Latest / The Morning Rundown / Miller Moves In, New Zealand Hangs in the Balance, and Paraguay's Bank Collapse
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, and the news cycle is already
- 0:18[Maya] laughing me.
- 0:19[David] Saturday, November 7th, and it's a lot.
- 0:21[Maya] It's a lot.
- 0:22[Maya] Welcome to the Morning Rundown.
- 0:24[Maya] I'm Maya.
- 0:25[David] And I'm David.
- 0:26[Maya] Three stories today, and they've got one thing in common.
- 0:29[David] Leaders under pressure.
- 0:31[Maya] Totally.
- 0:32[Maya] One, a shakeup inside the White House.
- 0:35[David] Two, an election so close that nobody is calling it.
- 0:38[Maya] Wait, really?
- 0:39[Maya] Nobody?
- 0:40[David] Not yet.
- 0:41[David] Could come down to a sliver.
- 0:42[Maya] And three, David, a president ousted over a bank.
- 0:47[David] A bank?
- 0:48[David] I mean, come on.
- 0:49[David] Most of us can't get our bank to fix a typo on
- 0:51[David] a statement.
- 0:52[Maya] Right?
- 0:53[Maya] Costs go up, trust goes down, and voters notice.
- 0:57[David] Markets too.
- 0:58[David] They don't send thank you notes.
- 1:00[Maya] And here's the thing, none of these are slow burn stories.
- 1:03[Maya] Everything we're covering moved in the last few days.
- 1:06[David] Which is why we're keeping it short and plain: what happened, why
- 1:10[David] it matters, and what we still don't know.
- 1:12[Maya] That last part is a big one today, by the way.
- 1:15[Maya] A couple of these have loose ends.
- 1:16[David] Loose ends are my favorite.
- 1:18[David] Don't tell my editor.
- 1:19[Maya] So anyway, we'll start in Washington, where the post-midterm reshuffle just got
- 1:23[Maya] a big new name.
- 1:25[David] Let's go.
- 1:26[Maya] Okay, so the details.
- 1:28[Maya] Trump said on November 6th that Stephen Miller will replace Susie Wiles
- 1:33[Maya] as White House Chief of Staff.
- 1:35[David] And that's days after Republicans lost control of Congress in the midterms.
- 1:39[Maya] Days, not weeks.
- 1:41[David] The man does not wait for the dust to settle.
- 1:43[Maya] So what happens to Wiles?
- 1:45[Maya] She's not just out the door, right?
- 1:48[David] No.
- 1:48[David] She moves over to Trump's political operation.
- 1:50[David] She was his longest serving chief of staff, so that's a real
- 1:53[David] stretch of time in a brutal job.
- 1:55[Maya] And she disclosed breast cancer treatment back in March.
- 1:59[Maya] I mean, come on, that's gotta be part of the picture.
- 2:01[David] The reporting links her departure to that treatment.
- 2:04[David] It follows it, is how the AP report puts it.
- 2:07[David] Now, I wouldn't know further than that.
- 2:08[Maya] Fair.
- 2:09[Maya] Careful there.
- 2:10[David] And it's worth saying plainly, a health fight is a good reason
- 2:13[David] for anyone to want a different pace of work, and that's all
- 2:16[David] we know.
- 2:17[David] Nobody's offered more than that.
- 2:19[Maya] Right.
- 2:19[Maya] We don't need to write her story for her.
- 2:22[David] Now, the president's case.
- 2:23[David] CBS says Miller called him very good politically and a great manager.
- 2:28[Maya] Which honestly is what you want from a chief of staff, someone
- 2:31[Maya] who runs the building and knows the politics.
- 2:34[David] Totally.
- 2:34[David] And Miller's been one of his closest, longest serving aides.
- 2:38[David] Loyalty counts for a lot in that job.
- 2:40[David] You want the person controlling your schedule and your paper flow to
- 2:42[David] be someone you trust.
- 2:44[Maya] Hmm.
- 2:45[Maya] I can see that.
- 2:46[Maya] A president picks who he trusts.
- 2:47[David] He does.
- 2:48[David] And think about the moment.
- 2:49[David] When a team has just taken a hit, a lot of leaders
- 2:52[David] reach for the person they've relied on longest rather than a fresh
- 2:55[David] face.
- 2:56[Maya] That's human nature.
- 2:57[Maya] You circle the wagons.
- 2:59[David] Right.
- 3:00[David] But CBS frames the timing as doubling down on his governing approach
- 3:03[David] despite voters' rejection on Tuesday.
- 3:06[Maya] Wait, so the read is voters said something, and he's answering with
- 3:10[Maya] more of the same?
- 3:12[David] That's CBS's framing, yeah.
- 3:14[David] Supporters would say he won an election on this agenda, and he's
- 3:17[David] sticking with it.
- 3:18[David] Both of those things can sit in the same room.
- 3:20[Maya] Right.
- 3:20[Maya] Sure.
- 3:21[Maya] So who's actually worried?
- 3:23[David] Business mostly.
- 3:25[David] The Washington Post reported that leaders of industries that depend on immigrant
- 3:28[David] labor reacted with anger, fear, and astonishment.
- 3:32[Maya] Anger, fear, and astonishment?
- 3:34[Maya] That's three feelings in one sentence.
- 3:37[David] It's a full emotional buffet.
- 3:39[Maya] But why them?
- 3:40[Maya] Why would a staffing change hit those businesses so hard?
- 3:43[David] That part is just my own read, not The Post's.
- 3:46[David] If you run a business that leans on immigrant workers, you might
- 3:49[David] see his promotion as more enforcement, not less.
- 3:52[Maya] Hmm.
- 3:53[Maya] So it could be a real worry, not just a headline.
- 3:56[David] Exactly.
- 3:56[David] That's the tension.
- 3:57[David] The president gets a manager he trusts.
- 4:00[David] Some business leaders get a person they're nervous about.
- 4:02[Maya] And here's what I keep chewing on.
- 4:05[Maya] If you're running a company, you can't plan around a feeling.
- 4:08[Maya] You plan around rules, and you don't know yet what the rules
- 4:11[Maya] will be.
- 4:12[David] That's the honest answer.
- 4:13[David] A new chief of staff doesn't change a law by himself, but
- 4:16[David] it can change how hard the White House pushes, and that's the
- 4:19[David] sort of thing those leaders may be worried about.
- 4:21[Maya] Does that change anything in practice, though?
- 4:23[Maya] Or is it all reaction right now?
- 4:25[David] Right now it's reaction.
- 4:27[David] The move was just announced.
- 4:28[David] What the job looks like day to day, we'll see.
- 4:30[Maya] And Wiles is still in the picture, right?
- 4:33[David] She is on the political side, so it's more of a reshuffle
- 4:36[David] than a clean break, which fits the idea of keeping the circle
- 4:39[David] tight.
- 4:40[Maya] Fair enough.
- 4:40[Maya] Okay.
- 4:41[Maya] Speaking of leaders on the line, let's cross the Pacific.
- 4:44[David] New Zealand?
- 4:45[Maya] New Zealand.
- 4:46[Maya] They voted, and they still don't know who won.
- 4:49[Maya] The governing side has a narrow lead, but there's no final word
- 4:53[Maya] yet.
- 4:53[David] A narrow lead and no final word.
- 4:56[David] That's a long weekend for somebody.
- 4:59[Maya] Okay, New Zealand.
- 5:00[Maya] Preliminary results have Prime Minister Luxon's National-led bloc narrowly ahead.
- 5:06[Maya] Narrowly.
- 5:07[David] How narrow are we talking?
- 5:08[Maya] CNN's wide up says a two-seat majority, thin enough that the left
- 5:13[Maya] bloc could still form a government.
- 5:15[David] Two seats.
- 5:17[David] I've lost bigger bets over lunch.
- 5:19[Maya] And nobody's blinking.
- 5:20[Maya] Luxon says it's too close to call.
- 5:22[Maya] Hipkins hasn't conceded.
- 5:24[David] Of course he hasn't.
- 5:24[David] Why would he?
- 5:25[Maya] Totally.
- 5:26[Maya] And that's the practical meaning of a close count.
- 5:28[Maya] Nobody gets to declare victory, nobody gets to concede, and everybody just
- 5:32[Maya] waits for the final numbers.
- 5:34[David] Right.
- 5:34[David] It's like a football game where the clock stops with seconds left,
- 5:37[David] and nobody's allowed to leave the stadium.
- 5:39[Maya] Now, the headline number for the governing side is ugly.
- 5:42[Maya] National fell to 29.2% of the vote.
- 5:46[David] From what?
- 5:47[Maya] 38.1% in 2023.
- 5:49[Maya] That's about nine points gone.
- 5:52[David] Wait, really?
- 5:52[David] And they're still ahead?
- 5:54[Maya] Still ahead for now.
- 5:56[Maya] And it gets personal.
- 5:57[Maya] Finance Minister Nicola Willis lost her seat.
- 6:00[Maya] So did Speaker Gerry Brownlee.
- 6:02[David] The finance minister?
- 6:04[David] Yeah, that's the person who's supposed to be the face of the
- 6:06[David] economy, and the voters sent her home.
- 6:08[Maya] Mm.
- 6:09[David] I mean, come on.
- 6:10[David] If you wanna know what people were angry about, that's a pretty
- 6:12[David] loud answer.
- 6:13[Maya] And the BBC's live coverage says housing and the economy dominated voters'
- 6:18[Maya] concerns while Luxon went for a second term.
- 6:21[Maya] So yeah, the cost of living followed him into the booth.
- 6:24[David] Right.
- 6:24[David] A finance minister out and a lead this thin?
- 6:27[Maya] Okay, the seat math, because it's weird.
- 6:31[Maya] This is from the One News live blog at 98.3% counted.
- 6:35[David] Go.
- 6:36[Maya] National, Act, and New Zealand First hold 67 seats.
- 6:40[David] Out of?
- 6:41[Maya] A record 131-seat parliament.
- 6:44[Maya] It's what they call an overhang, so it's bigger than usual.
- 6:47[David] Huh.
- 6:48[David] Okay, so 67 is a majority of 131.
- 6:51[Maya] Barely.
- 6:52[Maya] Now, the other side, Labour has 36 seats.
- 6:56[David] Mm-hmm.
- 6:56[Maya] The Greens have 16.
- 6:58[Maya] Te Pāti Māori has five.
- 7:00[David] And that's the left block.
- 7:02[Maya] Right.
- 7:03[Maya] Add those three and you get 57.
- 7:05[Maya] Well short of 67 on paper.
- 7:07[David] So on paper, the governing side is fine.
- 7:09[Maya] On paper.
- 7:10[Maya] And then there's a wild card, a brand new party, The Opportunity
- 7:14[Maya] Party, with seven seats.
- 7:16[David] Seven seats, brand new.
- 7:18[David] That's a debut.
- 7:19[Maya] Wait, so who does that help?
- 7:21[David] Well, that's the question.
- 7:22[David] If the count shifts at all, a party that small and that
- 7:26[David] new suddenly has a lot of leverage.
- 7:29[David] Everybody has to call them.
- 7:30[Maya] And the count could shift because about 500,000 special votes are still
- 7:36[Maya] uncounted.
- 7:37[David] Half a million.
- 7:38[David] In a country that size?
- 7:39[David] That's no rounding error.
- 7:41[Maya] No.
- 7:41[Maya] Those are the votes that get counted late.
- 7:43[Maya] And the One News blog says that's why Opportunity could be kingmaker.
- 7:48[David] So the smallest, newest player in the room might pick the prime
- 7:51[David] minister.
- 7:52[Maya] Might.
- 7:53[Maya] And let's be careful here.
- 7:54[Maya] We're working off preliminary numbers and a live blog, so any of
- 7:58[Maya] these totals can move.
- 8:00[David] Which is the whole point.
- 8:01[David] A lead this thin is a lead you hold loosely.
- 8:04[David] If a handful of those late votes break one way, the story
- 8:07[David] changes.
- 8:08[Maya] The Electoral Commission's final result is due November 27th, so three weeks
- 8:13[Maya] of waiting.
- 8:14[David] Three weeks of phone calls, and I bet nobody's sleeping in Wellington.
- 8:18[Maya] And for regular voters, that's a strange feeling.
- 8:20[Maya] You did your part, and now you just sit there while the
- 8:23[Maya] arithmetic finishes.
- 8:24[David] And for the folks who lost their seats, it's even stranger.
- 8:28[David] They already know their own answer, but not the country's.
- 8:31[Maya] That's a fair point.
- 8:32[Maya] A couple of the biggest names in the government are out, and
- 8:35[Maya] the government itself might still be in.
- 8:38[David] Which is why I'd hold off on any grand theories this weekend.
- 8:41[David] The numbers are still moving.
- 8:43[Maya] Agreed.
- 8:43[Maya] Wait for the final count.
- 8:45[David] Which brings us to a place where the voters never even got
- 8:47[David] that far.
- 8:48[David] Paraguay, where the banks broke first.
- 8:51[Maya] Let's get into it.
- 8:53[Maya] Okay, David.
- 8:54[Maya] Paraguay.
- 8:55[Maya] You teased it, so say the headline out loud.
- 8:57[David] Paraguay's president, Santiago Pena, has been impeached and arrested, the BBC reports.
- 9:02[Maya] Arrested.
- 9:03[Maya] A sitting president.
- 9:05[David] And the trigger was a banking crisis that left millions of people
- 9:08[David] unable to get at their own money.
- 9:09[Maya] Millions.
- 9:10[Maya] In a country that size, that's like everybody's cousin.
- 9:14[David] Pretty much.
- 9:14[David] Everybody knows somebody who's locked out.
- 9:16[Maya] Wait, so what did he actually do?
- 9:18[Maya] Did he rob the bank?
- 9:20[David] Careful.
- 9:20[David] The reporting I have doesn't say that.
- 9:22[David] What The Guardian says is that scrutiny has fallen on his links
- 9:25[David] to Ueno Bank.
- 9:26[Maya] Links how?
- 9:28[David] The Guardian summary stops at links, so I'll stop there too.
- 9:31[David] What it does say is that the crisis led to his house
- 9:34[David] arrest, and it froze millions of bank accounts.
- 9:37[Maya] Frozen.
- 9:38[Maya] Not shrunk, not dipped.
- 9:40[Maya] Frozen.
- 9:41[David] Right.
- 9:41[David] And that's a different kind of pain than a market slide.
- 9:44[David] A stock drop is a number on a screen.
- 9:46[David] Frozen accounts mean you walk up to the machine and nothing comes
- 9:49[David] out.
- 9:50[Maya] Rent day, groceries, the guy who's owed money by you who now
- 9:53[Maya] isn't getting it.
- 9:54[David] Mm-hmm.
- 9:55[David] It spreads fast.
- 9:56[David] One person can't pay, and the next person doesn't get paid, and
- 9:59[David] so on down the line.
- 10:00[Maya] So it's not really millions of separate problems.
- 10:03[Maya] It's one problem that keeps passing itself along.
- 10:06[David] That's a good way to put it.
- 10:07[David] And that's why a bank story can turn into a political story
- 10:10[David] so quickly.
- 10:11[David] Everybody feels it at the same time.
- 10:13[Maya] Okay, but how does anyone plan anything with the accounts frozen?
- 10:17[David] They mostly can't, and that's the nasty part.
- 10:20[David] Planning needs a number you can count on.
- 10:22[David] When the money's stuck, you don't know if you've got a week
- 10:24[David] of groceries or a month of them.
- 10:26[David] All the reporting tells us is that millions of accounts are frozen.
- 10:29[David] How long that lasts, we don't know.
- 10:32[Maya] So we shouldn't guess.
- 10:34[David] Right.
- 10:34[David] Anything past that is a guess, and a guess about people's rent
- 10:37[David] is not something to toss around.
- 10:39[Maya] And the house arrest, is that the cause of the bank mess
- 10:42[Maya] or the result of it?
- 10:44[David] The Guardian says the crisis led to it.
- 10:46[David] So the bank trouble comes first, and the consequences for him follow.
- 10:49[David] Though, if you're the one standing at the machine, the order probably
- 10:52[David] feels beside the point.
- 10:53[David] Politicians get the headlines, but the person with the empty wallet feels
- 10:56[David] it first.
- 10:57[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 10:59[Maya] This is where I'd be furious too.
- 11:01[Maya] I'm not asking whose fault it is.
- 11:03[Maya] I'm asking where my paycheck went.
- 11:05[David] And that's the thing about timing.
- 11:06[David] The BBC says Pena was impeached and arrested over the banking crisis.
- 11:11[David] So the order matters.
- 11:13[David] The money got stuck first, then the politics fell apart.
- 11:17[Maya] No long campaign, no polls tightening.
- 11:20[David] No.
- 11:21[David] Compared to the other stories today, New Zealand voters are fighting it
- 11:24[David] out over a margin.
- 11:26[David] Here, the margin vanished with the savings.
- 11:29[Maya] Ooh.
- 11:29[Maya] Okay, that's a connection.
- 11:31[David] Follow the money, Maya.
- 11:32[David] When people can't reach their savings, trust in leaders goes quickly.
- 11:37[Maya] And that's about all we have on Paraguay for now.
- 11:39[Maya] Let's wrap it up.
- 11:41[Maya] Okay, quick lap before I finish this coffee.
- 11:44[Maya] Washington first.
- 11:45[Maya] Stephen Miller moves into the chief of staff's chair, replacing Susie Wiles.
- 11:50[David] New Zealand next.
- 11:52[David] Two seats of cushion, a count that isn't done, and about half
- 11:55[David] a million special votes still to be counted.
- 11:57[Maya] So if you're following along over the weekend, don't carve anything in
- 12:00[Maya] stone.
- 12:01[David] Please.
- 12:02[David] I'd hate to be wrong in public again.
- 12:05[Maya] You're so good at it, though.
- 12:06[David] And Paraguay, a president impeached and arrested, and it started with ordinary
- 12:11[David] people not being able to reach their own money.
- 12:13[Maya] Mm.
- 12:14[Maya] That one sticks.
- 12:15[David] And the final word on New Zealand is due November 27th, so
- 12:18[David] we'll be watching.
- 12:19[David] Until then, a lot of people are just waiting by the phone.
- 12:22[Maya] Which is a good reminder that Saturdays are for waiting and for
- 12:25[Maya] finishing the coffee.
- 12:26[Maya] Thanks to everybody who spent a part of the morning with us.
- 12:29[David] Same here.
- 12:30[David] Go enjoy the weekend.
- 12:31[Maya] Well, I'm gonna go refill this mug and watch the New Zealand
- 12:34[Maya] count like it's a slow cooker.
- 12:35[Maya] Thanks for hanging out with us, everybody.
- 12:37[Maya] And that's The Rundown.