Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 224. Make Your Messages Epic: The Evolution of Words and the Stories They Carry
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: Language sits at the very heart of our ability to connect,
- 0:06to innovate, and to collaborate.
- 0:09If we are to get better at our communication, we first have to start by
- 0:13understanding language and its origins.
- 0:16My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:20Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:22Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:28Today I look forward to speaking with Laura Spinney.
- 0:30Laura's an author and journalist.
- 0:32Her writing appears in many locations including The Atlantic, National
- 0:36Geographic, Nature, and New Scientist.
- 0:39Laura is the author of Pale Rider: The Spanish Flu of 1918 and How It
- 0:43Changed the World, and her latest book is entitled, Proto: How One
- 0:47Ancient Language Went Global.
- 0:49Welcome, Laura.
- 0:50I'm really excited for our conversation.
- 0:53Laura Spinney: I'm delighted to be here.
- 0:53Thank you for the invitation.
- 0:55Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:56Shall we get started?
- 0:57Laura Spinney: Yes.
- 0:57Matt Abrahams: Alright.
- 0:58You have written on a wide range of topics, many which
- 1:01center around communication.
- 1:03I'm curious what motivates your interest in communication?
- 1:06Laura Spinney: I suppose that language is both something incredibly
- 1:11powerful, you can change the way that other people behave, almost
- 1:15telepathically with language.
- 1:16You don't have to operate to implant an idea in their head,
- 1:19you can just speak to them.
- 1:20And at the same time, it's a blunt instrument.
- 1:22So I suppose I'm fascinated by that kind of tension between the power of
- 1:25language and the sort of bluntness of it.
- 1:28Matt Abrahams: It's fascinating to me how there is so much we can accomplish
- 1:31with communication, and yet there are so many things that we struggle with
- 1:35in our communication, and I really appreciate that you take the time
- 1:38to reflect on it and write about it.
- 1:40I first came to know your work in an article you wrote
- 1:42about deception detection.
- 1:45Humans aren't really good at detecting when other people are lying.
- 1:48Referring back to that article in your research for it, what are some things that
- 1:51we can do to become better lie detectors?
- 1:54Laura Spinney: Yeah, indeed, people think that they're good
- 1:57at detecting other people's lies, but, but actually they're not.
- 2:00The point about lying is that it imposes a greater cognitive
- 2:03burden than telling the truth.
- 2:04Because you have to make sure that your story is straight and
- 2:06all the bits of it fit together.
- 2:08And if you've invented it, that's quite hard to do.
- 2:10So if you wanna catch someone out in a lie, some of the tips or recommendations
- 2:14are to try and sort of get 'em to tell the story backwards, or say that you've
- 2:19maybe got a witness who saw this part of the story, and could you just maybe
- 2:22check that the facts are aligned, and make them a little nervous, disrupt them
- 2:26a bit and try and catch them out that way.
- 2:28Or perhaps something like draw the scene they're describing because they've
- 2:32gotta make all the ingredients cohere.
- 2:34And if it's invented, that's tougher.
- 2:36Or something like if they're expressing a powerful point of view, maybe get them
- 2:40to play devil's advocate and pretend to support the other one, because that
- 2:44becomes harder if they're lying about it.
- 2:46So yeah, some of the tricks to leverage that extra cognitive
- 2:50burden that a lie poses.
- 2:52Matt Abrahams: So when we're being deceptive, it takes a lot of cognitive
- 2:55effort to do so, and anything that puts a little added burden, like
- 2:59telling the story backwards or having somebody draw things out, really
- 3:04forces them to overload themselves.
- 3:07And often the detection can become more visible.
- 3:10And the big takeaway from that work, and your reporting of it, is we're
- 3:15just not very good at detecting lies.
- 3:18Laura Spinney: And that we think we are.
- 3:19Matt Abrahams: That's right.
- 3:19And we think we are.
- 3:21And that can get us into lots of trouble.
- 3:22So I think the big point there is remember that you might not be as good
- 3:26at detecting the lies as you think.
- 3:28I found your article on the history of storytelling just fascinating.
- 3:32Where stories come from, why we tell those stories.
- 3:34Would you mind summarizing your central thesis of that article and
- 3:38then explain why storytelling is so important and essential to being human?
- 3:43Laura Spinney: Central thesis is a little difficult to address except for there's
- 3:47this new mindset about how to approach it.
- 3:49There's still quite a lot of theories about why we tell stories.
- 3:51If I was to summarize a few of them, there would be like, what one main
- 3:55school of thought is that it's about passing on really important ecological
- 3:58information that's essential to survival.
- 4:00Another would be that storytelling has a very social function.
- 4:04When people are sitting around being told a story, they're listening closely
- 4:08to this story, their neurons are firing in a sort of synchronized way with
- 4:11each other, and that inspires kind of feelings of groupiness and there's a
- 4:14sort of social cohesion effect of that.
- 4:17So there are lots of theories, and I don't think we were yet at the
- 4:19point of choosing between them.
- 4:21And any way they might all be valid.
- 4:23But the thing also that I think is fascinating about this new approach
- 4:25is that it's showing how very stable some stories can be over time.
- 4:30And so there's the evidence that some stories are as old as the first migrations
- 4:35out of Africa, sixty thousand years.
- 4:37Some stories that we still tell today were brought in by the first speakers of the
- 4:42Indo-European language, the subject of my most recent book, when they came into
- 4:45Europe, about five thousand years ago.
- 4:47Pretty old anyway.
- 4:48And by the way, pre-writing, importantly.
- 4:51Some stories in Australia, date to the end of the last ice age,
- 4:54because they talk about the rising of the seas and they describe
- 4:56land that is now covered by water.
- 4:58So some of these things that are coming out of this comparative approach,
- 5:02this possibility of storing stories and comparing them across space and
- 5:05time are truly mind boggling, I think.
- 5:08And so the point of the article again was just to talk about some
- 5:12of the ideas that are coming out.
- 5:14Not to say that we've got a fully front loaded theory of storytelling
- 5:17yet, we're working on it.
- 5:19Matt Abrahams: I think as we both agreed, this is really fascinating,
- 5:22that there are stories that have been told with relatively high fidelity.
- 5:26That is, they have maintained their essential ideas for a long, long time,
- 5:31millennia, and at the same time that there are some differences around
- 5:36how stories are told across cultures.
- 5:38But fundamentally, everybody tells stories and there's some theories about it.
- 5:43As you said, one is biological and evolutionary.
- 5:46Where is the food, where do we go?
- 5:49And then there's the cohesive nature where we actually connect
- 5:53better, share empathy through story.
- 5:55And as you mentioned, this all happened way before we had written word.
- 5:59And it's fundamental.
- 6:01Laura Spinney: You're absolutely right.
- 6:01And so some of the findings about how very stable certain types of stories
- 6:06are, are feeding into this other idea about what stories do for us.
- 6:09So like why are those particular stories stable over so long?
- 6:12Whereas these ones change faster.
- 6:15Matt Abrahams: Given that you've spent some time studying stories and you do
- 6:17very well writing your own stories, what do you find makes for a good story?
- 6:22Are there certain key elements or aspects that make for good story?
- 6:26Laura Spinney: Definitely.
- 6:27This kind of comparative approach that I referred to is allowing
- 6:30people to draw out the kind of more universal structures from stories
- 6:34that do repeat across space and time.
- 6:36They have this capacity to revive what eyewitnesses might have
- 6:40seen, put us in the places as if we are there at the action.
- 6:43And, and some of the ways that, some of the tricks they have
- 6:46to do that are, for example, to violate some of our expectations.
- 6:50So if you want to make people's hearts beat a bit faster and them to remember
- 6:54things, you need to give them a little bit of a shock, a tiny little surprise,
- 6:58not too much because then they'll shut down, but a little bit of a violation.
- 7:02That's one theory, for example, about why we love things like ghost
- 7:05stories, because ghosts are things that most people don't encounter.
- 7:09They violate our expectations of what you might meet in your daily
- 7:12round, but also a story intrigues and obviously a good story entertains.
- 7:17So one of the important theses for why we tell stories is that they have this
- 7:23appeal that draws us into the situation in the first place where we're gonna
- 7:26sit down with other people and listen.
- 7:28They have to be entertaining.
- 7:29And the hero's journey is one very common example of that.
- 7:33That would be Luke Skywalker, Spider-Man, Harry Potter, you know, the genial
- 7:38protagonist who comes up against a major obstacle, clears the obstacle.
- 7:43And this triumph over adversity inspires feelings of joy
- 7:48and empathy in the listener.
- 7:50So it's a fairly basic plot line that has endured through the ages and is
- 7:55apparently highly entertaining to us.
- 7:57Matt Abrahams: So it sounds like a few things that really make for a good
- 8:01story, and that is that there is some kind of violation of expectations.
- 8:06Our brains are certainly wired for things that are novel, and so a story
- 8:11can violate expectations and draw us in.
- 8:13I heard you, although not name it, but really describe it, this notion
- 8:17of building curiosity pulls us in.
- 8:20The entertainment value and the empathy.
- 8:23So if you're trying to craft a story that can really draw people in, I think using
- 8:27any or all of those novelty, curiosity, entertaining empathy, can really help.
- 8:32And you shared with us one of the most predominant
- 8:35structures, the hero's journey.
- 8:37Story falls into structures and one way is to use the hero's journey.
- 8:41There are others.
- 8:42And I think that's really important because if we're going to try to leverage
- 8:45storytelling for whatever goal we're trying to have, thinking about what we
- 8:49can do to make it relevant, engaging, interesting, is really important and
- 8:54I appreciate you delineating those.
- 8:56Laura Spinney: So you could think about sort of entertaining
- 8:58vehicle into which you load your ecologically important information,
- 9:02the message you wanna get across.
- 9:04Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 9:05And that was very helpful for our species for a long time, and still probably today.
- 9:10I'd like to turn our attention to your latest book, Proto, which dives deep
- 9:14into language and looks at the origins of the Proto-Indo-European language.
- 9:18That's a mouthful to say.
- 9:20Why is studying the origins and evolution of language important and what
- 9:25impact can the learnings we have from that affect how we communicate today?
- 9:29Laura Spinney: Great question.
- 9:30I think first of all, in the case of the language family that I'm talking
- 9:34about, Indo-European, the world's largest language family today,
- 9:36spoken by nearly half of humanity, that family was born before writing.
- 9:41And studying it does a number of things for us.
- 9:44First of all, it reveals the very deep connections, cultural, psychological,
- 9:51between groups of people who we would not necessarily connect on those levels.
- 9:56So the Ind0-European language family is so-called because even
- 9:59in the ancient world, it was spoken from Ireland in the West to the
- 10:03Indian subcontinent in the East.
- 10:04In fact, actually further afield because there was one branch of it
- 10:07that was spoken in what is now China.
- 10:09Uh, from 1492, the age of exploration on it went, moved onto the other continents.
- 10:14So it's huge.
- 10:15And yet when you look down into the deepest layers of these languages
- 10:19and the stories that people have been telling in those languages for five
- 10:22thousand years or more, the same tropes repeating, words and units of stories,
- 10:27things we've just been talking about.
- 10:29And for example, an obvious example is a Dragon Slayer stories.
- 10:33Across the Indo-European world we tell that story, which is
- 10:36very old, in similar ways with similar themes and similar words.
- 10:40There are levels in which we are really connected, but there's another
- 10:43really important function that this kind of research does for us.
- 10:46I said that the family predates writing, but language in a way is an
- 10:51archive of its own journey because languages are ceaselessly changing.
- 10:54They are, language is, and this is how we started the conversation, it's
- 10:58considered humanity's oldest tool.
- 11:00And so in order for it to be a useful tool, it has to adapt.
- 11:03It's the way that we function in our environment's, one of the ways
- 11:06that we adapt to our environment.
- 11:08And so it's constantly changing.
- 11:10And if you can extrapolate back and understand ancestry of our modern
- 11:14languages and how they've evolved over time, and much of that information is
- 11:18locked into them, then you can tell a lot about what was happening in the past,
- 11:22even before historical records began.
- 11:25Matt Abrahams: Language as a tool, not just to communicate what we need to
- 11:29communicate, as we do through stories, but language as a tool to better understand
- 11:34humans and our evolution is really cool.
- 11:37I want to take a step back because maybe some of our listeners
- 11:41aren't familiar with this, but you talked about language families.
- 11:43Can you just give an overview of what that means and perhaps some
- 11:47examples of other language families?
- 11:50Laura Spinney: Yes.
- 11:50Okay.
- 11:51Just to give the kind of basic concept, a language is spoken in a place.
- 11:55The people who speak it, their population, imagine grows.
- 11:59They spread out over space.
- 12:01The language divides into dialects.
- 12:03We see that happening all the time.
- 12:04And then if the circumstances allow or promote, those dialects can
- 12:09become languages in their own right.
- 12:11Become even more separated.
- 12:12And so you can imagine one ancestral language essentially diverging through
- 12:17branches to become many generations and a large number of offspring.
- 12:21That's what we think happened from, for example, the Indo-European family, that
- 12:24it was originally just a small cluster of dialects spoken by a group of people.
- 12:29Probably on the Eurasian Steppe about five thousand years ago as they moved
- 12:32out, as their descendants moved out, their languages diverged with them.
- 12:36There has to be a caveat there 'cause it's not exactly like human families or
- 12:39biological families because languages can change both vertically by dissent,
- 12:43but they can also change through horizontal transmission, through loans,
- 12:47lending to each other and contact.
- 12:49So both those mechanisms are very important in shaping language evolution.
- 12:53And when you see, for example, in my book, a family tree of languages,
- 12:57that's really only part of the story.
- 12:59It's kind of a simplification of the truth because in the white space
- 13:02between the nice crisp branches are all the effects of contact.
- 13:05So today it's estimated there are about a hundred and forty language
- 13:09families in the world, but most of us speak the top five of those.
- 13:12So it's very unevenly distributed.
- 13:14And the two behemoths, if you like, are Indo-European and Sino-Tibetan.
- 13:19The major representative of Indo-European is English.
- 13:21The language we are now speaking in, and the major representative
- 13:23of Sino-Tibetan is Mandarin.
- 13:26Mandarin has more native speakers than English, but Indo-European
- 13:30as a whole family has more native speakers than Sino-Tibetan.
- 13:32So Indo-European is, whether you measure it by the number of speakers
- 13:35or geographical spread, today the largest language family on earth.
- 13:39Matt Abrahams: Thank you for that explication, it's very helpful and
- 13:42I am fascinated by that transmission horizontally that you talked about.
- 13:47We see that all the time.
- 13:48So in English, we use words that, for example, came from French,
- 13:51even though that's the same family.
- 13:53The notion is that that we co-opt and leverage words.
- 13:57And what I find fascinating, and I don't mean to take us on a tangent, is that
- 14:00in some languages that are words that we just don't have easily explained
- 14:05or correlates to in other languages.
- 14:07So we borrow these concepts.
- 14:09And I find that really fascinating that if you have a term for it, you can have
- 14:13a shared meaning for an experience or an idea, but if you don't have a term for
- 14:18it, in some ways we're limited in how we envision and see what the world is like.
- 14:22And that to me is a really fascinating conundrum and really interesting
- 14:25because it means we have to rely a lot on our communication skills to
- 14:29try to build a shared mental model for whatever it is we're discussing.
- 14:33Laura Spinney: And by the way, both the vertical and the horizontal processes
- 14:37can be really informative about history.
- 14:39So if I compare what the same word across a number of Indo-European languages,
- 14:43I find that it has varied according to a sort of predictable set of rules.
- 14:47And so I can say that those languages are related, they form part of
- 14:50the same family, but I can also trace loans through languages and
- 14:55piece together history that way.
- 14:57And I'll give you one very concrete example of where that happened,
- 14:59fascinatingly, if you ask me.
- 15:01So the Romani people, who used to be called, and we don't use
- 15:05this term anymore because it's considered pejorative, gypsies.
- 15:07The word gypsy came from Egypt because there was a time when
- 15:10we thought they came from Egypt.
- 15:11They do not come from Egypt.
- 15:12They originally came from the south of India.
- 15:15And part of the piecing together of the Romani people's backstory was
- 15:19done with the help of lone words.
- 15:21So you could trace their, basically, it took them a thousand years to get from
- 15:25India to the eastern fringes of Europe.
- 15:27They passed through Persia, what is now mainly Iran.
- 15:30And there they picked up some Persian words.
- 15:32I think donkey was one of them, uh, honey, pear, as in the fruit.
- 15:37But they didn't pick up any Arab words so that we know they went through
- 15:40Persia before the Muslim conquests.
- 15:43So in this way you can use loan words as a sort of way of piecing together,
- 15:48reconstructing the history of peoples.
- 15:50Matt Abrahams: So language in essence, becomes the clues that we use to solve
- 15:54some of these mysteries about humanity.
- 15:56How neat that this is one of the fundamental investigation
- 16:00stories for being human.
- 16:03Before we end, I like to ask three questions of all my guests.
- 16:06One I create just for you, and the other two are similar across all of the guests.
- 16:10So, are you up for answering?
- 16:11Laura Spinney: Absolutely.
- 16:12Matt Abrahams: Question number one, given all the work that you do on a
- 16:14wide variety of topics, what advice would you give someone who wishes
- 16:19to improve their communication?
- 16:21Laura Spinney: So the biggest challenge is to make them care.
- 16:24And I suppose it's pretty simple a recipe really.
- 16:27Maybe imagine trying to tell a story to somebody you know, your
- 16:30friend in the pub where there are competing demands on their attention.
- 16:35There's a TV screen with a football match on it, or how are you gonna
- 16:38draw them in and how are you gonna get the information across to them
- 16:41and how are you gonna make them care, again, the most important thing.
- 16:43'Cause you have to engage their attention before you can do anything else.
- 16:47Matt Abrahams: Very well said.
- 16:48Yeah, it's all about attention and as you suggested, making it really relevant
- 16:52and salient is the place to start.
- 16:54But you do that, not by thinking about what it means for me, the writer, the
- 16:58communicator, but what does it mean for the people that I'm communicating to?
- 17:00And thank you for that.
- 17:02Question number two, I'll be curious to get your answer to this.
- 17:04Who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 17:07Laura Spinney: People I admire are people who raise us up.
- 17:10Give us a sense of grandeur, give us a sense of why this matters, how this
- 17:14story connects you to the bigger why.
- 17:16Why it's important to push against the big, enormous, black enveloping pillow
- 17:20of uncertainty in which we all live.
- 17:22I'm going to name a French journalist who I admire very greatly, although she's
- 17:25not a science writer at all, Florence Aubenas, who is a very important reporter
- 17:30at the newspaper, and she's written some amazing books where very often
- 17:35she goes underground for a long period of time and describes her experiences.
- 17:38Matt Abrahams: It sounds to me what's important to you, and communicators
- 17:41that you admire, is that they can engage, they can intrigue, they can
- 17:44entertain, and they can connect to something bigger, and that's important.
- 17:47So final question for you.
- 17:49What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 17:54Laura Spinney: I think I said it in other answers to others of your
- 17:57questions, but grab the attention, draw people in intrigue, lift.
- 18:03Give them the sense of that grandeur that, as I think of it, pushing against
- 18:06that great big pillow of uncertainty that surrounds us, and resolve whatever
- 18:11question you're asking, even if you're not giving the answer to the question
- 18:14so much as explaining why it's important and why the question needs to be asked.
- 18:19So it goes back to the beginning of what we were talking about, the vehicle of
- 18:22entertainment with the message inside it.
- 18:25But you have to also make sure your vehicle gets to the destination.
- 18:28Matt Abrahams: I like the analogy there to help us understand, but
- 18:31this notion of attention, lift, and resolution I think are really powerful.
- 18:36And we've heard some of that before, but this notion of lift, bringing
- 18:39people to something bigger, helping them understand the uncertainties of their
- 18:42worlds, I think is really powerful.
- 18:45Laura, you've done a fantastic job of introducing us to some really
- 18:49insightful and interesting ideas.
- 18:52The notion and power of language in our lives and understanding its evolution
- 18:56is really helpful, and I appreciate you taking the time to make us all
- 19:00better communicators, and please keep writing the interesting, intriguing,
- 19:04and uplifting articles that you do.
- 19:05Thank you.
- 19:06Laura Spinney: Thank you very much for some great questions
- 19:08and a great conversation.
- 19:11Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 19:14Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 19:16To learn more about storytelling, please listen to episode 168 with Matthew Dicks,
- 19:21and dive deeper into language by listening to episode 91 with Valerie Fridland.
- 19:26This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 19:32Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 19:34With thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 19:36Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 19:39Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 19:42Also follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 19:45And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 19:49learning content, and our newsletters.
- 19:51Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 19:55Ask Matt Anythings, and much more at fastersmarter.io/premium.