Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Dead Cat Experience
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Hey, it's Eric newcomer, I'm
- 0:15here with dead cat. We've got both Tom and Katie.
- 0:18We're doing a host only episode. We're gonna start off in disgust
- 0:23dead cat classic. Yes.
- 0:25Sort of the real where we really get to fight it out with nobody
- 0:28interfering and stopping us from just endless endless stream of
- 0:32take theirs, but oh no, journalism happening.
- 0:35This is a journalist so we're going to talk about what we'll
- 0:39get to the market, which I'm excited to talk about in the
- 0:42second half. But we're going to start off
- 0:44talking about spotify's decision to keep Joe Rogan on the program
- 0:50and let Neil Young pull his music and then sort of sub
- 0:56stack, obviously, close to home for me where I published
- 1:00newcomer has been in the news since the Washington Post and
- 1:04the guardian both. Said that you know subjects
- 1:07making like 2.5 million or some broiling small amount of money
- 1:11in the scheme of business off, anti-vaxxer sort of
- 1:15misinformation and so sub stack has been drawn into the Free
- 1:20Speech fight and you know, sub stack wrote this post.
- 1:24Basically just anyway, we'll talk about that in a second.
- 1:28Tom Katie, any initial take on. I mean, the core issue.
- 1:32I mean, should Joe Rogan be on Spotify, or do you?
- 1:35Do you have a strong point of view on on the core issue to
- 1:40start off with? I'd like to stick to the Neil
- 1:42Young part of it. Well, yeah, I agree.
- 1:45That's the interesting part like yeah.
- 1:48Are they losing Crosby? Stills, Nash and Young too
- 1:50because that's a bigger hit to me, personally, I mean, I like
- 1:54both catalogs but you know, csny has personal residence to maim,
- 1:58I grew up listening to my mom was obsessed.
- 2:00Listen to the deja vu record constant, make sense this all
- 2:03tracks Tom. Now we do.
- 2:05My I'm like, yeah. No.
- 2:07I would heavily heavily inundated by csny and then I saw
- 2:11Peter. Frampton is also pulling down in
- 2:14his catalog to, so we're losing the Boomers, but yeah.
- 2:19Seventies are coming back to attack and Frampton live.
- 2:22That is too bad weather. It's Frampton over there, still
- 2:23young. I think the interesting part is
- 2:26that issues around freedom of expression and when I wouldn't
- 2:30even call it free speech. Because if you look at the First
- 2:31Amendment, the way it's written is about whether the government
- 2:33to prohibit the speech. Of citizens, but I mean freedom
- 2:37of expression, right? And misinformation these issues
- 2:40that we would normally look to authorities to resolve or being
- 2:45resolved in the free market essentially by various actors
- 2:50deciding, whether or not they want to participate in a
- 2:52platform rather than any kind of Regulation.
- 2:55And I think that's what's fascinating to me.
- 2:57Also, that it's a Swedish company.
- 2:59You know, like, we're all viewing this through the lens
- 3:01of. I mean, obviously the first
- 3:03amendment is misapplied here but The, my understanding and
- 3:06talking to some folks and I'm not really reporting this.
- 3:08Just these are casual conversations people in and
- 3:11around Spotify, is that they actually very strongly believe
- 3:14in people's, you know, freedom of expression and that is more
- 3:19important than I would have thought out of a Swedish
- 3:21company. You would think, you know,
- 3:22stayed over each. They would love to regulate
- 3:24these kinds of things, but they're not that bothered from
- 3:27like, a corporate level. I think by the idea that there
- 3:29is like, bullshit being traffic to their platforms, I mean, it
- 3:33is an issue with Rogan Specifically, because he's not
- 3:36it's not just a platform, right? It's not just Apple podcasts and
- 3:40distributing it through there. They pay his they'd be you know,
- 3:42they'd rise checks that you know, he's on there for, he's
- 3:46their star podcaster that you know your subscription money
- 3:49goes directly to him. So there is a connection, I'm
- 3:52not saying that I agree or you know, that's not my stance but
- 3:55like it isn't purely a platform argument in the same way that I
- 3:58think a lot of people want to apply it to Facebook or even
- 4:03apple as like a podcast platform.
- 4:05I think the Free Speech part of this is sort of a misdirect
- 4:10right in sub Sachs policy which will come back to.
- 4:13They were like we will continue to take a strong stance in
- 4:16defense of free speech because we believe the alternatives are
- 4:20so much worse and to me that's just like an empty statement
- 4:23everybody is going to say in the western world that they believe
- 4:27in free speech to some degree what what they're missing is
- 4:31really like the case law, right? The sort of, okay, you can't
- 4:34say, You know, there's fire in a burning building or whatever.
- 4:37And all of these companies admit that there's some line, most of
- 4:42them would not host storm front, right?
- 4:45So the United States as a country believes in free speech,
- 4:48and we've had sort of a long evolving sort of legal history
- 4:52to Define what that exactly means and what all the burdens
- 4:55are. So for these tech companies to
- 4:57come out and just say, we believe in free speech, often
- 5:00feels like they've missed just like they're they're behind on
- 5:04the debate. It's like oh, Find your own free
- 5:06speech. That that's really not here, or
- 5:08there. It's how you define all the
- 5:10narrow points and then it's what is your policy on being anti
- 5:16vax? Or, you know, is that a red line
- 5:19or not and what are the lines and how do you do decide what
- 5:22speech isn't part of this sort of productive debate?
- 5:26So I just think the statement that your for free speech is
- 5:30just sort of pompous because it's when you're when you're
- 5:33also saying quiet, Or quietly we're for free speech.
- 5:37Except for in the moments were not and we could write our but
- 5:41we're not going to really talk about it right on sub stack.
- 5:44A lot of people are dunking on them because they don't allow
- 5:47pornography. And so it's, you know, you
- 5:49clearly don't allow free speech in the way of marriage.
- 5:52You know, America allows pornography and there, it's for
- 5:55free speech. You clearly have lines about
- 5:57what you allow and it, you know, on one level of looking at it
- 6:01seems crazy that you're okay, you're not you're okay with
- 6:05People leading people to their deaths by arguing that they
- 6:10shouldn't take the vaccine. I don't really understand.
- 6:11Thank part of us because there are these really strict Federal
- 6:14prohibitions on things, like child pornography, for which a
- 6:18company can genuinely get into trouble, right?
- 6:20And that is something that would be a disaster for a platform.
- 6:24Whereas the federal government hasn't really told us where the
- 6:27lines are around. In your words leading people to
- 6:30their deaths by spreading this information.
- 6:31So you can see from right if you were the general counsel you
- 6:34would say Definitely, no pornography and you know maybe
- 6:37when the government says that, they'll get there, we'll get in
- 6:40trouble with this misinformation.
- 6:42Then we will ban it, right? That's why the free speech thing
- 6:44is also so frustrating because they're clearly often acting out
- 6:47of their own economic interests, and have these perogative 's in
- 6:52terms of what the laws are and what they might get Super Saiyan
- 6:544, but they make it seem like it's some principled stance
- 6:57totally detach from all these economic decisions.
- 7:00So you're giving this sort of high-faluting, I mean these
- 7:03companies are basically run by Jerry from Succession.
- 7:07But what are they going to? I mean, yeah, the honest answer
- 7:09is like we pay Joe Rogan's. You know, we signed Joe Rogan's
- 7:12paychecks and he is a huge moneymaker for us.
- 7:15Therefore, the financial loss that we would take by kicking
- 7:18Rogan off. The platform is far worse than
- 7:20losing Neil Young's catalog like 1970s onwards, right?
- 7:23So it gets different gets more interesting.
- 7:26If a contemporary artist leaves it gets more interesting if
- 7:29Beyonce or Taylor Swift is like I'm out.
- 7:33This is ridiculous. Yeah, no.
- 7:35Hugely. So, I just want to say on the
- 7:37core issue, I think Joe Rogan should be allowed to be on
- 7:43Spotify, they should pay him. I wouldn't pull my music from
- 7:47Spotify. We're hosted on, WE publish on
- 7:50Spotify, by the way, so if you wanted to take a stance you can
- 7:54put we're on Spotify as a platform.
- 7:56We get no money from right out of fry whereas you know all of
- 7:59these artists are getting residuals for.
- 8:01I guess if I was doing executive we're again Spotify I would have
- 8:04said oh Rogue. And should be are like billboard
- 8:07artist. So we're going to pay a ton of
- 8:08money to come on. They knew what they were getting
- 8:10into. I mean in so much as they even
- 8:13pulled some of his older episodes because they're like,
- 8:16all right Joe, let's give you a clean slate.
- 8:18You're on Spotify now. Let's see what you give us and
- 8:20you know probably 85 to 90 percent of the time, they're
- 8:23completely fine. You know.
- 8:25It's like when he interviews carrot-top, that's not going to
- 8:27piss anybody off. I mean I haven't really well.
- 8:29I don't know about that. Well, yeah, actually watch part
- 8:31of that interview. Crimes against humor, he's a
- 8:34dumb guy who talks about MMA like and sort of admits that,
- 8:39right? I mean, regular guy, he's
- 8:40already most popular podcast or by a long shot and there's a
- 8:43reason for it. I just think it's much more
- 8:45pernicious. If some guys like, I'm a doctor,
- 8:48here's what you should believe about the vaccine while the tech
- 8:51platform is providing no rebuttal or like effort to to
- 8:55say, well, the scientific consensus doesn't agree.
- 8:57But for Joe Rogan, where it's like, this is some random guy
- 9:02who has it. Minions and sort of has a
- 9:04popular show. Are people really that misled
- 9:07that they're hearing from some dumb guy who interviews people.
- 9:10I'm sure they have a line with him.
- 9:12Why is Joe Rogan the most popular podcast or Tom because
- 9:15he speaks in a you know kind of a approachable affable Cadence
- 9:19he kind of sees always thinking out loud and just sort of
- 9:23whatever bubbles up there. He seems like open to it and
- 9:25then very lightly debates it to himself.
- 9:28And then moves on also, you know, he's an MMA guy and
- 9:31there's like no filter. I mean It's all right.
- 9:33Yeah, I have watched a number of his interviews.
- 9:36I think they're very watchable and right and entertaining.
- 9:40And yeah, yeah. I mean it's in the same way that
- 9:43people in Los Angeles have been kind of like ambiently absorbing
- 9:47Ryan Seacrest for like 20 years even though they don't really
- 9:50know why and they don't really have strong feelings about him,
- 9:53he's just sort of there and I think Rogen's the same thing.
- 9:56It's he's not a hard-hitting interview, but I don't know if
- 9:59it's also incredibly long. Each episode is like three or
- 10:02four hours. H which is like you know
- 10:04definitely they're probably you know spot at spotify's getting
- 10:07their money's worth in terms of like minutes from from Rogan.
- 10:10But it's a huge show and I think it's even grown as he's joined
- 10:15Spotify. Like this is worked for them.
- 10:16This isn't like buying something at its peak and then slowly
- 10:18declining. Like they got, they got a hot
- 10:21and podcasts, there was actually a good story that Lucas shot at
- 10:25Bloomberg. Did a couple weeks ago saying
- 10:27like podcasting as a medium is really hard up on trying to get
- 10:33Hit shows, there aren't that many things that kind of Bubble
- 10:36Up and become incredibly, you know, watched or listened to
- 10:40shows. And so the fact that they have
- 10:42like a true genuine star, they're like there.
- 10:44It's going to be hard for them to block away from that given
- 10:47how much of their, you know, their strategy is about
- 10:50podcasting right now and there is something annoying about
- 10:53liberals and the left that they want to try and make spotify's
- 10:57entire brand about Joe Rogan, when he's one of many people
- 11:00that they pay money for. And Like appeals to a certain
- 11:03audience and their, I don't know, it can be a little
- 11:06Annoying. Obviously there's something very
- 11:09free-market about people, pulling their content and
- 11:12protesting and you can capitalism to get that what they
- 11:15want. And so I'm sympathetic to that.
- 11:19But then there's also just sort of like a sensory as sort of
- 11:23attitude where it's like just whining about everything that
- 11:26people like is that said, there's clearly a lion for
- 11:29Spotify. I mean if he were to go out
- 11:31there and say things Better unambiguously racist.
- 11:34They would pull him, right? I do you think I got spotify's
- 11:37line? I guess.
- 11:39Racist is sort of, you know, things get a little muddy there,
- 11:42but if you were to, I mean, I guess there are and First
- 11:44Amendment violations or not violations.
- 11:46But if he were to Advocate violence, well yeah, anything
- 11:50anything that he could be, that would bring about a criminal
- 11:53charge, I think is a Ryan. Most companies would tell me
- 11:56anything. We saw with your mom, you know,
- 11:58where he was attacked on the China stuff, anything where
- 12:00Republicans and Democrats have To say he's terrible.
- 12:03That's, that's the thing you're going to get God.
- 12:07I don't know if you bring those constituencies together.
- 12:11Like, I think it's great. That Republicans and Democrats
- 12:13can agree. That genocide has bad eyes and
- 12:17she tripped over that line. I'm trying to imagine a scenario
- 12:19in which Joe Rogan started talking about the uyghurs.
- 12:23He would just be very off-brand for him.
- 12:26But you know if you were out there to say like you know,
- 12:28caring about the uyghurs genocide is below my line, he'd
- 12:32probably get a Talking to. I don't think, I don't think
- 12:34your mom canceled. Yeah, I don't know.
- 12:37Yeah, that's not looking. No, I think it would be like,
- 12:39weighing in on something like the depth charge Floyd Wright in
- 12:43a way that people thought yes, like wildly her.
- 12:46If exactly. Yeah.
- 12:47Right. That's, that's a good one.
- 12:48Yes. If at the height of the George
- 12:49Floyd protest, he was like, you know, guy got it coming or
- 12:52anything, even close to that. Then I think you would be in a
- 12:54position or Spotify would be in a position where they were,
- 12:57like, that's something we don't want to be, you know, assigning
- 13:01her name to at all which again. I mean, that's not really free
- 13:03speech. So there's obviously a
- 13:05squishiness to their statement that they're even trying to
- 13:08stand behind even if it's irrelevant and we saw this
- 13:11issue, come up with Twitter when Trump was still on Twitter.
- 13:15You know, they had all sorts of reasons why they said it was
- 13:17totally fine to have them on. And then it wasn't until after
- 13:20you know many, many, many people violently attacked Congress that
- 13:25they were like, okay, well actually actually think maybe
- 13:27not anymore. I mean, so I mean at the high
- 13:29levels, I doubt, Neil Young as making all that much from spot.
- 13:32If I these rights, but I'm trying to think like, yeah,
- 13:34Katie you brought it, Beyonce Taylor Swift.
- 13:38I think, Taylor for a time has pulled her music from Spotify.
- 13:41Right. I wish you had a whole huge
- 13:42thing but now she's like all in there's been a right now.
- 13:45That benefits you a lot Eric? Yeah I'm a top one percent I
- 13:51think yeah I'm making my way through read.
- 13:55It's taken me months but you know as I like this in a little
- 13:58bit and be like I have to remember the song and then I Get
- 14:02caught. We're the the tellers version.
- 14:06It was version, Taylor's Rich. Oh yeah, I know, at least which
- 14:10version to listen to. Yeah, I'm trying to think who
- 14:12would take for me if they got pulled, it would be more, just
- 14:15like individual songs, you know? Like if I couldn't listen to, I
- 14:20don't know. C&C Music, Factory everybody
- 14:22dance now, right? If all of the Consortium of your
- 14:25favorite artists took only, they're like top two hits off.
- 14:28Yeah, it has to be like deep cuts only.
- 14:30I couldn't do it. It oh well soon, see Music
- 14:33Factory deep Cuts. I don't think they had any.
- 14:35Yeah, I would I can't think of a second song by them but yes, I
- 14:39don't, I don't even think there is somebody who have paid all
- 14:42their music. I'm actually an apple music
- 14:44person stupidly, so I'm not even really relevant to this
- 14:47discussion. When I need to dust off my CDs,
- 14:49which I'm looking at my kajillion CD.
- 14:54I actually this this isn't. There's no segue here.
- 14:57It's just something actually wanted to bring it to you
- 14:59specifically. Katie.
- 15:00There is a Spotify. I have been obsessed with over
- 15:02the last week, it's called the 60 songs that explain the 90s,
- 15:07and it's this music critic who works for the ringer who goes
- 15:10song by song and explains why each song like it was emblematic
- 15:14of the ninth. When was the last song he chose
- 15:17I'm behind. I just found out about this
- 15:19thing like sugar but what was the last episode you listen to
- 15:24what was the song? I listen to A Tribe Called
- 15:27Quest. Absolutely 100%. 100% that was
- 15:29like yeah suddenly Hip-hop is okay for everyone, right?
- 15:34We can all like it and it's good and it's happy.
- 15:37It was so happy, it was like, it was right.
- 15:40But it's also stupid and kind of profane.
- 15:43Best episodes have been for rap, took a turn.
- 15:46Anyway. All right.
- 15:48Funs over? Yeah, sorry I think this is
- 15:52essential listening, but yeah, sure.
- 15:54They want to make a point on I know I've talked about.
- 16:00So I mean I'm Sub-sect. So I care and I just thought
- 16:04that the statement they put out was a little was just sort of
- 16:08naive to the whole debate around.
- 16:11Moderation on social media platforms that's been happening.
- 16:16They like they didn't like to me, the key distinction is what
- 16:19you allow on your platform versus what you're Distributing.
- 16:22Right? What your so what drives your
- 16:23business, right? What that, that matters but I'm
- 16:27saying in terms of ethically, ethically, like there's a It's
- 16:31between hosting something and pumping, something out to a
- 16:34bunch of people. And right now, sub stack just
- 16:37relies on their Publishers, people like me to build an
- 16:40audience. And so, if they host bad stuff,
- 16:43it doesn't bother me that much, right?
- 16:45Because it's like those people had that audience, they probably
- 16:48have it on some other on a WordPress site, it doesn't
- 16:51matter that much. That it's unsub stack, but if
- 16:54sub stack ever succeeds it building distribution, actually
- 16:57building audience, then the position will matter and right.
- 17:01They they just failed. Basically.
- 17:04It building distribution, right? They launched a reader app.
- 17:07If you're a writer on subsequent, they show you
- 17:10metrics. The try to emphasize the extent
- 17:12to which they're helping to build your audience, but they're
- 17:15not, everybody knows a not really building audience right
- 17:17now. So there's sort of a okay?
- 17:19Because we fail to building audience, no one's really going
- 17:21to complain that we're hosting people.
- 17:23I mean, people are complaining, but it's not as a sort of
- 17:26punishing critique. But obviously if it becomes the
- 17:29case that they're driving a huge, Audience to anti-vaxxers
- 17:33in are responsible for those that that was the critique of
- 17:36Facebook. That Facebook is finally started
- 17:38to recognize then it becomes more of an issue.
- 17:40And so I just feel like that they put out such an
- 17:43unsophisticated statement was really annoying because it's
- 17:48like this has been, well, discussed.
- 17:50There are lots of like experts on it and to just be like, oh
- 17:53no, we love Free Speech, just makes him seem sort of dumb.
- 17:56I mean, I like the people over there, but I'm like, come on.
- 17:59It's like if your whole point. The were a nuanced platform that
- 18:03hosts sophisticated debate, your own statement about it should
- 18:07like indicate a level of sophistication.
- 18:10I agree. But I think Jerry from
- 18:12succession. Probably had a lot of hand in
- 18:14that that it's just pure cynical right?
- 18:16That it's that it's like, okay. People like I mean, that's all
- 18:20we, that's I guess what I'm trying to say, people who are
- 18:22not following this closely like how Free Speech sounds.
- 18:25So if you make your point Free Speech, a certain segment of
- 18:29people will be like great but like that's Not a really
- 18:32sophisticated position. And so either, this is extremely
- 18:36cynical in that they don't want actually weigh in to the sort of
- 18:40thorny actual smart discussion. And of course, they don't want
- 18:45to this, that sucks. They don't want to be involved
- 18:48in, I mean, old into a debate in this paragraph would make your
- 18:51blood boil. They're like, in a pernicious
- 18:53cycle, these Dynamics in turn. Give each group license to
- 18:56point. They're just sort of.
- 18:57He's saying how those thoughts today.
- 18:59Yeah, they're both sides. Here, it's the It's like, I'm
- 19:03just like, good bad. What's the difference?
- 19:06You know, it's just like classic like, oh my God.
- 19:08Just like total both sides doing.
- 19:12It's just like the dumbest sort of shits.
- 19:14Why don't you just have a mandatory?
- 19:15Why don't they just have mandatory vaccinations for sub
- 19:17stack? That would be so funny like,
- 19:21yeah, this is ended there. Just like we have 100%
- 19:24vaccination everyone that rights results so just be a good troll,
- 19:28you know, it just like totally out of nowhere.
- 19:31We're gonna go right in the oven on, you know, mandatory Evac
- 19:34Splat forms. Be my guest.
- 19:35You know do stuff. I oh maybe they're vax.
- 19:38Maybe they're not. You know she drivers beware I
- 19:42don't want to get involved in this at all.
- 19:43This sucks for them isn't how experienced an unsub stack.
- 19:46Yes. Yes I'll be, I mean, he's
- 19:48terrible. Yeah.
- 19:50He's certainly the extreme of that.
- 19:51I'm sure they'd rather him not be on there but you know it's
- 19:55just not like you said the numbers are very large audience.
- 19:59I mean, people people say that he makes like Dollars a year, I
- 20:02think I saw. I'm not that he's he's kicked
- 20:04off Twitter, right? I think so.
- 20:06I think his stick, that's what I haven't really kept up with
- 20:08who's been banned from drought in the New York Times, alumni
- 20:11group. I mean, this is kitchen that
- 20:13what I'm This that's slack. Yeah this fits into I mean the
- 20:20fact that Twitter is basically doing distribution for sub
- 20:24stack, make sub Stacks editorial challenge much easier because
- 20:28the people driving audience to sub-sect are these social media
- 20:32companies which have had to think about this for a while and
- 20:34have stricter rules, whereas sub stack, which is just a like
- 20:38basically a hosting platform and sort of a sort of tool for
- 20:42writers can sort. Of play naive for the time being
- 20:46but obviously, if they ever succeed in building the business
- 20:48they aspire to then they're going to have to grow up and
- 20:51have a more sophisticated point of view.
- 20:54What would your ideal statement be from them, though?
- 20:57Other than, like, not as not as simple, my ideal statement would
- 21:00be, you know, inherently, we have to draw lines and we think
- 21:06we should have a pretty permissive attitude towards
- 21:09hosting people. Personally, we find anti-vaccine
- 21:14At abhorrent. And we understand that as we
- 21:17grow, we're going to try and direct people to sub Stacks that
- 21:20we think are interesting on a whole range of subjective
- 21:24factors like their ability to build audience in our own
- 21:27sensibility and brand. And we certainly don't want to
- 21:30drive audience to things that we think are morally reprehensible
- 21:33like anti-vaccine statement. So while we're happy to let a
- 21:36range of debate, we believe in free debate, we don't intend to
- 21:41drive audience, right to the These people Beyond Today to
- 21:45thinking attract platform, that drives audience less.
- 21:48So is one that is an economic vehicle for just like draw a
- 21:51strong distinction between the different types of that,
- 21:54understand that people are have different opinions about when
- 21:58you're driving attention versus when you're just hosting and
- 22:02make your position clear on both fronts.
- 22:05I mean, I was surprised that Casey noon on platformer sort of
- 22:10applauded sub stack for having a very Here position, which is
- 22:15like, we like free speech. I thought their position was
- 22:21simplistic. I also just don't think Clarity
- 22:23is the number one value. I think not promoting and
- 22:27distribute not drawing new attention to anti-vaxxer
- 22:31terrible speech. The outcomes matter more than
- 22:35sort of the tightness and Clarity of the the position I
- 22:38got to say, the only thing that's drawn my attention to the
- 22:41anti-vaccine people on sub, stack have been people learning
- 22:44about the anti-vaccine total unsub's.
- 22:45I mean that I've never would have even known that.
- 22:48Alex Barron sand has a sub stack or the, you know, the fact that
- 22:51there are two point five million dollars worth of value, being
- 22:53created from from these writers. So yeah, I don't know D
- 22:56platform, those people, they drove my attention.
- 23:00I mean, the other boy people made about sub stack is just,
- 23:03you know, it's sort of so people's opinions grow by being
- 23:06indirect like confrontation with each other, but subsets not
- 23:10doing anything to like surface rebuttals to these anti.
- 23:14X sub Stacks to those people. It's not like, oh, you're
- 23:16getting anti-vaxxer sub stack. Here's like the other side of it
- 23:20and why you should listen to that name though.
- 23:23I mean, like that, that was like the suggestion for Facebook for
- 23:25a while to be like, you may be interested in another side of
- 23:28the statement. It's like, come on the people
- 23:31that are DieHard anti-vaxxers or any of the misinformation on
- 23:34Facebook. They're not going to be swayed
- 23:36because there was a little like suggestion box saying like you
- 23:39might want to read Vox for another perspective.
- 23:42I really think that's what You want there at the bottom?
- 23:45Alex Berenson, someone who just got through, you know, hearing
- 23:47that like mRNA is gene therapy and, you know, you're going to
- 23:51die of cancer in the next six to eight weeks being like, you
- 23:54know, Eric Topol from the Scripps Institute, has a
- 23:57different view on this. There are core product failures
- 24:01at the heart of a lot of this, right?
- 24:02Like some crazy guy comes up to you on the street and like
- 24:06starts ranting about ants, you've acts and you like, see
- 24:10they're sort of hiss, they're troubled.
- 24:12They look they're a lot of Things off the internet that you
- 24:15can receive about someone to understand them and assess them
- 24:18that the internet obscures, in that these platforms, help
- 24:22people hide. And by not like, if you're
- 24:26experiencing that, no one sort of take seriously in the
- 24:29mainstream sort of medical authorities or anything.
- 24:33The failure of social media platforms, to let people really
- 24:37understand this person and have any sort of history on them and
- 24:40just get this sort of snapshot window into them.
- 24:43I do think it's their design choices about how social media
- 24:47platforms are built and sort of the sort of total abandonment of
- 24:52any sort of credentialism or yeah, I guess I mean like at the
- 24:57earliest days of the fake news debate.
- 25:00Remember the issue wasn't so much that there was an accurate
- 25:03information but that it was being presented as coming from
- 25:05an authoritative Source, right? Member like the pope endorse
- 25:09Trump was written on some site. That was like the the Colorado
- 25:13registry. Or something like that and and
- 25:15you know the argument there which is what I'm more buys like
- 25:19oh there could be well-meaning people that for some reason
- 25:21think that you total asset on this site is is legitimate here.
- 25:25And if that's the only news they read that day, then they could
- 25:28think that. You just, you know what you're
- 25:30getting with sub stack. If you're if you're signing up
- 25:32to read, sometimes I agree with that statement so yeah, I don't
- 25:36know, I don't know. Do you want to join them over to
- 25:38the markets? You agree that this sort of
- 25:41distribution versus hosting? Yeah.
- 25:43Does think I should get? Yeah, I think it's a slightly
- 25:46different debate. I think when it becomes to
- 25:47distribution substract has more responsibility than simply
- 25:52being, you know, an economic platform or, or, you know, like
- 25:55basically a payment platform and web hosting service.
- 25:58Well, stripe is a payment, a facilitator of using Straight.
- 26:01You know, there? So that's interesting though,
- 26:03right? I mean, like, that gets to like
- 26:04the real, like the, you know, the backbone of the internet
- 26:07when people like that start making distinctions and I know
- 26:09Christ and that would be, that would be pretty bad, right?
- 26:12I do think it's like a Scale, you want the infrastructure
- 26:16layer to be the least restrictive in the distribution
- 26:19layer to be the most that makes sense that's like TV shows in
- 26:22the past. You know you choose your brand,
- 26:24you play TV, you decide what's on the show?
- 26:26That makes sense to me. Right?
- 26:28Look, I'm on the more firm side of just not believing that any
- 26:32of these people should be pulled down under under almost any
- 26:35really? That's yeah, yeah.
- 26:37I might just like this people pretend it's so hard to say
- 26:41what's bad and what's good? It's like you read this fucking
- 26:43terrible thing. You talk to a bunch of X.
- 26:45I understand that there was an Impulse to like sensor the lab
- 26:50leak Theory which I believe I was very suspicious of the
- 26:53origins of the coronavirus. I was listening to Steve
- 26:57bannon's podcast but I was able to seek it out and find it on
- 27:00whatever like platform it was on because you're still allowed to
- 27:04have like, meta conversations about like, oh, there are people
- 27:07who believe that, you know what I mean?
- 27:08It's so that. So the interesting thing is that
- 27:11for broadcasters TV, L, there are certain kinds of things,
- 27:15they just can't put out to the public because they don't hit a
- 27:19standard. So platforms are relatively new
- 27:24in the history of like news distribution information,
- 27:26distribution, do you think that there should be a standard
- 27:30imposed on platforms? Akin to a broadcast standard.
- 27:33And if not why, why not? Just because it's user-generated
- 27:37for things like, trending topics distribution, right?
- 27:41For things were like, if you're on the Book profile very low
- 27:45standard. But if it's being pumped into
- 27:47the feed and being, you know, given virality, then I think
- 27:50there should be a more similar to a broadcast standard.
- 27:54And the other thing is, if you look at Australia, they did just
- 27:56post laws about distribution of certain kinds of harmful
- 28:00information. And it means that Publishers in,
- 28:03not just the platforms, but Publishers in Australia.
- 28:07So if you're a newspaper and you have a comment section and, you
- 28:11know, inappropriate under this law, On 10 is post in the
- 28:15comment section. Well, the newspaper could have a
- 28:17legal issue. And so I think that there are
- 28:20going to be countries that take a firmer hand in terms of, you
- 28:24know, the distribution of content that they think that's
- 28:27harmful to society. So I mean it's hard for me to
- 28:30imagine that Australia goes there but the EU doesn't go
- 28:33there. And then eventually, I mean
- 28:36other countries will have to consider it and they'll be a big
- 28:38dividing line between the countries that do in countries
- 28:41that don't seem like they're. I want free debate.
- 28:43On the internet. Like I don't want to be in a
- 28:45case where you can't even make an argument and publish it
- 28:49somewhere. It's just, I want people who are
- 28:51just like, so I want, you know, if you're really seeking
- 28:53something out, you're arguing something, there are more ways
- 28:56to share, you know, you can text people things, you can have
- 28:59group there, more ways to share your ideas, now across the world
- 29:02than ever before. I just don't think you have the
- 29:04right, just because an idea is like catchy and people reading
- 29:08it sort of believe it, without any other information to get it
- 29:12distributed, widely beyond your In audience.
- 29:15I guess it's not really about a matter of right or not.
- 29:17Right? I mean obviously we're not even
- 29:19talking constitutionally, right? It's just like human law or
- 29:24civilized, you know, right society that people should say
- 29:28things that you disagree with and have harmful effects because
- 29:32they are, you know, getting wide distribution for it.
- 29:35I, I guess it's just hard for me to get past the like, what is
- 29:37the n stand? What did people ultimately want?
- 29:39Because what they're mad about is that there's a lot of
- 29:41anti-vaxxers, right? That there's a lot of people.
- 29:43Out there have the decided one will reason or another, they
- 29:46don't want to get this vaccine and that is prolonged.
- 29:49The suffering. That we have all been
- 29:51experiencing for the last couple of years.
- 29:53I don't think it's going to make a huge difference.
- 29:55If sub stack, kicked off the anti-vaxxers of Joe Rogan was D.
- 29:57Platformed in terms of the number of people.
- 30:00I think in the countries where they do have stricter laws about
- 30:05distribution, there are still huge swaths of people that are
- 30:07protesting locked down there. Anti-vaxxers that are all these
- 30:10things. What I'm about to say, should be
- 30:12the refrain of every Conversation like this Fox is
- 30:16still worse, that's a problem, right?
- 30:17As long as Fox is pumping out with an editorial agenda stuff.
- 30:22That's as bad or worse than anything.
- 30:24You're going to find that were complaining about on the
- 30:26Internet. It's sort of a dumb argument
- 30:28because you have this super terrible broadcaster.
- 30:32That's just, you know, intentionally delivering the
- 30:37message to, you know, the Republican Party base and Sprite
- 30:41and they're theoretically regulated by, you know, The
- 30:43broadcast standards and it's still getting out there, right?
- 30:46Same way, and I'm not calling for the government, really, to,
- 30:48like, crack down more. I'm just saying, in sort of the
- 30:51elite discourse, sort of what what we should ask for in sort
- 30:56of these policy positions. And how well-intentioned people
- 30:59should think about sort of correctly moderating?
- 31:02Yeah, yeah, the market you want to go to the market?
- 31:06Let's go to the market what the song is called unfun.
- 31:13Mi glad ya Bitcoin unhappy is it down right now?
- 31:18I mean it's down overall but I don't know today whether it's
- 31:21our who cares? It's going to come out a couple
- 31:23days from now. I mean Robin Hood is what it's
- 31:26ten. Ten point five billion market
- 31:29cap right now II keep taking a Victory lap because rivi and
- 31:32that electric car company. I called a Horseman of the
- 31:35Apocalypse is way below its IPO price.
- 31:38It's now only worth a self-driven horse thief billion
- 31:40dollars as like no Revenue basically, it's worth He billion
- 31:44dollars. So to me, plenty of air, I mean
- 31:48test a respek, right? No.
- 31:50I think it was a traditional IPO Tesla is still an eight hundred
- 31:53billion dollars. I'm pulling it up, eight hundred
- 31:55thirty, five billion dollar company and what Ford is
- 31:59probably what a tenth of that. What is it?
- 32:03Yeah, for it is is 77 billion dollar company.
- 32:06So I do think there is a plenty of room to come out, but we saw
- 32:10lots of great companies like snowflake.
- 32:13You know, a lot of sad Zoom is way down.
- 32:16I think, you know, companies that just had high Revenue
- 32:20multiples, you know, corrected to sort of like pre-pandemic
- 32:25levels, right? Netflix is down below.
- 32:28Its pre-pandemic level. Then they were one of the
- 32:30winners and the first year or two.
- 32:32So, yeah, it feels like we've kind of reset everything back to
- 32:352020. I mean, I, we need a bear
- 32:37Market. I mean, they're, I mean, they're
- 32:39clearly companies that are ridiculous, right?
- 32:42And because there's, A set of companies.
- 32:44I think a lot of the EV company. I mean, I'm glad electric
- 32:47vehicles exist, but the multiples that they're trading
- 32:49at the absurdity of some, I mean, I would say on-demand sort
- 32:53of the go Puffs, the world. They have the ability of like,
- 32:56absurd businesses to do. So, well has meant that even the
- 33:00sort of the normal software businesses then, got insane
- 33:03multiples. And so now we've seen
- 33:06everything. Correct, but we have, we're not
- 33:08seeing like the truly ludicrous business.
- 33:11We haven't seen like bankruptcy attorney.
- 33:13Thing I don't and I'll say that, I just want to the SNP, it's
- 33:18still up more than 15 percent from a year ago, right?
- 33:21So even though it's come down a lot, like, overall, the market
- 33:25is up you on this year, just over the last 28 days.
- 33:29It's down a lot. It's down like nine percent.
- 33:32But if you look at the chart for a year it's not like we're in.
- 33:37It's not like we are in huge trouble.
- 33:39I say that. Like we're going to go to a bear
- 33:41Market. Yeah well yeah, I mean.
- 33:43It's really do you think we recovered?
- 33:45You think this is just a teaser and we're going to have real
- 33:49real paint so I don't two things.
- 33:51I don't make predictions that you like as reporters we're just
- 33:54reporters are generally about it predictions and we're pretty
- 33:57much all those wrongs. I don't like to do that.
- 33:59And the other thing is they think that the market and the
- 34:02real economy are two different things.
- 34:05And so I'm I feel like the markets kind of an indicator of
- 34:09what like kind of a subset of the country.
- 34:13Is doing, you know, it's like, they're all sorts of forces that
- 34:18have kind of made that sharp decoupling happen, right?
- 34:21So, like high-speed trading, Etc, you know, all sorts of
- 34:25things but I think that if you look at the economy, that is
- 34:29something that people might want to pay more attention to if
- 34:32they're trying to figure out whether or not we're going to go
- 34:34into a recession and I'm going to hitters like unemployment
- 34:37number of people leaving the workforce like consumer, you
- 34:41know, consumer activity and that is I think Start is what
- 34:44starting to get wobbly in a way that I find possibly more
- 34:47interesting, but that's just what the other employment rate
- 34:50is low. I watched Jerome, Powell the Fed
- 34:54chair. Give his sort of talk on what
- 34:57they plan to do. It's super funny to listen to
- 35:00not, you know, not being sort of a Fed reporter.
- 35:05You know, they speak in their own sort of little Arcane
- 35:08language and they don't want to give anything away but I mean,
- 35:11basically it was very clear that He called like the stock market
- 35:14like a market, you know what I mean?
- 35:16It was very clear that they're not orienting around the stock
- 35:19market, that fundamentally the mandates are unemployment and
- 35:23inflation. And they only really care about
- 35:25the stock market to the degree to, which it would derail, you
- 35:29know, cause people, you know, the stock market plunging could
- 35:32cause people to lose their jobs and I think that's right.
- 35:35It would have been funnier if he was just like, fuck the stock
- 35:37market, but but yeah, there is a degree.
- 35:39Like you're saying that the stock market is not the economy.
- 35:43And it's healthy for, I mean, you talk to most investors Savvy
- 35:48ones and they think we needed a correction that the valuations
- 35:52even in great companies, where a little were unsustainable, but
- 35:57where it goes from here. Yeah, I think we're all set on
- 35:59time when interest rates are so low that any investment, no
- 36:03matter how risky seems totally fine, especially if you're using
- 36:06borrowed money to do it, it's just everything.
- 36:08Kind of felt free and easy, and if inflation Rises and interest
- 36:13rates, rise, Won't be the case anymore.
- 36:14So I think that again like I'm not a predictor but I am less
- 36:19concerned about what's happening in the stock market.
- 36:22And I'm more interested in kind of what happens with interest
- 36:25rates. And then there's all this, like,
- 36:27weird stuff happening with Supply chains that it's sort of,
- 36:30it's sort of interesting, but people not being able to get
- 36:33stuff people, nothing to move things around the world.
- 36:35I have no idea how that will affect the economy, but it is
- 36:39fairly new. I mean, for decades, we ran on
- 36:41this weird just-in-time Manufacturing.
- 36:43Fracturing economy for almost every product that suddenly we
- 36:47can't and that's going to create cost and companies to write
- 36:51right? Well, there's so many pieces
- 36:52that are like to some degree, a bad supply chain.
- 36:57Problem could be seen as reassuring, because it means
- 37:00fundamental and flick that sort of the inflationary forces are
- 37:04the FED aren't the real problem, but it's actually supply chain
- 37:07problem. So there's a constant sort of
- 37:10what's good is bad and bad is good, right?
- 37:13So that's why, you know, people like David Sachs who I saw
- 37:16tweeted out and I don't follow him but I said this came to me a
- 37:18different way that like, you know, inflation was the result
- 37:21of government, you know, stimulus checks that were given
- 37:24out to families that that is directly the cause of inflation.
- 37:27And we did this to ourselves I think was his point there, which
- 37:30of course, I mean, there is a possibility.
- 37:32Well sure. I mean, look, I have not read a
- 37:34single good but one that I felt confident about explanation that
- 37:39holistically explained inflation.
- 37:40I think the I think the checks the people were great.
- 37:43I mean I Believe in them. But yeah, I mean putting
- 37:47government money behind a roaring economy can cause
- 37:51inflation. I mean, yeah, I think we've done
- 37:54that before. We put a lot of government money
- 37:56behind, like all of Wall Street, right order to recover faster,
- 38:01the try this, and it didn't, it didn't lead to Runaway inflation
- 38:06one and it also did not lead to like any Equitable outcomes
- 38:09whatsoever. So, yeah, that's like, well,
- 38:11let's take the money and see what happens.
- 38:12We put in the hands of the American people.
- 38:13Everybody goes out and buys a used car.
- 38:15Awesome. Like we have now have a used car
- 38:17shortage and inflation in the used car market.
- 38:19But you know, people is there's not going to be a perfect
- 38:23solution, but I do think it was possibly worth trying the
- 38:26alternative rather than putting the million dollars behind 10
- 38:29rodeo bull put a good jillion dollars behind like, just some
- 38:32people, well, I think that the challenge we face right now,
- 38:35right there in The Savvy, investing world, the line is
- 38:38always, you know, buy the rumor sell the news right.
- 38:41When you think something's going to happen, you make the trade
- 38:44and then when they actually announced it, send the market
- 38:47the other way, when Regular Joe consumer is reacting, right?
- 38:50So, right now, people sort of the inverse people are selling
- 38:55shares ahead of fed raising interest rates when the FED
- 38:59raises interest rates. Will the markets actually, you
- 39:02know, how will the markets react will it get worse or if they
- 39:04already priced in those decisions, right?
- 39:07That sort of the unknowable thing.
- 39:10What's your sense by the way? On the impact of The crash in
- 39:14the crypto Market on. I mean, water, a cup crypto
- 39:18Market, what at its peak with something like three trillion
- 39:21dollars and now mean it's like, it's 1.5.
- 39:25So Paul Krugman just did a column and I like Paul Krugman,
- 39:28I don't know. Yeah.
- 39:29I really enjoy his writing and, you know, he was sort of
- 39:31comparing it to like a past crisis was a credit default
- 39:34swaps, or I forget what, and it was just like a sort of a dumb
- 39:37call him that he acknowledged in some ways, just because the
- 39:40Bitcoin Market is just not large enough to Cabbage side some sort
- 39:44of shock. Where's the only reason that, I
- 39:46actually think there's some Merit to the crashing of the
- 39:49crypto, you know, like coin values.
- 39:50And any of those things is going to have impact is.
- 39:52I think they're, I understand that.
- 39:55Like it's a small number of people that control a huge
- 39:58percentage of all of the existing, you know, coins and
- 40:01ftes or anything and that space. But anecdotally talking to a lot
- 40:05of people in the ride-sharing, you know, the gig economy space.
- 40:09There's a lot of people that put their money into crypto I think
- 40:11for a time that was that was Suggested as a smart, hold and
- 40:15investment value. Sorry, hold a value or
- 40:17investment. And, you know, with and I don't
- 40:20know specifically what coins they always put their money
- 40:23into, but there will be impact on regular folk, right.
- 40:29And I mean some ways, the regular people are the ones who
- 40:31eat it because they come in right later, but I just don't
- 40:35think it's enough. It's not enough to go puff
- 40:36drivers talking to you would put who put her like a bunch of her
- 40:39savings into some like Shiba Inu NACA, right?
- 40:42Yeah, like that. A terrible idea, of course, I
- 40:44didn't say that to her but like, no.
- 40:46So don't worry. Knock off the shiba inu.
- 40:49I think, raises a no, no, it wasn't.
- 40:51It was an on Sheba. It was like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 40:58Which is like, that might be the most volatile pump-and-dump of
- 41:01them all, you know, just it is a little bit like all of the IPOs
- 41:04of the 90s where you had completely untested companies
- 41:07pumped up by Silicon Valley, money hitting the public markets
- 41:11and then investors retail investors getting Completely
- 41:14screwed by this. Even as like institutional
- 41:17investors were like, actually we're probably not going to buy
- 41:19these things anymore, it isn't that one of the tenants of why
- 41:21web three or crypto door going to call?
- 41:23It is good. Is because it like offers access
- 41:25to you know unaccredited investors to put money into a
- 41:29potentially. It does in a universe created
- 41:32and controlled by a few rich people.
- 41:33Yeah. Right, I really you guys are
- 41:35saying, but if the point is the stock market is not the economy.
- 41:39Bitcoin is not anything. Like I just think.
- 41:41It's just like, we do. You still think that like the
- 41:44actions Financial actions of companies and real consumers,
- 41:49probably is them. I mean, the two most important
- 41:51inputs in the real economy, right?
- 41:53That's it. I'm sure we are about to be
- 41:54flooded with stories of people who lost everything.
- 41:57Sure, on first, the coins, cash is on there.
- 42:00Any parties, you know, being scammed through enough to use
- 42:03all of that stuff. And yeah, I guess yeah.
- 42:04Like as a smart reader, we should remind ourselves that
- 42:07isn't necessarily the economy, but that is, I mean these are
- 42:10people's lives. I do think there's some
- 42:12Innovation innovation. In crypto, the speculation is
- 42:15fueling super smart people to try to invent a use case and so
- 42:21I don't think the government should stop people.
- 42:24I don't, I don't think the government should have stopped
- 42:26people. And so, then it's part of the
- 42:28free market. And that's right.
- 42:30Sort of buyer, beware, and they're sort of that fringy
- 42:33behavior. We saw like in the housing
- 42:34market in 2007 and six as well, you know, so like every year,
- 42:38the real problem Market, the government back something up or
- 42:40whatever. But like Mark is apperance
- 42:42always And of the outer reaches of it, where it gets the most
- 42:46dangerous. That's almost where you see the
- 42:47most risky consumer investment Behavior.
- 42:50So like whether it was super speculative stocks, whether it
- 42:55was insane, housing speculation, and now, if it's crypto, that
- 43:00will be this booms sort of defining asset class.
- 43:04But that doesn't mean that there were no other contributing
- 43:06factors to the room or that. The bust my Chicken Little case
- 43:11is not. Cryptic it would just be Index
- 43:14funds are driving a ton of money blindly into stocks, like if
- 43:19Tesla was to fall to Ford's valuation, it would lose more
- 43:22than 700 billion dollars in market cap.
- 43:26And it is a huge holding and most of the major index funds.
- 43:30So I think the much more risky scenario where the economy is
- 43:34impacted by the stock market is people lose face, faith and
- 43:38Tesla. Tesla is basically propped up
- 43:41most of this back Market the hole.
- 43:43Sort of belief system around how these companies are valued
- 43:48collapses. That has a major impact on index
- 43:51funds that has a real impact on the economy.
- 43:54And to me sort of the index funds support of Tesla.
- 43:58Just proportional to the amount that retail wants to drive it up
- 44:01is much more worrying than the entire crypto Market at.
- 44:04That's my point of view. Yeah, I guess I think see the
- 44:07crypto Market is like kind of Fringe behavior and maybe my
- 44:10analogy. Maybe my comparisons are totally
- 44:12wrong because like housing, And stocks were both things that
- 44:15both institutional investors in large swaths, looked at invested
- 44:20in and supported. And then later the highest risk
- 44:23retail investors. And then with crypto, you did
- 44:28not have like sort of broad by in.
- 44:31It's truly, truly a kind of like this fringy Fringe a thing.
- 44:34Yeah, it's not foundational to the economy in the world real
- 44:36estate. Or now, you know, mutual funds
- 44:39or index funds. I take it back and it's very
- 44:41Global. It's it wouldn't necessarily
- 44:43have America specific my point with bringing it up is just
- 44:46that, you know, the egalitarian nature of crypto has taken in a
- 44:49huge amount of people that otherwise would have been barred
- 44:52from extremely volatile stocks. And I'm just, you will see a lot
- 44:55more people losing their shirts than it would have happened, had
- 44:58they not been. So I lost some Bitcoin so don't
- 45:07do that. My whole portfolio just has to
- 45:11continue to be worth more than like, In dollars and I'm doing.
- 45:14Okay. Yeah, to be clear.
- 45:16I am very small percentage of my assets and crypto.
- 45:20Most in index funds, I'm pretty stressed by the rising interest
- 45:24rates, because I'm probably going to have to refinance
- 45:27actually think that in July a mortgage Bond marker are the
- 45:29most important thing to watch still.
- 45:32I'm sure a ton of people are on adjustable-rate mortgages to
- 45:35that will at some point be kicking into an awful.
- 45:37You know, an awful rate and the ability to refinance is
- 45:40basically not there if the interest rates are higher.
- 45:43So, It's it's pretty heroin. Yeah.
- 45:47Yes, we'll do a whole episode. Just on how terrifying is to own
- 45:50a home. It will just be Tom.
- 45:51Yeah, I figure I could patch it and I can pack it.
- 45:54I'll patch on my mortgage broker and you guys can see me cry live
- 45:57on air as he tells me what my race.
- 45:59Can it be owning a home is supposed to be smart in a period
- 46:01of high inflation? I guess your issue is that
- 46:03you're mostly financed. You are and if you only read
- 46:07yeah. Yes.
- 46:08If you are, you know stuck into a 30-year fixed-rate if you're
- 46:11like me, and you're going to have to refinance when
- 46:13Conversion goes. What's what decides?
- 46:15Whether you're a variable or fixed?
- 46:17Well, it's just a teaser rate. I mean, you can just buy into a
- 46:20rate that's like, you know, first five years two and a half
- 46:23percent, then it kicks up into like three at your shoes when
- 46:25you talk to the bank. Yeah.
- 46:27Yeah. But you can you can get a fixed
- 46:29rate at the beginning. It's like a church or hi.
- 46:31Rick. It's there and you have to
- 46:33qualify for it. Usually have some sort of income
- 46:35qualification. Then you also need to be able to
- 46:37put down so much on the house to get a fixed rate and often times
- 46:41with adjustable rate mortgages Has one of the reasons they at
- 46:44least used to entrap people is that you did not need as much
- 46:49Financial Security to get one because you could make the
- 46:54payments on the lower rate, right?
- 46:56But then when the rate change dramatically, those people are
- 47:00really vulnerable, is the prospect of a downturn.
- 47:04Something that is being discussed with any seriousness
- 47:07in the tech industry. And is it something that is
- 47:11having any kind of ripple effect?
- 47:12So I've been talking To a lot of investors Venture capitalists
- 47:16and some of the crossover people.
- 47:18I mean I think right now in Silicon Valley were still in the
- 47:22price adjustment period. It's not like Panic.
- 47:24It's not like oh, I'm worried Mike.
- 47:26This company is about to go bankrupt.
- 47:28Like so many companies raised so much more money right now.
- 47:31It's just how do we get private companies to match?
- 47:36You know, the public markets, who reorient strategy, I think
- 47:40if you know the stock market fell much more be a different
- 47:43conversation but right now it's more price adjustment, maybe
- 47:49some companies, wait, you know, we've seen companies raise two
- 47:52or three times in a single year, right?
- 47:54So some of these companies now could just sit out 2022 and say,
- 47:58okay? Actually we're not fundraising
- 48:00this year and funds that had been raising from their LPS
- 48:03every two years might Deploy Capital more slowly to make sure
- 48:08that they have more proof points so that they can raise, you
- 48:11know. So, maybe we'll see sort of a
- 48:13Slowdown in the Euphoria. But I don't see sort of, you
- 48:18know, we need like Peloton or Robin Hood or something, to go
- 48:21bankrupt, or like something like that, where these stocks are
- 48:24falling. And then there's no bottom that
- 48:27I think would be, sort of, totally a game changer.
- 48:31And I think talking to people right now, the conversations are
- 48:33much more sass multiples were at Sex on the private markets and
- 48:37now they're coming back down to earth.
- 48:39And, you know, I think that's the type of conversation at the
- 48:42moment and not sort of existential dread.
- 48:46What did you think? I thought the information had an
- 48:48interesting story about tiger glow.
- 48:50Yeah, super jealous. I'd heard about block Damon.
- 48:53I mean, basically Tiger Tiger Global, you know?
- 48:56And they also said, alky on had these agreements with unicorn
- 49:01startups to invest. And then when the market
- 49:03corrected, they said, oh, actually, we want About tweak
- 49:06your valuation down 20%, or whatever.
- 49:09Because of the correction, you know, basically clawed back
- 49:12their terms sheets to like, revalue the company's right.
- 49:15Which is very hedge fund behavior and not very sort of
- 49:18Silicon Valley, good standing, VC Behavior.
- 49:21But my question about that was, you know, like the angle for
- 49:25that sort of a story is like, you know, the froth is off and
- 49:28you know evaluations are coming back down to Earth.
- 49:30But these are all companies that still raised at higher
- 49:33valuations their last run around like we're Talking about flat
- 49:36rounds or down rounds from just like maybe not quite as frothy,
- 49:40which sure that is Meaningful, but it's not totally thing.
- 49:44Is that it? That's why I'm saying it's much
- 49:45more about. Where did the hedge funds?
- 49:47Say, in Silicon Valley in 2022, like he's tiger going to shift
- 49:52its strategy to be much more public focus and pull back on
- 49:55private investing. Do they still seem?
- 49:58I mean, the Venture Capital firms.
- 49:59Want tiger to look like a bad actor here, right?
- 50:01I mean, there's a strong. Incentive to say tiger is gonna
- 50:04play by different rules. Don't trust them because in the
- 50:07bad times they're going to screw you.
- 50:09But like your point. Exactly.
- 50:10I mean, these are questions about tiger.
- 50:13That's not a question about like the overall sort of Market or
- 50:16the sustainability of technology companies.
- 50:18You know, it's still about individual players and not sort
- 50:22of a huge risk. I don't know.
- 50:25Do you think it's going to get much worse?
- 50:28I don't know II mean. I mean again I cover probably
- 50:31one of the stranger parts of right.
- 50:33Going on right now though. Those companies I mean they
- 50:36should eat it in bed in a sort of high interest rate like that.
- 50:40That's a bad time to be sort of these costly has a ton of money
- 50:45and they're reliant on a gig labor force.
- 50:47That is pretty volatile and has been throughout the pandemic.
- 50:50So I'm I'm always worried about what want worry babies in the
- 50:53right word but like, you know, I think you should be wary of
- 50:56where any of those companies go and like what trend they're
- 50:59drafting off of in order to justify, you know the valuations
- 51:03are going for but you know, dope of is a company that also It's
- 51:06to go public this year. So like, they're going to really
- 51:08test this, what a good year. I mean II.
- 51:10Yeah, I definitely think we're going to see fewer.
- 51:13IPOs people are going to try and hold off.
- 51:15I was back Market as so weekend, now, that if they can't get out
- 51:19in a traditional IPO, what happens, right?
- 51:22Well, yeah, I mean, I guess you look to the private markets
- 51:24again which, you know, they're not dry, but I guess they're
- 51:28what you're saying a little bit less exuberant than they were
- 51:31last year. Hmm.
- 51:33We haven't seen any down rounds yet though, right?
- 51:35I mean, we have Seen, you know the kind of mini correction that
- 51:38we thought we were going it's so early.
- 51:40I mean honestly at this point in the year some of the deals
- 51:44getting announced or still deals, there were probably
- 51:47raised before the market turned so on the private markets it
- 51:51just takes a while for a sort of the publicly announced deals to
- 51:56come out. And then also hopefully you're
- 51:59not in a situation where you need to write raised right after
- 52:02the correction. So might not be till late much
- 52:05later in this. Year that we see truly desperate
- 52:07companies raising a Down Round so that can take time to hit the
- 52:12news stories. I do want her.
- 52:14So it's let me know. How do you think about?
- 52:17Let me back up. So, a few years ago when it
- 52:20looked like there was going to be a Slowdown in the public
- 52:22markets and exits were grinding out hard.
- 52:24It seemed like these were really incentivized to continue to fund
- 52:27startups because those startups seem to continue to serve some
- 52:32sort of Market. There were still people out
- 52:34there who seem to want me. Deliveries of warm chocolate
- 52:37chip cookies or, you know, these ghosts kitchen companies to
- 52:41deliver the meals everyday food boxes sent to their home, so
- 52:45they can make their own dinner and not have to measure anything
- 52:47I guess with the big innovation there anyway.
- 52:49Whatever it seemed like you of the Mockingbirds seem like the
- 52:53consumer was still interested in at least experimenting.
- 52:56With these companies. I wonder though, how consumer
- 52:59patterns changed so much since the pandemic that it wouldn't
- 53:05make as much sense. Or a VC to continue to help
- 53:07these companies float along with no exit in sight, if we're in a
- 53:12world where there just is not really a consumer with the
- 53:15desire or the or the disposable income to get a box of clothing
- 53:20to look through once a month and keep some stuff and send some
- 53:22stuff back. If there's not really a consumer
- 53:25desire to have a meal kit because they can't figure out
- 53:31how to measure something, especially if they don't have
- 53:34money. What you saw, you saw a Robin
- 53:35Hood. The ultimate retail investor has
- 53:38money. Story was down, not even growth.
- 53:42Slowing their revenue was down. I didn't see that.
- 53:47Yeah, which is like terrifying for a growth stock so that that
- 53:50fits into your thesis, I mean, but overall consumers, don't
- 53:55seem, I mean the unemployment rate is low and that's in part
- 54:00because a lot of people have left the workforce to, right?
- 54:03It's like the pictures, the consumers.
- 54:06It is muddled. I think I just think it's mostly
- 54:10an inflation story right now. I think the economy is good and
- 54:14in stocks are getting hit because of inflation for because
- 54:19because the FED will raise interest rates and then there
- 54:21will be less money that needs to flow in to the stock market,
- 54:25more will go into debt and, and I don't know.
- 54:29So interesting. I feel like also because we're
- 54:31coming out of the pandemic, like just intuitively, but I'm
- 54:35thinking about the people, I know, Like who don't live in DC
- 54:38or New York or SF like the people.
- 54:40I know like where I grew up, they're not economically
- 54:44thriving. I guess it's hard to put it.
- 54:46So again, it's like which part of the real economy and consumer
- 54:49economy? Are you focused on to like kind
- 54:52of like the upper middle class part of the economy that is
- 54:56going to get Stitch fix boxes? Right?
- 54:58Here are the big man these Services.
- 55:00I mean, Lauren are you talking about?
- 55:02Like the kind of probably more, I don't know.
- 55:05But in terms of Like their total income or there, but in terms of
- 55:09just total number of bodies in the United States of America.
- 55:12I wonder if they're more bodies in the United States of America
- 55:14who are not economically thriving, not doing well done.
- 55:17Don't have tons of expendable cash aren't really buying very
- 55:22much, which is possibly why holiday shopping numbers overall
- 55:26were down even though we all have friends, who knew we're
- 55:28buying lots of stuff for the holidays, you know, sort of like
- 55:32I just don't under there. I think there's sort of like in
- 55:35the data Real disparity between different groups of people and I
- 55:40don't think it's very well understood.
- 55:42And then how does that impact? Something like Silicon Valley,
- 55:45if the valley is really only making products for like, you
- 55:49know, the upper middle class. Right.
- 55:53Maybe it doesn't affect Silicon Valley at all.
- 55:55Right. Right now.
- 55:56So and then that makes a very interesting 2024 election.
- 56:01Oh you know what another good episode was another.
- 56:03Good episode was remember ska member thus Cabo Boom in the 90s
- 56:07a fucking horse. It was like Ska and then like
- 56:10the 1950s dance Revival. Oh yeah.
- 56:15Yeah. It was like swing Revival that
- 56:17Gap commercial and then like scar, I'm sorry, Papa gladion.
- 56:21Yeah. Like totally traumatic, like
- 56:24musical advertising blob and my mind.
- 56:27Yeah, any dark, the No Doubt episode really dives into that.
- 56:32Yikes. Ah yeah.
- 56:34And those low waisted jeans are back so there's a lot happening
- 56:38sort of like I feel like there could be a huge, no doubt
- 56:41Revival or ask our Revival. Oh wow!
- 56:44Wow, it's suspenders ready. I got a you know this is just
- 56:47like another reason for me to tune out.
- 56:52Any waves, go away, pop culture. Good good episode everybody.
- 56:57Thank you soon and tough. All right.
- 56:59See you Silicon Valley, goodbye, goodbye.
- 57:13Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 57:16Goodbye. Silicon Valley, goodbye,
- 57:13goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 57:15Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.