Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Market Adjustment Raise
Transcript
- Lucas: Let's talk about a conversation that stresses out a lot of professionals — asking for a raise when it's not about your performance, but about the market. Luna: Yeah, I think that's a subtle but important distinction. It's not 'I deserve more because I crushed it' — it's 'my role is now worth more externally, and my salary hasn't kept up.' Lucas: Exactly. And we got a version of this question from a listener in Denver — she's a marketing manager at a mid-sized tech company. She's been there for two years, got a small cost of living bump last year, but when she looked at LinkedIn salary data and industry surveys, she found her total comp was about twenty percent below the median for her title and geography. Luna: Ouch. And that gap can happen fast — especially in a hot market where companies are bidding up for talent. Lucas: Right. So the question is: how do you walk into that conversation without sounding entitled or threatening? Because the instinct might be to say, 'I know you're hiring new people at higher rates, and I want that too.' But that can backfire. Luna: So where do you start? She needs data, obviously. Lucas: Data is step one, but not just any data. You want to use three sources at minimum: a reputable third-party salary survey — like the Radford survey if your company is tech-adjacent, or a professional association report — then a platform like Levels.fyi or Glassdoor for real-time ranges, and finally, if you have it, anecdotal data from peers at other companies who are willing to share ballpark numbers. Luna: So you're triangulating. Not just one number, but a range. Lucas: Exactly. And you want to contextualize it for your specific role and geography. Our listener in Denver — she found that the typical range for a marketing manager with three to five years of experience in Denver is ninety-two to one hundred and eight thousand dollars. She was at seventy-eight. That's a clear gap. Luna: That's a seventeen thousand dollar gap on the low end. Hard to ignore. Lucas: Right. So she put together a one-page document — not a huge deck. It had three bullet points summarizing her contributions, two charts showing the market data, and a single ask: she wanted to be adjusted to the midpoint of that range within the next review cycle. She didn't demand immediate change. Luna: I like that framing — 'within the next review cycle.' It shows you're reasonable but also setting a clear expectation. Lucas: And when you present it, you lead with the value you've delivered, not the gap. Something like, 'I'm proud of how the Q2 campaign exceeded targets by thirty percent. As I look ahead, I want to make sure my compensation aligns with the market value for this role, and I've gathered some data I'd love to walk through.' Luna: That opens the door without putting the manager on the defensive. Lucas: Right. Now, if the manager says, 'We don't do off-cycle adjustments,' or 'The budget is frozen,' you have a follow-up: 'I understand. Could we set a check-in in three months to revisit this? I want to make sure I'm positioned fairly when the budget opens up.' Luna: And if they say no to that too? Then you have to assess whether it's time to look externally. Lucas: Exactly. But before you get to that point, one more tactic: if the company is actively hiring for your role at a higher salary, you can ask your manager, 'I saw the job posting for my role on the careers page lists a range of X to Y. Can you explain the discrepancy? Because I'm currently below that range.' That's very hard for them to wave away. Luna: That's a powerful move. It shows you're paying attention and that the company's own data contradicts your current pay. Lucas: And it's not an attack — it's a legitimate question. Now, if we've helped you think through how to prepare for a raise conversation, remember we keep this show ad-free thanks to listeners who support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a simple way to say the content is valuable to you. Luna: Even a dollar helps keep the lights on, and we really appreciate it. Lucas: So back to the conversation. Once you've made your case, the manager might say, 'Let me take this to HR.' That's a good sign, but you need a timeline. Ask, 'When would be a good time to follow up on that?' And then actually do it. Luna: And if they come back with a partial adjustment — say, half the gap — is that worth accepting? Lucas: It depends on your situation. If it comes with a commitment to close the rest in six months, that might be fine. But if it's a one-time 'take it or leave it,' you have to decide if you're willing to stay under market for another year. I'd recommend asking, 'Can we put a plan in place to reach the midpoint by the next annual review?' Luna: So it's not just about the number — it's about the trajectory. Lucas: Exactly. And one thing many people forget: you can also negotiate for non-salary items like additional vacation days, a professional development budget, or a guaranteed bonus. If the salary adjustment is a hard no, those can close the gap in value. Luna: Good point. Sometimes the total package matters more than base salary. Lucas: So to wrap up our listener's story: she presented her data, her manager was actually receptive — the company had just hired a new marketing manager at ninety-five thousand, so the discrepancy was obvious. They agreed to a mid-cycle adjustment to ninety-five thousand, with a review at the annual cycle to bring her to the midpoint. Luna: That's a win. And it worked because she did the homework and framed it as a market fairness issue, not a personal demand. Lucas: Exactly. So if you're in a similar spot, start with the data, lead with your contributions, and be prepared for a 'not now' that you can follow up on. The key is to stay professional and persistent. Luna: And if it doesn't work, you'll have a clear signal that your current employer doesn't value market alignment — and that's useful information for your next move. Lucas: Right. So question for our listeners: have you ever successfully gotten a market adjustment? What worked? We'd love to hear your stories.