Latest / The Ball is Round / The Ball is Round - Episode 154 - CanWNT Step Up, CFMTL Postmortem Part 2
Transcript
- 0:01Hello everyone, I'm Hidi RFL and welcome for another episode of The Ball Is
- 0:05Round. Tonight on our show, Gabriel Chevet Interview with La Prez and Horizon
- 0:12twenty twenty seven, the postmartem on goalkeepers and defenders of the c F Montreal
- 0:18and of course, the women's national team finally beats Brazil in Halifax. That
- 0:24and a lot more on episode one hundred and fifty four of The Ball Is
- 0:28Round. And as usual, I cannot see it. It's in a while,
- 0:56So we're back, all the three of us. So hide, I'm
- 0:58here and I'm joined by my friends, so Eve Fowl and Elias gregoriadis friends.
- 1:03It's been a while. I'm so happy with the three of us here
- 1:07for the rest of the post Mortan. Eve, have you been ah hanging
- 1:11in there. Thanks to see you again. Very nice to see you too.
- 1:15Elias. We were here together last week with a special guest. This
- 1:19time no special guest, but the special guests are the three of us together
- 1:25exactly. The gang's all here. The gang's all here exactly, and I'm
- 1:30pretty sure you're super happy with Real Madrid. Lucy. Today they drew,
- 1:34they drew, theyre Yeah. Zero zero. Yeah, right, you're right,
- 1:38you know what, like with the way the Classical went, with the
- 1:40way the Classical went, and Barcelona winning yesterday, silver lining you know,
- 1:48within a game again Eve, what about the Wolves? What's going on chandling
- 1:57their intern classic Montreal impact with a late, late concession. Oh wow wow,
- 2:05So I'm prepared for it. At least. I I've lived through plenty
- 2:10of struggle in my soccer fandom, so no water off my back by this
- 2:17point. Tell me about it, tell me all about it. If Marsell
- 2:23hasn't been very good that you know, lately on and off the field,
- 2:29unfortunately, but but yeah zero zero again, still not doing so well in
- 2:35ninth position in the league with one game in hand. It's not going very
- 2:38very well. But at least you know, your Paeague is still here to
- 2:43to help us out a bit. So hopefully I'll be able to qualify from
- 2:46the group stage this time. So yeah, so let's dive right into it.
- 2:53We are here to stay. That's one of the questions. One of
- 2:58the quotes that Gabriel said in his interview with La Prez with Alexander Pratt and
- 3:06Jean Franco, the two journalists that really had an eighty minute eighty to ninety
- 3:12minute interview with Gabriel gaff which is very very interesting to see the president,
- 3:17you know, giving that much time to traditional media to have. I think
- 3:23we had like five or six texts around that that interview. I really loved
- 3:30everything that I that I that I read. Some are kind of controversial,
- 3:38let's say that way, but the rest was very very positive, right right,
- 3:40Elias, Yeah, I think honestly credit to both of them because you
- 3:46know, like you said, all the articles that stem from it were really
- 3:47really good, and I mean they're they're excellent writers in their own rights,
- 3:52So there was nothing too surprising about the quality of it. But just the
- 3:55fact that you know, we haven't had somebody sit down and give such a
- 4:00comprehensive uh just you know, laying out of the team's plans in such a
- 4:08long time. That that's why it felt more like news than anything else,
- 4:11is because we haven't seen anybody be this candid and be this straightforward with what
- 4:15the club wants to do and with not just like you know, oh,
- 4:18hopefully we get this some of the actual concrete plans that are you know,
- 4:23very close to being set in motion. So I think that, Uh,
- 4:26it's it's a very nice gesture, and it's a very nice, uh step
- 4:30in the right direction from the club on behalf of its you know, of
- 4:33its people in charge of communicating with uh, with the public, with the
- 4:38medias and everything. So hopefully that is becoming more of a trend and not
- 4:42a one off exactly. Hopefully it will be more of a trend. But
- 4:46you know what, It's funny because last week simple Guy asked us about all
- 4:50of those subjects, and you know, his prayers were finally answered just that,
- 4:56not even a week after, which is really really interesting. Uh,
- 5:00if do you think that the club since started his tenure is really moving toward
- 5:08forward in a way where you know, we can see a reconciation between one
- 5:15hundred percent of the fans and and the club. I'm saying towards one hundred
- 5:21I was going to say, you're never going to have a sad words.
- 5:26So what do you think about Is it positive or do you see a bit
- 5:29of flaws here and there? I think definitely last year, I think it
- 5:32was such an overwhelming sentiment of relief when he came in, you know,
- 5:39and did so much kind of like work on the ground with fans to really
- 5:43rebuild a lot of those those bridges that were broken, not all the way
- 5:47burnt necessarily, but definitely in need of some repair. You know, this
- 5:53year it's definitely been I think a little bit more complicated for him and for
- 5:57the for the team as a whole. Obviously, we're going to talk about
- 5:59lots of the sport sides of things in some of his comments as it relates
- 6:01to those topics as well. But I do think he's moving in the right
- 6:08direction. And I think, you know, we only have one other president
- 6:13to compare with in Montreal history, because of course the position didn't exist,
- 6:17and in that case, it's night and day. And I agree, And
- 6:24let's talk about the interview altogether. Of course, we're not going to be
- 6:27able to, you know, go into all the texts. I think one
- 6:30of the texts is the one that really that I like the most is the
- 6:33one where he talked about Horizon twenty twenty seven. So we're going to take
- 6:39a look at that in depth. To be honest, let's give a small
- 6:44recap of what is being said and we'll break it down piece by piece.
- 6:48So he said, first of all, Joey Saputo is more connected to the
- 6:51club than what you think, which is something that's very very interesting. He
- 6:58said also that you know, the club ratings has been up by nine percent,
- 7:06so people that are listening or hearing about the c F Montreal or watching
- 7:12the games and everything is about nine percent, up nine percent in the last
- 7:16year. Next year, there will be more than ten thousand season ticket holders
- 7:25next next year, which is a record for c F Montreal, and that
- 7:30CF Montreal has a big, big, big project, the renovation of the
- 7:34stadium. The analysis is already done and to give you an idea, what
- 7:42he said is that the club will be playing in another stadium for one or
- 7:49two seasons. That's a bit of a recap of everything that was said during
- 7:55that interview. So let's go piece by piece. Let's start with Joey.
- 7:58Luisaputo not here anymore, he is in Bologna, but as Gabrieve, he's
- 8:05more interested than ever. What the The way Gabrieve explained that was that he
- 8:13has full confidence in Gabriel andre Vievna to handle the project without him being here.
- 8:22And he also said, you know what, he has a lot of
- 8:24projects on his hands and right now he's needed elsewhere but he is in a
- 8:30constant communication with him, and then he finishes with a small job. It's
- 8:37a bit ironic. When he's here, we says he's here too much.
- 8:41When he's not here, we say that he's not here enough. So,
- 8:45if what do you think about these these quotes about the owner Joeys Apudo.
- 8:52I mean, obviously his presence has been for me, I think his presence
- 8:58in Montreal has usually meant the bad thing are on the horizon for the club.
- 9:05He there, we go can flip a word fear not no, but
- 9:13it usually yeah, his his hands on presence, you know, before the
- 9:16era of the president c if you will, before that position existed. I
- 9:22think we can say that his very very very close management wasn't necessarily what the
- 9:26club needed. Was after wasn't what it needed either, But that's another story.
- 9:33And so I think it's it's normal that he's away a bit, especially
- 9:37now that that there's a president in place and things are not going off the
- 9:41rails, you know, as much as they were in the previous era.
- 9:46So for me, it's pretty normal that he that he'd be away. And
- 9:48I don't know what the right balance is for uh, for an owner of
- 9:54a club. I unfortunately am not a billionaire, so I will probably never
- 9:58know that feeling. But for me, I'm kind of like, if he's
- 10:01not all up in everybody's business, it probably means things are pretty stable,
- 10:07pretty under people interesting. Elias, lets you answer also the same question,
- 10:16because I think it's a very important question because he is right a lot of
- 10:20the time. When he's here, we complain that he's here. When he's
- 10:24not here, we complain that he's not here. So at the end of
- 10:26the day, what is the right balance in your opinion? I mean,
- 10:33we all know Montreal fans right, there will never be a right balance.
- 10:37There's always be something wrong. I think that you know, each owner operates
- 10:43differently. I think, you know, I agree with Eve that that need
- 10:46for a president was very clear, and the fact that Gave stepped in and
- 10:52done, you know, his job, at least so far, he's done
- 10:56a good job. And I think that the fact that we are treating this
- 11:01interview as such a rarity in such an event kind of speaks to the fact
- 11:05that people would have probably much better opinions of Joyce Puto if stuff like this
- 11:09happened more often, and if they were just either more transparent or just more
- 11:13available, right everything. Everyone is always talking about how we don't see Joyce
- 11:18putto enough, and to a certain degree, they're right, because the last
- 11:22time he was made available to the media was during the logo reveal last year.
- 11:28And I understand that he is not he's not a coach, he's not
- 11:31supporting director, he's not president, so he's not going to be available to
- 11:35the media, you know, at once a month stuff like that. But
- 11:37the fact that he when stuff goes poorly and there's questions surrounding aspects that are
- 11:45not related to the club on the field, such as the training center,
- 11:50such as you know, the medical staff, stuff like that. The fact
- 11:56that him or Javit are not available as we'd like kind of leads into that
- 12:01perception that always never hear because we just never hear from it. So if
- 12:05he is going to be now not necessarily a silent partner, but someone that
- 12:09is delegating the majority of the responsibilities to be like and to get then they
- 12:16both need to be made more available. Fairly. Enough is available quite often
- 12:20even when there isn't you know, a signing being made. He is available
- 12:26multiple times a season. I think that's a fair amount for a sportings director,
- 12:28but is available once maybe twice a year if there's like a huge news.
- 12:33So I think that just having him be regularly available to kind of speak
- 12:37about this and not need to give ninety minute interview worth of updates would make
- 12:43their life so much easier. Just be there to answer questions. I'm not
- 12:48saying every week, not saying, you know, show up with with Rosada
- 12:50before every game and stuff like that, but once every couple of months.
- 12:54I agree, though I actually agree with White. Lias says, go ahead.
- 12:58But to defense, Joey sap And first of all, was available for
- 13:05the media at least four or five times this year. You know, he
- 13:09was a couple of times just to uh. At one point, I think
- 13:13they they helped, uh, you know, build another stadium for in exactly,
- 13:24so he was there. Uh every time I see, he's always at
- 13:28the stadium, and you know what, he always comes and say hi.
- 13:31So I'm pretty sure. I don't know if I've never made any requests for
- 13:35an interview with Gabriel because maybe one day, you know, we'll do a
- 13:39request for him to show up on the ball is round. But it's pretty
- 13:43tough. We're not economists, right, So you know, I prefer to
- 13:46have someone that's more on the sporting side here at on the balls round.
- 13:50But I don't think there's a lot of interview requests for Gabriel because we're more
- 13:58focused on what happens on the field then off the field. But we did
- 14:03see Gabrishavi quite a few times. He was here for Logo revealed too.
- 14:05He was here a couple of times. He was here at least four or
- 14:09five times during in the season. And for a president to be here,
- 14:11I think it's already it's already pretty transparent from that side. Now for Joey,
- 14:16and that's my honest opinion, right, like you know, to each
- 14:20their own, but for Joey, I think that he already said he will
- 14:28be he will take a step back when he named Kevin Gilmore, that's when
- 14:33he decided to take a very big step back, and he did that and
- 14:37he gave his full confidence to Kevin Gilmore. And as soon as this became
- 14:43really bad, that's when he stepped right in again. And we all know
- 14:48the situation and he had to and right now he said, okay, you
- 14:52know what, I gave my full confidence to Kevin Gilmore, it didn't go
- 14:56well. I'm not going to change whatever I said last time, and I'm
- 15:00going to give again the full confidence to the new president, which is Gabrie
- 15:05saw Jaw and as of right now, in my opinion, we'll do that
- 15:09later. But as of right now, I don't he doesn't need, he
- 15:13doesn't have a reason to step back in, in my opinion, and we'll
- 15:18talk about it right now because yes, of course results are not what we
- 15:22want. Yes, of course we don't have any big names and everything,
- 15:26but the project is still in place, and the vision that the club has
- 15:31and was clearly said at the beginning of this year, is still on rails.
- 15:39It's still on track, it's still going well. So I don't know,
- 15:43I don't see any urgency first for Joey Saputo to to step right in.
- 15:48I don't know if you guys agree with me or if you have anything
- 15:52to say, we're going to die. I know. I think it's like
- 15:54like I said, if we don't see him, it means things are pretty
- 15:56stable. So exactly exactly now. He also said something that I didn't name
- 16:02at the beginning of that I didn't say at the beginning of the pod he
- 16:06said, we invested five million dollars US in player acquisitions. He said,
- 16:12he invested in vettering the infrastructures of the club, the facilities, and the
- 16:22women's program with BMO, and also in the academy. What do you think
- 16:29about those kinds of investments, because yes, I think that these investments are
- 16:33investments on the long term, which is very beneficial, again on the long
- 16:40term and not on the short term. Do you think this is enough EVE
- 16:44to to convince the fans of the investments and the money that's coming in,
- 16:51you know where the money is going. You know a lot of people are
- 16:53asking questions where the money is going at TC answered part of that or it's
- 16:56not enough for you. Well, people would probably argue that the the five
- 17:03million dollars spent on player acquisition may may not have been spent as wisely as
- 17:07it could have given how the season went. Different story. But obviously the
- 17:15women's or girls if you will program, nothing but phenomenal things to say about
- 17:19that. Infrastructure is like one of those really unsexy but necessary things that you
- 17:25have to spend money on. I mean, it's like you have to spend
- 17:26money on with your tires for your car, or you know, on like
- 17:33dumb stuff like the roof of your house and things like that that you just
- 17:36have to spend money on. But it's like not really fun or exciting,
- 17:41So like, it doesn't really surprise me that they spend money there, you
- 17:42know, I just kind of expected that they would, because otherwise the stadium
- 17:48would probably have crumbled in on us by now. Yeah. Yeah, And
- 17:55the Academy, I mean, I think I would imagine the Academy is something
- 17:57again that they regularly spend that money on. So I'd be curious to see
- 18:00sort of, you know, outside of your what you normally put into the
- 18:06academy. To me, if you say, okay, well we invested in
- 18:08the academy, that means they increase something, and I would be curious to
- 18:12know what was that increase, Like what extra say, Yeah, I like,
- 18:22yeah, I mean I agree with Eve, right, it's it's a
- 18:25lot of necessary spending that just isn't super flashy. I think that. But
- 18:30you know, I agree also with Eve that I would have liked to know
- 18:33what it was, like what did you invest? Yeah? I don't need
- 18:37like an itemized proceed or anything exactly. At least you just tell me show
- 18:42me, just show me something concrete, like just a general notion. Okay,
- 18:47you know what you invested in the academy. What did you do?
- 18:49Did you hire most scouts, you know, local regional scouts. Did you
- 18:53you know, expand any program? Did you like, tell us a bit
- 18:57more about it, like tell me where the money is going and how maybe
- 19:03not how much did you spend, but you know, kind of some kind
- 19:07of figure in a certain way, and and and and yes, and infrastructures.
- 19:11I'm sorry, but I haven't seen anything. Did you guys see because
- 19:17the stadium standing? Yeah, but he didn't he didn't talk about normal repairs.
- 19:22No, he talked about, you know, bettering the infrastructures. What
- 19:27did they better? What did we see that got better? Because the stadium
- 19:32is still the same, It still diabolical? No, But is it is?
- 19:38It? Is? It? Is it? The new food trucks?
- 19:41That could be something that that that? Yeah? But why not? But
- 19:47like just name them? I think that they weren't named. And and maybe
- 19:52because don't forget, maybe he gave an eighty minute interview and maybe you know,
- 19:56journalists didn't really write you know what we're what they were also, so
- 20:03we're not really sure. Maybe he said it and you know it wasn't you
- 20:07know, it wasn't written down. But what do you guys? Sorry,
- 20:10Elias, I cut you, I cut you off, But like, what
- 20:14did you think about that? Do you agree with that? Or didn't you
- 20:18need a bit more? Yeah? I mean it's it's always like, once
- 20:22you get a little bit of transparency, you're like okay, and and and
- 20:26I think that, you know, hopefully maybe he was just saving a bit
- 20:29for his you know, his yearly State of the Union, uh that he
- 20:33has, you know, towards the end of the of the calendar year,
- 20:37which then will also give us a chance to ask, you know, some
- 20:40more questions in depth, and hopefully he's got you know again not maybe not
- 20:44an itemized list, but he does have more details. Especially with the academy.
- 20:48Right, if you really are committing to to the philosophy your coup being
- 20:52developing and showcasing young talent, especially Canadian and Quebec young talent, then I
- 20:59expect you to be regularly not just investing in your academy, but upping your
- 21:03investment in the academy. So I don't want to see you just you know,
- 21:07same old, same old, every year making steps exactly. I don't
- 21:11want to status quote because right now you are not you are not a You're
- 21:15not Benfica, right, this is not You're not a world renowned academy yet,
- 21:18which means every year it has to stop to grow, it has to
- 21:22start somewhere. It has exactly. But but the thing is, we want
- 21:26to see a plan. No, but we want to see a concrete plan,
- 21:29right. We'd like to see you know, yes, you're taking steps.
- 21:32What are these steps? Right? And exactly are the is it scouts?
- 21:36Is it you know, we're finally uh, we're we're increasing you know,
- 21:40the funding for for recruiting players and making their lives easier so they can
- 21:45focus on soccer stuff like that. So I'd love to see building and you
- 21:49pitch for young for young players or something, you know, like, that's
- 21:55what I want to see. I completely agree with you the lies. I
- 21:56think we needed them more information to explain where the money's going, because yes,
- 22:03he did say that, you know, it's it's it's not a secret
- 22:06for anyone that you know. The c F Mantreal has been losing about ten
- 22:10million dollars every year in the past two or three years. But this time
- 22:14we got money back, what did you do with it? And that's that's
- 22:18that's we wanted what we wanted to understand. Now. He talked about also
- 22:25the stadium. I think that's I think the most interesting part of the whole
- 22:30interview in my opinion. He talked about adding premium sections to the to the
- 22:37stadium. He said that right now, six percent of the premium sections januarly
- 22:44thirty percent of revenues of the ticketing at the gates. And this is,
- 22:53you know, a lot less than all the new stations that we see across
- 22:57the league, and usually usually it should be a lot more. Ah.
- 23:06I know that's not what the average Joe wants to hear, but I think
- 23:11it makes a lot of sense to have more premium seats, to have more
- 23:15corporations and you know, get premium seats and get you know, large and
- 23:22and stuff like that. I think that's going to be very interesting and very
- 23:25important for the growth of the club and of course for the growth of the
- 23:29revenues. I like that. But also he said that they want to make
- 23:33sure that we are able to use the stageum all year long, so make
- 23:38sure that there is what the winter Rise pitch you know, some some heaters
- 23:48or whatever, some kinds of cover or I don't know if it's a roof
- 23:52or anything, or if you if you're just gonna make sure that all the
- 23:57seats covered in a certain in a certain way. You know, things need
- 24:02to be done, because you know, it's not normal that c F mandrel
- 24:04have has to play three four, five, ten games outside of their stage.
- 24:11And so do you guys, are you are you excited about you know,
- 24:15this new project around Statsuputo Elias? Do you think we really need a
- 24:21new stadium? I see a lot of fans saying, you know what,
- 24:23Statsuputo no more, Let's go for something new, better and everything. Or
- 24:29do you like that idea to keep that kind of small history alive in a
- 24:34certain way because we did live a lot of really good moments in that stagium
- 24:40exactly. Yeah. And I think that this stadium is nowhere near old enough
- 24:44to warrant just a complete redo. I think that it does need renovations for
- 24:49sure. And the thing is the location of it, right, the history
- 24:52of it. But also you know where it's located in the city, and
- 24:56you know it's in Olympic Park. The backdrop of the Olympic Stadium. It
- 25:00it's it's it's quintessential and it's as it's synonymous with the club. I think
- 25:03that increasing the seating of the stadium will then offer you know, because yes,
- 25:10I do agree with you that you need, you know, more corporate
- 25:12partnerships, maybe a premium section, yes, But if you grow the premium
- 25:17section without growing the rest of the stadium and the rest of the stands,
- 25:19then you're getting an increasingly corporate feeling, which is to kill the atmosphere.
- 25:23Right. So if you're going to you know, grow that premium seating that
- 25:27does generate that money, you need to, you know, you need to
- 25:32reciprocate that with an equal growth in an affordable seating, right because at the
- 25:37end of the day, the lottest fans are not necessarily always the ones that
- 25:41are paying one hundred dollars a ticket are never and the ones are never the
- 25:45ones that pay because I don't want to say people that pay one hundred dollars
- 25:48are not you know, are not vocal, but hundred dollars is we're not
- 25:56talking about a premium section, right and and and you know, the way
- 26:00I disagree with you is that I don't think you need because the premium sections
- 26:03are going to be you know, it's just gonna be in a box and
- 26:08you know, with tainted class or whatever like, you're not really gonna see
- 26:12them, and it's not gonna affect the atmosphere. You're not even going to
- 26:15realize that, you know, even renovations have been done. So I don't
- 26:21think that it's going to change anything about the atmosphere because you'll have exactly the
- 26:25same amount of people, you know, in the bowl, if you want
- 26:27to call it, with making exactly the same the same noise that that you're
- 26:33you're used to. So I don't think so. But I kind of get
- 26:37to your point that if the premium sections are going to be outside and close
- 26:41to where the whole party is, then yes, of course the atmosphere could
- 26:45be affected. Yeah, So if do you agree with that that adding that
- 26:52those premium sections could affect the atmosphere, note if it's done judiciously, because
- 26:57obviously most, if not all, other clubs in MLS have a higher proportion
- 27:04of those those fancy fancy as I prefer to call them, then then Montreal
- 27:11does. And you know, there are very few teams in MLS where I
- 27:18think that would be considered the source of a bad crowd atmosphere. So no,
- 27:25no, overall doesn't concern me. Just has to be done, you
- 27:27know, in a way that doesn't doesn't you know, look bad. I
- 27:32guess for like like you know, esthetically speaking, interesting. Interesting. Now
- 27:37he did add a few things about the stadium Elias. He said that hypothetical
- 27:42stadium. Yeah, exactly about the renovations, the stadium, hypothetic objective,
- 27:49the projected. I can meet you in the middle on that word. Now
- 27:55he's said, it is a project. It's called like I said, Horizon
- 27:59twenty twenties eleven. He said, you know, at most, it could
- 28:03take up to three years to be done, at the most because they need
- 28:10to wait for the the RIO, the uh, the Olympic Committee to take
- 28:18that decisions regarding the Olympic Stadium too, because you know, if they're gonna
- 28:23you know, do renovations, that satsa photos and maybe they're gonna have to
- 28:26play in the Olympic Stadium, so you know, they want to make sure
- 28:30that the Olympic Stadium is free before they start the renovations, which I kind
- 28:34of understand. We'll see what's gonna happen with that with that, and he
- 28:40also said he answered about the comparison made between the c F Montreal and the
- 28:48Expos because a lot of people are saying, oh, we're going to this
- 28:51appear like the Expos and he completely rejected that comparison, completely rejected. He's
- 28:57like just before the XP moved, Yes, they've sold their biggest salaries because
- 29:03they weren't able to pay them anymore. And he said, we're not the
- 29:07same right now. Yes, of course, we have some players that are
- 29:11here to go to Europe. They have you know, they see that as
- 29:17the main objective and everything. But we do have players that want to stay
- 29:21here until the end of their career. They don't have a problem to stay
- 29:23here until the end of their career, like like Nana and we all know
- 29:29that these two are the best players of the club this year. You know,
- 29:33they received all the awards this year, so he said, and we
- 29:36also saw like Samuel piet that that came back and he is now, you
- 29:41know, the team captain, and and he talked about you know, Schwan
- 29:45and pet being called by the national team and say, you know what,
- 29:48you can have a great career here in Montreal. What do you guys think
- 29:52about the comparison between c F Montreal and the expos Elias at you started this
- 29:56time. Yeah, I think that Montreal is a city, especially as a
- 30:00sporting city, still hasn't recovered from the Exposed leaving, which is why the
- 30:04second a team that isn't the habs starts to like financially and sportingly not do
- 30:11great. It's like a PTSD flashback, say, oh my god, the
- 30:15expot again. And I and like, I understand that I personally, you
- 30:18know, I've never been a huge baseball fan, and I'm also too young
- 30:22to have properly been affected by the Exposed departure. But I understand that that
- 30:29sentiment and not having gotten over, you know, a team leaving, because
- 30:32a team leaving your market is is a very traumatic thing for the sporting culture
- 30:34of a city, right and especially a city that doesn't have you know,
- 30:41like the Americans, where they have you know, six or seven professional teams
- 30:44right Montreal right now has four if you include the PHL team that's going to
- 30:48become in Montreal. So I think that, you know, there's it's very
- 30:53easy to jump to conclusions. I don't think that they're in any way in
- 30:56a similar situation. But yeah, I understand why there's concerns, but I
- 31:02think that those concerns have been properly addressed. If do you are you do
- 31:08you believe you know those people that really do the comparison? Are you afraid
- 31:15of that? Do you feel that it's an actual threat? Not at present?
- 31:19You know, obviously things can change, but at present, no period.
- 31:26Okay, love it, simple, concise and everything. I agree with
- 31:30you. I've never understood people that said that. I think you know,
- 31:34Josapuda has been here through thick and thin. He's been here you know,
- 31:40in the dark years of the club, and I don't see him leaving unless
- 31:45you know he's not able to afford it anymore. And then a'sk completely not
- 31:51the case. So no, I don't. I'm not at all afraid of
- 31:55that. I think also that what were your I think I think I said
- 32:00it quite a few times here on the ball is round. What is being
- 32:04built by the club, even if the average road doesn't really like it.
- 32:09The fact that it's local players, not a lot of bling, bling and
- 32:14everything. I love it. This is the kind of club that I want
- 32:17to support. So yes, maybe we're not gonna win silverware, every year,
- 32:22yes or never. But you know what, we're going to see local
- 32:29talent grow and and reach new heights that they never would have reached if there
- 32:36wasn't a club like c F Montreal giving them a chance. So for me,
- 32:39that's more than enough to support and help the club and cover the club
- 32:45because we do cover the club weekly. So yeah, that's my opinion regarding
- 32:50that. So that's what we got from that interview. I don't know if
- 32:54you guys have anything else to add on the interviews and all all the texts
- 33:00that were written on that interview. No, I don't think so perfect.
- 33:07So guys, if you have any questions, I haven't seen the comments here,
- 33:10So if you haven't questions, feel free we are here to answer them.
- 33:15Of course, moving on, after we discussed all that, we're going
- 33:21to go directly into the second part of the post mortem. Last week we
- 33:27talked about Hernando Sada and what we thought about it. We had Alex Gangey
- 33:31Rizzik that gave his opinion. Elias, you gave your opinion if you didn't,
- 33:37so I'll give you a chance to give your opinion on Hernaldo Sata.
- 33:40What do you think? What do you think? He did was good the
- 33:46pros and cons, but also give him a grade at the end out of
- 33:52time. Actually I got I got a pretty spicy text from the Holy Gail
- 33:55after you all give out your grades. So oh really I want to I
- 34:00want to hear all about it. I wouldn't say it was more than fuzzy.
- 34:06Oh she didn't. She didn't agree with us, then, not at
- 34:08all. She wants to say that, Okay, somebody, somebody gave him
- 34:14a six out of ten, and she and she was dying that it's not
- 34:21me. I'm pretty sure it's not. You gave him a four. You
- 34:24gave him a four exactly, and that is also the great that I'm going
- 34:29to give her Anosa is a four out of ten. I'm giving him afore
- 34:32because you know, injuries and and you know Kai Kamara leaving on the eve
- 34:37of the season starts. So I think at the early part of the season
- 34:39a lot was working against him. So I do find it a bit hard
- 34:44to judge him kind of on that really really really difficult early period of the
- 34:47season. Obviously, road games were a freaking disaster, hopeless I have I
- 34:55mean, Gabrielle Gervey said in his one of his interviews, he was like,
- 34:59I was with the t on the road. He was like, I
- 35:01don't know what went wrong, and nobody seems to know what went wrong on
- 35:04the road. But the end of the day, it is on the head
- 35:07of the coach. And let's face it, if Montreal had picked up even
- 35:09one more point on the road, they would be in the playoffs, even
- 35:14though their play may not have merited playoffs. You know, the tactics were
- 35:20very hit and miss. We saw occasional hints of attractive football, but we
- 35:23often saw a lot of really timid counter attacking, really rigid a play.
- 35:34Sometimes unfortunately it was dictated by injuries. But that being said, you know,
- 35:40you grow throughout the season and there were spells where a lot of players,
- 35:44plenty of players were healthy. A lot of concerns as well with the
- 35:47man management style of an Alasada. He clearly has alienated several players within the
- 35:53squad. I think that was made abundantly clear in the postseason pressers. Was
- 35:58it I Oh my god, because like we had Victor Wayama on the ball
- 36:04is round here right, and he was so nice and he gave Sam some
- 36:07mom his jersey and he was so sweet and lovely and beautiful. And then
- 36:10he was giving that interview when I was like, who is I was like,
- 36:14oh my god. After Dark, I don't know them. After Derek
- 36:22and I was like, I was like, well then I was also like,
- 36:25how dare you not not to? But tilS off right? So yeah,
- 36:32his man management style and I mean, let's face it, he didn't
- 36:35come into Montreal with a glowing reputation for how he had treated his players,
- 36:39and it's sound and when he did his introduction, he said, you know
- 36:45that he's young coach, he's learning, he wants to improve. I'm not
- 36:49sure he has, you know, hearing from some very very well respected world
- 36:53class footballers, I'm not inclined to believe that he has. So honestly,
- 36:59you know what, take my and put it down to a three point five.
- 37:02I've talked to yourself out of it. Wow, yeah, quick to
- 37:07change your mind. No, you know what I thought about Victorian Yama,
- 37:09that's all. That's all I had to think about was that's that's that lovely,
- 37:15kind, seft spoken Victorian Yama. And then he was upset and that
- 37:20made me upset. I love it. I love it three three and a
- 37:24half out of ten I was. I was asking myself if I became more
- 37:29pacifistic or you became more optimistic. Now you know you lever thinks before and
- 37:35I said my message, that's exactly exactly okay, So I think did you
- 37:43ask me something else here? I forget? Was that it? Do you
- 37:46think he has to stay or he has to leave? I can tell you
- 37:51I don't. I think both. I think he and Victor Manyama will not
- 37:54both be here for sure. So we we agreed on this, I think
- 38:00all four. So honestly, I'm not really in the mood for another season
- 38:09like that, and I don't necessarily see it getting better, so I'm gonna
- 38:13say see you later. Yeah, and Holy Gail is here by the way,
- 38:21so hey, Holy Yale. And and Patrick is I think he answered
- 38:24me, I'm happy about the project. He said, that's great. That's
- 38:30all great. But you played to win the game. Yeah, but that's
- 38:32That's not like they played to lose the game either. They're trying to win
- 38:36the game. They're just not good enough yet, so hopefully they'll get better.
- 38:39So now, yeah, you never know. Moving on, I think
- 38:45we can start with a post mortem, player by player. I really thought
- 38:51about it last week we wanted to do, but I think I'll wait at
- 38:55the last episode of the first morning because decisions have to be made until then.
- 39:00Yeah, so hopefully we'll get a clearer picture of you know, the
- 39:04vision of Ali for the future, and I wait him there, So we'll
- 39:07wait for the end, not today, but the end end. Thanks you
- 39:13for agreeing with me. So let's start with goalkeepers. Of course we all
- 39:17know goalkeepers. Well, we'll start with him because I think it's going to
- 39:22be very, very kind of the only goalkeeper we saw this season not true,
- 39:29well for okay, up for a hot minute, and we also saw
- 39:31a Logan Crediger. Yeah I forgot about him. Yeah, but statistically the
- 39:36most efficient goalkeeper and see contreal history, right, so you know what,
- 39:43it looks really good on his stats sheet. So good for him exactly,
- 39:46that's should well here he is. You can see him. I just adding
- 39:53him and removing him. Yeah, so is going to have a moment.
- 39:58Okay, so yeah was here. What a great first season he had.
- 40:05Uh, let's say our piece about Janata. I'm pretty sure we're all going
- 40:08to be very optimistic. Are great? Does he need to stay that he?
- 40:12Does he need to leave? If you want to give, you know,
- 40:15maybe your your pros and cons about his season. Uh, Elias,
- 40:20I'll let you start because I kind of know what you're you're gonna say about
- 40:24him, and like I can have a feeling that I know what you're going
- 40:27to say about him, and I think I like the cons that you're going
- 40:30to talk about, So go ahead, start with well with prose pros is
- 40:37The biggest one was his obviously his improvement. Right. Not only did he
- 40:40he take up the job and instantly, you know, play above expectations,
- 40:45but he continuously improved and added tools that you know, you I hope he
- 40:51would get over the course of the season. He had them rather quickly.
- 40:53The most notable one between his first game and his last game of the season
- 40:59was his distribution, especially in the long bowl department. At the beginning of
- 41:01the year, he was extremely unreliable. You know, when it comes to
- 41:07short passes, it's a short pass to the high percente pass. You know,
- 41:08if you're passing out to the center back or even to a fallback on
- 41:12the ground, you know, it's it's it's very unlikely that you mess that
- 41:15up. But picking out a midfielder or a forward and breaking multiple lines through
- 41:20the air was borderline unthinkable. You know, at the end of the season,
- 41:23he really struggled to pick out those passes, and towards the end of
- 41:27the season you really saw him and show that he had improved in that department.
- 41:31So I think that he still has a long way to come, especially
- 41:35given how if you compare him to James Battemis's distribution, which is I find
- 41:38to be much more reliable. I think that, you know, that is
- 41:43the next thing he has to get really good at. I think the you
- 41:46know, the cons is experience, and we saw it at the two arguably
- 41:51the two most important moments of the season. We saw it in the final
- 41:53of the Canadian Championship, and we saw it in that one nothing lead that
- 41:57they lost to cincinnatifc the Canadian Championship, you know, it costs a trophy
- 42:05that he doesn't come out of his net against Cincinnati, that ball gets cleared.
- 42:08Either way, Montreal is up at three points to the one they ended
- 42:12up forty three points of the season, and they host to play in game.
- 42:14So those two things are from a pure goaltending perspective, I feel are
- 42:20the only really bad things of the season. Yes, there's you know,
- 42:22the four nothing game, the fine nothing game, the three nothing in the
- 42:24four to nothing game. But those were complete team efforts. Those are you
- 42:30know, collective collapses. I think stuff where you could look at Jeana darciuat
- 42:34and say you dropped the ball. I could think of twice. And for
- 42:37a rookie goalie who was put in really out of the blue, with a
- 42:42ton of expectations and a team that was already so hot and cold, I
- 42:46think that he over delivered. And I said this after his mistake in Cincinnati,
- 42:52with the amount of points that he single handedly saved for Montreal, him
- 42:58losing two, I'm not that bad. It's just that when you look at
- 43:01it with hindsight, you go those two points would have put them in the
- 43:05playoffs. But overall, you know, it's it's so far net positive that
- 43:10you can't even look at that with I think other than just you know,
- 43:15it happens, you're great. Does he stay? Does he leave? I'll
- 43:22give him and I'll give him an eight because I think that no, I'll
- 43:29give an eight. I don't think anybody was near ten this year, So
- 43:31I'll give him an eight. And he's on the very high end of that
- 43:36of the median. So yeah, and absolutely states you know, stay for
- 43:38as long as you can keep him. For sure. If I'll go next
- 43:44and then I'll give you out, I'll let you talk. I'm not going
- 43:47to repeat everything that Elia said, of course, because I agree with most
- 43:52of it. We did see an improvement I of course, we saw also
- 43:58his inexperience, and that's some thing that really didn't help him at times.
- 44:02You know, in the high pressure games where we saw he fumbled the ball,
- 44:07he went, he gave that penalty, you know those This inexperience is
- 44:12a bit unfortunately, you know, created a bit of uncertainty I think in
- 44:17the back. But that's normal at this stage. It's completely normal now right
- 44:23now this year, of course, we can accept that. Next year it's
- 44:29going to be even harder to accept that, and the year after it's going
- 44:31to be very bad. So let's wait and see how he's going to grow.
- 44:37I do agree that he improved his distribution that I think there's a lot
- 44:42of improvement to be done there too. And what I like about him and
- 44:47his the biggest pro that I can give him is his confidence. I think
- 44:55that the confidence that he has shows on the pitch. The defenders feel his
- 45:05confidence. They are relieved when he's here to hear him. And his communication
- 45:12is pretty good too. We can hear him yell and scream, which a
- 45:15pandemic is very good at that too. So I like that. I think
- 45:20this is very very interesting as a first year, unbelievable as the first year,
- 45:24even when on the ball is round. Maybe I think last year,
- 45:30even the year before I said I think we should go with Jana is the
- 45:32number one. Everybody laughed at me. I wasn't even expecting that good of
- 45:38a first season. But you know what, I think, really really good
- 45:43season, and I agree with your great I would say I would give an
- 45:46eight out of ten, but not a higher eight. I would say,
- 45:49you know, a lower eight in that instance, I think eight is a
- 45:52bit generous. Even I would say seven and a half. But eight is
- 45:55good for me to trying to to go to not be with the seven and
- 46:02a half. Everything that's a half, I don't like it. Eight d
- 46:06is a good thing for Jona. I think to add, even you agree
- 46:09with everything, or you disagree with everything, it's gonna give him a tune.
- 46:13Now, Yeah, I know, I think a lot of what we've
- 46:20identified as shortcomings for Jonathan Saua are largely things that we can reasonably expect will
- 46:28be improved upon next year with more experience. I do think kind of towards
- 46:32the end of this season, when things started to get hot, I kind
- 46:36of felt that confidence was kind of diminishing from him. I didn't feel that
- 46:42he was as in control as as he had been in other stages of this
- 46:46season. So I think that is probably what I would add. It is
- 46:50that, you know, whether it was on a set piece, you know,
- 46:53we saw him, you know, missing some some relatively easy you know,
- 46:58whether it was a catcher punch or what have you, and sometimes perhaps
- 47:01staying behind when we would have expected him to be a little bit more aggressive.
- 47:06So I think that's probably something to work on next season, is just
- 47:09kind of maintaining that kind of steady composure and just regulating that, particularly,
- 47:17you know, when pressure does really ratchet up. As for a grade,
- 47:22I will go with a seven point five out of ten. Okay, so
- 47:34eight plus eight plus seven point five, and let's say Eliah said eight point
- 47:39five, so we come back, it's approximately an eight out of ten.
- 47:45So Sculimad of Talue that's so, I just wanted to show off with my
- 47:52greets. So yeah, so eight out of ten I think everybody agrees.
- 47:55I'm pretty sure everybody agrees with that, So it's not or they can tell
- 48:00us if they don't, or you can tell us if you don't exactly.
- 48:02So interesting enough is that James Tennis, sorry Jonathan said why. It's under
- 48:09contract until twenty twenty six, which is really really interesting for his growth,
- 48:15so we'll see how he's gonna involved. Next on the list is our friend
- 48:21James pen Temis. James ben Temis only two games this year and not actually
- 48:27two full games, and not actually two full games. It's impossible to rate
- 48:32his season, yes, but I want to talk first about he's at the
- 48:39end of his contract the option. The club has an option to either renew
- 48:45his from extended his contract by a year or two, or just release him
- 48:50completely. What would you do? We cannot really grade him. What would
- 48:54you do saying knowing that he's already twenty six, gonna be twenty seven in
- 49:02February so very shortly, so not a young goalkeeper. And you know,
- 49:08if you're looking at the future, you know you're going with Jana Facio that's
- 49:15only twenty two, so do you keep him or do you let him go?
- 49:20If I think for me, the question is more for the well being
- 49:24of James Pantemis's career, like never mind Sporting Montreal, whatever. I think.
- 49:31For James Pantemis to have a shot at being a number one, I
- 49:37think he should have gotten out last season or the season before, to be
- 49:39completely honest with you, and I have been saying that consistently, I think
- 49:45since twenty twenty one. So for me, you know, I think Montreal
- 49:53may may offer him the option to stay but as number two, and if
- 49:58he's content with that, if he's content, you know, just playing in
- 50:01cup games. I mean, he still gets paid, he's still on a
- 50:05professional team. You know, he gets to be local and be with his
- 50:07family. So there are pros to that for sure for him. But if
- 50:10he wants a shot at being number one, then I think the club should
- 50:15absolutely not trigger his option, and I would hope that they would have the
- 50:17respect for him and all the time he's been at the club to consult him
- 50:21on that interesting lice. I tend to agree with Eve right because of the
- 50:28fact that this guy has been such a fixture in the club for so long
- 50:31as part of the academy. He's done everything they've asked him. He's gone
- 50:36out on loan, he's come back from loan, he's been the helpful substitute,
- 50:39he's been the starter. He's done everything a keeper can do at a
- 50:45club in every facet. So I think that, you know, if it
- 50:47is time to move on, I think they should do him the courtesy of
- 50:51having it be an amicable departure. It's also important to remember he makes one
- 50:54hundred and sixty thousand dollars if you're content, which is a lot of money
- 51:02for a backup keeper, because I don't think anyone is expecting James Patamis to
- 51:07take the starting job next year, and Tontosiaua makes like eighty five I believe
- 51:13this year, which is going to go up obviously with his new contract.
- 51:17And two hundred and fifty thousand for your goalie duo is not bad, but
- 51:23with Jantarcioua definitely going to be making more than James Patemis this year, and
- 51:28if you're going to be looking at closer to three, three fifty even four
- 51:31hundred thousand dollars for goaltending duo, and that much of it is occupied by
- 51:36your backup then it starts to then you start to look at the salary a
- 51:39bit sideways. Given how fiscally Austere Montreal is with their salary, I think
- 51:46that having that much money in your goaltending duo is a bit irresponsible if you
- 51:52know has this much money to play with. So I think that, yeah,
- 51:55his his future probably lies elsewhere if he wants to be a number one
- 52:02keeper, if he has if he's okay with being the backup keeper. I
- 52:06think that this new contract will definitely take a significant pay hit, but that
- 52:10again, that ultimately lies to his relationship with the club and how he and
- 52:15what he wants out of the rest of his career because he is still he
- 52:17is still quite young, right, this is a veteran, but it is
- 52:20by no means someone you know mid to late thirty or early to mid thirties
- 52:23that you know on his way out of the game. So I think it
- 52:29all depends on what he wants out of it. Honestly, I'm gonna be
- 52:36a bit more decisive for me. No, I don't want James spent THEMS
- 52:42to stay with the club, even at the lower salary, because I would
- 52:46prefer to sign Ketterer as a backup goalkeeper who can do a decent job as
- 52:52a number two. He's cheaper, you know, he was a third goalkeeper,
- 52:58so I'm pretty sure he's going to welcome, you know, the opportunity
- 53:00to stay as a second goalkeeper and have a young goalkeeper be the number three
- 53:07in case, you know, the number three never really sees the bench even
- 53:12you know, he'd only be there just in case, you know, Ketterery
- 53:15is starting and you want to rest, gets injured or anything. And I
- 53:19think it's important to have young goalkeepers come and train with the pros on a
- 53:24regular basis and then play with the reserve. That's not a problem at all,
- 53:30but I would like that. I think that that's what Montreal missed in
- 53:36the last few years, not giving enough exposure to their young players with the
- 53:42first team, not necessarily on the pitch, but already in training. So
- 53:46I think you start right now. If you have a young goalkeeper that's seventeen,
- 53:51eighteen, sixteen, even, why not just, you know, right
- 53:54away, put him with the as a number three keeper, knowing that he's
- 53:59not going to see that as a number three. That's what I would do,
- 54:02and I think it's time for James Temis to really think hard about his
- 54:07career and go just get a new challenge, if it's in CPL or in
- 54:12USL. In a CPL, it's pretty tough for him to land in CPL,
- 54:16but maybe in USL or elsewhere, you know, in a second division
- 54:21in Europe or whatever. He does have a Greek passport, so that that's
- 54:24going to help him maybe land a contract in Europe. But I think it's
- 54:28time to see Jim spent Temis really leave c F Montreal forget. So let's
- 54:32wait and see. I didn't answer quickly, Logan Ketterer. Do you agree?
- 54:37Do we do we give him an extension or not? Just like that
- 54:43quickly. I have no opinion, really, I mean like, yeah,
- 54:47you're allowed, you're allowed. Unhis you have an opinion or not? Really?
- 54:53I mean he's been he's been a very faithful number three, right,
- 54:58so whatever happens, that good. Okay, moving on to the defenders right
- 55:04now, So let's start with the first defender. Let's go with central defenders
- 55:08first, our good friend Gabriel Corbol. What do you guys think about Corbra
- 55:15season? This time? Eve, you're the one starting. Yeah, So
- 55:20you know, kind of a little bit of a surprise return as he was
- 55:25on loan last year and then permanently signed. UH. Overall great versatility.
- 55:31Really appreciate that from him. I think he's probably the most mobile out of
- 55:36that defense central defender trio, because Campbell and Waterman are much slower. You
- 55:44know, he slotted in on the left, he slotted in on the right,
- 55:47and he looked at home in any of those positions. I think he's
- 55:52a very crisp player technically typically, not very flashy, you know, no
- 55:58dangerous slide talk, goals, nothing like too risky from him. But it's
- 56:06good, clean, simple play and it doesn't get him in hot water,
- 56:09doesn't get the team in hot water. What more can you ask for?
- 56:14So if I'm going to give him a grade, he's gonna probably be my
- 56:17highest graded defender. Maybe I'm going to give him a seven out of ten
- 56:22on the season, okoay Live, I agree with pretty much everything you've said.
- 56:30Right. He is your your typical, UH, technically sound and no
- 56:35nonsense center back. I think that I was very happy to see him come
- 56:38back. I was disappointed when he left last year. I thought he was
- 56:42being groomed to replace Rudy Camacho in the middle in the future. He's still
- 56:45very young. I think he's twenty three, twenty four, so there is
- 56:49still a lot of upside to him, and hopefully this is you know,
- 56:52we haven't even scratched the surface of of you know, his potential. I
- 56:57think that, uh, I'd love to see him be more assertive and kind
- 57:00of take this defense by the horns, kind of in a similar way to
- 57:06what Joel Waterman has done and make his position. But also his presence felt
- 57:12a lot more because there were a lot of games where he was just complacent
- 57:15with you, No, I did my job, okay, no mistakes.
- 57:20Then I go home and I think that he is so much better than okay
- 57:24and decent and solid. I think he can has the potential to be excellent.
- 57:30So I think I'd love to see him be more assertive and kind of
- 57:34insert himself a lot more and be a lot more decisive. Right. We
- 57:37saw that, you know, a couple of times he would pop up and
- 57:40take a shot from thirty to forty yards out and not look terrible. Stuff
- 57:45like that, Right, I'd like to see him leave his mark on the
- 57:47game more. He was a bit error prone this year, he was caught
- 57:52out a few times. I think that also has to do in large part
- 57:54to the fact that he had Ariel Leicester on his side. That's no described
- 57:59to aera laster, He's just not a left back. I think that he
- 58:00had to compensate for the fact that you had a winger at wing back,
- 58:05whereas you know George Campbell or Joe Waterman over played on the right side,
- 58:09had an actual proper right back to have kind of to cave that cover.
- 58:15So I'll give him. I'll give him a seven and a half, a
- 58:19light seven and a half, because I do think like Eve that he was
- 58:22overall still the best center back that the team had this year. I'll just
- 58:29add a few things to that. First of all, I'm sorry, Elias,
- 58:34but it feels that I'm really confrontational today. But I don't see every
- 58:38other Google playing playing in the middle of the back three. I think I
- 58:44love him on the left hand side of the back three. That's where I
- 58:46think he was at his best. With the current iteration, I agree with
- 58:51you, until they get a left footed center back, I agree with you.
- 58:53Yeah, yeah, exactly. I think that's when he was That's where
- 58:57he was at his best, even on the right, I think, you
- 59:01know, I didn't think he was as good than on the left because he's
- 59:08able to help that the absence of a real left wing back, and he's
- 59:15able to do that. Yes, he's going to do errors, but a
- 59:17lot of other players will do a lot more errors than him, So that's
- 59:21the first thing. Second thing, you know, he is only He's going
- 59:24to be twenty four in January, so he's very young. So I like
- 59:27that. He surprised me by his consistency. That's what really surprised me about
- 59:35Gabrielle Cobo because last year in twenty twenty two under Nanci, he just helped.
- 59:39He was a rotational piece, and this year, you know, being
- 59:44a number one, like a first team player, sor, he really really
- 59:47showed how consistent he can be. And I love that. I love that.
- 59:52This is very important for a central defender. Very good season. I
- 59:57love his long play too. He's able to really switch the ball all from
- 1:00:00one side to the other very easily. Very precise passing and very precise long
- 1:00:05balls. I like that too. I think he needs to improve a bit
- 1:00:08more on his heading abilities, but he's he's quite there for me, so
- 1:00:15I agree with your grade, Eve, I will go with a seven out
- 1:00:17of ten too. That was my grade for Gabriela Corbo, So seven out
- 1:00:22of ten for Gabriella Corbo. I think we all agree as of right now
- 1:00:28on our ratings of the players. So I really love that. Moving on
- 1:00:34to the next player, it's Joel Waterman. So Joel Waterman. Oh,
- 1:00:39just to say, Gabriel Corboy is under a contract with the club until I'll
- 1:00:45tell you, for one year, for twenty twenty four to twenty twenty five.
- 1:00:51If is an option, hopefully you know, we'll say see him,
- 1:00:55yeah exactly. Joe Waterman the same thing. I'll say it right now since
- 1:01:00talking about him extension, Yeah exactly for twenty twenty four. He'll have an
- 1:01:05option for twenty twenty five. So Elias, your turn. Let's start with
- 1:01:09Joel Watteron. It was so hot and cold this year. I think that
- 1:01:15you know, at his best he was excellent and at his worst he was
- 1:01:21dreadful. And I have I love Joe Waterman. I think that he's been
- 1:01:27a great addition. I think he's an incredible example for just how uh just
- 1:01:32how viable a pipeline the U Sports CPL MLS Pipe National team pipeline can be
- 1:01:39and I think that, you know, he has of all the center backs
- 1:01:44that we had at the beginning of the season, I think he's one adapt
- 1:01:46that adapted to a Sida style of play the best. If you look at
- 1:01:49you know, Ruby Camacho, when you look at Joe Wateron, Kamal Miller
- 1:01:52excuse me, not really, you know, uh getting a along with with
- 1:02:00Musada style of play. I think that it suits Joe Waterman much more,
- 1:02:04who's just a much more direct center back. I think that, you know,
- 1:02:07when he had the choice to play in the middle as a replacement for
- 1:02:12Rudy Camach show he didn't do that great. But once Camacho left and he
- 1:02:15was kind of it kind of it was thrust upon him, he embraced it
- 1:02:19like a leader. And I think that that was probably his biggest growth factor
- 1:02:23of the year, is the fact that he embraced that leadership role in the
- 1:02:28in the back three. I still want to see him be a bit more
- 1:02:31commanding. Uh he's not, you know, he is. Some games,
- 1:02:36he just wasn't as imposing and didn't it didn't exude that aura that you would
- 1:02:39see for Rudy camch Show as the middle center back, because again, as
- 1:02:44that middle center back, it's a lot of directing, it's a lot of
- 1:02:47game management, it's a lot of you know, uh, manage, It's
- 1:02:52a lot of managing not just your team, but also the other team's attackers.
- 1:02:55And you have to have this intimidation factor that we kind of talked about
- 1:03:00throughout the season that Montreal didn't have, and in some cases it started with
- 1:03:04Joel Waterman, where technically he was a solid defender, but at the same
- 1:03:08time you have to kind of have this discouraging factor that he just didn't bring
- 1:03:14sometimes. So overall, I would give him a six and a half and
- 1:03:20I give him a six and a half, and I feel like it's a
- 1:03:22bit high just because of the fact that his highs and his responsibility, especially
- 1:03:27post Camacho, was very impressive, and I feel like he had his best
- 1:03:30moments after Camacho left because he embraced that rule. So I'm going to go
- 1:03:37with a six and a half something lead with my grade just because I've committed
- 1:03:43to it. So I'm going to give him a six. I agree with
- 1:03:46a lot of the points that Elis made. There were definitely some ups and
- 1:03:50downs and I think twenty twenty one twenty two we had really kind of gotten
- 1:03:55a little bit spoiled, maybe a little bit accustomed to a consistent, commanding
- 1:04:01Joel Waterman playing on that left or sorry not left right. He's played everywhere
- 1:04:09by playing on that right side of the center. Bactery, Yeah, exactly,
- 1:04:14And so, you know, losing that consistency this year. Obviously,
- 1:04:17change of coach, like there were things, and you know, change of
- 1:04:20the partners in central defense as well. Certainly I'm sure that didn't help.
- 1:04:27But nonetheless a part of me was a little bit worried that maybe there was
- 1:04:30a degree of not limitation, but just just just kind of a falling off
- 1:04:39kind of. So he did, certainly, just like Elia said, he
- 1:04:43did certainly get it together both before and after Rudy Camacho left, I think
- 1:04:47in right center back. You know, during that really good spell the team
- 1:04:51had, I think he was back to kind of do the jowel Waterman we
- 1:04:55had come to expect to see in especially twenty twenty two m when he moved
- 1:05:01in as well. It was a little bit of a rocky transition, but
- 1:05:05eventually got the hang of that center of the central center back positions. So
- 1:05:13yeah, they were. There were hot moments, there were coal moments,
- 1:05:15There were there were, you know, some slow moves. You know,
- 1:05:17we know he's not the most agile, the most rapid defender out there.
- 1:05:21I think he's well aware of that as well, and generally tries to play
- 1:05:25in such a way that doesn't expose him too much. I like his I
- 1:05:30like his distribution. I think he plays a lovely long pass as well.
- 1:05:33He's gotten some some nifty assists on goals for the for the club, and
- 1:05:38I certainly hope he keeps that up. So that's how I feel. And
- 1:05:43of course I expect you sicks read interesting. I agree with both of you.
- 1:05:51I think it was hot and cold. I think that the system that
- 1:05:58Turnando Sada was playing was the best system suited for someone like Joel Waterman.
- 1:06:04Uh he's someone that likes to hold a bu little bit more and and uh,
- 1:06:09don't forget he's he's a former midfielder in a certain way, and and
- 1:06:14you didn't have that that Chris passing from the back that that we saw under
- 1:06:19Nanci And and that's where he thrives, in my opinion, and that's why
- 1:06:23that with Losada, I think that his position has to be in the middle
- 1:06:29of the back three. And we saw him really a lot better at the
- 1:06:31end of the year when the team was sinking. That's when we saw a
- 1:06:36great Joel Waterman. And for me, that's very important for a leader.
- 1:06:41When your ship is sinking, you need your leaders to really stand up and
- 1:06:45help the team at least for them to push the team forward and to give
- 1:06:49the team a chance. And he did just write that, and and for
- 1:06:54me, that's that speaks a lot about what kind of player he is.
- 1:07:00I think you both were a bit too harsh on him. I would give
- 1:07:04him a seven out of ten just because, yes, he had some difficulties
- 1:07:10at first, but I think all the defense has had a lot of difficulties
- 1:07:15at first. What he did was the only one, I think, the
- 1:07:19only player in c F Montreal that kept on improving and getting better until the
- 1:07:26last game of the season. He's the only player of c F Montreal.
- 1:07:30And for me, that says a lot from from Joel Waterman. So I'll
- 1:07:35give him a seven and hopefully you know he'll be back and I think he's
- 1:07:40going to be the kind of player that I want to see stay here until
- 1:07:44the end of his career, because I think he deserves to be here.
- 1:07:47He has his place here, and and he's he's an agent, and he's
- 1:07:53everything that we want to see from from a player. He's not afraid to
- 1:07:59speak up. Uh. At one point and doing the season, he said
- 1:08:01that he that they weren't expecting to play like that, and you know,
- 1:08:06he he did say a few things that were not really in favor of the
- 1:08:14of the coaching style of Naldo said at first, so I like what I
- 1:08:18saw from Joe Waterman, and for me to seven out of ten, of
- 1:08:21course six six point five. Unfortunately I don't have a six point five graphics,
- 1:08:27so I'm going to get one. I'll give him a seven. So
- 1:08:33the ball is round, let's let's let's let's let's do six, then hide
- 1:08:38it, then show seven. Okay, that's good, I think where everybody
- 1:08:42Okay, compromise, good, perfect. So moving on. Next player is
- 1:08:47George Campbell. I'll start if you don't mind, guys, I'm gonna be
- 1:08:56super strict, but I'm very disappointed from what I've seen from George Campbell.
- 1:09:01Uh. When he was signed, he was signed, and and he was
- 1:09:08presented as someone that's going to be the real the new gem of the MLS,
- 1:09:15of the the exchanges in MLS that you can have. I was expecting
- 1:09:20a lot more knowing that he's an American international or you know, called up
- 1:09:27by the US national team at one point. You know, he played in
- 1:09:31Atlanta, he played a lot when the team was going very well. He
- 1:09:35was young, you know, he was He's able to play the back three
- 1:09:41very easily and everything. And I said, you know what this guy might
- 1:09:45be, you know, the next big thing for c F Montreal at the
- 1:09:48back. Unfortunately, there's something that I hate in center backs, and this
- 1:09:57is something that I've always hated for the past twenty some years that I watch
- 1:10:00soccer is when a center back loses focus and concentration. For me, this
- 1:10:08is not something that you can learn. You either have it or you don't.
- 1:10:13And I've never seen a center back that loses concentration get very good at
- 1:10:20it. I've seen center backs get better, but never good. And for
- 1:10:27me, this is a big no no for a center back. And you
- 1:10:30know, we can talk. You know, for people that follow European soccer,
- 1:10:35you have quite a few center backs that are very good can get you
- 1:10:40be the man of the game for two three games in a row, and
- 1:10:44then they just lose it for one game, and then you're just you never
- 1:10:49know when they're gonna lose it, when they're gonna just be very bad for
- 1:10:55one game and costs you a game. And for me, this is unacceptable
- 1:10:59for a center So that's something that I can't get over with, is a
- 1:11:05loss of concentration. Hopefully he can prove me wrong and get good at that,
- 1:11:12but I haven't seen this, he said. Also, he was presented
- 1:11:15as someone that can play as a right center back, as a left center
- 1:11:18back, and in the middle. I don't at all agree with that.
- 1:11:25The only few games where he was good was as only as a right center
- 1:11:30back. He was really not good at all. We played in the middle
- 1:11:38of the back three. As a left center back not good at all either.
- 1:11:42So for me, I need someone that's a bit more versatile that can
- 1:11:47be learned. So hopefully he'll get better at that. But very disappointing season
- 1:11:53in my opinion for George Campbell. I give him a four out of them,
- 1:11:58and you know, I'm thinking I'm a bit generous. Lies I tend
- 1:12:04to agree with you. Just the fact that it was it was very inconsistent.
- 1:12:08And you know, for all the good he's done, he was exposed
- 1:12:12the number of games. I think that he's twenty two, right, And
- 1:12:17I think that's also important to remember he he is a lot more MLS ready
- 1:12:26and some academy products or some some people coming off back from loan would be
- 1:12:30or you know, people from if it's a if it's a foreign investment.
- 1:12:33So there is that, and I think he is more in tune with with
- 1:12:38the with the style of play that MLS brings. But yeah, I mean
- 1:12:43there'll be some moments where he would just switch off. I think that his
- 1:12:45role once they streamline his role and right center back and they kind of just
- 1:12:49said this is your job, and they not spelled it out for him,
- 1:12:54but they did make his role much more simple in that you know, you
- 1:12:59have to you play with your fullback and in terms of in terms of his
- 1:13:03defense of responsibilities, we're streamlined as well. I think that he did thrive
- 1:13:09a bit more. Yeah, Consistency, I think that's the name of the
- 1:13:13game for him. I think that's the biggest thing he has to work on
- 1:13:15because he has all the tools, right, he likes to play with He
- 1:13:17likes to have the ball at his feet. He's tall. He for someone
- 1:13:21with his frame, he is quite mobile. He's not rapid, but he
- 1:13:25is mobile for someone that's like six to four, I think. So,
- 1:13:29I think that with all that in mind, the next step really is just
- 1:13:34the same step for all youngsters. Right it's polishing your game and delivering it
- 1:13:40more consistently. I think that, you know, the experiment of having him
- 1:13:45in the middle or him on the left is is a big risk. I
- 1:13:48think that maybe, you know, if Lasada feels like he has that confidence
- 1:13:53in him, he can experiment with him maybe in some Kenchup games or some
- 1:13:56games where you know you want to rotate the squad and you want to try
- 1:13:59him out, even if it's for a half. But right as of right
- 1:14:01now, I haven't focused on that right center back position because as of now
- 1:14:06it's his. It's his spot to lose. There's nobody else that's going to
- 1:14:10contest him for that for that spot. So I think that now you just
- 1:14:13hammered down on the minutia of the job and just focus on being able to
- 1:14:18deliver that almost you know, through muscle memory. And I think that I
- 1:14:24think i'd give him a five this year just because of you know, the
- 1:14:28good moments or bad moments. I'll go with the five EF. I'm also
- 1:14:34going to give him a five. You know, it's his first season in
- 1:14:39Montreal. He's adjusting to a new team. Since time Memoriam, we've seen
- 1:14:45players have kind of an e first season and then go on to have a
- 1:14:48much improved second season in passing. Yes, I expect he will be with
- 1:14:54the club next year. He has two years. No exactly, I don't
- 1:15:00know. It's a question that sometimes comes up. You never know, you're
- 1:15:02right. No, I should have said it at the beginning. I apologize.
- 1:15:05So he's under contract in two and four and five very much that you
- 1:15:11will be gone. Yeah, no, I mean I think you guys already
- 1:15:15called out the shortcomings that he has. I do like his mobility overall,
- 1:15:18and I do think he's most at home in the right center back position.
- 1:15:24And as for right now, that's okay because we have other players who can
- 1:15:28fill in at the other positions. Unfortunately, you know, those players are
- 1:15:31currently head and shoulders above him. With that being said, I wonder if
- 1:15:36next season, you know, I mean, Joel Waterman's first season in Montreal
- 1:15:41was not much straight home about and now look at him right, So let's
- 1:15:47you know, I'll be interested how this conversation goes at the end of next
- 1:15:51season as it relates to George Campbell. Yeah, I agree, let's give
- 1:15:56him time. But you're wow, I'm more person stig name Eve. Wow,
- 1:16:00that's how bad I actually, So five out of ten for two of
- 1:16:05the ball is round for George Campbell. Of course, we'll give him time
- 1:16:10to grow one hundred percent. Of course, when we decided on grading players,
- 1:16:15we only decided to create players that have played five hundred minutes and more
- 1:16:20and are that are still with the club as of today. So we were
- 1:16:26not great really, Camacho and kamal Miller. There's no other center backs,
- 1:16:31real center backs that have reached that. But let's just give just a few
- 1:16:38things on the center backs that are still under contract, just quickly, quickly.
- 1:16:44Uh. First, First of all, we have Fernando al Virus.
- 1:16:46It's going to be for a couple of years. We've seen some some some
- 1:16:50some spells here and there. It's a project. We'll see what what what
- 1:16:56it will give. But also Robert Taklism that has as is at the end
- 1:17:01of the contract still has an option for twenty twenty four and twenty twenty five
- 1:17:06Husman Jabang that's not under contract either, an option also for twenty twenty four
- 1:17:14twenty twenty five. If you are only via, will you sign? Will
- 1:17:16you pick up the option for one of them Tokosen Usman Jabang or would you
- 1:17:23let them go? And for Fernando Rivares. Are you confident or not confident?
- 1:17:27Without giving greed? Of course, go ahead, Elias, I'll let
- 1:17:30you start. I think Usmanjabang is far more likely to get picked up than
- 1:17:35Robert Turklsen. I think Robert Turkosen was a nice idea. I think there
- 1:17:40was some potential there. But is the U twenty two form. Is the
- 1:17:44U twenty two initiative too? So it's true, but I think just from
- 1:17:48a sporting perspective, you you say thank you and you move on because it's
- 1:17:55it's unfortunately work. I think Jabang, you know, just come out of
- 1:17:58the draft. It's his first year. He wasn't expected. Can you get
- 1:18:00many minutes? God? I think he's made what like two or three appearances
- 1:18:05and look, you know, it's it is what it is. I think
- 1:18:09that next year will be a much more substantial year if you can stay fit.
- 1:18:13And for Fernando Os, except for that one mistake against Houston, he
- 1:18:15was relatively mistake free. I think that I like and exactly exactly so I
- 1:18:23think that you know what bringing up, Yeah, I agree with you.
- 1:18:26I think for me, by Tokilsen, let's wait and see what others can
- 1:18:31can give and I'll sign ja Bank for one option year and see where where
- 1:18:36he goes. I agree with that. If anything else to add on those
- 1:18:41three no elias first, so moving on, we do have a few other
- 1:18:48players, of course, and it's going to be the wing backs. Let's
- 1:18:51start first of all with I think the most difficult one is out of contract
- 1:19:00as of right now. Yes, the club has two option years for twenty
- 1:19:06twenty four and twenty twenty five. He's going to be twenty five this January.
- 1:19:13Let's create him knowing that you know, he had an okay season,
- 1:19:19Eve, I'll let you start, you know, would you keep him great?
- 1:19:25And whatever you want to say on it. Yeah, I mean his
- 1:19:30season this season was quite similar to last season. Obviously, another starting right
- 1:19:33wing back came in and kind of took the position over him. I think
- 1:19:38the only thing kind of is that Aaron Herrera didn't do it with as much
- 1:19:41a plum as Alister Johnston had done in twenty twenty two. So, I
- 1:19:47mean, I think Zach Bergierart has been with the club for quite some time,
- 1:19:50so I feel like we know really well what to expect from him.
- 1:19:54You know, his defensive coverage can be a little bit spotty when he's playing
- 1:19:57the wing back position. He likes to bomb up forward. I think his
- 1:20:00decision making has consistently improved year over year in the attacking phase of play when
- 1:20:05he's asked to contribute to it. So that is something that I will I
- 1:20:11will rate as positive in his column. I didn't see any you know,
- 1:20:15any thing there for me. He's he's been a servant of the of the
- 1:20:20club for a long time, and as for whether to keep him, I
- 1:20:27kind of almost feel like a little bit a little bit of a similar situation
- 1:20:31to James Pantemis. So if he's content to be a backup, you know,
- 1:20:38he has a long term contract. He just had a baby here in
- 1:20:43Montreal, so you know, he's obviously quite attached to the city. So
- 1:20:46if he's if he's okay with you know, playing on a bench roll and
- 1:20:50not being the starter necessarily every game. He did get a really good consistent
- 1:20:54run with Aaron Herrera's injury this year, and then I am all for keeping
- 1:20:59him because he is, you know, although he grew up a lot in
- 1:21:03Quebec certainly you know, or sorry, in France, actually more so than
- 1:21:08in Quebec. He is somebody who who's been with this club for a very
- 1:21:12long time, who's kind of been through the ringer. So I'm going to
- 1:21:16vote keep Zachary bro Gyard if he wants to stay in the spirit of the
- 1:21:24role that he currently has. For this I didn't see any huge improvement or
- 1:21:29any huge, you know, decrease I'm missing the word, any you know
- 1:21:38anything that that looked bad compared to last year for Zachary Brougyard in the performances
- 1:21:44we got from him. So I'm gonna say, if he stayed pretty consistent,
- 1:21:47I'll give him a six point five out of ten for that. Oh
- 1:21:54wow, Okay, that's wow, okay wow. Oh yeah. Well,
- 1:22:02I like this season as a super sub. I know that he wants to
- 1:22:08do more. Unfortunately, he doesn't have what it takes to be a starter
- 1:22:13in my opinion, because every time he starts the game, he's not very
- 1:22:16consistent. But as a bench player, when he comes in, he can
- 1:22:20bring that extra a pace, that extra you know, push to get a
- 1:22:29goal or and creates some very interesting things offensively just defensively, that's sometimes where
- 1:22:36it's not really good most of the time. I think he needs a change
- 1:22:42of scenery. I think also Montreal needs a change of scenery so that we
- 1:22:48don't have always the same discussion of as Ah is better than he should he
- 1:22:56is and he should he be the starter where there's another one. I think
- 1:23:00it has to be clearer, and I think he's paid a bit too much
- 1:23:05to be to be to be a backup right wing back in my opinion,
- 1:23:10So I think he's over two hundred. I think it's about two hundred and
- 1:23:13fifty or three thousand, Yeah, three hundred thousand, which is a bit
- 1:23:16too much, knowing the structure of the salaries that the Sefon trail has,
- 1:23:24so no for me, I wouldn't. I wouldn't really, you know,
- 1:23:27extend his contract. But you know what, I don't think Zach Oyeah wants
- 1:23:32to stay either. I think you guys were if you were a bit too
- 1:23:38generous I would give him a five out of ten because he did play quite
- 1:23:43a few games this year, and unfortunately, for someone that plays that high
- 1:23:50up as a right wing back, I would have liked to see a bit
- 1:23:55more status because we saw him most of the time played not even as a
- 1:23:59right wing back, but as a winger, like really really high up.
- 1:24:03And he only has like he played in twenty four games, yes, of
- 1:24:06course not a starter in all of them, but still twenty four games and
- 1:24:11he has just all competitions two goals and assist. And for me, right
- 1:24:15wing back that plays that high up should have at least a few more.
- 1:24:19Shit is two three four years a game. You forget the strikers that he
- 1:24:24was serving still, you know, for a few weeks from now, Yeah,
- 1:24:30exactly. But other players have able to give more assists than him playing
- 1:24:34that position. So you know, that's something that I'm looking at myself.
- 1:24:40Elias, do you are you more an Eve on Eve's seam or had he
- 1:24:46seem Because it's the first time I disagree on the player, Yeah, I
- 1:24:50am smack dab in the middle. I gave Zachar Bergard to six this year
- 1:24:57just because I do disagree with Eve A bit in that I did see some
- 1:25:01some significant steps forward. He also to remember he played double the minutes this
- 1:25:06year that he played compared to that he played under NELSI one because Aaron Herra
- 1:25:12got hurt for a long time this year. And also secondly, you're going
- 1:25:15up against Alistair Johnston, You're gonna come up second every single time. It's
- 1:25:19just you know, a byproduct of being in competition with arguably the best right
- 1:25:24back in the league at that point. Uh last year one of and I
- 1:25:29think this year I he was. He was exactly what was needed at certain
- 1:25:34moments. And I think that he would have looked even better if Aaron Hurrah
- 1:25:40stayed healthy and he would have kind of embraced his role as like this spark
- 1:25:43plug, because I feel like every time he came off the bench, it
- 1:25:46was a shot in the arm that the that the attack needed. And I
- 1:25:49think that he embodies this the other side. Like we always talk about metro
- 1:25:56and and and this this effort, he embodies the other side of it where
- 1:26:00he has this this aggression and this energy that wakes everybody up. And that's
- 1:26:06what you want from a super sub, especially you know, a fullback,
- 1:26:13especially one of those flank players because he doesn't necessarily have the legs to play
- 1:26:16at full ninety minutes, but those thirty minutes, he will run for thirty
- 1:26:21minutes, right, And I think that he kind of does embrace this this
- 1:26:26dog mentality where he is like, good, I'm going for a scrap,
- 1:26:30whether it is a physical scrap or if it's you know, like a territorial
- 1:26:33one with another fallback. I think that he loves those challenges, and I
- 1:26:38think that he is a bit expensive. But if I'm Montreal and he has
- 1:26:45and he is okay with you know again for the time being playing second fiddle
- 1:26:49to Aaron Herrera, I keep him on board because he has been I think
- 1:26:56he's taken massive steps forward. Even if his production's gone down compared to last
- 1:27:00year, I think he's taken master steps forward in terms of his the way
- 1:27:03he goes about his game. So I look forward to to seeing that continued
- 1:27:10evolution, especially in a in a style of play that's as vertical as Losadas.
- 1:27:15I think that, you know, this is a style made for him,
- 1:27:16and I hope that they keep him on board. We'll see He's a
- 1:27:21six out of ten for zach Aboga. Moving on next player Lassie lap a
- 1:27:27line and as the left wing back Lassie lap Line and played a few games
- 1:27:31this year, of course, a lot of injuries. Again, he is
- 1:27:35under contract for next year for twenty twenty four. By the way, guys,
- 1:27:41eve, let's let's start with the Lassi lap line. Yeah. I
- 1:27:45think he's going to be around, but I don't think it's like a good
- 1:27:47thing. I mean, he's already had a he's had an operation, you
- 1:27:55know, for a sports hernia, so he's not going to be ready to
- 1:27:58start the season next year. And unfortunately he is a bit of an injury
- 1:28:01prone player. I mean, the one thing I will say for Lassie is
- 1:28:06that Erna Lazada seemed to just super simplify it this year because we have been
- 1:28:11back and forth and back and forth and back and forth about Lastie is a
- 1:28:14left winger. Last he has left wing back, blah blah blah, and
- 1:28:16Lozada just seemed to say, you know what, screw it, let's just
- 1:28:19put him on the right since he's not left footed. And let's face it,
- 1:28:24he looked significantly more comfortable on that side than he did on the left
- 1:28:29side this year. Like, yeah, he did look really good on that
- 1:28:30side last year, but everybody looked good last year, so and I mean
- 1:28:35credit to him for making it work last year however, he did, but
- 1:28:40again this year it was back to that really really awkward left winger left wing
- 1:28:44back style of play that we've become accustomed to with Lassie. Unfortunately for him,
- 1:28:47though, Montreal has a bevy of right sided players available to them who
- 1:28:53are not tam players also taking up an international spot. So you know,
- 1:29:00for me for last of this year, I like, I mean, for
- 1:29:03the amount of money that the club pays him, he should be a difference
- 1:29:06maker, you know, especially for you know, the lowest salary in the
- 1:29:12league. If you're making tim like, it's basically a miracle. So I'm
- 1:29:18going to give him a four. We didn't see very much and when we
- 1:29:23did see it, he looked good, but it was on the wrong side
- 1:29:26of the pitch for where we actually need the players. So I'm going to
- 1:29:30give him a four. And do you keep him or you don't? I
- 1:29:33said, yeah, I said at the start, I think he is around
- 1:29:35next season, but like, I don't think it's a good thing. Yeah,
- 1:29:39but yeah, but do you keep him? And you know, independently
- 1:29:42of his contract you if it's my choice. No, no, okay,
- 1:29:45thanks, I just wanted to be to be clear. Uh. You know,
- 1:29:50that's very interesting, and that's the reason last se is the reason why
- 1:29:54I would not keep Zacharrbergiyut. And you know if answered a part of that
- 1:29:58question saying that sad I can't decided to play as a right wing back,
- 1:30:02and I think that's where he could be very interesting as a backup to the
- 1:30:06other right wing back. But also what's interesting also is to know what you
- 1:30:13just said, zach Uberguard makes too much money to be a backup. You
- 1:30:15want your player to be. I'm continuing. I think what's interesting is that
- 1:30:21he can play as a right wing back, he can play as a left
- 1:30:25wing back, and he can play as a forward because Lasada did play him
- 1:30:29as a forward at one point. Also, so I think that's very interesting
- 1:30:31to have a backup because he is on the contract either way next year,
- 1:30:34it's not because I don't think nobody's going to come and pay money for him.
- 1:30:39So I would keep him either way because he's going to be with us.
- 1:30:42I would keep him as as a backup, knowing that he can be
- 1:30:45versatile and play in other positions. Now, I didn't like his season at
- 1:30:51all for our of tennis. Also the grade that I would give him,
- 1:30:57And I think I'm generous too, but I don't think if we can maybe
- 1:31:06since we're stuck with him the next year, if we can't sell him,
- 1:31:11that will be better. But if we can't that, if we can sell
- 1:31:14him, I would resign. If we can't sell him, then I would
- 1:31:17not sign. Yeah, for me, their future is uh is uh is
- 1:31:23link is linked between between the two of them. So yeah, so four
- 1:31:28out of ten I want to see more of lastly, like I want to
- 1:31:31see him progress. Yeah, but like he's he's not evolving at all,
- 1:31:35and and that's he's not. But you okay, well you're you're signing up
- 1:31:42for another season, so I have a choice, he's No, you said
- 1:31:46I would keep him, yeah, because he has a contract, right,
- 1:31:51No, But you asked me earlier, Hattie, you said, like,
- 1:31:55irrespective of the contractual situation, Yeah, I would either I would let him
- 1:32:00say you would keep him. No, I would let him go. Sorry,
- 1:32:04oh okay, no, maybe I didn't. I wasn't clear myself.
- 1:32:11I would let him go. But if I have a choice between LASTI lapin
- 1:32:16and who who I can't second and signing and signing an extension for exec I
- 1:32:24would choose lastly, lap of lining and just not extend because for me,
- 1:32:28it's there's no reason why I would have the two of them together in the
- 1:32:31squad. Uh So, so that's my opinion. I stated, sorry,
- 1:32:36I didn't make sense at one point, Elias, what do you what do
- 1:32:40you think about last lapeline? I agree with the four, but I disagree
- 1:32:44with both of you and it hinges. It hinges mainly on what Hernan Losada
- 1:32:50does with his formation next year. If we have wingers, if we see
- 1:32:55wings okay, the coach touch, if we see wingers, Internsada's formation like
- 1:33:06we saw at the end, or or whomever's formation next year, I think
- 1:33:14he could be And again, this is operating under the assumption that, look,
- 1:33:18we're keeping him next year because I don't think they can get rid of
- 1:33:20that contract even if they do trade him. And he's got another year,
- 1:33:25so while he's here, may as well make good use of him. He
- 1:33:28was arguably the best offensive super sub that they had off the bench in terms
- 1:33:35of impact. When it came to breaking down low blocks, he usually was
- 1:33:41the one that was his burst to pace was the one that was breaking little
- 1:33:45blocks. I think if you have him as a winger, because it's it's
- 1:33:48very clear that defensively not only does not does he not have the stamina of
- 1:33:54Aria Lassiter. I think that air Laster is actually a better defender than last
- 1:33:57lap line in his But if you have him as an now winger, you
- 1:34:01see that effect that he has. He's good with the dribble, he's quick,
- 1:34:06and you know, without the burden of that defensive responsibility, if you
- 1:34:11have him for half an hour a game, he could be very impactful.
- 1:34:15So I think that you know, having him next year is not is not
- 1:34:23completely you know, it doesn't counsel at Zachary Brogard. I think the two
- 1:34:29of them can can exist, kind of can kind of coexist. But ultimately
- 1:34:35I think FOURG and ten is fair, and I think keeping him as a
- 1:34:39super sub there could be worse things in the world. Okay, moving on,
- 1:34:44we still have just a couple more players before we wrap it up with
- 1:34:49of course the last subject that we have. We put him there because he
- 1:34:56did play everywhere and I think we wanted to give I think a good grade
- 1:35:01to someone on this post mortem. I think I wanted to give a good
- 1:35:08grade what a player, honestly, what a player. I'm not gonna,
- 1:35:12you know, say too much on him. Just versatile, he's abled.
- 1:35:17He exceeded the perform the expectations of everybody. I think everybody, coach included,
- 1:35:26all the fans included, everybody. I think nobody was expecting a season
- 1:35:30like the one that Maya Shania had. I think an eight out of ten
- 1:35:39is the right grade that I will give him because it's very it's very hard
- 1:35:43for me to give more than that eight out of ten. Of course he's
- 1:35:46here. I think he should sign a contract extension as soon as possible to
- 1:35:51be to show our appreciation of that player that says that he's willing to stay
- 1:35:58here. He's very happy here, see him finish his career at the club.
- 1:36:02He's under contract in twenty twenty four with an option in twenty twenty five.
- 1:36:06But I'm pretty sure he's going to sign an extension pretty soon. He's
- 1:36:11only twenty four, he's going to be twenty five in February. Please stay
- 1:36:15and stay, and then let's let us have you a bit more at amazing
- 1:36:21player, amazing personality. So impressed, so impressed, likes. I'm giving
- 1:36:30him a nine just because of the fact that you know, I gave you
- 1:36:33to one eight and I feel like I have This year was borderline faultless,
- 1:36:41and so I gotta I gotta take one step up from that you said at
- 1:36:45all. I mean he stepped onto the first time the first game that he
- 1:36:49played. You know, he was like shot out of a cannon, and
- 1:36:55everyone's kind of waiting for his momentum to die down and just didn't. So
- 1:36:59I can't wait to see what he adds to his arsenal next year. And
- 1:37:02I can't wait to see the growing he's going to do, because it seems
- 1:37:05like he's got his he's got his head in the right place, and he's
- 1:37:08got his priority set out, and he seems to be very not content with
- 1:37:15like wrestling on his laurels, but the good season he's had, so it
- 1:37:16looks like he wants to keep on improving, which is exactly what you want
- 1:37:19to see from your best player. So yeah, it's a nine, and
- 1:37:23I can't wait to see the metrich running up again next season. Yeah,
- 1:37:30I'm sorry, were youdone? Oh I was about to see that you talk
- 1:37:34about. Yeah, no, has been one of my Yeah, he's been
- 1:37:42one of the great joys of Montreal these last couple of years. You know,
- 1:37:47I feel like we say it almost week in and week out, and
- 1:37:49sometimes, you know, he's the only positive point to talk about when we
- 1:37:54were talking about a Montreal match. I'm really really glad that he's been recognized.
- 1:38:00You know, he won Player of the Year at the club level,
- 1:38:02he won the Jason Tutulio Trophy. He finally got called up and got some
- 1:38:08minutes with the national team, even though like it wasn't you know, in
- 1:38:11the greatest match of national team history. So I'm really glad to see it,
- 1:38:16and I agree that I think some kind of extension does need to be
- 1:38:21offered. I'm kind of surprised it wasn't done and dusted oh quite a while
- 1:38:25ago. I understand, you know, he did get a you know,
- 1:38:30he does have his contract well underway. But I think it is important to
- 1:38:34acknowledge, like you said, Hattie, his importance to the club in the
- 1:38:38city. And I think we did get to see the captains aren't bent on
- 1:38:41him a couple of times this season, and for me it fits he is
- 1:38:45somebody no for me, he's somebody who should who should be around this club
- 1:38:51to the end of his days if that's what he wants. So yeah,
- 1:38:59nothing, nothing but good things to say. He was one of the few
- 1:39:02players, aren't we could rely consistently this season? Yeah? So yeah,
- 1:39:10okay, good, So we all agree on Nate. I know, I
- 1:39:14like to said nine, but it's going to be an eight for Marianne.
- 1:39:16But like two out of three said eight, so you know, good,
- 1:39:27So moving on, we still have one player to go, and I think
- 1:39:30he's not played in so long I can't even remember what to say an heir.
- 1:39:34Honestly, I'm going to start this time. Honestly, I think that
- 1:39:41his injuries really hurt c F Montreal. I think this player can be dominant
- 1:39:48in this league. He's able to give some great crosses and he saw it
- 1:39:53at the beginning of the season. How how many times has the team really
- 1:39:58given him the ball for him across the ball? That was very very interesting.
- 1:40:02His offensive flare is really nice. Defensively, he's very sound, there's
- 1:40:08no problem there. I think he's a very good player. I think that
- 1:40:12unfortunately, because he was injured for so long, so he didn't see the
- 1:40:17good part of the season in a certain way, and even when he was
- 1:40:21here, I felt that he was diminished in a certain way. But I
- 1:40:30love the player. I think that he's the right fit for Montreal. I
- 1:40:34think that he can be very very good for this club, and I can't
- 1:40:38wait to see him. It's not someone that's injury prone usually, so you
- 1:40:43know, I hope that we're going to be able to see him play a
- 1:40:46whole year next year. I would give him a five out of ten because
- 1:40:53unfortunately I can't give him more because he didn't play enough games. In my
- 1:41:00opinion, his injuries are taking you know, a toll on his on his
- 1:41:04overall grade in my opinion, and of course I would keep him with the
- 1:41:08club. He's still under contract with the club for twenty twenty four, with
- 1:41:14an option for twenty twenty five. Eve. Yeah, I completely agree with
- 1:41:21you. The injuries were not definitely not helpful to either the club or to
- 1:41:28the player himself. I think his adaptation to Montreal, and I mean obviously
- 1:41:32he came in there was an injury crisis to start with, you know,
- 1:41:35new coach. He was in a brand new environment. He had been you
- 1:41:39know at realesl Lake for quite a long time beforehand, so I think probably
- 1:41:44especially just given the reaction to the trade and kind of everything that we were
- 1:41:47told, we were kind of expecting fireworks out the gate with him, and
- 1:41:53that wasn't necessarily what Montreal got during his first several matches with the club.
- 1:41:58But once, you know, they kind of got over that hump whatever you
- 1:42:01want to call the disaster start to the season, we did start to see
- 1:42:08a lot of that attacking player that he could offer. That made us,
- 1:42:11you know, maybe cry a little less over the departure of Alistair Johnston to
- 1:42:15greener pastures as well. You know, he does still retain a really good
- 1:42:20defensive awareness, and I think he has a sufficient pace and energy to keep
- 1:42:26bombing up and down that right side of the quarter if it is indeed a
- 1:42:32wing back role that he's going to be expected to play next season. But
- 1:42:36yeah, being consistently healthy is so important. I really liked his crossing of
- 1:42:41the ball. I thought he delivered some great crosses. Unfortunately, you know,
- 1:42:44Montreal struggled with conversional season, so to give him a grade like,
- 1:42:50it's been a long time since he's last played like a match, so for
- 1:42:55me, it's kind of hard to give him my grade. So I'm going
- 1:42:58to kind of pull this one a little bit out of thin air. I'll
- 1:43:01give him a seven out of ten. Oh wow, I'm not sure though,
- 1:43:08I'm really not married. Oh wow, I'm impressed. No, it's
- 1:43:13just he's not played since oh my gosh. Yeah, that's why I give
- 1:43:16him five. Yeah, since August. Okay, well you know what,
- 1:43:21then I'm going to give him a six. I changed my mind. Sorry,
- 1:43:24I'm going to get him. Yeah, I'm not. I'm just not
- 1:43:28one hundred percent, like, I'm not committed to any number. Okay,
- 1:43:31lie, Yeah, I was going to give him a seven based on performances,
- 1:43:38but I was going to settle on the six because of availability. Right.
- 1:43:42Uh, just I don't remember what it's like seeing him play, which
- 1:43:46is just kind of depressing because he has he's been absent for so long.
- 1:43:49But yeah, I mean I think that he does have that similar profile to
- 1:43:54Alistair Johnston. I think I don't think he's a good defensively, but I
- 1:43:57do think he's actually better than he has He could be better going forward.
- 1:44:01So we'll see, Uh, we'll see what his usages like next season,
- 1:44:04hopefully, you know, a full season but I think you know again,
- 1:44:09it's another player with with tremendous upside that can play a variety of roles.
- 1:44:14And it's honestly just you know, your best abilities availability, right, so
- 1:44:20just getting there, staying healthy and being able to to put out you know,
- 1:44:26he played a few minutes in Brogiard. By the end of the season,
- 1:44:28right, he played one hundred minutes, So that if that, if
- 1:44:30that doesn't tell you anything, then like you know, there you go.
- 1:44:34So that's it. Just just keep doing keep growing from there, but just
- 1:44:40stay healthy. Exactly interesting. Interesting, So h so we're going to settle
- 1:44:46for a six out of ten because two of you decided to put a six.
- 1:44:50So that's it for the review of the players. We're get to move
- 1:44:55on to our last subject. It's not going to be a very long subject,
- 1:44:58but it's important for us to talk about it, even if it's been
- 1:45:01a while now. So many things happened. It's the game of the Canadian
- 1:45:05women's national team against Brazil. The second game of the double header for Canada
- 1:45:12that played against Brazil in Halifax, sold that stadium again in Halifax. Lineup
- 1:45:17for Webes Treatsman with D'Angelo playing as a goalkeeper, first time that she is
- 1:45:25between the posts for a long long time. As central defenders, we had
- 1:45:30Kadisha Buchanan, Shelina Zadorski and uh Vanessa Jill. As midfielders, we had
- 1:45:39Quinn along Reagan and uh who was the third one? It was let me
- 1:45:50know, not Fleming who was in the middle midfielders. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:45:58sorry, yeah, right, you're right right, sorry about that to midfielders.
- 1:46:01As a right wing back, we had Lawrence as the left wing back.
- 1:46:04We did have Rivier up front, we had on the right Leon on
- 1:46:11the left Heightma and upfront and upfront. Yeah, sorry, I'm just yeah,
- 1:46:17so looking at the substitutions between the first game and the rotation between the
- 1:46:23first game and the second alias. We talked about it last week and we
- 1:46:27said that, I said that it would have been nice to see some quebecers
- 1:46:31play in Montreal, and you know, you and Alexander were really told me
- 1:46:38that, no, that they weren't really surprised that. You know, we're
- 1:46:42building for Paris tenty twenty four and you know we have to see the starting
- 1:46:46eleven, but now we see a rotation. So what do you think about
- 1:46:49that? Knowing that you know, Beth Reeson really wanted to establish her starting
- 1:46:55eleven. But then in Halifax we see a Quebecers start I think would have
- 1:47:00been better in Montreal, and we see something different. Do you think it's
- 1:47:04related to results After the result that that the team had in Montreal. I
- 1:47:11think we have more of an emotional attachment to Quebecers playing Quebec than than bet
- 1:47:14Priestman does. I think that's the crux of it. I think that you
- 1:47:17know, clearly Casts and Illini are both in such phenomenal form that Bet Priest
- 1:47:23was probably like, you know, you get one start, you get one
- 1:47:25start, and then what kind of will aggregate? Exactly it would have been
- 1:47:30inted. It may be. It may also be there's there's a million,
- 1:47:36there's a million and one different different reasons why yeah, Iliandia is starting,
- 1:47:42you know in front of them would have been idea, yeah exactly. Yeah,
- 1:47:48But but ultimately I was, I was. I was happy to see
- 1:47:51because again, you know, that was probably the game of Montreal. Is
- 1:47:57probably your your your your strongest or what pre school field in a competitive match,
- 1:48:01but there's some other players that you know, do have a very decent
- 1:48:06shout at claiming a starting spot. So I think that you know, having
- 1:48:12them also get a start and having them control like you know, the ebbs
- 1:48:15and foes, not just as a sub, but how can you handle uh
- 1:48:18a starting role is very good to know. So I wasn't too surprised at
- 1:48:23some of the changes, and I was happy to see that, you know,
- 1:48:25a lot of people continue to get a look and that you know,
- 1:48:28we saw Lawrence on the right hand side two games in a row, which
- 1:48:31is great. Interesting talking about the changes, Eve, what did you think
- 1:48:39about I'm going to ask you just a couple more couple of questions together.
- 1:48:43First of all, what did you what did you think about the three forwards
- 1:48:47like Leon, the combinations between the three uh, the choice of profiles between
- 1:48:55the three, but also at the same time that pair up in the middle
- 1:48:59between Reagan and Quinn. What did you think about all that? Because I
- 1:49:03think, you know, there's a lot of interesting things that we can we
- 1:49:09can you know, get out of this game, So go ahead with with
- 1:49:13your thoughts. Yeah, So I think it was really interesting to see Jordan
- 1:49:18Haidem I deployed as a winger because that's typically not the role that we're used
- 1:49:21to seeing her play in the national team setup, definitely. You know,
- 1:49:27she is a very mobile player and Evelyn vienn needs to be the central striker.
- 1:49:30Like for me, there is no other role for her. She does
- 1:49:32not have that versatility in her arsenal and perhaps that as MoMA does go against
- 1:49:38her is that she is a striker's striker, you know, whereas Adriana Leon
- 1:49:44can play as well as a central striker if asked, although she is very
- 1:49:46reliable on the wing. For sure, I thought it was creative. We
- 1:49:53haven't seen a lot of creativity from Bev Priestman in quite a while, and
- 1:49:57I was really disappointed really with how Cookie Cover I felt the lineup that we
- 1:50:00saw in Montreal was, and I was really concerned that we were going to
- 1:50:03see the same thing in Halifax. So I was really pleased to see a
- 1:50:08degree of rotation and some innovation as well for it by Priestsman. I think
- 1:50:11she's clearly trying to, you know, move forward with a new formation,
- 1:50:15and I know she's talked a little bit about how she's wanted to change things
- 1:50:18up tactically, especially in the post Christine Saint Clair era which is coming quickly
- 1:50:24upon us. But that being said, you know, yeah, So for
- 1:50:30me, attacking wise, I thought it was creative. I mean, it
- 1:50:31took a long time for Canada to get going attackingly. It really wasn't until
- 1:50:36the second half that they produced many chances of note against against Brazil. But
- 1:50:43that being said, it was one of the more interesting changes I've seen from
- 1:50:47about priestsman in a little while. As for the midfield, Emma Reagan,
- 1:50:53you know, I'm going to be honest, I don't remember when she played
- 1:50:57for Canada in twenty eighteen, so I really don't have a basis comparison.
- 1:51:00That being said, I thought, you know, comparatively at that point,
- 1:51:03had a really disastrous game in Montreal unfortunately, and normally I am like their
- 1:51:09number one fan, but I thought that the setup was a lot more stable
- 1:51:15this time around against Brazil. You know, I don't know exactly how much
- 1:51:20rotation Brazil had done. I didn't pay a ton of attention. I just
- 1:51:24knew Martin was out there, so Elias was living his best life. And
- 1:51:30I did think there was a lot more simplicity and a lot more stability in
- 1:51:34the midfield compared to in Montreal. And maybe the loss of Jesse Funning might
- 1:51:39have contributed to the shambalic midfield in Montreal, but overall, Emma Reagan.
- 1:51:46For me, our sample size is really really small, but I think I
- 1:51:51would be interested to see some more of what she could bring as a depth
- 1:51:55and rotation option for Canada, because I do you feel like we've kind of
- 1:52:01tested the limits of the Quinn Grosso Fleming triad to its limits. Interesting.
- 1:52:12Honestly, I liked what I saw from from Reagan. Yes, small sample
- 1:52:15side, but I really like what I saw. I would be very interested
- 1:52:20to see a Reagan Fleming duo in the midfield. At one point. I
- 1:52:26think that the loss of Jesse Fleming in the midfield really heard us a lot,
- 1:52:30and that's why the first half was dismal, in my opinion, really
- 1:52:35really bad and really tough to watch. But I think when Jesse Fleming came
- 1:52:42in, we saw that spark in the midfield that really started to show.
- 1:52:46And obviously, you know, because you know, Jesse Fleming was here,
- 1:52:50bef Riesement substituted Livia, we saw a Dianne Rose come in, We saw
- 1:52:58colorin La Cask come in for Adrian Leon, and honestly, it made sense,
- 1:53:02you know, those changes made sense we needed something different with Diane Rose.
- 1:53:10I think I prefer Deane Rose to Adriana Leon personally, there are the
- 1:53:15same profile. Agree, I prefer Deane Rose, but I prefer to hide
- 1:53:23them on. But that's my personal opinion. So I we saw some interesting
- 1:53:28things from the Frieseman and we haven't seen that in the first game in Montreal.
- 1:53:33I just I don't like the link ups that that that she makes.
- 1:53:38I think we could have a better a better, better team, a better
- 1:53:43starting eleven with better choices from the get go in my opinion. But yeah,
- 1:53:48and yeah, go ahead, go ahead. I think my one concern
- 1:53:51is that whatever set up of placement deploys is so dependent on Jesse Forming to
- 1:53:59make things work, and I think she needs to have a plan B.
- 1:54:05Yeah, but not only that, I think we need to give a bit
- 1:54:10more responsibilities to Ashley Lawrence as the right way back, and we saw that
- 1:54:15in Montreal elis and we talked about it last week. On the left side,
- 1:54:20I can't wait to have a Gabrielle car because even if she played only
- 1:54:25a few minutes here and there in the two games, sorry, in the
- 1:54:28only game and in in Halifax, uh not Montreal, h she didn't play
- 1:54:33cal didn't play. Oh my god, oh god. And I really liked
- 1:54:40what she showed in the last ten minutes of the game where she came in
- 1:54:43in Halifax. And I think she's going to be a lot more impactful than
- 1:54:48Jade Riviere or whoever she chose. You know, Collins on the left.
- 1:54:54I think you need to see an Ashley Lawrence on the right and the Gabrielle
- 1:54:57car on the left. And I think that will be very interesting offensively too.
- 1:55:01So Lias, talk to me about that goal from Jordan Heidema, she
- 1:55:08hadn't scored in a while across of Ashley Lawrence, obviously, talk to me
- 1:55:14about that goal. How important is it for Canada, but also for Jordan
- 1:55:18Heidem. We talked about it last week. We were begging, we were
- 1:55:23pleading, right like, please play Jordan Hidema at her natural position and obviously
- 1:55:29is much more of a proper nine than Jordan Heidem is. You can play
- 1:55:33on the wing, but you know, with Tiandros coming in, Jordan Heidma
- 1:55:36playing up at number nine. You know, in in Montreal when we saw
- 1:55:43absolute lyon like shift over the middle and Jordan Heideman move over to the right,
- 1:55:46which was kind of just nobody understood why. So just you know,
- 1:55:51you put a poacher in the right spot, and you put someone with great
- 1:55:56crossing ability aiming right at her good things right, and and Jerda Heidema is
- 1:56:01just you know, she has his eye for goal and showed it again.
- 1:56:04And the second that, you know, she scored that, I was like,
- 1:56:09well, yeah, she's playing, she's playing in her preferred position.
- 1:56:12It's a poacher's goal and it was great. You know, everything we had
- 1:56:15asked for after the Monshalga and we saw in the second half, so it
- 1:56:19was you know, just all in all, just finally you know. So
- 1:56:24it's a display that you can kind of come away smileing. Yeah, very
- 1:56:29interesting. So interesting. Also, you know that the second goal with the
- 1:56:32flick header from I love that. Yeah, really nice. I just want
- 1:56:38to say, first goal in a while. So that's really interesting, especially
- 1:56:43given her injury journey that she was on. You know, I think the
- 1:56:45injury and also and also is her contractual situation with Reading and the whole problem
- 1:56:50behind it, and you know the fact that she signed with Lester after Yeah,
- 1:56:56exactly. No, she's definitely been through the Ringer I would say in
- 1:56:59the last year or so so really really really really happy for her. So
- 1:57:02thank you for mentioning that. Yeah, moving on, we do have a
- 1:57:06few questions, six questions, and we're so happy to answer your questions.
- 1:57:13Guys, really keep erstending them. It's always very interesting to interact with you.
- 1:57:17So let's go ahead and answer those questions. We'll start with amine,
- 1:57:21I mean, Savri. Now that all the MLS teams ask for big gam
- 1:57:26amounts for trades and also the international signing not working well, do you think
- 1:57:30naw would change his strategy this year? Maybe with free agency, reentry draft
- 1:57:35and higher and better super draft picks. Now that Justin Mapp is here,
- 1:57:42So do you think that do you think that will change his strategy? I
- 1:57:48think he should. I think he should especially I know yes, like yes,
- 1:57:55by young sign young players develop them blah blah blah. But do need
- 1:58:00veteran presence. And so if you are going to be investing the majority of
- 1:58:03your of your your player acquisition funds into those young project type players or back
- 1:58:15into your academy, however it may be, then you need to look for
- 1:58:18alternative channels to find veteran players. And MLS has a curious way of working
- 1:58:27that doesn't necessarily mean signing a free agent from abroad is going to lead to
- 1:58:31quick success because it's so sol to adapt to a league here. So,
- 1:58:35yeah, some of those alternative channels, like I mean mentioned, like the
- 1:58:40re entry draft and the litany of other drafts that that MLS puts on I
- 1:58:45think are worth are worth looking at. Uh, Elias said that we need
- 1:58:53to strengthen the forward line. Uh do you think that it comes with an
- 1:58:58international signing a veteran presence like you've said, or do you think it can
- 1:59:02be within the MLS through the re entry draft, through a super draft,
- 1:59:08or through another intra MLS exchange or trades? Sorry, what do you think
- 1:59:14about that? What do you think the strategy is the best strategy for It's
- 1:59:21it depends on what they're looking for, right, They're looking for a proper
- 1:59:25forward and that's much more easier said than done, especially within MLS. You
- 1:59:31know when you look at interm LST trades that you know, if you exclude
- 1:59:35dps, forwards are very hit or miss and are rarely consistent. Right,
- 1:59:42so you really are kind of going off a whim here now when it comes
- 1:59:45to international signings and stuff like that, We've seen a lot of teams find
- 1:59:51their their striker and just run with her. You look at your go to
- 1:59:56Kumaku, who Kumakis, who just won you Comer of the Year. You
- 1:59:59look at Kucho, You look at a litany of of players that come in
- 2:00:03and embrace a very straightforward role at least to start ray. Kucho now has
- 2:00:11flushed out his game, but he started off as just a proper nine,
- 2:00:14and then then he became this, this monster that we see now. Kamakis
- 2:00:17is a proper nine. So if they're looking for something straightforward like that,
- 2:00:24you can go looking. But again, you know, you can also end
- 2:00:26up with the chan and go four where you know, it's a bit rough
- 2:00:29around the edges. So I think that their MLS business has been so much
- 2:00:34better than their international business that I think that it's more reliable. So at
- 2:00:39this point they're just looking for reliable so you have to go inter themalt thing
- 2:00:43interesting, very interesting. There are a few options, of course on the
- 2:00:45free agent market, and you know, let the people that really want to
- 2:00:50go look at the international market as free agents. There are some interesting players
- 2:00:56that can can take a look at. Now are he is he is going
- 2:01:00to be able to pay for them. That's a completely different Bowl game.
- 2:01:04He does have quite a few key decisions to take this off season, not
- 2:01:11only the coach, but we talked about all the players, the options and
- 2:01:15everything, and I think it's going to be a very very important, uh
- 2:01:19you know, transfer window for Levevana, very very important. Moving on,
- 2:01:25so hopefully we answer your question. I mean, I think that Justin Mapp
- 2:01:30has a role to play with the Super draft, maybe to go get you
- 2:01:34know, those players that not a lot of teams take a look at because
- 2:01:40not a lot of teams have some insiders that can give them some tips on
- 2:01:45the super draft. So hopefully he can find us a gem or two within
- 2:01:49the super draft and that could be very interesting too. Moving on with a
- 2:01:53second question is from Norman, will when Yama be back or will the Impact
- 2:01:58try to move him use his and Kyoto's for quality Number ten and nine,
- 2:02:03Elias, what do you think said it earlier this year? I think this
- 2:02:09is Kyoto's last season in Montreal and we've already been very clear about Wan Yama's
- 2:02:14standing. I think they're both gone and that does free up like, oh,
- 2:02:17well, you know, almost three million dollars so I think that,
- 2:02:21you know, yeah, you've got to make good use of it. That's
- 2:02:25a lot of money for a talisman striker and go for it. Wow eveh
- 2:02:33Yeah, I actually I agree completely. I think there's too much bad blood
- 2:02:38for wan Yama unfortunately with how things went with Lozada and for Kyoto obviously the
- 2:02:43injury history. You know, it was very tumultuous this season, and publicly
- 2:02:49he's training with another team. So yeah, as to how they spent any
- 2:02:57money that would be spent on their salaries, I wouldn't begin to dream to
- 2:03:01guess. You know, I'm pretty sure will be back. Losada will not
- 2:03:06be here, but Kyoto will be gone. If I was Olivia, I
- 2:03:11would resign wan Yama for a couple more seasons, but with a very lower
- 2:03:15salary, not as a DP, maybe as a time player if he agrees.
- 2:03:20If not, and another club wants him, so yeah, let him
- 2:03:25go for a small fee or even for free if he wants to, and
- 2:03:28then lose his salary. So it all depends on what Yama wants to do.
- 2:03:31If he accepts a lower salary, then I would, you know,
- 2:03:35sign him, give him an extension, and of course put more money on
- 2:03:43the offense, I wouldn't go for a striker. I would go for a
- 2:03:45creative ten. But that's my opinion. I think we need someone that can
- 2:03:50be the mice throw in the midfield. But that's my personal opinion. Moving
- 2:03:56on, next question, what do you think about the choice of coach for
- 2:04:00the US national team? Uh? So, Eve, that's for you.
- 2:04:04So we have Emma Hayes that signed for I don't think I don't think it's
- 2:04:12officially yet, yeah, but it's kind of yeah, it's like one of
- 2:04:16those Yeah, just to present the Hayes if you don't mind. Ex Chelsea
- 2:04:25coach that won the league four times, the f A Cup a couple of
- 2:04:30times, and has been with Chelsea for for for a few years now.
- 2:04:35So very very experienced coach, but also someone that has has a few a
- 2:04:43few titles under the belt. Is it the the kind of resume that you
- 2:04:48want to see with the national team, someone that has expected the expectations,
- 2:04:56you know, very high expectations, you know, towards a national team program.
- 2:05:03Yeah, I think so. I mean for the US women's national team.
- 2:05:06You know, they are used to being the top of the table in
- 2:05:12women's football, So I think absolutely, you need a very competitive coach.
- 2:05:16Things definitely did not go to plan under their their previous manager. And Emma
- 2:05:23Hayes has coached elite players. She has coached strong personalities of which there are
- 2:05:29no shortage on the US women's national team. She has won a bevy of
- 2:05:33trophies and I think that that pedigree is going to do her a world of
- 2:05:39good with the US women's national team. The soccer her team plays is really
- 2:05:45nice to watch. Chelsea is a really great, really really easy on the
- 2:05:49ice, very attacking, very very dominant on the field, almost stifling their
- 2:05:57opponents, you know, most weeks. So for me, yeah, it's
- 2:06:01honestly like a match made in habit or or hell. For the rest of
- 2:06:04us, I guess if you're if you're not a fan of you, what's
- 2:06:09one's action team? What does it mean that? Yeah, I think she's
- 2:06:15gonna have very high standards and that's going to line up right with Yeah,
- 2:06:20oh sorry you got cut off? So sorry, yeah, I don't know
- 2:06:26we lost you. So okay, hello are you here? I'm back?
- 2:06:31Oh yeah you're back? Okay, good good good? Sorry, Yeah I
- 2:06:35can hear you, we can hear you. I can hear you. You
- 2:06:40can't hear us. Okay, she can't hear us, it seems can you
- 2:06:46hear us even hear you? Okay, so go ahead. She got cut
- 2:06:51off at one point. We couldn't hear you. Have no idea what happened.
- 2:06:55I couldn't hear you. Okay, Yeah, good, perfect, Okay,
- 2:07:00So just moving on, and Elias, what do you think this move
- 2:07:09is going to be for the Canadian players of Chelsea? Because we do have
- 2:07:14Lawrence, you have Buchanan, and we do have Flemming. All three players.
- 2:07:18Are we going to be able to see them all, the three of
- 2:07:20them on the pitch together. That could be very interesting too. So I
- 2:07:25can't wait to see what's gonna happen with the Chelsea players. Yeah. I
- 2:07:30mean they form a nice little triangle. They're center back, right back,
- 2:07:34and and central midfielder. So I think, you know, I think that
- 2:07:40they are They're all very versati players, and they're all very adaptable, and
- 2:07:43I think that they can thrive under any manager. I think, you know,
- 2:07:47some Mike Mahyes has brought out the best in a team like Chelsea is
- 2:07:50already full of talented full stars. So I think for the women's national team.
- 2:07:55This is a huge get, But yeah, I think it's it's gonna
- 2:07:59be very interesting to see what happens with Chelsea because they still have so much
- 2:08:01talent and that manager has massive shoes to fill. So the interesting time to
- 2:08:07the WSL. Let's wait and see what Hayes is going to do with the
- 2:08:11US women's national team and also what's going to happen with Chelsea moving on from
- 2:08:16Magid. While you're at it, can you explain to people why one dollar
- 2:08:18of gam doesn't equal one dollar. I wish everyone would understand it, because
- 2:08:22I don't think I can go through listening to one more person using the argument
- 2:08:26that we spent millions and millions in transfer this year. You know, I
- 2:08:30agree and I don't agree at the same time. Yes, of course a
- 2:08:33dollar of gam is not equal to a dollar. Completely agree with you.
- 2:08:37Dollar of gam is given by the league and a dollar is not given by
- 2:08:41the league. It's straight from the from the owner. Completely I agree with
- 2:08:45that. The only difference is that this is the amount that you have,
- 2:08:48whether it's gam or not. You can spend it or you can not spend
- 2:08:52it in this in this window. C F Montreal decided to spend all the
- 2:08:58GAM money. They maxed the budget of GAM money with the money coming from
- 2:09:03transfers, which is really really interesting. Yes, of course they could have
- 2:09:07used a lot more than that, but they didn't. It's still money that,
- 2:09:13yeah, they used. Even if it's league money, it's still money
- 2:09:16that they used, and they could have not use it. Because of GAM
- 2:09:20money, you can use it for two years, so even the twenty twenty
- 2:09:24three amount, you could have used it in twenty twenty four and they didn't
- 2:09:28use that. So that's why for me, yes, it's not money,
- 2:09:31but also it is money you can spend or not. Anybody else has anything
- 2:09:37to add on this, No, good, thank you, Moving on,
- 2:09:43doctor foot. It's in French, so he's asking, are we going to
- 2:09:48see Oliver and respond to the interest of Morobiello for being the coach, the
- 2:09:54head coach of c F Montreal. If you're very passionate about this, go
- 2:10:00ahead, firm now, okay, number one, you are the most anti
- 2:10:03return person here. I couldn't even get through the question. No, no,
- 2:10:15like, don't get me wrong, he's he's a legend of the Montreal
- 2:10:18Impact. Obviously he's super respected, you know, now, he's kind of
- 2:10:24navigating the in Dium national team manager role, but like I don't think tactically
- 2:10:30speaking, he would be an improvement on Lasaka. So for me, that's
- 2:10:35just a flat out no. We got spoiled under Wilfrid Nanci. We need
- 2:10:39the tactician now we've seen what it means to have one. Finally, Elias,
- 2:10:45anything to add except at all? Yeah, same, same, exactly
- 2:10:50for me. There's a coach that's available. His name is Georgie Sam Pauli
- 2:10:56and be very very very very very very very happy if that happens, even
- 2:11:01if he's going to be very expensive. So yes, he's available. My
- 2:11:07friend, Elias, that's not that's not. My eyes are open. Yeah,
- 2:11:16I know it's really out of the like very random choice, but you
- 2:11:20know, I was thinking about someone that can play positive soccer, and there's
- 2:11:24not a lot of coaches that really play positive soccer, very offensive soccer,
- 2:11:31you know, a bit like what now SI you know proposed now some probably
- 2:11:35has very high expectations on the money spent on the squad, So I don't
- 2:11:39think this will ever happen. Last question, but not least I think we
- 2:11:43all answered. I think doctor Food's question so no for Yellow Good next.
- 2:11:50Rhonda Brownie says opinions on Phil Neville possibly becoming the new head coach for the
- 2:11:54Timbers and the reaction of their supporters club, I'm pretty sure you're asking me
- 2:11:58what what was the reaction of the supporter club. So the reaction there it
- 2:12:03is from the Timbers Army. The Portland Timbers are currently rebuilding a team on
- 2:12:07the pitch in addition to their ongoing efforts to rebuild trust with their fans and
- 2:12:11the community. We are deeply disappointed that the club has reportedly settled on a
- 2:12:16finalist for head coach who has a history of sexist public statements that run counter
- 2:12:22to our ethos as a club, city and supporters group, and who also
- 2:12:26lacks a proven track record as a manager. We urge the Timbers to reconsider
- 2:12:31this higher and reevaluate other candidates before finalizing a contract. Timbers Army, Steering
- 2:12:37Committee and whatever boards of director. Wow Elias, it seems like very very
- 2:12:48bachelor's for the Timbers in case they do go ahead with Phil Nevill. No,
- 2:12:54I mean my feelings about film Neville notwithstanding, I'm very pressed and very
- 2:13:00proud that a supporters Uh Supporters group puts out a statement like that, I
- 2:13:07think that not standing for this at your club is a very important part of
- 2:13:13what makes supporters groups so special in the football and world in general, that
- 2:13:18we don't really see that at many other sports. So yeah, I mean
- 2:13:22it's been it's gonna be an interesting staga to follow. And remember the grass
- 2:13:28is not always greener at other clubs. So I think considering if and I
- 2:13:33think that, yeah, I mean, Portland has had its fair share of
- 2:13:45scandal I guess it's probably the appropriate word for it in the past couple of
- 2:13:50years, and you know, their relationship with their supporters group is is not
- 2:13:54in a great groups Ploral sorry, are not in a great place right now.
- 2:14:00So I think the supporters' groups are in the driver's seat when it comes
- 2:14:03to putting pressure on this because Portland is like one of the flagship clubs when
- 2:14:07it comes to that atmosphere that's so iconic in MLS. So good for them,
- 2:14:15honestly for recognizing what they will will not accept and what represents the values
- 2:14:20of their club. You know, I like it. I'm all for it.
- 2:14:28Power to them. I'll go even further than that. For me,
- 2:14:31it's unacceptable that a club doesn't take this in the equation when they take a
- 2:14:39decision. It's unacceptable in twenty twenty three, almost twenty twenty four that this
- 2:14:45happens, you know, when someone has a history of the bad history with
- 2:14:52his ethics, this is unacceptable. In twenty twenty three, getting a public
- 2:15:00oblique, you know, job is not the right thing right now. So
- 2:15:07because everything is known now, you can't hide anymore. And and you know
- 2:15:11what, the Timbers should know better. So hopefully we'll see that in the
- 2:15:16next we'll see that, We'll see the Timber state take that into concentration.
- 2:15:24Last, but not least, we do have a message from Rhonda Brownie and
- 2:15:26I'll leave Elias to talk about it. Yes, it's from Randon. This
- 2:15:31is This is in response to a tweet from the Canadian the Canada Soccer official
- 2:15:37Twitter account saying that of the of the five friendliest plan on on on Canadian
- 2:15:43soil right now, there's one left that hasn't been sold out and that is
- 2:15:48Vancouver at BC Place And basically Rhonda center some message saying, you know,
- 2:15:56talking about talking about you know, just you can we count you in on
- 2:16:00promoting this? And if I had to ask both of you to thirty second
- 2:16:05pitch on why you should go to this game. If I had to ask
- 2:16:09you first thirty second pitch on why you should go to this game and why
- 2:16:13you should get a ticket to see this game, I don't need thirty seconds.
- 2:16:18I just need one word, and I need the goat. That is
- 2:16:20the only word you need. This is your very last opportunity to see one
- 2:16:26of the most iconic athletes in Canadian history take to the pitch. This is
- 2:16:33somebody who played under so many challenging conditions during this time, who's helped pave
- 2:16:39the wave for future generations to have an easier time in soccer. This is
- 2:16:46your best opportunity to say thank you for trophies, say thank you for medals,
- 2:16:50say thank you for all the success and all the emotions on and off
- 2:16:54the pitch to Christine Sinclair, and finally to help usher in whoever is going
- 2:17:01to take up the mantle in her place. So absolutely it's going to be
- 2:17:07the place to be on December fifth, DC Place, Vancouver. Get there.
- 2:17:11Yeah, I'll add a couple of things to eve the comments sin saint
- 2:17:18Clair. For sure, you have to be here for her. The best
- 2:17:24goal scorer in football history as simple as that. For international football history,
- 2:17:30it's as simple as that. You can't get better than that. It just
- 2:17:33doesn't happen. So that's when Second of all, and you guys have been
- 2:17:41saying for a lot of time that anytime the women's or the men's national team
- 2:17:48go and play a home game in Canada, it's either in Toronto or they
- 2:17:52just don't play. You have a chance of seeing a national team elsewhere than
- 2:18:00in Toronto. Go show up and show your support so that it happens again.
- 2:18:05We didn't here in Montreal nineteen thousand, six hundred and eighty one.
- 2:18:11People showed up with a press box full of journalists. They did it in
- 2:18:18Halifax. They're gonna do it in Victoria. They did in Toronto. Why
- 2:18:22can't we do it in British Columbia. It should be as simple as that.
- 2:18:28It should be in British Columbia, Sorry in Vancouver, because in Victoria
- 2:18:31it's going to be full. It should be easy, it should be normal.
- 2:18:35So go ahead, go buy a ticket. They're not expensive. Support
- 2:18:41your national team, support the greatest athlete of all time, as simple as
- 2:18:46that. Christine's that clear. I think that's enough way to enter. So
- 2:18:54that's it. That's also thanks a lot for everybody for listening to us guys.
- 2:18:58I know it's in a long show, but we're doing as much as
- 2:19:01we can to to to to cover everything but still keep it as short as
- 2:19:07possible at this time, but we'll do better the next time. Thanks a
- 2:19:11lot. See you next week for another episode of The Ballus Round.