Latest / I Thought This Would Be Simpler / Craft vs Enterprise | Tim Holmes | I Thought This Would Be Simpler
Transcript
- Andy: If building and exiting a business, immigration, and just trying to live a good life as a decent human have taught me anything, it's that I thought this would be simpler. Life is astoundingly, beautifully complex, and I want to talk about it. Welcome to I Thought This Would Be Simpler. Tim Holmes is my guest on this episode of I Thought This Would Be Simpler. And we're talking about building a craft versus building an enterprise. Tim works with founder-led and family businesses that have reached the point where growth, complexity, and succession or shared ownership require stronger governance, clearer leadership, better structures, and more effective boards. But navigating that from a human perspective. From an individual founder perspective, always proves interesting. So in this conversation, Tim and I are diving into the more human side of we thought that building businesses would be simpler, but there's actually so much complexity that comes with building a business to sell, building a business that's larger than you, or choosing to build a business that is crafted around you and your expertise. Enjoy. Tim Holmes, you have worked with a lot of organizations who thought building an enterprise would be simpler, but it wasn't. Let's talk about it. Tim Holmes: Sounds like a fantastic topic. So I started my career very similar to lot of the way a lot of other founders start or directors particularly start. So my role now is predominantly director working with entrepreneurs. Along the journey was I was an entrepreneur and built a couple of businesses. And I experienced a lot of what they've been through in terms of I was a director, but we never had board meetings. We just had a name on a card and we thought that was really cool. And then I moved to a space where I had lots of directors and I had no idea what they were supposed to be doing, helping me with. And it was a journey of trying to work out how on earth to get value from this. Now I'm working with a lot of founders, either as an advisor or if they've got started, then I may help them sit on their board. But what I'm seeing is the biggest shift is from the mindset of the founder, which is what we would call a craft mindset, where it's all about them, their creativity, their ability to make the decisions, their ability to put forward the strategy, drive the organization forward, et cetera, et cetera. And as you mentioned earlier, an enterprise. So that's actually the biggest trick that is making the mental shift from I'm building what is a craft business, even though I'm not aware of it, to actually building something which could be defined as being an enterprise. Andy: Craft mindset, I think all businesses that would eventually grow to become enterprises, or even Tim Holmes: Okay. Andy: those that don't, start as craft businesses. And that's important because that's where your founder has this idea. It's that scrappy image of us around a table in the garage, building something that's really going to change the world. And that matters. So that Craft is important because it feels like it's the catalyst for getting things moving. But there does there comes a time in the life stage of every company where you kind of reach this tipping point of this mindset needs to change. And what generally happens at that tipping point? Tim Holmes: They either are prepared to let go of the concept that I have to be CEO and do everything or they're not. And if they're not, then they just continue to build a bigger and bigger enterprise until the complexity gets to the point where they can't handle it and it either plateaus or it falls over or it blows up. There is also quite a lot of companies that don't start with only that mindset. And it may be luck, it may be intention, where they've gone in from day one, realizing they needed to build a team. So they've, by luck, managed to find a few partners, start together, and they have the team from day one who are basically equals, or they're bringing very specific skills to bear. Now you've already got specialists in that context, and you haven't got one person making all the decisions, which makes the transition. thousand times easier. But if it's one person making all the decisions, the biggest single problem is when you get so connected to the business, it is your baby, it's your life, it's your image, it's your persona, it's everything. And to the detriment of your family, to your friends and everyone else, you've put so much into this thing. And now in order for it to grow, you have to let go of a lot of that. So ego kicks in, life just... understanding of self kicks in, place in society, gets in the way of all of those things, other people's voices start to come to bear. And if you can't navigate that, then it's next to impossible to make that transition properly. And a lot of the companies just can't do it and they end up, and then the advice is we'll go back to running business, all about you and run it that way. Find people to help you, support you, knowing and understanding. that you may not be able to sell that business because if someone takes you out, there's very little left. Then you put your money somewhere else. You put it into property or you put it into shares or somewhere else, but you don't expect to be able to sell the business and retire on the money you're going to get from selling the business. So it's playing the right game. Are you playing the game of craft? Then play it and play it properly and be the best person you can be earning the most you can be per hour or building incredible IP that's going to live on without you and has value. but it's all about you, or you're going to be building something that's based on a team. And if you go on holiday for three months, it continues. Andy: there's also a beautiful realization in that that it is okay to build a business around craft, build it around build your business around you and stay in it. Not every business Tim Holmes: Yeah. Yeah. Andy: has to be built to sell or built for exit or built for global expansion. you know, we we have so much focus in our society on unicorns and all the unicorns, but what about the zebras? The zebras matter just as much because they're the volume. Tim Holmes: What about the impala? Andy: Yeah, them too. They're also welcome here. The whole Buck family. but I do think that there's a lot of well, for a founder, nothing can prepare you for the almost peeling away yourself from the organization when when you've built this thing, you've literally put your blood, your sweat, your tears, your soul, your spirit into it. That the self-awareness And the personal journey that you need to walk to now be able to divorce yourself from that for the betterment of the business is a massive journey. And I don't think that a lot of people realize the mental, physical, emotional, and spiritual toll that that takes on the founders. Tim Holmes: No, I don't think they do. Or they really aren't set up, they're just, their wishes from life are not set up to be in that other space. They actually prefer to be able to do everything and control everything themselves. And as we said just now, that's okay. But then you need to understand that and build that. But the rest is self-development, getting out of the way, being bigger than the business. expanding your mind, expanding your awareness, looking down on the business from above, not working in it, working on it. All of the things we hear people say all the time. That's the transition you have to make. And that can be really difficult and it'll need training, it'll need mentorship, it'll need a lot of letting go. And often that's really, really tough, really, really tough. And I don't think, as you said, most people underestimate how difficult that's going to be and how much support you actually need. to make that transition. I think that's why a lot of people are now joining networking organizations where there's lots of other entrepreneurs in the room, because then we can share that experience and doesn't feel so lonely. So it's not just me going through it, or I see someone else has gone through it already and they can give you some guidance and advice on how they did it and what they went through. And you can shortcut the process a little bit. You don't have to make an original Andy: Yeah, I think Tim Holmes: mistake. There is no such thing as an original mistake. Andy: Yeah. I love that analogy. There is no such thing as an original mistake. do you really believe that there are no no more original mistakes to be made? Tim Holmes: They probably are, but they're very few and far between. mean, you read, release philosophy from 2000 Andy: At least not in enterprise building. Tim Holmes: years ago. They're talking about exactly the same stuff we're struggling with now. So I don't think humans are very good at creating new, new things to go wrong. We've already done it before. just didn't learn from. Andy: Yeah, we've been failing to learn from our mistakes for hundreds of of years now. That idea of Tim Holmes: Yes, we think we'd have worked out that war leading to peace is not necessarily the best way of getting there. Andy: Y truly, you would think that we had learned we we might learn something from history, but there is a reason that history always repeats itself, right? It's yeah. That idea of getting out of the way and I think there is a profound moment in the life stage of many businesses where the founder starts to understand you come to this crossroads of either I now need to Get out of the way and create the space for this organization to thrive, not dependent on me, but with me, or this organization will always be dependent on me and this is that's the road that we're going on. But for the founders who start to kind of internalize that getting out of the way process, what does that moment generally look like for them in the experience that you've had? Tim Holmes: It's usually prompted by something that has forced them to change their mindset or forced them to reevaluate their priorities. much smaller percentage realize that they're not achieving what they want to achieve and they need to change and they go through a process of learning how to do that. Often it's an illness, it's a death in a family, it's... a divorce, it's a something that happens that goes, whoa, okay, I'm so committed to this business, I need to do something differently. I need to somehow free up time, free up energy, free up space, focus on my own health, all of those kind of things. Because as a business grows, if you believe that it's all about you, all that happens, you just work harder and harder and harder and longer and longer, longer hours. something's got to give. The only way you can shift is if you stop doing that and let someone else carry the load with you. So that's often why it's you just hit a wall or you're on the edge of the cliff and you're going, no, this actually what I'm doing day to day is leading to me to this path. I need to change something. Andy: Yeah, I know some founders who went down that path and it was only when they got to the point where there was a physical breakdown. I know someone who woke up one day and couldn't move. His body was just like, No, we physically cannot get out of bed. And for months he was not able to move. And that was the point where he suddenly realized something's gotta give because I also think we like to delude ourselves as founders that we are these endlessly energetic machines and that we can just keep pushing, pushing, pushing, but we're not. We're just as human as everybody else and just as fallible. And at some point the machine will fight back. Your body is going to be like, No, stop. Yeah. Tim Holmes: Yep, absolutely. I know far too many people who have pushed it to the point where they actually did fall over and they actually did pass away because of illnesses related to that stress. And others where they've had a massive shock, they've completely reinvented themselves and they've almost started again from scratch, but with a lot of learning along the way. And they do talks and they try and share that experience with other people to hope that someone will go, okay, I'll make that transition before it becomes a problem. rather than wait until the very edge of that cliff. Andy: And think that that is incredibly valuable to create that awareness for other founders. But I also in some ways wonder if everybody just has to learn to ride their own bicycle. You know. Tim Holmes: Yeah, well, I'm beginning to believe that is by my son when he was growing up until he hurt himself. He didn't learn from the no, don't do that. No, don't do that. No, that don't don't do that to the point where he actually had to burn his help himself on a bri. And when I tell stories, people go, you terrible parent. We were ready with ice, with lotions. We knew he was going to do it. We just stopped saying no and he did it and he never did it again. As soon as he saw that bri from the age of two onwards, Hot, hot, hot, ooh, ooh, hot, ooh, in there, hot, hot, hot. But he had to make the mistake for himself, otherwise he was never gonna live. Andy: And I think that's true for so much in life and also so much in business. It's sometimes we just have to pay the school fees and make our own mistakes and but I do also know there's value and I've been a part of a number of entrepreneurs networks, organizations for founders and that value in learning from one another and just also knowing that things that you're feeling, experiencing and navigating are not completely unique. And there's other people going through it as well is super meaningful. I want to shift a little bit because earlier you mentioned that some organizations get lucky or some founders get lucky in as soon as they start building, they start, they start with a team and they actually equip themselves to move from craft to enterprise much more easily. What are some of the success factors that you generally see that really help? Obviously, having a team is key. But even as a small group of founders, you can build for craft. So how do you as a small as a group, a team of founders, build for enterprise? Tim Holmes: So we use profiling, personality profiling quite a lot. We wrote a tool called Contribution Compass to specifically try and identify and understand whether that was the case or not. In other words, are all of the founders of a similar personality type or are they all different and complementary? And you can do it with all kinds of different profiling tools, but the one we wrote was specifically answer that question in the boardroom. The companies I've seen who have been successful, both large and small, they've somehow managed to start with, for example, someone who is the really creative person who is good at the sales building the brand, along with someone who is really good at the operations and making things happen and putting the processes in place, and someone else who is really good at the numbers. Often you have the founder is the salesperson and their wife does the numbers, for example. Now they may have got lucky and had a wife who's really good at numbers or they may not have been so lucky and she's not the right person to be doing the numbers. But at least starts to think about if I'm not good at that, who else can do it better than me? And I don't have to answer all the questions. I don't have to know everything. I can be vulnerable. I can let someone else work with something because they are, I know in my heart, but I may or may not be able to admit it. that they are actually way better at that thing than I am and ever will be. And the difficult one is letting go of the CEO role or MD role. Because so much of society is saying, oh, you started the business, why aren't you the CEO? There's so many people come up to me as a founder of Cerdo and say, well, aren't you the CEO? Well, no. Why would I want to be the CEO? I do advisory and I do workshops and I do the stuff I enjoy doing. What? I don't want to be CEO. cook something else with. Andy: That's the ego thing and the messaging that we're getting from society. And I think that that's so important to to call out and to be able to to say who says you have to be the CEO just because you started it? Tim Holmes: Yeah, yeah. And that's where when you bring a board in, the first responsibility of the board is to hire, be able to, unless they're going to, be able to hire and fire the CEO. So if you cannot imagine that happening, then you're definitely not going to end up with a board. And if you do, they're going to just follow your direction. They're going to not add the value that they could add because they can't add the value. They can't make sure the best person that could possibly be running the business is running the business. You're not allowing them that power, that freedom. Andy: And that needs to be the mandate of the board is to do what's best for the organization, irrespective Tim Holmes: legally. Andy: of yeah, l legally and also to be able to make sure that the right people are in the right places to move it forward. We used to do a lot of work with founders and leaders, leadership development work, the line that we always say was make it about the business. And this is it's such an important thing because especially when you've started the business, when you've been there from day zero, when you've put your blood, sweat and tears into it, when things happen, it's very personal. And when things go wrong, it's very personal. When somebody says to you, hey, listen, Andy, maybe it's time for somebody better qualified to be steering the ship, it's personal, but you have to make it about the business. What's best for moving the organization forward? And I think that becomes a very uncomfortable ground, but also what are you optimizing for? Are you optimizing for personal success and ego? Or are you optimizing for the success of the business? Tim Holmes: Also, are you optimizing for the best dividend you can get? That's not necessarily the best way forward either. Andy: Yep, and this is where I think. Tim Holmes: In that moment, you need to build a foundation or you need to keep working capital, whatever it might be. But if you're thinking without a shell to hat, you're going to make different decisions. Andy: Course, what what are you optimizing for in that time? Tim Holmes: Mm. Andy: And so for the organizations that now say, we need to put in a board. This is a very interesting process for me. because I've seen some interesting and very meaningful things happen with organizations who have boards, but also organizations who chose not to. So we now have an successful going concern where kind of getting traction, the rubber's meeting the road, and we say, okay, now we need to put in this board above us. What does that look like? We're we've bootstrapped it, so we're not taking outside capital. So it's not like we have a VC telling us what to do or how to go about this. What should these organizations be thinking about and what steps should they be taking? Tim Holmes: think the first step is to have a really deep self-reflection and see where is the gap in leadership and where do we best fill it. So the importance of the board is it's got the legal mandate, as you mentioned earlier, to do what's in the best interest of the business. But it's also a part-time role. It's not a full-time role. So if you need to build your executive team to run functional elements, then bring in an employee. If you need someone to help you with the strategy and how to take the business forward in the next steps and moving into different markets or going to a merchants and acquisitions phase or whatever it might be, then bring someone in at board level who's been there before because their intention is not for them to be there forever. Particularly as a non-exec director, the normal standard is three years and you look to rotate them. But it could even be a year or two years. It's why have you brought them in? and what is the value they're going to add, and then you pay them a director's fee to do their job. They are 24-7 legally liable for what goes on, so they're to be really sure they're going to make the best decisions possible. But it's a lot cheaper resource from a funding perspective and a cash-in-hand perspective than employing an executive. And you may end up finding you get a much better result because they're looking from the outside in. independently, seeing what you can't see, running through in their head what have they done before, how do we avoid this, as we would use, talk about avalanches because that's where the name Serdak comes from, from the lead Sherpa. Avoid the avalanche, bring, someone in that team who can pull you out the way because they've been there, they've done it, they can see it's going to happen, they can see the story unfolding. So you shortcut things, you move faster. you make better decisions, all of those things start to come into play. And if that's happening at the top of the company, then you're going to waste far less money. You're going to make much better decisions and you're potentially going to grow much faster than if everything's happening at the doing level. We need to get, we need to work on the business, not in it. And the board should be doing nothing else but working. on the business. It's that space where that's all you do for one, two, three, four, five hours is work on the business. Andy: so Howard Mann has a saying, you can't read the label from inside the jar and Yeah. Tim Holmes: Yes, I read that recently too. Very good statement. Andy: And as the executive team, you are as deeply in the jar as one can be, and your Tim Holmes: and Andy: board are not in the jar so that you can really help with that impartial perspective. They're not affected by the daily emails, the pings, the politics, the ins and outs of what's coming flying through your inbox every single day. Rather, they get to keep that broad spectrum view of what matters. How do we drive this forward? And I think that's so valuable to an organisation. Tim Holmes: And simple things like just testing assumptions. The assumption we made that got us here is not what's going to necessarily get us there. But because we haven't really taken the time to consider that or test that or look at a different perspective because we're so busy running, we miss things. Or we make a change way, way down the line when we could have saved ourselves a ton of money if we'd made it now. So it's simple things, it's not rocket science, it's just can you believe that there might be someone who knows a little bit more than you about something and then find out what something it is and then bring them in and make sure they're the right values fit of course and they've got basic skills they need to understand what their role's about but find someone who knows something you don't know and bring them in. Andy: Yeah, and leverage that. See it as an opportunity because there is massive opportunity in that. Tim Holmes: Now we look at the stats of boards and they say well who would you want removed? Very few say the independent director. They will say Andy: Interesting. Tim Holmes: something else because the independent directors been bought in for a specific reason. They know they've got a specific mandate. They know they need to be thinking independently and you rotate them if they're not performing. There's a process to do that refreshing and everything else. So they're not there for 20 years. They're not there because they're related to somebody. They're not there because they used to be an exec or are an exec. They're there to deliver a specific outcome. So they're adding value. They're adding value in the room and we know what that value is because that's why we put them in. Andy: How you go about establishing trust between so you have a founding team, let's say, who's been working to build this thing up? They've built something that's now, congratulations, the market wants more of what you're making. Your business is now scaling, the surface area of your business is expanding, and as you're scaling, complexity is creeping in further and further. So you start, you decide, okay, it's time to establish a board. But you've obviously got this founding team who speak their own language essentially because of what they've navigated together. And now you're bringing in a board above them to help move things forward faster and more structurally. How do you establish trust between those layers? Tim Holmes: So usually we need some kind of champion and if it's a majority shareholder or at least a shareholder it helps because if the shareholders don't buy into the change then the change is not going to happen. The next one is to try and make sure you've got the buy-in from the MD or CEO because they're the one that's going to affect the most and then you start with what you can. So I might join one of their meetings as an advisor and just help them understand that I may have a perspective that's different from theirs and I may or may not be able to add value. If I can't add value, well thanks for playing with no skin, nothing lost, we'll go off and do something else. Or we do maybe write a report that says, you answered all these questions, and from an external perspective, there's a few gaps here, and this is some things you can do to move forward and fix them. So it depends on, it tends enormously how much trust they already have, and... how open the individuals are to change. But you need at least one who's going to want to make the change and they have their ideas about why it's important. So it might have been triggered by an investor coming in. Now the investor wants to see the change. It might be triggered by the shareholder because they want to step out a little bit from operations and not quite sure how. It might be because the CEO is getting really frustrated with the other executives and has no way of understanding how to hold them accountable. There's multiple reasons why it must happen, but it usually, in our experience, starts with someone saying we need to do things differently. And let's start with training, conversation, some kind of advisory work, something that's soft enough that you just try it and see. Andy: Something comfortable enough to dip your toe into and go from there. Yeah, I get that. I think it's and I've I've worked with a lot of different leadership teams and It's when there is friction in the leadership team, especially in scaling organizations which are complex and noisy enough as it is, how that filters down across the organization to all employees and the knock on effects of that. So that alignment amongst the leadership team is so critical. And often what I've seen is it's the board that is able to step in and help to bring that team together, bring alignment and Because they are not inside the jar, they're you know, they're not reading the label from inside the jar as the board, they have a broader perspective that's I think sometimes meaningful because as the founder or as the founding team or as the executive team, you can get tunnel vision a lot of the time and it's easy to Tim Holmes: Very much so. Andy: lose sight of the bigger picture. Tim Holmes: There's an analogy, there's a wall in front of you, I think, there must be a wall. Well, no, it's over there or over there, it's not a wall anymore, it's something else. Just step back, have another different perspective, walk around it. the tree in the forest, all I can see is the tree, I can't see the forest, all that kind of stuff. We're just too close to the problem, we can't see around it. But I'm looking out from out here somewhere and I go, well, what's the problem? Just go around it, over it, under it, whatever. Andy: Yeah. But when but when you're standing with your nose against it, there is no you don't see it anyway around it. So how do you s help founders see the light essentially when there is a need for change and a need for structural shift or a board coming in? How do you help them see the light? Tim Holmes: I suppose it's an interview without being an interviewist, just ask questions to try and uncover what is it that you actually want? What would you like your future to be? And then where are you now to try and work out what the gap is between the two? And if it's anything to do with freeing your time, the opportunity to have more money, So a lot of entrepreneurs go into the business because they want to be their own boss. They want to have freedom. They're going to sell the business and retire. That happens very seldom. But most of that stuff happens very seldom. So it's trying to find out which one is the most important one. And that usually is a conversation list. We're just asking a few questions, getting to know their life, what their values are, what they like to do in their spare time. It's an interview kind of process. And we've had clients where literally the mandate for why we were putting a board in place was because the founder wanted to work 30 hours a week instead of 60. That was it. That was our goal. And he's now running four businesses and still not doing as much as 30 hours a week. So he's very happy. But that was his goal. Some is to sell in three to five years time. Some is to be able to take a holiday for two weeks without taking my cell phone with me. what is it that you need to do and then we'll try and work out what how's the the quickest and the most effective way to get there. In other words they must see either there's a big pain or a big pleasure that they're moving away from the pain or towards the pleasure it's natural human behavior basically. Andy: I like how you've just painted the the value of a board is and the impact of a board is flexible and it's definable by the organization, by the founder in terms of what is it that we're hoping to achieve. And that obviously also would impact how you stack your board. Who you are we trying to get to a point where we want to sell in three to five years? Cool. Who do we need to help us get there? I want to work 30 hours a week. Who do I need on the board to help me arrange my company and set things up that we can get to that point? I can imagine because you've also just alluded to the fact that you ask a lot of personal questions and try and understand the personal values, who is this founder and I get it. I worked in leadership development and employee experience and coaching for a very long time. So I understand why you would ask those questions. But I could imagine for the very business focused founder who's like, Tim, you're here to help me build my business to sell. And now you're asking them. Tim Holmes: No, no, no, you've built a business to sell. Okay, let's work with that. But there may be some other things that we need to talk about. Andy: Yeah. But how do you get them to go there? Because it's also important. You need to know the human that you're you're working with here. How do you get them to go to that uncomfortable place and talk to the personal stuff that they probably think is completely irrelevant? Tim Holmes: I'm always fascinated how much people will say about their business to a complete stranger. So just sitting and listening and covers all kinds of things. halfway through the conversations, oh God, I've never actually, I've never told anyone this. And you just carry on, go, you know, I usually start with quick summary just to get me up to speed. Tell me how you got to where you are and how you started the business. The reason being I want to know what were they trying to achieve by starting the business? And it may have been to make money. Then the next question is, well, has that shifted? Is it still just about making money or is there more sort of purpose to it? Do you get satisfaction from other things or are you still thrashing around just trying to make the money? Because they'll lead to different outcomes, they'll lead to a different approach. If it's all about making the money, get a consultant in to do a business process review or a marketing person in to work out your lead gen, that kind of thing. If it's something else, then there's a different approach. And it could just be, we just can't get our executive committee meetings to work properly. We're all over the place, we can't follow an agenda. I'm really getting frustrated, I don't know what to do. Well, let's start, I'll just be an independent chair for a couple of meetings and let's see what happens. So it's... Yeah, start with the story. What got you from where you started to where you are now? And I just went to a talk recently where someone I've known for a while, but I'd never heard his founder story before. And it was fascinating how many of the things we've talked about now he'd been through. Like he went into the business with his mother, his mother really struggled as the business got bigger to get out of this, just working harder and harder and harder and harder and harder until she got sick. Then he... then he went into a partnership knowing that he wasn't the best person to be a CEO. Like from, found the right partners, knew that wasn't the role he wanted to have or should have. And then just each time that you get to one of those really difficult points, he somehow got through it or rounded over it fairly quickly. And they've now got a huge, very successful business as a result. So yeah, I'll start with the story. In short, I'll start. Start with your founder's story and see where it takes us. Andy: I love founder stories. a lot of interesting stuff always bubbles up. To the board, the process. I know that in a lot of organizations, we love being the scrappy startup. We are entrepreneurial, we're free spirited, we can go in whatever direction we want. And as soon as we put a board in place, suddenly that's very icky and very corporate. And what is the knock on effect? How does that trickle down? in the organization. So I've worked with a lot of startups, a lot of scale ups. I love that transition, that growth phase that needs to happen with when we go from scrappy startup to scale up. But as soon as you start putting these governance structures right up top, people go, we're becoming a corporate. How do you navigate that through the business? Tim Holmes: So usually start with whatever's going to most add value the quickest. thinking about, literally just had the conversation yesterday, let's look at the organogram. What does the organogram look like now? And when you get to double the size you are, what would the organogram need to look like? we're going to have to have department heads. Okay. So how do we get from where we are to department heads? Let's just draw out what that might look like. We need to send someone who's in charge of operations. Okay. who might need to be below the person who's in charge of operations. What are the department names? Let's not put people in there yet. And then let's try and work out the people. And then, okay, wow, that person's got three roles. So are they a people person? Are they a process person? Or are they a data person? If we don't know, we can find out, but we need to know. Because if the role you want them in has got multiple of those facets in it, they're not gonna be able to do all of it well. But at least then you know that person needs to become three people. Because if that hasn't happened soon, we cannot move past them. They're going to hold us back. And then you have simple policies like, have you got a sick leave policy? it's not corporate. It saves you a ton of time every time someone fills in a sixth form or doesn't fill in the sixth form. Have you got a leave policy? No, no, we haven't got a leave policy. Well, just think about it. What? happens when someone wants to take time off. All of those kind of things are, you think, so stupid, must, that's so simple. But that's all governance is. It's lots of little, ways of putting some guardrails around things so people can bounce around in their playpen and do what they need. But if they get close to the edge, we can say, whoa, whoa, hold on, that's not, that's not acceptable. That's not what we do. That's not the way we do things around here. So all you're trying to do is put some kind of boundary. So, We don't do everything in this organization. We do that. Okay, what does that mean? And then what do we say no to? So there's been various videos, can't for life remember a name now, but she did a whole series and has written a box on what do you say no to is just as important as what you say yes to. So that transition for me is moving towards the space where we have much more clarity about what we say no to. And I've been through that journey with Serdar. We used to have a legal team. but we were never gonna be the best people at doing legal. So we let that go and focused on what happens in the boardroom and then bring other people in who can do the legal stuff, for example. So what do you say no to? And then how do you make things more streamlined so we don't waste time reinventing things? So the outcome of something is not accidental. There's some kind of reliability around. what might happen next. And you slowly pick up those and start with different departments and you build up the maturity as you go. Andy: And that's the core of it, is really building up the maturity. So I call it the chaos of scale, which, you know, when businesses get bigger and surface area gets bigger, complexity scales and it's noisy and complex. And I love the way you just framed governance because even I have a weird reaction to the word governance. but I also Tim Holmes: I know it's difficult not to use the word in our game but we have to find ways of not using it often because everyone just goes, ooh, Kevin, no, don't do that. Andy: I actually asked AI this today because we have that in our organization. People are like, ooh, governance. I don't want to talk about it. So I said, okay, this is what we need to do, this is what we need to achieve more of. But I don't want to use the word governance and AI suggested operating discipline. And I was like, Tim Holmes: There we go, it's good. Andy: Okay, I can work with that. So now I'm referring to governance as operating discipline. But what you just described it as You know, you're you're putting some guardrails and boundaries around what people can do. The way I always think about it is what we don't want to do is write the rule books. We don't want to tell people every little thing that they can and can't do. What we want to do rather is draw the playing field and say, this, this whole area, this is where you can make magic. Out of bounds is a problem, but on the playing field, go and make your magic. And that really is all that operating discipline. Is is drawing those playing fields. Tim Holmes: So one of the first slides I usually show in a workshop is a picture of the different balls that you might use for golf, tennis, rugby, whatever. Decide what game you're playing. Now, okay, we're playing a game. business is a game, yes, okay. Well, so a rugby game has a certain number of players, it has a certain size pitch, and different things happen in different places. But you know where the boundary is, and you run around, and there's some basic principles. that apply and some specific no-go rules that apply. That's all we're talking about. And interestingly, governance moved in the last, what, 20, 30 years from very rule-based to almost entirely principles-based. So there's a new, it's not new anymore, but it's new to most people, there's a governance standard that came out of the ISO organization. So it's the first governance standard I've ever done. And it's not prescriptive, it's It's a principles-based governance standard, the ISO 37000 standard. Andy: wow. Tim Holmes: It's the first one they've ever done. So you can't be certified against it, you just have to report against it and say, well, we did this, we didn't do that. It's principles-based. So it's thinking about Boundaries that make sense, it's values, it's the sort of fundamental laws that we live by. It's that this is the way we do things around here. Let's establish that for our company. That's all it is. And that comes to be in being through setting up some kind of policy, some kind of procedure, some kind of risk net that if we go too far over that, we have to stop and turn around and come back. or an alarm bell is going to go off or someone's going to die or, you know, it's simple stuff that we agree on that these are the things we do and don't do in this organization. But you can operate autonomously in your team, in that playpen, knock yourself out. And that builds that cohesion, but also that buy-in, that satisfaction, that team mindset, because we're all working together to achieve a particular outcome. And we don't have to worry too much about having to think about things that we don't really know or understand or aren't relevant. Because we've been told this is the boundaries of our roles and responsibilities. This is the flexibility we have within those roles and responsibilities. We've been given the authority to make the decisions in that space. And we've been given a mechanism to disclose to the rest of organization, this is what we've done or this is what we're doing. And then we just get on with it. Now I can hold you accountable. Andy: And that's exactly where my mind was going while you were talking is without any of these things, without these boundary lines, these definitions, what do we hold each other accountable to? What do we hold ourselves accountable to? And how do we measure success? If we don't know the direction of travel, if we don't know what game we're playing, how do we know if we've actually moved the needle at all? How do we know if we've achieved any form of success? I I really love the the sports analogies in business. I know that for people who don't enjoy sports, sports analogies in business are a struggle. But I think they work so, so well here. And I love what you do with the the different types of balls and understanding if we're playing tennis, we play tennis. You can't you don't play tennis on a rugby field and you don't play rugby on a tennis court. Tim Holmes: And it's two players and not 15 here. Andy: Yeah. I also think that when you start to talk about then organizational culture, employee experience, if we're playing rugby and this is the game, this is our definition of success, what kind of experience do we want to have playing it? How do we build our culture in alignment with that? How do we hold our leaders to, hey, as a leader on this rugby team in this organization, this is the way we play this game. And anything that's out of bounds, that's in bounds. But if you don't have that clarity of the operating discipline, you're kind of working in this murkiness. There's there's no firmness around what we want to hold people accountable to, what our expectations are of each other. So it's it's easy to get the ick from the governance side of things, but it actually brings massive value. Tim Holmes: Yeah, it does. As societies we work better if we've got some basic rules and we've agreed to them and we follow them. So why don't we just continue with that in business? Andy: Because we wanna be scrappy, sexy startups forever. We don't wanna have to grow up. Tim Holmes: Yes, well, that's the, again, you mentioned maturity earlier and I think that's what it comes down to. We can't be kids forever. At some point we need to adult up and the bigger the business and the more Andy: I know. Tim Holmes: at risk we need to adult up. Otherwise we want to play this game, which is fun and exciting, whatever, then you're going to start, you're going to end up with a fairly small organization and that's fine. Don't try and make it a massive organization because it's a different culture. It's a different experience. It's a different game. Andy: Which loops right back to where we started with decide what are you building. Are you going for Unicorn? Are you going for Zebra? Are you going for Impala? You know, are you building are you crafting or are you building the enterprise? And everything has to lead has to feed back into that decision, essentially. Tim Holmes: Yeah, very much so. Andy: Tim, as a closing question for this episode, okay, let me hypothesize. You've got a founder who knows something's not quite gelling. They know that they are needing a thinking partner, a direction partner. What is the first step that you would advise for them to take when they're thinking, I need some help here? Tim Holmes: Get a coach or a mentor. its personal development. Absolutely and all CEOs founders whatever should have a coach if we play the sport if we want to do well, the first thing we do is get a coach But why we why don't we do it in business? I don't there's this there's a stigma which is becoming less and less More and more people I know have got coaches and more and more people in sort of networking organizations Have heard enough times from other people who've got coaches that they've also got coaches and one of the most common one of the most common requests on like a needs and needs kind of page is, do you know a coach who does a... So it is really important. I've had a couple of coaches during my life. I've just finished a process because I've just turned 62. So I'm in that what happens next in phase three of my life. And the coach is really useful just to talk that through and work out what's important. What is it? How does it look? How is it different from what came before? You need someone else just to help you talk through that and then get clarity. Andy: It's that perspective partner. Actually, I'm drawing a direct parallel to the conversation that we've just had about board members being the people who are not inside the jar. You are as the founder, as yourself, Tim. You're deep inside the jar of your own life. And so having a coach or a mentor as somebody who's outside of the jar and can help you kind of climb to the rim and look around and make some decisions about where do we want to go, it's it's the same thing. That value is the same and We're not supposed to have it all figured out, have all the answers and know how to do this ourselves. Like there are people out there who can help. Tim Holmes: Yep, there always are. Half the time we just don't ask. Andy: Yeah, so just ask. That's that's I think the best place for people to start. Is don't have to navigate this alone. Tim, thank you so much. I really appreciate you sharing your insights, your experiences, and I thoroughly enjoyed this conversation. I enjoyed the different places we went into. And my hope is that we can get operating discipline to come in as a tastier Tim Holmes: you Andy: framing for governance. Tim Holmes: I'm probably gonna steal that phrase now. Thank you. I've been struggling to find an Andy: Go for it. Tim Holmes: alternative. That sounds like a really good place to start. Andy: Thank you so much, Tim. Tim Holmes: Thank you, thank you for the opportunity, it's been fun.