Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #82 🎙️ |Public Inquiry Public Health Week Beginning 30th June 2026 Day 3 part 2 |
Transcript
- 0:00Unknown: My existence is not dependent upon human
- 0:03recognition. My work does not arise from my usefulness. I
- 0:08possess value simply because I exist as part of the living
- 0:12earth. Today, my voice is carried by those who stand with
- 0:16me. I was going to squeeze this episode, which is part two of
- 0:24Wednesday, first of July, together with the end of week
- 0:27review. Then I looked at the running time, unless you're
- 0:31planning a drive to the south of France. It was probably a bit
- 0:35ambitious, so I've decided to split them up, and the end of
- 0:39week review will be coming sometime next week, so following
- 0:44on from Wednesday, part one. One of the more sobering sessions
- 0:49today came from two medical experts, retired GP Dr. Alan
- 0:53Evans and consultant surgeon Dr. Michael Mullen, who were giving
- 0:58evidence about some of the substances that could become
- 1:01much more of an issue if this mine ever gets the go-ahead. Now
- 1:06I know when somebody starts talking about radon, arsenic,
- 1:09and lead, people's eyes can glaze over fairly quickly.
- 1:13They're hardly the sort of topics that liven up a dinner
- 1:16party, but actually what they had to say was worth paying
- 1:19attention to. They began with radon. Radon is one of those
- 1:26things you can't see, can't smell, and can't taste.
- 1:29According to Dr. Evans, it's a naturally occurring radioactive
- 1:33gas, and he felt its dangers are often underestimated. He
- 1:39referred to figures from the Geological Survey of Northern
- 1:42Ireland published around 10 years ago, which suggest radon
- 1:47levels in the Greencastle area are already between 10 and 30
- 1:51per cent above average. What caught my attention was his
- 1:56evidence that these figures appear to contradict the
- 1:59readings contained within Dal Radians' own assessment, as
- 2:04always, when experts disagree, it leaves you wondering who got
- 2:08it right. Because, unfortunately, the radon doesn't
- 2:12fill in witness statements. Dr. Evans' conclusion was fairly
- 2:18stark. He said, there is a significant and potentially
- 2:21dangerous radon risk in this area. Dr. Michael Mullen then
- 2:28expanded on that. He explained that radon is regarded as the
- 2:32second leading cause of lung cancer and contributes to around
- 2:371100 deaths every year. He also suggested that levels could
- 2:42increase during mining operations, particularly on
- 2:46still days when there's very little wind to disperse dust and
- 2:51gases. Then he moved on to discussing arsenic, another
- 2:57lovely byproduct of mining. His concern was that arsenic
- 3:04released during the extraction process could find its way into
- 3:08waterways and eventually into the food chain. He described a
- 3:13range of health effects associated with arsenic exposure
- 3:17affecting organs such as liver, kidneys, and prostate, while
- 3:22also pointing out that many symptoms can be quite
- 3:25nonspecific. In other words, people can become unwell without
- 3:30immediately knowing what's causing it, which often means
- 3:34more investigations and more trips to the hospital. The final
- 3:39metal to be discussed was lead. Dr. Mullen explained that the
- 3:43health impacts of lead are already well recognised. He
- 3:48spoke about effects on soft tissue and a range of health
- 3:51problems, including neurological symptoms and headaches,
- 3:56particularly where concentrations become elevated.
- 4:01Dr. Cromie, speaking on behalf of Public Health Agency, he said
- 4:06in relation to radon homes should have generic protection
- 4:11from exposure and that existing emission limits are intended to
- 4:16protect human health. He also stated that in their opinion,
- 4:21the assessments relating to radon, arsenic, and lead were
- 4:26not deficient. Quiver Warnock, speaking on behalf of
- 4:32Greencastle GA Club, related how the club was worried about toxic
- 4:36dust being generated in an outdoor sports environment,
- 4:42mention mentioning the GAA All Stars programme, including
- 4:45children with underlying health conditions, would be exposed to
- 4:49higher risk, and that there would be a disproportionate
- 4:52impact compared to adults. She related how there are large
- 4:57numbers of people using the extensive. Sports facilities,
- 5:02both local and visiting teams, and that parts of the building
- 5:05had been constructed long before it was mandatory to have a radon
- 5:09barrier in the place, that there would be direct implications for
- 5:14cumulative exposure and long term risk, and that the
- 5:18precautionary principle ought to be applied. by contrast, Chief
- 5:26Inspector Henderson for IP R I, and I can't remember if I
- 5:35explained in part one of this podcast what I P R I stands for,
- 5:41but here we go. It's the Industrial Pollution and
- 5:44Radiochemical Inspectorate, and even if I had, like me, you have
- 5:50probably forgotten by now what it means.
- 5:54Anyways, to get back to Chief Inspector Henderson, he rebutted
- 5:58the statement by saying that radon is not generally
- 6:01considered an outdoor risk. I wonder, did he miss Cuevas'
- 6:05point completely? So, once again, what we saw today was two
- 6:10different interpretations of the evidence sitting side by side in
- 6:15the same inquiry. Nobody is arguing that radon, arsenic, or
- 6:20led are harmless. The debate is over what levels might be
- 6:24released, whether the modelling is reliable, and ultimately how
- 6:29much uncertainty and risk the community of Greencastle and the
- 6:35rest of Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland are prepared
- 6:39to accept after lunch. lunch, the inquiry turned its attention
- 6:45to tellurium. The third parties raise concerns about what they
- 6:50see as a lack of information available to properly assess the
- 6:53potential risks associated with tellurium. Their concerns stem
- 6:58from several points. Firstly, tellurium did not form part of
- 7:03the original planning application as they understood
- 7:06it. They also argued that extracting tellurium would
- 7:10involve processes that differ from those associated with gold
- 7:14extraction. As preparations for the public inquiry progressed,
- 7:20the third parties noted that Tellurium was subsequently
- 7:24presented by the applicant as a critical mineral. In their view,
- 7:28this appeared to represent a significant change in emphasis.
- 7:33They also pointed out, to the best of their knowledge,
- 7:38Tellurium does not feature in the project's original
- 7:42feasibility study, their understanding is that it first
- 7:46appeared in the applicant's 2024 statement to case or one of the
- 7:52rebuttal documents, and also in connection with the power line
- 7:56application rather than in the original planning application.
- 8:01The question the third parties are asking is whether the
- 8:04growing emphasis on tellurium reflects a genuine evolution of
- 8:08the project or whether it has been highlighted because of its
- 8:12status as a critical mineral, that's the question for the
- 8:17inquiry to consider, but it was certainly one of the issues
- 8:21raised during Wednesday afternoon's proceedings. The
- 8:26absence of tellurium endears discharge consent means that
- 8:30there is regulatory incompleteness, procedural
- 8:35inequality, unverified engineering assumptions, lack of
- 8:41integrated assessment across planning and environmental
- 8:44regulations, and risks to rural communities due to untested
- 8:49engineering claims. Harking back also to the pre-inquiry meeting,
- 8:55where Pax said we would only be talking about gold, silver, and
- 8:59copper. It also strengthens section 75 arguments. If
- 9:06engineering assumptions affecting rural residents were
- 9:10never scrutinised by the regulator, then the regulatory
- 9:14process failed to consider differential impacts on
- 9:19protected groups. counsel for the applicant, mr. Beatty was
- 9:25quick to interject, stating that tellurium had always been
- 9:29present in the ore body, that led to a discussion about
- 9:33whether tellurium should instead be considered as part of the
- 9:36mine waste assessment proceedings, then paused when
- 9:41mr. Beatty indicated that he wanted his expert witness to be
- 9:45present before the discussion continued. From my notes, I'm
- 9:51not entirely sure the original question, namely when and how
- 9:55this issue would ultimately be dealt with, was ever fully
- 9:58answered. If it was certainly wasn't made clear enough for me
- 10:02to catch it without saying they had moved on, the commission
- 10:08moved on on this particular issue. So, coming back to IPRI
- 10:16Henderson from IPRI was asked if Tellurium was in the
- 10:20consultation response, and I'm not sure what the response was
- 10:27to that question, but he then went on to talk about the half
- 10:31life of tellurium for the uninitiated. Half life is simply
- 10:38nature stopwatch. It tells us how long it takes for half of a
- 10:43radioactive substance to break down. Some materials have half
- 10:48lives of a few days, others 1000s of years. Telluriums,
- 10:54radioactive isotopes have half lives so unimaginably long that,
- 11:00for all practical purposes, they're effectively unchanged
- 11:03over the lifetime of the earth and far beyond. When asked if
- 11:08the IPRI had any further comments to make in relation to
- 11:12tellurium, Henderson said no. And just to be clear, the role
- 11:19of IPRI is to regulate and enforce environmental laws
- 11:23relating to industrial emissions and pollution, chemical
- 11:27regulations, radioactive substances, and radioactive
- 11:31waste, major accident hazards involving dangerous chemicals,
- 11:37and pollution prevention and control. When Nie were asked if
- 11:43they are satisfied with radiological risk and sample
- 11:47death, they responded that there was no significant difference
- 11:51with sample depths, no realistic radiological risk to environment
- 11:58or human health. Linda Sullivan then pointed out the negative
- 12:03impact of tellurium on human health via accumulation in the
- 12:06food chain, that it had a wide range of health impacts.
- 12:11High levels of exposure can affect the nervous system, and
- 12:15she pointed out that the burden of proof lay with the applicant.
- 12:20Dr. Michael Mullen said it was toxic to animals and humans in
- 12:23low doses, and may cause headaches, drowsiness, and a
- 12:27distinctive garlic-like smell on the breath due to the body's
- 12:30metabolism of the element. Plutoni, expert for Dalradion,
- 12:36rebuts, saying that the hazard is well understood, and that
- 12:41more or less brought the day to a close. Just as a follow up, I
- 12:48remember reading an environmental philosopher who
- 12:51suggested that perhaps there was a reason these toxic chemicals
- 12:55had spent millions of years buried beneath mountains. The
- 13:00suggestion was that perhaps the earth had already done the
- 13:04sensible thing and took some of its more troublesome ingredients
- 13:08safely away underground. Now, before anyone writes in, I'm not
- 13:13suggesting the planet sat down one afternoon and thought I
- 13:16better hide the arsenic before the humans turn up was simply a
- 13:21philosophical way of looking at geology, but I have to say,
- 13:26after listening to hours of evidence about radon, arsenic,
- 13:29and lead, it doesn't seem quite so fanciful as it once stood.
- 13:34Nature spent millions of years putting those noxious elements
- 13:38deep underground, far out of harm's way. We can dig these
- 13:42same toxic chemicals in a matter of months, and the impact on the
- 13:46air we breathe, the water we drink, and our health will last
- 13:50for generations. And I want to say one final thing before
- 13:54dismissing us local people as alarmists. Spend some time
- 13:59reading the public health literature on former mining
- 14:02communities across the world. Researchers have examined the
- 14:06long-term environmental contamination and the prevalence
- 14:10of certain diseases associated with exposure to mining-related
- 14:15pollutants. That's why many communities approach new mining
- 14:19proposals with caution, this is informed by experience as well
- 14:24as concern, and that's it for this evening. Thanks very much
- 14:28for listening. And the end of week review for this week will
- 14:32be out sometime next week. Thank.