Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 069 – Is it okay to remarry after being divorced?
Transcript
- 0:43Hello, and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. My name is JD, and I blog over at uncoveringintimacy.com. And today we're talking about remarriage after divorce. And a friend of mine recently asked if the Bible allows you to remarry after you've been divorced. You see, her husband had divorced her years ago. And while she had no specific candidates in mind, she didn't want to even entertain the idea of a relationship that might lead to something romantic.
- 1:10I mean, who wants to be stuck choosing between God and someone you want to marry? If only more people had that foresight in different situations.
- 1:21And her impression from reading the Bible was that if you were divorced and remarried, not only would you be committing adultery in God's eyes, but so too would be your future or potential spouse.
- 1:31So then how could she entertain the idea of remarriage if it means that she's committing adultery and causing this potential spouse to also commit adultery?
- 1:40And knowing that I like to tackle difficult questions and find answers to them, she asked me, is it okay to remarry after being divorced?
- 1:49And after spending quite a bit of time digging into this and trying to figure out what the Bible said, because it wasn't quite so clear cut, I decided I might as well turn this into a blog post and a podcast.
- 2:00Now, things like this tend to lend themselves better to blog posts than podcasts.
- 2:05So, this is going to be a lot of verses on the blog.
- 2:09I have parts of them bolded so that it's easier to see the distinctions between them.
- 2:15If you get lost, maybe go check out the blog post.
- 2:18But I'm going to do my very best to keep it all straight and sane and simple in this episode.
- 2:25So, right away, when she asked, my first impression was that it didn't seem right for someone whose spouse had divorced them to be relegated to a life of singleness.
- 2:37You know, that doesn't mean that they're owed another spouse by any means, but if the opportunity presents itself, why not?
- 2:44I couldn't think of a biblical principle that I knew that would be violated by this.
- 2:49But, as Christians, we shouldn't be guided by our feelings, contrary to what many Christians seem to believe these days, but rather by the Word of God.
- 2:58So, I opened up my Bible and quickly saw why she had formed the opinion she had when I read this verse in Matthew 5, verse 32 from the New King James Version.
- 3:07And it says,
- 3:09But I say to you that whoever divorces his wife for any reason except sexual immorality causes her to commit adultery, and whoever marries a woman who is divorced commits adultery.
- 3:20Now, a plain reading of that seems pretty clear-cut, isn't it?
- 3:25On the surface level, it flat-out says that it causes her to commit adultery, and whoever marries her also commits adultery.
- 3:34However, the more I dug into it, the less clear it seemed.
- 3:40After all, how can a husband make his wife an adulterer by his actions?
- 3:45You know, the Bible is quite clear that we are responsible for our own actions for our own sins.
- 3:50Ezekiel 18 shows this principle clearly when talking about the righteous man and the unrighteous son.
- 3:55You'll have to go check that one out for yourself.
- 3:57I'm not going to read the whole chapter to you.
- 3:59So, I decided to look at some other translations and see what they did with this verse.
- 4:06And the NIV says that anyone who divorces his wife except for sexual immorality makes her the victim of adultery.
- 4:15The Berean Bible study says that he brings adultery upon her.
- 4:21The God's Word translation, which is more of a paraphrase, says,
- 4:26But I guarantee that any man who divorces his wife for any reason other than unfaithfulness makes her look as though she has committed adultery.
- 4:36Now, the God's Word translation, I think, is taking some liberties here, as many paraphrases do.
- 4:41But all in all, I think they're probably doing a better job of conveying the meaning.
- 4:47And reading scholars' opinions of the actual Greek shows that, you know, that phrase causes her to shows that the object of the sentence is the wife.
- 4:57And she's the one in the passive role here, not the one doing any action.
- 5:02In this case, then it's the husband who's doing the divorcing and acting upon her.
- 5:08In short, he's the one that's committing adultery.
- 5:12And we have kind of a similar thing happen in 1 John 10.
- 5:17It reads,
- 5:18If we say that we have not sinned, then we make him, that is God, a liar, and his Word is not in us.
- 5:25Now, can I cause God to be a liar?
- 5:27Can any action I do make him not to be truthful?
- 5:32And the answer is no, of course not.
- 5:34And by the same token, can I do anything to make my wife an adulteress?
- 5:40No, I can't.
- 5:42But in English, we don't really have good words to represent this.
- 5:46In Greek, the active and passive forms of the word are clear.
- 5:49But in English, we don't seem to have words for these tenses.
- 5:53We don't have a word for the one who is adultered against.
- 5:57So, lastly, I decided to check out one of the translations that were done from a Hebrew version of Matthew.
- 6:06Some believe that the Gospels, particularly Matthew, were first written in Hebrew, and then later translated into Greek, and then we lost the Hebrews.
- 6:17And in recent years, we've actually found Hebrew versions of them that seem to come from a prior translation than the Greek ones do.
- 6:27So, I was interested just to see how they translated this.
- 6:32So, this one comes from a version translated by George Howard from the Shem Tov Hebrew Matthew.
- 6:37Now, interestingly, it seems to agree that the husband, in this case, is the actor, and that the fault, responsibility, sin, and label of adulterer falls upon him.
- 7:00She has been adultered against.
- 7:03She's the violated one, not the one doing the violation.
- 7:07So, that seems to clear up the first part of the verse.
- 7:13What, then, do we do with the second part of the verse?
- 7:16Because it doesn't really help a whole lot if, great, she can remarry.
- 7:21It's not adultery for her, but anyone who marries her, it's still considered adultery for him.
- 7:26That really doesn't resolve anything at all.
- 7:29So, the second part of the verse reads,
- 7:30And whoever marries a divorced woman commits adultery.
- 7:33This is also problematic because we have other verses in the Bible, like 1 Corinthians 7, verse 15, that says,
- 7:41But if the unbelieving partner separates, let it be so.
- 7:44In such cases, the brother or sister is not enslaved.
- 7:47And this seems to contradict the plain text reading of Matthew 5, verse 32b.
- 7:51Like, so, if they divorce, then, no, you're still stuck to them, and anyone who marries you is committing divorce.
- 8:02But if they're not a believer and they leave, then you're not?
- 8:07That doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
- 8:09There is some contradiction going on.
- 8:11So, that clearly needs more study again.
- 8:15And later on in Matthew 19, we see Jesus tackle this subject again.
- 8:19In that chapter, we see the Pharisees coming to Jesus with a question, as they often did.
- 8:24They quote Deuteronomy 24 and ask if it's lawful for a husband to divorce his wife.
- 8:30Jesus responds, saying that God never intended for divorce.
- 8:34And afterwards, the disciples ask Jesus basically the same question.
- 8:39They want to know, what's the legalistic answer?
- 8:43Not the principle that Jesus was trying to teach, that marriage is a serious thing.
- 8:48And here's what Jesus says in Matthew 19, verse 9.
- 8:52I tell you that anyone who divorces his wife except for sexual immorality and marries another woman commits adultery.
- 9:00And that's it. He stops there.
- 9:01In Mark, we get the same story.
- 9:03And he says, whoever divorces his wife and marries another commits adultery against her.
- 9:08And if a woman divorces her husband and marries another, she commits adultery.
- 9:12And oddly enough, there's no mention of remarriage counting as adultery in these accounts.
- 9:19Also, what's interesting is that in Deuteronomy 24, the only mention of remarriage that appears to be abhorrent
- 9:25is if you divorce your wife and she marries another man and then he divorces her or dies,
- 9:31and then you marry your wife again.
- 9:33And I think maybe this was to stop husbands from trying to, quote-unquote, legally swap wives.
- 9:41And that would make the verse in Matthew 5, verse 32 make sense.
- 9:46You know, if you meet another man and you're each attracted to each other's wife,
- 9:49but you're bored with your own,
- 9:51if you each divorce your wife and marry the other,
- 9:54then legally it would be okay.
- 9:57But really, you're just conspiring to commit adultery together.
- 10:02As well, all of this is within a larger talk in Matthew 5 of Jesus trying to teach people,
- 10:08my guess is the Pharisees most of all,
- 10:10that the principles behind the laws are the more important part.
- 10:14To stop looking for legal loopholes.
- 10:16You know, not murdering isn't enough.
- 10:18You have to love even your enemy.
- 10:20Divorcing for lawful reasons isn't enough.
- 10:22You have to love your spouse even when it's hard or you don't want to.
- 10:25And the entire point is that a marriage should be a living example of the love God has for us.
- 10:31It's not a joke and it's not to be taken lightly.
- 10:33And we see this when we look at other verses on the same topic.
- 10:361 Corinthians 7 verses 10 to 11 says,
- 10:39To the married I give this charge, not I but the Lord.
- 10:42The wife should not separate from her husband,
- 10:44but if she does, she should remain unmarried or else be reconciled to her husband.
- 10:49And the husband should not divorce his wife.
- 10:52In short, it's kind of, if you're going to leave a marriage for frivolous reasons,
- 10:56like we fell out of love or it was just too hard or I was unhappy,
- 11:00well, then you better just stay unmarried.
- 11:03Marriage isn't for you.
- 11:04Frankly, you don't have the character it requires.
- 11:08If you can't take it seriously, don't get into another one.
- 11:12If you can convince your spouse to take you back and try again, fine,
- 11:15but don't make someone else miserable because you're the problem, not the marriage.
- 11:20Again, if you're divorcing for frivolous reasons,
- 11:23I'm not talking about adultery or real abuse, things like that.
- 11:27So looking at this 1 Corinthians 7 verse 15 verse again,
- 11:31you know, it says that if the unbelieving partner separates,
- 11:33let it be so in such cases, the brother or sister is not enslaved.
- 11:37You know, I was wondering, what does this enslaved mean?
- 11:41Well, I also found this other verse in 1 Corinthians 7 verse 39.
- 11:44So a couple dozen verses down.
- 11:47A wife is bound to her husband as long as he lives.
- 11:50But if her husband dies, she is freed to be married to whom she wishes only in the Lord.
- 11:55And these words bound and enslaved, you know, they share the same root in Greek.
- 11:59It's being subject to the law, a law that binds you together.
- 12:05Romans 7 verses 2 to 3 uses, again, kind of the same concept.
- 12:10For a married woman is bound by law to her husband while he lives.
- 12:14But if her husband dies, she is released from the law of marriage.
- 12:17Accordingly, she will be called an adulteress if she lives with another man while her husband
- 12:22is alive.
- 12:23But if her husband dies, she is free from that law.
- 12:26And if she marries another man, she is not an adulteress.
- 12:30So there seem to be clear ways that this binding can be broken.
- 12:35If your spouse dies, then you aren't bound.
- 12:40Likewise, seemingly, if they divorce you, you aren't bound.
- 12:43That's what a certificate of divorce was for.
- 12:45It was a legal document saying that you are no longer bound by the law.
- 12:50If your spouse leaves you for frivolous reasons, well, then it's not your fault.
- 12:54You haven't done anything wrong.
- 12:55You aren't bound by that law.
- 12:57You are free from it.
- 12:58And what I read from all of this is that marriage is really important.
- 13:04So important that choosing to enter or leave it is a serious thing.
- 13:08I think far more serious than our society seems to take it.
- 13:12I think more seriously than many Christians seem to take it, to be honest.
- 13:16I'm constantly amazed at some of the emails I get asking if it's okay to leave your spouse
- 13:21just because things have gotten difficult.
- 13:24And by difficult, I mean first world problems difficult, if you know what I mean.
- 13:28Not really serious issues.
- 13:31I do get those emails as well, but I'm not talking about that right now.
- 13:35So now, how do I read this verse in Matthew 5 verse 32?
- 13:39You know, the one that says,
- 13:40But I say to you that whoever divorces his wife for any reason except for sexual immorality
- 13:45causes her to commit adultery, and whoever marries a woman who is divorced commits adultery.
- 13:51My understanding of this is that if you choose to leave the marriage for a frivolous issue,
- 13:56then you aren't fit to be married.
- 13:58You aren't giving it the weight it deserves.
- 14:02Now, I think the corollary to this is the opposite case, that if you marry someone whose spouse
- 14:08divorced them for a serious issue like adultery, well, that's probably not wise either.
- 14:14What makes you think that they won't do the same behavior in your marriage as well?
- 14:17In fact, I just read a recent study called Once a Cheater, Always a Cheater, Serial Infidelity Across
- 14:24Subsequent Relationships, which found that someone who has cheated in a relationship is 3.4 times more
- 14:30likely to engage in infidelity in a subsequent relationship compared to someone who has never
- 14:35cheated.
- 14:35Another way to put it is that 44% of subjects who engaged in infidelity did so again in their
- 14:42next relationship.
- 14:43That's nearly a 50-50 chance.
- 14:46Sort of rolling the dice there.
- 14:49So, can you get married again if you're divorced?
- 14:52As far as I can tell, if you didn't instigate the divorce or cause the divorce through sexual
- 14:57immorality, I don't see why not.
- 15:00I cannot find a biblical reason for it.
- 15:03Alternatively, if you did instigate a divorce, repent, and convince your spouse to take you
- 15:09back, then you can marry them again.
- 15:12That's how I see it anyways.
- 15:14And if you disagree, I'd love to hear your reasons and verses.
- 15:18To back them up, head over to the blog and stick it in the comment section.
- 15:22Or shoot me an email at jay at uncoveringintimacy.com.
- 15:26That'll work too.
- 15:27That's it for today.
- 15:29I'm working on the questions I got in February, so they should be out shortly.
- 15:34And that's about it for now.
- 15:36See ya.