drowning and the
- 25:00government's like, oh, you guys need a life preserver.
- 25:02OK, here, I'll toss you this life preserver and the banks get
- 25:06the life preserver and they're like, well, I could sell this
- 25:08thing for 10 bucks. So they turn around and sell it
- 25:11and then they're drowning again and they say, oh, throw me
- 25:13another life preserver, I need help.
- 25:15And we're just caught in the cycle.
- 25:17It's particularly poetic almost. It's like an arrow barrel where
- 25:22the commercial banks particularly are like equity
- 25:24holders in the Federal Reserve and they're just completely
- 25:26taking advantage of it, hindering its ability to operate
- 25:29profitably and leading to all these negative externalities in
- 25:34that. It's like it's almost like a
- 25:37double edged sword where they're basically hurting the Fed with
- 25:43this arbitrage trade, but they're also exposing the weak
- 25:47spots, the where the unintended consequences exist.
- 25:50I don't know. I don't know if I'm articulating
- 25:52this, but it's like almost like a a snake eating its own tail at
- 25:55the end of the day, yeah. I I think a big part of this is
- 25:59the fact that the Fed has made it clear that they want these
- 26:03institutions to not fail. And So what we have is, and
- 26:07then, you know, when we have problems in the economy, people
- 26:10blame capitalism. This is not capitalism.
- 26:12This is corporatism. And we what we really need to do
- 26:16is somehow find a way to cut that link between the government
- 26:20and private business. We do need failure in the
- 26:23economy and keeping these zombie businesses alive, or having
- 26:26businesses that can only exist with a 0% fed funds rate or, you
- 26:32know, negative interest rates or government handouts or
- 26:35government backstops, you know that that doesn't lead to
- 26:39building any kind of wealth or prosperity in the long run.
- 26:42We're going to end up drowning in inflation.
- 26:45And you know, it's as unwise as I think it is for the consumer
- 26:50to be spending themselves into debt, particularly given what
- 26:53the banks charge on credit card debt or, you know, other kinds
- 26:56of debt. Fine, Fair enough.
- 26:58And it's easy for me to say that's unwise.
- 27:01But let's just take a step back and put yourself in the shoes
- 27:04of, you know, the regular American consumer, and you can
- 27:07understand why they might think it's a perfectly fine idea.
- 27:10They've seen corporations get bailed out.
- 27:12They've seen car companies get bailed out.
- 27:14They've seen the auto unions and their pensions get bailed out.
- 27:17Government agencies get bailed out of their budgetary problems
- 27:21and pension problems all the time.
- 27:23They've seen the banks get bailed out multiple times.
- 27:26They're looking at student loan bailouts.
- 27:28And people talk about debt cancellation.
- 27:30It is not cancellation. It is a transfer.
- 27:33The debt doesn't disappear. It simply gets transferred from
- 27:37the students or the former students, rather the graduates
- 27:40onto the American taxpayer, onto our government bill.
- 27:43Right? That that doesn't disappear.
- 27:44It's transferred. And so imagine you know you're a
- 27:47consumer and you're seeing with inflation the value of your
- 27:51savings being depleted every year, right?
- 27:53Maybe not the dollar amount, but what you can buy with those
- 27:56dollars and you see everybody else getting bailed out.
- 27:58And listen, I would never recommend that anyone listening
- 28:01to this spend yourself into debt and then declare bankruptcy,
- 28:04wash your hands and repeat. I think it's unwise to do that.
- 28:07But if you put yourself in the shoes of the American consumer
- 28:10and they look at everyone else getting bailed out and Congress
- 28:14and the Treasury taking aim at their savings accounts and
- 28:17making them worthless again, maybe not in aggregate dollar
- 28:21amount, but what they can purchase with those dollars, you
- 28:24can see why people might be willing to run up huge credit
- 28:27card debt and just say, you know what, we're going to make it
- 28:29somebody else's problem. Why am I the only one who has to
- 28:32be responsible? And a derivative of that is just
- 28:35the quality of life as we've seen the past, whatever it's
- 28:38year to 10 years, whether it's suicide and all the things
- 28:42associated with it, that as you you know, reduce the purchasing
- 28:46power of an individual, you you start to lose hope on week over
- 28:49week year over year on what you're working towards.
- 28:51And that's where the debt comes in and to a point where you just
- 28:53end up aimless because there's no there.
- 28:57Not that there's no hope, but there's this, like to Marty's
- 29:00point, the tail eating as you're effectively get to a point where
- 29:02you're like, what am I doing here?
- 29:06Yeah, there's there's no question it ends up becoming,
- 29:10like addictive behavior. We have huge amounts of deaths
- 29:13of despair. And if you look.
- 29:16At the the use of things like antidepressants, particularly in
- 29:19our big cities. They're huge numbers.
- 29:21And I'm not recommending that people who are not feeling all
- 29:24right or feeling depressed. I would never recommend that
- 29:28they not get help. But when we look at the these
- 29:30numbers, the statistics on it, it's not a sign of a healthy
- 29:35society. You know, I I, I have no idea if
- 29:38this is true, but I've read multiple times that 25% of the
- 29:42women in New York City are on antidepressants now.
- 29:45You know, should people who aren't feeling well get help?
- 29:47Yeah, absolutely. You know, if you're feeling
- 29:49depressed, anxious, whatever it is, if you're having difficulty
- 29:52coping, I think getting help is a great idea.
- 29:55But when you know 1/4 of your people are on brain altering
- 29:59chemicals, that's more of a societal problem.
- 30:02And you know how much of that's related to inflation?
- 30:05I don't know. There are multiple factors here.
- 30:06We haven't isolated it. But it's not.
- 30:09It's not a sign of of a society where people are feeling
- 30:14fulfilled and hopeful. Maybe switching gears on that
- 30:19though to a hopeful topic is one of the things I took away from
- 30:23our last conversation, Gary, was that you you articulated very
- 30:27well that where we're at is, is no different than where we've
- 30:30been before these cycles repeat and that there's ways to, I
- 30:33don't know, I don't know if benefit is the right word based
- 30:35on what we just described or you described talking about.
- 30:38But there's ways to make sure that you're protected and to
- 30:41play this situation whether it's from a business perspective or
- 30:43just an individual's purchasing power and investments.
- 30:46And I'd love to hear kind of how you're thinking about it and
- 30:48particularly with your, your clients that you referenced and
- 30:51your audience. Has anything changed or just to
- 30:55share like more color on that? Yeah, that's a great question.
- 30:59Look, one of the places where deep knowledge investing differs
- 31:02with some of the other firms that we, you know, partner with
- 31:06or compete with is you know we've seen over the last couple
- 31:09of years this narrative that you know we need 0% rates or lower
- 31:13rates so that the market will go up.
- 31:15And you know we're in a good market, a bad market and that's
- 31:19coming from kind of the indexed long only crowd, the asset
- 31:22gatherers who get a percentage and you know for them they just
- 31:27want the market to go up. And if it does, we're all
- 31:29getting richer and you know that's fine.
- 31:31But I don't know that that's skillful.
- 31:33What do you do when you're in a quote, UN quote bad market at
- 31:37deep knowledge investing? We don't believe in good markets
- 31:39or bad markets. If you know you think inflation
- 31:42is going to be a problem, you can prepare for that.
- 31:44If you think the market's going to go down, you can get
- 31:46defensive, you can reduce exposure, you can short
- 31:48something, you can be long volatility.
- 31:51There are all kinds of things that you can do to perform and
- 31:55make money in any market. And so you know, you're right.
- 31:58A lot of what we've talked about in the first part of this
- 32:00podcast has been very negative. But the fact that I think so
- 32:04much of our economic policy is unwise doesn't mean that as
- 32:08investors we can't take advantage of it and find ways to
- 32:11make money from it. And so, you know, if you're
- 32:13concerned about inflation, and I am owning things like gold, oil,
- 32:19energy, I love uranium right now.
- 32:21I think nuclear power, there's a huge supply demand imbalance
- 32:27right now in the uranium market. And then, you know, our favorite
- 32:30way to save in a an inflation Safeway is in Bitcoin.
- 32:36And that's a great response on that.
- 32:37If you're worried that the market's going to go down
- 32:40because you know, we've got 7 stocks that are priced for
- 32:43perfection and we saw huge growth numbers out of, you know,
- 32:47we're talking about Microsoft and Google, and the stocks are,
- 32:50you know, down. You know, that's that's going to
- 32:54be a rough thing. Apple, there's concern that
- 32:56they're going to have fewer iPhone sales, right, that their
- 33:00units are going to be down double digits this year.
- 33:04And so if you're worried about the market going in, you can own
- 33:07volatility, right? You can own the VIX, I, you
- 33:10know, I own VXX not in size of a tiny position and that you can
- 33:13also reduce exposure. You can short the market, right,
- 33:17You can go short or at least hedge out your equity exposure,
- 33:21which is one of my preferred ways to do it.
- 33:23There are stocks that I like, but I want to hedge out the
- 33:26market exposure and that take less market exposure while
- 33:30having exposure to the companies that I like.
- 33:33So there are all kinds of things you can do to benefit from what
- 33:36many would consider to be a bad or risky environment.
- 33:41Particularly digging into Bitcoin and your views on that,
- 33:44what are your thoughts on the ETF approvals and what impact
- 33:49that may or may not have on people's views of Bitcoin as we
- 33:53move through 2024? Yeah, big picture, I'm a fan of
- 33:58of the ETFs. Look I and I and I'm sure you
- 34:02guys are going to agree with this.
- 34:03If you want to own Bitcoin, your best option is to own it
- 34:08yourself. And self custody.
- 34:10Either you know on your own like I own and self custody my own
- 34:13Bitcoin or through a company like on RAMP Bitcoin where you
- 34:17can have you know multi factor authentication and spread the
- 34:23keys out. Right the way you guys do it.
- 34:26But the best way to do it is to own and self custody your own
- 34:30Bitcoin And that's great for people like us but there are
- 34:34issues for a lot of people for that.
- 34:37One is for some people it's confusing and they're afraid to
- 34:41do it and there's no 800 number to go.
- 34:43You can't call 1800 Bitcoin and ask to talk to your local branch
- 34:46manager, right. I mean, you're you can
- 34:48understand why somebody might be nervous going on, you know, say
- 34:52a crypto exchange, buying Bitcoin and then transferring
- 34:56that to, you know, a hard wallet and not knowing if it's going to
- 35:00get lost in transfer and knowing that if there's a problem,
- 35:02there's no one that you can call.
- 35:04I can see why people would be nervous from an institutional
- 35:07point of view. Pension funds, they can't own
- 35:10Bitcoin. There are lots of people with
- 35:12traditional brokerage accounts or family offices where they
- 35:16have rules that say you have to own something in a brokerage
- 35:19account in a traditional brokerage account.
- 35:22And so you know one of the key things that we we always say is
- 35:25Bitcoin is for everybody. It's not just for the 25 year
- 35:28old crypto punks, you know, it's also for your traditional asset
- 35:35management or hedge fund managers like me.
- 35:37It's for 80 year old grandmothers.
- 35:39It's for poor people in Venezuela or Argentina, you
- 35:43know, or Nigeria who can't save in their local currency, right?
- 35:48The use case for Bitcoin is enormous.
- 35:51And the thing that I like about the ETFs is it opens up
- 35:54ownership and accessibility to people who don't have or don't
- 35:59want to develop the technical skills to self custody, which,
- 36:03you know, I get it. It's it's hard for them not
- 36:07having anyone to call and you know for pension funds or
- 36:10traditional asset management firms where they can't own
- 36:13anything for compliance reasons outside of their brokerage
- 36:16account. Anything that makes Bitcoin more
- 36:18accessible, I think is long term, going to be a good thing.
- 36:23I think that articulates it really well.
- 36:25We, you know, we talked about how the ETFs make Bitcoin
- 36:29accessible to more capital. But you explain the mechanics of
- 36:32that that a lot of in a lot of these cases that there are
- 36:35prohibitions on what certain allocators can hold and how they
- 36:40can hold it. And the ETF solves for for a lot
- 36:43of those conditions and that's how it expands the the amount of
- 36:47capital that can access Bitcoin which is great ultimately it's
- 36:51great and and you know we agree with you that for people who can
- 36:56who are technical enough and confident enough to take on self
- 37:01custody that's a great situation.
- 37:03And you know everyone on this on this podcast is is doing that
- 37:08you know and also diversifying our how we're holding our coins
- 37:14with multi institution custody through on ramp because that's a
- 37:18great way to to have a a second set up for how you're custodying
- 37:22your Bitcoin that also retains the end users full control of
- 37:27that Bitcoin because of the the nature of multi institution
- 37:30custody where none of the key holders have unilateral control
- 37:33of the assets in that particular on chain vault and and anyway so
- 37:38you know that's the the the best way to do it but if you can't
- 37:41hold actual Bitcoin because you're a family office or a
- 37:46pension or whatever and and the ETF allows you to get some
- 37:51access to Bitcoin it comes with those risks that are inherent to
- 37:56the ETF of you know will BlackRock protect your rights to
- 38:03that Bitcoin. But but you at least have
- 38:06exposure to this asset so long as you know these terrible
- 38:09scenarios don't arise. And that's a a good thing on
- 38:13that and a great way for people to be dipping the everyone has
- 38:18to dip a toe into Bitcoin 1st. And that includes pensions.
- 38:22And you know they they they can dip a toe with BlackRock, start
- 38:26to learn more about it. Start to shape their investment.
- 38:29Theses around the the role of Bitcoin in an era after the last
- 38:3440 years of declining interest rates have meant the 6040
- 38:38portfolio has disproportionately performed and that that can't
- 38:42continue And so scarce assets might make more sense going
- 38:46forward. And having dipped a toe in the
- 38:49Black Rock ETF makes people more aware of that.
- 38:53It's all it's all good for Bitcoin in the end.
- 38:56Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 38:58exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 39:01about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 39:04allocation, we get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 39:09We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 39:12Top of funnel, it's a nice top of funnel first entry point for
- 39:17a lot of people. And I think bringing this back
- 39:21to the macro backdrop, I mean, Gary, you mentioned uranium as
- 39:26something that you're bullish on and that that is what we're
- 39:30shifting from pessimistic to optimistic views.
- 39:33That was really good to see. Earlier this week up in Canada,
- 39:37they announced that they're going to refurb one of their
- 39:39nuclear power plants. They were thinking about
- 39:41decommissioning. So it does seem like there is a
- 39:44massive sea change in terms of the the view toward nuclear
- 39:49energy. I think the energy crisis in
- 39:51Europe a couple of years ago really woke people up that it
- 39:55was probably a bad idea to decommission a material amount
- 39:59of. Nuclear power plants in Germany,
- 40:02specifically France was thinking about going the same way.
- 40:04They made a pivot last year and said hey, we're not going to
- 40:07decommission, we may actually be building more and that leaves
- 40:11the US where we still seem a bit hamstrung here.
- 40:15Do you have any hope that we can wise up in terms to in terms of
- 40:20nuclear power generation here in the United States?
- 40:24I think it's something we should definitely be doing, basically,
- 40:29whether you believe in man made global warming, global weirding,
- 40:34climate change or not. Nuclear is the only technology
- 40:40that will get you base load generation capacity without a
- 40:44carbon footprint. And so it should satisfy
- 40:48everybody's needs for, you know, we, we have all of this
- 40:51discussion about the electrification of everything,
- 40:54the sense that we want to have, you know, electric cars and
- 40:59everything to be electrified. And and it's being sold to us as
- 41:05an environmental good. Now I will easily question the
- 41:10environmental impact of EVs, but if you believe that and you want
- 41:16that, the the issue is we don't have enough grid infrastructure
- 41:20for it and nobody's building it right now.
- 41:23Nobody's permitting it right now.
- 41:25And so if you want to have a decent quality of life, that
- 41:29means higher energy usage without having more carbon
- 41:33emissions. Nuclear is the option.
- 41:35The reason I think they're making that shift in Europe is
- 41:39because they realized that they had to and they had, you know,
- 41:42just ridiculous outcomes like, you know, in order to save the
- 41:47environment, they were burning coal and and lumber, right?
- 41:51They were burning coal and trees and that's, you know, if you
- 41:54want to reduce your carbon emission, that's sort of the
- 41:56worst way to do it. They also got bailed out last
- 42:01winter by an unusually warm winter, but a cold winter and
- 42:05they would have been in trouble. I think the issue here in the US
- 42:08is we haven't had that energy emergency with the exception of
- 42:13a few things. You know, like we saw the
- 42:15horrible cold snap in Texas last year or maybe it was two years
- 42:19ago that led to some massive problems.
- 42:22But we haven't really had widespread grid unavailability
- 42:27that's caused people to move. And I think a big part of the
- 42:33current energy policy is actually just to have people
- 42:36living at lower, a lower standard of living.
- 42:39I think the people in charge of this want there to be fewer
- 42:41people on the planet living at lower energy levels.
- 42:44And even though cheap, reliable nuclear power would not be an
- 42:49environmental problem by anybodies definition, they don't
- 42:53really want that. And so, you know, anytime you
- 42:56see somebody who says I'm an environmentalist, I'm very
- 42:59concerned about climate change and they're also against nuclear
- 43:03power, I I think it's reasonable to assume that what they're
- 43:06really against is human beings. And so until we weed that out,
- 43:09we're going to have some nutty energy policy, which is kind of
- 43:12where we are right now. Yeah, nutty energy policy.
- 43:17Who knows whether or not it was a direct reaction to Governor
- 43:21Abbott's actions at the border to defend the border against the
- 43:25federal government, Not against the federal government, but
- 43:29because the federal government was refusing to defend the
- 43:32border. But last week the Biden
- 43:34administration came out and essentially said we're not going
- 43:37to be building any more LNG export infrastructure moving
- 43:43forward. They're going to put the Knicks
- 43:45in that. Which is insane because United
- 43:49States LNG exports essentially saved Europe during their energy
- 43:52crisis a couple of years ago and has been one of the glaring
- 43:56bright spots of the US energy industry over the last five
- 43:59years. We've I I think we've increased
- 44:02our production by an order of magnitude in rather QuickTime.
- 44:06To think that they would actively prevent that market,
- 44:12which has a lot of demand globally from expanding is
- 44:14insane. It also makes us unreliable,
- 44:18right? It makes us an unreliable
- 44:20partner. The reason we were exporting was
- 44:22we were telling our European allies, do not get your energy
- 44:26from Russia, right? We, we want to try to limit the
- 44:31cash flow going to Russia, which they were using to fight a war
- 44:35in Ukraine, OK. And so, you know, our, our
- 44:38European allies and partners said, OK, great, thanks us,
- 44:41We'll get the energy from you instead of from Russia, which is
- 44:44a whole lot closer. And you know, there were
- 44:46pipelines and those got destroyed.
- 44:49And so, you know, when we tell them, don't rely on the
- 44:53Russians, we're here for you. And then a couple years later we
- 44:56say, yeah, we're done with that. It makes us unreliable.
- 45:03Yeah, go just. Go ahead, Michael, go ahead.
- 45:07No, I was just going to. A different direction.
- 45:09Yeah, I was thinking on the global macro beside Gary, how
- 45:14you're thinking about and just any color on what's going on in
- 45:17the Middle East with you know oil trade or potential
- 45:19disruptions there? And then also the little further
- 45:22E before the pod, I think you were resetting Marty and I were
- 45:26talking about the China stock market and some of the
- 45:28volatility that's happening around there.
- 45:30Any color that you could share that would be nice.
- 45:34Yeah, I don't know that I have a whole lot more to add on China
- 45:38than what's being discussed. I mean I think they have a lot
- 45:41of the same problems we do here, only really in size.
- 45:45You know their public sector and private sector are very tied
- 45:49together. They have huge amounts of debt
- 45:51in their system. Their banks are over leveraged.
- 45:53The big thing there is the Chinese tend to hold their
- 45:56wealth and property and you know there's there's just there's an
- 46:01oversupply of property and you know we just saw their largest
- 46:05property developer finally had to declare bankruptcy.
- 46:09These companies are are over leveraged and having you know
- 46:14they take deposits from people but they don't have the money to
- 46:17finish the construction and that leaves you know people with
- 46:20massive losses. So there are all kinds of issues
- 46:24that China has throughout their economy.
- 46:27Plus on top of that, you have a lot of companies that are trying
- 46:31to diversify their supply chains.
- 46:34They don't want to rely on China.
- 46:35They don't feel like China is a reliable partner and they're
- 46:39also tired of the, the technology exchange, right.
- 46:42I mean part of the, the issue when you do business in China is
- 46:45you have to give them access to your technology which a couple
- 46:48years later you end up seeing copies from Chinese companies
- 46:52you know and so people are looking for ways around that and
- 46:56none of that is going to be good for China which is a country
- 47:00that you know their economy really runs internally on
- 47:03property and externally on you know consumer product export
- 47:07growth. So I I think they're going to be
- 47:09facing problems for on both of those sides and those could be
- 47:12long term problems for them. China's always not confused me,
- 47:19but I just have no idea what's going on there at any given
- 47:22point in time. I mean, Evergrand was a hot
- 47:25topic in the news maybe a year or two ago, and it seemed like
- 47:29their collapse was imminent. They were able to extend that
- 47:32for a considerable amount of time.
- 47:35And I don't know, yeah, I could just never tell the the the
- 47:38Great Firewall is real in terms of actually having any sense of
- 47:43clarity into what's going on within the Chinese economy at
- 47:46any given point in time. There's definitely an
- 47:50information asymmetry. When I talk to friends of mine
- 47:53who are Chinese and go back to visit China, so much of what we
- 47:59see reported here in terms of Chinese use of slave labor,
- 48:06their practices of harvesting organs, a lot of the really vile
- 48:10things that the CCP does of the Chinese Communist Party does is
- 48:14not reported there. And and there is, believe it or
- 48:17not, information that you can get about China here in the US
- 48:21that the Chinese people don't have.
- 48:23The other side of it is, I'm told by again, my Chinese
- 48:27friends who are watching Chinese television in China that there's
- 48:31just this constant negative drum beat about the US and it is just
- 48:37wall to wall daily propaganda about how horrible the US is.
- 48:41Now, you know, if you're the CCP, you might claim that our
- 48:44media is doing the same to them, or our politicians are, And you
- 48:48know, that's fair. But it's not clear that there's
- 48:52any consistency of information. The information you get on
- 48:56different sides of the ocean are different, and it's not clear
- 49:00how serious they're going to be about addressing these problems
- 49:02in a way that fixes them. Yeah.
- 49:11So we bullish or bearish this year that's I guess that's
- 49:17because it's all like the I'm I'm most worried about this
- 49:20banking crisis re emerging. It seems like the liquidity
- 49:25situation is beginning to appear its head.
- 49:27If you look at the outflows of deposits from the small to
- 49:30regional banks, especially minus the BTFP program, it seems like
- 49:35people are flooding out in mass. Jesse.
- 49:38Yeah, I I think it's, I saw a great chart the other day and I
- 49:42should have saved it. But yeah, we're we're, we've
- 49:46been living in this really anomalous time the last two
- 49:48years with M2 contraction and in the last 50 years that hasn't
- 49:55happened. There hasn't been a red year in
- 49:58M2 money, the money supply growth.
- 50:04And so all of this is, is unusual and because of our
- 50:10system the way it's constructed we have to expand the the, the
- 50:15money supply it. It is necessary for us to switch
- 50:18back to growing that at some point here.
- 50:21Quite remarkable that you know I think because we because of the
- 50:25the massive expansion in 2020 and the COVID response, they
- 50:31have basically been pausing it and allowing you know the the,
- 50:39the normal curve to catch up to where the COVID response you
- 50:43know jumped the money supply up to.
- 50:46And we're kind of there now and you know things are reeling a
- 50:50little bit and at some point, you know and maybe it's an
- 50:55election year and maybe it's the the rolling off of the BTFP
- 50:59which has to be replaced by something else because otherwise
- 51:05every regional bank that's underwater, that has underwater
- 51:09securities is in deep trouble And so they have to do something
- 51:14and and and they'll they'll just come up with a more exotic way
- 51:17to obfuscate the fact that they're backstopping the banking
- 51:23sector. But anyway that all of these
- 51:26things are are on the horizon here between election year Fed
- 51:34cutting BTFP ending the need for another acronym to replace it in
- 51:43order to shore up the banking sector.
- 51:46So you know that I think in a funny way that the all in
- 51:50podcast at the start of the show is in some ways right that to be
- 51:54optimistic about where the stock market is going but for the
- 51:58wrong reasons because you know I don't Gary did a great job of
- 52:02enumerating how we're not looking at healthy economic
- 52:05signals. It's quite it's the contrary.
- 52:08But at the same time the need for monetary debasement,
- 52:13national debt expansion, deficit spending means that overall the,
- 52:20you know, the the money supply goes up and the stock market
- 52:22with it. Even if what's actually
- 52:25happening is that in real terms it's flat or or potentially even
- 52:30down, down in real terms which is what happened in the 70s,
- 52:35flat in in in real terms, down flat in nominal terms, down in
- 52:40real terms for a whole decade. And you know, so I I think I'm
- 52:45bullish on, I'm bullish on the money supply which which will be
- 52:52a departure from the last two years.
- 52:54And I think that kind of means I'm bullish on on the stock
- 52:58market for the wrong reasons and I'm certainly bullish on an
- 53:03increase, increase in the deficit in deficit spending,
- 53:10which you know is a continuation of the last six months really
- 53:13ever since the the nine months since the end of the debt
- 53:18ceiling or the suspension of the debt ceiling.
- 53:20So you know Marty, to your point at the beginning of the show, it
- 53:23is weird times. It's just it's it's really weird
- 53:27and we're all trying to figure out what the causes are and how
- 53:32to explain it all and and what to expect going forward.
- 53:34But it's all weird because we're in this era of debt expansion
- 53:41and monetary debasement causing everything to be funky.
- 53:45And you know, there's no good measuring stick in markets
- 53:50anymore and so everything goes up.
- 53:53Yeah. The thing I keep anchoring back
- 53:55to is the gravity changed. We were on a one planet where it
- 53:59was 10 percent to build a business or do anything on the
- 54:03debt and now we're at 5 or whatever.
- 54:05And what does that manifest itself and how weird does it get
- 54:07is effectively what this pod's been about.
- 54:09And that that clip from all in and we're still continuing to
- 54:13see what what's happening. I think that the Gary brought up
- 54:20the the grocery store. So it's such a great like angle
- 54:23because at the end of the day, the core of it, it's like when
- 54:26you need to like your purchasing power, all you care about is you
- 54:28can buy more eggs every week than less and that's effectively
- 54:31what you're going the opposite way with what's happening.
- 54:34But you look around like local restaurants and not only does
- 54:36the cost increase, almost everybody on this call like
- 54:40their local restaurants are either closing or there's a
- 54:42degradation in there like experience from all different
- 54:45whether it's like the inputs in the food to the prices to
- 54:47effectively they just like end up having to close up shop.
- 54:51And it's just like a small anecdote, but that like you can
- 54:53extrapolate that to all different things all the way up
- 54:55to, you know, Wall Street Journal.
- 54:57Their gravity's changed for a while and it got accelerated
- 54:59with the increase in, you know, the the cost of capital.
- 55:03So now they have to tolerate that.
- 55:05So yeah, the gravity. We're on a different planet
- 55:07right now, and people are going to catch up to it.
- 55:10Well, we're back to Earth right now.
- 55:11We're not on a different planet. This is the way things are
- 55:14supposed to. Now we'll get We'll get to Earth
- 55:16when the cost of capital is a a BTC.
- 55:19We're just we're just like we're falling back to earth.
- 55:21Maybe we're we're leaving different than the planet.
- 55:25I actually agree with you guys that it's an election year.
- 55:29The we are going to be flooded with liquidity all year.
- 55:33The one thing I would add though is I don't know that the
- 55:36Treasury and the Federal Reserve are as concerned about the
- 55:39failure of a few small banks as we might think that they would
- 55:42be. My thinking on this is if
- 55:46Washington DC had their way, we wouldn't have thousands of
- 55:52banks. They would prefer us to have
- 55:54half a dozen mega banks that were controlled by the
- 55:56government. And you know where you got a guy
- 55:59like Jamie Dimon, you can call him into the office and tell
- 56:01him, yeah, this is what we need you to do or you know, you want
- 56:04to stay in our good graces, follow this policy D platform,
- 56:07this person. More banks mean less control by
- 56:11the government of our financial lives.
- 56:13So I think if they had their way, they'd love to see a bunch
- 56:17of small bank failures as long as it didn't you know, ruin
- 56:20their stock market and and just have all of those assets
- 56:24transferred to half a dozen mega banks.
- 56:26And then you know you you have regulatory capture and they
- 56:31basically become the banking arm, the quasi governmental
- 56:35banking arm. Yeah, that makes it seems to be
- 56:40the plan since 2008. Even if you just look at the
- 56:43consolidations after the great financial crisis, it's just
- 56:47trending in this direction slowly but surely over time at a
- 56:50quicker pace at different points in time like last year and
- 56:53potentially this year. And Gary, I know you have to go
- 56:56prep for something, but one question I want to ask you
- 57:00before we wrap up here is another thing that's not really
- 57:03being talked about. But Janet Yellen announced last
- 57:06year that they were going to open up the buyback window for
- 57:09treasuries in 2024. Do you view that as a mechanism
- 57:13to mask falling demand in U.S. Treasuries, U.S. debt more
- 57:19broadly? You know, I'm not actually sure
- 57:23on that one. The one thing I do see Yellen
- 57:26and the Treasury doing that, I understand why they're doing it,
- 57:29but it's dangerous is they're shortening, sorry, shortening
- 57:32the duration on the the new issues, right, rolling over
- 57:37debt. So you know let's just say for a
- 57:39minute you have a billion dollars of you know 10 year debt
- 57:43that's come due and instead of refinancing that with 10 year
- 57:47debt, they're refinancing it with three month debt or six,
- 57:50six month debt. And I understand why they're
- 57:53doing this because the yield curve is, is such that they're
- 57:58sorry, it's not the yield curve. They're actually just expecting
- 58:01the Fed is going to reduce rates and so they'll be able to
- 58:04refinance that 10 year debt maybe a year from now at lower
- 58:08rates which you know it makes sense, I understand that.
- 58:10But the problem is what they're doing is reducing supply of the
- 58:15long term debt and increasing supply of the short term debt
- 58:18which by definition needs to be rolled over more often.
- 58:21And so if she keeps pursuing this policy and again I
- 58:25understand why they're doing it, but if they keep pursuing this
- 58:27policy, the size of the weekly auctions and the monthly
- 58:31auctions are going to continue to grow, right.
- 58:34Because if if you have 10 year debt that rolls over by
- 58:37definition once every 10 years and you replace that with three
- 58:40month or six month debt, you need to reissue that debt 20 to
- 58:4540 times more often. And that means larger and larger
- 58:48auctions. And so we saw last year there
- 58:51were a couple auctions that had some pretty bad tails.
- 58:54They weren't failed auctions, but they weren't a sign of a
- 58:57healthy bond market either. And if the bond vigilantes wake
- 59:01up and decide, hey, I don't really want to own, you know,
- 59:05treasuries at less than a 2% yield, I'm talking about real
- 59:09yield, not the nominal one, You know, after inflation or, you
- 59:13know, they become concerned about the dollar, then that
- 59:16problem will happen with larger and larger auctions.
- 59:19And they're giving themselves less room to maneuver by pushing
- 59:24the duration more toward the the auctions that are coming up
- 59:28sooner rather than out further. Unintended consequences seems to
- 59:34be a theme of all these actions. Yeah.
- 59:36Or in this case, I I think they know, I hope they know the risk
- 59:40they're taking. I think they're just willing to
- 59:42roll the dice and take the risk, right.
- 59:44And and we do see that at times. You know, Biden took a huge risk
- 59:51running down the SPR before the last election, the Strategic
- 59:54Petroleum Reserve. And you know, had there been a
- 59:58bad hurricane that had ripped through the Gulf and taken
- 1:00:01production and refining capacity offline, it would have been a
- 1:00:05disaster, right? Because we would have had a lack
- 1:00:07of supply, fuel prices would have spiked and it would have
- 1:00:10absolutely thrown the election the other direction by using the
- 1:00:14SPR to get fuel prices down. You know, they gambled on good
- 1:00:19weather. They got good weather and they
- 1:00:21got fuel prices down. And, you know, they had a much
- 1:00:23better election than anybody had expected, you know, in 22.
- 1:00:28So, you know, I don't know that for Yellen, its unintended
- 1:00:32consequences. I think she knows what she's
- 1:00:35doing. I hope.
- 1:00:36I hope she's aware of the risk she's taken.
- 1:00:38I think they're just willing to roll the dice and, you know,
- 1:00:41sort of hope it turns out OK. Yeah, that would explain what
- 1:00:49people were surmising toward the end of last year when you had
- 1:00:53the Jerome Powell and the Fed sort of shift their language to
- 1:00:59a Mordovich stance where she essentially banking on rate
- 1:01:03cuts, then they can refi 10 year bonds at lower rates at some
- 1:01:08point later this year, next year.
- 1:01:11Yeah, to me, the most interesting part of this whole
- 1:01:13drama is Congress and the Treasury Department are in a
- 1:01:19very quiet fight with the Federal Reserve.
- 1:01:21They're undoing everything Powell's trying to do, right?
- 1:01:24So Powell is they've they've done more than a trillion
- 1:01:27dollars of quantitative tightening.
- 1:01:29Granted, it was from a ridiculous $9 trillion number.
- 1:01:31It should have never been that high, but they have decreased
- 1:01:35the amount of liquidity in the system and then, you know, run
- 1:01:37rates from 0% to a much more reasonable, you know, where we
- 1:01:42now 5.3% on the Fed Funds rate. And he's trying to bring
- 1:01:46inflation and the money supply under control.
- 1:01:49That's what he's supposed to do. But Congress, they're spending
- 1:01:53an extra $2 trillion a year and running up an extra, you know,
- 1:01:57few trillion dollars of debt every year.
- 1:01:59That's going to get worse as interest expenses now spike to
- 1:02:01well over a trillion dollars a year and will continue to rise.
- 1:02:05And, you know, the Treasury is monetizing that.
- 1:02:07And so there's this really interesting quiet fight between
- 1:02:11the Fed trying to reduce the money supply and get inflation
- 1:02:14under control on one hand, and Congress and the Treasury, which
- 1:02:17are saying no, we are going to increase liquidity, increase
- 1:02:20spending, increase Fiat dollar creation, and just monetize
- 1:02:24everything. And who cares about inflation?
- 1:02:25Will blame that on somebody else.
- 1:02:27So watching these government institutions have this quiet
- 1:02:32fight out in public has been fascinating.
- 1:02:37They're supposed to be separate. That's supposed to be able to
- 1:02:41influence each other. You would think I I you know I
- 1:02:44can't prove it. I suspect they talk to each
- 1:02:46other. Yeah.
- 1:02:49It might. It might be on speed dial I
- 1:02:51think. Yeah, not even.
- 1:02:53I mean there's we have phone. Yeah, we we have seen photos of
- 1:02:58of Powell and Yellen in the same room before.
- 1:03:00So you know, theoretically, they at least you know, greet each
- 1:03:03other on a friendly basis. Gary, before wrapping, maybe if
- 1:03:06you wanna give a plug for anything you're working on, but
- 1:03:08also your El Salvador trip, any learnings from there?
- 1:03:10I know you're really excited about that trip if you wanna
- 1:03:14share any key learnings or insights.
- 1:03:16Yeah. So we don't have key learnings
- 1:03:19yet. I haven't left yet.
- 1:03:21But it hasn't happened. Sorry.
- 1:03:22I thought it happened OK. Yeah.
- 1:03:25No, no, no. I'm just back from the
- 1:03:26Philippines and Thailand, but within the next month I'm going
- 1:03:30to head to El Salvador. And I want to get a sense of how
- 1:03:34their lives and their economy has changed since adopting
- 1:03:39Bitcoin and going on the Bitcoin standard.
- 1:03:41You know, their crime rate is down a huge amount, their
- 1:03:43economy is improved. You know, this is one of these
- 1:03:47things where you can look at the government statistics, but I
- 1:03:50don't know that I necessarily believe that.
- 1:03:52I think there's huge value in going to these places and
- 1:03:55talking to the people who are living that experience.
- 1:03:58You know, whether it's somebody working in a hotel or a cab
- 1:04:01driver or somebody in a restaurant or you know, as
- 1:04:04everyone knows, you know, we we need to figure out how people
- 1:04:07are buying coffee because that does seem to be the test case
- 1:04:11for whether something's a currency or not.
- 1:04:13So you know, we need to go use Bitcoin to buy coffee, talk to
- 1:04:16the person who's making the coffee, you know, to prove that
- 1:04:18it is a currency. But I'm excited about it because
- 1:04:23I like having these experiences where you find out from people
- 1:04:25what their life is like. And last year I spent part of my
- 1:04:29winter in Buenos Aires. And you know, it's one thing
- 1:04:33we've all read for years, for decades about the issues that
- 1:04:37Argentina has had with inflation, with the peso, with
- 1:04:41their economy. But when you go there and you
- 1:04:44talk to the people there, I I spoke to people who run small
- 1:04:47businesses. I spoke to, you know, just
- 1:04:51friends who were trying to work there, or cab drivers or
- 1:04:55waiters. You really get a sense of how
- 1:04:58hard these people work to get out of pesos and convert their
- 1:05:03pesos into something that won't be losing 10% of its value every
- 1:05:06month. And when you read the stories on
- 1:05:11this stuff, you know, the thing that you don't get is how hard
- 1:05:13it is to rent an apartment in Buenos Aires.
- 1:05:16Because how do you set the rent, right.
- 1:05:19You learn how hard it is when you talk to them to buy a house
- 1:05:22there, because how do you, how do you have a mortgage right
- 1:05:25when your inflation rate is 120%?
- 1:05:27What do you do? You charge people 140%.
- 1:05:29But what if your inflation rate drops to 80%?
- 1:05:32Then you're killing the people who have the mortgage, but you
- 1:05:35know your inflation rate could go to 200%.
- 1:05:37And then the bank is losing money at certain levels.
- 1:05:40There's just no way to finance anything.
- 1:05:43And so people can't finance a home.
- 1:05:45They can't save for a home in pesos renting an apartment.
- 1:05:51You might have a three-year lease, but your rent is only
- 1:05:53guaranteed for the first six months.
- 1:05:55So try to imagine how do you live when one, the currency that
- 1:06:01you get paid in depreciates in value by 10% every month and
- 1:06:05two, you don't know what your rent will be 6 months from now,
- 1:06:10right? It's, I mean, the amount of
- 1:06:12effort and energy these people have to put into protecting
- 1:06:15themselves from the government abuse of their currency is
- 1:06:20exhausting. And you don't get that from
- 1:06:23reading the statistics. You don't get that from reading,
- 1:06:25oh, Argentina's economy grew by X percent or it contracted by Y
- 1:06:29percent. Their inflation rate is this,
- 1:06:31their CPI? Is that they're, you know,
- 1:06:33converting pesos to dollars, you know, went from this straight to
- 1:06:37that, right? Those are the dry statistics.
- 1:06:39When you get there and you talk to people and you start to
- 1:06:41understand what their lives are like, Some of the policies that
- 1:06:46the Argentinian government has, which you would have never known
- 1:06:49here in the US, actually prevent people from doing business
- 1:06:53legally. People need to have foreign
- 1:06:55subsidiaries in order to live up to the contracts that they have
- 1:06:59with their suppliers. And so because the government
- 1:07:04controls the supply of dollars in the economy and you can't pay
- 1:07:07for things in pesos or have contracts in pesos, these things
- 1:07:11create massive problems for people and they end up creating
- 1:07:15all of these quasi legal subsidiaries to manage it.
- 1:07:19And it's not until you really talk to them that you find that
- 1:07:21out. And So what I'm hoping is to go
- 1:07:24to El Salvador and have the same experience, but the opposite.
- 1:07:28I think you know where things in Argentina have gotten really
- 1:07:31bad, It would be fascinating to go to El Salvador and find out
- 1:07:35how their lives have changed. And I'm hoping to hear, you
- 1:07:38know, similar transformational stories, But I suspect that it
- 1:07:42may be a much more positive trip than the one to Argentina last
- 1:07:45winter. Yeah, the, the, the number that
- 1:07:49I remember from when El Salvador adopted Bitcoin as as a legal
- 1:07:54tender, it's that stuck out to me was I think it was like 24%
- 1:07:58of their GDP is remittances, international remittances mostly
- 1:08:03from the US And that because of the like fixed rate fees that
- 1:08:09they pay Western Union, they're losing 7% of that in transit or
- 1:08:167% of that of that total. So basically that Bitcoin, by
- 1:08:21adopting Bitcoin and replacing Western Union, they could boost
- 1:08:24their GDP 7%, so 1/4 of that 25% and and I wonder how much of
- 1:08:31that has happened. I think that learning curve is
- 1:08:35still significant to change that kind of behavior.
- 1:08:37But, you know, speaks to how big of an opportunity there is a low
- 1:08:41hanging fruit for boosting GDP by just cutting out
- 1:08:45intermediaries for, you know, for sending money from the US
- 1:08:49back home to El Salvador. That's a great point, Jesse.
- 1:08:52The one thing I do know is if you are a worker here in the US
- 1:08:59and you have family in El Salvador and you're sending
- 1:09:01money to them and you're losing 7% of your money on slippage,
- 1:09:06they will absolutely find a way to use Bitcoin or something
- 1:09:09else. If there is technology that
- 1:09:11allows them to avoid that, they will figure it out.
- 1:09:14Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:09:15I think I garbled it. I think it's like a effective
- 1:09:17rate of like 1/4 of you know, all the money that you're
- 1:09:21sending home. So, like, so that comes out to
- 1:09:24like 7% of, you know, from that 25% of their GDP, roughly.
- 1:09:30Yeah, so incredible. And that's because there's fixed
- 1:09:33fees and they're sending small amounts.
- 1:09:35They're extending $50 home at a time and you pay a fixed fee.
- 1:09:39That's how it gets eaten up. Yeah.
- 1:09:41And we have some insight at 10:31.
- 1:09:44It seems like that use case for strike is going a bit viral,
- 1:09:47where as soon as somebody does it once they can, it's like, oh,
- 1:09:51this is way better than what I was using before.
- 1:09:54And it's inevitable, just a a matter of time and and people
- 1:09:58telling people. Yeah, yeah, it's and the reverse
- 1:10:06diaspora that's happening too. I think that's an encouraging
- 1:10:09indicator that people are actually going back to El
- 1:10:11Salvador from the countries they fled to.
- 1:10:15It's just a good data point to be like, huh, Maybe things are
- 1:10:18getting better. People feel comfortable coming
- 1:10:21back. I'll let you country.
- 1:10:22I'll let you guys know in a few weeks.
- 1:10:24Yeah, Gary, we know you gotta go.
- 1:10:27We're over time here. Enjoy your trip to El Salvador.
- 1:10:30Thank you for joining us again, always bringing incredible
- 1:10:33insight to what's going on in markets and a different
- 1:10:37perspective than the Jason Calacanises of the world, so.
- 1:10:40Thanks guys. Thanks so much.
- 1:10:41Thanks so much for having me. Always great talking with you
- 1:10:44and I love what you're doing to make Bitcoin more accessible for
- 1:10:48institutional accounts, for large accounts and making it
- 1:10:51safer and finding different ways to make Bitcoin something that's
- 1:10:55usable by a larger percentage of the population.
- 1:10:58You know, I will always love talking to you guys just for
- 1:11:01that alone. Awesome.
- 1:11:03Thanks Gary for coming back before having you on again.
- 1:11:06Thanks. That's all we got this week.
- 1:11:07We'll see you guys next week.