Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 111
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two one one one one
- 0:22one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. Mass killings in Michigan the Post Family murders. On the morning of
- 0:46February sixteenth, nineteen eighty two, the Post family all got up with plans
- 0:51of reuniting with their twenty three year old daughter, Garnetta, who just arrived
- 0:55by bus from her home in Florida. Her visit wasn't just a social call,
- 1:00though. The following day she had a court hearing schedule to finalize the
- 1:04divorce between herself and her estranged husband, Robert Haggart. The two had been
- 1:11married barely under two years, and already the romance had soured. This had
- 1:15been a regular occurrence in their relationship from the very beginning. The first major
- 1:21split between the two had come after Garnetta found herself pregnant and decided to have
- 1:26an abortion, something Robert was against at the time. The two reconciled in
- 1:32the latter part of nineteen eighty nine and tied the knot in February nineteen eighty
- 1:36one, the ring did not fix their problems. The couple argued over a
- 1:42number of issues. The most heated seemed to revolve around Haggart spending a great
- 1:47deal of time at bars and writing a number of checks without the money to
- 1:49cover them. There was even a case where Garnetta arrived at work with fresh
- 1:55bruises on her face that were courtesy of her husband. Wasn't until Robert bounced
- 2:00a check for nearly eighteen thousand dollars in an attempt to buy thirty five head
- 2:06of cattle that police took an interest. One month later, Garnetta had reached
- 2:10her limit with Robert, prompting her to move in with her mother and file
- 2:14for divorce. Shortly after, a warrant was issued for Haggard's arrest for the
- 2:17bad checks. This wasn't the first, or even the second time Robert had
- 2:23found himself in trouble with the law. In nineteen seventy four, after spending
- 2:29a night drinking at a veteran's organization, he took advantage of a fourteen year
- 2:32old girl who had also been drinking there. Although initially charged with rape,
- 2:38it was later reduced to a charge of taking indecent liberties. As part of
- 2:43a plea deal. For this, he got three years probation. He didn't
- 2:47make it through the duration of his sentence before he was accused by another woman
- 2:52of assaulting her. This time he didn't get such a minor slap on the
- 2:55wrist. He would spend two years in prison before finally walking out the front
- 3:00gates in June nineteen seventy seven. Instead of taking his medicine, he ran
- 3:06away to Tennessee, where he began dating another woman who worked as a cook
- 3:09in a pizza shop. It is from here that he took a bus like
- 3:14his soon to be ex wife to attend the court hearing. The reality was
- 3:19he had no intention of ever being there. On February sixteenth, nineteen eighty
- 3:23two, Haggart arrived at the Post family's pig farm. The first person he
- 3:29came to was George Post, Garnetta's stepfather. He was a well known and
- 3:35liked member of the small community. Not only did he serve as a mail
- 3:38carrier for the town, the treasurer of the local school board, and the
- 3:43commander of the local VFW post. Haggart took Post's own shotgun and pulled the
- 3:47trigger, killing the father of seven. His body would later be found at
- 3:53the bottom of the stairs in the basement of the farmhouse. Upon hearing this
- 3:58shot, Garnetta's stepsist, mister Helen, who was at the family home,
- 4:01attempted to run from Robert with her three children in tow. The five of
- 4:06them jumped into a pickup truck parked outside, and that is when Haggard opened
- 4:11up on the vehicle with both the shotgun and a rifle. Helen's daughter Angela,
- 4:16age ten, son Tom age eight, and daughter Amy, age seven
- 4:21were all fatally struck. The only one to survive the ordeal was the youngest
- 4:27of Helen's three children, fifteen month old Amanda, who was found clutching her
- 4:31dead sister Angela, while covered in the blood of her mother and other siblings.
- 4:38Having already killed four members of the Post family, he hid in the
- 4:42kitchen to await the arrival of Garnetta. Using the freshly fallen snow, he
- 4:46covered the blood that had seeped out of the truck and stained the ground red.
- 4:51Just as his wife and her mother, Vaudrey, walked into the room,
- 4:56he shot them both. All six murders were committed in the span of
- 5:00one point five hours. Between the times of five till just before six thirty
- 5:04p m. It was then Alice, another of the Post family, arrived
- 5:10at the home with her husband and two children. When she walked into the
- 5:14darkened house and turned on the light in the kitchen, she found the bodies
- 5:17of her dead mother and sister. Upon the terrible discovery, she ran to
- 5:21a neighbor's house and called the police. Robert, meanwhile, had fled the
- 5:27scene of the crime back to Tennessee using Vodry's own vehicle, arriving home late
- 5:31the night of the seventeenth. The following day, he went to a restaurant
- 5:36that was owned by his roommate, Glenn Davis. Glen had read a story
- 5:41about the killings that mentioned the vehicle that Haggard had arrived in. He called
- 5:45the police when he saw a roadblock set up on the road ahead of him.
- 5:49He tried to turn round, but was quickly cut off by other officers.
- 5:54At his feet, he had a loaded thirty eight revolver, but the
- 5:58shotgun and officer had pressed to his ear kept him from resisting. It wouldn't
- 6:03be until September that the trial for the seven murders actually took place because of
- 6:09the sensationalism of the events that wouldn't take place in the county the crimes were
- 6:14committed in. The prosecution went about proving its case by bringing forth witnesses who
- 6:19swore to have seen Robert at the post's farm on the day of the murders.
- 6:24Using ballistics, they proved that one of the bullets recovered at the scene
- 6:28had been fired by the same gun that had been found in the car at
- 6:30the time of Robert's arrest. Blood from clothes found in the apartment Haggart was
- 6:35staying in in Tennessee also came back as that of one of the victims.
- 6:41Robert never took the stand in his own defense. His attorney argued the prosecution
- 6:46hadn't met the burden of proof against his client, and in his closing argument,
- 6:50stated that Haggart had found the bodies at the farm and fled the scene
- 6:54using the car. On October eighth, nineteen eighty two, the jury came
- 7:00back with a verdict in the case. After deliberating for seven point five hours
- 7:03over the span of three days, Robert Haggart was found guilty of first degree
- 7:09murder for six of the seven victims. In regards to the seventh, the
- 7:14seven year old Tom Gaffney was found guilty of second degree murder. He also
- 7:19received a guilty verdict for the attempted murder of Amanda Gaffney. For all of
- 7:24this, he was sentenced to seven life sentences, plus an additional thirty two
- 7:29years in prison. Haggart would spend just over twenty years behind bars before he
- 7:33passed away of natural causes at the age of fifty three in November two thousand
- 7:38two. The Post family did receive a financial judgment of thirty six million dollars
- 7:44after filing and winning a civil suit against him in two thousand nine, seven
- 7:48years after his death. Another crime perpetrated in nineteen seventy seven, was linked
- 7:54to Robert. In this he raped and then strangled a woman named Doris Arndt.
- 8:01To this day, it is still the third largest mass murder in the
- 8:03history of the state of Michigan. The slaying of the Post family has been
- 8:07called many things, the Rock Road Massacre, the Farewell Murders, and the
- 8:13Clare County Murders. In the end, the name does not matter. It
- 8:18is a tragedy that changed not only a family forever, but a community that
- 8:22didn't know such evil existed. May it be the last it ever does