Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Sunday School Remix: Adam & Eve — Shame, Blame, and the Real Story
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, I've got a new
- 0:03idea I want to try out. I'm calling it Sunday school
- 0:06remix. We're going to take an old Bible
- 0:08story that you heard about in Sunday school and look at what
- 0:11it really has to say with to us today.
- 0:14Here we go. Welcome to the Together for Good
- 0:16podcast, a podcast created by Bethany Lutheran Church in
- 0:19Cherry Hills Village, Co and hosted by me, Pastor Nate
- 0:23Pricinger and Together for Good. Our goal is to provide
- 0:27practical, engaging content that supports you without
- 0:30expectations. Whether you're feeling
- 0:32disconnected from traditional religion or simply exploring
- 0:36what faith means in your life, we are here to walk alongside
- 0:39you. No matter where you are on your
- 0:41journey of faith, we're glad you're here.
- 0:44Welcome to Together for Good. Welcome to the Sunday School
- 0:47remix. I'm really excited to try this
- 0:50out because I've got a ton of ideas about Bible stories that
- 0:54we hear about and we learn about as kids, but I don't think we
- 0:57ever really mind the depths of them.
- 0:59And often what happens is we end up having a very different
- 1:04understanding about the main message of the story than what I
- 1:09think the texts are actually trying to say to us.
- 1:12Some of that is just because as a kid, you need to have simpler
- 1:16messages. And it's really hard, as we'll
- 1:18see today, to talk about things like guilt and shame and
- 1:21scapegoating. How are you going to do that in
- 1:24a first grade Sunday school class?
- 1:27But I also think that sometimes we just get maybe a little lazy,
- 1:31and we assume, like, yeah, that's the way I learned it this
- 1:33first time in my life. So that just has to be how it
- 1:36always is. Now, often times these stories
- 1:40have multiple ways of working on us.
- 1:43And so it's OK if you learned about it and it was more of a
- 1:46moral example in first grade. And then now today you can
- 1:50revisit that story and discover that God has been trying to tell
- 1:54you something totally new and different for your life.
- 1:58Now you see, this is a lot about how Lutheran's read the Bible.
- 2:02I shouldn't just say Lutheran's. I think a lot of denominations
- 2:05think about the Bible as the living Word of God, and so every
- 2:09time we pick it up, the Spirit is speaking through these
- 2:14ancient words in new ways to us. I make a lot of little short
- 2:19videos for social media. Maybe you've seen some of us
- 2:22where I just read a very short passage of Scripture and I
- 2:25always tell folks, this was written thousands of years ago,
- 2:29and yet I feel as if it was written exactly for us today.
- 2:34That's kind of the idea behind the living Word of God is that
- 2:38these words that were written in a particular moment in time, in
- 2:41a particular context for a particular purpose.
- 2:45We believe that the Holy Spirit is still working through those
- 2:48words, that it's a living word that can speak to our unique
- 2:54situation today, in 2025, next year, whatever might be
- 2:59happening, every time we pick it up, something new is being told
- 3:05to us. And that's why studying the
- 3:09Bible is a lifelong process. And not just studying it to, to
- 3:14learn about it because there is there's a lot of words there.
- 3:16There's a lot of details in there, but even more than that,
- 3:20there's a lot that it can teach us every time we pick it up.
- 3:24And depending on what group you're with, you can hear those
- 3:27words differently. I've talked about that on the
- 3:29podcast many times before, that reading the Bible in community
- 3:34is such a gift because the insights, the emotions, the life
- 3:39experiences of those reading it with you will cause you to hear
- 3:45those words and stories in a different way.
- 3:47And So what we're going to do today in this Sunday School
- 3:50remix episode is look at the story of Adam and Eve and the
- 3:55crafty serpent. This is in Genesis chapter 3,
- 4:00and I'm guessing it's a story you know really well.
- 4:02Let's review, shall we? Yes, Adam and Eve are in the
- 4:05garden and then Eve is tempted by this serpent who's Satan and
- 4:10eats the forbidden apple and it causes the complete downfall of
- 4:15all of humanity because of her unfaithfulness.
- 4:19Now forever, we are not living in the Garden of Eden.
- 4:22We have been kicked out of paradise.
- 4:24Paradise has been lost, to use a Steinbeckian phrase, and we are
- 4:29in deep trouble. OK, that's how the story often
- 4:34gets portrayed. And cute little children's
- 4:37cartoons and books. And some people talk about this
- 4:40as the fall of humanity. And that just becomes this crazy
- 4:46theological idea that the actions of these people in the
- 4:51garden, The Who knows how long ago, has forever caused the
- 4:58downfall of humanity. And then people talk about how
- 5:02Jesus needed to come along and redeem all of the original fall.
- 5:05There's some pretty cool theological stuff written about
- 5:08that. I don't want to Pooh, Pooh it.
- 5:09But today I want to look at this story a little more closely
- 5:13because there's a bunch of assumptions that we throw into
- 5:17this Bible story simply because that's the way that it was
- 5:21depicted in the Hanna Barbera cartoon that we all saw.
- 5:25First and foremost, it says that there was a crafty serpent, but
- 5:31it also tells us that this serpent ran across the ground.
- 5:34It was low to the ground. So it so it wasn't really a
- 5:37snake, even though that's what we always assumed.
- 5:39No, I had it had four legs. Well, I guess it doesn't tell us
- 5:42how many legs it had, but it had legs and it scurried about the
- 5:45ground. Then later in the story, part of
- 5:48God's punishment for everything that happens is God takes away
- 5:52the legs of the serpent and and then it's, you know, it slithers
- 5:55on the ground moving forward. The story was likely told to
- 5:58explain like why does snake slither on the ground?
- 6:00Like here's why the here's the etymology of what happened
- 6:05there. But additionally, the way that
- 6:08the story plays out is that it begins with, you know, paradise
- 6:12is wonderful, everything's great.
- 6:14And then one day the serpent went and talked to Eve.
- 6:18So apparently this serpent that wasn't quite a snake yet could
- 6:22talk. That's kind of cool, don't we
- 6:25don't spend a lot of time thinking about that.
- 6:27But also, it never says that this serpent was Satan.
- 6:32We've just attached that to it because it's the character in
- 6:35the story that elicits temptation.
- 6:38We assign it to Satan, the great tempter, but nowhere does it say
- 6:42that this was, you know, the adversary of God in animal form.
- 6:48Man, it's just interesting. Just show how we make these
- 6:51assumptions. And so the serpent comes along
- 6:53and says to Eve, like, hey, I think you should eat of the
- 6:57fruit from that one tree over there.
- 7:01And Eve is like, no, she says no, at first she says no, like
- 7:04that. That's the one tree we were told
- 7:06not to eat from. So someone's like, no, no, no,
- 7:09but but you really should. And Eve says, like we're told
- 7:13that if we eat of that tree, we will die.
- 7:16And the serpent says, no, no, no, your eyes will be opened.
- 7:21And what we're told is that the tree that they're discussing
- 7:24here is the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.
- 7:29Now, what an interesting little detail that we don't talk about
- 7:33in Sunday school. The knowledge of good and evil
- 7:38is the tree that God says that humans should not eat from.
- 7:43Why is that? And isn't it even more
- 7:46interesting that Eve says if we eat of that tree, we will become
- 7:50like God? And so here in the story we're
- 7:53hearing about, God needs to be the only one who gets to declare
- 8:00what is good and what is evil. That responsibility should not
- 8:06be left up to humans. This is what the story has been
- 8:10trying to tell us, and Eve says that if humans were to gain that
- 8:16power, death would be the result.
- 8:21Don't you see how poignant this story is for our world today?
- 8:27When humanity starts to take hold of the power of good and
- 8:34evil, death is often the result. When we take it on to ourselves
- 8:40to say they are the good people and they are the evil people who
- 8:43are deserving of death, death is the result.
- 8:47I think there's something incredibly wise about this
- 8:50ancient story for us today to consider the ways that when we
- 8:55get too caught up in getting to declare what is good and what is
- 8:59evil, yeah, that's a moment when we're trying to play God.
- 9:03That's a moment when we're committing idolatry would be the
- 9:06terms that the Bible uses. That's the sinful behavior here.
- 9:09We are trying to become like God.
- 9:12And that was Eve's chief concern when the serpent proposed eating
- 9:15of that fruit. Just like, no, I don't know,
- 9:16like, well, I don't, I don't want to become like God.
- 9:19I, I guess she doesn't really say that, but the serpent says
- 9:22that as the temptation. So the temptation has always
- 9:29been since the beginning of human history, humans will be
- 9:33tempted to want to become like God.
- 9:37And don't we see that playing out in so many ways in our world
- 9:40today, Whether we want to be more powerful, more in control,
- 9:47more masters of our own universe?
- 9:50And where is that getting us when we try to cling to control
- 9:54like that or insist on our own ways?
- 9:57I'm not sure it plays out too well for us in the end.
- 10:02Moving on in the story, though, eventually the serpent does
- 10:06convince Eve to eat of the fruit.
- 10:08And let's pause here. They never tell us it's an
- 10:11apple. That's just always what gets
- 10:13depicted. But they never actually tell us
- 10:16that one really cool thing that I, I don't know if it's true,
- 10:20but I mean, just thinking about where the story is likely taking
- 10:23place, it wasn't in the apple orchards that Johnny Appleseed
- 10:27frequented. There weren't a lot of apples
- 10:30growing. I mean, they don't know where
- 10:32the Garden of Eden was or even necessarily if it was a real
- 10:36place. That's a conversation for a
- 10:37longer podcast. But if this is the Middle East,
- 10:41yeah, not, not a ton of apple trees over there in, you know,
- 10:45Bethlehem. More likely, maybe this was a
- 10:48fig tree. And the reason I say that is
- 10:51because in Jesus's last hours, he takes time to curse a fig
- 10:58tree in Jerusalem. It's one of the first things he
- 11:01does after entering Jerusalem on the first day of the week or
- 11:06Holy Week. And I always thought that that
- 11:08was the weirdest story of just like Jesus.
- 11:09Jesus like had some pent up anger.
- 11:11He just needed to de stress by killing the fig tree.
- 11:15And then I ran awesome commentary of it.
- 11:18What if what this is, is Jesus cursing that original sin, the
- 11:27fig tree, the very place where humanity's downfall began?
- 11:33Isn't that the work that Jesus is trying to do and undo?
- 11:36I should say, during his journey to the cross and his
- 11:40resurrection, he is trying to undo the curse of sinfulness
- 11:44that has always played humanity, the the curse that originally
- 11:48began with a fig tree in the Garden of Eden.
- 11:51Perhaps I just think that that's a neat connection.
- 11:54And so whenever I picture this story in Genesis 3, I'm
- 11:58imagining A fig tree because again, it doesn't tell us it's
- 12:01just the forbidden fruit, not the forbidden apple from
- 12:04Washington state. I don't know.
- 12:07Anyways, Eve does eventually eat the fruit and then she hands it
- 12:12to Adam. That's what the Scripture tells.
- 12:15Let's just stop here. There has been so much over the
- 12:19history of the Christian Church that has been patriarchal and
- 12:23manner. A lot of that is because of the
- 12:25cultural settings of the time, but often times people have used
- 12:30the Bible to try and defend these viewpoints.
- 12:33Like no, like men are in charge because Eve ate the forbidden
- 12:36fruit. Hold up for one second.
- 12:38If you read the story for what's there rather than watching the
- 12:42Hanna Barbera cartoon. Yes Eve may have been the one
- 12:45who originally ate the fruit. Yes, Eve may have been the one
- 12:48who this had the conversation with with the serpent.
- 12:52But it really seems like Adam was just standing by the entire
- 12:57time and he never objects to any of this.
- 13:02He just is standing there and Eve eats the fruit and then she
- 13:05handed it to Adam and he ate. That's what the Bible says.
- 13:07So he's right there. He's not objecting to any of
- 13:11this. Why do we blame it all on Eve?
- 13:14Doesn't seem real fair to me. Adam seems like a really passive
- 13:18bystander who really, you know, if if we're weren't going to be
- 13:22blaming it all on evil, maybe Adam could have done a little
- 13:25more to help his cause here, but I digress.
- 13:29So they eat the fruit and then it says that their eyes were
- 13:34opened. So something happened.
- 13:37They have gained now the knowledge of good and evil.
- 13:42But what's so fascinating is the what they do next after this,
- 13:48because immediately after gaining the knowledge of good
- 13:51and evil, the ability to say what is good and what is bad,
- 13:56they covered themselves with fig leaves.
- 13:59Mind you, that's what the Scripture says.
- 14:01Also, why maybe this is a fig tree.
- 14:03They use fig trees, fig leaves to cover themselves.
- 14:07And so I think it's so fascinating that when Adam and
- 14:11Eve have their eyes opened and they gain this godly knowledge
- 14:16of good and evil, their first response is a feeling of shame,
- 14:21because isn't that often how we use our current knowledge of
- 14:25good and evil? We call ourselves evil, bad,
- 14:29disgusting, gross. We turn this ability in on
- 14:34ourselves. When we gain the knowledge of
- 14:37good and evil, oftentimes the next result is shame.
- 14:43And so then after that, now that they are have covered
- 14:45themselves, they're walking around and God apparently is
- 14:48just walking through the garden. Apparently that is a thing that
- 14:50used to happen, just walking along and I'm taking a walk and
- 14:55God's like, oh, hey, Adam, what what's up?
- 14:57We haven't seen you in a minute. And Adam, it's like I like I'm
- 15:01I'm hiding from you. That's what Adam says.
- 15:04We were naked, so we hid from you God.
- 15:06And God's response is, Who told you you were naked?
- 15:11This is the moment that God figures out all that's happened.
- 15:14Like before this point, Adam and Eve lived without shame, without
- 15:19this feeling that they were less than or that they needed to be
- 15:23covered up, that there was something that shouldn't be
- 15:26shown about themselves. And God recognizes this.
- 15:31Who told you that you were naked?
- 15:35How did you come to bring on these feelings of shame and
- 15:39guilt on yourselves? And then the whole story comes
- 15:43out about what happens And, and it's really interesting.
- 15:47The next response that Adam and Eve have is to blame other
- 15:53people. So God's like, who told you
- 15:55naked? And it's all upset.
- 15:56And Adam's like, he made me do it.
- 15:59She she, she gave me the apple. Sorry, not the apple, the fig.
- 16:02And then he's like, no, no, like it was, it was the serpent God.
- 16:06It was your serpent that you made that made me do this.
- 16:09And so isn't that the second thing that often happens when we
- 16:13lay hold of this knowledge of good and evil?
- 16:16Yeah. We we turn the in on ourselves
- 16:18first for shame, and then we point the accusations to others
- 16:23in blame. This is what happens.
- 16:28This is the original sin, as the story has often been used to
- 16:35describe. Shame and blame, I would argue,
- 16:40are what the original sin is actually all about, and maybe
- 16:44even taking it a step before that.
- 16:47Idolatry is really the first original sin when we take it
- 16:53upon ourselves to think that we can be the arbiters of declaring
- 16:57what is good and what is evil. So often the way that that power
- 17:01gets used is to shame people and to blame people, turning it in
- 17:06on ourselves or turning it outward on someone else.
- 17:09And as Eve predicted, that causes death.
- 17:14Shame and blame are are the tools and the functions of this
- 17:18world that caused so much evil and so much suffering.
- 17:22As we try and scapegoat other people.
- 17:24This is like, oh, it's all their fault.
- 17:25This This is why our country isn't working anymore.
- 17:29It's all that people groups fault.
- 17:32This is why I wasn't able to advance in my career.
- 17:35It's because of that initiative or those individuals.
- 17:41We find ways to push it off on someone else because it's too
- 17:46much for us to bear. The evil is elsewhere.
- 17:50Or what can be even worse is when we turn that power in on
- 17:54ourselves to say gosh, like I am such a screw up.
- 17:57I can't do anything right. I have nothing to give and we
- 18:01just wallow in our shame. The story of the fall of
- 18:06humanity in Genesis 3. Adam and Eve in the forbidden
- 18:10fruit. This is a story about the very
- 18:14core of our human existence in that we are not created to be
- 18:19God. We need to trust in God to be
- 18:24the one who shows us what is good and what is evil.
- 18:28And beyond even that, we need to make sure that we are not
- 18:33falling into the original sins of shame and blame.
- 18:39God didn't create us to be ashamed of who we are or how
- 18:43we've been made, and God didn't create us to constantly be
- 18:48pointing the finger at other people and trying to blame them
- 18:51for our shortcomings. This is what this story has
- 18:55always been trying to tell us. I think it's so tragic that we
- 18:59get lost in the shuffle of it just being a children's story
- 19:02about how everything is Eve's fault.
- 19:06That doesn't do us any good. That doesn't allow for any self
- 19:08reflection. More than anything else, we need
- 19:12to be very careful when we use the power of good and evil
- 19:17because so often, as I've said throughout, blame and shame is
- 19:20the result. This has been a Sunday School
- 19:24remix conversation about Adam and Eve and Serpent in the fall
- 19:29of humanity and what it has to say to us today as we dig into
- 19:33its stories. I hope you enjoyed this.
- 19:35Maybe learn something new and got a new perspective on this
- 19:38old story. Share it with family members or
- 19:40friends who might be interested in learning more.
- 19:43I'm going to be new and more of these.
- 19:44I got a lot of ideas about Sunday school stories.
- 19:47There's more to come on it. As always, thanks for listening.
- 19:50Thanks for sharing, liking, commenting on this and as
- 19:53always, stay in peace. Thank you for listening to the
- 19:57Together for Good podcast. If you'd like more resources for
- 20:00your walk of faith, please visit our website bethanydenver.org or
- 20:05download our mobile app by searching Bethany Connect in
- 20:09your phones App Store.