Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline For Monday, September 11, 2023
Transcript
- 0:22Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network. Decision
- 0:27you are surrounded were in the list? Were which a million Virginity welcome her
- 0:34radio turned on. From the studios of w VRC Media and the Metro News
- 0:39Radio Network, the voice of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in
- 0:45West Virginia. This this he is Metro News Talk Live with Hobby Kirchick Activated
- 0:53switch network control from Charles kun stand by you, Hoppy. You're on Metro
- 1:00News. Talk Line with Hoppy Kirchiville is brought to you by in COVID Insurance,
- 1:03encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting coovid
- 1:07dot com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on Metro
- 1:11News all across the great state of West Virginia. Broadcasting from the Encove Insurance
- 1:15Studios in the Dale Miller Building. Hoppy Kirchiville with you, Joe Nelson's eye
- 1:21producer Luke Rowsy with the video stream you can watch at wv Metronews dot com.
- 1:26Of course, today the anniversary of nine to eleven. We will get
- 1:29to that in just a little bit, but first up this morning, a
- 1:33majority of the faculty who participated in a faculty assembly at w VU last week
- 1:38voted in support of a resolution expressing no confidence and President Gordon Gee. The
- 1:45motion past seven ninety seven four one hundred against eight votes were invalid. The
- 1:49vote reflects the anger and frustration stemming from the university administration's proposed cuts and academic
- 1:56programs, the elimination of as many as one hundred sixty nine faculty positions to
- 2:00try to offset a forty five million dollar budget deficit. Faculty members argue that
- 2:06GI missed the dramatic enrollment decline while simultaneously simultaneously overspending. They also continue administration
- 2:13has not been adequately transparent about the process. G has vigorously defended the process
- 2:17to right size the university by shifting resources away from academic programs with declining enrollment
- 2:23to protect majors that are attracting more students. Joining us on Metro News talk
- 2:28line WWU Board of Governor's Chair Tanya Willis Miller and former board chair Tom Jones,
- 2:34Good morning to you both, Thanks for coming on, Thank you both.
- 2:37Good morning, Hapy, thanks for having us. Good morning Tom.
- 2:42Let me start with you. I went back to a March meeting on the
- 2:45Board of Governors where you said the foggling You said, I would encourage us
- 2:52board the university to look at every administrative and academic program for ways to improve
- 2:57and advance our university. Do not be timid in making changes that may be
- 3:01overdue in making. So was this a directive from the board with you as
- 3:07chair at that time, to make the kinds of changes that are taking place,
- 3:10or was this reflective of changes that WVU wanted to make that the board
- 3:15was endorsing. Was it one or the other or a bit of both.
- 3:20It was a bit of both, but clearly the board was very strongly and
- 3:23unanimously supportive of doing an in depth study and to make changes strategically to improve
- 3:30the university. Why. Well, we did have a budget shortfall projected.
- 3:38Now there's a big difference between a budget shortfall and a budget crisis. We
- 3:43had a budget shortfall, and every organization has finite resources, and we have
- 3:47to prioritize as to where we're going to spend those resources. And we could
- 3:51have cut across the board easily, that would have been the easy thing to
- 3:55do, but instead we decided to embark upon as strategic restructuring based on what
- 4:00programs were growing in which we're declining, what programs were relevant in today's job
- 4:05market, Is a number of faculty appropriate to the number of students, and
- 4:10what programs could grow if provided more resources. All of this was based on
- 4:14data, and the process is really designed to reposition the university and allocate resources
- 4:18to make it even more successful. Time in your opinion, is this process
- 4:24going according to what you believe the board once done, Yes, it is,
- 4:30and we set up the process, approved the process in advance where recommendations
- 4:35would initially be made, people would have the opportunity to appeal those decisions,
- 4:41and I think the appeal process has worked very well and a number of the
- 4:44recommendations have been changed. Let me go to Tanya Willis Miller, who is
- 4:48the current chair of the Board of Governors. Tanya, thanks for joining us.
- 4:51You issued a statement. It literally was just a very short time after
- 4:56the Faculty Assembly had the no confidence vote. You said the following. The
- 5:00Board of Governors unequivocally supports the leadership of President Gee and the strategic repositioning of
- 5:05WWU and rejects the multiple examples of misinformation that inform these resolutions. You said,
- 5:14the university's transforming to better reflect the needs of today. We must continue
- 5:17to act boldly. President Gee has shown time and again he's not afraid to
- 5:21do the difficult work required. So, in your opinion, what is the
- 5:26misinformation that is that you believe is out there by those who've been critical of
- 5:31these moves that the university's making. I think some of the numbers that have
- 5:39been reflected, for instance, with respect to the World Language is program,
- 5:46there are I'm trying to if the numbers exact numbers for you, I can
- 5:56do that. There are twenty two students and primary majors, so there was
- 6:01concern that we weren't counting double majors. If you count the double majors,
- 6:08it takes it up to seventy three and there are twenty three faculty. There
- 6:14was an assertion that there is a eight hundred thousand dollars surplus in world languages,
- 6:23and the eight hundred thousand dollars is a result of a requirement that students
- 6:31take a foreign language as opposed to the actual majoring or even minoring in foreign
- 6:42languages. And more importantly, this is not an attack at all on the
- 6:48humanities or for world languages or any of the humanities. A liberal arts education
- 6:59entail the studies of humanities, science and mathematics, and social services. And
- 7:06after the transformation, if one looks at the recommendations, and again we have
- 7:15not yet voted on those, we will do that on Friday, But if
- 7:17you look at the recommendations afterwards, WVU will still offer international studies mathematics,
- 7:27philosophy, physics, political science, psychology, social work, anthropology, criminology,
- 7:31sociology, history, English, communications, chemistry, biology. So there
- 7:41is still going to be a rigorous opportunity for our students to engage in the
- 7:46intellectual discourse that is associated with a liberal arts education. Tony Willis Miller's wins
- 7:55let me let me jump in here. Tony Willis Miller, who's the current
- 7:57chair of the w Board of Governors. Tom Joe is the previous chair of
- 8:00the Board of Governors. On these changes at w VU, Tanya, I
- 8:03want to ask you this, and I'm going to go to Tom on this,
- 8:05and that is one of the criticisms is that Gordon Gey his administration WV
- 8:11leadership, and I guess that includes the Board of Governors two should have seen
- 8:16this sooner, should have anticipated the decline in enrollment and therefore maybe had a
- 8:22softer landing than what's happening now, and that is having to make dramatic cuts.
- 8:26Did WVU and or the Board of Governors missed the signs, tany,
- 8:31I'll start with you and go to Tom. We actually have been planning on
- 8:37what we knew was coming, based on declining college enrollment rates, based on
- 8:45the what is referred to as the demographic clip, based on a reduced job
- 8:54high holding in high regard of higher education. We actually started planning for those
- 9:01things pre pandemic. The planning was installed during the pandemic, but then we
- 9:09started again in twenty twenty one with the academic transformation. Back as far as
- 9:16two thousand and sixteen, we started with administrative type reductions and consolidations and efficiencies
- 9:26to keep our budget in line. So we were a little also guarded by
- 9:35the number of students who did not return, called the Great Dropout after the
- 9:39pandemic. But with respect to the overall headwinds that higher education has been facing,
- 9:48I think the answer to that is no. Let me go to Tom
- 9:50Jones on that. So Tom again, as Tonio said, as far back
- 9:54as twenty sixteen, there were signs that the demographic cliff but he knew twenty
- 10:00sixteen about the pandemic. But certainly Gordon Gey had made bold predictions about enrollment
- 10:03being at forty thousand. So your analysis to w VU and with the Board
- 10:09of Governors miss signs that contributed to the kinds of changes that are being made.
- 10:16Now. You know, it's easy to look back and say, would
- 10:22you have done things differently? I will tell you that we did not miss
- 10:24the signs completely. We certainly have. We started reducing expenditures with classified staff
- 10:31and administration over the last five years, and those cuts were significant. I
- 10:37think they totaled twenty one million dollars. And it came to a point where
- 10:43it wasn't about and part of one emphasized, this is not just about budget
- 10:46cuts. We could absolutely have just cut across the board. It's really a
- 10:50strategic repositioning and whether it was done a little bit of the time or all
- 10:56at once, it would have come out to the same endpoint, Tom,
- 11:00what is the vote by the faculty? And granted, those who are those
- 11:05who object to what is going on or angry with Gordon Guy, those are
- 11:09the individuals who are more motivated to show up at the faculty assembly. I
- 11:13think that contributed to that gathering last week. But that's a pretty significant vote,
- 11:16almost eight hundred to whatever it was, one hundred to one hundred for
- 11:22the lack of confidence. Do you maintain complete confidence in Gordon Guy and this
- 11:30leadership team today? I do, And I would just point out, although
- 11:35certainly eight hundred votes is significant, that's out of twenty eight hundred faculty,
- 11:39a majority of the faculty did not participate in vote. Only nine hundred took
- 11:43the time to vote, and so it's not a majority. But you know,
- 11:48we certainly heard the message, we appreciate the message, we value their
- 11:52input, but ultimately, the Board of Governors is responsible for making the decisions
- 11:58in the best interests of the university, this sort of fituciary responsibility. We
- 12:03absolutely maintain faith in Gordon g or he wouldn't have extended his contract for a
- 12:07year. I tell you Willis Miller. Do you stand with the Tim Jones
- 12:11on that and is there any wavering in your opinion on the Board of governor
- 12:16has given that vote last week or do you all remain committed to making these
- 12:20changes or supporting the changes that the Gay administration is making, Tanya, I
- 12:26do remain committed with respect to the Board of Governors as a whole. Obviously,
- 12:31we are going to have public opinion expressed on Thursday and a presentation with
- 12:37respect to the final recommendations on Friday, so I don't want to presume what
- 12:45that vote will be ahead of time. But I have not received any requests
- 12:50for instance, or a reconsideration of Gordon's extended contract, and that will not
- 12:58be taken up. It's not on the agenda. And as far as the
- 13:03process itself, the Board approved the process, and I think the process worked
- 13:11as it was supposed to, as evidenced by the appeals which, while we
- 13:16haven't yet received a summary shoot, we received the decisions on each of the
- 13:22appeals and the appeals process appeared very thoughtful and Sorry, finally, Tom,
- 13:31let me go to you. Do you believe that that obviously you all support
- 13:35these support these changes. But again, and you know, a number of
- 13:39faculties showed up and expressed their displeasure. So these cuts are going to be
- 13:43made. I mean, these changes are I would predict the Board of Governors
- 13:46is going to sign off on this. So these changes are going to be
- 13:48made by the way, I'm as soon they're going to be made whether Gordon
- 13:50Gey's there or not, although you anticipate he would, he would be there.
- 13:54So do you believe that this is, as Gordon Geese said, a
- 13:56right sizing of the university? But in doing so, will you have a
- 14:01fourth of the faculty that will be unhappy and discontent discontented with the state of
- 14:07affairs. I think you summarized it well. I think you know, we
- 14:13have a great empathy for people that are being affected. It affects their lives
- 14:16and their families, and we understand that and we've tried to work through that
- 14:20with them to help them through this process. But they've had the opportunity for
- 14:24input. The administration regularly meets with the faculty Senate and listens to them.
- 14:30We have had campus wide conversations where they've had the opportunity for input. We've
- 14:35had a hotline where they can call in with questions or text questions, and
- 14:39they have The faculty elects two of their representatives to the Board of Governors that
- 14:43provides input to the full board. And they certainly have been at least to
- 14:48date supportive of the process. Telling you anything you want to add before we
- 14:54wrap up any point you want to make now. I do appreciate to the
- 15:00a tunity. I think it is important to note we are not in a
- 15:03financial crisis. We would be doing transformation and a review of our academic programs
- 15:11regardless of our budget deficits. We actually started before the forty five million dollar
- 15:16budget deficits. It's what you do to make sure that your strong university remains
- 15:24strong. WV Board of Governor's Chair Tanya Willis Miller and former board chair Tom
- 15:30Jones, thank you both for coming on. I appreciate it. Thanks me
- 15:33all right, thank you. Talkline continues. We'll be right back. So
- 15:37joint pain or muscle injuries holding you back. Trust the experts at CMC Orthopedics
- 15:41and CMC Orthopedic Trauma for personalized treatment options tailored to your needs. CMC offers
- 15:48comprehensive orthopedic treatment for all types of pain and injuries. Our specialists provide tailored
- 15:54options from diagnosis to rehab with state of the art facilities for top quality care.
- 15:58Visits SEMC dot org slash Orthopedics to learn more. Metro News talk Line
- 16:15with Hobby Kirchiblas brought to you by in COVID Insurance encircling you with coverage to
- 16:19protect what you care about most. Visitingcovid dot com to learn more talk line
- 16:25from the Cove Insurance Studios. A man who was wanted for crimes in two
- 16:29states, including an Ohio murder, was killed early Sunday morning after an overnight
- 16:33hostage standoff at a Wayne County, West Virginia gas station. Chris Lawrence as
- 16:36the story. He joins us from the Metro News News and Chris, what
- 16:38happened here? Good morning, Hobby. This apparently started on Saturday when this
- 16:44individual, fifty four year old David Maynard from Ironton, Ohio, gave police
- 16:48the slip and he was wanted for a murder in Ohio, and he got
- 16:52away and they continued looking for him. He was also Eventually they added to
- 16:57his list of crimes a carjacking and a kidnapping and several other crimes that occurred
- 17:03during his flight in neighboring Kentucky. Apparently Saturday afternoon Saturday evening, there was
- 17:10some information developed by police in Canova and the West Virginia State Police that he
- 17:15might be in that area, and they spent several hours on Saturday afternoon and
- 17:18evening searching for him without any luck, so they called off the search.
- 17:22One state trooper who had wrapped up his work there, was on his way
- 17:26home and stopped at the Speedway Convenience store in Cerrito and as he was going
- 17:32into the store, even before he got in, he recognized Maynard standing behind
- 17:37the counter with the clerk. Unfortunately, Maynard saw him coming to and pointed
- 17:40a pistol at him. That led to a full on response by all area
- 17:45law enforcement, and in the process, Maynard took three hostages, the clerk
- 17:49along with two customers who were inside the store. The State Police Special Response
- 17:55team responded along with a hostage negotiation team. They were success full negotiating through
- 18:00the night and got two of the hostages released unharmed, and that left the
- 18:04one who I think they agreed that they would provide a blanket, that that
- 18:08particular hostage wanted a blanket, so they placed it in front of the door
- 18:11of the Speedway. From what I understand from the State Police, as Maynard
- 18:17came to retrieve that blanket, they took the opportunity and rushed him. In
- 18:21the process of that happening, gunfire was apparently exchanged and Maynard ended up being
- 18:25fatally wounded. The hostage that he had inside was not injured, and no
- 18:29law enforcement was injured as well, but he died of his injuries at Cavil
- 18:33Huntington Hospital. Terrifying time for those hostages. My good, no, no
- 18:36doubt about it. Yeah, yeah, all right, Chris. Thanks.
- 18:37Story posted at WV metro news dot com. Tech toppy. Aren't we kind
- 18:41of making the ACC's point for them? We're not really about educating people.
- 18:48Were about a job placement service as a college. The two majors that caught
- 18:52my eye were Masters in Doctoral in Math and Foreign Languages in Global Society.
- 18:57And with all the STEM promotion, we really need these. Well a couple
- 19:03of points. One is you still got three hundred majors. You're still gonna
- 19:06have three hundred plus majors. You're still gonna have a lot of liberal arts
- 19:10majors and degree opportunities, you know. The second thing is that a lot
- 19:15of this is based on enrollment, and the enrollment for World Languages as as
- 19:22a major as a major has been declining, and in I don't know about
- 19:26the doctrine and math, I'm not sure about that, but I think that
- 19:30Again, the cuts are directly associated with where there have been declined in enrollment.
- 19:37So that's that again, is it's disappointing for those in that field or
- 19:41those who want to study in that field. But there's some there are real
- 19:45economic realities here of you have a forty two million dollar deficit and you've cut
- 19:53staff and now you're down to people. Now you're down people, and there
- 20:00is a directive from the Board of Governors to right size. So I think
- 20:03that's what's going on here. Let's see, I'll be future students need to
- 20:11know what programs are solid cut programs students currently are midway completing. Is just
- 20:18it's just wrong. I'm not sure how they how they're handling that. For
- 20:22people who are have majors in programs that are being eliminated, I'm not sure
- 20:26what. I'm not sure how that's been handled. Off to check on that,
- 20:30But the cuts aren't secret. In fact, one of the reasons that
- 20:33this has become such a big national story in the education on the in the
- 20:37education field, inside higher it's been writing about it, national organizations have been
- 20:42writing about it is that it's been pretty forthright. I mean, it's been
- 20:47pretty out there what's being done. All right, We're gonna take a break
- 20:52and come back. When we come back, another perspective, We're going to
- 20:55talk with a WWU student who is part of the movement that has been enviously
- 21:00objecting to the changes that are being made, to the cuts are being made.
- 21:03That's coming up next. This is talk Line on Metro News. Metro
- 21:06News is the voice of West Virginia. It's then thirty. Let's get a
- 21:11news update. Checking with the Metro News radio network. Find him what's happening
- 21:14statewide this hour, all across the great state of West Virginia. Metro News
- 21:29talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling
- 21:33you with coverage to protect what do you care about most? Visitingcovid dot com
- 21:37to learn more. Talk Line from me and COVA Insurance Studios, jack pots
- 21:41and the migians here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire?
- 21:44Getting the powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays, the Mega Millions drawings
- 21:48on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big winner? Play today?
- 21:52The powerball jackpot is five hundred twenty two million dollars Mega Megas Jackpot one
- 21:56hundred and forty one million dollars. Please welcome former Charleston merri Anny Jones.
- 22:00Cony, Danny, how are you? I'm being fine off are you well?
- 22:04Where were you twenty two years ago? Right about now? I was
- 22:10on my second day working for Ocean Craigo and I was I had a six
- 22:15month gig with him, involved with franchising and and working for tutors. And
- 22:23it was it was the second day and his main secretary came walking through.
- 22:32I was in the kind of the conference room, and she said, they
- 22:37fit the Trade Center built the Trade Center building and the countries at war,
- 22:41and I thought, what you know, so it's kind of hard to believe,
- 22:48really it really is. And you know, Danny, I was.
- 22:52I wrote about it today And also I mean I was around, was working,
- 22:56I was on the job, and then it happened and we went to
- 22:59Lives coverage for several days. But I was this morning when I had the
- 23:03coverage on and they were reshowing a lot of the video, which I think
- 23:07is absolutely essential. I think it absolutely needs to be shown every year.
- 23:10What happened. It was really really hard to watch. I mean, just
- 23:14reopens those wounds from twenty two years ago, and it was just it was
- 23:18painful to watch. Which it should be, which it should be in our
- 23:22country unfortunately. Yeah, I mean only speak for myself to here, but
- 23:29our country is in a very dark place. And I don't know if you
- 23:34feel like that or anybody else feels like that, but it really does.
- 23:38And I'm it's just hard, you know, to to to see what's happening.
- 23:45And of course I'm an older person now and I was fifty, I
- 23:48was fifty, I was just I was fifty one. Then now I just
- 23:53turned fifty one and now I'm seventy three. It's just it's just hard,
- 23:57you know. Do you agree about the country, Yeah, yeah, and
- 24:03I i am. I've said there's many times I am too much, maybe
- 24:07a prisoner of the moment, And yeah, it feels it feels dark on
- 24:12one level. And that level is and it was the Metro News West Virginia
- 24:15pool last week that found that our faith in institutions across the board, whether
- 24:22it's government, elections, education, even to some degree, the military,
- 24:29certainly the media, it's it's just at all time lows and when we lose
- 24:34faith in institutions, it feels like things start to unravel, because those are
- 24:41the things, the faith in these institutions. And I'm not saying we should
- 24:48never question him, obviously we should, but if we completely lose faith in
- 24:52these institutions, it really it feels like that our society becomes threadbare. And
- 24:59that what concerns me. And now you have this hyper injection of the twenty
- 25:04twenty four election. You have two unpopular candidates. Everybody is at each other's
- 25:11throat in these campaigns. Yeah, I'll go with dark, I'll go And
- 25:15in some respects, in other respects, people go out their business every day,
- 25:18they do good things for each other, They take care of each other
- 25:22in their community, they take care of their families. So in that respect,
- 25:25in a micro way, I think things are fine or very good or
- 25:27very strong. But in the macro it feels very threadbare. Now you go
- 25:33on the tangible stuff, I mean like, I don't know how normal people
- 25:40are able to shop at the grocery store. I mean I look at the
- 25:44prices and some stuff, and then the UAW workers are getting ready to go
- 25:51out on strike, and I mean I know a guy that just paid one
- 25:55hundred and twenty five thousands for a new Catallac Escalade. And I wonder how
- 26:03far is that going to go up. Who's going to be buying these cars?
- 26:07I mean, that's just and that's not a political statement. I just
- 26:11because I have never voted for either the two major candidates since two thousand sixteen.
- 26:18And I'm not out to pick a political fight with anybody. But but
- 26:23if you saw Biden in Vietnam, I mean it was pretty pitiful. Well
- 26:27what did you take away from that? Oh, he's he's just, he's
- 26:32not with it, hoppy, he's just And David axel Rod was on Meet
- 26:37the Press yesterday, and you know, these leaders and these political star makers
- 26:47today, I'll just mentioned the Democrats are saying they're dancing around it, but
- 26:52this is not going to work. President Biden is not with it. And
- 26:56if you vote for him, you're voting for Kamala Harris. But of course,
- 27:02if President of Trump gets nominated and you vote for him, you're voting
- 27:04for Kamala Harris. Because unless it's a three way race, President Trump cannot
- 27:10win a national election. Why that's Giden because he can't get he never has
- 27:15been able to. He didn't get it with Hillary, and he got covered
- 27:19by by President of Biden by seven over seven seven almost eight million votes.
- 27:26And so Biden, there's no way he finishes. I'm wondered if he's going
- 27:33to finish this term. And so I made a whole lot of money in
- 27:41the building that I used to work in downtown Betton on the twenty twenty election
- 27:48with some some of your very good friends, because I've been on Biden and
- 27:52they sure Trump is gonna win. He was never gonna win, and he
- 27:55won't win this time either. And that's my own personal perspective. Well,
- 27:59I'm gonna I'm gonna talk with Michael Tamaski next hour because he's a loyal Democrat.
- 28:04He's a progressive, but he's not a far left progressive. He's just
- 28:08a liberal. He's just a liberal guy, but he's not totally off at
- 28:12the far end of the counter. But Michael Tamaski, Michael Tamaski's from Morgantown.
- 28:18He's the editor of the New Republic. He's authored a number of books,
- 28:21He's been on this program a number of times. Very very Oh my
- 28:23god. But but look there, you can you can tell you can just
- 28:30feel it that there is this increasing concern that was always there and now it's
- 28:34starting to bubble to the surface of the concerns about Biden. I mean,
- 28:38now it's almost every time that there's a public appearance, there's something or some
- 28:45things that cause people to question. And I'm not talking about the far right.
- 28:48I'm talking about people. I'm talking about the left. I'm talking about
- 28:52the middle Americans who are trying to figure out what to do, who look
- 28:56at that and go, holy cow, he's not He is struggle. He
- 29:00is struggling mightily and saying something strange things and sometimes not making sense, and
- 29:06things like I don't know about you, but I'm going to bed. I
- 29:08don't blame him from wanting to go to bed because of the dramatic timeshift,
- 29:11but still, that's not the kind of thing you say when people are questioning
- 29:15your alacrity. He's not up to the job. But he's the only parts
- 29:23the people across the stage at the debate, the only I mean he I
- 29:29think any one of those people could beat President the President. Trump can't.
- 29:33He'll never get to fifty percent. He'll get less than he got last time.
- 29:37And unless it's a three way race, if there's a three way race
- 29:42and somehow no labels or somebody gets ten percent, then a miracle, I
- 29:48mean, you know, from the Trump perspective, a miracle might happen,
- 29:52but I'm not seeing it. And I think it's sad that the choice has
- 29:56come down to those two people. But the Republican Party, Hoppy that I
- 30:00registered to vote for the vote for Richard Nixon, that's not the same party
- 30:04now and it had minces twenty twelve. It's the party of Donald Trump,
- 30:12and those older guys like me just need to get used to that because that's
- 30:18what it is. And I don't know how many more races they're gonna lose.
- 30:22You know, they're getting ready to throw McCarthy out of the speaker.
- 30:26These are people that they think Mitch McConnell's the enemy. So it's I just
- 30:33think the whole thing's very, very dark and a little bit depressing. But
- 30:37yeah, I still by my health. So all right. Former charlesby Danny
- 30:42Jones. Thanks Danny, good to talk to you, Thanks Hobby, thanks
- 30:45for having me on take Care Talk on continues. We'll do one. It's
- 31:03acline from me in Colvi Insurance Studios. You know again, thinking about nine
- 31:07to eleven this morning and watching all the video again from from twenty two years
- 31:12ago, and like many of you, which is very very hard to watch,
- 31:17very hard to remember, but necessary, but necessary. This was our
- 31:19generation's pearl Harbor, certainly, and but also remembering a couple other things.
- 31:26One is that the heroism of so many people that day, the rescuers and
- 31:32the firemen who rushed to the rescue in the in the Twin Towers lost their
- 31:37lives, those who helped out immediately at the Pentagon, those on board flight
- 31:42ninety three when that plane, before the plane crashed in Shanksville, I mean
- 31:47all those people, because what's our inclination. I mean we we are we
- 31:51are wired. We are wired to react. We are wired to acknowledge fear
- 31:57and get away from danger. That's the way we're wired. And all those
- 32:02people that day had to overcome that fear and act in ways that were truly,
- 32:10truly heroic. And of course we remember how for a period of time
- 32:15our country was united, united in anger sorrow, and of course that has
- 32:22all dissipated. And I'm not suggesting we need another tragedy to unitis, but
- 32:28there was, if there was this brief but shining silver lining. It was
- 32:36that we came together as a country, as a people united for a period
- 32:43of time Hoppy. The lackness is tax three or four tas three or four
- 32:46Hoppy. The lack of accountability from the legislature and Board of Governors is mind
- 32:51boggling. They created the crisis through their mismanagement. I'm tired of these cuts
- 32:54being blamed on external forces, says the texture three or four talk three or
- 33:01four hoppy. The elimination of world languages does seem odd. Scaling back to
- 33:06the most common languages seems like a better solution. Also, the elimination of
- 33:09graduate level mathematics seems absurd. But I am most upset with the elimination of
- 33:15the degree program and puppetry. Why did no one tell me I could have
- 33:20gone to college for puppetry while in high school? Happy people are unhappy with
- 33:25the w cuts don't seem to acknowledge key facts and make false assertions like puppetry
- 33:31has zero costs. These people have weak arguments, but they are allowed and
- 33:36led by emotions, not by reality, says the texture Hoppy. If you've
- 33:42heard of cuts in physical education, the program that most athletes are enrolled.
- 33:46I have not text copy. The loss of faith can be attributed to one
- 33:51man? How can that be that one man could bring down a country?
- 33:55Although the textures does not mention that man. All right, we'll take a
- 33:59break and come back when we come back, Michael Tamaski joins us. That
- 34:04is next. This is talk Line on Metro News. Metro News is the
- 34:07Voice of West Virginia, our number two of talk line on the Metro News
- 34:29radio network all across the great state of West Virginia. President Biden, according
- 34:32to CNN. According to a CNN poll, President Biden faces continuing head winds
- 34:37from broadly negative job approval ratings, widespread concerns about his age, and decreased
- 34:44confidence among Democratic aligned voters. His job approval rating, according to the CNN
- 34:49poll, stands at just thirty nine percent. Roughly three quarters of Americans say
- 34:53they're seriously concerned that Biden's age might negatively affect his current level of physical and
- 35:00mental competence seventy three percent and his ability to serve out another full term if
- 35:04reelected Seventy six percent have concerns about that. A Wall Street Journal poll that
- 35:10was a couple of days earlier found that seventy three percent of registered voters say
- 35:15mister Biden is too old to run for presidents. Biden turns eighty one in
- 35:21two months. Let me bring in Michael Tamaski, Morgantown, West Virginia native
- 35:23w graduate, editor of The New Republic, also author of a number of
- 35:28books, including his latest The Middle Out, The Rise of Progressive Economics and
- 35:32a Return to Shared Shared Prosperity. Michael, good to talk to you.
- 35:36How are you, sir? I'm all right, how are you? You're
- 35:38You're just all right, just all right. Yeah, I don't know,
- 35:42you know, things are weird, but you know, personally, I'm fine.
- 35:45Okay, personally you're fine. But that's the micro. What's the macro?
- 35:49What are you worried about? I mean, I don't know what you
- 35:52were just talking about. For starters, Well, go, I'm listening.
- 35:57Yeah, there's a lot of concern, uh you know, I mean,
- 36:01the polls are the polls, you know, numbers don't lie, and there's
- 36:06a lot of concern. Biden's age is a real issue, and I'm not
- 36:08exactly sure what he does about it. I think I think he's in good
- 36:13shape for an eighty year old. But you know when you had those words
- 36:16for an eighty year old. Uh, you know, he goes on bike
- 36:20rides. I doubt Donald Trump goes on bike rides. I wonder if Donald
- 36:22Trump's ever even been on a bike. But you know, I think he's
- 36:27probably healthier than Donald Trump. But I don't think that gets through. Uh,
- 36:31and there are only three years apart, but you know there can be
- 36:34a difference between seventy seven and eighty. Sure, you know. So I
- 36:38don't know what he does about it, you know, I mean, he
- 36:40just has to come up, no matter what they say about me on Fox.
- 36:45You know, I'm mentally lucid. I'm all there, you know I'm
- 36:49here. But then that sounds defensive, So you know, I don't know,
- 36:53I got no answers. So just show that he's just show by his
- 36:59action and you know that he's up to the job. And look, I'm
- 37:02I don't want to pick I don't want to pick on the guy. Okay,
- 37:06but but I'm not gonna say. But I guess I'll say and that
- 37:13you say, show that he's you know, he's up to the job.
- 37:15But candidly when there are public appearances and opportunities for him to show. That's
- 37:21where a lot of these fumbles come in, a lot of the stumbling,
- 37:23and it simply raises more questions about his about his guess, I guess it
- 37:32does. But you know, I mean, he can't go into hiding,
- 37:35you know, I mean you can run a rose garden strategy to some extent,
- 37:38to use the old cliche, but but only to some extent. You
- 37:43know, you still have to get out there in campaign. And you know
- 37:45he benefited, Let's be honest about this too in twenty twenty from the pandemic
- 37:51and the fact that there wasn't an it wasn't possible to campaign in the normal
- 37:55way. Uh. You know, when it's September and October of next year,
- 38:01is he going to be up to giving him for speeches a day and
- 38:06doing a head to head debate? Oh? I think he can probably handle
- 38:09himself in a debate. But I mean if he's yeah, I think he
- 38:14can handle a debate. But but the rigors of campaigning, you know,
- 38:21I doubt he'll be giving four speeches to day, maybe two. Michael Tamaski
- 38:24is with us, So is there any is there any buzz among your people?
- 38:30A Democrats who say I mean, are they just saying what you're saying,
- 38:36or are they saying, we gotta maybe do something about this, or
- 38:39I mean what or is it just lamenting the status of things. There's plenty
- 38:45of chatter, but there's no consensus for if not Biden, what or who?
- 38:52You know, there's no great enthusiasm for Kamala Harris, right, and
- 38:59if somehow Biden decides by the end of the year say that I'm not going
- 39:04to do this, and I think that's possible. I do. I think
- 39:07there's a small chance of that. But but but a chance, you know,
- 39:12like somewhere under Yeah. But if he did that, obviously there would
- 39:22not be automatic acclamation of Harris. A lot of people, a lot of
- 39:25people would throw their hats in the ring. There is a good bench of
- 39:30governors, uh Gavin Newsome in Pittsburg of Illinois and Gregor Whitmer of Michigan and
- 39:38a bit of a newbie, but Josh Sapiro in Pennsylvania. You know,
- 39:43when you can reopen the busiest highway in the United States in twelve days,
- 39:45man, you've got something going for you. I keep an eye on that
- 39:52guy. He's I think he's a real talent, so but you know,
- 39:55I don't know, you know, I just I don't know. So there'll
- 39:59be a primary process, and then you know, Bernie's too old, right,
- 40:04Okasio Cortez is too young. I mean she will technically be thirty five
- 40:08before, but you know she can't you know, she's awfully young. And
- 40:14House members, you know, don't really run for president very much. So
- 40:19there's nobody from like that wing of the party who's an obvious choice, and
- 40:22they'll probably want to put somebody in there, but I don't really know who.
- 40:25Maybe Rocanna, I guess the congressman, you know, you know,
- 40:30Michael. I read a big piece about Gavin Newsom over the weekend, and
- 40:34you know, Newsome is kind of doing kind of a shadow campaign. I
- 40:38mean, he's out he's making a clear he's out there supporting Biden, but
- 40:42he's working in conjunction with the White House. He doesn't want to be seen.
- 40:45He's trying to push Biden aside. But he's critically positioning himself. But
- 40:47maybe he's thinking that, you know, whatever happens happens in twenty twenty four,
- 40:52and I'm positioned well for twenty twenty eight. I don't know, but
- 40:54I mean he's there, he's in the wings. He's like the closest one
- 40:58in the wings. I think, yeah, yeah, And you know,
- 41:01government of California obviously just has a lot of juice. A lot of people
- 41:06like Gretchen Whitmer because they like what has happened in Michigan, where the Dems
- 41:12have rolled the Republicans went very extreme and the Dems have taken every statewide office
- 41:17and so on, and likely to elect another senator. So but you know,
- 41:23I mean, a woman, you know, it's you always have to
- 41:27wonder. You know, there's never been a woman president, and you know,
- 41:30the one who was clearly supposed to win didn't. So yeah, I
- 41:37don't know, there's just there's a lot of stuff. But I you know,
- 41:39people a lot of people also say, well, tell me why any
- 41:45of those people have a better chance of winning than Joe Biden. And I'm
- 41:52not sure any of them do. I mean, maybe maybe because they're younger
- 41:54and fresh, you know, and all those questions go away. But but
- 41:59you know, well, I just don't know. I mean, it is
- 42:02unknowable. We're just talking because it's unknowable, right, and and circumstances may
- 42:07change dramatically over the next twelve months. So it's it's unknowable, but it's
- 42:09this huge topic of conversation. Michael Damascus with us working down West Virginia,
- 42:14native w graduate, editor of New Republic, author of a number of books,
- 42:16as latest is The Middle Out, The Rise of Progressive Economics and Return
- 42:21to Shared Prosperity. When I finish your book, I'll have you on again
- 42:23and we'll talk about that. But you know, I it occurs to me
- 42:30that and we remember, like Robert Byrd in West Virginia, and you know,
- 42:35you got Mitch McConnell, you got Diane Feinstein. You I mean,
- 42:37they aren't they aren't the first people who've been there, you know, too
- 42:42long. But you know you're you're You're not entitled to that office. I
- 42:47mean, it's it's a matter of maybe I'm being too naive, but it's
- 42:51a matter of service. And even though the people elect you, at some
- 42:54point, don't you analyze and say what is the greater good here? I
- 42:58mean, what is what is in the best interest of the country rather than
- 43:01my personal interests? And what I'm getting to is, I think that Biden's
- 43:05decision to run again is selfish. I mean, he was elected primarily not
- 43:10not not completely, primarily because people were tired of Trump. It was the
- 43:14anti Trump. Okay, Biden's going to be a good placeholder. And I
- 43:17don't see that as a as a mandate. I see that as and not
- 43:22not a placeholder. That's don't agree, but as just Okay, I'm we're
- 43:25gonna get rid of Trump and I'm going to be the guy. But it's
- 43:30selfish, given his current negatives, to run again in my opinion. Your
- 43:35take, uh, you know I thought back then that he would be a
- 43:42one term president. Okay, that not that he would ever say it,
- 43:45because he can't say that, you know, right, make yourself a lame
- 43:47duck, but that there would be a kind of understanding that he was only
- 43:53going to do the one term and that his job was what you just said.
- 43:58He was the best against Trump, he was the most likely to meet
- 44:01Trump. So let's get Trump out of there and let Biden do his thing,
- 44:07but not seek a second term. Then you know that conventional wisdom changed.
- 44:15You know, it changed partly because he got stuff done, and he
- 44:17did pass all this stuff, and you know, people learnt he's not getting
- 44:21credit for it. Today. Maybe a campaign can can change that a little
- 44:25bit. But you know, he got stuff done, and his leadership on
- 44:30Ukraine has been salutary, has been fantastic. So he's hasn't been you know.
- 44:37I mean, I imagine law of your listeners won't like to hear this,
- 44:39but like, he's had many successes as as president, and you're just
- 44:44not going to talk to somebody like that into not seeking a second term.
- 44:46He's just it's just not going to happen. You're if you will only serve
- 44:51one term. Think of the people who've served one term. Are they considered
- 44:53successes? Jimmy Carter considers success is George H. W. Bush considers success
- 45:00No, No is Martin van Buren considered Let me answer, I don't know.
- 45:07Well, I can tell you Martin van Buren was a it was a
- 45:09rare statesman and a very impressive politician, but a bad president because there was
- 45:14a recession in eighteen thirty seven. So no, So no one termer goes
- 45:20down in history as a great And you know, I'm sure that that's what
- 45:24got into Biden, and you know gets it would get into anybody. Yeah,
- 45:30all right, Michael TAMASKI I don't he's I don't know. I mean,
- 45:35we count Wait a minute, we count on. You're the editor of
- 45:37the New Republic. You're supposed to be prying this great insight, like,
- 45:39here's what's going to happen. I don't know. I don't know. Well,
- 45:42you know, it's very very likely that he's running, and you know
- 45:45he would. I would bet on him today to win because I think Trump's
- 45:51going to have at least one conviction under his belt by them, and I
- 45:53think Trump is still more unpopular with swing voters than bidenist. Michael, always
- 45:59good to talk to you. We'll have you back soon when I finish your
- 46:00book. How about that terrific six? All right? Thanks Michael Tamaski,
- 46:05editor of The New Republic, Morgantown, West Virginia native. His new book
- 46:07is The Middle Out, The Rise of Progressive Economics and Return to Shared Prosperity.
- 46:12Talk line continues. We'll be right back. Metro News talk Line with
- 46:24Hobby Kirchiblas brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage to
- 46:29protect what you care about most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more.
- 46:34Talk line from me in COVID Insurance studios. Jared Halfred, Fox News Radio
- 46:37in Washington. Jared, Good morning, sir. So where were you twenty
- 46:42two years ago today about this time? You remember, I was in my
- 46:47I was a senior in high school, so I would have been heading in
- 46:51the I guess first period or we had debate practice. I was on the
- 46:53debate team before school, so I think that's where I was when I first
- 47:00kind of understood what was happening. And my father, who is a retired
- 47:06pilot, had a flight that morning, and I do remember a few kind
- 47:13of chaotic, hectic attempts to kind of reach him. Obviously, cell phones
- 47:20weren't what they are today with the ability to kind of text and message and
- 47:23everything. And I think I heard from him later in the morning and was
- 47:31able to kind of talk through the situation with him a little bit about where
- 47:36he was and when he was going to be able to maybe come home.
- 47:40Sort of That was sort of my nine. Yeah, airspace was shut down
- 47:44for a few days. He was in we were living in Texas. We
- 47:46he was in I think Minneapolis, and he had not flown yet. That
- 47:51morning he had a flight. He was in the cockpit. I think they
- 47:54were boarding the flight. When they when they shut down you airspace. Wow,
- 48:01incredible, it was I was saying earlier, I was, I was
- 48:06working and I was I can't I can't remember if I was on the air
- 48:09or about to go on the air. I just I just don't remember that.
- 48:13But I do remember when it happened, obviously, and I was at
- 48:15work, and it just like what and and you know, Jared, I
- 48:20what I think the response everybody was was what's happening? What's happening? Is
- 48:24this is this? Is this an accident? Was it a small plane?
- 48:28It was the first plane, the first plane hitting, you know, I
- 48:30think even in his autobiography, Uh, President Bush talks about believing initially,
- 48:37like the assessment was this was just some kind of you know, horrible accident,
- 48:43right right, I mean, it wasn't. In hell, the second
- 48:45plane hits that he's notified by his chief of staff that this is an attack,
- 48:49and you know, there's going to have to be a response, because
- 48:52my father even told me he was sort of walking to the gates at the
- 48:58airport kind of out of the corner of his eye, saw you know,
- 49:00the plane, the tower and firing. Just assume like, oh, this
- 49:04is probably a smaller, like a pilot got lost or disoriented, you know,
- 49:07flying around New York. He's like, you know, and he thought
- 49:10it was a small plane. We all thought it was a small plane initially,
- 49:14right, and then yeah, obviously the second plane made it obvious.
- 49:20That the Pentagon attack made it obvious. And I was actually looking back at
- 49:24some footage for a piece I was working on President Bush that day. You
- 49:29know, he's at this elementary school in Sara sot To, Florida. He's
- 49:32reading to that second grade class. Andy Carter's keep of staff whispers in his
- 49:37dear, what's happening, And in his first remarks about the events of that
- 49:40day, happened in the auditorium of that elementary school, which had been set
- 49:45up for him to give an education speech. And as he walks into the
- 49:50room, the students, the staff, the teachers are all applauding because they
- 49:53don't know what's happening. And he kind of quickly says, I'm sorry,
- 49:58something's happened, and that's what's happening, and then has to leave. I
- 50:02mean that, And it's strange to think about that twenty two years later,
- 50:08because you know, there's no social media news isn't exactly what it is.
- 50:13There's not instantaneous information at the palm of your hand. For most of us,
- 50:17that was our first indication that something awful had happened. Yeah, Jared
- 50:22Halpern is with is reflecting on the nine Oven attacks twenty two years ago,
- 50:25and I went there the following year and did a show from there. It
- 50:30was one of those things where talk shows were invited in. I just I
- 50:34remember that a gaping hole. I mean, it was almost unimaginable, the
- 50:37size of the hole that was there, because then they cleared away the debris.
- 50:40Now, of course there's a memorial there, but it was just this
- 50:44gaping on it beautiful new building because you know, I haven't I haven't been
- 50:46there since. Have you seen it since? It's extraordinary, is it?
- 50:52Yeah? And I do you because I think it's great, because right,
- 50:57wasn't that kind of the ultimate act of defiance. Yeah? Yes, it's
- 51:00reopen for business. It's a financial hub. There's obviously a memorial with the
- 51:07names inscribed. But we rebuilt and the city got back on its feet,
- 51:15the country got back on its feet. The Pentagon is still the Pentagon.
- 51:20It's open for business today. They had a service there this morning, and
- 51:23that's a I think that's an important element as well. Yeah. Absolutely,
- 51:29I mean the fact that when you consider for those of us who were here
- 51:32at that time, and the severity of the attacks, the great unknown what
- 51:38followed, and today in so many ways, and I'm not talking about the
- 51:43families who lost loved ones in that, but that there is this great sense
- 51:46of normalcy two decades later. It's pretty remarkable because you could not have imagined
- 51:52that twenty two years ago. As you know, I have a ten year
- 51:54old son, and so we've been talking a little bit about the events of
- 51:59that day, and even this morning I was kind of explaining to him about
- 52:01even the simplicity of like what air travel was like before then. Yeah,
- 52:06yeah, yeah, you remember. I mean we went through security. There
- 52:08was like metal detectors, I guess, but you remember, like anybody could
- 52:12just go to the gate. You could meet your love going at the gate.
- 52:15Yes, you remember that, yeah, yeah, yeah. And now
- 52:19it's it's changed, not only here, but I just got back from international
- 52:22around the world, around the world well, and a big part of that
- 52:25is because the US says, if you're going to fly an airplane in the
- 52:29our air space, you've got to meet certain standards and so and listen,
- 52:32I think, you know, obviously you want uniformity, and you want global
- 52:36security and and sort of all of these assurances. But absolutely I traveled to
- 52:42Europe less than a year after the attack, and even then it was remarkable
- 52:49to see the change in in the posture of of you know, security around
- 52:55the world. We were in on on our trip, my wife had all
- 52:59the old dental kit okay that you could use, you know, personal hygiene,
- 53:05dental kit, and we were in at a security location I think it
- 53:08was Rwanda, and they stood up, can't take that, took that away.
- 53:13I can't have that. That could be a weapon, could be a
- 53:15weapon. Yeah, and I mean, and now, you know, we
- 53:17kind of make a lot of the security situation. I think that, you
- 53:22know, it's inconvenient for a lot of folks. But listen, I mean,
- 53:25there's a reason I think that we've been spared another catastrophic type of event,
- 53:34and you know, it is what it is. But yeah, I
- 53:37remember even this morning, sort if it's funny to my son, like you
- 53:38know, how it used to be playing like I'm the old man saying like,
- 53:43well, back in my day, but like that is the reality,
- 53:45right it was? It changed air travel, It changed a lot of obviously
- 53:51the way that we think about and lisc I think that's important too, righte.
- 53:54This attack happened, this awful thing happens. The country respond and we
- 53:58are continuing the debate and analyze what, you know, what's our foreign policy,
- 54:04what's our when a security and civil liberties meet? What happens if they're
- 54:07in contrast with one another? How much are you willing to give up for
- 54:12safety? And these are important conversations that are still happening to this day in
- 54:15Congress because as they come back, they're going to have to talk about re
- 54:19authorizing a lot of the FISA provisions that were put in place. Jared halperin
- 54:22Fox News Radio, Jared, thank you for coming on. Always good to
- 54:25talk to you. Appreciate it. Thank you, sir. To the Biden
- 54:30thing text topic, I'm an independent voter, I support unions. I will
- 54:32support Biden over Trump. The veteran hater says the texture Biden's been great for
- 54:37West Virginia's look at the jobs coming here, says the texture will take a
- 54:40break and be back. This is talk Line on Metro News Metro News is
- 54:45the voice of West Virginia. Talk line from me and COVID Insurance Studios in
- 54:53the Miller Building Networks. Security is serious business. In city net is serious
- 54:58about protecting your business and your employees from today's constant barrage of cyber security threats.
- 55:04Let's sitting net be your cyber security hero. Learn more city net dot
- 55:07net. One of the biggest stories in West Virginia in the last half of
- 55:12the last century was the Kanal County textbook controversy. It started when there was
- 55:17the adoption of a new set of language arts classroom textbooks for Kana County.
- 55:24The books were recommended by a group of English teachers to reflect America's increasingly multicultural
- 55:30society at the time. A member of the county Board of Education, Alice
- 55:36Moore, raised questions and objections to those books. She found a number of
- 55:42passages that in themes that she thought were objectionable. What followed were serious protests.
- 55:50There was violence, There were boycotts. It got a lot of national
- 55:52attention and went on for some time. There were molotov Coddale's school bus is
- 56:00hit by sniper bullets. Just a lot that went on in Kanaal County of
- 56:04the Great County Textbook Controversy. Trey Kay is a veteran reporter and producer of
- 56:09The Great Textbook Wore a documentary about the textbook controversy. And reason I'm bringing
- 56:14Trey in is because that Alice Moore, one of the key figures in that
- 56:17controversy, has just died. She passed away over the weekend. Trey,
- 56:21thanks for joining us, Good morning, How are you hey, Thank thanks
- 56:23so much happy. I'm really grateful that you're willing to speak with me today
- 56:29and that we could pay a bit of tribute and just note the passing of
- 56:34Vallis Moore. What was her role? What was what was her role in
- 56:37the controversy? So she was she was on the school board and they were
- 56:44adopting these new textbooks, and she saw some things that were just initially presented
- 56:51that there was some things about dialecttology. They were they were textbooks that were
- 56:55that were with the intention of being kind of multiculture role, and she saw
- 57:00things that she didn't she didn't approve of, and she asked the superintendent of
- 57:07the time to send all those books to her house and she sat down and
- 57:09read them and and saw things that that that that that alarmed her and sought
- 57:16to go out and show to people in the in the area to show her
- 57:22what her showed them what her objections were. And uh, and that really
- 57:27in many ways just kind of ignited the whole controversy. So Trey. So
- 57:31she had objections to what was in some of these textbooks, and certainly by
- 57:37today's standard, that's not new. That happens a lot. How did it
- 57:39get from raising objections to violent protests? Well, I'm not sure. And
- 57:46one of the things I'd want to say is that I don't think that Alice
- 57:50Moore was the one who was saying, you know, let let go out
- 57:52and uh, you know, bomb schools with that in my Chilotov cocktail of
- 57:55course. But but it was But but you know, people in the Kanaw
- 58:00County in West Virginia, people feel very passionate about about things that that would
- 58:07relate to their their faith. There were things in the textbooks that some some
- 58:12of the local thought were anti Christian. This happened in the early nineteen seventies
- 58:16when the Vietnam War was going on. There were there were there were passages
- 58:22in the books that would have been critical of the Vietnam War. Those were
- 58:25those were things that some people found objectionable because it's found them to be unpatriotic.
- 58:30There were there, there were This was around the time also the civil
- 58:36rights movement, and this was the first time that there would have been passages
- 58:39that would have been by black, black authors, and some of them in
- 58:45one case, Eldridge Cleaver was was one of the authors who was in one
- 58:50of the supplemental texts, and that that drew a lot of fire. So
- 58:55these were things that that that in some ways, Whether there was a rational
- 59:02discussion about these textbooks and the objections, that's for some other people to debate.
- 59:08I'm not going to get into that right now. But but but but
- 59:13the fact that these things were brought up and people were very upset and they
- 59:19pulled their kids out of schools. They coal miners had a sympathetic protest in
- 59:27Boycott that was sympathetic to the textbook controversy. And it's shut down or hampered
- 59:32the economy for Kanak County and what about eight surrounding counties. I mean,
- 59:38it was a big deal. Sure it was. Hey, Trey, you
- 59:42treyky is with this documentaryan reporter Trey you did a wonderful hour long documentary about
- 59:49the Ka County textbook controversy. You got to know a lot of the principles
- 59:52involved, and of course you got to know Alice Moore pretty well. And
- 59:55Alice Moore we're talking about today because you passed away over the weekend. So
- 1:00:00give us a personal reflection on Alice Moore. Well, first of all,
- 1:00:04when I was a student in the Kannau County schools during the time of the
- 1:00:07textbook controversy, and on my side of the tracks, you know, we
- 1:00:10thought Alice Moore was a kuk and we just thought she was a troublemaker,
- 1:00:16and we just there was a lot of people in with regard to people at
- 1:00:22my parents knew the teachers at my school, they thought Alice Moore was a
- 1:00:24nut. And if you would have had a crystal ball back in those days
- 1:00:30and you would have shown me, first he would have said, Trey,
- 1:00:32you're going to be a journalist, and second, you're going to make a
- 1:00:36documentary about the Kannau County textbook controversy. And third, if you would have
- 1:00:40said that in that process, you're going to become friends with Alice Moore and
- 1:00:45she is going to be an important figure in your life. I would have
- 1:00:47thought you were crazy and I would have laughed in your face. So changed.
- 1:00:52But well, you know, when I first called her on the phone,
- 1:00:55I literally my knees shook. I was afraid that she was going to
- 1:01:00tell me that I was, you know, some type of liberal from MPR
- 1:01:04or something like that. And she just was an incredibly warm person. And
- 1:01:09she listened and she talked, and she heard you, and she didn't she
- 1:01:15didn't kind of come at me with a bunch of of of defensiveness. She
- 1:01:22listened and she had a discussion and and somehow along the way, I just
- 1:01:27found her to be a warm individual. And and I think I can say
- 1:01:34this now. I mean she loved me. She did she she treated me
- 1:01:40as though I was one of her own kids. And as a matter of
- 1:01:44fact, this weekend, I'm going down to speak at her memorial service.
- 1:01:49It turned into probably one of the most tender friendships that I've had in my
- 1:01:55whole Did it did it make you more? Because again you started out again,
- 1:02:00and you think, and she was a kook. You were on the
- 1:02:01other side on this growing up, your family was and then you did this
- 1:02:05what I think was a very fair documentary about it. So in this did
- 1:02:09you become more sympathetic to her points of view? Not necessarily, not necessarily
- 1:02:19in some ways that she when she left this earth, there were points of
- 1:02:22view that that she had that that I am diametrically opposed to. But the
- 1:02:29but I think that the thing that I I just really appreciated was that she
- 1:02:37there was something about that there was something beyond our political different our differences over
- 1:02:43politics, our differences over religion, that there was that there was a love
- 1:02:47and affection between us that that that allowed us to talk about those things and
- 1:02:53talk about them in a critical way. Now, sometimes she and I did
- 1:02:58get heated. On my podcast, I've talked about certain times where Alice,
- 1:03:02like you know, drove me nuts. One time she drove me so nuts,
- 1:03:07but I thought I was having a heart attack. But but in the
- 1:03:09end, I just felt such a warm affection for her. And I guess,
- 1:03:15Hoppy to your question is that she she inspired me to be more empathetic
- 1:03:24to people who share her point of view and and and to not and to
- 1:03:30not just write her off or marginalize her as a kook. And I think
- 1:03:35that's, you know, that's really important. That's a that's a good lesson
- 1:03:37for any time, you know, Yeah, that's a good lesson. Yeah
- 1:03:40you can disagree, but you can all but you can listen, listen with
- 1:03:44understanding, be empathetic, disagree, but not you know, not not think
- 1:03:51somebody's evil. And if the textbook controversy we're happening today and I'm in the
- 1:03:55age that I am now, I probably would would be against Ali More and
- 1:04:00the position that she took. There's various things that are happening across the nation
- 1:04:05with regard to banning books and questions over what is so called critical race theory
- 1:04:13and that being taught in school. I think Alice and I would be on
- 1:04:17the different opinion, different side of those issues. That said, I think
- 1:04:24that what she did her willingness to step forward and do service for community,
- 1:04:30I mean work serving on the school board. In many ways, I think
- 1:04:33it's a thankless job. And I think she yeah, she did that,
- 1:04:38and I think that that that putting aside, you know, the violence that
- 1:04:44happened, et cetera, which I think is is really regrettable. I think
- 1:04:47that what she did back then was a great exercise in democracy, standing up
- 1:04:55coming to the public square and sharing her truth and in aging with people when
- 1:05:01I made the documentary, When you listen to the audio of her, you
- 1:05:05know, asking questions she was she was really quite formidable. And again I
- 1:05:15might have reached different conclusions than she did, but I was really inspired by
- 1:05:18her example to to basically get involved in our community as opposed to just kind
- 1:05:26of sitting back and and and letting things just kind of go on and say
- 1:05:31that you're helpless. Well, we're going to leave it there. The passing
- 1:05:34of Alice More very seminal figure in the Canal textbook Controversy of the seventies and
- 1:05:43Trey Kay Nationale Public radio reporter documentarian who knew her very very well. Alice
- 1:05:48passed away over the weekend. She was eighty to Trey, good to talk
- 1:05:53to you again. Thanks for coming on, buddy, Thanks so much.
- 1:05:56Hobby, Thanks all right. Talklin continues Tony Creedia Coming up next. Metro
- 1:06:10News talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought to you by in COVID Insurance,
- 1:06:14encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care about most? Visit incod
- 1:06:17dot com to learn more. Joined by Tony Creedy in the Cove Insurance Studios.
- 1:06:21Tony, good morning. What did you learn Saturday about the WVU Mountaineer
- 1:06:25of football team. I think this team has proven itself without a shadow of
- 1:06:29a doubt that it's the best Mountaineer team in school history to play after a
- 1:06:32lightning delay and we'll just leave it at Wait a minute, what happened?
- 1:06:36I don't remember that they well, they beat Marshall. There was that was
- 1:06:41that was the third one with nineteen ninety one, and it's you know,
- 1:06:44it's it's pretty ironic. Nineteen ninety one West Virginia was in a lightning delay
- 1:06:48game here against Virginia Tech. That's right, And when play resumed, West
- 1:06:53Virginia was at the goal line to go in at the win, and Chris
- 1:06:57Gray, who was killed today in September, fumbled the football. And I
- 1:07:02wrote a story from a writer in New Jersey this morning that was detailing Chris
- 1:07:06and the scholarship that his family has created. And he said that for years,
- 1:07:12Chris would he if you remember his personality, he was just absolutely a
- 1:07:15live wire. Becaues he would he would, he said, he always would
- 1:07:19retell and he would go through the whole thing and how he fumbled the ball,
- 1:07:23but that was the that was the one of three lightning games now in
- 1:07:28stadium history. And you know, Hoppy, the way I look at it
- 1:07:30was this, and I don't know if I'm putting too much into it.
- 1:07:32I thought that there was great build up obviously for the Penn State game.
- 1:07:35They knew they had to be at their absolute, you know, pinnacle.
- 1:07:39I think there was whether he wanted a subconscious let down Saturday. They were
- 1:07:45all right, but they just missed a few plays early on in that game
- 1:07:47and they were gonna win, you know, regardless. But at fourteen to
- 1:07:50ten, it made everyone, you know, kind of get a little bit
- 1:07:54of a short breath. And then afterwards I think it finally reality finally hit
- 1:07:58them and they went out there and they did what they needed to do.
- 1:08:00So I think it just sets up for what we knew that this Pit game
- 1:08:05is just a massive game for this program and for this season. Did you
- 1:08:13have Hudson Clement on your bingo card? I had him on my depth chart.
- 1:08:16He was making you know, Hoppy, he was making those plays routinely
- 1:08:20in preseason practices, but you don't know when you're doing it in preseason practice.
- 1:08:26If that will translate to the field. And I had asked Neil about
- 1:08:30it, and they said, oh no, that's for real. That's just
- 1:08:33not a practice guy that's having big practices. And they were going to scholarship
- 1:08:36him at some point this season. It was going to be probably you know,
- 1:08:42several weeks from now. But I did like the way that they did
- 1:08:44it on Saturday, right after the game, and that's well deserved. I
- 1:08:46think I think he can become one of the top three or four receivers on
- 1:08:53this team. I think as the season goes, I think it'll be Devin
- 1:08:55Carter, it'll be the true freshman trailing Ray, and I think Hudson Clement
- 1:08:58now will be one of those top three four receivers on this team. Okay,
- 1:09:02pit week will take the liberty of looking ahead now. We'll talk more
- 1:09:08about it later this week. But to pit with a disappointing loss to Cincinnati
- 1:09:13at home on Saturday. So they struggled, They struggled in the game,
- 1:09:16struggled to stop the run. They did, Yeah, they did. So.
- 1:09:19Cincinnati is not a team that was given much preseason pub because they're also
- 1:09:25in a coaching transition with a new first year coach and So that's a great
- 1:09:29win for Cincinnati. They have struggled to you know, as far as running
- 1:09:33the ball, nothing that overwhelms you and passing the ball. Their quarterback,
- 1:09:36the transfer Phil jerko Eck, who came from Boston College, was you know,
- 1:09:42in that a low forty percentile and is passing. So I think it
- 1:09:45sets up well for West Virginia. You know, it's it's nothing more than
- 1:09:49you could ever dream about. You've got pit on your home field under the
- 1:09:54lights. You have to win. Let's go. You have to win.
- 1:09:57You have to win. You have to win because there are wins here for
- 1:10:00West Virginia for the rest of this season. You got to get these two.
- 1:10:03Houston obviously stumbled and has not looked overly impressive in its first two outings.
- 1:10:11Baylor, again, that's a good Utah team. But I'm just saying
- 1:10:14there's wins out there for you. You can make yourself. You can have
- 1:10:16yourself a very nice season and so you got to take care of your work
- 1:10:21at home before you can think about those other ones. Anybody else stand out
- 1:10:25to you from Saturday? Oh, I think that Jem White White Jaheem White,
- 1:10:30as advertised, was really hoppy running backs are super deep. I mean
- 1:10:34Jaheem White, DJ Oliver, Justin Johnson didn't even go Jaalen Anderson solid CJ.
- 1:10:41You know, you're the opportunity to run the ball. And Trey Lathan
- 1:10:44is another one that's that's up and coming at that linebacker spot. He's going
- 1:10:47to be a guy. There's several guys and there are also several guys that
- 1:10:50now for the second week in a row, showed that they're not ready to
- 1:10:56do this, and there need to be there need to be changes, and
- 1:10:59there need to be less repetitions for certain players because you have going forward,
- 1:11:02you no longer have any margin of air. Now everything would be fatal if
- 1:11:09you make key mistakes. And the defensive backfield, the safeties in particular,
- 1:11:12is a major major concern. Coner, you know you got you got a
- 1:11:15situation. Not so much. I mean, safety is fine, but corners,
- 1:11:18Oh yeah, it's the corners. Okay. Also shout out to the
- 1:11:24WVU men's soccer team. Wow zo, how about that that was That's the
- 1:11:28equivalent of a basketball buzzer beater. Yeah, they got a buzzer beater in
- 1:11:31soccer, which you don't often see. No, you think about that you
- 1:11:34play an entire match and it comes down to the last three seconds and they
- 1:11:40banged a home a goal against the third rated team in the nation. And
- 1:11:44so great, great win for the guy that you hired, Dan Stratford,
- 1:11:47the head soccer coach at West Virginia. You facilitated that deal, and yeah,
- 1:11:51they they had. There's fine, that's that's a program on the on
- 1:11:56the rise, and very encouraged by that. Yeah. In fact, they
- 1:12:00got a great stat they they're five and zero, I believe, and in
- 1:12:03those five games there, they've outscored the opponiners ten one. Yeah, that's
- 1:12:09pretty good. Being very stingy behind the pipes, being very stingy. So
- 1:12:12yeah, so folks need to get excited about that. And the women last
- 1:12:15yesterday they battled the zip zipper against Villanova. Also, our congratulations to Marshall.
- 1:12:21Marshall was struggling with East Carolina. I think that a weather delay in
- 1:12:24that as well, but they made up for it with a couple of fourth
- 1:12:28quarter touchdowns. Had a trick play and I got a touchdown seventy five yard
- 1:12:32touchdown pass out of that when the was a receiver passed, So that was
- 1:12:35a nice play and they knocked off East Carolina thirty one to thirteen. So
- 1:12:41congratulations to the Marshall thundering hurt. All right, we'll take a break and
- 1:12:44be back. Talk like continues after around the world talk line from me and
- 1:13:09Coventsurance Studios in the Miller Building, Jack potts from the Milligansure in West Virginia.
- 1:13:12Doesn't want to be a millionaire? Getting the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays
- 1:13:15and Saturdays and the Megamillions drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the
- 1:13:19next big winner? Plate Today? The Powerball jackpot is five hundred twenty two
- 1:13:24million dollars. The Megami is jack pot one hundred and forty one million dollars.
- 1:13:28Text three or four Talk three or four, hoppy, It's hard to
- 1:13:30fathom the nine to eleven happened. I still have trouble wrapping my head around
- 1:13:34the fact that human beings could do that to other human beings. Still very
- 1:13:38sad after all these years. Indeed, indeed it is. It's it's surreal
- 1:13:45to look back and watch that, watch that all over again. I'll be
- 1:13:50discussed what he's gotten done and the issues his administration are tackling. Prescription drugs,
- 1:13:55China, et cetera. He's boring and effective and reporters can't stand it
- 1:13:58because there's no drama. Yeah, I look, the Biden administration can certainly
- 1:14:03make arguments on accomplishments the Inflation Reduction Act. I know a lot on the
- 1:14:10right don't like it, but there's a lot of money flowing to a lot
- 1:14:13of projects, a lot of economic development that he can tout. There's the
- 1:14:18prescription drug issue with Medicare, the negotiation of the time of the first ten
- 1:14:24drugs. There's improved international relations on a lot of levels. But you still
- 1:14:29look at the poll numbers. Look at the poll numbers, and a majority
- 1:14:31of Americans still just aren't buying it. And look, inflation has come down,
- 1:14:35but still the tough part about inflation is that once prices go up,
- 1:14:41they lots of times they just stay up and then you go to the grocery
- 1:14:45store, you come back and go, who what's going on here? And
- 1:14:48Biden gets sit with that. So all right, we gotta run. Thanks
- 1:14:51for tuning in today. We regroup at ten or six tomorrow. This has
- 1:14:55been talk Line on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia.