Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / 2020 City EVs vs The Market
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Today's Explainer. We've got a really fascinating
- 0:03one for you. Today we are launching an
- 0:04exclusive investigation into a massive economic anomaly that's
- 0:08happening right under our noses in the automotive market.
- 0:11We're going to dig into the numbers, bust some pretty major
- 0:14myths and show you exactly what is really going on in the world
- 0:17of electric vehicles. So if you love a good
- 0:19data-driven mystery with some serious financial implications,
- 0:22well, you are in exactly the right place.
- 0:25It's a surprising hook, isn't it?
- 0:27I mean, right now, massive premium electric SU VS once
- 0:30packed to the absolute brim with cutting edge tech are crashing
- 0:34in resale value. I mean, they are plummeting.
- 0:36Yet the tiny, humble electric city cars that rolled off the
- 0:39production lines back in 2020, they're actually reigning
- 0:42supreme on the second hand market.
- 0:43So why is this happening? How are these little urban
- 0:46warriors totally defying the economic gravity that's pulling
- 0:48down the luxury giants? OK, let's dive into this.
- 0:52Here's our data-driven journey today.
- 0:54One, the 2020 city EV boom 2 driven real world mileage 3, the
- 1:01battery health truth 4 what owners really think and five,
- 1:05second hand market champions Section 1 the 2020 city EV boom.
- 1:11So 2020 was an absolute watershed moment.
- 1:14It was the year the market for small battery powered vehicles
- 1:17just completely exploded. We saw the arrival of these
- 1:21instant urban icons, right? Cars like the new Fiat 500 E,
- 1:25the Renault Twingos AE an incredibly popular Volkswagen EU
- 1:29alongside its Koda and Seat cousins.
- 1:32And the reason we're focusing specifically on that 2020 class
- 1:35today is because those vehicles have actually matured enough.
- 1:39Time has finally passed. We don't have to rely on those
- 1:42optimistic factory promises or, you know, laboratory estimates
- 1:45anymore. We finally have hard real world
- 1:48data straight from the streets of Europe on their mileage,
- 1:51their battery longevity and genuine owner satisfaction.
- 1:55Moving right along to Section 2 driven real world mileage, let's
- 2:00look at how these cars have actually been used over the last
- 2:03four to five years. Remember, unlike massive
- 2:06electric SUVs or those long haul corporate sedans, these city
- 2:10cars were born specifically for the urban and short range
- 2:13suburban environment. And according to European
- 2:16statistical data plus reports from major rental operators,
- 2:19these 2020 urban cars are averaging somewhere between 9000
- 2:23and 11,000 kilometers driven per year.
- 2:26So if you just do the math on the fleet registered back in
- 2:282020, we're looking at an accumulated average of about
- 2:3155,000 to 65,000 kilometers on their odometers today.
- 2:35But how they actually gathered those kilometers varies wildly.
- 2:39Now, what's really interesting about this slide is the clear
- 2:42split we're seeing in driver behavior.
- 2:44On one hand, we have the urbanites.
- 2:46These folks use the EV strictly as a second car for short office
- 2:50commutes, maybe grocery runs, sitting at a total of 35,000 to
- 2:5440,000 kilometers. But on the other hand, we have
- 2:56the commuters. These are people living out in
- 2:58the suburbs who quickly realized they could exploit really cheap
- 3:01home charging. They've been using these little
- 3:03cars for heavy daily commuting and have easily surpassed 80,000
- 3:07to 100,000 kilometers. Think about your own driving
- 3:09habits for a second. Where do you think you'd fit in?
- 3:12All right Section 3, The battery health truth We are about to
- 3:16bust wide open the absolute biggest fear buyers had back in
- 3:192020. The fear was always, will I have
- 3:22to throw this car in the trash after a few years because the
- 3:25battery is going to be completely dead?
- 3:27Well, the answer from the field is a resounding definitive no.
- 3:32Honestly, the numbers are staggering.
- 3:34According to durability tests from the German tube and
- 3:37recurrent data, after hitting about 60,000 kilometers, the
- 3:40battery state of health remains incredibly high.
- 3:43We're talking an average of between 92% and 95% of its
- 3:47original capacity. The data shows there was a
- 3:49slight initial degradation in the first two years, but then it
- 3:53just stabilized. Let's translate that percentage
- 3:56into actionable practical range so we can really grasp what that
- 3:59means. If you bought a 2020 city EV,
- 4:03they could drive 200 real world kilometers on a full charge when
- 4:06it was brand new. Today, four years later, it's
- 4:09still comfortably drives 185 to 190 kilometers.
- 4:14These cars are incredibly resilient.
- 4:16They are far, far away from the scrap yard.
- 4:18Section 4 What owners really think European reliability and
- 4:22satisfaction rankings like the famous What Car Reliability
- 4:26Survey, put these small electrics at the absolute top of
- 4:29their categories. Models like the Mini Cooper SE
- 4:31and the VWE Up are hitting staggering 95 to 98% reliability
- 4:36ratings. But let's break down the
- 4:37specifics. Let's look at the unexpected
- 4:40joys owners are reporting. First off, if you can charge at
- 4:43home, your running costs are about 1/3 of an equivalent gas
- 4:46car and you have almost zero mechanical servicing.
- 4:48Second, the instant torque at traffic lights and the total
- 4:51silence makes city driving genuinely stress free.
- 4:54But here's the absolute wildest fact.
- 4:56At 60,000 kilometers, many owners haven't even touched
- 4:59their original brake pads because regenerative braking
- 5:02does all the heavy lifting by capturing energy.
- 5:04The second you lift your foot off the accelerator, your
- 5:07physical brakes are basically just there for decoration.
- 5:09But look, it's not all sunshine and we want to look at the data
- 5:13neutrally. Here are the real gripes.
- 5:16Ironically, the most common failure isn't the massive high
- 5:19tech traction battery at all. It's the old school 12 Volt
- 5:22service battery. You know, the one that runs the
- 5:24headlights and displays. It tends to die pretty quickly
- 5:27if the car just sits idle. Second gripe.
- 5:29Improvised Hwy. trips are painful.
- 5:32The aerodynamics of these little cars are frankly poor.
- 5:34At 130 kilometers per hour, they lack gears and they only
- 5:37tolerate slow 40 to 50 kilowatt fast charging.
- 5:41Finally, the winter chill using the heater, especially on models
- 5:44without a heat pump, can slash your range by 25 to 30%.
- 5:48The big take away, if you bought it knowing it's urban limits,
- 5:51you absolutely love it. If you try to make it your only
- 5:54car for summer Rd. trips, you'll probably pretty frustrated.
- 5:57And finally, Section 5 second hand market champions.
- 6:00It's time to look at the top used market performers and solve
- 6:03that mystery from the very beginning of our explainer.
- 6:06So the crucial point is this, why are they beating luxury SU
- 6:09VS? Well, it's because they're 200
- 6:11to 250 kilometer range is considered absolutely perfect
- 6:14for urban use today. While massive 2020 premium SU VS
- 6:18have seen their prices completely collapse, mostly due
- 6:21to rapid technological advancements that make them look
- 6:23totally outdated. The demand for affordable, easy
- 6:26to manage second cars is just sky high.
- 6:28The data completely justifies this economic paradox.
- 6:32Let's actually countdown the podium of the absolute champions
- 6:35that are retaining their value best against their 2020 purchase
- 6:38prices. In 3rd place, we've got the Mini
- 6:41Cooper SE, holding its value tightly between 16 and €20,000
- 6:45thanks to its premium status and fun driving dynamics.
- 6:49In second place, the Fiat 500 E with a 42 kWh battery.
- 6:53It is an undisputed style icon commanding 13 to €17,000 today
- 6:58and taking first place the Super efficient rationalists, the VWE
- 7:02Up, Skoda, Citigo and Seat Me Electric trio.
- 7:07And this brilliantly illustrates why that trio is sitting in
- 7:10first place. Just look at this quote.
- 7:12Owners practically drove for free for years back in 2020.
- 7:16With all the government incentives, you could buy a
- 7:18brand new VWE Up for around 12,000 to €14,000.
- 7:23Today, with 50,000 kilometers on the clock, they are being resold
- 7:27for between 11,000 and €13,500. Sellers are literally finding
- 7:32buyers in days by holding almost all of their original purchase
- 7:36value while costing a fraction of a gas car to run.
- 7:39It's just a phenomenal financial win.
- 7:41OK, before we wrap up, I want to give you 1 crucial piece of
- 7:44buying advice regarding another wildly popular 2020 model, the
- 7:48Renault Zowe. If you were shopping the second
- 7:51hand market right now, you absolutely must watch out for
- 7:54the battery scheme. Models with an owned battery
- 7:57hold a solid residual value of 12 to 14 point €5000.
- 8:01But models with the Flex rented battery, where you have to pay a
- 8:05separate monthly subscription fee just for the battery itself,
- 8:08those have plummeted to 8.5 to €10,000.
- 8:11Buyers today are actively avoiding those recurring fixed
- 8:14costs, so just know what you're looking at.
- 8:17And that brings us to the end of our investigation.
- 8:20I sincerely want to thank you all for joining me today to
- 8:23explore this data. I really hope you're walking
- 8:25away with a totally new perspective on the electric
- 8:27vehicle market, armed with the actual facts about real world
- 8:31range depreciation and exactly why these timey 2020 cars have
- 8:35become such massive financial champions.
- 8:37So I'm going to leave you with this final thought.
- 8:39Now that the great dying battery myth is completely busted, is
- 8:43your next Citi car going to have a plug?
- 8:45Let that sink in, thanks for learning with me, and I'll catch
- 8:48you in the next exlainer.